Дрёмов С.В., Сёмин И.Р. - Измененные состояния сознания

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

.G 34+:/8/=/2 + 34+:+5.*/2 (Adams et al., 1976; Halifax, 1979; Walsh, 1990) . *+ E./, 2 @3/.*-78--

1+- 22/D+.4; 3/1;.+- "+C,-1-11G- 4/4./;1+; 4/C151+;", 6/./*/-, 656 3*-D4.528;-.4;, 43/4/71/ :5*56.-*+C/25.A 6*+C+4 + 2G:/D +C 1-=/, 1- 3*+7-=5; 6 C52-D/,/ 35./8/=+9-46+, /7/C159-1+;,. ( +1-2+9, *€,/2, 1994).

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

121

*/:/D; 3@.A E6C+4.-1F+58A1/=/ 2/C*/ID-1+;, <5,51 /D1/2*-,-11/ + -4.-4.2-11G, /7*5C/, 4/- 4*-D/./9+25-. 2 42/+: *@65: 24H D@:/21@H I+C1A */D5. H7/- *+.@58A1/- D-04.2+-, 2G3/81;-,/- <5,51/,, +,--. D2/01/0 4,G48 - 456*58A1G0 + C*-8+?1G0. B/*,8-1+- /7*5C/2, 42;C@H?+: 98-1/2 6/88-6.+25 ,-ID@ 4/7/0, 4/ 42/+,+ ,+B/8/=+9-46+,+ 3*-D65,+, + C159+., 4 /6*@I5H?-0 D-04.2+.-8A1/4.AH, ;28;-.4; 3-*-2/D/, 15 ;CG6 4/2*-,-11/4.+ 3*-I1+: *-=@8;.+21G: ,-:51+C- ,/2. 85=/D5*; E./,@ 65IDG0 98-1 */D/2/=/ 6/88-6.+25 4.51/2+.4; 43/4/71G,, .56 465C5.A, C51/- 2/ 150.+ 3/D:/D 6 =8@7/950<+, +4./91+65, I+C1+, 6/./*G- +1597G8+ 7G 3/.-*;1G. 4+,2/8+- 9-46/0 6/,,@1+65F++ <5,515 4 .-,, 9./ 1-3/4*-D4.2-11/ 1-D/4.@31/ D*@=+, 98-15, */D5, 4/4./- +. 4/F+58A15; C159+,/4.A -=/ */8-2/=/ 3/2-D-1+;. -, 7G /1 1+ C51+,584;, 7@DA ./ 4-C/11G- 5=- *5*1G- F-*-,/1++, 3*/2/DG D@<+ @,-*<-=/ 2 3/.@4./*/11+- ,+*G +8+ 8-9-715; 3*56.+65, /1 24-=D5 C51;. ./8A6/ /D1+, - 2/C*/ID-1+-, + 3-*-2/D/, "152-*:" E6C+4.-1F+58A1/ C159+,G: D8; 6/88-6.+25 ,/.+2/2. E./0 F-8AH +43/8AC@H.4; *5C1//7*5C1G- 4*-D4.25, 6/./*G,+ <5,51 D/8- I-1 285D-.A 2 4/2-*<-14.2-. "'5,5146/- 65,851+- 153/,+15-. D*5,5.+9-46/- 3*-D4.528-1+- 1-

./8A6/ 21-<1-, 3/ .+3@ D-04.2+;, 3/ 4/D-*I51+H, B@16F+;,, 1/ + 3/ ./0 =8@7/6/ 21@.*-11- 4:/D- 1/0 4 56.-*46/0 34+:/8/=+9-46/0 /41/2- .2/*9-46/0 D-;.-8A1/4.+ <5,515, 3/ /4/7/,@ :@D/I-4.- 2-11/,@ ,G<8-1+H (43/4/71/4.+ ,G48+.A 9@24.2-11G,+ /7*5C5,+ + /7*5?5.A4; 6 C53545, 3*-I- 1+: 3-*-I+251+0)" ( -2@1-16/25, 1992, 4.145).

56+, /7*5C/,, 15 <5,51+4.+9-46/, E.53- 6@8A.@*1/0 +4./*++ ,G ,/I-, 1578HD5.A, 656 2 6/8- 8-6.+21/-+1D+2+D@58A1/, 2C5+,/D-04.2++ @4.51528+25H.4; 42/-/7*5C1G- /.1/<-1+; 43*/45 + 3*-D8/I-1+;. C7*511+6, 3-*-I+25; 6*+C+4 5@./+D-1.+B+65F++, @D/28-.2/*;; +1D+2+D@58A1G- E6C+4.-1F+58A1G- 3/.*-71/4.+, 3/8@95-. 2 +./=- 1/2G0 4/F+58A1/-*/8-2/0 4.5.@4, 5 6/88-6.+2, 3/7@ID5; 1-/B+.5 6 3*+1;.+H 1/2/0 */8+, @4.51528+25-. 9-*-C 1-=/ D+5:*/1+9-46@H 42;CA 4 3*-D65,+, 3/8@95-. ,+B/8/=+9-46+- (2 7/8-- <+*/6/, 4,G48- - +D-/8/=+9-46+-) 3/D.2-*ID-1+; 42/-0 4.57+8A1/4.+, 9@24.2/ 1-48@9501/4.+ 42/-=/ 4@?-4.2/251+; + @6*-38;-.4; 2 E6C+4.-1F+- 58A1/0 C5?+?-11/4.+.

