Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Организационно-правовые основы регулирования миграционных процессов. Административно-правовой аспект. Монография
.pdf
VlcY]gacd_g _ ]aYVli ]^W [l^YKiejW TgagSldZg c [lc^i]YHGj\ _lT_agGieji\ eg c_lH al]jeY.
*gjSl^ii TegKj\Ui [ajTegZj daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj — Ji^i_gW eg-
[ag_^ieelcdP, ]lSalcl_icdelcdP, ]lSal_l^PelcdP, _lT_agdelcdP.
7cel_eU\j [ajKjeg\j daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj ciVl]eW W_^WHdcW:
SiTagSldjJg _ al]eUM cdagegM (_c^i]cd_ji jTSUdlKelVl egci^iejW
j^j ejTZlVl Yal_eW clJjg^Pel-?Zlel\jKicZlVl agT_jdjW ]geelVl VlcY]gacd_g); ejTZjQ Yal_ieP ]lMl]l_ daY]l_UM \jVagedl_
_ c_liQ
cdagei, Tgcdg_^WHGjQ jcZgdP TgagSldlZ _ ]aYVjM cdagegM; _ci\jaegW
V^lSg^jTgJjW — agcDjaieji j YV^YS^ieji MlTWQcd_ieeUM j ZY^PdYaeUM c_WTiQ \iN]Y cdageg\j.
#^g_eU\j ld^jKjdi^PeU\j [ajTegZg\j daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj egci^iejW, [l cag_eiejH c _eYdaieeiQ, c^YNgd [iaiciKieji VlcY]gacd_ieelQ VagejJU j clld_idcd_YHGjQ VlcY]gacd_ieeUQ Zledal^P ZgZ Tg
CgZdl\ cg\lVl [iai]_jNiejW KiaiT VagejJY (j _ cdagei _UiT]g,
j, lclSieel, _ cdagei _0iT]g), dgZ j Tg [lc^i]YHGj\ [aiSU_geji\ _ cdagei
(daY]lYcdalQcd_l\ j [lcdY[^ieji\ eg YKiSY j^j cdgNjal_ZY).
7cel_lQ cjcdi\U cl_\icdelQ SiTl[gcelcdj cl cdageg\j A*#,
Zl\[iecjaYHGiQ Y[agT]eieji «[alTagKeUM» VagejJ, eg egD _TV^W],
\lNid cdgdP clT]geji i]jelQ jeCla\gJjleelQ cjcdi\U j Vga\lejTgJjW \jVagJjleelVl TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_g cdage A*#. =l] Vga\lejTgJjiQ
[aj ?dl\
[lej\gidcW YejCjZgJjW egJjleg^PeUM [ag_l_UM ela\ _ ldelDiejj [iaiciKiejW _eiDejM VagejJ Al]aYNicd_g (_0iT]g-_UiT]g j
dageTjdelVl [aliT]g), [alJi]Ya _U]gKj j [al]^iejW _jT, daiSl_gejQ
Z ]lZY\iedgJjj jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g, eg^lNiejW \gZcj\g^PeUM cgeZJjQ eg ^jJ, ei^iVg^Pel [iai_lTWGjM ^H]iQ,
ei j\iHGjM eilSMl]j\UM [Ydi_UM ]lZY\iedl_.
: c_WTj c ?dj\ cdageU—YKgcdejJU el_lVl
clV^gDiejW ]l^NeU
SY]Yd _TWdP eg ciSW lSWTgdi^Pcd_l ei [ajej\gdP l]elcdlaleejM \ia
[l YNicdlKiejH j^j ^jSiag^jTgJjj egJjleg^PeUM \jVagJjleeUM TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_. : [aldj_el\ c^YKgi cdalVji \iaU \jVagJjleelVl
Zledal^W ^HSlQ jT cdage A*# \lVYd SUdP eiQdag^jTjal_geU [Ydi\
_0iT]g KiaiT cdageY c \ieii NicdZj\ aiNj\l\.
ejCjZgJjW \jVagJjleelVl TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_g cdage—YKgcdejJ
[ldaiSYid agTagSldZj i]jelVl [leWdjQelVl g[[gagdg, _ Kgcdelcdj
dgZjM [leWdjQ, ZgZ «j\\jVaged», «?\jVaged», «jelcdageeUQ VagN]geje», «SiNieiJ», «[l^jdjKicZli YSiNjGi», «_eiDeWW daY]l_gW \jVagJjW», «ei^iVg^PegW \jVagJjW», g dgZNi Yc^l_jQ [ai]lcdg_^iejW
ZgN]lVl jT ?djM cdgdYcl_ _ egDjM VlcY]gacd_gM.
