Научно-практический комментарий к Федеральному конституционному закону от 31 декабря 1996 г. № 1-ФКЗ «О судебной системе Российской Федерации» (2-е из
.pdfB>3>, CG0AB2CNB ;8 3@0640=5, =5 O2;ONI85AO AC4LO<8, 2 @01>B5 AC4>2 8;8 =5B. %CI5AB25==0O @07=8F0 :0A05BAO ;8HL AB0BCA0 AC1J5:B0, >ACI5AB2;ONI53> ?@02>AC485. ;O AC4L8 — MB> 45OB5;L=>ABL ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=0O 8 >ACI5AB2;O5BAO =0 ?>AB>O==>9 >A=>25, 4;O ?@82;5:05<>3> 2 >?@545;5==KE A;CG0OE 3@0640=8=0 — =5?@>D5AA8>=0;L=0O, =5?>AB>O==0O 45OB5;L=>ABL.
>=AB8BCF8O $( (G. 5 AB. 32) 8 :><<5=B8@C5<0O AB0BLO ?@54CA<0B@820NB 2>7<>6=>ABL
CG0AB8O 3@0640= $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O. C:20;L=>5 B>;:>20=85 40==>9 =>@<K ?>72>;O5B A45;0BL 2K2>4 > B><, GB> 8=K5 ;8F0, 0 8<5==> ;8F0, O2;ONI85AO 3@0640=0<8 8=>AB@0==KE 3>AC40@AB2, 0 B0:65 ;8F0 157 3@0640=AB20 CG0AB2>20BL 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O =5 <>3CB. ':070==K9 ?@8=F8?80;L=K9 70?@5B A2O70= A B5<, GB> B>;L:> C 3@0640= $>AA88 ACI5AB2C5B B0 CAB>9G820O ?@02>20O A2O7L A 3>AC40@AB2><, :>B>@0O ?@8405B F5==>ABL 8 A<KA; CG0AB8N 2 @50;870F88 ?C1;8G=>9 2;0AB8. 8F>, =5 O2;ONI55AO 3@0640=8=>< $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, :0: ?@028;>, 2@O4 ;8 ?@8=04;568B =0@>4C-8AB>G=8:C 2;0AB8, A;54>20B5;L=>,
:>=AB8BCF8>==K5 =>@<K > =5?>A@54AB25==>< 8 >?>A@54>20==>< A?>A>15 @50;870F88 2;0AB8 =5 <>3CB @0A?@>AB@0=OBLAO =0 MB> ;8F>.
#>4 3@0640=AB2>< $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 ?>=8<05BAO CAB>9G820O ?@02>20O A2O7L ;8F0 A $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F859, 2K@060NI0OAO 2 A>2>:C?=>AB8 8E 2708<=KE ?@02 8 >1O70==>AB59. A>>B25BAB288 A> AB. 5 (545@0;L=>3> 70:>=0 >B 31 <0O 2002 3. № 62-( «" 3@0640=AB25 $>AA89A:>9
(545@0F88» 3@0640=0<8 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 O2;ONBAO:
;8F0, 8<5NI85 3@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 =0 45=L 2ABC?;5=8O 2 A8;C C:070==>3> 70:>=0; ;8F0, :>B>@K5 ?@8>1@5;8 3@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 2 A>>B25BAB288 A C:070==K< 70:>=><.
>:C<5=B><, C4>AB>25@ONI8< 3@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, O2;O5BAO ?0A?>@B 3@0640=8=0 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 8;8 8=>9 >A=>2=>9 4>:C<5=B, A>45@60I85 C:070=85 =0 3@0640=AB2> ;8F0.
@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 <>65B 1KBL ?@8>1@5B5=>:
?> @>645=8N;
2 @57C;LB0B5 ?@85<0 2 3@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88;
2 @57C;LB0B5 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O 2 3@0640=AB25 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88;
?> 8=K< >A=>20=8O<.
><<5=B8@C5<0O AB0BLO (G. 1) CAB0=02;8205B, GB> ?>@O4>: CG0AB8O 3@0640= 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88
?@02>AC48O ?@54CA<0B@8205BAO D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><. #@54AB02;O5BAO, GB> 2A5 =>@<K, B0: 8;8 8=0G5 @53C;8@CNI85 C:070==CN 45OB5;L=>ABL 3@0640=, <>6=> @0745;8BL =0 B@8 :0B53>@88:
1)=>@<K, CAB0=02;820NI85 D>@<K CG0AB8O 3@0640= 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O;
2)?@>F5AAC0;L=K5 =>@<K, @53C;8@CNI85 ?>@O4>: CG0AB8O 3@0640= 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O;
3)AB0BCA=K5 =>@<K, B.5. ?>;>65=8O > ?@020E, >1O70==>ABOE, 30@0=B8OE 45OB5;L=>AB8 8 >B25BAB25==>AB8 3@0640=, CG0AB2CNI8E 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O.
2. !081>;55 @0A?@>AB@0=5==>9 D>@<>9 CG0AB8O 3@0640= $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 2
>ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O =0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L O2;O5BAO 8=AB8BCB ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59, ?@54CA<0B@820NI89 CG0AB85 3@0640= 2 C3>;>2=>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25 ?> >B45;L=K< :0B53>@8O< 45; 2 >?@545;5==KE 70:>=>< CA;>28OE. 0: CB25@6405BAO 2 ?@50<1C;5 ?>AB0=>2;5=8O #;5=C<05@E>2=>3> %C40 $( >B 22 =>O1@O 2005 3. № 23 «" ?@8<5=5=88 AC40<8 =>@< '3>;>2=>-
?@>F5AAC0;L=>3> :>45:A0 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, @53C;8@CNI8E AC4>?@>872>4AB2> A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59», A =0G0;0 2>7@>645=8O 2 $>AA88 MB>9 D>@<K AC4>?@>872>4AB20 >:>;>
31
20% >128=O5<KE 5653>4=> 70O2;ONB E>40B09AB20 > @0AA<>B@5=88 8E 45; A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE
70A540B5;59.
