Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Концепция реабилитации и организационно-правовые механизмы ее реализации в российском уголовном процессе. Монография
.pdf
8 ^ojYekm, geoYKmm Wi _ijjT] emc]kjo], d Widkgk]ogek oe ji^cid-
amjkY ;\jZNkojkcodijkY k g^mNk;kZk oSciW\IKkM ,am]mjeod \RmjTm
dZai_TdiIe ciWakRjom go_mcJijkm. i^ck]mc, ]mMijkW] ^cidodoXo
cmX\akcodijkY, X\]ijkeicjTP ^cidoWiKkejTP ]mMijkW], goNkiaQjoIck_kRmgZkP ]mMijkW] oSmg^mRmjkY ^cid RmaodmZi k XciJ_ijkji, ]mMijkW] Xog\_icgedmjjoP WiKkeT \RigejkZod \XoaodjoXo ^coNmggi ji
^cm_dickemaQjo] gam_gedkk
1
.
8 oSKm] ^aijm d ZiJ_o] ga\Rim cmRQ k_me o g\Kmgedodijkk jmZoP
gkgem]T, dZaIRiIKmP d gmSY d ciWakRjTM goRmeijkYM godoZ\^jogeQ
dWik]ogdYWijjTM gec\Ze\cjTM ,am]mjeod, oS\gaodakdiIKkM cmiaQjo
_mPged\IKkP k Smg^cm^YegedmjjTP ^coNmgg mm ;\jZNkojkcodijkY
2
.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, ^o ]jmjkI \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod ]mMijkW]
doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ dZaIRime d
gmSY ogjodijkY k \gaodkY doWjkZjodmjkY ^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i
k ^ocY_oZ mXo doW]mKmjkY
3
.
Cck]mjkemaQjo Z kggam_\m]o]\ ^cidodo]\ kjgeke\e\ jiakRkm go-
doZ\^jogek ^cm_^kgijkP, i_cmgodijjTM em] kak kjT] ji_mamjjT]
o^cm_mamjjoP Zo]^memjNkmP ocXiji] k _oaJjogejT] akNi], jm oWjiRime, Reo Xog\_icgedmjjTm oSYWiemaQgedi ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i \^cido]oRmjjT] g\S%mZei] ideo]iekRmgZk ^cmedocYIegY d JkWjQ.
Co_ ]mMijkW]o] cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ]oJjo
^ojk]ieQ ji_amJiKm ocXijkWodijjom k ^aijo]mcjo ;\jZNkojkc\IKmm \gecoPgedo
gkgem]T dWik]ogdYWijjTM ,am]mjeod, dZaIRiIKmP d
gmSY godoZ\^jogeQ jmo_joco_jTM ^o gdomP Ick_kRmgZoP ^ckco_m
joc]iekdjo-^cidodTM ^cm_^kgijkP, ji^cidamjjTM ji doW]mKmjkm
k]\KmgedmjjoXo k Zo]^mjgiNkI ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, doggeijodamjkm
kjTM, jic\FmjjTM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^cid; og\KmgedaYm]Tm ji kM ogjodm _mPgedkY k ^ckjk]im]Tm d Mo_m kM cmiakWiNkk cmFmjkY, ZiZ Ick_kRmgZk WjiRk]Tm cmW\aQeieT cmiakWiNkk
^cidooejoFmjkP, doWjkZiIKkM ]mJ_\
gooedmeged\IKk]k \RigejkZi]k ^ck og\Kmgedamjkk ^cm_ogeidamjjTM k] ^cid k kg^oajmjkk doWaoJmjjTM ji jkM oSYWijjogemP.
1
amZgmmd A.A.
Aeie\e, 1999. A. 364;
Skm. /.: >/1A, 2003. A. 139;
Nkojjo-^cidodoXo kggam_odijkY: kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. /., 2002. A. 162;
"mocmekRmgZkm k ^cidodTm ogjodT Xog\_icgedmjjoP WiKkeT \RigejkZod \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi d EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk: kg. … _oZe. Ick_. ji\Z. /., 2007. A. 280—294.
2
iWod . .
/.: iZoj k ^cido, 2010. A. 177.
3
k]kRmdi 1.8., iJijod .8.
$]\KmgedmjjTP dcm_, ^o_amJiKkP doW]mKmjkI: :RmS. ^ogoSkm. /.: $"$- :
iZoj k ^cido, 2012. A. 76—104.
Ccido: iWS\Zi, emockY, ;kaogo;kY. 1^Te Zo]^amZgjoXo kggam_odijkY. /.:
>i^kNTj 8./.
>ojgeke\NkojjTm Xicijekk ^cid k gdoSo_ RmaodmZi k XciJ_ijkji d Eoggkk.
Ccidi RmaodmZi k ]mMijkW]T kM WiKkeT: \RmSjom ^ogo-
8aiWjmd 8.8.
CcoSam]i cmiSkakeiNkk d \Xoaodjo] g\_o^cokWdo_gedm.
ciJ_ijgZom oSKmgedo ZiZ ^cm_]me Zojgeke\-
iPNmd 1..
201
8WXaY_ ji ]mMijkW] cmiakWiNkk kggam_\m]oXo ^cidodoXo kjgeke\ei
ZiZ ji \^ocY_oRmjj\I godoZ\^jogeQ dWik]ogdYWijjTM ,am]mjeod, ^oWdoaYme ^cm_^oaoJkeQ, Reo mXo ,;;mZekdjom _mPgedkm o^cm_maYIe:
^cm_\g]oecmjjom >ojgeke\NkmP E?, gooedmeged\IKk]k WiZo-
ji]k k dm_o]gedmjjT]k joc]iekdjT]k ^cidodT]k iZei]k goXai-
godijjom ;\jZNkojkcodijkm \^cido]oRmjjTM k ^cidooSYWijjTM
g\S%mZeod ^o cmiakWiNkk d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i gooedme-
gedmjjo ^cm_ogeidamjjTM ^cid k doWaoJmjjTM oSYWijjogemP;
\jk;kNkcodijjTm joc]iekdjTm ^cm_^kgijkY, ^oWdoaYIKkm
m_kjooSciWjo k gdomdcm]mjjo og\KmgedaYeQ ^cidod\I ^coNm_\c\
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk;
ji_amJiKiY iZekdjogeQ gi]kM ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ji^cidamjjiY ji cmiakWiNkI ^cm_ogeidamj-
jTM k] ^cid.
