Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

J"9/ +#9*'/, '% 8<9 -/">&%''# 3!%+#&9%' # "#"2#5!G%& "5 -%$%?#+% -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3, '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$

2 8.& $H1 ",61#.5"+D, 1+5' L.3051('1 " L.#1,1 -/",'0 ,/12"0.('3 -1/0"(. #.5D("F" &/1A',"/. +A15.(" A"5H('&"6 A" 6"61(,. $+,$-&' Y,"F" ,/12"0. ('3, ," C1A1(, $+,$-'5 (1+$K1+,0$OK11 -/.0" ,/12"0.('3 ' A"5H1( (1+,' L. Y," ",01,+,01(("+,D.

176

12. C#;37,/' 4. 4.

177

C8$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

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

G/2"5 (-9)2) :) -#93;%''#% #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) -$) !# 2$%8#!)'/5, #2"32"2!/% !"2$%;'#(# -$%+#"2)!9%'/5 "# "2#$# '< +#9*'/,)).

H),#'%@, ! :),9=;%'/% $)""$%'/5 !#-$#") # -$/&% '%'// "2. 390 KA .N '%#8?#+/ #2&%2/2>, ;2# ! 2%? "93;) 5?, ,#(+) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 3"23-)%2"5 ! $)&,)? +#(#!#$) E/ ')'"/$#!)'/5 -#+ 3"23-,3 +%'%*'#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 (E),2# $/'(), -$/&%'%'/= -#+9%*)2 "-%@/)9>'<% -$)!/9) $%(39/$#!) '/5 +)''<? #2'#G%'/7 ((9. 43 KA .N), ! 2#& ;/"9% / -$)!/ 9), "!5:)''<% " #2!%2"2!%''#"2>= @%+%'2) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) 3"23-,3 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. H% 83+%& #"2)

')!9/!)2>"5 ') +)''#& !#-$#"%1, ) #8$)2/& !'/&)'/% 2#9>,# ') 2#, ;2# ! #29/;/% #2 -#9#*%'/7 "2. 390 KA .N "2#$#'< +#(#

!#$) E),2#$/'() "#(9)"'# -. 1 "2. 827 KA .N (32 /",9=;/2> #2!%2"2!%''#"2> @%+%'2) (,9/%'2)) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& (E/')'-

' J2 "+"21(("+,3X ",01,+,01(("+,' &5'1(,. -1/1A E'(.(+"046 .F1(,"6 -" A"F" 0"/$ E'(.(+'/"0.('3 -"A $+,$-&$ A1(1H("F" ,/12"0.('3 +6.: O"<,?L& G. *&.L. +"#. =. 18; H"'"#&-"'$ O.(. N'(.(+'/"0.('1 -"A $+,$-&$ A1(1H("F" ,/12"0. ('3 //

)1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 2001. No 5. =. 133-134.

3%$.7,.$ 2;#K&=" (%9,7%$>+"=" F5?$ @W 8" '"8%"#$< 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

$%"-#'+%'2",#(# ";%2) / ! "/93 -. 1 "2. 388 KA .N '% +#-3",)%2 "5 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 29 )-$%95 1997 (. No 4966/96).

*H) &%'2 :),9=;%'/5 "#(9)G%'/5 #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$% 8#!)'/5, #"'#!)''#(# ') '%/"-#9'%'// 8)',#& #85:)2%9>"2! -# +#(#!#$3 8)',#!",#(# ";%2), -#"9%+'/7 +%7"2!#!)9. 19%+#!) 2%9>'#, -%$%+);) ,9/%'2#& -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 -# ,#',$%2'<& -9) 2%*'<& +#,3&%'2)& '% -#!9%,9) -%$%&%'< !9)+%9>@) ";%2) / '% "##2!%2"2!3%2 '#$&)& KA .N #8 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 (-#"2)'#! 9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 27 &)5

1997 (. No 584/97).

