Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin
.pdf
J"9/ /"2%@ '% +#,):)9 2% #8"2#52%9>"2!), ') ,#2#$<% #' ""<9)%2"5 ,), ') #"'#!)'/% "!#/? 2$%8#!)'/7, 2# #' +#9*%' -$%2%$-%!)2> '%89)(#-$/52'<% -#"9%+"2!/5 ! !/+% #2,):) !
1 !"+,.("051('1 )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N ", 26 ("32/3 2002 F. No 8218/0.1 ()1+,('& )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N. 2003. No 3. =. 49).
§ 2. 3%&?<&7 #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
3+#!9%2!#$%'// /",#!<? 2$%8#!)'/7. 4<!#+ *% # 2#&, ;2# ! 2) ,#7 "/23)@// «"9%+3%2 -$/:')2> +#(#!#$ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 8%"-$%+&%2'<&, ! "!5:/ " ;%& #' '% *%2 5!952>"5 #"'#!)'/%& +95 #8$)6%'/5 " ')"2#56/& /",#&», ') ')G !:(95+, '% "##2!%2 "2!3%2 '/ '#$&)& &)2%$/)9>'#(#, '/ '#$&)& -$#@%""3)9>'#(# -$)!).
4 :),9=;%'/% $)""$%'/5 !#-$#") # -$%+&%2% +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ?#2%9#"> 8< #8$)2/2> !'/&)'/% ') #-$%+%9%''3= #"#8%''#"2>, ,#2#$)5 !"% ;)6% -$#5!95%2"5 ! -$),2/,% )$8/2$)*'<? "3+#!.
J"9/ -$#)')9/:/$#!)2> "#!$%&%''3= "3+%8'#-)$8/2$)*'3= -$),2/,3, 2# *'# #8')$3*/2>, ;2# :');/2%9>'3= ;)"2> $)" "&)2$/!)%&<? "3+)&/ "-#$#!, "!5:)''<? " 3"23-,#7 -$)!) 2$% 8#!)'/5, "#"2)!95=2 /",/ # -$/:')'// +#(#!#$#! @%""// '%:) ,9=;%''<&/.
S#, ;2# +#9*'/,/, ')?#+5"> ! -$#"$#;,%, #($#&'<% 3"/9/5 2$)252 '% ') ')+9%*)6%% /"-#9'%'/% "!#/? #85:)2%9>"2!, ) ') -$/:')'/% @%""// '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 "+%9,#7 9/8# -$/:')'/% +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '%:),9=;%''<& (!#:$)*)5 -$#2/! 2$%8#!)'/5 '#!#(# ,$%+/2#$) 9/8# :)5!955 ")"2#5 2%9>'<7 /",), - I2# 3*% #86%/:!%"2'<7 +95 8#9>G/'"2!) =$/ "2#! E),2.
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
O '%,#2#$<? "3+#! 2),/% "2)$)'/5 3;)"2'/,#! ($)*+)'",#- I # #8#$#2) ')?#+52 -#++%$*,3.
U U
154
755
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
4,);%"2!% -$/&%$) -$/!%+%& "9%+3=6%% +%9#1.
4/='% 1998 (. &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '# !<& ,$%+/2#$#& 8<9 :),9=;%' +#(#!#$, -# ,#2#$#&3 -%$!<7
3"23-/9 !2#$#&3 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #-9)2% +#9*'/,#& -# 2$%89%''#7 /& I9%,2$#I'%$(//.
4 "%'258$% 2003 (., 2.%. "-3"25 -52> 9%2 -#"9% 2#(#, ,), +#(# !#$ 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 8<9 :),9=;%' / (#8$)6)%& ') I2# !'/&)'/%) -#9'#"2>= /"-#9'%', @%""/#')$/7 «!+$3(» -$/G%9 , !<!#+3 # 2#&, ;2# &%*+3 "2#$#')&/ +#(#!#$) '% +#"2/('32# "#
(9)G%'/% # -$%+&%2% +#(#!#$). 4 "!5:/ " I2/& @%""/#')$/7 #8 $)2/9"5 ! )$8/2$)*'<7 "3+ :) :)6/2#7 "!#/? «')$3G%''<? -$)!».
C$/'/&)5 $%G%'/%, "3+ -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// 3,):)9 "9%+3= 6%%. «1#(9)"'# "2)2>5& 382 / 384 KA .N -$%+&%2#& 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 5!95%2"5 -$)!# 2$%8#!)2> /"-#9'%'/5 ,#',$%2'#(#
#85:)2%9>"2!). 4 +#(#!#$% (3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. - 2.3.) #2"32"2!3%2 3,):)'/% ') +#(#!#$, -#"93*/!G/7 #"'#!)'/%& !#:'/,'#!%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!), !"9%+"2!/% ;%(# '%9>:5 #-$%+%
9/2> -%$%+)!)%% ,$%+/2#$#& -$)!#. Q2"32"2!/% ! +#(#!#$% -$%+&%2) +#(#!#$) 5!95%2"5 +#"2)2#;'<& #"'#!)'/%& +95 -$/ :')'/5 %(# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'<&, 2), ,), -$%+&%2 +#(#!#$) 5!95%2
"5 %(# "36%"2!%''<& 3"9#!/%&. C#",#9>,3 :),9=;%'')5 "+%9,) -$#2/!#$%;/2 -. 1 "2. 382 / "2. 384 KA .N, +)''3= "+%9,3 "9%+3 %2 ! "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 168 KA .N ";/2)2>
'/;2#*'#7»2.