" *+,-1+.-8A1/ 6 <5,51@ 3*-D-8A1/ C5/4.*-1G 24- ,+*/2/CC*-19-46+- 65.-=/*++. <5,51656 7@D./ + 1-. 1+9-=/ .56/=/, 9-=/ 1-8AC; 7G8/ 7G /715*@I+.A @ +1G: 456*58A1G: 8+F. D156/ 24- E.+ 659-4.25 + 42/04.25 ;28-1G 2 <5,51- 42-*: ,-*G --=/ /4/7-11/4.+ 2/43*+;.+; ,+*5, 6/1.56.G 4 3*-D65,+ + D@:5,+, I+C1-D-;.-8A1G- 3/.-1F++, 285D-1+- 48/2/, + ..D. /C,/I1/, 49+.58/4A, 9./ <5,51 /785D5-. .56+, 7/=5.4.2/, -?- + 3/./,@, 9./ -=/ "D/1/*/," 4.51/2+.4; 2-4A */D" ( 5- =585-2, 6.;7*A465;, 1990, 4.96). +3/8/=+9-46+ 78+C6/- ;28-1+-, 6/=D5 "D2+I-1+- 9-8/2-65 6 4/7- 4.2-11/0 F-8/4.1/4.+ + =5*,/1++ +,--. +4./*+9-46+0 EBB-6.", 6/=D5 "+1D+2+D@58A1/4.A /7*-9-- 15 15 +4./*+9-46+- D-04.2+;" ( /7*/25, 1997, 4.109), ,G @I- *544,5.*+258+ 2 42;C+ 4 8+91/4.AH-/15*D/ D5 +19+. *@=/0 E.1+9-46+0 6/1.-64. E3/:+ /C*/ID-1+; 8+<A 15685DG25-. 42/+ 6@8A-

.@*1G- /4/7-11/4.+ 15 51.*/3/8/=+9-46@H C56/1/,-*1/4.A +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ *5C2+.+;, @I- 48/- I+2<@H4; 2 <5,51+C,-: /7*-.-1+- 154./;?-0 +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+ 1- 3*+43/4/78-1+-, 6 .*-7/25- 1+;, 56.@58A1/=/ 4/F+@,5, 5 9-*-C 4/F+58A1/ C159+,/- 3/2./*-1+- 6/88-6.+21G: 43/4/7/2 D/4-

.+I-1+; E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 C5?+?-11/4.+. 56 7G8/ /.,-9-1/, E./ 4.51/28-1+- 4/3*/2/ID5-.4; *54<+*-1+-, 45,/4/C151+; + /B/*,8-1+-, 2 4/74.2-11/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ "574/8H.1/=/ " - 3*/-

./.+35 4/F+58+C+*@H?+: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0. D-*I+,/4.A +C7*511+65 D@:/,-3/6*/2+.-8-,,

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

122

.+21/4.AH (4 "574/8H.1G, "), 48@I5?-- F-8;, 6/88-6.+21/0 , 4.51/2+.4; 1/2G, 2 6@8A.@*1/0 +4./*++ +1D+2+D@58A1G, 43/4/7/, 4/F+58A1/0 5D53.5F++.

D-4A, 3/I58@0, @,-4.1G D/7528-1+; 6 *544@ID-1+;, . 43-*45 (1991, 4.32) / .56 15CG25-,/, /4-2/, 2*-,-1+, 4//.2-.4.2@H?-, 45,/,@ *-C6/,@ 3/2/*/.@ 2 +4./*++, 6/=D5 3/;2+84; 9-8/2-6

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

[11]/=8541/ *5C1G, 52./*5,, 2+.58A1/- 45,/4/C151+- - E./ ".-,1G-" /?@?-1+;, 6/./*G- 4/3*/- 2/ID5H. 2+.58A1G- 3*/F-44G ( . . -9-1/2); /7?-- 9@24.2/ 4@?-4.2/251+; ( . 43-*4); 9@24.2/ 4/74.2-11/=/ , 6/./*/- +49-C5-., 4/=8541/ .'150D-*@, ./8A6/ 4 2G68H9-1+-, 4/C151+;; 4-14/*- 1/-3-*F-3.+21G0 @*/2-1A ( . . -=*57;1); 4/,5./8/=+9-465; +D-1.+B+65F+; 8+91/4.+ ( . . 58+,/2).

[12]/D/71/=/ ,G 1- 2+D+, D5I- 2 /.4./;?-, /. <5,51+C,5 15 ,1/=+- 2-65 4/2*-,-11/, /7?-- 4.2-. -B/*,5 !. +1-88;. /42/7/D+2 D@<-21/7/8A1/=/ +C B+C+9-46+: /6/2, 1- 4D-8585 -=/ 42/- 7/D1-0 4/F+58A1/ + 34+:/8/=+9-46+. 5I- 4/2*-,-11G- *-57+8+.5F+/11G- 3*/=*5,,G 1- 4,/=8+

3*+78+C+.A4; 6 *-<-1+H E./0 C5D59+. [13] " .@ /4A, - 3+<-. . 43-*4 (1991, 4.32-33), - 48-D@-. +465.A .5,, =D- 2/C1+68+ 3*-D3/4G86+, 3/C2/8+2<+- 9-8/2-6@ 4.5.A .56+,, 656/2 /1 -4.A... -*-D 1+, /.6*G25-.4; @I54 ,+*5 + 4/74.2-1- 15; 7-43/,/?1/4.A. ./; 15D 3*/354.AH, /1 4.52+. *5D+658A1G- 2/3*/4G, .*-7@-. /42/7/ID-1+; + 4354-1+;. 4/C1525; 42/+ =*51+FG, /1 4.52+. 3-*-D 4/7/0 2G4<+- F-8+, 3/C15-. 574/8H.1/4.A 2 =8@7+15: 45,/4/C151+;".

