Административная ответственность. Учебно-методическое пособие

6. H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH> *';H?HJCM HB?'*HJ OB@ OBHJ%B&% W/M?';=%B- A&HU H=L%=*HA=@ (W/M?';=%BA&@U W';'*A, H=L%= H OB@WC;#M @ /WC=&'M, B'A- L%=C OH *';H?/ *' @>/^%A=JH, $%&;'B'N@@ OH *';H?/ *' OB@WC;<, , *';H?/ A OBH$'T S' 2003 ?H$' @ 1-2 &J'B=';C 2004 ?H$') WC;H HW*'B/T%*H, L=H $@B%&=HB . AHJ%Be@; OBH=@JHOB'J*C% $%UA=J@#, OB%$/A>H=B%*- *C% A='=<%U 15.5 @ L'A=<K 1 A='=<@ 15.6 HV D. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H;.

@BHJHU A/$<#, B'AA>'=B@J'# $%;H HW h=@M '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH- *'B/e%*@#M, /A='*HJ@;, L=H $@B%&=HB . *% >H? OB%$A='J@=< AJH%- JB%>%**H J *';H?HJCU HB?'* /&'S'**/K H=L%=*HA=< J AJ#S@ A =%>, L=H JA% MHS#UA=J%**C% @ OB'JH/A='*'J;@J'K^@% $H&/>%*=C WC;@ @Sg#=C OH /?H;HJ*H>/ $%;/, H L%> . @SJ%^'; *';H?HJC% HB?'*C. ' h=H> HA*HJ'*@@ A/$<# JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H OB%&B'^%*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;/ S' H=- A/=A=J@%> AHA='JHJ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U.

N ? , +8 ; 8 7 ? * 8 & 8 8 * 2 .

7. 20 @K;# 2007 ?H$' J A&J%B% *' /;. /M'B%JA&HU J ?. HA&J% WC; S'- $%BT'* ?B'T$'*@* '+H*HJ VYZ., &H=HBCU AOB'J;#; AJH@ %A=%A=J%**C% *'$HW*HA=@, /&BCJe@A< J *%JCAH&@M OHA'$&'M A&J%B'. B@S*'&HJ HO<#*%- *@# / '+H*HJ' *% *'W;K$';HA<, A AH=B/$*@&'>@ HB?'*HJ OB'JHOHB#$&' H* $%BT';A# A$%BT'**H @ &HBB%&=*H. SJ@*##A< '+H*HJ OH#A*@;, L=H, & AHT';%*@K, *% >H? WH;<e% =%BO%=<, ' OHW;@SHA=@ H= A&J%B' @ J A'>H> A&J%B%, >%A= AO%N@';<*H OB%$/A>H=B%**CM $;# f E – *%=.

F H=*He%*@@ '+H*HJ' AH=B/$*@&H> F D A=. OB'OHB^@&H>HBSHJC> Y . WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/- e%*@@ OH L. 1 A=. 20.1 HV D. F AJHK HL%B%$< '+H*HJ *'O@A'; S'#J- ;%*@% A OBHA<WHU B'AA>H=B%=< $%;H OH >%A=/ AJH%?H T@=%;<A=J', =Y%. ?. #- S'*<, OB. @B', $. 15', $'**H% S'#J;%*@% J OB@A/=A=J@% '+H*HJ' WC;H OH$e@=H & OBH=H&H;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@.

F%B*/Je@A< $H>HU (J #S'*<), '+H*HJ =^%=*H T$'; OHJ%A=&/ @;@ @*HU $H&/>%*=, /J%$H>;#K^@U %?H H =H> ?$% @ &H?$' W/$%= B'AA>'=B@- J'=<A# %?H $%;H @ B%e@;, L=H AH=B/$*@&@ OH;@N@@ /L;@ %?H B'A&'#*@# @ HAJHWH$@;@ H= H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.

5 H&=#WB# 2007 ?H$' '+H*HJ HW*'B/T@; J AJH%> OHL=HJH> #^@&% &H*J%B=, J &H=HBH> WC;H OHA='*HJ;%*@% H OB@J;%L%*@% %?H & '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ @ *';HT%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' J B'S- >%B% H$*HU =CA#L@ B/W;%U, JC*%A%**H% *'L';<*@&H> %^'*A&H?H H=$%;' J*/=B%**@M $%; V ?. HA&JC 18 A%*=#WB# 2007 ?H$'.