13+ )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// $%G%'/% #2&%'/9 / ! /",% # -$/:')'// +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '%+%7"2!/2%9> '<& #2,):)9.
§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:
D:3;/! -$%+"2)!9%''<% "2#$#')&/ +#,):)2%9>"2!), "3+ 3" 2)'#!/9, ;2# ! -$#@%""% :),9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '/,),/? !#-$#"#!, ,)")=6/?"5 -$%+&%2) +#(#!#$), 2.%. 3"23-)%(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, &%*+3 "2#$#')&/ '% !#:'/ ,)9#. C$/ :),9=;%'// +#(#!#$) #86)5 !#95 "2#$#' 8<9) ') -$)!9%') ') -%$%+);3 @%+%'2#& @%""/#')$/= ,#',$%2'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3 - -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# #-9)2% +#9*'/
,#& -#2$%89%''#7 /& I9%,2$#I'%$(//. ]2# -#+2!%$*+)%2 / -# "9%+3=6%% -#!%+%'/% "2#$#'. C#"9% :),9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) 3" 23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2# $#&, '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& / +#9*'/,#& 8<9/ -$#!%+%'<
$):9/; '<% !:)/:);%2<, ! 2#& ;/"9% " 3;%2#& 3"23-9%''#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. O"23-9%''#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 5!95%2"5 #-$%+%9/ &<&.
S),/& #8$):#&, #"'#!)'/5 +95 -$/:')'/5 +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '%:),9=;%''<& #2"32"2!3=2.
13+ ,)"")@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// "#(9)"/9"5 " !<!#+#& "3+) )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// / #"2)!/9 -#"2)'#!9%'/% )-%995@/ #''#7 /'"2)'@// 8%: /:&%'%'/5.
4<"G/7 T$8/2$)*'<7 13+ .N #2,):)9 ! -%$%+);% +%9) ! C$%:/+/3& 4<"G%(# T$8/2$)*'#(# 13+) .N +95 -%$%"$) "3+%8'<? ),2#! ! -#$5+,% ')+:#$).
§ 3. JG):G=G):;;J=GT [:7:;GM SM ;:7:]=G)<G:BT;J=GT
!:>:7M;;JUJ G>:9J)M;<Q
T$8/2$)*'<% "3+<, $):$%G)5 2#2 /9/ /'#7 "-#$, !"% ;)6% "2)9,/!)=2"5 " /'"2/232#& 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 / ! -$# @%""% $)""$%'/5 +)''<? +%9 +)=2 #@%',3 #2'#G%'/5&, "9# */!G/&"5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/ 2#$)&. 4 -#"9%+'%% !$%&5 3"2)'#!/9)"> -$),2/,) -$/:')'/5 "# (9)G%'/7 #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 -# 2%& /9/ /'<& #"'# !)'/5& '%+%7"2!/2%9>'<&/. 4&%"2% " 2%& #8$)6)%2 ') "%85
157
1=6. (.AL"/("1 -/"'L0"A+,0" )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N No 4248/04 (M/X'0 )4+I1F" M/2',/.H("F" =$A. >N).
2*H1 +.6. -" +121 6",'0'/"0&. +$A12("F" .&,. 04L40.1, "-/1A151((41 +" 6(1('3 0 L.&"(("+,' ' "2"+("0.(("+,' -/'(3,"F" /1I1('3: 1+5', -" 6(1('O +$A., +,"/"(4 (1 A"+,'F5' +"F5.I1('3 " -/1A61,1 A"F"0"/., ," ,.&"% A"F"0"/
30531,+3 (1L.&5O#1((46 ' -"Y,"6$ "( $H1 ('&.& (1 6"H1, 24,D -/'L(.( (1 A1%+,0',15D(46 (('#,"H(46).
156
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
!'/&)'/% 2#2 E),2, ;2# -$),2/,) #8$)6%'/5 '#!<? ,$%+/2#$#! " /",)&/ , -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$)& # !:<",)'// " '/? 38<2 ,#! ! "!5:/ " 3"23-,#7 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5
*'# ",):)2> #2"32"2!3%2.
