- •List of Tables
- •List of Figures
- •Table of Notation
- •Preface
- •Boolean retrieval
- •An example information retrieval problem
- •Processing Boolean queries
- •The extended Boolean model versus ranked retrieval
- •References and further reading
- •The term vocabulary and postings lists
- •Document delineation and character sequence decoding
- •Obtaining the character sequence in a document
- •Choosing a document unit
- •Determining the vocabulary of terms
- •Tokenization
- •Dropping common terms: stop words
- •Normalization (equivalence classing of terms)
- •Stemming and lemmatization
- •Faster postings list intersection via skip pointers
- •Positional postings and phrase queries
- •Biword indexes
- •Positional indexes
- •Combination schemes
- •References and further reading
- •Dictionaries and tolerant retrieval
- •Search structures for dictionaries
- •Wildcard queries
- •General wildcard queries
- •Spelling correction
- •Implementing spelling correction
- •Forms of spelling correction
- •Edit distance
- •Context sensitive spelling correction
- •Phonetic correction
- •References and further reading
- •Index construction
- •Hardware basics
- •Blocked sort-based indexing
- •Single-pass in-memory indexing
- •Distributed indexing
- •Dynamic indexing
- •Other types of indexes
- •References and further reading
- •Index compression
- •Statistical properties of terms in information retrieval
- •Dictionary compression
- •Dictionary as a string
- •Blocked storage
- •Variable byte codes
- •References and further reading
- •Scoring, term weighting and the vector space model
- •Parametric and zone indexes
- •Weighted zone scoring
- •Learning weights
- •The optimal weight g
- •Term frequency and weighting
- •Inverse document frequency
- •The vector space model for scoring
- •Dot products
- •Queries as vectors
- •Computing vector scores
- •Sublinear tf scaling
- •Maximum tf normalization
- •Document and query weighting schemes
- •Pivoted normalized document length
- •References and further reading
- •Computing scores in a complete search system
- •Index elimination
- •Champion lists
- •Static quality scores and ordering
- •Impact ordering
- •Cluster pruning
- •Components of an information retrieval system
- •Tiered indexes
- •Designing parsing and scoring functions
- •Putting it all together
- •Vector space scoring and query operator interaction
- •References and further reading
- •Evaluation in information retrieval
- •Information retrieval system evaluation
- •Standard test collections
- •Evaluation of unranked retrieval sets
- •Evaluation of ranked retrieval results
- •Assessing relevance
- •A broader perspective: System quality and user utility
- •System issues
- •User utility
- •Results snippets
- •References and further reading
- •Relevance feedback and query expansion
- •Relevance feedback and pseudo relevance feedback
- •The Rocchio algorithm for relevance feedback
- •Probabilistic relevance feedback
- •When does relevance feedback work?
- •Relevance feedback on the web
- •Evaluation of relevance feedback strategies
- •Pseudo relevance feedback
- •Indirect relevance feedback
- •Summary
- •Global methods for query reformulation
- •Vocabulary tools for query reformulation
- •Query expansion
- •Automatic thesaurus generation
- •References and further reading
- •XML retrieval
- •Basic XML concepts
- •Challenges in XML retrieval
- •A vector space model for XML retrieval
- •Evaluation of XML retrieval
- •References and further reading
- •Exercises
- •Probabilistic information retrieval
- •Review of basic probability theory
- •The Probability Ranking Principle
- •The 1/0 loss case
- •The PRP with retrieval costs
- •The Binary Independence Model
- •Deriving a ranking function for query terms
- •Probability estimates in theory
- •Probability estimates in practice
- •Probabilistic approaches to relevance feedback
- •An appraisal and some extensions
- •An appraisal of probabilistic models
- •Bayesian network approaches to IR
- •References and further reading
- •Language models for information retrieval
- •Language models
- •Finite automata and language models
- •Types of language models
- •Multinomial distributions over words
- •The query likelihood model
- •Using query likelihood language models in IR
- •Estimating the query generation probability
- •Language modeling versus other approaches in IR
- •Extended language modeling approaches
- •References and further reading
- •Relation to multinomial unigram language model
- •The Bernoulli model
- •Properties of Naive Bayes
- •A variant of the multinomial model
- •Feature selection
- •Mutual information
- •Comparison of feature selection methods
- •References and further reading
- •Document representations and measures of relatedness in vector spaces
- •k nearest neighbor
- •Time complexity and optimality of kNN
- •The bias-variance tradeoff
- •References and further reading
- •Exercises
- •Support vector machines and machine learning on documents
- •Support vector machines: The linearly separable case
- •Extensions to the SVM model
- •Multiclass SVMs
- •Nonlinear SVMs
- •Experimental results
- •Machine learning methods in ad hoc information retrieval
- •Result ranking by machine learning
- •References and further reading