8 gdYWk g ,ek] ]mMijkW] cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^cm_geidaYmegY ZiZ gaoJjTP k ]joXogeocojjkP, dZaIRiIKkP d gmSY jm eoaQZo Ick_kRmgZ\I1, jo k ocXijkWiNkojj\I
gogeidaYIK\I, Reo ^oWdoaYme cigg]ieckdieQ mXo ZiZ ocXijkWiNkojjo^cidodoP.
CoZiWiemaQjo, Reo d ji\RjTM kggam_odijkYM, gdYWijjTM g ^coSam]i]k cmiSkakeiNkk, ocXijkWiNkojj\I _mYemaQjogeQ ^cidooMcijkemaQjTM
k g\_mSjTM ocXijod, ji^cidamjj\I ji doggeijodamjkm ^cid k gdoSo_
akNi, doW]mKmjkm ^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\ k]\KmgedmjjoXo k Zo]^mjgiNkI
]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, dT_maYIe jicY_\ g ^coNmgg\iaQjoP _mYemaQjogeQI2.
oemaogQ ST ^o_RmcZj\eQ, Reo ^ck ;oc]kcodijkk ZojNm^Nkk cmiSkakeiNkk k ocXijkWiNkojjo-^cidodTM ]mMijkW]od mm cmiakWiNkk d
coggkPgZo] \Xoaodjo] ^coNmggm ]T jm Zigim]gY do^cogod ocXijkWiNkk _mYemaQjogek ^cidooMcijkemaQjTM k g\_mSjTM ocXijod g ^oWkNkk
kM ;\jZNkojkcodijkY d ci]ZiM oSKmP Zo]^memjNkk, i kggam_\m] d
kmcicMkRmgZoP ^ogam_odiemaQjogek godoZ\^jogeQ i_cmgodijjTM k]
joc]iekdjo-^cidodTM iZeod g ^oWkNkk cmX\aYekdjoP ;\jZNkk k ocXijkW\IKmP coak ^ogam_jkM d ^cidooejoFmjkYM d g;mcm cmiSkakeiNkk k doW]mKmjkY dcm_i.
1^cm_maYIKk] ;iZeoco] ji_amJiKmXo ;\jZNkojkcodijkY kggam_\m]oXo ]mMijkW]i YdaYmegY jiakRkm Ick_kRmgZkM XicijekP,
oSmg^mRkdiIKkM doW]oJjogeQ Smg^cm^YegedmjjoP k gdomdcm]mjjoP
1
Cck ,eo] jmoSMo_k]o \RkeTdieQ ocXijkW\IK\I coaQ ^cidodTM joc].
2
ia\]odi ..
Xijod ^o cmiSkakeiNkk: deocm;. _kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. ZiemckjS\cX, 2007. A. 8.
CcoSam]T ocXijkWiNkk ciSoeT ^cidooMcijkemaQjTM k g\_mSjTM oc-
202
cmiakWiNkk WikjemcmgodijjT]k akNi]k ^cm_ogeidamjjoXo WiZojo]
^cidi ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i.
:SmJ_mjjogeQ cmiSkakekcodijjoXo kak kjoXo akNi, Wi ZoeocT]
^ckWjijo ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i, d eo], Reo d ga\Rim WiYdamjjoXo
ecmSodijkY mXo ^oecmSjogek S\_\e \_odamedocmjT gdomdcm]mjjo k d
ji_amJiKm] oS%m]m, i kjkNkkcodijkm ^coNm_\cT doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
jm ^cmdciekegY d \jkWkemaQjTm k _akemaQjTm «MoJ_mjkY» ^o kjgeijNkY], d
ZiJ_o] ZojZcmejo] ga\Rim o^cm_maYmegY godoZ\^jogeQI oS%mZekdjTM k g\S%mZekdjTM ;iZeocod. m]iaodiJjiY coaQ W_mgQ oedo_kegY k g;oc]kcodidFm]\gY d oSKmgedmjjo] goWjijkk ]jmjkI oS
,;;mZekdjogek ;\jZNkojkcodijkY ^cm_geidamjjoXo d :C> E? kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk.
jiakW joc]iekdjo-^cidodoP ogjodT ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\ o g\Kmgedodijkk ecmS\IKkM ciWcmFmjkY ^coSam], oS\gaodamjjTM
kM jmgodmcFmjgedo] k jmgoXaigodijjogeQI. :ZiWijjom oSgeoYemaQgedo YdaYmegY ^cm_]meo] oSg\J_mjkY ji gecijkNiM Ick_kRmgZoP ^mRiek, dm_me Z Wiec\_jmjkY] ^ciZekRmgZoXo gdoPgedi, dTciJiIKk]gY d ciWakRjo] ^ojk]ijkk ^cido^ck]mjkemaY]k go_mcJijkY i_cmgodijjTM k] ^cidodTM joc] k ^ogam_odiemaQjogek kM cmiakWiNkk. eo, d gdoI oRmcm_Q, oeciJimegY ji MiciZemcm ^ckjk]im]TM cmFmjkP, k, ZiZ gam_gedkm, ji
doW]oJjogek gdomdcm-
]mjjoP cmiakWiNkk ^cid XciJ_ij, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i.
8WYeTm Xog\_icgedo] oSYWiemaQgedi ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ^cm_^oaiXiIe jmoSMo_k]ogeQ dT_mamjkY gcm_ged kW ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk, d gdYWk
g Rm], jm_ogeieoRjiY ,;;mZekdjogeQ ocXijkWiNkojjo-^cidodoXo ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i ji^cY]\I WieciXkdime mXo kjemcmgT.