H# -$%*+% ;%& )')9/:/$#!)2> "9#*/!G3="5 "/23)@/=,
-$/!%+%& +!) "93;)5 /: "3+%8'#7 -$),2/,/. Q86%"2!%'')5 #$()'/:)@/5 /'!)9/+#! #8$)2/9)"> ! )$8/2
$)*'<7 "3+ " /",#& , /'+/!/+3)9>'#&3 -$%+-$/'/&)2%9= Y # !:<",)'// :)+#9*%''#"2/, #8$):#!)!G%7"5 ! "!5:/ " '%/"-#9 '%'/%& #85:)2%9>"2!) -# +#(#!#$3, :),9=;%''#&3 &%*+3 ($)* +)'/'#& T / #2!%2;/,#&. C$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 !:<",)'/5 +#9() "
-$%+-$/'/&)2%95 Y -%$%G9# #2 ($)*+)'/') T , /"2@3 ') #"'# !)'// "#(9)G%'/5 # @%""//.
4 -$#@%""% $)""$%'/5 +%9) "3+ ,!)9/E/@/$#!)9 +#(# !#$, :),9=;%''<7 &%*+3 ($)*+)'/'#& T / -$%+-$/'/&)2% 9%& Y, ,), +#(#!#$ -$#"2#(# 2#!)$/6%"2!), "3+ -$/G%9 , !<!# +3 # '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ +)''#(# +#(#!#$) / "#(9)"'# "2. 168 /
1041 KA .N -$/:')9 "+%9,3 '/;2#*'#7.
.%G%'/%& "3+) -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// ! 3+#!9%2!#$%'// /",)
#2,):)'#. C#"2)'#!9%'/%& "3+) )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// $% G%'/% #"2)!9%'# 8%: /:&%'%'/5. 13+ ,)"")@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// '% ')G%9 #"'#!)'/7 +95 3+#!9%2!#$%'/5 ,)"")@/#''#7 *)9#8< /"2@) / #"2)!/9 3,):)''<% "3+%8'<% ),2< 8%: /:&%'%'/5.
C$/ I2#& "3+ ,)"")@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// ! -#"2)'#!9%'// "-%@/)9>'# #8$)2/9 !'/&)'/% ') "9%+3=6%%.
1#(9)"'# "2. 382 KA .N -$)!# (2$%8#!)'/%), -$/')+9%*) 6%% ,$%+/2#$3 ') #"'#!)'// #85:)2%9>"2!), *%2 8<2> -%$%+) '# /& +$3(#&3 9/@3 -# "+%9,% (3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5) /9/ -%$%72/ , +$3(#&3 9/@3 ') #"'#!)'// :),#').
K$)*+)'/' T -# +#(#!#$3 @%""// 3"23-/9 /"2@3 -$)!# 2$% 8#!)'/5 , -$%+-$/'/&)2%9= Y, ,#2#$<& '% #89)+)9, ! "!5:/ " ;%& "3+< -%$!#7 / )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@/7 -$/G9/ , !<!#+3 # '/;2#*'#"2/ @%""// ! "/93 "2. 168 KA
.N.
158
§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:
C# &'%'/= "3+) ,)"")@/#''#7 /'"2)'@//, !<!#+ "3+#! -%$!#7 / )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)'@/7 "##2!%2"2!3%2 &)2%$/)9)& +%9) / '#$&)& -$)!)1.
D %6% #+/' -$/&%$.
Q2,$<2#% ),@/#'%$'#% #86%"2!# #8$)2/9#"> ! )$8/2$)* '<7 "3+ " /",#& , -$#/:!#+"2!%''#&3 ,##-%$)2/!3 / #86%"2!3 " #($)'/;%''#7 #2!%2"2!%''#"2>= # -$/:')'// '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#7 ('/;2#*'#7) "+%9,/ - +#(#!#$) 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, :) ,9=;%''#(# &%*+3 #2!%2;/,)&/.
.%G%'/%& "3+) -%$!#7 /'"2)'@// /",#!<% 2$%8#!)'/5 3+#!9%2!#$%'<. C#"2)'#!9%'/%& "3+) )-%995@/#''#7 /'"2)' @// $%G%'/% #"2)!9%'# 8%: /:&%'%'/5.
C$#!%$/! -$)!/9>'#"2> -$/&%'%'/5 '#$& &)2%$/)9>'#(# / -$#@%""3)9>'#(# -$)!), "3+ ,)"")@/#''#7 /'"2)'@// '% ')G%9 #"'#!)'/7 +95 3+#!9%2!#$%'/5 *)9#8< #86%"2!) " #($)'/;%' '#7 #2!%2"2!%''#"2>= / #"2)!/9 "3+%8'<% ),2< 8%: /:&%'%'/5 -# "9%+3=6/& #"'#!)'/5&.
A), "9%+#!)9# /: &)2%$/)9#! +%9), /"2%@ /&%9 :)+#9*%' '#"2> -%$%+ -$#/:!#+"2!%''<& ,##-%$)2/!#&. 4 -#"9%+3=6%& -$#/:!#+"2!%''<7 ,##-%$)2/! -# +#(#!#$3 @%""// 3"23-/9 #8 6%"2!3 " #($)'/;%''#7 #2!%2"2!%''#"2>= -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 " /"2@).
