Административная ответственность. Учебно-методическое пособие

i'JYH=$%;%*@%> HWT';HJ'; OHA='*HJ;%*@% J AJ#S@ AH A=BH?HA=< *'S*'L%*- *H?H *'&'S'*@#. '& OH#A*@; S'J%$/K^@U, H* WC; JO%BJC% OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@, *@&'&@M H=#?L'K^@M HWA=H#=%;<A=J /A='*HJ;%*H *% WC;H, @ OH;HT@=%;<*H M'B'&=%B@S/%=A# *' B'WH=%, L=H OH$=J%BT$'%=A# M'B'&=%B@A=@&HU, $'**HU ?;'JJB'LH>, OHh=H>/ OB@ *'S*'- L%*@@ *'&'S'*@# >HT*H WC;H HWHU=@A< OB%$/OB%T$%*@%>.

/$<# B'UH**H?H A/$' HA='J@; OHA='*HJ;%*@% W%S @S>%*%*@U, >H=@J@BH- J'J AJH% B%e%*@% =%>, L=H OB%$/OB%T$%*@% *'S*'L'%=A# =H;<&H ?B'T$'*'>, @ S'J%$/K^%>/ H=$%;%*@%> WC; *'S*'L%* >@*@>';<*CU B'S>%B *'&'S'*@#, &H=HBH% OB%$/A>H=B%*H L. 1 A=. 20.4 HV D $;# $H;T*HA=*CM ;@N.

" /C7* * & :. 2 8 * * 27?

6. %BT'*= ABHL*HU A;/TWC '&'BHJ WC; H=O/^%* J /JH;<*%*@% *' JCMH$*C%. B@$# $H>HU, H* O%B%H$%;A# J ?B'T$'*A&/K +HB>/ H$%T$C @ OHOBHA@; AJH%?H A='Be%?H WB'=' $'=< %>/ &;KL@ H= >'e@*C, L=HWC Ag%S- $@=< J ?HBH$. T% JC%M'J @S $H>', '&'BHJ HW*'B/T@;, L=H S'WC; $H>' OB'J', *H JHSJB'^'=<A# *% A=';. F ?HBH$%, JA=B%=@Je@A< A $B/S<#>@, '- &'BHJ *%>*H?H JCO@;, OHA;% L%?H OH%M'; HWB'=*H $H>HU. H $HBH?% $H>HU H* WC; HA='*HJ;%* @*AO%&=HBH> , &H=HBCU, OB%$A='J@Je@A<, OHOBH- A@; '&'BHJ' OH&'S'=< $H&/>%*=C, ' ='&T% OHOBHA@; JCU=@ @S >'e@*C @ OBHU=@ HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@% *' AHA=H#*@% ';&H?H;<*H?H HO<#*%*@#. '- &'BHJ H=&'S';A# OB%$HA='J@=< $H&/>%*=C, ' ='&T% *% AH?;'A@;A# OBHMH- $@=< HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@%, S'W;H&@BHJ'J $J%B@ 'J=H>HW@;#, H=&'S';A# @S *%?H JCMH$@=<.

H=B/$*@&'>@ 'J=H>HW@;< WC; JA&BC=, ' '&'BHJ WC; $HA='J- ;%* J $%T/B*/K L'A=<, ?$% J H=*He%*@@ *%?H WC;H AHA='J;%*H L%=CB% OBH=H&H;' OH L.1 A=. 12.3 HV D, L.1 A=. 12.8 HV D, L. 1 A=. 12.26HV D, L. 1 A=. 19.3 HV D, OHA;% L%?H '&'BHJ WC; S'$%BT'* $H JC=B%SJ;%*@#, ' S'=%> OB%OBHJHT$%* & >@BHJH>/ A/$<%.

@BHJHU A/$<#, B'AA>H=B%J >'=%B@';C OH L.1 A=. 12.8 HV D JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '&'BHJ/ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# J J@$% ;@e%*@# OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> ABH&H> *' OH;- =HB' ?H$'. 'AA>H=B%J >'=%B@';C OH L. 1 A=. 12.26 HV D JC*%A OHA='- *HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# J J@$% ;@e%*@# OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> ='&T% ABH&H> *' OH;=HB' ?H$'.'AA>H=B%J >'=%B@';C OH L. 1 A=. 19.3 HV D HV D JC*%A OHA='- *HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# J J@$% '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*H?H 'B%A=' *' ABH& 3 A/=H&.

