Учебный год 22-23 / Pochuykin

«S), ,), "38M%,2/!'#% -$)!# -$%+-#9)()%2 ')9/;'#"2> "38M%,2), ) 8%""38M%,2'#% "36%"2!#!)'/% -$)!) !"2$%;)%2"5 9/G> ,), !$%&%''#% / "$)!'/2%9>'# $%+,#% /",9=;%'/%, - -/ G%2 4.0. F!#"2#!, - 2# !#:'/,'#!%'/% -$)!) %"2> ! 2# *% !$%&5 -$/#8$%2%'/% I2#(# -$)!) #-$%+%9%''<& 9/@#&. C$/#8$%2%'/% -$)!) %"2>

3"2)'#!9%'/% "!5:/ -$)!) " 9/@#&»1. 1##2!%2"2!%''# ! 2%? "93;)5?, ,#(+) "!5:> &%*+3 -$)!#& / 9/@#& $):$<!)%2"5, '%#8?#+/ (#!#$/2> # -$%,$)6%'// -$)!##2'#G%'/5 (! '%,# 2#$<? $)8#2)? +#$%!#9=@/#''<? =$/"2#! $%;> /+%2 #8 «3'/; 2#*%'//» -$)!)).

§ 2. !J;QG<: «*=G*!8M !>M)M G>:9J)M;<Q»

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

"-#"#8 -$%,$)6%'/5 -$)!) '):<!)9/ #2;3*+%'/%& -$)!) - alienatio2), ) '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& -$/#8$%2)%2"5. S),#% -$/#8$% 2%'/% '):<!)%2"5 -$#/:!#+'<&.

«F)$),2%$/:3=6/& -$/:'),#& 2),#(# -$)!#-$/#8$%2%'/5 (-$#/:!#+'#(#. - 2.3.) ! #29/;/% #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# -$)!#-$/ #8$%2%'/5 5!95%2"5 "!5:> &%*+3 -$/#8$%2%''<& -$)!#& /9/

P'"#7"' 2.1. ='+,16. /'6+&"F" -/.0.: *#12('&. ?.: =-./&, 1996. =. 139140.

2 =6. ,.6 H1. =. 143; V&%K&+&',4 C.W. *#12('& /$++&"F" F/.HA.(+&"F" -/.0. (-"

'LA. 1907 F.). ?.: =-./&, 1995. =. 60.

16

§ 2. 3"+:7,& «5#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:»

#85:)''#"2>= / -%$!#');)9>'<& -$)!##2'#G%'/%&» . C$/ -$# /:!#+'#& -$/#8$%2%'// -$)!# -$/#8$%2)2%95 #-/$)%2"5 ') -$) !#, "36%"2!#!)!G%% 3 -$)!#+)2%95, 2.%. -%$%?#+/2 , '%&3 "# !"%&/ -$%/&36%"2!)&/ (')-$/&%$, :)9#(, -#$3;/2%9>"2!#) / '% +#"2)2,)&/ (')-$/&%$, !#:$)*%'/5 +#9*'/,), ,#2#$<% #' ( 8< -$%+M5!/2> -%$!#');)9>'#&3 #89)+)2%9= -$)!)). C$)!# -$/ #8$%2)2%95 !"%(+) :)!/"/2 #2 2#(#, ,),#% -$)!# /&%9 -$)!#+)- 2%9>.

W/@#, ,#2#$#% -%$%+)%2 -$/#8$%2)2%9= "!#% -$)!#, ! $/& ",#& -$)!% /&%'#!)9#"> auctor, ) ")& -$/#8$%2)2%9> - successor. C$#/:!#+'#% -$/#8$%2%'/% -$)!) 5!95%2"5, " 2#;,/ :$%'/5 auctor'), -%$%+);%7 -$)!), ) " 2#;,/ :$%'/5 successor') - -$%%& "2!#& !

-$)!% - successio2.

«C32%& successio -%$%?#+52 '% 2#9>,# -$)!), '# / #85:)''# "2/, - -/")9 4.0. F!#"2#!, - +)*% "9#*'<% -$)!##2'#G%'/5, -#$#*+)=6/% /: "%85 -$)!) / #85:)''#"2/. H# !# !"%? "93;)5? -$/#8$%2%''<% successor'#& -$)!##2'#G%'/5 :)!/"52 #2 #8M%&) -$)!

auctor')»3.

S),/& #8$):#&, ! +)''#& "93;)% $%;> /+%2 # 2#& /'"2/232% ($)*+)'",#(# -$)!), ,#2#$<7 ! "#!$%&%''#& -$)!% '):<!)%2"5 -$)!#-$%%&"2!#&. C# "9#!)& V.V. ^%$%-)?/'), «-$)!#-$%%&"2!# %"2> -%$%?#+ "38M%,2/!'#(# -$)!) (! G/$#,#& "&<"9% - 2),*% -$)!#!#7 #85:)''#"2/) #2 #+'#(# 9/@) (-$)!#+)2%95) , +$3(#&3 (-$)!#-$%%&'/,3) ! -#$5+,% -$#/:!#+'#(# -$)!#-$/#8$%2%'/5 (! "##2!%2"2!3=6/?