$W\Rmjkm
g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk gdk_memaQged\me, Reo _akemaQjom jmkg^oajmjkm g\_mSjTM cmFmjkP (jmWidkgk]o oe ^ckRkjT) ^ckdo_ke Z
jmoSMo_k]ogek _o^oajkemaQjTM dT^aie, gdYWijjTM g kj_mZgiNkmP
g\]], ^mcdojiRiaQjo dWTgZijjTM g /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod d gRme
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o-
1
^cokWdo_gedi
.
c\XiY geocoji ^coSam]T jcidgedmjjoXo gdoPgedi WiZaIRimegY
d _akemaQjTM k WiRige\I jmo^cid_ijjTM g\_mSjTM eYJSiM, jm ^oWdo-
1
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
E? oe 30 joYScY 2006 X. & 44-106-129; Cogeijodamjkm >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? ^o
_ma\ o ^codmcZm Zojgeke\Nkojjogek ^oaoJmjkP ge. 242.1 I_JmejoXo Zo_mZgi E? d gdYWk
g JiaoSoP :^oajo]oRmjjoXo ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi d EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk oe 2 ]icei
2010 X. & 5-C / icije.
203
aYIKkM ^ogeci_idFk] XciJ_iji] d ZocoeZkm gcoZk cmiakWodieQ
^cm_ogeidamjjom k] ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm dcm_i.
EmW\aQeieT ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY ^oWdoaYIe XodockeQ o
eo], Reo d ogjod\ ]mMijkW]i cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
ji WiZojo_iemaQjo] \codjm WiaoJmj cY_ ^oaoJmjkP, go_mcJijkm ZoeocTM d Nmao] o^cm_maYme ji^cidamjkm _mYemaQjogek g^mNkiaQjo
\^oajo]oRmjjTM Xog\_icgedo] ocXijod k _oaJjogejTM akN.
_mgQ gam_\me dg^o]jkeQ, Reo
d gooedmegedkk g ^. 1 ge. 1070 > E?
dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP XciJ_ijkj\, doW]mKimegY Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP
?m_mciNkk, i d ga\RiYM, ^cm_\g]oecmjjTM WiZojo], Wi gRme ZiWjT g\S%mZei EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk kak ZiWjT ]\jkNk^iaQjoXo oSciWodijkY.
Cck ,eo] ^cm_geidkemaY]k oedmeRkZi ^o kgZi] o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i,
^ckRkjmjjoXo ;kWkRmgZo]\ akN\ d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjTM _mPgedkP Xog\_icgedmjjTM ocXijod
kak _oaJjogejTM akN ,ekM ocXijod, d eo]
Rkgam k ^ck jmWiZojjo] \Xoaodjo] ^cmgam_odijkk, ^o dm_o]gedmjjoP
^ckji_amJjogek ^ckdamZimegY aidjTP cig^ocY_kemaQ gcm_ged akSo
;m_mciaQjoXo SI_Jmei, akSo SI_Jmei g\S%mZei EoggkPgZoP ?m_mci-
1
Nkk, akSo SI_Jmei ]\jkNk^iaQjoXo oSciWodijkY
.
1_jiZo ^ciZekZi ^ck]mjmjkY \ZiWijjTM joc], em] jm ]mjmm, _m]ojgeckc\me jmo^cm_mamjjogeQ d do^cogm o eo], ZiZoP ocXij jmgme oedmegedmjjogeQ ^o oSYWiemaQgedi], gdYWijjT] g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i
akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi. "iZ, ji^ck]mc, CcmWk_k\] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? ^ckFma Z dTdo_\ o eo], Reo
g\_ oFkSoRjo doWaoJka oSYWijjogeQ ^o doW]mKmjkk
dcm_i ji emcckeockiaQjTP ocXij ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi, ZoeocoP ^o _odmcmjjogek akFQ ^cm_geidaYme kjemcmgT /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E?, ;iZ-
2
ekRmgZk kg^oajYIKmXo g\_mSjTm iZeT ^o kgZi] Z Eoggkk
.
1
?m_mciaQjTP WiZoj oe 27 _mZiScY 2005 X. & 197-? «1 djmgmjkk kW]mjmjkP d I_JmejTP
Zo_mZg E?, ciJ_ijgZo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP Zo_mZg E?, cSkeciJjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP Zo_mZg
E? k ?m_mciaQjTP WiZoj «1S kg^oajkemaQjo] ^cokWdo_gedm» / >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
2
A\_mSjiY >oaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo g\_i E? ogeidkai SmW kW]mjmjkY ^ogeijodamjkm g\_Qk Aeidco^oaQgZoXo ZcimdoXo g\_i o dWTgZijkk Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP
?m_mciNkk _mjmJjTM gcm_ged d ^oaQW\ cmiSkakekcodijjoXo C. g :^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo
ZiWjiRmPgedi ^o Aeidco^oaQgZo]\ ZciI. 8 ji_WocjoP JiaoSm :^cidamjkm ?m_mciaQjoXo
ZiWjiRmPgedi ^o Aeidco^oaQgZo]\ ZciI ^cogkao oe]mjkeQ g\_mSjom cmFmjkm, icX\]mjekc\Y em], Reo ocXijT ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi jm d^cidm dTge\^ieQ oe k]mjk ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ^ck doW]mKmjkk dcm_i Wi mm gRme. CcmWk_k\] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E?
12 gmjeYScY 2007 X. kW]mjka g\_mSjTm cmFmjkY, oe]mekd, Reo, ogjodTdiYgQ ji ge. 1070 >
E?, g\_ ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk ^cidkaQjo o^cm_maka >iWj\ EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ZiZ kgeoRjkZ
gcm_ged doW]mKmjkY dcm_i. 1_jiZo goXaigjo ^oaoJmjkY] ge. 1071 > E? d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i
dcm_ ^o_amJke doW]mKmjkI Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk, oe mm k]mjk dTge\^iIe
ji_amJiKkm ;kjijgodTm ocXijT, mgak d gooedmegedkk g ^. 3 ge. 125 > E? ,ei oSYWijjogeQ
jm doWaoJmji ji _c\XoP ocXij, Ick_kRmgZom akNo kak XciJ_ijkji. A].: Cogeijodamjkm CcmWk_k\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 12 gmjeYScY 2007 X. & 287-C07 / icije.
