экономика для чайников

KaK H 06'bHCHHIO B rJIaDe 11, BhI nOJIY'lHTe 3TOT TPeyroJIhHHK, npe,llCTaDHB BCe Bep­ THKaJIhHhIe 0TPe3KH Me)({)ly KpHBOH cnpoca H KpHBOit npe,lleJIhHoit CTOHMOCTH, KOTOphIe paCnOJIOXeHhI Ha,Il BCeMH e,llHHHuaMH npo.uyKTa Mex.uyq'" H rf. Bee 3TH KopOTeHhKHe BePTHKaJIhHhIe 0TPe3KH 3amTPHXOBaHhI B TPeyrOJIhHHKe He06paTH­ MhIX noreph, CYMMHpYlOIUeM YIUep6, KOTOPhIit HaHOCHTCH 06IUeCTBY B pe3YJIhTare COKPaIUeHHH npOH3BO,IlCTBa npo.uyKTa MOHOnOJIHeit.

TpeyroJIhHHK He06paTHMhIX nOTeph ,IleMOHCTPHpyeT, qTO KOf,lla MOHOnOJIHH COKpaIUalOT npo.uyKT C ueJIhlO MaKCHMH3aUHH npH6hmH, HM He y,llaeTCH npOH3BO,llHTh Te e)lHHHUhI npo­

.uyKTa, )lJIH KOTOPhIX BhIfO,llhI npeBhImalOT H3,1lepXKH. 3TO Bpe,llHT 06IUecTBy. CJIe)lyJOIUHH paJ­

. ,IleJI nOKaJhIBaeT, qTO perneHHe COKpaTHTh BhInyCK TaKXe npHBO)lHT K nOBhImeHHIO npOH3BO,ll­ CTBeHHhIX H3,IlepxeK.

O,-,eHK834»4»eKTMBHOCTM

ApyraH np06JIeMa, CBHJaHHaH C MOHOnOJIHHMH, JaKJIlOqaeTCH B TOM, qTO OHH He OTHOCHT­

.CH K KareropHH 3<p<peKTHBHhIX npOH3BO)lHTeJIeH. BhI Moxere YBH)leTh 3TO, eCJIH CHOBa 06pa­ THreCh K pHC. 12.4.

KOHKYPeHTHhIe <pHpMhI npOH3BO,llHT npo.uyKT Ha ypOBHe rf. ECJIH BhI nO,llHHMeTeCh Bep­ THKaJIhHO BBepx OT 3TOro ypOBHH ,IlO KPHBOit A'lt:', TO ,IlOCTHfHeTe TOqKH F, KOTOpaH pacnOJIO­ XHJIaCh B caMOM HH3Y U-06pa3HOH KpHBOH A'lt:'. KaK H 06bHCHHlO B maBe 10, KOHKYpeHUHH llpHBO,llHT KOHKYPHPYlOIUHe <pHPMhI K npOH3BO,llCTBy Ha ypOBHe npo)1yKTa, COOTBeTCTBYIOIUero HRXHeH TOqKe U -06Pa3HOit KpHBOft A'lt:'.

Il!T 3TOT ypOBeH~npO.uyKTa MHHHMH3HpyeT npOH3BO,llCTBeHHhIe 3aTPaThI Ha e,llHHHUY

@j npO,llYKTa, qTO BhI MoxeTe YBH)leTh, eCJIH cpaBHHTe rf C KaKHM-HH6Y,llh ,IlPYfHM ypOBHeM npO,llYKTa. EY,lleTe JIH BhI npOH3BO,llHTh 60JIhme HJIH MeHhme rf, cpe,llHHe 3aTPaThI Ha e,llHHHuy 6y)lyT BhIrneno U-06Pa3HO:A KPHBO:A A'lt:'.

B qaCTHOCTH, nOCMOTPHTe Ha ypOBeHh npO,llyKTa MOHOnOJIHH, q"'. ECJIH BhI nO,llHHMe­ reCh BepTHKaJIhHO BBepx OT 3TOro ypOBHH npO.uyKTa ,IlO KPHBOH A'lt:', TO ,IlOCTHrneTe TOqKH E.

IIoCKOJIhKY BepTHKaJIhHOe paCCTOHHHe Mex.uy roPH30HTaJIhHOH OChlO H E )lJIHHHee, qeM BeP­ THKaJIhHOe paCCTOHHHe Mex.uy fOPH30HTaJIhHOft OChlO H TOqKOH F, BhI 3Haere HaBepHHKa, qTQ

COBOKYnHhIe H3,IlepXKH Ha e)lHHHuy npo.uyKTa, KOf,lla MOHOnOJIHH npOH3BO,llHT Ha ypOBHe q"',

Bhlrne, qeM re xe H3,1lepXKH npH npoH3BO,llCTBe Ha ypOBHe npo.uyKTa y KOHKYPHPYlOIUeH <pHp­ MhI, rf. OrclO,Ila CJIe.uyeT, qTO MOHOnOJIhHaH <pHpMa npoH3Bd,llHT npo.uyKT npH 60JIee BhICOKOM ypOBHe COBOKylIHhIX H3,1lepXeK, qeM KOHKYPHPYlOIUaH . '

3TOT llJIOXOH pe3YJIhTaT - eIUe O,llHO ,IlOKa3aTeJIhCTBO TOfO <paKTa, qTO MOHono­ JIHCThI HMelOT ,IleJIO C llJIaBHO cHRXaIOIUHMHcH KpHBhIMH npe,lleJIhHOH npH6hmH. KOHKYPHPYlOIUaH <pHpMa B JII060M CJIyqae 06JIa,IlaeT cTHMyJIOM: YBeJIffqHTh npo­ H3BO,llCTBO npO)lyKTa ,IlO rf, nOCKOJIhKY HMeHHO 3TO npHBe,lleT K CHmKeHHIO COBO­ KYllHhIX H3,1lepXeK Ha e,llHHHuy np0,llYKUHH, a 3HaqHT, - pOCTY npH6hmH. TaKoH xe CTHMyJI CYIUeCTByeT H )lJIH MOHOnOJIHCTa, HO 3TO 60JIee qeM KOMneHcHpyeTcH COKpaIUeHHeM ,IlOXO,llOB, KOTopoe npOHCXO,llHT, eCJIH MOHOnOJIhHaJr <pHpMa YBeJIH­ qHT 06beM npOH3BO,llHMOfO elO npO,llYKTa. B pe3YJIhTare npH6hurh MOHOnOJIHCTa MaKcHMH3HpoBaHa npH q"', ,Ilaxe eCJIH rf COOTBeTCTByeT caMoMY HH3KOMY YPOBHlO H3,IlepxeK.