"93;)5? - -$#/:!#+'#(# -$/#8$%2%'/5 -$) !#!#7 #85:)''#"2/)»4.

C# #8M%&3 -%$%+)!)%&<? -$)! / #85:)''#"2%7 -$)!#-$%%& "2!# +%9/2"5 ') 3'/!%$")9>'#% (successio universalis) / "/'(3 95$'#% (successio singularis). «C$/ 3'/!%$")9>'#& -$)!#-$%%& "2!% /&36%"2!# 9/@) ,), "#!#,3-'#"2> -$)! / #85:)''#"2%7, %&3

1 *&%&8$J,+ N.N. !/.0"-/116+,0" -" +"01,+&"6$ F/.HA.(+&"6$ -/.0$. ?.:

U"+O/'LA.,, 1962. =. 7.

" F,.:P'"#7"' 2.1. *&.L. +"#. =. 140. G.6 H1. =. 141.

4 *&%&8$J,+ N.N. *&.L. +"#. =. 6.

2. C#;37,/' 4. 4. /7

UU

§ 2. 3"+:7,& «5#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:»

4 "##2!%2"2!// " -. 1 "2. 382 KA .N -$)!# (2$%8#!)'/%), -$/')+9%*)6%% ,$%+/2#$3 ') #"'#!)'// #85:)2%9>"2!), *%2 8<2> -%$%+)'# /& +$3(#&3 9/@3 -# "+%9,% (3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5) /9/ -%$%72/ , +$3(#&3 9/@3 ') #"'#!)'// :),#'). S),/& #8$) :#&, '#$&< +)''#7 "2)2>/ 3"2)')!9/!)=2 +!) #"'#!)'/5 -%$% ?#+) -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3. C%$!<& 2),/& #"'#!)'/%& 5!95%2"5 "+%9,), !2#$<& - :),#'.

H%#8?#+/ #8$)2/2> !'/&)'/% ') 2#, ;2# :),#'#+)2%9>, (#!#$5 # -%$!#& #"'#!)'//, ! ",#8,)? 3,):)9: «3"23-,) 2$%8#!) '/5». S),/& #8$):#&, 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 - I2# ;)"2'<7 "93;)7 -%$%&%'< ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%, -%$%&%'<, #"'#!) '/%& ,#2#$#7 5!95%2"5 "+%9,).

A "#*)9%'/=, /'#(+) !"2$%;)%2"5, ') ')G !:(95+, '% "#!"%& -$)!/9>'#% -#'/&)'/% -#'52/5 «3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5». S),, )!2#$< #+'#(# /: 3;%8'/,#! -# ($)*+)'",#&3 -$)!3, ,#& &%'2/$35 '#$&< K$)*+)'",#(# ,#+%,") #8 /"-#9'%'// #85:) 2%9>"2!) 2$%2>/& 9/@#& (-. 2 "2. 313), #2&%;)=2, ;2# «! -#+#8 '#& "93;)%... /&%%2

&%"2# 3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5, "#!%$G)%&)5 ! "/93 :),#'), ) '% -# "#(9)G%'/= "2#$#'»1.

4 3;%8'/,% ($)*+)' ",#(# -$)!) -#+ $%+),@/%7 T.C. 1%$(%%!) / \.A. S#9"2#(# ",) :)'#, ;2# «! "/93 :),#') 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 *%2 /&%2>

&%"2# ! "93;)5?, -$%+3"$%''<? "2. 387 KA»2. 4 3;%8'/,% ($)*+)'",#(# -$)!) -#+ $%+),@/%7 J.T. 13?)'#!) @%""/5 #-$% +%9%') ,), «),2 -%$%+);/ (3"23-,/) -$)!) ! "/93 :),9=;%''#7 &%*+3 -$%*'/& ,$%+/2#$#& (@%+%'2#&) / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& (@%""/#')$/%&) "+%9,/ 9/8# ') #"'#!)'// /'<? -$%+3"$%' '<? '%-#"$%+"2!%''# :),#'#& =$/+/;%",/? E),2#!, -$/!#+5

6/7 , :)&%'% ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!%»3.

1U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& A53 0$L"0 / !"A "2K. /1A. A.O.(., -/"E. G.<. <55. /'"("0"%, &.O.(., A"C. 9.?. U"(F.5". ' &.O.(., A"C. ) M. !51,(10.. W. 1. ?.: <LA.,15D+&.3 F/$--. <(E/.?-;"/6., 1998. =. 368.

2U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / !"A /1A. M.!. =1/F110., @.8. G"5+,"F". W. I. ?:

<LA-0" G:<=, 1996. =. 469.

