Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Academic_Writing_Reference_Book (1).doc
Скачиваний:
34
Добавлен:
17.04.2019
Размер:
852.48 Кб
Скачать

Formulating the counterarguments against the thesis

When presenting counterarguments you should:

  • Present at least two arguments against your point of view (counterarguments) with evidence.

  • Answer these counterarguments with evidence.

  • Avoid strong language (“This is a stupid idea”).

Organizing the essay The classical system of argumentation based on that of ancient Greek and Roman orators

The Introduction

  • Gains reader’s attention (question, story, quotation).

  • Establishes your qualifications to write about topic.

  • Establishes common ground with readers.

  • Demonstrates fairness.

  • States thesis.

The Background (any necessary background information about the topic).

The Arguments

  • Reasons in support of thesis (logical/emotional/ethical).

  • Reasons presented in order of importance (most important first).

The Counterarguments

  • Present alternative points of view.

  • Notes reasons for/against these points of view.

  • Shows why your view is better.

The Conclusion

  • Summarize the argument.

  • Elaborate on implications of the thesis (if we do this, then…).

  • State what you want readers to think or do.

  • Make a strong ethical or emotional appeal.

5. Argumentation Designs Diagram I

PRO

CON

Thesis: “This is so.”

“Of course, that is so, too.”

“But that is too high a price…

“And …

“Moreover…

“…, and so forth.

“Therefore,…”

Diagram II: Controlling Handguns – Pro and Con

PRO

CON

Thesis: Possession of handguns should be controlled.

To be sure, self-protection is a natural right….

But pistols in homes kill many more relatives than intruders….

Of course, ownership by hunters and collectors is justified….

Large numbers of weapons in homes, however, give easy access to theft….

We concede that any restrictions invade privacy and freedom….

Nevertheless, the intrusion is no more restrictive than registering an automobile….

Indeed, all arguments about individual rights pale before the crime rate and the annual slaughter of individuals….

Besides, handguns kill thousands more in the United States than in any other country.

Therefore, controlling handguns is reasonable and necessary.

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]