- •Flat clustering
- •Clustering in information retrieval
- •Problem statement
- •Evaluation of clustering
- •Cluster cardinality in K-means
- •Model-based clustering
- •References and further reading
- •Exercises
- •Hierarchical clustering
- •Hierarchical agglomerative clustering
- •Time complexity of HAC
- •Group-average agglomerative clustering
- •Centroid clustering
- •Optimality of HAC
- •Divisive clustering
- •Cluster labeling
- •Implementation notes
- •References and further reading
- •Exercises
- •Matrix decompositions and latent semantic indexing
- •Linear algebra review
- •Matrix decompositions
- •Term-document matrices and singular value decompositions
- •Low-rank approximations
- •Latent semantic indexing
- •References and further reading
- •Web search basics
- •Background and history
- •Web characteristics
- •The web graph
- •Spam
- •Advertising as the economic model
- •The search user experience
- •User query needs
- •Index size and estimation
- •Near-duplicates and shingling
- •References and further reading
- •Web crawling and indexes
- •Overview
- •Crawling
- •Crawler architecture
- •DNS resolution
- •The URL frontier
- •Distributing indexes
- •Connectivity servers
- •References and further reading
- •Link analysis
- •The Web as a graph
- •Anchor text and the web graph
- •PageRank
- •Markov chains
- •The PageRank computation
- •Hubs and Authorities
- •Choosing the subset of the Web
- •References and further reading
- •Bibliography
- •Author Index
9.3 References and further reading |
193 |
evant statistically correlated terms. For example, a query for Apple computer may expand to Apple red fruit computer. In general these thesauri suffer from both false positives and false negatives. Moreover, since the terms in the automatic thesaurus are highly correlated in documents anyway (and often the collection used to derive the thesaurus is the same as the one being indexed), this form of query expansion may not retrieve many additional documents.
Query expansion is often effective in increasing recall. However, there is a high cost to manually producing a thesaurus and then updating it for scientific and terminological developments within a field. In general a domainspecific thesaurus is required: general thesauri and dictionaries give far too little coverage of the rich domain-particular vocabularies of most scientific fields. However, query expansion may also significantly decrease precision, particularly when the query contains ambiguous terms. For example, if the user searches for interest rate, expanding the query to interest rate fascinate evaluate is unlikely to be useful. Overall, query expansion is less successful than relevance feedback, though it may be as good as pseudo relevance feedback. It does, however, have the advantage of being much more understandable to the system user.
?Exercise 9.7
If A is simply a Boolean cooccurrence matrix, then what do you get as the entries in
C?
9.3References and further reading
Work in information retrieval quickly confronted the problem of variant expression which meant that the words in a query might not appear in a document, despite it being relevant to the query. An early experiment about 1960 cited by Swanson (1988) found that only 11 out of 23 documents properly indexed under the subject toxicity had any use of a word containing the stem toxi. There is also the issue of translation, of users knowing what terms a document will use. Blair and Maron (1985) conclude that “it is impossibly difficult for users to predict the exact words, word combinations, and phrases that are used by all (or most) relevant documents and only (or primarily) by those documents”.
The main initial papers on relevance feedback using vector space models all appear in Salton (1971b), including the presentation of the Rocchio algorithm (Rocchio 1971) and the Ide dec-hi variant along with evaluation of several variants (Ide 1971). Another variant is to regard all documents in the collection apart from those judged relevant as nonrelevant, rather than only ones that are explicitly judged nonrelevant. However, Schütze et al. (1995) and Singhal et al. (1997) show that better results are obtained for routing by using only documents close to the query of interest rather than all
Online edition (c) 2009 Cambridge UP
194 |
9 Relevance feedback and query expansion |
documents. Other later work includes Salton and Buckley (1990), Riezler et al. (2007) (a statistical NLP approach to RF) and the recent survey paper Ruthven and Lalmas (2003).
The effectiveness of interactive relevance feedback systems is discussed in (Salton 1989, Harman 1992, Buckley et al. 1994b). Koenemann and Belkin (1996) do user studies of the effectiveness of relevance feedback.
Traditionally Roget’s thesaurus has been the best known English language thesaurus (Roget 1946). In recent computational work, people almost always use WordNet (Fellbaum 1998), not only because it is free, but also because of its rich link structure. It is available at: http://wordnet.princeton.edu.
Qiu and Frei (1993) and Schütze (1998) discuss automatic thesaurus generation. Xu and Croft (1996) explore using both local and global query expansion.
Online edition (c) 2009 Cambridge UP