Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
dijkY, \RkeTdieQ g\_mSj\I ^ciZekZ\1, e.m. ^ciZekRmgZk jmo^cm_mamjjT] Zc\Xo] ^cm_^kgijkP.
Cck ,eo] gam_\me Wi]mekeQ, Reo doW]mKmjkm dcm_i akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, cmXai]mjekc\IegY ZiZ
\Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjT], eiZ k XciJ_ijgZk] Zo_mZgi]k, i gZai_TdiIKiYgY g\_mSjiY ^ciZekZi jm _ime o_joWjiRjTM kgRmc^TdiIKkM
2
oedmeod ji doWjkZiIKkm g^ocjTm do^cogT
.
$gMo_Y kW jmoSMo_k]ogek cmiakWiNkk jiWjiRmjkY \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, oSmg^mRmjkY gdomdcm]mjjoP k ,;;mZekdjoP WiKkeT
^cid ^ogeci_idFkM XciJ_ij NmamgooSciWjo dTciSoeieQ o^ek]iaQjTm ^cidkai, cmXai]mjekc\IKkm doW]mKmjkm ^ckRkjmjjoXo dcm_i.
Cck ,eo] jmoSMo_k]o \RkeTdieQ gam_\IKmm:
1) kW Zojgeke\Nkojjo-^cidodoXo g]Tgai joc]iekdjoXo cmX\akcodijkY kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i jm \g]ieckdiIegY ZiZkm-akSo
Wi^cmeT ji doW]oJjogeQ iaQemcjiekdjoXo ^o_Mo_i Z doW]mKmjkI
dcm_i WikjemcmgodijjT]k \RigejkZi]k ZiZ d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo,
eiZ k \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi;
2) jmWidkgk]o oe ;oc]T cmiakWiNkk ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i,
godoZ\^jogeQ Zo]^mjgiNkojjo-doggeijodkemaQjTM ]mc o^cm_maYmegY
doamkW%Ydamjkm] akNi, ^ogeci_idFmXo d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi;
3) Wi kgZaIRmjkm] ga\Rimd doW]oJjoXo ciWcmFmjkY do^cogod o
doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo ^ck]mjmjkm] ]mc ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo
^ckj\J_mjkY (ge. 125 :C> E?), cmiakWiNkY WiYdamjjTM
ecmSodijkP
og\KmgedaYmegY Wi ^cm_mai]k g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\;
4) jmoSMo_k]ogeQ _oZ\]mjeiaQjoXo ^o_edmcJ_mjkY ciW]mcod ^o_amJiKmXo doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, ZojZcmekWiNkk ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod,
o^cm_maYIKkM MiciZemc ^ckjk]im]oXo g\_o] cmFmjkY, doW]oJjogeQ
mXo og^ickdijkY _oaJjogejT]k akNi]k, ^cm_geidaYIKk]k ZiWj\
EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk, ZiZ ^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo, eiZ k XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, gdk_memaQged\me oS
oeg\egedkk ogjodijkP ^oaiXieQ,
Reo doW]mKmjkm dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi oSmg^mRkdime oSamXRmjjTP _oge\^ XciJ_ij Z cmiakWiNkk ^cidi ji mXo doW]mKmjkm;
1
C\jZe 6 CckZiWi mjmciaQjoP ^coZ\cie\cT E? oe 20 YjdicY 2009 X. & 12, /kjkgemcgedi
;kjijgod E? k & 3j «1 dWik]o_mPgedkk ocXijod ^coZ\cie\cT k ]kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod
EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ^ck ^oge\^amjkk gdm_mjkP oS oSciKmjkk d g\_ XciJ_ijkji g kgZo]
(WiYdamjkm]) o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \XoaodjoXo
^cmgam_odijkY».
2
1SogjodijjogeQ _ijjoXo emWkgi ^o_edmcJ_imegY k godoZ\^jogeQI ^oaoJmjkP, kWaoJmjjTM d ^ogeijodamjkk Camj\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 29 joYScY 2011 X. & 17. A].: ^. 10,
11, 13, 16, 20, 24 ^ogeijodamjkY.