'+H*HJ HWB'=@;A# A T';HWHU J A/$. F AJH%U T';HW% H* /&'S';, L=H %>/ WC;H *%HWHA*HJ'**H H=&'S'*H J /$HJ;%=JHB%*@@ MH$'='UA=J' H B'A- A>H=B%*@@ $%;' OH >%A=/ %?H T@=%;<A=J' @ $%;H WC;H B'AA>H=B%*H OH >%-

41

A=/ AHJ%Be%*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. '&T% '+H*HJ /&'SCJ';, L=H H JB%>%*@ @ >%A=% B'AA>H=B%*@# $%;' H* @SJ%^%* *% WC;, @ AHH=J%=A=J%**H *% >H? S'^@=@=< A%W#. F J#S@ A L%>, '+H*HJ =B%WHJ'; H=>%*C OHA='*HJ;%*@# @ OB%&B'^%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%$/.

4 73 " 7/ 7 7 2- * ? + : 8 * & + 7, C7 7 8 * / * + * 8 -7 ? * ( 7 , 6 & , ; / *2 * ? 3 *( * 7 *7 ** ( 7 * * * * (7 * ** * ? 2- * 7?

)* * 76 * * *7, * 8 (.1 * . 20.1 3 "- & ** 2 8 7 +8 ; 8 ** .

* 2 & 6 ? + * (-* * * (? + .

8. F H=*He%*@@ ?B'T$'*@*' F. WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> A=. 12.3 HV D. EB'T- $'*@* F. S'#J@; MH$'='UA=JH H B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' OH >%A=/ T@=%;<A=J'. qH$'='UA=JH WC;H /$HJ;%=JHB%*H. F A/$%W*H> S'A%$'*@@ OB'JH*'B/e@- =%;< S'#J@; MH$'='UA=JH H B'AA>H=B%*@@ >'=%B@';' OH >%A=/ /L%=' =B'*A- OHB=*H?H AB%$A=J' @ O%B%$'L% $%;' J $B/?HU A/$.

3 ? 7 2 * 27?

9. 19 >'# 2007 ?H$' J 7.00 L'AHJ *' B%&% HA&J% J B'UH*% $. /B>'&@*H ?B'T$'*% ?*'=HJ VY . (17 ;%=) @ D%$HBHJ Y . (28 ;%=) OBH@SJH$@;@ *%- S'&H**CU ;HJ BCWC A%=#>@ $;@**HU 30 >, JCAH=HU 1,8 > A #L%U&'>@ 30M30 >>. %=@ OBHJ%B#;@ A B%S@*HJHU *'$/J*HU ;H$&@ J 20 >%=B'M H= W%B%?'. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ 21 >'# 2007 ?H$' A='Be@> @*AO%&=HBH> OB'J- ;%*@# D%$%B';<*HU A;/TWC OH J%=%B@*'B*H>/ @ +@=HA'*@='B*H>/ *'$SH- B/ OH ?. HA&J% @ HA&HJA&HU HW;'A=@ =H;#BHJC> Y . *' ?*'=HJ' @ D%$HBHJ' WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 2 A=. 8.37 HV D, &H=HBCU WC; *'OB'J;%* J H>@AA@K OH $%;'> *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M HT'UA&H?H >/*@N@O';<*H?H B'UH*' HA&HJA&HU HW;'A=@ ($';%% H>@AA@#) 28 >'# 2007 ?H$'.

27 @K*# 2007 ?H$' H>@AA@# JC*%A;' OHA='*HJ;%*@% H JHSJB'^%*@@ OBH=H&H;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ @ $B/?@M >'=%B@';HJ $%;', AAC;'#A< *' =H, L=H H$@* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'- B/e%*@@ *% >HT%= WC=< AHA='J;%* J H=*He%*@@ $J/M ;@N AHJ%Be@Je@M OB'JH*'B/e%*@%.

42

F AJHK HL%B%$< A=. @*AO%&=HB HWB'=@;A# S' B'Sg#A*%*@#>@ J @*@- A=%BA=JH KA=@N@@ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. ' S'OBHA A=. @*AO%&=HB' @- *@A=%BA=JH KA=@N@@ OH#A*@;H, L=H AHA='J;%*@% *%A&H;<&@M OBH=H&H;HJ J A;/L'%, %A;@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@% AHJ%Be%*H *%A&H;<&@>@ ;@N'>@, H$%&AH> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M *% OB%$/A>H=- B%*H J AJ#S@ A L%>, J A;/L'% AHJ%Be%*@# OB'JH*'B/e%*@# ?B/OOHU ;@N HW h=H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ $H;T%* AHA='J;#=<A# H$@* OBH=H&H;, J &H=HBH> A;%$/%= /&'S'=< AJ%$%*@# H &'T$H> ;@N%, J H=*He%*@@ &H=HBH?H JHSW/T- $%*H $%;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@.