266 '1acrb III. MH/cpo3KOHOMHKa - HByKB 0 n08~eHHH norpe6Hreneii Hnpe,anpHJmfH

~jun 'JeojtOIlatJe H Ji,OH,OhfU,UU

€~BhlCOKOit ce6ecTOHMOCTH H npo,n;aeT ero CJIHIIIKOM ,n;oporo. IIpH BhlIUenepeqHCJIeH­ HhIX TPex "ITJIOXHX" cPaKTOpax BaM 3axOqeTCH HeMe,!J;JIeHHO H36aBHTbCH OT Bcex MOHOnOJIHit pa30M. Ho eCJIH BhI c,n;eJIaere 3TO, TO CqHTaitTe, qTO He06,nyMaHHO rrOTO­ pOnHJIHCb. B HeKOTOphIX CJIY':laHX nOJIb3a, nOJIY'!eHHaH OT MOHOnOJIHH, npeBhlIUaeT CBH3aHHhle C HHMH pacxo,n;h1.

nOO~peH~eMHHOBaQM~

CaMhlM nOKa3aTeJIbHhlM npHMepOM TOro, KaK MHOro ,n;06pa MOryI' npHHOCHTb 06mecTBy MOHOnOJIHH, HBJIHIOTCH naTeHThI. IIaTeHThI ,n;alOT HCCJIe,n;OBaTeJIHM 3KCKJIlO3HBHOe npaBO Ha npo,n;IDKY HX H306peTeHHH B TeqeHHe 20 JIeT, no HCreqeHHH 3Toro CpoKa HX H306pereHHH CTa­ HOBHTCH c06CTBeHHOCTblO 06IUeCTBa. 3100 3HaqHT, qTO naTeHThI ,n;alOT H306peTaTeJIHM npaBO Ha MOHOrrOJIHIO Ha nepHO,n; 20 JIeT.

IIp~HHa, no KOTOpOit MOHOnOJIHH B 3TOM KOHTeKCTe CqHTaIOTCH HaCTOJIbKO BIDK­ HhlMH, 3aKJIlOqeHa B TOM, qTO 6e3 HHX H306peTareJIb e,n;Ba JIH YBH,!J;eJI 6bI KaKOe­ JIH60 MaTepHaJIbHOe B03Harpax,neHHe 3a CBOH TIDKeJIhlH TPy,n;, nOCKOJIbKY Macca no,n;paxareJIeit HeMe,!J;JIeHHO YKPa,n;yT Y Hero M,n;elO H HarrOJIHHT PhlHOK BopOBaHHOH rrpO.u;yKI.J;HeH, TaKHM 06Pa30M CHH3HB ueHY. CJIe,n;OBaTeJIbHO, B MHpe, JIHWeHHOM nareHTOB, HaMHOro Memwee KOJI~eCTBOJIIO,n;eit peWHJIOCb 6h1 TPaTHTb CBoe Bpe­ MH, yCHJIHH H ,n;eHbrH, He06xo,!l;HMhle ,!J;JIH H306peTeHHH qero-TO HOBOro.

QT06h1 HcnpaBHTb 3TY CHTYaUHIO, rocy,n;ap~TBaBcero MHpa npeMaralOT rrareHTHbIe MO­

HOnOJIHH ,!J;JIH H306peTaTeJIeit. B pe3YJIbTaTe npouecc nOHCKa HOBOro npoxo,n;HT 3HaqHTeJIbHO 6h1cTPee, HaMHoro 6bICTPee npOXo,n;HT 3KOHOM~eCKHHpOCT H HaMHoro 6h1cTPee pacreT :lKH3­ HeHHhlH ypOBeHb. B caMOM ,n;eJIe TIDKeJIO npH,!J;YMaTb 60JIee nOJIe3HYJO B COUHaJIbHOM ITJIaHe MOHOnOJIHlO, qeM nareHTbI.

COKpa~eHMe'Ipe3MepHOrO KOnM'IeCTBa KOHKypeHToB

focy,n;apCTBO ,n;OJDKHO TalOKe BMeWHBaTbCH B C03,!J;aHHe MOHOnOJIHit B Tex CHTYaUHHX, r,n;e KOHKYpeHUHH HeBhlro,!l;Ha 06IUeCTBy. IIpHBe,n;y JIHWb HeCKOJIbKO npHMepOB.

I"IIpHpo,lUlhli raJ. TIPOKJU1,D,Ka TPyG, rro KOTOpbIM ,D,OCTaBJUleTCR rrpHpo,D,HbIit ra3, - O'IeHb ,D,oporag BeIUb, H pa3MeIUeHHe MHOrHX ra30BbIX TPyG Ha O,D,HOM H TOM xe yqacTKe Moxer OKa3aTbCR ,D,OBOJIbHO HaKJIa,D,HbIM.

CJIe,D,OBaTeJIbHO, MHome ropO,D,a pellIaIOT, 'Iro y HHX 6Y,D,eT ,D,eitCTBOBaTb Bcero O,D,Ha MY­ copoy60PO'IHaR KOMrraHHR, O,D,HO Ka6eJIbHoe TeJIeBH,D,eHHe H O,D,Ha J{OMrraHHR, JaBe,nyIOIUaR rrOCTaBKaMH rrpHpO,D,HOro ra3a. Kax,D,aH Ta.KlUI KOMrraHHR 6Y,D,eT HMeTb MOHOrrOJIbHoe rrpaBO ' H, CJIe,lJ,OBaTeJIbHO, KOHTPOJIHP0BaTbCR, qro6bI rapaHTHpOBaHHO He .n;aTb eit 3KCIIJIYaTHpoBaTb rroTPe6HTeJIeit. (CM. CJIe)J,yIOIUHit pa3)J,eJI "PeryJIHpoBaHHe ,D,eRTeJIbHOCTH MOHOrrOJIHit".)

HM3KMe M3AepJKKM eCTeCTSeHHblX MOHOnOnMM

CJIe)J,yIOIUHit rrpHMep TOro, KOr,lJ,a 06m;ecTBo pelliaer C03.n;aTb MOHOrrOJIHIO BMecro KOHKY­ peHUHH, 3TO cnyqait, KOTOpblit 3KOHOMHCTbI Ha3hIBaIOT ecmeCm6eHHblMU MOHOnOAbHblMU om­ paCARMU, HJIH ecmeCm6eHHblMU MOHOnOAUJl.MU.

