Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
_ijkji (R. 1 ge. 151 > E?), ZoeocTm ]oX\e STeQ gdYWijT g ^ogYXiemaQgedi]k ji JkWjQ, W_ocodQm, _ogeokjgedo akRjogek, _maod\I cm^\eiNkI, Rigej\I JkWjQ, akRj\I k gm]mPj\I eiPj\, ji ^cidi kjemaamZe\iaQjoP goSgedmjjogek, i eiZJm g \ecieoP co_gedmjjkZod, jmdoW]oJ-
1
jogeQI ^co_oaJieQ og\KmgedaYm]\I cijmm _mYemaQjogeQ k e._.
.
mPged\IKm]\ XciJ_ijgZo]\ WiZojo_iemaQged\ kWdmgejT _di g^o-
goSi Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i: ^\em] _mjmJjoP Zo]^mjgiNkk,
Zoeoc\I g\_ ]oJme doWaoJkeQ ji jic\FkemaY (ge. 151 > E?), ^\em]
WiKkeT Rmgek, _ogeokjgedi k _maodoP cm^\eiNkk (ge. 152 > E?).
Co ciW_maYm]o]\ ji]k ]jmjkI ./. c_mamdgZoXo, oedmegedmj-
jogeQ Wi ^ckRkjmjkm ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i jogke Ydjo dTciJmjjTP Zo]^mjgiNkojjTP MiciZemc
. 8cY_ ak mgeQ jmoSMo_k]ogeQ _oZiWTdieQ, Reo
oNmjZi geci_ijkP d _mjQXiM kak kjoP ]iemckiaQjoP ;oc]m jmdoW]oJji. /iemckiaQjiY Zo]^mjgiNkY Wi ^ckRkjmjkm ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i
^ckWdiji dTWdieQ ^oaoJkemaQjTm ,]oNkk, g^ogoSjTm gXai_keQ jmXiekdjTm kW]mjmjkY d ^gkMkRmgZoP g;mcm akRjogek, oS\gaodamjjTm ^mcmjmgmjjT]k geci_ijkY]k
2
.
8 ge. 136 :C> E?, cmXai]mjekc\IKmP g^ogoST Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ^cm_\g]oecmjo o;kNkiaQjom ^ckjmgmjkm kWdkjmjkP oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi ^coZ\coco]. mWidkgk]o oe
eoXo, ji ZiZo] ,ei^m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi k _mPgedkY]k ZiZoXo _oaJjogejoXo akNi ^ckRkjmj dcm_, oSYWijjogeQ ^ckjogkeQ kWdkjmjkY doWaoJmji WiZojo] ji
\ZiWijjom _oaJjogejom akNo.
CoZiWiemaQjo, Reo d ^cidm $g^ijkk Xog^o_ged\me _oZeckji o ^ckdamRmjkk Z oedmegedmjjogek _]kjkgeciNkk; e.m., mgak ^cm_geidkemaQ
daigek kak Xog\_icgedmjjTP ga\JiKkP godmcFka _mYjkm, ^odamZFmm
eYJmaTm ^ogam_gedkY, cmRQ k_me oS oedmegedmjjogek gooedmeged\IKmXo \RcmJ_mjkY kak ocXijkWiNkk, Z ZoeocT] ^ckji_amJke akNo,
^ckRkjkdFmm dcm_, ZoeocTm k oSYWijT mXo doW]mKieQ ^ck jiakRkk
^cidi
^cm_%YdamjkY cmXcmggjoXo kgZi3.
8 _ijjo] ga\Rim o^Te ^cm_geidaYmegY kjemcmgjT] jm g eoRZk WcmjkY doW]oJjogek doW]mKmjkY dcm_i Wi gRme gooedmeged\IKmXo \RcmJ_mjkY, eiZ ZiZ ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z cigg]ieckdim]o]\ ^cidodo]\ kjgeke\e\ d :C> k > E? g;oc]\akcodij kjoP ZojNm^e\iaQjTP ^o_Mo_, i
g ^oWkNkk doW]oJjoP ^mcgojk;kZiNkk oedmegedmjjogek.
1
Cogeijodamjkm Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 20 _mZiScY 1994 X. & 10 « mZoeocTm do-
^cogT ^ck]mjmjkY WiZojo_iemaQgedi o Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i» // >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
2
c_mamdgZkP ./.
1994. & 10. A. 17.
3
o]kjXo maao ijmPco.
d $g^ijkk // iZoj. 2007. & 7. A. 215—225.
1 ciW]mcm doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i // EoggkPgZiY IgekNkY.
$]\KmgedmjjiY oedmegedmjjogeQ ^\SakRjTM ocXijod daigek
231
Co oejoFmjkI Z eiZo]\ g^ogoS\ doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i,
ZiZ ^ckjmgmjkm kWdkjmjkP, doW]oJjogeQ ^o_oSjoP ^ogeijodZk do^cogi jm akFmji ogjodijkP
1
.
Aam_\me oSciekeQ djk]ijkm ji eo, Reo k ^cid\ Eoggkk kWdmgemj
kjoP ^o_Mo_ Z ^coNm_\cm ^ckjmgmjkY kWdkjmjkP: dTjmgmjkm g\_mSjoXo cmFmjkY, i_cmgodijjoXo ZojZcmejo]\ _oaJjogejo]\ akN\ g \Zi-
2
Wijkm] «kg^cogkeQ ^coKmjkm \ k] oSkJmjjoXo»
.
