Административная ответственность. Учебно-методическое пособие
.pdf. ., % 2 '. . BHW;%>C OB@>%*%*@# >@BHJC>@ A/$<- #>@ OH;HT%*@U A=. 15.11 HV D «EB/WH% *'B/e%*@% OB'J@; J%$%*@# W/M?';=%BA&H?H /L%=' @ OB%$A='J;%*@# W/M?';=%BA&HU H=L%=*HA=@» // V&- =/';<*C% OBHW;%>C AHJB%>%**HU KB@$@L%A&HU *'/&@ @ OB'&=@&@:
%TJ/S. AW. *'/L. =B. – S$ JH 'B'=. * =', 2007. – FCO. 2. . 153–159.. . BHW;%>C '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ KB@-
$@L%A&@M ;@N. B'A*H$'B. 1999.
. . A=HL*@&@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@, @M J@$C @ AHH=*He%*@% // ZB@A=g B'JHJ%$g. 2011. j 1. . 102–105.
0: . . JHOBHA/ H OH*#=@@ >%B '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB%A%L%*@# J A@A=%>% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB@*/T$%*@# // V$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% @ >/*@- N@O';<*H% OB'JH. 2010. j 7 (31). . 65–67.
. ., ; . $. V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# KA=@N@# @ '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*H% A/$HOBH@SJH$A=JH J HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. .: V&'$%>@- L%A&@U OB'JHJHU /*@J%BA@=%= OB@ *A=@=/=% ?HA/$'BA=J' @ OB'J' V , 2001.
< ($. . V$>@*@A=B'=@J*C% *'&'S'*@#, OHA='*HJ;%*@# H *'S*'L%- *@@ &H=HBCM @AOH;*#K=A# $H JA=/O;%*@# J S'&H**/K A@;/: OBHN%AA/';<- *C% 'AO%&=C / '=%B@';C >%T$/*'BH$*H?H A@>OHS@/>' 10–11 A%*=#WB# 2005 ?. «F%BMHJ%*A=JH S'&H*' J A+%B% O/W;@L*H OB'J H=*He%*@U. >%T- *C% KB@$@L%A&@% OBH+%AA@@». 'e&%*=, 2005. . 246–256.
= . . ='=/A A/Wg%&=' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU KB@A$@&N@@ @ OBH- W;%>C %?H B%';@S'N@@. ., 1999.
3. ' '- PH%$! ( ! ''$%!!:
* . H>>%*='B@U & H$%&A/ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?. j 195-Di. ., 2006.
$ . HA='=%U*CU &H>>%*='B@U & VBW@=B'T*H>/ OBHN%AA/';<- *H>/ &H$%&A/ D. @A=%>' EV V , 2010.
$. H>>%*='B@U & H$%&A/ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M. @A=%>' EV V , 2010.
H>>%*='B@U & VBW@=B'T*H>/ OBHN%AA/';<*H>/ &H$%&A/ D (OHA='- =%U*CU). H$ B%$. . . =. ., 2003.
H>>%*='B@U & H$%&A/ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M / OH$ HW^. B%$. YE. ';@^%JHU. 6-% @S$., O%B%B'W. @ $HO. ., 2009.
HA='=%U*CU &H>>%*='B@U & H$%&A/ D HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'- JH*'B/e%*@#M / OH$ B%$. #. $. -, . '. > . ., 2008.
11
@F O 0 Q E C@ 0 0/ @ 0/ /
' 1. @ "$! ! ( # ($! '! !($% $! ) $ $($ ($!.
1.H*#=@% @ J@$C '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB@*/T$%*@#. V$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< &'& +HB>' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H OB'JHJH?H OB@*/T$%*@#.
2.H*#=@%, OB@S*'&@, +/*&N@@ @ A=B/&=/B' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=-
A=J%**HA=@.
3. A='*HJ;%*@% @ OB@>%*%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
:
H*A=@=/N@# HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 2009. – j 4, A=. 445.
H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 2002. – j 1, L. 1.