F =HT% JB%>#, *'L';<*@& B'UH**H?H H=$%;' B'AA>H=B%J >'=%B@'- ;C $%;' J H=*He%*@@ '&'BHJ' OH L.1 A=. 12.3 HV D JC*%A OHA='*HJ- ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# J J@$% e=B'+' J B'S>%- B% 100 B/W;%U.

31

/ * & : * ( / 7 3 " . - * : 8 * 8 * 2 * 7 + 7 3 " ? + : * 2 7 / ( 7 * 8 /-

* 2 8 * 7 * * + : + * 8 3 " .

' 6. @% !+ ($ H ' # '! !($% $! -& H% % J !"&. #M " & % $ %!($! .

1.H*#=@% @ H=;@L@=%;<*C% HAHW%**HA=@ OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M. WCL*H%, *%OBH=H&H;<*H% OBH@S- JH$A=JH @ OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M J 'BW@=B'T*CM A/$'M.

2.L'A=*@&@ OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'- B/e%*@#M, @M OBHN%AA/';<*'# OB'JHA/Wg%&=*HA=<.

3.H&'S'=%;<A=J' @ $H&'SCJ'*@% J OBH@SJH$A=J% OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@-

A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M: OH*#=@% @ J@$C.

4.H$J%$H>A=J%**HA=< $%; J OBH@SJH$A=J%, %% J@$C. /$%W*'# OH$J%- $H>A=J%**HA=< @ OH$A/$*HA=<.

5.B'JHJ'# OH>H^< OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M.

:

H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.

VBW@=B'T*CU OBHN%AA/';<*CU &H$%&A D H= 24 @K;# 2002 ?. j 95-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 30, A=. 3012.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 17 #*J'B# 1992 ?. j 2202-I « OBH&/B'=/B%HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // F%$H>HA=@ @ F D. 1992. j 8. =. 366;HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2011. — j 48, A=. 6730.

i'&H* 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@ H= 29 @K;# 2009 ?. j 104-i « W '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M *' =%BB@=HB@@ 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@» //HWB'*@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@. — 2009. — j 17, A=B. 3930–3936.

HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'

32

HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.

:

1.=H OB%$A='J;#%= @S A%W# OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M?

2.'&@% OB@*N@OC OBH@SJH$A=J' S'&B%O;%*C J H*A=@=/N@@ @ S'&H- *H$'=%;<A=J% HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M?

3.'&@% J'B@'*=C OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'- JH*'B/e%*@#M OB%$/A>H=B%*C S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH>?

4.'U=% M'B'&=%B@A=@&/ OB'JHJH?H A='=/A' S'^@=*@&' @ OB%$A='J@=%- ;# J OBH@SJH$A=J% OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M.

5.&'&H?H >H>%*=' >HT%= /L'A=JHJ'=< S'^@=*@& J OBH@SJH$A=J% OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M?

6.'U=% AB'J*@=%;<*/K M'B'&=%B@A=@&/ OB'JHJH?H A='=/A' h&AO%B=' @ AO%N@';@A=' J OBH@SJH$A=J% OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/- e%*@#M.

7.=H >HT%= A;/T@=< $H&'S'=%;<A=J'>@ OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@?

8.=H ='&H% OH$J%$H>A=J%**HA=< $%; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'- B/e%*@#M? '&@% J@$C OH$J%$H>A=J%**HA=@ /A='*HJ;%*C J HV D?

9.%> H=;@L'%=A# A/$%W*'# OH$J%$H>A=J%**HA=< H= OH$A/$*HA=@?

E ! ! H% R !"

