Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

&'%'/= "3+), -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 !#:&%6%'/5 38<2,#! ! "!5:/ " -$/;/'% '/%& !$%+) !#:'/,9# 3 @%+%'2) '% /: +#(#!#$'#(# #85:)2%9>"2!), ) /: -$)!) "#8"2!%''#"2/, -#I2#&3 " 2$%8#!)'/%& # !#:&%6%'// 38<2,#! *%2 #8$)6)2>"5 2#9>,# ")& "#8"2!%''/, +%'2/$# !)''#(# "2$#%'/5, +)''#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 '% *%2 -%$%+) !)2>"5 +$3(#&3 9/@3.

H% "#(9)G)5"> " !<!#+#& # '/;2#*'#"2/ +#(#!#$) @%""//, C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N "#"9)9"5 ') -#9# *%'/5 "2. 307 KA .N, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$#7 #85:)2%9>"2!) !#:'/,)=2 /: +#(#!#$) !"9%+"2!/% -$/;/'%'/5 !$%+) / /: /'<? #"'#!)'/7, 3,):)''<? ! A#+%,"%. S),/& #8$):#&, -$/;/'%'/% !$%+) 5!95%2"5 #+'/& /: #"'#!)'/7 !#:'/,'#!%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!).

19%+#!)2%9>'#, -$)!# ') !#:&%6%'/% 38<2,#!, !#:'/,G/? ! $%:39>2)2% -$/;/'%'/5 !$%+), *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# +$3(#&3 9/@3 -# +#(#!#$3 @%""//1.

A), "9%+3%2 /: "2. 307 KA .N, #85:)2%9>"2!) !#:'/,)=2 '% 2#9>,# /: +#(#!#$) / !"9%+"2!/% -$/;/'%'/5 !$%+), '# / /: /'<? #"'#!)'/7, 3,):)''<? ! A#+%,"%.

=6. -"+,.("051('1 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 11 6.3 1999 F. No 8352/98 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).

§ 9. 6#758.$ '+&?"="'"%+;J 8%$'

4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 167 KA .N -$/ '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ "+%9,/ ,)*+)5 /: "2#$#' #85:)') !#:!$)2/2> +$3(#7 !"% -#93 ;%''#% -# "+%9,%, ) ! "93;)% '%!#:*'#"2/ !#:!$)2/2> !"% ! ')23$% - !#:&%"2/2> %(# "2#/"2> ! +%'>()?, %"9/ /'<% -#"9%+ "2!/5 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ "+%9,/ '% -$%+3"$%'< :),#'#&.

C$/ $)""$%'// #+'#(# /: +%9 8<9# 3"2)'#!9%'#, ;2# #+ ') /: "2#$#' '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,/ 3"23-/9) -# +#(#!#$3 @%""// +$3(#&3 9/@3 2$%8#!)'/% !#:!$)2/2> !"% -#93;%''#% -# I2#7 "+%9,%.

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

C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N '% "#(9)"/9"5 " 2),/& &'%'/%& / 3,):)9 ') 2#, ;2# +)''<% -#9#*%'/5 "2. 167 A#+%,"), /"?#+5 /: "&<"9) "2. 307 KA .N, "!/+%2%9>"2!3=2 # ')9/;// &%*+3 "2#$#')&/ -# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,% #85:) 2%9>"2!%''<? #2'#G%'/7, 2), ,), "2#$#'), -#93;/!G)5 /"-#9 '%'/% -# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,%, #85:)') -$#/:!%"2/ ! -#9> :3 +$3(#7 "2#$#'< #-$%+%9%''<% +%7"2!/5 - !#:!$)2/2> -#93 ;%''#%.

C$/:')!)5 #85:)2%9>"2!%''<7 ?)$),2%$ #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 "2#$#')&/ -# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,%, *'# -$/72/ , !<!#+3 # !#:*'#"2/ -$/&%'%'/5 ,

3,):)''<& #2'#G%'/5& '#$& #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/51.

C#",#9>,3 -$/ '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ "+%9,/ 3 ,)*+#7 /: "2#$#' !#:'/,)%2 #85:)''#"2>, 2# !#:'/,)=2 / #85:)2%9>"2!%'-

1 =6. -"+,.("051('1 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 8 E10/.53

119

2000 F. No =. 37). 1066/99 ()1+,('&

)4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 2000. No 6 .