*4%,"%9>, !<+)''<7 " #(#!#$,#7 «'% -$/,):3» /9/ /'#7 $)!'#:');'#7 #(#!#$,#7, *%2 8<2> -%$%+)' 9/G> " "#89=+% '/%& E#$&< / " -#"9%+"2!/5&/ #8<,'#!%''#7 @%""// (-. 7 /' E#$&)@/#''#(# -/">&) C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 25 /=95 1997 (. No 18 «Q8:#$ -$),2/,/ $):$%G%'/5 "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " /"-#9> :#!)'/%& !%,"%95 ! ?#:57"2!%''#& #8#$#2%»).

*R%""/#')$/7, -$)!# ,#2#$#&3 3"23-/9 '% ,$%+/2#$ ("2$) ?#!)2%9>), )

!<(#+#-$/#8$%2)2%9>, '% !-$)!% 2$%8#!)2> !:<",) '/5 "2$)?#!#(# !#:&%6%'/5 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 6 5'!)$5 1998 (. No 1386/96).

* T$8/2$)*'<7 "3+ #"2)!95%2 8%: $)""$%'/5 /", ') #" '#!)'// -. 2 "2. 87 TCA .N ! "93;)% @%""// 2#(+), ,#(+) #"'#! '#7 +#(#!#$, -# ,#2#$#&3 "#"2#59)"> 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, "#+%$*)9 2$%2%7",3= :)-/"> # -%$%+);% "-#$#! -# "+%9,% ! &% *+3')$#+'<7 ,#&&%$;%",/7 )$8/2$)* (-. 15 /'E#$&)@/#''#(# -/">&) C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 16 E%!$)95 1998 (. No 29 «Q8:#$ "3+%8'#-)$8/2$)*'#7 -$),2/,/ $):$%G%'/5 "-#$#! -# +%9)& " 3;)"2/%& /'#"2$)''<? 9/@»).

181

3%,-">&+,&

*C# #85:)2%9>"2!)&, !<2%,)=6/& /: ,$%+/2'<? +#(#!#$#!, 9/;'#"2> ,$%+/2#$) +95 +#9*'/,) :');%'/5 '% /&%%2. H%!<-#9 '%'/% ,$%+/2#$#&, #+'#!$%&%''# 5!95=6/&"5 #8"93*/!)=6/& +#9*'/,) 8)',#&, #85:)2%9>"2! -# +#(#!#$3 8)',#!",#(# ";%2) '% 5!95%2"5 #8"2#52%9>"2!#&, #2'#"56/&"5 , 9/;'#"2/ ,$%+/2#$), ,#2#$#% 8< /&%9# "36%"2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 +#9*'/,) (-#"2) '#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 17

&)$2) 1998 (. No 6173/97).

*O"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 +#-3",)%2"5 ') 9=8#7 "2)+// )$8/2$)*'#(# -$#@%""), ! 2#& ;/"9% / ') "2)+// /"-#9'%'/5 $%G%'/5 "3+) ! #2'#G%'// 3,):)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 (-#"2)'#!9% '/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 7 )-$%95 1998 (. No 4095/97).

*P),#'#+)2%9>"2!# # -$/!)2/:)@// (#"3+)$"2!%''#(# / &3 '/@/-)9>'#(# /&36%"2!) '% -$%+3"&)2$/!)%2 !#:*'#"2> -% $%+);/ )$%'+)2#$#& 2$%2>%&3 9/@3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , )$%'+# +)2%9= /9/ /'#&3 #$()'3, !<"23-)=6%&3 -$#+)!@#& )$%'+#

!)''<? #8M%,2#! '%*/9#(# E#'+), :),9=;/2> +#(#!#$ ,3-9/- -$#+)*/ )$%'+3%(# -#&%6%'/5 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 7 )-$%95 1998 (. No 2203/97).

* C#"9% $)"2#$*%'/5 +#(#!#$) 8)',#!",#(# ";%2) ! "##2!%2 "2!// "# "2. 859 KA .N 3 ,9/%'2) !#:'/,)%2 -$)!# 2$%8#!)2> #2 8)',) !<+);/ #"2)2,) +%'%*'<? "$%+"2! 9/8# %(# -%$%;/"9%'/5 ') +$3(#7 ";%2. 4 "!#= #;%$%+> 3 8)',) !#:'/,)%2 #85:)2%9>"2!# -# !<+);% ,9/%'23 #"2)2,) +%'%*'<? "$%+"2! ! "%&/+'%!'<7 "$#, /9/ -%$%;/"9%'/= ! 2#2 *% "$#, #"2)2,) ') +$3(#7 ";%2, 3,):)''<7 ,9/%'2#&.