7 * # ' # & ' & -

2 5

$ ... , $. %, ! % 2 !2 , , $

,- !23 , .

, %

7*5?-1+- 6 43-F+58+4.@ C5 3/,/?AH 42+D-.-8A4.2@-. / C5.*@D1-1+;: 15 3@.+ *5C2+.+; 9-8/2-- 65 + / 158+9++ D-C5D53.+21G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0. E./0 42;C+ 34+:/.-*53+; + 34+:+5.*+9-465; 3*56.+65 42/+,+ C5D595,+ D/8I1G 4.52+.A +C,-1-1+- 45,/4/C151+; 35F+-1.5 15 7/8-- 5D53.+2-

123

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

48+ /7*5.+.A4; 6 +4./65, 34+:+5.*+9-46+: ,-./D/2 8-9-1+;, ./ ,/I1/ @2+D-.A, 656 @I- ./=D5 3*+,-1;8+4A </6/2G- ,-./DG, 153*528-11G- B56.+9-46+ 15 56.+2+C5F+H D+15,+6+ + 2G2-- D-1+- 7/8A1/=/ +C 4/4./;1+; 35./8/=+9-46/=/ *521/2-4+;. *5?5.-8A1G- ,5<+1G + 6/8-45, /7- 8+251+- :/8/D1/0 2/D/0, 15C159-1+- *2/.1G: 4*-D4.2 + 3*/9. 7G8+ ,/?1G,+ 4*-D4.25,+ +C,-- 1-1+; E64.-*/- + +1.-*/F-3F++, 153*528-11G,+ 15 +1D@6F+H . -=/D1;, 9./7G 15*@<+.A C5- 4./01@H D+15,+6@ +C,-1-11G: 4/4./;1+0 4/C151+;, +43/8AC@H.4; 7/8-- F+2+8+C/2511G- (/42;- ?-11G- -4.-4.2-11/15@91/0 35*5D+=,/0) ,-./DG - E8-6.*/- + +14@8+1/</6/25; .-*53+;. 60-- ==. 7G8/ <+*/6/ *543*/4.*51-1/ +43/8AC/251+- 34+:/8+.+9-46/0 .-*53++ 34+:/C/2, 5 2 154./;?-- 2*-,; E./ /4.5-.4; .-*53+-0 2G7/*5 *5C1/=/ */D5 C52+4+,/4.-0. */2/D+8+4A E643-*+,-1.G 3/ +43/8AC/251+H 2 8-9-1++ <+C/B*-1++ 4-14/*1/0 +C/8;F++, =D- /41/21G, .-*53-2.+9-46+, 4*-D- 4.2/, 2G4.@3585 +1D@6F+; (Brownfield, 1965). C2-4.1G 3*+,-1-1+- "5,B-.5,+1/2/=/ </65" 2 8-9-1++ +4.-*++ ( +8E0, -1+6-*, 1963) + 3/3G.6+ +43/8AC/251+; +1.-*-6@**-1.1G: +1./64+65- F+/11G: 34+:/C/2 (D-8+*+/C1/=/ +C,-1-1+; 4/C151+;) 2 8-9-1++ .-*53-2.+9-46+ *-C+4.-1.1G: B/*, <+C/B*-1++ ( 5I+1, 1968). *+,-1;-,G- 2 4/2*-,-11/0 34+:/B5*,56/8/=++ ,-./DG 15- C159-1+; ,564+,58A1G: D/C + /D1/,/,-1.1/0 /.,-1G 3*-35*5./2 +,-H. 3/D 4/7/0, 2+D+,/, .- I- /41/251+; - "*54659+251+-" C54.G2<-0 D+15,+6+ . *-D+ .-:1+9-46+: 4*-D4.2 D8; .-*53-2.+- 9-46/=/ 152-D-1+; +43/8AC/258+4A + +43/8AC@H.4; 7+/8/=+9-46+ /7*5.15; 42;CA ( 3+256, 1992), 5@D+/-2+C@58A15; 4.+,@8;F+; (Brauchly et al., 1995; -*+6/2, *€,/2, €,+1 + D*., 1998).-*-9+48-11G- 3*+,-*G, 6/./*G- ,/I1/ 3*/D/8I5.A, +88H4.*+*@H. D-04.2-11/4.A 4.5*/=/ =/-

124

,-/35.+9-46/=/ 3*+1F+35: "3/D/71/- 8-9+.4; 3/D/71G,". 54.G2<5; D+15,+65 + 35./8/=+- 9-465; B+645F+; 45,//./ID-4.28-1+0 35F+-1.5 3*-/D/8-25H.4; +1D@6F+-0 +C,-1-11G: 4/4./;- 1+0 4/C151+;.

