Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
(_oaJjogeQ). 8 ga\Rim akZdk_iNkk ^cm_^ckYekY, \RcmJ_mjkY, ocXijk-
WiNkk, goZciKmjkY _oaJjogek, i eiZJm ^ck jiakRkk kjTM ogjodijkP,
^cm^Yeged\IKkM doggeijodamjkI ec\_odTM ^cid d ^cmJjm] oS%m]m,
1
akN\ ^cm_ogeidaYmegY _c\XiY cidjoNmjjiY ciSoei (_oaJjogeQ)
.
aY cmFmjkY _ijjTM do^cogod ^cm_\g]oecmj gcoZ — jm ^oW_jmm
o_joXo ]mgYNi go _jY oSciKmjkY d Zo]^memjejTm ocXijT, ^ck \gaodkk, Reo ojo ^ogam_odiao d emRmjkm ecmM ]mgYNmd g ]o]mjei dge\^amjkY
d WiZojj\I gka\ o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci akSo dTjmgmjkY ^ogeijodamjkY (o^cm_mamjkY) o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai ^o cmiSkak-
2
ekc\IKk] ogjodijkY]
.
8]mgem g em] \Xoaodjom _mao (\Xoaodjom ^cmgam_odijkm) ]oJme
STeQ ^cmZciKmjo k ^o kjT] ogjodijkY], ZoeocTm jm YdaYIegY cmiSkakekc\IKk]k, jo, em] jm ]mjmm, ^ocoJ_iIe ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm
dcm_i, d eo] Rkgam k ^\em] doggeijodamjkY d ec\_odTM ^cidiM.
/T ^oaiXim], Reo _o ^ckdm_mjkY d gooedmegedkm g _mPged\IKk]
WiZojo_iemaQgedo], joc]T CoaoJmjkY gam_\me eoaZodieQ cigFkck
emaQjo ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z g\S%mZei], RQk ec\_odTm ^cidi ^o_amJie
doggeijodamjkI.
8o^cogT, gdYWijjTm g jm^ogcm_gedmjjoP cmiakWiNkmP ^cm_ogeidamjjoXo ^cidi, e.m., g ^cm_ogeidamjkm] ciSoeT, doggeijodamjkm] d
_oaJjogek k eiZ _iamm, ji gecijkNiM Ick_kRmgZoP ^mRiek ogdmKmjT
3
_ogeieoRjo ^o_coSjo
.
i ^ciZekZm kM ciWcmFmjkm ^cm_geidaYmegY gaoJjT], ogoSmjjo
d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i jmdoW]oJjo doggeijodkeQ akNo d ^cmJjmP _oaJjogek, ^cm_ogeidkeQ ^cmJjII ciSoe\ d gdYWk g oS%mZekdjo oS\gaodamjjT]k ^ckRkji]k (ji^ck]mc, akZdk_iNkmP ^cm_^ckYekY, goZciKmjkm] Feieod).
:ZiWijjTm do^cogT dTMo_Ye Wi ci]Zk \XoaodjoXo ^coNmggi. A\_
]oJme ^ckjYeQ cmFmjkm d gooedmegedkk g WiYdamjjT]k ecmSodijkY]k,
]oJme \gecijkeQ ^ckRkjT, ^cm^Yeged\IKkm mXo cmiaQjo]\ kg-
jo jm
^oajmjkI. Co,eo]\, cmFiY do^cogT d gooedmegedkk go ge. 399 :C>
E? g \Rmeo] goScijjTM _aY ,ekM NmamP k kW\RmjjTM ]iemckiaod, d
ci]ZiM ^cm_aiXim]oXo ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ga\FijkY g \Rigekm], ji^ck]mc, ciSoeo_iemaY k WiYdkemaY ]oJjo ^ckPek Z o^ek]iaQjo]\,
cmiaQjo]\ k \gecikdiIKm]\ geocojT cmFmjkI.
-
1
C\jZe 5 CoaoJmjkY oe 18 ]iY 1981 X. «1 ^ocY_Zm doW]mKmjkY \KmcSi, ^ckRkjmjjoXo
XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY,
^coZ\cie\cT k g\_i».
2
Cckdm_mjjom CoaoJmjkm.
3
"ieQYjkj .8.
^coNmgg\iaQjTP ^ocY_oZ: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. $JmdgZ, 2005. A. 219—221.
EmiSkakeiNkY d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm Eoggkk (^ojYekm, dk_T, ogjodijkY,
241
?oc]iaQjo-Ick_kRmgZk]k ogjodijkY]k _aY doggeijodamjkY ec\_odTM ^cid akNi YdaYmegY gi] ;iZe mXo o^cid_ijkY kak ^cmZciKmjkY
d oejoFmjkk jmXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY ^o ogjodijkY], _iIKk] ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, Wi;kZgkcodijjTP gooedmegedmjjo
do dge\^kdFm] d WiZojj\I gka\ o^cid_iemaQjo] ^ckXodocm kak ^ogeijodamjkk (o^cm_mamjkk) o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY), i eiZJm — ^ogeijodamjkm
g\_i, ^ckjk]im]om
^o cmW\aQeiei] cigg]oecmjkY WiYdamjjoXo ^ogeci_idFk] akNo] ecmSodijkY d ^ocY_Zm ge. 399 :C> E?.