1. EB'T$'*@* . OB@HWB%; J E%B>'*@@ 'J=H>HW@;< F 5 A%B@@ @ =B'*AOHB=@BHJ'; %% J HAA@UA&/K D%$%B'N@K. i'$%&;'B@BHJ'J =B'*A- OHB=*H% AB%$A=JH, . *% /O;'=@; J /A='*HJ;%**C% ABH&@ ='>HT%**C% OH- e;@*C. F H=*He%*@@ . ='>HT%**C> @*AO%&=HBH> WC;H JHSW/T$%*H $%- ;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> A='=<%U 16.22 HV D, @ *'S*'L%*H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% B'AA;%$HJ'*@%, OH B%S/;<- ='='> &H=HBH?H WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'- B/e%*@@. '=%B@';C $%;' WC;@ O%B%$'*C *'L';<*@&/ ='>HT%**H?H OH- A=', &H=HBCU OB@J;%& ?B'T$'*@*' . & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**H- A=@ J J@$% e=B'+' J B'S>%B% $J/M =CA#L B/W;%U.

BH&/BHB OB@*%A OBH=%A= J B'UH**CU A/$ *' $'**H% OHA='*HJ;%*@%, >H=@J@B/# %?H =%>, L=H AH?;'A*H O/*&=/ 2 L'A=@ 3 A='=<@ 23.1 HV D $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, &H=HBC% /&'S'*C J L'A=#M 1 @ 2 h=HU A='=<@, @ OBH@SJH$A=JH OH &H=HBC> HA/^%A=J;#%=A# J +HB>% '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*H?H B'AA;%$HJ'*@#, B'AA>'=B@J'K=A# A/$<#>@ B'UH**CM A/$HJ.

? : * ?

33

2. EB'T$'*@* ., JCU$# J%L%BH> JH $JHB >*H?H&J'B=@B*H?H T@;H?H $H>', B'SW@; S'$*KK +'B/ 'J=H>HW@;# AJH%?H AHA%$' ., &H=HBCU OHL=@ &'T$CU J%L%B AH AJH@>@ $B/S<#>@, A=H@= OH$ H&*'>@ ., B'AO@J'# AO@B=- *C% *'O@=&@ @ A;/e'# ?BH>&H >/SC&/. %UA=J@# . WC;@ &J';@+@N@BHJ'- *C &'& />Ce;%**H% OHJB%T$%*@% L/TH?H @>/^%A=J', L=H OB%$/A>H=B%*H A='=<%U 7.17 HV D.

B@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ . &'& AJ@$%=%;< OH#A*@;, L=H H* A $B/S<#>@ J@$@=A# B%$&H, ' J h=H= $%*< / *@M WC;H AHWC=@% — OB@HWB%=%*@% *HJH?H 'J=H>HW@;# H$*H?H @S @M $B/S%U.

H B%S/;<='='> B'AA>H=B%*@# $%;' A/$<# JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@%, J &H- =HBH> /&'S'; =H;<&H H *';HT%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+'.

3 + * * 27?

3. H=B/$*@&'>@ Vi F WC;' OBHJ%$%*' OBHJ%B&' $%#=%;<*HA=@ J@*H JH$HL*H?H S'JH$' « HBH? V», J B%S/;<='=% &H=HBHU WC;H HW*'B/T%- *H, L=H ';&H?H;<*'# OBH$/&N@# OBH@SJH$@;'A< A *'B/e%*@%> A'*@='B*CM *HB>. F H=*He%*@@ S'JH$' WC;H JHSW/T$%*H $%;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> A='=<%U 6.14 HV D, @ *'S*'L%*H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% B'AA;%$HJ'*@%. '=%B@';C $%;', AH?;'A*H O/*&=/ 2 L'A=@ 3 A='=<@ 23.1 HV D WC;@ O%B%$'*C J B'UH**CU A/$, &H=HBCU JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> e=B'+% J B'S>%B% 200000 =C- A#L B/W;%U A &H*+@A&'N@%U ';&H?H;<*HU @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@, @AOH;<S/%>HU $;# OBH@SJH$A=J' JH$&@.

BH&/BHB $'**H% OHA='*HJ;%*@% HOBH=%A=HJ';.

38 * ** 7/ - 7 * 7 / 8 ? > * + 7 * - * 2 + * 8 7 ?