159+,G, 5*=@,-1./, 2 3/8AC@ /3*-D-8-1+; 656 .-*53-2.+91G:. +, 2 6/1-91/, 49-.-, 5D53-

.+*@H?+: 48@I+. D/7*/659-4.2-11/4.A 1/C/8/=+9-46+: B/*,, 4/9-.511G: 4 3-*-I+251+-, +1.-1- 4+21G: +C,-1-1+0 45,/4/C151+;. . -D@15, 2GD-8;; 48@95+ 4 /1-0*/+D1G, +C,-1-1+-, 4/C151+; 2 45,/4./;.-8A1@H 1/C/8/=+9-46@H =*@33@ 3/D 15C251+-, "/1-0*/B*-1+;", /.,-958 -- D/7*/65- 9-4.2-11/4.A + 2/C,/I1/4.A 3/81/=/ 2GCD/*/28-1+;. 4/7/- ,-4./ 2 /74@ID5-,/0 .-,- ,/I1/ 7G8/ 7G /.2-4.+ 43-F+58A1/,@ +C@9-1+H /1-0*/+D1G: , 15+7/8-- 954./ 1578HD5-,G: 3*+ 45,/0 D/7*/659-4.2-11/0 3-*+/D+9-46/0 B/*,- <+C/B*-1++. /I1/ 243/,1+.A + / .56 15CG25-- ,/0 =*E.-*/246/0 B/*,- <+C/B*-1++. 56 3*-D4.528;-.4;, 1-,58/25I1@H */8A 2 -- 785=/3*+;.- 1/, .-9-1++ +=*5H. *-=@8;*1G- +1D@6F++ 4 3/,/?AH 586/=/8;.

48+ 7G C5 +43/8AC@-,G,+ ,-./D5,+ + /4/7-11/4.;,+ .-9-1+; 1-6/./*G: C57/8-251+0 /715*@- I+258/4A /7?-- 3*/4.*514.2/ 42;C511G: 4 3*/78-,, ./ *-<-1+- ,1/=+: 954.1G: 2/3*/4/2 34+:+5.*+9-46/0 .-/*++ + 3*56.+6+ +,-8/ 7G, 2/C,/I1/, 7/8-- 3*/D@6.+21/- *5C2+.+-. D156/

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

.-8A1/ 8@9<-, 3*/=1/C- 3*+ "3*/*57/.6-" 4+,3./,5.+6+ 2 *5C2-*1@./, /1-0*/+D-, 9-, 2 48@95;:, 6/=D5 /1 /4.51528+25-.4; 15 7*-D/2/, E.53- *5C2+.+; ( ./;1/2, 1961; 6/3/25, 1965).

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

./ D-85-. 2/C,/I1G, 1- ./8A6/ 4/3/4.528-1+-, 153*+,-*, 4/4./;1+0 <5,515 4 3-*-I+251+;,+ 15<+: 4/2*-,-11+6/2, 1/ + /.6*G25-. 3-*43-6.+2G 6 <+*/6+, ,-ID+4F+38+15*1G, /7/7?-1+;,.*+,-95.-8A1G 2 E./0 42;C+ *57/.G / .&1=- + . 588+251-, 6*+C+41G- 4/4./;1+; 6/./*G: *5C- 2+8+4A 1- 2 4@,54<-4.2+-, 5 2 .-*53-2.+9-46+- 4+4.-,G (Senn, 1989; Goldwert, 1992). E./ 8+<A /.D-8A1G-, 15+7/8-- 78+C6+- +4./*+9-46+ + 3*/B-44+/158A1/, 3*+,-*G @D52<-04; E6C+4.-1F+-

125

58A1/0 5D53.5F++, 6/./*G- 4 <5,5146/0 .*514B/*,5F+-0 /7R-D+1;-. ,/.+2 3*-/D/8-1+; 34+:/-

.+9-46/=/ 6*+C+45 2 4/F+58A1/ C159+,/0 */8+.

9-2+D1/, 9./ 3*-D8/I-11G0 .-/*-.+9-46+0 5158+C 2 42;C+ 4 E3+4.-,/8/=+9-46+,+ + E6C+- 4.-1F+58A1/-51.*/3/8/=+9-46+,+ 543-6.5,+ 34+:/35./8/=++, 6@8A.@*1/-+4./*+9-46+,+ E646@*45- ,+ 2 34+:/8/=+H *511+: 6@8A.@* ,/I-. +,-.A 3*56.+9-46+0 +1.-*-4 8+<A 3*+ 158+9++ 5D-625.1G: ,-ID+4F+38+15*1G: + ,-I6@8A.@*1G: 3-*-:/D/2.

34+:/.-*53++ 656 48/I+2<+04; B56. ,/I1/ /.,-.+.A D/4.5./91/ @4./09+2G- 35*588-8+ .-*5- 3-2.+9-46/0 3*/F-D@*G 4 +1+F+5F+-0 (Stein, Stein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possesion).

-4/,1-11G 3/8/I+.-8A1G- ,/,-1.G *-8;.+2+C,5. 3*+,-*@, ,G @I- 4/ C159+.-8A1/0 D/8-0 6*+.+6+ ,/I-, /.1/4+.A4; 6 2G465CG251+;, / ./,, 9./ 6@8A.@*G 4 ,5=+9-46/0 6/1B+=@*5F+-0 46*G25H. 85.-1.1G- 7*-D/2G- *544.*/04.25, 1/ 6@8A.@*G 4 *5F+/158A1/0 15@91/0 /*+-1.5F+-0 *543/C15H. 34+:/.+6/2 (Kaplan, Sadok, 1982). *5146@8A.@*1G- +448-D/251+;, 3*/2/D+,G- 2 4/- 2*-,-11G: + .*5D+F+/11G: /7?-4.25:, 6/**-6.+*@H. 68+1+9-46+- 3*-D4.528-1+; 3/8/I-1+-, / 25*+57-8A1/4.+ 34+:/35./8/=++ 2 E.1+9-46/, + +4./*+9-46/, 3*/4.*514.25: (Spanos, 1978; Saeed, 1987). E./0 42;C+ 45,/ @3/.*-78-1+- 4/2*-,-11/=/ .-*,+15 "7*-D/2G- *544.*/04.25" D8; /F-16+ ;28-1+0 5*:5+91/0 6@8A.@*G 2G=8;D+. 1-6/**-6.1/, 5 +1.-*3*-.5F+; 3/2-D-1+; <5- ,515 2 68+1+9-46+: .-*,+15: - 1-=*5,/.1/.