8gm dk_T dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, doW]mKiIegY d gooedmegedkk g Xog\_icgedmjjT]k oSYWiemaQgedi]k, jmWidkgk]o oe dkjT _oaJjogejTM akN. 1_jiZo \ ^ogeci_idFkM
d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^ckRkjmjkm dcm_i d ZiJ_o] ZojZcmejo] ga\Rim, ZiZ ^cidkao, iggoNkkc\megY g _mPgedkY]k ZojZcmejoXo
_oaJjogejoXo akNi, ^oa\Rmjkm kWdkjmjkP jm^ogcm_gedmjjoXo oe ZoeocoXo g eoRZk
WcmjkY ]ociaQjoXo \_odamedocmjkY ^cm_^oRekemaQjmm.
"m] jm ]mjmm, jmaQWY jm \RkeTdieQ eo oSgeoYemaQgedo, Reo eiZk]
_oaJjogejT] akNo], kgMo_Y kW g\S%mZejoXo gogeidi ^cidooejoFmjkP,
doWjkZiIKkM d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ]oJme STeQ _oWjidiemaQ, gam_odiemaQ, c\Zodo_kemaQ gam_gedmjjoXo ocXiji, jiRiaQjkZ ^o_ciW_mamjkY _oWjijkY, ^coZ\coc, g\_ (g\_QY). Cck ,eo] cmiakWiNkY ^cidi ji
doW]mKmjkm dcm_i ]oJme og\KmgedaYeQgY \Jm ^ogam
^cmZciKmjkY Xog\_icgedmjjTM ^oajo]oRkP \ gooedmeged\IKmXo _oaJjogejoXo akNi.
m kgZaIRmjT gke\iNkk, ZoX_i ^mcgojk;kNkcodieQ oedmegedmjjom
_oaJjogejom akNo gaoJjo kak jm ^cm_geidaYmegY doW]oJjT] akSo ^ogeci_idFkP jm k]mme ZojZcmejTM ^cmemjWkP.
eo ^ckdo_ke Z jmoSMo_k]ogek dTSoci \jkdmcgiaQjoXo iaXocke]i
_mPgedkP, ^ck Zoeoco] ^ckjmgmjkm o;kNkiaQjTM kWdkjmjkP oe k]mjk
Xog\_icgedi STao ST _mamXkcodijo o^cm_mamjjo]\ _oaJjogejo]\
akN\. _mgQ ^oaiXim]
doW]oJjT] ciW_makeQ ^oWkNkI WiZojo_iemaY d
eoP Rigek, Reo eiZk] _oaJjogejT] akNo] gam_\me ^ckWjieQ ^coZ\coci, ZiZ Xicijei goSaI_mjkY WiZojjogek ji dgmM ,ei^iM \XoaodjoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
8 ^. 31 ge. 5 :C> E? \ZiWijo, Reo ^o_ ^coZ\coco] gam_\me ^ojk]ieQ mjmciaQjoXo ^coZ\coci E? k ^o_RkjmjjTM m]\ ^coZ\cocod, kM
Wi]mgekemamP k kjTM _oaJjogejTM akN ocXijod ^coZ\cie\cT, \Riged\IKkM d \Xoaodjo] g\_o^cokWdo_gedm k ji_mamjjTM gooedmeged\IKk]k ^oajo]oRkY]k ;m_mciaQjT] WiZojo] o ^coZ\cie\cm. Cck ,eo]
WiZoj jm cmXai]mjekc\me, ZiZoP k]mjjo ^coZ\coc _oaJmj ^ckjmgek
1
1SciKime ji gmSY djk]ijkm d ,eoP Rigek o^Te cmg^\SakZ maic\gQ, >iWiMgeij, >Tc-
XTWgZoP cmg^\SakZk, "\cZ]mjkgeiji.
2
1caodi ..
/.: $"$- , 2011. A. 35, 36.
>ojNm^NkY cmiSkakeiNkk d coggkPgZo] \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm: /ojoXc.
232
kWdkjmjkY k d ZiZo] ^ocY_Zm gam_\me og\KmgedaYeQ \ZiWijj\I ^coNm_\c\. $]mIKmm ]mgeo gogeoYjkm jmo^cm_mamjjogek jm ]oJme jm gZiWTdieQgY ji g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZm.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, >ocYJm]gZk] Xoco_gZk] g\_o] ^o WiYdamjkI cmiSkakekcodijjoXo . STao dTjmgmjo ^ogeijodamjkm, oSYWTdiIKmm ^coZ\coci cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek ^ckjmgek oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi kWdkjmjkY Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP dcm_ ^\em] ji^cidamjkY
d i_cmg cmiSkakekcodijjoXo ^kgQ]i k ciW]mKmjkY ji kjemcjme-giPem ^coZ\cie\cT cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek gdm_mjkP o mXo cmiSkakeiNkk. m \RkeTdiY, Reo g\_
^ckjk]ia cmFmjkm kgMo_Y kW eoXo, Reo do^cog o ^ckdamRmjkk . Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek cmFiagY ^coZ\cie\coP cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek, i kj;oc]iNkY oS ,eo] STai ciW]mKmji ji mm kjemcjme-giPem
^coZ\coc cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek g jk] jm goXaigkagY
1
.
