Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

"2'#"2/ -#:!#95%2 -$/72/ , )')9#(/;'#&3 !<!#+3: !"5,#% #85 :)2%9>"2!%''#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 *%2 8<2> 3"23-9%'# ,$%+/ 2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 - I2# #86%% -$)!/9#, '%+#-3"2/"2> 3" 23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ! "/93 -$/$#+< (?)$),2%$), "36'#"2/)

+)''#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 9/8# ! "/93 -$5(# :)-$%6%'/5 :) ,#'#& - I2# /",9=;%'/%.

P),#' "#+%$*/2 "9%+3=6/% #($)'/;%'/5 / 3"9#!/5 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

C%$!#%. H% +#-3",)%2"5 -%$%?#+ , +$3(#&3 9/@3 -$)!, '% $):$<!'# "!5:)''<? " 9/;'#"2>= ,$%+/2#$), ! ;)"2'#"2/ 2$%8# !)'/7 #8 )9/&%'2)? / # !#:&%6%'// !$%+), -$/;/'%''#(# */:'/ /9/ :+#$#!>= ("2. 383 KA .N).

H%"#89=+%'/% -$%+-/")'/7 +)''#7 '#$&< !9%;%2 '/;2#* '#"2> "#(9)G%'/5 #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

42#$#%. 1#(9)"'# -. 1 "2. 388 KA .N 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 '% +#-3",)%2"5, %"9/ #') -$#2/!#$% ;/2 :),#'3 /9/ /'<& -$)!#!<& ),2)&.

T')9/: -#9#*%'/7 K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .N -#:!#95%2 #8 ')$3*/2> $5+ 3"2)'#!9%''<? :),#'#& #($)'/;%'/7 3"23-,/ 2# (# /9/ /'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

H)-$/&%$, ! "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 372 KA .N -$/')+9%*)6%% 8%'%E/@/)$3 -# 8)',#!",#7 ()$)'2// -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , ()$)' 23 '% *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# +$3(#&3 9/@3, %"9/ ! ()$)'2// '% -$%+3"$%'# /'#%. B)'')5 '#$&) 5!95%2"5 +/"-#:/2/!'#7 («%"9/ ! ()$)'2// '% -$%+3"$%'# /'#%»), -#I2#&3 "2#$#'< "!#/& "#(9)G%'/%& !-$)!% 3"2)'#!/2> !#:*'#"2> -%$%+);/ +$3(#&3 9/@3 -$/')+9%*)6%(# 8%'%E/@/)$3 -# 8)',#!",#7 () $)'2// -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , ()$)'23, '# %"9/ "2#$#'< I2/& -$) !#& '% !#"-#9>:3=2"5, 2# 83+%2 +%7"2!#!)2> :)-$%2 ') 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, 3"2)'#!9%''<7 "2. 372 KA .N.

-/.0.. 1891. No 2 . =. 79.

38

39

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

4 "2. 355 KA .N («O"23-,) -$)! -# +#(#!#$3 # :)9#(%») "# +%$*/2"5 %6% #+'# #($)'/;%'/% ') 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. 1#(9)"'# +)''#7 '#$&% 3"23-,) :)9#(#+%$*)2%9%& "!#/? -$)! -# +#(#!#$3 # :)9#(% +$3(#&3 9/@3 +%7"2!/2%9>'), %"9/ 2#&3 *% 9/@3 3"23-9%'< -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3 -# #"'#!'#&3 #85:)2%9>"2!3, #8%"-%;%''#&3 :)9#(#&.

J"9/ 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 -$#2/ !#$%;/2 :),#'3 /9/ /'<& -$)!#!<& ),2)& (-. 1 "2. 388 KA .N), 2# 2),#% "#(9)G%'/% #8 3"23-,% 5!95%2"5

'/;2#*'<& /, "9%+# !)2%9>'#, -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) , '# !#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 '% -%$%?#+/2.

S $ % 2 > % . 4 "##2!%2"2!// " -#9#*%'/5&/ 2#(# *% -. 1 "2. 388 KA .N 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 +#-3",) %2"5, %"9/ #') '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 +#(#!#$3.

.%;> ! +)''#7 '#$&% /+%2 # +#(#!#$%, :),9=;%''#& &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / +#9*'/,#&. 4 2),#& +#(#!#$% "2#$#'< ! "##2!%2"2!// " #+'/& /: #"'#!#-#9)()=6/? -$/'@/ -#! ($)*+)'",#(# -$)!) - -$/'@/-#& "!#8#+< +#(#!#$) - !-$) !% 3"2)'#!/2> :)-$%2 ') 3"23-,3 +$3(#&3 9/@3 2$%8#!)'/7, !< 2%,)=6/? /: +#(#!#$).

Q+'),# /: +)''#(# -$)!/9) "36%"2!3=2 /",9=;%'/5.