211
5) d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi XciJ_iji] ]oJme STeQ
^ckRkjmj jm eoaQZo k]\KmgedmjjTP, jo k ]ociaQjTP dcm_, Zo]^mjgiNkY ZoeocoXo d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk og\KmgedaYmegY d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi (R. 2 ge. 136 :C> E?). Aam_odiemaQjo, ^ck
WiYdamjkk ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i k Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk, NmamgooSciWjo ^cm_ogeidkeQ ^ogeci_idFm]\
doW]oJjogeQ cigg]oecmeQ mXo g\eQ d ci]ZiM
o_joXo ^cokWdo_gedi, jm oScmZiY ji jmoSMo_k]ogeQ cmiakWiNkk ^cidi
ji doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, i ji Zo]^mjgiNkI ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i d _mjmJjo] dTciJmjkk — d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo;
6) ^o gdomP ^cidodoP ^ckco_m kjgeke\e doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, d oeakRkm oe kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk, YdaYmegY g]mFijjT] ]mJoecigamdT] ^cidodT] kjgeke\eo], ^oaoJmjkY ZoeocoXo ^oWdoaYIe og\KmgedaYeQ WiKke\ kjemcmgod ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi XciJ_ij, ZiZ d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo, eiZ k XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
8 ZojemZgem kggam_\m]oXo do^cogi ^cm_geidaYmegY Wiga\JkdiIKmP
djk]ijkY ^oWkNkY $cZ\egZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i. "iZ, ^o cmW\aQeiei]
kW\RmjkY g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk d $cZ\egZoP oSaigek oe]mRmjo, Reo g\_T
cigg]ieckdiIe WiYdamjkY XciJ_ij
o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo
dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d gdYWk g jmWiZojjT] ^ckdamRmjkm] Z \XoaodjoP
oedmegedmjjogek, og\J_mjkm] kak go_mcJijkm] ^o_ geciJmP, d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi (ge. 1070 > E?), i jm d ^ocY_Zm, ^cm_\g]oecmjjo] ge. 399 :C> E?, d emM ga\RiYM, ZoX_i ^ck
cigg]oecmjkk _ijjTM WiYdamjkP doWjkZime g^oc o ciW]mcm ^ckRkjmjjoXo k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, ^ocY_Zm
kak g^ogoSm mXo doW]mKmjkY, jmoSMo_k]ogek kgecmSodijkY _oZiWiemaQged, dTWodi gdk_memamP k e._.;
e.m. d ga\Rim, ZoX_i g^oc ]oJjo ciWcmFkeQ akFQ d ^ocY_Zm kgZodoXo
^cokWdo_gedi, o^cm_mamjjo] XciJ_ijgZk] k XciJ_ijgZk] ^coNmgg\iaQjT] WiZoji]k k jmdoW]oJjogek mXo ciWcmFmjkY d ci]ZiM, \geijod-
1
amjjTM ge. 399 :C> E?
.
A o_joP geocojT oSciKime ji gmSY djk]ijkm ^cm_^oaiXim]iY doW]oJjogeQ cigg]oecmeQ ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ZiZ d ^ocY_Zm
XciJ_ijgZoXo, eiZ k \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, g _c\XoP, — go
gZai_TdiIKmPgY gke\iNkmP dcY_ ak ]oJjo goXaigkeQgY. Cogam ^ckWjijkY Wi akNo] ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i m]\ jmoSMo_k]o ciW%YgjkeQ ^ocY_oZ mXo cmiakWiNkk. 8 ,eoe ]o]mje
oSgeoYemaQgedi, kW-
aoJmjjTm $cZ\egZk] oSaigejT] g\_o], jm ]oX\e STeQ jk kWdmgejT,
1
$jemcjme-^oceia A «Ccidog\_km»: URL://http://www.sudrf.ru
212
jk ^coXjoWkc\m]T. Co,eo]\ WiZojo]mcjo doWjkZiIe do^cogT ZoX_i,
Zm] k ^oRm]\ \^cido]oRmjjo]\ akN\ ]oJme STeQ oeZiWijo d cigg]oecmjkk _mai g\_o] d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi? >co]m
eoXo, ji^ciFkdimegY dTdo_, Reo d ci]ZiM ^coNm_\cT, g^mNkiaQjo
^cm_\g]oecmjjoP :C> E? _aY doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] d
Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, _iamZo jm dgm doWjkZiIKmm do^cogT ]oJjo ciWcmFkeQ.
Cck ,eo] d o^cm_mamjjoP Rigek ,eo gooedme-
ged\me _mPgedkemaQjogek.
EmWI]kc\Y kWaoJmjjom, ^oaiXim] jmoSMo_k]T] _o^oajkeQ go_mcJijkm ^cm_aiXim]oP cm_iZNkk ge. 134 :C> E?, ^oaoJmjkm] gam_\IKmXo go_mcJijkY:
«EmiakWiNkY ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i
cmiSkakekcodijjT] kak kjT] ^ogeci_idFk] akNo] og\KmgedaYmegY
^o kM \g]oecmjkI d ;oc]m \XoaodjoXo kak XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 8oW]mKmjkm dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT] d gdYWk g oeZiWo]
RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY oe oSdkjmjkY og\KmgedaYmegY d ^ocY_Zm XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi».
iciZemckW\Y oSKkm ji^cidamjkY godmcFmjgedodijkY ocXijkWiNkojjo-^cidodoXo ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kggam_\m]oXo ^cidodoXo kjgeke\ei, gam_\me oSciekeQ djk]ijkm ji gam_\IKmm oSgeoYemaQgedo.
AoXaigjo R. 6 ge. 399 :C> E? d g\_mSjo] Wigm_ijkk d^cidm \RigedodieQ ^coZ\coc, e.m. ^o aoXkZm WiZojo_iemaQjoP Zojgec\ZNkk \ZiWijjom ^oaoJmjkm jm YdaYmegY k]^mciekdjT].
