Chapter 23: Ten GIS Data Sources 341
datasets are licensed and for sale, and ACASIAN encourages collaborative research that uses its datasets. ACASIAN can provide datasets that include special projections for additional fees.
Contact Info: ACASIAN, Lawrence Crissman, Dept. of International Business and Asian Studies, School of Business, Griffith University, Brisbane Q 4111, Australia. Phone: 61-7-3875-7285. Fax: 61-7-3875-5111. E-mail: l.crissman@ griffith.edu.au. Web: www.asian.gu.edu.au.
Geoscience Australia
Part of the Australian Government’s Department of Resources, Energy, and Tourism, Geoscience Australia produces geoscientific information and knowledge. The primary applications are related to decision-making for resource exploration, environmental management, and maintaining the infrastructure critical for the well-being of Australian citizens.
Geoscience Australia provides hardcopy maps and aerial photography, in addition to its digital products. It also has educational materials available for primary and secondary schools. You can also download free data viewers.
Contact Info: Street address: Cnr Jerrabomberra Ave. and Hindmarsh Dr., Symston, ACT 2609, Australia. Postal address: GPO Box 378, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia. Phone: 1800-800-173 (products and services) or 61-2-6249-9111 (all other inquiries). Fax: 61-2-6249-9999. Web: http://www.ga.gov.au/.
Canada Geospatial Data Infrastructure
The Canada Geospatial Data Infrastructure (CGDI) is a combination of technology, geographic data standards, methods, and protocols needed to coordinate and manage Canadian geospatial databases. The databases include topographic maps, aerial photography, aeronautical and nautical charts, satellite imagery, and environmental data (including forestry, soil, marine, and biodiversity inventories). They also contain socioeconomic and demographic (Census) data, and electoral boundaries.
The primary purposes for maintaining this managed resource include geospatial analyses to benefit public health, safety and security, the environment, and Canada’s Aboriginal peoples.
Contact Info: GeoGratis Client Services, Natural Resources Canada, 2144 Kind W. Street, Ste. 010, Sherbrooke, Quebec J1J 2E8, Canada. Phone: 613-995-0947. Fax: 819-564-5698. E-mail: geoinfo@nrcan.gc.ca. Web: http://geogratis. cgdi.gc.ca.
342 Part VI: The Part of Tens
A cautionary note
Not all GIS data are created equal. Commercial firms sometimes package data that you can find for free or at a minimal reproduction fee elsewhere, claiming that the data they offer are value-added data. Calling something valueadded implies that the company is justified in charging for these products because it has modified the data in some way beyond their original form.
But you need to determine whether the added value warrants the added cost. The companies may claim that they improved the data’s quality, packaged them specifically for your application, or actually added some attributes to the data that make the data considerably different than their raw, unmodified form. Some modifications actually degrade the original data. In some cases, a company really does add necessary attributes, package the data with your specific application in mind, and provide additional services that make the data much more adaptable to your organization. So, you just need to decide whether these changes really add value to the data for you.
Here are some guidelines that I like to use to help me decide whether to buy value-added data:
Ask for complete metadata. You can use the metadata to determine the original source of the data and how they were modified, as well as get an indication of the quality of the data. If the company isn’t forthcoming with metadata, walk away.
Ask for a list of clients. Get contact information for clients who have purchased similar value-added data from the data provider, including both happy and not-so- happy clients.
Talk to some GIS professionals and ask their advice. Many universities have GIS faculty who know about alternate data sources or lower-cost data, or they may be able to advise you about the possible value of value-added data. Also, go to user group blogs and lists online to find additional insights about each data provider and the quality of its products.
Get a contract. Make sure it includes a guarantee that the data aren’t already available free or at minimal cost in essentially the same quality and format that the vendor is offering. The contract should include a statement that explicitly indicates the value that the company added to existing data, especially public-domain data.
Resist expediency. You might find the idea of purchasing data that you can obtain quickly very attractive, with the promise of getting your GIS up and running in no time. But remember that the value of your GIS operation lies fundamentally on the quality of your data. If you get poor-quality data quickly, the time it takes to clean up the mess can ultimately cost you more than taking the time to obtain quality data.