4 "##2!%2"2!// " -#9#*%'/5&/ "2. 993 KA .N, $%(39/$3= 6%7 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%/"-#9'%'/% "+%9,/, :),9=;%''#7 ,# &/""/#'%$#& +95 ,#&/2%'2), ! "93;)% '%/"-#9'%'/5 2$%2>/& 9/@#& "+%9,/, :),9=;%''#7 " '/& ,#&/""/#'%$#&, ,#&/""/#'%$ #85:)' '%&%+9%''# "##86/2> #8 I2#& ,#&/2%'23, "#8$)2> '%#8 ?#+/&<% +#,):)2%9>"2!), ) 2),*% -# 2$%8#!)'/= ,#&/2%'2) -% $%+)2> %&3 -$)!) -# 2),#7 "+%9,% " "#89=+%'/%& -$)!/9 #8 3" 23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 ("2. 382-386, 388 / 389 KA .N).

«C%$%+)2> -$)!) -# "+%9,% " "#89=+%'/%& -$)!/9 #8 3"23- ,% 2$%8#!)'/5» #:');)%2, ;2# ,#&/""/#'%$ / ,#&/2%'2 +#9*'< :),9=;/2> "#(9)G%'/% #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, ! 2#& ;/"9% / " "#89=+%'/%& 3"9#!/7, -$%+3"$%''<? "2. 388 KA .N. C# ",#9>,3 "#(9)"'# +)''#7 "2)2>% 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 +#-3",)%2"5, %"9/ #') '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 +#(#!#$3,

§ 1. 2"L<">+"#7M 5#758., .$. #'"/#7'" #59T&.7,'+"=" "9:L$7&-M#7'&++"=" 8%$'$

) ! +#(#!#$%, :),9=;%''#& &%*+3 ,#&/""/#'%$#& / 2$%2>/& 9/ @#&, *%2 8<2> 3"2)'#!9%' :)-$%2 ') 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!) '/5 +$3(#&3 9/@3, 2# ! -. 3 "2. 993 KA .N "-%@/)9>'# 3,):<!) %2"5 ') 2#, ;2# 3"23-,) -$)! ,#&/2%'23 -# "+%9,% +#-3",)%2"5 '%:)!/"/ #2 "#(9)G%'/5 ,#&/""/#'%$) " 2$%2>/& 9/@#&, :) -$%6)=6%(# /9/ #($)'/;/!)=6%(# 2),3= 3"23-,3. ]2# '% #" !#8#*+)%2 ,#&/""/#'%$) #2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ -%$%+ 2$%2>/& 9/ @#& ! "!5:/ " 3"23-,#7 -$)!) ! ')$3G%'/% "#(9)G%'/5 # %% :) -$%2% /9/ #8 #($)'/;%'//.

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

J6% $): -#+;%$,'%&: -#9#*%'/5 "2. 828 / 993 KA .N 5!95 =2"5 /",9=;%'/%& /: #86%(# -$)!/9), 3"2)'#!9%''#(# -. 1 "2. 388 KA .N.

J"9/ 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 -$#2/ !#$%;/2 +#(#!#$3 (-. 1 "2. 388 KA .N), 2# 2),#% "#(9)G%'/% #8 3"23-,% 5!95%2"5 '/;2#*'<& /, "9%+#!)2%9>'#, -$)!# 2$%8#!) '/5 #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) , '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 '% -%$% ?#+/2.

^%2!%$2#%. 4 "##2!%2"2!// " -. 2 "2. 388 KA .N '% +#-3",) %2"5 8%: "#(9)"/5 +#9*'/,) 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2 !3, ! ,#2#$#&19/;'#"2> ,$%+/2#$) /&%%2

"36%"2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,) .

' J -/"2516.X, +03L.((4X + 5'#("+,DO &/1A',"/., '61OK1% +$K1+,01(("1 L(.#1('1 A53 A"5H('&., 2$A1, +&.L.(" ('H1.

41

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

H%#8?#+/ #8$)2/2> !'/&)'/% ') 2#, ;2# :),#'#& '% 3"2) '#!9%' :)-$%2 ') 3"23-,3 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2!3, ! ,#2# $#& 9/;'#"2> ,$%+/2#$) /&%%2 "36%"2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,). S# #8"2#52%9>"2!#, ;2# 9/;'#"2> ,$%+/2#$) /&%%2 "36%"2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,), ") -# "%8% '% 5!95%2"5

#($)'/;%'/%& +95 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5. S),#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 "9%+3%2 -$/:')2> "-#"#8'<& , @%+/$#!)'/=, '# 3"23-,) 83+%2 ";/2)2>"5 +%7"2!/2%9>'#7 /, "9%+#!)2%9>'#, -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 -%$%7+%2 #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) , '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 2#9>,# -$/ ')9/;// "#(9)"/5 +#9*'/,) ') 2),3= 3"23-,3, ?#25,

-# #86%&3 -$)!/93, +95 -%$%?#+) , +$3(#&3 9/@3 -$)! ,$%+/2# $) '% 2$%83%2"5 "#(9)"/% +#9*'/,) (-. 2 "2. 382 KA .N).