204
1_jiZo jmoSMo_k]o Wi]mekeQ, Reo jmWidkgk]o oe ^ckRkj, d ^ckdm_mjjo] ^ck]mcm cmiSkakekcodijjTP XciJ_ijkj C. d emRmjkm _d\M
ame jm ]oX jm eoaQZo ^oa\RkeQ ^ckRkeidFkmgY m]\ _mjQXk, jo _iJm
o^cm_makeQgY d do^cogm, ZiZoP ocXij oSYWij doW]mgekeQ ^ckRkjmjjTP dcm_.
Cck ,eo] jmoSMo_k]o \RkeTdieQ, Reo g\]]i, ^o_amJiKiY cmiaQjoP dT^aiem, jm _oaJji kgRkgaYeQgY d
ciW]mcm, \geijodamjjo]
jmgZoaQZo ame jiWi_ g\_o] ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk ddk_\ jmoSMo_k]ogek
mm kj_mZgiNkk g \Rmeo] \codjY kj;aYNkk (R. 4 ge. 135 :C> E?), i
eiZJm _o^oajkemaQjTM dT^aie, gdYWijjTM g Zo]^mjgiNkmP Wiecie
ji \Rigekm i_doZiei d g\_iM i^maaYNkojjoP, ZiggiNkojjoP k ji_WocjoP kjgeijNkP.
>cigjocmRkdo gdk_memaQged\Ie o _akemaQjom dcm]Y g\Kmged\IKmP
^coSam]m k gke\iNkY, _m]ojgeckc\IKiY, Reo ^ogeci_idFkP d emRmjkm
ecmM ame \geijidakdia d g\_mSjo] ^ocY_Zm ji_amJiKmXo g\S%mZei kg^oajmjkY oSYWiemaQged, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] ^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\
1
.
dcm_i
CoZiWiemamj, ji jiF dWXaY_ k ga\RiP, ZoX_i ^cm_geidkemaQ :^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi oSJiaodia cmFmjkm g\_i o dWTgZijkk g /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? dT^aie d gRme doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i o^cid_ijjo]\ >. ji eo] ogjodijkk, Reo ji_amJiKk]
oedmeRkZo] gam_\me ^ckWjieQ _c\XoXo XaidjoXo cig^ocY_kemaY
gcm_ged — mjmciaQj\I ^coZ\cie\c\ E?. Aam_\me Wi]mekeQ, Reo \ZiWijjom
k ji XciJ_ijgZom WiZojo_iemaQgedo k ji I_JmejTP Zo_mZg E?
_oaJjogejom akNo ggTaiaogQ d oSogjodijkm gdokM ecmSodijkP
2
.
8Tdo_T, g_maijjTm d Mo_m ^codm_mjjoXo kggam_odijkY, ^o_Zcm^aYIegY k cmW\aQeiei]k ijiakWi g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk ji ,ei^m mm ;oc-
1
"iZ, g\_QmP /ogZodgZoXo oSaigejoXo g\_i 19 ;mdciaY 2004 X. \_odamedocmjo ecmSodijkm
cmiSkakekcodijjoXo . o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm], k ^ogeijodamjo dWTgZieQ g /kjkgemcgedi ?kjijgod /ogZodgZoP oSaigek Wi
gRme ;m_mciaQjoXo SI_Jmei 265 460 c\S. A\_mSjiY ZoaamXkY ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? 21 i^cmaY 2004 X. kW]mjkai ^ogeijodamjkm, doWaoJkd oSYWijjogeQ ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i ji \^cidamjkm ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? ^o
/ogZodgZoP oSaigek. 8 ji_WocjoP JiaoSm o^cid_ijjTP . ^cogka ^mcmg]oecmeQ g\_mSjTm
cmFmjkY, eiZ ZiZ dgam_gedkm jm^cidkaQjoXo o^cm_mamjkY g\_o] ji_amJiKmXo oedmeRkZi,
oSai_iIKmXo ^oajo]oRkY]k ^cm_geidaYeQ kjemcmgT ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk, oj
akFmj doW]oJjogek cmiakWodieQ ^cido ji doW]mKmjkm ^ckRkjmjjoXo m]\ dcm_i, gdYWijjoXo
g \XoaodjT] ^cmgam_odijkm]. CcmWk_k\] 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? 21
g\_mSjTm cmFmjkY d oejoFmjkk ., ^mcm_ia _mao d g\_ ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk ji jodom g\_mSjom
cigg]oecmjkm d ^ocY_Zm, \geijodamjjo] ge. 399 :C> E?. Cogeijodamjkm CcmWk_k\]i 8mcModjoXo A\_i E? oe 21 joYScY 2007 X. & 463-C07 / icije.
2
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP ZoaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
E? oe 13 ;mdciaY 2007 X. mao & 89-o07-2.
205
joYScY 2007 X. oe]mjka
]kcodijkY ciPojjT]k g\_i]k, cmFmjkY ZoeocTM mKm jm ^o^iak d
1
^oam WcmjkY dTFmgeoYKkM g\_mSjTM kjgeijNkP
.
/joXooSciWkm ^cidodTM ^cm_^kgijkP, amJiKkM d ogjodm cmFmjkY geoaQ ogecTM ZiZ _aY \^cido]oRmjjTM, eiZ k _aY ^cidooSYWijjTM
g\S%mZeod ^coSam], _kZe\me jmoSMo_k]ogeQ ZojZcmekWiNkk ji_amJiKmXo ocXiji, oSYWijjoXo oe k]mjk Xog\_icgedi oedmRieQ ji ecmSodijkY o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i ^ogeci_idFk] oe _mPgedkP _oaJjogejTM akN
d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi k oS\gaodamjjTP ,ek] m_kjTP
2
iaXocke] _mPgedkP
.