4. 'UH**CU OBH&/BHB, OBHJH$# *'$SHB*/K OBHJ%B&/ $%;' HW '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, *'MH$@Je%?HA# J OBH@SJH$A=J% >@BHJH?H A/$<@, /A='*HJ@;, L=H OHA;%$*@U JC*%A *%S'&H**H% HOB%$%;%*@% H JHSJB'^%*@@ OBH- =H&H;' AH JA%>@ >'=%B@';'>@ $%;' $H;T*HA=*H>/ ;@N/, AHA='J@Je%>/ OBH=H- &H; $;# /A=B'*%*@# He@WH&. * OB@*%A OBH=%A= *' $'**H% HOB%$%;%*@% J B'UH**CU A/$. /$<# H=&'S'; J /$HJ;%=JHB%*@@ OBH=%A='.

)+C7* , ( 2 * / * 27? 3 8- , 7$3 " 3 " * * ?

' 7. %- # (H !" H% !+ ($

H ' # '! !($% $! -& H% % J !"&

1. @A=%>' >%B HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M. M N%;@.

34

2.%BC HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, H?B'*@L@J'K^@% OB'JH *' AJHWH$/ @ ;@L*/K *%OB@- &HA*HJ%**HA=<.

3.%BC HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, *'OB'J;%**C% *' H?B'*@L%*@% @>/^%A=J%**CM OB'J.

4.%BC HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, *'OB'J;%**C% *' H?B'*@L%*@% A/Wg%&=@J*CM OB'J /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> AHH=J%=A=J/K^%?H J@$'.

:

H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.

HA='*HJ;%*@% B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 18 $%&'WB# 2003 ?. j 759 G W /=J%BT$%*@@ B'J@; S'$%BT'*@# =B'*AOHB=*H?H AB%$A=J', OH>%^%- *@# %?H *' A=H#*&/, MB'*%*@#, ' ='&T% S'OB%^%*@# h&AO;/'='N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2003. — j 51, A=. 4990.

HA='*HJ;%*@% B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 15 H&=#WB# 2003 ?. j 627 G W /=J%BT$%*@@ H;HT%*@# HW /A;HJ@#M AH$%BT'*@# ;@N, S'$%BT'**CM S' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%, *HB>'M O@='*@# @ OHB#$&% >%$@- N@*A&H?H HWA;/T@J'*@# ='&@M ;@N» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%- B'N@@. — 2003. j 42, A=. 4077.

HA='*HJ;%*@% B'J@=%;<A=J' D H= 26 @K*# 2008 ?. j 475 G W /=J%BT$%*@@ B'J@; HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@# ;@N', &H=HBH% /OB'J;#%= =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>, *' AHA=H#*@% ';&H?H;<*H?H HO<#*%*@# @ H+HB>- ;%*@# %?H B%S/;<='=HJ, *'OB'J;%*@# /&'S'**H?H ;@N' *' >%$@N@*A&H% HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@% *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@#, >%$@N@*A&H?H HAJ@$%=%;<- A=JHJ'*@# h=H?H ;@N' *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@# @ H+HB>;%*@# %?H B%S/;<='- =HJ @ B'J@; HOB%$%;%*@# *';@L@# *'B&H=@L%A&@M AB%$A=J @;@ OA@MH- =BHO*CM J%^%A=J J HB?'*@S>% L%;HJ%&' OB@ OBHJ%$%*@@ >%$@N@*A&H?H HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@# *' AHA=H#*@% HO<#*%*@# ;@N', &H=HBH% /OB'J;#%= =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2008. — j 27, A=. 3280.

B@&'S D D H= 19 #*J'B# 2009 ?. j 8 « W /=J%BT$%*@@ B'J@; HWHB/$HJ'*@# AO%N@';<*H H=J%$%**CM OH>%^%*@U OH?B'*@L*CM HB?'*HJ $;# AH$%BT'*@# ;@N, S'$%BT'**CM S' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%» // V. — 2009. — j 9.