';H?HJCU &H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. 'A=< J=HB'# // HWB. S'&H- *H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 2000. – j 32, A=. 3340.
?H;HJ*CU &H$%&A D // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 1996. – j 25, A=. 2954.
B/$HJHU &H$%&A D // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 2002. – j 1. L. 1, A=. 3.
i'&H* 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@ H= 29 @K;# 2009 ?. j 104-i « W '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M *' =%BB@=HB@@ 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@» //HWB'*@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@. – 2009. – j 17, A=B. 3930–3936.
:
1.'& AHH=*HA#=A# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB@*/T$%*@% @ '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=<?
2.'SHJ@=% OB@S*'&@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@?
3.=H HS*'L'%= /A='*HJ;%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@?
4.=H HS*'L'%= OB@>%*%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@?
5.'&@% h;%>%*=C AHA='J;#K= A=B/&=/B/ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@?
6.'SHJ@=% *%=B'$@N@H**C% +HB>C '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
12
E ! ! H% R !":
1. M'B'&=%B@S/U=% H=;@L@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ H= /?H;HJ*HU, $@AN@O;@*'B*HU, >'=%B@';<*HU OH A;%$/K^@> OB@S*'&'>: HA*HJ'*@#, A/Wg%&=C H=J%=A=J%**HA=@, KB@A$@&N@H**C% A/Wg%&=C, >%BC H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
2. OH>H^<K *HB> HV D HM'B'&=%B@S/U=% OH*#=@# «/A='*HJ;%- *@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@» @ «OB@>%*%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@». B?'*'>@ &'&H?H ?HA/$'BA=J%**H?H /BHJ*# >HT%= /A='*'J;@J'=<A# @ OB@>%*#=<A# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=<?
3. nJ;#%=A# ;@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=<K OB@HA='*HJ;%*@% $%UA=J@# ;@N%*S@@ @ '**/;@BHJ'*@% ;@N%*S@@ (h=@ >%BC OB%$/A>H=B%*C A=. 13 D%$%B';<*H?H S'&H*' H= 8 'J?/A=' 2001 ?. j 128-Di « ;@N%*S@BH- J'*@@ H=$%;<*CM J@$HJ $%#=%;<*HA=@»)? &'&H>/ J@$/ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H- ?H OB@*/T$%*@# H=*HA#=A# $'**C% >%BC?
4. FH$@=%;< $';<*HWHU^@& HA/^%A=J;#; B%UA OH $HA='J&% =HJ'B', OB@*'$;%T'^%?H « BhU$» @S 'B'=HJ' J FH;?H?B'$. H O/=@ A;%$H- J'*@#, H* B%e@; O%B%&/A@=< J OB@$HBHT*H> &'+%, ?$% OHS*'&H>@Je@A< A $B/?@>@ $';<*HWHU^@&'>@, JCO@; 100 ?B'>> JH$&@ A *@>@ S' S*'&H>A=JH.HA;% h=H?H H* OBH$H;T@; $J@T%*@% OH >'BeB/=/. $*'&H, *'MH$#A< J AHA=H#*@@ ';&H?H;<*H?H HO<#*%*@#, $HO/A=@; A=H;&*HJ%*@% A ;%?&HJC> 'J=H>HW@;%>, J B%S/;<='=% L%?H JH$@=%;K OHA;%$*%?H WC; OB@L@*%* JB%$ S$HBHJ<K, &H=HBCU JOHA;%$A=J@@ WC; HOB%$%;%* &'& ;%?&@U.
3 : ( * * * ? +8 2- ( 2A 2 + ; ? ? * 7 - * * 2 7 2*7 * : ( * * * ?
' 2. ( !" ! ( !" '! !($% $! ) $ $($ ($!.
1.H*#=@% @ J@$C HA*HJ'*@U '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
2.HB>'=@J*H% HA*HJ'*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@. 'S- J@=@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
3.D'&=@L%A&H% @ OBHN%AA/';<*H% HA*HJ'*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@: HW^'# M'B'&=%B@A=@&'.
