Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

2),/&, ,),/& #'# 8<9#, 2#2 #2!%;)%2 9/G> :) 2#, ;2# I2# 2$%8#!)'/% "36%"2!3%2, ) '% :) 2#, ;2# (-#,3-)2%9>) *%2 ;2#-9/8# !:<",)2>»3,4) 2),*% ! C$#%,2% K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5 .#""/7",#7 /&-%$// .

12)2>/ 1686 / 1687 C$#%,2) K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5 $%G) 9/ !#-$#"< #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5 / "#"2#5 2%9>'#"2> +#9*'/,).

S),, ! "/93 "2. 1686 «3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/% :) '"L+$=%$ >?&+,& (,3$"/! . - 2.3.) #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ -$/#8$%2)2%9%& :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5, $):!% 8< -$/#8$%2)2%9= !# !$%&5 3"23-,/ %&3 2$%8#!)'/5 8<9# /:!%"2'# # "-#$'#"2/ /9/ "#&'/ 2%9>'#"2/ %(#. Q:');%'')5 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> "#"2#/2 ! #85:)''#-

1 =6.: 1$/ F.!. J#1/& "2K1% #.+,' 2$/H$.L("F" "23L.,15D+,01(("F" -/.0.. ?.:

)(1I,"/F'LA.,, 1953. =. 194.

§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:

"2/ !#:!$)2/2> -#93;%''3= :) 3"23-9%''#% 2$%8#!)'/% "3&&3 / !#:')($)+/2> :) 38<2,/».

12)2>5 1687 (9)"/9), ;2# «3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/% 9/G> 2# (+) #2!%;)%2 :) "#"2#52%9>'#"2> +#9*'/,), ,#(+) , 2#&3 #85:)9 "5. C$/ I2#& %"9/ 2$%8#!)'/% 3"23-9%'# +# "$#,) %(# /"-#9'% '/5, 2# 3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/% #2!%;)%2 :) "#"2#52%9>'#"2> +#9*'/,) !# !$%&5 ')"23-9%'/5 I2#(# "$#,); %"9/ *% 3"23-,) "#!%$G%') -#"9% "$#,) /"-#9'%'/5, 2# 3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/% #2!%;)%2 :) "#"2#52%9>'#"2> +#9*'/,) !# !$%&5 3"23-,/ 2$%8# !)'/5. Q:');%'')5 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> "#"2#/2 ! #85:)''#"2/ '"L '%$7,7M 8"-54&++5U :) 3"23-9%''#%

2$%8#!)'/% #5<<5 (,3$"/! . - 2.3.)»1.

4 "!5:/ " /:9#*%''<& *'# "+%9)2> !<!#+, ;2# -%$!#') ;)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ ( #2!%;)2> -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& :) '% +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 3"23-9%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 / :) "#"2#52%9> '#"2> +#9*'/,) 2#9>,# ! 2#& "93;)%, ,#(+) +)'')5 3"23-,) 8<9) !#:&%:+'#7. Q+'),#, 3;/2<!)5, ;2# C$#%,2 K$)*+)'",#(# 39# *%'/5 2), / #"2)9"5 -$#%,2#&, :),#'#+)2%9>"2!# 2#(# !$%&%'/ 2),#7 !<!#+ '% -#+2!%$*+)9#.

D2),, )')9/: /:9#*%''<? !<G% '#$& N$)'@3:",#(# ($)* +)'",#(# ,#+%,"), T!"2$/7",#(# ($)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5, Z!%/L@)$",#(# #85:)2%9>"2!%''#(# :),#'), ) 2),*% § 437 K%$&)'",#(# ($)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5, ,#2#$<% $):$%G)=2 !#-$#" #8 #2!%2"2 !%''#"2/ @%+%'2) :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 3"23-9%''#(# 2$%8#!) '/5, -#:!#95%2 -$#!%"2/ $):($)'/;%'/% &%*+3 !#:&%:+'#7 / 8%:!#:&%:+'#7 @%""/5&/. 4 "2. 390 KA