OrpaCJIb RBJUleTCR eCTeCTBeHHoit MOHOrrOJIHeit, eCJIH O,D,HH KPYIIHbIit rrpoH3BO,lJ,H­ TeJIb MoxeT rrpOH3BeCTH rrpo.n;yx:T rro 60JIee HH3KOit ce6ecToHMoCTH, 'IeM MHOro­ 'IHCJIeHHbIe MaJIeHbKHe rrpOH3BO,D,HTeJIH. XOpOlliHit rrpHMep TaKOH MOHOrrOJIHH ­ rrpOH3BO,lJ,CTBO 3JIeKTP03HepmH. TIo rrpH'IHHe KOHCTPYKUHOHHhIx oc06eHHocTeH ,lJ,eCRTHMeraBaTTHaR 3JIeKTPOCTaHUHR Moxer rrpOH3BeCTH 3HepmIO .n;ellIeBJIe, 'IeM O,lJ,HOMeraBaTTHaR.

,AJIR TOro 'lT06b1 YBH,D,eTb, KaK 3TO rrpHBO,D,HT K C03.n;aHHIO eCTecTBeHHoit MOHOrrOJIHH, rrpe.n;CTaBbTe ce6e CHTYaUHIO, Kor.n;a ropo,lJ" KOTOPOMY TPe6yeTcR .n;eCRTb MeraBarr 3JIeKTPO­ 3HeprHH, H3Ha'IaJIbHO 06CnyxHBaJICR .n;eCRTbIO MaJIeHbKHMH, O,D,HOMeraBaTTHbIMH 3JIeKTpo­ CTaHUHRMH. Ho 3aTeM B03HHKJIa 60JIbllIaR KoprrOpaUHR H rrocTPOHJIa .n;eCRTHMeraBaITHYIO 3JIeKTPOCTaHUHIO. TIOCKOJIbKY 3Ta 60JIbllIaR CTaHI.J;HR MoxeT rrpOH3BO.D;HTb 3HeprHIO rro 60JIee HH3KOit ce6ecrOHMOCTH, 'IeM MeHbniHe, MeHee 3CP<I>eKTHBHbIe CTaHlUUI, OHa rrpe,nnaraeT 6oJI.ee HH3KHe ueHbI H rrOCTerreHHO "3aBJIa,lJ,eBaer" BCeMH KJIHeHTIlMH, - a 3m 3HalJHT, qro MeHbllIHe 3JIeKTPOCTaHUHH O'IeHb 6bICTpo 06aHKpoTRTCR.

TaKaR OTPaCJIb MoxeT Ha3bIBaTbCR ecmecm6eHHou MOHonOAueu, rrOCKOJIbKY OHa eCTeCTBeH­ HbIM IIyTeM craHer .n;OMHHHpoBaTb B Ka'IeCTBe e.n;HHCTBeHHoro ,D,ellIeBOro rrpoH3BO,lJ,HTeJIR. ,AJIg rrOJIHTHlJeCKHX ,lJ,eRTeJIeit 3)J,eCb B03HHKaeT .n;OCTllTO'IHO CJIOXHaR rrp06JIeMa: qro xe ,lJ,eJIaTb C eCTeCTBeHHoJt. MOHOrrOJIHeit?

C O,lJ,HOit CTOpOHbI, BceM rrpHRTeH TOT !paKT, 'ITO 60JIbllIaR CTaHUHR HaMHoro 60JIee 3!p­ !peKTHBHa: OHa CXHraeT MeHbllIe TOIIJIHBa H MeHbllIe JarpR3HReT OKpyxaIOIIJYIO cpe.n;y. Ho rrOCKOJIbKY OHa YHH'lTOXHJIa BCex KOHKfpeHTOB, JIIO,D,H Terrepb ,D,OJIXHbI 6ecrroKoHTbCR 0 TOM, 'ITO HOBaR MOHOrrOJIHR MoxeT Ha3Ha'IHTb BbICOKHe ueHbI H rrpoH3BO.D;HTb rrpO.D;YKTa MeHbllIe COI.J;HaJIbHO OrrTHMaJIbHoro ypOBHR.

3TH KOH!pJIHKTYIOIUHe "3a" H "rrpOTHB" 06bI'lH0 3Ha'IaT, 'IT0JOCy.n;apcTBO rr03BOJIReT ec­ TeCTBeHHoit MOHOrrOJIHH OCTllBaTbCR B 6H3Hece B Ka'IeCTBe e.D;HHCTBe~lHoit!PHPMbI B 0TPaCJIH, HO B TO xe BpeMR peryJIHpyeT ee TllKHM 06pa30M, 'lTo6bI JIIO.D;RM He HyXHO 6b1JIO BOJIHOBaTbCR o BbICOKHX ueHax HJIH He.n;OCTaro'IHOM KOJIH'leCTBe rrpO.D;YKTa. TIOCTfIIaR TaKHM 06pa30M, 06­ IIleCTBO H3BJIeKaeT rrOJIb3Y, rrpHHOCHMyIO CaMbIM 3«PcPeKTHBHbIM crroco60M, 6e3 TOro, 'ITOObI BOJIHOBaTbCR 0 rrpo6JIeMax, KOTOpbIe B03HHKJIH 6bI, eCJIH 6bI MOHOrrOJIHIO OCTaBHJIH Ha CaMO­ peryJIHpoBaHHH.

:PezlfJ,upodaJtIte Jl,oJtOJ1,().,(,uu

[ocy,napCTBO ,nOJDKHO peIIIaTb, KOr,na nO,lJ.Ilep)[{HBaTb H KOr,na "no,naBJUlTb" MOHOnOJIHH. HanpHMep, naTeHTbl nO,lJ.Ilep)[{HBalOT MOHOnOJIbHOe npaBO H306peTaTeJIeit Ha npOH3BO,nCTBO H npo,nIDKy CBOHX H306peTeHHit B TeqeHHe 20 JIeT. no HCTe'leHHH 3TOro nepHo,na npoH3BO,nCTBO H npo,nIDKa H306peTeHIDI CTaHOBHTCH OTKPbITbIMH ~ KOHKYPeHIJ,HH.