4.A;HJ@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
:
H*A=@=/N@# HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. – 2009. - j 4, A=. 445.
13
H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.
VBW@=B'T*CU OBHN%AA/';<*CU &H$%&A D H= 24 @K;# 2002 ?. j 95-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 30, A=. 3012.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 17 #*J'B# 1992 ?. j 2202-I « OBH&/B'=/B%HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // F%$H>HA=@ @ F D. 1992. j 8. =. 366;HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2011. — j 48, A=. 6730.
i'&H* 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@ H= 29 @K;# 2009 ?. j 104-i « W '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M *' =%BB@=HB@@ 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@» //HWB'*@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@. — 2009. — j 17, A=B. 3930-3936.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' FCAe%?H VBW@=B'T*H?H /$' D H= 2 @K*# 2004 ?. j 10 « *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&e@M J A/$%W*HU OB'&=@&% OB@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 *H#WB# 2011 ?.) // F%A=*@& FCAe%?H VBW@=B'T*H?H /$' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. 2004. j 8.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005.
:
1.'SHJ@=% J@$C HA*HJ'*@U '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
2.'SHJ@=% HA*HJ*C% h='OC &H$@+@&'N@@ S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M.
3.'&@% J@$C S'&H*HJ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ >H?/= OB@*@>'=< A/Wg%&=C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@?
4.=H #J;#%=A# OBHN%AA/';<*C> HA*HJ'*@%> '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@?
5.=H *%HWMH$@>H OH*@>'=< OH$ /A;HJ@#>@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@?
6.B@ &'&@M /A;HJ@#M >HT*H AL@='=<, L=H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH- *'B/e%*@% AHJ%Be%**H OB@ &B'U*%U *%HWMH$@>HA=@?
E ! ! H% R !"
1. i'&H*'>@ A/Wg%&=HJ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ /A='*HJ;%*' '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=A=J%**HA=< S' OB%JCe%*@% JH$@=%;#>@ =B'*AOHB=*CM AB%$A=J /A='*HJ;%**HU A&HBHA=@ $J@T%*@# *' J%;@L@*/ H= 5 $H 30 &>pL'A J J@$% e=B'+' J B'S>%B% H= H$*H?H $H $J/M >@*@>';<*CM B'S>%BHJ HO;'- =C =B/$' @;@ ;@e%*@# AO%N@';<*H?H OB'J' *' ABH& $H 1 ?H$', ' ='&T% S'
14
&/B%*@% ='W'&' *' B'WHL@M >%A='M, J ?HBH$A&H>, OB@?HBH$*H> =B'*AOHB=%, J S'&BC=CM AOHB=@J*CM AHHB/T%*@#M, HB?'*@S'N@#M S$B'JHHMB'*%*@#, HWB'SHJ'=%;<*CM HB?'*@S'N@#M @ HB?'*@S'N@#M &/;<=/BC, OH>%^%*@#M, S'*@>'%>CM HB?'*'>@ ?HA/$'BA=J%**HU J;'A=@, S' @A&;KL%*@%> &/B%*@# ='W'&' J AO%N@';<*H H=J%$%**CM $;# h=H?H >%A='M J J@$% OB%$/OB%T$%*@# @;@ *';HT%*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' *' ?B'T$'*, ' J H=*He%*@@ *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M - *' BH$@=%;%U @;@ @M S'&H**CM OB%$A='J@=%;%U, J B'S>%B% H= H$*H?H $H =B%M >@*@>';<*CM B'S>%BHJ HO;'=C =B/$'.
* * +C & *-* * / 8 7? 3 8 3- " 8?
'&@% JHOBHAC J HW;'A=@ S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M H=*HA#=A# & J%$%*@K A/Wg%&=HJ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@?
