экономика для чайников

B 3TOit maDe paCCKa3bIBaeTCH 0 n03HTHBHbIX H HeraTHBHbIX 8HeWHUX 3rJ)(pelCmax, UJlU 31CC­ mepHO/lURX (externalities), - CHTYaUHHX, KOr,lJ,a nOBe,n;eHHe O,n;HOro tIeJIOBeKa JIH60 npHHOCHT nOJIb3Y LlPyrHM JIIOL\HM, JIH60 nOBepraeT HX B paCXOLlhl, HO r,n;e npaBa C06CTBeHHOCTH HaCTOJIb­ KO nJIOXO onpe,n;eJIeHbI, tITO HeJIb3H TOtIHO onpe,n;eJIHTb HH 3aTPaT, HH BbIro,n;. (HeraTHBHbIe BHeIIIHHe 3<J><J>eKTbI npHBOL\HT K B03HHKHOBeHHIO TaKHX Cepbe3HbIX npo6JIeM, KaK 3arpH3He­ HHe 0KP}')KaIOmeit cpe,n;bI H m06aJIbHOe nOTenJIeHHe.) .SI TaJOKe npo,n;eMOHCTPHPYIO, tITO 60JIb­ IIIHHCTBO CJ1y'IaeB B03HHKHOBeHHH OnaCHOCTH BbIMHPaHHH HJIH HCtIe3HOBeHHH BHL\OB )KJ{BOT­ HbIX HBJIHeTCH pe3YJIbTaTOM OTCYTCTBHH npaB 'C06CTBeHHOCTH, H TO, KaK onpe,n;eJIeHHe npaB C06CTBeHHOCTH MO)KeT cnaCTH <J>JIOPY H <J>aYJiy.

.Jlfte'l0cihaA.J.eltue6'OUtO.Jltltocihu /lbtItJtaJI.

'I0Clhultb CO/iUaJ,bItO O~aJ,bItOZO

'IP()6'1Ul lI.jtoua6'0'lcJli6a

;::J)uI TOro 'IT06bI PbIHOK ,n;OCTHr COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHOro ypOBHH npOH3Bo,n;CTBa, OH ,n;OJI)KeH YtIHTbmaTb Bce 38TPaTbI H BbIro,n;bI OT BCHKOro BHL\a ,n;eHTeJIbHOCTH, He­ 3aDHCHMO OT TOro, KTO omymaeT Ha ce6e BJIHHHHe 3THX 3aTPaT H BbIro,n;. ECJIH pbI­ HOK OTBetIaeT 3TOMY TPe60BaHHIO, KPHBaH cnpoca YtIHTbIB8eT Bce BbIrO,n;bI, KpHBaH npeLIJIO)KeHHH - Bce 3aTPaTbI, a PbIHOtIHbIit paBHoBecHbIit o6beM npOH3Bo,n;CTBa rapaHTHpyeT, 'ITO 6y.nYT npOH3Bo,n;HTbCH TOJIbKO re eLIHHHl(bI npo.nyKTa, ,n;OXO,n;bI OT KOTOpbIX npeBbICHT 3aTPaTbI Ha HX npoH3BO,n;CTBO.

B maDe 11 BbI Ha~eTe ,n;eTaJIbHOe onHcaHHe TOro, KaK cnpoc H npeLIJIO)KeHHe C03,n;aIOT COUHaJlbHO OnTHMaJIbHbIit npo.nyKT, a :meCb H XotIY npeLIJIO)KHTb BaM TOJIbKO KpaTKHit 0030p. B3rJIHHHTe Ha pHC. 14.1, r,n;e HatIeptIeHa KPHBaH cnpoca H KpHBaH npeLIJIO)KeHHH Mopo)KeHoro. PbIHOtIHoe PaBHOBecHoe KOJIH'IeCTBO npo.nyKTa paDHO q",a PbIHO'IHaH paBHOBeCHaH ueHa - PO.

q'

Kon~ecTBo

PHC. 14. 1. C '19TKO onpe,o,eneHHblMH npsB8MH C06CTB9HHOCTH PblHOK npOH3BO,D,HT COL{HanbHO onTHManbHoe KOnH'I9CTBO npo,o,yKTS q'

298 '1acn. III. MMKPGaKOHOMMKa - HayKa 0 n08e,qeHMM norpe6KreneM Mnpe.qnpMflTMM

BaxHO OC03HaTb, 'ITO MSI 06mecTBa llOJIe3HO rrpOH3BO,lJ.HTb Ka.XOJYlO e,1J.HHHuY TOBapa, BhI­ rrymel1HylO ,lJ.0 (H BKJIIO'Iall:) q'. Y3HaTb, rro'leMY 3TO CrrpaBe,1J,JIHBO, BhI CMOlKeTe, eCJIH HCCJIe­ )J.yere e,lJ.HHHuY qo- Ha KPHBOit crrpoca Moxim YBH)l.eTb, 'ITO rrOIcyrrareJIH rorOBhI IIJIanm. I.(eHY

Po 3a e,1J.HHHuY qo, HO MSI rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBa e,1J.HHHI.(hI qorrpoH3BO,lJ.HTeJIH 3aTpaTHJIH TOm.Kb Co­ qTO 3TO 03Ha'laeT? 06.w;all: y,lJ.OBJIeTBOpeHHOCTb 06.w;ecTBa YBeJIH'lHBaeTCH rrpH rrpOH3BO,lJ.­

CTBe e,lJ.HHHI.(hI qo, rrOCKOJIbKY rrOIDlJHO, 'ITO CTOHMOCTb ee rrOJIe3HOCm MSI JIIO,lJ.eH rrpeBhIlllaeT CTOHMOCTb pecypCOB, HCrrOJIb30BaHHhIA)J.JlH ee C03,lJ.aHHH. TIOCKOJIbKY KpHBaH crrpoca pacrro­ JIaraeTCH Ha,lJ. KpHBOit rrpe,1J,JIoxceHHH )J.JlH Bcex e,1J.HHHI.(, rrpOH3Be,lJ.eHHbIX ,lJ.0 H BKJIIO'Iall: q', Bce 3TH e,lJ.HHHL(hI ~BJIHIOTCH BhIfO,lJ.HhIMH )J.JlH rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBa.