B@&'S >@*@A=%BA=J' h&H*H>@L%A&H?H B'SJ@=@# @ =HB?HJ;@ 'B'=HJ- A&HU HW;'A=@ H= 2 *H#WB# 2009 ?. j 701 « W /A='*HJ;%*@@ OB%$%;<*CM B'S>%BHJ O;'=C S' MB'*%*@% S'$%BT'**CM =B'*AOHB=*CM AB%$A=J *' AO%-

35

N@';@S@BHJ'**CM A=H#*&'M 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@» // HWB'*@% S'&H*H$'- =%;<A=J' 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@. — 2009. — j 27, A=B. 8816.

:

1.'SHJ@=% N%;@ OB@>%*%*@# >%B HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M.

2.F L%> B'S;@L@% ='&@M >%B HW%AO%L%*@# OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;'> HW

'$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M, &'& OB@JH$ @ $HA='J;%*@%?

3.'&HJC ABH&@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H S'$%BT'*@#?

4.H;T*HA=*C% ;@N' &'&@M HB?'*HJ JOB'J% OB@>%*#=< $HA='J;%*@% @ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% S'$%BT'*@%?

5.'&HU $H&/>%*= @ *' &'&HU ABH& JC$'%=A# JS'>%* @Sg#=H?H /$HA=H-

J%B%*@#, $'K^%?H OB'JH *' /OB'J;%*@% =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> AHH=J%=-

A=J/K^%?H J@$', OB@ AHJ%Be%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#,

J;%&/^%?H ;@e%*@% OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>?

6.'&HU OHB#$H& OB%$/A>H=B%* J H=*He%*@@ @Sg#=CM J%^%U, OH$J%B- ?'K^@MA# WCA=BHU OHBL%?

7.=H >HT%= WC=< OH$J%B?*/= OB@JH$/?

8.'&HJ ABH& JB%>%**H?H S'OB%=' $%#=%;<*HA=@?

9.'&@> HWB'SH> HOB%$%;#%=A# B'S>%B S';H?' S' 'B%A=HJ'**H% A/$*H?

10.=H JCA=/O'%= OBHN%AA/';<*C> HA*HJ'*@%> $;# OH>%^%*@# J

AO%N@';<*C% /LB%T$%*@# @*HA=B'**CM ?B'T$'* @;@ ;@N W%S ?B'T$'*A=J', OH$;%T'^@M '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H>/ JC$JHB%*@K S' OB%$%;C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@?

E ! ! H% R !"

1.EB * ., /OB'J;## ;@L*C> 'J=H=B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>, WC;

HA='*HJ;%* AH=B/$*@&H> E ?. H;<#==@ A N%;<K $HA>H=B' =B'*AOHB=*H?H AB%$A=J'. B@ $HA>H=B% =B'*AOHB=*H?H AB%$A=J' WC;H JC- #J;%*H *';@L@% *'B&H=@L%A&H?H AB%$A=J' - >'B@M/'*C J%AH> 0,227 ?B. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ AH=B/$*@&H> E ?. H;<#==@ 29.04.05 WC; AH- A='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%*- *H> A=. 6.8 KoA D « %S'&H**H% OB@HWB%=%*@% ;@WH MB'*%*@% *'B&H=@- L%A&@M AB%$A=J @;@ OA@MH=BHO*CM J%^%A=J, ' ='&T% HWHBH= @M '*';H?HJ».;# /A='*HJ;%*@# ;@L*HA=@ / ?B *' . WC;@ @Sg#=C JH$@=%;<A&@% OB'J' @ JC$'*H JB%>%**H% /$HA=HJ%B%*@% *' /OB'J;%*@% =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$- A=JH>. ' HA*HJ'*@@ MH$'='UA=J' ?B *' . H *'OB'J;%*@@ >'=%B@';HJ $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH >%A=/ T@=%;<A=J', >'=%B@';C $%;' WC;@ *'OB'J;%*C >@BHJH>/ A/$<% FH;TA&H?H B *' ?. 'B'=HJ', ' ?B *. OH&@*/; ?. H;<#==@. BH'*';@S@B/U=% A;HT@Je/KA# A@=/'N@K.