2. F WH;<e@*A=J% S'&H*HJ A/Wg%&=HJ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M /A='*HJ;%*' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*'# H=J%=- A=J%**HA=< S' AWC= (B%';@S'N@K) &B%O&@M AO@B=*CM *'O@=&HJ $H>'e*%U JCB'WH=&@. D%$%B';<*C> S'&H*H> H= 22.11.1995 ?. « ?HA/$'BA=J%**H> B%?/;@BHJ'*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' @ HWHBH=' h=@;HJH?H AO@B=', ';&H?H;<*HU @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@ @ HW H?B'*@L%*@@ OH=B%W;%*@# (B'AO@=@#) ';&H?H;<*HU OBH$/&N@@» /A='*HJ;%*C OB'J@;' OBH@SJH$A=J' @ HWHBH=' ';&H?H;<*HU @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@.
H?;'A*H O. 3 L.1 A=. 1.3 HV D & J%$%*@K HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ J HW;'A=@ S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M H=*H- A@=A# /A='*HJ;%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH JHOBHA'>, @>%K^@> +%$%B';<*H% S*'L%*@%, J =H> L@A;% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ S' *'B/e%*@% OB'J@; @ *HB>, OB%$/A>H=B%**CM +%$%B';<*C>@ S'&H*'>@ @ @*C>@ *HB>'=@J*C>@ OB'JHJC>@ '&='>@ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'- N@@;
" /C7* , : *7 ( 7 ? / * +C " + * 8 7 * . 1.3 3 " *-7 * * * + * ?
' 3. '! !($%$! H% % J !
K$! ( ( ! '! !($%$! ) $ $($($!.
1.H*#=@% @ OB@S*'&@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. ?H H=- ;@L@% H= OB%A=/O;%*@#, $@AN@O;@*'B*H?H OBHA=/O&' @ @*CM OB'JH*'B/- e%*@U.
2.H*#=@% AHA='J' OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. f;%>%*=C @ OB@S*'&@ AHA='JHJ. F@$C AHA='JHJ.
15
:
H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.
VBW@=B'T*CU OBHN%AA/';<*CU &H$%&A D H= 24 @K;# 2002 ?. j 95-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 30, A=. 3012.
';H?HJCU &H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@. 'A=< J=HB'# // HWB. S'&H- *H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2000. — j 32, A=. 3340.
?H;HJ*CU &H$%&A D // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 1996. — j 25, A=. 2954.
'>HT%**CU &H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ H= 28 >'# 2003 ?. j 61Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2003. — j 22, A=. 2066.
*A=B/&N@# OH h&AO;/'='N@@ T%;%S*H$HBHT*CM O%B%%S$HJ HA- A@@, /=J. D 29.06.1998 j -566 // E'B'*=.
i'&H* 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@ H= 29 @K;# 2009 ?. j 104-i « W '$>@- *@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M *' =%BB@=HB@@ 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@» //HWB'*@% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' 'B'=HJA&HU HW;'A=@. — 2009. — j 17, A=B. 3930–3936.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.
:
1.F L%> H=;@L@% OB@S*'&' HW^%A=J%**HU JB%$*HA=@ H= OB@S*'&' HW- ^%A=J%**HU HO'A*HA=@? q'B'&=%B%* ;@ OHA;%$*@U $;# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U?
2.'U=% HOB%$%;%*@% AHA='J' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#?
3.=H OHSJH;#K= HOB%$%;@=< OB@S*'&@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'- B/e%*@# @ OB@S*'&@ AHA='J' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#?
4.&H;<&H h;%>%*=HJ J AHA='J% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, AHJ%Be%**H?H KB@$@L%A&@> ;@NH>?
5.%> H=;@L'%=A# OB%$>%= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@# H=
%?H HWg%&='?
6.'SHJ@=% J@$C AHA='JHJ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U.
7.'U=% OH*#=@% $;#^%?HA# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#.
8.%> OBH$H;T'%>H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@% H=;@L'%=A# H= OHJ=HB*H?H?
9.=H A;%$/%= OH*@>'=< OH$ >';HS*'L@=%;<*HA=<K '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H- ?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#?
16
E ! ! H% R !"