1 U/.HA.(+&"1 -/.0": *#12('& / J,0. /1A. -/"E. :.M. =$X.("0. ) 2 ,. G. II. !"5$ ,"6 1. =. 37.

18 2' 19

C-$'$ 1. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

' #,#7&<& =%$>?$+#.,J 8%$'""7+"K&+,/

-$/')+9%*)6/?, -%$%?#+/2 , -$)!#-$%%&'/,3 /9/ , -$)!#-$% %&'/,)& ,), %+/'#% @%9#%, -$/;%& ! I2#7 "#!#,3-'#"2/ %+/'<& ),2#& -%$%?#+52 !"% #2+%9>'<% -$)!) / #85:)''#"2/, -$/')+9% *)!G/% ') &%'2 -$)!#-$%%&"2!) -$)!#+)2%9=, '%:)!/"/

#2 2#(#, !<5!9%'< 9/ #'/ , I2#&3 &%'23 /9/ '%2»1. A9)""/;% ",/& -$/&%$#& 3'/!%$")9>'#(# -$)!#-$%%&"2!) 5!95%2"5 !"23- 9%'/% ! ')"9%+"2!#: , ')"9%+'/,3 -%$%?#+/2 !"5 ')"9%+"2!%'')5 &)"") ,), " -$)!)&/ 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,)& ')"9%+#+)2%95, 2), / " +#9()&/ -#"9%+'%(#.

^2# *% ,)")%2"5 "/'(395$'#(# -$)!#-$%%&"2!), 2# #'# « *%2 ,)")2>"5 #2+%9>'#(# -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 /9/ #2+%9>'#7 ($)* +)'",#--$)!#!#7 #85:)''#"2/. Q'# *%2 #?!)2<!)2> #-$%+% 9%''3= ($3--3 #85:)2%9>"2!%''<? 2$%8#!)'/7, #2+%9>'3= ($3--3

-$)!#!<? #85:)''#"2%7»2.

A), 3,):<!)9#"> !<G%, "38M%,2)&/ #85:)2%9>"2!) 5!95=2"5 ,$%+/2#$ / +#9*'/,, "38M%,2/!'<& -$)!#& ,$%+/2#$)- %(# -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3, ) "38M%,2/!'#7 #85:)''#"2>= +#9*'/,) - %(# +#9( ,$%+/2#$3. O;/2<!)5 I2# #8"2#52%9>"2!#, ) 2),*% !<G%3,):)''#% #-$%+%9%'/% "/'(395$'#(# (/9/ ;)"2'#(#) -$)!#-$%%&"2!), &< !/+/&, ;2# /:&%'%'/% ,$%+/2#$) ! #2+%9>'# !:52#& -$)!##2'#G%'// !9%;%2 -%$%?#+ , '#!#&3

,$%+/2#$3 -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 , +#9*'/,3, ) /:&%'%'/% +#9*'/,) - -%$%?#+ +#9() , '#!#&3 +#9*'/,3. 4# !"%& #"2)9>'#& -$)!##2'#G%'/% #"2)%2"5 '%/:&%''<&.

1/'(395$'#% -$)!#-$%%&"2!# ') "2#$#'% +#9*'/,) /&%'3 %2"5 «-%$%!#+#& +#9()» ("2. 391 / 392 KA .N), "/'(395$'#% -$) !#-$%%&"2!# ') "2#$#'% ,$%+/2#$) - «-%$%?#+#& -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3» ("2. 382-390 KA .N).

C$%+&%2#& ')G%(# /:3;%'/5 5!95%2"5 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, -#I2#&3 8#9%% -#+$#8'# $)""$/& '#$&<, $%(3 9/$3=6/% #86/% -#9#*%'/5 -%$%?#+) -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(# &3 9/@3.

U

1 *&%&8$J,+ N.N. *&.L. +"#. =. 20. 2 G.6 H1. =. 63.

C-$'$ 1. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

' #,#7&<& =%$>?$+#.,J 8%$'""7+"K&+,/

A), !/+'#, ! +)''<? "93;)5? -$#/"?#+/2 "&%G%'/% #"'#!) '/7 -%$%?#+) -$)! ,$%+/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3. 4 "/93 -#9#*%'/7 -. 2 "2. 313 KA .N / "2. 387 KA .N -$#/"?#+/2 -%$%&%') ,$%+/ 2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% ') #"'#!)'// :),#'), ) '% 3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5. Q @%""// *'# (#!#$/2> 2#9>,# ! 2#& "93;)%, ,# (+) #"'#!)'/%& -%$%&%'< ,$%+/2#$) ! #85:)2%9>"2!% 5!95%2"5 "+%9,).

Q2'#G%'/5, !#:'/,)=6/% ! "!5:/ " 3"23-,#7 -$)!) 2$%8# !)'/5, '%#8?#+/ #29/;)2> #2 /'<? #2'#G%'/7, ",9)+<!)= 6/?"5 ! ($)*+)'",#& #8#$#2%.

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«-%$%)+$%"#!)'/%& /"-#9'%'/5»'.