CoZiWiemaQjT] d ,eoP Rigek YdaYmegY k ^ck]mc, ZoX_i ^coZ\coc
1]gZoP oSaigek d ZiggiNkojjo] o^cm_mamjkk ^cogke kW]mjkeQ ^ogeijodamjkm g\_Qk, oSYWidFmXo mXo ^ckjmgek kWdkjmjkY oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ ?., doWaoJkd _ijj\I oSYWijjogeQ ji
^coZ\cie\c\ 1]gZoP oSaigek. Co mXo ]jmjkI, kW go_mcJijkY ^. 31
ge. 5 k R. 1 ge. 136 :C> E? jm \g]ieckdimegY doW]oJjogeQ
^ckjmgmjkY
o;kNkiaQjoXo kWdkjmjkY cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ k]mjjo ^coZ\coco]
g\S%mZei EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk
2
.
A\Kmged\IK\I gke\iNkI d ^ciZekZm ^ck]mjmjkY ^oaoJmjkP R. 1
ge. 136 :C> E? MiciZemckW\Ie k ga\Rik, ZoX_i ^coZ\cocT jm goXaigjT g ecmSodijkm] o ^ckjmgmjkk kWdkjmjkP, dog^ckjk]iY kM ji
gdoP gRme; ^ckjogYe kWdkjmjkY jm oe gdomXo k]mjk, i oe k]mjk ^coZ\cie\cT, jm JmaiIe goSaI_ieQ ecmSodijkY WiZoji o jmoSMo_k]ogek
^ckjmgmjkY kWdkjmjkP
3
.
"m] jm ]mjmm, cmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo d Mo_m jigeoYKmXo kggam_odijkY o^cogi ^coZ\cocod ^oZiWTdime, Reo d Nmao] ojk ^oaoJkemaQjo dog^ckjk]iIe doWaoJmjj\I ji jkM oSYWijjogeQ ^ckjmgmjkY
,
1
Cogeijodamjkm >ocYJm]gZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek. mao & 22-0280/10.
2
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A> ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 17 i^cmaY
2003 X. & 50-o03-16 // icije.
3
>o]]mjeickP ^cidodoXo ijiakekZi /mJcmXkojiaQjoP ggoNkiNkk «1E» E. M]meXiakmdi cmW\aQeieod Wigm_ijkY ZoaamXkk mjmciaQjoP ^coZ\cie\cT E? ji em]\
«:Zcm^amjkm WiZojjogek ^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod, dTemZiIKkM kW ^ciZekZk doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo jmWiZojjT] ^ckdamRmjkm] Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek», gogeoYdFmXogY 27 ]iY 2007 X.: URL://http://www.regnum.ru. 1;kNkiaQjTm kWdkjmjkY
^coZ\cie\cT X. Aicieodi oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi X-j\ ?mPeakMmc\ . . oe 2 kIaY 2009 X.:
URL://http://www.sarprok.ru. Co _ijjT] ^cmgg-ga\JST 8ai_k]kcgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i
^o _ma\ cmiSkakekcodijjoXo /. \_TZkji ^coZ\cocgZkP jkXkakW] cigg]oecmj d g\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk 8ai_k]kcgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i. /iemckia oe 1 gmjeYScY 2009 X.:
URL://http://www.wld.sudrf.ru
233
kWdkjmjkP oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi cmiSkakekcodijjT], \g]ieckdiY d
,eo] g^mNk;kRmgZkP dTgoZkP geie\g ^coZ\cie\cT.
8]mgem g em] ji do^cogT o eo], ZiZod, g \Rmeo] oeg\egedkY cmXai]mjeiNkk d WiZojm, iaXocke] kM _mPgedkP ^o cmiakWiNkk ^cid WikjemcmgodijjTM akN, go_mcJijkm oedmeod Wi]mejo ciWjkegY.
igeQ kW ^ckjk]idFkM \Rigekm d o^cogm _oaJjogejTM akN \ZiWiak ji
jmoSMo_k]ogeQ oSciKmjkY d ocXijT ^coZ\cie\cT, jmZoeocTm
^oaiXiIe, Reo ecmS\megY gooedmeged\IKmm cmFmjkm g\_i, _c\Xkm ^cm_^oRak ST ^kgQ]mjjTm kWdkjmjkY, ji^cidamjjTm ^o ^oRem.
. . aTSkji, MiciZemckW\Y jmXiekdjTm geocojT ^ciZekZk doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i g^ogoSo], ^cm_\g]oecmjjT] d R. 1 ge. 136
:C> E?, oe]mRime, Reo d cY_m ga\Rimd cmiSkakekcodijjTm dTj\J_mjT oSciKieQgY d g\_ g
ecmSodijkY]k oSYWieQ ^coZ\coci ^ckjmgek
kWdkjmjkY, Reo ^cY]o ^coekdocmRke S\Zdm WiZoji, eiZ ZiZ ^coZ\coc
_oaJmj _maieQ ,eo ^o gdomP kjkNkiekdm, RmXo jm _maime kak ddk_\ jmJmaijkY kg^oajYeQ ecmSodijkY WiZoji, kak kW-Wi oeg\egedkY ^coNm_\cT ^ckjmgmjkY kWdkjmjkY
1
.
/T ciW_maYm] ^oWkNkI ideoci d eoP Rigek, Reo oeg\egedkm ji_amJiKmP cmXai]mjeiNkk ^ocY_Zi cmiakWiNkk ^oaoJmjkP R. 1 ge. 136
:C> E? ]oJme STeQ ^ckRkjoP ^coYdaYIKkMgY jmXiekdjTM emj_mjNkP, k \g]ieckdim] doW]oJjogeQ kW]mjmjkY gke\iNkk d RmeZo ^co^kgijjoP ^coNm_\cm.