8]mgem g em], jiRiaQjkZi] XaidjTM \^cidamjkP k \^cidamjkP
mjmciaQjoP ^coZ\cie\cT E?, ^coZ\coci] g\S%mZeod EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk, ^ckcidjmjjT] Z jk] domjjT] ^coZ\coci] k ^coZ\coci] kjTM
g^mNkiakWkcodijjTM ^coZ\cie\c d gooedmegedkk g \geijodamjjoP Zo]^memjNkmP mjmciaQjT] ^coZ\coco] _ijo \ZiWijkm ^ck ^oge\^amjkk
gdm_mjkP oS oSciKmjkk d g\_ XciJ_ijkji g kgZo] (WiYdamjkm]) o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \XoaodjoXo
^cmgam_odijkY jmWi]m_akemaQjo jiWjiRieQ
_mSjo] ciWSkciemaQgedm
1
.
^coZ\coci _aY \RigekY d g\-
A\Kmged\Ie oS%mZekdjTm ogjodijkY ^cm_^oaoJkeQ, Reo ZoaQ
gZoco \Rigekm ^coZ\coci d g\_mSjTM Wigm_ijkYM oNmjkdimegY ZiZ jmoSMo_k]ogeQ, ^ck cigg]oecmjkk _mai SmW kM \RigekY ^oYdkegY oRmdk_jTP ^odo_ _aY oSJiaodijkY ^ckjk]im]TM cmFmjkP.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ^cm_aiXim] _o^oajkeQ R. 6 ge. 399 :C> E? ^oaoJmjkm] gam_\IKmXo go_mcJijkY:
«Cck cigg]oecmjkk do^cogod, gdY-
1
Aod]mgejTP CckZiW mjmciaQjoP ^coZ\cie\cT oe 20 YjdicY 2009 X. & 12 k &3j /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? «1 dWik]o_mPgedkk ocXijod ^coZ\cie\cT k /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ^ck ^oge\^amjkk gdm_mjkP oS oSciKmjkk d g\_ XciJ_ijkji g
kgZo] (WiYdamjkm]) o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY» // >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
213
WijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT], i eiZJm kjT]
akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, \Rigekm
^coZ\coci oSYWiemaQjo».
>co]m eoXo, cmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY ^oWdoaYIe
dTPek g ^cm_aoJmjkm] o ;oc]\akcodijkk ^oajoXo go_mcJijkY ge. 134
:C> E? d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
«AeieQY 134. CckWjijkm ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i.
1. Ccido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i dZaIRime d gmSY ^cido ji Zo]^mj-
giNkI ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, doggeijodamjkm d ec\_odTM, ^mjgkojjTM, JkakKjTM k kjTM ^cidiM.
2. A\_ d ^ckXodocm, o^cm_mamjkk ^ogeijodamjkk, i _oWjidiemaQ, gam_odiemaQ, c\Zodo_kemaQ gam_gedmjjoXo ocXiji, jiRiaQjkZ ^o_ciW_mamjkY _oWjijkY, ^coZ\coc d
^ogeijodamjkk ^ckWjiIe Wi cmiSkakekcodijjT] kak kjT] ^ogeci_idFk] akNo] ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i,
^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\ _mPgedkY]k _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 8 ga\Rim g]mcek cmiSkakekcodijjoXo ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i ^ckWjimegY Wi mXo jigam_jkZi]k.
3. 1cXij kak _oaJjogejom akNo, ^ckWjidFkm ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm
dcm_i, ^ckjk]ime ]mcT Z ciW%YgjmjkI akN\, Wi
ZoeocT] ojo ^ckWjijo,
^ocY_Zi mXo doW]mKmjkY, ^cm_\g]oecmjjoXo Xa. 18 jigeoYKmXo >o_mZgi.
4. 8oW]mKmjkm dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT], i eiZJm kjT] akNi],
^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, og\KmgedaYmegY
Xog\_icgedo] d ^oajo] oS%m]m jmWidkgk]o oe dkjT ocXiji _oWjijkY,
_oWjidiemaY, jiRiaQjkZi ^o_ciW_mamjkY _oWjijkY, gam_odiemaY, c\Zodo_kemaY gam_gedmjjoXo ocXiji, ^coZ\coci, g\_i Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk. ijjom
^cidkao jm cig^cogecijYmegY ji ga\Rik
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT] d gdYWk g oeZiWo] oe oSdkjmjkY RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY.
5. EmiakWiNkY ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT] kak
kjT] ^ogeci_idFk] akNo] og\KmgedaYmegY ^o kM \g]oecmjkI d ;oc]m
\XoaodjoXo kak XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. 8oW]mKmjkm dcm_i
cmiSkakekcodijjT] d gdYWk g oeZiWo] RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY oe oSdkjmjkY og\KmgedaYmegY d ^ocY_Zm
XciJ_ijgZoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi».
44.4. i^cidamjkY godmcFmjgedodijkY ^cidodoP
cmXai]mjeiNkk doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
?\jZNkojkcodijkm ocXijkWiNkojjo-^cidodoXo ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi jmoe_mak]o oe ^ciZekRmgZoXo ^ck]mjmjkY ZojZcmejTM ^cidodTM joc], cmX\akc\IKkM
214
^cidooejoFmjkY, doWjkZiIKkm d Mo_m cmiakWiNkk \^cido]oRmjjT]k
g\S%mZei]k ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo k Zo]^mjgiNkI ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, doggeijodamjkm kjTM jic\FmjjTM ^cid.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] kggam_odijkm ^cidodTM ^cm_^kgijkP, jm^ogcm_gedmjjo ZigiIKkMgY doW]mKmjkY k Zo]^mjgiNkk ZojZcmejTM dk_od
dcm_i, ^cm_geidaYmegY WjiRk]T] g eoRZk WcmjkY dTYdamjkY jikSoamm
iZe\iaQjTM ^coSam] kM ^cidodoP cmXai]mjeiNkk k dTciSoeZk ji^cidamjkP
88oW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i (ge. 135 :C> E?).
mm godmcFmjgedodijkY.