B'JH>%B*H ;@ H>@AA@# JC*%A;' HOB%$%;%*@% H JHSJB'^%*@@ OBH=H- &H;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ @ $B/?@M >'=%B@';HJ $%;'?

HT%= ;@ AHA='J;#=<A# H$@* OBH=H&H; *' $J/M ;@N AHJ%Be@Je@M '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%? HH=J%=A=J/K= ;@ $'**C% @*@A=%BA=JH> KA=@N@@ D B'Sg#A*%*@# *HB>'> H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M?

%* 2/ 7 * / ( , * * 2 8 + *-% . ) * * 2** 7 8 & - ( 8 * * * :; * .

9. ' /?;/ /;@N 'MHJ' @ H&H;HJHU OBH@SHe;H $HBHT*H =B'*AOHB=*H% OBH@Ae%A=J@%. $@* @S JH$@=%;%U OHOC=';A# A&BC=<A# A >%A=' OBH@Ae%- A=J@#. EB'T$'*@* ., JH$@=%;< 'J=H>HW@;#, A &H=HBC> OBH@SHe;H A=H;&*HJ%- *@%, *' /?;/ /;@N 'MHJ' @ /=#&HJ' $H?*'; JH$@=%;#, OC='Je%?HA# A&BC=<A#.B@WCJe@% @*AO%&=HBC E AHA='J@;@ AM%>/ >%A=' HW*'B/T%*@# =B'*A- OHB=*CM AB%$A=J. H @M OB@WC=@K J H=$%; E @*AO%&=HB . JB/L@; /L'A=*@&'> &HO@@ OBH=H&H;' @ OHA='*HJ;%*@# H *';HT%*@@ *' &'T$H?H @S *@M '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' J B'S>%B% 200 B/W;%U OH L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 12.27 HV D S' HA='J;%*@% >%A=' .

FH$@=%;< . HWB'=@;A# J A/$ A T';HWHU *' OHA='*HJ;%*@% A OBHA<WHU A*@S@=< B'S>%B '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+', OHA&H;<&/ H* #J;#%=A# @*J'- ;@$H> II ?B/OOC.

3 ? 8 * * ? * 2 7.

10. '& A;%$/%= OHA=/O@=< HB?'*/, &H=HBH>/ WC;' OH$'*' T';HW', %A;@ H*' *%OH$J%$H>A=J%**' %>/ @ J *%U *% /&'S'* HB?'*, &H=HBH>/ H*' '$B%AH- J'*'?

11. %e%*@%> %*=B';<*H?H ='>HT%**H?H /OB'J;%*@# OH OBH=%A=/ OBH&/BHB' WC;@ HA='J;%*C W%S @S>%*%*@# OHA='*HJ;%*@# HA=BH>A&HU ='>HT*@ OH $J/> $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M J H=*H- e%*@@ , ' OBH=%A= W%S /$HJ;%=JHB%*@#. F D HAA@@ OHA=/O@; OBH- =%A= H= OBH&/B'=/BC HA=BH>A&HU HW;'A=@ *' JCe%/&'S'**CM $J' OHA='- *HJ;%*@# HA=BH>A&HU ='>HT*@ @ B%e%*@% %*=B';<*H?H ='>HT%**H?H

43

/OB'J;%*@# OH OBH=%A=/ OBH&/BHB' *' HW' h=@ OHA='*HJ;%*@#. @A<>H> D HAA@@ /J%$H>@;' OBH&/B'=/B/ H *%JHS>HT*HA=@ B'AA>H=B%*@# OBH- =%A='.

3 8 0 " ** * *2 ? ? 0 " ** 7 7 2 9 -

2 ? 7 * * * ? ) + * **8 / 2* /C7* 7 0 " .

12. EB'T$'*@* F. HWB'=@;A# J HW;'A=*HU A/$ A T';HWHU J OHB#$&% *'$SHB' *' JA=/O@Je%% J S'&H**/K A@;/ B%e%*@% A/$<@ B'UH**H?H A/$' OH T';HW% *' OHA='*HJ;%*@% @*AO%&=HB' E . BH>% =H?H, J T';HW% H* OBHA@;, L=HWC $%;H OH %?H T';HW' B'AA>'=B@J';HA< A %?H /L'A=@%>.

/ ? 8 ( ? +8 7 / (* .30.11 3 " ) ( ( * & , ? + , ** ?

