Административная ответственность. Учебно-методическое пособие

% : *7 * ( * 7 7 ( 7 8 &* * * ? 3 2 8 & *- * 2 8 7 +8 ; 8?

3. HA='*HJ;%*@%> B'UH**HU @*AO%&N@@ D HAA@@ ?. +' $@B%&=HB

WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A=.14.5 H- V D S' *%OB@>%*%*@% OB@ HA/^%A=J;%*@@ $%*%T*CM B'AL%=HJ A *'A%;%*@%>.

VBW@=B'T*CU A/$ B%AO/W;@&@ 'e&HB=HA='* OB@S*'; OHA='*HJ;%*@% *%S'&H**C>, OHA&H;<&/ OB'JH*'B/e%*@% OBH@SHe;H OH J@*% OBH$'JN'- &H*A/;<='*=', &H=HBCU AH?;'A*H =B/$HJH>/ $H?HJHB/ A *% @>%; OB'- J' HA/^%A=J;#=< OBH$'T/ =HJ'BHJ *%OHAB%$A=J%**H, >@*/# OBH$'JN'- &'AA@B'.

D%$%B';<*CU 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$ B';<A&H?H H&B/?' OH T';HW% B'UH*- *HU @*AO%&N@@ D ?. +' B%e%*@% 'BW@=B'T*H?H A/$' H=>%*@;, /&'S'J, L=H HW#S'**HA=< OH OB@>%*%*@K JHS;HT%*' *' KB@$@L%A&@M ;@N @ @*$@J@$/';<*CM OB%$OB@*@>'=%;%U, *%AHW;K$%*@% B'WH=*@&H> KB@$@L%- A&H?H ;@N' OB'J@; OB@>%*%*@# J;%L%= H=J%=A=J%**HA=< KB@$@L%A&H- ?H ;@N', H= @>%*@ &H=HBH?H AHJ%Be%*C HO%B'N@@.

H '*';H?@L*H>/ $%;/ D%$%B';<*CU 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$ B';<A&H?H H&B/?' HA='J@; T';HW/ @*AO%&N@@ W%S /$HJ;%=JHB%*@#, /&'S'J J OHA='*HJ- ;%*@@, L=H %A;@ >%T$/ OB%$OB@#=@%> @ OBH$'JNH> WC; S'&;KL%* =B/$H- JHU $H?HJHB, OH &H=HBH>/ OBH$'J%N HW#S'* WC; OB@>%*#=< OB@ B%'- ;@S'N@@ =HJ'BHJ OH&/O'=%;#>, =H h=H HWA=H#=%;<A=JH AJ@$%=%;<A=J/%= H J@*HJ*CM $%UA=J@#M OBH$'JN' @ HW H=A/=A=J@@ J@*C KB@$@L%A&H?H ;@N' J AHJ%Be%**H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@.

8* ? * K ?

4. @B%&=HB &'+% WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**H- A=@ OH A='=<% 6.6 HV D S' *'B/e%*@% A'*@='B*H hO@$%>@H;H?@L%A&@M =B%WHJ'*@U & HB?'*@S'N@@ O@='*@# *'A%;%*@#. ' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 3000 B/W;%U. F /A='*HJ;%**CU ABH& e=B'+ /O;'L%* *% WC;. @B%&=HB S' *%/O;'=/ e=B'+' WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 20.25 J $J/&B'=*H> B'S>%B% H= A/>>C *%/O;'L%**H?H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+'. @B%&=HB OH#A*@;, L=H H* /O;'=@; e=B'+, &HO@# &J@='*N@@ / *%?H @>%%=A# *' B'WH- =%, ' A'> H* *'MH$@;A# J $;@=%;<*HU &H>'*$@BHJ&%.

4 +8 ( * * * 6 ?

5. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ O'B@&>'M%BA&H?H A';H*' « B'AH='» WC;H /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H O'B@&>'M%BA&@% /A;/?@ H&'SCJ'K=A# OB@ H=A/=A=J@@ A%B=@- +@&'=' AHH=J%=A=J@#. @B%&=HB O'B@&>'M%BA&HU WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L'A=@ 2 A='=<@ 14.4 HV D. @B%&=HB OH-

51

AL@='; *%S'&H**C> OB@J;%L%*@% %?H & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@, OHA&H;<&/ $;# O'B@&>'M%BA&@M /A;/? A%B=@+@&'= *% =B%W/%=A#.

