Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
A\]]T, dT^aiRmjjTm Wi oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk, ^o_amJie doW]mKmjkI ji ogjodijkk _oZ\]mjeod, gdk_memaQged\IKkM o gooedmeged\IKm] oSciKmjkk. Cck ,eo] ^ciZekZi k_me ^o ^\ek, ZoX_i
oeg\egedkm _oZ\]mjeod, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM cigMo_T ji o^aie\ ec\_i
i_doZiei, gi]o ^o gmSm jm YdaYmegY ogjodijkm] Z oeZiW\ d \_odamedocmjkk ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, jmg]oecY ji \emcI
_oZ\]mjeod, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM
;iZe dT^aieT doWjiXciJ_mjkY i_doZie\ "., _odo_T o mXo \Rigekk d
^cokWdo_gedm ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY d ZiRmgedm WiKkejkZi ^o goXaiFmjkI k dT^aiem m]\ Wi ,eo 35 eTg. c\S., jiFak gdom ^o_edmcJ_mjkm
^oZiWijkY]k gdk_memaY (JmjT cmiSkakekcodijjoXo, WiZaIRidFmP goXaiFmjkm g i_doZieo] k djmgFmP dTFmjiWdijj\I g\]]\ d Zigg\ Ick_kRmgZoP Zojg\aQeiNkk), gi]oXo i_doZiei; ^ckoSKmjjT]
Z ]iemckiai] \XoaodjoXo _mai oc_mco] o mXo \Rigekk d _mam, gam_gedmjjT]k k
g\_mSjT]k _oZ\]mjei]k, ^o_edmcJ_iIKk]k ;iZe oZiWijkY Ick_kRm-
1
gZoP ^o]oKk WiYdkemaI ji ,ei^m ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY
.
8 eo Jm dcm]Y jm ciWcmFmj ji_amJiKk] oSciWo] do^cog o eo],
^o_amJie ak doW]mKmjkI cigMo_T, ^ojmgmjjTm kjT]k akNi]k ^ck
WiZaIRmjkk goXaiFmjkY g i_doZieo].
i g\Kmgedodijkm _ijjoP ^coSam]T \ZiWiak, d Rigejogek, goec\_jkZk oe_mai kg^oajmjkY g\_mSjTM iZeod ^cidodoXo _m^icei]mjei /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E?, cmW\aQeieT o^cogi ZoeocTM ^ckdo_Ye Z
dTdo_\, Reo jm_ogeieoRjo RmeZom
cmX\akcodijkm ^cidooejoFmjkP d
,eoP Rigek g^ogoSged\me doWjkZjodmjkI gke\iNkP, ZoX_i g\_T oeZiWTdiIe \^cido]oRmjjo]\ akN\ d o^aiem ec\_i WiKkejkZi, ^ckXaiFmjjoXo _aY oZiWijkY m]\ Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk _c\Xk] akNo].
1 jiakRkk ^o_oSjTM ;iZeod gdk_memaQged\me k g\_mSjiY ^ciZekZi
2
.
1
Cogeijodamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? ^o _ma\
8. A^cidZi ^o cmW\aQeiei] oSoSKmjkY ^ciZekZk ^ck]mjmjkY g\_i]k maYSkjgZoP oSaigek ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi o cmiSkakeiNkk (Xa. 18 :C> E?).
2
8 2008 X. o^cid_ijjTP ^ckXodoco] /ogZodgZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i XciJ_ijkj . oSciekagY
d _ijjTP g\_ g WiYdamjkm] o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, d Zoeoco], jicY_\ g _c\Xk]k, ^cogka cigg]oecmeQ do^cog o dT^aiem m]\ d ZiRmgedm doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i g\]], dT^aiRmjjTM Wi oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk. >iZ \g]ieckdimegY kW ^cm_geidamjjTM d g\_
_oXodocod ^oc\RmjkY, _o^oajkemaQjTM goXaiFmjkP Z _oXodoc\ ^oc\RmjkY, goXaiFmjkP oS
oZiWijkk Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk, Zo^kP _oXodocod oS oZiWijkk Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk ;kWkRmgZo]\ kak Ick_kRmgZo]\ akN\, g^cidoZ /ogZodgZoXo NmjeciaQjoXo ;kakiai /ogZodgZoP
oSaigejoP ZoaamXkk i_doZieod, Zo^kP ZdkeijNkP, ciW]mc g\]], dT^aiRmjjTM k] Wi oZiWijkm
Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk, gogeidaYme 200 eTg. c\S. 8]mgem g em], g\_ jm gRma doW]oJjT] \_odamedockeQ ecmSodijkm . d Rigek dWTgZijkY _mjmJjTM g\]], dT^aiRmjjTM ^o goXaiFmjkY]
oS oZiWijkk m]\ Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk, eiZ ZiZ ojk STak WiZaIRmjT jm jm^ogcm_gedmjjo
cmiSkakekcodijjT], i mXo ]iemcQI. A].: Cogeijodamjkm /ogZodgZoXo Xoco_gZoXo A\_i
oe 4 _mZiScY 2008 X. mao & 2-77-30/07. iamm . oSciekagY g ZiggiNkojjoP JiaoSoP d A\_mSj\I ZoaamXkI ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8A E?, ZoeociY d gdom] o^cm_mamjkk oe 21 YjdicY 2009 X.
221
Co g\ek d ijiaoXkRjoP ^ckdm_mjjo]\ ^ck]mc\ gke\iNkk, A\_mSjiY
ZoaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E?, ^ck cigg]oecmjkk
ZiggiNkojjoP JiaoST ^cm_geidkemaY :^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? ji ^ogeijodamjkm maYSkjgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i oe 27 joYScY 2006 X. ^o _ma\ o^cid_ijjoXo >.
ogeidkd mXo d gkam, ^cm_geidkai jmgZoaQZo _c\Xkm icX\]mjeT.