C-$'$ 2. G#+"'+;& ."+B&875$-M+;& , 8%$'"8%,<&+,7&-M+;& 8%"9-&<; 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

'<% -$)!##2'#G%'/5 (-$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 - +#9(). C3',2 2 "2. 167 KA .N 9/G> '):<!)%2 9/@, &%*+3 ,#2#$<&/ -%$!#');)9>'# !#: '/,)=2 #85:)2%9>"2!) -# !#:!$)23 !"%(# -#93;%''#(#, '# '% :) -$%6)%2 -%$%&%'< 9/@) ! I2/? #85:)2%9>"2!)? -#"$%+"2!#& 3" 23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

19%+#!)2%9>'#, "2#$#') ! '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,% !-$)!% 3"23-/2> "!#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)2> -$/&%'%'/5 -#"9%+"2!/7 '%+%/L"2!/2%9>'#"2/ "+%9,/ +$3(#&3 9/@3 " "#89=+%'/%& 3"9#!/7, -$%+3"$%''<? "2. 388 KA .N.

KWT4T 3. CQHXSDJ D C.T4Q4TX C.D.QBT 1QKWTZJHDX QV O1SOCAJ C.T4T S.JVQ4THDX

§ 1. U>M\7M;=8J-!>M)J)J] 7JUJ)J> 8M8 J=;J)M;<: [:==<<

C#"9% !"23-9%'/5 ! "/93 K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .N, ! (9. 24 ,#2#$#(# 3$%(39/$#!)'< #2'#G%'/5, "!5:)''<% " -%$%?#+#& -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3, "+%9,/ -# 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5 "2)9/ !"% ;)6% !"2$%;)2>"5 ! -$)!#-$/&%'/2%9>'#7 -$), 2/,%. H%"$5 ') 2#, ;2# '#$&< # @%""// "#+%$*)9/"> / ! K$) *+)'",#& ,#+%,"%

.1N1. 1922 (., / ! K$)*+)'",#& ,#+%,"% .1N1. 1964 (., /&%''# "%7;)", ! -%$/#+ "2)'#!9%'/5 / $):!/2/5 ! "2$)'% $<'#;'<? #2'#G%'/7, /'"2/232 @%""// ! $#""/7",#& ($)*+)'",#& -$)!%, #8$):'# (#!#$5, ');)9 '#!3= */:'>.

4"% ;)6% "+%9,/ -# 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 "2)'#!52"5 -$%+&%2#& $)""$%'/5 ! "-#$)?, $):$%G)%&<? )$8/2$)*'<&/ "3+)&/.

Q+'),# 2% /9/ /'<% !#-$#"<, ,)")=6/%"5, ')-$/&%$, "36 '#"2/ / 3"9#!/7 @%""//, #8M%&) -%$%+)!)%&<? -$)! / 2.+., -#$#7 "2)!52 "3+< ! 23-/,.

S),, -# #+'#&3 /: +%9 )$8/2$)*'<7 "3+ 3"2)'#!/9 "9% +3=6%%1.

1 =6. -"+,.("051('1 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 29 A1 &.2/3 1998 F. No 1676/98 ()1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 1999. No 3. =. 48).

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

D'+/!/+3)9>'<7 -$%+-$/'/&)2%9> #8$)2/9"5 " /",#& , 2# !)$/6%"2!3 " #($)'/;%''#7 #2!%2"2!%''#"2>= # !:<",)'// G2$)E) :) '%"!#%!$%&%''3= #-9)23 2#!)$) ') #"'#!)'// +#(# !#$) -#"2)!,/ / -$#@%'2#! :) -#9>:#!)'/% ;3*/&/ +%'%*'<&/ "$%+"2!)&/ ! "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 395 KA .N.

C$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 /"2@) 8<9# #"'#!)'# ') +#(#!#$% 3"23- ,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%""//).

.%G%'/%& "3+) -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// ! /",% /'+/!/+3)9>'#&3 -$%+-$/'/&)2%9= 8<9# #2,):)'# "# ""<9,#7 ') 2#, ;2# -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5), -$/')+9%*)6/% -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3, -%$% +)'< '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -# "+%9,% ,3-9/--$#+)*/ :) 10 QQQ $38., ;2#, -# &'%'/= "3+), -$#2/!#$%;/2 -$)!#!#7 -$/$#+% @%""//, "9%+#!)2%9>'#, +#(#!#$ @%""// :),9=;%' " ')$3G%'/%& :),#'# +)2%9>"2!) / 5!95%2"5 '/;2#*'<& ! "/93 "2. 168 KA .N.