13. @BHJHU A/$<# OB@J;%& & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ ?B'T$'*@*' . S' AHJ%Be%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H A='=<%U 5.12 HV D. F B%SH;K=@J*HU L'A=@ OHA='- *HJ;%*@# WC;H $'*H B'Sg#A*%*@%, L=H AH?;'A*H A='=<@ 30.3 HV D OB'- JH*'B/e@=%;< >HT%= HWT';HJ'=< OHA='*HJ;%*@% J =%L%*@% 10 $*%U A >H- >%*=' OH;/L%*@# @;@ JB/L%*@# &HO@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@# OH $%;/ J B'UH**CU A/$. EB'T$'*@* . WB'=@;A# A T';HWHU J B'UH**CU A/$ *' h=H OHA='*HJ- ;%*@% L%B%S 8 $*%U OHA;% JB/L%*@# %>/ &HO@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@#. 'UH**CU A/$<# H=&'S'; J OB@*#=@@ T';HWC, OHA&H;<&/ $;# T';HW OH $%;'> H *'B/- e%*@#M J A+%B% @SW@B'=%;<*CM OB'J ?B'T$'* OB%$/A>H=B%* O#=@$*%J*CU ABH&. H HWA=H#=%;<A=JH, L=H ?B'T$'*@* *% S*'; HW h=H>, *% @>%%= S*'L%- *@#, ='& &'& J HV D, A &H=HBC> H* >H? HS*'&H>@=<A#, L%=&H /A='*HJ- ;%* ABH&. BH>% =H?H, AH?;'A*H L'A=@ 2 A='=<@ 30.3 HV D OBHO/^%*- *CU O#=@$*%J*CU ABH& *% OH$;%T@= JHAA='*HJ;%*@K.

N ? , +8 ; 8 7. 3 * ( +8 2 ? ".?

14. EB'T$'*@* r. @ $JH% %?H OB@#=%;%U 30.05.2006 ?. WC;@ OB@J;%L%*C & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 20.1 HV D S' =H, L=H H*@ J &J'B=@B% ?B'T$'*@*' r. 27.05.2006 ?. J 2 L'A' *HL@ B'AO@J'# AO@B=*C% *'O@=&@, A;/e';@ ?BH>&H >/SC&/ @ O%;@ O%A*@, =%> A'>C>, >%- e'# AHA%$#>. F h=H= T% $%*< (30.05.06), *% /AO%J OH;/L@=< &HO@K OHA='- *HJ;%*@#, ?B'T$'*@* r. HWB'=@;A# J A/$ A T';HWHU *' OHA='*HJ;%*@% HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> e=B'+%.

! ? * 27 7 2 ? + , * ? ; ( : * 7 ? ? + ?* ( * *( * 7 2 * ** 7 ? +8? 3? 8 * * 27 ? + ?

44

15. WC;H OB@J;%L%*H & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L'A=@ 1 A='=<@ 14.17 HV D. ' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 80000 B/W;%U A &H*+@A&'N@%U OBH@SJ%$%**H?H h=@;HJH?H AO@B='. H *' $%*< OB%$g#J;%*@# OHA='*HJ;%*@# & @AOH;*%*@K WC;H B%HB?'*@SHJ'*H J V . E%*%B';<*CU $@B%&=HB OHAL@=';, L=H JSCA&'*@% $%*%T*CM AB%$A=J S' AL%= *HJH?H KB@$@L%A&H?H ;@N' *%S'&H**H, OHA&H;<- &/ H*H *% AHJ%Be';H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#.

! & * & . 3 * ( ?

16. F H=*He%*@@ ?B *' . 22.05.05 AH=B/$*@&H> E AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**C> A=. 12.26 HV D. F &'L%A=J% >%A=' AHA='J;%*@# OBH=H&H;' HWHS*'L%*H: ?.'B'=HJ, /;. . /A'=HJ', $. 54, L=H H=*HA@=A# & &=#WB<A&H>/ B */ ?. '- B'=HJ'. F OBH=H&H;% /&'S'*H, L=H ?B * . AHJ%Be@; *'B/e%*@% OH$O. 2.3.2.B'J@; $HBHT*H?H $J@T%*@# D, H* *% JCOH;*@; S'&H**H?H =B%WHJ'*@# AH=B/$*@&' OH;@N@@ H OBHMHT$%*@@ >%$@N@*A&H?H HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@#.

'=%B@';C $%;' *'OB'J;%*C *' B'AA>H=B%*@% >@BHJH>/ A/$<% DB/*S%*- A&H?H B'UH*' ?. 'B'=HJ' 1.08.05 ?. F A/$%W*H> S'A%$'*@@ ?B * . J@*/ J AHJ%Be%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H A=. 12.26 HV D *% OB@S*';, >H=@J@B/# h=H =%>, L=H J%L%BH> 21 >'# JCO@; 50 ?B'>> JH$&@.