8 ga\RiYM, ZoX_i ec\_odTm ^cidi jic\FmjT d gdYWk g \XoaodjT]
^cmgam_odijkm], ^cmZciKmjkm ZoeocoXo jm ^odamZao cmiSkakeiNkI,
jo, ^o g]Tga\ ^oaoJmjkP Xa. 18 :C> E?, ^cm_^oaiXime ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm ciWakRjoXo co_i dcm_i, i eiZJm ZoX_i ^ogeijodamjkm o
^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai ^o cmiSkakekc\IKk] ogjodijkY] dTjmgmjT ji _og\_mSjTM ,ei^iM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, geijodkegY
iZe\iaQjT] do^cog o eo], g ZiZoXo ]o]mjei \^cido]oRmjjTP g\S%mZe
d^cidm kjkNkkcodieQ ^coNm_\c\ doggeijodamjkY d ec\_odTM ^cidiM.
i gecijkNiM jigeoYKmXo kggam_odijkY oe]mRiaogQ, Reo ^ogeijodamjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY),
dTjmgmjjTm d Mo_m _og\_mSjoXo ^cokWdo_gedi, ]oX\e STeQ
oSJiao-
dijT. 1_jiZo gcoZk eiZoXo oSJiaodijkY WiZojo] jm o^cm_mamjT.
"m] jm ]mjmm, akNo, ^oemcYdFmm ciSoe\, Wikjemcmgodijo d gZocmPFm] doggeijodamjkk ec\_odTM ^cid. Co,eo]\ ojo ]oJme oSciekeQgY
Wi cmiakWiNkmP jic\FmjjoXo ^cidi gciW\ Jm ^ogam dTjmgmjkY ^ogeijodamjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY)
^o ogjodijkY], ^cm_^oaiXiIKk] eiZ\I doW]oJjogeQ.
8]mgem g em], cmW\aQeieo]
oSJiaodijkY ^ckjYeoXo cmFmjkY ]oJme
STeQ ^ogeijodamjkm g\_Qk o ^ckWjijkk mXo jmWiZojjT] kak jmoSogjodijjT], Reo akFime cmiSkakekcodijjoXo, i eiZJm kjom akNo, k]mIKmm ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, doW]oJjogek kjkNkkcodieQ ^coNm_\c\ doggeijodamjkY ec\_odTM ^cid. 8 Mo_m ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY jm dTYdamjo
ga\Rimd ;iZekRmgZoXo doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, d eo] Rkgam
k doggeijodamjkY d ^cidiM ^ck ^ogam_\IKmP oe]mjm ^mcdojiRiaQjoXo ^ckjYeoXo
cmFmjkY, _iIKmXo ji ,eo ^cido. "m] jm ]mjmm, Xk^oemekRmgZk, g \Rmeo]
oeg\egedkY ^o _ijjo]\ ^odo_\ dTciJmjjoP ji WiZojo_iemaQjo] \codjm ^oWkNkk, jmakFjm k]meQ d dk_\ doW]oJjogeQ doWjkZjodmjkY ^o_oSjTM gke\iNkP.
AoXaigjo R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E? doggeijodamjkI d ^cm_\g]oecmj-
jTM WiZojo] ga\RiYM
^o_amJie k ^mjgkojjTm ^cidi.
8oggeijodamjkm XciJ_ijkji d ^mjgkojjTM ^cidiM gam_\me oeak-
RieQ oe eiZoXo g^ogoSi doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, ZiZ doW-
242
]mKmjkm ^mjgkk (^. 1 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?), ZoX_i cmRQ k_me o g\]]iM,
^o_amJiKkM Zo]^mjgiNkk.
8oggeijodamjkm ^mjgkojjTM ^cid og\KmgedaYmegY d gooedmegedkk
g cijmm \^o]kjidFk]gY CoaoJmjkm], goXaigjo Zoeoco]\ dcm]Y go_mcJijkY ^o_ geciJmP, dcm]Y oeSTdijkY jiZiWijkY, i eiZJm dcm]Y, d
emRmjkm ZoeocoXo XciJ_ijkj jm ciSoeia d gdYWk g oegecijmjkm] mXo oe
_oaJjogek, WigRkeTdimegY d
oSKkP ec\_odoP geiJ k geiJ ciSoeT ^o
g^mNkiaQjogek. eo dcm]Y dZaIRimegY d jm^cmcTdjTP ec\_odoP geiJ,
ZoX_i ^mcmcTd ]mJ_\ dge\^amjkm] d WiZojj\I gka\ o^cid_iemaQjoXo
^ckXodoci kak dTjmgmjkm] ^ogeijodamjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo
_mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY) k _jm] ^oge\^amjkY ji ciSoe\ jm
^cmdTFime ecmM ]mgYNmd.
8]mgem g em] ZoX_i akN\ jm \_imegY doggeijodkeQ ec\_odTm ^cidi d
\ZiWijjTm gcoZk, ^cidkai o jm^cmcTdjo] ec\_odo] geiJm jm ciSoeiIe.
8o^cogT, gdYWijjTm g o^cm_mamjkm] geciModoXo geiJi, \geijodamjkY ciW]mci ^mjgkP d gooedmegedkk g ciW]mco] WiciSoejoP ^aieT, Zoeoc\I cmiSkakekcodijjTP k]ma _o ^ckdamRmjkY Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek, cmFiIegY d gooedmegedkk g ^mjgkojjT] WiZojo_iemaQgedo].
CmcmcigRmeT ^mjgkk og\KmgedaYIegY ^o g\_mSjo]\ cmFmjkI.
8oggeijodamjkm d JkakKjTM ^cidiM
^cm_^oaiXime doWdcie ji ogjodijkk ^ogeijodamjkY g\_i cijmm Wijk]im]oXo k] JkaoXo ^o]mKmjkY, i ^ck jmdoW]oJjogek — djmoRmcm_jom ^cm_ogeidamjkm cidjoNmjjoXo SaiXo\gecomjjoXo JkaQY.