*gjSl^ii ?CCiZdj_eU\ c[lclSl\ YKidg j Zledal^W _0iT]g, [aiSU_gejW, [iai]_jNiejW j _UiT]g agT^jKeUM ZgdiVlajQ daY]WGjMcW-\jV-
,
171
agedl_ \lNid cdgdP __i]ieji i]jeUM [l Cla\i, cl]iaNgejH, calZg\
]iQcd_jW _0iT]eUM ]lZY\iedl_ (_jT) ]^W _ciM cdage A*#, l[ai]i^ieji
i]jelVl _ ?Z_j_g^iedel\ jT\iaiejj agT\iag cSlal_ Tg _U]gKY, [laW]lZ [al]^iejW calZg _jTU, g dgZNi _lT\lNelcdP [l^YKiejW _jTU _ TgVage[ai]cdg_jdi^Pcd_i ^HSlQ jT cdage, [l][jcg_DjM AlV^gDieji.
.lla]jegJjj daY]l_lQ \jVagJjleelQ [l^jdjZj SY]id c[lclScd_l_gdP: g
) cldaY]ejKicd_l ]j[^l\gdjKicZjM j ZlecY^PcZjM YKaiN]iejQ VlcY]gacd_—YKgcdejZl_ clV^gDiejW; S) lS\ie jeCla\gJjiQ l clcdlWejj _ cdagegM—jcdlKejZgM [alJiccg daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj; _) l ^jJgM, ageii [alcj_DjM YSiNjGi, Ml]gdgQcd_YHGjM l [ai]lcdg_^iejj
j^j [ajlSaidDjM cdgdYc SiNieJg, g dgZNi cl_iaDj_DjM [ag_legaYDieji j^j [aicdY[^ieji eg diaajdlajj ^HSlVl jT VlcY]gacd_—YKgcdejZl_; V) _Tgj\llS\ie
cdgdjcdjKicZj\j ]geeU\j ]^W [alVelTjal-
_gejW agT_jdjW die]ieJjQ _ cCiai \jVagJjj j d.].
:Tgj\l]iQcd_ji [ag_llMagejdi^PeUM laVgel_ eg egJjleg^Pel\ j
\iNVlcY]gacd_ieel\ Yal_ei, \iN]Yegal]eli cldaY]ejKicd_l \iN]Y
[ag_llMagejdi^PeU\j laVgeg\j Flccjj j jelcdageeUM VlcY]gacd_
lcdgidcW [ajlajdidelQ [alS^i\lQ _ cCiai daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj. 7cel_eU\j Cla\g\j \iN]Yegal]elVl cldaY]ejKicd_g _ _l[alcgM [l_UDiejW ?CCiZdj_elcdj _ cCiai ei^iVg^PelQ daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj
]l^NeU
cdgdP: cl_iaDiecd_l_geji \iMgejT\g ?Zcdag]jJjj; [l_UDieji l[iagdj_elcdj _ jc[l^eiejj [jcP\ieeUM Ml]gdgQcd_, clV^gcel [l^lNiejW\
]lVl_lal_ l [ag_l_lQ _Tgj\l[l\lGj (c Ji^PH _U[l^eiejW eilSMl]j\UM c^i]cd_ieeUM ]iQcd_jQ), g dgZNi c_li_ai\ieelcdP jc[l^eiejW Tg[alcl_ [ag_llMagejdi^PeUM YKaiN]iejQ l [ai]lcdg_^iejj l[iagdj_elQ [l\lGj. . [iac[iZdj_eU\ Cla\g\ l[iagdj_elVl _Tgj\l]iQcd_jW
laVgel_ Tgjediaicl_geeUM cdage \lNel, ldeicdj clT]geji cl_\icdeUM
c^i]cd_ieel-l[iagdj_eUM
VaY[[, g dgZNi [al_i]ieji cl_\icdeUM agcc^i]l_gejQ, [al_l]j\UM _ ag\ZgM YejCjJjal_geeUM \iN]Yegal]el[ag_l_UM [alJi]Ya.