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

' )"QQ& G.F. J23L.,15D+,01(("1 -/.0". =. 78. 20

§ 2. 3"+:7,& «5#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:»

H%#8?#+/ 2),*% ;%2,# $):($)'/;/!)2> -%$%?#+ -$)! ,$% +/2#$) , +$3(#&3 9/@3 / $%($%""'<% 2$%8#!)'/5. S),/% $):9/ ;/5 &< $)""$/& ') -$/&%$% "38$#()@//, # ,#2#$#7 /+%2 $%;> ! -. 2 "2. 313 KA .N, )2),*% ! "2. 965 KA .N / ,#2#$)5 5!95%2"5 ;)"2'<& "93;)%& -%$%?#+) -$)! ,$%+/2#$) ') #"'#!)'// :),#').

138$#()@/5 - I2# !"23-9%'/% 2$%2>%(# 9/@) ! -$)!) ,$%+/ 2#$) -32%& /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)''#"2/ +#9*'/,); I2# -%$%&%') 9/@) ') "2#$#'% ,$%+/2#$) ! 3*% "36%"2!3=6%& #85:)2%9>"2!%; ;2# -%$%?#+ -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 , '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 ! 2#& #8M%&%, ! ,#2#$#& /"-#9'%') #85:)''#"2> :) +#9*'/,); I2# -%$%?#+ -$)!, #"'#!)'/%& !#:'/,'#!%'/5 ,#2#$<? 5!95=2"5 #2'#G%'/5

&%*+3 -%$!#');)9>'<& ,$%+/2#$#& / +#9*'/,#&. .%($%"" - I2# !"%(+) '#!#% #85:)2%9>"2!#; I2# '% -%$%?#+ -$)!, ) !#:'/,'#!% '/% '#!<? -$)!.

«138$#()@/= ,), :)&%'3 ,$%+/2#$) ! 3*% "36%"2!3=6%&, $)'%% !#:'/,G%& #85:)2%9>"2!% '%#8?#+/ #29/;)2> #2 $%( $%""'#(# #85:)2%9>"2!) - '#!#(# #85:)2%9>"2!), ,#2#$#% $)'>G% '% "36%"2!#!)9#, ?#25 #'# / !#:'/,)%2 ') 8):% $)'%% "!5:<!)! G/? %(# 3;)"2'/,#! #2'#G%'/7 / ! "/93 =$/+/;%",#(# E),2), !#:*'#"2> ')"23-9%'/5 ,#2#$#(# -$%+3"$%') I2/&/ #2'# G%'/5&/», - -/G%2 4.T.

.)?&/9#!/;. «Q2 =$/+/;%",#7 -$/$# +< / "#+%$*)'/5 I2/? -$%+G%"2!3=6/? #2'#G%'/7 &%*+3 +#9*'/,#& / ,$%+/2#$#& $%($%""'#(# #85:)2%9>"2!) :)!/"/2 "#+%$*)'/%, #8M%& -$)! / #85:)''#"2%7 ! $%($%""'#& #85:)2%9> "2!% / 2#, ,),/& -$)!/9)& I2# #85:)2%9>"2!# -#+;/'5%2"5. C$/ "38$#()@// - :)&%'% ,$%+/2#$) ! "36%"2!3=6%& #85:)2%9>"2

! % - -$%+G%"2!3=6/% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 +#9*'/,#& / '#!<& ,$%+/2#$#& =$/+/;%",#(# :');%'/5 +95 +%7"2!/2%9>'#"2/ / "# +%$*)'/5 +)''#(# #85:)2%9>"2!)

'% /&%=2; ! 8#9>G/'"2!% "93 ;)%! #'/ !##86% #2"32"2!3=2»1.

H%#8?#+/ -#+;%$,'32>, ;2# 4.T. .)?&/9#!/; (#!#$/2 2#9>,# # "38$#()@//, 3-#&/')% ! "2. 965 KA .N. ^2# *% ,)-

1 @$J<,-"',4 2.(. ;"041 0'A4 +,/.X"0.('3 0 U/.HA.(+&"6 &"A1&+1 // @/'A'

#1+&'% 6'/. 1997. No 12. =. 22-23.

21

C-$'$ 1. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

' #,#7&<& =%$>?$+#.,J 8%$'""7+"K&+,/

")%2"5 -. 2 "2. 313 KA .N, 2# :+%"> "/23)@/5 #8$)2')5 (! ;)"2/ -#"9%+'%(# 32!%$*+%'/5 )!2#$)): :),#' -$5 3,):<!)%2, ;2# -$%+G%"2!3=6/% #2'#G%'/5 &%*+3 +#9*'/,#& / '#!<& ,$%+/ 2#$#& /&%=2 $%G)=6%% :');%'/%. V%: "#(9)"/5 +#9*'/,) 2$%2>% 9/@# *%2 :) "!#7 ";%2 3+#!9%2!#$/2> 2$%8#!)'/% ,$%+/2#$) 2#9>,# ! 2#& "93;)%, ,#(+) #'# -#+!%$()%2"5 #-)"'#"2/ 32$)2/2> "!#% -$)!# ') /&36%"2!#