Q -$#89%&)? / !#-$#")?, !#:'/,)=6/? -$/ 3"23-,% 2#(# /9/ /'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, / -#7+%2 $%;> +)9%%.

§ 2. *=G*!8M !>M)M G>:9J)M;<Q, )JS;<8V:UJ <S 7)*=GJ>J;;: J9QS_)M@`:UJ 7JUJ)J>M

Q+'#7 /: (9)!'<? -$#89%&, "!5:)''<? " /'"2/232#& 3"23- ,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, 5!95%2"5 -$#89%&) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!) '/5 /: 2), '):<!)%&<? +!3"2#$#''% #85:<!)=6/? +#(#!#$#!. .%;> /+%2 # +#(#!#$%, -# ,#2#$#&3 ,)*+)5 /: "2#$#' I2#(# +#(# !#$) '%"%2 #85:)''#"2/ ! -#9>:3 +$3(#7 "2#$#'< / ";/2)%2"5 +#9*'/,#& +$3(#7 "2#$#'< ! 2#&, ;2# #85:)') "+%9)2> ! %%

-#9>:3, / #+'#!$%&%''# %% ,$%+/2#$#& ! 2#&, ;2# /&%%2 -$)!# #2 '%% 2$%8#!)2>1 (,3-95--$#+)*), -#"2)!,), -#+$5+, )$%'+), !#:-

' ) O/'A'#1+&"% 5',1/.,$/1 I'/"&"1 /.+-/"+,/.(1('1 -"5$#'5 A/$F"% ,1/ 6'( - «A0$+,"/"(('% A"F"0"/», "A(.&", (. (.I 0LF53A, ,.&"% ,1/6'( 30531, +3 (1 +"0+16 $A.#(46. !"+&"5D&$ A"F"0"/"6 -/'L(.1,+3 +"F5.I1('1 A0$X '5' (1+&"5D&'X 5'C, ," +,"/"(.6' A"F"0"/. 6"F$, 24,D A0. 5'C. '5' (1 +&"5D&" 5'C. JA("+,"/"(('X A"F"0"/"0 (1 +$K1+,0$1, 0 -/'(C'-1 (0 A"F"0" /1 (1 6"H1, 24,D ,"5D&" "A("% +,"/"(4), . A0$+,"/"(('1 A"F"0"/4 6"F$, 24,D ' "A("+,"/"((1 "23L40.OK'6' (L.16, A./1('1), ' A0$+,"/"((1 "23L4

0.OK'6'. )"L6"H(", ,1/6'( (1+&"5D&" «F/"6"LA&'%», (" + O/'A'#1+&"%

42

§ 2. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, '"L+,.K&=" ,L ?'5#7"%"++& "9:L;'$UR&=" ?"="'"%$

&%:+'#% #,):)'/% 3"93( / 2.+.), 2.%. # 2#& +#(#!#$%, ,#2#$<7 ')/8#9%% $)"-$#"2$)'%' ! ($)*+)'",#& #8#$#2%, ) ! -$%+-$/'/ &)2%9>",#7 +%52%9>'#"2/ /&%%2, *'# ",):)2>, (9)!%'"2!3= 6%% -#9#*%'/%.

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

C$#89%&) !#:*'#"2/ ('%!#:*'#"2/) 2),#7 3"23-,/ !< "!%2/9)"> -$/ $%G%'// "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " 3"23-,#7 -$)!) 2$% 8#!)'/5 /: 2), '):<!)%&<? +956/?"5 #85:)2%9>"2!. H)3,) ($)* +)'",#(# -$)!) '% :')%2 2),#(# -#'52/5, ,), «+956%%"5 #85:) 2%9>"2!#»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

,"#&' L/1('3 «A0$+,"/"((1 "23L40.OK'% A"F"0"/», (. (.I 0LF53A, (.'2"511 ,"#(" ",/.H.1, X./.&,1/ ",("I1('% 61HA$ +,"/"(.6'.

43

U U U U

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

9%''#(# -%$/#+) !$%&%'/ (&%"5@, ,!)$2)9, -#9(#+), (#+, '% ",#9>,# 9%2) "#!%$G)2>

#-$%+%9%''<% +%7"2!/5 (-#"2)!952> 2# !)$, "')8*)2> I9%,2$#I'%$(/%7, ():#&, !#+#7, #,):<!)2> ,#&&3 ')9>'<% 3"93(/ / 2.+.), ) +$3()5 "2#$#') -# I2#&3 +#(#!#$3 - ! 3"2)'#!9%''<% +#(#!#$#& "$#,/ #-9);/!)2> -#93;%''#% 89)(#. S),/% #2'#G%'/5 '#"52 +956/7"5 ?)$),2%$.