.N 2),#(# $):($)'/;%'/5 '%2. H% 8<9# %(# / ! K$)*+)'",#& ,#+%,"% .1N1. 1964 (.2

^2# *% ,)")%2"5 K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .1N1. 1922 (., 2# ! "##2!%2"2!3=6/? "2)2>5? #8 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& -# -# !#+3 !#:*'#7 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ -%$%+)''#(# -$)!) !##86%

1 U/.HA.(+&"1 *5"H1('1. !/"1&, )4+"#.%I1 $#/1HA1(("% >1A.&C'"(("% 2

8"6'++'' -" +"+,.051('O U/.HA.(+&"F" *5"H1('3. =. 271.

>1A.&C'3 +,. 390 U8 >N -/.&,'#1+&' -"5("+,DO +"",01,+,0$1, /1A.&C'' #. 2 +,. 212 U8 >=N=> 1964 F.

167

U U

2[',.: V01%C./+&'% "23L.,15D+,01((4% L.&"( (30 6./,. 1911 F.) / !1/. M. U'- -'$+.. ?.: >M;<J;, 1930.

37'F1+,4 @+,'('.(.. <L2/.((41 E/.F61(,4 0 -1/10"A1 ' + -/'61#.('36' <.=. !1/1,1/+&"F". =. 355.

4=6.: U/.HA.(+&"1 *5"H1('1. !/"1&, )4+"#.%I1 $#/1HA1(("% >1A.&C'"(("% 8"6'++'' -" +"+,.051('O U/.HA.(+&"F" *5"H1('3 / !"A /1A. <. GO,/O6"- 0..

=!2., 1910.

166

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

'% $%(39/$3=2"5. Q+'),# +)''<7 !#-$#" ')G%9 $):$%G%'/% ! +$3(/? '#$&)? K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .1N1. 1922 (.

A), -#+;%$,/!)9 D.V. H#!/@,/7, «#2!%2"2!%''#"2> 3"23 -)=6%(# -$)!# -%$%+ -$/'/&)=6/& -$)!#, !##86% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 '/&/ ",9)+<!)=2"5 ! :)!/"/"2/ #2 2#(# -$)!##2'#G% '/5, ') ,#2#$#& -#,#/2"5 3"23-,) -$)!). K$)*+)'",/7 ,#+%," I23 &<"9> -#+;%$,/!)%2 ")&/& $)"-#9#*%'/%& &)2%$/)9). 4 "2)2>5? K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 #8 I2#& #8#86%'// 2%#$// -$)!/9>'# '% 3-#&/')%2"5. H# :)2# ! $):+%9 # ,3-9%--$#+)*% !,9=;%') "2. 202 #8 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/

-$#+)!@) +#9(#!#(# 2$%8#!)'/5. D ! ")& +%9%, #2!%2"2!%' '#"2> 9/@), 3"23-/!G%(# -$)!#, ,#'%;'#, '% #+/'),#!), ! :)!/ "/"2/ #2 2#(#, !#:&%:+')5 /9/ 8%:!#:&%:+')5

8<9) ! +)''#& "93;)% 3"23-,)»1.

4 "/93 "2. 202 K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .1N1. 1922 (. -$#+) !%@ +#9(#!#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 #2!%;)%2 :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8# !)'/5, %"9/ /'#% '% -$%+3"$%'# +#(#!#$#&. O;/2<!)5, ;2# #2'#"/2%9>'# #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ ,$%+/2#$), 3"23-/!G%(# -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 8%:!#:&%:+'#, K$)*+)'",/7 ,#+%," .1N1. 1922 (. '/,),/? -#9#*%'/7 '%

"#+%$*/2, D.V. H#!/@,/7 -$/?#+/2 , !<!#+3, ;2# 3"23-/!G/7 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 8%:!#:&%:+'# '% '% "%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ '/ :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5, '/ :) E),2/;%",3= %(# #"36%"2!/"2>.