C$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 # !<+);% #"2)2,) +%'%*'<? "$%+"2! -% $%+)'# ,9/%'2#& +$3(#&3 =$/+/;%",#&3 9/@3, # ;%& +#9*'/, 8<9 3!%+#&9%'.

C$/ 2),/? #8"2#52%9>"2!)? 3 "3+) '% /&%9#"> -$)!#!<? #" '#!)'/7 +95 -$/:')'/5 +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '/ ;2#*'#7 "+%9,#7, / "#"2#5!G/%"5 "3+%8'<% ),2< -#+9%*)2 #2&%

$:

3%$.7,.$ 2;#K&=" (%9,7%$>+"=" F5?$ @W 8" '"8%"#$< 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

'% (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 1 "%'258$5 1998 (. No 3947/98).

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

C$/ '%-$%+"2)!9%'// ')+9%*)6% #E#$&9%''#(# +#(#!#$) -#$3;%'/5 /9/ +#!%$%''#"2/ /",#!#% :)5!9%'/% -#+9%*/2 !#: !$)23 ! "##2!%2"2!// " -. 2 ;. 1 "2. 108 TCA .N.

C%$%+);) -$)! ($3:#-#93;)2%9%& / ($3:##2-$)!/2%9%& ! -#$5+,%, -$%+3"$%''#& "2. 135 S$)'"-#$2'#(# 3"2)!), '% 5! 95%2"5 3"23-,#7 -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #85:)2%9>"2!)&, "!5:)''<& " -%$%!#:,#7 ($3:).

S$%8#!)'/5 , *%9%:'<& +#$#()&, !#:'/,)=6/% ! "!5:/ " #"36%"2!9%'/%& -%$%!#:,/ ($3:), (32 8<2> -$%+M5!9%'< ($3 :##2-$)!/2%9%& /9/ ($3:#-#93;)2%9%& (-. 27 -#"2)'#!9%'/5 C9%'3&) 4T1 .N #2 12 '#58$5 1998 (. No 18 «Q '%,#2#$<? !# -$#")? "3+%8'#7 -$),2/,/ )$8/2$)*'<? "3+#! ! "!5:/ " !!%+% '/%& ! +%7"2!/% S$)'"-#$2'#(# 3"2)!) *%9%:'<? +#$#( .#""//L",#7 N%+%$)@//»).

* A '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -%$%?#+52 -$)!), #8%"-%;/!)=6/% /"-#9'%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!), ! 2#& ;/"9% -$)!# ') '%3-9);%''<% -$#@%'2<. C$/ #2"32"2!// ! +#(#!#$% 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 "-% @/)9>'<? #(#!#$#, '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$ -$/#8$%2)%2 -$)!) ') -$# @%'2< 2),/% *%, ,),/% /&%9 3"23-/!G/7 I2# -$)!# -$%*'/7

183

U U

3%,-">&+,&

,$%+/2#$ (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 15 +%,)8$5 1998 (. No 2884/98).

* C$%:/+/3& ";/2)%2 "#+%$*)6/7"5 ! -$#2%"2% !<!#+ # -$)!#&%$'#"2/ !#:&%:+'#7 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%""//) -$) !/9>'<&.

P),#'#+)2%9>, $%(9)&%'2/$35 !#:*'#"2> -%$%+);/ -$)! (2$%8#!)'/5) -# "+%9,%, '%

#-$%+%9/9 !/+) +#(#!#$), -# ,#2#$# &3 I2) -%$%+);) -$#/"?#+/2. C#I2#&3 +#(#!#$ ,3-9/--$#+)*/ *%2 "93*/2> #"'#!)'/%& -%$%+);/ -$)! (2$%8#!)'/7). 4 +)' '#& "93;)% /&%%2 &%"2# !#:&%:+')5 @%""/5. 19%+#!)2%9>'#, -% $%+);) -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5) -# +#(#!#$3 -$#+)*/ '% -$#2/!#$% ;/2 "2. 386 KA .N / ! @%9#& § 1 (9. 24 KA .N.

