Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

1 =6. -"+,.("051('3 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 24 A1 &.2/3 2002 F. No 10425/02 ' No 10426/02 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

: =6. U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / J,0. /1A. -/"E. :.M.=$X.("0. ) 2 ,. G. II. !"5$,"6 2. =. 95; N%$=,+#.,/ 1.)., 2,7%:+#.,/ 2.2. 7"F"0"/("1 -/.0". 8(. 3:

7"F"0"/4 " 04-"5(1('' /.2", ' "&.L.('' $+5$F. ?.: =,.,$,, 2002. =. 291.

3 =6. U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / J,0. /1A. -/"E. :.M. =$X.("0. ) 2 ,. G"6 <. !"5$,"6 2. =. 306.

85

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

+95 /:!9%;%'/5 -$/8<9/ /9/ +#"2/*%'/5 /'#7 '% -$#2/!#$%;) 6%7 :),#'3 @%9/.

S),, !'%"%''#% 2#!)$/6)&/ /&36%"2!#, ,#2#$<& #'/ #89) +)9/ ') -$)!% "#8"2!%''#"2/, ) 2),*% -$#/:!%+%'')5 ! $%:39>2) 2% "#!&%"2'#7 +%52%9>'#"2/ -$#+3,@/5 / -#93;%''<% #2 2),#7 +%52%9>'#"2/ -9#+< / +#?#+< -$/:')=2"5 /? #86%7 +#9%!#7 "#8"2!%''#"2>=, 2.%. -#9>:#!)'/% 2),/& /&36%"2!#& #"36%"2! 95%2"5 -# /? #86%&3 "#(9)"/=; -$/ !%+%'// #86/? +%9 ,)*+<7 2#!)$/6 !-$)!% +%7"2!#!)2> #2 /&%'/ !"%? 2#!)$/6%7; $%G%'/5, ,)")=6/%"5 #86/? +%9 2#!)$/6%7, -$/'/&)=2"5 2#!)$/6)&/ -# #86%&3 "#(9)"/=; #85:)''<&/ -# "#!%$G%''<& "+%9,)& "2)'#!52"5 !"% 2#!)$/6/; #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%/"-#9'%'/% #8 6/? #85:)2%9>"2! '%"32 !"% 2#!)$/6/, -$/ I2#& %"9/ +#(#!#$ -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!) "!5:)' " #"36%"2!9%'/%& %(# 3;)"2'/,) &/ -$%+-$/'/&)2%9>",#7 +%52%9>'#"2/, 2#!)$/6/ #2!%;)=2 "# 9/+)$'# -# !"%& #86/& #85:)2%9>"2!)&, '%:)!/"/ #2 #"'#!) '/7 /? !#:'/,'#!%'/5 / 2.+.

H%#8?#+/ 2),*% #"#8# #8$)2/2> !'/&)'/% / ') #"'#!) '/5 -$%,$)6%'/5 +#(#!#$) -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!).

H)-$/&%$, "#(9)"'# -. 1 "2. 1050 KA .N +#(#!#$ -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!) -$%,$)6)%2"5 !"9%+"2!/% "&%$2/ 2#!)$/6) /9/ 9/,!/+)@// 9/8# $%#$()'/:)@// 3;)"2!3=6%(# ! +#(#!#$% -$# "2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!) =$/+/;%",#(# 9/@), %"9/ +#(#!#$#& /9/ -#"9%+3=6/& "#(9)G%'/%& '% -$%+3"$%'# "#?$)'%'/% +#(# !#$) ! #2'#G%'/5? &%*+3 #"2)9>'<&/ 2#!)$/6)&/ 9/8# :)&% 6%'/% 3&%$G%(# 2#!)$/6) (9/,!/+/$#!)''#(# /9/ $%#$()'/:# !)''#(# =$/+/;%",#(# 9/@)) %(# ')"9%+'/,)&/ (-$)!#-$%%&'/ ,)&/).

19%+#!)2%9>'#, -# #86%&3 -$)!/93 ! "93;)% "&%$2/ 2#!) $/6) /9/ $%#$()'/:)@// =$/+/;%",#(# 9/@) -$)!#-$%%&"2!) ! +#(#!#$% -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!) '% -$#/"?#+/2 (! #29/;/% #2 8#9>G/'"2!) +$3(/? +#(#!#$#!), -$)!) / #85:)''#"2/ , ')"9%+ '/,)& (-$)!#-$%%&'/,)&) '% -%$%?#+52.