1/"2%&)2/;%",#% 2#9,#!)'/% K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") .N -# :!#95%2 "+%9)2> )')9#(/;'<7 !<!#+. C$/ I2#&, -#9)()%&, 2%-%$> '%#8?#+/ #8$)2/2>"5 '% , $):+%93

#,3-9%--$#+)*%, ,), I2# "+%9)9 ! "!#% !$%&5 D.V. H#!/@,/7, ) , -#9#*%'/5& A#+%,")

#+#(#!#$% +)$%'/5.

4 "##2!%2"2!// " -. 3 "2. 576 KA .N +)$%'/% -$/')+9%*) 6%(# +)$/2%9= -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3 #"36%"2!95 %2"5 " "#89=+%'/%& -$)!/9, -$%+3"$%''<? "2. 382-386, 388 / 389 A#+%,"). A), !/+/&, -$)!/9), 3"2)'#!9%''<% "2. 390

' H"',B.,/ ).N., O5+BO.(. *&.L. +"#. =. 226. 168

§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:

KA .N, ') 8%:!#:&%:+'<% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& '% $)"-$#"2$)'5=2"5.

S),/& #8$):#&, " &%'2) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 +)9> '%7G/% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 @%+%'2#& / @%""/#')$/%& (32 $): !/!)2>"5 -#-$):'#&3, ! :)!/"/"2/ #2 2#(#, 8>G) 9/ 2),)5 3" 23-,) !#:&%:+'#7 /9/ 8%:!#:&%:+'#7. 4 "93;)% '%+%7"2!/2%9> '#"2/ -%$%+)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 -# !#:&%:+'#7 "+%9,% -%$!#') ;)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ #85:)' !#:!$)2/2> '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 !"% -#

93;%''#% -# "+%9,%, ) 2),*% !#:&%"2/2> 38<2,/ (%"9/ #'/ %"2>). O"23-/!G/7 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 -# +#(#!#$3 +)$%'/5 '% '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5. O;/2<!)5 /&-%$)2/!'<7 ?)$),2%$ -. 3 "2. 576 KA .N, '%#8?#+/ "+%9)2> !<!#+ # '%!#:*'#"2/ -# "#(9)G%'/= "2#$#' !#:9#*%'/5 #2 !%2"2!%''#"2/ ') @%+%'2) :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)!)%(# -# +#(#!#$3 +)$%'/5 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.

D2),, ! +)9>'%7G%& 83+%& /"?#+/2> /: 2#(#, ;2# +%7"2 !3=6/7 K$)*+)'",/7 ,#+%,"

.N +)%2 #"'#!)'/% -#9)()2>, ;2# @%+%'2 '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''# (# 2$%8#!)'/5 2#9>,# ! "93;)% :),9=;%'/5 " @%""/#')$/%& !#: &%:+'#7 "+%9,/ -# 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. C$/ I2#&, ,), -#+;%$,/!)%2 W.T. H#!#"%9#!), «-#9#*%'/5 "2)2>/ 390 KA .N -#:!#95=2 "+%9)2> !<!#+ # 2#&, ;2# "#(9)G%'/%& -%$!#');)9> '#(# ,$%+/2#$) " '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& '% *%2 8<2> 3"2)'#!9%'#

3"9#!/%, /",9=;)=6%% #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 3"23-9%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5»1.

S%-%$> #"2)'#!/&"5 ') "9%+3=6%& !#-$#"%. K9)!')5 -$# 89%&) #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ @%+%'2) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) '%+%7"2 !/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5, ') ')G !:(95+, :),9=;)%2 "5 ! 2#9,#!)'// "9#!#"#;%2)'/5 «'%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)' '#(# 2$%8#!)'/5».

G%'/% #8 3"23-,% '%"36%"2!3=6%(# (-#9'#"2>= /9/ ! ;)"2/) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 /9/ ! $%:39>2)2% "#8"2!%''#(# :)893*+%'/5. R%+%'2 '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> '%:)!/"/ #2 2#(#, /:!%"2'< %&3 !#:$)*%'/5 +#9*'/,), "-#"#8'<% -)$)9/:#!)2> 3"23-9%''#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, /9/ '%2. R%+%'2 2),*% #2!%;)%2 :) 2#, ;2# 3"23-/9 2$%8#!)'/%, ,#2#$#% ! &%'2 3"23-,/ ?#25 / 8<9#

+%7"2!/2%9>'<&, '# ! -#"9%+3=6%& 8<9# -$/:')'# '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'<&.