-ID@ .-,, 6@8A.@*1G0 *-8;.+2+C, 3*-D4.528;-. 4/7/0 @4.@36@ 3*/78-,5, ,-I6@8A.@*1/=/ 3-*-- 1/45 +, 656 3*-D4.528;-.4;, ,G 2 *-C@8A.5.- /3*-D-8-1+; 51.*/3/8/=+9-46+: @1+2-*458+0

,/I-, +D.+ D58A<-. 5D+658A15; *-8;.+2+4.465; 3/C+F+; 1- 23/81- 2G*5I5-. 4685DG25H?+-4; +C 6@8A.@*B+8/4/B46/=/ + 34+:/8/=+9-46/=/ +C@9-1+; 3*-D4.528-1+;, 4 @9-./, 6/./*G: 3/- +46 6@8A.@*1G: 3*+C156/2 34+:+9-46/=/ CD/*/2A; + ,-I6@8A.@*1G- .*5148;F++ 43/4/7/2 -=/ D/4-

.+I-1+; 1- 3*/.+2/*-95. B56.@ 6@8A.@*1G: *5C8+9+0. ./7G 3/1;.A E./, 1-/7:/D+,/ 2+D-.A, 9./ 6@8A.@*1G0 *-8;.+2+C, 34+:/8/=+9-46/0 51.*/3/8/=++ 3*-D4.528;-. 4/7/0 E3+4.-,/8/=+9-46@H 5158/=+H 3*+1F+35 6/12-1F+58A1/4.+ 2 34+:+5.*++. /12-1F+58+C, /.4.5+25-. 6*+.-*++ @1+- 658A1/4.+ 35./8/=++, 9-.6/=/ /.=*51+9-1+; -- /. 1/*,G 15 /41/2- 4/F+/6@8A.@*1G: 3*-D4.528-- 1+0 / 1/*,5.+21/,. ./ I- 2*-,;, -48+ ,G 4.52+, 2/3*/4 /7 51.*/3/8/=+9-46+: 6*+.-*+;: 1/*- ,G, ./ 3*+1F+3 6/12-1F+58A1/4.+ 2 34+:+5.*++ @4.5*-25-., 656 E./ 3*/+C/<8/ 2 34+:/8/=+9-46/0 51.*/3/8/=++ 4 6@8A.@*1G, *-8;.+2+C,/,. *@=+,+ 48/25,+, -48+ ,G =/2/*+, / 1/*,5.+21/, 2 51.*/3/8/=+9-46/, 4,G48-, ./ 2/C,/I1/4.A ,-I6@8A.@*1/0 .*5148;F++ 43/4/7/2 D/4.+I-1+; 34+- :+9-46/=/ CD/*/2A; 4.51/2+.4; *-58A1/4.AH.

126

- 48@9501/ E./. 2/3*/4 3/D1+,5-.4; 2 42;C+ 4 <5,51+C,/,. '5,51+4.+9-465; 6@8A.@*5 - E./ 1-

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

+3/8/=+9-46+- 35*588-8+ ,-ID@ <5,5146/0 7/8-C1AH + 34+:+9-46+, *544.*/04.2/, (42/-/7*5- C+- 3*-,/*7+D5, 5@.+C5F+;, 3*/D@6.+215; 4+,3./,5.+65, 15*@<-1+; 2 3/2-D-1++, 3*/=*-D+-1.- 1/4.A *544.*/04.2, 1578HD5-,5; @ <5,51/2 7-C 3*56.+6+ + ..3.) 3/C2/8;-. 465C5.A, 9./ 4 "<5,5146+, D5*/," @ 4/2*-,-11G: 35F+-1./2 24- 2 3/*;D6-. 1+ 3/D2-*I-1G , +43G.G25H. .- I-

.-1D-1F++ *5C2/38/?-1+; 4 4/F+58A1G,+ +D-1.+B+65F+;,+, .56 I- /.6*G.G 3*-D-8A1G, +C,-- *-1+;, 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ + .56 I- +?@. 45,/./ID-4.2-11/4.+ 2/ 21-8+91/4.1G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65- F+;:. 548-D4.2-115; 3*-D*543/8/I-11/4.A 48@I+. -?- /D1+, 3/2/D/, 6 4*521-1+H 35F+-1./2 34+:+5.*5 4 1-/B+.5,+, 3*+C2511G,+ 6 <5,5146/,@ 48@I-1+H.

4.51/2+,4; 15 2./*/, 2GD-8-11/, . . '5.+8/2G, 3@16.- + 3/3*/7@-, /.2-.+.A 15 2/3*/4 /

./,, 9-,@ ,G ,/I-, 15@9+.A 7@D@?-=/ "<5,515". 4.-4.2-11/, *-9A +D-. 1- / 3/D=/./26- 6@8A./- 2/=/ D-;.-8; (E./ 3*/78-,5 /7*5C/251+;, 6545H?5;4; 46/*-- 34+:+5.*/2 + 34+:/.-*53-2./2), 5 / 3/,/?+, 6/./*@H 43-F+58+4. ,/I-. 3*-D/4.52+.A 9-8/2-6@ 4 +C,-1-11G, 45,/4/C151+-,.