C#",#9>,3 '/ :),#', '/ /'<% -$)!#!<% ),2< '% "#+%$*)2 :)-$%2 ') 3"23-,3 2$%8#!)'/7, !#:'/,G/? /: +#(#!#$) -$#"2#(#

§4. G -,4+"#7, .%&?,7"%$, ,<&UR&/ #5R'&++"& L+$4&+,& ?-: ?"->+,.$

2#!)$/6%"2!) (-. 1 "2. 388 KA .N), '%#8?#+/ "+%9)2> !<!#+, ;2# 2),)5 3"23-,) ! -$/'@/-% !#:*').

Q+'),#, /"?#+5 /: -$/$#+< (?)$),2%$), "#+%$*)'/5) #2'# G%'/7 &%*+3 3;)"2'/,)&/ 2),#(# +#(#!#$), 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$% 8#!)'/5 8%: "#(9)"/5 !"%? 3;)"2'/,#! '%!#:*'), -#",#9>,3 I2# -$#2/!#$%;/2 -. 2 "2. 388 KA .N. Q8 I2#& "!/+%2%9>"2!3%2 /

)$8/2$)*')5 -$),2/,)1.

1 &%'2) *% -$%,$)6%'/5 +#(#!#$) -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2 !) 3,):)'')5 #"#8%''#"2> #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 3;)"2'/,)&/ +#(# !#$) 32$);/!)%2"5 / -#I2#&3 2$%8#!)'/5 , 8<!G/& 3;)"2'/,)& +#(#!#$), ') ')G !:(95+, (32 8<2> 3"23-9%'< 3*% 8%: 3"9#!/5, -$%+3"$%''#(# -. 2 "2. 388 KA .N.

4<!#+ # '%#8?#+/"2/ -#93;%'/5 "#(9)"/5 !"%? 3;)"2'/ ,#! +#(#!#$) -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!), ') ')G !:(95+, '% +#9*%' )!2#&)2/;%",/ $)"-$#"2$)'52>"5 ') /'<% $):9/;'<% &'#(#"2# $#''/% +#(#!#$<.

S),, -# &'%'/= #+'#(# /: )$8/2$)*'<? "3+#!, «-# "&<"93 (9)!< 24 KA .N -%$%&%') ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% " '%",#9> ,/&/ 3;)"2'/,)&/, /&%=6/&/ #-$%+%9%''<% -$)!) / #85:)''# "2/ -%$%+ #"2)9>'<&/ 3;)"2'/,)&/, !#:*') 2#9>,# " /? "#

(9)"/5»2.

C#9)()%&, ;2# ,), $): 2),#(# «"&<"9)» ! (9. 24 KA .N / '%2, ) %"2> #($)'/;%'/5 ("2. 383, -. 1 "2. 388) / 3"9#!/5 (-. 2 "2. 382, -. 2 "2. 388) +95 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. 1)& -# "%8% &'#(# "2#$#''/7 +#(#!#$ '% 5!95%2"5 -$%-52"2!/%& +95 @%""// !#:

'/,G/? /: '%(# #85:)2%9>"2!, ) -#",#9>,3 @%+%'2#& 3"23-)%2"5 ,#',$%2'#% 2$%8#!)'/%, 2# / '%#8?#+/ ! ,)*+#& ,#',$%2'#& "93;)% !<5"'52>, /&%%2 9/ 9/;'#"2> ,$%+/2#$) "36%"2!%''#%

1 =6. -. 4 J2L"/. -/.&,'&' /.L/1I1('3 ./2',/.H(46' +$A.6' +-"/"0, +03L.( (4X + A"F"0"/.6' (. $#.+,'1 0 +,/"',15D+,01 ('(E"/6.C'"(("1 -'+D6" !/1 L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 25 'O53 2000 F. No 56).

;. (1-1/1A.0.16"+,D -/.0 #51(. ,"0./'K1+,0., "2$+5"051((4X 1F" 5'# (46' &.#1+,0.6', "2/.K.5' 0('6.('1 ' /"++'%+&'1 A"/10"5OC'"((41 C' 0'5'+,4. =6., (.-/'61/: V&%K&+&',4 C.W. *&.L. +"#. =. 391.