Cck ,eo] d ZiRmgedm doW]oJjoXo dTMo_i kW gaoJkdFmPgY gke\iNkk jmo^cm_mamjjogek dk_kegY kW]mjmjkm ^o_Mo_i
Z ;oc]\akcodijkI go_mcJijkY R. 1 ge. 136 :C> g \Rmeo] goSaI_mjkY kjemcmgod
\^cido]oRmjjTM akN.
CoaiXim] NmamgooSciWjT] ^cm_ogeidkeQ ^ogeci_idFm]\ akN\
^cido ji mXo \g]oecmjkm o^cm_maYeQ o^ek]iaQjTP g^ogoS ^ckjmgmjkY
kWdkjmjkY, goXaigodid mXo g g\_QmP. Co cmW\aQeiei] eiZoXo goXaigodijkY d gooedmeged\IKm] ^ogeijodamjkk g\_Qk, i_cmgodijjo] ZojZcmejo]\ _oaJjogejo]\ akN\, ]oJme STeQ \ZiWij ^ckm]am]TP _aY
^ogeci_idFmXo g^ogoS ^ckjmgmjkY
kWdkjmjkP (ji^ck]mc, ^kgQ]mjjo,
ji kjemcjme-giPem, \gejo).
A \Rmeo] kWaoJmjjoXo go_mcJijkm R. 1 ge. 136 :C> E? ^cm_aiXimegY kWaoJkeQ d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
«1;kNkiaQjom kWdkjmjkm oe
k]mjk Xog\_icgedi Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP dcm_ ^ckjogke ^coZ\coc. Co ^ogeijodamjkI g\_Qk, i_cmgodijjo]\ ZojZcmejo]\ _oaJjogejo]\ ak-
1
aTSkji . .
^coNmggm Eoggkk: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. "o]gZ, 2006. A. 146.
EmiSkakeiNkY k doW]mKmjkm dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm cmiSkakeiNkk d \Xoaodjo]
234
N\, ^coZ\coc ^ckjogke kWdkjmjkm d \gejoP kak ^kgQ]mjjoP ;oc]m ^o
JmaijkI akNi, WiYdkdFmXo ecmSodijkm o Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo
dcm_i. Cckjmgmjkm kWdkjmjkY d \gejoP ;oc]m og\KmgedaYmegY d g\_mSjo] Wigm_ijkk ^ck cigg]oecmjkk do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm]
dcm_i, d ^ocY_Zm ge. 399 jigeoYKmXo >o_mZgi. CkgQ]mjjom kWdkjmjkm,
^o JmaijkI ^ogeci_idFmXo akNi, ji^cidaYmegY ^o ]mge\ mXo JkemaQgedi,
\RmST, ciSoeT kak ^\SakZ\megY ji kjemcjme-giPem»1.
8oW]mKmjkm ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ]oJme og\KmgedaYeQgY ZiZ d \Xoaodjo^coNmgg\iaQjo] ^ocY_Zm, eiZ k d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 1_jiZo g\Kmged\IKiY iaQemcjiekdi cig^cogecijYmegY jm ji dgm
g^ogoST doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i.
"iZ, goXaigjo R. 2 ge. 136 :C> E? kgZk o Zo]^mjgiNkk Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP ]ociaQjTP dcm_ d _mjmJjo]
dTciJmjkk ^cm_%YdaYIegY d
^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
1SKiY gke\iNkY, gaoJkdFiYgY d ^cidodo] cmX\akcodijkk ^cidooejoFmjkP, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, _ime \RmjT]-^coNmgg\iakgei] ogjodijkY _aY dTdo_i o eo], Reo o_joco_jTm
Zo]^mjgiNkojjTm oejoFmjkY, doWjkZiIKkm kW ^ckRkjmjkY dcm_i \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] jmdkjodjoXo, cmX\akc\IegY ^ckjNk^kiaQjo
ciWakRjT]k
^o gdomP Ick_kRmgZoP ^ckco_m oecigaY]k ^cidi2.
i gecijkNiM Ick_kRmgZoP ^mRiek ^cm_geidamjT k kjTm ]jmjkY.
i^ck]mc, o eo], Reo kjgeke\e doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo
d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo ^coNmggi, jm ]oJme STeQ o_joWjiRjo oejmgmj Z
\Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoP oecigak ddk_\ ]joXooSciWkY ^ckWjiZod,
^ckg\KkM eiZJm k XciJ_ijgZo-^cidodT] ]meo_i] cmX\akcodijkY.
$ak, Reo d _mPged\IKm] \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjo] WiZojo_iemaQgedm d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo ^coNmggi
^cm_\g]oecmji eoaQZo doW]oJjogeQ \gecijmjkY ^ogam_gedkP ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i (R. 1 ge. 133 :C>
E?), kgZk Jm o Zo]^mjgiNkk d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP
1
Camj\] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? d gdom] ^ogeijodamjkk oe 29 joYScY 2011 X. d o^cm_mamjjoP Rigek oSoWjiRmjjoP ^coSam]T _ime ciW%YgjmjkY goXaigjo ZoeocT] «gak do^cog o
^ckjmgmjkk kWdkjmjkY ^coZ\coco] ^ogeidamj cmiSkakekcodijjT] ^mcm_ g\_o], g\_ doWaiXime kg^oajmjkm eiZoP oSYWijjogek ji ^coZ\coci gooedmeged\IKmXo \codjY, o Rm]
\ZiWTdime d ^ogeijodamjkk» (^. 19). "m] jm ]mjmm ^oaiXim], Reo g;oc]\akcodijjTm
^cm_aoJmjkY oMdieTdiIe Soamm FkcoZkP Zc\X do^cogod, i kM ZojNm^e\iaQjiY WjiRk]ogeQ o^cm_maYmegY jmoSMo_k]ogeQI ji_amJiKmP ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk ^ocY_Zi doW]mKmjkY dcm_i.
