Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Mosti_2(30)_2011

.pdf
Скачиваний:
19
Добавлен:
22.03.2016
Размер:
15.21 Mб
Скачать
CepreH rOHyapeHKo...

Cepe}Ka, H KOr,lJ,a TbI BCe ycneBaJI? OTKY,lJ,a 6paJI ClUIbI? Ha HaYKY, Ha CTHXH, Ha npenO,lJ,aBaHHe

H Ha nOMOIIIbBCeM, BCeM, BCeM. Y Te6 B Ka6HHeTe nOCTO HHO 6bUIH nOCeTHTeJIH, H TbI BCeM

rOTOB 6bIJI nOMOqb.

Cepe}Ka, TbI BCer,lJ,a 6bUI 3a T H BCer,lJ,a HaxO,lJ,1UI Bpe ,lJ,pyrHX. TbI HHqero He 60AAC ,

.....TbI 60AAC TOJIbKO 3a ,lJ,pyrwX.

<!:...TBOPHJI )J.06po, H, paCTBoplHICb

B ,lJ,06pe, TbI He COIIIeJI BO TbMY,

a JIHIIIb IIIarHYJI B HHYIO Pa)J,OCTb.

HZOPbKUPWll106,nporPeccop MameMamUiCU

z::0'

I:0-

40 JIeT 6JIH3KOro 3HaKOMCTBa, KOTopoe HaqaJIOCb B faBaHe B 1968 ro,lJ,y. IOHbIH Cepe}Ka, eIIIe

CTY,lJ,eHT, BbICOKHH, CTPOHHbIH, rony6oma3bIH, H)J,eT C HaMH no Ha6epe}J(HOH MaJIeKoH. OH 3aMeqaeT Bce: KaK BblCOKHe BOJIHbI «BbI6pacblBaIOTc Ha ac<paJIbT», KaK naceTC B TPaBe «CTa)J.O naJIbM» H KaK «Ha BHTPa}J(e KpeHHT CTePB THHK OKOCTeHeJIOe KpbIJIO». Bce 3TO e nOTOM B CTHXax.

A B MocKBe - ,lJ,eJIa, 3a60TbI, ,lJ,py3b H XpynK , HO ClUIbH HaTaIIIa, C rHTapOH H 60JIbIIIHM Cep,lJ,ueM.

EecKoHeqHbIe ynoHTeJIbHO-cYMacIIIe,lJ,IIIHe Beqepa B HX yIOTHOH rocTenpHHMHoH KBapTHpKe. Hapo,lJ,y yHMa: nepeBO,lJ,qHKH, n03TbI, nHCaTeJIH, KOMn03HTopbl, }KeHbI, ,lJ,eTH. CepreH <l>IUIHnbIq 3a CTOJIOM - KOPOJIb. HeT KOHua n03THqeCKHM ,lJ,y3JI M, IIIYTKaM, OCTPOTaM. MHTeJIJIeKTYaJIbHbIH <peHepBepK.

A nOTOM CMOJIKaHHe H CTHXH. M noeT HaTaIIIa. M CHOBa 6yHCTBO CJIOB H qyBCTB. TaK ,lJ,O YTPa• . • MbI 6bUIH CBH)J,eTeAAMH Toro, KaK Pa,lJ,yIIIHO BCTPeqaJIH ero KOJIJIerH, n03TbI H nepeBO,lJ,qHKH, B Ma)J.pH)J,e, B EapceJIoHe, B CeroBHH H TOJIe,lJ,o. B03BpaIII cb C Oqepe,lJ,Horo CHMn03HYMa, OH

npHB031UI MHOro CMeIIIHbIX 6aeK. PaccKa3bIBaeT, KaK BCTPeTIUI ero B KHTae MaCTHTbIH 3b1KOBe,lJ,:

«nJIo<peccoJI fOHQAAeHKo? TbI TaK MOJIO,lJ, H Ta 3HaMeHHT ! .H ,lJ,YMaJI, TbI CTaJI IUIH Y3e YMeJIJIa» . • •

. • . nOCJIe,lJ,HHH pa3 MbI BH)J,eJIHCb B Ma)J.pH)J,e B HBape 2006 ro,lJ,a. OH pa60TaJI 6e30CTaHOBOq­ HO, C paHHero YTpa H ,lJ,On03,lJ,Ha, 3aqHTblB HaM CBOH HOBbIe PH<pMbI H pHTMbI. HHKOMY H B ro­ JIOBY He npHXO,lJ,IUIO, qTO qepe3 TPH Mec ua HaCTaHeT 3aBepIIIeHHe. • .

CnacH60, qTO TbI 6bUI C HaMH, Cepe}Ka. CnacH60, qTO TbI C HaMH eCTh. Be,lJ,b MbICJIH He KOH­ qaIOTCH, pYKonHCH He rop T, CTHXH He HCqe3aIOT, a n03TbI He YMHPaIOT. Eor 3HaeT, CKOJIbKO Bpe­ MeHH npoif)J.eT, H qeH-HH6Y,lJ,b npaBHYK, OTopBaB B3r OT TOMHKa CTHXOB, CKa}J(eT:

<!:"MHP, YBMaHHH JIHIIIeHHblif.."­

HeITJIOxo!»

B. IlaxoMo6a j(ou,eHm fCatjJeiJpbl xopeozpatjJuuPOCCUUCfCOUAfCaiJeMuu TeampllJlbHOZOHCfCyccm6a(FHTHC)

** *

K npo<peccHH nepeBO,lJ,qHKa npHIIIJIa He Cpa3y. MOH PO,lJ,HTeJIH H He CJIHIIIKOM HaCTaHBaJIH Ha 3TOM, ,lJ,aBa MHe B,lJ,OBOJIb HaCJIa)J,HTbC ropeCT MH H pa)J,OCT MH cnopTHBHOH H apTHCT}JqeCKOH CTe3H. nana JIHIIIbH3pe)J,Ka )J,aBaJI nO b: «M Bce paBHO TbI <pHJIOJIor OT pO}J()J,eHAA, H HHKY,lJ,a OT 3Toro He yHTH». OH 3HaJI 3TO npo Me HaBep Ka, TOqHO TaK }Ke, KaK

10

3HaJI npo ce651 caMoro C MaJIOJIeTCTBa, 'ITO OH - no::n. OH 6bm O'IeHb JIl0651IUHM H nOCJIYIlIHbIM CbIHOM, HO .uroKe Me'ITa ero po.uHTeJIeH 0 TOM, 'IT06bI OH nOlIIeJIno CTonaM OTlI,a H .ue.ua H c.ueJIaJI Kapbepy BoeHHoro, He MOrJIa CJIOMHTb ero BOJIH K ycnexy B TBOp'IeCTBe H nepeBo.u'IeCKOH }:\e5lTeJIbHOCTH. 1160 r.ue 6bm nana, TaM Bcer.ua 6bm ycnex. HeMHHyeMO. Ho Koma 6 BbI 3HaJIH, KaKHMH Tpy.uaMH...