36

2.#=*'$N'=@;%=*@U w/&@*, e%A=*'$N'=@;%=*@U x'W'BHJ @ x'e- &@* A%>*'$N'=@ ;%= "H=>%=@;@" %*< HW%$C, B'AO@J W/=C;&/ JH$&@, @ J 21-00 OHe;@ *' $@A&H=%&/. B@ OH$MH$% & ?HBH$A&HU ='*N%J';<*HU O;H- ^'$&% $B/S<# WC;@ HA='*HJ;%*C AH=B/$*@&'>@ @, *%A>H=B# *' =H, L=H H*@ *% *'B/e';@ HW^%A=J%**CU OHB#$H&, AOH&HUA=J@% H&B/T'K^@M @ *% J%;@ A%W# B'SJ#S'*H, WC;@ $HA='J;%*C J $%T/B*/K L'A=< S' OH#J;%*@% J O<#*H> J@$% J HW^%A=J%**H> >%A=%.

O%B'=@J*CU $%T/B*CU O%B%$'; S'$%BT'**CM @ B'OHB=' *' *@M @*- AO%&=HB/ $;# $';<*%Ue%?H B'SW@B'=%;<A=J'.

3 ? 7 2 * & , /+ 7*2 * * ?

3.F H=*He%*@@ ?B'T$'*@*' F. @*AO%&=HBH> WC; AHA='J;%*

OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L. 4 A=. 12.19 HVD S' A=H#*&/ 'J=H>HW@;# «%;HL&HU» *' OBH%ST%U L'A=@, L=H AHS$'J';H OB%O#=A=J@# $J@T%*@K $B/?@M =B'*AOHB=*CM AB%$A=J. ?H 'J=H>HW@;< FVi 2110 WC; S'$%BT'* @ hJ'&/@BHJ'* *' AO%N@';@S@BHJ'**/K A=H#*&/ J OHB#$&% A=. 27.13 HV D. EB'T$'*@* F. HWB'=@;A# A T';HWHU J A/$ H OB@S*'*@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@# *%S'&H**C>, OHA&H;<&/ @*AO%&=HBC S'$%BT';@ %?H =B'*AOHB=*H% AB%$A=JH, MH=# H* >H? /A=B'*@=< OB@L@*/ S'$%BT'*@# *' >%A=%, H=H?*'J >'e@*/, =%> A'>C> H*@ *'B/e@;@ L. 1 A=. 27.13 H$%&A'.

2 +8 + * ( 7 / *- , +8 ; 8 A + 7 ?

' 8. $ !! H% !+ ($

H ' # '! !($% $! -& H% % J !"&

1.H*#=@% A='$@@ J OBH@SJH$A=J% OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M. F@$C A='$@U.

2.FHSW/T$%*@% $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@. V$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H% B'AA;%$HJ'*@%

3.'AA>H=B%*@% $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@. HA='- *HJ;%*@% @ HOB%$%;%*@% OH $%;/. M J@$C.

3.%B%A>H=B OHA='*HJ;%*@U @ B%e%*@U OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M. %B%A>H=B OHA='*HJ;%*@U, JA=/O@Je@M J S'&H*- */K A@;/.

4.AOH;*%*@% OHA='*HJ;%*@U OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH- *'B/e%*@#M.

5.HB#$H& @AOH;*%*@# H=$%;<*CM J@$HJ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'-

*@U.

37

:

H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.

D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 17 #*J'B# 1992 ?. j 2202-I « OBH&/B'=/B%HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // F%$H>HA=@ @ F D. 1992. j 8. =. 366;HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2011. — j 48, A=. 6730.

HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.

OB%$%;%*@% H*A=@=/N@H**H?H /$' D H= 4 'OB%;# 2006 ?. j 113- G H T';HW% ?B'T$'*@*' JL@**@&HJ' F@&=HB' V;%&A'*$BHJ@L' *' *'B/e%*@% %?H &H*A=@=/N@H**CM OB'J L'A=<K 3 A='=<@ 30.11 H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» // GF%A=*@&% H*A=@=/N@H**H?H /$' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@». 2006. j 4.