2
1caodi /.8.
/., 2006. A. 103.
$jgeke\e cmiSkakeiNkk d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z.
235
ji]k
jmWiZojjT] kak jmoSogjodijjT] \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] ]ociaQjTP dcm_, _oaJjT ^cm_%YdaYeQgY d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o-
1
^cokWdo_gedi (R. 2 ge. 136 :C> E?)
.
8 eoP Rigek, X_m \RmjTm-^coNmgg\iakgeT gZaojYIegY Z ]Tgak o
doW]oJjogek g\KmgedodijkY iaQemcjiekdjTM ;oc] doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, _ijjTP ^o_Mo_ ^cm_geidaYmegY ji] Soamm ^cidkaQjT] k Wiga\JkdiIKk] djk]ijkY.
i ^ciZekZm Wi;kZgkcodijT ga\Rik ZoX_i, ggTaiYgQ ji ^oaoJmjkY ge. 151 > E?, goXaigjo ZoeocoP oSYWijjogeQ _mjmJjoP Zo]^mjgiNkk Wi ^ckRkjmjjTP ]ociaQjTP dcm_ doWaiXimegY ji
jic\FkemaY,
cmiSkakekcodijjT] oeZiWTdiIe d ^ckm]m WiYdamjkP ji eo] ogjodijkk, Reo ^o kM _ma\ ^ckXodoco] g\_i mKm jm \geijodamjo _oaJjogejom
akNo, ZoeocoXo eiZodT] ]oJjo ^ckWjieQ
2
.
8 ^o_oSjTM gke\iNkYM, ^o dgmP dk_k]ogek, kgMo_Ye kW ;oc]iaQjTM ecmSodijkP _ijjoP joc]T, WiSTdiY, Reo ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z kjemcmg\IKmP jig ZiemXockk akN, ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, cmRQ k_me o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP
?m_mciNkk, jmWidkgk]o oe dkjT _oaJjogejTM akN.
CoaoJmjkY R. 2 ge. 136 :C> E?, jogYKkm ^o gdomP
g\ek k]^mciekdjTP MiciZemc k jm _o^\gZiIKkm iaQemcjiekdjTM ;oc] doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk, jm d^kgTdiIegY d
aoXkZ\ WiZojo_iemaQjoP Zojgec\ZNkk, ^oWdoaYIKmP d godoZ\^jogek
k]mIKkMgY ^cm_^kgijkP ciWcmFieQ do^cogT, gdYWijjTm g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i ZiZ d \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjo] ^ocY_Zm, eiZ k d ^ocY_Zm
XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 1S iZe\iaQjogek _ijjoXo do^cogi
gdk_memaQged\me k g\_mSjiY
^ciZekZi3.
Adm_mjkm doW]oJjogek Zo]^mjgkcodieQ ]ociaQjTP dcm_ d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk Z kgZodo]\ ^cokWdo_ged\, ^ckdo_ke Z jmoSMo_k]ogek
oSciekeQgY Z ogjodjT], MiciZemcjT] _aY jmXo ^ckWjiZi], Z Rkga\ ZoeocTM jicY_\ g jiakRkm] ]iemckiaQjo-^cidodoXo ecmSodijkY, g^oci
o g\S%mZekdjo] ^cidm, oejogkegY k jiakRkm _d\M geocoj g ^coekdo^o-
1
mecoWod A.A.
Ick_. ji\Z. ACS, 2006. A. 145;
(^ojYekm, dk_T, ogjodijkY, ^coNmgg\iaQjTP ^ocY_oZ): kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. $JmdgZ,
2005. A. 206, 207.
2
1^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o XciJ_ijgZk] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 27
gmjeYScY 2005 X. & 31-d05-5 // icije.
3
1^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP >oaamXkk ^o XciJ_ijgZk] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? ^o _ma\
& 18-08-18; 1^cm_mamjkm >iggiNkojjoP ZoaamXkk 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? ^o _ma\
& >A08-541 / 1SWoc WiZojo_iemaQgedi k A\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe
5 _mZiScY 2008 X., 3 kIjY 2009 X. // >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
$jgeke\e cmiSkakeiNkk d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Eoggkk: kg. … Zij_.
"ieQYjkj .8.
EmiSkakeiNkY d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Eoggkk
236
aoJjT]k kjemcmgi]k, i gi]o kgZodom ^cokWdo_gedo ^ck ,eo] jogke go-
1
geYWiemaQjTP MiciZemc
.
1_joP geocojoP W_mgQ YdaYmegY cmiSkakekcodijjTP, ZoeocTP _oaJmj _oZiWTdieQ k gogeYWieQgY g _c\XoP geocojoP — Xog\_icgedo], _oScodoaQjo dWYdFk] ji gmSY oSYWiemaQgedi ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\ _mPgedkY]k _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 1Rmdk_jo, Reo g eiZk] ^oaoJmjkm] ec\_jo goXaigkeQgY.