A$#&% 2#(#, -. 4 "2. 454 KA .N -$%+3"$%'#, ;2# #86/% -#9#*%'/5 # ,3-9%--$#+)*% -$/&%'5=2"5 , -$#+)*% /&36%"2 !%''<? -$)!, %"9/ /'#% '% !<2%,)%2 /: "#+%$*)'/5 /9/ ?)$),2% $) I2/? -$)!.

C#I2#&3 !<!#+, "#+%$*)6/7"5 ! #"-)$/!)%&<? "3+%8'<? ),2)? ! ;)"2/ -$/:')'/5 -$#+)*/ -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5) -$#2/!#$% ;)6/& -$)!#!#7 -$/$#+% § 1 (9. 24 KA .N, 5!95%2"5 #G/8#;'<& (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 29 +%,)8$5 1998 (. No 1676/98).

* C#",#9>,3 -# +#(#!#$3 @%""// @%+%'2 -%$%+)9 @%""/#') $/= !"% -$)!), !#:'/,G/% /: :),9=;%''<? &%*+3 '/& / 2$%2> /& 9/@#& "+%9#, :) #-$%+%9%''<7 -%$/#+, ) ,#',$%2'<% 2$%8# !)'/5 '% 3,):)'<, -$%+&%2 +#(#!#$) '% *%2 ";/2)2>"5 "#(9) "#!)''<& (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 29 +%,)8$5

1998 (. No 1676/98).

* P),#'#& '% -$%+3"$%') #85:)''#"2> -$%*'%(# ,$%+/ 2#$) /:!%6)2> +#9*'/,) # "#"2#5!G%7"5 ! -#9>:3 '#!#(# ,$%+/ 2#$) 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 12 5'!)$5 1999 (. No 7112/97).

3%$.7,.$ 2;#K&=" (%9,7%$>+"=" F5?$ @W 8" '"8%"#$< 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

*D", #8 #85:)'// -#+2!%$+/2> 3"23-,3 5!95%2"5 -$)!#&%$ '<&, %"9/ +#,):)'#, ;2# -$)!), #"'#!)''<% ') +#(#!#$% @%""//, ')$3G%'< (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1

.N #2 12 5'!)$5 1999 (. No7112/97).

*C$)!# ') !#:&%6%'/% 38<2,#!, !#:'/,G/? ! $%:39>2)2% -$/;/'%'/5 !$%+), *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# +$3(#&3 9/@3 -# +#(# !#$3 @%""// (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1

.N #2 11 &)5 1999 (. No 8352/98).

*O"9#!/% # !#:&%:+'#%TM +#(#!#$) @%""// '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 2$%8#!)'/5& (9. 24 KA

.N / '% 5!95%2"5 #"'#!)'/%& +95 -$/ :')'/5 %(# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'<& (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 11 &)5 1999 (. No 8352/98).

*C$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , #2!%2;/,3, !<2%,)=6%% /: "-#$'#(# +#(#!#$), !?#+/2 !

,#',3$"'3= &)""3 / *%2 8<2> $%)9/:#!)'# ,#',3$"'<& 3-$)!95=6%& -# !#:&%:+'#7 "+%9,% #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 15 /='5 1999 (. No 1020/99).

* 0)2%$/)9< +%9) "!/+%2%9>"2!3=2 # 8%:!#:&%:+'#"2/ "# (9)G%'/5 #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 / !#:*'#"2/ %(# ,!) 9/E/,)@// ,), +#(#!#$) +)$%'/5. 12)2>5 575 KA

.N :)-$%6)%2 +)$%'/% ! #2'#G%'/5? &%*+3 ,#&&%$;%",/&/ #$()'/:)@/5&/, :) /",9=;%'/%& -#+)$,#!, "2#/"2> ,#2#$<? '% -$%!<G)%2 -52/ 3"2)'#!9%''<? :),#'#& &/'/&)9>'<? $):&%$#! #-9)2< 2$3+) (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2

15 /='5 1999 (.