.):$%G)5 "-#$<, )$8/2$)*'<% "3+< "2#9,'39/"> " "/23)@/ %7, ,#(+) 9/8# I'%$(#-, ():#-, !#+#"')8*)=6)5 #$()'/:)@/5, 9/ 8# #$()'/:)@/5, #,):<!)=6)5 ,#&&3')9>'<% 3"93(/, 3"23-)9) 2$%2>%&3 9/@3 "!#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , -#2$%8/2%9= #8 #-9)2% -#93;%''#7 I9%,2$#I'%$(// (():), !#+<) :) #-$%+%9%''<7 -%$/ #+, '# -$/ I2#& ') +)''#7 #$()'/:)@// "#?$)'59)"> #85:)''#"2> "')8*)2> -#2$%8/2%95 I9%,2$#I'%$(/%7 (():#&, !#+#7) ! -#"9% +3=6/% -%$/#+< !# !$%&5 +%7"2!/5 +#(#!#$). 4 "!5:/ " I2/&

!#:'/, !#-$#" # +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ 3"23-,/ #+'#7 /: "2#$#' +# (#!#$) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +$3(#7 "2#$#'% -$/ #+'#!$%&%''#& "#?$)'%'// "!#/? #85:)''#"2%7 -# +)''#&3 +#(#!#$3.

4 "!#% !$%&5 C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N !<$)8#2)9 "9%+3=63= -#:/@/=. C# &'%'/= C$%:/+/3&), 3,) :)'')5 !<G% @%""/5 5!95%2"5 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7, -#",#9>,3 '% +#-3",)%2"5 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2!3, !#: '/,G%&3 /: +#(#!#$), ,#2#$<7 -$#+#9*)%2 +%7"2!#!)2>. B)' '3= -#:/@/= ?#2%9#"> 8< -$#/99="2$/$#!)2> ') ,#',$%2'#& -$/&%$%.

Q"#8<7 /'2%$%" *%2 -$%+"2)!/2> -#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/ +/3&) 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N #2 10 "%'258$5 1996 (. No 1617/96', ! ,#2#$#& "3+ !<"G%7 /'"2)'@// "+%9)9 $5+ !<!# +#!, "36%"2!%''# -#!9/5!G/? ') -$),2/,3 -$/&%'%'/5 '#$&, $%(39/$3=6/? 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

1#(9)"'# &)2%$/)9)& +%9), &3'/@/-)9>'#% -$%+-$/52/% «K#$!#+#,)')9» (@%+%'2) 3"23-/9 D^C «12#9/@)» (@%""/#') $/7) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 +#9() #2 TQQS «P%7",)5 K]1», #"2)!)5">

' )1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 1996. No 11. =. 76.

44

§ 2. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, '"L+,.K&=" ,L ?'5#7"%"++& "9:L;'$UR&=" ?"="'"%$

-$/ I2#& "2#$#'#7 (/"-#9'/2%9%&) -# +#(#!#$3 #8 #,):)'// 3" 93( -#9>:#!)'/5 !#+#-$#!#+#& / ,)')9/:)@/%7.

B)'')5 "+%9,) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -$/:')') "3+#& '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 -# "9%+3=6/& #"'#!)'/5&.

4#--%$!<?, ,$%+/2#$, -%$%3"23-/!G/7 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, /: #85:)2%9>"2!) '% !<8<9. 0%*+3 2%&, "#(9)"'# § 1 (9. 24 KA .N, #2&%;)%2 C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N, 3" 23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 -$%+-#9)()%2 8%:3"9#!'3= :)&%'3 9/@) ! #85 :)2%9>"2!%.

D, !#-!2#$<?, -$)!/9) 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 '% (32 8<2> -$/&%'%'< -#2#&3, ;2# #85:)2%9>"2!#, '%/"-#9'%'/% ,#2#$#(# 5!/9#"> #"'#!)'/%& +95 :),9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, '#"/2 +956/7"5 ?)$),2%$. «4 '%& "#?$)'5%2"5 2#2 *% "#"2)! 9/@ (0C «K#$!#+#,)')9» - '#-#9/"2 -# #,):)'/= 3"93( -#9>:#!)'/5 !#+#-$#!#+#& / ,)')9/:)@/%7, / K]1, -#9> :3=6)5"5 I2/&/ 3"93()&/) / #"'#!)'/5 !#:'/,'#!%'/5 -$)!# #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 '/&/. C#",#9>,3 #"'#!'#% #85:)2%9>"2!# '% -$%,$)2/9#">, '% *%2 8<2> -$#/:!%+%') 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5 -# '%&3».