C#"2)'#!9%'/%& "3+) )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// $%G%'/% "3+) -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// #"2)!9%'# 8%: /:&%'%'/7 -# 2%& *% #" '#!)'/5&.

D2),, )$8/2$)*'<7 "3+ "2#9,'39"5 " "/23)@/%7, ,#(+) -%$ !#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ 3"23-/9 "!#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9* '/,3 '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3, ) -#"9%+'/7 :) -#93;%''#% -$)!# 2$% 8#!)'/5 :)-9)2/9 @%+%'23 10 QQQ $38. C# &'%'/= "3+) -%$!#7 /'"2)'@//, ,#2#$<7 8<9 -#++%$*)' "3+#& )-%995@/#''#7 /' "2)'@//, "9#*/!G/%"5 !#:&%:+'<% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 @%+%'2#& / @%""/#')$/%& '%+#-3"2/&<, 2), ,), #'/ -$#2/!#$%;)2 -$)!# !#7 -$/$#+% @%""//. 4 "!5:/ " I2/& "+%9,) -# 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '/;2#*').

B95 2#(# ;2#8< $):#8$)2>"5 ! 2#&, 5!95%2"5 9/ "+%9)''<7 "3+)&/ !<!#+ #8#"'#!)''<& /9/ '%2, #8$)2/&"5 , "36'#"2/ #2'#G%'/7, ",9)+<!)=6/?"5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2# $#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&.

O"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%""/5) - I2# "+%9,), -#"9%+"2 !/%& ,#2#$#7 5!95%2"5 "/'(395$'#% (;)"2'#%) -$)!#-$%%&"2!#: -%$%&%') ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% "

),2)... D +%7"2!/2%9>'#, 3 ')" '%$%+,# (#!#$/2"5 # -$#+)*% / -#,3-,% !%,"%95,

:)%&'#(# -/">&)»1.

A.C. C#8%+#'#"@%! -/")9, ;2# «-%$%+);) *%2 8<2> "+%9) ') :) +%'>(/ (2.%. -$#+)%2"5 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2!3), ! 3+#!9%2!#$%'/% +#9(), +95 3$)!'%'/5 @%''#"2%7 -$/ $):+%9% ')"9%+"2!) / 2.-. C%$%+);) *%2 8<2> "+%9)') / "

+)$"2!%''#7 @%9>=2.

T !#2 &'%'/% D.H. S$%-/@<'): «R%""/5 -$#/:!#+/2"5 !"% (+) ') ,),#&-'/83+> #"'#!)'//. S),/& #"'#!)'/%& (causa) *%2 8<2> /9/ !#:&%:+'#% #2;3*+%'/%, ')-$/&%$, -$#+)*) 2$% 8#!)'/5 :) +%'>(/, -%$%+);) %(# !:)&%' 3-9)2< +%'%(, /9/ *% #2;3*+%'/% 8%:!#:&%:+'#%, +)$%'/%» .

4#-$#" #8 #"'#!)'// @%""// :)2$)(/!)%2"5 / ! $)8#2)? "# !$%&%''<? $#""/7",/? @/!/9/"2#!. H)-$/&%$, 0.D. V$)(/'",/7 -/G%2, ;2# @%""/5 !<$)*)%2"5 ! -%$%+);% @%+%'2#& @%""/#') $/= #-$%+%9%''#(# -$)!) ! "/93 "+%9,/. S%& ")&<& ")&) -%$% +);) /&%%2 #"'#!)'/%& +#(#!#$, "!5:<!)=6/7 @%+%'2) " @%" "/#')$/%&. H# I2/& +#(#!#$#& 5!95%2"5 '% @%""/5, ,), '%$%+,# -#9)()=2, ) 2) "+%9,), ') ,#2#$3=

#-/$)%2"5 -%$%?#+, "#"2)! 95=6/7 "36'#"2> @%""//4.

T')9#(/;'#(# &'%'/5 -$/+%$*/!)%2"5 / W.T. H#!#"%9#!): «C# "!#%7 -$/$#+% I2) "+%9,) (3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5. - 2.3.) "?#+') " /:!%"2'#7 $/&",#&3 -$)!3 -%$%+);%7 !9)+%'/5 !%6>= +95 -%$%'#") -$)!) "#8"2!%''#"2/ (tradicio).