+#9*'/,) ! "/93 3*% /&%=6/?"5 &% *+3 '/&/ #2'#G%'/7 ()$%'+), :)9#( / +$.). Q+'),# I2/ #2'#G% '/5 5!95=2"5 2#9>,# #+'/& /: #"'#!)'/7 "38$#()@// (')$5+3 " E),2#& 3+#!9%2!#$%'/5 2$%2>/& 9/@#& 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$)), +95 $%G%'/5 *% /'<? !#-$#"#! (')-$/&%$, "#+%$*)'/% / #8M%& -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5, -%$%?#+56/? #2 -%$!#');)9>'#(# ,$%+/2#$) , 2$%2>%&3 9/@3) #'/ '/,),#(# =$/+/;%",#(# :');%'/5 '% /&%=2.

4.4. 4/2$5'",/7 2),*% #8$)6)%2 !'/&)'/% ') 2#, ;2# $%( $%""'<% 2$%8#!)'/5 '% #2'#"52"5 , E#$&)& -%$%?#+) -$)! -# #85:)2%9>"2!3, ')-$#2/!, $%($%"" -#$#*+)%2 -$)!#. C$/ -%$%?# +% -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 '#!<7 ,$%+/2#$ -#93;)%2 I2# -$)!# ! 2#& !/+%,

,),#7 #'# /&%9# ') &%'2 -%$%?#+)1.

C#'52/5 «@%""/5», «3"23-,) -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5», «3"23-,) -$) !)», «3"23-,) 2$%8#!)'/5» 5!95=2"5 $)!'#:');'<&/. B.D. 0%7%$, (#!#$5 # "#(9)G%'// &%*+3 !%$/2%9%& (,$%+/2#$#&) / "2#$#' '/& 9/@#&, -$/#8$%2)=6/& -$)!# ('#!<& ,$%+/2#$#&), #2&% ;)9: «H) =$/+/;%",#& 5:<,% P)-)+) I2) "+%9,) '):<!)%2"5 #8<,'#!%''# @%""/%7 -$)!) (cessio, cession). C#-$3"",/ * '# '):!)2> %% #?&-."/ "9

5#758.& 8%$'$ /9/ -$#"2# 5#758."/ 8%$'$»1.

C#'52/5 «-$)!# ,$%+/2#$)», «2$%8#!)'/% ,$%+/2#$)», «-$) !# 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$)» 2),*% 5!95=2"5 $)!'#:');'<&/. 1# !$%&%''<7 K$)*+)'",/7 ,#+%," .N 3-#&/')%2 / -$)!# ,$%+/ 2#$) (-. 2 "2. 313, "2. 355, 365, 382-384, 387, -. 3 "2. 993), / 2$% 8#!)'/% ,$%+/2#$) ("2. 355, 382, 385, 386, 388-390, -. 2 "2. 993),

1 =6.: ;.$#("--/.&,'#1+&'% &"661(,./'% & #.+,' -1/0"% U/.HA.(+&"F" &"A1& +. >"++'%+&"% N1A1/.C'' A53 -/1A-/'('6.,151%. ?., 1999. =. 480.

22

§ 2. 3"+:7,& «5#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:»

/ -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 ,$%+/2#$) ("2. 355, 372, -. 2 "2. 385, "2. 965) / -$/ I2#& '% 3"2)')!9/!)%2 ,),/?-9/8# $):9/;/7.

4.T. V%9#! +)%2 2),#% #-$%+%9%'/% "#(9)G%'/= # @%""//: «B#(#!#$ "/'(395$'#7 "3,@%""// (),2/!'#7 @%""//) - I2# +!3 "2#$#''%% "#(9)G%'/%, ! "/93 ,#2#$#(# #+') "2#$#') (-%$!#') ;)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$, @%+%'2) -%$%+)%2 +$3(#7 "2#$#'% ('#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3, @%""/#')$/=) -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 /"-#9'%'/5 #85:)

2%9>"2!) 2$%2>/& 9/@#& (+#9*'/,#&, @%""/#')$#&), ) @%""/#') $/7 -$/#8$%2)%2 I2# -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 #2 @%+%'2) ') 3"9#!/5?, '% 3?3+G)=6/? -#9#*%'/5 +#9*'/,)»1.