"ACI5AB2;5=85 AC4>?@>872>4AB20 A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59 C?><8=05BAO 2 A;54CNI8E =>@<0E >=AB8BCF88 $(:
2 G. 2 AB. 20, A>3;0A=> :>B>@>9 A<5@B=0O :07=L 2?@54L 4> 55 >B<5=K <>65B CAB0=02;820BLAO
D545@0;L=K< 70:>=>< 2 :0G5AB25 8A:;NG8B5;L=>9 <5@K =0:070=8O 70 >A>1> BO6:85 ?@5ABC?;5=8O ?@>B82 687=8 ?@8 ?@54>AB02;5=88 >128=O5<><C ?@020 =0 @0AA<>B@5=85 53> 45;0 AC4>< A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59;
2 G. 2 AB. 47, CAB0=02;820NI59, GB> >128=O5<K9 2 A>25@H5=88 ?@5ABC?;5=8O 8<55B ?@02> =0
@0AA<>B@5=85 53> 45;0 AC4>< A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59 2 A;CG0OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><;
2 G. 4 AB. 123, A>3;0A=> :>B>@>9, 2 A;CG0OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><,
AC4>?@>872>4AB2> >ACI5AB2;O5BAO A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59.
@0728B85 :>=AB8BCF8>==KE =>@< A>>B25BAB2CNI85 ?>;>65=8O A>45@68B '# $( (A<., =0?@8<5@, 3;. 42 «#@>872>4AB2> ?> C3>;>2=K< 45;0<, @0AA<0B@8205<K< AC4>< A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59»), :@><5 B>3>, 459AB2C5B ( «" ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;OE D545@0;L=KE AC4>2 >1I59 N@8A48:F88 2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88» (A<. :><<5=B0@89 : G. 2 AB. 5 0:>=0); A<. B0:65 ?>AB0=>2;5=85 #;5=C<0 5@E>2=>3> %C40 $( >B 22 =>O1@O 2005 3. № 23 «" ?@8<5=5=88 AC40<8 =>@< '3>;>2=>-?@>F5AAC0;L=>3> :>45:A0 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, @53C;8@CNI8E AC4>?@>872>4AB2> A CG0AB85< ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59».
% B>G:8 7@5=8O @50;870F88 :>=AB8BCF8>==>3> ?@8=F8?0 CG0AB8O 3@0640= 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O =5 <5=55 206=K< 4;O 45<>:@0B870F88 AC4>?@>872>4AB20 O2;O5BAO 8=AB8BCB 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;59, C@53C;8@>20==K9 ( «"1 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;OE 0@18B@06=KE AC4>2 AC1J5:B>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88».
%?5F8D8:0 8=AB8BCB0 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;59 ?@54>?@545;O5BAO >A>15==>ABLN 45;, @07@5H05<KE 40==K<8 AC40<8. A;8 2 C3>;>2=>< ?@>F5AA5 ?@82;5G5=85 3@0640= : CG0AB8N 2 >B?@02;5=88 ?@02>AC48O >1CA;>2;5=> =5>1E>48<>ABLN 70I8BK >B =5>1>A=>20==>3> C3>;>2=>3> ?@5A;54>20=8O 3@0640=, 8AE>4O 87 ?@8=OBKE 2 >1I5AB25 ?>=OB89 > A?@0254;82>AB8, B> 2 3@0640=A:8E 45;0E AB>@>=K ?@5A;54CNB ?@>B82>?>;>6=K5 G0AB=K5 8=B5@5AK. 0640O 87 AB>@>= AB@5<8BAO : 70I8B5 >B =5>1>A=>20==>3> 2<5H0B5;LAB20 2 55 G0AB=K5 45;0, 0 B0:65 : ?@8=C645=8N 4@C3>9 AB>@>=K 2K?>;=8BL >?@545;5==K5 459AB28O 8;8 157459AB2>20BL 2 A2>N ?>;L7C. #>MB><C CG0AB85 2 >B?@02;5=88 ?@02>AC48O ?> 3@0640=A:8< 45;0< 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;59, 30@0=B8@C5B C2068B5;L=>5 >B=>H5=85 : 70:>=C 8 AC4C, AB8<C;8@C5B A10;0=A8@>20==>ABL 8=B5@5A>2 CG0AB2CNI8E 2 45;5 ;8F =0 >A=>25 ?@8=F8?0 :>;;5380;L=>AB8 @0AA<>B@5=8O 0@18B@06=KE 45;, ?>2KH05B 4>25@85 : ?@02>AC48N 1;03>40@O <8=8<870F88 ?>AB>@>==53> 2>7459AB28O =0 =57028A8<>ABL ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>3> AC4L8 (A<. ?>4@>1=55 :><<5=B0@89 : G. 2 AB. 5 0:>=0).
3.><<5=B8@C5<0O AB0BLO (G. 2) >A>15==> 2K45;O5B B>B D0:B, GB> CG0AB85 ?@8AO6=KE 8
0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;59 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O O2;O5BAO 3@0640=A:8< 4>;3><.=0;>38G=K5 ?>;>65=8O A>45@60BAO B0:65 8 2 ( «" ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;OE D545@0;L=KE AC4>2 >1I59 N@8A48:F88 2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88», 8 ( «"1 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;OE 0@18B@06=KE AC4>2 AC1J5:B>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88».