CoWkNkY g\_i dTciWkaigQ d
eo], Reo _odo_T JiaoST oS oeg\egedkk
\ o^cid_ijjoXo >. ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm cigMo_od Wi oZiWijj\I m]\
i_doZieo] Ick_kRmgZ\I ^o]oKQ ^o em] ogjodijkY], Reo goXaiFmjkm
g i_doZieo] k _oXodoc ^oc\RmjkY STak WiZaIRmjT jm k]k akRjo, i
mXo ]iemcQI, jm ]oX\e STeQ ^ckWjijT oSogjodijjT]k.
A\_o] oe]mRmjo, Reo d gooedmegedkk g ^cidkai]k ge. 50 R. 1 :C>
E?
WiKkejkZ ]oJme STeQ ^ckXaiFmj ^o_oWcmdim]T], oSdkjYm]T], i
eiZJm _c\Xk]k akNi]k ^o ^oc\RmjkI kak g goXaigkY ^o_oWcmdim]oXo,
oSdkjYm]oXo. iZaIRmjkm goXaiFmjkY ji oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk co_joP ]iemcQI akNi, ^ckdamRmjjoXo Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek k go_mcJiKmXogY ^o_ geciJmP, gooedmeged\me ge. 25 iZoji «1S
i_doZiegZoP _mYemaQjogek k i_doZie\cm d EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk».
A\_mSjiY ZoaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT]
_mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? goXaigkaigQ g dTdo_i]k g\_Qk maYSkjgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i d eoP Rigek,
Reo >., jiMo_kdFkPgY ^o_ geciJmP, STa akFmj cmiaQjoP doW]oJjogek
WiZaIRkeQ goXaiFmjkm k o^aiekeQ \ga\Xk i_doZiei, Reo gdk_memaQged\me o _mPgedkYM mXo ]iemck d mXo kjemcmgiM k ^o mXo ^oc\RmjkI.
CoZiWiemaQjT] dk_kegY k eoe icX\]mje, dT_dkj\eTP A\_mSjoP
ZoaamXkmP
d ^oaQW\ cmFmjkY maYSkjgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i, Reo \edmcJ_mjkY o^cid_ijjoXo o eo], Reo mXo ]ieQ, _mPged\Y ^o mXo ^oc\RmjkI,
dT^aiRkdiai ^cm_\g]oecmjjom goXaiFmjkm] doWjiXciJ_mjkm i_doZie\ kW mXo gcm_ged, jkRm] jm o^codmcXj\eo
1
.
8 \ZiWijjo] ^ck]mcm ^ckdamZiIe djk]ijkm _di ]o]mjei: do-^mcdTM, jm geoYa do^cog o jmoSMo_k]ogek ZiZkM-akSo ^o_edmcJ_mjkP
eoXo oSgeoYemaQgedi, Reo ]ieQ o^cid_ijjoXo ^ck ^ckXaiFmjkk WiKke-
oe]mjkai ^ogeijodamjkm /ogZodgZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i k ji^cidkai _mao ji jodom cigg]oecmjkm d eoe Jm g\_ d kjo] gogeidm. Co ijiakWkc\m]oP Rigek ecmSodijkP cmiSkakekcodijjoXo
d o^cm_mamjkk \ZiWijo, Reo cmFmjkm oS oeZiWm d dT^aiem gcm_ged, WieciRmjjTM ]iemcQI og\J_mjjoXo, ^ckjYeo SmW \Rmei eoXo, Reo gi] . jiMo_kagY ^o_ geciJmP. A\_ jm ^codmcka, ]oX ak
oj, jiMo_YgQ ^o_ geciJmP, akRjo WiZaIRkeQ goXaiFmjkm o WiKkem g i_doZieo] k o^aiekeQ mXo
\ga\Xk, jm ^ckSmXiY Z ^o]oKk ]iemck. /mJ_\ em], ZiZ gZiWijo d o^cm_mamjkk, g\_ jm \Rma,
Reo goXaigjo ge. 50 :C> E? WiKkejkZ ]oJme STeQ ^ckXaiFmj _c\Xk] akNo] ^o ^oc\RmjkI
oSdkjYm]oXo k g mXo goXaigkY. "iZk] oSciWo], g\_ _oaJmj dTYgjkeQ k \ZiWieQ d ^ogeijodamjkk Zeo oSYWij STa d _ijjo] ga\Rim o^aiekeQ \ga\Xk i_doZiei. A].: 1^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP
ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8A E? oe 21 YjdicY 2009 X. mao & 5-108-276 // icije.
1
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E?
oe 6 ;mdciaY 2007 X. mao & 48-o07-3 // icije.
222
jkZi _mPgedodiai ^o mXo ^oc\RmjkI, i do-deocTM, doWjkZ jmZkP jIijg,
WiZaIRiIKkPgY d eo], Reo >. oSogjodTdia ^cokgMoJ_mjkm gcm_ged,
Wi gRme ZoeocTM ^cokgMo_kai o^aiei mXo \ga\X. $W go_mcJijkY o^cm_mamjkY ]oJjo g_maieQ dTdo_, Reo d ga\Rim, mgak ST \edmcJ_mjkm >. o
eo], Reo _ijjTm gcm_gedi ^ckji_amJiak m]\, STak o^codmcXj\eT, \ZiWijjom
oSgeoYemaQgedo ]oXao ST ^odakYeQ ji cmFmjkm g\_i.