Kax: 06bHCHHeTCH B maBe 11, Y PbIHKOB eCTb O,lJ.Ha "rrpeBOCXO,lJ.Hall: 'lePTa" - rrpe,lJ.­ JIOXCeHHe H crrpoc B3aHMO,lJ.eHCTBYIOT TaKHM 06pa30M, 'ITO rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBO BhI)J.aeT rrpo.u.yKT Ha COI.(HaJIbHO OIITHMaJIbHOM ypOBHe, q'. Ee3YCJIOBHO, TOT <paKT, 'ITO :lTO

rrOJIY'laeTCH B pe3YJIbTaTe rrpeCJIe,lJ.OBaHHH JIIO,lJ.bMH c06CTBeHHbIX HHTepeCOB, 06b­ HCHHeT rrOBe,lJ.eHHe PbIHKOB. TIoxoxce, 6y.u.ro HeBH,1J.HMall: PYKa HeKoero ,lJ.06poro 60­ XeCTBa BOJIIIIe6HbIM 06pa30M rrpeBpa.w;aeT rrpeCJIe,lJ.OBaHHe C06CTBeHHhIX I.(eJIeH B rrpo.u.yKT, rrpHHocHmHit rrOJIbJy 06mecTBy.

A CeH'IaC H rrOCTapalOCb ,lJ.OKa3aTb, 'ITO TaKoit XOpoIIIHit pe3YJIbTaT ,lJ.OCTHraeTCH TOm.KO TOr,lJ.a, KOr,lJ.a rrpaBa C06CTBeHHOCTH orrpe,lJ.eJIeHhI ~e.tlU1WM u nOAHocmblO, 'ITO 3Ha'lHT - KPH­

Ball: crrpoca B6HpaeT B ce6H Bce BhIro,lJ.hI, 3a KOTophIe JIIO,lJ.H roTOBbI IIJIaTHTb, a KpHBall: rrpe,lJ.­ JIOXCeHHH OXBaThIBaeT Bce H3,lJ.ep:lKKH, CBH3aHHhIe C rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBOM. KaK BbI caMH CMoxceTe y6e,lJ.HTbCH, eCJIH rrpaBa c06CTBeHHocm ,lJ.OJI:lKHhIM 06pa30M He orrpe,lJ.eJIeHhI, PhIHOK He CMO­ xceT rrpoH3BO,lJ.HTb rrpo.u.yKT Ha COI.(HaJIbHO OIITHMaJIbHOM ypOBHe rrO,lJ.06HO q'. B TaKHX CJIY'l8.ll:X

, rrpe,lJ.rrOJIaraeMall: HeBH)l.HMall: PYKa rrpeBpa.w;aeTCH B (jeUcm8Ume.tlbHO HeBH)l.HMYJO - rrOCKOJIbKY ee B caMOM ,lJ.eJIe HeT!

tlCCJ.e9'1eJt 'JteIMJtI4e 3rprpe~bt:3aliiftalMt

II, 'btZ09bt , ju!3'1.,lb~aJlie JtalMtLX geucJIi6'uu

TIpaBa C06CTBeHHOCm rrpe,lJ.OCTaBJIHIOT CBOHM BJla,lJ.eJIbL(aM rrpaBO KOHTpOJIH Ha,lJ. HX c06­ CTBeHFfOCTblO. HarrpHMep, CBOit co6cTBeHHhIit aBTOM06HJIb H'MOry rrOKPaCHTb B TOT QBeT, KO­ TOPhIH MHe 3a6JIaropaCCY,lJ.HTCH. 3axoqy - MO,1J.H<pHI.(HPYlO ,lJ.BHraTeJIb HJIH BhIXJIOrrHYJO Tpy6y. jJ: Taae HMelO B03MO)KHOCTb YCTaHOBHTb 6oJIbIIIHe, 6JIeCTH.w;He 19-,lJ.IOHMOBhIe KOJIeCa, CTapa­ HCb CKPhITb TOT <paKT, 'ITO H, rrO,lJ.06HO 60JIbWHHCTBy 3KOHOMHCTOB, He TaKoit yx H KPyro~t

C ,lJ.pyrOH CTOpOHhI, rrpaBac06cTBeHHOCTHHe MOryT 6hITb C(>BepIIIeHHO HeorpaHH'IeH­ HhIMH. 06.w;eCTBOM YCTaHOBJIeHhI o~e,lJ.eJIeHHhIerpaHHI.(hI TOro, 'ITO H HMelO npaBO C,lJ.eJIaTb CO cBoeit MaIIIHHoH. HarrpHMep, H He MOry 6hITb HCTO'lHHKOM IIIyMa, eCJIH MHe. K rrpHMe~ py, B3.u.yMaeTCH CHHTb mYIIIHTeJIb. jJ: He MOry BeCTH MaIIIHHY CO CKOpOCTblO 60JIee 90 MHJIb B 'lac, eCJIH 6y.u.y rrpoe3xcaTb PMOM C HaqaJIbHoit IIIKOJIOit. He3aKOHHhIM 6Y,lJ.eT C4HTaTbCH H TO, eCJIH rr03,1J.HHM Be'lepOM MHe B3.u.yMaeTCH BKJIIO'IHTb CBOR 2000-aaTTHhIR cTepeOMarHHTo<poH

Ha rroJIHYJO rpoMKOCTb.

TIpWIHHa TOro, 'ITO 3aKOHOM MHe 3aIIpemeHO COBepIIIaTb nO,lJ.06HhIe ,lJ.eHCTBHH, 3aKJIlO'Ia­ eTCH B TOM, 'ITO XCHBY H He Ha c06cTBeHHoM ocTpoBe. jJ: XCHBY B o6mecTBe, r,lJ.e KPOMe MeHH eCTb Macca ,lJ.PyrHX JIIO,lJ.eR, a 06HJIHe wyMOBbIX 3<P<PeKTOB HJIH BO:lK,1J.eHHe Ha 60JIbIIIOH CKOpO­ cm MoxceT nOBJIHHTb Ha ypoBeHb HX XCH3HH. 3KOHOMHCThI onHChlBaIOT 3TY CHTYaQHIO, YTBep­

:lK,1J.all:, 'ITO MOH ,lJ.eRCTBHH BbI3bIBaIOT

'"

OnpeAeneHMe n03MTMBHbiX M HeraTMBHblX BHeWHMX acl»cI»eKToB

BHeUJHUe 3¢¢eKmbl, 3KCmepHaIlUU, - 3TO 3aTPaThl HJIH Bblro.lU>I, KOTOpble Bblna,zJ;aioT He TOJlbKOoHa .Ilomo qeJlOBeKa (mO.lleit), HanpHMYJO CBH3aHHOro C .IlewreJlbHOCTbIO, HO H Ha·.IlPY­ rnx. BHeIllHHe 341<PeKTbI MOryr 6hITb n03HTHBHblMH H HeraTHBHblMH.

HeAocrsrKH ytfers 3SrpSr, HSnSrSeMIJIX HS ApyrHX

B cJIY'lae 3arpH3HeHHH OKPYJKaIOmeit cpe.llbl CTaJIeJIHTeitHblM npOH3BO.llCTBOM ero ynpaB­ JIHIOmHe npHHHMaIOT B paCqeT JlHlIIb Co6cTBeHHble H3,Ilep)I{KH - T.e. CTOHMOCTb CblpbH H pa­

60Ty 3aBO.Ila•. 3To npOHCXO.llHT no npHtIHHe TIJlOXO onpe.lleJIeHHblX npaB Co6CTBeHHOCTH B 3TOM pemOHe.