#>=OB85 «3@0640=A:89 4>;3» 2 1>;LH8=AB25 A;CG052 @0AA<0B@8205BAO :0: <>@0;L=>-
MB8G5A:0O :0B53>@8O, :>B>@0O =5 8<55B =>@<0B82=>3> C@53C;8@>20=8O 8 ?@54?>;0305B 55 @50;870F88 A ?>78F88 2=CB@5==53> C15645=8O. A0<>< >1I5< 2845 3@0640=A:89 4>;3 2KABC?05B :0: :0B53>@8O, E0@0:B5@87CNI0O >B25BAB25==>ABL 3@0640=8=0 ?5@54 >1I5AB2>< 70 ?@8=OB>5 8<
32
@5H5=85, 2 B>< G8A;5 70 70:>==>ABL 8 >1J5:B82=>ABL ?@8 @0AA<>B@5=88 45;0 2 A>AB025 0@18B@06=>3> AC40. MB>9 A2O78 CAB0=>2;5=85 548=KE :@8B5@852 40==>3> ?>=OB8O =52>7<>6=> 8 ACI=>ABL C:070==>3> O2;5=8O >?@545;O5BAO :064K< 3@0640=8=>< 4;O A51O A0<>AB>OB5;L=>*(18).
0: >B<5G05B =0 MB>B AG5B . . 'H0:>2, E>BO CG0AB85 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O 2 :0G5AB25 ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59 =5 >?@545;5=> 70:>=>40B5;5< 2 :0G5AB25 N@848G5A:>9 >1O70==>AB8 3@0640=8=0, B.5. 2 :0G5AB25 04@5A>20==>3> 3@0640=8=C ?@54?8A0=8O, =58A?>;=5=85 8;8 =5=04;560I55 8A?>;=5=85 :>B>@>3> >15A?5G8205BAO A0=:F8O<8 N@848G5A:>3> E0@0:B5@0, B5< =5 <5=55, 2 G. 3 AB. 333 '# $( ?@54CA<>B@5=>, GB> 70 =5O2:C 2 AC4 157 C2068B5;L=>9 ?@8G8=K
?@8AO6=K9 70A540B5;L <>65B 1KBL ?>425@3=CB 45=56=><C 27KA:0=8N 2 ?>@O4:5, CAB0=>2;5==>< AB. 118 '# $(*(19). G. 4 AB. 333 '# $( B0:65 ?@54CA<>B@5=>, GB> ?@54A540B5;LAB2CNI89
?@54C?@56405B ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;59 > B><, GB> 2 A;CG05 =0@CH5=8O B@51>20=89, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE G0ABLN 2B>@>9 =0AB>OI59 AB0BL8, ?@8AO6=K9 70A540B5;L <>65B 1KBL >BAB@0=5= >B 40;L=59H53> CG0AB8O 2 @0AA<>B@5=88 C3>;>2=>3> 45;0 ?> 8=8F80B825 AC4L8 8;8 ?> E>40B09AB2C AB>@>=. MB>< A;CG05 >BAB@0=5==K9 ?@8AO6=K9 70A540B5;L 70<5=O5BAO 70?0A=K<.
4. G. 4 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 2 :0G5AB25 >1I59 =>@<K 70:@5?;5=>, GB> 70 2@5<O CG0AB8O 2
>ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O ?@8AO6=K< 8 0@18B@06=K< 70A540B5;O< 2K?;0G8205BAO 2>7=03@0645=85 87 D545@0;L=>3> 1N465B0. >=:@5B870F8O MB>9 =>@<K =0E>48B A2>5 >B@065=85 2 A>>B25BAB2CNI8E D545@0;L=KE 70:>=0E.
&0:, 2 G0AB=>AB8, AB. 6 ( «"1 0@18B@06=KE 70A540B5;OE 0@18B@06=KE AC4>2 AC1J5:B>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88» ?@54CA<>B@5=>, GB> 0@18B@06=><C 70A540B5;N ?@>?>@F8>=0;L=> :>;8G5AB2C @01>G8E 4=59, 2 B5G5=85 :>B>@KE >= CG0AB2>20; 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O, A>>B25BAB2CNI8< 0@18B@06=K< AC4>< AC1J5:B0 $( 70 AG5B A@54AB2 D545@0;L=>3> 1N465B0 2K?;0G8205BAO :><?5=A0F8>==>5 2>7=03@0645=85 2 @07<5@5 >4=>9 G5B25@B>9 G0AB8 4>;6=>AB=>3> >:;040 AC4L8 40==>3> 0@18B@06=>3> AC40, => =5 <5=55 ?OB8:@0B=>3> <8=8<0;L=>3> @07<5@0 >?;0BK B@C40, CAB0=>2;5==>3> 70:>=>40B5;LAB2>< $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 (A<. (545@0;L=K9 70:>= >B 19 8N=O 2000 3. № 82-( «" <8=8<0;L=>< @07<5@5 >?;0BK B@C40»).
&0:65 0@18B@06=><C 70A540B5;N 2>7<5I0NBAO :><0=48@>2>G=K5 @0AE>4K 2 ?>@O4:5 8 @07<5@5, :>B>@K5 CAB0=>2;5=K 4;O AC459 ?@8 :><0=48@>20=88 2 ?@545;0E $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88.
%B0BLO 11 ( «" ?@8AO6=KE 70A540B5;OE D545@0;L=KE AC4>2 >1I59 N@8A48:F88 2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88» >?@545;O5B, GB> 70 2@5<O 8A?>;=5=8O ?@8AO6=K< 70A540B5;5< >1O70==>AB59 ?> >ACI5AB2;5=8N ?@02>AC48O A>>B25BAB2CNI89 AC4 2K?;0G8205B 5<C 70 AG5B A@54AB2 D545@0;L=>3> 1N465B0 :><?5=A0F8>==>5 2>7=03@0645=85 2 @07<5@5 >4=>9 2B>@>9 G0AB8 4>;6=>AB=>3> >:;040 AC4L8 MB>3> AC40 ?@>?>@F8>=0;L=> G8A;C 4=59 CG0AB8O ?@8AO6=>3> 70A540B5;O 2 >ACI5AB2;5=88 ?@02>AC48O, => =5 <5=55 A@54=53> 70@01>B:0 ?@8AO6=>3> 70A540B5;O ?> <5ABC 53> >A=>2=>9 @01>BK 70 B0:>9 ?5@8>4.