/T ^oaiXim], Reo doW]mKmjkm g\]], dT^aiRmjjTM Wi oZiWijkm
Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk, ZiZ o_kj kW jikSoamm dogecmSodijjTM ji ^ciZekZm g^ogoSod doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, j\J_imegY d ]iZgk]iaQjoP ZojZcmekWiNkk ]mMijkW]od mXo cmiakWiNkk. Ccm_geidaYmegY
WjiRk]T] eo oSgeoYemaQgedo, Reo k Camj\] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? jm_ogeieoRjo ^oajo ciW%YgjYme ^ocY_oZ
Kmjkk dcm_i d gdYWk g oZiWijkm] Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk
ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod o doW]m-
1
.
AoXaigjo R. 1 ge. 50 :C> E? WiKkejkZ ^ckXaiFimegY ^o_oWcmdim]T], oSdkjYm]T], mXo WiZojjT] ^cm_geidkemam], i eiZJm _c\Xk]k akNi]k ^o ^oc\RmjkI kak g goXaigkY ^o_oWcmdim]oXo, oSdkjYm]oXo
2
.
8 gdYWk g ,ek], d ZiZoP-eo ZojZcmejoP gke\iNkk _mPgedkemaQjo
]oJme doWjkZj\eQ do^cog o eo], _idia ak ^o_oWcmdim]TP kak oSdkjYm]TP ^oc\Rmjkm kak goXaigkm ji WiZaIRmjkm goXaiFmjkY g i_doZieo] gdomP ]iemck, ZoeociY ^o g]Tga\ go_mcJijkY R. 1 ge. 50 :C> E?
dTge\^ime d ZiRmgedm _c\XoXo akNi kak ZiZo]\-akSo kjo]\ akN\, Zc\X
ZoeocTM
WiZojo] jm o^cm_mamj.
"iZk] oSciWo], g ;oc]iaQjoP eoRZk WcmjkY ecmSodijkY WiZoji,
ZiZ ^oZiWTdime ^ciZekZi, g\_i]k oS%mZekdjo ]oX\e STeQ goSaI_mjT
k o^cid_ijjo]\ akN\ ^oecmS\megY ^cm_geidaYeQ _o^oajkemaQjTm icX\]mjeT, Reo mgemgedmjjo ^odamRme oegcoRZ\ d cmiakWiNkk mXo ^cidi
ji doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i.
>co]m eoXo, gam_\me o^cm_makeQgY k d ^oWkNkk, ^cido]mcji ak ^ogeijodZi do^cogi
o _oZiWTdijkk WiYdkemam] eoXo oSgeoYemaQgedi, Reo
ji \ga\Xk i_doZiei ^oeciRmjT mXo akRjTm gcm_gedi.
geQ ogjodijkY ^cm_^oaoJkeQ, Reo _aY ciWcmFmjkY ^o_oSjTM
g^ocod d ^ciZekRmgZoP _mYemaQjogek jmoSMo_k]o kgMo_keQ kW eoXo,
Reo ^oaoJmjkY R. 1 ge. 50 :C> E? YdaYIegY oSKk]k ecmSodijkY]k
_o^\gZi WiKkejkZi Z \RigekI d g\_o^cokWdo_gedm ^o ZojZcmejo]\
\Xoaodjo]\ _ma\, goSaI_mjkm ZoeocTM _oaJjo STeQ ^o_edmcJ_mjo d
mXo ]iemckiaiM.
EmFiY do^cog o _o^\gZm WiKkejkZi, jmoSMo_k]o \_ogeodmckeQgY,
mgeQ ak goXaigkm kak ^oc\Rmjkm ji mXo ^ckXaiFmjkm _c\Xk]k akNi]k
1
C\jZe 15 ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i oe 29 joYScY 2011 X. & 17.
2
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo d ^ckdm_mjjTM ^ck]mciM oSdkjYm]Tm YdaYIegY godmcFmjjo-
amejk]k, gam_odiemaQjo, cmRQ jm k_me oS kM WiZojjTM ^cm_geidkemaYM (^. 12 ge. 5 :C> E?).
223
d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i WiKkejkZ jm ^ckXaiFmj jm^ogcm_gedmjjo ^o_oWcmdim]T] kak oSdkjYm]T], e.m., goSaI_mjT ak ecmSodijkY, \ZiWijjTm
d R. 1 ge. 50 :C> E?.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ]T ^oaiXim], Reo ZocmjQ ^coSam]T gam_\me kgZieQ
jm d ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk, i d oeg\egedkk m_kjooSciWjoXo mm ^ojk]ijkY k ^ck]mjmjkY g\_i]k.
Co jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, NmamgooSciWjo oSciekeQ
jmoSMo_k]ogeQ Wi^ciFkdieQ (jicY_\ g _c\Xk]k) k _ijjTm, gdk_memaQged\IKkm o jiakRkk d ]iemckiaiM \XoaodjoXo _mai gdm_mjkP, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM ;iZe ^oc\RmjkY kak goXaigkY ^o_oWcmdim]oXo, oSdkjYm]oXo, ^o_g\_k]oXo, og\J_mjjoXo ji ^ckXaiFmjkm WiKkejkZi _c\Xk]k akNi]k.