OB%$%;%*@% H*A=@=/N@H**H?H /$' D H= 12 >'# 2005 ?. j 145- G H T';HW% ?B'T$'*@*' V*$B%%J' @&H;'# J'*HJ@L' *' *'B/e%*@% %?H

H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» // «F%A=*@& H*A=@=/N@H**H?H /$' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@». 2005. j 5.

:

1.'&@% A='$@@ AHA='J;#K= OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@?

2.'SHJ@=% OHJH$C & JHSW/T$%*@K $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'- JH*'B/e%*@@.

3.&'&H?H >H>%*=' $%;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ AL@-

='%=A# JHSW/T$%**C>?

4.=H ='&H% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% B'AA;%$HJ'*@%? '&HU OHB#$H& @ ABH- &@ %?H OBHJ%$%*@#?

5.=H @S A%W# OB%$A='J;#%= OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'- B/e%*@@? F &'&@% ABH&@ H* AHA='J;#%=A# @ &%> OH$O@ACJ'%=A#? F &'&@M A;/L'#M H* >HT%= *% AHA='J;#=<A#?

38

6.'&@% $%UA=J@# HA/^%A=J;#%= A/$<# OB@ OH$?H=HJ&% $%;' & B'A- A>H=B%*@K?

7.'&@% HOB%$%;%*@# @ OHA='*HJ;%*@# JC*HA@= A/$<# OHA;% OH$?H=H- J@=%;<*CM $%UA=J@U?

8.'&@% ABH&@ B'AA>H=B%*@# $%;' OB%$/A>H=B%*C HV D?

9.'&@% '&=C >HT%= JC*%A=@ A/$<# OH B%S/;<='='> B'AA>H=B%*@# $%- ;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@

10.'&@% OHB#$H& @ ABH&@ HWT';HJ'*@# OHA='*HJ;%*@U OH $%;'> HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M?

11.'&@% OHB#$H& @ ABH&@ O%B%A>H=B' OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@?

12.'&@% B%e%*@# >H?/= WC=< JC*%A%*C OH B%S/;<='='> O%B%A>H=B'?

13.'&HU OHB#$H& O%B%A>H=B' JA=/O@Je@M J A@;/ OHA='*HJ;%*@U?

14.B@ &'&@M /A;HJ@#M JA=/O'%= J S'&H**/K A@;/ OHA='*HJ;%*@% OH

$%;/?

15.HA='*HJ;%*@# H *'S*'L%*@@ &'&@M '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'*@U @AOH;*#K=A#, *% JA=/O@J J S'&H**/K A@;/?

E ! ! H% R !"

1. EB'T$'*@* ., *'OB'J;##A< $H>HU J =B'>J'%, J%S A AHWHU $%=A&/K &H;#A&/. O;'=@J AJHU OBH%S$ &H*$/&=HB/, H* H=&'S';A# HO;'L@J'=< OBHJHS $%=A&HU &H;#A&@. FHe%$e@U *' A;%$/K^%U HA='*HJ&% &H*=BH;%B OBH- J%B@; / ?B'T$'*@*' . *';@L@% HO;'L%**H?H OBH%S$' @ OBHJHS' &H;#A&@. i' *%HO;'=/ %% OBHJHS' &H*=BH;%B *';HT@; *' O'AA'T@B' e=B'+, 'AA'- T@B H=&'S';A# HO;'L@J'=< e=B'+, OHA&H;<&/ OBHJHS $%=A&HU &H;#A&@ *% HO;'L@J'%=A#. H*=BH;%B HWg#A*@;, L=H &H;#A&' OB%JCe'%= /A='*HJ;%*- *C% B'S>%BC B/L*HU &;'$@, OBHJHS &H=HBHU *% HO;'L@J'%=A#, @ *'A=H#; *' /O;'=% e=B'+' *' >%A=%. EB'T$'*@* . OH=B%WHJ'; AHA='J@=< J h=H> A;/- L'% OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@. H*=BH;%B HWg#A- *@;, L=H AHA='J;#=< OBH=H&H; H* *% W/$%=, OHA&H;<&/ e=B'+, *% OB%JCe'- K^@U 100 B/W;%U, JSCA&@J'%=A# *' >%A=% W%S AHA='J;%*@# OBH=H&H;'.