S),#7 -#+?#+ :),#'#+)2%95 *'# #8M5"'/2> "9%+3=6/&.

R%+%'2, ,), 3*% #2&%;)9#">, '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) 3" 23-,3 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 2#9>,# ! "93;)% :),9=;% '/5 " @%""/#')$/%& !#:&%:+'#7 "+%9,/. D.H. S$%-/@<' #8$)6)9 !'/&)'/% ') 2#, ;2# @%+%'2 :) 3"23-,3 "!#%(# -$)!) -#93;)%2 +%'>(/, -#I2#&3 «#' +#9*%' '%-$%&%''# #2!%;)2> :) +%7"2!/

2%9>'#"2> /9/ "36%"2!#!)'/% -%$%+)!)%(# -$)!), 2), ,), /') ;% !<?#+/9# 8<, ;2# #' -# !#:&%:+'#&3 #8&%'3 @%''#"2%7 -# 93;)%2 +%'>(/, '% -$%+#"2)!955 !:)&%' '/,),#(# I,!/!)9%'2)»'.

B%7"2!/2%9>'#, %"9/ @%+%'2 -#93;)%2 #2 @%""/#')$/5 '%,/7 /&36%"2!%''<7 I,!/!)9%'2, ) -#2#& !<5"'5%2"5, ;2# /& -%$% +)'# '%"36%"2!3=6%% (-#9'#"2>= 9/8# ! ;)"2/) /9/ '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'#% (9/8# +%7"2!/2%9>'#% ') &%'2 3"23-,/, '# ! -#"9% +3=6%& -$/:')''#% '%+%7"2!/2%9>'<&) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, 2#

E),2/;%",/ @%""/#')$/7 #+)$/!)%2 @%+%'2), ;2# "#!"%& '% !?# +/9# ! %(# -9)'< / '% 5!959#"> @%9>= :),9=;%''#7 &%*+3 "2# $#')&/ "+%9,/. C$/ I2#& '% /&%%2 :');%'/5, :)893*+)9"5 @% +%'2 #2'#"/2%9>'# +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ 2$%8#!)'/5 /9/ '%2.

D:&%'52"5 9/ #2!%2< ') /:9#*%''<% !<G% !#-$#"<, %"9/ 83+%2 3"2)'#!9%'#, ;2# @%+%'2 +# :),9=;%'/5 "#(9)G%'/5 # @%" "// -$%+3-$%+/9 @%""/#')$/5 # "-#$'#"2/ (-#9'#"2>= /9/ ! ;)"2/) -%$%+)!)%(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5?

J"9/ $)""&)2$/!)2> +)''<7 !#-$#" de lege ferenda, 2# "9% +3%2 "#(9)"/2>"5 " 4.T. V%9#!<&, -# &'%'/= ,#2#$#(#, %"9/ @% +%'2 +# -#+-/")'/5 +#(#!#$) @%""/#')$/%& -$%+3-$%+/9 -#-

1 S%&8,B;+ ).H. *&.L. +"#. =. 211-212. 172

§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:

"9%+'%(# # !#:*'<? !#:$)*%'/5? "# "2#$#'< +#9*'/,), -$% +#"2)!/9 ! %(# $3,/ !"% +#,3&%'2< / "!%+%'/5, '%#8?#+/&<% +95 -)$)9/:)@// I2/? !#:$)*%'/7, ) @%""/#')$/7, -$#/('#$/$# !)! -$%+3-$%*+%'/%, !-#"9%+"2!// '% -#*%9)9 /9/ '% "( -$) !/9>'# !#"-#9>:#!)2>"5 -$%+#"2)!9%''<&/ %&3 @%+%'2#& &)2% $/)9)&/, 2# !"% -$#/"G%+G/% #2 I2#(# '%89)(#-$/52'<% -# "9%+"2!/5 +#9*'< -)+)2> ') ")(#

@%""/#')$/51.