_mgQ, o_jiZo, gam_\me k]meQ d dk_\, Reo ecmSodijkY R. 1 ge. 50 :C>
E? d kjemcmg\IKmP jig
dijT ji ,ei^m ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY, e.m. d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i
ocXijT ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY ^o ZiZk]-eo ^ckRkji] jm
goRak jmoSMo_k]T] oeciWkeQ d ]iemckiaiM \XoaodjoXo _mai ;iZe ^oc\RmjkY kak goXaigkY oSdkjYm]oXo, ^o_oWcmdim]oXo ji ^ckXaiFmjkm
WiKkejkZi _c\Xk] akNo].
"iZk] oSciWo], ^cm_geidaYmegY NmamgooSciWjT] djmgek _o^oajmjkm
. 1 ge. 50 :C> E?, kWaoJkd mm d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
d R
Rigek ]oX\e STeQ jm d ^oajoP ]mcm cmiakWo-
djk]ijkm g\_od ji
«iKkejkZ
^ckXaiFimegY ^o_oWcmdim]T], oSdkjYm]T], mXo WiZojjT] ^cm_geidkemam], i eiZJm _c\Xk]k akNi]k ^o ^oc\RmjkI kak g goXaigkY ^o_oWcmdim]oXo, oSdkjYm]oXo.
kak g goXaigkY ^o_oWcmdim]oXo, oSdkjYm]oXo _c\Xk]k akNi]k,
8
\ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo _oaJjo jiPek oeciJmjkm d ]iemckiaiM \XoaodjoXo
_mai.
Co_oWcmdim]TP, oSdkjYm]TP d^cidm WiZaIRkeQ goXaiFmjkm oS
oZiWijkk m]\ Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk g jmgZoaQZk]k WiKkejkZi]k».
A\_mSjiY ^ciZekZi k_me ^o ^\ek ciWXcijkRmjkY cigMo_od, gdYWijjTM g o^aieoP \ga\X WiKkejkZi, gdYWijjTM g oZiWijkm] Ick_kRmgZoP
^o]oKk k kjTM, WieciRmjjTM ji oSmg^mRmjkm mXo \RigekY d _mam.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, kJmXoco_gZkP oSaigejoP g\_ ^ogeijodka dT^aiekeQ o^cid_ijjo]\ /. d gRme doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i,
gdYWijjoXo g mXo \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm], WiYdamjjTm k] g\]]T
^ojmgmjjTM cigMo_od Wi o^aie\ ec\_i WiKkejkZod d gei_kk
d gRme
^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY, cigg]oecmjkY _mai g\_i]k ^mcdoP
k ZiggiNkojjoP kjgeijNkP. >co]m eoXo, g\_ \_odamedocka ecmSodijkY /. d Rigek doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, ^ojmgmjjoXo d
gdYWk g YdZoP k ^coJkdijkm] mXo, i eiZJm _d\M i_doZieod, og\KmgedaYdFkM mXo WiKke\ d 8mcModjo] A\_m E? ^ck cigg]oecmjkk Ziggi
NkojjoXo ^cm_geidamjkY ji ^ckXodoc kJmXoco_gZoXo g\_i. Cck
-
224
,eo] STak Zo]^mjgkcodijT cigMo_T ji ^comW_ oe X. . odXoco_i
1
_o X. /ogZdT k oSciejo, cigMo_T ji ^coJkdijkm d XogekjkNm
.
$ggam_odijkm ^oaoJmjkP, cmXai]mjekc\IKkM doW]mKmjkm \STeZod, ^mcmRkgamjjTM d R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo
\^ocY_oRmjkI ciWcmFmjkY g^ocjTM do^cogod, d Nmao] ji^cidamjjo]\ ji godmcFmjgedodijkm ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kggam_\m]oXo ^cidodoXo kjgeke\ei d Rigek doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i ]oJme
g^ogoSgedodieQ djmgmjkm kW]mjmjkP d go_mcJijkm R. 1 _ijjoP joc]T,
Zoeoc\I ^cm_aiXim] kWaoJkeQ d gam_\IKmP
cm_iZNkk:
«1. $]\KmgedmjjTP dcm_, ^o_amJiKkP doW]mKmjkI cmiSkakekcodijjo]\, i
cidjo kjo]\ akN\, ^ogeci_idFm]\ d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, dZaIRime d gmSY:
1) WiciSoej\I ^aie\, ^mjgkI, ^ogoSkY, _c\Xkm gcm_gedi, ZoeocTM
akNo akFkaogQ d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi;
2) Zoj;kgZodijjom k oSciKmjjom d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi ji ogjodijkk ^ckXodoci kak cmFmjkY g\_i, i cidjo \eciRmjjom ^o_amJiKmm
doWdcie\, kW%Yeom
ocXiji]k ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkI k]\-
Kmgedo akNi;
3) Feci;T k ^coNmgg\iaQjTm kW_mcJZk, dWTgZijjTm g akNi do
kg^oajmjkm ^ckXodoci g\_i;
4) g\]]T, dT^aiRmjjTm akNo] Wi oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk;
5) kjTm, ^ojmgmjjTm \STeZk».
8oW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi d Rigek ^ckjYekY cmFmjkP ^o oSciKmjkI dWTgZijkP ji
gcm_gedi SI_Jmeod SI_JmejoP gkgem]T EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk jm
ogaoJjmjo jiakRkm] d ,eoP Rigek ^coekdocmRkP XciJ_ijgZoXo k XciJ_ijgZoXo ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi g I_JmejT] Zo_mZgo]
E?, oSmg^mRkdiIKk] k]]\jkeme SI_Jmeod k doW]oJjogeQ oSciKmjkY
ji jkM dWTgZijkP eoaQZo ji ogjodijkk g\_mSjTM iZeod
(ge. 239 > E?).
o ^ckjYekY ?m_mciaQjoXo WiZoji oe 1 kIaY 2010 X. & 144-? k
djmgmjkY gooedmeged\IKkM kW]mjmjkP d go_mcJijkm ge. 135 :C> E?,
,eoXo jmaQWY STao gZiWieQ o ^cidodo] cmX\akcodijkk doW]mKmjkY
dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ZoX_i ^ogeijodamjkm
o ^cokWdo_gedm dT^aie d doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, dTjmgmjjom _oaJjogejT]k akNi]k ocXijod ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY, YdaYaogQ ogjodijkm]
EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk
_aY oSciKmjkY dWTgZijkY ji gcm_gedi SI_JmejoP gkgem]T
2
.