8]mgem g em] ZoX_i cmiSkakekcodijjTP _oScodoaQjo kW%YdaYme
Jmaijkm oegeikdieQ
gdok kjemcmgT d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi kak ZoX_i mXo ^cm_^oRemjkm oS%mZekdjo oS\gaodamjo
(ji^ck]mc, NmamgooSciWjogeQI m_kjodcm]mjjoXo cigg]oecmjkY do^cogi o jmgoXaigkk g ^ckjYeT]k g\_mSjT]k cmFmjkY]k k doW]mKmjkm] ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i), ogjodijkY XodockeQ oS \Km]amjkk mXo ^cid
oeg\eged\Ie.
1_jiZo, ZiZ STao oe]mRmjo ji gecijkNiM jigeoYKmXo kggam_odi-
jkY, ^ck doW]mKmjkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjo]\
d gdYWk
g oeZiWo] RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY oe oSdkjmjkY, ^ogeijodZi do^cogi o
mXo doW]mKmjkk d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi d^oajm
oSogjodiji.
iga\Jkdime djk]ijkY ^oaoJmjkm, go_mcJiKmmgY d R. 3 ge. 136
:C> E?, ^cm_\g]ieckdiIKmP doW]oJjogeQ o^codmcJmjkY cig^cogecijmjjTM d gcm_gediM ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk gdm_mjkP, ^ocoRiKkM
cmiSkakekcodijjoXo. $W go_mcJijkY _ijjoP joc]T jmdoW]oJjo g_maieQ dTdo_, d ZiZoP ;oc]m g\_o^cokWdo_gedi
^o_amJie ciWcmFmjkI
_ijjTm do^cogT.
8 XciJ_ijgZo] WiZojo_iemaQgedm ^o_oSjTm _mPgedkY k]mj\IegY WiKkeoP Rmgek, _ogeokjgedi k _maodoP cm^\eiNkk (ge. 152 > E?), i XciJ_ijkj, d oejoFmjkk ZoeocoXo cig^cogecijmjT ^ocoRiKkm gdm_mjkY,
WieciXkdiIKkm mXo RmgeQ, _ogeokjgedo kak _maod\I cm^\eiNkI, d^cidm
jicY_\ g o^codmcJmjkm], ecmSodieQ doW]mKmjkY \STeZod k ]ociaQjoXo
dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjTM kM cig^cogecijmjkm] (^. 5 ge. 152 >
E?).
Co go_mcJijkI ^oaoJmjkP R. 3 ge. 136 :C> E? d Ick_kRmgZoP
akemcie\cm ^cm_geidamji eoRZi WcmjkY, goXaigjo ZoeocoP k ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z do^cogi] Rmgek Xog\_icgedo oedmegedmjjo ^mcm_ jmdkjodjT] d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY XciJ_ijkji akFQ Wi eo, Reo
YdaYmegY jm^ogcm_gedmjjT] jmXiekdjT] ^ogam_gedkm] mXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY k og\J_mjkY. gak Jm ^ocoRiKkm akNo gdm_mjkY
geiak _ogeoYjkm]
Xaigjogek kW gcm_ged ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk, i
1
ck_kRmgZkP ,jNkZao^m_kRmgZkP gaodicQ / Co_ cm_. /. . /icRmjZo. /.: Ccog^mZe,
2009. A. 255.
237
d^ogam_gedkk geiao kWdmgejo, Reo akNo cmiSkakekcodijo, eo Xog\-
1
_icgedo W_mgQ jk ^ck Rm]
.
8 ^ckjNk^m g _ijjoP ^oWkNkmP ]oJjo goXaigkeQgY. 1_jiZo jiakRkm d :C> E? eiZoXo g^ogoSi doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ZiZ o^codmcJmjkm
^ocoRiKmP kj;oc]iNkk, gdYWijo, ^o jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, g ^cm_^ckjYeoP WiZojo_iemam] ^o^TeZoP ^cm_ogeidkeQ doW]oJjogeQ cmFmjkY ^o_oSjTM do^cogod d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, Reo ^oWdoakao ST (^ck Soamm \_iRjoP ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk) o^ek]kWkco-
WiKke\ ^cid WikjemcmgodijjTM akN.
dieQ
CoZiWiemaQjo, Reo :C> ?E go_mcJke joc]\, goXaigjo ZoeocoP
d ga\Rim o^cid_ijkY akNi k dTjmgmjkY cmFmjkY oS oe]mjm ^ckXodoci,
^o ^cm_aoJmjkI WiYdkemaY gooSKimegY d ;m_mciaQjo] kW_ijkk, i g\_
d^cidm ^o gdom]\ \g]oecmjkI g_maieQ ^\SakZiNkI k d _c\XkM XiWmeiM
2
; e.m., ^o_oSjTm do^cogT ]oX\e ciWcmFieQgY g\_QmP d ci]ZiM
(§371)
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
jiakW ^oaoJmjkP \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo k XciJ_ijgZoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\ o eo], Reo d R. 3 ge. 136 :C> E?,
eiZJm ZiZ k d XciJ_ijgZo] Zo_mZgm, XodockegY oS o^\SakZodijkk k doW]oJjogek o^codmcJmjkY gdm_mjkP, WieciXkdiIKkM RmgeQ, _ogeokjgedo
k _maod\I cm^\eiNkI XciJ_ij.
