Административная ответственность. Учебно-методическое пособие
.pdf4.AHW%**HA=@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ KB@$@L%A&@M ;@N.
5.AHW%**HA=@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ JH%**HA;/T'^@M.
6.AHW%**HA=@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ @*HA=B'**CM ?B'T$'*.
:
H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 8 >'# 1994 ?. j 3-Di « A='=/A% L;%*' HJ%=' D%$%B'N@@ @ A='=/A% $%O/='=' EHA/$'BA=J%**HU />C D%$%B';<*H?H H- WB'*@# HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'- N@@. — 1994. — j 2, A=. 74.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 17 #*J'B# 1992 ?. j 2202-I « OBH&/B'=/B%HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // F%$H>HA=@ @ F D. 1992. j 8. =. 366;HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2011. — j 48, A=. 6730.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 24 @K*# 1999 ?. j 120-Di « W HA*HJ'M A@A=%>C OBH+@;'&=@&@ W%S*'$SHB*HA=@ @ OB'JH*'B/e%*@U *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M» //HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 1999. — j 26, A=. 3177.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 25 @K;# 2002 ?. j 115-Di « OB'JHJH> OH;H- T%*@@ @*HA=B'**CM ?B'T$'* J HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'- =%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 30, A=. 3032.
i'&H* D H= 26 @K*# 1992 ?. j 3132-I « A='=/A% A/$%U J HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // F%$H>HA=@ D @ F D. 1992. j 30. =. 1792.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ H= 28 $%&'WB# 2010 ?. j 403-Di « ;%$A=J%**H> &H>@=%=% HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2011. — j 1, A=. 15.
&'S B%S@$@/>' F D H= 3 @K*# 1967 ?. « W /=J%BT$%*@@ OH- ;HT%*@# H &H>@AA@#M OH $%;'> *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=*@M» (J B%$. 25 +%JB';# 1993 ?.) // JH$ S'&H*HJ D . H> 8.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D H= 24 H&=#WB# 2006 ?. j 18 « *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@AHW%**HU L'A=@ H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 11 *H#WB# 2008 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H/$' D. 2006. j 12.
21
:
1.%> H=;@L'%=A# AO%N@';<*CU A/Wg%&= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ H= HAHWH?H?
2.F &'&@M A;/L'#M A/Wg%&= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ *% AHJO'$'%= A A/Wg%&=H> '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@#?
3.'& *%A/= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*/K H=J%=A=J%**HA=< $%O/='=C, A/$<@, OBH&/BHBA&@% B'WH=*@&@, A;%$HJ'=%;@ ;%$A=J%**H?H &H>@=%=' HAA@U- A&HU D%$%B'N@@?
4.HT%= ;@ KB@$@L%A&H% ;@NH AHJ%Be@=< '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB'JH- *'B/e%*@% OH *%HA=HBHT*HA=@?
5.F L%> HAHW%**HA=< '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ @*$@J@$/- ';<*CM OB%$OB@*@>'=%;%U?
E ! ! H% R !"
1. 'U$@=% J HV D AHA='JC '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@U, A/Wg%&='>@ &H=HBCM #J;#K=A# $H;T*HA=*C% ;@N' ?HA/$'BA=J%*- *CM HB?'*HJ.
2. i'>%A=@=%;%> ?;'J*H?H ?HA/$'BA=J%**H?H @*AO%&=HB' HW;'A=@ OH HMB'*% H&B/T'K^%U AB%$C . h&A&'J'=HB^@& V. WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@- A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' AHJ%Be%*@% $%UA=J@U, JCB'S@Je@MA# J A'>HJH;<*H> A*#=@@, O%B%>%^%*@@ O;H$HBH$*H?H A;H# OHLJC @ OH?B/S&% @M *' 'J=H=B'*AOHB= J HWg%>% H&H;H 3 &/W. >. '**C% $%UA=J@# OH$O'$'K= OH$ AHA='J OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H L'A=<K 1 A='=<@ 8.6 HVD. HA='*HJ;%*@%> *' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 3000 B/W;%U &'& $H;T*HA=*H?H ;@N'.
f&A&'J'=HB^@& V. HWT';HJ'; $'**H% OHA='*HJ;%*@% ?;'J*H>/ ?HA/- $'BA=J%**H>/ @*AO%&=HB/ HW;'A=@ OH HMB'*% H&B/T'K^%U AB%$C ., HWHA*HJCJ'# %% =%>, L=H H* *% #J;#%=A# $H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH>.