/kjkgemcgedo] ;kjijgod E? k ?m_mciaQjT] ZiWjiRmPgedo]
^cm_^ckjYei ^o^TeZi \cmX\akcodieQ k \^ocY_oRkeQ doWjkZiIKkm ji
3
^ciZekZm do^cogT ^\em] kW_ijkY god]mgejTM ^ckZiWod
.
1_jiZo d _ijjo] ga\Rim cmRQ k_me o dm_o]gedmjjTM joc]iekdjTM ^cidodTM iZeiM, ^ckWdijjTM \^ocY_oRkeQ ^coNm_\c\ \Rmei k
cmiakWiNkk gooedmeged\IKkM _mPgedkP ocXiji]k k _oaJjogejT]k
akNi]k, ^cm_geidaYIKk]k kjemcmgT /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod k CcidkemaQgedi E?.
>iZ ^oZiWTdime ^ciZekZi, kjemcmgT dm_o]ged ]oX\e ^coekdocmRkeQ _c\X _c\X\, ZiZ, ji^ck]mc, d ^ckdm_mjjo] ^ck]mcm, ZoX_i d ciW-
1
8 2008 X. ^ckXodoco] :geQ-JmX\ekjgZoXo ciPojjoXo g\_i >iciRimdo-mcZmggZoP cmg^\SakZk XciJ_ijkj . STa o^cid_ij d ^cm_%Ydamjjo] m]\ oSdkjmjkk k oSciekagY d g\_
g kgZo] Z /kjkgemcged\ ;kjijgod E? o doW]mKmjkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo
m]\ d cmW\aQeiem \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY k dWTgZijkk g\_mSjTM cigMo_od ji o^aie\
\ga\X ^cm_geidkemaY. 8 2009 X. ^o mXo WiYdamjkI STao cigg]oecmjo XciJ_ijgZom _mao,
X_m d ZiRmgedm ^cm_geidkemaY oedmeRkZi — /kjkgemcgedi ?kjijgod E?, ^o _odmcmjjogek
dTge\^ia ^cm_geidkemaQ :^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi ^o >iciRimdo-mcZmggZoP cmg^\SakZm, ZoeocTP kgZodTm ecmSodijkY cmiSkakekcodijjoXo . jm ^ckWjia, \ZiWid ji eo, Reo dcm_, ^ckRkjmjjTP jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod ^cm_dickemaQjoXo
gam_gedkY jm doW]mKimegY /kjkgemcgedo] ;kjijgod E? k ji_amJiKk] oedmeRkZo]
_oaJjo STeQ /kjkgemcgedo dj\ecmjjkM _ma >iciRimdo-mcZmggZoP cmg^\SakZk / Cogeijodamjkm :geQ-JmX\ekjgZoXo ciPojjoXo g\_i >E. mao & 2-148/2009 X.
2
8 ,eo] g]Tgam ^oZiWiemaQji ^oWkNkY dco^mPgZoXo A\_i ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi goXaigjo
ZoeocoP \geijodamjkm Xog\_icgedmjjoXo ocXiji, dTge\^iIKmXo d ZiRmgedm oedmeRkZi ^o
Xog\_icgedmjjT] oSYWiemaQgedi] k oedmegedmjjoXo Wi kg^oajmjkm g\_mSjoXo cmFmjkY,
g^ogoSged\me WiKkem ^cid WiYdkemaY d Rigek kM gdomdcm]mjjoP k ^oajoP cmiakWiNkk.
A].: Cogeijodamjkm dco^mPgZoXo A\_i ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi oe 12 kIjY 2008 X. ^o JiaoSm
& 42940/02 « i_mJZkj ^coekd EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk» // IaamemjQ dco^mPgZoXo A\_i
^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi. 2009. & 4.
3
Aod]mgejTP ^ckZiW /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? k ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi oe 25 idX\gei 2006 X. & 114j k 9j (d cm_. ^ckZiWi /kj;kji E? & 133j, >iWjiRmPgedi E? &9j oe
24 joYScY 2008 X.) «1 ^ocY_Zm ocXijkWiNkk k dm_mjkY ciSoeT ^o ^cm_geidamjkI d g\_mSjTM
ocXijiM kjemcmgod /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk k kjemcmgod CcidkemaQgedi EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk d ga\RiYM, ZoX_i kM ^cm_geidamjkm ^oc\Rmjo /kjkgemcged\ ;kjijgod EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk»; CckZiW ]kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? oe 15 idX\gei 2006 X.
& 271 «1S \edmcJ_mjkk ^ocY_Zi ocXijkWiNkk ciSoeT d /kjkgemcgedm ;kjijgod EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ^o kg^oajmjkk g\_mSjTM iZeod o dWTgZijkk _mjmJjTM gcm_ged ^o kgZi] Z
EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk d gooedmegedkk g SI_JmejT] Zo_mZgo] EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk».
206
cmFmjkk do^cogi o ji_amJiKm] oedmeRkZm STak Wiecoj\eT k kjemcmgT mjmciaQjoP ^coZ\cie\cT E?.
8]mgem g em], ^o_oSjTm gke\iNkk, jm^ogcm_gedmjjo WieciXkdiIKkm ^cidi akN, ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi,
WieYXkdiIKkm ^coNm_\c\ doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, jm^ogcm_gedmjjo ZigiIegY jcidgedmjjTM ig^mZeod cmiSkakeiNkk, ^o_cTdiIe ogjodT XicijekcodijjoP Xog\_icgedo] WiKkeT ^cid WikjemcmgodijjTM akN,
;oc]kc\Ie jm_odmckm oSKmgedi Z
doW]oJjogek dT^oajmjkY gooedme-
ged\IKkM Xog\_icgedmjjTM oSYWiemaQged.
