Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
akRjT] ZiemXockY] akN, eiZ kak kjiRm ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, jm oSai_ime ^ckWjiZi]k RmeZo dTciJmjjoP
oecigamdoP ^ckji_amJjogek.
E.. Z\^od oe]mRia, Reo MiciZemcjT]k gdoPgedo] ^cido^ck]mjmjkY YdaYmegY cmiakWiNkY joc] \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^cidi do
dWik]ogdYWk g ^ck]mjmjkm] _c\XkM oecigamP dj\eckXog\_icgedmjjoXo
^cidi, i eiZJm ]mJ_\jico_joXo k kjogecijjoXo ^cidi. 1_jk] kW ^\-
^cojkZjodmjkY kjoco_jTM» joc] ^cidi d \XoaodjTP ^coNmgg Yd-
emP «
aYIegY ^cY]Tm ^cm_^kgijkY \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTM joc]
1
.
/oJjo ^cm_^oaoJkeQ, Reo dodamRmjkm d ^coNm_\c\ \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi joc] _c\XkM oecigamP ^cidi ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z kjgeke\e\ doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN
d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, oS\gaodamjo jmoSMo_k]ogeQI
dgmgeocojjmXo \cmX\akcodijkY oSKmgedmjjTM oejoFmjkP, doWjkZiIKkM ]mJ_\ ^cm_\g]oecmjjT]k d WiZojm \RigejkZi]k d gdYWk g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i.
"iZ, goXaigjo R. 5 ge. 133
:C> E?, d kjTM ga\RiYM (Zco]m ^mcmRkgamjjTM d R. 1—4 \ZiWijjoP geieQk) do^cogT, gdYWijjTm g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i, ciWcmFiIegY d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
i ogjodijkk R. 2 ge. 136 :C> E? kgZk o Zo]^mjgiNkk Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP ]ociaQjTP dcm_ d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk ^cm_%YdaYIegY d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 8 \ZiWijjo] ^ocY_Zm ]oX\e
ciWcmFieQgY
k do^cogT d ga\Rim jm\_odamedocmjkY g\_o] ecmSodijkP
o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i kak jmgoXaigkY cmiSkakekcodijjoXo g ^ckjYeT]
g\_mSjT] cmFmjkm] (R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E?).
$W ^oaoJmjkP ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe
29 joYScY 2011 X. & 17 \g]ieckdimegY, Reo d Rigek ecmSodijkP, ogeidamjjTM
SmW cigg]oecmjkY
d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] ge. 399 :C> E?,
cmiSkakekcodijjTP d^cidm oSciekeQgY d g\_ d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo
2
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi (^. 10)
.
$WaoJmjjom ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z cmiakWiNkk
^cidooejoFmjkP d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ]oJjo XodockeQ jm geoaQZo o dWik]ogdYWk ^ck]mjmjkY joc] :C> E? g joc]i]k XciJ_ijgZoXo
^cidi, oS kM Wik]gedodijkk g NmaQI \gZocmjkY ^coNm_\cT ciWcmFmjkY
do^cogi d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo ^coNmggi, gZoaQZo o ;iZekRmgZoP doW]oJjogek cmFmjkY do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i d
^ocY_Zm XciJ_ij-
gZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
1
Z\^od E..
/.: /8/ /8 E?, 1993. A. 18.
2
EoggkPgZiY XiWmei. 2011, 5 _mZ.
Ccido^ck]mjmjkm d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Eoggkk (Ick_kRmgZkm ^coSam]T).
121
1SciKime ji gmSY djk]ijkm eo oSgeoYemaQgedo, Reo d gooedmegedkk g R. 2 ge. 135 :C> E? do^cogT o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo
g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm], ]oX\e STeQ ciWcmFmjT d ^cm_maiM gcoZod kgZodoP _idjogek, \geijodamjjTM > E?. ijjom ^oaoJmjkm WiZoji ]oJjo cigg]ieckdieQ ZiZ g^ogoSged\IKmm \^ocY_oRmjkI
^ocY_Zi doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ZiZ d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo, eiZ
k \Xo-
aodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
:Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP WiZoj ^cm_ogeidaYme doW]oJjogeQ oSciekeQgY g ecmSodijkm] o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 8 ga\Rim doamkW%YdamjkY WikjemcmgodijjoXo akNi
kjkNkkcodieQ ^coNm_\c\ cmiakWiNkk Zo]^mjgiNkojjo-doggeijodkemaQjTM ]mc d ;oc]m XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ]iemckiaQjo^cidodT] ogjodijkm] _aY doW]mKmjkY dcm_i S\_me ge. 1070 > E?,
^cm_\g]ieckdiIKiY oedmegedmjjogeQ Wi dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP
jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY,
^coZ\cie\cT k g\_i, i ^ck doW]mKmjkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i — ge. 151,
152, 1099—1101 > E?.
mg]oecY ji eo, Reo MiciZemc ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i oS\gaodamj mXo ^ckRkjmjkm] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ^ogeci_idFkP g\S%mZe, goXaigjo ge. 38 C> E? ^ckoScmeime geie\g
XciJ_ijgZoXo kgeNi, ji ZoeocoXo cig^cogecijYIegY ^oaoJmjkY ^o_
ciW_. II C> E?, cmXai]mjekc\IKkm kgZodom ^cokWdo_gedo.