No 1134/99).

* 4<'%"%'/% "3+#& $%G%'/5 # !:<",)'// :)+#9*%''#"2/ '% &%'5%2 -$/$#+< / ?)$),2%$) +#9(#!<? 2$%8#!)'/7 / '% +%9)%2 !#:*'#7 -%$%&%'3 ,$%+/2#$) ! "93;)5?, ,#(+) 3+#!9%2!#$%''#%

185

3%,-">&+,&

"3+#& 2$%8#!)'/% '% (9# 8<2> 3"23-9%'# -# #"'#!)'/5&, -$% +3"$%''<& "2. 383 / 388 KA .N (-#"2)'#!9%'/5 C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 26 #,258$5 1999 (. No4641/99, #2

24 +%,)8$5 2002 (. No 10424/02).

* 1#(9)"'# +#(#!#$3 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 9/,!/+/$3=6//L"5 8)', E),2/;%",/ 3"23-)9 "!#/ ),2/!< ! #8#$#2% =$/+/;% ",#&3 9/@3, '% /&%=6%&3 -$)!) -%$!#7 #;%$%+/ -$/ 3+#!9%2!# $%'// 2$%8#!)'/7 ,$%+/2#$#!, -$%+3"$%''#7 "2. 64 KA .N.

C#",#9>,3 3,):)''<7 +#(#!#$ ')$3G)%2 #;%$%+'#"2> 3+#! 9%2!#$%'/5 2$%8#!)'/7 ,$%+/2#$#!, 3"2)'#!9%''3= -$/ 9/,!/ +)@// =$/+/;%",#(# 9/@), #' 5!95%2"5 '/;2#*'<& ') #"'#!) '// "2. 168 KA .N (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2

16 '#58$5 1999 (. No 1273/99).

* J"9/ +#9*'/, '% 8<9 -/">&%''# 3!%+#&9%' # "#"2#5! G%&"5 -%$%?#+% -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3, '#!<7 ,$%+/ 2#$ !-$)!% /"2$%8#!)2> /"-#9'%''#% +#9*'/,#& #2 -$%*'%(# ,$%+/2#$) ,), '%#"'#!)2%9>'# -#93;%''#% (-. 10 /'E#$&)@/#' '#(# -/">&) C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 11 5'!)$5 2000 (. No 49 «Q8:#$

3%,-">&+,& ________

Q+'),#, -$/'/&)5 #-$%+%9%'/% # -$#@%""3)9>'#& -$)!#-$% %&"2!%, "3+ '% !<5"'/9, /&%9#"> 9/ 3 8)',) -$)!# ') -$/'3+/ 2%9>'#% /"-#9'%'/% $%G%'/5 -# ')"2#56%&3 +%93 ') &%'2 :) ,9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ I2#(# -$)!) -# 3,):)''#&3 /"-#9'/ 2%9>'#&3 9/"23 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 29 )!(3 "2) 2000 (. No 352/96).

* C%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ - (#"3+)$"2!%''#% 3'/2)$'#% -$%+-$/52/%, #"'#!)''#% ') -$)!% ?#:57"2!%''#(# !%+%'/5. 4 "/93 "2. 49 KA .N 3'/2)$'<% -$%+-$/52/5 #89)+)=2 "-%@/)9> '#7 -$)!#"-#"#8'#"2>=. B%7"2!/5 -$%+-$/52/5 -# $)"-#$5*% '/= :),$%-9%''<& :) '/& /&36%"2!#& "#8"2!%''/,) +#9*'< 8<2> #83"9#!9%'< -$%*+% !"%(# :)+);)&/ %(# 3"2)!'#7 +%52%9> '#"2/ / @%9%!<& '):');%'/%& -$%+#"2)!9%''#(# +95 I2/? @%9%7 / :)+); /&36%"2!).

19%+#!)2%9>'#, "3+3 '%#8?#+/ -$#!%$/2>, "##2!%2"2!3=2 9/ 3"2)!3 (#"3+)$"2!%''#(# 3'/2)$'#(# -$%+-$/52/5 %(# +%7"2 !/5 -# 8%:!#:&%:+'#7 -%$%+);% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 +#9() '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 10

#,258$5 2000 (. No 4642/00).