1+%9,3 -# -%$%+);% !9)+%'/5 !%6>= '%9>:5 $)""&)2$/!)2> ! #2$<!% #2 #"'#!)'/5 -%$%+);/, 2.%. 89/*)7G%7 @%9/, $)+/ ,# 2#$#7 #') -$#/:!%+%'). C%$%+);) !9)+%'/5 *%2 8<2> "#!%$ G%') " @%9>= #+)$/2> -$/#8$%2)2%95 9/8# +95 /"-#9'%'/5 $) '%% "36%"2!#!)!G%(# #85:)2%9>"2!), ')-$/&%$, ,3-9/--$#+)*/, 9/8# ;2#8< "#:+)2> #85:)2%9>"2!) -# :)7&3. Q-$%+%9/2> @%9>

' 1&/&%I.). *&.L. +"#. =. 116.

2=6.: 3"9&?"+"#B&' !. *&.L. +"#. =. 231.

3S%&8,B;+ ).H. *&.L. +"#. =. 206.

4=6.: N%$=,+#.,/ 1.)., 2,7%:+#.,/ 2.2. 7"F"0"/("1 -/.0": J2K'1 -"5"H1

('3. =. 373.

§ 1. C%$>?$+#."-8%$'"'"/ ?"="'"% .$. "#+"'$+,& B#,,

-%$%+);/ '%!#:*'#, '% :')5 -$/$#+< "+%9,/ (,), -$)!/9#, +#(#!#$)), ') #"'#!)'// ,#2#$#7 / 8<9) "#!%$G%') -%$%+);) !%6/.

S#;'# 2), *% ! #2'#G%'/5?, "!5:)''<? " -%$%+);%7 -$)!), "+%9,) @%""// '%

#-$%+%95%2 #"'#!)'/5 -%$%+);/... O"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5 '/,#(+) '% "#!%$G)%2"5 «")&)

-# "%8%», 2#9>,# $)+/ 2#(#, ;2#8< -%$%+)2> -$)!# -$%*'%(# ,$%+/2#$) '#!#&3. 12#$# '< -$/ %% "#!%$G%'// -$%"9%+3=2 ,),3=-9/8# @%9>...»1.

0.D. V$)(/'",/7 -$/!#+/2 %6% #+/' +#!#+ ! -#9>:3 #2$/ @)'/5 ")"2#52%9>'#"2/ +#(#!#$) @%""//. K9)!) 24 K$)*+)' ",#(# ,#+%,") «C%$%&%') 9/@ ! #85:)2%9>"2!%» ! 8#9>G%7 ;)"2/ $%(39/$3%2 #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 +#9*'/,#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&, )

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«4 I2#7 "!5:/ !#:'/,)%2 -#2$%8'#"2> ! /"-#9>:#!)'//

#-$%+%9%''<?, '% "!5:)''<? "# "-%@/E/,#7 !%6%7 '#$& # ,3-9%--$#+)*% - 2),/?, ')-$/&%$, ,#2#$<% #-$%+%95=2 &%'2 /"-#9'%'/5 +#(#!#$), 3"2)')!9/!)=2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) $):9/;'<% ')$3G%'/5, -$% +3"&)2$/!)=2 -#$5+#, !<-#9'%'/5

#2+%9>'<? #85:)''#"2%7 "2#$#')&/ / +$.»2.

1 H"'"#&-"'$ O.(. *+,$-&. -/.0. ,/12"0.('3 -" A"F"0"/$ (,1"/'3 ' -/.&,'&.) //

S.&"("A.,15D+,0". 1997. No 6. =. 14.

" N%$=,+#.,/ 1.)., 2,7%:+#.,/ 2.2. 7"F"0"/("1 -/.0": J2K'1 -"5"H1('3. =. 373.

125

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

D2),, 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 !"%(+) -$%+-#9)()%2 ')9/ ;/% #85:)2%9>"2!), ') #"'#!)'// ,#2#$#(# -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$% +/2#$ -%$%+)%2 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3.

Q+'),# ! "#!$%&%''#7 =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23$% *'# !"2$%2/2> / +$3(#% &'%'/%, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$<& @%""/5 -$%+"2)!95%2"5 ,), "+%9,) «")&) -# "%8%».