8 ZiRmgedm XciJ_ijgZoXo oedmeRkZi S\_me dTge\^ieQ /kjkgemcgedo
;kjijgod E?, ^cm_geidaYIKmm ZiWj\ Eoggkk, Wi gRme ZoeocoP goXaigjo
1
ge. 1070 > E? og\KmgedaYmegY doW]mKmjkm ^ckRkjmjjoXo dcm_i
.
"iZk] oSciWo], ]oJjo g_maieQ dTdo_, Reo ^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ^ck o^cm_mamjjTM \gaodkYM k doamkW%Ydamjkk
^ogeci_idFmXo akNi, ^cidooejoFmjkY d \ZiWijjoP g;mcm ^mcmMo_Ye d
^aogZogeQ XciJ_ijgZo-^cidodTM k ^o_amJie cmX\akcodijkI d ci]ZiM
XciJ_ijgZoXo k XciJ_ijgZoXo ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^cidi.
8]mgem g em] goXaigjo R. 5 ge. 135 k R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E?, doW]mKm-
k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i k doggeijodamjkm kjTM ^cid cmiSkakek-
jkm
codijjoXo og\KmgedaYmegY d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] ge. 399 :C> E?
_aY ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g kg^oajmjkm] ^ckXodoci.
jiakW go_mcJijkY _ijjoP joc]T ^ckdo_ke Z gam_\IKk] dTdo_i]. AoXaigjo ^. 1 R. 1 ge. 399 :C> E?, do^cogT, gdYWijjTm g kg^oajm-
-
1
C\jZe 118 EmXai]mjei CcidkemaQgedi E?, \ed. ^ogeijodamjkm] CcidkemaQgedi E? oe
1 kIaY 2004 X. // A E?. 2004. & 23. Ae. 2313; CoaoJmjkm o /kjkgemcgedm ;kjijgod E?,
\ed. ^ogeijodamjkm] CcidkemaQgedi E? oe 30 kIjY 2004 X. & 329 // A E?. 2004. & 31.
Ae. 3258; CoaoJmjkm o ?m_mciaQjo] ZiWjiRmPgedm, \ed. ^ogeijodamjkm] CcidkemaQgedi
E? oe 1 _mZiScY 2004 X. & 703 // A E?. 2004. & 49. Ae. 4908.
122
jkm] ^ckXodoci, cigg]ieckdiIegY g\_o] ^o Mo_ieiPged\ cmiSkakekcodijjoXo d ga\Rim, \ZiWijjo] d ^. 1 ge. 397 :C> E?, X_m XodockegY o
eo], Reo g\_ cigg]ieckdime do^cogT o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjo]\, doggeijodamjkk mXo ec\_odTM, ^mjgkojjTM, JkakKjTM k
kjTM ^cid d gooedmegedkk g R. 5 ge. 135 k R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E?, ZoeocTm,
d gdoI oRmcm_Q, oegTaiIe
^cido^ck]mjkemaY Z ge. 399 :C> E?.
8oWjkZime do^cog o g\Kjogek ecmSodijkP akNi, cmiakW\IKmXo
^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, i eiZJm k o ^cidodo] geie\gm \^cido]oRmjjTM k ^cidooSYWijjTM g\S%mZeod.
kZiZkM ZojZcmejTM \ZiWijkP ^o ,eo]\ ^odo_\ ge. 399 :C> E?
jm go_mcJke, i d R. 2 _ijjoP joc]T ^cm_geidamjo ^oaoJmjkm, goXaigjo
Zoeoco]\ «mgak do^cog ZigimegY kg^oajmjkY ^ckXodoci
d Rigek XciJ_ijgZoXo kgZi, eo d g\_mSjom Wigm_ijkm ]oX\e STeQ dTWdijT XciJ_ijgZkP kgemN k XciJ_ijgZkP oedmeRkZ», Zoeocom ji ^ciZekZm ^o ijiaoXkk
^ck]mjYmegY k Z ^cidooejoFmjkY] d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, A\_mSjiY ZoaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcMod-
joXo A\_i E?, cigg]oecmd d g\_mSjo] Wigm_ijkk _mao
^o ZiggiNkojjoP
JiaoSm c\Zodo_kemaY :^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod ^o >cigjo_icgZo]\ ZciI ji ^ogeijodamjkm g\_Qk
>cigjo_icgZoXo ZcimdoXo g\_i o dWTgZijkk _mjmJjTM gcm_ged d ^oaQW\
cmiSkakekcodijjoXo E., oe]mjkai og^ickdim]om ^ogeijodamjkm. 1gjodijkm] _aY eiZoXo cmFmjkY g\_ gRma eo, Reo d _mam oeg\eged\Ie _ijjTm oS kWdmKmjkk o ga\Fijkk _mai ^cm_geidkemaY XciJ_ijgZoXo
oedmeRkZi, ZoeocT]
, ^o ]jmjkI g\_i, g Rm] dcY_ ak ]oJjo goXaigkeQgY,
YdaYmegY :^cidamjkm ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod ^o >cigjo_icgZo]\ ZciI k _mao ;iZekRmgZk STao cigg]oecmjo
1
SmW mXo \RigekY
.