EiW%YgjYY ^ocY_oZ ciWcmFmjkY g\Kmged\IKkM ^coSam], Camj\]
8mcModjoXo A\_i E? d gdom] ^ogeijodamjkk oe 29 joYScY 2011 X. & 17
\ZiWTdime, Reo Z \RigekI d _maiM ^o ecmSodijkI cmiSkakekcodijjTM
o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i d ZiRmgedm oedmeRkZi oe k]mjk
ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk ^ckdamZimegY /kjkgemcgedo ;kjijgod
E? d akNm gooedmeged\IKkM ocXijod (^. 14
^ogeijodamjkY)1.
Cckjk]iY do djk]ijkm, Reo g\eQ ^coSam]T WiZaIRimegY jm d eo],
Reo ji_amJiKkP oedmeRkZ ^ck cmFmjkk do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i
^ogeci_idFk] d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi jm o^cm_mamj, i
d eo], Reo k]mIKiYgY godoZ\^jogeQ ^cidodTM ^cm_^kgijkP jm dgmX_i
k jm dgmM \RigejkZod kjemcmg\IKkM jig ^cidooejoFmjkP ^ckdo_ke
Z o_joWjiRjo]\ k m_kjgedmjjo ^cidkaQjo]\ dTdo_\ o eo],
Zeo ZojZcmejo _oaJmj oedmRieQ ^o Xog\_icgedmjjT] oSYWiemaQgedi], mm o^ek]iaQjom ciWcmFmjkm dk_kegY d ji_amJiKm] WiZojo_iemaQjo]
cmX\akcodijkk. _mgQ diJjo k]meQ d dk_\, Reo cmiakWiNkY kjgeke\ei
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i og\KmgedaYmegY k d ci]ZiM \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, o_jiZo jkZiZkM ZojZcmejTM \ZiWijkP ji eo, Wi gRme ZiZkM
gcm_ged Xog\_icgedo oSYW\megY doW]mgekeQ ^ckRkjmjjTP dcm_, \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjTP
WiZoj jm go_mcJke.
\J_imegY d ciWcmFmjkk k do^cog o eo], Zeo k d ZiZo] ^ocY_Zm
_oaJmj oedmRieQ Wi ^ckRkjmjkm dcm_i akN\, cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ d
gdYWk g oeZiWo] RigejoXo oSdkjkemaY oe oSdkjmjkY. Xo iZe\iaQjogeQ
oS\gaodamji em], Reo oSYWiemaQgedi Xog\_icgedi ^o doW]mKmjkI dcm_i
ji ^o_oSjTm gke\iNkk jm cig^cogecijYIegY. 1_jiZo akFmjkm cmiSkakekcodijjoXo ^cidi ji doW]oJjogeQ mXo
^cidoP ^ckco_m k jcidgedmjjT] ogjodi] cmiSkakeiNkk
doW]mKmjkY ^coekdocmRke
2
.
1
moSMo_k]o oSciekeQ djk]ijkm ji ^cm_geidamjjom d _ijjo] ^ogeijodamjkk ^oaoJmjkm,
goXaigjo Zoeoco]\ kjemcmgT /kjkgemcgedi ;kjijgod E? d g\_iM ^cm_geidaYIe ^o _odmcmjjogek (g ^cido] ^mcm_odmckY) \^cidamjkY ?m_mciaQjoXo ZiWjiRmPgedi ^o g\S%mZei] EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk. ijjiY jmeoRjogeQ, ^o jiFm]\ ]jmjkI, ]oJme ^odamRQ o^cm_mamjjTm
^ogam_gedkY ^ck \Rigekk d g\_mSjTM Wigm_ijkYM d X. /ogZdm ^cm_geidkemamP g\_mSjoXo _m^icei]mjei /kj;kji, oSai_iIKkM gooedmeged\IKk]k ^cido]oRkY]k ^o _oaJjogek.
2
Cogeijodamjkm >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E? oe 17 oZeYScY 2011 X. & 22-C.
207
$WaoJmjjom ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\ o jmoSMo_k]ogek WiZcm^keQ d joc]iM :C> E? ^oaoJmjkY, jm^ogcm_gedmjjo gdYWijjTm g cmiakWiNkmP
kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY dcm_i d Rigek ZojZcmekWiNkk ji_amJiKmXo oedmeRkZi ^o Xog\_icgedmjjT] oSYWiemaQgedi]. aY ,eoXo ^cm_aiXim] oeciWkeQ d go_mcJijkk ge. 134 :C> E?, cmXai]mjekc\IKmP d gooedmegedkk g ^cm_aiXim]oP ji]k ZojNm^NkmP cmiSkakeiNkk «CckWjijkm ^cidi
ji doW]mKmjkm
dcm_i», ^oaoJmjkm gam_\IKmXo go_mcJijkY:
«8oW]mKm-
jkm dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT], i eiZJm kjT] akNi], ^ogeci_idFk] d
Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, og\KmgedaYmegY Xog\_icgedo] d
^oajo] oS%m]m jmWidkgk]o oe dkjT ocXiji _oWjijkY, _oWjidiemaY, jiRiaQjkZi ^o_ciW_mamjkY _oWjijkY, gam_odiemaY, c\Zodo_kemaY gam_gedmjjoXo ocXiji, ^coZ\coci, g\_i Wi gRme ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk. ijjom ^cidkao jm cig^cogecijYmegY ji ga\Rik doW]mKmjkY
dcm_i cmiSkakekcodijjT] d gdYWk
g oeZiWo] oe oSdkjmjkY RigejoXo
oSdkjkemaY».
1Smg^mRmjkI ^cid ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, ZoeocTm d gaoJkdFmPgY gke\iNkk _akemaQjom dcm]Y jm
]oX\e _oSkeQgY doW]mKmjkY ^ckRkjmjjoXo k] dcm_i, ^ckWdij g^ogoSgedodieQ cijmm \^o]kjidFkPgY ?m_mciaQjTP WiZoj «1 Zo]^mjgiNkk Wi jic\Fmjkm ^cidi ji g\_o^cokWdo_gedo d ciW\]jTP gcoZ kak
^cidi ji kg^oajmjkm g\_mSjoXo iZei d ciW\]jTP gcoZ» oe 30 i^cmaY
2010 X. &
68-?.