A\_o] ]oX\e STeQ ^ckWjijT jm_mPgedkemaQjT]k ^ckdiekWiNkY
JkaQY co_gedmjjkZi]k SmW \Rmei kjemcmgod akNi, ^o_dmcXj\eoXo \Xoaodjo]\ ^cmgam_odijkI, _oXodoc ^mcm_iRk ZdicekcT d goSgedmjjogeQ,
g_maZk, g ZdicekcoP, jiMo_YKmPgY ji ^cidm goSgedmjjogek cmiSkakek
codijjoXo, godmcFmjjTm SmW mXo goXaigkY.
CmcmRmjQ _oZ\]mjeod, jmoSMo_k]TM _aY ji_amJiKmXo ciWcmFmjkY
g\_o] do^cogod o^cm_maYmegY oS%m]o] k go_mcJijkm] WiYdamjjTM ecmSodijkP, Reo, ZiZ ^oZiWiak cmW\aQeieT o^cogi g\_mP, dTWTdime ji
^ciZekZm gaoJjogek, ecmS\me WjiRkemaQjTM dcm]mjjTM Wiecie k ji_amJiKmP Zdiak;kZiNkk _ijjTM _oaJjogejTM akN, ZoeocTm d ^o_oSjTM ga\RiYM ^ckWdijT cmFieQ do^cogT, dTMo_YKkm Wi
ci]Zk \Xoaod-
joXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
> doggeijodamjkI kjTM ^cid cmiSkakekcodijjoXo gam_\me oejogkeQ
doggeijodamjkm d \RmSjo] Widm_mjkk, kW ZoeocoXo oj STa oeRkgamj, doggeijodamjkm d ^cmJjkM RkjiM k WdijkYM, doWdciKmjkm ^oRmejTM WdijkP,
dm_o]gedmjjTM jiXci_, WjiZod oeakRkY k ciWcmFieQ kjTm do^cogT
1
.
-
1
mWam^Zkj .".
ciNkk. A. 201;
>o]]mjeickP Z :Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjo]\ Zo_mZg\ EoggkPgZoP ?m_m-
Ei]mjgZiY 8.A.
$jgeke\e cmiSkakeiNkk d \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm. A. 92, 93.
243
1SciKime ji gmSY djk]ijkm gec\Ze\ci R. 1 ge. 138 :C> E?, X_m WiZojo_iemaQ \ZiWTdime, Reo mgak ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkm dcm_i g\_o]
jm \_odamedocmjo kak cmiSkakekcodijjTP jm goXaigmj g ^ckjYeT] g\_mSjT] cmFmjkm], oj d^cidm oSciekeQgY d g\_ d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
1_jiZo d _ijjoP joc]m cmRQ k_me o doggeijodamjkm kjTM ^cid cmiSkakekcodijjoXo
dimegY ^o_ doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i. $_me ak W_mgQ cmRQ jm^ogcm_gedmjjo o
doggeijodamjkk kjTM (^mcmRkgamjjTM d ge. 138 :C> E?) ^cid kak Jm
d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi d \ZiWijjTM ga\RiYM gam_\me cmFieQ do^cogT o doW]mKmjkk dgmM dk_od dcm_i.
/T ^oaiXim], Reo \ZiWijjom ^oaoJmjkm R. 1 ge. 138
\]mgejo d go_mcJijkk ge. 137 :C> E?, cmXai]mjekc\IKmP oSJiaodijkm cmFmjkY o ^cokWdo_gedm dT^aie, Zoeocom g \Rmeo] kW]mjmjkP d
gec\Ze\cm :C> E?, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM d ? oe 29 _mZiScY 2010 X.
& 433-?, ^cm_aiXim] kWaoJkeQ d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
. Co,eo]\ jm godgm] ^ojYejo, Reo d jmP ^o_ciW\]m-
:C> E? Soamm
«1. Cogeijodamjkm g\_Qk o ^cokWdo_gedm dT^aie, doWdciem k]\Kmgedi, doggeijodamjkk kjTM ^cid ^ogeci_idFmXo oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ]oJme STeQ oSJiaodijo
d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] Xa. 45.1, 47.1, 48.1, 49 jigeoYKmXo >o_mZgi.
2. gak ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i g\_o] jm \_odamedocmjo kak
^ogeci_idFmm akNo jm goXaigjo g ^ckjYeT] g\_mSjT] cmFmjkm], eo ojo
d^cidm oSciekeQgY
8
:C> E? \g]ieckdimegY, Reo dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP Ick_kRmgZk] akNi]
jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k (SmW_mPgedkm]) k cmFmjkY]k g\_i, ^coZ\coci, gam_odiemaY, _oWjidiemaY, ocXiji _oWjijkY doW]mKimegY Xog\_icgedo] d ^oajo] oS%m]m d ^ocY_Zm k gcoZk, \geijodamjjTm Xa. 18 _ijjoXo
>o_mZgi.
jiakW ^oaoJmjkP, go_mcJiKkMgY d \ZiWijjoP Xaidm, jm ^oWdoaYme oedmekeQ ji NmaTP cY_ WiZojo]mcjo doWjkZiIKkM
ZigiIKkMgY ogjodijkP, go_mcJijkY, ^ocY_Zi k g^ogoSod doW]mKmjkY dcm_i Ick_kRmgZk] akNi].
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP ocXijod
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^ck ciggam_odijkk ^cmge\^amjkY k
ciWcmFmjkk ^o g\Kmged\ ZojZcmejoXo \XoaodjoXo _mai, doW]mKmjkI
k Zo]^mjgiNkk ^o_amJke gooedmegedmjjo k]\KmgedmjjTP k ]ociaQjTP dcm_, doggeijidakdiIegY kjTm \eciRmjjTm ^cidi.