8 ^mcd\I
oRmcm_Q oSciKime ji gmSY djk]ijkm eo oSgeoYemaQgedo, Reo d R. 1 \ZiWijjoP dTFm joc]T :C> E? XodockegY o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjo]\. eo oS%YgjYmegY em], Reo jmWidkgk]o oe MiciZemci ^ckjYeoXo cmFmjkY ^o ogjodijkY], ^mcmRkgamjjT]
d ge. 133 :C> E? akNo k]mj\Ie cmiSkakekcodijjT]. ?iZekRmgZk Jm
ZoX_i cmRQ k_me o doW]mKmjkk
k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, eo ^cido ji
jmXo, ZiZ STao oe]mRmjo, k]mme WjiRkemaQjo Soamm FkcoZkP Zc\X akN.
AoXaigjo ^mcmRjI, ^cm_geidamjjo]\ d R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i dZaIRime doW]mKmjkm WiciSoejoP ^aieT,
^mjgkP, ^ogoSkP, _c\XkM _oMo_od, ZoeocTM cmiSkakekcodijjTP akFkagY d cmW\aQeiem \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY; Zoj;kgZodijjoXo kak
oSciKmjjoXo d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi ji ogjodijkk ^ckXodoci
kak cmFmjkY g\_i k]\Kmgedi; Feci;od k ^coNmgg\iaQjTM kW_mcJmZ, dWTgZijjTM
do kg^oajmjkm ^ckXodoci g\_i; g\]], dT^aiRmjjTM Wi oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk; kjTM cigMo_od.
_mgQ jmoSMo_k]o oe]mekeQ, Reo _ijjiY joc]i go_mcJke jm ^oajTP
^mcmRmjQ \STeZod, ZoeocTm ]oXak STeQ ^ckRkjmjT akN\ _mPgedkY]k
_oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. o d jmP oeg\eged\Ie k
ZiZkm-akSo oXcijkRmjkY, ^oWdoaYIKkm oeZiWieQ \^cido]oRmjjo]\ akN\ d doW]mKmjkk, ji^ck]mc, \^\KmjjoP dTXo_T, gcm_ged,
^oeciRmjjTM ji amRmjkm SoamWjk, gdYWijjoP go gecmggo], ^oa\RmjjT]
ddk_\ ji^cigjTM oSdkjmjkP, og\J_mjkY, og\KmgedamjkY d^ogam_gedkk
^cmZciKmjjoXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY; cigMo_od, gdYWijjTM g ^omW_Zi]k d g\_T, ^coJkdijkm] d XogekjkNm d ga\Rim cigg]oecmjkY _mai
d _c\Xo] Xoco_m, ^oReodTM cigMo_od. "m] jm
^o _ijjo]\ do^cog\ gZai_TdimegY jmo_joWjiRjo
]mjmm, g\_mSjiY ^ciZekZi
1
.
A\Kmged\IKiY jmo^cm_mamjjogeQ ^ckdo_ke Z ga\RiY] oSJiaodi-
jkY ^mcdojiRiaQjo ^ckjYeTM g\_i]k cmFmjkP d dTFmgeoYKkm g\_mS-
1
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
E? oe 6 ]icei 2003 X. & 18-Z^o03-11; 1^cm_mamjkm >iggiNkojjoP ZoaamXkk 8mcModjoXo
A\_i E? oe 1 kIjY 2004 X. & >A04-203 // icije; Cogeijodamjkm 1ZeYScQgZoXo ciPojjoXo g\_i X. cMijXmaQgZi. mao & 4/22-1/08: URL://http://www.sudrf.ru
215
jTm kjgeijNkk k gdk_memaQged\me o jmoSMo_k]ogek ZojZcmekWiNkk
_ijjoXo ^oaoJmjkY WiZoji.
CoZiWiemaQji, d ,eoP gdYWk, ji^ck]mc ^oWkNkY >ojgeke\NkojjoXo
g\_i E? ^o _ma\ «1S oeZiWm d ^ckjYekk Z cigg]oecmjkI JiaoST XciJ_ij "c\jodi $.. k Pdic ("c\jodoP) .>. ji jic\Fmjkm kM Zojgeke\NkojjTM ^cid ge. 2 CoaoJmjkY o ^ocY_Zm doW]mKmjkY \KmcSi, ^ckRkjmjjoXo
XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY,
^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY, ^coZ\cie\cT k g\_i», oe]mekdFmXo, Reo
_mPged\IKmm WiZojo_iemaQgedo d ga\Rim ^ckRkjmjkY XciJ_ijkj\ dcm_i
_mPgedkY]k ^cidooMcijkemaQjTM ocXijod, jm oXcijkRkdime ^cido ji
doW]mKmjkm ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod, dZaIRiY \^\Kmjj\I dTXo_\1.