#@8AO6=><C 70A540B5;N B0:65 2>7<5I0NBAO AC4>< :><0=48@>2>G=K5 @0AE>4K, 0 B0:65 B@0=A?>@B=K5 @0AE>4K =0 ?@>574 : <5ABC =0E>645=8O AC40 8 >1@0B=> 2 ?>@O4:5 8 @07<5@5, CAB0=>2;5==KE 70:>=>40B5;LAB2>< 4;O AC459 40==>3> AC40.
!F4FPO 9. ;0A=>ABL 2 45OB5;L=>AB8 AC4>2
$0718@0B5;LAB2> 45; 2> 2A5E AC40E >B:@KB>5. %;CH0=85 45;0 2 70:@KB>< 70A540=88 4>?CA:05BAO 2 A;CG0OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><.
33
КB@@9AF4D<= > EF. 9
1.:><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL5 CAB0=>2;5= >1I89 ?@8=F8? >ACI5AB2;5=8O ?@02>AC48O — 3;0A=>ABL AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20. %>3;0A=> ?. 1 AB. 123 >=AB8BCF88 $( @0718@0B5;LAB2> 45;
2> 2A5E AC40E >B:@KB>5. #>4 ?@8=F8?>< 3;0A=>AB8 ?>=8<05BAO A2>1>4=K9 4>ABC? 2 70; AC451=KE 70A540=89 2A5E 3@0640=, 65;0NI8E ?@8ACBAB2>20BL =0 ?@>F5AA5, 0 B0:65 8E ?@02> =0 D8:A0F8N 2A53> ?@>8AE>4OI53> 2 70;5 AC451=>3> 70A540=8O A 70=8<05<>3> <5AB0. &0:, =0?@8<5@, 2 G. 7 AB. 11
# $( CAB0=>2;5=>, GB> ;8F0, ?@8ACBAB2CNI85 2 >B:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88, 8<5NB ?@02> 45;0BL 70<5B:8 ?> E>4C AC451=>3> 70A540=8O, D8:A8@>20BL 53> A ?><>ILN A@54AB2 72C:>70?8A8.8=>- 8 D>B>AJ5<:0, 2845>70?8AL, 0 B0:65 B@0=A;OF8O AC451=>3> 70A540=8O 0@18B@06=>3> AC40 ?>
@048> 8 B5;52845=8N 4>?CA:05BAO A @07@5H5=8O AC4L8 — ?@54A540B5;LAB2CNI53> 2 AC451=>< 70A540=88. =0;>38G=CN =>@<C A>45@68B # $( (G. 7 AB. 10); > 3;0A=>AB8 8 >B:@KB>AB8 AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20 A<. B0:65 AB. 11 % $(; 2 '# $( 2>?@>A0< 3;0A=>AB8 ?>A2OI5=0 AB.
241.>=AB8BCF8>==>5 AC4>?@>872>4AB2> B0:65 >A=>20=> =0 ?@8=F8?5 3;0A=>AB8. 0: CAB0=>2;5=>
2AB. 31 ( «" >=AB8BCF8>==>< %C45 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88», @0AA<>B@5=85 45;, =07=0G5==KE
: A;CH0=8N 2 70A540=88 >=AB8BCF8>==>3> %C40 $(, O2;O5BAO >B:@KBK<.
;0A=>ABL AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20 — 206=0O 30@0=B8O 2K=5A5=8O >1>A=>20==KE 8 70:>==KE AC451=KE ?>AB0=>2;5=89 8 =5?@5<5==>5 CA;>285 ?>A;54CNI59 >F5=:8 A> AB>@>=K >1I5AB20 @01>BK AC4>2.
?>AB0=>2;5=88 #;5=C<0 5@E>2=>3> %C40 $( >B 13 45:01@O 2012 3. № 35 «"1 >B:@KB>AB8
83;0A=>AB8 AC4>?@>872>4AB20 8 > 4>ABC?5 : 8=D>@<0F88 > 45OB5;L=>AB8 AC4>2» =0 MB>B AG5B >B<5G5=>, GB> >B:@KB>ABL 8 3;0A=>ABL AC4>?@>872>4AB20, A2>52@5<5==>5, :20;8D8F8@>20==>5, >1J5:B82=>5 8=D>@<8@>20=85 >1I5AB20 > 45OB5;L=>AB8 AC4>2 >1I59 N@8A48:F88 A?>A>1AB2CNB ?>2KH5=8N C@>2=O ?@02>2>9 >A254><;5==>AB8 > AC4>CAB@>9AB25 8 AC4>?@>872>4AB25, O2;ONBAO 30@0=B859 A?@0254;82>3> AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20, 0 B0:65 >15A?5G820NB >1I5AB25==K9 :>=B@>;L 70 DC=:F8>=8@>20=85< AC451=>9 2;0AB8. "B:@KB>5 AC451=>5 @0718@0B5;LAB2> O2;O5BAO >4=8< 87 A@54AB2 ?>445@60=8O 4>25@8O >1I5AB20 : AC4C.
"1 >15A?5G5=88 3;0A=>AB8 2 0@18B@06=>< ?@>F5AA5 A<. ?>AB0=>2;5=85 #;5=C<0 KAH53>@18B@06=>3> %C40 $( >B 8 >:BO1@O 2012 3. № 61.
2.7 ?@028;0 >1 >B:@KB>< AC451=>< @0718@0B5;LAB25 ACI5AB2CNB 8A:;NG5=8O. E =0;8G85 >1CA;>2;5=>, 3;02=K< >1@07><, =5>1E>48<>ABLN A>1;N45=8O ?@02 8 70:>==KE 8=B5@5A>2 3@0640=,
0B0:65 ?C1;8G=KE 8=B5@5A>2.
><<5=B8@C5<0O AB0BLO =0 MB>B AG5B ?@54CA<0B@8205B, GB> A;CH0=85 45;0 2 70:@KB>< 70A540=88 4>?CA:05BAO 2 A;CG0OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><.