8]mgem g em], ^mcmRmjQ ^o_amJiKkM
o^codmcJmjkI gdm_mjkP ZojZcmekWkc\megY ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z _mPgedkY], og\KmgedaYm]T] d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
$W go_mcJijkY ge. 152 > E? \g]ieckdimegY, Reo o^codmcJmjkm
^ocoRiKkM gdm_mjkP og\KmgedaYmegY ^o cmFmjkI g\_i. >co]m eoXo,
XciJ_ijgZom WiZojo_iemaQgedo ^cm_\g]ieckdime cmiaQjTm ]mMijkW]T
cmiakWiNkk ecmSodijkY g\_i d dk_m Feci;i d ga\Rim mXo jmkg^oajmjkY.
eoXo, Z goJiamjkI, jmaQWY
ZojgeiekcodieQ ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z oSmg^mRmjkI WiKkeT ^cid WikjemcmgodijjTM akN d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
"m] jm ]mjmm, \ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo oS%mZekdjo oS\gaodamjo,
eiZ ZiZ dgm _mPgedkY k cmFmjkY d ci]ZiM :C> E? og\KmgedaYIegY k
^ckjk]iIegY d oejoFmjkk \RigejkZod \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ZoeocT]k gcm_gedi ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk, o^\SakZodidFkm ^ocoRiKkm gdm_mjkY, jm YdaYIegY.
Ao_mcJijkm R. 3 ge
. 136 :C> E? g;oc]\akcodijo eiZk] oSciWo],
Reo ^ck mm ^ciZekRmgZoP cmiakWiNkk dgecmRiIegY ciWakRjTm ^o_Mo_T
Z mXo eoaZodijkI.
1
1caodi /.8.
2
?m_mciekdjiY Emg^\SakZi mc]ijkY. :Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP Zo_mZg. /.: /ij\-
gZck^e, 1994.
:ZiW. goR. A. 121, 122.
238
8 Mo_m o^cogi ^ciZekRmgZkM ciSoejkZod, ijiakWi g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk geiao kWdmgejo o g\Kmgedodijkk ;iZeod, ZoX_i WikjemcmgodijjTm
akNi, c\Zodo_ged\YgQ ^oaoJmjkm] WiZoji o doW]oJjogek ^oecmSodieQ
o^codmcJmjkY, gi]k jm^ogcm_gedmjjo oSciKiakgQ Z gcm_gedi] ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk.
>co]m eoXo, cmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY ^ckdo_Ye Z
dTdo_\, Reo ^cm_geidamjjTP d R. 1 ge. 136 :C> E? ^mcmRmjQ gdm_mjkP,
o ]mciM, ZoeocTm
]oXak ST STeQ ^ckjYeT Z d^ogam_gedkk cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ akN\ k geieQ _ogeoYjkm] Xaigjogek d gcm_gediM ]iggodoP
kj;oc]iNkk, _iamZo jm ^oajTP k d ^ckjNk^m jm ^o_amJke ;oc]\akcodijkI kgRmc^TdiIKk] oSciWo]
1
. Co,eo]\ NmamgooSciWjo ^cm_gei-
dkeQ mXo d oSoSKmjjo] dk_m.
8 gdYWk g kWaoJmjjT] ^oaiXim], Reo jTjm g\Kmged\IKiY cm_iZNkY
R. 3 ge. 136 :C> E? j\J_imegY d ZojZcmekWiNkk k ^cm_aiXim] kWaoJkeQ mm d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
«gak gdm_mjkY o ^ck]mjmjkk ]mc ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^ckj\J_mjkY kak kjTm, WieciXkdiIKkm RmgeQ, _ogeokjgedo k _maod\I cm^\eiNkI akNi, ^ogeci_idFmXo d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, STak o^\SakZodijT d ^mRiek, cig^cogecijmjT ^o
ci_ko, emamdk_mjkI kak d kjTM gcm_gediM ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk,
akNo, Wi ZoeocT] ^ckWjijo ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, d^cidm oSciekeQgY d g\_
g ecmSodijkm] oS kM o^codmcJmjkk. Co ^ogeijodamjkI
g\_i gcm_gedi ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk, ZoeocT] ojo i_cmgodijo, oSYWijT d emRmjkm 30 g\eoZ g_maieQ gooSKmjkm oS o^codmcJmjkk cijmm
o^\SakZodijjTM ^ocoRiKkM gdm_mjkP».
8
EmW\aQeieo] \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY ]oJme STeQ jm eoaQZo ^ckRkjmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo k ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, jo k \eciei ^cmJjmP ciSoeT, ^mjgkk, cijmm Wijk]im]oXo JkakKi, i eiZJm kjTM ^cid, ^mcmRmjQ ZoeocTM ^o g]Tga\ R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E? YdaYmegY oeZcTeT].
8 ga\Rim doamkW%YdamjkY cmiSkakekcodijjoXo kak kjoXo akNi, d
oejoFmjkk ZoeocoXo \Xoaodjom _mao (\Xoaodjom
^cmgam_odijkm) ^cmZciKmjo ^o ogjodijkY], ^cm_\g]oecmjjT] d ge. 133 :C> E?, jige\^kdFkm jmSaiXo^ckYejTm ^ogam_gedkY ^o_amJie \gecijmjkI d ^ocY_Zm, ^cm_\g]oecmjjo] ge. 399 :C> E?.