1_jiZo akNo, k]mIKmm ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, jkX_m jm ;kX\ckc\me ZiZ XciJ_ijgZkP
kgemN, d eo Jm dcm]Y jm \cmX\akcodij k do^cog o ^cido] geie\gm g\S%mZeod, ^cm_geidaYIKkM kjemcmgT ZiWjT. 1SogjodijjT] ^cm_geidaYmegY dTdo_, Reo \ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo j\J_imegY d ji_amJiKmP
^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk.
8 Ick_kRmgZoP akemcie\cm oe]mRimegY, Reo
^ogZoaQZ\ XciJ_ijgZkP kgZ d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm goXaigjo oSKm]\ \RmjkI oS kgZiM, YdaYmegY kgZo] o ^ckg\J_mjkk, eo ,eo oSgeoYemaQgedo ^cm_^oaiXime
jiakRkm _d\M ^coNmgg\iaQjTM geocoj g ^coekdo^oaoJjT]k kjemcm-
1
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A> ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 6 ]icei
2003 X. & 18-Z^o03-11.
123
gi]k — kgeNi k oedmeRkZi. $gemN d ,eo] ga\Rim og\KmgedaYme ;\jZNkI ^o__mcJZk XciJ_ijgZoXo kgZi, i oedmeRkZ doWciJime ^coekd
1
^cm_%YdamjjoXo kgZi
.
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z doW]mKmjkI dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi dcY_ ak ^cidkaQjo XodockeQ o jiakRkk \ geocoj ^coekdo^oaoJjTM kjemcmgod, eiZ ZiZ doW]mKmjkm dcm_i YdaYmegY
cmiakWiNkmP Xog\_icgedmjjTM oSYWiemaQged. _mgQ \]mgejmm XodockeQ
oS \eoRjmjkk geocoji]k oS%m]i ^o_amJiKmXo doW]mKmjkI dcm_i.
>co]m eoXo, goXaigjo ge. 44 :C> E? XciJ_ijgZk] kgeNo] YdaYmegY
akNo, ^cm_%YdkdFmm ecmSodijkm o
doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ^ck jiakRkk ogjodijkP ^oaiXieQ, Reo _ijjTP dcm_ ^ckRkjmj m]\ k]mjjo ^cmge\^amjkm]. Cck ,eo] d ZiRmgedm XciJ_ijgZoXo oedmeRkZi, goXaigjo R. 1
ge. 54 :C> E?, ]oJme STeQ ^ckdamRmjo ;kWkRmgZom kak Ick_kRmgZom
akNo, Zoeocom d gooedmegedkk g > E? jmgme oedmegedmjjogeQ Wi dcm_,
^ckRkjmjjTP ^cmge\^amjkm].
1Rmdk_jo, Reo jk Z o_joP kW
\ZiWijjTM ZiemXockP jmaQWY oejmgek
jk akNo, ji_mamjjom ^cido] ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i d gooedmegedkk g
^oaoJmjkY]k Xa. 18 :C> E?, jk ^cm_geidkemamP ZiWjT, Wi gRme ZoeocoP dcm_ ^o_amJke doW]mKmjkI.
:RmjTm-^coNmgg\iakgeT oe]mRiIe, Reo ^cm_]meo] XciJ_ijgZoXo
kgZi d \Xoaodjo] _mam YdaYmegY oSciKmjjom Z g\_\ ecmSodijkm o ^ckj\_kemaQjoP ^mcm_iRm dmKk kak _mjmX d ZiRmgedm
doW]mKmjkY Wi dcm_,
^ckRkjmjjTP ^cmge\^amjkm]. 1gjodijkY]k kgZi dTge\^iIe Ick_kRmgZkm ;iZeT, kW ZoeocTM kgemN dTdo_ke gdok ^ckeYWijkY k g ZoeocT]k
WiZoj gdYWTdime doWjkZjodmjkm ^cidooejoFmjkY ]mJ_\ kgeNo] k oedmeRkZo]: godmcFmjkm ^cmge\^amjkY, ^ckRkjmjjTP kgeN\ dcm_, jiakRkm
^ckRkjjoP gdYWk ]mJ_\ godmcFmjjT] ^cmge\^amjkm] k jige\^kdFk]k
2
^ogam_gedkY]k d dk_m ]iemckiaQjoXo k ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i
.