E;'J*CU ?HA/$'BA=J%**CU @*AO%&=HB . OHA='*HJ;%*@% HA='J@; W%S @S>%*%*@U, ' T';HW/ W%S /$HJ;%=JHB%*@#, >H=@J@BHJ'J B%e%*@% =%>, L=H J OBH=H&H;% V. WC; S'O@A'* &'& $H;T*HA=*H% ;@NH, ' J ?B'+% «$H;T*HA=<» S'O@A'* &'& h&A&'J'=HB^@&. HA&H;<&/ V. OBH=H&H; OH$O@A';, h=H HS*'L'- %=, L=H H* A *@> AH?;'A@;A#. ' h=H> HA*HJ'*@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@% WC;H OB@- S*'*H S'&H**C> @ HWHA*HJ'**C>.
f&A&'J'=HB^@& V. HWB'=@;A# A T';HWHU J A/$.
3 ? 8 * * 27?
3. B@ OBHJ%B&% J >'?'S@*% WC;H /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H @*$@J@$/';<*CU OB%$OB@*@>'=%;< ?B'T$'*&' . @ %% OBH$'J%N r. HA/^%A=J;#;@ B%';@S'- N@K ';&H?H;<*HU OBH$/&N@@, *% AHH=J%=A=J/K^%U A'*@='B*C> @ ?@?@%*@- L%A&@> *HB>'=@J'>. @BHJHU A/$<# OB@J;%& @M & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=- J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A='=<% 6.14 HV D.
22
4 ( * * ** 2 2 7 & . 3 7 7 *7 * +C 7?
4. 17-;%=*@U . OB%$;HT@; AJH%>/ OB@#=%;K 14-;%=*%>/ . JCO@=< W/=C;&/ JH$&@ >%T$/ ?'B'T'>@ AHA%$*%?H $H>'. M S'>%=@; B'AO@J'K- ^@>@ JH$&/ OB%$A%$'=%;< ?'B'T*H?H &HHO%B'=@J' @ AHHW^@; /L'A=&HJH- >/, &H=HBCU AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ J H=*He%*@@ . OH A=. 6.10 HV D.
? . * * * , * - * 2: / * : ?
5. EB'T$'*@* F., W/$/L@ ?%*%B';<*C> $@B%&=HBH> , B%?/;#B*H S'$%BT@J'; S'BO;'=/ B'WH=*@&'>, J AJ#S@ A L%>, H* WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L. 1 A=. 5.27 HV D. %B%S 7 >%A#- N%J OHA;% /O;'=C e=B'+' J H=*He%*@@ *%?H @*AO%&=HBH> HW;'A=*HU @*- AO%&N@@ =B/$' HO#=< WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'- JH*'B/e%*@@ S' *'B/e%*@% ABH&HJ JCO;'=C S'BO;'=C, *H OH L. 2 A=. 5.27HV D. O'A'#A<, L=H %?H >H?/= $@A&J';@+@N@BHJ'=<, F. /JH;@;A# OH AHWA=J%**H>/ T%;'*@K A $H;T*HA=@ ?%*%B';<*H?H $@B%&=HB'. V$JH&'= ?B'T$'*@*' F. OB@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' J A/$% OH#A*@;, L=H F. *% >HT%= WC=< OB@J;%L%* & H=J%=A=J%**HA=@, OHA&H;<&/ H* *% #J;#%=A# A/Wg%&=H> H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH L. 2 A=. 5.27 HV D @ *% >HT%= WC=< $@A&J';@+@- N@BHJ'*.
3 * * 2 * ( * 2 ? > / *7, * . *7 /+ ? 7 + * ?
6. F MH$% OBHJ%B&@ AHW;K$%*@# *HB>'=@J*H $HO/A=@>CM O'B'>%=BHJ J OH>%^%*@@ B'UH**HU *';H?HJHU @*AO%&N@@ *' B'WHL@M >%A='M AH=B/$*@- &HJ @*AO%&N@@ HB?'*H> A'*hO@$*'$SHB' /A='*HJ;%*C OB%JCe%*@# &H*- N%*=B'N@@ H=B@N'=%;<*CM 'hBH@H*HJ JHS$/M', /BHJ*# h;%&=BH>'?*@=*H?H @S;/L%*@#, =%>O%B'=/BC JHS$/M', L=H #J;#%=A# AHA='JH> OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H A=. A=. 6.3 HV D. ' HA*HJ'*@@ AHA='J;%**H?H OBH- =H&H;' H *'B/e%*@@ A'*@='B*H?H S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%- *@% H OB@J;%L%*@@ *';H?HJHU @*AO%&N@@ & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%*- *HA=@ OH A=. 6.3 HV D J J@$% e=B'+' J B'S>%B% 10000 B/W.
7. B%$OB@*@>'=%;< W%S HWB'SHJ'*@# KB@$@L%A&H?H ;@N' H=&BC; AL%= J W'*&% $;# *'&HO;%*@# AB%$A=J *' OH&/O&/ >'e@*C. F AHH=J%=A=J@@ A S'&H*H$'=%;<A=JH> W'*& AHHW^@; HW H=&BC=@@ AL%=' L'A=*C> OB%$OB@*@- >'=%;%> J *';H?HJC% HB?'*C. HA;% L%?H *' L'A=*H?H OB%$OB@*@>'=%;# WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; OH A=. 15.4 HV D.