H)-$/&%$, A. W%8%+%! ";/2)%2, ;2# «! 2%? "93;)5?, ,#(+) -$%+&%2#& "+%9,/ 5!95%2"5 -%$%+);) -$)!, I2) "+%9,) +#9*') 8<2> ,!)9/E/@/$#!)') ,), "+%9,) 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5, #89% ,)%&)5 9/8# ! E#$&3 #"#8#(# +#(#!#$), #8<;'# /&%'3%(# +#(#!#$#& @%""// (!<+%9%'# &'#7. - 2.3.), 9/8# ! E#$&3 ,3-

9/--$#+)*/ /9/ E#$&3 +#(#!#$) &%'<». D +)9%%: «...-$)!# /&36%"2!%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# +$3(#&3 9/@3 ,), -# 8%:!#:&%:+'#7, 2), / -#

!#:&%:+'#7 "+%9,%. 1 3;%2#& I2#(# *'# 8<9# -$#!%"2/ $):($)'/;%'/% +#(#!#$#!,

#-#"$%

+3=6/? 3"23-,3 2$%8#!)'/5, "9%+3=6/& #8$):#&: -$/ 8%:!#: &%:+'#7 -%$%+);% -$)!) :),9=;)%2"5 +#(#!#$ @%""// (+#(#!#$ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 ! 3:,#& "&<"9% "9#!)), -$/ !#:&%:+'#7 -% $%+);% " #-9)2#7 +%'>()&/ - +#(#!#$ ,3-9/--$#+)*/, -$/ !#: &%:+'#7 -%$%+);% ') 3"9#!/5? #8&%') ') +$3(#7 2#!)$ - +#(#!#$

&%'<»1.

S$3+'# "#(9)"/2>"5 " 2),/& &'%'/%&, ! 2#& ;/"9% / " 2%&,

;2# 8%:!#:&%:+')5 -%$%+);) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 #89%,)%2"5 «! E#$&3 #"#8#(# +#(#!#$)».

4 "/93 -. 1 "2. 572 KA .N -# +#(#!#$3 +)$%'/5 #+') "2#$#') (+)$/2%9>) 8%:!#:&%:+'# -%$%+)%2 /9/ #85:3%2"5 -%$%+)2> +$3 (#7 "2#$#'% (#+)$5%&3) !%6> ! "#8"2!%''#"2> 9/8# / & 3 6 % " 2 !%''#% -$)!# (2$%8#!)'/%) , "%8% /9/ , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3. J"

9/ !#95 "2#$#', :),9=;)=6/? "#(9)G%'/% # @%""//, ')-$)!9%') ') 8%:!#:&%:+'3= -%$%+);3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, 2# I2# +#(#!#$ +)$%'/5, ) '% «+#(#!#$ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 ! 3:,#& "&<"9% "9#!)».

' O&9&?&' !. ?1X.('L6 /1.5'L.C'' A12',"/+&"% L.A"5H1(("+,' // P"L3%+,0" '

-/.0". 1999. No 7. =. 29-30.

§ 1. C%$>?$+#."-8%$'"'"/ ?"="'"% .$. "#+"'$+,& B#,,

136%"2!#!)'/% «+#(#!#$) #8 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5» (/9/ «+#(#!#$) @%""//») $)!'#"/9>'# "36%"2!#!)'/= «+#(#!#$) # -%$%+);% /&36%"2!)». C#"9%+'/% +%952"5 ') +#(#!#$< -# -%$% +);% /&36%"2!) ! "#8"2!%''#"2> / +#(#!#$< -# -%$%+);% /&3 6%"2!) ! -#9>:#!)'/%, +#(#!#$< !#:&%:+'<% / 8%:!#:&%:+'<%.

C$%+&%2#& +#(#!#$#! -# -%$%+);% /&36%"2!) ! -#9>:#!) '/% (32 8<2> 2#9>,# '%-#2$%895%&<% /'+/!/+3)9>'#-#-$%+% 9%''<% !%6/, -#I2#&3 ,#'"2$3,@/5 «+#(#!#$) @%""//» , 2),/& +#(#!#$)& '/,), '% *%2 8<2> -$/&%'%'). 4 "!5:/ " I2/& &< *%& $)""&)2$/!)2> 2#9>,# +#(#!#$< -%$!#(# !/+) - +#(#!#$< -# -%$%+);% /&36%"2!) ! "#8"2!%''#"2>. S),/% +#(#!#$< (,), / !"5,/% /'<% +#(#!#$<) (32 #"'#!<!)2>"5 9/8# ') !#:&%:+'<? (,3-95--$#+)*), &%')), 9/8# ') 8%:!#:&%:+'<? #2'#G%'/5? (+) $%'/%). 19%+#!)2%9>'#, 2),/% *% #"'#!)'/5 83+32 / 3 «+#(#!#$) @%""//».