: Ji^l\ %gZle l VagN]gecd_i Flccjj 2002 V. (_ ai]. ld 12 elWSaW
2012 V.) cdaljdcW eg [ajeJj[gM «Z^gccjKicZlVl» egJjleg^PelVl VagN]gecd_g, el [alGi j [agZdjKeii [ai]U]YGiVl. : Kgcdelcdj _ ei\
^YKDi aiVY^jaYidcW VagN]gecd_l ]idiQ. =ajlSaidieji VagN]gecd_g
di[iaP c_WTU_gidcW c aW]l\
daiSl_gejQ, _ Kjc^i ZldlaUM — jcKjc^Wi\li c \l\iedg [l^YKiejW _j]g eg Njdi^Pcd_l [Wdj^ideii [alNj_geji
eg diaajdlajj Flccjj, eilSMl]j\lcdP ldZgTg ld [aiNeiVl VagN]gecd_g. =ag_]g, [l^eUQ ldZgT ld ]_lQelVl VagN]gecd_g _ el_l\ %gZlei
ei_lT\lNie jT-Tg ZlecdjdYJjleelQ ela\U, ]l[YcZgHGiQ ]_lQeli
VagN]gecd_l.
$cc^i]l_geji [ag_l_UM lcel_ TgGjdU clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj-
_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\, dgZNi [lT_l^Wid cCla\Y^jal_gdP
aW] _U_l]l_.
172
=ag_l_lQ lcel_lQ TgGjdU [ag_ clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\ W_^WHdcW .lecdjdYJjW FB j B% «7 VlcY]gacd_ieelQ [l^jdjZi FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj _ ldelDiejj clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\», «7
VagN]gecd_i FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» j ]a. 7cel_U [lcdaliejW egJjleg^PeUM ldelDiejQ Tg^lNieU _ .lecdjdYJjj FB. Aai]cd_g TgGjdU
clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\ _ Sl^PDiQ cdi[iej ldelcWdcW Z cCiai
\iN]Yegal]el-[ag_l_UM
ldelDiejQ.
#^g_eU\ [ajeJj[l\ ldiKicd_ieelVl TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_g W_^WidcW
[ajeJj[ Vlc[l]cd_g [ag_g, ZldlaUQ _UagNgidcW _ dl\, Kdl VlcY]gacd_l [ajTegid j clS^H]gid [ag_g Ki^l_iZg j TgGjGgid iVl ZgZ elcjdi^W ?djM [ag_.
FlccjW lSic[iKj_gid [lcdlWeeYH [l]]iaNZY j TgGjdY clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\. dl [ag_l VlcY]gacd_g lSYc^l_^iel VlcY]gacd_ieeU\ cY_iaiejdidl\ j gZdYg^jTjaYidcW _ ldelDiejWM c
]aYVj\j
cdageg\j. 7SWTgeelcdj _ ]geelQ cCiai FlccjW eicid clV^gcel ]iQcd_YHGiQ .lecdjdYJjj. i^j VlcY]gacd_ieelQ [l^jdjZj _ ldelDiejj
clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\ TgZ^HKgHdcW _ lZgTgejj VlcY]gacd_ieelQ [l]]iaNZj j [l\lGj _ clld_idcd_jj c lSGi[ajTegeeU\j [ajeJj[g\j j ela\g\j \iN]Yegal]elVl [ag_g, \iN]Yegal]eU\j ]lVl_lag\j FB, TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_l\ FB c YKidl\ TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_g jelcdageeUM VlcY]gacd_.