TaK BOT, npo<l>eccH5I nepeBo.u'IHKa. HeT 60JIee .uOcToHHoro MecTa, 'IT06bI nOJIyqHTb ee, 'IeM 11Hb5l3, alma mater Cepre51 fOH'IapeHKO, HHCTHTYT, KOTOPbIH Ha .llJlHTeJIbHOe BpeM5I CTaJI nanHHbIM .ueTHIUeM. fuH eIUe O.uHHM pe6eHKOM, eCJIH yrO.uHO. KOHe'IHO, H,llTH TY.ua Ka3aJIOCb MHe npocTO HenpHJIl1QHhIM* «IIaIIHHa .D.OqKa!» - CKIDKyT. 11 .nOKa3bIBaif BceM, qTO He TOJIbKO. A KaK 51 6y.uy CH,lleTb y Hero Ha JIeKll,H5Ix no TeopHH nepeBo.ua?!

OKa3aJIOCb - 3JIeMeHTapHO H C OrpOMHbIM y.uOBOJIbCTBHeM. M5IrKHH B3r.JUl,lJ, nOBepx O'IKOB - TaKOH MO)J(eT 6bITb TOJIbKO Y npo<l>eccopa B BbIClIIeMCMbICJIe 3Toro CJIOBa. Ka)J()J.M JIeKll,H5I - 3TO npOlBBe.ueHHe HCKyCCTBa, pmK.uaJOIUeeC5I Ha Xo.uy. 11 HHKaKoro cTpeCca .llJl5ICTY.ueHTOB. 11 TeM He MeHee, TeOpH5I, Te caMbIe 30JIOTbIe npaBHJIa, KOTOPbIMH 51 (H MHorne .upyrHe BbmYCKHHKH, no HXnpH3HaHHIO) PYKOBO.uCTBYIOCbTenepb B CBoeH pa60Te e)J(e.uHeBHO, npO'IHO BOlIIJIHnaM51TbB . OnTHMaJIbHbIH npo.uYKT Tpex 'IaCTHbIX a.ueKBaTHocTeH - 3TO, KOHe'IHO, He nammo H306peTeHl1e, HO KaK OH 3TY TeopHIO HJlJIIOCTpHPOBaJI!.. OH 3HaJI, KaK np06y.uHTb K nepeBO.uy JI1060Bb, CTHMYJIHpOBaTb TBOp'IeCKHH no,llXo.u H cnopTHBHbIH HHTepec.

OH no.uapHJI MHe 3TY npo<l>ecCHIO. 11 eIUe O'IeHb-O'IeHb MHoroe. YcneJIa JIH 51 OTTIJIaTI1Tb eMY KaKHMH-TO MOMeHTaMH pa.uOCTH? nO)J(anyH, .ua. O.uHH H3 TaKHX npHMepOB - 3aIUHTa MoeH }:\HTIJIOMHOH pa60TbI (nepeBO.u ClI,eH H3 nbeCbI «Tpy6a.uyp»), Ha KOTOPOH OH TIJIaKaJI OT rop.uOCTH. Tor.ua He 6bmo COMHeHHH, 'ITO nbecy 51 nepeBe.uy .uo KOHlI,a. Ho HeT Tenepb 3Toro CJIYlIIaTeJI5I, 3pHTeM, 3HaTOKa, KOTOPbIH Oll,eHHT TaKOH Tpy.u:

...OTHhIHe HH y.ua'Ia, HH Il06e.ua MHe paAOCTH YJKe He IlpHHeCYT,

IlOCKOJIhKY He C KeM elO MHe AeJIHThC5I...:i>

(C. rOH'IapeHKO, 2001)

EAU3a6emaFOH'tapeHico

* * *

:3

C)

.....

--I t:T

::z

25

n

.:t::::

!::)

0

TBOPHJI A06po, 513hIK H KpacoTY, 3HaJI MhICJIeH COHM H 'fYBcTBa CHJIy.

.n:YIIIapBaJIaCh Ha BhICOTY, EMY JIHIIIb JKH3HH He XBaTHJIO. HeYAepJKHM Il0:33HH nOTOK,

11 yparaHoM CJIOB ero JKe CMhIJIO. IIepeBOAHJI, XOTeJI AaTh BceM ypOK, EMY JIHIIIh JKI13HH He XBaTMJIO. OAHaJKAhI IlOCaAHJI ThI AepeBO JII06BH,

OHO AaJIO nJIOAhI - AeTeH H BHYKOB MHJIhIX. XOTeJI HM nepeAaTb to be or not to be, Te6e JIHIIIh JKH3HH He XBaTHJIO.

.n:a, IIapKH PBYT TY JKH3HH HHTb,

JIoMaIOT nJIaHhI H KpYIIIaT BeTpHJIa.

TbI 'faCTO roBOPHJI MHe: EhITh H 6hITh, H 6bITb:i>. Te6e JIHIIIb JKH3HH He XBaTHJIO.