3 K * & ? % *7 * ( * * - * 7, * / * 2 ?

6. 20 A%*=#WB# 2005 ?H$' @*T%*%B H=$%;' @*T%*%B*H h&H*H>@L%A&@M h&AO%B=@S E « 'B'=HJA&@U HW;'A=*HU N%*=B B%'W@;@='N@@ @ AHN@';<*HU @*=%?B'N@@ @*J';@$HJ» OB@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ OBH$/&=HJH?H >'?'S@*' HW*'B/T@;, L=H *' JMH$% J >'?'S@* @>%%=A# A=/O%*<&' JCAH=HU WH;%% 3 A>, L=H $%;'%= >'?'S@* *%$HA=/O*C> $;# @*J';@$HJ. *$@J@$/';<*H>/ OB%$- OB@*@>'=%;K . @*T%*%BH> WC;H $'*H OB%$O@A'*@% HW /A=B'*%*@@ $'*- *H?H *'B/e%*@# @ JCOH;*%*@@ B'WH= OH HW/A=BHUA=J/ JMH$' J >'?'S@* $H 21 H&=#WB# 2005 ?H$'. F MH$% HL%B%$*HU OBHJ%B&@, OBHJ%$%**HU 24 $%&'W- B# 2005 ?H$', WC;H HW*'B/T%*H, L=H *'B/e%*@# *% /A=B'*%*C. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ WC;H JHSW/T$%*H J H=*He%*@@ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;# . $%;H HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A='=<% 9.13 HV D @ S' /&;H*%*@% H= @AOH;*%*@# =B%WHJ'*@U $HA=/O*HA=@ $;# @*J';@$HJ AHN@';<*HU @*+B'- A=B/&=/BC @ OH L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 19.5 HV .

/$<# B'UH**H?H A/$' JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H OB@J;%L%*@@ & '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;# OH A='=<% 9.13 @ L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 19.5 HV D, OHA&H;<&/ OHA;%$*@U ='& @ *% JCOH;*@; =B%WHJ'- *@# OH HW/A=BHUA=J/ JMH$' J >'?'S@*.

3 +8* ? 4 ( 7 * * * ?

7. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ HW^%*'$SHB*HU OBHJ%B&@ AHW;K$%*@# V S'&H- *H$'=%;<A=J' H AJH%JB%>%**HU @ OH;*HU /O;'=% *';H?HJ WC;H JC#J;%*H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%. F 16.25 OH>H^*@& >%TB'UOBH&/BHB'. OB@ OBHJ%$%*@@ HW^%*'$SHB*HU OBHJ%B&@ OB@WC; & S$'*@K OBHMH$*HUV . B%$A='J@Je@A< @ OB%$g#J@J A;/T%W*H% /$HA=HJ%B%*@% HMB'**@&/,. OH=B%WHJ'; OBHO/A=@=< %?H $;# OBHJ%$%*@# OBHJ%B&@. $*'&H HMB'**@& H=&'S';A# %?H OBHO/A=@=<, OHA&H;<&/ B'WHL@U $%*< OH$MH$@; & &H*N/, @ *@&H?H @S B/&HJH$A=J' *% WC;H, ' J @M H=A/=A=J@% H* *% >HT%= *@&H?H OBHO/A=@=<, ='& &'& HA/^%A=J;#%= HMB'*/ HWg%&=HJ V .

H $'**H>/ +'&=/ >%TB'UOBH&/BHB JHSW/$@; $%;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A='=<% 17.7 HV D S' />Ce;%**H% *%JCOH;- *%*@% =B%WHJ'*@U OBH&/BHB', JC=%&'K^@M @S %?H OH;*H>HL@U, /A='*HJ- ;%**CM +%$%B';<*C> S'&H*H>. i'^@=*@& HMB'**@&', &H=HBCU #J;#%=A# KB@A&H*A/;<=H> V , J A/$% /&'S';, L=H J $%UA=J@#M %?H OH$S'^@=*H?H H=A/=A=J/%= AHA='J '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J AJ#S@ A =%>, L=H J A='=<% 17.7 HV OB%$/A>H=B%*' H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' *%JCOH;*%*@% =B%- WHJ'*@U OBH&/BHB', ' *% OH>H^*@&' OBH&/BHB'. @BHJHU A/$<# OB@J;%& HMB'**@&' & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.

52

4 * , : *7 * (* - 7 7 ( 7 * * * , - 2 / * 27?

8. '&HU HB?'* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU KB@A$@&N@@ $H;T%* B'AA>'=B@J'=< $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, OB%$/A>H=B%**CM L'A=<K 2 A='=<@ 19.3 H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH- *'B/e%*@#M, J A;/L'%, %A;@ A='J@=A# JHOBHA H *'S*'L%*@@ ='&H?H J@$' '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@#, &'& '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU 'B%A=?

9. F H=*He%*@@ /OB'J;#K^%?H &H>>%BL%A&HU +@B>HU « » 23 @K;# 2005 ?. OBH&/BHBH> FH;TA&H?H B *' ?. 'B'=HJ' WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ- ;%*@% H JHSW/T$%*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH- *'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> L. 3 A=. 14.1 HV D. F A/$%W*H> S'A%$'- *@@ OB'JH*'B/e@=%;< OH#A*@;, L=H B%e%*@%> 'BW@=B'T*H?H A/$' H= 18 @K;# 2005 ?. H OB@J;%L%*@@ &H>>%BL%A&HU +@B>C « » & '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ WC;H H=&'S'*H J AJ#S@ A =%>, L=H «*' $%*< B'AA>H=- B%*@# $%;' H OB@J;%L%*@@ &H>>%BL%A&HU +@B>C & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@ O/W;@L*'# HW#S'**HA=< OH ;@N%*S@BHJ'*@K $'**H?H J@$' $%#=%;<*HA=@, *'B/e%*@% &H=HBHU J>%*%*H +@B>%, H=>%*%*'». H AAC;&'- >@ *' AHH=J%=A=J/K^@% A='=<@ HV D OB@>@=% B%e%*@% OH $'**H>/ $%;/.