* 13+ -$/ $)""$%'// "-#$) '% !<5"'/9, :),9=;%') 9/ "+%9,) 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 ') !#:&%:+'#7 #"'#!%. ]2# #8"2#5 2%9>"2!# /&%%2 "36%"2!%''#% :');%'/% +95 -$)!/9>'#(# $)" "$%'/5 "-#$), -#",#9>,3, /"?#+5 /: -. 1 "2. 576 KA .N, =$/ +/;%",#% 9/@#, ,#2#$#&3 !%6> -$/')+9%*/2 ') -$)!% ?#:57"2 !%''#(# !%+%'/5 /9/

#-%$)2/!'#(# 3-$)!9%'/5, !-$)!% -#+)$/2> %% 2#9>,# " "#(9)"/5 "#8"2!%''/,), %"9/ :),#'#& '% 3"2)'#!9%'# /'#%. C#I2#&3 "3+3 '%#8?#+/ /""9%+#!)2> !#-$#" # ')9/;//

/9/ #2"32"2!// "#(9)"/5 "#8"2!%''/,) /&36%"2!) ') +)$%'/% (3"23-,3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 +#9()) (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 10 #,258$5 2000 (. No 4642/00).

188

3%$.7,.$ 2;#K&=" (%9,7%$>+"=" F5?$ @W 8" '"8%"#$< 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

*C$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 *%2 8<2> 3"23-9%'# +$3(#&3 9/@3 ! ,);%"2!% #2"23-'#(# (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 21 '#58$5 2000 (. No 3583/00).

*J"9/ !%,"%9%+)2%9> -#&%"2/9 ! -%$%!#+'#& !%,"%9% "9#!) «'% -$/,):3» /9/ ,),#%- 9/8# $)!'#:');'#% !<$)*%'/%, 2# +#,3 &%'2 *%2 8<2> -%$%+)' 9/G> " "#89=+%'/%& E#$&< / "1-# "9%+"2!/5&/ #8<,'#!%''#7 @%""// ()8:. 2 "2. 11 C#9#*%'/5 ). 4

"##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 77 C#9#*%'/5 I2/ -$)!/9) -$/&%'5=2"5 / , -$#"2#&3 !%,"%9=.

Q(#!#$,)&/, !,9=;)%&<&/ ! !%,"%9> ! @%95? :)-$%2) -%$% +);/ %(# -# /'+#"")&%'23, 5!95=2"5, ! ;)"2'#"2/, #(#!#$,/: «-9)2/2% 2#9>,# 2),#&3-2# 9/@3», «-9)2/2% 2),#&3- 2#, '# '% %(# -$/,):3», «8%: -$)!) /'+#""/$#!)'/5», «-%$%+);) ! #86%($)* +)'",#& -#$5+,%».

C$/ ')9/;// -#+#8'<? #(#!#$#, !%,"%9> +#9*%' $)""&)2 $/!)2>"5 ,), /&%'')5 @%'')5 83&)(), -$)!) -# ,#2#$#7 -%$%+) =2"5 ! -#$5+,% / " -#"9%+"2!/5&/, 3"2)'#!9%''<&/ +95 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%""//) (-. 2 "2. 146, § 1 (9. 24 KA .N).

1+%9,) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# !%,"%9= +#9*') 8<2> #E#$&9%') -/">&%''# ') !%,"%9% 9/8# ') +#8)!#;'#& 9/"2% /9/ #2+%9>'<& +#,3&%'2#& (+#,3&%'2)&/), "#"2)!9%''<& ("#"2)! 9%''<&/) @%""/#')$/%& / @%+%'2#& ! "##2!%2"2!// " 2$%8#!) '/5&/ -. 1 "2. 160 KA .N.

C$/ #E#$&9%'// 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 #2+%9>'<& +# ,3&%'2#& ! '%& '%#8?#+/ /'+/!/+3)9/:/$#!)2> !%,"%9>, -$) !) -# ,#2#$#&3 5!95=2"5 -$%+&%2#& 3"23-,/. C$/ #2"32"2!// 2),#7 /'+/!/+3)9/:)@// 3"23-,) '% *%2 ";/2)2>"5 "#"2#5! G%7"5, ,), '% "#+%$*)6)5 3"9#!/5 # "!#%& -$%+&%2%.