Aam_odiemaQjo, g\KjogeQ XciJ_ijgZoXo kgZi d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm,
cigZcTdiIKiYgY d mXo ^cm_]mem k ogjodijkk, oeakRimegY oe g\Kjogek
ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i XciJ_iji], ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP
daigemP d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. Cogam_jYY WiZaIRimegY
d ^ckWjijjo] Wi ^ogeci_idFk] XciJ_ijkjo] ^cidm ji mXo doW]mKmjkm,
d XicijekcodijjoP WiZojo] doW]oJjogek _ijjom ^cido cmiakWodieQ,
ZiZ d ;oc]m XciJ_ijgZoXo, eiZ
k \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, jmWi-
dkgk]o oe dkjT ocXijod k _oaJjogejTM akN.
1
oJQmd 8.C.
Jm.
ciJ_ijgZkP kgZ d \Xoaodjo] _mam ZiZ ^cm_]me \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTM oejoFm-
jkP // EoggkPgZkP gam_odiemaQ. 2011. & 16. A. 16—19.
2
/iMod 8. ., EiW\]odgZkP ..
, 2009. A. 28, 29, 36, 37.
ciJ_ijgZkP kgZ d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm // iZojjogeQ. 2004. & 7. A. 3;
ciJ_ijgZkP kgZ d \Xoaodjo] _mam. /.: $"$-
124
1j
"iZk] oSciWo], ^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i d
^ocY_Zm ge. 399 :C> E? _aY ^codm_mjkY ijiaoXkk g XciJ_ijgZk] kgZo]
d \Xoaodjo] _mam oeg\eged\Ie ZiZkm-akSo oS%mZekdjTm ogjodijkY.
>co]m eoXo, d WiZojm ^cm_\g]oecmj NmaTP cY_ ^coNm_\cjTM do^cogod doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo k Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo
dcm_i (ge. 135, 136 :C> E?). Aam_odiemaQjo, do^cogT, doWjkZiIKkm
d gdYWk g doW]mKmjkm]
aodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZoji, eiZ k XciJ_ijgZoXo, XciJ_ijgZoXo
^coNmgg\iaQjoXo. Cck ,eo] ^coNmgg cmiakWiNkk Zo]^mjgiNkojjodoggeijodkemaQjTM ]mc ]oJme dTMo_keQ Wi ^cm_maT \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\, og\KmgedaYeQgY
^ck goSaI_mjkk gcoZod kgZodoP _idjogek, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM > E?,
\Jm ^ogam mXo WidmcFmjkY.
geQ ogjodijkY ^oaiXieQ, Reo
ogjod\ k d eo Jm dcm]Y gi]ogeoYemaQjTP kjgeke\e
dcm_i, ]oX\e STeQ cmFmjT ZiZ ji ogjodm \Xo-
k]mIKkP \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQj\I
«8oW]mKmjkY dcm_i
^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi»
^cidodoXo kjgeke\ei, eiZ ZiZ ^cidooejoFmjkY d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY
dcm_i cmX\akc\IegY joc]i]k kjTM, Zco]m \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo,
oecigamP ^cidi.
oSai_ime ^ckWjiZi]k g]mFijjoXo ]mJoecigamdoXo
aidi 3. CcidodTm ogjodT, ]mMijkW]T
cmiakWiNkk k ^mcg^mZekdT godmcFmjgedodijkY
kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk
3.1. :Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTm ogjodijkY cmiSkakeiNkk
1gjodTdiYgQ ji cmW\aQeieiM ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY, cigZcTdiIKkM \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQj\I ^ckco_\ kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk,
oeakRj\I oe ^cidodoP ^ckco_T ]mJoecigamdoXo ^cidodoXo kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN
d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, jmoSMo_k]o ^ogam_odiemaQjo
cigg]oecmeQ do^cogT, ^oWdoaYIKkm cigZcTeQ go_mcJijkm k ogoSmjjogek cmiakWiNkk ZiJ_oXo kW jkM.
8 ^mcd\I oRmcm_Q ^o_amJie kW\RmjkI em kM
WijT g g\KjogeQI k ^ogam_gedkY]k ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM d ci]ZiM _mPged\IKmXo kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk ogjodijkP, \geijodamjkm ZoeocTM
oS\gaodakdime doWjkZjodmjkm k cmiakWiNkI ^cidooejoFmjkP d g;mcm
cmiSkakeiNkk k (kak) doW]mKmjkY dcm_i. Cck ,eo], MiciZemckW\Y go_mcJijkm kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk g eoRZk WcmjkY ^cm_aiXim]TM ji]k
ZojNm^e\iaQjTM ^o_Mo_od Z ^ojk]ijkI g\Kjogek cmiSkakeiNkk,
ogeijodk]gY, d ^mcd\I oRmcm_Q
, ji damZ\KkM mm ogjodijkYM.