S),/& #8$):#&, "+%9)' !<!#+ # '%!#:*'#"2/ 3"23-,/ -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& #2+%9>'<? -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 8%: -%$%+);/ !"%? -$)! / #85:)''#"2%7 -# +#(#!#$3. 1##2!%2"2!%''# '% *%2 8<2> / $%;/ # "/'(395$'#& -$)!#-$%%&"2!% ! +!3"2# $#''%

#85:<!)=6%& +#(#!#$%1.

Q+#8$%'/% 2),#7 -#:/@// C$%:/+/3&) 4<"G%(# T$8/2 $)*'#(# 13+) .N *'# !"2$%2/2> / ! =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23$%. S),, -# &'%'/= Q. W#&/+:%, «%"9/ /'#% '% -$%+3"$%'#

:),#'#&, '%+#-3"2/&< -%$%+);) "2#$#'#7 #85:)2%9>"2!) -$/ ')+9%*)6%(# %7 -$)!) 8%: -%$%!#+) !#:9#*%''#7 ') '%% #85:)' -

1 M(.5"F'#(4% 040"A !/1L'A'$6 )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N +A15.5 -/' /.++6",/1('' A/$F'X A15, -/1A61,"6 +-"/. &","/4X 245. $+,$-&. -/.0. ,/1 2"0.('3, 0"L('&I1F" 'L A"F"0"/., &","/4% -/"A"5H.5 A1%+,0"0.,D. =6., (. -/'61/, -"+,.("051('3 ", 25 ("32/3 1997 F. No 2233/97; ", 18 'O53 1998 F. No 6677/97; ", 17 ("32/3 1998 F. No 4735/98; ", 30 6./,. 1999 F. No 6925/98 (<!=

«8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

'#"2/, $)!'# ,), / !<+%9%'/% "2#$#'#7 #85:)2%9>"2!) /: "#"2)!) -$/')+9%*)6%(# %7 -$)!) / -%$%+);) 2$%2>%&3 9/@3 #2+%9>'#(# -$)!#/5»'.

0.4. A$#2#!, $)""&)2$/!)5 -$#89%&3 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5 /: +!3"2#$#''% #85:<!)=6%(# +#(#!#$) 3,):<!)%2 ') 2#, ;2# ! 2),#& "93;)% «-%$%&%') 9/@ #:');)%2 /

3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$% 8#!)'/5, / -%$%!#+ +#9() #+'#!$%&%''#», ) -#",#9>,3 -%$%!#+ +#9() "#(9)"'# 2$%8#!)'/5& KA .N !#:*%' 2#9>,# " "#(9)"/5 ,$%+/2#$), 2# )!2#$ -$/?#+/2 , !<!#+3 # 2#&, ;2# «'%!#:*'# $):+%9/2> #85:)2%9>"2!# / 3"23-/2> 2#9>,# -$)!), "#?$)'/! :) "#8#7 #85:)''#"2/, $)!'# ,), '%!#:*'# "#!%$G/2> 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, -#93;/! #2$/@)2%9>'<7 #2!%2 +#9*'/,)...» .

C# &'%'/= S.W. W/-#!%@,#7, :)&%') #+'#7 "2#$#'< ! #85 :)2%9>"2!%, #"'#!)''#& ') +!3"2#$#''% #85:<!)=6%& (!:)/& '#&) +#(#!#$%, !#:*') 8%: "#(9)"/5 +$3(#7 "2#$#'<, «')-$/ &%$, %"9/ -#2%'@/)9>'<7 @%+%'2 (-#"2)!6/,) !<-#9'/2 -%$%+ ,#'2$)(%'2#& !"% #85:)''#"2/, !#:9#*%''<% ') '%(# +#(#!#$#& -#"2)!,/ (-%$%+)2> /&36%"2!# ! "#8"2!%''#"2> -#,3-)2%95 / +$.), #' *%2 -%$%+)2> -$/')+9%*)6%% %&3 ') #"'#!)'// +# (#!#$) -#"2)!,/ -$)!# 2$%8#!)2> #-9)23 -#2%'@/)9>'#&3 @%"

"/#')$/=»3.

H) ')G !:(95+, +95 2#(# ;2#8< $):#8$)2>"5 ! -$#89%&% 3" 23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 /: +!3"2#$#''% #85:<!)=6%(# +#(#!# $), '%#8?#+/ %6% $): #8$)2/2>"5 , -#9#*%'/5& (9. 24 KA .N, ,#2#$)5 $%(39/$3%2 #2'#G%'/5, "!5:)''<% " -%$%&%'#7 9/@ !

#85:)2%9>"2!%. Q ,),#& «#85:)2%9>"2!%» /+%2 $%;> ! +)''#7 (9) !%? D: ,),#(# #85:)2%9>"2!) ,$%+/2#$, 3"23-/!G/7 -$)!# 2$%8# !)'/5, +#9*%' '%-$%&%''# «!<8<!)2>»?