13+)& "9%+3%2 3;/2<!)2>, ;2# 9/@#, #"'#!<!)=6%% -$/#8 $%2%'/% /& !%,"%9>'#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 "+%9,#7 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!) '/5, "#!%$G%''#7 /& / (/9/) ,%&-9/8# /: %(# -$%+G%"2!%''/ ,#!, +#9*'# -$%+"2)!/2> -/">&%''<% +#,):)2%9>"2!) "#!%$G%-

1 !"5"H1('1 " -1/10"A("6 ' -/"+,"6 01&+151. - 3%,<. $'7"%$. 189

U U U

3%,-">&+,&

'/5 2),#7 "+%9,/, %"9/ 2#9>,# #') '% #E#$&9%') ') !%,"%9% /9/ ') +#8)!#;'#& 9/"2%. 4 "##2!%2"2!// " -#9#*%'/5&/ "2. 386 KA .N #2!%2;/,, , ,#2#$#&3 -$%+M5!9%'# !%,"%9>'#% 2$%8#!)'/%, #"'#!)''#% ') "+%9,% ("+%9,)?) 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5, !-$)!% :) 5!952> -$%+M5!/2%9= I2#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 9=8<% !#:$)*%'/5, ,# 2#$<% #' (#2!%2;/,) /&%%2 , -$)!#-$%+G%"2!%''/,)& /"2@), "# !%$G/!G/& "+%9,/ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%+%'2)&).

1#!%$G%'')5 ') !%,"%9% /9/ ') +#8)!#;'#& 9/"2% !%,"%95, '% /&%=6%(# #($)'/;%'/7 ') %(# -%$%+);3 -# /'+#"")&%'23, :)-/"> # -%$%+);% -$)! +$3(#&3 9/@3 +#9*') $)""&)2$/!)2>"5 ,), /'+#"")&%'2, %"9/ 2#9>,# /: %% "#+%$*)'/5 #-$%+%9%''# '% !<2%,)%2 ')&%$%'/% -%$%+)=6%7 "2#$#'< -%$%+)2> -$)!) ! #8 6%($)*+)'",#& -#$5+,% (! -#$5+,% 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5) (-. 8 -#"2)'#!9%'/5 C9%'3! 4%$?#!'#(# 13+) .N / 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N #2 4 +%,)8$5 2000 (. No 33/14 «Q '%,#2# $<? !#-$#")? -$),2/,/ $)""$%'/5 "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " #8 $)6%'/%& !%,"%9%7»).

* 12)2>5 20 C#9#*%'/5 -$%+3"&)2$/!)%2, ;2# /'+#"")&%'2, "#!%$G%''<7 -#"9% "$#,) -9)2%*), /&%%2 2% *% -#"9%+"2!/5, ;2# / -$%+G%"2!3=6/7 /'+#"")&%'2, #+'),# /'+#"")&%'2, "# !%$G%''<7 -#"9% -$#2%"2) ! '%-9)2%*% /9/ -#"9% /"2%;%'/5 "$#,), 3"2)'#!9%''#(# +95 "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2), /&%%2 -#"9%+ "2!/5 9/G> #8<,'#!%''#7 @%""// ("+%9,/ 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5). C#",#9>,3 #8$)2'#% '% 83+%2 +#,):)'#, '%+)2/$#!)''<7 /'+#"")&%'2 ";/2)%2"5 "#!%$G%''<& +# /"2%;%'/5 "$#,), 3"2)

'#!9%''#(# +95 "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2).