13+ 3"2)'#!/9, ;2# %6% +# :),9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) @%""// -$#/:!#+"2!%''<7 ,##-%$)2/! / /"2%@ :),9=;/9/ "#(9)G%'/% # '#!)@// -%$!#');)9>'#(# #85:)2%9>"2!), "36%"2!#!)!G%(# &%* +3 '/&/, ! '#!#% #85:)2%9>"2!#, 2%& ")&<& #85:)''#"2> /"2@) 8<9) -$%,$)6%'), ) 3"23-9%''#% #86%"2!3 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , /"2@3 #2"32"2!#!)9#.
O+#!9%2!#$55 /",#!<% 2$%8#!)'/5, "3+< !"%? /'"2)'@/7 -$/G9/ , !<!#+3 # '/;2#*'#"2/ +#(#!#$) @%""//.
C# "&<"93 -. 1 "2. 382 KA .N 2#9>,# "36%"2!3=6%% -$)!# *%2 8<2> -$%+&%2#& 3"23-,/. 1#(9)"'# "2. 388 KA .N 3"23--
1 =6. -"+,.("051('1 NM= !"0"5H+&"F" "&/$F. ", 5 +1(,32/3 2000 F. No M49- 1638/00-82/18 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).
159
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
,) 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$#& +$3(#&3 9/@3 +#-3",)%2"5, %"9/ #') '% -$#2/!#$%;/2 :),#'3. A#9> ",#$# #85:)2%9>"2!# '#!/$#!)'#, 2# -%$%&%') 9/@) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%, -$%,$)6%''#& '#!)@/%7, -$#2/!#$%;/2 2$%8#!)'/5& (9. 24 KA .N. 19%+#!)2%9>'#,
+#(# !#$ @%""// 5!95%2"5 '%+%7"2!/2%9>'<& ,), -$#2/!#$%;)6/7 :),#'31.
D2),, ! #8#/? -$/!%+%''<? ')&/ -$/&%$)? "3+< "2#9,'3 9/"> " "/23)@/%7, ,#(+) -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ 3"23-/9 '# !#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5, ,#2#$#% 8<9# 9/8# '%+%7"2 !/2%9>'# (! -%$!#& "93;)%), 9/8# -$%,$)6%'# +# 3"23-,/, 2.%. ') &%'2 3"23-,/ '% "36%"2!#!)9# (!# !2#$#& "93;)%).
4 #8#/? +%9)? "3+< ),2/!'# ""<9)9/"> ') "2. 382 KA .N. T')9/:/$35 %% -#9#*%'/5, "3+< +%9)9/ !<!#+ # +#-3"2/"2/ 3"23-,/ 2#9>,# "36%"2!3=6%(#, +%7"2!/2%9>'#(# -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5, # :),#''#"2/ "#(9)G%'/5 # @%""// 2#9>,# -$/ 3"9#!// -%$%+);/ 2#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, ,#2#$<& -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$% +/2#$ ') &%'2 3"23-,/ +#9*%' '%-$%&%''# #89)+)2>. H) ')G !:(95+, " #8#"'#!)''#"2>= 2),#(# -#+?#+) 2$3+'# "#(9)"/2>"5.
B%9# ! 2#&, ;2# ! @%9#& -#9#*%'/5 (9. 24 KA .N $%(39/$3 =2 #2'#G%'/5, "!5:)''<% " -%$%&%'#7 9/@) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%. C3',2 1 "2. 382 KA .N 3"2)')!9/!)%2 #"'#!)'/5
-%$%?#+) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) , '#!#&3 (2),/&/ #" '#!)'/5&/ 5!95=2"5 "+%9,) / :),#'), #+'),# -#9#*%'/5 -. 1 "2. 382 KA .N, ') ')G !:(95+, '% 3"2)')!9/!)=2 ,),/?-9/8# 2$% 8#!)'/7 "#8"2!%''# , ")&3 "#(9)G%'/= # @%""//. J"9/ -%$
!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ '/,),/& -$)!#& 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3 '% #89)+)9, %"9/ I2# -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 '% "36%"2!3%2 !##86%, %"9/ #'# '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#, 2# / '% -$#/"?#+/2 '/,),#7 -%$%&% '< 9/@) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% (-#2#&3 ;2# / '%2 '/,),#(# #85:)2%9> "2!) &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / +#9*'/,#&), '/,),#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 '% -%$%?#+/2 , '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 '/ ') #"'# !)'// "+%9,/, '/ ') #"'#!)'// :),#'), '/,),#(# +#9() 3 +#9*-
1 =6. -"+,.("051('1 NM= =101/"-S.-.A("F" "&/$F. ", 26 A1&.2/3 2000 F. No M5621260/2000 (<!= «8"(+$5D,.(,!5O+»).
