Добавил:
kiopkiopkiop18@yandex.ru t.me/Prokururor I Вовсе не секретарь, но почту проверяю Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
Ординатура / Хирургия / Библиотека им академика М.И. Перельмана / Книга_905_Библиотеки_им_академика_М_И_Перельмана.pdf
Скачиваний:
0
Добавлен:
31.08.2026
Размер:
32 Мб
Скачать
302
E. Switzer and T. O’Keee
who may wish for a merciful release for their patient if recovery is not possible. Nevertheless, many surgical oncologists and/or surgeons who perform palliative surgery may still form strong bonds with their patients. To a certain extent, this may depend on how the surgeon identies with their patient as well as with their family, their social circumstances, and the specic disease.
In another example, many trauma surgeons will be all too familiar with the change in epide­miology of gun violence that has occurred over the last few years, with many more children and adolescents suffering injuries [5]. These patients are innitely more stressful to operate on, and the challenge of then talking to the family of a child who has passed away from gun violence is one we would not wish on anyone.
Most of us will still remember the rst patient that we cared for that died—the authors certainly still have a strong recollection of that event. Over time physicians who deal with death on a regular basis develop coping mechanisms to at least par­tially insulate themselves from the emotional dis­tress that they may feel from this. That doesn’t mean that we forget, but this ability to be at least somewhat dispassionate can help to prevent burn­out and keep the surgeon functioning to the best of their ability.

Second Victim Syndrome

The death of a patient is clearly traumatic for the patient’s family and loved ones, and is something all doctors try to avoid to the best of their abili­ties, but there is increasing evidence that sur­geons can also suffer emotional angst and suffering in a constellation of symptoms that has been referred to as second victim syndrome [10]. In a paper from 2017 by Han etal., up to 84% of surgeons reported feelings of anxiety, guilt, sad­ness, shame, and anger [6]. These feelings were pronounced in some cases, with a surgeon writ­ing “We all hide our grief, suffer in silence. The pain can be close to debilitating.” In the world of surgery, resilience and stoicism are thought highly of, and this can make it harder to acknowl­edge our feelings after a poor patient outcome.

Guilt

Guilt can be a powerful emotion that the surgeon has to deal with after the death of a patient, par­ticularly if the surgeon ascribes some blame to themselves for the cause of the death. In his book “Complications. A surgeons note on an imperfect science,” Dr. Gawande describes his emotions “I felt a sense of shame like a burning ulcer. This was not guilt: guilt is what you feel when you have done something wrong. What I felt was shame: I was what was wrong.” [4] These emo­tions can be especially damaging to surgeons early in their career, such as residents, who may not have yet dealt with a patient’s death. In one recent study, 88% of residents reported being part of a medical error, with 86% of these surgery residents experiencing emotional sequelae. A good peer support system in the residency, in addition to a sympathetic program director can make sure that the resident is able to move through this trauma effectively. Unfortunately, in this study, only 24% of the respondents stated that they had received emotional support [7].

Acceptance

As surgeons, we need to accept that death is unfortunately an integral part of our lives; on many occasions we are merely trying to slow the inexorable march of a disease, or trying to bring comfort to a patient. End of life care may be a larger or smaller part of a surgeon’s practice, depending on their exact specialty. Burnout appears to be highest amongst intensivists and is also very high in general surgeons, which is not surprising considering the number of life and death circumstances that are encountered by these specialists. In addition, much has been written on compassion fatigue amongst nurses, oncologists, and intensivists, but less data exists in the literature regarding the incidence and the difculties surgeons experience with it. Unless the surgeon is careful, this can be an unfortunate consequence of over-exposure to the seriously ill and dying. The COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 and 2021 was a once in a lifetime event for many of
24 The Surgeon’s Response toaPatient Death
303
us, who often provided ICU care as we were unable to operate, and saw death on a scale that was highly unusual. For some doctors, there were tragic consequences, and more than a few sui­cides in doctors have been reported as an after­math of the chaotic breakdown of our medical systems during that time.