10. /&HJH$@=%;< *';H?HJH?H HB?'*' AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A=. 15.5 HV D J H=*He%*@@ $@B%&=HB' A';H*' &B'AH=C S' *%OB%$A='J;%*@% *';H?HJHU $%&;'B'N@@ OH %$@*H>/ *';H?/ *' J>%*%**CU $HMH$. F A/$% OB@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' $@B%&=HB A'- ;H*' HWg#A*@;, L=H *';H? S' H=L%=*CU O%B@H$ WC; /O;'L%* $HABHL*H, OH- h=H>/ $%&;'B'N@# *% WC;' OB%$A='J;%*'. @BHJHU A/$<# *';HT@; '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ *' $@B%&=HB' A';H*' &B'AH=C.

2 * * 27? % *2 * 7 7 ( 7 * * * ?

11. FH$@=%;< V., JC%ST'# AH $JHB' *' $HBH?/, OHJ%B*/; *';%JH, OBH- %M'J OH;HA/, &H=HB'# WC;' OB%$*'S*'L%*' $;# $J@T%*@# 'J=HW/AHJ. B@ h=H> H* O%B%A%& AO;He*/K B'S$%;@=%;<*/K OH;HA/. * WC; HA='*HJ;%* @*AO%&=HBH> E , &H=HBCU JOHA;%$A=J@@ AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> L. 3 A=. 12.15 HV D.

'=%B@';C $%;' WC;@ O%B%$'*C >@BHJH>/ A/$<%, &H=HBCU ;@e@; JH$@=%- ;# OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> *' 4 >%A#N'.

! & * & . 2 +8 ( 2- * * ? 3 : / & :K 8* / -?

12. *AO%&=HBH> WC; HA='*HJ;%* 'J=H>HW@;< F 3 A%B@@, *' &H=HBH> AO%B%$@ H=A/=A=JHJ'; ?HA/$'BA=J%**CU B%?@A=B'N@H**CU S*'&.

53

S'$@ B%?@A=B'N@H**CU S*'& WC; /A='*HJ;%*. *AO%&=HB AHA='J@; OBH=H- &H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 2 A=. 12.2 HV D, OH- A&H;<&/ JH$@=%;%> WC;@ *'B/e%*C =B%WHJ'*@# E 50577-93 «i*'&@ ?HA/$'BA=J%**C% B%?@A=B'N@H**C% =B'*AOHB=*CM AB%$A=J. @OC @ HA*HJ- *C% B'S>%BC. %M*@L%A&@% =B%WHJ'*@#», AH?;'A*H &H=HBH>/ *' =B'*AOHB=- *H> AB%$A=J% $H;T*C WC=< /A='*HJ;%*C $J' ?HA/$'BA=J%**CM B%?@A=B'- N@H**CM S*'&' J OB%$/A>H=B%**CM $;# h=H?H >%A='M. '=%B@';C $%;' WC- ;@ O%B%$'*C >@BHJH>/ A/$<%.

3 K * & ? * 2 * 27? % * * ( * 7? > / *7, * * * * * & 8 / * *- , *7 / / * ?

13. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ $H&/>%*=HJ / 2 A=/$%*=HJ @S ?. '>WHJ, OBHT@J'K^@M J A*@>'%>HU @>@ &J'B=@B%, /L'A=&HJC> /OH;*H>HL%**C> OH;@N@@ WC;H /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H H$@* @S *@M, ?B'T$'*@* ., OBHT@J'%= OH O'AOHB=/, ABH& $%UA=J@# &H=HBH?H @A=%& OH $HA=@T%*@K ?B'T$'*@*H> 20 ;%=. F *'A=H#^%% JB%># %?H JHSB'A= AHA='J;#%= 21 ?H$, @ O'AOHB= OH *'A=H#^%% JB%># @> *% WC; S'>%*%*.

AHHW^@;, L=H H* JC*/T$%* W/$%= AHA='J@=< OBH=H&H; HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 1 A=. 19.15 HV D S' OBHT@J'*@% W%S O'AOHB='.

EB'T$'*@* . *% AH?;'A@;A# A «/L'A=&HJC>», OHA&H;<&/ O'AOHB= / *%- ?H @>%%=A#, MH=# @ OBHABHL%**CU. « L'A=&HJCU» AHHW^@;, L=H =H?$' AH- A='J@= OBH=H&H; OH h=HU T% A='=<%, *H S' OBHT@J'*@% OH *%$%UA=J@=%;<- *H>/ O'AOHB=/. =/$%*= *% AH?;'A@;A# @ A h=@>, OHA&H;<&/ %?H O'AOHB= *% #J;#%=A# AH?;'A*H H;HT%*@K H O'AOHB=% ?B'T$'*@*' D *%$%UA=J@=%;<- *C>. L'A=&HJCU /OH;*H>HL%**CU OB@J;%& ?B'T$'*@*' . & '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L. 1 A=. 19.15 HV D S' OBHT@J'*@% OH *%$%UA=J@=%;<*H>/ O'AOHB=/.