* * ?
> / *7, * * K *( ( * 8 2 +* ( 2*7 / ?
23
> / *7, **( 8 ( * 8 2, : ( * & ?
8. *HA=B'**CU ?B'T$'*@* S'&;KL@; =B/$HJHU $H?HJHB A OB%$A='J@- =%;%> KB@$@L%A&H?H ;@N' @ HA/^%A=J;#; =B/$HJ/K $%#=%;<*HA=< *' HA*H- J'*@@ /A=*H?H S'J%B%*@# B'WH=H$'=%;# H =H>, L=H *' *%?H OH;/L%*H B'SB%- e%*@% *' B'WH=/. HT%= ;@ @*HA=B'**CU ?B'T$'*@* WC=< OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ J AHH=J%=A=J@@ AH A=. 18.10 HV D, S' HA/^%A=J;%*@% @*HA=B'**C> ?B'T$'*@*H> =B/$HJHU $%#=%;<*HA=@ JHAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ W%S B'SB%e%*@# *' B'WH=/?
9. B@ OBHJ%$%*@@ OBHJ%B&@ $%#=%;<*HA=@ *';H?HJC>@ HB?'*'>@ JC#J;%* +'&= *'B/e%*@# S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' H ?HA/$'BA=J%**H> B%?/;@BH- J'*@@ OBH@SJH$A=J' @ HWHBH=' h=@;HJH?H AO@B=', ';&H?H;<*HU @ AO@B=HAH- $%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@, JCB'S@Je@UA# J =H>, L=H *' ';&H?H;<*/K OBH$/&- N@K *% S'OH;*%*C ?B'+C «&H;@L%A=JH OBH$/&N@@», «>'B&@BHJ&' AO%N@- ';<*C>@ >'B&'>@», «$'=' H=?B/S&@», «j =HJ'BHAHOBHJH$@=%;<*HU *'&;'$*HU», OBHA='J;%*C OH$O@A< H=OB'J@=%;# @ *% /&'S'*' %?H $H;T- *HA=<, L=H HWB'S/%= AHA='J OB'JH*'B/e%*@#, OB%$/A>H=B%**CU L. 2 A=. 14.16 HV D.
F A/$%W*H> S'A%$'*@@ OB%$A='J@=%;< /&'S'**C% +'&=C OB@S*';, H$*'&H OH#A*@;, L=H J@*HJ*C> J AHJ%Be%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'- B/e%*@#, OH %?H >*%*@K, #J;#%=A# S'J%$/K^@U A&;'$H> r., ' OB@L@*HU AH- J%Be%*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@# #J@;HA< *%*'$;%T'^%% @A- OH;*%*@% @> AJH@M $H;T*HA=*CM HW#S'**HA=%U, L=H J A@;/ A=. 2.1 HV D HAJHWHT$'%= A'>/ HB?'*@S'N@K H= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
3 ? 8 * * ?
10. H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH> *';H?HJCM HB?'*HJ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A=. 15.5 HV D J H=*He%*@@ $@B%&=HB' S' *%OB%$A='J;%*@% $%&;'B'N@@ OH *';H?/ *' OB@WC;< J /A='*HJ;%**CU ABH&. B@ B'AA>H=B%*@@ $%;' >@BHJC> A/$<%U $@B%&=HB OH#A*@;, L=H HW#S'**HA=< OB%$A='J;#=< *';H?HJ/K $%&;'B'N@K ;%T@= *' ?;'J*H> W/M?';=%B%. L'A=J/K^@U J &'L%A=J% AJ@$%=%;# W/M?';=%B HWg#A- *@;, L=H S' OB%$A='J;%*@% $%&;'B'N@@ H= @>%*@ *';H?HO;'=%;<^@&', &H=H- BC> J AHH=J%=A=J@@ A ';H?HJC> &H$%&AH> D #J;#%=A# KB@$@L%A&H% ;@- NH, H=J%=A=J%**HA=< *%A%= B/&HJH$@=%;< HB?'*@S'N@@.
" /* & :. 3 // 8( * ? - * * * . 15.5 3 " ?