H) ')G !:(95+, !,9=;)2> ! #-$%+%9%'/% +#(#!#$) @%""// 3,):)'/% ') 2#, ;2# @%""/#')$/7 -$/#8$%2)%2 -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 «') 3"9#!/5?, '% 3?3+G)=6/? -#9#*%'/5 +#9*'/,)», '%2 '/,) ,#7 '%#8?#+/"2/, 2), ,), «3?3+G%'/% -#9#*%'/5 +#9*'/ ,)» - I2# +#-#9'/2%9>'#% 8$%&5, +#-#9'/2%9>'<% #85:)''#"2/,

!#:9)()%&<% ') +#9*'/,). 4 "/93 -#9#*%'/7 -. 3 "2. 308 KA .N #85:)2%9>"2!# '% "#:+)%2 #85:)''#"2%7 +95 9/@, '% 3;)"2!3=6/? ! '%& ! ,);%"2!% "2#$#' (+95 2$%2>/? 9/@). B#9*'/, '% 5!95%2"5 3;)"2'/,#& "#(9)G%'/5 # @%""//, -#I2#&3 9=8<% 3"9#!/5 +)' '#(# "#(9)G%'/5, 3?3+G)=6/% -#9#*%'/5 +#9*'/,), 83+32 -#

-$#"23 +,47">+;<,, ) -%$!#');)9>'<7 ,$%+/2#$ / '#!<7 ,$% +/2#$ "!#/& "#(9)G%'/%& '/,), '% (32 9/G/2> -$)!) +#9* '/,) ""<9)2>"5 ') -$#-3", "$#,) /",#!#7 +)!'#"2/ ("2. 201

KA .N), !<+!/()2> !#:$)*%'/5 -$#2/! 2$%8#!)'/5 '#!#(# ,$% +/2#$) ("2. 386 KA .N), -$)!) :)5!/2> # :);%2% ("2. 412 KA .N), -#",#9>,3 +)''<% -$)!) ()$)'2/$#!)'< :),#'#&. B95 $%G%'/5 !#-$#"#!, 5!95%2"5 9/ "#"2#5!G)5"5 "+%9,) @%""/%7 /9/ '%2, 5! 95%2"5 9/ @%""/5 +%7"2!/2%9>'#7 /9/ '%2, 3"2)'#!9%'/% «3?3+ G%'/5 -#9#*%'/5 +#9*'/,)» '% /&%%2 ,),#(#-9/8# :');%'/5, 2), ,), '/,),#(# 3?3+G%'/5 ! -$/'@/-% '% *%2 8<2>.

)7$., 5#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,: (B#,:) - D7" #?&-.$ <&>?5 8&%'"+$4$-M+;<

.%&?,7"%"< , +"';< .%&?,7"%"<, 8" #-&?#7',&< ."7"%"/ :'-:&7#: #,+=5-:%+"& (4$#7+"&) 8%$'"8%&-

' N&-"' 2.(. ='(F$53/("1 -/.0"-/116+,0" 0 "23L.,15D+,01. ?, 2000. =. 140. 23

U U

2 1&/&% I.). *&.L. +"#. =. 116.

C-$'$ 1. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

' #,#7&<& =%$>?$+#.,J 8%$'""7+"K&+,/

&<#7'": 8&%&<&+$ .%&?,7"%$ ' "9:L$7&-M#7'& # #"J%$+&+, &< '#&J "#7$-M+;J D-&<&+7"' "9:L$7&-M#7'&++"=" 8%$'""7+" K&+,:.

§ 3. <=GJ><Q >MS)<G<Q *=G*!8< !>M)M G>:9J)M;<Q

K$)*+)'",#--$)!#!)5 ,)2%(#$/5 3"23-,/ -$)!) 2$%8#!)'/5 (@%""/5) 3?#+/2 "!#/&/ ,#$'5&/ ! $/&",#% ;)"2'#% -$)!#. S) ,/& #8$):#&, @%""/5 ! 2#& !/+%, ! ,#2#$#& &< !/+/& I2#2 /' "2/232 ! "#!$%&%''#& -$)!%, "E#$&/$#!)9)">, -$#7+5 +#9(/7 / "9#*'<7 -32>.

Q85:)2%9>"2!# ! $/&",#& -$)!% '#"/9# "2$#(# 9/;'<7 ?) $),2%$1 . P),9=;)5 +#(#!#$, ,$%+/2#$ /"?#+/9 /: 2#(#, ;2# #85:) 2%9>"2!# 83+%2 /"-#9'%'# /&%''# +#9*'/,#&, ) -#"9%+'/7 ";/ 2)9 "%85 "!5:)''<& 2#9>,# -%$%+ «"!#/&» ,$%+/2#$#&.

B#(#!#$ -$%+"2)!959"5 ,), "#=:, "!5:<!)=6/7 %(# 3;)"2 '/,#! !#%+/'#, ,), «=$/+/;%",)5 "!5:>» («vinculum iuris»). D -#2#&3 "2)'#!/2"5 2$3+'# -$%+"2)!/2>, ;2# 2$%2>% 9/@#, ')?# +56%%"5 !'% +#(#!#$), (9# 8< #-$%+%9%''<& #8$):#& ! '%& 3;)"2!#!)2>, ,),/&-9/8# #8$):#& -$/#8$%2)2> -$)!) ,$%+/2#$) 9/8# :)&%'52> -#"9%+'%(# -#9'#"2>=. Q2"=+) / !<2%,)9/ #8 6/% -$)!/9): '%-%$%+)!)%"2> -$)!,

'%!#:*'#"2> /"-#9'% '/5 #85:)2%9>"2!) 2$%2>/& 9/@#& " #+'#!$%&%''<& -%$%?#+#& , -#"9%+'%&3 !"%? -$)! ,$%+/2#$), '%!#:*'#"2> :),9=;%'/5 +#(#!#$) ! -#9>:3 2$%2>%(# 9/@) («Alteri stipulari nemo potest» - «'/,2# '% *%2 +#(#!)$/!)2>"5 !