12#/2 2),*% %6% $): !"-#&'/2> -#9#*%'/5 "2. 1686 C$#%, 2) K$)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$#7 3"23-/! G/7 2$%8#!)'/% :) !#:')($)*+%'/% #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ -$/#8$%2)2% 9%& :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5, %$L'& 9; 8%,"9%&7$7&-U '" '%&<: 5#758., &<5 7%&9"'$+,: 9;-" ,L'+" " #8"%+"#7, ,-, #"<+,7&-M+"#7, &=".

B%7"2!/2%9>'#, 8<9# 8< '%"-$)!%+9/!# -$/!9%,)2> @%+%'2) , #2!%2"2!%''#"2/, %"9/ #' +#,)*%2, ;2# @%""/#')$/7 8<9 -$% +3-$%*+%' / ') &%'2 3"23-,/ :')9, ;2# -$#2/! -$/#8$%2)% (# /& 2$%8#!)'/5 "# "2#$#'< +#9*'/,) (32 8<2> !<+!/'32<

"%$>%:'<% !#:$)*%'/52.

H#, ') ')G !:(95+, de lege lata 3,):)''#% -$%+3-$%*+%'/% @%+%'2#& @%""/#')$/5 -#9#*%'/% !%6%7 '% &%'5%2. D ! +)''#& "93;)% @%+%'2 +#9*%' '%"2/ #2!%2"2!%''#"2>. Q-52> *% 2#9,# !)'/% "2. 390 KA .N '% -#:!#95%2 "+%9)2> /'#7 !<!#+. B)'')5 '#$&) "E#$&39/$#!)') 2),/& #8$):#&, ;2# '%#8?#+/ ,#'"2) 2/$#!)2> '%/:8%*'#"2> ')"23-9%'/5 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ @%+%'2) :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 '%:)!/"/ #2 2# (#, -$%+3-$%*+)9 @%+%'2 @%""/#')$/5 # ;%&-9/8# /9/ '% -$%+3 -$%*+)9.

4 2),#7 "/23)@// @%+%'23 *'# -#"#!%2#!)2> ""<9)2>"5 ') "2. 404 KA .N, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$#7 "3+ !-$)!% 3&%'> G/2> $):&%$ #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ +#9*'/,) (! ')G%& "93;)% - I2# @%+%'2), %"9/ ,$%+/2#$ (! ')G%& "93;)% - I2# @%""/#')$/7)

1 =6.: N&-"' 2.(. ='(F$53/("1 -/.0"-/116+,0" 0 "23L.,15D+,01. =. 156.

" )"-/"+ " ,"6, L.#16, (1+6",/3 (. -/1A$-/1HA1('1, C1++'"(./'% 0+1-,.&' -/'"2/1,.1, +"6(',15D("1 -/.0" ,/12"0.('3, (1 30531,+3 -/1A61,"6 (.I1F"

U U U U

'L$#1('3.

173

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

3&<G9%''# /9/ -# '%#"2#$#*'#"2/ "#+%7"2!#!)9 3!%9/;%'/= $):&%$) 38<2,#!, -$/;/'%''<? '%/"-#9'%'/%& /9/ '%')+9%*) 6/& /"-#9'%'/%&, 9/8# '% -$/'59 $):3&'<? &%$ , /? 3&%'>G% '/=. Q+'),# #2!%2"2!%''#"2> @%+%'2) ! "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 404 KA .N *%2 8<2> 2#9>,# 3&%'>G%') (!-9#2> +# "/&!#9/;%",#7 "3&&<), '# -#9'#(# #"!#8#*+%'/5 #2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ '% -$#

/:#7+%2.

A#&&%'2/$35 -#9#*%'/5 "2. 390 KA .N, J.T. 13?)'#! 3,)

:<!)%2, ;2# -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ '#!<& :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 3"23-9%''#(# /& 2$%8#!)'/5 / «" 2),#(# ,$% +/2#$) *'#, "9%+#!)2%9>'#, !:<",)2>

38<2,/, ')-$/&%$, :) 3"23-,3 -$#"$#;%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5»1. H) ')G !:(95+, +)''#% 32!%$*+%'/% 5!95%2"5 "-#$'<&.