11. *AO%&=HB'>@ E WC; HA='*HJ;%* 'J=H>HW@;< FVi 2110 OH$ /OB'J;%*@%> ?B'T$'*@*H> ., J H=*He%*@@ &H=HBH?H @>%;@A< HA*H- J'*@# OH;'?'=<, L=H H*H *'MH$@;HA< J AHA=H#*@@ ';&H?H;<*H?H HO<#*%*@#. EB'T$'*@* . H=&'S';A# OBHMH$@=< >%$@N@*A&H% HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@%, /=J%BT$'#, L=H H* =B%SJCU. '& JC#A*@;HA< OHST%, J;'$%;<N%> 'J=H>HW@-
24
;# WC; *'MH$@Je@UA# J >'e@*% O'AA'T@B ., &H=HBCU $'; AJH%>/ $B/?/ OH&'='=<A#. F AJ#S@ A h=@> H=*He%*@@ . WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A=. 12.26, ' J H=*He%*@@ . — OH L. 2 A=. 12.8 HV D. '=%B@';C $%; WC;@ O%B%$'*C >@BHJH>/ A/$<%, &H- =HBCU OB@J;%& HWH@M & H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ @ *'S*'L@; @> ;@e%*@% OB'J' /OB'J;%*@# =B'*AOHB=*H?H AB%$A=J' *' 2 ?H$'.
3 / & 7 * & ?
12. FH JB%># OBHJ%$%*@# OBH+@;'&=@L%A&@M >%BHOB@#=@U, *' L%B$'&% T@;H?H $%J#=@h='T*H?H $H>' WC;@ HW*'B/T%*C L%=J%BH OH$BHA=&HJ: L%=CB- *'$N'=@;%=*@% J'*HJ @ %=BHJ, O#=*'$N'=@;%=*@U %>%*HJ @ @&H;'%J e%A=*'$N'=@ ;%=, &H=HBC% B'AO@J';@ A'>H?H*. FH JB%># B'AO@=@# H*@ J%;@ A%W# =@MH, &'&@M - ;@WH S'#J;%*@U H= T@;<NHJ $H>' *% OHA=/O';H.
F $%T/B*HU L'A=@ E F WC;H OB@*#=H B%e%*@% OB@J;%L< JA%M OH$BHA=- &HJ & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A=. 20.20 HV D (B'AO@=@% ';&H?H;<*HU @ AO@B=HAH$%BT'^%U OBH$/&N@@ J HW^%A=J%**H> >%A=%).
?
13. H=B/$*@&'>@ OH;@N@@ J OH$J';% T@;H?H $H>' WC;@ HW*'B/T%*C 15-;%=*@U H>;%J @ 17-;%=*@U q'W'BHJ, &H=HBC% &/B@;@ A'>H$%;<*C% O'O@BHAC A M'B'&=%B*C> S'O'MH> >'B@M/'*C. &'S'**C% ;@N' WC;@ $H- A='J;%*C J $%T/B*/K L'A=< E F .
B@ ;@L*H> $HA>H=B% OH$BHA=&HJ / H>;%J' WC;H HW*'B/T%*H *%- WH;<eH% &H;@L%A=JH J%^%A=J' AB%$A=J B'A=@=%;<*H?H OBH@AMHT$%*@# OHMHT%?H *' >'B@M/'*/. F AJHK HL%B%$<, H* S'#J@;@ H $HWBHJH;<*HU A$'L% *'B&H=@L%A&@M AB%$A=J, &H=HBC% OB@HWB%=';@A< @> @A&;KL@=%;<*H $;# ;@L*CM */T$.
+HB>@J /A='*HJ;%**C> OHB#$&H> @Sg#=@% *'B&H=@L%A&@M AB%$A=J @ OBH@SJ%$# HAJ@$%=%;<A=JHJ'*@% H>;%J' @ q'W'BHJ', WC;H OB@*#=H B%e%- *@% HW @M OB@J;%L%*@@ & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' OH=B%W;%- *@% *'B&H=@L%A&@M AB%$A=J W%S *'S*'L%*@# JB'L' (A=. 6.9 HV D).
F $';<*%Ue%> H>;%J @ q'W'BHJ WC;@ O%B%$'*C BH$@=%;#>, ' >'=%- B@';C *'OB'J;%*C J A/=HL*CU ABH& >@BHJH>/ A/$<%.
7 ?
14. L'A=&HJCU /OH;*H>HL%**CU ;%U=%*'*= OH;@N@@ =%O'*HJ S'- $%BT'; $J/M OH$BHA=&HJ, &H=HBC% @S H&*' ;%A=*@L*HU O;H^'$&@ L%=J%B=H- ?H h='T' WBHA';@ J OBHMHT@M ?*@;C% HJH^@, O'&%=C A JH$HU, *%WH;<e@% &H><# S%>;@. $@* O'&%= OHO'; *' &BCe/ 'J=H>'e@*C «l@?/;@», HWB'SH- J'J *%WH;<e/K J>#=@*/. q/;@?'*C WC;@ $HA='J;%*C J &H>*'=/ /L'A=&H- JH?H /OH;*H>HL%**H?H, ?$% WC;' /A='*HJ;%*' @M ;@L*HA=< – O#=*'$N'=@- ;%=*@U A@OL/& @ e%A=*'$N'=@;%=*@U VS'B#*.
