- •Modular structure of proteins
- •Structural domains
- •The evolution and shuffling of domains
- •Sequence homology and the acquisition of function
- •Domain function
- •Catalytic domains
- •Protein interaction domains
- •The inventory of domains
- •Detection
- •Classification
- •Examples of domains with roles in signalling
- •Domains that bind oligopeptide motifs
- •SH2 domains
- •PTB domains
- •SH3 domains
- •Phosphoinositide-binding domains
- •PH domains
- •Other phosphoinositide-binding domains
- •Polypeptide modules that bind Ca2
- •Calcium-binding motifs and domains
- •The EF-hand motif
- •C2 domains
- •Zinc finger domains
- •Protein kinase domains
- •Protein kinases share a common domain
- •Structural elements that regulate kinase activity
- •References
Signal Transduction
The Interpro database (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/interpro/) integrates information from a range of so-called signature databases, including those mentioned above. Release 12.1 has 12953 protein entries and an inventory of 3585 domain types. However, the number of well characterized families is much smaller, of the order of 50–100.
Examples of domains with roles in signalling
A glance at the protein databases reveals the multidomain structure of many proteins, especially signalling proteins. As more domain types have been identified, it has become clear that the potential combinatorial diversity
is huge. As already discussed, signal propagation within cells commonly involves the formation of molecular complexes at particular cellular sites. Such complexes may contain catalytic domains that perform covalent modifications on substrate molecules that are then recognized by domains on other proteins (e.g. SH2 domains binding to phosphorylated tyrosine head groups).
Thus, in response to a ligand binding to its receptor and in a seemingly amorphous and disordered cytoplasm, organized signalling complexes are assembled which recruit yet other molecules to project the signal onwards. Interactions between domains lie at the heart of all this, but although we have accrued extensive information about their incidence in a wide range of proteins, our understanding of the mechanisms in which they take part is
limited. Importantly, for the reasons given above, the presence of a particular domain in a protein is no guarantee of function.
The list of domains in signalling proteins is large, and the electronic databases provide the most comprehensive source of information. Table 24.1 summarizes properties of domains that have received mention in previous chapters and the sections that follow provide illustrative examples of some of the most important.
Domains that bind oligopeptide motifs
SH2 domains
SH2 domains are exemplars of protein interaction domains that take part in signalling. They bind to short motifs containing a phosphotyrosine and were first observed in the viral non-receptor protein tyrosine kinase v-fps/fes, in the form of a regulatory region separate and distinct from the kinase domain. The region is conserved among other nrPTKs and is commonly located immediately N-terminal to the catalytic domain, (see Figure 17.1, page 514). It was named SH2 for Src homology region 2.6 In Src it regulates kinase activity through an intramolecular association with a phosphotyrosine near the
768
Protein Domains and Signal Transduction
Table 24.1 Examples of protein domains important in signalling
Domain |
Name/origin |
Binds to/ |
Function |
Examples of proteins |
|
|
associates with |
|
with the domain |
|
|
|
|
|
SH2 |
Src homology 2 |
pY, some SH3 |
complex |
Src, Btk, RasGAP, PLC- , |
|
|
|
assembly |
Grb2, PI3K-p85, Vav, Dbl, |
|
|
|
|
Shc, STATS, |
|
|
|
|
|
PTB |
Phosphotyrosine |
pY, |
complex |
IRS1, IRS2, Shc |
|
binding |
phosphoinositides |
assembly |
|
|
|
|
|
|
PID |
Phosphotyrosine |
pY, Y, |
complex |
Shc, RGS12 |
|
interaction |
phosphoinositides |
assembly |
|
|
|
|
|
|
WD40 rpt |
Trp-Asp repeats |
pS, pT, pS short |
complex |
G , STE4 |
|
|
motifs |