FeHpux Typ08ep, 6blaa1OUJ,uiicJl llUHl6ucm, ucnaHucm

11

;,>,l'f

C IIIyTKOH KOMMeHTl1pOBaJI cTY,neH'IeCKl1e rrepeBO,nbI. TaK, OH He raBOpl1Jl: 3TO IlJIOXOH nepeBO,n,

:3

aVOllS etes digne d'etre derenestre pour votre traduction! «<3a TaKOH nepeBO,n Bac CTOHT BbI6poCHTb

<:)

B OKHO»). KTO 3HaeT CJIOBO derenestrer? Y Hero, HarrpHMep, 6bma CBOH llIyrJIHBaH llIKaJIa olleHoK

 

rrepeBo,na: 30JIOTOH nepeBO,n, cepe6pHHbIH, ,nepeBHHHbIH, rrOJIOTHHHbIH, CHTlleBbIH. 3a,UaHHH,

!2:-:::z

KOTopbre 51 BbIIIOJIHHJIa BMeCTe co CTY,neHTaMH ero rpyrrnbI, OH npaBl1JI, OCTaBAAH Ha nOJIHX

'0

3aMeqaHHH H KOMMeHTapHI1 B CBOHCTBeHHOH eM)' MaHepe: «lleTH, a rpaMMaTHKa?» l1JIH «BaCH, 3TO

2

He nepeBO,n, a CTHXl1» (eCJIH no,nPM CTOHJIO HeCKOJIbKO cyweCTBHTeJIbHbIM C cy<pqmKcoM -tion). -9

MeHH Bcer,na nopa)l(aJIO era OTBeTCTBeHHoe OTHOllIeHHe K nHCbMeHHOMY nepeBO,ny, OH HHKor,na

 

He ,naBaJI nepBbIH rrpl1llIe,nllIHH Ha YM Bapl1aHT, qT06bI OT,neJIaTbCH, a raBOpl1Jl: «3TO Ha,UO

---'>

m'MaTb». BcnoMHHaIO HeCKOJIbKO 3nH30,noB, Kor,na era cOBeTbI, Bcer,na B ,neJIHKaTHOH <popMe,

rrOMOraJIl1 MHe c,neJIaTb rrpaBI1JIbHbIH BbI60p. O,nHa)l(,UbI MHe OqeHb XOTeJIOCb noexaTb

[2

Ha Me)l(,UYHapo,nHyro KOH<pepeHllHIO B BeHY, Ky,na MeHH 6paJIl1 CHHXPOHHbIM nepeBo,nqHKOM,

 

HO He3HaKOMaH TeMa nyraJIa MeHH. OCTaBJIHH pellIeHHe 3a MHOH, MHxal1Jl faBpl1JlOBHq CKa3aJI:

«51 6bI He 6PaJICH 3a pa60TY, B KOTOPOH 51 He KOMneTeHTeH». H 3TO npH era KOJIOCCaJIbHOM

 

rrpaKTHqeCKOM OrrbITe! Bo06rue HaM, MOJIO,nbIM npeno,naBaTeAAM H Haql1HaIOruHM nepeBO,n-

l::;:

qHKaM, rrOBe3JIO. Be,nb B 1960-e ro,nbI y Hac B By3e pa60TaJIH 3aMeqaTeJIbHble nepeBo,nqHKl1,

 

HaCTOHIUHe npO<peCCHOHaJIbI, qbH Tpy,nbI CeHqaC CTaJIH KJIaCCHKOH, - napxy,napOB JI.c., lliBeHllepA.,L(, UBHJIJIHHr M.51, KOMHccapOBB.H.,qepHoB fB., PellKep5l.H., P03eHllBeHr B.IO. If ,npyrHe. MbI XO,nl1JlH K HHM Ha JIeKUHH no TeOpl1H nepeBo,na, Ha npaKTHqeCKl1e 3aHHTH51, CJIYWaJIl1 HX BbICTYIIJIeHHH Ha MHOrOqHCJIeHHbIX B TO BpeMH TeOpeTHqeCKl1X KOH<pepeHllH51X, If3yqaJIH HX CTaTbH H KHHrH.Bcex HX 51 CqHTaro CBOHMH yqHTeJIHMH.

-qTO ,na.JIa BaM npo4»ecclUI nepeBO,U'lHKa?

-B03MO)l(HOCTb MHOroe Y3HaTb (Be,nb npHxo,nHTC51 nepeBo,nHTb MaTepHaJIbI, OTHOC51IUHeC51

K caMbIM pa3HbIM 06JIaCT51M 3HaHHH), ynH,UeTb CBOro cTPaHY (MHe nOCQaCTJIHBl1JIOCb n06bIBaTb BO MHomx pecrry6JIHKaX CCCp, corrpOBO)l(,Ua51 <ppaHUY3CKl1e ,neJIerallHH) H ,npyme CTPaHbI, BCTPeQaTbCH C HHTepeCHbIMH JIIO,nbMH - yqeHbIMH, KOHCTPYKTOpaMH, KOCMOHaBTaMI1. HCnbITaTb HaCT051ruee y,nOBJIeTBOpeHHe, Kor,na crrpaBHllIbC51 C TPy,nHOH 3a,UaQeH, H a3apT, Kor,na 6epellIbC51 3a CJIO)l(Hyro pa60TY. JIHQHO MHe npO<peCCHH rrOMoma npeo,nOJIeTb HeKOTopble KOMIlJIeKCbI. ny.nyqH no npl1po,ne QeJIOBeKOM p06Kl1M H HeynepeHHbIM B ce6e, 51 I1CnbITbIBaJIa 60JIbllIHe Tpy,nHOCTH, Kor,na Ha,UO 6bmo 06paruaTbcH K 60JIbllIOH ay,nHTopHH. llPHXO,nl1JlOCb npeo,nOJIeBaTb ce651, QT06bI nOCJIe,nOBaTeJIbHO rrepeBo,nHTb ,nBYCTopOHHHe neperOBopbI, HanpHMep, <ppaHKO­ COBeTCKOH pa60QeH rpyrrnbI no llBeTHOM)' TeJIeBH,UeHHIO l1JIl1 MallIHHOCTPoeHHIO. A O,nHa)l(,UbI rrepeBo,nl1Jla BbICTYIlJIeHHe <ppaHUY3cKoH ,neJIerallHH Ha MHTHHre B rpOMa,UHOM llexe 3HJIa. MO)l(HO CKa3aTb, QTO npo<peccHH nepeBo,nQI1Ka nOMoma BbIIIpaBI1Tb xapaKTep, npH06pecTH TaKl1e KaQeCTBa, KaK KOHTaKTHOCTb, OTKPbITOCTb, ,n06pO)l(eJIaTeJIbHOcTb.

-KaKHe KHHm y Bac Bcer,na no,n PYKOH?