HA;% OB@?;'e%*@# H=N' A@OL/&', *' *%?H WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; OH A=. 5.35. HV D S' *%@AOH;*%*@% HW#S'**HA=%U OH JHAO@='*@K *%AH-
25
J%Be%**H;%=*%?H AC*' @ H* /J%; AJH%?H AC*' $H>HU. '& &'& BH$@=%;%U VS'B#*' *% WC;H $H>', =H =%O'*HJ A='; S'*@>'=<A# A *%AHJ%Be%**H;%=- *@> OB'JH*'B/e@=%;%>: HOBHA@; %?H, AHA='J@; OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A=. 20.1. HV D, HS*'&H>@; *'B/e@=%;# A >'=%B@';'>@ @, OH %?H OBHA<W%, JB/L@; &HO@K OBH=H&H;'. @*/= L%B%S 30– 40 J A;/T%W*H% OH>%^%*@% JW%T';' JSJH;*HJ'**'# >'=< VS'B#*' @, /S*'J, L=H OBH@SHe;H, A=';' B/?'=< AC*' *' AJH%> BH$*H> #SC&%. B@$# J A%W#, H*' OHOBHA@;' AH=B/$*@&' OH;@N@@ OH&'S'=< %U JA% >'=%B@';C OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@, (HWg#A*%*@# OH=%BO%Je@M, S'#J;%- *@# J;'$%;<N' 'p>, HWg#A*%*@# AC*' @ A@OL/&' @ $B.). i'=%> H*' OH=B%- WHJ';' HW%AO%L@=< %U *%S'>%$;@=%;<*/K JA=B%L/ A '$JH&'=H> @ H&'S'=< AH$%UA=J@% J /A;/?'M O%B%JH$L@&'.
2 * ( * 8 ( |
8 - |
& , /+ 7*2 * ? |
|
8 + 7 ? / 7 ? |
|
3 ? * 2 ( * 8 ( |
8 & ? |
15. H?/= ;@ WC=< A/Wg%&='>@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ HB- ?'*C ?HA/$'BA=J%**HU J;'A=@ @ HB?'*C >%A=*H?H A'>H/OB'J;%*@#?
16. ' ;%=H ?B'T$'*&' i'J'BS@*' H=OB'J@;' OH O/=%J&% AJH%?H *%AH- J%Be%**H;%=*%?H AC*' ( H*A='*=@*', 15 ;%=) H=$CM'=< J OBH+@;'&=HB@U G J%=;'*'». 'MH$#A< J OBH+@;'&=HB@@, H*A='*=@* @ %^% 2 >';<L@&' J JHSB'A=% 13 @ 14 ;%=, &/O@;@ / H$*H?H >%A=*H?H T@=%;# 0,5 ;@=B' A'>H?H*' @ *'L';@ %?H B'AO@J'=< J H$*HU @S &H>*'= OBH+@;'&=HB@#. T% *'MH$#A< J AHA=H#*@@ HO<#*%*@#, H*@ B%e@;@ @$=@ &/O'=<A# *' B. FH;?'. *@ OH&@- */;@ =%BB@=HB@K OBH+@;'&=HB@# @ *'OB'J@;@A< *' O;#T, ?$% J%;@ A%W# JCSCJ'K^% @ OB@A='J';@ & H=$CM'K^@> ='> ?B'T$'*'>, &H=HBC% @ JCSJ';@ AH=B/$*@&HJ OH;@N@@.
F AJ#S@ A $'**C> @*N@$%*=H> AH=B/$*@&'>@ WC; AHA='J;%* OBH- =H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ OH A=. 20.22 HV D J H=- *He%*@@ $@B%&=HB' OBH+@;'&=HB@# E'JB@;HJHU.
* * ? 37 7 *7 / 8 - * * / * + - * 8 7 ? 3 * & 7 7 *7 * +C- * * ?
17. F AJ#S@ A /L'A=@Je@>@A# J ?HBH$% OHT'B'>@, ?HA/$'BA=J%**C> @*AO%&=HBH> OH OHT'B*H>/ *'$SHB/ WC; OBHJ%$%* B%U$ OH $He&H;<*C> $%=A&@> /LB%T$%*@#> ($%=A&@% A'$C) A N%;<K OBHJ%B&@ @AOH;*%*@# B/&H- JH$@=%;#>@ $'**CM /LB%T$%*@U =B%WHJ'*@U OHT'B*HU W%SHO'A*HA=@.