34+:+5.*+9-46/0 + 34+:/.-*53-2.+9-46/0 3*56.+65: +,38+F+.1/ 3*+4@.4.2@-. +D-58 1/*,G, 3*-D3/85=5H?+0 21@.*-11HH +1.-=*+*/2511/4.A (F-8/4.1/4.A) + 43/4/71/4.A 6 *5C2+.+H. /1;-

.+; F-8/4.1/4.+ + *5C2+.+; 1- 1/2G. D156/ + F-8/4.1/4.A, + *5C2+.+-, /4/C1525-,G- 2 6/1.-64.- C535D1G: 15@91G: 35*5D+=,, +,-H. 3*-D-8 2 4/F+58A1/ 5D53.+*/2511/, +1D+2+D- + /=*51+9+25- H.4; D/4.+I-1+-, 4/F+58A1/-1/*,5.+21/=/ @*/21; +D-1.+B+65F++. 56 3+<-. . 4-:42;.46+0

127

(1995, 4.28): " *+ 24-, ,1/=//7*5C++ *5C*57/.511G: .-:1+6 + 3/D:/D/2 7/8A<+14.2/ 2-.2-0 34+- :/.-*53++ D/4.5./91/ 1-21;.1/ /.2-95H. 15 2/3*/4 / 15958A1/0 + 6/1-91/0 ./96- .-*53-2.+9-- 46/=/ 3*/F-445". 42;C+ 4 E.+, 43*52-D8+2G, C5,-951+-, 52./* 3*-D4.528;-. ,/D-8A .56 15CG- 25-,/0 E2/8HF+/11/ /*+-1.+*/2511/0 34+:/.-*53++.

/ 42/-0 4./*/1G ,G ,/I-, 465C5.A 48-D@H?--. *+1+,5;, 9./ D/4./+14.25 954.1G: + 78+I50- <+: F-8-0 .-*53++ /3*-D-8;H.4; +: /.1/<-1+-, 6 /7?-0 + 3/48-D1-0 F-8+ E2/8HF+/11/=/ *5C- 2+.+; 4/C151+;, ,G 23*52- +43/8AC/25.A 6@8A.@*B+8/4/B46+- D511G- 3/ 3*/78-,- 4@7R-6.+21/- 4.+ + *-C@8A.5.G 6@8A.@*1/-+4./*+9-46/=/ +C@9-1+; . *+ E./, 3*56.+9-46+0 2/3*/4 / F-8;:

.-*53++ 3*-D85=5-.4; *544,/.*-.A 2 42;C+ 4 /7?+, 2/3*/4/, / F-8+ *5C2+.+; 4/C151+;. /43/8A- C@-,4; D8; E./=/ 3*-D4.528-11/0 *51-- 4:-,/0 *5C2+.+; +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ 4/C151+;.

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b) 3*+21/4;. 9@24.2/ C5?+?-11/4.+ 3-*-D 74/8H./,.

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

.-1.1G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 15 3*-I1+0 4/F+58A1/-*/8-2/0 @*/2-1A, /=*51+9-11G0 /.*-C6/, -. 4:/D; +C E.+: /41/2/3/85=5H?+: 3@16./2, *544,/.*+, /41/21G- /*+-1.+*G .-*53-2.+9-46/0 3/,/?+.

34+:/.-*53++ 34+:/C/2 D/8I1G +43/8AC/25.A4; 3*-D4.528-1+; /7 51.*/3/8/=+9-46/0 1/*,5.+2- 1/4.+ 85.-1.1G: @*/21-0 4/C151+;. .+ 3*-D4.528-1+; 43/4/74.2@H. ./8-*51.1/4.+ 6 85.-1.1G, 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+;, + 3*+1;.+H +: E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 C159+,/4.+ D8; 35F+-1.5. 3*/.+21/, 48@95- -=/ 85.-1.1G- 45,/+D-1.+B+65F++ -?- 7/8A<- /.D58;H.4; /. 4/F+58A1/-*/8-2/=/ @*/21; + 3*/4.*514.2/ 21@.*-11-0 *5CD2/-11/4.+ (*544./;1+- ,-ID@ @*/21;,+ b--) @2-8+9+25-.4;. /8-- *51.1/4.A 1-,G48+,5 21- 4@7R-6.-4@7R-6.1G: /.1/<-1+0, 7-C 4/3*+954.1/4.+, 6/./*5;, 3/I. -82@D@ (1996, 4.269), /C1595-. 8H7/2A 6 4@?-4.2/251+H D*@=/=/, ./ -4.A 8H7/2A 46/*-- 6 4@- ?-4.2@, 1-I-8+ 6 8+91/4.+. /=8541/ I. -82@D@, 2 ,/,-1.G 4/3*+954.1/4.+ ",1- D/4.@31G =8@- 7+1G ,/-=/ 4/74.2-11/=/ 7G.+; + 2 ./ I- 2*-,; =8@7+1G 7G.+; 35*.1-*5".

8; 35F+-1.5 @4.51/28-1+- 4@7R-6.1G: /.1/<-1+0 4 6-,-8+7/ +C /6*@I-1+; I+C1-11/ 25I1/, 3/- 46/8A6@ 43/4/74.2@-. 3*+1;.+H 9@I/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ + /D1/2*-,-11/ 3*/1+F5-,/4.+ 4/74.2-1- 1/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+, =D- 4 3/,/?AH 43-F+58+4.5 ,/I-. 7G.A 6/1F-3.@58+C+*/251/ 5D-625.1/- D8; 2C5+,/D-04.2+; 4 74/8H./, "574/8H.1/- ". 3*/.+21/, 48@95- 3*/F-44 /B/*,8-1+; "57-