1
Cogeijodamjkm kJmXoco_gZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i oe 4 ]iY 2008 X. mao & 2-47/07. jiaoXkRjT] oSciWo] do^cog cmFmj k A\_mSjoP >oaamXkmP ^o :XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
E? ^o _ma\ /. A].: >iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm oe 17 i^cmaY 2003 X. & 50-o03-16 // icije.
2
Cogeijodamjkm >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? oe 2 ]icei 2010 X. & 5-C: URL://http://www.sudrf. ru
225
8 jigeoYKmm dcm]Y ^oaoJmjkY R. 2 ge. 135 :C> E? d Nmao] jm ^coekdocmRie ^oaoJmjkY] I_JmejoXo WiZoji, ji^cidamjjT] ji kg^oajmjkm g\_mSjTM iZeod ^o kgZi] Z EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk.
"m] jm ]mjmm, jm^coWciRjogeQ ^coNm_\cT ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod,
gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, ^o-^cmJjm]\, jm
_ime ogjodijkP ZojgeiekcodieQ kgRmc^TdiIKkP MiciZemc cY_i go_mcJiKkMgY d
ge. 135 :C> E? ^cidodTM ^oaoJmjkP.
AoXaigjo R. 5 ge. 135 :C> E? ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i ciWcmFimegY g\_QmP d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] ge. 399
:C> E? _aY ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g kg^oajmjkm] ^ckXodoci, i keoXodT] cmFmjkm] ^ck ,eo] YdaYmegY ^ogeijodamjkm g\_i
(ge. 401 :C> E?), ji Zoeocom cig^cogecijYIegY oSKkm ^cidkai oSJiaodijkY k
dge\^amjkY d WiZojj\I gka\.
/mJ_\ em], I_JmejT] Zo_mZgo], cmXai]mjekc\IKk] ogjodijkY k ^ocY_oZ kg^oajmjkY g\_mSjTM iZeod ^o kgZi] o dWTgZijkk _mjmJjTM gcm_ged Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk (^. 1 ge. 242.2,
^. 2 ge. 242.1 > E?) \geijodamjo, Reo _aY og\KmgedamjkY dT^aie
/kjkgemcgedo] ;kjijgod E?, d mXo i_cmg ji^cidaYmegY kg^oajkemaQjTP _oZ\]mje, Z Zoeoco]\
^ckaiXimegY ji_amJiKk] oSciWo] WidmcmjjiY g\_o] Zo^kY g\_mSjoXo iZei, ji ogjodijkk ZoeocoXo
oj dT_ij.
Cck ,eo] kg^oajkemaQjTP akge dT_imegY g\_o] dWTgZiemaI kak
^o mXo ^cogQSm ji^cidaYmegY g\_o] _aY kg^oajmjkY ^ogam dge\^amjkY
g\_mSjoXo ^ogeijodamjkY d WiZojj\I gka\ (^. 1 ge. 428 C> E?). gak
g\_mSjom ^ogeijodamjkm ^cm_\g]ieckdime dWTgZijkY ji gcm_gedi SI_Jmeod SI_JmejoP gkgem]T EoggkPgZoP
?m_mciNkk, Z dT_idim]o]\
kg^oajkemaQjo]\ akge\ _oaJji ^ckaiXieQgY WidmcmjjiY g\_o] d \geijodamjjo] ^ocY_Zm Zo^kY g\_mSjoXo ^ogeijodamjkY, _aY kg^oajmjkY
ZoeocoXo dT_ij kg^oajkemaQjTP akge (^. 3 ge. 428 C> E?).
AoXaigjo cijmm \^o]kjidFm]\gY ^ckZiW\ /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod
E? oe 15 idX\gei 2006 X. & 271 kg^oajmjkm g\_mSjTM iZeod _ijjT]
ocXijo] ^cokWdo_kegY ji ogjodijkk kg^oajkemaQjTM _oZ\]mjeod, g
\ZiWijkm] g\]], ^o_amJiKkM dWTgZijkI, Z
ZoeocT] _oaJjT STeQ
^ckaoJmjT ji_amJiKk] oSciWo] WidmcmjjTm Zo^kk g\_mSjTM iZeod,
ji ogjodijkk ZoeocTM ojk dT_ijT
1
.
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo :C> E?, ^ckWdijjTP d ci]ZiM cmi-
akWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP
1
CckaoJmjkm & 1 Z CocY_Z\ ocXijkWiNkk ciSoeT d /kjkgemcgedm ;kjijgod E?, \edmc-
J_mjjo]\ CckZiWo] /kj;kji E? oe 15 idX\gei 2006 X. & 271.
226
_oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, cmX\akcodieQ
^ocY_oZ mXo doW]mKmjkY, jm go_mcJke ^o _ijjT] ^ckjNk^kiaQjo
WjiRk]T] do^cogi] jkZiZkM ZojZcmejTM \ZiWijkP, gaoJkdFiYgY gke\iNkY j\J_imegY d ZckekRmgZo] ^mcmog]Tgamjkk.