1^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc, ^ogeijodamjkm (o^cm_mamjkm) o ^cmZciKmjkk
Zojjo ^ck]mjmjjoP ]mcT \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^ckj\J_mjkY,
\XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY), oe]mjm jmWi-
d g\_ d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi».
$W go_mcJijkY ge. 139
do^cogod,
244
YdaYIKkmgY ogjodijkm] _aY og\KmgedamjkY Zo]^mjgiNkojjo-doggeijodkemaQjTM ]mc, i_cmgodijT ZojZcmejo]\ ;kWkRmgZo]\ akN\, Wi ZoeocT] k ^ckWjiIegY gdYWijjTm g jk]k ^cidi. $]mjjo _ijjom akNo
(mXo ^cido^cmm]jkZk) d^cidm oSciekeQgY d g\_ g ecmSodijkm] o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i.
"iZk] oSciWo], mgak kg^oaQWodieQ _aY cmiakWiNkk ^oaoJmjkP
ge. 139 :C> E? ijiaoXkI g godoZ\^jogeQI kjTM joc]
, go_mcJiKkMgY
d Xa. 18 :C> E?, eo ji^ciFkdimegY dTdo_ o eo], Reo Ick_kRmgZiY
^ckco_i ^cidooejoFmjkP, doWjkZiIKkM ^o ^odo_\ doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
Ick_kRmgZk] akNi], jmoe_mak]i oe ciWcmFmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai o^cid_iemaQjT] ^ckXodoco] kak ^ogeijodamjkm] o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai.
Aam_odiemaQjo, d ci]ZiM o_joXo \XoaodjoXo _mai dcm_ STa ^ck-
Rkjmj jm eoaQZo cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ kak kjo]\ akN\
, k]mIKm]\ d
^cm_\g]oecmjjTM WiZojo] ga\RiYM, ^cido ji mXo doW]mKmjkm, jo k
Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\.
1eg\egedkm RmeZoP ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk ogjodijkP k ^ocY_Zi
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i Ick_kRmgZk] akNi] d gooedmegedkk g Xa. 18 :C>
E? ^ckdo_ke \RmjTM Z dTdo_\, Reo d ge. 139 :C> E? cmRQ jm k_me o
doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo jmWiZojjT] kak jmoSogjodijjT]
\XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm], ZiZ ,eo
k]mme ]mgeo d ga\Rim g ;kWkRmgZk]k akNi]k. "iZ ZiZ Ick_kRmgZkm akNi jm YdaYIegY g\S%mZei]k
\XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek, ]oJjo XodockeQ o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, jige\^kdFmXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo ^ck]mjmjkY d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ]mc ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^ckj\J_mjkY (oSTgZi, dTm]Zk, jiaoJmjkY icmgei ji k]\Kmgedo k e._.)
1
.
maQWY jm goXaigkeQgY g em], Reo ^ck ^cokWdo_gedm ^o ZojZcmejo]\
\Xoaodjo]\ _ma\ ]oX\e STeQ Wiecoj\eT kjemcmgT Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi.
1_jiZo ^o aoXkZm WiZojo_iemaQjoP Zojgec\ZNkk Xa. 18 :C> E? do^cogT o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i Ick_kRmgZk] akNi] jiMo_YegY d ^cY]oP
Widkgk]ogek oe cmiSkakeiNkk akNi, ^ckdamZim]oXo Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek akSo oe ^cmZciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo
^cmgam_odijkY), _iIKmXo eiZom ^cido, akSo oe oe]mjT d \geijodamjjo]
WiZojo] ^ocY_Zm ]mc ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^ckj\J_mjkY, Z ZoeocT], ^o
jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, gam_gedmjjTm _mPgedkY jm oejogYegY.
Co,eo]\ eoe ;iZe, Reo ^mcmRmjQ _mPgedkP ocXijod \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, damZ\KkM ^ckRkjmjkm dcm_i, jm god^i_ime g ^ocoJ_iIKk]k ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i ;kWkRmgZk] akNi], Wiga\Jkdime
djk]ijkY.
1
A]kcjod .8., >iakjodgZkP >..
.8. A]kcjodi. ACS.: Ckemc, 2004. A. 308.
:XoaodjTP ^coNmgg: :RmSjkZ _aY d\Wod / Co_ cm_.
245
i^ck]mc, ]oJme oeckNiemaQjo gZiWieQgY ji cm^\eiNkk Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi kak ^odamRQ k]\KmgedmjjTP dcm_ ^cokWdo_gedo oSTgZi, dTm]Zk _oZ\]mjeod, jiaoJmjkm icmgei ji SijZodgZkm gRmei kak k]\Kmgedo.
"iZom doW]oJjo, ZoX_i, ji^ck]mc, gooSKmjkY o ^cokWdo_gedm
oSTgZi kak ^ckdamRmjkk Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek o_joXo kW \Rcm_kemamP, oeciJimegY ji _maodoP cm^\eiNkk Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi,
dm_me Z gcTd\
g_maoZ, ^oemcm Zakmjeod, e.m. goRmeime d gmSm ^ogam_gedkY
d dk_m k]\KmgedmjjoXo k ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i. iaoJmjkm icmgei ji _mjmJjTm gcm_gedi, kW%Yekm k]\Kmgedi g^ogoSjT k dodgm ^iciakWodieQ
ciSoe\ Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi.