AeieQY 133 :C> E? k]mj\megY «1gjodijkY doWjkZjodmjkY ^cidi
ji cmiSkakeiNkI». 8 Ick_kRmgZoP akemcie\cm mm go_mcJijkm eciZe\megY jmo_joWjiRjo. CckRkji doWjkZiIKkM ciWjoXaigkP gcm_k \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod dk_kegY jm eoaQZo d gaoJjogek ;oc]\akcodZk,
jmo_joco_jo] go_mcJijkk ^oaoJmjkP, jo k d jmoSMo_k]ogek \geijodamjkY kM aoXkRmgZoP dWik]ogdYWk g godoZ\^jogeQI kjTM ^cido-
^cm_^kgijkP, go_mcJiKkMgY ZiZ d Xa. 18 :C> E?, eiZ k d _c\XkM
dTM
Zoccmg^oj_kc\IKkM g jmP ^cidodTM joc]iM.
8 gooedmegedkk g ^cm_aiXim]oP ideoco] ZojNm^NkmP cmiSkakeiNkk,
d jiWdijkk ge. 133 :C> E? gam_\me oeciWkeQ ^oaoJmjkY, cigZcTdiIKkm ;iZekRmgZom go_mcJijkm _d\M Xc\^^ ogjodijkP. > ^mcdoP kW jkM
oejogYegY ogjodijkY cmiSkakeiNkk, i Zo deocoP — ogjodijkY doW]mKmjkY
dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ZoeocTm ]oX\e jm god^i_ieQ. _mgQ gam_\me
^o_RmcZj\eQ, Reo ]T ciW_maYm] eoRZ\ WcmjkY \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod,
^oaiXiIKkM jmoSMo_k]T] ciWXcijkRmjkm ogjodijkP ^cmZciKmjkY
\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY, damZ\KkM cmiSkakeiNkI k jm ^ocoJ_iI-
1
KkM ^ogam_gedkP d dk_m cmiSkakeiNkk
.
ig^mZeT, ZoeocTm gdY-
1
ciFkRmdi 1. .
gedkk g cmiSkakeiNkmP akN: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. /., 2009. A. 20.
CcmZciKmjkm \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY ji ^cm_dickemaQjo] gam_-
126
Eigg]oecmjkm ogjodijkP ^cmZciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY) ^cm_^oaiXimegY gooedmegedmjjo d ci]ZiM kggam_odijkY go_mcJijkY «$jgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk» k «$jgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi» k ^cm_geidaYmegY Soamm cmW\aQeiekdjT] d
ZojemZgem ^cm_aoJmjjoP cm_iZNkk k]mjodijkY ge. 133 :C> E? —
«1gjodijkY cmiSkakeiNkk k doW]mKmjkY dcm_i».
Aam_\me Wi]mekeQ
, Reo d WiZojo_iemaQgedm ?cijNkk doW]mKmjkm
\KmcSi gdYWTdiIe g ;iZeo] oZojRijkY ^coNmggi g\_o^cokWdo_gedi d
oejoFmjkk ZojZcmejoXo akNi k godoZ\^jogeQI \geijodamjjTM g^mNkiaQjoP Zo]kggkmP \gaodkP: ^o_edmcJ_mjkm ;iZei, Reo ^cm_dickemaQjom
WiZaIRmjkm ;iZekRmgZk k]mao ]mgeo k STao ^coekdoWiZojjT] k \STeoRjT] _aY kjemcmgod ^oemc^mdFmXo; jiakRkm cmFmjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk
\XoaodjoXo _mai kak o^cid_ijkY; eYJmgeQ \KmcSi, o^cm_maYm]iY ^co_oaJkemaQjogeQI ^cm_dickemaQjoXo WiZaIRmjkY k gem^mjQI mXo doW_mPgedkY ji goNkiaQj\I k ,]oNkojiaQj\I JkWjQ ^ogeci_idFmXo akNi
1
iciZemckW\Y d ci]ZiM kggam_\m]oXo do^cogi go_mcJijkm ge. 133
:C> E?, gam_\me oe]mekeQ, Reo jmZoeocTm ideocT, ogeidaYY SmW djk]ijkY eoe ;iZe, Reo d _ijjoP joc]m cmRQ k_me oS ogjodijkYM doWjkZjodmjkY
^cidi ji cmiSkakeiNkI
:C> E? o^cm_mamjT ogjodijkY _aY cmiSkakeiNkk
, oSogjodijjo ^oaiXiIe, Reo d ge. 133
2
.
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo kW ^mcmRjY ogjodijkP, go_mcJiKkMgY
d ge. 133 :C> E?, jm dgm kW jkM ^ckdo_Ye Z ^ckjYekI cmFmjkP, gdYWijjTM g cmiSkakeiNkmP, jmoSMo_k]o ZojZcmekWkcodieQ, ZiZkm k]mjjo damZ\e ^ck]mjmjkm ^oaoJmjkP kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk.
8 ^mcd\I oRmcm_Q, cigg]oeck] ogjodijkY dTjmgmjkY o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci, ji ZoeocTP \ZiWijo d ^. 1 R. 2 ge. 133 :C>
E?.