1SogjodijjT] ^cm_geidaYmegY dTdo_ o eo], Reo ;iZekRmgZk ^coNm_\ci doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ji ,ei^m cigg]oecmjkY _mai g\_o] d ci]ZiM
WiYdamjjTM ecmSodijkP _oaJji dTXaY_meQ jm godgm] eiZ,
\g]oecmjo d ^oaoJmjkYM R. 4 k 5 ge. 135 :C> E?.
A\_, dTjmgFkP ^ogeijodamjkm o ^cokWdo_gedm dT^aie d doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, ^ogam mXo dge\^amjkY d WiZojj\I gka\ dT_ime (kak ^o ^cogQSm dWTgZiemaY ji^cidaYme d /kjkgemcgedo ;kjijgod
E?) kg^oajkemaQjTP akge, ^ckaiXiY Z jm]\ Widmcmjj\I Zo^kI g\_mSjoXo ^ogeijodamjkY, _aY kg^oajmjkY ZoeocoXo
_oZ\]mjeT YdaYIegY ogjodijkm] _aY oSciKmjkY dWTgZijkY ji SI_JmejTm gcm_gedi EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ^oaiXim] NmamgooSciWjT] djmgek d jTjm _mPged\IK\I cm_iZNkI R. 4 k 5 ge. 135 :C> E? kW]mjmjkY, gooedmeged\IKkm ;iZekRmgZk] ecmSodijkY] WiZoji k ^cm_geidkeQ kM d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
RigeQ 4 ge. 135 :C> E?:
« m ^oW_jmm o_joXo ]mgYNi go _jY ^o-
oj dT_ij. :ZiWijjTm
ZiZ ^cm_-
ge\^amjkY ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i g\_QY
o^cm_maYme mXo ciW]mc k dTjogke ^ogeijodamjkm o ^cokWdo_gedm
dT^aie d doW]mKmjkm ,eoXo dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] ge. 399
jigeoYKmXo >o_mZgi _aY ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g kg^oa-
jmjkm] ^ckXodoci. :ZiWijjTm dT^aieT ^cokWdo_YegY g \Rmeo]
\codjY kj;aYNkk»
RigeQ 5 ge. 135 :C> E?:
;
«8T_iRi g\_o] kg^oajkemaQjoXo akgei
og\KmgedaYmegY ^ogam dge\^amjkY g\_mSjoXo ^ogeijodamjkY d WiZoj-
j\I gka\ ^o ^cidkai], ^cm_\g]oecmjjT] ^. 1, 3 ge. 428 >C E?».
8 Nmao] oSoSKmjkm cmW\aQeieod g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk k o^cogi
_oaJjogejTM akN ocXijod \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi gdk_memaQged\me, Reo jikSoamm ek^kRjT]k ^ck ciWcmFmjkk WiYdamjjTM ecmSodijkP o doW]mKmjkk ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod, ^mcmRmjQ ZoeocTM ^cm_geidamj d R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, YdaYIegY ga\Rik oSJiaodijkY ^ckjk]im]TM cmFmjkP ddk_\ jmgoXaigkY g WiYdamjjoP (\_odamedocmjjoP)
g\]]oP ecmSodijkP.
8 cY_m
amjjTm ]iemckiaT, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkm ciW]mc g\]] ^o WiYdamjjT]
ecmSodijkY], _o^\gZiIe oFkSZk d kM cigRmeiM, jm dgmX_i \RkeTdiIe ecmSodijkY _mPged\IKmXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi k joc]iekdjTM
ga\Rimd g\_T jm_ogeieoRjo Xa\SoZo kggam_\Ie ^cm_geid-
227
iZeod1. Ake\iNkI, ^o jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, ogaoJjYme k \ZiWijkm, g;oc]\akcodijjom d ^. 18 ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E?
oe 29 joYScY 2011 X. & 17, goXaigjo Zoeoco]\
«ciW]mc dT^aie, ^o_amJiKkM doW]mKmjkI cmiSkakekcodijjo]\, o^cm_maYmegY g\_o] g
\Rmeo] kj_mZgi cogei ^oecmSkemaQgZkM Nmj ^o ]mge\
emaQgedi
_odijkY,
cmiSkakekcodijjoXo
ciggRkeijjoXo Xog\_icgedmjjT]k ocXiji]k geiekgekZk
ji ]o]mje jiRiai \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam-
c
EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk d g\S%mZem EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk
^ckjYekY cmFmjkY o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i
»
(dT_.
_kggmceijeo]
ji ]o]mje
kak
).
Jk-
ijjom jm_ogeieoRjo RmeZom ^cm_^kgijkm d godoZ\^jogek g ]joXoRkgamjjT]k kjT]k, ji^cidamjjT]k ji \cmX\akcodijkm do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g goSaI_mjkm] ^cid akN, WiYdkdFkM ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkk
k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, jm ^oWdoaYIe g_maieQ o_joWjiRjTP dTdo_ o
eo], Reo g\_T k]mIe kgRmc^TdiIKkP icgmjia ^cidodTM gcm_ged _aY
gdomdcm]mjjoP k ,;;mZekdjoP cmiakWiNkk ecmSodijkP, ^cm_\g]oecmj-
2
jTM d ge. 135 :C> E?
.