160
§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:
'/,) '%2. D&%''# 2),#!< -#"9%+"2!/5 2), '):<!)% -%$%+);/ '%"36%"2!3=6%(# ('%+%7"2!/2%9>'#(#) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5.
C3',2 1 "2. 382 KA .N '/,), '% $%G)%2 "3+>83 ")(# "# (9)G%'/5 # @%""//. Q') $%G)%2"5 ,), "3+>8) 9=8#(# /'#(# "# (9)G%'/5 &%*+3 "2#$#')&/, -# ,#2#$#&3 #+') "2#$#') #85:)') "#!%$G/2> #-$%+%9%''<% +%7"2!/5 (-%$%+)2> /&36%"2!#, 3-9) 2/2> +%'>(/, !<-#9'/2> $)8#23, #,):)2> 3"93(3), '# -# 2%& /9/ /'<& -$/;/')& (/9/, ')#8#$#2, 8%: ,),/?-9/8# -$/;/') +)''3= #85:)''#"2> '% /"-#9'5%2.
H%/"-#9'%'/% +#9*'/,#& -$/'52#7 ') "%85 #85:)''#"2/ (! +)''#& "93;)% - '%/"-#9'%'/% @%+%'2#& #85:)''#"2/ -# -% $%+);% @%""/#')$/= -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5) '%#8?#+/ $)"@%'/!)2> '% ,), #8"2#52%9>"2!#, "!/+%2%9>"2!3=6%% # '%+%7"2!/2%9>'# "2/ "+%9,/, ) ,), ')$3G%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!). 4 2),#& "93;)% #85 :)''#% 9/@# +#9*'# '%"2/ #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%/"-#9'%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!).
B%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> "+%9,/ -# 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 '% +#9*') "2)!/2>"5 ! :)!/"/"2> #2 +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ -$)!), ,# 2#$#% -%$%+)%2"5 '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3. H%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 3"23- 9%''#(# -$)!) !9%;%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> @%+%'2), ) '% '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'#"2> "+%9,/ 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5. B)''<7 !<!#+ *'# "+%9)2> /: -#9#*%'/7 "2. 390 KA .N, ! "##2!%2"2!// " ,#2#$#7 -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$, 3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/%, #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''#(# %&3 2$%8#!)'/5.
C$%+"2)!95%2"5, ;2# #+'# 9/@# *%2 / +#9*'# '%"2/ #2 !%2"2!%''#"2> -%$%+ +$3(/& 9/@#& 2#9>,# 2#(+), ,#(+) #'/ 5! 95=2"5 "2#$#')&/ ,),#(#-9/8# -$)!##2'#G%'/5.
B#(#!#$#& -$/:')%2"5 "#(9)G%'/% +!3? /9/ '%",#9>,/? 9/@ #8 3"2)'#!9%'//, /:&%'%'// /9/ -$%,$)6%'// ($)*+)'",/? -$)! / #85:)''#"2%7. 4 2#& "93;)%, ,#(+)
#+'# 9/@# #85:3%2"5 -%$%+ +$3(/& 9/@#& -%$%+)2> -#"9%+'%&3 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3, &%*+3 +)''<&/ 9/@)&/ 3"2)')!9/!)%2"5 #85:) 2%9>"2!%''#%, ) /&%''# +#(#!#$'#% -$)!##2'#G%'/%.
11. C#;37,/' 4 4 161
U U
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
4 =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23$% #"'#!)'/%& #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ 2$)+/@/#''# -$/:')%2"5 -$)!#')$3G%'/%. C# "&<"93 "2. 390 KA .N, @%+%'2 '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) ')$3G%'/% +#(#!#$'#(# #85:)2%9>"2!).
H%+%7"2!/2%9>')5 "+%9,) '% !9%;%2 =$/+/;%",/? -#"9%+"2 !/7, :) /",9=;%'/%& 2%?, ,#2#$<% "!5:)'< " %% '%+%7"2!/2%9> '#"2>=. C$/ I2#& ,)*+)5 /: "2#$#' #85:)') !#:!$)2/2> +$3(#7 !"% -#93;%''#% -# "+%9,%.
S),/& #8$):#&, %"9/ @%+%'2 3"23-/9 @%""/#')$/= '%+%7"2 !/2%9>'#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 /, -# &'%'/= "3+#!, ! "!5:/ " I2/& "#(9)G%'/% #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 5!95%2"5 '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'<&, 2# @%+%'2 +#9*%' !"%(# 9/G> !#:!$)2/2> @%""/#')$/= !"% -#93;%''#% #2 -#"9%+'%(#, #+'),# "2. 390 KA .N (#!#$/2 /&%''# #8 #2!%2"2!%''#"2/.