Q+'),# ,#'"2$3,@/5 «-%$%+);/ -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2# $#& -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ! "#8"2!%''#"2> '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3» +95 "#(9)G%'/7 # @%""// '%-$/&%'/&), -#I2#&3-2# -. 4 "2. 454 KA .N (9)"/2, ;2# , -$#+)*% /&36%"2!%''<? -$)! 8%,<&+:U7 #: Q86/% -#9#*%'/5 # ,3-9%--$#+)*%, %"9/ /'#% '% !<2%,)%2 /: "#+%$*)'/5 /9/ ?)$),2%$) I2/? -$)!.

4 #"'#!% @%""// *%2 8<2> '% 2#9>,# +#(#!#$ ,3-9/- -$#+)*/ /&36%"2!%''#(# -$)!) 9/8# +#(#!#$ +)$%'/5.

4 "/93 -. 1 "2. 824 KA .N +%'%*'#% 2$%8#!)'/% , +#9*'/,3 *%2 8<2> 3"23-9%'# ,9/%'2#& E/')'"#!#&3 )(%'23 ! @%95? #8%"-%;%'/5 /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!) ,9/%'2) -%$%+ E/')'"# !<& )(%'2#&. C#9#*%'/5 -. 2 "2. 831 KA .N $%(39/$3=2 '%,#2# $<% !#-$#"< #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 ,9/%'2#& / E/')'"#!<& )(%' 2#& ! 2#& "93;)%, ,#(+) 2$%8#!)'/% 3"23-)9#"> ! ,);%"2!% "-# "#8) #8%"-%;%'/5 /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!).

H%"$5 ') 2#, ;2# #8% 3,):)''<% '#$&< ')?#+52"5 ! (9. 43 KA .N, ,#2#$)5 $%(39/$3%2 #2'#G%'/5 -# +#(#!#$3 E), 2#$/'() (E/')'"/$#!)'/% -#+ 3"23-,3 +%'%*'#(# 2$%8#!)'/5), ') ')G !:(95+, '%2 '/,),/? -$%-52"2!/7 +95 2#(#, ;2#8< @%""/5 (9) !<"23-)2> ! ,);%"2!% "-#"#8) #8%"-%;%'/5 /"-#9'%'/5

127

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

#85:)2%9>"2!) / ! +$3(/?, '% "!5:)''<? " E),2#$/'(#& #2'#G% '/5?. S%& 8#9%% -%$%;%'> 2),/? "-#"#8#!, 3"2)'#!9%''<7 ! -. 1 "2. 329 KA .N, '% 5!95%2"5 /";%$-<!)=6/&.

1#(9)G%'/% # @%""// &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& *%2 8<2> "#!%$G%'# ! $)&,)? +#(#!#$) ,#&/""//.

4 "##2!%2"2!// " -#9#*%'/5&/ -. 2 "2. 993 KA .N ! "93;)% '%/"-#9'%'/5 2$%2>/& 9/@#& "+%9,/, :),9=;%''#7 " '/& ,# &/""/#'%$#&, ,#&/""/#'%$ #85:)' '%&%+9%''# "##86/2> #8 I2#& ,#&/2%'23, "#8$)2> '%#8?#+/&<% +#,):)2%9>"2!), ) 2),*% -# 2$%8#!)'/= ,#&/2%'2) -%$%+)2> %&3 -$)!) -# 2),#7 "+%9,% " "#89=+%'/%& -$)!/9 #8 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 ("2. 382-386, 388 / 389).

S),)5 -%$%+);) ,#&/""/#'%$#& ,#&/2%'23 -$)!) 2$%8#!) '/5 , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3 5!95%2"5 @%""/%7. A#&/""/#'%$ / ,#&/2%'2 +#9*'< :),9=;/2> "#(9)G%'/% # @%""// " 3;%2#& -#9#*%'/7 "2. 388 KA .N, 2.%. -$%+!)$/2%9>'# +#9*%' 8<2> $%G%' !#-$#" # !#:*'#"2/ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 !##86% - '% 83+%2 9/ 2),)5 3"23-,) -$#2/!#$%;/2> :),#'3 / /'<& -$)!#!<& ),2)&; '%#8?# +/ 9/ -#93;)2> "#(9)"/% +#9*'/,) ') 3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!) '/5 (-. 2 "2. 388 KA .N). 1#(9)G%'/% # @%""// &%*+3 ,#&/""/#

'%$#& / ,#&/2%'2#& +#9*'# "##2!%2"2!#!)2> #-$%+%9%''#7 :) ,#'#& E#$&% ("2. 389 KA .N). R%+%'2 (,#&/""/#'%$) #85:)' "# !%$G/2> #-$%+%9%''<% +%7"2!/5: -%$%+)2> ,#&/2%'23 +#,3&%' 2<, 3+#"2#!%$5=6/% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5; "##86/2> "!%+%'/5, /&%=6/% :');%'/% +95 #"36%"2!9%'/5 2$%8#!)'/5.