!"+,.("051('1 NM= =101/"-8.0&.L+&"F" "&/$F. ", 7 .-/153 2003 F. No N08-

1075/2003 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

87

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

:');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,). C$/ I2#& 8$%&5 +#,):<!)'/5 +)''#(# #8"2#52%9>"2!) 9%*/2 ') +#9*'/,% 8%: ""<9#, ') $):9/;'<% «"&<"9<».

A 2#&3 *% /: @/2/$3% !<+%$*,/ /: "3+%8'#(# ),2) !/+ '#, ;2# "3+ +#-3",)%2 /:!%"2'#% "&%G%'/% -#'52/7 «+#(#!#$» / «#85:)2%9>"2!# ».

§ 5. *=G*!8M !>M)M G>:9J)M;<Q, )_>M\:;;JUJ ) <;J=G>M;;J] )MB@G:

4-$)!#-$/&%'/2%9>'#7 +%52%9>'#"2/ -%$/#+/;%",/ !#:'/ ,)%2 !#-$#" # +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ "#(9)G%'/5 #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, !<$)*%''#(# ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%.

4"##2!%2"2!// " -. 7 «)» "2. 1 P),#') .#""/7",#7 N%+%$)@// #2 9 #,258$5 1992 (. No

3615-1 «Q !)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !) 9=2'#& ,#'2$#9%»1 , !)9=2'<& #-%$)@/5& #2'#"52"5 #-%$)@//, "!5:)''<% " -%$%?#+#& -$)!) "#8"2!%''#"2/ / /'<? -$)! ') !) 9=2'<% @%''#"2/, ! 2#& ;/"9% #-%$)@//, "!5:)''<% " /"-#9>:# !)'/%& ! ,);%"2!% "$%+"2!) -9)2%*) /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2< / -9) 2%*'<? +#,3&%'2#! ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%.

4 "/93 -. 10 «%» "2. 1 I2#(# *% P),#') !"% !)9=2'<% #-%$) @//, '% 5!95=6/%"5 2%,36/&/ !)9=2'<&/ #-%$)@/5&/, #2'# "52"5 , !)9=2'<& #-%$)@/5&, "!5:)''<& " +!/*%'/%& ,)-/2)9).

H%,#2#$<% )$8/2$)*'<% "3+<, ""<9)5"> ') 3,):)''<% '#$ &< P),#') .N «Q !)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !)9=2'#& ,#'2$# 9%», -$/?#+52 , !<!#+3 # 2#&, ;2# 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2!3, -#+9%*)6%&3 /"-#9'%'/= ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9= 2%, #2'#"/2"5 , !)9=2'<& #-%$)@/5&, "!5:)''<& " +!/*%'/%& ,)-/2)9). 4 "!5:/ " I2/& +95 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2% -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 / '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 '%#8 ?#+/ -#93;/2> $):$%G%'/% (9/@%':/=) V)',) .#""// ') -$#-

) /1A.&C'', A1%+,0$OK1% A" 0+,$-51('3 0 +'5$ N1A1/.5D("F" L.&"(. ", 10 A1 &.2/3 2003 F. No 173-NS «J 0.5O,("6 /1F$5'/"0.('' ' 0.5O,("6 &"(,/"51».

88

§ 5. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, ';%$>&++"=" _____

X ' ,+"#7%$++"/ '$-U7&

!%+%'/% !)9=2'#7 #-%$)@//, "!5:)''#7 " +!/*%'/%& ,)-/2)9)1. T')9#(/;'#% &'%'/% *'# !"2$%2/2> / ! =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)- (3$%2.

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

H%#8?#+/ 2),*% #8$)2/2> !'/&)'/% ') 2#, ;2# "+%9,/, :) ,9=;%''<% ! ')$3G%'/% -#9#*%'/7 P),#') .N «Q !)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !)9=2'#& ,#'2$#9%», 5!95=2"5 '%+%7"2!/2%9> '<&/. W/@), "#!%$G/!G/% 2),/% "+%9,/, '%"32 3(#9#!'3=, )+ &/'/"2$)2/!'3= / /'3= #2!%2"2!%''#"2> ! "##2!%2"2!// " :),# '#+)2%9>"2!#&

.#""/7",#7 N%+%$)@// (-. 4 "2. 2 P),#')).