&0:, A>3;0A=> AB. 10 # $( @0718@0B5;LAB2> 2 70:@KBKE AC451=KE 70A540=8OE
>ACI5AB2;O5BAO ?> 45;0<, A>45@60I8< A2545=8O, A>AB02;ONI85 3>AC40@AB25==CN B09=C, B09=C CAK=>2;5=8O (C4>G5@5=8O) @515=:0, 0 B0:65 ?> 4@C38< 45;0<, 5A;8 MB> ?@54CA<>B@5=> D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><. $0718@0B5;LAB2> 2 70:@KBKE AC451=KE 70A540=8OE 4>?CA:05BAO 8 ?@8 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 E>40B09AB20 ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI53> 2 45;5 8 AAK;0NI53>AO =0 =5>1E>48<>ABL A>E@0=5=8O :><<5@G5A:>9 8;8 8=>9 >E@0=O5<>9 70:>=>< B09=K, =5?@8:>A=>25==>ABL G0AB=>9 687=8 3@0640= 8;8 8=K5 >1AB>OB5;LAB20, 3;0A=>5 >1AC645=85 :>B>@KE A?>A>1=> ?><5H0BL ?@028;L=><C @0718@0B5;LAB2C 45;0 ;81> ?>2;5GL 70 A>1>9 @073;0H5=85 C:070==KE B09= 8;8 =0@CH5=85 ?@02 8 70:>==KE 8=B5@5A>2 3@0640=8=0. #@8 @0AA<>B@5=88 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 ?@8ACBAB2CNB ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI85 2 45;5, 8E ?@54AB028B5;8, 0 2 =5>1E>48<KE A;CG0OE ?@8ACBAB2CNB B0:65 M:A?5@BK, A2845B5;8 8 ?5@52>4G8:8. 5;> 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88
34
@0AA<0B@8205BAO 8 @07@5H05BAO A A>1;N45=85< 2A5E ?@028; 3@0640=A:>3> AC4>?@>872>4AB20.A?>;L7>20=85 A8AB5< 2845>:>=D5@5=F-A2O78 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 =5 4>?CA:05BAO.
0@18B@06=KE AC40E A>3;0A=> AB. 11 # $( @0718@0B5;LAB2> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=><
70A540=88 4>?CA:05BAO 2 A;CG0OE, 5A;8 >B:@KB>5 @0718@0B5;LAB2> 45;0 <>65B ?@825AB8 : @073;0H5=8N 3>AC40@AB25==>9 B09=K, 2 8=KE A;CG0OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><, 0 B0:65 ?@8 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 E>40B09AB20 ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI53> 2 45;5 8 AAK;0NI53>AO =0 =5>1E>48<>ABL A>E@0=5=8O :><<5@G5A:>9, A;C651=>9 8;8 8=>9 >E@0=O5<>9 70:>=>< B09=K. " @0718@0B5;LAB25 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 2K=>A8BAO >?@545;5=85. #@8 @0718@0B5;LAB25 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 ?@8ACBAB2CNB ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI85 2 45;5, 8E ?@54AB028B5;8, 0 2 =5>1E>48<KE A;CG0OE 8 2 ?>@O4:5, :>B>@K5 CAB0=>2;5=K # $(, ?@8ACBAB2CNB B0:65 M:A?5@BK, A?5F80;8ABK, A2845B5;8 8 ?5@52>4G8:8. $0718@0B5;LAB2> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 >ACI5AB2;O5BAO A A>1;N45=85< ?@028; AC4>?@>872>4AB20 2 0@18B@06=KE AC40E. A?>;L7>20=85 A8AB5< 2845>:>=D5@5=F-A2O78 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88
=5 4>?CA:05BAO.
C3>;>2=>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25 A>3;0A=> AB. 241 '# $( 70:@KB>5 AC451=>5 @0718@0B5;LAB2>
4>?CA:05BAO =0 >A=>20=88 >?@545;5=8O 8;8 ?>AB0=>2;5=8O AC40 2 A;CG0OE, :>340:
@0718@0B5;LAB2> C3>;>2=>3> 45;0 2 AC45 <>65B ?@825AB8 : @073;0H5=8N 3>AC40@AB25==>9 8;8 8=>9 >E@0=O5<>9 D545@0;L=K< 70:>=>< B09=K;
@0AA<0B@820NBAO C3>;>2=K5 45;0 > ?@5ABC?;5=8OE, A>25@H5==KE ;8F0<8, =5 4>AB83H8<8 2>7@0AB0 H5AB=04F0B8 ;5B;
@0AA<>B@5=85 C3>;>2=KE 45; > ?@5ABC?;5=8OE ?@>B82 ?>;>2>9 =5?@8:>A=>25==>AB8 8 ?>;>2>9 A2>1>4K ;8G=>AB8 8 4@C38E ?@5ABC?;5=8OE <>65B ?@825AB8 : @073;0H5=8N A2545=89 >1 8=B8<=KE AB>@>=0E 687=8 CG0AB=8:>2 C3>;>2=>3> AC4>?@>872>4AB20 ;81> A2545=89, C=860NI8E 8E G5ABL 8 4>AB>8=AB2>;
MB>3> B@51CNB 8=B5@5AK >15A?5G5=8O 157>?0A=>AB8 CG0AB=8:>2 AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20, 8E 1;87:8E @>4AB25==8:>2, @>4AB25==8:>2 8;8 1;87:8E ;8F.
>?@545;5=88 8;8 ?>AB0=>2;5=88 AC40 > ?@>2545=88 70:@KB>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20 4>;6=K 1KBL C:070=K :>=:@5B=K5, D0:B8G5A:85 >1AB>OB5;LAB20, =0 >A=>20=88 :>B>@KE AC4 ?@8=O; 40==>5 @5H5=85. '3>;>2=>5 45;> @0AA<0B@8205BAO 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 A A>1;N45=85< 2A5E =>@< C3>;>2=>3> AC4>?@>872>4AB20. "?@545;5=85 8;8 ?>AB0=>2;5=85 AC40 > @0AA<>B@5=88 C3>;>2=>3> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 <>65B 1KBL 2K=5A5=> 2 >B=>H5=88 2A53> AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20 ;81> A>>B25BAB2CNI59 53> G0AB8.