Co g^cidm_akdo]\ ]jmjkI \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod ^ckXodoc g\_i
iZZ\]\akc\me cmW\aQeieT kggam_odijkY _oZiWiemaQged d Mo_m g\_mSjoXo
ciWSkciemaQgedi. Cck oS%mZekdjo], dgmgeocojjm] k ^oajo ^codm_mjjo] g\_mSjo] gam_gedkk goW_iIegY ^cm_^ogTaZk _aY dTjmgmjkY ZiZ oS-
3
dkjkemaQjoXo, eiZ k o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci
.
AoNkiaQjo-jcidgedmjjTm k ^cidodTm ^ogam_gedkY o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci dgmX_i jiMo_kakgQ d ^oam WcmjkY \RmjTM, MiciZemckW\Y ^cmm]gedmjjogeQ ^o_Mo_od Z kM oNmjZm.
.
1
/mjQFkM ..
^coNmggm ?cijNkk // \cjia coggkPgZoXo ^cidi. 2003. & 5. A. 124—129.
2
"ieQYjkj .8.
^coNmgg\iaQjTP ^ocY_oZ): kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. $JmdgZ, 2005. A. 82.
3
Cmec\Mkj $..
Ccog^mZe, 2009. A. 82.
iKkei ^cid jmWiZojjo WiZaIRmjjTM kak og\J_mjjTM d \Xoaodjo]
EmiSkakeiNkY d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Eoggkk (^ojYekm, dk_T, ogjodijkY,
1^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc k ^cido ji cmiSkakeiNkI: /ojoXc. /.:
127
"iZ, \RmjTm-^coNmgg\iakgeT oe]mRiak, Reo o^cid_ijkm jmdkjodjoXo, jmoSogjodijjo ^ckdamRmjjoXo Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek, YdaYmegY diJjT] gcm_gedo] mXo ^\SakRjoP cmiSkakeiNkk, doggeijodamjkY ^cid k cm^\eiNkk, ^ckWTdiY dgm]mcjo ^odTFieQ WjiRmjkm k ^cmgekJ o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci, goW_idiY \gaodkY _aY eoXo, ReoST
g\_Qk jm \ZaojYakgQ oe kM dTjmgmjkY ^ck jiakRkk Z eo]\ ogjodijkP
AoXaigjo R. 2 ge. 302 :C> E? dTjmgmjkm o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci oSYWiemaQjo d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i jm \geijodamjo goSTekm ^cmge\^amjkY, ^o_g\_k]TP jm ^ckRigemj Z godmcFmjkI ^cmge\^amjkY, d
_mYjkk ^o_g\_k]oXo oeg\eged\me gogeid ^cmge\^amjkY, d oejoFmjkk
^o_g\_k]oXo ZoaamXkmP ^ckgYJjTM Wigm_iemamP dTjmgmj o^cid_iemaQjTP dmc_kZe.
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z ^ogam_jm]\ ogjodijkI, gciW\ Jm MoemaogQ ST oe]mekeQ, Reo
oeckNiemaQjTm oedmeT ^ckgYJjTM Wigm_iemamP ji do^cogT
o eo], _oZiWijo ak, Reo _mYjkm k]mao ]mgeo, _oZiWijo ak Reo ,eo _mYjkm
godmcFka ^o_g\_k]TP, dkjodmj ak ^o_g\_k]TP d godmcFmjkk ,eoXo
_mYjkY, gi]k ^o gmSm gdk_memaQged\Ie oS kM \SmJ_mjjogek d jmoSMo_k]ogek kgZaIRmjkY ^o_oWcmjkP k oSdkjmjkP.
"iZk] oSciWo], dTjmgmjkI o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci ^cm_Fm-
ged\me \geijodamjkm godoZ\^jogek oSgeoYemaQged,
gdk_memaQged\I-
KkM o jiakRkk ogjodijkP _aY _ijjoXo cmFmjkY.
8 godmegZo] \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Z ogjodijkY] ^ogeijodamjkY
o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci oejogkak, jicY_\ g _c\Xk]k, jm_oZiWijjogeQ \RigekY ^o_g\_k]oXo d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY. Cck ,eo] dgm
2
ogjodijkY d cidjoP gem^mjk cmiSkakekcodiak o^cid_ijjoXo
.
8]mgem g em] \RmjTm oe]mRiak, Reo dTjmgmjjTP ^o ogjodijkI jm_oZiWijjogek \RigekY ^o_g\_k]oXo d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY ^ckXodoc Scogia emjQ ji cm^\eiNkI o^cid_ijjoXo, jm gjk]ia g jmXo ^o_oWcmjkm d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY. AoW_idiaogQ d^mRieamjkm, Reo o^cid_ijjTP dgm Jm godmcFka ^cmge\^amjkm, jo m]\ \_iaogQ \ZaojkeQgY oe
Wiga\JmjjoP oedmegedmjjogek. "iZk] oSciWo], goMcijYagY
3
dTP kjgeke\e «ogeidamjkY d ^o_oWcmjkk»
.
gcm_jmdmZo-
8 jigeoYKmm dcm]Y ^cmW\]^NkY jmdkjodjogek, ZiZ ^ckjNk^ \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, WiZcm^amjjTP d ge. 14 :C> E?, oWjiRime,
Reo oSdkjYm]TP gRkeimegY jmdkjodjT], ^oZi mXo dkjodjogeQ d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY jm S\_me _oZiWiji d ^cm_\g]oecmjjo] WiZojo]
1
.