C$%*+% !"%(# '% "#!"%& -#'52'#, # ,),#& «-$#"$#;%''#& 2$%8#!)'//» /+%2 $%;>. 1,#$%% !"%(# -#+ «-$#"$#;%''<& 2$%8# !)'/%&» /&%9#"> ! !/+3 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, ,#2#$#% '% *%2 8<2> $%)9/:#!)'# @%""/#')$/%& ! "!5:/ " !#:*'<& :)5!9%'/ %&

+#9*'/,) ! "3+% # -$#-3",% "$#,) /",#!#7 +)!'#"2/2.

4 =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23$% !"2$%;)=2"5 $):9/;'<% -#+?# +<, ?)$),2%$/:3=6/% -$)!#!3= -$/$#+3 #85:)2%9>"2!), 9/G%' '#(# /",#!#7 :)6/2<. C# &'%'/= #+'/? =$/"2#!, -$)!# 8%: -$/'3+/2%9>'#7 :)6/2< "36%"2!#!)2> '% *%2, -#I2#&3 9/

G%'/% 2$%8#!)'/5 /",#!#7 "/9< #:');)%2, ;2# 9/@# 9/G%'# "!# %(# "38M%,2/!'#(# -$)!). C# &'%'/= +$3(/?, 9/G%''#% /",#!#7 :)6/2< "38M%,2/!'#% -$)!# :),#'#&

-$/:')%2"5, #'# "36%"2!3 %2 / 5!95%2"5 +%7"2!/2%9>'<&3.

§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:

D:9#*%'')5 -$#89%&) - '% -$%+&%2 ')"2#56%7 $)8#2<, -# I2#&3 #2&%2/& 2#9>,# 2#, ;2# &< -#++%$*/!)%& !2#$#% !<",) :)''#% &'%'/%, -#",#9>,3 /"2%;%'/% "$#,) /",#!#7 +)!'#"2/ '% 3'/;2#*)%2 ")(# #85:)2%9>"2!), ) !%+%2 9/G> , #2"32"2 !/= 3 2$%8#!)'/5, #"'#!)''#(# ') 2),#& #85:)2%9>"2!%, "3+%8 '#7 :)6/2< (2), '):<!)%%

')23$)9>'#% #85:)2%9>"2!#)1. B)''#% 2$%8#!)'/% 9/G%'# /",#!#7 :)6/2<, #+'),# I2# #8"2#5 2%9>"2!# '% !9%;%2 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ 2$%8#!)'/5. P),#'#& *% '% -$%+3"$%') #2!%2"2!%''#"2> @%+%'2) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/ %& :) ")& E),2 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 /: ')23$)9>'#(# #85:)2%9> "2!).

C# &'%'/= 4.4. 4/2$5'",#(#, «! -$/'@/-% '% /",9=;)%2"5 !#:*'#"2> -%$%?#+) ,

'#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, -# ,#2#$#&3 3*% /"2%, "$#, /",#!#7 +)!'#"2/»2. S),#% 2$%8#!)'/% *%2 8<2> 3"23-9%'# ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 " 3;%2#& -# 9#*%'/7 "2. 388 KA .N, !#-$#" *% # @%9%"##8$):'#"2/ -$/#8$% 2%'/5 @%""/#')$/%& 2),#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 !<?#+/2 :) $)&,/ -$%+&%2) ')G%(# #8"3*+%'/5.