' O"<,?L& G. *+,$-&. -/.0. (C1++'3) // >"++'%+&.3 O+,'C'3. 1998. No 5. =. 17. !%"7"' 1.2. J (1&","/4X -/"2516.X -1/161(4 5'C 0 "23L.,15D+,01 // J#1/ &' -"

,"/F"0"6$ -/.0$: =2. (.$#. ,/$A"0 / !"A /1A. :.M. 8/.I1('(('&"0.. Q/"+5.05D, 1999. )4-. 6. =. 67-68.

3 O,8"'&B.$: S.O. ;1&","/41 0"-/"+4 /1F$5'/"0.('3 F/.HA.(+&'6 L.&"("A.

,15D+,0"6 A"F"0"/. E'(.(+'/"0.('3 -"A $+,$-&$ A1(1H("F" ,/12"0.('3 // M&,$.5D(41 -/"25164 F/.HA.(+&"F" -/.0. / !"A /1A. =.=.M51&+110.. ?., 2000. =. 278.

§ 2. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, '"L+,.K&=" ,L ?'5#7"%"++& "9:L;'$UR&=" ?"="'"%$

C#'52/% #85:)2%9>"2!) / #"'#!)'/5 %(# !#:'/,'#!%'/5 +) &< ! "2. 307 KA .N. 4 "##2!%2"2!// " -. 1 +)''#7 "2)2>/ ! "/93 #85:)2%9>"2!) #+'# 9/@# (+#9*'/,) #85:)'# "#!%$G/2> ! -#9>:3 +$3(#(# 9/@) (,$%+/2#$)) #-$%+%9%''#% +%7"2!/%, ,),-2#: -%$% +)2> /&36%"2!#, !<-#9'/2> $)8#23, 3-9)2/2> +%'>(/ / 2.-., 9/8# !#:+%$*)2>"5 #2

#-$%+%9%''#(# +%7"2!/5, ) ,$%+/2#$ /&%%2 -$) 0" 2$%8#!)2> #2 +#9*'/,) /"-#9'%'/5 %(# #85:)''#"2/.

C$)!3 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$) "##2!%2"2!3%2 +#9( +#9*'/,). J"9/ *% +#9*'/, /&%%2 "!#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , ,$%+/2#$3 (/&%''# 2),)5 "/23)@/5 ",9)+<!)%2"5 ! +!3"2#$#''% #85:<!)= 6%& +#(#!#$%), 2# #' (+#9*'/,) 5!95%2"5 ,$%+/2#$#&, '# 3*% !

+$3(#& -$)!##2'#G%'//, +$3(#& #85:)2%9>"2!%. «Q85:)2%9>"2!# ,3-9/--$#+)*/» 9/8# «#85:)2%9>"2!# )$%'+<» '% "36%"2!3%2. A2# ! 2),/? «#85:)2%9>"2!)?» 5!95%2"5 ,$%+/2#$#&, ) ,2# +#9* '/,#&?

H) ')G !:(95+, "3+%8'<% #$()'< +#-3",)=2 "&%G%'/% -# '52/7 «#85:)2%9>"2!#» / «+#(#!#$». 4 ,),#7-2# &%$% I2#&3 «"-#"#8"2!3%2» / '):!)'/% ;)"2/ !2#$#7 K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%, +. .N - «Q2+%9>'<% !/+< #85:)2%9>"2!». Q+'),# "/"2%&)2/;% ",#% 2#9,#!)'/% !"%(# K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") -#:!#95%2, ,), -$%+"2)!95%2"5, -$/:')2> #2+%9>'<% !/+< #85:)2%9>"2!, -$%+3 "$%''<% ! ;)"2/ !2#$#7 A#+%,"), «#85:)2%9>"2!)&/ ! G/$# ,#& "&<"9%», " 2%& ;2# ,#',$%2'<% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$) , +#9*'/,3 ! $)&,)? #85:)2%9>"2!) ! G/$#,#& "&<"9% (32 $)""&)2$/!)2>"5 ,), «#85:)2%9>"2!) ! 3:,#& "&<"9%». Q85:) 2%9>"2!) ! G/$#,#& "&<"9% '%9>:5, #;%!/+'#, '):<!)2> «+#(# !#$)&/», -#2#&3 ;2# , -#"9%+'/& '/,), '% (32 8<2> #2'%"%'< #85:)2%9>"2!) !"9%+"2!/% -$/;/'%'/5 !$%+), #85:)2%9>"2!) !"9%+"2!/% '%#"'#!)2%9>'#(# #8#()6%'/5 / +$3(/% «'%+#(#!#$ '<% #85:)2%9>"2!)».