128

4/8H.1/=/ " + 42-*:8+91/4.1G- 45,/+D-1.+B+65F++ *5C2+25H.4; 43/1.511/ + 2 D-C5D53.+21G: B/*,5:. 74/8H. 8+7/ 48+25-.4; 4 E=/-+D-1.+B+65F+;,+, 8+7/ 3*-D4.5-. 2 42/-, @=*/I5H?-, /78+9+0, + 3-*-I+251+- /.6*G./4.+ +1+F++*@-. *5C2+.+- 7*-D/2G: +1.-*3*-.5F+0 /3G.5[1]. 1- D+2+D@58A1G- B/*,G /65CG25H.4; 1-5D-625.1G,+ 2 4/F+@,-. */,- ./=/, /.4@.4.2+- 3/8/I+-

.-8A1/=/ E,/F+/158A1/=/ /.1/<-1+; +C21- 3*+2/D+. 6 1-@4./09+2/4.+ 21/2A 4B/*,+*/2511G:

.*5143-*4/158A1G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 + 1- 43/4/74.2@-. 3/81/F-11/,@ +CI+251+H .*-2/=+.

56+, /7*5C/,, .-*53+; .*-7@-. 1- ./8A6/ 3*+1;.+; *-58A1/4.+ 24-: 6/,3/1-1./2 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+, 1/ + @4+8+0 43-F+58+4.5, 153*528-11G: 15 3*+1;.+- 7/8A1G, *-58A1/4.+ 4/74.2-1- 1/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+. 4:/D1G, 2 E./0 3*/F-D@*- ;28;-.4; 158+9+- 4@7R-6.-4@7R-6.1G: /.1/<-- 1+0. 48+ 2 /7GD-11/0 I+C1+ /1+ 4/4.528;H. 8+<A /D+1 +C D2@: *521/C1591G: 543-6./2 4/F+58A- 1G: /.1/<-1+0, ./ 2 .-*53-2.+9-46/0 3*56.+6- 4@7R-6.-4@7R-6.1G- /.1/<-1+; D/8I1G 7G.A 3*+- C151G 2-D@?+,+. /8A6/ 2 .-*53-2.+9-46/, 4@7R-6.-4@7R-6.1/, D+58/=- ,/I-. 7G.A 3*-/D/8-1 *5C*G2 21-<1-0 + 21@.*-11-0 D-04.2+.-8A1/4.+, @*-=@8+*/251G 5BB-6.+21/-6/=1+.+21G- 4/- 4.528;H?+- 45,/4/C151+; 7/8A1/=/ + /.6*G.G 4./8A 25I1G- 2 5D53.+21/, /.1/<-1++ 4/F+58A1/ C159+,G- E,/F++. /.8+9+- /. 34+:/.-*53++ 1-2*/.+6/2 EBB-6.+21/4.A 34+:/.-*53++ 35F+-1./2 4 34+:/C/, 2/ ,1/=/, /3*-D-8;-.4; C151+-, .-*53-2./, 21-8+91/4.1/=/ ,5.-*+585, 3-*-I+25-- ,/=/ 34+:/.+6/,, + 2/C,/I1/4.AH 3*+1;.+; 35F+-1.5 2/ 24-, -=/ *5CD2/-11/, 7G.++. .*@D1/4.+ E./=/ .56 15CG25-,/=/ D@<-21/=/ "4/I+.-8A4.25" 4 34+:/.+6/, 34+:/.-*53-2.@ 153/,+15H. 3*/- 78-,G 3-*-1/45 + 6/1.*3-*-1/45, 2/C1+65H?+- 2 8-9-1++ 7/8-- 3*/4.G: .-*53-2.+9-46+: 48@95- -2.

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

*+ 6/**-6F++ 3/C1525.-8A1G: + 5BB-6.+21/-E,/F+/158A1G: 4/4.528;H?+: 34+:+9-46/0 D-;-

.-8A1/4.+ 1- D/8I-1 7G.A /7/0D-1 21+,51+-, .*5D+F+/11/ 2GD-8;-,G0 2/8-2/0 543-6.. /8; 6 I+C1+, +C@95-,5; 4 *5C1G: 4./*/1 2 B+8/4/B++ 2/8H1.5*+C,5 ( 2=@4.+1, .'/3-1=5@E*,

. 5*.,51), 2 34+:/8/=++ 56.+21/4.+ ( . @1D., . I-0,4, . . ;4+?-2, . . -*1<.-01) + 2 34+- :+5.*++ ( /1*5D), +1.-*3*-.+*@-,5; 4 3/C+F+0 68544+9-46/=/ D-.-*,+1+C,5 +8+ 656 /4/75; 15D- 3*+*/D15; 4+85, 2/ 24-: 48@95;: 3*+C15-.4; 656 B@16F+; (43/4/71/4.A), /3*-D-8;H?5; 2-4A :/D 34+:+9-46+: 3*/F-44/2. 56 2G*5C+84; . 516, 24- 8+91/- 4@?-4.2/251+- +D-1.+91/ 43/4/71/4.+ 2G*5I5.A 2 ,+*- 42/H 2/8H (3/: 445DI+/8+, 1965), +, 656 3+458 .&1= (1997, 4.14), / 34+:+9-46/, ,/I1/ =/2/*+.A 8+<A 2 48@95;:, "6/=D5 C542+D-.-8A4.2/251/ 3*+4@.4.2+- 2/8+, 43/4/71/0 ,/D+- B+F+*/25.A *-B8-64G 8+7/ +14.+16.+21G- 3*/F-44G". /8;, 3*/;28;-,5; 2 45,/D-.-*,+15F++, +1.+,1/ 42;C515 4 45,/3/C151+-, + /B/*,8-1+-, 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 2 +D-5./*1G: 3*/F-445:; 2/8;, 3*/;28;-,5; 2 45,/*-=@8;F++, +=*5-. 25I1@H */8A 2 .*514B/*,5F++ 21-8+91/4.1/0 .*-2/- =+ 2 E,/F+/158A1G- 4/4./;1+; + 2 3/2-D-1+-, 5D-625.1/- 21-<1+, .*-7/251+;,. 56+, /7*5C/,, 2/8; 15*;D@ 4 +D-5./*1G,+ + 5BB-6.+21/-E,/F+/158A1G,+ 6@8A.@*1/-34+:/8/=+9-46+,+ @1+2-*-