/ * & :. * * * + 7 3 " * * 2 7 .

17. EB'T$'*@* . HWB'=@;A# J B'UH**CU A/$ A T';HWHU *' OHA='*HJ- ;%*@% H OB@J;%L%*@@ & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L.1 @ L. 2 A=. 14.4 HV D @ *'S*'L%*@@ %>/ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' J B'S>%B% 4000 B/W;%U @ &H*+@A&'N@@ A%>@ AH=HJCM =%;%+H*HJ, #J@Je@MA# OB%$>%- =H> '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. JHK T';HW/ H* HWHA*HJCJ'; =%>, L=H *' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ &'& *' OB%$OB@- *@>'=%;#, MH=# H* #J;#;A# ;@e< OBH$'JNH>.

/$<# B'UH**H?H A/$' /A='*HJ@;, L=H OBH=H&H; WC; AHA='J;%* $H;T- *HA=*C>@ ;@N'>@ HB?'*HJ J*/=B%**@M $%; A He@W&'>@, &H=HBC% JOHA;%$- A=J@@ WC;@ /A=B'*%*C OHA;% %?H JHSJB'=' >@BHJC> A/$<%U, HA/^%A=J;#J- e%?H OH$?H=HJ&/ $%;' & B'AA>H=B%*@K. F B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' *@ ., *@ %?H '$JH&'= *% /L'A=JHJ';@, @ J $%;% *% WC;H $H&'S'=%;<A=J @M *'$;%T'^%?H @SJ%^%*@#. '&@> HWB'SH>, WC;@ $HO/^%*C A/^%A=J%**C% *'B/e%*@# OBHN%AA/';<*CM =B%WHJ'*@U HV D. /$<# ='&T% /A='*HJ@;, L=H ., $%UA=J@=%;<*H, HA/^%A=J;#; OBH$'T/ AH=HJCM =%;%+H*HJ, *% @>%Je@M AHH=J%=A=J/K^%U >'B&@BHJ&@ @ W%S A%B=@+@&'=HJ AHH=J%=A=J@#, #J;##A< B'WH=*@&H> Zr ?B'T$'*@*' V.

* * * 27 7 + / - * 7 ( * / / 7 / ( * - 6 / 2000 + * 6 * & * 8 6 .

2 7 * 27?

45

18. EB'T$'*@* . HWB'=@;A# A T';HWHU *' OHA='*HJ;%*@% OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L.1 A=. 12.27 HV D S' HA='J;%- *@% >%A=' , J &H=HBHU OBHA@; H=>%*@=< OHA='*HJ;%*@% @ OB%&B'=@=< OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;/. JHK T';HW/ H* HWHA*HJCJ'; =%>, L=H H* HA='J@; >%A=H , L=HWC $H?*'=< A&BCJ'Je%?HA# $B/?H?H /L'A=*@&' A >%A=' =H?H T% , &BH>% =H?H OHA='*HJ;%*@% WC;H JC*%A%*H *%/OH;*H>HL%**C> $H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH>. F OBHN%AA% B'AA>H=B%*@# T';HWC ?B'T$'*@* . B%- e@; H=HSJ'=< AJHK T';HW/, OHA&H;<&/ OH*#;, L=H A/$<# >HT%= *'OB'J@=< $%;H *' *HJH% B'AA>H=B%*@%, @ =H?$' OB'JH*'B/e%*@% W/$%= &J';@+@N@- BHJ'*H OH L. 2 A=. 12.27 H$%&A' @ *';HT%* WH;%% JCAH&@U e=B'+.

/$<# H=&'S'; J OBHA<W% S'#J@=%;#.

)& * & :. ? ? / 2 * : ? + ,? 7 2 * 27?

19. 12 @K;# 2007 ?H$' >'A=%B N%M' r%T'J', OB@ B'S?HJHB% AH AJH@> OH$L@*%**C>, 17-;%=*@> =H&'B%> qHBHe@;HJC>, S'>%=@;, L=H *%MHBHeH S'WCJ'=< A='BC% =B'$@N@@ O%BJHU S'B'WH=*HU O;'=C. F HW%$%**CU O%B%- BCJ qHBHe@;HJ «S'O'AA#» 3-># W/=C;&'>@ &B'A*H?H J@*' (0,75 ;) A AH- $%BT'*@%> AO@B=' 12% @, >@*/= S' 30 $H H&H*L'*@# B'WHL%U A>%*C, OB@- *%A AO@B=*H% J A;/T%W*H% OH>%^%*@% >'A=%B'. i'=%> H* OB@?;'A@; A;%A'- B# @&@+HBHJ' @ H*@ J=BH%> A=';@ B'AO@J'=< J@*H. '& @ OH;'?'%=A# A='Be%>/, r%T'J' B/&HJH$@; qHBHe@;HJC>, *% OHSJH;#; %>/ H=;C*@J'=< @ OB@*/T$'; $HO@J'=< AO@B=*H% $H &H*N'.