F 10 @S OBHJ%B#%>CM /LB%T$%*@U @*AO%&=HB JC#J@; +'&=C AHJ%Be%- *@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H OB'JH*'B/e%*@# OB%$/A>H=B%**H?H L'A=<K 1 A=. 20.4 HV D, H L%> J H=*He%*@@ &'T$H?H +'&=' WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H;
26
HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@ *' KB@$@L%A&H% ;@NH ($He&H;<- *H% HWB'SHJ'=%;<*H% /LB%T$%*@%).
'**C% OBH=H&H;C WC;@ *'OB'J;%*C ?HA/$'BA=J%**C> @*AO%&=HBH> OH OHT'B*H>/ *'$SHB/ J A/$, &H=HBCU JC*%A J H=*He%*@@ 6 $He&H;<*CM /LB%T$%*@U OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *'S*'L%*@@ e=B'+' J B'S>%B% 10 =CA#L B/W- ;%U, ' J H=*He%*@@ HA=';<*CM 4 '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB@HA='*HJ;%*@% $%#- =%;<*HA=@ ABH&H> *' 30 A/=H&.
/&HJH$@=%;#>@ $He&H;<*CM HWB'SHJ'=%;<*CM /LB%T$%*@U, J H=*He%- *@@ &H=HBCM WC;H JC*%A%*H OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *';HT%*@@ e=B'+', $'**C% OHA='*HJ;%*@# WC;@ HWT';HJ'*C. /&HJH$@=%;@ /=J%BT$';@, L=H HWB'SHJ'- =%;<*C% /LB%T$%*@# @>%K= A='=/A >/*@N@O';<*CM, +@*'*A@B/K=A# @S AB%$A=J >%A=*H?H WK$T%=' @ A'>HA=H#=%;<*CM $HMH$HJ *% @>%K=, J AJ#S@ A L%>, /O;'=' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' #J;#%=A# *%JHS>HT*HU, ='&T% H*@ /&'S';@, L=H /A=B'*%*@% *'B/e%*@U A@;'>@ @ AB%$A=J'>@ A'>@M /LB%T$%*@U *%JHS>HT*H. AC;'#A< *' AJHU A='=/A, H*@ /=J%BT$';@, L=H *'B/e%*@# JHS- *@&;@ JA;%$A=J@% H=A/=A=J@# +@*'*A@BHJ'*@# AH A=HBH*C HB?'*HJ >%A=*H?H A'>H/OB'J;%*@# @ J@*C A'>@M /LB%T$%*@U J A;/L@Je%>A# *%=.
)+ * 8 8 ? +8 2 8 ( ?- ? ? 2*7 * 8 6 & 2- 8 ( ? 7? 3 ? +8 2 * * 8 6, * ( *: ( * & * * :/ ? * 2 2?
+8 8 * * + * * 7 2 * & 2 8 2 8 ( ? ?
? +8 2 / ( * * - 7 2 * , * * 7 : ( * & + * * 2( , 6 * / ? * * + : 2 *-8 / 8), 2 7 7 2 * 2 :- ( * & * / / ? / / 2: ? ?
18. H$/>'U=%, JHS>HT*H ;@ OB@J;%L%*@% & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ OH A=. 17.7 HV D « %JCOH;*%*@% S'&H**CM =B%WHJ'*@U OBH&/BHB', A;%$HJ'=%;#, $HS*'J'=%;# @;@ $H;T*HA=*H?H ;@N', HA/^%A=J- ;#K^%?H OBH@SJH$A=JH OH $%;/ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/e%*@@» A;%$HJ'=%;# ;%$A=J%**H?H &H>@=%=' S' />Ce;%**H% *%JCOH;*%*@% =B%- WHJ'*@U OBH&/BHB' HW /A=B'*%*@@ *'B/e%*@U +%$%B';<*H?H S'&H*H$'- =%;<A=J'. B@ H=J%=% *' JHOBHA OBH'*';@S@B/U=% A=YA=. 6, 44 D%$%B';<*H- ?H S'&H*' H= 28 $%&'WB# 2010 ?. j 403-Di « ;%$A=J%**H> &H>@=%=% HA- A@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@», D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 17 #*J'B# 1992 ?. j 2202-I G OBH&/B'=/B% HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» @ WSHB A/$%W*HU OB'&=@&@ F%B- MHJ*H?H /$' D S' O%BJCU &J'B='; 2004 ?H$' (OH ?B'T$'*A&@> $%;'>).
27
' 5. '! !($%$!- + !".
1.H*#=@% @ N%;@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'*@U.
2.@A=%>' @ J@$C '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'*@U.
3.B'J@;' *'S*'L%*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'*@U.
4.AJHWHT$%*@% H= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@.
:
H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@#M H= 30 $%&'WB# 2001 ?H$' j 195-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 1, L. 1, A=. 1.
i%>%;<*CU &H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ H= 25 H&=#WB# 2001 ?. j 136-Di // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2001. — j 44, A=. 4147.