-#9>:3 -#"2#$#''%(#» (O9>- -/)'B. 45. 1,38. 17))2.

W/;'<7 ?)$),2%$ #85:)2%9>"2!) -#$#*+)9 / 9/;'<7 ?)$), 2%$ #2!%2"2!%''#"2/ +#9*'/,). H% 3-9)2/!G/7 ! "$#, +#9() (# 9#!#7 !<+)!)9"5 ,$%+/2#$3. T.D. A#")$%! -$/!#+/2 "9%+3=6/7 -$/&%$: «Q2$/@)2%9>'<% -#"9%+"2!/5 '%/"-#9'%'/5 #85:)2%9>-

1

2 =6.: H"',B.,/ ).N. >'6+&"1 -/.0". ?., 1996. =. 140-141.

A'$/=&%7 !., !&7BP. *&.L. +"#. =. 181. 24

§ 3. )#7"%,: %$L',7,: 5#758., 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

"2!), ')-$/&%$ -$/ :)7&%, !<$)*)9/"> ! 3"2)'#!9%'// ,$%+/2# $ # & "!#%7 !9)"2/ ')+ 9/;'#"2>= +#9*'/,). A$%+/2#$ «')9) ()9 ') +#9*'/,) $3,3» - ( 60 +'%7 +%$*)2> %(# ! "!#%& -#+!)9% :),#!)''<& ! @%-/. 4 2%;%'/% I2#(# !$%&%'/ +#9*'/, 2$/*+< !<!#+/9"5 ') (#$#+",3= -9#6)+> ! $)";%2% ') 3-9)23 +#9() ,%&-9/8# /: %(# +$3:%7 / 89/:,/?, ) ! 2$%2/7 8):)$'<7 9%'> -$%+)!)9"5 "&%$2'#7 ,):'/ /9/ -#"23-)9 !

-$#+)*3 :) ($) '/@3»1.

S),/& #8$):#&, :)&%') ! #85:)2%9>"2!% ,$%+/2#$) /9/ +#9*'/,) -%$!#');)9>'# ! $/&",#& -$)!% '/,#(+) '% $)""&)2 $/!)9)">, 2), ,), !<8<2/% #+'#7 /: "2#$#' )!2#&)2/;%",/ !9%, 9# / -$%,$)6%'/% #85:)2%9>"2!). «D",9=;%'/% +%9)9#"> 2#9>,# +95 "93;)%! "&%$2/ ')"9%+#+)2%95, -#",#9>,3 ') ')"9%+'/,) (/9/ ')"9%+'/,#!) -%$%?#+/9# -$%%&"2!# ! -$)!)? / #85:)''# "25?», - -/G%2 P.0. ^%$'/9#!",/7. H)

')"9%+'/,#! #2@) " $%9/ ,), ') «-$#+#9*)2%9%7 %(# 9/;'#"2/»2.

«C$/#8$%2%'')5 #+')*+< +95 ,#(#-'/83+> "2/-395@/5 (-$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5) #8<;'# '% -%$%?#+/2 , +$3(#&3 :) /",9=;%'/%& -%$% ?#+) , ')"9%+'/,3.. .»3.

B%7"2!/2%9>'#, +95 -$)!#-$%%&"2!) ! -#$5+,% ')"9%+"2!) ! B$%!'%& ./&% '% 8<9#

'/,),/? -$%-52"2!/74. V#9%% 2#(#, ! ?# :57"2!%''#7 */:'/ $/&95' ),2/!'#% $)"-$#"2$)'%'/% -#93;/9) 3"23-,) -$)! 2$%8#!)'/5 -$/ -$#+)*% ')"9%+"2!%''#7 &)""<. Q8 I2#& -#+$#8'# (#!#$/2 K)7, ,#2#$<7 !<+%95%2 +!) "93;)5 -$#+)*/ ')"9%+"2!).

4 -%$!#& "93;)% ')"9%+'/, :)5!959 # -$#+)*% +# -$/'52/5 ')"9%+"2!), -$/ I2#& !"% -$)!) ')"9%+'/,) -#9'#"2>= -%$%?# +/9/ , -#,3-)2%9=: «J"9/ 2#2, , ,#&3 -%$%?#+/2 ')"9%+"2!# -# P),#'3, 3"23-/2 %(# in jure +$3(#&3 +# -$/'52/5 ')"9%+"2!), 2. %.