Burnout

Surgeon burnout is increasingly being recognized as a serious entity, with up to 35% of general sur­geons reporting symptoms of burnout, with an incidence of up to 70% in trainees. Burnout is covered eloquently elsewhere, so will not be cov­ered exhaustively here, but it is clear that there are many forces at play. The emotional distress associated with caring for dying patients can cer­tainly predispose to burnout, but it can also be a consequence of systemic organizational prob­lems, which may be more relevant as more and more surgeons become employees of large heath care systems, as opposed to group or academic practice [3, 8].
from patient care to compose oneself is advisable and very necessary. Having a debrief with the rest of the surgical team is very important to ensure that all members can continue to function at their best, as it is easy to suffer from compassion fatigue in the aftermath of a patient’s death.
The challenge of continuing to perform at one’s best for each new consult or subsequent operation cannot be understated, and although surgeons are proud of their “grit,” we must be mindful of our own vulnerabilities and respond appropriately for the safety of all our patients [1]. In another quote from his book “Complications” Dr. Gawande writes about a colleague who had made an error: “Afterward, he could barely bring himself to operate. When he did operate, he became tentative and indecisive. The case affected his performance for months.” Seeking guidance from a senior colleague may be helpful in these circumstances to help the surgeon nd their equilibrium anew [4]. This may be particu­larly important if the surgeon has to operate on another patient with a similar condition, where fear of the outcome can impact the surgeons’ per­formance—asking for assistance may help the physician overcome this hurdle.
Performance Issues andResilience
After caring for a patient who dies, a surgeon will likely need to emotionally and mentally pivot and refocus so they can effectively perform their other immediate clinical demands. This may be extremely difcult. In general, in the case of an unexpected intra-operative death on an elective list, the surgeon would be wise to postpone or reschedule other non-urgent cases to give them time to regain their equilibrium and to be able to devote the necessary physical and mental energy to a new operation. Acute care surgeons nd themselves in the situation of operating on high­risk cases with greater frequency, and so are likely to experience this event more often, and may not have this option to step “away” from call commitments in this event. Nevertheless, experi­encing a patient death in the middle of a busy 24-hour call can be a signicant drain, and if at all possible, at least a few minutes of time away
Patient andHospital Factors
Some of the fear and stress that comes from dealing with a patient’s death are related to the interaction with the patient’s family, particularly if the death has been in any way unexpected. Grief manifests in different ways in people, and both aggressive verbal and physical outbursts are not uncommon, and can be directed at the physi­cian, even if they have done their utmost to avoid a bad outcome. Unfortunately, there have even been instances in which patients or their family have targeted and killed physicians for real or perceived dereliction of care. In our increasingly multicultural society, there are also additional factors that come into play, depending on the ethnicity and/or belief systems of the patient and their family. Most surveys show that between 70% and 80% of people in the United States believe in God in some form, and up to 80%
304
E. Switzer and T. O’Keee
believe in miracles [9]. This can make the pro­cess of death harder for some families to accept, especially if this has been an unexpected event. Dealing with a patient’s family members who do not accept their death can certainly increase the physician’s stress and discomfort, which can be especially problematic with brain death, as the patient’s body remains warm and vital, despite their lack of brain function and clinical diagnosis of death.
It is also relatively common to face legal repercussions in cases with a patient death, espe­cially if it is felt to be related to the care provided. This may cause the surgeon to be less forthcom­ing about the circumstances of the death, in an attempt to avoid litigation, which may in turn make the patient’s family feel that there is some­thing to hide, and actually make litigation MORE likely. Most of the studies around medical litiga­tion seem to favor full disclosure and a timely honest conversation about the complication as the best way to avoid a medical malpractice suit, although this will likely be very uncomfortable in the moment.
Although surgeons have by tradition always had some form of oversight of their performance in our weekly mortality and morbidity confer­ences, most hospital organizations have a paral­lel but different process known as peer review. In the case of the hospital peer review commit­tee, the peers are usually NOT surgeons, and the process unfolds very differently and can be a source of additional stress and concern for the surgeon. Having experience on these commit­tees, and having experienced how surgeons respond to them, it is clear that this kind of over­sight, while well- intended and necessary to identify issues, is not well liked by the average physician, who nearly always regards the review as punitive in nature.