1
Cige\Mod /.$.
2
AodmegZkP \XoaodjTP ^coNmgg: :RmSjkZ / Co_ cm_. ./. >icjmmdoP, C.. \^kjgZoP,
$.8. "TckRmdRi. /.: ck_. ake., 1980. A. 396, 397; :XoaodjTP ^coNmgg: :RmSjkZ; 2-m kW_. /
Co_ cm_. >.?. \NmjZo. /.: mcNiao, 1997. A. 372.
3
Cmec\Mkj $..
1^cid_ijkm ^o_g\_k]oXo. /kjgZ, 1985. A. 25.
1^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc k ^cido ji cmiSkakeiNkI. A. 102.
128
^ocY_Zm k \geijodamji dge\^kdFk] d WiZojj\I gka\ ^ckXodoco] g\_i,
i jm_oZiWijjiY dkji, ^ckcidjkdimegY Z _oZiWijjoP jmdkjodjogek.
Aam_odiemaQjo, eiZom ogjodijkm _aY ^cmZciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai
(\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY) k o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci, ZiZ jm_oZiWijjogeQ \RigekY oSdkjYm]oXo (kak ^o_g\_k]oXo) d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY (^. 2 ge. 208 k ^. 3 R. 2 ge. 309 :C> EA?AE) cigNmjmjo
WiZojo_iemam] ZiZ \eciekdFmm
gdoI iZe\iaQjogeQ k jm jiFao gdomXo
oeciJmjkY d :C> E?.
idmcFmjkm ^cokWdo_gedi ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\ o^cid_iemaQjT]
^ckXodoco] gdk_memaQged\me o jmdkjodjogek akNi d kjZck]kjkcodijjo] _mYjkk. :ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo ^ocoJ_ime jmoSMo_k]ogeQ
o^cm_makeQgY d Xaidjo] do^cogm — YdaYmegY ak o^cid_iemaQjTP ^ck-
1
Xodoc
cmiSkakeiNkmP XciJ_ijkji, e.m. o;kNkiaQjT] ^ckWjijkm] Xog\_icgedo] d akNm g\_i ;iZei mXo jmdkjodjogek k doggeijodamjkY
akNi, ^ogeci_idFmXo d cmW\aQeiem \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY, d ^cmJjm] ^cidodo] geie\gm.
1SogjodijjT] ^cm_geidaYmegY dTdo_, Reo ji ,eoe do^cog gam_\me
oedmekeQ \edmc_kemaQjo ddk_\ eoXo oSgeoYemaQgedi, Reo _ijjT] cmFmjkm] o;kNkiaQjo Zojgeiekc\megY ;iZe o^cid_ijkY akNi, e.m., mXo
jmdkjodjogeQ.
mg]oecY ji oeg\egedkm ^cY]TM \ZiWijkP ji eo, Reo ogjodijkY dTjmgmjkY o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci oejogYegY Z ZiemXockk cmiSkakekc\IKkM, em] jm ]mjmm, ,eo g oRmdk_jogeQI \g]ieckdimegY kW g\Kjogek g\_mSjoXo iZei, ^ogam_gedkm] ZoeocoXo YdaYmegY ^oajom kgZaIRmjkm cijmm ^cm_%YdamjjTM oSdkjmjkP k cmiSkakeiNkY.
/.A. AecoXodkR g^cidm_akdo oe]mRia, Reo «dgYZkP o^cid_iemaQjTP
^ckXodoc, jmWidkgk]o oe ogjodijkP o^cid_ijkY, mgeQ ZiemXockRmgZom \edmcJ_mjkm, Reo ^o_g\_k]TP jmdkjodmj, \_ogeodmcmjkm
mXo jmdkjodjogek, ^oajiY k SmWoXodocoRjiY cmiSkakeiNkY o^cid_ijjoXo ^o_g\_k]oXo»
2
.
Ccm_geidaYmegY oRmdk_jT], Reo o^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc gam_\me cigg]ieckdieQ d ZiRmgedm iZei cmiSkakeiNkk ^o_g\_k]oXo k d
,eoP gdYWk jmoSMo_k]o mKm ciW ^o_RmcZj\eQ, Reo ^cidkaQjmm XodockeQ
jm o ^ckWjijkk ^cidi ji cmiSkakeiNkI, ZiZ \g]ieckdimegY kW go_mcJijkY R. 2 ge. 133 :C> E?, i o cmiSkakeiNkk, Reo k _oaJjo STeQ oeciJmjo d cmWoaIekdjoP Rigek
^ckXodoci.