/oJm] ak ]T d _ijjo] ga\Rim XodockeQ o jmWiZojjTM _mPgedkYM
k cmFmjkYM, ^ckjk]im]TM ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\? 1edme
ji] dk_kegY oeckNiemaQjT], eiZ ZiZ
og\Kmgedamjkm gam_gedmjjTM
_mPgedkP ji^cidamjo ji ^oa\Rmjkm _oZiWiemaQged, Reo jmoSMo_k]o
_iJm d eo] ga\Rim, ZoX_i \Xoaodjom _mao (\Xoaodjom ^cmgam_odijkm) d
oejoFmjkk ;kWkRmgZoXo akNi S\_me ^cmZciKmjo ^o ogjodijkY], damZ\Kk] cmiSkakeiNkI kak doW]mKmjkm dcm_i.
i ^ciZekZm k]mIe ]mgeo ga\Rik, ZoX_i ^codm_mjkm _mPgedkP, gdYWijjTM g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] ZojZcmejoXo ;kWkRmgZoXo akNi
^ckRkjYme cmiaQjTP \KmcS jm
gdYWijjT] g jk] Ick_kRmgZk] akNi].
i^ck]mc, ^ck Wi_mcJijkk akNi ^o ^o_oWcmjkI d godmcFmjkk
^cmge\^amjkY d amRmSjo] \RcmJ_mjkk, _ijjo]\ \RcmJ_mjkI STa ^ckRkjmj dcm_ d dk_m ^odcmJ_mjkY gemj k ]m_kNkjgZoXo oSoc\_odijkY.
Cck ^cokWdo_gedm jm _idFmXo cmW\aQeieod oSTgZi d gZai_gZkM ^o]mKmjkYM RigejoP ;kc]T ^odcmJ_mji eici, i eiZJm ^ckRkjmj dcm_, gdYWijjTP g
^cogcoRZoP ^ogeidoZ XoeodoP ^co_\ZNkk. m]ia\I _oaI
oe ^oge\^iIKkM JiaoS k WiYdamjkP gogeidaYIe ZigiIKkmgY doWdciei
k]\Kmgedi, kW%YeoXo \ Ick_kRmgZkM akN, Zoeocom \eciRmjo d gdYWk g
jm_oScogodmgejT] Mcijmjkm] ocXiji]k _oWjijkY kak ^cm_dickemaQ-
1
joXo gam_gedkY
.
jiakW \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTM joc], cmXai]mjekc\IKkM ^cidooejoFmjkY d g;mcm cmiSkakeiNkk k doW]mKmjkY dcm_i (d eo] Rkgam
k Ick_kRmgZk] akNi]) ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z ^ogam_jk], cmRQ ]oJme k_ek k oS kjTM, jm k]mIKkM oejoFmjkY Z \Xoaodjo]\ ^cmgam_odijkI ZojZcmejoXo akNi, _mPgedkYM (SmW_mPgedkk),
2
cmFmjkYM gooedmeged\IKkM ocXijod k _oaJjogejTM akN
.
1
URL://http://www.uprosess.narod.ru
2
CoZiWiemamj d ,eoP gdYWk gam_\IKkP ^ck]mc. /mKijgZk] ciPojjT] g\_o] X. /ogZdT
cigg]oecmjo \Xoaodjom _mao d oejoFmjkk XciJ_ijkji A., o^cid_ijjoXo ^o ^cm_%Ydamjjo]\
m]\ oSdkjmjkI d godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY, ^cm_\g]oecmjjoXo R. 4 ge. 159 :> E?. $W ]iemckiaod _mai gam_\me, Reo A. d ^okgZiM ciSoeT o^\SakZodia gdom oS%Ydamjkm d $jemcjme.
246
ikjemcmgodijjTm akNi jm ]oX\e oSciekeQgY d ^o_oSjTM ga\RiYM
Wi WiKkeoP gdokM ^cid k d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi,
eiZ ZiZ _mYemaQjogeQ ocXijod \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ;oc]iaQjo STai k WiZojjoP k oSogjodijjoP, og^ockeQ _mPgedkY gcm_ged
]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk eiZJm jm ^cm_geidaYmegY doW]oJjT], eiZ ZiZ d
jmP kWaoJmjT oSgeoYemaQgedi d _mPgedkemaQjogek k]mdFkm ]mgeo.
AeieQY 139 :C> E?
Zoccmg^oj_kc\me go ge. 1069 k ^. 2 ge. 1070
> E?.
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z kggam_\m]o]\ do^cog\, ^o g]Tga\ ge. 1069 >
E? dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\ d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjTM
_mPgedkP (SmW_mPgedkY) Xog\_icgedmjjTM ocXijod akSo _oaJjogejTM
akN ,ekM ocXijod, ^o_amJke doW]mKmjkI. 8cm_ doW]mKimegY Wi gRme
ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk (ge. 1069 > E?).
$W go_mcJijkY ^. 2 ge. 1070 > E?, d gdoI
oRmcm_Q, \g]ieckdimegY, Reo dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\ d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoP _mYemaQjogek ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY,
^coZ\cie\cT, jm gdYWijjTP g ^ogam_gedkY]k, ^cm_\g]oecmjjT]k d ^.