1. L'A=&HJH>/ /OH;*H>HL%**H>/ OH;@N@@ OHA=/O@;H S'#J;%*@% H= ?B'T$'*@*' V. H =H>, L=H %?H AHA%$ . OH$&;KL@;A# & '*=%**% &'W%;<*H?H =%;%J@$%*@# W%S B'SB%e%*@#. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ 12 >'# WC;H /A='- *HJ;%*H, L=H J &J'B=@B/, J &H=HBHU OBHT@J'%= ., $%UA=J@=%;<*H, OBHJ%- $%* &'W%;<, OH$&;KL%**CU & &HBHW&% &'W%;<*H?H =%;%J@$%*@#. L'A=&H- JC> /OH;*H>HL%**C> J H=*He%*@@ AHWA=J%**@&' &J'B=@BC ?B'T$'*@*'. WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> A=.13.2 HV D. B@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' ?B'T$'*@* . OH#A*@;, L=H &/O@; &J'B=@B/ 4 >%A#N' *'S'$, &'W%;< /T% WC; OBHJ%$%*, OHh=H>/ H* W%AO;'=*H OH;<SHJ';A#. J@$%=%;< V. OH$=J%B$@; A;HJ' .
L'A=&HJCU /OH;*H>HL%**CU *';HT@; *' ?B'T$'*@*' . '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 500 B/W;%U.
4 * ( * * ? 3-
* |
:? |
3*2, *3. * / :( *7 - |
|
+ 2 |
: 10 6 7 * .? |
2. '&@% @S *@T%O%B%L@A;%**CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U #J;#K=A# $;#^@>@A#?'>HJH;<*C% /A='*HJ&' @;@ h&AO;/'='N@# /S;' OBHJH$*H?H J%^'*@#, A'>HJH;<*H% OH$&;KL%*@% & A%=@ h;%&=B@L%A&HU AJ#S@ H&H*%L*H?H HWHB/- $HJ'*@#, *'B/e%*@% /A='*HJ;%**H?H ABH&' OH$'L@ S'#J;%*@# H OHA='*HJ&% *' /L%= J *';H?HJH> HB?'*% @;@ HB?'*% ?HA/$'BA=J%**H?H J*%WK$T%=*H?H +H*$', *'B/e%*@% /A='*HJ;%**CM S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH> H *';H?'M @ AWHB'M ABH&HJ OB%$A='J;%*@# *';H?HJHU $%&;'B'N@@ J *';H?HJCU HB?'* OH >%A=/ /L%=', HA/^%A=J;%*@% OB%$OB@*@>'=%;<A&HU $%#=%;<*HA=@ W%S ?HA/$'B- A=J%**HU B%?@A=B'N@@ @;@ W%S AO%N@';<*H?H B'SB%e%*@# (;@N%*S@@), *%- #J&' ?B'T$'*@*', AHA=H#^%?H @;@ HW#S'**H?H AHA=H#=< *' JH@*A&H> /L%=%, OH JCSHJ/ (OHJ%A=&%) JH%**H?H &H>@AA'B@'=' @;@ @*H?H HB?'*', HA/^%A=J- ;#K^%?H JH@*A&@U /L%=, J /A='*HJ;%**C% JB%># @ >%A=H W%S /J'T@=%;<- *HU OB@L@*C, /OB'J;%*@% =B'*AOHB=*C> AB%$A=JH>, *% S'B%?@A=B@BHJ'*- *C> J /A='*HJ;%**H> OHB#$&% @;@ *% OBHe%$e@> ?HA/$'BA=J%**H?H =%M-
*@L%A&H?H HA>H=B',
3 7 * 7; *7 " ?
3. F H=*He%*@@ ?B'T$'*&@ Z. AH=B/$*@&H> OH;@N@@ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> L'- A=<K 2 A='=<@ 15.12 HV D S' OBH$'T/ J AJH%> $JHB% W/=C;&@ JH$&@ W%S '&N@S*CM >'BH&. F A/$% ?B'T$'*&' Z. AJHK J@*/ OB@S*';' @ OH#A*@- ;', L=H OBH$';' JH$&/ J AJ#S@ A *'MHT$%*@%> J =#T%;H> +@*'*AHJH> OH- ;HT%*@@. /$<# OB%&B'=@; $%;H OH >';HS*'L@=%;<*HA=@. F OHA='*HJ;%*@@ A/$<# HOB%$%;@;, L=H W/=C;&' JH$&@ OH$;%T@= /*@L=HT%*@K.