-llpHcTpacTHH MeHHJIHCb C B03paCTOM. nbmo BpeMH, Kor,na C JII060ro MeCTa QHTaJIa «MepT-

Bble ,nYllIH», nOTOM nOQTH Hal13YCTb BbIyql1Jla HJIb<pa H lleTpoBa. 3TO 6bmo nOBaJIbHOe YBJIeQe­ HHe. MbI C ,nPY3bHMH pa3raBapl1BaJIH llHTaTaMH, ,na)l(e He 3aKaHQHBaH l1X, H TaK Bce 6bmo nOHHT­ HO. Hy H KOHeQHO, llYWKl1H. Kor,na-TO QHTaJIa ero CTHXl1 0 MOJIO,nOCTH, ,np 6e, JIro6BH. Cero,nH51 C y,nI1BJIeHHeM 06Hap Baro cTPOKl1, Ha KOTopble paHbllIe He 06paruaJIa BHHMaHHe, a CeHQaC TPOraroT:

Ho )lHH MJIa)lble npOJIeT51T, BeCeJIMI, Hera Hac nOKHHYT, )KeJIaHMIM QYBCTBa H3MeH51T, Cep)ln:a HCCOXHYT If OCTbIHYT, Tor)la - 6e3 neceH, 6e3 nO)lPyr,

13

::,;.

Ee3 HaCJI(l)I(JJ;eHMH, 6e3 :lKeJIaHMH

HaHJJ;eM OTPaJ];Y, MMJIbIH JJ;pyr,

B mYMa1-fltOM CHe BocnOMUHaHUU!

11 3TO HarrMCaJI 20-JIeTHM:H lOHOllIa!

nO-MOeM)', MOM OTBeTbI Ha 3ry aHKery rro.rryqMJIMCb CITJIOllIHbIM TYMaHHbIM CHOM BocrrOMM-

HaHM:H.

c;

- KaKHe CJIOBapH Y Bac BCer,lJ,a no,lJ, PYKOH?

'""-J

=

- 3HUMKJIOrre,lJ,MM (6ecrro.u06HbI:H <ppaHuY3CKM:H Larousse), .uBYH3blqHble M 0.uHOH3blqHble

C2 CJIOBapM rro pa3JIMqHbIM rrpo<peCCMHM. Bce rrpMro.uMJIOCb B pa60Te. O.uHO BpeMH MHOro rrepeBO­

:: .uMJIa Ha <ppaHuY3CKM:H MOHT(l)I(Hble JIMCTbI <pMJIbMOB L(JUI 3apy6e:lKHbIX <peCTMBaJIe:H. I1Hor.ua z::

..0 rrorraJ];aJIMCb CTMXOTBopHbIe TeKCTbI - rrpMro.uMJICH CJIOBapb <ppaHuY3CKMX PM<pM. ,I:(mI <pMJIbMa 0

I- COBpeMeHHO:H MOJIO,lJ,e)l(J1 MCrrOJIb30BaJIa CJIOBapb MOCKOBCKOro apro M <ppaHUY3CKMe CJIOBapM

.....,

o apro. OqeHb JII06JIlO <ppaHuY3CKYIO 3HUMKJlOrre.uMlO Quid, BbIXO.uMBllIYlO.uO 2006 ro.ua e)l(ero.uHO,

rrOrrOJIHHBllIyIOCH HOBbIMM rrOHHTM5IMM. TaM MO:lKHO Ha:HTM Bce! B O.uHOM <pMJIbMe repo:H qMTaJI

MOJIMTBY Orqe HallI, HallIJla B Quid. .il:MITJIOMHMK rrepeBo.uMJI KHMry 0 llIBe:HuapCKMX qacax, HY:lK­ HbI 6bIJIM He TOJIbKO .ueTaJIM qaCOBOro MexaHM3Ma, HO M <paMMJIMM 3HaMeHMTbIX qaCOBmMKOB, rro­ Mor Quid. K CO)l(aJIeHMlO, Quid He BblL(ep)l(aJI KOHKYPeHUMM C I1HTepHeTOM M rrepeCTaJI BbIXO­

.uMTb.

- CaMblH TpY,lJ,IIbIH CJIY'laH B BaweH npaKTHKe?

- Tpy.uHbIX CJIyqaeB 6bIJIO MHOro M Bce OHM 6bIJIM rroyqMTeJIbHbIMM.

- CaMblH nOY'lHTeJIbHbIH cnyqaH B BaweH npaKTHKe?

- HarrpMMep, O.uHa:lKL(bI MOMM HarrapHMKOM rro CMHXPOHHO:H Ka6MHe 6bIJI Halli MOJIO.uO:H rrperrO,lJ,aBaTeJIb. 3aKOHqMB CBOlO qaCTb, $I rrepe.ualO eMY HayuIHMK M c06MpalOCb BbI:HTM M3 Ka6MHbI, KaK B.upyr OH 060paqMBaeTCH KO MHe C OCTeKJIeHeBllIMMM rJIa3aMM M, He BbIKJIlOqMB MMKpO<pOHa, MeL(JIeHHO roBOPMT: «51 HMqerO He rrOHMMalO». OpaTOp M3 fpeUMM roBOPMJI rro-<ppaHuY3CKM, M Hallia Ka6MHa 6bIJIa rrMJIOTOM. npMllIJIOCb BKJIlOqaTbCH, He YCJIbIlliaB HaqaJIa, He 3HaH, KTO BbI­ CTYIIaeT. C Tex rrop CTapaJIaCb pa60TaTb B rrape TOJIbKO C JIlO.ubMM, B KOTOPbIX 6bIJIa YBepeHa. I1JIM

.upyrO:H c.rryqa:H. 3ace.uaHMe <ppaHuY3CKO-COBeTCKO:H rpyrrrrbI (He rrOMHlO Y:lKe, rro KaKO:H TeMaTMKe) rrpoxo.uMJIO B napM)l(e, r.ue $I rrepeBo.uMJIa COBeTCKYIO CTOPOHY Ha <ppaHUY3CKM:H 513bIK, a <ppaHUY3CKM:H KOJIJIera - Ha PYCCKM:H. nOCJIe rreperoBopoB 3a CTOJIOM, rrOCemeHM5I rrpe.urrpMHTM:H 6bIJI rrO,lJ,rrMCaH rrpOTOKOJI, qTO 6bIJIO OTMeqeHO rrpMeMOM M He r.ue-HM6y.ub, a B peCTopaHe «MaKCMM». nepBbIM, eCTeCTBeHHO, BblcryrraJI <ppaHUY3CKM:H corrpe.uce.uaTeJIb, $I He CTOJIbKO CJIyuIaJIa, CKOJIb­ KO paCCMaTpMBaJIa POCKOllIHbI:H 3aJI JIereHL(apHOrO peCTopaHa. KaK B.upyr pacrrOPMMTeJIb .ueJIaeT MHe 3HaK BCTaTb M rrepeBo.uMTb, qero $I COBepllIeHHO He O)l(ML(aJIa, Be.ub $I rrepeBO:lKY COBeTCKYIO CTOPOHY! 11 BOT Tor.ua $I rrOHMa, qTO, pa60TaH, HeJIb3H paCCJIa6AATbCH, HaJ];O CJIe.uMTb 3a BceMM BbICTYIIJIeHM5IMM M 6bITb rOTOBO:H rrepeBo.uMTb B JI1060:H MOMeHT.