ECJlH 6bl KTO-TO BJla.ueJI aTMOC<Pepoit, TO ynpaBJIHIOIIJ;He CTaJleJIHTe1tHblM 3aBO.IlOM .IlOJDKHbl 6bIJ1H 6bl 3aTIJIaTHTb 3a npaBO Bbl6pacblBaTb B Hee 3arpH3HHIOmHe BeInecrna. 11 eCJIH aTMOC<Pe­ pa HaXO.llHJIaCb 6bl B C06CTBeHHOCTH JlIO.Ileit, KOTOpble .IlOJDKHbl 6blJ1H 6bl ,IlblmaTb B paitoHe 3arpH3HeHHH, TO 4lHPMY 3aCTaBHJIH 6bl TIJlaTHTb 3THM JlIOMM 3a npaBO 3arpH3HHTb HX B03.!lYX, H B TaKOM cJIY'lae OHa 6blJ1a 6bl BbIJIY)K,lleHa CqHTaTbCH C TeM Bpe.llOM, KOTOPblit npHtIHHHeT npHH3,lI,JIe)l{aIIJ;Hit eit 3aBO.ll, 3arpH3HHH B03.!lYX.

Ho nOCKOJlbKY HHKTO H3 Hac He JlBJIHeTCH C05CTBeHHHKOM aTMOC<PePbl H HHKaKHe 4lHPMbl He .IlOJl)l{Hbl TIJlaTHTb 3a npaBO ee 3arpH3HHTb, TO He CYIIIeCTByeT H npaBO­ BOro MeXaHH3p.1a ,IlJIH TOro, 'IT06bl 3aCTaBHTb ynPaBJIHIOmHX CTaJIeJIHTeitHblM 3aBO­

.IlOM npHHHTb B pacqeT H3,Ilep.lKKH Ha 3arpH3HeHHe B03.llYX3, KOTOpble Bblna.uaIOT Ha

.IlOJlIO tt1IeHOB 60Jlee lIIHPOKOro co06IIJ;ecTBa. B pe3YJIbTaTe n0JIY'laeTCH, 'ITO 4lHPMa nepenpOH3BO.llHT CTaJIb.

AaBa1he B KalleCTBe npHMepa paCCMOTPHM ypOBeHh npo.zxyKTll , KOTOPhlit paCnOJIO)KeH Me­ xc.ny qs« H (J"'. EcJrH nO,llHHThCH sepmKaJIhHO BBepx OT .n.o nepecelleHIDI C KpHBOit cnpoca, TO BhI YBH.lI.HTe, liTO PhIHOllHaJI ~eHa, KOTOPYIO JIIO.n.H roTOBhI nJIaTHTh 3ll 3TOT yposeHh npo.n.yK­ Ta, npeBhlWaeT co6cTBeHHhle npe.n.eJIhHhIe H~ep)KJQf Ha ee npOH3BO.n.CTBO. (3TO 03HallaeT, lITO KpHBaJI cnpoca HaxO.n.HTCH Ha.n. KpHBOit "tIaCTHhIe Me;' Ha ypOBHe npo.lI.yxTa .) Ho eCJIH Bhl

nO,llHHMeTeCh ewe BhIwe, TO YBH.lI.HTe, lITO Ta CYMMa, KOTOPYIO JIIO,llH roTOBhl nJIaTHTb 3a STOT YPOBeHh npo,llyKTIl, 6Y,lleT ,lleACTBHTeJIhHO MeHbWe COBOKYJIHOA, C yqeroM CO~a.m.HhIXH3,llep­

xeK, CTOHMOCTH npOH3BO,llCTBa 3TOro npo.nyKTa. (3TO 3HallHT, lITO KpHBaJI "06weCTBeHHhIe

Me" pacnOJIO)KeHa BhIwe KpHBoA cnpoca Ha ypOBHe npo.lI.yxTa .)

YpOBeHh npo,llyKTa He ,llOJI)KeH 6hITb npOH3Be,lleH, nOCKOJIbKY COBOKYllHlUI CTOHMOCTb ero rrpOH3BO,llCTBa npeBhIwaeT CYMMy, KOTOPYIO KTO-JIH60 6Y,lleT roTOB 3a Hero 3anJIaTHTb. TI03TOMY ypOBeHb npO.LlYKTa qm, ¢laKTHlIeCKH npOH3Be,lleHHhIA PhIHOllHOA 3KOHOMHKOA, HB­ JIHeTCH HeXeJIaTeJIbHblM. KIDK.n:1UI e,llHHHua STOro npOH3Be.lleHHoro npo,nyKTa, KOTOPlUl npeBhI­ waeT YP0BeHb qroc, eCTh e,llHHHUa,.llJIH KOTOpoA CYMMapHhIe 3llTPaThI npeBhlwaIOT nOJIyqaeMhle OT Hee BbIro,llbi.

nO"leMy Bbi XOTMTe HeKOTOpOrO KOnM"IeCTBa

HefaTMBHblX BHeWHMX 3c1»cI»eKToB

OlleHb B8XHO nOHSlTb, liTO pacnpOCTPaHeHHlUI peaKUHSI Ha HeraTHBHhIe BHeWHHe 3¢1­ cPeKThI - "TIOCTaBHM HX BHe 3aKOHa!" - nOllTH HHKOr.lla He 6Y.lleT COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHoA. B3rJISlHHTe elll,e paJ Ha pHC. 14.2 H OTMeTbTe, lITO COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHhIA npo.llyxT 'I'D<: ­ nOJlO)l(HTeJIbHOe qHCJIO. 3To 03HallaeT, lITO npoH3BO.llCTBO CTaJIH 6Y,lleT COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIb­ HhIM .llaxe npH yCJIOBHH, lITO BMeCTe C HelO 6Y,lleT npOH3BO.llHThCH H HeKoTopoe 3arpSl3HeHHe oKpyxaIOllI,eA Cpe.llhI.