\$/+/;%",)5 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> -$%+"2)!95%2 "#8#7 #+'3 /: E#$& (#"3+)$"2!%''#- -$/'3+/2%9>'#(# !#:+%7"2!/5 ') ')$3G/ 2%9%7 '#$& -$)!), :),9=;)=63="5 ! -$/&%'%'// , '/& -$%+3 "$%''<? :),#'#& ")',@/7 - &%$ #2!%2"2!%''#"2/,
!9%,36/? +95 '/? +#-#9'/2%9>'<% '%89)(#-$/52'<% -#"9%+"2!/51.
S),/& #8$):#&, "#(9)G%'/% #8 3"23-,% -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, '%"$5 ') 2# ;2# E),2/;%",/ -$%+&%2#& +#(#!#$) 5!95%2"5 "#!%$G%'/% @%+%'2#& +%7"2!/7 -# -%$%+);% @%""/#')$/= '% +%7"2!/2%9>'#(# ('%"36%"2!3=6%(#) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9* '/,3 /9/ 2),#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, ,#2#$<& @%+%'2 '% #89)+)%2, 5!95%2"5 +%7"2!/2%9>'<& / /&%''# '%/"-#9'%'/% @%+%'2#& "!# %7 #85:)''#"2/ -# +)''#&3 "#(9)G%'/= !9%;%2 %(# #2!%2"2!%' '#"2> -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%&.
A), -/G%2 4.T. V%9#!, «+#9*'/, ! "/93 "2)2>/ 386 KA .N /&%%2 -$)!# -$#2/!#-#"2)!/2> '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 !"% 2% !#:$) *%'/5, ,#2#$<% #' ( 8< !<+!/'32> -$#2/! "2)$#(#, ! 2#& ;/"-
' =6.: C%,9$+"' 2.3. J,01,+,01(("+,D L. (./$I1('1 F/.HA.(+&'X -/.0 ' "23
L.(("+,1%. ?. 1973. =. 38-39. 7.(("1 "-/1A151('1 -"(3,'3 «",01,+,01( ("+,D» 0"+-/"'L01A1(" 0 "A("6 'L +"0/161((4X $#12('&"0. =6.: U/.HA.( +&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / J,0. /1A. -/"E. :.M.=$X.("0. ) 2 ,. G. I. ?.: 9:8, 1998. =. 429.
162
§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:
9% / !#:$)*%'/% /: '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ #"'#!)'/5 !#:'/,'#!% '/5 2$%8#!)'/7, -#"9% ;%(# @%""/#')$/7 -#93;)%2 -$)!# #8$) 2/2>"5 # %&=%#"< (,3$"/! . - 2.3.) ,
@%+%'23 ') #"'#!)'// "2)2>/ 390 KA .N»1.
1 2),/& &'%'/%& 2$3+'# "#(9)"/2>"5. H% "#!"%& -#'52'# #"'#!)'/% !#:'/,'#!%'/5 3 @%""/#')$/5 $%($%""'#(# 2$%8#!) '/5 , @%+%'23. J"9/ -$#+)!%@ #85:3%2"5 -%$%+)2> -#,3-)2%9= '%,#% /&36%"2!# / '% /"-#9'5%2 "!#= #85:)''#"2>, 2# #' +#9
*%' '%"2/ -%$%+ -#,3-)2%9%& #2!%2"2!%''#"2>, '/,),#(# $%( $%""'#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 3 -#,3-)2%95 , -$#+)!@3 '%2. T')9#(/;')5 "/23)@/5 ",9)+<!)%2"5 / -$/ 3"23-,% '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5: @%+%'2 +#9*%' '%"2/ #2!%2"2!%''#"2>, '/,),#% $%( $%""'#% 2$%8#!)'/% @%""/#')$/5 , @%+%'23 '% !#:'/,)%2.
4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 390 KA .N -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$, 3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/%, #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)''#(# %&3 2$%8#!)'/5, '# '% #2!%;)%2 :) '%/"-#9'%'/% I2#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 +#9*'/,#&, ,$#&% "93;)5, ,#(+) -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ -$/'59 ') "%85 -#$3;/2%9>"2!# :) +#9*'/,) -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&.
4 =$/+/;%",#7 9/2%$)23$% !"2$%;)=2"5 ! #"'#!'#& ,#& &%'2)$// !2#$#(# -$)!/9), :),$%-9%''#(# ! "2. 390 KA .N (@% +%'2 '% #2!%;)%2 :) '%/"-#9'%'/% 3"23-9%''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5
+#9*'/,#&). C#I2#&3 #"2)'#!/&"5 ') '%,#2#$<? !#-$#")? #2 !%2"2!%''#"2/ -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) :) '%+%7"2!/2%9> '#"2> -%$%+)''#(# 2$%8#!)'/5 '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3.
O*% ! B$%!'%& ./&% 8<9/ 3"2)'#!9%'< -$)!/9), "!5:)''<% " -$%+%9)&/ #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ @%+%'2) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%&. ./& ",/% =$/"2< (#!#$/9/: ,2# -$#+)9 (@%+/$#!)9) 2$%8#!)'/% ! 2#& !/+%, ! ,),#& #'# 8<9#, 2#2 #85:)' #2!%;)2> 2#9>,# :) 2#, ;2# I2# 2$%8#!)'/% "36%"2!3%2, ) '% :) 2#, ;2# " +#9*'/,) *%2 8<2> ;2#-'/83+>
+%7"2!/2%9>'# !:<",)'#2.