3 K * & ? ? ** ? * (* * * ? * ( 7 * * 7 *7+ * ( -* * * ?

2. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H B'AA;%$HJ'*@# @*AO%&=HBH> ='>HT%**H?H OHA=' WC;H /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H OB@ JHSW/T$%*@@ $%;' @ *'S*'- L%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H B'AA;%$HJ'*@# WC;' *%OB'J@;<*H OBH@SJ%$%*' &J';@+@&'N@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#.

39

? ? * & , 7; * *- * , / * 6 & : * -7 * ** 7?

3. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ *';H?HJHU @*AO%&N@%U AHJ>%A=*H A HB?'- *'>@ J*/=B%**@M $%; AHW;K$%*@# S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' H OB@>%*%*@@ OB%$OB@*@>'=%;%> . WC;H HW*'B/T%*H OBHW@=@% L%&', *' &H=HBH> *% L@=';'A< L'A=< AJ%$%*@U. ;# AHA='J;%*@# OBH=H&H;' OB%$OB@*@>'=%;< WC; JCSJ'* J *';H?HJ/K @*AO%&N@K OHJ%A=&HU, &H=HB'# WC;' JB/L%*' OBH$'JN/. ' A;%$/K^@U $%*< $;# AHA='J;%*@# OBH=H&H;' #J@;A# '$JH&'= OB%$OB@*@>'=%;#, J OB@A/=A=J@@ &H=HBH?H WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, J &H=HBH> H* @ B'AO@A';A#. H @>%Je@>A# >'=%B@';'> $%;' OB%$OB@*@>'=%;< WC; OB@J;%L%* S'>%A=@=%- ;%> *'L';<*@&' B'UH**HU *';H?HJHU @*AO%&N@@ & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A='=<% 14.5 HV D. B%$OB@*@>'=%;< . HWB'=@;A# J 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$ A S'#J;%*@%> H OB@S*'*@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@# *%S'&H**C>.

3 ? 8 * * 27? 3 * * 7 *7 + * ?

4. HA&HJA&HU A%J%B*HU ='>HT*%U OH +'&=/ *%$%&;'B@BHJ'*@# =HJ'- BHJ WC;H JHSW/T$%*H $%;H HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ J H=- *He%*@@ *%/A='*HJ;%**H?H ;@N' OH L. 1 A=. 16.2 HV D. F MH$% '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H?H B'AA;%$HJ'*@# ;@NH, AHJ%Be@Je%% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%, /A='- *HJ;%*H *% WC;H, OHh=H>/ $H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH> ='>HT%**H?H HB?'*' OBH- @SJH$A=JH OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ WC;H OB%&B'- ^%*H OH O. 2 A=. 24.5 HV D. BH&/BHB, *% AH?;'A@Je@A< A OHA='*HJ;%- *@%>, OB@*%A OBH=%A= J OB'J;%*@% HA&HJA&HU ='>HT*@ A =B%WHJ'*@%> H=>%*C OHA='*HJ;%*@# @ *'OB'J;%*@# $%;' J ='>HT%**CU HB?'* *' *HJH% B'AA>H=B%*@%.

3 ? 8 * N ? * ?

5. *AO%&=HB E HA='*HJ@; 'J=H>HW@;< FVi 21093, &H=HBC> /OB'J;#; ?B'T$'*@* V. B@ OBHJ%B&% $H&/>%*=HJ JC#A*@;HA<, L=H JH$@- =%;< *% @>%%= @M OB@ A%W%. *AO%&=HBH> WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, &H=HBH% H* &J';@+@N@BHJ'; OH L.1 A=.12.7HV D. B@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' *'L';<*@&H> E WC;H /A='*HJ;%- *H, L=H V. 2 >%A#N' WC; *'S'$ ;@e%* OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH> *' 1,5 ?H$'. '&@> HWB'SH>, V. AHJ%Be@; OB'JH*'B/e%*@%, OB%$/A>H=B%**H% L.2 A=.12.7 HV D.

3? * 2 ( 2 $% !!? / ? - 6 & 7 * 7 * ** 7 , ** :, * * ?

40