AlQKe 3HlUI 0 TOM, liTO 60JIbWHe, "nHTaIOUlHeCH" TOnJIHBOM MaIDHJIhI, npoH3BOlUlT Heno­ MepHoe KOJlHlleCTBO COBepweHHO 6ecnOJIe3HhIX 3arpH3HHIOllI,HX BemeCTB, BhI .lleACTBHTeJIbHO XOTHTe H36aBHThCSI OT Bcex MawHH, BKJlIOqlUl MaWHHhI CKOpOit nOMomH H noxapHhIx rpy­ 30BHKOB? MHe K8XeTCSI, lITO HeT: XOTH MaIDHHhI H 3arpH3HHIOT OKpyxaIOUlYIO cpe.llY, Te/H3­ ,llep)l(lQl, KOTOphIe 06meCTBO HeceT B CBSl3H C 3arpSl3HeHHeM, 60JIee qeM KOMneHCHPYIOTCSI HX COUHaJIbHOA nOJIe3HOCTbIO - Be.llb OHH npOBOlUlT OlleHb BaJKHYIO .llJIH JIIO.n.eit cnaCaTeJIbHYIO ,lleSlTeJlbHOCTh. ,

To xe caMoeOTHOCHTCH H K JarpH3HeHHIO, npOH3BO.llHMOMY CTaJIeJIHTeitHhI:M 3aBo.n.OM npH npOH3BO,llCTBe npO.llyxTa Ha ypoBHe qsoc. E.llHHCTBeHHhIA cnoc06 nOJIHOCThIO H36aBHThCSI OT 3arpH3HeHHH, npOH3Bo.n.HMoro CTaJIeJIHTeAHbIM3aBO,llOM, 3aKJIIOlIaeTCH B ero 3aKphITHH. Ho STO 6Y,lleT 03HallaTh, liTO y 06ll1,ecTBa OTHHM}'T BCIO nOJIe3HOCTb, KOTOPYIO npe.llOCTaBJISleT eMY CTaJIb: HarrpHMep, nOCTPoitKH, YCToAlIHBhle K 3eMJIeTPSlCeHIDIM, HJIH CaJIOHhI aSTOM06HJIeA, KOTOphle 3aUJ,HllI,aIOT naCCaxHpoB, nOnaBWHX B asapHIO.

~He HYJIOfO 3~8B8ThCJI UeJlblO yHH'ITOJKHTb HeraTHBHbIe BHeWHHe 3cPcPeJcr'bI. BMecTO 3TOro HYJIOfO rapllHTHPOBaTb, 'ITO Kor,na B3BeWHBlUOTCJI tlce 3aTPaThl H tlC1I nOJIb3a,

TO nOJIytleHHaJI BbIro,na OT npoH3Be,neHHbIX e,nHHHU npo,nYKTa 6y,neT npeBbIwaTb

38TPaTbI Ha HX npOH3BO,nCTBO - C yqeTOM H3,nep:xceK Ha HeraTHBHbIe BHeWHHe 3cP­ cPeKTh1. Ha pHC. 14.2 ,It1IJI Bcex e,nHHHU npo,nYKTa, npoH3Be,neHHhIx ,no H BKJIJO':IaJI qsoc, 06maJI nOJIe3HOCTb KaK MHHHMYM pasHa cYMMapHbIM H3,nepJKIC8.M, ':ITO 3Ha':lHT: B UeJlOM 06weCTBO nOJIytlaeT nOJIb3Y OT npOH3BO,nCTBa 3THX e,llHHHU.

Cne,nYJQwee. B lIeM Hy:xcHO pa306paThCJI. - 3TO KaK rapaHTHpOBaTb, ':ITO npOH3Be,neHO TOJIbKO qsoc e,nHHHU npO.nyKTa, Kor,na (KaK 3TO npo,neMOHCTPHpOBaHO B npe,llbUlYIUeM pa3,lJ;eJIe) PbIHOK CKJIOHeH nepenpOH3BO,llHTb TOBapbI C HeraTHBHbIMH BHeWHHMH 3<txl>eKTaMH.

CMRr'leHMe Hef8TMBHblX BHeWHMX 3c1»cI»eKToB

ECTh TPH OCHOBHbIX cnoc06a CMSIT':IeHHJl HeraTHBHbIX BHeWHHX 3<1><I>eKTOB•

./ IIpHHJlTHe 3aKOHOB, 3aIIpemaJOWHX HJIH OrpaHH':lHBaJOWHX aKTHBHOCTh, KOTO­ paR reHepHPyeT HeraTHBHbIe BHeWHe 9<I><PeKThl. HanpHMep, cemac B 6oJThWHH­ CTBe roPO,llOB BaM 3aIIpeIUaIOT H36aBIDrrbcg OT M}'Copa nyTeM ero C:lICHraHHj:J•

./ IIpHHj:JTHe 3aKOHOB. KOTOpbIe Hanpj:JMYJO HanpaBJIeHhI npOTHB BHewHero 9<1>­

<l>eKTa (BMecTo TOro, 'lT06bI 3anpew.aTb ,llegTeJIbHOCTb, KOTOpaR npHBeJIa K B03HHKHOBeHHltI BHeWHero 3<1><I>eKTa). HanpHMep, OT CTaJIeJIHTeHHbIX 3aBO­ ,llOB ceif'lac TPe6yeTCg yCTaHoBKa ra300llHCTHTeJIeH Ha ,llhIMOBhIX TPy6ax, KO­ TophIe B6HpaJOT B ce6g 60JIbWYJO lIaCTb Bpe,llHbIX BemeCTB H3 ra3006pa3HhIX OTXO,llOB npOH3BO,llCTBa CTaJIH; B pe3YJIbTaTe B aTMoc<I>epy nona.naeT MeHbwe 3arpH3HgJOmHX ee BeWeCTB•

./ B03JIo:xceHHe paCXO,llOB - TaKHX, KaK HaJIOrn - Ha JIJO,lleH HJIH <l>HPMhI, KOTO­ pbIe reHepHPYJOT HeraTHBHhIe BHeWHHe 3<txl>eKTbI. HanpHMep, 3a I<ll)I{,llylO TOH­

MY 3arpg3HgIOmHX semeCTB, KOTophIe npOH3BO,llHT onpe,lleJIeHHbIe KOMnaHHH, rocy,llapCTBO MO:XCeT nOTpe60BaTb OT HHX ynJIaTbI ,lleHeJKHOH KOMneHcaUHH.

IIocJIe,llHee H3 BhIWenepeqHCJIeHHbIX Tpex peweHHH OlleHb HpaBHTCg 3KOHOMHCT8M, no­ CKOJIbKy HMeHHO 3TO peweHHe 6bICTpee Bcero npHBe,lleT K npOH3BO,llCTBY npo.nyKTa Ha COUH­ aJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHOM ypOBHe.

BbI Mo:xceTe YBH,lleTb, noqeMy 3KOHOMHCTaM TaK HpaBHfcg HaJIOrn Ha KOMnaHHH, 3arpH3­ HgIOWHe 0KPy:xcaIOWYJO cpe.ny, eCJIH BepHeTeCb OnHTb K pHC. 14.2. BCnOMHHTe, 'ITO XC - no CTOHMOCTb BHeWHero 3<1><I>eKTa CTaJIeJlHTeHHOro 38B0,lla, 3arpg3HgIOwero 0KPY:lICaJOID;YJO cpe­ ,lly H Bpe,llHwero ,llpyrHM. ECJIH rocy,llapCTBOM YCT8.HOBJIeH HaJJor B XC ,llOJIJIapOB Ha Kll)«,llyIO e,llHHHuY CTaJIH, npoH3Be,lleHHOH 3TOH KOMnaHHeH, HaJIOr nO,llHHMeT KPHBYJO 3aTpaT <l>HpMhI BePTHKaJIbHO BBepx - H3 n03HUHH "lJ.aCTHhIe MC' B n03HUHIO "06wecTBeHHbIe MC".