CoZiWiemaQji d ,eoP gdYWk ^oWkNkY \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod, ^oaiXiIKkM, Reo kgMo_Y kW oSKmXo ^cidkai, d gooedmegedkk g ZoeocT]
k]\KmgedmjjTP dcm_ doW]mKimegY XciJ_ijkj\ d ^oajo] oS%m]m, gam_\me WiZaIRkeQ, Reo cmiSkakekcodijjTP XciJ_ijkj d^cidm ciggRkeieQ, oSogjodieQ _oZ\]mjeiaQjo k ^oecmSodieQ oe Xog\_icgedi
1
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A> ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 12 YjdicY
2006 X. & 58-005-71; >iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A> ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo
A\_i E? oe 20 joYScY 2006 X. & 44-106-129; >iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 24 i^cmaY 2008 X. & 51-008-25 // icije; Cogeijodamjkm /ogZodgZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i ^o _ma\ . mao &2-60/94; A^cidZi ^o
cmW\aQeiei] oSoSKmjkY g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk cMijXmaQgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] (cmiSkakeiNkY) d 2007—2009 XX.:
URL://http://www.arhcourt.ru
2
CoaoJmjkm «1 ^ocY_Zm doW]mKmjkY \KmcSi, ^ckRkjmjjoXo XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k
_mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY, CcoZ\cie\cT k g\_i»,
\edmcJ_mjjoXo :ZiWo] CcmWk_k\]i 8mcModjoXo Aodmei AAAE oe 18 ]iY 1981 X.; $jgec\ZNkY «Co ^ck]mjmjkI CoaoJmjkY o ^ocY_Zm doW]mKmjkY \KmcSi, ^ckRkjmjjoXo
XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY,
^coZ\cie\cT k g\_i», \edmcJ_mjjoP 2 ]icei 1982 X.(g kW]. k _o^.); "c\_odoP Zo_mZg E?;
Cogeijodamjkm Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 17 ]icei 2004 X. & 2 «1 ^ck]mjmjkk
g\_i]k EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ec\_odoXo Zo_mZgi EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk» (d cm_. ^ogeijodamjkY Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 28 _mZiScY 2006 X. & 63); CoaoJmjkm oS
ogoSmjjogeYM ^ocY_Zi kgRkgamjkY gcm_jmP WiciSoejoP ^aieT, \edmcJ_mjjom ^ogeijodamjkm] CcidkemaQgedi E? oe 24 _mZiScY 2007 X. & 922; Cogeijodamjkm Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i AAAE oe 23 _mZiScY 1988 X. & 5 (cm_. oe 29 ]icei 1991 X.) «1 jmZoeocTM
do^cogiM ^ck]mjmjkY d g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZm :ZiWi CcmWk_k\]i 8mcModjoXo Aodmei AAAE
oe 18 ]iY 1981 X. «1 doW]mKmjkk \KmcSi, ^ckRkjmjjoXo XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k Xog\_icgedmjjTM k oSKmgedmjjTM ocXijkWiNkP, i eiZJm _oaJjogejTM akN ^ck
kg^oajmjkk k]k ga\JmSjTM oSYWijjogemP» // >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
228
_mjmJjoP Zo]^mjgiNkk aISTM \STeZod, ^cokgMoJ_mjkm ZoeocTM jiMo_kegY d ^ckRkjjoP gdYWk g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] jmdkjodjoXo,
dZaIRiY d gmSY \^\Kmjj\I dTXo_\, d eo] Rkgam d g;mcm ^cm_^ckjk]i-
1
emaQgZoP _mYemaQjogek
.
"m] jm ]mjmm, ^ck cigg]oecmjkk ecmSodijkP o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i,
doWjkZiIe ]joXoRkgamjjTm jIijgT, ZoeocTm d ZiJ_o] ZojZcmejo]
ga\Rim damZ\e ^ogam_gedkY, gdYWijjTm g og^ickdijkm] g\_mSjTM cmFmjkP go geocojT WiYdkemamP k ^cm_geidkemamP oedmeRkZi, jm \_odamedocmjjTM \geijodamjjT]k g\_o] g\]]i]k dT^aie. $M jiakRkm o^cm_maYmegY ]joXk]k ;iZeoci]k k oSgeoYemaQgedi]k, oS\gaodamjo godoZ\^jogeQI ^ckRkj ^ck]mjkemaQjo
Z ZiJ_o]\ ZojZcmejo]\ ga\RiI.
eo ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\ o jmoSMo_k]ogek ^okgZi ZojNm^e\iaQjoXo
^o_Mo_i Z ^ckjYekI g\_i]k cmFmjkP, ji^cidamjjTM ji \_odamedocYIKmm geocojT o^cm_mamjkm ciW]mci ^o_amJiKmXo doW]mKmjkI k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, g^ogoSged\IKmXo godmcFmjgedodijkI g\_mSjoP
^ciZekZk k ]kjk]kWiNkk Rkgai oSJiaodijkY g\_mSjTM cmFmjkP.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ^cm_aiXimegY ddmgek d \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP
WiZoj ^oaoJmjkY, ^oWdoaYIKmm og\KmgedaYeQ
^cm_dickemaQjoXo ga\Fijkm do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
CoaiXim] NmamgooSciWjT] ^ogam ^oa\RmjkY k kW\RmjkY dgmM jmoSMo_k]TM _oZ\]mjeod, ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM (kak jm ^o_edmcJ_iIKkM)
ciW]mc WiYdamjjTM dT^aie,
^cm_ogeidkeQ g\_Qm ^cido
jiWjiRkeQ _ie\
^cm_dickemaQjoXo ga\FijkY do^cogod o goXaigodijkk g\]] WiYdamjjTM ecmSodijkP g \dm_o]amjkm] WiYdkemaY, ^coZ\coci, ji_amJiKmXo
^cm_geidkemaY oedmeRkZi, ^cm_geidkemamP ocXijod, ^cokWdo_kdFkM
cigRmeT ^o Wi^cogi] g\_i.