1 _ijjoP joc]T, doW]mKimegY ^o ogjodijkY] k d ^ocY_Zm dTFm ^ckdm_mjjoP ge. 1069 > E?. Cck ,eo] dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP ^ck og\Kmged-
A ^cm_aoJmjkm] ciSoeT d e\ckgekRmgZoP ;kc]m 111 « amg \_» Z jm]\ oSciekagY jm \geijodamjjTP gam_gedkm] /., ^ckXaigkd mXo ji goSmgm_odijkm d o;kg _ijjoP ;kc]T, X_m ciSoeiak mKm _di RmaodmZi, Wijk]iYgQ ^o_XoeodZoP k ^codm_mjkm] ZojNmcejoP ^coXci]]T «jk
EoggkPgZoP ]\WTZk ji >k^cm». Cckge\^kd Z ciSoem, A. ^o ^oc\RmjkI /. o;oc]aYa _oXodocT g edocRmgZk]k ZoaamZekdi]k, JmaiIKk]k ^ckjYeQ \Rigekm d ]mco^ckYekk, ^oa\Ria
oe jkM _mjmJjTm gcm_gedi, ZoeocTm ^mcm_idia ^ogam_jm]\. Cck WiZaIRmjkk _oXodocod ^cm_geidkemak ZoaamZekdod g_idiak WiXcijkRjTm ^ig^ocei, ^o kM ecmSodijkI A. ^cm_%YdaYa gdoP
^ig^oce, dT_idia dkWkejTm ZiceoRZk g \ZiWijkm] emam;oji. >oX_i ^cm_geidkemak edocRmgZkM
ZoaamZekdod jm g]oXak dTmMieQ ji >k^c, ojk oSciekakgQ d 111 «amg \_», o_jiZo jiMo_kdFkmgY ei] goec\_jkZk jkRmXo jm g]oXak oS%YgjkeQ. Cogam dgZcTekY gmP;od oZiWiaogQ,
Reo ei] jiMo_YegY eoaQZo WiXcijkRjTm ^ig^ocei. i ;kc]\ STak ^ckXaiFmjT ^cm_geidkemak
gcm_ged ]iggodoP kj;oc]iNkk, ZoeocTm gjYak gIJme, ^oZiWid o;kg 111 «amg \_», jiWdid
mXo ]oFmjjkRmgZoP ;kc]oP. A\_o] \geijodamjo, Reo A., eiZJm ZiZ k _di _c\XkM goec\_jkZi
111 «amg \_» _oScogodmgejo oejogkakgQ Z ^oc\RmjjT] k] oSYWijjogeY], ^oa\RmjjTm
g\]]T djogkak d ^ckMo_jo-ZiggodTm oc_mci, _oXodocT WidmcYak ^mRieQI, ^ckji_amJiKmP
Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\. oZiWieQ ^ckRigejogeQ A. Z kjZck]kjkc\m]o]\ m]\ _mYjkI, jm ^cm_geidkaogQ doW]oJjT] k oj STa o^cid_ij. 1_jiZo d _ijjo] ga\Rim cmiSkakeiNkY akNi k gdYWijjom g jmP ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i jm ^odamZao jkZiZkM, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM ge. 139 :C>
E? ^ogam_gedkP _aY \ZiWijjoXo Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi. 8 cmWoaIekdjoP Rigek ^ckXodoci g\_
\ZiWia, Reo dmKmgedmjjTm _oZiWiemaQgedi: kW%YeTm d 111 «amg \_» _oZ\]mjeT, mXo ^mRieQ,
ogeiIegY d Zi]mcm McijmjkY dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged A: ^ck :8 1 X. /ogZdT, i
\Xoaodjom _mao ji^cidaYmegY ^coZ\coc\ _aY ^cokWdo_gedi ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY k
\geijodamjkY akNi, ^o_amJiKmXo ^ckdamRmjkI d ZiRmgedm oSdkjYm]oXo. 8 _ijjo] ga\Rim oRmdk_jo, Reo Wiecoj\eT RmgeQ k _ogeokjgedo akN, ciSoeidFkM d 111 «amg \_», k] ^ckRkjmj
]ociaQjTP dcm_, ^ogeci_iai _maodiY cm^\eiNkY Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi, geiai jmdoW]oJjoP mXo
_iaQjmPFiY _mYemaQjogeQ // cMkd /mKijgZoXo ciPojjoXo g\_i X. /ogZdT. CckXodoc oe
1 idX\gei 2005 X. mao & 1-484/2005.
247
amjkk ^cidog\_kY, doW]mKimegY d ga\Rim, mgak dkji g\_Qk \geijodamji
^ckXodoco] g\_i, dge\^kdFk] d WiZojj\I gka\.
$gMo_Y kW go_mcJijkY ^oaoJmjkP \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo k
XciJ_ijgZoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi, jmaQWY g_maieQ dTdo_od o ZiZo]
dcm_m, ^ckRkjmjjo] Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\, gam_\me XodockeQ ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z jmoSMo_k]ogek mXo doW]mKmjkY d gooedmegedkk go ge. 139
:C> E? k o ^ciZekRmgZoP dWik]ogdYWk \ZiWijjTM ^oaoJmjkP XciJ_ijgZoXo k \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojod.
CoZiWiemaQjT] ^ck]mco], YdaYmegY, ji jiF dWXaY_, o^cm_mamjkm
>ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? «1S oeZiWm d ^ckjYekk Z cigg]oecmjkI
JiaoST oSKmgedi g oXcijkRmjjoP oedmegedmjjogeQI «"» ji jic\Fmjkm Zojgeke\NkojjTM ^cid k gdoSo_ ge. 139 :C> E?»
1
, X_m oSoWji-
Rmji mXo ^oWkNkY goXaigjo ZoeocoP ge. 139 :C> E? YdaYmegY oSKmP ^o
gdom]\ MiciZemc\ joc]oP, ^cm_^oaiXime doW]mKmjkm dcm_i Ick_kRmgZk] akNi] d ^oajo] oS%m]m k jm go_mcJke ZiZkM-akSo ^cidka, _o^\gZiIKkM kgZaIRmjkm doW]mKmjkY eoXo kak kjoXo dk_i dcm_i. 1ji
dTge\^ime XicijekmP cmiakWiNkk Zojgeke\NkojjoXo ^cidi Ick_kRmgZkM akN ji doW]mKmjkm
dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k
(SmW_mPgedkm]) ocXijod Xog\_icgedmjjoP daigek kak kM _oaJjogejTM
akN, jiMo_kegY do dWik]ogdYWk g _c\Xk]k, ^cm_\g]oecmjjT]k d Xa. 18
:C> E?. >co]m eoXo, WiYdkemaQ d^cidm oSciekeQgY g ecmSodijkm] o
doW]mKmjkk ^ckRkjmjjoXo dcm_i d kjo] ^ocY_Zm, ji Reo \ZiWTdiaogQ
d ^ckjYeTM ^o mXo _ma\ g\_mSjTM cmFmjkYM
2
.