While many surgeons are their “own worst enemy” in terms of how they review their own cases in terms of the patient’s death, fear of retri­bution from the patient’s family, the hospital or even the State medical board may compound the stress from the event and contribute to the “sec­ond victim syndrome.”
How Can Surgeons Find Eective Coping Mechanisms?
Although things do seem to be changing, we are often taught in medical training to maintain a cer­tain degree of emotional detachment. The predom­inant surgical culture in US medical establishments would regard a physician’s emotional response to death as a sign of weakness and unprofessional­ism. Nevertheless, it is important to acknowledge the death of a patient in whose care we were involved, and also to acknowledge the feelings that are evoked within us. This will help us to become more aware of the needs of our patients and also to recognize our own needs. Physicians who deal with death on a regular basis must develop coping mechanisms to at least partially insulate them­selves from the emotional distress that they may feel from this. These coping strategies can be healthy or unhealthy. The later tend to provide only temporary relief and are generally maladap­tive and serve to suppress the emotion or response rather than process and acknowledge it. Table24.1 lists some “good” and “bad” coping mechanisms.
At the outset it may be helpful to some degree, to share feelings of loss with members of the family of the deceased. The grief of the family must of necessity take precedence, but some­times family members, too, can gain a great deal of comfort from sharing experiences with some­one who has been involved with the care of their relative. All too often in medicine we do not acknowledge events such as this, and our own feelings get lost because we then become involved with new cases and new situations. As surgeon intensivists, we were very busy early in the COVID-19 pandemic, caring for patients both surgically and in the intensive care units. Due to the quarantining and restrictions set in place, there was limited personal interaction and connection with patients’ families. We felt the negative impact when this component of the cop­ing strategy broke down.
The support of our peers is another avenue from which we can draw assistance. This includes our partners, senior colleagues, mentors, or oth­ers in positions of authority. This may be more
24 The Surgeon’s Response toaPatient Death
305
Table 24.1 Coping strategies
Negative Positive Alcohol or substance misuse Talking openly with
the patient’s family
Suppression of your emotions Attending the patient’s
funeral Feeling guilty and blaming yourself Brooding over events Guidance/support
Obsessing how things could have been different Blaming others—anesthesia, nurses, colleagues, patient, family
Supporting the
surgical team
from colleagues
Support from your
family
Seeking professional
help
difcult if the surgeon is a solo practitioner, and especially in the case of the rural surgeon who may not have professional colleagues in close vicinity. Academic or group practice will afford more local opportunities for peer-to-peer coun­seling and support, however, with the explosion of Information Technology over the last decade, peer support is much more accessible indepen­dent of geographic location or practice size. For instance, numerous applications and mobile Apps have been developed as resources and to provide various surgeon and non-surgeon physician spe­cic support network for its users. Likewise, social media can provide another way for sur­geons to interrelate and commiserate.
The importance of personal family connections obviously cannot be over-emphasized here, whether it is a spouse, siblings, or other family members in the medical profession, who may be sources of support, sounding boards, or even able to provide advice from their own real-life experi­ences. Having good family relationships that allow the surgeon to decompress, relax with, and discuss the issue in an unguarded fashion is absolutely essential for their emotional well-being. The unconditional love that we receive from our fami­lies at times like these allows us to remain grounded and get through what can be very difcult times.
Many surgeons nd solace in their pastimes, whether these consist of physical activities or more cerebral pursuits. Having a sport, hobby, or social outlet outside of work may also be a good
way to nd work-life balance, and enable the sur­geon to move through the emotional turmoil of the death of a patient. Personal strategies, such as practicing meditation and mindfulness, can regu­late stress and anxiety, and help a surgeon refocus by observing and acknowledging thoughts and emotions and allowing them to pass. Physical exercise with its endorphin-promoting effects may be a particularly effective way to mitigate against the multiple types of stress associated with such an event.
Professional organizations are starting to rec­ognize the emotional strain modern medical practice puts upon the practitioner. There are an increasing number of resources available to help surgeons deal with these stressors [2].