i' 15 >@*/= $H H&H*L'*@# B'WHL%?H $*# J OH>%^%*@% JHe%; ?;'J*CU @*T%*%B S'JH$', @ S'A=H;<% OB@e;HA< OB%&B'=@=<. ' A;%$/K^@U $%*< OH S'JH$/ WC; @S$'* OB@&'S HW HWg#J;%*@@ A=BH?H?H JC?HJHB' r%T'J% @ JC- ?HJHBHJ @&@+HBHJ/ @ qHBHe@;HJ/.

9 A%*=#WB# 2007 ?H$' @*AO%&=HB/ OH$B'S$%;%*@# OH $%;'> *%AHJ%B- e%**H;%=*@M J'*HJ/ A=';H @SJ%A=*H H $'**H> +'&=% @ H* AHA='J@; *' r%T'J/ @ @&@+HBHJ' OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 2 A=. 6.10 HV D (JHJ;%L%*@% *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*%?H J /OH=B%W;%- *@% AO@B=*CM *'O@=&HJ…). F =%L%*@% A/=H& J%A< >'=%B@'; *' /&'S'**CM ;@N WC; *'OB'J;%* J ?HBH$A&/K &H>@AA@K OH $%;'> *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M @ S'^@=% @M OB'J. ' 15 A%*=#WB# 2007 ?H$' WC;H *'S*'L%*H S'A%$'*@%, *' &H=HBH> *' r%T'J/ @ @&@+HBHJ' WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 500 B/W;%U.

2 * * ! % ? 3 6 & * 7-? 8 6 ./ ( * / 3! ?

20. 19 @K;# 2002 ?H$' J 20 L'A. 30 >@*. *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@U q'B@* (16 ;%=), AHJ>%A=*H A r'Oe@*C> (15 ;%=) JH $JHB% e&H;C j 8 ?. W*@*A&' A=B%;#;@ OH A'>H$%;<*HU >@e%*@ @S ?;'$&HA=JH;<*H?H HMH=*@L<%?H B/-

46

T<#. L'A=&HJCU /OH;*H>HL%**CU OH;@N@@ HJ@&HJ S'$%BT'; *'- B/e@=%;%U @ *' HWH@M AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; OH A=. 20.13. HV D (A=B%;<W' @S HB/T@# J *'A%;%**CM O/*&='M).

B@ B'SW@B'=%;<A=J% JC#A*@;HA<, L=H HW' *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M AHA=H- #= *' /L%=% J S' B'S;@L*C% OBHA=/O&@. $*HJB%>%**H A h=@>, /L'A=- &HJCU JC#A*@;, L=H q'B@* JS#; B/T<% $H>', JHAOH;<SHJ'Je@A< H=A/=A=J@- %> BH$@=%;%U. *H J@A%;H J *%S'O@B'K^%UA# &;'$HJHU, B#$H> A *@> *'MH- $@;A# O'=BH*='T A *%A&H;<&@>@ S'B#T%**C>@ O'=BH*'>@. HJ@&HJ JS#; +'&= *' S'>%=&/ A N%;<K OBHJ%$%*@# OBH+@;'&=@L%A&HU B'WH=C A H=NH> q'B@*'.

2 * ( * 8 ( 8 & (NN )? 3 ** : *7 8 + * 8 -

7 * ?

21. HA='*HJ;%*@%> A/$<@ B'UH**H?H A/$' H= 1 A%*=#WB# 2006 ?H$' ?B'T$'*@* B%AO/W;@&@ VB>%*@# . WC; OB@S*'* J@*HJ*C> J AHJ%Be%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H A=. 18.8 HVD, JCB'S@Je%?HA# J *%AHW;K$%*@@ /A='*HJ;%**H?H OHB#$&' B%?@A=B'N@@ *' =%BB@=HB@@ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. ' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 1500 B/W;%U A '$>@*@A=B'=@J*C> JC$JHB%*@%> S' OB%$%;C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@.