-BawH nO}KeJlaHH5I MOJlO,lJ,bIM KOJlJleraM?

-)l(eJIalO MM MCrrOJIb30BaTb JI106yIO B03MO:lKHOCTb, qT06bI rropa60TaTb rrepeBo.uqMKOM,

6paTbcH 3a JI106yIO pa60ry, qT06bI MMeTb 60JIbllIe rrpaKTMKM, He3aBMCMMO OT OITJIaTbI, BpeMeHM ro.ua M T.rr.! 51 He c.rryqa:HHO rOBOplO 06 3TOM. HeCKOJIbKO JIeT Ha3aJ]; $I C OrpOMHbIM Tpy.uOM HallIJla ,lJ,Byx cry.ueHTOB L(JIH pa60TbI rrepeBo.uqMKaMM Ha .il:H5IX POCC11:HCKO:H KYJIbTYPbI B HMuue, rrOTOMY qTO 6bIJI aBrycT «<3TO )I(e KaHMKYJIbI, a Kor.ua )I(e oT.ublxaTb?!»), rrOTOM)' qTO OITJIaqMBaJIMCb TOJIb­ KO .uopora, rrMTaHMe 11 OTeJIb, HO 6e3 CYTOqHbIX (<<EeCITJIaTHo? Hy HeT!»). TaK M XOqeTCH rrO-CTa­ PMKOBCKM BOCKJIMKHYTb: « B Hallie BpeMH MbI 6bI rrelliKOM rr06e)l(aJIM B HMUUY», - HO He 6y.uy...

14

'-l

- B BameM CTHXoTBopeHHH "Translation" eCTb TaKHe CYPOKH: "Able to look like my father's

 

father, squinting, / I am the hands of the Saddlemaker". PaccKIDKHTe, nO'ieMY BLI cpaBHHBaeTe CBoii

 

Tpy)1. - no:na H nepeBO)1.'1HKa - C H3fOTOBJIeHHeM ce,lJ,eJl?

 

- MHe BCer)1.a 6bIJIO HHTepeCHO CJIYUIaTb paCCKa3bI OTu;a 0 MoeM )1.e)1.e <I>oTHoce, KOToporo

U

:t:

51 HHKOma He BH)J.eJI. MOM npa)1.e)1. H )1.e)1. )!(HJIHB rpeqeCKOH )1.epeBHe fapraJIb5lHOC, a nOTOM Ha

OaTMoce. OHH 6bIJIH Ce)1.eJIbHHKaMH, )1.eJIaJIH ce)1.JIa H KO)KaHble peMHH )1.JIH naXOTHbIX JIOllIa)1.eM

 

 

H OCJIOB. 003TOMY Moero )1.e)1.a np03BaJIH CaMapaCOM ('ITO 3HaqHT «ce)1.eJIbHHK»), H KOr)1.a OH HM­

MHrpHpOBaJI B AMepHKY, Ha ocrpOBe 3JIJIHC 3anHCaJIH He ero HaCT05l1llYJO <paMHJIHIO, a np03BH­ me. OPH pemCTpaU;HH TaK qaCTO nocrynaJIH, eCJIH <paMHJIH51 Ka3aJIaCb CJIHllIKOM CJIO)KHOH.

M051 <paMHJIH5I HanOMHHaeT MHe 0 npO<peCCHH )1.e)1.a. KpOMe TOro, 51 BCer)1.a paccMarpHBaJI

TBOpqeCTBO KaK <pH3HqeCKHH rpy)1., nHCaTeJIb Be)1.b nHllIeT PYKaMH Ha 6YMare. TaK )Ke, KaK MOM z::)1.e)1. npH)J.aBaJI He06pa60TaHHOH KO)Ke <P0PMY H <PYHKUHOHaJIbHOCTb (CHaqaJIa B fpeU;HH, a nOTOM

Ha )1.y6HJIbHOM 3aBO)1.e r. Y06epHa B MaccaqyceTce), TaK H 51 nepeBo)J()' CBOH qyBcTBa B CJIOBa

L:

H npH)J.alO CJIOBaM <P0PMY H u;eHHocTb. II03T nepeBO)1.HT qYBCTBa OC060H pa3HHU;bI Me)K)J.yTeM, 'ITO )1.eJIalO 51, H TeM, 'ITO )1.eJIaJI MOH

Ha 6YMary, TaK 'ITO 51 He BH)KY )1.e)1..

- B O)1.HOM H3 BamHX HHTepBLIO BLI CKa3aJIH, 'ITO pa60Ta nHcaTeD H n03Ta - 3TO cBoe06pa3HLlii nepeBO)1..

- CTHXOTBopeHHe - 3TO nOTOK 3HeprHH. KaK nepe)1.aTb H C<pOKYCHpOBaTb 3TY 3HepmlO? B 3TOM H 3aKJIIOqaeTC51 npou;ecc «nepeBO)la» . B MOHX CTHxOTBopeHH5lX 51 nOJIHOCTblO nepeBO)J()' CBOIO )lyllIY KPOBbH Ha 061l1HH 513bIK C nOMOlllblOCJIOB. Y MeH5I eCTb CTHXOTBOpeHHe, r)1.e 51 rOBoplO 0 «nepeBO)1.e» )1.YllIH.

-KOf)1.a BLI Ha'laJIH 3aHHMaTLCB nepeBO)1.0M?