1_jiZo d ^. 5 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E? cmRQ k_me jm oS \STeZiM, Reo
oWjiRime «\KmcS» kak «\coj», i o cigMo_iM, Reo oWjiRime «WiecieT»2.
CojYekm «\STeZk» ^cm_geidaYmegY Soamm FkcoZk], dZaIRiIKk] d
gmSY dgm doW]oJjTm jm_o^oa\RmjkY, i eiZJm cigMo_T, ^ojmgmjjTm ^ogeci_idFk] akNo] dgam_gedkm \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY, d ^coNmggm
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, i eiZJm d ^mcko_ k d Mo_m cmiakWiNkk
Zo]^mjgiNkojjo-doggeijodkemaQjTM ]mc d ci]ZiM WiYdamjjTM k] ecmSodijkP o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i.
>co]m eoXo, ^. 5 _mPged\IKmP cm_iZNkk R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?
g;oc]\akcodijjTP, ZiZ «kjTM cigMo_od», ^ckdo_ke ^ck mm ^coRemjkk Z dTdo_\, Reo dgm dk_T ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod, ^mcmRkgamjjTm d
^. 1—4 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, eiZJm YdaYIegY cigMo_i]k, dZaIRiY,
ji^ck]mc, WiciSoej\I ^aie\, ^mjgkk, Zoj;kgZodijjom kak oSciKmjjom d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi k]\Kmgedo.
_mgQ, ^o jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, _o^\Kmji g]TgaodiY jmeoRjogeQ, Zoeoc\I gam_\me \gecijkeQ. 8 gdYWk g ,ek] ^cm_aiXim] ^. 5 R. 1 ge. 135 :C>
E? kWaoJkeQ d gam_\IKmP cm_iZNkk:
«kjTM ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod».
8 Mo_m doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i ^o ZiJ_o]\ kW ^mcmRkgamjjTM dk_od ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod ji ^ciZekZm doWjkZiIe oS%mZekdjo oS\gaodamjjTm ^coSam]T, ciWakRjTm ^o gdomP Ick_kRmgZoP
^ckco_m k ^ocoJ_iIKk] ^ckRkji]. $ggam_odijkm dk_od, ^o_amJiKkM doW]mKmjkI ^ojmgmjjTM \STeZod, ^oZiWTdime, Reo d SoaQFkjgedm ga\Rimd cmRQ k_me o _mjmJjoP Zo]^mjgiNkk.
$gZaIRmjkm] YdaYmegY ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 135
:C> E?, ^cm_\g]ieckdiIKkP doWdcie k]\Kmgedi, Zoj;kgZodijjoXo kak oSciKmjjoXo d _oMo_
Xog\_icgedi ^ckXodoco] kak cmFmjkm] g\_i. Co jTjm _mPged\IKm]\
1
1^cm_mamjkm >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? oe 20 oZeYScY 2005 X. & 441-1 // >ojg\aQeije
CaIg.
2
1JmXod A.$. AaodicQ c\ggZoXo YWTZi. A. 666, 819.
216
WiZojo_iemaQged\ Zoj;kgZiNkmP k]\Kmgedi ^ckWjimegY ^ckj\_kemaQjom SmWdoW]mW_jom kW%Yekm k oSciKmjkm d goSgedmjjogeQ Xog\_icgedi
ji ogjodijkk oSdkjkemaQjoXo ^ckXodoci _mjmX, NmjjogemP k kjoXo
k]\Kmgedi, ^cm_\g]oecmjjoXo d R. 1 ge. 104.1 :> E?.
:XoaodjTP Zo_mZg E? ^cm_\g]ieckdime ^oaoJmjkY, goXaigjo ZoeocT] jm ]oJme STeQ Zoj;kgZodijo k]\Kmgedo, ^o_amJiKmm doWdciKmjkI WiZojjo]\ dai_maQN\, eiZ ZiZ ^ck cmFmjkk do^cogod o
Zoj;kgZiNkk d ^mcd\I oRmcm_Q ^o_amJke doW]mKmjkI \KmcS, ^ckRkjmjjTP ^cmge\^amjkm]. $W geok]ogek k]\Kmgedi, ^o_amJiKmXo Zoj;kgZiNkk, dcm_ WiZojjo]\ dai_maQN\ doW]mKimegY d eo] ga\Rim, mgak \
dkjodjoXo oeg\eged\me kjom k]\Kmgedo, ji Zoeocom ]oJme STeQ oSciKmjo dWTgZijkm (ge. 104.3 :> E?).
8 ^. 2.1 R. 1 ge. 81 :C> E? \ZiWijo, Reo _mjQXk, Nmjjogek k
kjom
k]\Kmgedo, ^oa\RmjjTm d cmW\aQeiem godmcFmjkY ^cmge\^amjkY, YdaYIegY dmKmgedmjjT]k _oZiWiemaQgedi]k. Aam_odiemaQjo, k]\Kmgedo,
^o_amJiKmm Zoj;kgZiNkk d ga\RiYM, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM ge. 104.1 :> E?,
d ^coNmggm g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\ ^mcdojiRiaQjo ^ckoScmeime geie\g dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged.