1#(9)G%'/% # @%""// &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& *%2 8<2> "#!%$G%'# ! $)&,)? +#(#!#$) +#!%$/2%9>'#(# 3-$)!9%'/5 /&36%"2!#&.

4 "/93 -. 3 "2. 1024 KA .N, %"9/ +#(#!#$#& '% -$%+3" $%'# /'#%, -$/ -$%,$)6%'// +#(#!#$) +#!%$/2%9>'#(# 3-$)!9% '/5 /&36%"2!#, ')?#+56%%"5 ! +#!%$/2%9>'#& 3-$)!9%'//, -% $%+)%2"5 3;$%+/2%9= 3-$)!9%'/5.

1#(9)"'# -. 2 "2. 1020 KA .N -$)!), -$/#8$%2%''<% +#!%$/ 2%9>'<& 3-$)!95=6/& ! $%:39>2)2% +%7"2!/7 -# +#!%$/2%9>'#

§ I. C"$>?$+#."-8%$'"'"/ ?"="'"% .$. "#+"'$+,& B#,,

&3 3-$)!9%'/= /&36%"2!#&, !,9=;)=2"5 ! "#"2)! -%$%+)''#(# ! +#!%$/2%9>'#% 3-$)!9%'/% /&36%"2!). C$%+"2)!95%2"5, ;2# ! +)''#7 '#$&% $%;> /+%2 ! 2#& ;/"9% / #8 #85:)2%9>"2!%''<? -$)!)? (-$)!)? 2$%8#!)'/5), ,#2#$<% -$/#8$%9 ! $%:39>2)2% "!# /? +%7"2!/7 +#!%$/2%9>'<7 3-$)!95=6/7.

B95 2#(# ;2#8< 8<9# !<-#9'%'# 2$%8#!)'/% -. 3 "2. 1024 KA .N (+#!%$/2%9>'<7 3-$)!95=6/7 #85:)' -%$%+)2> 3;$%+/ 2%9= 3-$)!9%'/5 -$)!)"2$%8#!)'/5, -$/#8$%2%''<% ! $%:39>2)2%

+%7"2!/7 -# +#!%$/2%9>'#&3 3-$)!9%'/= /&36%"2!#&), "2#$# '< +#9*'< :),9=;/2> "#(9)G%'/% # @%""//.

O"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 - I2# "+%9,), #"'#!)'')5 ') #2 '#G%'/5? &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/ 2#$#&, $%(39/$#!)'/% ,#2#$<? '% #($)'/;/!)%2"5 -#9#*%'/5&/ (9. 24 KA .N.

C$%+"2)!95%2"5, ;2# /&%''# 2), $)""3*+)9 C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+)

.N, ,#(+) $)""&)2$/!)9 -$#2%"2 ') $%G%'/% "3+) -%$!#7 / -#"2)'#!9%'/% )-%995@/#''#7 /' "2)'@// -# 3,):)''#&3 !<G% +%93.

D: &)2%$/)9#! +%9) "9%+#!)9#, ;2# -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5), -$/')+9%*)6/% -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3, -%$%+)'< '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 - /'+/!/+3)9>'#&3 -$%+-$/'/&)2%9= (/"2@3) -# "+%9,% ,3-9/--$#+)*/ :) 10 QQQ $38.

«P),#'#+)2%9>, - #2&%;)%2"5 ! -#"2)'#!9%'// C$%:/+/3&) 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N, - $%(9)&%'2/$35 !#:*'#"2> -%$%+);/ -$)! (2$%8#!)'/5) -# "+%9,%, '%

#-$%+%9/9 !/+) +#(# !#$), -# ,#2#$#&3 I2) -%$%+);) -$#/"?#+/2. C#I2#&3 +#(#!#$ ,3-9/--$#+)*/ *%2 "93*/2> #"'#!)'/%& -%$%+);/ -$)! (2$% 8#!)'/7). 4 +)''#& "93;)% /&%%2 &%"2# !#:&%:+')5 @%""/5. 19%

+#!)2%9>'#, -%$%+);) -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5) -# +#(#!#$3 -$#+)*/ '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 "2)2>% 386 KA .N / ! @%9#& -)$)($)E3 1 (9) !< 24 KA .N.