EB'T$'*A&@U &H$%&A HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ H= 30 *H#WB# 1994 ?. j 51-Di. 'A=< 1 // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 1994. — j 32, A=. 3301.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 25 @K;# 2002 ?. j 115-Di « OB'JHJH> OH;H- T%*@@ @*HA=B'**CM ?B'T$'* J HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'- =%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2002. — j 30, A=. 3032.
D%$%B';<*CU S'&H* H= 26 @K;# 2006 ?. j 135-Di « S'^@=% &H*&/- B%*N@@» // HWB. S'&H*H$'=%;<A=J' HA. D%$%B'N@@. — 2006. — j 31. L. I, A=. 3434.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D 24 >'B=' 2005 ?. j 5 G *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ H$%&A'HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 10 @K*# 2010 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D. 2005. j 6.
HA='*HJ;%*@% ;%*/>' F%BMHJ*H?H /$' D H= 24 H&=#WB# 2006 ?. j18 « *%&H=HBCM JHOBHA'M, JHS*@&'K^@M / A/$HJ OB@ OB@>%*%*@@ AH- W%**HU L'A=@ H$%&A' HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@ HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'- JH*'B/e%*@#M» (J B%$. 11 *H#WB# 2008 ?.) // K;;%=%*< F%BMHJ*H?H /$'D. 2006. j 12.
:
1.'SHJ@=% N%;@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM *'&'S'*@U.
2.'&@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*C% *'&'S'*@# OB@>%*#K=A# J &'L%A=J% HA- *HJ*CM @ $HOH;*@=%;<*CM?
28
3.'&@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*C% *'&'S'*@# >H?/= WC=< *'S*'L%*C *%A/- $%W*C>@ HB?'*'>@?
4.'&@% AOHAHWC @AL@A;%*@# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' S'&B%O;%*CHV D?
5.'&HJC J@$C AO%N@';<*CM OB'J, ;@e%*@% &H=HBCM OB%$/A>'=B@J'- %= HV D?
6.'&H% W%SJHS>%S$*H% @Sg#=@% @>/^%A=J' *% #J;#%=A# &H*+@A&'N@%U?
7.F H=*He%*@@ &'&@M A/Wg%&=HJ >HT%= WC=< OB@>%*%*' $@A&J';@+@- &'N@#? '&HJC %% HA*HJ'*@#?
8.H>/ *% >HT%= WC=< *'S*'L%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU 'B%A=?
9.F L%> S'&;KL'%=A# JC$JHB%*@% S' OB%$%;C D, &'&HJ OHB#$H& B%'- ;@S'N@@ $'**H?H J@$' '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@#?
10.B@ AHJH&/O*HA=@ &'&@M /A;HJ@U >HT%= *'S*'L'=<A# ='&HU J@$ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H *'&'S'*@# &'& '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% OB@HA='*HJ;%*@% $%#=%;<*HA=@?
11.'& *'S*'L'K=A# '$>@*@A=B'=@J*C% *'&'S'*@# OB@ >*HT%A=J%*- *HA=@ OB'JH*'B/e%*@U?
12.'&HJC ABH&@ $'J*HA=@ OB@J;%L%*@# & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=- A=J%**HA=@ OB@ AHJ%Be%*@@ $;#^%?HA# OB'JH*'B/e%*@#?
E ! ! H% R !"
1. B%$OB@*@>'=%;< W%S HWB'SHJ'*@# KB@$@L%A&H?H ;@N' . *';H?H- JC>@ HB?'*'>@ WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A='=<% 14.5 HV D S' *%JC$'L/ &'AAHJH?H L%&' OB@ OBH$'T% =HJ'B' @ OH$J%B?*/= '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H>/ e=B'+/ J A/>>% 4000 B/W;%U.
B%$OB@*@>'=%;< *% AH?;'A@;A# A B'S>%BH> *';HT%**H?H *' *%?H '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' @ HWB'=@;A# A T';HWHU J 'BW@=B'T*CU A/$, J &H=HBHU /&'S';, L=H &H*=BH;<*H &'AAHJCU 'OO'B'= / *%?H *% B'WH='; ;@e< 15 >@*/=, OHA&H;<&/ *% WC;H O@='*@# J h;%&=B@L%A&HU A%=@; H* OBH$'; ;@e< H$*/ %$@*@N/ =HJ'B', A=H@>HA=<K 165 B/W;%U; @>%%= *' @T$@J%*@@ 2 >';H;%=*@M $%=%U; *@&H?$' & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' '*'- ;H?@L*C% OB'JH*'B/e%*@# *% OH$J%B?';A#; ' J *'A=H#^%% JB%># &H*- =BH;<*H &'AAHJCU 'OO'B'= *' %?H =HB?HJHU =HL&% B'WH='%= @AOB'J*H.