1 3;%2#& +)''<? -#9#*%'/7 "3+)& -$/ $)""$%'// "-#

$#! "9%+3%2 /"?#+/2> /: 2#(#, ;2# !%,"%9> *%2 8<2> -%$%+)' -#"$%+"2!#& /&%''#(# /9/ 89)',#!#(# /'+#"")&%'2) / -#"9% "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2) !%,"%95 ! '%-9)2%*% 9/8# -#"9% /"2%;%'/5 "$#,), 3"2)'#!9%''#(# +95 "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2) (%"9/ -$#2%"2 '% "#!%$G)9"5). W/@), /'+#""/$#!)!G/% !%,"%9> -#"9% "#!%$ G%'/5 -$#2%"2) !%,"%95 ! '%-9)2%*% / (/9/) -#"9% /"2%;%'/5 "$#,) +95 "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2), '% #2!%;)=2 -%$%+ -$/#8$%2)

3%$.7,.$ 2;#K&=" (%9,7%$>+"=" F5?$ @W 8" '"8%"#$< 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

2%9%& !%,"%95 :) /"-#9'%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!) -# !%,"%9=, '# #2!% ;)=2 :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 ("2. 390 KA .N).

D'<% 9/@), #85:)''<% -# !%,"%9=, !-$)!% ') #"'#!)'// "2. 386 A#+%,") !<+!/()2> -$#2/! 2$%8#!)'/5 !%,"%9%+%$*)2%95 2% !#:$)*%'/5, ,#2#$<% #'/ /&%9/ -$#2/! 9/@) (9/@), /'+#""/ $#!)!G%(# (/'+#""/$#!)!G/?) !%,"%9> -#"9% "#!%$G%'/5 -$# 2%"2) -# '%&3 9/8# -# /"2%;%'// "$#,) +95 "#!%$G%'/5 -$#2%"2) (-. 17 -#"2)'#!9%'/5 C9%'3! 4%$?#!'#(# 13+) .N / 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N #2 4 +%,)8$5 2000 (. No 33/14 «Q '%,#2# $<? !#-$#")? -$),2/,/ $)""$%'/5 "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " #8 $)6%'/%& !%,"%9%7»).

*H%"#89=+%'/% E#$&< 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 '% !9%;%2 %% '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 19 +%,)8$5 2000 (. No 4131/00).

*T-%995@/#'')5 /'"2)'@/5 #8#"'#!)''# 3,):)9), ;2# , #2 !%2;/,3 -%$%G9# '% -$)!# "#8"2!%''#"2/ ') !)9=2'<% @%''#"2/ /"2@), ) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 -# ,$%+/2'<& +#(#!#$)&, /"-#9'%'/% -# ,#2#$<& ! "/93 "2. 317 KA .N '% "#:+)%2 #85:)''#"2/ -9)2% *%7 ! /'#"2$)''#7 !)9=2% (-#"2)'#!9%'/% C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 10 5'!)$5 2001 (. No 5040/00).

*1+%9,) -# 3"23-,% -$)!) (2$%8#!)'/5) +#9*') $)""&)2$/ !)2>"5 ,), ,$3-')5 / :),9=;)2>"5 " "#89=+%'/%& 2$%8#!)'/7, 3"2)'#!9%''<? "2. 78 / 79 N%+%$)9>'#(# :),#') «Q8 ),@/#'%$ '<? #86%"2!)?», %"9/ "2#/"2> 3"23-)%&<? -# "+%9,% -$)! -$%!<G)%2 25 -$#@%'2#! 8)9)'"#!#7 "2#/"2/ ),2/!#! #86% "2!) ') +)23 -$/'52/5 $%G%'/5 # "#!%$G%'// "+%9,/ (-. 6 /' E#$&)@/#''#(# -/">&) C$%:/+/3&) 4T1 .N #2 13 &)$2) 2001 (. No 62 «Q8:#$ -$),2/,/ $):$%G%'/5 "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " :),9= ;%'/%& ?#:57"2!%''<&/ #86%"2!)&/ ,$3-'<? "+%9#, / "+%9#,, ! "#!%$G%'// ,#2#$<? /&%%2"5 :)/'2%$%"#!)''#"2>»).

3%,-">&+,& ________

* B#(#!#$ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 &%*+3 @%+%'2#& / @%""/#') $/%& :),9=;%', ?#+)2)7"2!# /"2@) (@%+%'2)) # :)&%'% "2#$#'< ! -$#@%""% -#+)'# +# )''39/$#!)'/5