#5@5?8A:0, 70?8AL B5;5D>==KE 8 8=KE ?5@53>2>@>2, B5;53@0D=K5, ?>GB>2K5 8 8=K5 A>>1I5=8O ;8F <>3CB 1KBL >3;0H5=K 2 >B:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 B>;L:> A 8E A>3;0A8O. ?@>B82=>< A;CG05 C:070==K5 <0B5@80;K >3;0H0NBAO 8 8AA;54CNBAO 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88. 0==K5 B@51>20=8O ?@8<5=ONBAO 8 ?@8 8AA;54>20=88 <0B5@80;>2 D>B>3@0D8@>20=8O, 0C48>- 8 (8;8) 2845>70?8A59, :8=>AJ5<:8, =>AOI8E ;8G=K9 E0@0:B5@.
&0:65 >1@0B8< 2=8<0=85, GB> 2 A8;C G. 7 AB. 241 '# $( ?@83>2>@ AC40 ?@>2>73;0H05BAO 2
>B:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88. A;CG05 @0AA<>B@5=8O C3>;>2=>3> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 8;8 2 A;CG05 @0AA<>B@5=8O C3>;>2=>3> 45;0 > ?@5ABC?;5=8OE 2 AD5@5 M:>=><8G5A:>9 45OB5;L=>AB8, 0 B0:65 > ?@5ABC?;5=8OE, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE AB. 205-206, 208, G0ABLN G5B25@B>9 AB. 211, G. 1 AB. 212, AB. 275, 276, 279 8 281 ' $(, =0 >A=>20=88 >?@545;5=8O 8;8 ?>AB0=>2;5=8O AC40
<>3CB >3;0H0BLAO B>;L:> 22>4=0O 8 @57>;NB82=0O G0AB8 ?@83>2>@0.
A8;C AB. 55 ( «" >=AB8BCF8>==>< %C45 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88» >=AB8BCF8>==K9
%C4 $( =07=0G05B 70:@KB>5 70A540=85 2 A;CG0OE, :>340 MB> =5>1E>48<> 4;O A>E@0=5=8O
35
>E@0=O5<>9 70:>=>< B09=K, >15A?5G5=8O 157>?0A=>AB8 3@0640=, 70I8BK >1I5AB25==>9 =@02AB25==>AB8. !0 70:@KB>< 70A540=88 ?@8ACBAB2CNB AC4L8 >=AB8BCF8>==>3> %C40 $(, AB>@>=K 8 8E ?@54AB028B5;8. >7<>6=>ABL ?@8ACBAB28O 4@C38E CG0AB=8:>2 ?@>F5AA0 8 A>B@C4=8:>2 %5:@5B0@80B0 >=AB8BCF8>==>3> %C40 $(, =5?>A@54AB25==> >15A?5G820NI8E =>@<0;L=K9 E>4 70A540=8O, >?@545;O5BAO ?@54A540B5;LAB2CNI8< ?> A>3;0A>20=8N A AC4LO<8.
#@8 ?@>2545=88 70:@KB>3> 70A540=8O =5 4>?CA:0NBAO :8=>- 8 D>B>AJ5<:0, 2845>70?8AL, ?@O<0O @048>- 8 B5;5B@0=A;OF8O 70A540=8O, 0 B0:65 B@0=A;OF8O 70A540=8O 2 8=D>@<0F8>==>- B5;5:><<C=8:0F8>==>9 A5B8 « =B5@=5B». 5;0 2 70:@KBKE 70A540=8OE @0AA<0B@820NBAO A
A>1;N45=85< >1I8E ?@028; :>=AB8BCF8>==>3> AC4>?@>872>4AB20.
7 ?>;>65=89 G. 2 AB. 11 % $( A;54C5B, GB> @0718@0B5;LAB2> 04<8=8AB@0B82=KE 45; 2
70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 >ACI5AB2;O5BAO 2 A;CG05, 5A;8 <0B5@80;K @0AA<0B@8205<>3> 04<8=8AB@0B82=>3> 45;0 A>45@60B A2545=8O, A>AB02;ONI85 3>AC40@AB25==CN 8;8 8=CN >E@0=O5<CN 70:>=>< B09=C. $0718@0B5;LAB2> 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 4>?CA:05BAO B0:65 2 A;CG05 C4>2;5B2>@5=8O E>40B09AB20 ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI53> 2 45;5, AAK;0NI53>AO =0 =5>1E>48<>ABL A>E@0=5=8O :><<5@G5A:>9 8;8 8=>9 >E@0=O5<>9 70:>=>< B09=K, =0 A>45@60I85AO 2 04<8=8AB@0B82=>< 45;5 A2545=8O :>=D845=F80;L=>3> E0@0:B5@0, =0 =5?@8:>A=>25==>ABL G0AB=>9 687=8 3@0640= 8;8 8=K5 >1AB>OB5;LAB20, 3;0A=>5 >1AC645=85 :>B>@KE <>65B ?><5H0BL ?@028;L=><C @0718@0B5;LAB2C 04<8=8AB@0B82=>3> 45;0 ;81> ?>2;5GL 70 A>1>9 @073;0H5=85 C:070==KE B09= 8 =0@CH5=85 ?@02 8 70:>==KE 8=B5@5A>2 3@0640=8=0.
" @0718@0B5;LAB25 04<8=8AB@0B82=>3> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 2K=>A8BAO <>B828@>20==>5 >?@545;5=85 AC40. "?@545;5=85 2K=>A8BAO 2 >B=>H5=88 2A53> AC451=>3> @0718@0B5;LAB20 8;8 53> G0AB8.