B#(#!#$ ,3-9/--$#+)*/ 5!95%2"5 #85:)2%9>"2!#& ! G/$# ,#& "&<"9%. Q85:)''#"2> -$#+)!@) (+#9*'/,) -%$%+)2> !%6> ( 2!)$) ! "#8"2!%''#"2> -#,3-)2%9= (,$%+/2#$) - I2# #85:)2%9>- 11 !# ! 3:,#& "&<"9%. Q85:)''#"2> -#,3-)2%95 (+#9*'/,) -$/ '52> 2#!)$ / 3-9)2/2> :) '%(# -$#+)!@3 (,$%+/2#$) #-$%+%9%'-

47

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

'3= +%'%*'3= "3&&3 (@%'3) - I2# +$3(#% #85:)2%9>"2!# ! 3:,#& "&<"9%.

B#(#!#$ )$%'+< 5!95%2"5 #85:)2%9>"2!#& ! G/$#,#& "&<" 9%. Q85:)''#"2/ )$%'+#+)2%95 (+#9*'/,) -$%+#"2)!/2> /&36% "2!# )$%'+)2#$3 (,$%+/2#$) ! "#"2#5'//, "##2!%2"2!3=6%& 3" 9#!/5& +#(#!#$) )$%'+< / '):');%'/= /&36%"2!); -$#/:!#+/2> :) "!#7 ";%2 ,)-/2)9>'<7 $%'2 -%$%+)''#(# ! )$%'+3 /&36% "2!) - I2# #85:)2%9>"2!) ! 3:,#& "&<"9%. Q85:)''#"2/ )$%'+)2# $) (+#9*'/,) "!#%!$%&%''# !'#"/2> )$%'+#+)2%9= (,$%+/2#$)

)$%'+'3= -9)23 :) -#9>:#!)'/% /&36%"2!#&; -#9>:#!)2>"5 I2/& /&36%"2!#& ! "##2!%2"2!// " %(# '):');%'/%&; -$#/:!#+/2> :) "!#7 ";%2 2%,36/7 $%'2 - I2# 2),*% #85:)2%9>"2!) ! 3:,#& "&<"9%.

4 +#(#!#$% ,3-9/--$#+)*/ ()$%'+<, I'%$(#"')8*%'/5, -#+ $5+), !#:&%:+'#(# #,):)'/5 3"93( / 2.+.) '%2 ,$%+/2#$) / +#9* '/,), ) %"2> ,$%+/2#$ / +#9*'/, ! ,)*+#& ,#',$%2'#& #85:) 2%9>"2!%.

C$%+"2)!95%2"5, ;2# ! -#+$):+. I «Q86/% -#9#*%'/5 #8 #85 :)2%9>"2!)?» $):+. III «Q86)5 ;)"2> #85:)2%9>"2!%''#(# -$)!)» K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .N ((+% ')?#+/2"5 (9. 24) $%;> /+%2 /&%''# #8 #85:)2%9>"2!)? ! 3:,#& "&<"9%, / I2# -#+2!%$*+)%2"5 "9%+3=6/&/ -$/&%$)&/.

4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 329 KA .N /"-#9'%'/% #85:)2%9>"2! *%2 #8%"-%;/!)2>"5 '%3"2#7,#7, :)9#(#&, 3+%$*)'/%& /&3 6%"2!) +#9*'/,), -#$3;/2%9>"2!#&, 8)',#!",#7 ()$)'2/%7, :) +)2,#& / +$3(/&/ "-#"#8)&/, -$%+3"$%''<&/ :),#'#& /9/ +#(#!#$#&. A),#% «#85:)2%9>"2!#» :+%"> 3-#&/')%2"5? C$%+"2) !/& "%8% "/23)@/=, ,#(+) -#,3-)2%9> -$%+#"2)!95%2 -$#+)!@3

8)',#!",3= ()$)'2/= / #+'#!$%&%''# 2$%83%2 #2 -$#+)!@) :) ,9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) :)9#(), +)8< -$%+3-$%+/2> !#:*'<% 38<2,/ ! "93;)% '%/"-#9'%'/5 -#"9%+'/& "!#/? #85:)''#"2%7. C#'52'#, ;2# ! +)''#& "93;)% 8)',#!",)5 ()$)'2/5 #8%"-%;/!) %2 #85:)2%9>"2!# -#,3-)2%95, ) :)9#( - #85:)2%9>"2!# -$#+)!@). D 2)&, / 2)& $%;> /+%2 #8 #8%"-%;%'// /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2 !) ! 3:,#& "&<"9%, ) '% #8 #8%"-%;%'// /"-#9'%'/5 +#(#!#$).