1#(9)"'# -. 3 "2. 14 P),#') !"% -#93;%''#% $%:/+%'2)&/, !,9=;)5 3-#9'#%''<% 8)',/, / '%$%:/+%'2)&/ -# '%+%7"2 !/2%9>'<& ! "/93 P),#') "+%9,)&, ) 2),*% !"% '%#8#"'#!)''# -$/#8$%2%''#% '% -# "+%9,%, ) ! $%:39>2)2% '%:),#''<? +%7"2 !/7 -#+9%*/2 !:<",)'/= ! +#?#+ (#"3+)$"2!).

=6., (.-/'61/, -"+,.("051('3 NM= ?"+&"0+&"F" "&/$F. ", 24 6.3 1999 F. No 8U-

M40/1453-99; ", 22 E10/.53 2000 F. No 8U-M40/476-00; ", 28 6./,. 2000 F. No 8U- M40/1070-00; ", 1 .0F$+,. 2000 F. No> 8U-M40/3224-00; ", 28 E10/.53 2002 F. No

8U-M40/825-02; -"+,.("051('3 NM= */.5D+&"F" "&/$F. ", 28 3(0./3 2000 F. No

N09-895/99-U8; ", 19 'O(3 2003 F. No N09-1411/03-U8; -"+,.("051 ('1 NM= )"+,"#("-='2'/+&"F" "&/$F. ", 8 .0F$+,. 2001 F. No M19-3088/01-23- N02-1806/01- =2 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

U

!/.&,'&. !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N -" A.(("6$ 0"-/"+$ ",/.H1(. 0 -"+,.("051('3X ", 23 .0F$+,. 2000 F. No 3807/00; ", 10 3(0./3 2001 F. No 5040/00; ", 29 "&,32/3 2002 F. No 4554/02 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

: =6., (.-/'61/: N&-"' 2.(. *&.L. +"#. =. 143. 89

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,: ___

S),/& #8$):#&, ')$3G%'/% @%+%'2#& / @%""/#')$/%& 2$%

8#!)'/7 P),#') .N «Q !)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !)9=2'#&

,#'2$#9%» !9%;%2 +95 '/? #-$%+%9%''<% '%89)(#-$/52'<% -#

"9%+"2!/5. C$/ I2#& A#'"2/23@/#''<7 13+ .N "-%@/)9>'# 3,)

:)9 ') 2#, ;2# !:<",)'/% "3&& G2$)E#! / /'<? ")',@/7, 3"2)

'#!9%''<? P),#'#&, 5!95%2"5 '),):)'/%& :) !)9=2'#% -$)!#')

$3G%'/%, 2.%. :) -$%+3"$%''#% :),#'#& -$#2/!#-$)!'#% !/

'#!'#% +%5'/%, "#!%$G%''#% 3&<G9%''# /9/ -# '%#"2#$#*'# "2/1.

C$%+"2)!95%2"5, ,#(+) $%;> /+%2 #8 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/, '),) :)'/5?, '%89)(#-$/52'<? -#"9%+"2!/5? +95 3;)"2'/,#! "+%9,/ / 2.+., 2# :),#' +#9*%' "#+%$*)2> ;%2,/% / -#'52'<% '#$&<, -#9#*%'/5 :),#') '% +#9*'< 8<2> +!3"&<"9%''<&/, '%5"'<&/ /

'%+#"2)2#;'# #-$%+%9%''<&/. «1)',@// +#9*'< #2!%;)2> 2$%8#!)'/5& A#'"2/23@//

.N, ! 2#& ;/"9%... /",9=;)2> !#: *'#"2> /? -$#/:!#9>'#(# /"2#9,#!)'/5 / -$/&%'%'/5»2.

P),#' .N «Q !)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !)9=2'#& ,#'2$# 9%» '% "#+%$*/2 '#$&, 2#9,#!)'/% ,#2#$<? -#:!#95%2 "+%9)2> -$5, ;%2,/7 / 5"'<7 !<!#+ # 2#&, ;2# 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5, !<$)*%''#(# ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%, 5!95%2"5 !)9=2'#7

#-%$)@/%7.

S#, ;2# 2),)5 "+%9,) '% 5!95%2"5 !)9=2'#7 #-%$)@/%7, -#+

2!%$*+)%2 / -#:/@/5 R%'2$)9>'#(# 8)',) .#""/7",#7 N%+%$) @//3.