> Rkga\ do^cogod, ciWcmFim]TM g\_o] ^ck ^ogeijodamjkk ^ck-
Xodoci, d Rigejogek, oejogYegY: _oZiWijo ak, Reo k]\Kmgedo,
JiKmm Zoj;kgZiNkk
, ^oa\Rmjo d cmW\aQeiem godmcFmjkY ^cmge\^amjkY
^o_am-
kak YdaYmegY _oMo_i]k oe ,eoXo k]\Kmgedi, akSo kg^oaQWodiaogQ kak
^cm_jiWjiRiaogQ _aY kg^oaQWodijkY d ZiRmgedm oc\_kY ^cmge\^amjkY
akSo _aY ;kjijgkcodijkY emccockW]i, ocXijkWodijjoP Xc\^^T, jmWiZojjoXo dooc\JmjjoXo ;oc]kcodijkY, ^cmge\^joP ocXijkWiNkk;
ZiZ ^oge\^keQ g dmKmgedmjjT]k _oZiWiemaQgedi]k (^. 10.1, 12 R. 1
ge. 299 :C> E?).
8]mgem g em] goXaigjo ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?
amJke k]\Kmgedo, Zoeocom
STao Zoj;kgZodijo kak oSciKmjo d _oMo_
doW]mKmjkI ^o_-
Xog\_icgedi ji ogjodijkk ^ckXodoci kak cmFmjkY g\_i.
E.8. idckaIZ oe]mRime: \RkeTdiY, Reo ^ck ^cmZciKmjkk ^cokWdo_gedi ^o _ma\ ji _og\_mSjo] ,ei^m ocXijT ^cm_dickemaQjoXo
ciggam_odijkY oSYWijT cmFkeQ d ^ogeijodamjkk o ^cmZciKmjkk
\XoaodjoXo _mai k do^cog o dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQgediM (^. 9 R. 2
ge. 213 :C> E?), ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, \ZiWTdiIKkP akFQ ji
1
^ckXodoc g\_i, gam_\me eoaZodieQ cigFkckemaQjo
.
EmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY jm ^oWdoaYIe SmWoXodocoRjo ^ckjYeQ \ZiWijj\I eoRZ\ WcmjkY, eiZ ZiZ ijiakW ^cidodoP cmX-
1
idckaIZ E.8.
Ick_. ji\Z. /., 2008. A. 26.
EmiSkakeiNkY d coggkPgZo] \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm: deocm;. _kg. … Zij_.
217
ai]mjeiNkk do^cogod, ZigiIKkMgY doW]mKmjkY dcm_i g^ogoSo], ^cm_\g]oecmjjT] d ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, ^ckdo_ke Z _c\Xk] dTdo_i].
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo ^ckXodoc g\_i ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk dge\^ime d WiZojj\I gka\ ^o kgemRmjkk gcoZi oSJiaodijkY kak ^mcmg]oeci g\_o] dTFmgeoYKmP kjgeijNkk, XodockeQ o Zoj;kgZodijjo]
kak oSciKmjjo] d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi k]\Kmgedm ]oJjo
eoaQZo ^ogam
dge\^amjkY mXo d WiZojj\I gka\. 1_jiZo gam_\me k]meQ d dk_\, Reo d
_oMo_ Xog\_icgedi, d eo] Rkgam k ji _og\_mSjTM ,ei^iM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ]oJme STeQ oSciKmj WiaoX (R. 6 ge. 118 :C> E?). o
k d ^ogam_jm] ga\Rim XodockeQ oS oSciKmjkk gooedmeged\IKmXo _dkJk]oXo kak jm_dkJk]oXo k]\Kmgedi d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi, ^cido]mcjo eoaQZo ^ogam dge\^amjkY cmFmjkY g\_i d WiZojj\I gka\.
:ZiWijjTm oSgeoYemaQgedi ^cm_geidaYIegY diJjT]k _aY ^ciZekRmgZoP cmiakWiNkk ^cid WikjemcmgodijjTM \RigejkZod ^ck WiYdamjkk k]k ecmSodijkP o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^cm_\g]oecmjjoXo d ^. 2
R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?.
/o]mje dge\^amjkY ^ckXodoci d WiZojj\I gka\ gam_\me oeakRieQ
oe ]o]mjei oSciKmjkY mXo Z kg^oajmjkI, Zoeocom og\KmgedaYmegY
emRmjkm ecmM g\eoZ go _jY mXo dge\^amjkY d WiZojj\I gka\ kak doWdciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai kW g\_i i^maaYNkojjoP kjgeijNkk.