I~B ,npyrHX CHTYaIJ,HHX 6bIJIH paJpa60TaHbI pa3Hble peryJIHTOpHble HHCTHTYTbI, KaK

.... i: AJUI paJpyIIIeHIDI MOHOnOJIHH nyreM paJ.neJIeHIDI Ha qaCTH, TaK H AJUI peryJIHpoBa­

\~ HIDI ee ,neHTeJIbHOCTH rrocJIe npHHHTIDI peIIIeHIDI n03BOJIHTb eit npo,nOJDKaTb 6blTh e,nHHCTBeHHoit lPHpMOit B OTpaCJIH. B 3TOM paJ.neJIe BaIIIeMy BHHMaHHIO npe,nCTaB­ JIeHbl HeCKOJIbKO TaICHX peryJIHTOPHblX cxeM H npoBe,neH aHaJIH3 TOrn, 'ITO OHH ,ne­ JIalOT AJUI YJIY'lIIIeHHSl "nOBe,neHIDI" MOHOnOJIHit Ha pbIHKe.

Cy6CMAMpOBaHMe MOHononMM AnSI yBenM"IeHMSI 06'beMa BblnycKa

PaHee B ::/TOH fJIaBe Sl yrBepX,ll,aJI, 'lT0 MaKCHMH3HpyroIUHe npH6blJIb MOHOnOJIHH npo­ H3BOAAT npo,llyKT Ha ypOBHe, HaxoAAIIJ,eMCH HIDKe COIJ,HaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHoro. B 'IaCTHOCTH, MaKCHMH3HpyromaSl npH6bIJIb MOHOnOJIIDI Ha pHC. 12.4 npoH3Bo,nHT llpo.nyKT B TOqKe nepece­ 'IeHHSl cBoeit llJIaBHO cHIDKalOmeitcSl KpHBOit npe,neJIbHOrb ,noxo,na, MRm, H no,nHHMalOmeitcSl BBepx KpHBOlt npe,neJIbHblX H3,nep)l{eK, Me. 3TOT ypoBeHb npo.uyKTa, if", MeHbIIIe COIJ,HaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHoro ypOBHSl, KOTOPblit Mor 6blTb npoH3Be,neH KOHKYPHpyromeit lPHPMOit, if.

+9~Bt,. OMH H3 cnoc06oB, KOTOPblM MO)I{HO ,n06HTbCSl OT MOHOnOJIHH llpoH3BO,nCTBa 6oJIb­

~~ IIIero KOJIH'leCTBa npo,llyKTa, 3aKJIIO'IaeTCSl B cy6cH,nHpOBaHHH ee npoH3Bo,nCTBeH­

~1 HbIX JaTpaT TaKHM 06pa30M, 'ITO KpHBaH npe,neJIbHbIX H3,Uep)l{eK B pe3YJIbTaTe nepe­ MeCTHTCJI BeprnKaJIbHO BHH3. TaKoe ,neitCTB.He npHBe,neT K TOMy, 'lT0 KpHBble npe­ ,neJIbHblX H3,nep)l{eK H npe,neJIbHoro ,noxo,na BCTpeTJlTCH Ha 60JIee BbICOKOM ypOBHe

npo.nyKTa. 11 ec.iH Cy6cH,nIDI 6y,neT ,nOCTaTO'IHO 6OJIbIIIoit, MOHOnOJIIDI MO)l{eT 6bITh BbllfY)l{.neHa nOCTOSlHHO YBeJIH'lHBaTb npo,llyKT ,no if.

HeKOTOpble rocy,napCTBa HCnOJIb3YlOT 3TOT BH,n cy6CH.lUiH AJUI TOro, 'lT06bI nOCTaBJIHlOmHe raJ, npOH3BOMmHe 3JIeKTpo3HeprnlO H YCJIYfH TeJIe.poHHoit CBH3H KOMllaHHH 06CJIY)l(HBaJIH 60JIbIIIee KOJIH'IeCTBO JIIO,neH, oc06eHHO npe,nCTaBHTeJIeit 6e,nHblx CJIOeB HaCeJIeHIDI. ECJIH pacxo,nbI Ha npHBJIeqeHHe nOTpe6HTeJIeH npo.uyKTa lPHpM-MOHOnOJIHH 6y.nYT Cy6cH,nHpOBaHbl Ha ,nOCTaTO'IHO BblCOKOM ypoBHe, lPHPMbl JaxOTIlT npHBJIe'Ib 60JIbIIIee KOJIH'iecTBO nOTpe6HTe­ JIeit, 'IeM OHH MOfJIH 6bl 6e3 npe,nOCTaBJIeHlfe Cy6CH,nHH.

HeKOTOpble JIIOM BbICTYllalOT npornB cy6CH,nHpOBaHIDI MOHOnOJIHCTOB, TaK 'lT0 3TOT BH)]. peIIIeHIDI He Bcer,na C~MbIit nonyJlSlpHbIit B nOJIHTHQeCKOM OTHOIIIeHHH, HO OH 3lPlPeKTHBeH

AJUI YBeJIH'IeHIDI BbITIyCKa npo,llyKTa.

MMHMManbHble Tpe60BaHMSI K 06'beMy npOM3BOACTBa

OHH 6y)];yr B HeA H}'}K,lI;aTbC$I.) 3To :>Ke npaBHJIO qaCTO cnpaBeMHBO H )l,1UI KOMna­ HHH, KOTOpbIe o6ecneqHBaIOT 060rpeB HaillHX )];OMOB 3HMOA; B HeKOTOpbIX pemoHax BaM He HMelOT npaao OTK.1IIO~TbOTOnJIeHHe, )];a:>Ke eCJIH BhI He OnJIaTHJIH CqeTa.

MHHHMaJIbHhIe Tpe60BaHH$I K npo)];YKTY MOryr 3aCTaBHTb MOHOnOJIHIO npOH3BO)];HTb npo­ )];YKT Ha COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHOM ypOBHe. TaKHe Tpe6oBaHH$I qaCTO O'IeHb nonyJI$lpHbI B nOJIHTHqeCKOM OTHOIlleHHH, nOCKOJIbKy MHome JIIO)];H CqHTalOT MOHOnOJIHCTOB 3JIOCTHhIMH 3KCnJIyaTaTOpaMH H He npOTHB 3aCTaBHTb MOHOnOJIHH npOH3BO)];HTb 60JIbIllee KOJIHqeCTBO rrpo)];YKTa.