8cm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\, doW]mKmjkm ZoeocoXo d
^oajo] oS%m]m, ^o ]jmjkI >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E?, ^cm_\g]oecmjo Xa. 18 :C> E?, o^cm_maYmegY g^mNk;kZoP geie\gi g\S%mZei, RQk
kjemcmgT ]oX\e ^ogeci_ieQ oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\.
EmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY ^ckdo_Ye Z dTdo_\, Reo
Ick_kRmgZkM akN, k]mIKkM ^cido ji
doW]mKmjkm dcm_i d gooedme-
gedkk g Xa. 18 :C> E?, \gaodjo ]oJjo ciW_makeQ ji ZiemXockk:
1
$W ^cm_geidamjjTM d >ojgeke\NkojjTP A\_ ]iemckiaod gam_\me, Reo $j_\geckiaQjTP
g\_ X. Cmc]k oeZiWia XciJ_ijkj\ . — _kcmZeoc\ k \Rcm_kemaI 111 «"», d oejoFmjkk
ZoeocoXo STao ^cmZciKmjo \Xoaodjom _mao k ^ckWjijo ^cido ji cmiSkakeiNkI, d \_odamedocmjkk WiYdamjkY, ^o_ijjoXo d ^ocY_Zm ge. 139 :C> E?, o dWTgZijkk g /kjkgemcgedi
;kjijgod E? d ^oaQW\ 111 «"» \STeZod dgam_gedkm jmWiZojjoXo \_mcJijkY dmZgmaY k
\KmcSi d cmW\aQeiem \ecieT jmcig^cm_mamjjoP ^ckSTak, i eiZJm \^\KmjjoP dTXo_T d
gdYWk g ^cokWdo_gedo] ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\. A\_mSjiY ZoaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] Cmc]gZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i ogeidkai ^ogeijodamjkm g\_i ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk SmW kW]mjmjkY k
\ZiWiai, Reo dcm_, o doW]mKmjkk ZoeocoXo Mo_ieiPged\me WiYdkemaQ, jm ]oJme STeQ doW]mKmj d ^cY_Zm Xa. 18 :C> E?, ^ogZoaQZ\ ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk \^\KmjjoP dTXo_T jm
^o_amJie \_odamedocmjkI d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
2
1^cm_mamjkm >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? oe 21 _mZiScY 2006 X. & 621-1 // >ojg\aQeije
CaIg.
248
Ick_kRmgZkm akNi, ^ogeci_idFkm d cmW\aQeiem \XoaodjoXo ^cm-
gam_odijkY akN, YdaYIKkMgY kM \Rcm_kemaY]k (\RigejkZi]k), jijYeT]k _aY og\KmgedamjkY _mYemaQjogek FeiejT]k ciSoejkZi]k;
Ick_kRmgZkm akNi, ^ogeci_idFkm oe _mPgedkP ocXijod k _oaJ-
jogejTM akN ^ck ^cokWdo_gedm ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\, jm k]mIKm]\
oejoFmjkY Z kM _mYemaQjogek.
8 Widkgk]ogek oe \ZiWijjoXo oSgeoYemaQgedi ogjodijkY k ^ocY-
_oZ doW]mKmjkY ^ckRkjmjjoXo k] dcm_i S\_me ciWakRjT].
8 ^mcdo] ga\Rim, _o WidmcFmjkY ^cokWdo_gedi ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\
^ogeijodZi do^cogi o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ^cm_geidaYmegY akFmjjoP
oS%mZekdjTM ogjodijkP. Cck dge\^amjkk o^cid_iemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci d WiZojj\I gka\, ^ck ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai ^o ogjodijkY], _iIKk] ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i akNo, ^ogeci_idFmm oe
\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY, d^cidm WiYdkeQ
ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk
dcm_i, d eo] Rkgam k d ^oaQW\ Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi, RQk kjemcmgT, ^o
mXo ]jmjkI, ^ogeci_iak. Cck kW%Yekk \ Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi k]\Kmgedi, ^ckoSKmjjoXo d ZiRmgedm dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged, do^cog
o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ^\em] mXo doWdciei kak Zo]^mjgiNkk ji ogjodijkk ^^. «S» ^. 2 R. 2 ge. 82 :C> E? cmFimegY eiZJm ^ogam
WidmcFmjkY
^cokWdo_gedi ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\.
i ^ciZekZm k]mIe ]mgeo gke\iNkk, ZoX_i ZoakRmgedo k]\Kmgedi,
;kX\ckc\IKmXo d ^coeoZoam dTm]Zk k go_mcJiKmXogY d ^ogeijodamjkk o ^ckoSKmjkk Z _ma\ d ZiRmgedm dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged, ciWakRimegY. eo ]oJme STeQ gdYWijo g ciWakRjT]k oSgeoYemaQgedi]k, d
eo] Rkgam k jm gdk_memaQged\IKk]k o jmWiZojjTM kak jmoSogjodijjTM _mPgedkYM gooedmeged\IKkM
_oaJjogejTM akN.