17
% *2 * 7 7 / 7 7 / ( 2-
8 ? 3 77 7: *7 / ( 2 8 ? 4 |
|
* 2 + 8, 7; *7* +* |
- |
* ? ., * +8 ; / * ? -* * 8 * 8 , * 8 * . 15.12 6.14 3 " .
4. FH$@=%;< V., OB%JCA@J A&HBHA=*HU B%T@>, *% /AO%; S'=HB>HS@=< @ OBH%M'; *' S'OB%^'K^@U A@?*'; AJ%=H+HB', J B%S/;<='=% L%?H OBH@SHe;H $HBHT*H =B'*AOHB=*H% OBH@Ae%A=J@%. ' O%B%&B%A=&% H* JB%S';A# J 'J=H- >HW@;<, &H=HBCU *'L@*'; $J@T%*@% *' S%;%*CU A@?*'; AJ%=H+HB'. *- AO%&=HBH> E JH$@=%;< V. WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ OH L'A=@ 2 A='=<@ 12.9 @ A='=<% 12.12 HV D.
/ , / * * , * 8 / - 8 * 27 , 7 7 *7 2 8 , 6 2 8 ? >7 * 2 8 * * , 6 2 8 * * ?
5. EB'T$'*@* V. WC; S'$%BT'* HMB'**@&H> >'?'S@*' OB@ OHOC=&% JC- *%A=@ &/AH& &H;W'AC J%AH> 450 ?B'>> *' A/>>/ 81 B/W;<. B@WCJe@% AH=B/$*@&@ OH;@N@@ AHA='J@;@ OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'- B/e%*@@, OB%$/A>H=B%**H> A='=<%U 7.27 HV D.
@BHJHU A/$<# OB%&B'=@; OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;/ J H=*He%*@@ V. S' >';HS*'L@=%;<*HA=<K AHJ%Be%**H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. 'UH**CU OBH&/- BHB HOBH=%A=HJ'; OHA='*HJ;%*@% H OB%&B'^%*@@ $%;' J B'UH**CU A/$, /&'S'J, L=H J $%#*@@ V. H=A/=A=J/K= OB@S*'&@ >';HS*'L@=%;<*HA=@.
/$<# B'UH**H?H A/$' H=>%*@; OHA='*HJ;%*@% @ *'OB'J@; $%;H *' *H- JH% B'AA>H=B%*@%.
: ( * / * & .
6. B@J%$@=% @S HV D @ S'&H*HJ A/Wg%&=HJ D HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M OH 5 OB@>%BHJ OBH$H;T'%>CM '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@U.
7. 'UH**C> OBH&/BHBH> WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%*@% H JHSW/T$%- *@@ $%;' HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ J H=*He%*@@ $@B%&=HB' OB%$OB@#=@# OH L'A=@ 2 A='=<@ 5.27 HV D S' OHJ=HB*H% AHJ%Be%*@% *'B/e%*@# A='=<@ 22 B/$HJH?H &H$%&A' D — *%/O;'=/ J %*A@H**CU DH*$ A=B'MHJCM JS*HAHJ HW#S'=%;<*H?H O%*A@H**H?H A=B'MHJ'*@#. @BHJHU A/$<# JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H $@A&J';@+@&'N@@ $@B%&=HB' *' 1 ?H$. V$JH&'= $@B%&=HB' OB@*%A J B'UH**CU A/$ T';HW/, J &H=HBHU /&'SCJ'; *' =H, L=H J $%UA=J@#M %?H OH$S'^@=*H?H H=A/=A=J/%= AHA='J '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#. @B%&=HB *'B/e@; *% =B/$HJH% S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH, ' S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH HW HW#S'=%;<*H> AHN@';<*H> A=B'MHJ'*@@.