Conclusions

How we deal with a patient’s death can dene us; whether we wall ourselves off, become emotion­ally over attached and vulnerable, or in those cases where it leads to consequences in terms of anger, depression, or even substance abuse. The pressures of modern surgical practice and the increasing expectations of patients can make what is a highly rewarding career increasingly fraught with difculties. Surgeon burnout is real, and we need to come up with ways to openly discuss it, and provide support to those surgeons in their time of need. The individual physician needs to have insight into their own feelings and either have robust coping strategies of their own, or seek appropriate help when it is needed. Although the notion of “second victim syndrome” may not be fashionable amongst our profession, where we pride ourselves on our resilience, we must not fool ourselves that our junior colleagues and trainees wish to continue to suffer in silence, and we must remove the stigma. Personally we would rather be cared for by a surgeon who is affected by a patient’s death, than one who has become stone­hearted to the suffering of his patients. This is what we entered the sacred profession of surgery for, to alleviate suffering, and we should keep that foremost in our minds.
306
E. Switzer and T. O’Keee
Conicts of Interests There are no identiable conicts of interests to report.
The authors have no nancial or proprietary interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript.

References

1. Burkhart RA, etal. Grit: a marker of residents at risk for attrition? Surgery. 2014;155(6):1014–22.
2. El Hechi MW, et al. Design and impact of a novel surgery-specic second victim peer support program. J Am Coll Surg. 2020;230(6):926–33.
3. Ferguson CM. Addressing the source of surgeon burnout. Bull Am Coll Surg. 2015;100(7):73–4.
4. Gawande A.Complications: a surgeon’s notes on an imperfect science. New York: Metropolitan Books;
2002.
5. Goldstick JE, etal. Current causes of death in children and adolescents in the United States. N Engl J Med. 2022;386(20):1955–6.
6. Han K, et al. The surgeon as the second victim? Results of the Boston intraoperative adverse events surgeons’ attitude (BISA) study. J Am Coll Surg. 2017;224(6):1048–56.
7. Khansa I, Pearson GD.Coping and recovery in sur­gical residents after adverse events: the second vic­tim phenomenon. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2022;10(3):e4203.
8. Maslach C, Leiter MP.The truth about burnout: how organizations cause personal stress and what to do about it. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 1997.
9. The Harris poll. Americans’ belief in god, miracles and heaven declines. From http://www.theharrispoll.
com/health-and-life/Americans__Belief_in_God__ Miracles_and_Heaven_Declines.html.
10. Wu AW. Medical error: the second victim. The doc­tor who makes the mistake needs help too. BMJ. 2000;320(7237):726–7.
The Surgeon’s Burnout: How toDeal withIt
ChristinaColosimo, SaiKrishnaBhogadi, andBellalJoseph
25
Irrespective of seniority, most of us in the world of medicine in general, and surgery in particular, go through situations where we feel helpless, lose interest, and feel unappreciated; everything looks bleak, and it’s difcult to muster up the energy to care. There comes a time when dragging ourselves out of bed requires the strength of Hercules, prob­lems look overwhelming and even breathing becomes a task. The impact of such feelings forces individuals to reconsider their self-worth, and this cascade of events eventually leads to helplessness. Experiencing these feelings most of the time may lead them to suffer burnout, which can threaten one’s career, relationships, and health.

What Is Burnout?

It is not surprising that the term “burnout” was coined by American psychologist Herbert Freudenberger in 1974 to describe, “the conse­quences of severe or prolonged stress and anxiety experienced by people working in the healing professions” [1]. Maslach and Jackson later dened burnout as “a syndrome of emotional exhaustion and cynicism that occurs frequently
C. Colosimo · S. K. Bhogadi · B. Joseph (*) Division of Trauma, Critical Care, Burns, and Emergency Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA e-mail: ccolosim@arizona.edu;
saikbhogadi@arizona.edu; bjoseph@arizona.edu
among individuals who do people work of some kind” [2]. In simple terms, burnout refers to a mental or physical collapse caused by overwork or stress. It has been described in the literature as a syndrome of emotional, mental, and physical exhaustion, high depersonalization, and a feeling of low personal accomplishment caused by
excessive and prolonged stress [3].
It is well established that emotional exhaus­tion lies at the center of the problem and exces­sive psychological and emotional demands result in emotional exhaustion. Depersonalization is a tendency to view others in a markedly detached manner and represents the individual’s attempt to protect against further emotional exhaustion. All these components are self-perpetuating and ulti­mately lead to a mixed matrix propagating the other components. Burnout is a continuous vari­able ranging from emotional exhaustion to low personal accomplishment.
Burnout syndrome is an endless list of prob­lems including physical illness, emotional labil­ity, increased turnover, absenteeism, poor job performance, drug abuse, and negative attitudes that have been associated with burnout. These problems present as a part of a “generalized psy­chological distress” which is variable in each individual [4]. Burnout leading to burnout syn­drome ultimately occurs in individuals who require spending time and intensive involvement with other people. Given the severity and impact an individual has, it is important to deal with burnout in a dened stepwise approach.
© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2024 R. Lati (ed.), Surgical Decision-Making, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-67391-7_25
307
308
C. Colosimo et al.