BC$lKOe HaCHJIbCTBeHHoe yaeJIHqeHHe npO)];yKTa TaK:>Ke 03HaqaeT cOKpameflHe rrpH6hIJIH

MOHOnOJIHH. IIo 3TOH rrpmHHe rrO)];06HhIe nporpaMMhI TaK:>Ke rrOJIb3YIQTC$I rronyMpHoCTbIO,

rrOCKOJIbKy MHome CqHTaIOT, qTO MOHOrrOJIHH rro~alOTnpH6hIJIb HeqeCTHhIM rryreM, o6pa­ mM BHHMaHHe Ha TOT ¢laKT, qTO ¢lHpMa rro~aeTnpH6hIJIb, He rro6e:>K,Zl.M KOHKYPeHTOB.

TeM He MeHee, Bce peryJI$lTOpHhIe opraHhI )];OJI:>KHbI 6hITb OqeHb BHHMaTeJIbHhIMH, qT06hI He rrpHBeCTH MOH,OrrOJIHH, KOTophIe HaxO)];$lTC$I rro)]; HX rrOrreqHTeJIbCTBOM, K 6aHKpoTcTBy. B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT KpHBbIX rrpOH3BO)];CTBeHHbIX H3)];ep:>KeK'MOHOrrOJIHH cymecTByeT peaJIbHM B03MO:>KHOCTb JaCTaBHTb MOHOnOJIHIO rrpOH3BO)];HTb rrpo)];YKT Ha TOM ypOBHe, Ha KOTOpOM OHa 6y)];eT Tep$lTb )];eHbrH. IIOCKOJIbKy peryJI$lTOpHhIe opraHhI He XOT$lT 6aHKpOTCTBa MOHOrrOJIHA H, KaK CJIe)];CTBHe, JIHIllaTb nOTpe6HTeJIeA )];OC'ryIla K TOBapaM HJIH YCJIYfaM, rrpOH3BO)];HMhIM 3THMH MOHOrrOJIH$lMH, OHH BHHMaTeJIbHO paCCMaTpHBalOT CTpYKTYPY paCXO)];OB MOHOrrOJIHH npH paCqeTe MHHHMaJIbHbIX Tpe60BaHHH K o6beMY rrpOH3BO)];CTBa.

PerynMpoB8HMe MOHOnOnbHOrO L4eHoo6p830B8HMfI

B03MO:>KHO, caMhIM pacrrpOCTpaHeHHhIM crroco60M peryJIHpoaaHH$I )];e$lTeJIbHOCTH MOHOrrOJIHH eCTb HaJHaqeHHe TaKOH ueHbI, rrpH KOTOPOH MOHOnOJIH$I 'CMO:>KeT rrpo­ )];aTb Bce e)];HHHUhI rrpOH3Be)];eHHoro elO rrp0.ll}'KTa. 3TOT no,lJ,XO)]; pa60TaeT noTOMy,

~o OH rrpeBpamaeT KpHBYIO' rrpe)];eJIbHOro )];OXo)];a ¢lHPMhI-MOHOrrOJIHCTa H3 nJIaBHO CHH:>KaIOmeHC$I a ropH30HTaJIbHyIO. TaKHM 06paJOM, HH.BeJIHPYIOTC$I 06hI'IHhIe npo­ 6JIeMhI MOHOrrOJIHH, CB$l3aHHhIe C TeM, ~o qeM 60JIbwe npo.ll}'KTa npO)];aeTC$I, TeM MeHbIIIYIO ueHY Ha rrpo)];aBaeMYIO e)];HHHUY rrpo.nyKTa MOHOrrOJIH$I MO:>KeT HaJHaqHTb.

TeM He MeHee, KaK H B c~ae C Tpe60aaHH$lMH K o6beMY rrpoH3BO)];CTBa, peryMTOpHhIe opraHhI )];OJI:>KHhI y)];eJIHTb oco60e BHHMaHHe cTpYKTYP.e 3aTpaT MOHOrrOJIHH, qTo6hI peryJIHpO­ BaRHe ueH He npHBeJIO K 6aHKpoTCTBY MOHOnOJIHH.

';[VuI: TOro qT06hI rrOH$lTb rrpo6JIeMy, )];aBattTe paCCMOTpHM MOHOrrOJIHIO, KpHBhIe JaTpaT KO­ TOpoH rrpHBe)];eHhI Ha pHC. 12.5. OCTaBwHcb 6e3 BHHMaHH$I peryJI$lTOpHOrO opraHa, MOHorro­ JIH$l6y)];eT npOH3BO)];HTb Ha MaKcHMH3HPYIOmeM rrpH6hIJIb ypOBHe f/", orrpe)];eMeMOM TOqKOH rrepeCeqeHH$I MR H MC. 113 KpHBOH crrpoca BhI MO:>KecTe BH,ll,eTb, qTO )l,1UI 31'0ro 06'beMa npo­ )];YKTa OHa 6y)];eT crroc06Ha HaJHaqHTb ueHY pm Ja e)];HHHUY JIPo)];YKTa. (BoJIee rro)];p06HYIO HH­ lPoPMaUHIO 0 rrOBe)];eHHH HeperyJIHpyeMoH MOHOrrOJIHH BhI HaA)];eTe B pa3)];eJIe "BhI60p 06'be­

Ma rrpOH3BO)];CTBa ~ MaKCHMH3aI.J;HH rrpH6hIJIH" paHee B 3TOH rJJ,aBe.)·

3aTeM )];aBaATe rrO)];yMaeM 0 TOM, KllK peryMTopHhItl: opraH MO:>KeT 3axOTeTb MO)];HqlHUHpo­ BaTb rrOBe)];eHHe MOHOnOJIHH. HarrpHMep, peryMTOPHhIH opraH, HCXO)];$l H3 ~WHXrr06y}K,D;e­ HHH, 'MO:>KeT 3axOTeTb 3aCTaBHTb MOHOrrOJIHIO rrpOH3BO)];HTb Kaxm'lO e)];HHHUY rrpO)];YKTa, ~

KOTOPOH )];OXO)];hI rrpeBhIIllaIOT paCXO)];hI. IIocMOTpeB Ha pHC. 12.5, BhI MoxeTe YBH,ll,eTb, qro OH 3axOTeJI 6hI 3aCTaBHTb MOHOnOJIHIO,rrpoH3BO)];HTb npo.zlYKT fla ypoBfle f/"c, onpe)];eJIeHHhIH KaK MecTO rrepeCeqeHH$I nnaBHO cHIDKlllOmeAc$I KpHBOH crrpoca C KpHBOH MC.