:eciei ciSoeT ^ckdo_ke Z Nmao]\ cY_\ jmXiekdjTM ^ogam_gedkP.
1jk WiZaIRiIegY jm eoaQZo d jm^oa\Rmjkk WiciSoejoP ^aieT (kjTM
1
EmFmjkm k]ZkjgZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i /ogZodgZoP oSaigek ^o kgZ\ AecmaQRmjZo 8.8.
Z mao\god\ $.$., 1 E$ « odiY XiWmei» (cm_iZNkY jodoP XiWmeT), 111 «ZNmje»
(emamdkWkojjTP Zijia E "8), 1 «"mamZo]^ijkY E "8», 111 «/m_ki oa_kjX
E "8», 111 « QIg ]m_ki — E:A», 1 A8E — /m_ki» k _c. o WiKkem Rmgek k _o
geokjgedi, _maodoP cm^\eiNkk, Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i k oSYWTdijkk ^\SakZiNkk o^codmcJmjkP d A/$ oe 29 gmjeYScY 2009 X. mao & 2-166/10.
239
-
dT^aie), Zo]^mjgiNkY ZoeocTM doW]oJji d ;oc]m doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, d ;iZekRmgZo] ^ckRkjmjkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, jo
k d \eciem goNkiaQjTM gdYWmP, doW]oJjogek Wijk]ieQgY aISk]T]
_mao], ^gkMoaoXkRmgZkM kW]mjmjkYM akRjogek.
1_jiZo _akemaQjom oeg\egedkm akNi WiRige\I ^ckdo_ke ji ^ciZekZm Z jmdoW]oJjogek doggeijodkeQ mXo d ^cmJjkM ec\_odTM ^cidiM,
dmcj\d m]\ ^cmJjII _oaJjogeQ, oSmg^mRkeQ ciSoeoP ji
^cmJjm]
^cm_^ckYekk, d \RcmJ_mjkk, ocXijkWiNkk.
1
AoXaigjo ^. 10 ge. 77 "c\_odoXo Zo_mZgi E?
o_jk] kW oSKkM ogjodijkP ^cmZciKmjkY ec\_odoXo _oXodoci YdaYIegY oSgeoYemaQgedi,
jm WidkgYKkm oe doak geocoj. i^ck]mc, og\J_mjkm ciSoejkZi Z jiZiWijkI, kgZaIRiIKm]\ ^co_oaJmjkm ^cmJjmP ciSoeT, d gooedmegedkk g ^ckXodoco] g\_i, dge\^kdFk] d WiZojj\I gka\ (ge. 83 "> E?).
Co ^ogeijodamjkI g\_Qk, ^ckjYeo]\ ji ogjodijkk Mo_ieiPgedi
gam_odiemaY kak _oWjidiemaY, ^o_oWcmdim]TP kak oSdkjYm]TP
]oJme
STeQ dcm]mjjo oegecijmj oe _oaJjogek, Reo jiaiXime ji ciSoeo_iemaY gooedmeged\IKkm oSYWijjogek, WiZaIRiIKkmgY d jmoSMo_k]ogek kg^oajkeQ cmFmjkm g\_i (R. 1 ge. 114 :C> E?, ge. 76 "> E?).
>ojgeke\Nkojjom ^cido XciJ_ij ji ec\_ oMcijYmegY d _ijjo]
ga\Rim ecmSodijkY]k \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi,
goXaigjo ZoeocT] ji doWS\J_mjkm ^mcm_ g\_o] Mo_ieiPgedi o dcm]mjjo] oegecijmjkk oe
_oaJjogek ecmS\megY goXaigkm c\Zodo_kemaY
gam_gedmjjoXo ocXiji (mgak oS ,eo] Mo_ieiPged\me gam_odiemaQ) kak
^coZ\coci, ZoX_i mXo doWS\J_mjkm kjkNkkc\me _oWjidiemaQ (R. 1
ge. 114 :C> E?).
8 R. 5 ge. 114 :C> E? go_mcJiegY ^oaoJmjkY, oSmg^mRkdiIKkm
oMcij\ ec\_odTM ^cid akN, oSai_iIKkM ^co;mggkojiaQjT] k]]\jkemeo].
kNo, dcm]mjjo oegecijmjjom oe _oaJjogek k]mme ^cido ji mJm]mgYRjom ^ogoSkm d ciW]mcm ^Yek
]kjk]iaQjTM ciW]mcod o^aieT
ec\_i.
:ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo \RkeTdimegY ^ck doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i d gooedmegedkk go ge. 135 :C> E?, dakYY ji g\]]T dT^aie, ^o_amJiKkM doW]mKmjkI, jo jm gdYWijo g ciWcmFmjkm] ^o g\Kmged\ do^cogod o doggeijodamjkk ec\_odTM ^cid.
ciJ_ijkj\, ogdoSoJ_mjjo]\ oe ciSoeT (_oaJjogek) d gdYWk g
og\J_mjkm] akSo oegecijmjjo]\ oe _oaJjogek
d gdYWk g ^ckdamRmjkm]
Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek, d ga\RiYM, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM ^oaoJmjkY]k Xa. 18 :C> E?, _oaJji STeQ ^cm_ogeidamji ^cmJjYY ciSoei
1
"c\_odoP Zo_mZg E? oe 30 _mZiScY 2001 X. & 197- ?: URL://http://www.consultant.ru
240
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]