% *7 * (* * * -7?

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e@%A# 8 &HO%%& @S B'AL%=' 100 B/W;%U.

54

H B%S/;<='='> OBHJ%B&@ WC;H JC*%A%*H HOB%$%;%*@% HW H=&'S% J JHS- W/T$%*@@ $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ J AJ#S@ A H=A/=- A=J@%> AHA='J' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OHA&H;<&/ *% WC;H *'B/e%*@U B'J@; =%M*@L%A&HU h&AO;/'='N@@ Vi . EB'T$'*@* HWT';H- J'; h=H= H=&'S J A/$..

3 ? 8 * * 27? 8 * 7 7 / /+ ? ?

15. H=B/$*@&'>@ F ?. '*&= %=%BW/B? OB@ OBHJ%B&% 'O=%L*H?H O/*&=' «VO=%&' », JC#J;%* +'&= H=O/A&' OB%O'B'=' « 'J@*=H*» W%S B%N%O=' JB'L', ' ='&T% +'&= OBH$'T@ ;%L%W*HU &HA>%=@&@ W%S A%B=@+@&'- =' AHH=J%=A=J@# @ =HJ'B*H =B'*AOHB=*CM $H&/>%*=HJ. ' S'J%$/K^/K 'O=%L*C> O/*&=H> AH=B/$*@&H> OH;@N@@ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 4 A=. 14.1 HV D.

2 +8 ; ( 8 ? 2 +8 6 & 8 K 7?

16. ';H?HJC>@ HB?'*'>@ AHJ>%A=*H A /L'A=&HJC> @*AO%&=HBH> F WC;' OBHJ%$%*' OBHJ%B&' AHW;K$%*@# S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' J A+%B% OBH@S- JH$A=J' @ HWHBH=' h=@;HJH?H AO@B=' @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@ J >'?'S@*%, OB@*'$;%T'^%> @*$@J@$/';<*H>/ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;K r. B@ OBHJ%B&% OBH$'J%N >'?'S@*' *% OB%$g#J@; =HJ'B*H =B'*AOHB=*C% *'&;'$- *C%, AOB'J&@ & *@> @ A%B=@+@&'=C AHH=J%=A=J@# *' B#$ *'@>%*HJ'*@U ';&H?H;<*HU OBH$/&N@@, *'MH$#^%UA# J OBH$'T%. BH$'J%N OH#A*@;, L=H JA% *%HWMH$@>C% $H&/>%*=C *' ';&H?H;<*/K OBH$/&N@K @>%K=A# J W/M- ?';=%B@@, *H OHA&H;<&/ B'WHL@U $%*< /T% S'&H*L%*. M OB%$A='J@=< *%- JHS>HT*H. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> L'A=<K 2 A='=<@ 14.16 HV .

*AO%&N@# HWB'=@;'A< J 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$ A S'#J;%*@%> H OB@J;%- L%*@@ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;# & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@. F A/- $%W*H> S'A%$'*@@ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;< OB%$A='J@; A/$/ JA% *%HWMH$@>C% $H&/>%*=C, OH$=J%BT$'K^@% ;%?';<*HA=< OBH$'T@ $'**HU ';&H?H;<- *HU OBH$/&N@@.

3 ? 8 * * ?

17. H=B/$*@&H> B%?@H*';<*H?H H=$%;%*@# %*A@H**H?H +H*$' D 22 A%*=#WB# 2006 ?. WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH- *'B/e%*@@ OH L. 1A=. 15.6 HV D *' $@B%&=HB' S' *%OB%$A='J;%-

$%;H 12 #*J'B# 2007 ?. @ JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*H?H e=B'+' J B'S>%B% 300 B/W;%U.

3+8; 8 7? 2 +86 &-?

55

18. *AO%&=HBH> =%BB@=HB@';<*H?H DV *' @*$@J@$/';<*H?H OB%$- OB@*@>'=%;# . WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'- B/e%*@@ OH A=. 14.3 HV D S' B%&;'>/ OBH$'T@ @> O'B+K>%B*CM @S- $%;@U, *% @>%# ;@N%*S@@ *' HO=HJ/K OBH$'T/. 'L';<*@&H> =%BB@=HB@- ';<*H?H /OB'J;%*@# OB%$OB@*@>'=%;< WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' *%*'$;%T'^/K B%&;'>/. B%$OB@*@>'=%;< HWT';HJ'; J VBW@=B'T*CU A/$ HW;'A=@ OHA='*HJ;%*@#, HWHA*HJCJ'# AJHK T';HW/ =%>, L=H B%&;'>' WC;' A$%;'*' J AHH=J%=A=J@@ A D%$%B';<*C> S'&H*H> « B%&;'>%».