D

KOflHyeCTBO

MR

PHc.12.5. PerynHpoB8HHe MOHOnOnHff C HCnOnb30B8HHeM l..leHoot5­ P830B8HHR H8 OCHOBe Cpe,aHHX COBO/cynHblX H3,aepJKeK HB e,aHHHI..lY npO,aYIIT8 H /.4eHoot5p830B8HHR H8 OCHOBe npe,aenbHblX H3,D,epJKeK H8 e,aHHH/.4Y npO,aYIIT8

KaK JI 06'LJlCIDIIO B pll3,lJ.eJIe "He06paTHMhle nOrepH: H3MepeHHe Bpe,n;a, npH1J:HHeHHoro MOHOnOJIHJlMH" (CM. BbIIlIe), ,ll;JUI COIlHYMa Bhlro,n;HO npOH3Bo,n;HTb KIDIQ:(yIO e,n;HHHllY npo,n;yKTa ,n;o (BKJII01J:aJI) q"'c. 3'1'0 CnpaBe,lJ)lHBO nOTOMY, qro,D;JIJI KIDK,ZlOit e,D;HHHI.lhl npO,llyKTa CYMMa~KO­ TOPYIO JIIO,D;H roTOBhl ITJIaTHTL C lleJIhIO ee nOTPe6JIeHHJI (3a,n;aHHaJI BepmKaJIhHhlM 0TPe3KOM OT rOpH30lITaJIhHoit OCH ,n;o KpHBOit cnpoca), npeBhlwaeT npe,n;eJIhHhle 3aTPa1hl Ha ee npOH3­ BO,n;CTBO (3a,n;aHHhle BepmKaJIhHhlM OTpe3KOM 01' roPH30lITaJIhHOit OCH,n;O KpHBOit MG).

B pe3YJIhTare peryJIJlTOpHhlit opraH yCTaHOBHT lleHY Ha ypOBHe pmc. llpH 3TOit lleHe KpH­ BaJI cnpoca roBOpHT HaM, ~O nOTpe6HTeJIH JaXOTJlT npH06pecTH q"'c e,n;HHHIl npO,llyKTa. ROJIee TOro, MOHOnOJIHJI 3ax01J:eT nOCTaBHTb 3TOT ypOBeHh npo,n;yKTa, nOCKOJIhKY npe,n;eJIhHhlit ,n;OXO,n; OT npO,n;WKH KaJK,L{oit e,D;HHHllhl npeBhlWaeT npe,n;eJIhHhle H3,D;epJKKH Ha ee npOH3BO,n;CTBO.

Ho, reM He MeHee, cyWeCTByeT 60JIhillaJI npo6JIeMa C no,n;06Hoit nOJIHTHKoit npH ,n;aHHOH CTPYK'J'YPe 3aTPaT MOHOnOJIHH: MOHOnOJIHJI CTaHeT 6aHKpOToM. 31'0 npOH30H,n;eT nOTOMY, 'iTO Ha yPOBHe npo,n;yKTa q"'c COBOKYITHhle H3,D;epXKH «pHpMhl npeBhlCJlT ee COBOKYITHhlit ,n;OXo,n;.

Bhl MOXeTe BH.!leTL 9TY npo6JIeMY B paC'iere Ha e,n;HHHIlY npo,n;yKTa, 3aMe'iaJI, 'ITO cpe,n;HHe ~OBOKYITHhle H3,D;ep*l{H Ha e,n;HHHllY npo,n;yKTa npH ypOBHe npo,n;yKTa q"'c (3a,n;aHHhle BepTH­ KaJIhHhlM OTPe3KOM 01' ropH30HTaJIhHotl OCH ,n;o KpHBOit A1C) npeBOCXO,llHT yCTaHOBJIeHHhlit peryJIJlTOpHhlM OpraHOM ,n;OXO,n; B pmc Ha e,n;HHHllY npo,n;yKTa. llOCKOJIhKY cpe,n;HHe CYMMapHhle H3,D;epXKH Ha e,n;HHHllY npo.zlYKTa npeBhlillaIOT ,n;OXO,D;hl 01' e,D;HHHllhl npo,llyKTa, MOHonOJIHJI 6y­ ,n;eT «PYHKllHOHHpOBaTh B y6hlTOK. If eCJIH peryJIJlTOpHhlit opraH He CMJlrqHTCJI H He Ha3HaqHT 60JIee BhlCOKYIO lleHY Ha npo,n;yKT, MOHOnOJIHJI CTaHeT 6aHKpOTOM, eCJIH rocy,n;apCTBO He npe­ ,n;OCTaBHT eit Cy6CH,D;HIO B CYMMe nOHeceHHoro yWep6a.

.IJ:o 1984 ro.na AT&T 6hVIa 06Il\eHauHoHan:b~OHMOHOIIOJIHeH. ECJIH BaM HyxHO 6blJIO II03BOHHTb Ky.na-JIH60 B Coe.nHHeHHbIX IIITllTax, BbI IIOJIb30BaJIHCb YCJIYTIlMH

AT&T, IIOCKOJIbKy OHa 6hVIa e,IJ;HHCTBeHHOH TeJIe<PoHHOH KOMIIaHHeH B cTPaHe. Ee perymqJOBaJIH Ha OqeHb BblCOKOM ypOBHe, eH IIpe.zo,HBJIIDIH 'I'pe60BaHIDI K KaqeCTBy 06CJIYXHBaHHH, TPe60BaJIH IIpe.nOCTaBJIeHIDI TeJIe<pOHOB .lJ)Ul Bcex H BbI,Zumran:H ueHOBbIe TPe60BaHIDI, KOTOpble IIo.n.nep:lKHBaJIH KaqeCTBO ee TeJIeKOMMYHHKaUHOH­ HOro 06CJIYXHBaHIDI Ha BblCOKOM ypOBHe. Ho Bce paBHO 3TO 6blJIa CTOIIpoueHTHaH MOHOIIOJIIDl, H B 1984 ro.ny perneHHeM cy.na 6blJIO IIpe.nIIHcaHO paJ6HTb KOMIIaHHIO Ha MHO~ecTBOJIOKaJIbHbIX <pHpM ,IJ;JUI TOro, trro6bI CTHMYJIHpOBaTb KOHKYPeHUHIO.