S),/& #8$):#&, %"9/ @%""/#')$/= 83+%2 #2,):)'# ! /",% # !:<",)'// +#9() " +#9*'/,) ! "!5:/ " :)5!9%'/%& -#"9%+'/& ! "3+% # -$#-3",% "$#,) /",#!#7 +)!'#"2/, 2#, ') ')G !:(95+, 2#9 ,#!)'/% "2. 390 KA .N -#:!#95%2 "+%9)2> !<!#+ # 2#&, ;2# @%" "/#')$/7 '% !-$)!% 2$%8#!)2> " @%+%'2) !#:&%6%'/5 -#'%"%' '<? 38<2,#!, 2), ,), %&3 8<9# 3"23-9%'# +%7"2!/2%9>'#% 2$% 8#!)'/%. D'#% *%2 8<2> -$%+3"$%'# "#(9)G%'/%& @%+%'2) / @%""/#')$/5, 2.%. -$/ 3"23-,% «-$#"$#;%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5» "2#$#'< ! "#(9)G%'// !-$)!% 3"2)'#!/2> 3"9#!/%, ! "##2!%2"2 !// " ,#2#$<& @%+%'2 #85:)' -$/ ')"23-9%'// /:!%"2'#(# #8 "2#52%9>"2!) !#:!$)2/2> @%""/#')$/= !"% -#93;%''#% / !#:&%" 2/2> -$/;/'%''<% 38<2,/.

1=6.: F$%9$K F2. )"-/"+4 '+&"0"% A.0("+,' // P"L3%+,0" ' -/.0". 2000. No 5. =.

2;.$#("--/.&,'#1+&'% &"661(,./'% & #.+,' -1/0"% U/.HA.(+&"F" &"A1&+. >"++'%+&"% N1A1/.C'' A53 -/1A-/'('6.,151%. =. 480.

175

U U U

U

1U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / !"A /1A. :.M. =$X.("0.. ) 2 ,. G. 2. !"5$,"6 1. =.

2) +'5$ +,. 201 U8 >N -1/161(. 5'C 0 "23L.,15D+,01 (1 051#1, 'L61(1('3 +/" &. '+&"0"% A.0("+,' ' -"/3A&. 1F" '+#'+51('3.

3!"A/"2(4% .(.5'L 0LF53A"0 C'0'5'+,"0 A"/10"5OC'"(("F", +"01,+&"F" ' +"0/161(("F" -1/'"A"0 (. -/"25164 -/.0"0"% -/'/"A4 -/.0 5'C., 1+5' "(' (1 6"F$, 24,D -/'($A',15D(" "+$K1+,051(4, A.( 0 +,.,D1 7.M. *L"%&'(. «). 5O,(41 +A15&', 5'I1((41 '+&"0"% +'54» (+6.: S.&"("A.,15D+,0". 2001. No 8. =. 53-61).

174

C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

J"9/ +#9*'/, '% 8<9 -/">&%''# 3!%+#&9%' # "#"2#5!G%& "5 -%$%?#+% -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3, '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$ '%"%2 $/", '%89)(#-$/52'<? -#"9%+"2!/7. 4 I2#& "93;)% /"-#9 '%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!) -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -$/:')%2"5

/"-#9'%'/%& ')+9%*)6%&3 ,$%+/2#$3 (-. 3 "2. 382 KA .N).

4 2),#7 "/23)@// -#9#*%'/5 "2. 390 KA .N -$/&%'52>"5 '% (32 / -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ '% 83+%2 '%"2/ #2!%2"2!%'

'#"2> -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&, -#",#9>,3 #' 3"23-/9 +%7"2!/ 2%9>'#% ("36%"2!3=6%%) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5. H#!<7 ,$%+/2#$ !-$)!% /"2$%8#!)2> /"-#9'%''#%

+#9*'/,#& #2 -$%*'%(# ,$% +/2#$) ,), '%#"'#!)2%9>'# -#93;%''#%1.

C#9#*%'/5 "2. 390 KA .N '% -$/&%'5=2"5 2),*% / ! 2%? "93;)5?, ,#(+) +#9*'/, !#"-#9>:#!)9"5 "!#/& -$)!#&, -$%+#" 2)!9%''<& %&3 "2. 412 KA .N, / :)5!/9 # :);%2% -$#2/! 2$%8#!) '/5 '#!#(# ,$%+/2#$) "!#% !"2$%;'#% 2$%8#!)'/% , -%$!#') ;)9>'#&3

,$%+/2#$32.