129

458+;,+ +=*5-. 25I1-0<@H */8A 2 *5C2+.++ 6*-5.+21G: 25*+51./2 . 5*@<-1+- 2/8-2G: 56./2 3*+D5-. 34+:+9-46/0 D-;.-8A1/4.+ 35./8/=+9-46+0 :5*56.-*.

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

.+9-46/=/ (2 7/8-- <+*/6/, 4,G48- - 4/F+58A1/=/) 2,-<5.-8A4.25 + 21@.*-11+,+ 3/.-1F+585,+ 45,/*-=@8;F++, +1D+2+D@58A1G,+ 3/.*-71/4.;,+ + 153*528-1+-, -4.-4.2-11/=/ *5C2+.+; 45,/- 4/C151+;.

9-2+D1/, 9./ 2/8-2G- @4+8+; .-*53-2.5 D/8I1G 7G.A 153*528-1G 15 D/4.+I-1+- 35F+-1./, 4/- F+58A1/-*/8-2/=/ @*/21; -. 5<- +C@9-1+- 3*/78-,G + 2 /4/7-11/4.+ 3*-F-D-1.5 <5,51+- 4.+9-46/0 6@8A.@*G 3/65CG25-., 9./ 2 48@95- 6*+C+45 2/C2*5?-1+- 6 4/F+58A1/-*/8-2/,@ @*/21H

.*-7@-. +1.-=*5F++ 1/2G: +D-1.+B+65F+/11G: :5*56.-*+4.+6 8+91/4.+ 15 /.*-C6- - . /C2*5- ?-1+- 6 3*-I1+, +D-1.+B+65F+;, 15 /.*-C6- - - E./ 1- 2G:/D +C 6*+C+45, 5 2/C2*5?-1+- 6 D/- 7/8-C1-11/,@ 4/4./;1+H.

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

.+; 4/C151+; + .-*53-2.+9-46/=/ 3*/F-445 /7/C159-15 F+B*/0 3. /4.+I-1+- E./=/ 3@16.5 4//.- 2-.4.2@-. 3*+1;.+H /.1/4+.-8A1/4.+ +D-1.+B+65F+0 /.*-C65 - , 574/8H.1/0 C*-8/4.+ 8+91/4.+ + 41;.+H E6C+4.-1F+58A1/ .;=/4.1/=/ 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+; 74/8H.@ 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+.

7/C159-1+- D511/0 .*@D1/D/4.+I+,/0 .-*53-2.+9-46/0 F-8+ (./91-- - ,-.5F-8+) +,--. 3*56.+- 9-46/- C159-1+- 2 ./,, 9./ /3*-D-8;-. ,-4./ 45,/=/ .-*53-2.5 2 4:-,- *5C2+.+; 4/C151+;. 56 43*52-D8+2/ C5,-95-. . 51*/ (1985, 3/: +*6+1, 1987, 4.296), /7?+- D8; *5C1G: EBB-6.+21G: B/*, 34+:/.-*53++ 3*+C156+ 48-D@-. +465.A 3*-ID- 24-=/ 2 8+91/4.1G: :5*56.-*+4.+65: 34+:/-

.-*53-2./2, 5 1- 2 .-/*+;: +8+ .-:1+9-46+: 3*+-,5: *5C1G: <6/8. //.2-.4.2-11/, 9-, 78+I- .-- *53-2. 2 42/-, 8+91/, *5C2+.++ 6 /7/C159-11/0 ,-.5F-8+ *5C2+.+; 45,/4/C151+;, .-, <+*- -=/ 6/,3-.-1F+; + EBB-6.+21-0 .-*53+;.

544,/.*-1+- 3*/78-,G ,/I1/ C56/19+.A 2G2/D/, D/4.5./91/ .*5D+F+/11G, + D5I75- 158A1G, D8; 43-F+58+4./2, C156/,G: 4 =@,51+4.+9-46/0 .*5D+F+-0. I- 2 4-*-D+1- XX 2. 7G8/ 153+451/, 9./ ,G D/8I1G *57/.5.A 15D 4/7/0 3/D/71/ ./,@, 656 ,G *57/.5-, 4/ 42/+, 68+1+9-- 46+, ,5.-*+58/, ( 43-*4, 1997). D156/ 2 3-*2@H /9-*-DA 2 42;C+ 4 .-,/0 +C,-1-11G: 4/4./;1+0 4/C151+; 154 +1.-*-4/258 2/3*/4 / ./,, 9./ 1-/7:/D+,/ 49+.5.A 4/74.2-11/ 68+1+9-46+, ,5.-- *+58/,, 656 *5C=*51+9+.A 1/*,58A1/- + 35./8/=+9-46/-? 544,5.*+25; E./. 2/3*/4 2 6/1.-64.- =@,51+4.+9-46/0 6/1F-3F++ *5C2+.+; + 2 42;C+ 4 E6C+4.-1F+58A1/-51.*/3/8/=+9-46+, +C@9-1+-,

130