8o^cog o doWdciem eiZoXo k]\Kmgedi ^o ecmSodijkI Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi, ]oJme STeQ cmFmj, ^o jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, eiZJm ^ogam WidmcFmjkY ^cokWdo_gedi ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\ (mgak _oaJjogejTm akNi
jm goRe\e doW]oJjT] g_maieQ ,eo cijQFm). 8 Mo_m ciggam_odijkY ^cmge\^amjkY ]oX\e ^oYdkeQgY jodTm _oZiWiemaQgedi, gdk_memaQged\IKkm o jmoSMo_k]ogek ^ckoSKmjkY dgmXo k]\Kmgedi
Z \Xoaodjo]\
_ma\ d ZiRmgedm dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged.
8o deoco] ga\Rim, ZoX_i ^ck ^cokWdo_gedm ^o \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\
dcm_ ^ckRkjmj Ick_kRmgZk] akNi] d gka\ ga\RiPjoXo gemRmjkY jm^cm_dk_mjjTM oSgeoYemaQged, oj ^o_amJke doW]mKmjkI d ^ocY_Zm,
^cm_\g]oecmjjo] ge. 1069, ^. 2 ge. 1070 > E?.
jiakW ^oaoJmjkP Xa. 18 :C> E? ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo joc]T,
d jmP go_mcJiKkmgY,
jm ^ck]mjk]T Z ^o_oSjT] gke\iNkY], eiZ ZiZ, d
gka\ kjoP Ick_kRmgZoP ^ckco_T, jm go_mcJie ]mMijkW]od cmiakWiNkk
_ijjTM ^cidooejoFmjkP. >iZ, ji^ck]mc, jm ]oJme oSciekeQgY d ^o-
249
cY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi g ecmSodijkm] o doW]mKmjkk
dcm_i, ^oeciRmjjoXo ji amRmjkm, akNo, \ ZoeocoXo oe kg^\Xi kW-Wi dTgecmai, ^cokWdm_mjjoXo do dcm]Y Wi_mcJijkY akNi, ^o_oWcmdim]oXo d
godmcFmjkk ^cmge\^amjkY, ga\RkagY gmc_mRjTP ^ckge\^. 1_jiZo mXo
jkZeo jm akFime ^cidi oSciekeQgY Wi WiKkeoP d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ZoX_i g\_ g]oJme oNmjkeQ STak ak d ZojZcmejoP
gk-
e\iNkk _mPgedkY _oaJjogejoXo akNi WiZojjT]k k oSogjodijjT]k.
Cck ^ciZekRmgZoP cmiakWiNkk ^oaoJmjkP ge. 139 :C> E? dTWTdiIe gaoJjogek k do^cogT, ZigiIKkmgY doW]mKmjkY ]ociaQjoXo
dcm_i Ick_kRmgZk] akNi], o_jk] kW \gaodkP \g^mFjoP _mYemaQjogek
ZoeocTM YdaYmegY _maodiY cm^\eiNkY.
Co g]Tga\ jTjm g\Kmged\IKmP cm_iZNkk _ijjoP joc]T ]oJjo
^cm_^oaoJkeQ, Reo ^oaoJmjkY ge. 136 :C> E? ]oX\e STeQ ^ck]m
jk]T k Z Ick_kRmgZk] akNi].
eo, ji gi]o] _mam, _iamZo jm eiZ. CcokWdoaQjom eoaZodijkm
joc]T ^ck]mjkemaQjo Z kjT], jm \ZiWijjT] d jmP g\S%mZei], jm _o^\gek]T, eiZ ZiZ g\S%mZejTP gogeid gooedmeged\IKkM ^cidooejoFmjkP YdaYmegY jmoe%m]am]T] ,am]mjeo] kM gogeidi. ck_kRmgZkm
akNi jm ]oX\e STeQ oejmgmjT jk Z ZiemXockk cmiSkakekcodijjTM, jk
Z k]mIKk] ^cido
ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i ddk_\ ^cmZciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai (\XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY), ^ckWjijkY jmWiZojjT] ^ck]mjmjkY ]mc ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo ^ckj\J_mjkY.
AoXaigjo ^. 5 ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe
20 _mZiScY 1994 X. & 10 « mZoeocTm do^cogT ^ck]mjmjkY WiZojo_i-
1
emaQgedi o Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i»
, ^cidkai, cmX\akc\IKkm
Zo]^mjgiNkI ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i d gdYWk g cig^cogecijmjkm] gdm_mjkP, ^ocoRiKkM _maod\I cm^\eiNkI XciJ_ijkji, ^ck]mjYIegY k d
ga\RiYM cig^cogecijmjkY eiZkM gdm_mjkP d oejoFmjkk Ick_kRmgZoXo
akNi. Aam_odiemaQjo, Ick_kRmgZom akNo eiZJm k]mme ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ji ^ciZekZm ^cidkai o Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo
dcm_i ]oX\e STeQ ^ck]mjmjT Z
WiKkem _maodoP cm^\eiNkk Ick_kRmgZoXo akNi, jmg]oecY ji eo, Reo ]ociaQjTP dcm_, goXaigjo ^. 1 ge. 151
> E? o^cm_maYmegY ZiZ ;kWkRmgZkm kak jcidgedmjjTm geci_ijkY, ZoeocTm ]oJme ^cmemc^mdieQ eoaQZo ;kWkRmgZom akNo.
8 ^. 7 ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? «1 g\_mSjoP
^ciZekZm ^o _mai] o WiKkem Rmgek k _ogeokjgedi XciJ_ij, i eiZJm _maodoP cm^\eiNkk Ick_kRmgZkM akN», ^o_ cig^cogecijmjkm] gdm_mjkP,
^ocoRiKkM _maod\I cm^\eiNkI Ick_kRmgZkM akN, ji^ck]mc, gam_\me
-
1
8A E?. 1997. & 1; 1998. & 3; 2007. & 5.
250
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]