#@8 @0718@0B5;LAB25 04<8=8AB@0B82=>3> 45;0 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 ?@8ACBAB2CNB ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI85 2 45;5, 8E ?@54AB028B5;8, 0 2 =5>1E>48<KE A;CG0OE B0:65 A2845B5;8, M:A?5@BK, A?5F80;8ABK, ?5@52>4G8:8. 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 04<8=8AB@0B82=>5 45;> @0AA<0B@8205BAO 8 @07@5H05BAO A A>1;N45=85< 2A5E ?@028; 04<8=8AB@0B82=>3> AC4>?@>872>4AB20.A?>;L7>20=85 A8AB5< 2845>:>=D5@5=F-A2O78 2 70:@KB>< AC451=>< 70A540=88 =5 4>?CA:05BAO.
!F4FPO 10. /7K: AC4>?@>872>4AB20 8 45;>?@>872>4AB20 2 AC40E
1.%C4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> 2 >=AB8BCF8>==>< %C45 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88,5@E>2=>< %C45 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, 0@18B@06=KE AC40E, 2>5==KE AC40E 254CBAO =0 @CAA:>< O7K:5 -
3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88. %C4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> 2 4@C38E D545@0;L=KE AC40E >1I59 N@8A48:F88 <>3CB 25AB8AL B0:65 =0 3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 @5A?C1;8:8, =0 B5@@8B>@88 :>B>@>9 =0E>48BAO AC4.
2.%C4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> C <8@>2KE AC459 8 2 4@C38E AC40E AC1J5:B>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 254CBAO =0 @CAA:>< O7K:5 ;81> =0 3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 @5A?C1;8:8, =0 B5@@8B>@88 :>B>@>9 =0E>48BAO AC4.
3.'G0AB2CNI8< 2 45;5 ;8F0<, =5 2;045NI8< O7K:>< AC4>?@>872>4AB20, >15A?5G8205BAO ?@02> 2KABC?0BL 8 4020BL >1JOA=5=8O =0 @>4=>< O7K:5 ;81> =0 ;N1>< A2>1>4=> 871@0==>< O7K:5 >1I5=8O, 0 B0:65 ?>;L7>20BLAO CA;C30<8 ?5@52>4G8:0.
36
КB@@9AF4D<= > EF. 10
1.:><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL5 CAB0=02;8205BAO >1I55 ?@028;>, :0A0NI55AO O7K:0, =0 :>B>@>< 2 AC40E $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 254CBAO AC4>?@>872>4AB2> (>A=>2=0O 45OB5;L=>ABL >@30=>2 AC451=>9 2;0AB8, >ACI5AB2;5=85 ?@02>AC48O) 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> (4>:C<5=B8@CNI0O 45OB5;L=>ABL, >15A?5G820NI0O =>@<0;L=>5 DC=:F8>=8@>20=85 AC451=KE >@30=>2 8 8E 2708<>459AB285 A 8=K<8 >@30=0<8 3>AC40@AB25==>9 2;0AB8, >@30=0<8 <5AB=>3> A0<>C?@02;5=8O, D878G5A:8<8 8 N@848G5A:8<8 ;8F0<8).
#>A:>;L:C AC451=0O A8AB5<0 548=0 =0 2A59 B5@@8B>@88 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, 8
3>AC40@AB25==K< O7K:>< =0 2A59 B5@@8B>@88 =0H53> 3>AC40@AB20 O2;O5BAO @CAA:89 O7K: (A>3;0A=> G. 1 AB. 68 >=AB8BCF88 $( 8 ?. 1 AB. 1 (545@0;L=>3> 70:>=0 >B 1 8N=O 2005 3. № 53-( «" 3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88»), B> ?>;>65=85 G. 1 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 >
B><, GB> AC4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> 2 >=AB8BCF8>==>< %C45 $(, 5@E>2=>< %C45 $(, 0@18B@06=KE AC40E, 2>5==KE AC40E 254CBAO =0 @CAA:>< O7K:5, 5ABL =5 GB> 8=>5, :0: :>=:@5B870F8O C:070==KE 2KH5 :>=AB8BCF8>==KE ?@8=F8?>2.
$>AA89A:0O (545@0F8O — <=>3>=0F8>=0;L=>5 3>AC40@AB2>, ?>MB><C 2>?@>AK 8A?>;L7>20=8O =0 55 B5@@8B>@88 8=KE O7K:>2, =5 8<5NI8E AB0BCA0 >1I53>AC40@AB25==>3> O7K:0, 0:BC0;L=K 8 4;O AD5@K >ACI5AB2;5=8O AC451=>9 2;0AB8. 7 A>45@60=8O G. 1 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 A;54C5B,
GB> AC4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> 2 4@C38E D545@0;L=KE AC40E >1I59 N@8A48:F88 <>3CB 25AB8AL B0:65 =0 3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 B>9 @5A?C1;8:8, =0 B5@@8B>@88 :>B>@>9 =0E>48BAO AC4.
2.A8;C G. 2 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 AC4>?@>872>4AB2> 8 45;>?@>872>4AB2> C <8@>2KE
AC459 8 2 4@C38E AC40E AC1J5:B>2 $( 254CBAO =0 @CAA:>< O7K:5 ;81> =0 3>AC40@AB25==>< O7K:5 @5A?C1;8:8, =0 B5@@8B>@88 :>B>@>9 =0E>48BAO AC4. &> 5ABL, 2 40==>< A;CG05 @50;87C5BAO ?@8=F8? 48A?>78B82=>AB8. "4=0:> A;54C5B >B<5B8BL, GB> =>@<0 > 2K1>@5 O7K:0 AC4>- 8 45;>?@>872>4AB20
A>E@0=O5B ACI5AB25==CN =5>?@545;5==>ABL 2 2>?@>A5 > B><, >B GL53> @5H5=8O 1C45B 7028A5BL 40==K9 2K1>@ :064>< :>=:@5B=>< AC45.