H) ')G !:(95+, ! -$%+-$/'/&)2%9>",#7 +%52%9>'#"2/ !-#9 '% !#:*') "/23)@/5, ,#(+) '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$, -#93;/! -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, !<$)*%''#% ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%,

(#2#! -#93;/2> +#9( #2 +#9*'/,) ! $#""/7",/? $3895?4 9/8# -$/#8$%2)%2 -$)!#

§ 5. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, ';%$>&++"=" ' ,+"#7%$++"/ '$-U7&

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

.)""&)2$/!)5 "-#$, #+/' /: )$8/2$)*'<? "3+#! 3,):)9 ') 2#, ;2# «!)9=2'#7

#-%$)@/%7 '%#8?#+/ ";/2)2> $)";%2< ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%, '# '% "+%9,3, -#"93*/!G3= #"'#!)'/%& +95 /? "#!%$G%'/5. D "9%+#!)2%9>'#, -#93;%'/% $):$%G%'/5 R%'2$)9>'#(# 8)',) .#""/7",#7 N%+%$)@// ') #"36%"2!9%'/% 2),#7 !)9=2'#7 #-%$)@// '%#8?#+/ +95 /"-#9'%'/5 +%'%*'# (# #85:)2%9>"2!) ! -#9>:3 9/@), ,#2#$#&3 3"23-)%2"5 2$%8#!) '/%, -$/ 3"9#!// #"36%"2!9%'/5 2),/? !<-9)2 !

/'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%»1.

T')9/: -#9#*%'/7 '#!#(# N%+%$)9>'#(# :),#') #2 10 +% ,)8$5 2003 (. No 173-NP «Q

!)9=2'#& $%(39/$#!)'// / !)9=2 '#& ,#'2$#9%»2 -#:!#95%2 "+%9)2> !<!#+ # 2#&, ;2# -$)!# 2$%8# !)'/5, !<$)*%''#(# ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%, '% *%2 8<2> #2'% "%'# '/ , /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2%, '/ , !'%G'/& @%''<& 83&)()&, -#I2#&3 #'# '% 5!95%2"5 !)9=2'#7 @%''#"2>= (-. 5 ;. 1 "2. 1 P) ,#')), ) 3"23-,) 2),#(# -$)!) '% 5!95%2"5 !)9=2'#7 #-%$)@/%7 (-. 9 ;. 1 "2. 1 P),#')), -#",#9>,3 -%$%;%'> 2),/? #-%$)@/7 5!95 %2"5 :),$<2<&.

!"+,.("051('1 NM= =101/"-S.-.A("F" "&/$F. ", 5 6./,. 2001 F. No M13-1191/00- 04 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(, !5O+»).

="2/.('1 L.&"("A.,15D+,0. >N. 2003. No 50. =,. 4859.

U U U U

'=6.: J-/1A151('1 8"(+,',$C'"(("F" =$A. >N ", 4 6./,. 1999 F. No 50-J (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

2 !"+,.("051('1 8"(+,',$C'"(("F" =$A. >N ", 30 'O53 2001 F. No 13-! (<!= « 8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+ »).

1 =6.: J2"2K1('1 -/.&,'&' -/'61(1('3 ("/6.,'0(4X .&,"0 [1(,/.5D("F" 2.(&. >N -" 0"-/"+.6 0.5O,("F" /1F$5'/"0.('3 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

4 <61((" ,.&.3 +',$.C'3 ",/.H1(. 0 -"+,.("051('' !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2', /.H("F" =$A. >N ", 29 "&,32/3 2002 F. No 4554/02 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

90

91

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

§ 6. *=G*!8M !>M)M G>:9J)M;<Q <S 8>:7<G;JUJ 7JUJ)J>M

4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 819 KA .N -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3 8)', /9/ /')5 ,$%+/2')5

#$()'/:)@/5 (,$%+/2#$) #85:3=2"5 -$%+#"2)!/2> +%'%*'<% "$%+"2!) (,$%+/2) :)%&6/,3 ! $):&%$% / ') 3"9#!/5?, -$%+3"$%''<? +#(#!#$#&, ) :)%&6/, #85:3%2"5 !#:!$)2/2> -#93;%''3= +%'%*'3= "3&&3 / 3-9)2/2> -$#@%'2< ') '%%.