8 R. 2 ge. 393 :C> E? \ZiWijo, Reo _aY kg^oajmjkY ^ckXodoci d
Rigek k]\KmgedmjjTM dWTgZijkP d]mgem g Zo^kmP ^ckXodoci g\_mSjo]\
^ckgeid\-kg^oajkemaI ji^cidaYmegY kg^oajkemaQjTP akge. iaQjmPFiY _mYemaQjogeQ ^o oSciKmjkI k]\Kmgedi d _oMo_
Xog\_icgedi og\-
KmgedaYmegY d ci]ZiM kg^oajkemaQjoXo ^cokWdo_gedi.
jiakW g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk gdk_memaQged\me, Reo Zoj;kgZodijjom
kak oSciKmjjom d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi ji ogjodijkk ^ckXodoci kak cmFmjkY g\_i k]\Kmgedo, dZaIRiY ^ckdiekWkcodijjom JkaQm, doWdciKimegY d jie\cm em] ocXijo], d cig^ocYJmjkk ZoeocoXo ojo jiMo_kegY. Cck ,eo] Mcijmjkm, ^mcmgTaZi kak _ogeidZi k]\Kmgedi og\KmgedaYmegY Wi
gRme ,ekM ocXijod. 8 ga\Rim mgak k]\Kmgedo jm goMcijkaogQ,
STao \eciRmjo, cmiakWodijo, kg^ocRmjo, eo \^cido]oRmjjo]\ akN\
doW]mKiIe mXo geok]ogeQ, ZoeociY o^cm_maYmegY ^o Xog\_icgedmjjT]
Nmji] ji _mjQ dTjmgmjkY ^ckXodoci kak ^ogeijodamjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai
1
.
iZojo]mcjT] ^cm_geidaYmegY dTdo_ o jmoSMo_k]ogek ciWakRieQ
^o_amJiKmm doW]mKmjkI Zoj;kgZodijjom k oSciKmjjom d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi k]\Kmgedo oe k]\Kmgedi ^o g]Tga\ ge. 104.1 :> E?, ^o_am-
d
1
A^cidZi ^o cmW\aQeiei] kW\RmjkY g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk o doW]mKmjkk \KmcSi d gdYWk g
jmWiZojjT] ^ckdamRmjkm] Z \XoaodjoP oedmegedmjjogek $cZ\egZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i:
URL://http://www.sudrf.ru
218
JiKmXo Zoj;kgZiNkk, jo _o dge\^amjkY ^ckXodoci (cmFmjkY) g\_i d
WiZojj\I gka\ ^cmSTdiIKmXo d geie\gm dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged.
8 R. 3 ge. 81 :C> E? ^cm_\g]oecmjT ^cidkai cmFmjkY do^cogod
o dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQgediM ^ck dTjmgmjkk ^ckXodoci, i eiZJm
o^cm_mamjkY kak ^ogeijodamjkY o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai, d
eo] Rkgam k ji ,ei^m ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY.
8 eiZoP gke\iNkk g\_\, dTjmgFm]\ dge\^kdFkP d WiZojj\I gka\
o^cid_iemaQjTP ^ckXodoc, i eiZJm ocXiji] ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY jmoSMo_k]o cmFkeQ g\_QS\ k]mIKkMgY d _mam dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged, ^o_^i_iIKkM ^o_ ^ckWjiZk, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTm
R. 1 ge. 104.1 :> E?.
AoXaigjo ^. 4 R. 3 ge. 81 :C> E?, _mjQXk, Nmjjogek k kjom k]\Kmgedo, ^oa\RmjjTm d cmW\aQeiem godmcFmjkY ^cmge\^amjkY, k _oMo_T
oe ,eoXo k]\Kmgedi,
^o_amJie doWdciKmjkI WiZojjo]\ dai_maQN\.
Aam_\me o^cm_makeQgY, k_me ak d eiZkM ga\RiYM cmRQ eoaQZo o goSaI_mjkk ^cm_\g]oecmjjoP \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjT] WiZojo] ^coNm_\cm doWdciKmjkY dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged kak Jm eiZk] oSciWo] ;iZekRmgZk cmFiIegY do^cogT o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo
dcm_i kjemcmg\IKmP jig ZiemXockk \^cido]oRmjjTM akN.
Cck ,eo] jmaQWY oSoPek ]oaRijkm] eoe ;iZe, Reo mgak
^ck_mcJkdieQgY ^oWkNkk o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i ^\em] doWdciei
dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged ^ogam ^cmZciKmjkY \XoaodjoXo _mai ji
,ei^m ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY, eo eoX_i jmoSMo_k]o XodockeQ
o g\Kmgedodijkk
k]\KmgedmjjTP dcm_ doW]mKimegY ^o
kgZaIRmjkY
kW oSKmXo ^cidkai, goXaigjo Zoeoco]\
g\_mSjo]\ cmFmjkI
.
>co]m eoXo, ^oaoJmjkY R. 3 ge. 81 :C> E? jogYe k]^mciekdjTP
MiciZemc. 8mKmgedmjjTm _oZiWiemaQgedi ^o_amJie doWdcie\ jmWidkgk]o oe doamkW%YdamjkY akNi djm ^cm_\g]oecmjjoP Xa. 18 :C> E? ^coNm_\cT, oS\gaodamjjoP cmiakWiNkmP ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i.
eo ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo ^ck ^oajo] doWdciem kW%YeoXo k]\Kmgedi jm _oaJjT doWjkZieQ do^cogT, gdYWijjTm g jmoSMo_k]ogeQI
mXo
doW]mKmjkY, i doWdcie dmKmgedmjjTM _oZiWiemaQged ^o g\ek _mai
oeoJ_mgedaYmegY g mXo doW]mKmjkm].