3 ? 7 2 * 27 + ? * ?

19. HA='*HJ;%*@#>@ =%BB@=HB@';<*H?H DV B%&;'>H$'=%;< @ B%- &;'>H@S?H=HJ@=%;< WC;@ OB@J;%L%*C & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**H- A=@ OH A=. 14.3 HV D S' @AOH;<SHJ'*@% HWB'SHJ $%=%U J JHSB'A=% H= 1 ?H$' $H 3-M ;%= J B%&;'>% =HJ'BHJ, *% H=*HA#^@MA# & =HJ'B'>, OB%$*'S*'- L%**CM $;# *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M. , &H=HBH% WC;H B%&;'>H$'=%;%>, HWB'=@;HA< J 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$ A S'#J;%*@%> HW HAO'B@J'*@@ OHA='*HJ;%- *@#, J &H=HBH> HWg#A*#;H, L=H B%&;'>' *HA@;' HW^@U M'B'&=%B, ' *'SJ'*@% G =$%;HL*C% >'=%B@';C» /&'SCJ';H *' *';@L@% ='> =HJ'BHJ AHH=J%=- A=J/K^%?H 'AAHB=@>%*='. WB'S $%=%U J B%&;'>% OB%$HA='J;#; OH=B%W@=%- ;#> @*+HB>'N@K H *';@L@@ J >'?'S@*% H=$%;HL*CM >'=%B@';HJ, J AHH=- J%=A=J@@ A OH=B%W*HA=<K $%=%U ($%=A&@% HWH@, AO%N@';<*C% >#?&@% OH- &BC=@# $;# OH;', $%=A&@% />CJ';<*@&@ @ /*@='SC @ =YO.). B%$A='J@=%;<DV OH#A*@;, L=H B%&;'>' WC;' *'OB'J;%*' *' @*+HB>@BHJ'*@% H =HJ'- B'M, &H=HB'# OB%$*'S*'L%*' *% =H;<&H $;# @AOH;<SHJ'*@# OH OH=B%W*HA=#> $%=%U.

3 , :, * 7 2 * 2 ?

20. 6 >'# 2006 ?H$' /;&@*/ ;%?/ F;'$@>@BHJ@L/ @AOH;*@;HA< 14 ;%=, *H ='& &'& J A%><% /;&@*CM WC;H %^% $JH% >';H;%=*@M $%=%U, &H=H- BCM >'=< JHAO@=CJ';' H$*' (A%><# *'MH$@;'A< J =#T%;HU T@S*%**HU A@- =/'N@@) $%*%? *' H+HB>;%*@% O'AOHB=' *'U=@ *% /$';HA<. 20 'J?/A=' 2007 ?H$' >'=< ;%?', /;&@*' J%=;'*' @&H;'%J*', @SCA&'J +@*'*AHJ/K JHS>HT*HA=<, OHe;' H+HB>;#=< A AC*H> O'AOHB=, *H J>%A=% A JC$'L%U $H&/>%*=' J H=*He%*@@ *%% A=. /L'A=&HJC>, >'UHBH> OH;@N@@ @W@*C> VYF., WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> L. 2 A=. 19.15 HV D, ' 25 'J?/A=' 2007 ?H$' J H=*H- e%*@@ *%% @W@*C> VYF. WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' J B'S>%B% $J/M =CA#L O#=@AH= B/W;%U.

/;&@*' HWB'=@;'A< A T';HWHU *' OHA='*HJ;%*@% J B'UH**CU A/$. F AJH%U T';HW% H*' /&'S';', L=H OHA='*HJ;%*@% JC*%A%*H A *'B/e%*@%> OH;HT%*@U A=. 4.5 H$%&A' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M J AJ#- S@ A L%> $H;T*H WC=< H=>%*%*H.

56

nJ;#%=A# ;@ B'AA>H=B%**CU J S'$'L% A;/L'U $;#^@>A# '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*C> OB'JH*'B/e%*@%>? >%K=A# ;@ / /;&@*HU HWA=H#=%;<A=J' A>#?- L'K^@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*/K H=J%=A=J%**HA=<? WHA*HJ'**H ;@ J $'**H> A;/L'% *'S*'L%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# >'&A@>';<*H?H B'S>%B'? nJ;#K=A# ;@ $%UA=J@# /;&@*HU J@*HJ*C>@?

% : *7 7 * . 4.5. 3 " ?

) * * 2 ? + , ? & - ( 8 * ? + .

21. O%B'=@J*CU B'WH=*@& &'O@='* /BT@&HJ OH%S$H> JHSJB'^';A# @S &H>'*$@BHJ&@. F H$*H> @S &/O% J'?H*' H* S'>%=@;, &'& >/TL@*' OH MH$/ $J@T%*@# OH%S$' OBH@SJH$@= +H=H?B'+@BHJ'*@% @S H&*'. F h=H JB%># OH%S$ OBHMH$@; OH >%A=*HA=@, ?$% B'AOH;'?';@A< B'S;@L*C% HWg%&=C, J L'A=*HA=@: ;@*@@ JCAH&HJH;<=*CM O%B%$'L, H=J%=J;%*@# T%;%S*H$HBHT- *CM O/=%U, 'hBH$BH>, '*=%**C% OH;# @ $B.