ITo.n06HaH IIOJIHTHKa cpa60TaJIa HeBepOHTHO xoporno. BCKOpe B CIlIA 06paJOBaJICH PbIHOK TeJIe<PoHHbIX yc.rryr, r;LJ;e yCTaHOBHJIaCb BbICOKaH KOHKypeHUIDI MeJK,D;y <pHpMaMH, KOTOpble pa­ Hee 6billH qaCThIO AT& T. A COBCeM He.naBHO HH.nyCTPIDI TeJIe<poHHbIX c~ CTaJIa eIIJ.e 60JIee KOHKypeHTHOH, 6JIaro.napH IIOHBJIeHHIO KOMIIaHHH Mo6HJIbHOH CBH3H, KOMIIaHHH MHTepHeT­ TeJIe<pOHHH H .n~e KOMIIaHHH Ka6eJIbHoro TeJIeBH.IJ;eHIDI, IIpe,IJ;JIaraIOIl\HX ~JIe<poHHbleYCJIY­ rH. IIo.no6HaH 3.nOpOBaH KOHKypeHUIDI COKPaIllaeT npo6JIeMbI, CBH3aHHble C MOHOIIOJIIDIMH, H rapaHTHpyeT, ~o c~6aTeJIeKOMMYHHKaUHH 6y.neT ~BaTbKJIHeHTOB IIO HH3KOH ce6e­ CTOHMOCTH, HO Ha BblCOKOM ypoBHe:

C03,UaHHe KOHKypeHUHH OqeHb y.n06Ho C TOqKH 3peHIDI B3aHMo.neHcTBIDI C MOHOIIOJIHeH, IIOCKOJIbKy no aHHYJIHpyeT JaTPaTbI, CBH3aHHbIe C 06H3aTeJIbHbIM npo.no~eHHeMHa6JIIO.ne­

HIDI 3a peryJIHpyeMoH MOHOIIOJIHeH. Kax H 06'bSlCHHIO B maBe 11, KOHKypeHUIDI 06eCIIeqHBaeT COUHaJIbHO OIITHMaJIbHbIJt ypoBeHb IIpOH3BO.nCTBa 6e30 BCHKOro ueH1'paJIH30BaHHOro KOHTPQ­

JUl. B peryJIHPyeMbIX MOHOIIOJIIDIX, Hao6,opoT, 06~HO TPe6yeTcH C03.naHHe .nOporocTOHIl\ero 6IOpoKpa~ecKoroaIIIIapaTa H BBe.neHHe B .neijCTBHe 3aKOHOB H HHCTPYKUHJt.

rJlasa 13

OnMrononMSI M MOHOnOnMCTM'IeCKaR

KOHKYpeH,-,MSI

B.!J1Iio1i uale...

»'-lTO AellaTb - KOHKYpHpOBaTb HllH AOrOBOpHTbCIl H pa60TaTb B OllHrOnOllHH?

»KaK AOroBOpHBWH9CIl cPHpMbI npWIHHlllOT BpeA nOTpe6HTellllM H 06w,eCTBY

»KOHTPOl1b HaA cPHpMaMH, 'lT06b1 OHH He MOr11H AorOBopHTbCIl

»HcnOllb30BaHHe AHcPcPepeHLlHallHH npoAYKTa Mil

YKJlOHeHHIl OT HAeanbHo~ KOHKYpeHIIHH

»OrpaHH'leHHe npH6b111H B MOHonOl1HCTH'leCKO~

KOHKYpeHIIHH

<pHPMaMH H MOHOnOJIHH, f,l(e eCTb TOJIbKO O,l(Ha <pHpMa (H n03TOMY OTCyrCTByeT KOHKYpeH­ UHH). 3Ta rJIaBa nOCBSlIueHa ,l(B):M HHTepeCHblM npOMexyroqHblM <popMaM.

nepBCUl H3 HHX - 3TO OJIHronOJIHSI, OTPaCJIb, B KOTOpoit eCTb TOJIbKO He6oJIbWOe qHMO <pHpM - ,l(Be, TPH HJlll HeMHoro 60JIbwe. CaMO CJIOBO HMeeT rpeqecKoe npOHCXO:JK,UeHHe H 03HaqaeT "MaJIO npo,l(aBUOB". K OJIHrOnOJIHHM OTHOCSITCSI TaKHe OTPaCJIH, KaK npOH3BO,l(CTBO 6e3aJlKOroJIbHbIX HanHTKOB, ,l(06b1t(a He<l>TH H 3JIeKTPOHHble Hrpbl. HanpHMep, Ha pbIHKe 003­ aJIKOroJIbHblX HanHTKOB ,l(OMHHHPYIOT KOMnaHHH Coke H Pepsi, 3HaqHTeJIbHO Onepe)f{llIOUJ;He no YPOBHIO npo,l(ax<: OCTaJIbHblX npOH3BO,l(HTeJIeit fa3HpoBKH. nOXOXHM o6pa30M BcefO TPH HJlH qeTblpe CTPaHbI npOH3BO,l(SIT 60JIbWyK> qaCTb Bceit ,l(06b1BaeMoit B MHpe He<pTH. M eCTb TOJIbKO TPH KOMnaHHH, KOTopble npoH3BO,lUlT H np0,l(aIOT aBTOMaTbI)J)UI BH,D;eoHrp, KOTOpblMH 3aTeM nOJIb3yeTCSI BeCb MHp.

OJIHfOnOJIbHble 0TPaCJIH HHTepecHbI TeM, 'ITO B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT OC06bIX 06CTOSITeJIbCTB <pHPMbI MOryr HJlH 6e3XaJIOCTHO KOHKYPHpOBaTb ,l(pyr C ,l(pyrOM, HJlH BblCTYnaTb e,l(HHblM <pPOHTOM - nOqTH TaK :lKe, KaK 3TO .zleJIaIOT MOHOnOJIHH. 3TO 3HaqHT, 'ITO B HeKOTOpblX CJIy­ qaSIX OJIHfOnOJIHH MOryr 6bITb npe,l(OCTaBJIeHbI caMH ce6e, nOC}COJIbKY KOHKYPeHUHSI rapaHTH­ pyeT, 'ITO OHH npOH3BO,l(SIT npo.ztYKT He COUHaJIbHO OnTHMaJIbHbIX ypOBHSIX, TOf,l(a KaK B ,l(pyrHX CJIY'laSIX He06xo,l(HMO peryJIHpOBaHHe CO CTOpoHbI focy,l(apCTBa C UeJIbIO npe,l(yllpe:JK,UeHIDI MO­ HOnOJIH3aUHH H COUHaJIbHO He:lKeJIaTeJIbHOfO nOBe,l(eHHH.