1 N&-"& 2.(. ='(F$53/("1 -/.0"-/116+,0" 0 "23L.,15D+,01. =. 268. 2 =6.: >'6+&"1
#.+,("1 -/.0". =. 312.
/* 163
UU
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
§ 3. G7'&7#7'&++"#7M B&?&+7$ L$ +&?&/#7',7&-M+"#7M 8&%&?$++"=" 7%&9"'$+,:
+)''#(# %&3 2$%8#!)'/5...») '%2 / ')&%,) ') ,),/%-9/8# /",9= ;%'/5. Q+'),# '/*% &< 3!/+/&, ;2# I2# '% 2),.
C$%+"2)!95%2"5 9=8#-<2'<& "$)!'/2> '#$&<, "#+%$*) 6/%"5 ! "2. 390 KA .N, " )')9#(/;'<&/ '#$&)&/ :),#'#+)2%9> "2!) +$3(/? "2$)'.
S),, N$)'@3:",/7 ($)*+)'",/7 ,#+%," $):+%95%2 -#"9%+"2 !/5 3"23-,/ 2$%8#!)'/5 ! :)!/"/"2/ #2 !#:&%:+'#"2/ (8%:!#: &%:+'#"2/) 2),#7 3"23-,/. 4 "##2!%2"2!// "# "2. 1693 NKA ') -$#+)!@% 2$%8#!)'/5 /9/ +$3(#(# 8%"2%9%"'#(# -$)!) 9%*/2 () $)'2/5 2#(#, ;2# -$)!# "36%"2!#!)9# !# !$%&5 %(# -%$%?#+), ?# 25 8< ! ),2% # -%$%?#+% '%
8<9# 3,):)'# ') I23 ()$)'2/=1. S) ,/& #8$):#&, ! +)''#7 "2)2>% /&-%$)2/!'# ",):)'#
# ()$)'2// @%+%'2) (-$#+)!@)) +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ 3"23-)%(# /& '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3.
A#&&%'2/$35 -#9#*%'/5 "2. 1693 NKA, J. K#+I&I 3,):<!) %2 ') 2#, ;2# ()$)'2/5 -$)!) #2'#"/2"5 /",9=;/2%9>'# , "36%"2 !#!)'/= -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ! &%'2 -%$%+);/. R%+%'2 '% ()$)' 2/$3%2 -9)2%*%"-#"#8'#"2/ +#9*'/,) ("2. 1694 NKA), «#' 83+%2 #2!%;)2> 2#9>,# ! 2#& "93;)%, %"9/ -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 '% "36%"2 !#!)9#, %"9/ #'# 8<9# #8%""/9%'# !#:$)*%'/%&, %"9/ #'# -$/ ')+9%*)9# 2$%2>%&3 9/@3, /9/ %"9/ '%2
'%#8?#+/(# #8%"-%;% '/5»2.
H# I2) ()$)'2/5 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 !#:*') 2#9>,# ! 2#& "93;)%, %"9/ @%+%'2 5!95%2"5 -$#+)!@#&, 2.%. #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& 5!95=2"5 !#:&%:+'<&/. Q2!%;)%2 9/ @%+%'2 -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) '%+%/L "2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%+)!)%(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 ! 2#& "93;)%, %"9/ #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3
'/&/ 5!95=2"5 8%:!#:&%:+'<&/, ') I2#2 !#-$#" NKA -$5(# #2!%2) '% +)%23.
UU
C$),2/;%",/ )')9#(/;'<% '#$&< :),$%-9%'< ! :),#'#+) 2%9>"2!% &'#(/? (#"3+)$"2!. H)-$/&%$, ! "/93 § 437 K%$&)'",# (# ($)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5 -$#+)!%@ 2$%8#!)'/5 /9/ /'#(# -$) !) #2!%;)%2 :) +%7"2!/2%9>'#% "36%"2!#!)'/% I2#(# 2$%8#!)'/5
U U
/9/ -$)!)1.