%B%S OBHJH$*@&' HO%B'=@J*CU B'WH=*@& JC#A*@;, L=H J $'**H> &/O%

22. *AO%&=HB/ @S HWB'SHJ'=%;<*H?H /LB%T$%*@# OHA=/O@;' @*+HB- >'N@# H =H>, L=H *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@U '&A@>HJ (12 ;%=) OHA=H#**H &/B@= J e&H;<*H> =/';%=% @ *% B%'?@B/%= *' S'>%L'*@# /L@=%;%U. ?H >'=< '&A@>H- J' J$H&@# %B?%%J*' *%H$*H&B'=*H JCSCJ';'A< J e&H;/, A *%U OBHJH$@;@A< B'Sg#A*@=%;<*C% W%A%$C, *H J OHA;%$*%% OHA%^%*@% &;'AA*H?H B/&HJH$@=%;# H*' S'#J@;', L=H $' %% AC* &/B@=, H*' h=H S*'%= @ A'>' OHA;%$*%% JB%># OH&/- O'%= %>/ MHBHe@% A@?'B%=C. '&A@>HJ' S'#J@;', L=H O/A=< ;/Le% &/B@= MHBHe@% A@?'B%=C, L%> W/$%= AHW@B'=< «S'B'S*C% WCL&@».

*AO%&=HBH> J H=*He%*@@ '&A@>HJHU WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ AH?;'A*H A=. 5.35 HV D, *' HA*HJ'*@@ &H=HBH?H OB@J;%&;' %% & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%*- *HA=@ @ *'S*'L@;' e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 300 B/W;%U.

'&A@>HJ' &'=%?HB@L%A&@ *% AH?;'A@;'A< A OHA='*HJ;%*@%> @ HWB'=@- ;'A< J B'UH**CU A/$ A T';HWHU, J &H=HBHU /&'S';', L=H AJH@ HW#S'**HA=@ OH JHAO@='*@K AC*' H*' JCOH;*#%=, ='& &'& %% B%W%*H& *@&H?$' *% OBH?/- ;@J'%= e&H;/ @ /L@=A# *' H=;@L*H, H*' A'>' *@&H?$' *% @?*HB@BHJ';' JCSHJC J e&H;/ @ *@ &H?$' *% OBHO/A&';' BH$@=%;<A&@% AHWB'*@#, *H OH*#J, L=H %% W%A%$C A AC*H> OH OHJH$/ &/B%*@# A=';@ W%AOH;%S*C>@ H*' B'SB%- e@;' %>/ &/B@=< H+@N@';<*H @ A=';' OH&/O'=< A@?'B%=C A'>'. '**CU AJHU e'? H*' HWHA*HJ';' =%>, L=H ='& %U W/$%= AOH&HU*%U, L=H H* *% *'L*%= @A&'=< $%*<?@ *' A@?'B%=C OB%A=/O*C> O/=%> @ *% S'B'S@=<A# &'- &HU ;@WH WH;%S*<K, OH$W@B'# WCL&@ *' /;@N%.

57

7? * 3! ? * 2-? + * .

23. 13 #*J'B# *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*## '+H*HJ' (17 ;%=) %% OH$B/?' E'J- B@;HJ' (17 ;%=) @ >'=< '+H*HJHU OB'S$*HJ';@ « ='BCU *HJCU ?H$» @ B'AO@;@ 3 W/=C;&@ e'>O'*A&H?H. HA;% L%?H '=< @ $HL< OHe;@ OBHJH- T'=< E'JB@;HJ/, HT@$'# =B'>J'# *' HA='*HJ&%, H*@ ?BH>&H A>%#;@A< @ O%;@ B/AA&@% *'BH$*C% O%A*@, OHA;% L%?H & *@> OH$He%; *'B#$ OH;@N@@, &H=HBCU $HA='J@; @M J $%T/B*/K L'A=< B'UH**H?H H=$%;' J*/=B%**@M $%;, ?$% J H=*He%*@@ >'=%B@ '+H*HJHU WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; OH L. 3 A=. 6. 10 HV D. F AJH@M HWg#A*%*@#M '+H*HJ' /&'S';', L=H S*';' H =H>, L=H $%JHL&@ *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@%, *H AL@='%=, L=H *@L%?H OBH=@JHOB'J*H?H H*' *% AHJ%Be@;', =%> WH;%%, L=H E'JB@;HJ' /T% S'>/T%>, ' %% $HL%B@ 18 ;%= @AOH;*#%=A# L%B%S >%A#N.

) , * 2 * 7 6 * * - * 7 * 8 (. 3 * . 6.10 3 " ? ? +8 2 / / ( 2 8 ? ? ( * 2 8 8 +* 7 2* * 7 ( :;* : * * 2? ? 3! 6 &- 2 * 7 * (. 3 * . 6.10 3 " , * . 20.21 3 " , * , * 7 ?