3 ? 8 * 8 * 27? )+ * **8 / 2* .
18
8. @BHJC> A/$<%U r%*@*A&H?H B'UH*' ?. 'B'=HJ' J H=*He%*@@ ?;'J- *H?H W/M?';=%B' &H>>%BL%A&HU HB?'*@S'N@@ ., AHJ%Be@Je%U '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%, OB%$/A>H=B%**H% A=. 15.11 HV D, WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%*@% H OB%&B'^%*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' OH $%;/ J AHH=J%=- A=J@@ A O. 2 'WS'N' 2 L. 1 A=. 29.9 HV D @ HWg#J;%*@@ /A=*H?H S'>%L'- *@# J AHH=J%=A=J@@ AH A=. 2.9, J J@$/ >';HS*'L@=%;<*HA=@ AHJ%Be%**H?H $%#*@#.
F HWHA*HJ'*@% AJH@M JCJH$HJ >@BHJHU A/$<# AHA;';A# *' =H, L=H A/>- >' *%$H@>&@ OH;*HA=<K /O;'L%*', ' . B'*%% & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ *% OB@J;%&';'A<.
8 * * ?
3 * ? +8 2 *& / ( 2 ?
9. '&@% @S /&'S'**CM *@T% OB'JH*'B/e%*@U #J;#K=A# $;#^@>@A#?
-*%@AOH;*%*@% BH$@=%;#>@ @;@ @*C>@ S'&H**C>@ OB%$A='J@=%;#>@ *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M HW#S'**HA=%U OH AH$%BT'*@K @ JHAO@='*@K *%AH- J%Be%**H;%=*@M (A=. 5.35 HV D);
-A'>HJH;<*H% S'*#=@% S%>%;<*H?H /L'A=&' (A=. 7.1 HV D);
-*%@AOH;*%*@% J;'$%;<N%> =B'*AOHB=*H?H AB%$A=J' /A='*HJ;%**HU +%$%B';<*C> S'&H*H> HW#S'**HA=@ OH A=B'MHJ'*@K AJH%U ?B'T$'*A&HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ (L. 2 A=. 12.37 HV D);
-*%OB%$A='J;%*@% MH$'='UA=J, /J%$H>;%*@U (S'#J;%*@U), AJ%$%*@U t@*+HB>'N@@) J +%$%B';<*CU '*=@>H*HOH;<*CU HB?'*, %?H =%BB@=HB@';<-
*C% HB?'*C, HB?'*C B%?/;@BHJ'*@# %A=%A=J%**CM >H*HOH;@U @;@ HB?'*C, /OH;*H>HL%**C% J HW;'A=@ h&AOHB=*H?H &H*=BH;# (A=. 19.8 HV D);
-OBHT@J'*@% ?B'T$'*@*' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ W%S /$HA=HJ%B%*@# ;@L*HA=@ ?B'T$'*@*' (O'AOHB=') @;@ W%S B%?@A=B'N@@ (A=. 19.15 HVD);
-*%/O;'=' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' J ABH&, OB%$/A>H=B%**CU H- V D (L. 1 A=. 20.21 HV D);
-*%#J&' ?B'T$'*@*', AHA=H#^%?H @;@ HW#S'**H?H AHA=H#=< *' JH@*- A&H> /L%=%, OH JCSHJ/ (OHJ%A=&%) JH%**H?H &H>@AA'B@'=' @;@ @*H?H HB?'- *', HA/^%A=J;#K^%?H JH@*A&@U /L%=, J /A='*HJ;%**C% JB%># @ >%A=H W%S /J'T@=%;<*HU OB@L@*C (A=. 21.5 HV D).
'&@% OB'JH*'B/e%*@# H=*HA@= & $;#^@>A# ;%*/> F%BMHJ*H?H /$'D J OHA='*HJ;%*@@ 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 « *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@- &'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M».