YCTaHOBKa HaJIOra Ha 3arpg3HeHHe 0KPy:xcaIOWeH Cpe,llbI npH TO':IHO XC ,llOJIJIapax BhIH}')K­ ,llaeT KPHBYJO npe,lleJIbHbIX 3aTpaT <l>HpMhI paCnOJIOXHTbCg TO'IHO TaM, r,lle pa3MewaeTCg KPH­ BaR "06meCTBeHHbIe MC'. IIOCKOJIbKy KPHBM npe,lleJIbHbIX 3aTpaT <l>HpMbI - 3TO KPHBaR ee npe,llJIO)l(eHHJl, B pe3yJIbTaTe, Kor,lla cnpoc H npe,llJIo:xceHHe Ha'lHHaIOT B3aHMO,lleHCTBOBaTb, Ha'lHHaeT npOH3BO,llHTbCg npo.nyKT Ha COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJJbHOM ypOBHe qJOC.

3TO 03HallaeT, liTO, yCTaHoBHB npgMOH HaJIOr Ha CTaJIb, rocy,llapCTBO MO)l(eT caMOyCTpa­ HHTbCg H n03BOJIHTb pbIHKy ,llO,lleJIaTb Bce OCTaJIbHoe. 3T0 ,lleJIaeT CTparernIO, HanpaBJIeHHYIO Ha COKpaweHHe 3arpg3HeHHg OKpy:xcaIOweH Cpe,llbI, O'leHb BhIHrpbIWHOH no cpaBHeHHIO C ,llpyrHMH nOTeHUHaJThHbIMH peWeHHJlMH.

· CpaBHHTe nO,lJ.06HOe peIIIeHHe C CHCTeMOH, npH KOTOpoH <pHPMaM npe,lJ.nHChIBaioT yCTa­ HaBJIHBaTb ra300'lHCTHTeJIH Ha ,llhlMOBhIX TPy6ax .LJ.]IJI COKPameHIDI KOJIH'leCTBa 3al'pR3ID1IOmHX BemeCTB. ITPH 3TOH CHCTeMe BaM H}')KHO 6Y,lJ.eT OIUIatIHBaTb pa60Ty CneUHaJIbHhIX HHCneKTO­ pOB, KOTOpbIe ,lJ.OJDKHbI 6y,!J.YT nOCTORHHO KYPHpOBaTb 3aBO,lJ.bI C TeM, '1r06bI y6e,lJ.HThCR: OHH He )l{fJIbHH'lalOT. ITO,lJ.06HOe peIIIeHHe HaMHoro 60JIee ,lJ.oporoe B HCnOJIHeHHH, '1eM npOCTaR ycTaHOBKa HaJIOra Ha JIerKO H3MepReMoe KOJIHtIeCTBO npOH3Be.n;eHHoH CTaJIH H .n;aJIbHeHIIIee "n03BOJIeHHe" CaMOMY MexaHH3MY BJaHMO,lJ.eHCTBIDI cnpoca H npe,lJ.JlO:llCeHIDI YCTaHaBJIHBaTb COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHbIi!: ypOBeHb npo,!J.YKTa.

C ,lI.pyroH GTOpOHbI, onpe,lJ.eJIeHHe TO'IHOH BeJIH'lHHbI HaJIOra XC MO:llCeT OKaJaTbCH CJIO:llC­ HOi!: 3a,lJ.a'lei!:, TaK 'ITO CHCTeMa YCTaHOBJIeHIDI HaJIOroB Ha 3arpR3HeHHe 0KPyxalOmeH cpe.n;bI TOJKe He JIHIIIeHa He,lJ.pcTaTKOB.

PaC'IeT 110CneACTBMM n03MTMBHbiX BHeWHMX Sct»ct»8KTOB

a;~....-r. BHeIIIHHe 3<p<peKTbl MOryT 6bITb KaK HeraTHBHble, TaK H n03HTHBHble. OCHOBHoe, fir ;h< 'ITO HyxHO nOHHTb 0 n03HTHBHhIX BHeIIIHHX 3<P<PeKTaX, 3m 'ITO TOBapbI H ycnyrH,

~' KOTOpbIe npe.n;OCTaBJIHlOT n03HTHBHble BHeIIIHHe 3<P<PeKTbl1J)eTl>eH CTOpOHe, npH­ BO,lI.HT K BbInycKY npO,!J.YKUIDI B He.n;OCTaTO'lHOM KOJIHtIeCTBe.

npOH3BO,qCTBO He,qOCTBTOlfHOro lConHlfeCTBB TOBBpOB, KOTopble Bbl31J1BBIOT n03HTHBHblH BHeWHHH 3f/Jf/JelCT'

~M~ AJm TOro 'IT06h1 yaH,lJ.eTb, nO'leMY TOaapbI BhIIlYCKaIOTCR B He.n;OCTaTOtIHOM KOJIH'le­ CTBe,,lJ.aBaHre npe,lJ.CTaBHM ce6e ll'IeJIOBO,lJ.a no HMeHH Carr.rrH. Carr.rrH Pa3BO,lUIT ll'IeJI,

~ n03TOMY OHa MO:llCeT np0,lJ.aTb Me,lJ. H Japa60TaTb 3HHYlO CYMMY .n;eHer. JIIO,lJ.H, noKY­

•

nalOmHe ee. Me.n;, 6y,!J.YT 3TO .n;eJIaTb, nOCKOJIbKY Me.n; npHHOCHT HM nOJIb3y. Ho no­ CKOJIbKY ll'IeJIbI CaJIJIH JIeTalOT noBCIO,lJ.y, onblJIIDl UBeTbI Ha nOJUlX MecTHhIX <PePMe­ pOB, HX BJIa,lJ.eJlbUhI TaK:lKe nOJIY'laJOT n0JIb3Y OT ee ntIeJIOBO.n;qecKOH .n;eRreJIbHOCTH.

Ho - H 3,lJ.eCb HaCTYllaeT KPHTH'IeCKHH MOMeHT - <PePMepbI He IUlaTHT CllIIJIH Ja TY nOJIb­ 3Y, KOTOPYlO ee ll'IeJIbI npHHOCHT HM; ntIeJIhI CBo60.n;HO JIeTalOT no pa3HbIM nOJIHM, H He cyme­ CTByeT cnoc06a npoCJle,lJ.HTh Ja HX nOJIeTOM. B pe3YJIbTaTe CaJIJIH 6Y,lJ.eT YCTaHaBJIHBaTb MeHb­ IIIee KOJIH'leCTBO YJIbeB C ll'IeJIaMH, '1eM OHa Morna 6bI, eCJlH 6bI <PePMepbI IUlaTHJIH eH Ja TY n0JIb3y, KOTOPYlO ee ll'IeJIbi npHHOCHT HX ypo:lKaHM.