: egcdlWGii
_ai\W ZaYV ld_idcd_ieelcdj ]l^NelcdeUM ^jJ Tg egaYDiejW \jVagJjleelVl TgZlel]gdi^Pcd_g eilSMl]j\l agcDjajdP,
g j\ieel:
6 __icdj g]\jejcdagdj_eYH ld_idcd_ieelcdP Tg ei[ai]lcdg_^ieji
j^j eic_li_ai\ieeli [ai]lcdg_^ieji _ Ci]iag^PeUQ laVge jc[l^ejdi^PelQ _^gcdj _ cCiai \jVagJjj Y_i]l\^iejQ j c_i]iejQ [aj
[aj_^iKiejj _UclZlZ_g^jCjJjal_geeUM c[iJjg^jcdl_ j jc[l^PTl_gejW jM daY]g;
6 ]l[l^ejdP cd. 18.15 .l]iZcg [l^lNiejW\j, Ycdgeg_^j_gHGj\j
ld_idcd_ieelcdP Tg
egaYDieji Ycdgel_^ieelVl [laW]Zg j calZl_
eg[ag_^iejW Y_i]l\^iejQ l [aj_^iKiejj Z daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj
_ FB jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j ^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g, _Z^HKgW Y_i]l\^ieji l agcdlaNiejj daY]l_UM ]lVl_lal_ j^j VagN]gecZl-[ag_l_UM ]lVl_lal_ eg _U[l^eieji agSld (lZgTgeji Yc^YV)
c jelcdageeU\j agSldejZg\j, g dgZNi l [ai]lcdg_^iejj j\ ld[YcZl_ SiT clMageiejW TgagSldelQ [^gdU
[al]l^Njdi^PelcdPH
Sl^ii l]elVl Zg^ie]gaelVl \icWJg _ diKieji Vl]g;
6 ]l[l^ejdP cd. 18.16 .l]iZcg [aj\iKgeji\, Ycdgeg_^j_gHGj\,
Kdl _ c^YKgi [aj_^iKiejW Z daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj, lcYGicd_^Wi\lQ eg dlaVl_UM lS0iZdgM (_ dl\ Kjc^i dlaVl_UM Zl\[^iZcgM), c
173
egaYDieji\ Ycdgel_^ieeUM [ag_j^ ]_YM j Sl^ii jelcdageeUM
VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g, g]\jejcdagdj_egW ld_idcd_ieelcdP Tg egaYDieji [ag_j^ [aj_^iKiejW Z daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj
egcdY[gid _ ldelDiejj ZgN]lVl jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j
^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g _ ld]i^Pelcdj.
.al\i ?dlVl, eilSMl]j\l clT]gdP ]jeYH cjcdi\Y YKidg VagN]ge
daidPjM VlcY]gacd_ j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g, _0iTNgHGjM eg diaajdlajj VlcY]gacd_
TegKieg ]^W g_dl\gdjTjal_geelVl cSlag, lSagSldZj, egZl[^iejW,
MageiejW, [iai]gKj j jc[l^PTl_gejW jeCla\gJjj, [lT_l^WHGiQ _icdj
c_li_ai\ieeUQ YKid VagN]ge daidPjM VlcY]gacd_, [iaiciZgHGjM VagejJU cdage A*#.
— YKgcdejZl_ A*# (A). ]jegW cjcdi\g [ai]eg-
$F!F!
*la\gdj_eUi [ag_l_Ui gZdU
1. .lecdjdYJjW FB ([ajeWdg _ciegal]eU\ Vl^lcl_geji\ 12 ]i-
ZgSaW 1993 V.) (c YKidl\ [l[ag_lZ, _eicieeUM Bi]iag^PeU\j ZlecdjdYJjleeU\j TgZleg\j l [l[ag_ZgM Z .lecdjdYJjj FB ld 30 ]iZgSaW
2008 V. & 6-B.%, ld 30 ]iZgSaW 2008 V. & 7-B.%).
2. :cilSGgW ]iZ^gagJjW [ag_ Ki^l_iZg ld 10 ]iZgSaW 1948 V. //
<iN]Yegal]eUi clV^gDiejW j aiZl\ie]gJjj 77* _ lS^gcdj TgGjdU
[ag_ j c_lSl] Ki^l_iZg
3. <i\lage]Y\ l cldaY]ejKicd_i \iN]Y B<A (FlccjQcZgW Bi]i-
agJjW) j <jejcdiacd_l\ clJjg^PelQ [l^jdjZj ZagjeU [l _l[alcg\ daY]l_lQ \jVagJjj ld 23 \gadg 2011 V.
4. .leJi[JjW VlcY]gacd_ieelQ \jVagJjleelQ [l^jdjZj FB eg
[iajl] ]l 2025 V.
5. .l]iZc FB lS g]\jejcdagdj_eUM [ag_legaYDiejWM ld 30 ]i-
ZgSaW 2001 V. & 195-B%. (_ ai]. ld 15 We_gaW 2013 V.).
6. Vl^l_eUQ Zl]iZc FB ld 13 jHeW 1996 V. & 63-B3 (_ ai]. ld
30 ]iZgSaW 2012 V.).
j SlaPSU c [aicdY[elcdPH. <., 1989. & 1.
.l]iZcU
Bi]iag^PeUi TgZleU
7. %gZle FB ld 25 jHeW 1993 V. & 5242-1 «7 [ag_i VagN]ge eg
c_lSl]Y [iai]_jNiejW, _USlag \icdg [aiSU_gejW j Njdi^Pcd_g _
[ai]i^gM FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» (_ ai]. ld 6 ]iZgSaW 2011 V.).
8. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 15 g_VYcdg 1996 V. & 114-B% «7 [laW]Zi
_UiT]g jT FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj j _0iT]g _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH» (_ ai]. ld 30 ]iZgSaW 2012 V.).
9. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 24 \gW 1999 V. & 99-B% «7 VlcY]gacd-
_ieelQ [l^jdjZi FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj _ ldelDiejj clldiKicd_ieejZl_ Tg aYSiNl\» (_ ai]. ld 23 jH^W 2010 V.).
10. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 31 \gW 2002 V. & 62-B% «7 VagN]ge-
cd_i FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» (_ ai]. ld 12 elWSaW 2012 V.).
11. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 25 jH^W 2002 V. & 115-B% «7 [ag_l_l\
[l^lNiejj jelcdageeUM VagN]ge _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» (_ ai].
ld 30 ]iZgSaW 2012 V.).
175
12. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 18 jH^W 2006 V. & 109-B% «7 \jVag-
Jjleel\ YKidi jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» (_ ai]. ld 28 jH^W 2012 V.).
13. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 20 \gadg 2011 V. & 42-B% «7 _eiciejj
jT\ieiejQ _ Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle «7 \jVagJjleel\ YKidi jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g _
]i^PeUi TgZlel]gdi^PeUi gZdU FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
14. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 30 ]iZgSaW 2012 V. & 320-B% «7 _eici-
ejj jT\ieiejQ _ Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle «7 [ag_l_l\ [l^lNiejj jelcdageeUM VagN]ge _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
15. Bi]iag^PeUQ TgZle ld 30 ]iZgSaW 2012 V. & 321-B% «7 _eici-
ejj jT\ieiejQ _ cd. 26 Bi]iag^PelVl TgZleg «7 [laW]Zi _UiT]g
FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj j _0iT]g _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH».
FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj» j ld-
jT
ZgTU =aiTj]iedg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj
16. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 13 \gadg 1997 V. & 232 «7S lcel_el\
]lZY\iedi, Y]lcdl_iaWHGi\ ^jKelcdP VagN]gejeg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj eg diaajdlajj FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
17. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 21 jH^W 1997 V. & 746 «7S Yd_iaN]i-
ejj [l^lNiejW l [laW]Zi [ai]lcdg_^iejW FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjiQ
[l^jdjKicZlVl YSiNjGg».
18. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj 14 elWSaW 2002 V.
& 1325 «7S Yd_iaN]iejj =l^lNiejW l [laW]Zi
VagN]gecd_g FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjiQ» (_ ai]. ld 29 ]iZgSaW 2012 V.).
19. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 22 jHeW 2006 V. & 637 «7 \iagM [l
lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\» (_ ai]. ld
14 ciedWSaW 2012 V.).
20. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 1 g_VYcdg 2006 V. & 814 «:l[alcU
<iN_i]l\cd_ieelQ Zl\jccjj [l aig^jTgJjj #lcY]gacd_ieelQ [al
Vag\\U [l lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\»
(_ ai]. ld 14 ciedWSaW 2012 V.).
21. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 3 \gadg 2008 V. & 301 «7 [ai]cdg_j-
di^Pcd_gM j [ai]cdg_jdi^WM Bi]iag^PelQ \jVagJjleelQ c^YNSU Tg
aYSiNl\».
22. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 12 We_gaW 2010 V & 60 «7 _eiciejj jT-
\ieiejQ _ VlcY]gacd_ieeYH
al_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\, j _ [^ge \ial[ajWdjQ [l aig^jTgJjj
[alVag\\Y [l lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW ]lS-
agcc\ldaiejW _l[alcl_
-
176
VlcY]gacd_ieelQ [alVag\\U [l lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal_l^Pel\Y
[iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\, Yd_iaN]ieeUi YZgTl\ [aiTj]iedg FlccjQcZlQ
Bi]iagJjj ld 22 jHeW 2006 V. & 637».
23. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 21 \gW 2012 V. & 636 «7 cdaYZdYai
Ci]iag^PeUM laVgel_ jc[l^ejdi^PelQ _^gcdj».
24. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 14 ciedWSaW 2012 V. & 1289 «7 aig^j-
TgJjj #lcY]gacd_ieelQ [alVag\\U [l lZgTgejH
_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_,
[alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\».