10. EB'T$'*@* . HWB'=@;A# A S'#J;%*@%> & /L'A=&HJH>/ /OH;*H>H- L%**H>/ @*AO%&=HB *' AJH%?H AHA%$' r., &H=HBCU OBHT@J'%= *'$ *@> @ N%;C>@ $*#>@ *' OHJCe%**HU ?BH>&HA=@ A>H=B@= =%;%J@SHB @;@ A;/e'%=
19
>/SC&/ ='&, L=H A;Ce*H *' /;@N%, *' S'>%L'*@# AHA%$%U H=J%L'; *%N%*- S/B*C>@ A;HJ'>@. EB'T$'*@* r. OH#A*@; /L'A=&HJH>/, L=H $H 23.00 H* >HT%= A;/e'=< ?BH>&H >/SC&/ @;@ A>H=B%=< =%;%J@SHB. L'A=&HJCU /OH;*H>HL%**CU AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; OH L.1 A=. 20.1 HV D.
? +8 2 -. ( * * - * ?
11. @B%&=HB OB%$OB@#=@# *% JCO;'=@; &H>O%*A'N@@ B'WH=*@&'>, &H- =HBC% *% @AOH;<SHJ';@ OH;HT%**C% @> H=O/A&', OH @M S'#J;%*@#>, L=H WC;H OH$=J%BT$%*H OBHJ%B&HU =B/$HJHU @*AO%&N@@. @B%&=HB WC; OB@- J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L.1 A=. 5.27 HV D.
%B%S OH;?H$' OB@ OBHJ%$%*@@ J*%HL%B%$*HU OBHJ%B&@ *' $'**H> OB%$OB@#=@@ OH S'#J;%*@#> B'WH=*@&HJ WC;H /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H B'WH=*@- &'> WH;%% 2 >%A#N%J *% JCO;'L@J'%=A# S'BO;'='. *AO%&=HBH> WC; AH- A='J;%* OBH=H&H; OH L. 2 A=. 5.27 HV D.
B@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' '$JH&'= $@B%&=HB' S'#J@;, L=H %?H OH$S'^@=- *CU *% >HT%= WC=< OB@J;%L%* OH $'**HU L'A=@, OHA&H;<&/ %?H $%UA=J@# *% AHA='J;#K= '*';H?@L*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@%, S' &H=HBH% H* /T% OB@J;%&';A#.
@BHJHU A/$<# JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H $@A&J';@+@&'N@@, >H=@J@BHJ'J %?H =%>, L=H '*';H?@L*H% OB'JH*'B/e%*@% S'&;KL'%=A# J =H>, L=H H* AH- J%Be@; @>%**H *'B/e%*@% =B/$HJH?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J', ' *% $B/?@% OBH- =@JHOB'J*C% $%UA=J@#.
4 * * 2 ? > (?
12. FH$@=%;< V., OBH%ST'# T%;%S*H$HBHT*CU O%B%%S$, OBH%M'; T%;%S- *H$HBHT*H% OH;H=*H. $*'&H HWB'SHJ'Je@UA# S' O%B%%S$H> S'=HB JC*/- $@; %?H HA='*HJ@=<A# / 'J=H>'=@L%A&H?H e;'?W'/>'. =H#Je'# S' O%B%%S- $H> O'=B/;<*'# >'e@*' E S'+@&A@BHJ';' $'**CU +'&= *' J@$%HB%- ?@A=B'=HB. H $'**H>/ +'&=/ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J- *H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH L.1 A=.12.10 HV D. '=%B@';C $%;' WC;@ O%B%$'*C >@BHJH>/ A/$<%. F A/$% V. J@*/ AJHK *% OB@S*'; @ >H=@J@BHJ'; h=H =%>, L=H H* OBH%M'; /T% O%B%%S$ @ HA='*HJ@;A# S' %?H OB%$%;'>@.
" / * & :. % *7 * 7 7 . * ** 7?
' 4. #L $- '! !($% $! ) $ $($ ($!.
1.H*#=@% @ J@$C A/Wg%&=HJ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
2.AHW%**HA=@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ *%AHJ%Be%**H- ;%=*@M.
3.AHW%**HA=@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ $H;T*HA=*CM ;@N.
20