Bbi MO:llCeTeyaH,lJ.eTb 3m, eCJlH nOCMQTPHTe Ha pHC. 14.3. KPHBaR npe,lJ.JlO:llCeHIDI CaJIJIH­ 3TO KPHBaR ee rrpe,lJ.eJIbHhIX JaTPaT, H H o603Ha'IHJI ee S = MC. Cnpoc Ha ee Me,lJ. y n<npe6HTe­ JIei!:, KOTOpbIe IUlaTHT 3a Hero, H Ha3BaJI "qacTHbIH cnpoc". B TO'lKe, r.n;e KPHBaR npe,lJ.JlO:llCe­

H~ H KPHBaR "qaCTHhIH cnpoc" nepeceKalOTCH, HaxO,lJ.HTCR PhIHO'lHaR paBHOBeCHaR BeJIH'IH­ HaMe,lJ.a, qm.

Ho 3TOT YP0BeHb npO.nyKTa He npHHHMaeT B paC'IeT TOH nOJIb3h1, KOTOPYlO ll'IeJIbi npH­ HOCJIT <PePMepaM. IIpe,lJ.noJIo:lKHM, 'ITO 3Ta nOJIb3a HMeeT ,lJ.OJIJIapoBblH 3KBHBaJIeHT B XB, 'ITO 03Ha'laeT nOJIe3HOCTb BHeIIIHero 3<P<PeKTa. CoBOKYllHblH 06meCTBeHHblH cnpoc Ha Me,lJ. CaJIJIH BhlPaxeH KPHBOH: "06meCTBeHHblH cnpoc", KOTOPaR nepeMeCTHJIa KPHBYlO "qaCTHbIH cnpoc" BepTHKaJIbHO BBepx Ha XB ,lJ.0JIJl. ,lJ.JlH TOro, 'IT06bI yqeCTb <PaKT, 'ITO npoH3BO.n;cTBO Me.n;a npH­ HOCHT nOJIb3Y <pepMepaM TO'IHO TaK :lICe, KaK H "Me.n;oJl106HBbIM" nOKYllaTeJISIM CllIIJIH.

S=MC

tU

!

06UUlCTBeHHbl'l cnpoc= 4aCTHblil cnpoc +XB

4aCTHblil cnpoc

qm qSOC

KOnl'l"leCTBO

PHC. 14.3. PblHOK npoH3sCJ,QHT HeAOCTaTO'lHOe KOnH'IecTso Tosapa, KOTOpblH

OKa3b1SaeT n03HTHSHblil sHewHHH aeJ>f/>eKT

COlJ,HaJIbHO OllTHMaJIbHhIH ypoBeHb IIpo,llyICI'll, qsoc, 6y,neT HaxO,nHTbCH B TO'lKe IIepece'le­ HHH KPHBOH "06meCTBeHHhIH crrpoc" H KPHBOH IIpe,lI,JIOXeHHH CaruIH, IIOCKOJIbKY ,l(JIH KaX­ ,nOH e,nHHHJ..Ud IIpO,nYKTIl, rrpoH3Be,neHHoH,n0 H BKJIIO'laH ere, COBOKYIIHaH COlJ,HaJIbHllH BbITO,lJ,a KaK MHHHMYM pauHa rrpoH3BO,nCTBeHHhIM JaTPaTaM CaruIH.

KaK BbI MOXeTe BH,lJ,eTb, IIpOH3Be,neHHaH PbIHO'lHaH paBHOBeCHaH BeJIH'lHHa, qm, Memwe COlJ,HaJIbHO OIITHMaJIbHOro ypoBHH rrpo,llyICI'll, q'O". ,LlpyrHMH CJIOBaMH, IIOCKOJIbKY PbIHO'lHbIH MexaHH3M He MMeeT B03MOXHOCTM yqeCTb II03HTMBHbIH BHeWHHH 3c1>$eKT, CaJIJIH IIpoH3BO­

.nuT Memnle Me,na, qeM HYXHO,l(JlH CQOTBeTCTBHH COlJ,HaJIbHO OllTMMaJIbHOMY KOJIM'IecTBy.

llPOH3BO,nCTBO He,nOCTaTO'lHOrO KOJIH'leCTB8. TOuapoB TMIIH'lHO ,l(JIH TOBapoB, KOTO­ pbIe reHepHPYIOT II03MTMBHhIe BHeUIHHe 3<lxPeKTbI. llOCKOJIbKY rrpaua C06cTBeH­ HOCTM YCTaHOBJIeHhI TaKHM 06PaJOM, 'iTO pelJ,HIIHeHTbl II03MTMBHhIX BHeWHHX 3¢l­

4>eKTOB He ,nOJI)KHhI 3a mix IIJIaTH1"b, rrpOH3BO.nMTeJIb TOuapa, reHepHpYIOmero IIO­ 3HTHBHhle BHeIIIHHe 34>4>eKTbI, He HMeeT cTMMYJIa IIPOH3BO,nMTb ,nOIIOJIHHTeJIbHOe KOJIH'leCTBO rrpo.nyKTa B IIOJIb3Y TeX, KTO IIOJIyqaeT II03MTMBHbIH BHeWHHH ~KT.

BMecTO 3TOTO OH IIpOH3BO,nMT rrpO.nyKT TOJIbKO ,l(JIH Tex JIl0,neH, ,KOTOpbIe MOryT Ja Hero JaIIJIaTMTb.

Cy6CJf,ltJfpOBBHJfe ,lteflTen"HOCTJf, KOropSfI

npOJf3BO,ltJfT nb3JfTJfBHwii BHeWHJfii 34Jct>eKT

llOCKOJIbKY PbIHKH MMeIOT TeH,lJ;eHlJ,HIO K He,nOCTaTO'lHOMY rrpOH3BO,nCTBy TOuapoB H YCJIYf, KOTOphIe HMelOT II03MTMBHbIe BHeWHHe 3CP4>eKTbI, JIIO,nH ,nOJI)KHhI H306peTaTb CIIOC06h1 co­

,neHCTBHH 60JIee BbICOKHM rP0BHHM rrpoH3BO,nCTBa. ,-

CaMhIH paCIIpocTPaHeHHhIH cIIoc06 co,neHCTBHH 60JIee BbICOKOMY ypoBHIO rrpoH3­ Bo,nCTBa TOBapOB, KOTOphIe reHepMPY1<>T II03HTMBHbIeBHeWHHe 34><l>eKTbI, - 3TO IIpe,nOCTaBJIeHHe cy6c:H.D;HH. B CJIyqae C rrqenOBO,nqecKHM 6H3HeCOM CanJIH rocy.nap­ CTBO MoxeT BblIIJIaTMTb eH cy6cH,nHIO - CKaXeM, B paJMepe 20 lJ,eHTOB Ja 4>yHT, ­