-Koma OH MHJITOH 3aKOHqHJI llIKOny, ero oTeu; nOMep)KHBaJI ero MaTepHaJIbHO ellle ceMb JIeT, qT06bI .1l.)KOH Mor CTaTb nHCaTeJIeM. MOH oTeu; C)1.eJIaJI TO )Ke caMoe )1.JIH MeH51. II03TOMY 51, B CBOIO Oqepe)1.b, 3a60THJIC51 0 CBoeM OTu;e, nOMOraJI eMY )1.0Ma H B u;epKBH. BnepBble 51 conpH­ KOCHYJIC5I C nepeBO)1.0M, KOr)1.a OTeu; yqHJI MeH51 513bIKY HallIHX npe)lKOB. 11 KOma OH nepeBO)lHJI u;epKOBHble CJIY)K6bJ Ha aHrJIHHCKHH, 51 pa60TaJI BMeCTe C HHM. 3TO 6bIJIO 3aMeqaTeJIbHOH npaK­

THKOH.

-IIo'leMY BLI nepeBeJlH n033HIO ,l1;opoca JIOH3Y H Tacoca JIHBa)J.HTHca? He MomH 6LI BLI paCCKa3aTL 06 3THX n03Tax?

-Oocne OKOHqaHH51 llIKOJIbI 51 nocrynHJI B 60CTOHCKHM KOJIJIe)l)K - XOTeJI CTaTb nHCaTeJIeM. TaM 51 H3yqaJI rpeqeCKHH 513bIK, KJIaCCHqeCKHM H COBpeMeHHbIM. 51 CJIbIllIaJI,'ITO B MoeM KOJIJIe)l)Ke

yqHJIC5I KHnpCKHH n03T .1l.opoc JIOH3Y, KOTOPblM nOTOM BepHYJIC51 Ha KHnp H nom6 B 1974 ro)1.Y, BO BpeM51 rypeU;Koro BTOp)KeHH51i . CTHXH JIOH3Y CTaJIH MOHMH nepBbIMH nepeBO)1.aMH, HX nOTOM ony6JIHKOBaJIH B aMepHKaHCKHX HaJIax. lJepe3 )1.eC51Tb JIeT, B 1988 ro.ny, KOr)1.a H )!(HJI B KOJIopa)1.o (oTu;a K TOMY BpeMeHH nepeBeJIH B )1.eHBepcKYJO enapXHIO), H npOqHTaJI HeKpOJIOr 0 rpeqeCKOM n03Te Tacoce JIHBa)1.HTHce. 51 Y)1.H­ BHJIC5I, 'ITO 3Ta BeCTb )1.0llIJIa)1.0 .1l.eHBepa H3 )1.aJIeKOM fpeU;HH. XOTH TOma 0 JIHBa)1.HTHCe51 HHqero He 3HaJI, Y MeH51 B03HHK HHTepec. KpOMe TOro, MHe 6bIJIO HeMHoro 06H)J.HO, 'ITO B AMepHKe CqH­ TaIOT, 6Y)1.TO cymecTBYJOT TOJIbKO qeTblpe rpeqeCKHX n03Ta: KaBa<pHC, Ce<pepHC, 3JIHTHC H PHU;OC. 51 3HaJI, 'ITO )1.0JI)KHbI 6bITb H )1.pyrHe, H MHe XOTeJIOCb n03HaKOMHTb C HHMH aHrJI0513bI'IHbIM MHp. 003TOMY H nOJIeTeJI B A<pHHbI, BcrpeTHJICH C ceMbeH JIHBa)1.HTHCa H nOJIyqHJI pa3pellIeHHe nepe­ BeCTH ero n033HIO. CHaqaJIa H C06HPaJIC5I nepeBecTH KHHry ero CTHXOTBopeHHH. 51 3aKOH'-lHJI nepeBO)1.bJ HeCKOJIbKHX 60JIbllIHX npOH3Be)1.eHHM H - OCTaHOBHJIC51. OKa3aJIOCb, 'ITO B pa3HbIX KYJIbrypax K nepeBO)1.qeCKOH pa60Te OTHOCHTCH no-pa3HOMY. MOH nepeBO)1.bI, BbInOJIHeHHbIe 6e3y­ npeqHO, Ony6JIHKOBaJIH B qHKarCKOM HaJIe Luna, HO ceMb51 n03Ta, )1.aB YCTHoe pa3pellIeHHe Ha

I O.n;HH H3 JlH.LJ;epOBllBillKeHIDICOL\HaJI-.n;eMOKpaTOB 311EK, II03T H IIepeBo.n;'IHKllopocJIOH3Y (DOTOS Loizou) 6bIJI y6HT CTOpOHHHKaMH XYHTbl «'IepHbIX IIOJlKOBHHKOB» . (llpUM. nep.)

16

nepeBO,IJ" He npe,IJ,OCTaBMJIa MHe nHChMeHHoro pa3peIlleml5l. Kor,IJ,a OHH npeKpaTMJIH nepenHCKY, JInepeCTaJI nepeBO,IJ,HTh. Bce npOCTO.

)Iill3Hh npenO,IJ,aJIaMHe H eme O,IJ,HH ypOK. MOH XOPOIllHH ,IJ,pyr yexaBIlIHH Ha A<pOH, npe,IJJlO- )!{}illMHe nepeBeCTH KHHry 0 COBpeMeHHOM CBSITOM ApceHHH Kanna,IJ,oKHHcKOM. 51 pa60TaJI Ha,IJ, nepeBO,IJ,OM ueJIhIH ro,IJ" coxpaHSlSl BepHOCTh H aBTOpy, H aHfJIHHCKOH CTMJIHCTHKe. BnOCJIe,IJ,CTBHH II Y3HaJI, qTO MOHaXHHH, BJIa,IJ,eBiliHe OpHrHHaJIOM, nOnpOCMJIH eIUe ,IJ,Byx HJIH rpex JIIO,IJ,eH nepeBeCTH TY )l(e caMYIO KHHry. B pe3YJIhTaTe 6hW ony6JIHKOBaH ,IJ,pyrOH nepeBO,IJ,. 51 Mor 6bI OTqaSlTb- CJI, HO BMeCTO 3Toro Sl 6JIarO,IJ,aplO CBSlToro ApceHHSl 3a TO, qTO OH CTaJI MHe ,IJ,pyrOM H nOMor ycoBepIlleHCTBOBaTb MOH nepeBO,IJ,qeCKHe HaBbIKH.

DJIarO,IJ,apH 3THM ypOKaM, 51 nOH5lJI, qTO 3a nepeBO,IJ, Ha,IJ,O 6paTbCH TOJIbKO nOCJIe nO,IJ,nHCaHHH

.l\OrOBOpa, Kor,IJ,a Bce yxe TOqHO COfJIaCOBaHO.