At Risk Population

The phenomenon of burnout has been investi­gated in a wide variety of occupations, including physicians and surgeons. In the published litera­ture, up to 40% of practicing surgeons suffer from considerable stress and subsequent burnout during their career that may affect their personal and professional performance. Campbell et al. reviewed burnout among 582 American surgeons and found that one-third (32%) of them had high levels of emotional exhaustion, whereas 13% had higher depersonalization, and 4% indicated a low level of personal accomplishment [5]. In a sys­tematic review and meta-analysis including 27 articles with 8617 surgeons, the prevalence of burnout was found to be 47%, with rates per spe­cialty ranging between 15% and 77% [6]. In a recent systematic review and meta-analysis on trends in surgeon burnout in the US and Canada including 103 studies representing 63,587 indi­viduals, 41% of the surgeons met criteria for burnout [7].
Burnout more likely occurs in young female surgeons who have younger children or delay childrearing and assume greater parental respon­sibility while they have similar clinical duties as male surgeons [8]. Younger surgeons experience more emotional stress as a result of different social expectations regarding the balance of career, family, and personal growth and develop­ment. The implication is that we continue to fail to prepare our young trainees to survive in their personal and professional lives while maintain­ing good mental health. The impact of this failure is substantial as literature demonstrates that many of these young burned out practitioners leave sur­gical specialties to retrain in other specialties or begin retiring earlier [9].
Although some evidence demonstrated that physicians in private practice might be at a greater risk for burnout, there is no difference in burnout among surgeons based on practice setting. However, some limited evidence suggests that there may be some differences in burnout among different surgical subspecialties [10]. The surgi­cal specialties involved with the care of emergen­cies and acute adverse events are usually at higher
risk of burnout due to their longer work hours and stressful nature of the eld. In a survey conducted on the members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma and American Association for the Surgery of trauma, 40% of the trauma sur­geons reported symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and 15% had a diagnosis of PTSD [11].
Burnout is not limited to practicing physicians or surgeons, and there are other vulnerable groups including medical students and residents who suffer from burnout. More than half of the medi­cal students in the US manifest burnout while in medical school. Nearly 38% of orthopedic sur­gery residents and 45% of vascular surgery train­ees reported symptoms of burnout in surveys, with sizeable amount of trainees reporting mis­treatment, duty hour violations, thoughts of attri­tion, specialty change, and suicide [12, 13]. High levels of stress and burnout have also been reported in nurses. Burnout is higher in acute pediatric nurses compared to non-acute care nurses. Similar results have been reported in nurses working night shifts and those involved in the intensive care setting [14].

Burnout vs. Stress

Often burnout and stress are words that are used interchangeably however they are not the same. Constant stress causes an individual to initiate losing interest that may have been a motivator to take on a certain role in the rst place. Like burn­out, stress can also affect the quality of family relationships and the nature of the doctor–patient relationship. The difference is that stressed peo­ple can imagine and visualize rationally. Often the condition is reversible and once the stress is managed or dealt with, people are often able to successfully manage their professional perfor­mance and feel better. On the other hand, burnout deters one’s ability to rationalize or imagine and ultimately the ability to reverse the condition is complex, requiring management of more than one condition.
Burnout is often associated with a devoid of motivation. It can result in feeling as though one
25 The Surgeon’s Burnout: How toDeal withIt
309
“has nothing left to do,” negative attitudes toward patients, and a reduced feeling of competence. People with high levels of burnout are hopeless and cannot see the positive changes in their situ­ation. In contrast to stress, burnout is character­ized by disengagement. It produces blunted feelings and causes helplessness, hopelessness, loss of motivation, and ideals. It may lead to detachment and depression. Primary damage in burnout is emotional and may make life seem not worth living. However, burnout is a psychologi­cal construct to investigate the stress.