! * * * * - 7 * * . 6.10 3 " / * +C , +C , ? / : * * +C +C * 7.

58

T 0 /0 E

@ O@ F 0/ OQ <

/BAHJ'# B'WH=' AHA='J;#%= L'A=< /L%W*H?H OBHN%AA' J KB@$@L%A&@M J/S'M. f=H '&'$%>@L%A&'# +HB>' *'/L*H @AA;%$HJ'=%;<A&HU B'WH=C A=/- $%*='.

/BAHJ'# B'WH=' $H;T*' H=B'T'=< /?;/W;%**H% @S/L%*@% HOB%$%;%*- *HU =%>C @;@ H=$%;<*H?H JHOBHA' OH AO%N&/BA/ «V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=- J%=A=J%**HA=<», $%UA=J/K^%?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' @ OB'&=@&@ %?H OB@>%*%- *@# OH JHOBHA/ &/BAHJHU B'WH=C, AH$%BT'=< JCJH$C @ OB%$;HT%*@# OH HA*HJ*C> JHOBHA'> =%>C. /BAHJ'# B'WH=' OB%$A='J;#%= AHWHU H$*/ @S +HB> &H*=BH;# B'WH=C A=/$%*=' J =%L%*@% /L%W*H?H ?H$'.

1. E ! %( ) % #$-

=/$%*= HA/^%A=J;#%= &/BAHJ/K B'WH=/ J =%L%*@% JA%?H /L%W*H?H ?H- $'. A*HJ*'# S'$'L' &/BAHJHU B'WH=C AHA=H@= J /?;/W;%**H> @S/L%*@@ H$*HU @S =%> AO%N&/BA', J B'SJ@=@@ / A=/$%*=HJ *'JC&HJ A'>HA=H#=%;<*H HA/^%A=J;#=< *'/L*H @AA;%$HJ'=%;<A&/K B'WH=/.

F OBHN%AA% B'WH=C A=/$%*= $H;T%* A'>HA=H#=%;<*H OBHB'WH='=< =%>/, @S/L@J /L%W*/K @ AO%N@';<*/K ;@=%B'=/B/, *HB>'=@J*C% @A=HL*@&@ @ OB'JHOB@>%*@=%;<*/K OB'&=@&/, @ A$%;'=< HWHA*HJ'**C% JCJH$C @ OB%$- ;HT%*@# OH @AA;%$/%>HU =%>%, @S;'?'# @M OHA;%$HJ'=%;<*H, ;H?@L%A&@, HO%B@B/# *'/L*C> #SC&H>.

FCOH;*%**'# &/BAHJ'# B'WH=' $H;T*' OH&'S'=< />%*@% A=/$%*=' B'WH- ='=< A /L%W*HU @ *'/L*HU ;@=%B'=/BHU, @S/L'=< *HB>'=@J*/K W'S/ @ OB'- JHOB@>%*@=%;<*/K OB'&=@&/; *' HA*HJ% '*';@S' @S/L'%>H?H >'=%B@';' $%;'=< HWHW^%*@#, JCJH$C, OB'J@;<*H +HB>/;@BHJ'=< OB%$;HT%*@#, *'OB'J;%**C% *' AHJ%Be%*A=JHJ'*@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' @ OB'&=@&@ %?H OB@>%*%*@#.

2. -# % $'-

FCW@B'# =%>/, A=/$%*= $H;T%* B/&HJH$A=JHJ'=<A# AJH@>@ @*=%B%A'- >@, JHS>HT*HA=#>@ @ S*'*@%> OB%$>%='. %>C &/BAHJCM B'WH= OB%$;'?'%= &'+%$B'. =/$%*=/ B'SB%e'%=A# ?H=HJ@=< &/BAHJ/K B'WH=/ @ OH =%>%, A+HB>/;@BHJ'**HU @> A'>@>, OB%$J'B@=%;<*H AH?;'AHJ'J %% AH AJH@> *'/L*C> B/&HJH$@=%;%>. FCWB'J =%>/, A=/$%*= B%?@A=B@B/%= %% / ;'WH- B'*=' &'+%$BC. &'S'**C% HB?'*@S'N@H**C% $%UA=J@# $H;T*C WC=< HA/- ^%A=J;%*C J ABH& $H 15 *H#WB# =%&/^%?H /L%W*H?H ?H$'.

3. @$ %( ) % #$-

B@ OH$?H=HJ&% &/BAHJHU B'WH=C, A=/$%*=/ A;%$/%= J*@>'=%;<*H @S/L@=< O%B%L%*< AO%N@';<*HU ;@=%B'=/BC @ *HB>'=@J*CM OB'JHJCM '&=HJ, @ JCWB'=< ='&/K =%>/, &H=HB'# OH;/L@;' J ;@=%B'=/B% $HA='=HL*H% HAJ%^%*@%.

59

S/L@J OB%$>%= @AA;%$HJ'*@#, A=/$%*= AHA='J;#%= OBH%&= O;'*' &/B- AHJHU B'WH=C, AO@AH& *HB>'=@J*H?H >'=%B@';' @ ;@=%B'=/B*CM @A=HL*@- &HJ, HOB%$%;#%= HA*HJ*C% *'OB'J;%*@# *'/L*H @AA;%$HJ'=%;<A&HU B'WH=C.