CcoZ\coc k ^cm_geidkemaQ oedmeRkZi d^cidm Wicijmm oWjiZo]keQgY
g kjemcmg\IKk]k kM ]iemckiai]k.
8 Mo_m eiZoXo Wigm_ijkY ^cm_geidaYmegY doW]oJjT] ^ckjYeQ ]mcT
Z ]iZgk]iaQjo]\ \gecijmjkI ^coekdocmRkP, jiakRkm ZoeocTM d^ogam_gedkk ^ckdo_ke
Z oSJiaodijkI, damZ\Km]\ jmo_joZciejom cig-
g]oecmjkm o_joXo k eoXo Jm do^cogi ciWakRjT]k g\_mSjT]k kjgeij-
2
NkY]k, jmo^cid_ijjT] ]ociaQjT] k ]iemckiaQjT] Wieciei]
.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ^cm_aiXim] _o^oajkeQ:
1
mWam^Zkj .".
2
Co _ijjT] 8mcModjoXo A\_i Emg^\SakZk iZigkY d 2008 X. d ZiggiNkojjo] ^ocY_Zm STak
oe]mjmjT 11,1% cmFmjkP ciPojjTM g\_od o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, d 2009 — 13,6%. 1SWoc g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk ^o do^cogo] doW]mKmjkY \KmcSi d gdYWk g jmWiZojjT] ^ckdamRmjkm] Z
\XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o XciJ_ijgZk] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
Emg^\SakZk iZigkY Wi ^mcko_ g 2008 X. ^o 1-m ^oa\Xo_km 2010 X.: URL://http://vs.hak.sudrf.ru
igeoaQjiY ZjkXi g\_Qk ^o \Xoaodjo]\ ^coNmgg\. A. 173.
229
RigeQ 2 ge. 229 :C> E? (1gjodijkY ^codm_mjkY ^cm_dickemaQ-
joXo ga\FijkY) ^. 7 gam_\IKmXo go_mcJijkY:
«7) _aY \eoRjmjkY d
gooedmegedkk g WiYdamjjT]k ecmSodijkY]k ciW]mci dcm_i, ^o_amJiKmXo doW]mKmjkI ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM
akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi»;
RigeQ 1 ge. 236 :C> E?, cmXai]mjekc\IKmP dk_T cmFmjkP, ^ck-
jk]im]TM g\_QmP ji ^cm_dickemaQjo] ga\Fijkk, ^. 8 gam_\IKmXo
go_mcJijkY:
«Cck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM ^. 7
R. 2 ge. 229 jigeoYKmXo >o_mZgi ^ckjk]imegY cmFmjkm o jiWjiRmjkk g\_mSjoXo Wigm_ijkY d gooedmegedkk g R. 4 ge. 135 :C> E?
akSo, ^o Mo_ieiPged\ WikjemcmgodijjTM \RigejkZod, oS oeaoJmjkk jiWjiRmjkY g\_mSjoXo Wigm_ijkY _aY o^cm_mamjkY ciW]mci
dcm_i, ^o_amJiKmXo doW]mKmjkI»;
geieQI 399 :C> E? — R. 5 (_aY goMcijmjkY ^ogam_odiemaQjogek
d j\]mciNkk ddk_\ eoXo, Reo _ijjiY RigeQ d ^cmJjmP cm_iZNkk d
jigeoYKmm dcm]Y gRkeimegY \eciekdFmP gka\ d gooedmegedkk g ?
oe 8 _mZiScY 2003 X. & 161-?), kWaoJkd mm d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
«5. Cck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i
cmiSkakekcodijjT], i eiZJm kjT] akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, g\_QY d^cidm jiWjiRkeQ ^cm_dickemaQjom ga\Fijkm Zoeocom ^codo_kegY d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo]
ge. 234 :C> E?».
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo d ci]ZiM ^cm_aoJmjkP, g;oc]\ak-
codijjTM ji gecijkNiM jigeoYKmXo kggam_odijkY, jiXc\WZi ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk ji ge. 399 :C> E? jm eoaQZo doWcigeime, jo k
;iZekRmgZk gdk_memaQged\me o cmX\akcodijkk ^cidooejoFmjkP, dTMo_YKkM Wi ci]Zk kg^oajmjkY ^ckXodoci, eiZ ZiZ d cY_m ^cidodTM
^oaoJmjkP jTjm ^cm_^oaiXim]iY ijiaoXkY jm cmFime dgmM doWjkZiIKkM ^coSam]
Jkd mXo d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
, NmamgooSciWjo djmgek kW]mjmjkY d mm jiWdijkm, kWao-
«AeieQY 399. CocY_oZ ciWcmFmjkY
do^cogod, gdYWijjTM g kg^oajmjkm] ^ckXodoci k doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i
^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
:ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo ^ckdm_me Z jmoSMo_k]ogek djmgmjkY
kW]mjmjkP d gooedmeged\IKkM joc]iM Xa. 18 :C> E?, X_m k_me cmRQ
o ggTaZm ji ge. 399 :C> E?.
>>o]^mjgiNkY ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i (ge. 136 :C> E?).
Co_ ]ociaQ-
jT] dcm_o] ^ojk]iIe ;kWkRmgZkm kak jcidgedmjjTm geci_ijkY XciJ-
1
1
ijjom ^cm_aoJmjkm goXaig\megY g cijmm djmgmjjT]k ^cm_aoJmjkY]k oS kW]mjmjkk
go_mcJijkY ge. 135 :C> E?.
230
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]