Measuring Tools

The Maslach Burnout Inventory is a reliable measurement instrument to sample large popula­tions for stress [8]. This measuring tool has sepa­rate subscales to evaluate each domain of burnout [15]. There are some standard categorical thresh­olds to classify each domain score as high, mod­erate, or low. According to this classication scoring system, surgeons are considered as high scores in depersonalization and emotional exhaustion [8]. However, burnout in the surgical environment is sparsely reviewed and the quanti­tative assessment of surgical burnout is limited.
Burnout inSurgeons
As mentioned in the previous sections, the preva­lence of burnout in surgeons is very high. This indicates that there is a concern in the personal and professional life of the surgeons. Surgeons work long for irregular hours, deal repeatedly with their patients, and make considerable sacri­ces to practice in their eld. They have an unwritten but understood code of rules and expectations. This code includes coming in early and staying late, working nights and weekends, performing a high volume of procedures, meet­ing multiple simultaneous deadlines, never com­plaining, and keeping personal problems away from work.
Ultimately all of these qualities are both
dened and rendered by the surgeons; however,
when there is no ne line between dedication and hard work it can lead to unhealthy and self­destructive behavior, which can affect patient care as well.
COVID-19 Pandemic andBurnout
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to unprece­dented impact on people, healthcare workers, and the healthcare system alike. Healthcare systems all over the world had to deal with patients beyond their capacities, often with limited staff. Many surgeons signicantly curtailed elective surgeries and were deployed on the teams provid­ing frontline treatment. In addition to being in the frontline teams, surgeons also provided acute care surgery support whenever necessary. Similar to professionals from other specialties, surgeons faced extreme levels of burnout during the pan­demic. In a systematic review including 19 arti­cles with 3866 surgical trainees, the prevalence of burnout in surgical trainees during the pan­demic was reported between 9.1% and 95.2%, with general surgery having the highest burnout rates (33.1–95.2%) compared to other surgical specialties. Another systematic review by Shaikh etal. assessing burnout among surgeons and sur­gical trainees during the COVID-19 pandemic also found high rates of burnout ranging from 6% to 86% [16].
There are several theories behind increased burnout in surgeons and surgical trainees during the pandemic. Limited prior working experience with this patient population and sudden increase in the COVID-19 patient clinical load, redeploy­ment to COVID-19 wards, reduction in the regu­lar operative cases, decreased hands-on experience, and not being able to complete case requirements are some factors that have been proposed as the possible reasons. In addition, repeated episodes of quarantine and self­isolation, violence and harassment, lack of psy­chological support, stigmatization and discrimination, and concerns of care for family members have placed surgeons and health care workers at higher risk for burnout during the pandemic.
310
C. Colosimo et al.