48

§ 2. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, '"L+,.K&=" ,L ?'5#7"%"++& "9:L;'$UR&=" ?"="'"%$

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

12)2>5 328 KA .N $%(39/$3%2 #2'#G%'/5, "!5:)''<% "# !"2$%;'<& /"-#9'%'/%& #85:)2%9>"2! () '% +#(#!#$#!): ')-$/ &%$, -#,3-)2%9> (+#9*'/, -# #85:)2%9>"2!3

#-9)2/2> 2#!)$) !-$)!% '% /"-#9'52> "!#= #85:)''#"2> +# 2%? -#$, -#,) -$#+) !%@ (+#9*'/, -# #85:)2%9>"2!3 -#"2)!/2> 2#!)$) '% /"-#9'/2 "!#=.

H),#'%@, %6% #+/' -$/&%$.

A), 3*% 8<9# ",):)'# !<G%, "#(9)"'# "2. 382 KA .N 3"23- ,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 5!95%2"5 #+'/& /: +!3? !/+#! -%$%&%'< ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%. 42#$<& 2),/& !/+#& 5!95%2"5 -%$% ?#+ -$)! ,$%+/2#$) ! "93;)5?, 3"2)'#!9%''<? :),#'#&. C%$% ;%'> 2),/? "93;)%! (,#2#$<7 '% 5!95%2"5 /";%$-<!)=6/&) 3"

2)'#!9%' "2. 387 KA .N. B$3(/% "2)2>/ K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") ,#',$%2/:/$3=2 2% "/23)@//, # ,#2#$<? /+%2 $%;> ! '):!)''#7 "2)2>%.

S),, ') #"'#!)'// :),#') -$)!) ,$%+/2#$) -# #85:)2%9>"2!3 -%$%?#+52 , +$3(#&3 9/@3 !"9%+"2!/% /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!) +#9*'/,) %(# -#$3;/2%9%& ("2. 365 / 387 KA

.N)1.

)-/"#16, (1+6",/3 (. ,", #," L.&"( -/36" $&.L40.1, '61((" (. -1/1X"A & -"/$#',15O -/.0 &/1A',"/., (1&","/41 ./2',/.H(41 +$A4 ",&/"01((" 'F(" /'/$O, -"5"H1('3 +,. 365 ' 387 U8 >N. G.&, 0 "A("6 'L +$A12(4X .&,"0 $&. L.(" +51A$OK11: «<+-"5(1('1 -"/$#',1516 "21+-1#1(("F" -"/$#',15D+,0"6 "23L.,15D+,0. &/1A',"/$ -/1&/.K.1, "23L.,15D+,0" A"5H('&. -1/1A &/1A',"-

U U U

U

O C#;37,/' 4 4. 49

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

4 "/93 "2. 365 KA .N , -#$3;/2%9=, /"-#9'/!G%&3 #85:) 2%9>"2!#, -%$%?#+52 -$)!) ,$%+/2#$) 8" D7"<5 "9:L$7&-M#7'5 / -$)!), -$/')+9%*)!G/% ,$%+/2#$3 ,), :)9#(#+%$*)2%9=, ! 2#& #8M%&%, ! ,#2#$#& -#$3;/2%9> 3+#!9%2!#$/9 2$%8#!)'/% ,$%+/ 2#$). Q ,),#& «#85:)2%9>"2!%» ! +)''#& "93;)% /+%2 $%;>? B3 &)%2"5, ;2# /&%%2"5 ! !/+3 !"% 2# *% #85:)2%9>"2!# ! 3:,#& "&<"9%.

§ 2. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:, '"L+,.K&=" ^ X

X ,L ?'5#7"%"++& "9:L;'$UR&=" ?"="'"%$

&3 ,$%+/2#$3 (') -$/&%$% "2. 365) -#:!#95%2 (#!#$/2> #8 #85:) 2%9>"2!% ! 3:,#& "&<"9%, ) '% # +#(#!#$%, 2# '%2 '/,),/? #"'# !)'/7 3"2)')!9/!)2> #"#8<7 -#$5+#, -%$%&%'< ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% ') #"'#!)'// "#(9)G%'/5.

B%9%'/% #85:)2%9>"2! ') #85:)2%9>"2!) ! G/$#,#& "&<"9% / ') ,#',$%2'<% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 (#85:)2%9>"2!# ! 3:,#& "&<"9%) -$/:')%2"5 ! 9/2%$)23$%, ! 2#& ;/"9% $#""/7",#7 +#$%!#9=@/

C$%+"2)!/& "/23)@/=, ,#(+) -#$3;/2%9> #85:<!)%2"5 #2!% #''#7.

;)2> :) )$%'+)2#$) ! ;)"2/ !'%"%'/5 -#"9%+'/& )$%'+'#7 -9)2<. B#-3"2/&, '%$)+/!<7 )$%'+)2#$ '% 2#9>,# "!#%!$%&%''# '% !'%" )$%'+'3= -9)23 :)

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