';%% A=/$%*= $H;T%* AH?;'AHJ'=< A *'/L*C> B/&HJH$@=%;%> OBH%&= O;'*', AO@AH& *HB>'=@J*H?H >'=%B@';' @ ;@=%B'=/B*CM @A=HL*@&HJ. A;@ O;'* B'WH=C OB%$J'B@=%;<*H *% WC; AH?;'AHJ'*, ='&'# B'WH=' *' &'+%$B/ $;# B%N%*S@BHJ'*@# *% OB@*@>'%=A#.

HA;% B'SB'WH=&@ @ AH?;'AHJ'*@# O;'*' B'WH=C A=/$%*= $H;T%* @S/- L@=< AO%N@';<*/K ;@=%B'=/B/. B@ h=H> A;%$/%= HWB'^'=< J*@>'*@% *% =H;<&H *' &H*&B%=*H% AH$%BT'*@% JHOBHA', *H @ *' H=*He%*@% 'J=HB' &'T$HU >H*H?B'+@@ @;@ $B/?HU O/W;@&'N@@ & B'AA>'=B@J'%>H>/ JHOBHA/, &B@=@&/ $B/?@M &H*N%ON@U @ *'/L*CM JCJH$HJ. %&H>%*$/%=A# OHA;% @S/- L%*@# B'WH= &B'=&H S'O@A'=< HA*HJ*C% JCJH$C @ OB%$;HT%*@# 'J=HBHJ.

i'=%> A=/$%*=/ A;%$/%= @S/L@=< S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH, B%?/;@B/K^%% JHOBHAC, S'=B'?@J'%>C% J &/BAHJHU B'WH=%: AHH=J%=A=J/K^@% A='=<@ H*- A=@=/N@@ D, $%UA=J/K^%?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' @ $B/?@M *HB>'=@J*CM '&- =HJ.

S/L%*@% =%HB@@ JHOBHA' @ $%UA=J/K^%?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' OH WH;<- e@*A=J/ =%> &/BAHJCM B'WH= =B%W/%= B'AA>H=B%*@# @ HWHW^%*@# KB@A- $@&N@H**HU OB'&=@&@ B'WH=C A/$HJ @ *%A/$%W*CM HB?'*HJ. ;%$/%= HOB%- $%;@=< KB@A$@&N@H**C% HB?'*C, OB'&=@&/ &H=HBCM A=/$%*= AL@='%= *%HWMH$@>C> HWHW^@=<, JC$%;@=< JHOBHAC @ OBHN%AA/';<*C% $H&/>%*=C $;# @S/L%*@#. FA% h=H AH?;'AHJCJ'%=A# A *'/L*C> B/&HJH$@=%;%>, &H=HBCU $'%= *'OB'J;%*@% $;# @S/L%*@# OB'&=@&@ J AHH=J%=A=J/K^@M ?HA/$'B- A=J%**CM HB?'*'M.

%S/;<='=C OB'&=@&@ HWHW^'K=A# O@A<>%**H, H=>%L'K=A# OH;HT@- =%;<*C% >H>%*=C @ JC#J;#K=A# *%$HA='=&@, +HB>/;@B/K=A# JCJH$C @ OB%$;HT%*@#.

N%*&' AHWB'**CM >'=%B@';HJ $'%=A# OB@>%*@=%;<*H & HA*HJ*C> JHOBHA'> O;'*' &/BAHJHU B'WH=C.

4. % # !" ( %R !U %( ) % #$-

HA;% AWHB', @S/L%*@# @ A@A=%>'=@S'N@@ >'=%B@';HJ A=/$%*= OB@A=/- O'%= & H&H*L'=%;<*H>/ H+HB>;%*@K &/BAHJHU B'WH=C.

=B/&=/B' &/BAHJHU B'WH=C $H;T*' WC=< OHA=BH%*' OH A;%$/K^%U AM%>%: JJ%$%*@%, HA*HJ*C% =%>'=@L%A&@% B'S$%;C (OH O;'*/), S'&;KL%*@%, OB@;HT%*@#, %A;@ @>%K=A# (*HB>'=@J*CU >'=%B@';, >'=%B@';C OB'&=@&@ @S 'BM@JHJ @ $B/?@% $H&/>%*=C), W@W;@H?B'+@#.

FH JJ%$%*@@ HWHA*HJCJ'%=A# '&=/';<*HA=< =%>C &/BAHJHU B'WH=C, @ HOB%$%;#K=A# S'$'L@ *'/L*H?H @AA;%$HJ'*@#.

F HA*HJ*HU L'A=@ B'A&BCJ'%=A# AH$%BT'*@% =%>C OH JHOBHA'> O;'*'.H &'T$H>/ JHOBHA/ O;'*' B'AA>'=B@J'K=A# %?H =%HB%=@L%A&@% 'AO%&=C,

60