Causes

There are several causes for burnout. Originally, it stems from the occupation, however anyone who is overworked is at risk of burnout. Additionally, lifestyle and personality traits con­tribute to burnout. Being younger and having a spouse employed outside the home is associated with a higher risk of burnout. It means that lack of balance among career, family, and personal growth in the younger surgeons is directly associ­ated with burnout. On the other hand, having children is associated with a lower risk of burnout [10]. Causes of burnout are presented in Table25.1 [10, 17, 18].
One or combination of these factors can pre­dispose a professional to burnout. Excess work­load, inefciency, loss of self-sufciency, and a lack of meaning in work seem to be central fac­tors to cause burnout among surgeons [19]. There is a probability that gender differences may be another cause of burnout. Female physicians have a higher level of burnout in comparison to their male counterparts. However, among sur­geons, gender disparity does not have a robust impact on burnout [14]. In a survey including 291 trauma surgeons, poor work-life balance, being midcareer, having more work hours, fewer awake hours at home, and feeling that there is a better job were identied as predictors of burnout [20].
Surgeons andSleep Deprivation
Surgeons often work for long hours with erratic schedules with constant on-call duties and emer­gencies which create a perfect storm where ade­quate restful sleep becomes a rare commodity. Sleep deprivation among professionals working in high-risk industries has been shown to be a proven factor in the loss of civilian life. Constant sleep deprivation affects cognitive function, the very bedrock on which surgeons build their preci­sion and decision-making prowess. Since surgery is a eld where split-second decisions can be life­altering, sleep deprivation in surgeons is a major issue that needs attention. In a systematic review of 33 studies assessing sleep deprivation in sur­gery, sleep deprivation was found to negatively
Table 25.1 Causes of burnout [10, 17, 18]
Work related
Lack of control over the work Lack of appreciation for decent work Uncertain job expectations Doing unchallenging work Working in a high-pressure situation
Lifestyle related
Uneven distribution of time between work and
personal life making a safe training environment Lack of relaxation and socializing time Lack of enough sleep Taking on too many duties without enough help Research and educational situation Lack of supportive relationships
Personality traits
Type A personality Perfectionistic feeling Negative view of oneself and world
impact technical performance with a 12–32% decrement in performance [21]. This issue of sleep deprivation is even more signicant in acute care surgeons as their clinical activities include surgical critical care, emergency general surgery, and trauma, all of which require around- the- clock clinical coverage. In a 6-month prospective study of 224 acute care surgeons by Coleman etal., sur­geons reported feelings of moderate, very, or extreme burnout for 25.7% of days during the study period, and feelings of being moderately, slightly, or not at all rested occurred 75.91% of days. Decreased amount of time between the inhouse calls, reduced sleep duration, and having a bad patient outcome have been linked to greater feelings of daily burnout [22].
Signs andSymptoms
Burnout occurs gradually over a period of time. Signs and symptoms of burnout are subtle at rst, but they get worse over time. It is associated with depression and anxiety. In a study, evaluating members of the American College of Surgeons, approximately 30% of study participants screened positive for depression [10]. Some reports also suggest that the exhaustion component of the burnout syndrome may be related to depression.
Burnout and depression among practicing sur-
geons are independent predictors of medical
25 The Surgeon’s Burnout: How toDeal withIt
311
errors. The inherent stressful nature of the sur­gery along with excessive and erratic work hours put surgeons at a much higher risk for burnout and may also affect personal relationships. The increasing incidence of divorce after 30years of marriage is the highest among surgeons, regard­less of the amount of work resources or hours worked. Moreover patients with chronic burnout have specic cognitive impairments in non­verbal memory and attention [23].
Symptoms ofSurgeon’s Burnout
Signs and symptoms of surgeons’ burnout can be broadly classied into three groups: physical, behavioral, and emotional. Physical signs and symptoms include feeling tired most of the time, change in appetite or sleep habits, frequent headache and body pain, and reduced immunity. Among the emotional symptoms; loss of moti­vation, negative attitude, feeling failure, decreased satisfaction, feeling hopeless and helpless, and detachment are remarkable. Furthermore, isolation, careless attitude, gener­alizing frustration toward others, and procrasti­nation are among the emotional factors associated with burnout.
Surgeons, with high levels of burnout, are more likely to report increasing intake of alcohol, keeping things to themselves, engaging in less sports or recreation and mixing less with friends in response to work-related stress [14].
Consequences ofBurnout
In the demanding world of surgery, where preci­sion is paramount and split-second decisions can be a matter of life and death, burnout emerges as a silent but pervasive threat. Beyond the immedi­ate toll it takes on an individual, burnout casts a long shadow, inuencing not only the surgeon but also the entire healthcare ecosystem.
(a) Effects at the Individual Level:
Previous reports have identied burnout to be associated with numerous detrimental personal consequences, including a higher
risk of mental health disorders and poorer physical quality of life [24]. Among surgical trainees, burnout has been linked with higher levels of depression, anxiety, PTSD, and sui­cidality [25]. Burnout has also been associ­ated with unhealthy behaviors in surgical trainees such as alcohol misuse and engaging less frequently in exercise.
(b) Impact on Patient Care:
Burnout poses a threat to patient-centered care, a principle which is the cornerstone of medicine. As surgeons battle with their own emotional and physical exhaustion, the abil­ity to connect empathetically with patients diminishes. The downstream effect is a potential decline in patient satisfaction and trust [26]. The manifestation of burnout has been associated with challenges in cognitive task performance, posing a concern for sur­geons and their professional aptitude [27]. Higher levels of emotional exhaustion and burnout have been linked with greater num­ber of perceived medical errors [28, 29]. In a systematic review and meta-analysis by Al­Ghunaim et al., burnout was found to be associated with 2.5-fold increased risk of involvement in medical error [30].

Burnout Prevention

Considering the early symptoms of burnout as warning signs is important. By having insight to these warning signs and recognizing them early, we can prevent a major breakdown and the devel­opment of burn out. Taking steps to get life back into balance can prevent burnout from becoming a full-scale failure. Individual efforts to develop a balance between personal and professional life may help reduce burnout rate in surgeons. Overall, enhanced institutional support and increased opportunities for professional progres­sion can decrease burnout rate among surgeons [31]. One effective method to prevent burnout among surgeons is to actively protect their per­sonal and professional well-being at physical, emotional, psychological, and spiritual levels. These efforts need to occur from medical school through retirement.