' !"#$%&' (.). >'6+&"1 -/.0". ?.: @/'A. 5',., 1986. =. 36.

'' *&%+,-"'#.,/ 0.1. B1&C'' -" /'6+&"6$ #.+,("6$ -/.0$. ?.: @/'A. 5',.,

1991. =. 145-146.

F7'F1+,4 @+,'('.(.. <L2/.((41 E/.F61(,4 0 -1/10"A1 ' + -/'61#.('36' | <.=. !1/1,1/+&"F". ?.: <LA-0" «;.$&.», 1984. =. 145.

* =6.: H"',B.,/ ).N. *&.L. +"#. =. 141.

25

C-$'$ 1. 6#758.$ 8%$'$ 7%&9"'$+,:

' #,#7&<& =%$>?$+#.,J 8%$'""7+"K&+,/

-$%*+% ;%& "+%9)9"5 ')"9%+'/,#&, 2# 2#2, ,#&3 3"23-9%'# ') "9%+"2!#, "2)'#!/2"5 ')"9%+'/,#& "#!%$G%''# 2),, ,), %"9/ 8< #' 8<9 -$/:!)' , ')"9%+#!)'/= ! "/93

:),#')...»1. S%-%$> '/ +#9*'/,, '/ +%7"2!/2%9>'<7 ')"9%+'/, '% (32 #"-#$/2> -$) !) '#!#(# ,$%+/2#$), 2), ,), -#"9%+'/7 83+%2 2$%8#!)2> /"-#9 '%'/5 #85:)2%9>"2!), #89)+)5 !"%&/ -#9'#/5&/ ')"9%+'/,).

42#$#7 "93;)7 - -$#+)*) ')"9%+"2!%''#7 &)""< -#"9% -$/ '52/5 ')"9%+"2!): «...%"9/ *% -%$!<7 3"23-/2 ')"9%+"2!# -#"9% %(# -$/'52/5, 2# 2%& '% &%'%% #' ')"9%+3%2 / -#2#&3 83+%2 #2 !%2"2!%''<& -%$%+ !%$/2%95&/, ) +#9(/ -#()G)=2"5: 2),/& #8 $):#& +#9*'/,/ ')"9%+'/,) /:!9%,)=2 !<(#+3, ) ')"9%+"2!%' ')5 &)"") -%$%?#+/2 , 2#&3, ,#&3 3"23-9%'), "#!%$G%''# 2),,

,), %"9/ 8< #2+%9>'<% -$%+&%2< 8<9/ %&3 -%$%+)'< ;%$%: "3 +56/? -$%2#$#&»2. D2),, ! 2),#7 "/23)@// ')"9%+'/, #"2)%2"5 +#9*'/,#& -%$%+ "!#/&/ ,$%+/2#$)&/, ')"9%+"2!%'')5 &)"") ! !/+% #2+%9>'<? !%6%7 -%$%?#+/2 , -#,3-)2%9= ')"9%+"2!), )

!"% +#9(#!<% 2$%8#!)'/5 ')"9%+#+)2%95 -#()G)=2"53.

A), !/+/&, ! $%:39>2)2% -$#+)*/ ')"9%+"2!) -#9'<7 -%$% ?#+ !"%? -$)! , '#!#&3 ,$%+/2#$3 +#-3",)9"5, '# 2#9>,# ! "93 ;)% -$#+)*/ ')"9%+"2!) +# %(# -$/'52/5, ) !#2 -%$%?#+ #2+%9> '<? 2$%8#!)'/7 '% +#-3",)9"5 !##86%.

4 $):!/2#& ($)*+)'",#& #8#$#2% 2),#% -#9#*%'/% !%6%7 '%&<"9/. 12$#(# 9/;'<7 ?)$),2%$ #85:)2%9>"2!) "# !$%&%'%& "2)9 -$%-52"2!#!)2> $):!/2/= I,#'#&/;%",/? #2'#G%'/7. 4#: '/,)9/ "/23)@//, ,#(+) T +#9*%' '%,#2#$3= +%'%*'3= "3& &3 4, ) 4 - 1 ! "##2!%2"2!// "# "!#/& #85:)2%9>"2!#& -%$%+ -# "9%+'/&. H% !<:<!)%2 "#&'%'/7, ;2# ! 2),#& "93;)% 4, ;2#8<

#"!#8#+/2>"5 #2 "!#/? #85:)2%9>"2! -%$%+ 1, $):3&'%% 3"23-/2> %&3 "!#% -$)!# 2$%8#!)'/5 , T, '# -#"9%+'/7 8<9 "!5:)' #85:) 2%9>"2!#& 2#9>,# " 4, -#I2#&3 ! "93;)% #8$)6%'/5 , '%&3 1

1 C$/. <(+,',$C'' / !1/. + 5.,. N. 7DK4(+&"F"; !"A /1A. ).M. =.015D10., B.B. 8"-

E.("0.. ?: @/'+,D, 1997. =. 93.