25. ZgT =aiTj]iedg FB ld 15 We_gaW 2013 V. & 30 «7 eiZldlaUM
_l[alcgM <:" Flccjj j B<A Flccjj».
cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal-
==lcdgel_^iejW =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj
26. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 17 jH^W 1995 V. & 713
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =ag_j^ aiVjcdagJjj j ceWdjW VagN]ge FlccjQcZlQ
Bi]iagJjj c aiVjcdagJjleelVl YKidg [l \icdY [aiSU_gejW j [l \icdY
Njdi^Pcd_g _ [ai]i^gM FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj j [iaiKeW ]l^NelcdeUM
^jJ, ld_idcd_ieeUM Tg aiVjcdagJjH» (_ ai]. ld 21 \gW 2012 V.).
27. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 12 ]iZgSaW 1995 V. & 1227
Y]lcdl_iaiejj SiNieJg».
«7S
28. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 22 Ci_ag^W 1997 V. & 199
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =laW]Zg _U]gKj j Cla\U c_j]idi^Pcd_g l aiVjcd-
agJjj Ml]gdgQcd_g l [ajTegejj ^jJg _UeYN]ieeU\ [iaici^ieJi\ j
Y]lcdl_iaiejW _UeYN]ieelVl [iaici^ieJg».
29. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 23 \gW 1998 V. & 484 «7
agT\iai i]jel_ai\ieelVl ]ieiNelVl [lclSjW j =laW]Zi iVl _U[^gdU
^jJY, [l^YKj_Di\Y c_j]idi^Pcd_l l agcc\ldaiejj Ml]gdgQcd_g
Tegejj SiNieJi\ eg diaajdlajj FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj [l cYGicd_Y».
30. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 28 \gW 1998 V. & 523 «7
c_j]idi^Pcd_i l agcc\ldaiejj Ml]gdgQcd_g l [ajTegejj SiNieJi\ eg
diaajdlajj FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj [l cYGicd_Y».
31. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 1 lZdWSaW 1998 V. & 1142
«7 aig^jTgJjj ld]i^PeUM ela\ Bi]iag^PelVl TgZleg «7 [laW]Zi _U-
iT]g jT FlccjQcZlQ
32. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 1 elWSaW 2002 V. & 789
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =l^lNiejW l _U]gKi jelcdageeU\ VagN]geg\ j
^jJg\ SiT VagN]gecd_g agTaiDiejW eg _ai\ieeli [alNj_geji».
33. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 24 \gadg 2003 V. & 167
«7 [laW]Zi [ai]lcdg_^iejW VgagedjQ \gdiajg^PelVl, \i]jJjecZlVl
Bi]iagJjj j _0iT]g _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH».
l [aj-
177
j Nj^jGelVl lSic[iKiejW jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g eg [iajl] jM [aiSU_gejW _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
34. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 7 g[ai^W 2003 V. & 199 «7S
Yd_iaN]iejj =l^lNiejW l [ajeWdjj aiDiejW l eiNi^gdi^Pelcdj [aiSU_gejW ([alNj_gejW) jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j ^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj j =iaiKeW Ci]iag^PeUM laVgel_
jc[l^ejdi^PelQ _^gcdj,
Y[l^el\lKieeUM [ajej\gdP aiDieji l eiNi^gdi^Pelcdj [aiSU_gejW ([alNj_gejW) jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j
^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
35. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 9 jHeW 2003 V. & 335 «7S
Yd_iaN]iejj =l^lNiejW lS Ycdgel_^iejj Cla\U _jTU, [laW]Zg j
Yc^l_jQ ii lCla\^iejW j _U]gKj, [al]^iejW calZg ii ]iQcd_jW, _lccdgel_^iejW ii _ c^YKgi YdagdU, g dgZNi [laW]Zg geeY^jal_gejW
_jTU».
36. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 16 g_VYcdg 2004 V. & 413
«7 \jVagJjleelQ Zgadi».
37. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 19 We_gaW 2005 V. & 30
«7 j[l_l\ aiV^g\iedi _Tgj\l]iQcd_jW Ci]iag^PeUM laVgel_ jc[l^ejdi^PelQ _^gcdj».
38. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 6 g[ai^W 2005 V. & 186
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =l^lNiejW l clT]gejj, _i]iejj j jc[l^PTl_gejj
Jiedag^PelVl SgeZg ]geeUM [l YKidY jelcdageeUM
VagN]ge, _ai\ieel
[aiSU_gHGjM j _ai\ieel j^j [lcdlWeel [alNj_gHGjM _ FlccjQcZlQ
Bi]iagJjj».
39. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 28 jH^W 2005 V. & 452
«7 j[l_l\ aiV^g\iedi _eYdaieeiQ laVgejTgJjj Ci]iag^PeUM laVgel_ jc[l^ejdi^PelQ _^gcdj».
40. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 11 elWSaW 2005 V. & 679
«7 =laW]Zi agTagSldZj j Yd_iaN]iejW g]\jejcdagdj_eUM aiV^g-
\iedl_ jc[l^eiejW VlcY]gacd_ieeUM CYeZJjQ ([ai]lcdg_^iejW VlcY]gacd_ieeUM
Yc^YV)».
41. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 20 lZdWSaW 2006 V. & 622
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =ag_j^ [ai]lcdg_^iejW cYS0iZdg\ FlccjQcZlQ Bi-
]iagJjj, _Z^HKieeU\ _ #lcY]gacd_ieeYH [alVag\\Y [l lZgTgejH
cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH
clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\, VlcY]gacd_ieelQ [l]]iaNZj Tg cKid cai]cd_ Ci]iag^PelVl SH]Nidg».
42. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 15 elWSaW 2006 V. & 681
«7 =laW]Zi _U]gKj
agTaiDjdi^PeUM ]lZY\iedl_ ]^W lcYGicd_^i-
ejW jelcdageeU\j VagN]geg\j _ai\ieelQ daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj
_ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
178
43. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 7 ]iZgSaW 2006 V. & 751
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =ag_j^ agcc\ldaiejW j clV^gcl_gejW [aliZdg [al-
Vag\\U cYS0iZdg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj [l lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW
]lSal_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\».
44. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 22 ]iZgSaW 2006 V. & 783
«7 =laW]Zi l[ai]i^iejW jc[l^ejdi^PeU\j laVgeg\j VlcY]gacd_ie-
elQ _^gcdj [ldaiSelcdj _
[aj_^iKiejj jelcdageeUM agSldejZl_ j
Cla\jal_gejW Z_ld eg lcYGicd_^ieji jelcdageeU\j VagN]geg\j
daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
45. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 10 We_gaW 2007 V. & 1 «7
Zl\[iecgJjleel\ [gZidi YKgcdejZg #lcY]gacd_ieelQ [alVag\\U [l
lZgTgejH cl]iQcd_jW ]lSal_l^Pel\Y [iaici^iejH _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH clldiKicd_ieejZl_, [alNj_gHGjM Tg aYSiNl\».
46. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 17 We_gaW 2007 V. & 21
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =ag_j^
[l]gKj jelcdageeU\ VagN]gejel\ j^j
^jJl\ SiT VagN]gecd_g Y_i]l\^iejW l [l]d_iaN]iejj c_liVl [alNj_gejW _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
47. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 9 Ci_ag^W 2007 V. & 91
«7 =laW]Zi l[ai]i^iejW cai]ei\icWKelVl ]lMl]g jelcdageelVl
VagN]gejeg j^j ^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g j cai]ei\icWKelVl cai]ei]YDi_lVl ]lMl]g K^ieg ci\Pj jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j ^jJg SiT
VagN]gecd_g».
48. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld
14 Ci_ag^W 2007 V. & 94
«7 VlcY]gacd_ieelQ jeCla\gJjleelQ cjcdi\i \jVagJjleelVl YKidg».
49. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 17 Ci_ag^W 2007 V. & 97
«7S Ycdgel_^iejj c^YKgi_ lcYGicd_^iejW daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj jel-
cdageeU\ VagN]gejel\ j^j ^jJl\ SiT VagN]gecd_g, _ai\ieel [aiSU_gHGj\j ([alNj_gHGj\j) _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj, _ei [ai]i^l_
cYS0iZdg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj, eg diaajdlajj ZldlalVl j\ _U]gel
agTaiDieji eg agSldY (agTaiDiel
_ai\ieeli [alNj_geji)».
50. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 18 \gadg 2008 V. & 183
«7S Yd_iaN]iejj =ag_j^ [l]gKj agSldl]gdi^i\ j^j TgZgTKjZl\ agSld
(Yc^YV) Y_i]l\^iejW l [aj_^iKiejj j jc[l^PTl_gejj ]^W lcYGicd_^i-
ejW daY]l_lQ ]iWdi^Pelcdj jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j (j^j) ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g, [ajSU_DjM _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH _ [laW]Zi, ei daiSYHGi\ [l^YKiejW _jTU, j j\iHGjM
agTaiDieji eg agSldY».
51. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 27 Ci_ag^W 2010 V. & 98 «7
_eiciejj jT\ieiejQ _ [l^lNieji lS Ycdgel_^iejj Cla\U _jTU, [laW]Zg
j Yc^l_jQ ii lCla\^iejW j _U]gKj, [al]^iejW calZg ii ]iQcd_jW, _lccdgel_^iejW ii _ c^YKgi YdagdU, g dgZNi [laW]Zg geeY^jal_gejW _jTU».
179
52. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 4 \gadg 2010 V. & 125 «7
[iaiKei [iacleg^PeUM ]geeUM, Tg[jcU_gi\UM eg ?^iZdaleeUi elcjdi^j jeCla\gJjj, cl]iaNgGjicW _ lcel_eUM ]lZY\iedgM, Y]lcdl_iaWHGjM ^jKelcdP VagN]gejeg FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj, [l ZldlaU\
VagN]gei FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj lcYGicd_^WHd _UiT] jT FlccjQcZlQ
Bi]iagJjj j _0iT] _ FlccjQcZYH Bi]iagJjH».
53. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 12 elWSaW 2010 V. & 895
«7S l[ai]i^iejj
SldejZl_ j Yd_iaN]iejj clld_idcd_YHGjM Z_ld eg 2011 V.».
54. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 11 elWSaW 2010 V. & 885
«7 _eiciejj jT\ieiejQ _ =ag_j^g aiVjcdagJjj j ceWdjW VagN]ge
FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj c aiVjcdagJjleelVl YKidg [l \icdY [aiSU_gejW j [l \icdY Njdi^Pcd_g _ [ai]i^gM FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
55. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g
«7 _eiciejj jT\ieiejQ _ [ag_j^g aiVjcdagJjj j ceWdjW VagN]ge alc-
cjQcZlQ Ci]iagJjj c aiVjcdagJjleelVl YKidg [l \icdY [aiSU_gejW
j [l \icdY Njdi^Pcd_g _ [ai]i^gM alccjQcZlQ Ci]iagJjj».
56. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 13 jH^W 2012 V. & 711
«7 _l[alcgM Bi]iag^PelQ \jVagJjleelQ c^YNSU».
57. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 9 Ci_ag^W 2012 V.
_eiciejj jT\ieiejQ _ =ag_j^g lcYGicd_^iejW \jVagJjleelVl YKidg
jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
58. =lcdgel_^ieji =ag_jdi^Pcd_g FB ld 21 We_gaW 2013 V. & 19 «7
_eiciejj jT\ieiejQ _ =ag_j^g lcYGicd_^iejW \jVagJjleelVl YKidg
jelcdageeUM VagN]ge j ^jJ SiT VagN]gecd_g _ FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj».
[ldaiSelcdj _ [aj_^iKiejj _ FB jelcdageeUM ag-
FB ld 26 lZdWSaW 2011 V. & 869
& 106 «7
==ajZgTU <:" Flccjj
59. =ajZgT <:" Flccjj, <$" Flccjj, BA Flccjj ld 27 ]iZgSaW
2003 V. & 1048/19723!/922 «7S Yd_iaN]iejj =iaiKeW «i^j [liT]lZ»,
jc[l^PTYi\lVl Y[l^el\lKieeU\j VlcY]gacd_ieeU\j laVgeg\j FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj [aj lCla\^iejj [ajV^gDiejQ j _jT jelcdageeU\ VagN]geg\ j ^jJg\ SiT VagN]gecd_g».
60. =ajZgT <:" Flccjj ld 26 g_VYcdg 2004 V. & 533 «7S laVgejTgJjj ]iWdi^Pelcdj laVgel_ _eYdaieejM ]i^
Bi]iag^PelQ \jVagJjleelQ c^YNSU [l ]i[ladgJjj ^jSl g]\jejcdagdj_el\Y _U]_laiejH Tg [ai]i^U FlccjQcZlQ Bi]iagJjj jelcdageelVl VagN]gejeg j^j ^jJg SiT VagN]gecd_g».
61. =ajZgT <:" Flccjj ld 28 ]iZgSaW 2006 V. & 1105 «7S Yd_iaN]iejj !]\jejcdagdj_elVl aiV^g\iedg Bi]iag^PelQ \jVagJjleelQ
c^YNSU [l [ai]lcdg_^iejH VlcY]gacd_ieelQ Yc^YVj [l _U]gKi, Tg\iei
180
FlccjQcZjQ Bi]iagJjj j
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]