H) #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 -$%*'/& / '#!<& !%$/2%95&/ (,$%+/
2#$)&/) #8$)6)9/ !'/&)'/% / $#""/7",/% +#$%!#9=@/#''<% @/!/9/"2<. S),, B.D. 0%7%$ -/")9: «R%+%'2 #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ @%" "/#')$/%& :) /"2/''#"2>, -#+9/''#"2>
#85:)2%9>"2!) (veritas)»2. C# &'%'/= K.N. Z%$G%'%!/;), -$%*'/7 !%$/2%9> #2!%;)%2 -% $%+ '#!<& :) 2#, ;2# -%$%+)9 %&3 !-#9'% +%7"2!/2%9>'#% -$)!#, '% /&%=6%% '/,),#(# =$/+/;%",#(# '%+#"2)2,). «J"9/ 8< #8 ')$3*/9#">, ;2# -%$%+)''#% -$)!# '% "36%"2!3%2 -# '%+%7"2!/ 2%9>'#"2/ #85:)2%9>"2!), ')-$/&%$ %"9/ #'# :),9=;%'# 8<9# '%"#!%$G%''#9%2'/& /9/ *% 3*% /"-#9'%'# (#-9);%''#% :)%& '#% -/">),
2#(+) -$%*'/7 !%$/2%9> #2!%;)%2 :) '%#"36%"2! 9%''<7 /'2%$%"»3.
C%$!<7 !<!#+, ,#2#$<7 *'# "+%9)2> /: "#+%$*)'/5 "2. 390 KA .N, 2),#!: @%+%'2 #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) '%/"-#9'%'/% +#9*'/,#& "!#/? #85:)2%9>"2! 2#9>,#
! 2#& "93 ;)%, ,#(+) -$/'59 ') "%85 -#$3;/2%9>"2!# :) +#9*'/,). C# #8 6%&3 *% -$)!/93 @%+%'2 '% '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) '%/"-#9 '%'/% +#9*'/,#& "!#/? #85:)2%9>"2!.
42#$#7 !<!#+ ')-$)G/!)%2"5 ")&: @%+%'2 !"%(+) '%"%2 #2 !%2"2!%''#"2> -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$% +)''#(# %&3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3. A):)9#"> 8<, ;2# "# &'%'/7 ! I2#& !<!#+% 8<2> '% +#9*'#, 2%& 8#9%% ! "2. 390 KA .N («-%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$, 3"23-/!G/7 2$%8#!)'/%, #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& :) '%+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> -%$%-
1[',. -": U1/6.(+&"1 -/.0". W. I. U/.HA.(+&"1 $5"H1('1 / !1/. + (16. (+1/'3: ="0/161(("1 L./$21H("1 ' 61HA$(./"A("1 #.+,("1 -/.0"). ?.: ?1HA$(. /"A(4% C1(,/ E'(.(+"0"-Y&"("6'#1+&"F" /.L0','3, 1996.
21&/&% I.). *&.L. +"#. =. 118.
3V&%K&+&',4 C.W. *&.L. +"#. =. 288.
164
1[',. -": N/.(C$L+&'% F/.HA.(+&'% &"A1&+ 1804 F"A. / !1/10"A <.=. !1/1,1/ +&"F". ?.: @/'A. 'LA-0" ;@J ===>, 1941.
2C"?D<D E. *&.L. +"#. =. 464.
3;1+6",/3 (. ",+$,+,0'1 0 NU8 ",01,. (. A.((4% 0"-/"+, >. =.0.,D1 &.,1F"
/'#(" L.30531,: «G",, &," -1/1A.1, -/.0" ,/12"0.('3 21L0"L61LA(", F./.(,' /$1, ,"5D&" +$K1+,0"0.('1 -/.0.». =6.: F$'$7M& @. *&.L. +"#. =. 374.
165
C-$'$ 3. 3"+:7,& , 8%$'"'$: 8%,%"?$ #"=-$K&+,: "9 5#758.& 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:
C# )!"2$/7",#&3 -$)!3 (§ 1397 T!"2$/7",#(# ($)*+)'",#(# 39#*%'/5), %"9/ 2$%8#!)'/% 3"23-)%2"5 8%: !#:')($)*+%'/5, 2.%. ! -#$5+,% +)$%'/5, 2# @%+%'2 '% '%"%2 #2!%2"2!%''#"2> :) I2# 2$%8#!)'/%; %"9/ *%, ')-$#2/!, 3"23-,) /&%%2 !#:&%:+'<7 ?) $),2%$, @%+%'2 #2!%;)%2 -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& :) =$/+/;%",3= -$)!/9>'#"2>
2$%8#!)'/5 (Richtigkeit)1.
4 "/93 ;. 1 "2. 171 Z!%7@)$",#(# #85:)2%9>"2!%''#(# :),# ') -$/ !#:&%:+'#7 3"23-,% 3"23-)=6/7 #2!%;)%2 :) +%7"2!/ 2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/5 ! &%'2 3"23-,/. 1#(9)"'# ;. 3 I2#7 *% "2)2>/ -$/ 8%:!#:&%:+'#7 3"23-,% 2$%8#!)'/5 3"23-)=6/7 '% #2!%;)%2 :)
+%7"2!/2%9>'#"2> 2$%8#!)'/52.
4#-$#"< #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ @%+%'2) -%$%+ @%""/#')$/%& -# !#:&%:+'#7 "+%9,% &< *%& #8')$3*/2> ! /"2#;'/,)? $/&",# (# -$)!): «A2# -$#+)9 +#9(#!#% 2$%8#!)'/%