Q+'#7 /: -$#89%&, #8"3*+)%&<? ! =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23 $%, 5!95%2"5 !#-$#" # !#:*'#"2/ 3"23-,/ 8)',#& (/'#7 ,$% +/2'#7 #$()'/:)@/%7) "!#%(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , :)%&6/,3 -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3. 4"% $)""3*+%'/5 "2$#52"5 ! #"'#!'#& !#,$3( +!3? "/23)@/7: *%2 9/ 8)', (/')5 ,$%+/2')5 #$()'/:) @/5) -%$%+)2> "!#/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3

!##86%; %"9/ *%2, 2# 2),)5 3"23-,) !#:*') 2#9>,# +$3(#&3 8)',3 (/'#7 ,$%+/2'#7 #$()'/:)@//) /9/ 9=8#&3 2$%2>%&3 9/@3.

S),, '%,#2#$#% !$%&5 '):)+ -$/ $):$%G%'// "-#$#!, "!5:)' '<? "# !:<",)'/%& @%""/#')$/%& " :)%&6/,) :)+#9*%''#"2/ -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3, "9#*/9#"> "9%+3=6%% &'%'/%.

4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 819 KA .N ,$%+/2#$#& -# #85:)2%9> "2!3, !#:'/,G%&3 /: ,$%+/2'#(# +#(#!#$), *%2 !<"23-)2> 2#9>,# 8)', /9/ /')5 ,$%+/2')5 #$()'/:)@/5. 4 "!5:/ " 2%&, ;2# , "38M%,2'#&3 "#"2)!3 ,$%+/2'#(# +#(#!#$) :),#'#& 3"2)'#!9% '< "-%@/)9>'<% 2$%8#!)'/5, 3"23-,) -$)! ! #2'#G%'// +#9* '/,) -# 2),#&3 +#(#!#$3 *%2 8<2> -$#/:!%+%') 2#9>,# ! -#9>:3 "##2!%2"2!3=6/? "-%@/)9/:/$#!)''<? =$/+/;%",/? 9/@ (8)',#!, /'<? ,$%+/2'<? #$()'/:)@/7). O"23-,) 8)',)&/

-$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , :)%&6/,3 -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3 ! -#9>:3 =$/+/;%",/? 9/@, ,#2#$<% '% 5!95=2"5 8)',)&/ /9/ /'<&/ ,$%+/2'<&/ #$()'/:)@/5&/, '% +#-3",)%2"5, -#",#9>,3 ! "/93 -. 1 "2. 388 KA .N 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(# &3 9/@3 +#-3",)%2"5, %"9/ #') '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 :),#'3, /'<& -$)!#!<& ),2)& /9/ +#(#!#$3.

§ 6. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,: ,L .%&?,7+"=" ?"="'"%$

.)""&)2$/!)5 "-#$<, )$8/2$)*'<% "3+< -$/?#+/9/ , !<!# +3 # '/;2#*'#"2/ +#(#!#$) @%""//, -#",#9>,3, -# &'%'/= "3 +#!, 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 /: ,$%+/2'#(# +#(#!#$) '% "##2 !%2"2!3%2 -#9#*%'/5& "2. 1, 5 / 11 N%+%$)9>'#(# :),#') «Q 8)',)? / 8)',#!",#7 +%52%9>'#"2/». 1#(9)"'# +)''#&3 P),#'3 ,$%+/2')5 +%52%9>'#"2> 5!95%2"5 8)',#!",#7 #-%$)@/%7, / -# I2#&3 '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$ +#9*%'

8<2> ,$%+/2'#7 #$()'/:)@/%7 / /&%2> "##2!%2"2!3=63= 9/@%':/=1.

B%7"2!/2%9>'#, ') -%$!<7 !:(95+ 9#(/,) +)''<? $)""3*+% '/7 !-#9'% -#'52'). O"23-,) -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 5!95%2"5 ;)"2'<& "93;)%& -%$%&%'< 9/@) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%.