AoXaigjo m]\ ^o_oWcmdim]Tm, oSdkjYm]Tm, ^o_g\_k]Tm, og\J_mjjTm, o^cid_ijjTm ^ck jic\Fmjkk kM ^cidi ji g\_o^cokWdo_gedo d ciW\]jTP gcoZ kak ^cidi ji kg^oajmjkm g\_mSjoXo iZei, ^cm_\g]ieckdiIKmXo dWTgZijkY ji gcm_gedi SI_Jmei SI_JmejoP gkgem]T EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk d ciW\]jTP gcoZ, d^cidm oSciekeQgY d g\_ g WiYdamjkm]
o ^ckg\J_mjkk Zo]^mjgiNkk Wi eiZom jic\Fmjkm
(ge. 1).
EiW]mc Zo]^mjgiNkk o^cm_maYmegY g\_o], kgMo_Y kW ecmSodijkP
WiYdkemaY, oSgeoYemaQged _mai, ^o Zoeoco]\ STao _o^\Kmjo jic\Fmjkm, ^co_oaJkemaQjogek jic\FmjkY k WjiRk]ogek mXo ^ogam_gedkY
_aY WiYdkemaY (ge. 2).
$W\Rmjkm ^ciZekZk dco^mPgZoXo A\_i ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi gdk_memaQged\me o eo], Reo ^ck ciWcmFmjkk do^cogod ^o g\Kmged\ _ijjT]
g\_mSjo] ocXijo], jic\Fmjkm ciW\]jogek gcoZod ^ck og\Kmgedamjkk
g\_o^cokWdo_gedi,
cigNmjkdimegY ZiZ jic\Fmjkm joc] ]mJ_\jico_joXo ^cidi d g;mcm WiKkeT ^cid RmaodmZi, Reo damRme ^ckjYekm cmFmjkP o jmoSMo_k]ogek dT^aieT Zo]^mjgiNkP
1
.
1
mao «>ocF\jod ^coekd EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk» iaoSi & 38971/06. Cogeijodamjkm
dco^mPgZoXo A\_i ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi oe 25 oZeYScY 2007 X.; mao «m]mjeodi ^coekd EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk» iaoSi & 942/02. Cogeijodamjkm dco^mPgZoXo A\_i ^o ^cidi] RmaodmZi oe 27 gmjeYScY 2007 X. // >ojg\aQeije CaIg.
208
ic\Fmjkm ciW\]jTM gcoZod g\_mSjoXo ciWSkciemaQgedi ^cm_geidaYmegY, em] jm ]mjmm, gam_gedkm] godoZ\^jogek g\Kmged\IKkM d
ZiJ_o] ZojZcmejo] ga\Rim ^ckRkj, Reo ^o_edmcJ_ime dTgZiWijjTm
cijmm ]Tgak o jmoSMo_k]ogek gecm]keQgY \gecijYeQ, ji^ck]mc, ^ckRkjT WieYXkdijkY ^coNmggi cmFmjkY do^cogod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i.
8TYdamjkm, ijiakW k o^cm_mamjkm ,;;mZekdjTM g^ogoSod doW]oJjoXo
\gecijmjkY kW%Yjod d _mPged\IKm] ]mMijkW]m cmiakWiNkk kjgeke\ei
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
, ]oJme g^ogoSgedodieQ ^odTFmjkI ZiRmgedi XicijekcodijjoP Xog\_icgedo] WiKkeT ^cid ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi.
1SKmP j\J_iIKmPgY d ciWcmFmjkk ^coSam]oP YdaYmegY g\Kmgedodijkm jmo_joWjiRjTM ^o_Mo_od Z ^coNmgg\iaQjoP ;oc]m cmiakWiNkk ^cid XciJ_ij, gdYWijjTM g doW]mKmjkm] dcm_i.
$jemcmgT cmiSkakekcodijjTM k kjTM akN, ^ogeci_idFkM d Mo_m
\XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi ^o ZojZcmejo]\ \Xoaodjo]\ _ma\, oS%
m_kjYme doW]oJjogeQ WiYdkeQ ecmSodijkm o doW]mKmjkk k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i k ^oa\RkeQ gooedmeged\IK\I Zo]^mjgiNkI.
8o^cog o ;oc]iM doW]mKmjkY dcm_i \^cido]oRmjjT] g\S%mZei],
_kgZ\ggkojjTP ^o gdomP g\ek, jm^ogcm_gedmjjo gdYWij g ^cidodoP
^ckco_oP jTjm _mPged\IKmXo kjgeke\ei cmiSkakeiNkk.
1 mXo WjiRk]ogek, d Rigejogek, gdk_memaQged\me ^cm_geidamjjiY d
Ick_kRmgZoP akemcie\cm ^oWkNkY $.. >i]Tjkji, oe]mekdFmXo, Reo
^codm_mjjTP k] ijiakW
g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk ^oWdoaYme dTYdkeQ _di
^ckjNk^kiaQjTM do^cogi o eo], d ZiZo] ^ocY_Zm _oaJjT cigg]ieckdieQgY ecmSodijkY WikjemcmgodijjTM akN o doW]mKmjkk, d Rigejogek,
]iemckiaQjoXo dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod gam_gedkY, _oWjijkY k g\_i k oSai_iIe ak ojk ^cido] dTSoci
1
dk_i g\_o^cokWdo_gedi _aY mXo doW]mKmjkY
.
Ze\iaQjogeQ ^ogeidamjjTM do^cogod oS\gaodamji jm eoaQZo oeg\egedkm] doW]oJjogek oedmei ji jkM, kgMo_Y kW go_mcJijkY godoZ\^jogek cmX\akc\IKkM ^cidooejoFmjkY d g;mcm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i
joc]iekdjTM ^cidodTM iZeod, jo k ddk_\ oeg\egedkY m_kjTM ^o_Mo_od Z kM ciWcmFmjkI gcm_k \RmjTM-^coNmgg\iakgeod k ^ciZekRmgZkM
ciSoejkZod.