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z do^cog\ oS ogjodijkYM cmiSkakeiNkk gam_\me
ciWakRieQ ogjodijkY dTjmgmjkY o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci, Zoeo-
1
A ]o]mjei dge\^amjkY mXo d WiZojj\I gka\.
2
AecoXodkR /.A.
Zi_m]kk ji\Z AAAE, 1947. A. 248, 249.
:Rmjkm o ]iemckiaQjoP kgekjm d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm. /.; .: $W_-do
129
cTm ]oJjo cigg]ieckdieQ ZiZ ogjodijkY cmiSkakeiNkk, k o^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc, ZiZ cmiSkakeiNkI.
Cco_oaJiY kggam_odijkm ^oaoJmjkP, gdYWijjTM g ogjodijkY]k
cmiSkakeiNkk, gam_\me Wiecoj\eQ do^cog o go_mcJijkk ^. 2 R. 2 ge. 133
:C> E?, goXaigjo Zoeoco]\ ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i k]mme ^o_g\_k]TP, \Xoaodjom ^cmgam_odijkm d oejoFmjkk ZoeocoXo ^cmZciKmjo d gdYWk g oeZiWo]
Xog\_icgedmjjoXo oSdkjkemaY
oe oSdkjmjkY1.
CcmZciKmjkm \XoaodjoXo _mai g\_o] ^o ogjodijkI oeZiWi ^coZ\coci oe oSdkjmjkY goXaigjo R. 1 ge. 239 :C> E? ]oJme STeQ og\Kmgedamjo d Mo_m ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ga\FijkY, i ^o ogjodijkI oeZiWi
oSdkjkemaY oe oSdkjmjkY goXaigjo ^. 2 ge. 254 :C> E? — d Mo_m g\_mSjoXo Wigm_ijkY.
8 ^mcdo] ga\Rim ^cmZciKmjkm \XoaodjoXo _mai gdYWijo g oeZiWo]
oSdkjmjkY ^coZ\coci, e.m. Xog\_icgedmjjoXo oSdkjkemaY, i do deo-
oe
co] — g oeZiWo] oe oSdkjmjkY oSdkjkemaY, geie\g ZoeocoXo ^ojk]imegY d WiZojm Fkcm k jm oXcijkRkdimegY Xog\_icgedmjjT] oSdkjkemam],
eiZ ZiZ ^cm_^oaiXime doW]oJjogeQ \RigekY d \Xoaodjo] g\_o^cokWdo_gedm RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY.
1_jiZo d ge. 133 :C> E? cmRQ k_me o eiZo] g\S%mZem,
_icgedmjjTP oSdkjkemaQ
. Co,eo]\ _aY kggam_odijkY do^cogi oS og-
ZiZ Xog\-
jodijkYM cmiSkakeiNkk ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z go_mcJijkI ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 133
:C> E? jmoSMo_k]o \eoRjkeQ, oeZiW ZiZoXo ZojZcmejo g\S%mZei oe
oSdkjmjkY, damRme ^cmZciKmjkm \XoaodjoXo _mai g\_o].
Ccm_dicYY _iaQjmPFmm kggam_odijkm do^cogi, MoemaogQ ST ^o_RmcZj\eQ, Reo, ZiZ g^cidm_akdo oe]mRimegY d Ick_kRmgZoP akemcie\cm,
_mYemaQjogeQ ^coZ\coci ^o ^o__mcJijkI Xog\_icgedmjjoXo oSdkjm-
SiWkc\megY ji o^cm_mamjjTM ;iZekRmgZkM _ijjTM (_oZiWiemaQ-
jkY
gediM), gdk_memaQged\IKkM o jiakRkk ogjodijkP _aY ^ckWjijkY oSdk-
2
jYm]oXo dkjodjT] d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY
.
Aam_odiemaQjo, ZoX_i Xog\_icgedmjjTP oSdkjkemaQ oeZiWTdimegY
oe ^o__mcJijkY oSdkjmjkY, ,eo ]oJme, d eo] Rkgam, gdk_memaQgedodieQ
k oS oeg\egedkk ;iZekRmgZkM _ijjTM, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM dkjodjogeQ
akNi d kjZck]kjkc\m]o] _mYjkk, o doW]oJjogek ^ckWjijkY mXo jmdkjodjT], e.m. cmiSkakekcodijjT], i eiZJm o eo], Reo _ijjom akNo ^ogeci_iao oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi
k k]mme ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm ^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\ dcm_i.
1
$W go_mcJijkY ^. 6 ge. 5 :C> E? gam_\me, Reo ^o_ Xog\_icgedmjjT] oSdkjkemam] gam_\me ^ojk]ieQ ^o__mcJkdiIKmm oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi oSdkjmjkm d g\_m ^o \Xoaodjo]\
_ma\ _oaJjogejom akNo ocXiji ^coZ\cie\cT.
2
>cIZod 8.?.
8ocojmJ, 1996. A. 98.
1eZiW ^coZ\coci oe Xog\_icgedmjjoXo oSdkjmjkY: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z.
130
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]