- ECTb J1H B COBpeMeHHOH rpe'leCKOH n033HH PHTM H pH«i»Ma? BbI HX coxpalUleTe npH nepeBO,IJ,e?

3:

C)

0-

ii!-

:::::

.9

I"-'

=

- YJI1060ro H3hIKa H JII060ro CTHxOTBopeHHSl eCTb CBOH c06CTBeHHhIH pHTM. ,lLJIH MeHH CJIOBa

I::l

If MY3bIKa Hepa3,IJ,eJIHMhI. 51 JI106JIIO n033HIO H pa60TaIO B 3TOH 06JIaCTH, OrqaCTH nOTOMY qTO

I::l

qyBCTBYIO JIIpHqeCKHH-I

CMhICJI pJ.ITMa B MY3hIKe H JIIepaTYPe-lT . fpeqeCKHe H pYCCKHe CJIOBa

 

plfcPMOBaTb 3HaqHTeJIbHO JIerqe, qeM aHfJIHHCKHe. CHCTeMa CKJIOHeHHH npHBO,IJ,HT K H306HJIH1O PlfcPM, O,IJ,HO CKJIOHHeMOe CJIOBO pH<pMyeTcH C ,IJ,pyrHM CKJIOHHeMbIM. 003TOMY 51 Bcer,IJ,a qyBCTBOBaJI, qTO B aHfJIHHCKOM B03MO)I(HOCTeH B 3TOM IIJIaHe MeHbIlle, qeM B ,IJ,pyrHX H3bIKax. 51 nOMHIO, B ,IJ,eTCTBe MHe Ka3aJIOCh crpaHHhIM, qTO K CJIOBY «love» ,IJ,OCTaTOqHO rpy,IJ,HO nO,IJ,06paTh PlfcPMY. KCTaTH, HHTepeCHO, qTO B rpeqeCKOM pa3HhIe CBoHcTBa, ypOBHH JII06BH, ee fJIy6HHa, orrHChIBalOTCH IISlTbIO pa3HhIMH CJIOBaMH.

B MOHX nepeBO,IJ,aX JIeHBa,IJ,HTHCa, JIOH3Y, CB. ApceHHSl H OaHCHH 51 OTTaJIKHBaJICH, rrpe)l(,lJ,e Bcero, OT CMhICJIa. ECJIH 3HaqeHHe B nepeBO,IJ,e He BocnpOH3BO,IJ,HTCH ,IJ,OJI)I(HhIM 06pa30M, TOr,IJ,a, ,lO'MalO, OHO nOJIHOCTbIO TepHeTCH. TOJIhKO nOCJIe nepe,IJ,aqH CMbICJIa 51 nepexoxy K pHTMy H PW<pMe (B n033HH). 51 6bI TaK OnHCaJI CBOH nepeBO,IJ,qeCKHe npHopWTeTbI: CMbICJI npe)l(,lJ,e Bcero, 3aTeM BocnpOH3Be,IJ,eHHe pHTMa, eCJIH 3TO B03MO)l(HO, a Y)l(e nOTOM pH<pMa, eCJIH eCTb B03MO)l(HOCTb. 51 BceM MOry nO)l(epTBOBaTb Pa,IJ,H coxpaHeHHH 3HaqeHHSl. ,lLJIH MeHSl HCKYCCTBO 06meHHSl - 3TO, B nepBYIO Oqepe,IJ,h, 06IUeHHe, H TOJIbKO nOTOM - HCKYCCTBO.

-Barna n0331U1 nepeBe,IJ,eHa Ha HHocTpaHHbIe B3bIKH. HeCKOJlbKO CTHXoTBopeHHH eCTb H Ha PYCCKOM. KaK BbI OTHOCHTeCb K nepeBO,IJ,aM BarnHX CTHXOB?

-OepeBO,IJ, Ha JI1060H Sl3hIK - 3TO 60JIhiliaH qeCTb ,IJ,JIB MeHSl. 51 BCer,IJ,a qYSCTBOBaJI, qTO nHillY

.lI.illIBcero MHpa, ,IJJlHcnaceHHSl H 06IUeHHH. B MoeM CTHXOTBopeHHH "No Countries But the

Distance ofthe World", ony6JIHKOBaHHoM B Paris Review, eCTb TaKHe CTPOKH: "Through language and breath, then, ; I am getting to the world. My purpose has always been the world. ; What could be the word? When all I ever wanted then was three chords ; and the truth. Not the lie that begins everything wrong. There is only ; the simple, only human dignity and we must bear the quiet witness. ; What is language but consciousness? IfI am alive, then I am alive ; to the world. IfI write, then I write for the world. I am writing ; to meet the world" . 003TOMY JII060H nepeBO,IJ, nOMoraeT MHe BcrpeTHTbcH C MHPOM, H 51 OqeHb 6JIaro,IJ,apeH nepeBO,IJ,qHKaM.

-ECTb MHeHHe, 'ITO n033HIO ,IJ,OJDKHbI nepeBO,IJ,HTb TOJlbKO n03TbI. BbI COfJIaCHbI?

-HeT, 51 TaK He ,IJ,yMalO. 0033H1O ,IJ,OJI)l(eH nepeBO,IJ,HTb TOT, KTO CB060,IJ,HO BJIa,IJ,eeT Sl3bIKOM rrepeBO,IJ,a (He OpHfHHaJIa) H, no KpaHHeH Mepe, qysCTByeT, qTO Ha,IJ,O ,IJ,eJIaTb, HaXO,IJ,5ICh B npo­ CTpaHCTBe Me)l(,lJ,y 6YKBaJIbHhIM 3HaqeHHeM H ,IJ,YXOM 3HaqeHHH. TaK )l(e, KaK MbI pa3JIHqaeM aKUeHTbI, nepeBO,IJ,qHK ,IJ,OJl)l(eH yqHTbIBaTb TOHKOCTH H3bIKa H BblpaxeHHH.

-BbI C'IHTaeTe, 'ITO n033HB nepeBO,IJ,HMa?

-COBepIlleHHO B 3TOM ysepeH. 51 qaCTO BcnOMHHalO BbICKa3hIBaHHe P06epTa <DpoCTa: «n033HSl - 3TO TO, qTO TepHeTCH B nepeBO,IJ,e» . 51 YJIhI6a1OCh H B03paxa1O C nOqTeHHeM: Sl BCer,IJ,a HaxOiJWl POBHO CTOJIhKO )l(e n033HH B nepeBO,IJ,e, CKOJIbKO ee «TepHeTCH» , no MHeHHIO <DpoCTa.