1_jiZo jkZeo jm Xicijekc\me, Reo kW%YeTm _mjQXk, Nmjjogek, kjom
k]\Kmgedo jm ]oJme STeQ \eciRmjo, \jkReoJmjo kak kg^ocRmjo, Reo
^ckdm_me Z jmoSMo_k]ogek Zo]^mjgiNkk ^ckRkjmjjoXo dcm_i d oSKm]
^ocY_Zm Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk.
CoaiXim], Reo _aY ^o_oSjTM gke\iNkP jmoSMo_k]o ^cm_\g]oecmeQ d
WiZojm ]mMijkW]T WiKkeT k]\KmgedmjjTM ^cid kggam_\m]oP
ji]k ZiemXockk akN.
Aam_odiemaQjo, doW]mKmjkm k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i dZaIRime jm
eoaQZo doW]mKmjkm k]\Kmgedi, Zoj;kgZodijjoXo ^o ^ckXodoc\ g\_i,
219
jo k ^o_amJiKmXo Zoj;kgZiNkk ^o dmcgkk gam_gedkY (_o cmFmjkY do^cogi o ^cmZciKmjkk \XoaodjoXo _mai), ^ckWjijjoXo dmKmgedmjjT]k
_oZiWiemaQgedi]k, jo jm doWdciKmjjoXo WiZojjo]\ dai_maQN\ d gka\
o^cm_mamjjTM ^ckRkj.
$WaoJmjjTm oSgeoYemaQgedi jm jiFak gdomXo oeciJmjkY d \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjo] WiZojm. eo ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\ o jmoSMo_k]ogek g;oc]\akcodieQ ^cm_aoJmjkm o djmgmjkk gooedmeged\IKkM kW]m-
d go_mcJijkm ^. 2 R. 1 ge. 135 :C> E?, kWaoJkd mXo d gam_\IKmP
jmjkP
cm_iZNkk:
«Zoj;kgZodijjoXo k oSciKmjjoXo d _oMo_ Xog\_icgedi ji
ogjodijkk ^ckXodoci kak cmFmjkY g\_i, i cidjo \eciRmjjoXo ^o_amJiKmXo doWdcie\, kW%YeoXo ocXiji]k ^cm_dickemaQjoXo ciggam_odijkY k]\Kmgedi akNi».
:Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP Zo_mZg Emg^\SakZk :WSmZkgeij, ji^ck]mc, go_mcJke ^oaoJmjkY, goXaigjo ZoeocT] doW]mKmjkI ^o_amJke
geok]ogeQ k]\Kmgedi, kW%YeoXo ocXiji]k _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY kak g\_o] k \eciRmjjoXo k]k (^. 4 R. 1 ge. 304 :C> Emg^\SakZk :WSmZkgeij).
EmW\aQeieT ijiakWi ^ciZekZk ^ck]mjmjkY ^oaoJmjkP, go_mcJiKkMgY d ge. 135 :C> E?, gdk_memaQged\Ie o g\Kmgedodijkk jmo_joWjiRjTM ^o_Mo_od k
^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk g\]],
dT^aiRmjjTM akNo] Wi oZiWijkm Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk (^. 4 R. 1
ge. 135 :C> E?).
CoZiWiemaQjo d ,eoP Rigek, Reo d Mo_m oSoSKmjkY g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk Wi ^mcko_ 2007—2009 XX. ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo g
\XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm], d 22 g\_iM cMijXmaQgZoP oSaigek \geijodamjo, Reo ogjodjT] dk_o] k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, doW]mKmjjoXo
cmiSkakekcodijjT], YdaYaigQ
1
Ick_kRmgZoP ^o]oKk
. Co_oSjiY gke\iNkY MiciZemcji, ji^ck]mc,
k _aY g\_od maYSkjgZoP oSaigek
Zo]^mjgiNkY cigMo_od Wi oZiWijkm
2
.
A\_T Zo]^mjgkc\Ie cigMo_T, dT^aiRmjjTm jm eoaQZo ^o goXaiFmjkI ^co;mggkojiaQjT] i_doZiei], oZiWTdiIKk] Ick_kRmgZ\I ^o]oKQ d gooedmegedkk g ? «1S i_doZiegZoP _mYemaQjogek k i_doZie\cm
3
d EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk»
, jo k ^o _oXodoc\ kjT] akNi], _o^\Kmj-
jT] ^o cmFmjkI g\_i d ZiRmgedm WiKkejkZod d gooedmegedkk g ^oao-
4
JmjkY]k R. 2 ge. 49 :C> E?
.
1
A^cidZi ^o cmW\aQeiei] oSoSKmjkY g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm] (cmiSkakeiNkY) d 2007—2009 XX. cMijXmaQgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i: URL://http://www.arhcourt.ru
2
A^cidZi ^o cmW\aQeiei] oSoSKmjkY ^ciZekZk ^ck]mjmjkY g\_i]k maYSkjgZoP oSaigek
\Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi o cmiSkakeiNkk (Xa. 18 :C> E?) Wi ^mcko_
g 2009 X. ^o 1-m ^oa\Xo_km 2010 X.
3
? oe 31 ]iY 2002 X. & 63-? (d cm_. oe 28 oZeYScY 2003 X.): URL://http://www.consultant.ru
4
Cogeijodamjkm >ocYJm]gZoXo Xoco_gZoXo g\_i. mao & 4/17-1/2010.
220
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]