4 +)''#7 "/23)@// '%#8?#+/ #2&%2/2>, ;2# :);%2 5!95%2 "5 #+'/& /: #"'#!)'/7 -$%,$)6%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!, :);%2 5!95%2 "5 «"3$$#()2#&» /"-#9'%'/5.

H) ')G !:(95+, ! "2. 412 KA .N 3"2)'#!9%') -$%:3&-@/5, )')9#(/;')5 2#7, ,#2#$)5 :),$%-9%') ! -. 3 "2. 382 KA .N.

J"9/ +#9*'/, '% 8<9 -/">&%''# 3!%+#&9%' # "#"2#5!G%& "5 -%$%?#+% -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3 / #"36%"2!/9 /" -#9'%'/% -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3, 2# E),2/;%",/ +)''#% /"-#9'%'/% -#"9% "#"2#5!G%7"5 @%""// 5!95%2"5 /"-#9'%'/%&

'%')+9%*)6%&3 ,$%+/2#$3. Q+'),# -. 3 "2. 382 KA .N 3"2)')! 9/!)%2 -$%:3&-@/= ')+9%*)6%(# /"-#9'%'/5 +#9*'/,#& "!#%(# #85:)2%9>"2!).

___

§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:

U

1 =6. -. 10 '(E"/6.C'"(("F" -'+D6. !/1L'A'$6. )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 11 3(0./3 2000 F. No 49 «J2L"/ -/.&,'&' /.++6",/1('3 +-"/"0, +03L.((4X + -/'61(1('16 ("/6 " (1"+("0.,15D("6 "2"F.K1(''».

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

C$%:3&-@//, 3"2)'#!9%''<% ! -. 3 "2. 382 KA .N / ! "2. 412 KA .N, $):9/;)=2"5 2%&, ;2# ')+9%*)6/& /"-#9'%'/%& (/'<&/ "9#!)&/ - ')+9%*)6/& -$%,$)6%'/%& #85:)2%9>"2!)) -# -. 3 "2. 382 KA .N -$/:')%2"5 2#9>,# 2# /"-#9'%'/% -%$!#');)9>'# &3 ,$%+/2#$3, ,#2#$#% #"36%"2!9%'# +#9*'/,#& +# &%'2) -#93;%'/5 /& 3!%+#&9%'/5 # "#"2#5!G%&"5 -%$%?#+% -$)! #2 ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3. D"-#9'%'/% -%$!#');)9>'#&3 ,$%+/ 2#$3, "#!%$G%''#% -#"9% -#93;%'/5 +#9*'/,#& 3!%+#&9%'/5 #8 3"23-,%, '% 5!95%2"5 ')+9%*)6/&.

H)+9%*)6/& -$%,$)6%'/%& #85:)2%9>"2!) -# "2. 412 KA .N -$/:')%2"5 :)5!9%'/% # :);%2% 2$%8#!)'/5 +#9*'/,) , -%$!#') ;)9>'#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -$#2/! 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3 '#!#(# ,$% +/2#$) -$/ 3"9#!//, %"9/ 2$%8#!)'/% +#9*'/,) !#:'/,9# -# #" '#!)'/=, "36%"2!#!)!G%&3 , &%'23 -#93;%'/5 +#9*'/,#& 3!%+#&9%'/5 #8 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5, 2.%. #85:)2%9>"2!#, ! #29/ ;/% #2 "/23)@//, /:9#*%''#7 ! -. 3 "2. 382 KA

.N, *%2 8<2> -$%,$)6%'# ,), +# -#93;%'/5 +#9*'/,#& 3!%+#&9%'/5, 2), / -#"9%.

C$%:3&-@//, 3"2)'#!9%''<% -. 3 "2. 382 KA .N / "2. 412 KA .N, /&%=2 #86%% -#"9%+"2!/%: #85:)2%9>"2!# +#9*'/,) -$% ,$)6)%2"5. ^2# *% ,)")%2"5 +)9>'%7G/? #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 -%$ !#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&, 2# / :+%">, ') ')G !:(95+, -#"9%+"2!/5 +#9*'< 8<2> #+/'),#!<&/.