,IJJUI TOro 'IT06bl C03,ll,aTb Y Hee CTHMYJI JJ:epJlCaTb 60JIbWee KOJIH'leCTBO YJIbeB. ~ pe­

3YJIbTare 60JIbWee KOJIH'IeCTBO nqeJI OnbIJUrr 60JIbWee KOJIH'IeCTBO QBeTOB, 'ITO npHBe,o;eT K 60JIee BblCOKOMY YPOBHIO npO,llyKTHBHOCTH <l>epMepcKHX XO:ul~CTB. B JJ:e:l1CTBHTeJTbHOCTH rocYJJ:apcTBO MOXeT ycTaHOBHTb CneQHSJIbHbl~HSJIOr JJ:JUI <l>epMe­

POB, 'Iro6b1 nOJIY'lHTb JJ:eHbrH JJ:JUI Cy6(:HJJ:HPOBaHHJI rrqeJI CaruIH. 3Ta Mepa CJJ:eJIaeT nporpaMMY CllMo4lHHaHcHPYIOweAc$I.

TIoxmKHM 06pa30M roCYJJ:apCTBO qaCTO Cy6cHJJ:HpyeT nOCll,lI;KY JJ:epeBbeB lia TeppHTOpHH H

3a npe)leJIaMH roPOJJ:OB. OHO JJ:OJI)I(HO 310 JJ:eJIaTb, nOCKOJIbKY pa3HbIe BHJJ:bl nOJIb3bl OT JJ:epeBb­ eB - reHb, npOXJIll,lI;a, 60JIee 'IHCTbl~ B03,D;YX, MeHbwe rpYHTOBOA 3P03HH H T.,o;. - $lBJI$lIOTC$I n03HTHBHblMH BHeWHHMH 3lPlPeKTaMH, KOTophIe He yqHTblBaIOTC$I pblHKOM. Be3 3TOA Cy6CH­ ,o;HH Hac C BaMH OKpyxaTlO 6hI MeHbwee KOJIH'IeCTBO ,llepeBbeB, qeM He06xo,llHMO JUUl: COQH­ aJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHOro YPOBH$I.

BIDKHYIO 3KOHOMWleCKYIO np06JIeMY, KOTOPlUI npOHCTeKaeT H3 nJIOXO npOJJ:YMaHHbIX npaB c06CTBeHHOCTH, He yqHThIBaJOIUHX HeraTHBH\de BHeWHHe 3<l>lPeKTbl, 3KOHOMHCThI Ha3hIBaIOT "Tpare.n:Heil 06IUHH". B CJIeJlYlOIUHX pa3,D;eJIax 3Ta np06JIeMa paCCMO'rpeHa 60JIee .n:eTaJIbHO.

COAep*aHMeKopOB:~pe3MepHoeCTpaBnMBaHMe

n'acT6Mllta Ha 06I1teCTBeHH~M none

~".M~ L(JUI Toro 'IT06bl nOH$lTb CMhICJI np06JIeMhI, npe,o;CTaBbTe ce6e He60JIbWOH npo­ iD BHHlIHaJIbHhIM rOpOL\OK, B KOTOpOM 60JIbWlUI qaCTb 3eMJIH HaxOL\HTC$I B PYKax y

~.qaCTHhIX c06CTBeHHHKOB. OL\HaKO eCTb H O,D;HO 60JIbWOe nOJIe o6/14eCmeeHHou 3eM­ AU - yqacToK, Ha KOTOpOM Bce ~TeJIH 3Toro ropOL\Ka MOryI' BblnacaTb CBOM CKOT. HaM Hy)KHO paCCMOTPeTb pa3HHUY Me:lK,lW KOJIWleCTBOM rOJIOB KPYTIHOrO poraToro CKOTa, BbmacaeMoro Ha qaCTHOA 3eMJIe, H KOJIWleCTBOM nacYIUeroc$I CKOTa Ha 3eM­ JIe, npHHaLIJle)l{aIUeH 06IUeCTBy.

Ha qaCTHOM nOJIe ero BJIa.o;eJIeQ HMeeT CTHMYJI orpaHH'IHTb KOJIH'leCTBO roJIOB, KOTOpoe OH 6y.n:eT BhInacaTb. 3T0 npOHCXOL\HT nOTOMY, liTO eCJIH BbI B03bMere CJIHWKOM MHOro CKOTa, OHH 6hICTPO C'be.wrr BCIO Tpaay, H nacT6Hme CTaHeT HenpHrOL\HhIM M$I L\aJIbHeAwero HCnOJIb30­ BaHH$I. CJIeL\QBaTeJIbHO, BJIa,n:eJIeQ lIaCTHoro nacT6HIUa 6YL\eT L\epJKaTb JIHWb He60JIbwoe KO­ JIHlIeCTBO KOpOB JJ:JUI BhInaca. TIOL\06HOe peweHHe COKPaIUaeT ero KPaTKocpollHylO npH6hIJIb (noCKOJIbKY OH COKPaTHT CYIUeCTBYIOIUee KOJIH'leCTBO KOpOB), HO MaKCHMH3HpyeT np'H6hIJIb L\OJIrOBpeMeHHYIO (noCKOJIbKY nacT6HIUe 6YL\eT nOL\.D:ep)l{HBaTbC$I B xopoweM COCTO$lHHH, H OH CMO)l(eT npO)lOJIJKaTb BbmacaTb KOpOB B 6YL\YIUeM).

C L\pyroA CTOpOHhI, cymecTBYIOT CTHMYJIld, C KOTOPldMH CTaJIKHB8.lOTC$I JIIOL\H, KOrL\a Ha 06IUecTBeHHoM nacT6Hllle CB060L\HO MOXHO BldnaCaTl> npOH3BOJIbHOe KOJIHtfeCTBO KOpOB. TIOCKOJIbKY nOJIe npHHa.n:ne)l{HT 06mecTBY, HHKOMY He HYXHO 6YJJ:eT rmaTHTb 3a npaBO BblIIaca cBoero CKOTa. Tax: 'ITO Bce HaMepeBaIOTC$I nOJIb30BaTbC$I 06meCTBeHHldM nyroM, nOCKOJIbKY HHKTO He HeceT HHKaKHX nepCOHaJIbHbIX 3aTPaT.