assembly |
|
|
|
|
|
|
SH3 |
Src homology 3 |
PXXP, RXXK, tandem |
complex |
Src, Btk, RasGAP, PLC- , |
|
|
Y, -helical segment |
assembly |
Grb2, PI3K-p85, Vav, Nck |
|
|
|
|
|
PH |
pleckstrin homology |
phosphoinositide, |
recruitment to |
RasGAP, Sos, PLC- 1, PKB, |
|
|
G |
membrane |
Grb2, GRK2/ ARK, Vav, Dbl |
|
|
|
|
|
C2 |
C2 domain of PKC |
phosphoinositide/ |
recruitment to |
PKC, RasGAP, PLC- 1, |
|
|
Ca2 |
membrane |
PLC- 1, Syt |
FYVE Zn |
Fab1, YOTB/ZK632.12, |
phosphoinositide |
recruitment to |
EEA1, SARA |
finger |
Vac1, EEA1 |
(PI(3)P) |
membrane |
|
|
|
|
|
|
PX |
Phox homol. |
phosphoinositides |
recruitment to |
p40phox, p47phox, PLD1 |
|
|
|
membrane |
|
|
|
|
|
|
DH |
Dbl homol. |
Rho GTPase |
RhoGEF |
ARK, Dbl, Vav, Sos |
|
|
|
|
|
C1 |
C1 domain of PKC |
DAG |
activates PKC |
PKC, DAG kinase, Vav |
|
|
|
|
|
EFh |
EF hand |
Ca2 |
intracellular |
CaM, troponin C, DAG |
|
|
|
Ca2 sensor |
kinase, calcineurin B, |
|
|
|
|
GCAP |
|
|
|
|
|
cadherin |
cadherin repeat |
Ca2 |
cell adhesion |
cadherins |
rpt |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
DED |
death effector domain |
self associates |
recruits |
procaspases, FADD |
|
|
|
procaspases |
|
|
|
|
|
|
DD |
death domain |
self associates |
regulation of |
TNF receptors, FADD, |
|
|
|
apoptosis |
TRADD |
|
|
|
|
|
CARD |
caspase recruitment |
self associates |
recruits |
APAF, procaspases |
|
domain |
|
procaspases |
|
|
|
|
|
|
MH1 |
MAD homology 1 |
DNA |
transcriptional |
Smads (N-term) |
|
|
|
activation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
(Continued) |
769
Signal Transduction
Table 24.1 Continued
Domain |
Name/origin |
Binds to/ |
Function |
Examples of proteins |
|
|
associates with |
|
with the domain |
|
|
|
|
|
MH2 |
MAD homology 2 |
pSXpS (Smads), |
transcriptional |
Smads (C-term) |
|
|
SARA |
activation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
bromo |
brahma protein |
acetylated Lys |
transcriptional |
Snf-2, pCAF, CBP, p300, |
|
|
|
co-activation |
TFIID complex |
|
|
|
|
|
chromo |
chromatin organization |
methylated Lys |
transcriptional |
Swi-6, HP1 |
|
modifier |
|
repression |
|
|
|
|
|
|
PDZ |
post-synaptic density |
C-termini of |
assembly/ |
InaD |
|
p95, Dlg & ZO1 |
channels/receptors, |
membrane |
|
|
|
phosphoinositides |
recruitment |
|
|
|
|
|
|
RGS |
regulator of G protein |
G |
increases |
RGS proteins, GRK2/ ARK, |
|
signalling |
|
GTPase activity |
RhoGEF |
|
|
|
|
|
pkinase |
protein kinase |
Ser, Thr |
phosphorylation |
PKC, PKA, PKB |
|
|
|
|
|
Y kinase |
protein tyrosine kinase |
Tyr |
phosphorylation |
Insulin receptor, |
|
|
|
|
Src, Btk |
|
|
|
|
|
Zn finger |
with 2 Cys and 2 His |
DNA, RNA, proteins |
transcription |
transcription factors |
(C2H2) |
residues |
|
complex |
|
|
|
|
assembly |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Zn finger |
with 4 Cys residues |
DNA, RNA, proteins |
transcription |
nuclear receptors |
(C4) |
|
|
complex |
|
|
|
|
assembly |
|
See end of chapter for abbreviations.
C-terminus. This keeps the kinase in a compact, inactive conformation. (The mechanism by which this inhibition is lifted is discussed below.) The affinity of SH2 domains for non-phosphorylated tyrosines or for phosphoserines or phosphothreonines is generally negligible.
SH2 domains are present in at least 110 different human proteins, which fall into 11 different functional classes.7 These may have catalytic activity, such as the receptor and non-receptor tyrosine kinases, RasGAP, phospholipase C , the regulatory subunits of PI3-kinase, and some protein tyrosine phosphatases. In all of these, the ability of the SH2 domain to bind to a phosphotyrosine has important consequences for enzyme activity. SH2 domain-containing proteins that are devoid of a catalytic activity, but carry other protein interaction domains, include adaptor proteins, typified by Grb2.
SH2 domains and protein tyrosine kinases are expressed throughout the animal kingdom, but they are less apparent in other eukaryotic organisms.