V$JH&'= ?B'T$'*@*' VB>%*@@ . OH$'; J HW;'A=*HU A/$ T';HW/ *' OHA='*HJ;%*@%, AAC;'#A< *' =H, L=H . A 1999 ?H$' AHA=H@= J WB'&% A ?B'T- $'*&HU D, H= WB'&' @>%%= $JH@M *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M $%=%U, @ OB@>%*%- *@% $HOH;*@=%;<*H?H *'&'S'*@# J J@$% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H JC$JHB%*@# S' OB%$%;C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ J;%L%= *'B/e%*@% A%>%U*CM H=*He%*@U.

3 ? * 2 * 27 + * * ?

* 2 * , ? + , * 2 + * * ? + .

! : * * * * 8, * 8 ) (. 1 2 * . 18.8 3 " +) * . 18.12 3 " .

' 8. '! !($%$! " $ $($($

+ $ - !- '! !($%$!-& H% % J !)

1. V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OHA#?'K-

^@% *' OB'J' ?B'T$'*.

47

2.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OHA#?'K- ^@% *' S$HBHJ<%, A'*@='B*H hO@$%>@H;H?@L%A&H% W;'?HOH;/L@% *'A%;%*@# @ HW^%A=J%**/K *B'JA=J%**HA=<.

3.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ HMB'*C AHWA=J%**HA=@.

4.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ HMB'*C AHWA=J%**HA=@ J HW;'A=@ HMB'*C H&B/T'K^%U OB@BH$*HU AB%$C @ OB@BH$HOH;<SHJ'*@#.

5.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J OBH>Ce- ;%**HA=@, A=BH@=%;<A=J% @ h*%B?%=@&%.

6.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J A%;<A&H> MHS#UA=J%, J%=%B@*'B@@ @ >%;@HB'N@@ S%>%;<.

7.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# *' =B'*A-

OHB=%.

8.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ $HBHT*H?H $J@T%*@#.

9.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ AJ#S@ @ @*+HB>'N@@.

10.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J A+%B% OB%$OB@*@>'=%;<A&HU $%#=%;<*HA=@.

11.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' *'B/e%*@# '*=@>H*HOH;<- *H?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J'.

12.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@

+@*'*AHJ, *';H?HJ @ AWHBHJ, BC*&' N%**CM W/>'?.

13.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ ='>HT%**H?H $%;'.

14.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OHA#?'- K^@% *' @*A=@=/=C ?HA/$'BA=J%**HU J;'A=@.

15.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ S'^@=C EHA/$'BA=J%**HU ?B'*@NC D @ HW%AO%L%*@# B%T@>' OB%WCJ'*@# @*HA=B'**CM ?B'T$'* @;@ ;@N W%S ?B'T$'*A=J' *' =%BB@=HB@@ D.

16.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# OBH=@J OHB#$&' /OB'J;%*@#.

17.V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OHA#?'-

K^@% *' HW^%A=J%**CU OHB#$H& @ HW^%A=J%**/K W%SHO'A*HA=<.

18. V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB'JH*'B/e%*@# J HW;'A=@ JH@*A&H?H /L%='.

48

:

H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.

B/$HJHU &H$%&A D // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1. L. 1, A=. 3.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 22 >'# 2003 ?. j 54-Di « OB@>%*%*@@ &H*- =BH;<*H &'AAHJHU =%M*@&@ OB@ HA/^%A=J;%*@@ *';@L*CM $%*%T*CM B'AL%- =HJ @ (@;@) B'AL%=HJ A @AOH;<SHJ'*@%> O;'=%T*CM &'B=» // HWB. S'&H*H- $'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2003. — j 21, A=. 1957; 2011. — j 27, A=. 3873.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 27 $%&'WB# 2002 ?. j 184-Di « =%M*@L%A&H> B%?/;@BHJ'*@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 52, L. I, A=. 5140.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 24 *H#WB# 1995 ?. j 181-Di « AHN@';<*HU S'^@=% @*J';@$HJ J HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J'HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 1995. j 48. =. 4563.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 22 *H#WB# 1995 ?. j 171-Di « ?HA/$'BA=J%*- *H> B%?/;@BHJ'*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' @ HWHBH=' h=@;HJH?H AO@B=', ';&H?H;<- *HU @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%- $%B'N@@. — 1995. — j 48, A=. 4553.

HA='*HJ;%*@% HJ%=' @*@A=BHJ – B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 23 H&=#WB# 1993 ?. j 1090 « OB'J@;'M $HBHT*H?H $J@T%*@#» // HWB'*@% '&=HJ B%- S@$%*=' @ B'J@=%;<A=J' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. 1993. j 47. =. 4531;HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2012. — j 1, A=. 154.