17

Koma H CTaJI CB060,ll,HO roBOPMTb M no-aHrJIMi1cKM, M no-rpeqeCKM, H )'BMeJI KpaCOT)' H3blKOBblX

COOTBeTCTBMH, «aKll,eHTOB» 3HaqeHMH, KOHHOTaU:HH. MHe KIDKeTCH, paCCTaHOBKa B n033MM TaK )I{e

Ba)I{Ha, KaK M C03,ll,aHMe.

U - KaK Bbl OTHOCHTeCb K BOJIbHblM nepeBO))'aM? HaCKOJIbKO Bbl 'lYBCTBYeTe CeOB CBOOO,ll,HbIM, ::x::KOma nepeBO,ll,HTe?

- 51 He COBceM nOHHMaIO, qTO TaKoe «BOJIbHbIH nepeBO,u» , HO, rro)l(aJl)'il:,CKaJKy, qTO q)'BCTByIO

ce651 a6COJIIOTHO CB060,ll,HbIM rrpH nepeBO,ll,e,rrOCKOJIbKY yqacTByIO B TBOpqeCKOM rrpou:ecce. 51 TaK

o

)I{e cB060,ll,eH, KOr,ll,anHIIlY CTHXOTBopeHHe B CTporOH COHeTHOH Q:>opMe. HecMoTp51 Ha

("',J

8 orrpe,ll,eJIeHHble Q:>OPMaJlbHble orpaHHqeHIDI, H qy,ll,eCHbIM 06pa30M cB060,ll,eH. TaK )I{e H B rrepeBO,ll,e.

("',J

- C KaKHMH TPY,ll,HOCTBMH Bbl CTOJIKHYJIHCb KaK nepeBO.lJ.'lHK?

0'

z::

::i3

- MHe 60JIbHO, qTO rrepeBo.uqHKOB He u:eHHT. 51 rr03HaKOMlfJI aHrJI0513bJllHbIX qHTaTeJIeH C

I-

JIHBa,ll,MTHCOM, H Mor 6bI C,ll,eJIaTb eme 60JIbIIle, rrepeBeCTll u:eJIyIO KHHry, eCJIM 6bl TOJIbKO

'-"'

 

o nOJIyqHJI pa3peIIleHHe OT ceMbM. OHH OT 3TOro BbIMrpaJIM 6bI HaMHoro 60JIbIIle, qeM H.

I:

fpYCTHO, qTO pa60Ta rrepeBO,ll,qHKa He 06eCneQHBaeTC51 ,ll,OJl)I{HbIM 06pa30M. 51 3HaIO, qTO Bce

rrepeBO,ll,bI peJIMrM03HbiX TeKCTOB, KOTopbre H qMTaJI, He OIIJIaqMBaJlMCb. ll03TOMY ,ll,eB51HOCTO rrpou:eHTOB TaKMX rrepeBO,ll,OB, BbmOJIHeHHbIX HerrpOQ:>eCCMOHaJlaMH, - npOCTO Cblpble. 51 nOMHIO O,ll,HH nepeBO,ll,JIHTYPrHH, Ha,ll,KOTOPbIM HBHO rropa60TaJla u:eJIaH rpyrrrra rrepeBO,ll,qMKOB. Dbmo BI1)lHO, r,ll,e3aKOHqlfJI O,ll,HH nepeBO,ll,qHK M HaqaJI ,upyrOH. lleqaJIbHaH MCTOpIDI.JII060H rrHCaTeJIb, 6y,ll,bTO aBTOp lfJIH nepeBO,ll,qHK, yqHTC51 CKpblBaTb IIlBbI.

- KaK Obi Bbi CcjlOPMYJIHPOBaJIH CBOH nepeBO)J,'leCKHe npHHlI,Hnbl?

- He06xo,ll,MMO rrpe)I{,ll,eBcero YBa)I{aTb pa60TY aBTopa. llepeBO,ll,HTb ,ll,YIIlYTeKCTa. lJ)'BCTBOBaTb aTMocQ:>epy, MHToHaU:MIO, aKll,eHTbI TeKCTa. lloHMMaTb, KaK CJIe,ll,OBaTb 0pHrMHaJlY M KaK OTXO,ll,HTb OT 6yKBbi. He CTaHOBMTbC51 Q:>apHceeM. 3TO M3JIMIIlH5lH CTPOroCTb. Ha,ll,onpOCTO OCTaBaTbCH BepHbIM TeKCT)' M n03BOJIMTb eMY BeCTH Te6H.

- Oopa3bl HrpalOT KJIIO'IeByIO pOJIb B n033HH. C 'IeM Obi Bbl MOrJIH cpaBHHTb nepeBO))'?

- llepeBO,ll,3TO- ,ublxaHHe, OT,ll,aqa, 06meHHe, o60rameHMe. llepeBO,ll"nO,ll,06HOrr033MM, 3TO caMoe BbICOKoe YCTPeMJIeHMe qeJIOBeKa.

- nOCJIe,ll,HBBCTpOKa B BameM CTHXOTBOpeHHH "Translation" - "Your language returned to you". IIepeBo))' MO)K)lO nOHHMaTb KaK cBoeoopa3Hoe B03Bpam,eHHe oom,ero B3blKa JIIO)J,BM.

- 3T0 npeKpaCHaH HHTepnpeTaU:IDI! 51 aBTOp, KOTOPblH roBOPMT: «J1HTepnpeTaU:MH qMTaTeAA - 3TO npaBlfJIbHaH HHTeprrpeTaU:IDI».

"lhmslation" by Nicholas Samaras (published in

The rock's grey place is precise and phrases everything

else.

Be ginger.

Sit on the green hill, the high view sloping in declension.

Watch the movement of trees.

The cursive branches.

Verb of the wind over a whitened plain.

I am home. And lost. My hands on my knees. This paper. These words.

Able to look like my father's father, squinting, I am the hands of the Saddlemaker.

Hands ofth eSaddlemaker, 1 992)

Rising up the olive slope, the sound

of mule bells tonguing.

On the parchment of land, bodies, what is rendered

by the creased text in a worker's palms, the blunt eyes of ancient pictures.

I send this. Your language returned to you.

HHmepOblO u nepeooiJ ,a. T. lllam(J/looa

18

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]