Ho nOCKOJIbKY Bce L\YMalOT O,llHHaKOBO, TO BCKope 06meCTBeHHOe nOJIe oKaxeTCSI QeJIH­ KOM 3anOJIfleHHhIM KopOBaMH H 6hICTPO OCKYL\eeT, nOCKOJIbKY Macca rOJIO,llHbIX )l{HBOTHblX C'beCT BCIO TPaBy H npeBpaTHT nJIOL\OPO,llHblA ~ B 60JIbWOe, rp$l3HOe MeCHBO. TaK liTO L\O rex nop, nOKa HHKTO He 6YL\eT HeCTH JIH'lHbIX 3aTPaT npH Bblnace KOpOBhI Ha 06meCTBeHHOM

nOJIC,OHH 6yiJym OTHOCHTbCJI H8 06W:CCTBCHHhIlt ClIeT. Kuc.aBH ,D;OnOJIHHTeJIbHBH KOpoBa 6y­

,D;eT Bpe,D;HTh nacroHW;Y - H TaKHM 06pa3oM COKpaTHT 6y,D;yw;yIO ero 94xl!eKTHBHOCTb.

~P83HHua B TOM, 'ITO npoH3o'1lleT C 'l8CTHhIM nOJIeM H nOJleM o6111eCTBeHHhIM, eCTh UeJlHK,OM H nOJIHOCThlO pe3YJIhTaT Pa3HhIX npaB co6cTBeHHOCTH, KOTOpble YCTaHOB­ JIeHhI .lVUI 9THX ~yx,BH,D;OB 3eMeJlh. B CJIY'l.ae C lIacTHoR' C06CTBeHHOCTblO Ha 3eMJIIO

cPepMephI HMelOT CTHMYJI B3BeWHB8Th 38rp8ThI TalC xe, KaK H npH6bU1h OT Bblnaca 60JIhwero KOJIH'leCTB8 KOpoB. B qaCTHOCTH, OHH yqHThIB8IOT H 6y,D;YlUY/O npH6b1JIh, KOTOPlUI 6y,D;eT COKPallleHa, eCJIH CY11leCrBy/oIIJ;lUI cHryaUlul C YHH'iTOlKeHHeM KO­ JIHtleCTBa rpaBhI pa3pywHT 6y,D;y11lYJO nOJIe3HOCTb noJUl.

O,D;HaKO B cJIyqae C nOJIeM 06IIJ;eCTBeHHhIM HHKTO He HMeeT JlHqHOIt JaHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH B coxpaHeHHH ero 6y,D;yIIJ;eit nOJIe3HOCTH. B ,D;eitCTBHTeJIhHOCTH xe Bce 3TO }')KaCHO HenpaBWlb­ HO, nOCKOJIhKY eCJIH 06lUeCTBeHHlUI 3eMIDI B HacToHlUHit MOMeHT HBJUler c06010 npeBOCXO,D;­ Hoe nacroHIIJ;e, Bawe XeJIaHHe BhmaCaTh KaK MOXHO 60JIbWee KOJIHqeCTBO KOPOB npHBe,D;eT K TOMY, 'ITO OHM OqeHh 6hIcrpo C'be,D;HT BOlO rpaBy H Ha 3TOM yqaCTKe )')ICe HHKoro HeJIb3H 6Y,D;eT HaKopMHTh. H, nOCKOJIbKY Bce cPepMepbI paCCMarpHBalOT nOT Bonpoc O.L\HHaKOBO, HaJIHqe­ cTByeT 6e3JJYMHOe XeJIaHHe BhlnaCTH KaK MOXHO 6hIcrpee KaK MO}KHO 60JTbWee KOJIH'leCTBO KOpoB. Be3YCJIOBHO, B pe3YJIbTare oKaXercH, 'ITO nOJIe CTaJIO 6eCnJIO,D;HbIM - H TaKHM OHO 6y­ ,D;eT ,D;JIH KIDI<lI.oro.

BbI Moxere paccMarpHBaTh 3TY CHry8UHIO B KaqeCTBe npHMepa HeraTHBHbIX BHeWHHX 3Q>­ cPeKTOB. ECJIH H YBIDKY 6y:AHYJO paCTHTeJIbHOCTb Ha 06IIJ;ecTBeHHoM nOJIe, H no6ery 3arolUlTb ry.L\a KaK MOXHO 60JIbWee KOJIH'IeCTBO CBOHX KOpOB, He JlYWUI 0 TOM ymep6e, KOTOpbIH MQ)KeT npHqHHHTh nOJIIO HX MaccoBoe HallleCTBHe. 3To xe 6YlIeT CnpaBe)l]lHBblM H no OTHOWeHHIO KO BceM OCTaJlhHbIM. HHKTO He 3a6oTHrcH 0 HeraTHBHbIX BHeWHHX 3Q>Q>eKTax onycToweHHoro nacT6HlUB. nOCKOJIhKY y Hero HeT qaCTHhIX BJI3,lIeJIbueB, a 3HaQHT, HeT H nocrpa,uaBWHX OT ero }'HHtlTO)f(eHHH.

XoPOWO. 'ITO B CJIyqae C nOJIeM, HaxO,D;HIIJ;eMCH B qaCTHOM BJIa,ueHHH, ero BJIa,ueJIeu 06H3a­ TeJIbHO npHMer B paCqeT CTOHMOCTh onycToweHHH nOJIH OT H36bITOqHOrO KOJTH1.JeCTBa Bbma­ caeMbIX )f(HBOTHbIX. H nOCKOJIhKY OH C 3THM CqHTaeTCH. TO onycTomeHHH ero nOJTH He npo­ H30:A,!J;eT.

Pbl6Hai npo6neMa: BbIMMpaHM8, Bbl3BaHH08 nnoxo

npoAyMaHHblMM npaBaMM C06CTB8HHOCTM

MHorne npo6JIeMbI, CBHJaHHhIe C oKp}')KaIOIIJ;eit cpe.L\oR', BbI3BaHhI CHryaUHHMH H3 pB3pH.ll.a "Tpare.L\HH 06IIJ;HH", Koma y onpe,D;eJIeHHhIX pecypCOB HeT BJI3,lIeJIbua, nOJlb3YlOIUerOCH rrpa­ BOM c06CTBeHHOCTH. B oc06eHHOCTH Hy)f(HO nOlIqepKHYTh, qTO 60JIhIIIHHCTBO HC1.Je3HYBIIIHX BH,D;OB )f(HBOTHhIX HBHJIOCb pe3YJIbTaTOM OrcyrcTBHH npaB c06cTBeHHoCTH.

C .npyroit CTOpOHbI, eCJIH BbI, K npHMepy, noitMaeTe ryHua H nOJIO)f(HTe ero B CBOIO JIO.L\­ KY, 3TO 6Y.L\eT 03HaqaTh. qTO y Bac nOHBHJIOCb Ha Hero npaBO c06CTBeHHHKa, H BbI MO.lKeTe np0.L\aTh noitMaHHYJO pbl6y. OrcIO.L\a CJIe.L\YeT. 'ITO e.L\HHCTBeHHhIit cnoc06 H3BJIeqb 3KOHOMHqe­ cKYJO nOJIb3Y OT TyHua - 3TO y6HTh ero.