770
Protein Domains and Signal Transduction
There is evidence that they may have coevolved in protozoans that were predecessors of multicellular organisms. For example, the slime mould Dictyostelium discoideum encodes 12 proteins having SH2 domains. Some of these are similar to the mammalian STAT proteins that dimerize, through mutual interactions involving SH2 domains and phosphotyrosines (see page 353), to become transcription factors, although this interaction does not appear to be essential for nuclear translocation8. In addition, while Dictyostelium does not express conventional PTKs, it does encode tyrosine kinase-like proteins.
The credentials of Dictyostelium as a transitional species between unicellular and multicellular life are surpassed by choanoflagellate protozoans, such
as Monosiga brevicollis. This species is also colonial and expresses not only SH2 domains but also PTKs similar to those of mammals.9 Such organisms may resemble the immediate predecessors of multicellular eukaryotes and it possible that the coordinated evolution of PTKs and SH2 domains contributed to the metazoan radiation.
The structure of the SH2 domain of the nrPTK Lck is depicted in the central panels of Figure 24.1. Like other SH2 domains, it consists of about 100 amino acids and possesses a central antiparallel -sheet, flanked by two -helices. The phosphopeptide ligand shown in the figure contains the motif -pYEEI-. Two pockets, on either side of the -sheet, provide binding sites for the phosphotyrosine and for the isoleucine residue at pY 3, respectively. The combined effect of the two sites is to enable high affinity binding that is phosphorylation-dependent. Within the phosphotyrosine binding pocket, two arginine residues make contacts with the phosphate group (Figure 24.1).
In general, SH2 domains recognize ligand motifs of 4–7 amino acids with an N-terminal pY and, commonly, a hydrophobic residue at pY 3. Different types of SH2 domain have different binding preferences. For example, while the SH2 domain of Src kinase binds optimally to the sequence pYEEI, a mutation of a threonine to a tyrosine in the specificity pocket changes its preference to pYVNV,11 enabling it to bind Grb2.
SH2 domains have been classified on the basis of their preferred ligand sequences, but an optimal sequence may not be the same as the sequence in an actual target. Ligand selectivity has been investigated in vitro using degenerate phosphopeptide libraries and the data indicate considerable binding versatility.7 For example, Src can bind to pY-[E/D/T]-[E/N/Y]-[I/M/L] and while the C-terminal SH2 domain of phospholipase C prefers pY-[V/I/L]- [E/D]-[P/V/I], it binds to pY-I-I-L-P-D-P in the activated PDGF receptor.
PTB domains
The PTB (phosphotyrosine-binding) domain also recognizes phosphotyrosine residues, but its structure is completely different from that of the SH2 domain. Figure 24.2 shows the PTB domain of IRS-1 (insulin receptor substrate-1). Its
The social slime mould
Dictyostelium discoideum exists as single cells for most of the time, but under stressful conditions such as starvation, these cells aggregate to form a ‘slug’ which can migrate as a coherent organism. The cells differentiate, forming a stalk and an independent fruiting body which distributes spores.
771
Signal Transduction
Fig 24.1 SH2 domain of the Src kinase Lck.
The structure on the left shows the central -sheet and flanking helices. A rotated view is shown in the central panel. A polypeptide containing the -pYEEI- motif is depicted as spheres at the top of the figure. The bottom panel shows the polypeptide bound to the domain. The phosphotyrosine residue (salmon pink) makes a number of contacts with residues that line the pocket, including two arginines, one of which is displayed as grey and blue spheres. The isoleucine residue (yellow) is located in a hydrophobic cleft (1lcj.pdb10).
FIG 24.2 The PTB domain of IRS-1. Two views of the domain rotated 90° about a vertical axis. The right-hand
structure includes a phosphotyrosyl ligand (LVIAGNPApYRS, shown as blue sticks). Also indicated are three lysine residues (purple) that take part in binding to acidic phospholipid headgroups (1irs13).
structure is based on the highly conserved PH domain superfold
(see Figure 24.4) adopted by PH, EVH1, and a number of other protein interaction domains. The rigid -barrel, closed off at one end by a long -helix, provides a conserved scaffold, the surface of which has been adapted in different ways to bind diverse protein motifs or lipid head groups. Note that PH and EVH1 domains do not bind to phosphotyrosines and, despite their name, nor do a large number of PTB domains. The PTB domains that do, prefer
772