"iZ, ji^ck]mc, ^o ]jmjkI o_jkM ideocod ^coSam]jT] do^cogo]
d g;mcm
doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo dcm_i YdaYmegY ^cm_ogeidamjjom
cmiSkakekcodijjo]\ ^cido oSciekeQgY d g\_ d ^ocY_Zm kgZodoXo ^cokWdo_gedi, d eo dcm]Y ZiZ :C> E? oe_ime ^ckockeme i_]kjkgeciekd-
-
1
>i]Tjkj $..
aodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY // :XoaodjTP ^coNmgg. 2005. & 12. A. 48.
iKkei ^cid akNi, cmiSkakekcodijjoXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \Xo-
209
jo]\ (kjgeijNkojjo]\) ^ocY_Z\ cigg]oecmjkY _ijjTM g^ocod. Cck
,eo] ^cm_aiXimegY oXcijkRkeQ ^ocY_oZ doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo XciJ_ijkj\ jmWiZojjT]k _mPgedkY]k ocXijod _oWjijkY, ^cm_dickemaQjoXo gam_gedkY, ^coZ\cie\cT k g\_i joc]i]k \Xoaodjo-^coNmg-
1
g\iaQjoXo ^cidi
.
AeocojjkZk ^coekdo^oaoJjoP eoRZk WcmjkY ^oaiXiIe, Reo _iaQjmPFmm ciWdkekm kjgeke\ei doW]mKmjkY k]\KmgedmjjoXo k Zo]^mjgiNkk ]ociaQjoXo dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo XciJ_ijkj\ d \Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoP g;mcm, gam_\me og\KmgedaYeQ d ci]ZiM XciJ_ijgZoXo ^cidi
2
^\em] djmgmjkY kW]mjmjkP d _mPged\IKmm WiZojo_iemaQgedo
.
1^cog ^ciZekRmgZkM ciSoejkZod, ^codm_mjjTP d Mo_m jigeoYKmXo
kggam_odijkY, ^ckdo_ke Z dTdo_\, Reo gcm_k _oWjidiemamP, gam_odiemamP, ^coZ\cocod k g\_mP, eiZJm jme m_kjo_\FkY d ^o_Mo_iM Z ciWcmFmjkI _ijjoXo do^cogi. "iZ, 64 cmg^oj_mjei kW 320 o^coFmjjTM (Reo
gogeidaYme 20%) ^oaiXiIe, Reo doW]mKmjkm dcm_i gam_\me og\KmgedaYeQ
d ^ocY_Zm \XoaodjoXo g\_o^cokWdo_gedi, 82 (25,6%) oe_iIe ^cm_^oRemjkm XciJ_ijgZo]\ g\_o^cokWdo_ged\, 157 (49,1%) gZaojYIegY Z
doW-
]oJjogek iaQemcjiekdjoXo ^o_Mo_i, 17 (5,3%) Wiec\_jkakgQ oedmekeQ.
8 gdoI oRmcm_Q cmW\aQeieT ijiakWi g\_mSjoP ^ciZekZk gdk_memaQged\Ie o eo], Reo jmo^cm_mamjjogeQ d do^cogm o ji_amJiKmP ;oc]m
doW]mKmjkY dcm_i kjemcmg\IKk] jig akNi], damRme Wi goSoP ^ogam_gedkY, gdYWijjTm g jmdoW]oJjogeQI cmiakWiNkk k]k ^cm_ogeidamjjTM
WiZojo] ^cid d ]iZgk]iaQjo ZocoeZkm gcoZk, ^ocoJ_ime WieYXkdijkm
g\_mSjTM eYJS, ^mcmg]oec WiYdamjjTM
3
jT]k kjgeijNkY]k
.
ecmSodijkP ciWakRjT]k g\_mS-
8 NmaYM m_kjooSciWjoXo ^ck]mjmjkY ^coNmgg\iaQjoXo WiZojo_iemaQgedi k \^ocY_oRmjkY ocXijkWiNkk ciSoeT, gdYWijjoP g cigg]oecmjkm] kgZod o doW]mKmjkk dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo XciJ_ijkj\ d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_odijkY, Wi gRme gcm_ged ZiWjT EoggkPgZoP ?m_mciNkk /kj;kj E? oSYWTdime gdokM ^cm_geidkemamP ^ck cigg]oecmjkk _ma g\_o] c\Zodo_gedodieQgY ecmSodijkY]k
\Xoaodjo-^coNmgg\iaQjoXo k XciJ_ijgZoXo Zo_mZgod
, ^ogeijodamjkY]k >ojgeke\NkojjoXo A\_i E?, ^ogeijodamjkY]k Camj\]i k ciW%YgjmjkY]k 8mcModjoXo A\_i E?, ZigiIKk]kgY do^cogod doW]mKmjkY
dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo d cmW\aQeiem jmWiZojjoXo \XoaodjoXo ^cmgam_o-
1
/iZgk]mjZo /.8.
ji\Z. 8ai_k]kc, 2006. A. 21.
2
Em^Qmd ..
_mSjT]k ocXiji]k: deocm;. _kg. … Zij_. Ick_. ji\Z. /., 2007. A. 10.
3
>iggiNkojjom o^cm_mamjkm A\_mSjoP >oaamXkk ^o \XoaodjT] _mai] 8mcModjoXo A\_i
E? oe 29 YjdicY 2004 X. & 2-o03-30 / icije.
EmiSkakeiNkY d g\_m ^mcdoP kjgeijNkk: deocm;. _kg. … Zij_. Ick_.
ciJ_ijgZo-^cidodom cmX\akcodijkm doW]mKmjkY dcm_i, ^ckRkjmjjoXo g\-
210
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]