A$#&% 2#(#, -3',2#& 4 "2)2>/ 454 KA .N -$%+3"$%'#, ;2# Q86/% -#9#*%'/5 # ,3-9%--$#+)*% -$/&%'5=2"5 , -$#+)*% /&36%"2!%''<? -$)!, %"9/ /'#% '% !<2%,)%2 /: "#+%$*)'/5 /9/ ?)$),2%$) I2/? -$)!».

U

128

D !"#$%&'( 4 4.

129

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

C# &'%'/= C$%:/+/3&) 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N, !<!#+, "#+%$*)6/7"5 ! ),2)? "3+#! -%$!#7 / )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@/7 ! ;)"2/ -$/:')'/5 -$#+)*/ -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5) -$# 2/!#$%;)6/& -$)!#!#7 -$/$#+% § 1 (9. 24 KA .N, 5!95%2"5 #G/

8#;'<&1.

C# +$3(#&3 +%93 "3+ -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// 2),*% "#"9)9"5 ') 2#, ;2# +#(#!#$ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 '% *%2 8<2> !#:&%:+'<&, 2), ,), I2# -$#2/!#$%;/2 '#$&% "2. 382 KA

.N, #+'),# C$%:/+/ 3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N 3,):)9, ;2# 3"9#!/% # !#: &%:+'#%TM +#(#!#$) @%""// '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 2$%8#!)'/5& (9. 24 KA .N / '% 5!95%2"5 #"'#!)'/%& +95 -$/:')'/5 %(# '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'<&, -#",#9>,3 -. 3 "2. 423 KA .N 3"2)'#!9%'#, ;2# +#(#!#$ -$%+-#9)()%2"5 !#:&%:+'<&, %"9/ /: :),#'), /'<? -$)!#!<?

), 2#!, "#+%$*)'/5 /9/ "36%"2!) +#(#!#$) '% !<2%,)%2 /'#%2.

A#'%;'# *%, ! 8#9>G/'"2!% "93;)%! !#:&%:+')5 @%""/5 #" '#!)') ') +#(#!#$% ,3-9/- -$#+)*/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, #+'),# !#:*'< / +$3(/% !)$/)'2<.

C# #+'#&3 /: +%9, $)""$%''<? C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N ! -#$5+,% ')+:#$), 8<9# 3"2)'#!9%'#, ;2# -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 8<9# 3"23-9%'# ! #8&%' ') #8M%,2 '%+!/ */"2/. 13+ )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// -$/G%9 , !<!#+3 # :) ,9=;%'// "2#$#')&/ +#(#!#$) &%'<. C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$ 8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N

"#(9)"/9"5 " 2),/& !<!#+#&, 2), ,), #' "##2!%2"2!3%2 "2. 567 KA .N3.

' =6. -"+,.("051('1 !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 29 A1 &.2/3 1998 F. No 1676/98 ()1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 1999. No 3. =. 48).

§ I. C%$>?$+#."-8%$'"'"/ ?"="'"% .$. "#+"'$+,& B#,,

J"9/ @%""/#')$/7 #85:3%2"5 -%$%+)2> @%+%'23 /&36%"2!#, 3-9)2/2> %&3 +%'>(/, #,):)2> 3"93(3, !<-#9'/2> $)8#23 / 2.-. 9/8# #85:3%2"5 !#:+%$*)2>"5 #2 "#!%$G%'/5

#-$%+%9%''#(# +%/L"2!/5, 2# , 2),#&3 «+#(#!#$3 @%""//» +#9*'< -$/&%'52>"5 -# 9#*%'/5, $%(39/$3=6/% "##2!%2"2!%''# -#$5+#, -%$%+);/ /&36%"2!), /"-#9'%'/% +%'%*'<? #85:)2%9>"2!, #,):)'/% 3"93(, !<-#9'%'/% $)8#2 / 2.-.

C# +#(#!#$3 @%""// -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3 *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# @%+%'2#& @%""/#')$/= ! ,);%"2!% #2"23-'#(#.

4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 409 KA .N -# "#(9)G%'/= "2#$#' #85:)2%9>"2!# *%2 8<2> -$%,$)6%'# -$%+#"2)!9%'/%& !:)&%' /"-#9'%'/5 #2"23-'#(#.

«D&36%"2!%''<% -$)!) (-$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5), - -/G%2 Q.\. Z/- 9#?!#"2, - (32...

!<"23-)2> ! ,);%"2!% -$%+&%2) #2"23-'#(#, 2), ,), -$%+"2)!95%2"5 !-#9'%