BTopoe npOMe:JKYTOqHOe COCTOHHHe OTPaCJIH Ha3bIBaeTCH He HHaqe, KaK MOHonOAucmu­

3TO O,lJ,HO 11,3 COqeTaHHA H,ll,eaJIbHOH KOHKypeHUHH II, MOHOnOJIHH. OCHOBHoe, ~O OTJI~aeT<pHPMbI 3TOro THna OT <pHpM, pa60TaIOillHX B YCJIOBIDIX H,ll,eaJIbHoH. KOHIcypeHUHH, - 3TO aUrjxpepeHt(uat(UJI npoiJylCma (product differentiation) - TaKoe HRJIeHHe, KOr,lJ,a KIDK,lJ;aH <pHpMa npOH3BO,lJ,HT HeMHoro OTJIWlaIO:mIDtcH OT ,lJ,PyrHX llpO.nyIcr.

3'ra maBa HaqHHaeTCH C ,lJ,eTaJIbHoro paCCMOTPeHHH OJIHronOJIHH II, nepeqHH TeX peweHHA, KOTopbIe <pHPMbI 3TOro BH,ll,a ,lJ,OJDKHbI npHHHMaTb. 3aTeM nepeMeM K aHaJIH3Y ~OHOnOJIH­

CTHqeCKOH KOHKYPeHUHH II, nOKlUKeM, noqeMY ,lJ,H<p<pepeHUHallHH npO,lJ,YKTa He 06H3aTeJIbHO npHHOCHT 3HaqHTeJIbHYIO npH6bIDb.

BbtO(lp: "OJUtlffu!JtIl,IIJl /LI,f,(, czo6'op·

B OTPacJIHX, r,lJ,e <PYHKUHOHHPYIOT TOJIbKO HeCKOJIbKO <PJlPM, npe,lJ,npIDITIDI ,lJ,OJDKHbI c,lJ,e­ JlaTb BbI60p, KOHKYPHpOBaTb HM Mil, KoonepHpoBaTbCH. 3Ta CH1YaUHJI oqe:fn, OTJI~aeTCHOT

HAeaJIbHOH KOHKYPeHUHH, onHcaHHOH B maDe 11.

B YCJIOBHHX HAeaJIbHO KOHKYPeHTHbIX PbIHKOB <PYHKUHOHHpyeT MHO)l(eCTBO Pa3HbIX <pHPM,

II, Ka)l()l;aH <pHpMa HBJIHeTCH HaCTOJIbKO MaJIOH qacTHueA pbIHKa, 'ITO ee npo.nyIcr He OKa3b1­ BaeT HHKaKoro RJIHHHHH Ha PbIHOqHYIO ueHy. B pe3YJIbTaTe KOHKYPHpYIOillHe <pHPMbI TOJIbKO npHHHMaIOT PbIHOqHYIO ueHy KaK ,lJ,aHHOCTb II, COOTBeTCTBeHHO KOppeKTHPYIOT OObeM CBoero npoH3BO,lJ,CTBa AJIH TOro, ~bI n~HTbKaK MO)I(HO 6oJIbrnyIO npH6bIDb.

CTpaTenUI§_ onr,UOnOflbHblX cl»MpM

~W:"~ O,lJ,HaKO Ha pbIHKe, r,lJ,e ecTb Deero HeCKOJIbKO npo)laBUOB, ~ 11,3 HHX npoH3BO­

,ll,HT ,lJ,OCTaTOqHO 6oJIbrnyIO 'IaCTb BceH llpoA}'KUHH AJIH TOro, 'lT06bI 6bITb cnoco6HbIM

~.nOBJIHHTb Ha PbIH0'lHYJO ueHy. HanpHMep, B CoeAHHeHHbIX ill'IJiTaX ,lJ,eHCTBYJOT,lJ,Ba OCHOBHbIX npoH3BO,lJ,HTeJIH CO,lJ,OBOH co BKYCOM KOJIbI: Coke II, Pepsi. ~ ABe Kopno­

paUHH npoH3BO,lJ,HT HacTOJIbKO 3Ha'lHTeJIbHYIO qacTb Bee» npoA}'KUHH, 'ITO eCJIH O,lJ,HH 11,3 HHX BHe3anHO yBeJIH'IHT nOCTIlBKH, PbIHO'IHaH ueHa Ha CO,lJ,OBYIO co BKYCOM KOJIbI ynan;eT ,lJ,O KpHTHqeCKOH OTMeTKH. YBeJI~eHHeom.eMa BbmycKa, C,lJ,eJIaHHoe OAHOH KOMnaHHeH, CHH3HT ueHbI Ha llpo)(yKUHIO APyrHX KOMllllHHH 3TOro PbIHKa.

)l,pyrHMH CJlOBaMH, eCJIH Pepsi BbinyCTHT BABOe 60JIbme CBoero npO,lJ,yKTa II, 6YKBaJIbHO 3aJIbeT PbIHOK CBOe:H ra3HpoBKoA, ueHa 3TOro HanHTKa qpe3BhI'IaHHO CHH3HTCH. Ho nOCKOJIb­

KY 60JIbllIHHCTBO JIIO,lJ,eH He CTonpOueHTHO JIOHJIbHbI no OTHomeHHIO K TOMY Mil, ,lJ,pyrOMY 6peH,!J,Y, TO eCJIH ueHa Pepsi CHH3HTCH ,lJ,O KP~eCKOH OTMeTKH, MaCca nOCTOHHHbIX nOTpe6H­ TeJIeH npO.lJYKllHH KOMnaHHH Coke nepeMeTHeTCH K KOH~H'I)' II, CTaHeT nRTh Pepsi. A nOTOM CHH3HTCH ueHa II, Ha /

Pepsi II, Coke BOBJIeqeHbI B CH1YauHIO, r,lJ,e KIDK,lJ;oe 11,3 peweHHH 0 KOJI~ecTBe npo­ H3BO,lJ,HMOA npo,lJ,YKUHH RJIHHeT He TOJIbKO Ha HX C06cTBeHHbIe npo,lJ,a)I(H, HO II, Ha npo,lJ,~ KOHKYPeHTOB. 3KOHOMHCTbI Ha3bIBaIOT TaKHe CH'I)'auHH cml!amezuIteclCu­ MU cumyat(UJlMu, nOCKOJIbKY <pHpMbI, BOBJIeqeHHble B HHX, ,lJ,OJI)I(Hbi pemaTb, KaKOH BHA CTPaTerHH HM BbI6paTb. B qaCTHOCTH, OHH ,lJ,OJDKHhI peWHTb, KOHKypHpoBaTb HM./Mil, KoonepHpoBaTbCH.

1