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

D&%''# 2),)5 -#:/@/5 :),$%-9%') ! "#!$%&%''#7 "3+%8'#7 -$),2/,%. S),, -# #+'#&3 /: $)""$%''<? C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N +%9 -$%+&%2#& /:3;%'/5 8<9) 3"23-,) #+'/& 8)',#& "!#%(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , :)%&6/,3 -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3 +$3(#&3 8)',3. O;/2<!)5, ;2# ! +)''#& "93;)% -$)!#&%$'#"2> @%""// '% "2)!/9)"> -#+ "#&'%'/% / "-#$ 8<9 $):$%G%' -# "36%"2!3, *'# "+%9)2> !<!#+: !<"G/7 "3-

1 =6., (.-/'61/, -"+,.("051('3 NM= ?"+&"0+&"F" "&/$F. ", 6 3(0./3 1999 F. No

8U-M40/3379-98, ", 13 3(0./3 2000 F. No 8U-M40/4487-99; NM= =101/"- S.-.A("F" "&/$F. ", 2 ("32/3 1999 F. No M56-3228/99; NM= !"0"5H+&"F" "&/$F. ", 17-18 E10/.53 2000 F. No M 65-6100/99-=U1-17 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

93

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

+%8'<7 #$()' '% !/+/2 '/,),/? -$%-52"2!/7 +95 3,):)''#7 !< G% 3"23-,/1.

4#-$#" *% # !#:*'#7 3"23-,% 8)',#& -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# ,$%+/2'#&3 +#(#!#$3 /'#&3 9/@3 ('% 5!95=6%&3"5 8)',#& 9/8# /'#7 ,$%+/2'#7 #$()'/:)@/%7) #"2)%2"5 #2,$<2<&, / +95 %(# $):$%G%'/5 "+%9)%& '%8#9>G#7 /"2#$/;%",/7 I,",3$".

4 ,#&&%'2)$// , "2. 1679 C$#%,2) K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5, ! ,#2#$#7 3"2)'#!9%'# #86%% -$)!/9# # -$)!% !%$/2%95 8%: "# (9)"/5 +#9*'/,) 3"23-/2> -$/')+9%*)6%% %&3 2$%8#!)'/% +$3 (#&3 9/@3, 8<9# 3,):)'#: «C$#%,2 ')?#+/2 /:9/G'/& #"#8# 3-#&/')2> # 2#&, ;2# 3"23-,% -#+9%*)2 !"5,/% 2$%8#!)'/5 '% :)!/"/ #2 /? /"2#;'/,) (!<+%9%'# &'#7. - 2.3.), /8# I2# 5!"2!3%2 /: &%"2), :)'/&)%(# "2. 1679 ! $5+3 #86/? -$)!/9 #8 #85:)2%9>"2!)? -# +#(#!#$)&, / #2"32"2!/5 ! '%7 #(#!#$,/ #8

#($)'/;%'// %% +%7"2!/5 /:!%"2'<&/ 2#9>,# #85:)2%9>"2!)&/»2. S),/% #($)'/;%'/5 3"2)')!9/!)9/">, ')-$/&%$, "2. 1680 C$#%, 2) K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$#7 '% -#+9% *)2 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5, '%$):$<!'# "!5:)''<% " 9/;'#"2>= !%$/2%95, /9/ 2),/%, ! ,#2#$<? 9/;'#"2> !%$/2%95 /&%%2 "36% "2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,), ) 2),*% 2$%8#!)'/5, ') ,#2# $<% -# :),#'3 '% *%2 8<2> #8$)6%'# !:<",)'/%.

«C# #86%&3 -$)!/93, @%""/5 !#:*') +95 !"%? #85:) 2%9>"2!, 2), ,), -#;2/ !"% #'/

-$%+"2)!95=2 /: "%85 8%:9/;'<% /&36%"2!%''<% 2$%8#!)'/5»3, - -/")9 D.H. S$%-/@<'. D +)9%% ! "!#%7 $)8#2% 3,):<!)9 ') /",9=;%'/5 /: I2#(# -$)!/9), -%$% ;%'> ,#2#$<? -#;2/ -#9'#"2>= "#!-)+)%2 " -%$%;/"9%''<&/ ! "2. 1680 C$#%,2) K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5 #($)'/;%'/5&/. C$/

1=6. -"+,.("051('1 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 5 .0F$ +,. 1997 F. No 2422/97 ()1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 1997. No 12. =. 54).

2U/.HA.(+&"1 *5"H1('1. !/"1&, )4+"#.%I1 $#/1HA1(("% >1A.&C'"(("% 8"6'++'' -" +"+,.051('O U/.HA.(+&"F" *5"H1('3 / !"A /1A. <.?. GO,/O-

§ 6. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,: ,L .%&?,7+"=" ?"="'"%$

>2#& '%#8?#+/ #2&%2/2>, ;2# !"% I2/ /",9=;%'/5 (#($)'/;% '/5) "!5:)'< " 9/;'#"2>= ,$%+/2#$).