HA='*HJ;%*@% B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 26 @K*# 2008 ?. j 475 « W /=J%BT$%*@@ B'J@; HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@# ;@N', &H=HBH% /OB'J;#%= =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>, *' AHA=H#*@% ';&H?H;<*H?H HO<#*%*@# @ H+HB>- ;%*@# %?H B%S/;<='=HJ, *'OB'J;%*@# /&'S'**H?H ;@N' *' >%$@N@*A&H% HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@% *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@#, >%$@N@*A&H?H HAJ@$%=%;<- A=JHJ'*@# h=H?H ;@N' *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@# @ H+HB>;%*@# %?H B%S/;<='- =HJ @ B'J@; HOB%$%;%*@# *';@L@# *'B&H=@L%A&@M AB%$A=J @;@ OA@MH- =BHO*CM J%^%A=J J HB?'*@S>% L%;HJ%&' OB@ OBHJ%$%*@@ >%$@N@*A&H?H HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@# *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@# ;@N', &H=HBH% /OB'J;#%= =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2008. — j 27, A=. 3280.

HA='*HJ;%*@% B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 7 $%&'WB# 1996 ?. j 1449 « >%- B'M OH HW%AO%L%*@K W%AOB%O#=A=J%**H?H $HA=/O' @*J';@$HJ & @*+HB>'- N@@ @ HWg%&='> AHN@';<*HU @*+B'A=B/&=/BC» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J'HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 1996. — j 51, A=. 5806.

49

@A<>H i'>%A=@=%;# B%$A%$'=%;# F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D H= 6 >'B=' 2006 ?. j 1936-5/HW^. // OB'JHL*'# OB'JHJ'# A@A=%>' «E'B'*=».

HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.

HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D H= 24 H&=#WB# 2006 ?. j18 « *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ AH- W%**HU L'A=@ H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'- JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 11 *H#WB# 2008 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$'D. 2006. j 12.

HA='*HJ;%*@% F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D H= 13 @K;# 2006 ?. j 16-V 06-6 // OB'JHL*'# OB'JHJ'# A@A=%>' «E'B'*=».

*+HB>'N@H**H% O@A<>H EHAA='*$'B=' D H= 11 @K;# 2003 ?. j F - 110-28/2522 « A%B=@+@&'N@@ /A;/? J @A=%>% A%B=@+@&'N@@ E » // F%A=*@& EHAA='*$'B=' HAA@@. 2003. j 8.

:

'SW%B@=% AHA='JC '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U, OB%$/A>H=- B%**CM L. 2 A=. 5.27, L. 1 A=. 12.8, L. 1 A=. 14.1, A=. 17.7, L. 1 A=. 19.4, A=. 20.1, A=. 20.25 HV D.

E ! ! H% R !"

1. 8 >'B=' 2005 ?H$' J 13.30 ?B'T$'*@* . /A=BH@; $H>' A%><% A&'*- $';. * JCB'T';A# *%N%*S/B*HU WB'*<K J '$B%A AJH%U T%*C, ?HA=%U, B'S- >'M@J'; B/&'>@, B'SWB'ACJ'; OH $H>/ OHA/$/. @BHJHU A/$<# &J';@+@- N@BHJ'; $%UA=J@# . &'& *'B/e%*@% HW^%A=J%**H?H OHB#$&', JCB'T'K^%% #J*H% *%/J'T%*@% & HW^%A=J/, L=H OB%$/A>H=B%*H L'A=<K 1 A='=<@ 20.1HV D. H $'**H>/ OB'JH*'B/e%*@K WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%*@% HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> 'B%A=% *' 10 A/=H&.

4 * * 2 ?

2. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ J H$*H> @S >'?'S@*HJ OBHJ%B&@ S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' H OB@>%*%*@@ WC;H JC#J;%*H *'B/e%*@% J J@$% OBHW@=@# &'AAHJH?H L%&', *' &H=HBH> WC;H S'+@&A@BHJ'*H JB%># A B'S*@N%U J 7 >@*/= A +'&- =@L%A&@> JB%>%*%> HA/^%A=J;%*@# OH&/O&@. BH>% =H?H, / OB%$OB@*@>'- =%;# H=A/=A=JHJ'; $H?HJHB *' =%M*@L%A&H% HWA;/T@J'*@% @ B%>H*= &'AAHJH?H 'OO'B'=' *' =%&/^@U ?H$, @ *' &'AAHJH> 'OO'B'=% H=A/=A=JHJ';@ AB%$A=J' J@S/';<*H?H &H*=BH;#. B@ h=H> &'AAHJCU 'OO'B'= WC; @AOB'J%* @ B'WH='; J +@A&';<*H> B%T@>%. /&HJH$@=%;%> *';H?HJH?H HB?'*' WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=- B%**H> A=.14.5 HV D.

50