/$ /L%; *';@L@% A>#?L'K^@M HWA=H#=%;<A=J OH $%;/ @ A*@S@; B'S>%B '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' $H 1500 B/W;%U.
* & : * ( / 7 * :; / - 2* .
/ ? / ( * / 7 ? /-( * 7 ( :; +* 7 2* ?
2. F B%S/;<='=% OBHJ%$%**HU *';H?HJC>@ HB?'*'>@ J >'?'S@*% G » OBHJ%B&@ OB@>%*%*@# &H*=BH;<*H &'AAHJCM >'e@* OB@ HA/^%A=J;%-
29
*@@ $%*%T*CM B'AL%=HJ A *'A%;%*@%> /A='*HJ;%*H, L=H OBH$'T' *'WHB' >%W%;@ +@S@L%A&H>/ ;@N/ OBH@SJ%$%*' W%S OB@>%*%*@# . %*%T*'# *';@L*HA=<, OH;/L%**'# S' =HJ'B, J &'AA/ *% HOB@MH$HJ'*'.
' HA*HJ'*@@ $'**H?H $%#*@# W^%A=JH OB@J;%L%*H & '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' AHJ%Be%*@% '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CM OB'JH*'B/e%- *@U J AHH=J%=A=J@@ AH A='=<#>@ 14.5, 15.1 HV D @ OH AHJH&/O*HA=@ A'*&N@U h=@M A='=%U OHA='*HJ;%*@%> B/&HJH$@=%;# *';H?HJH?H HB?'*' *' *%?H *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 70000 B/W;%U.
W^%A=JH HWB'=@;HA< J VBW@=B'T*CU A/$ A S'#J;%*@%> HW HAO'B@J'- *@@ OHA='*HJ;%*@#.
8 8 * :; / 2* 8 * * 7?
3 / ( *7 * / * - * 2 ?
3. H;T*HA=*C> ;@NH> *';H?HJCM HB?'*HJ J H=*He%*@@ $@B%&=HB' OB%$OB@#=@# WC; AHA='J;%* OBH=H&H; HW '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H> OB'JH*'B/- e%*@@ OH A=. 15.5 HV D S' *%AJH%JB%>%**H% OB%$A='J;%*@% *';H?HJCM $%&;'B'N@U OH *';H?/ *' OB@WC;<, , *';H?/ A OBH$'T S' A%*=#WB<, H&=#WB< @ *H#WB< 2006 ?H$'. @BHJHU A/$<# JC*%A OHA='*HJ;%*@% H *';H- T%*@@ '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H?H e=B'+' *' $@B%&=HB' J B'S>%B% 500 B/W;%U, HWHA*HJCJ'# >'&A@>';<*CU B'S>%B e=B'+' =%>, L=H OB%$OB@#=@%> *% WC- ;H OB%$A='J;%*H *%A&H;<&H $%&;'B'N@U OH AHH=J%=A=J/K^@> *';H?'>.
3 ++8 ; 8 ? * 8 & 8 -8 * 2 . 3 / ( 7 * 8 / * * 2 * 8 /-2* ?
4. EB'T$'*@* '$T@&@A='*' . WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$>@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ OH A=. 18.10 HV D S' HA/^%A=J;%*@% =B/$HJHU $%#- =%;<*HA=@ W%S B'SB%e%*@# *' B'WH=/. /$<%U B'UH**H?H A/$' *' . WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'=@J*CU e=B'+ J B'S>%B% 1000 B/W;%U @ *'S*'L%*H '$>@*@A=B'=@J*H% JC$JHB%*@% S' OB%$%;C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@.
HA;% JA=/O;%*@# J S'&H**/K A@;/ OHA='*HJ;%*@# . WC; JC$JHB%* S' OB%$%;C HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@, *% /O;'=@J e=B'+. /$%W*CU OB@A='J- @AOH;*@=%;< /A='*HJ@;, L=H . *% @>%; *@&'&H?H @>/^%A=J' @ $%*%T*CM AB%$A=J *' =%BB@=HB@@ HAA@UA&HU D%$%B'N@@.
3 + / * ( ? /8* 2 * 8 6 * + 8 * A * 2?
5. i'J%$/K^@U H=$%;%*@%> ?HBH$A&HU WH;<*@NC WC; OB@J;%L%* & '$- >@*@A=B'=@J*HU H=J%=A=J%**HA=@ S' *'B/e%*@% =B%WHJ'*@U OHT'B*HU W%SHO'A*HA=@ OH L. 1 A=. 20.4 HV D. ' *%?H WC; *';HT%* '$>@*@A=B'- =@J*CU e=B'+ &'& *' $H;T*HA=*H?H ;@N' J B'S>%B% 1000 B/W;%U.
30