%>3;0A=> AB. 3 0:>=0 $( >B 25 >:BO1@O 1991 3. № 1807-I «" O7K:0E =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9
(545@0F88» @5A?C1;8:8 2?@025 CAB0=02;820BL 2 A>>B25BAB288 A >=AB8BCF859 $( A2>8 3>AC40@AB25==K5 O7K:8. %C1J5:BK $( 2 A>>B25BAB288 A C:070==K< 70:>=>< 2?@025 ?@8=8<0BL 70:>=K 8 8=K5 =>@<0B82=K5 ?@02>2K5 0:BK > 70I8B5 ?@02 3@0640= =0 A2>1>4=K9 2K1>@ O7K:0 >1I5=8O, 2>A?8B0=8O, >1CG5=8O 8 B2>@G5AB20.
<5AB=>AB8 :><?0:B=>3> ?@>6820=8O =0A5;5=8O, =5 8<5NI53> A2>8E =0F8>=0;L=>- 3>AC40@AB25==KE 8 =0F8>=0;L=>-B5@@8B>@80;L=KE >1@07>20=89 8;8 682CI53> 70 8E ?@545;0<8,
=0@O4C A @CAA:8< O7K:>< 8 3>AC40@AB25==K<8 O7K:0<8 @5A?C1;8:, 2 >D8F80;L=KE AD5@0E >1I5=8O <>65B 8A?>;L7>20BLAO O7K: =0A5;5=8O 40==>9 <5AB=>AB8. #>@O4>: 8A?>;L7>20=8O O7K:>2 2 B0:8E <5AB=>ABOE >?@545;O5BAO 70:>=>40B5;LAB2>< $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 8 AC1J5:B>2 $(.
>AC40@AB2> ?@87=05B @02=K5 ?@020 2A5E O7K:>2 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 =0 8E A>E@0=5=85 8 @0728B85. A5 O7K:8 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 ?>;L7CNBAO ?>445@6:>9 3>AC40@AB20.
%B0BL59 4 0:>=0 $( >B 25 >:BO1@O 1991 3. № 1807-I «" O7K:0E =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9
(545@0F88» 70:@5?;5=>, GB> O7K:8 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 ?>;L7CNBAO 70I8B>9 3>AC40@AB20. "@30=K 70:>=>40B5;L=>9, 8A?>;=8B5;L=>9 8 AC451=>9 2;0AB8 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 30@0=B8@CNB 8 >15A?5G820NB 70I8BC 2A5E O7K:>2 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88:
37
1)A>F80;L=CN. %>F80;L=0O 70I8B0 O7K:>2 ?@54CA<0B@8205B ?@>2545=85 =0CG=> >1>A=>20==>9 O7K:>2>9 ?>;8B8:8, =0?@02;5==>9 =0 A>E@0=5=85, @0728B85 8 87CG5=85 2A5E O7K:>2 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 =0 B5@@8B>@88 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88;
2)M:>=><8G5A:CN. -:>=><8G5A:0O 70I8B0 O7K:>2 ?@54?>;0305B F5;52>5 1N465B=>5 8 8=>5 D8=0=A>2>5 >15A?5G5=85 3>AC40@AB25==KE 8 =0CG=KE ?@>3@0<< A>E@0=5=8O 8 @0728B8O O7K:>2 =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, ?@>2545=85 2 MB8E F5;OE ;L3>B=>9 =0;>3>2>9 ?>;8B8:8;
3)N@848G5A:CN. .@848G5A:0O 70I8B0 O7K:>2 ?@54?>;0305B >15A?5G5=85 >B25BAB25==>AB8 N@848G5A:8E 8 D878G5A:8E ;8F 70 =0@CH5=85 70:>=>40B5;LAB20 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 > O7K:0E =0@>4>2 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88.
3. G. 3 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 70:@5?;O5BAO ?@>F5AAC0;L=>5 ?@02> ;8F0, =5 2;045NI53>
O7K:>< AC4>?@>872>4AB20, =0 2KABC?;5=8O 8 >1JOA=5=8O =0 @>4=>< 8;8 ;N1>< A2>1>4=> 871@0==>< O7K:5, 0 B0:65 ?@02> ?>;L7>20BLAO CA;C30<8 ?5@52>4G8:0. &5< A0<K< =0 70:>=>40B5;O 2>7;>65=0 >1O70==>ABL 2>A?@>8725AB8 8 :>=:@5B878@>20BL =0 ?@>F5AAC0;L=>< C@>2=5 40==K5 ?@02><>G8O.
#>;>65=8O > O7K:5 AC4>?@>872>4AB20 ?>2B>@ONBAO 8 @072820NBAO 2 A;54CNI8E =>@<0B82=KE ?@02>2KE 0:B0E:
2 C3>;>2=>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25: AB. 18 8 4@. '# $(;
2 3@0640=A:>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25: AB. 9 8 4@. # $(;
2 0@18B@06=>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25: AB. 12 8 4@. # $(;
2 04<8=8AB@0B82=>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25: AB. 12 % $(;
2 :>=AB8BCF8>==>< AC4>?@>872>4AB25: AB. 33 8 4@. ( «" >=AB8BCF8>==>< %C45 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88».
?464 2. EAB6O EF4FGE4 EG89= 6 BEE<=E>B= (989D4J<<
!F4FPO 11. %C4L8
1.%C4LO<8 O2;ONBAO ;8F0, =045;5==K5 2 A>>B25BAB288 A >=AB8BCF859 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 8 =0AB>OI8< (545@0;L=K< :>=AB8BCF8>==K< 70:>=>< ?>;=><>G8O<8 >ACI5AB2;OBL ?@02>AC485 8 8A?>;=ONI85 A2>8 >1O70==>AB8 =0 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>9 >A=>25.
2.%C4LO, 8<5NI89 AB06 @01>BK 2 :0G5AB25 AC4L8 =5 <5=55 45AOB8 ;5B 8 =0E>4OI89AO 2 >BAB02:5, AG8B05BAO ?>G5B=K< AC4L59. "= <>65B 1KBL ?@82;5G5= : >ACI5AB2;5=8N ?@02>AC48O 2 :0G5AB25 AC4L8 2 ?>@O4:5, CAB0=>2;5==>< D545@0;L=K< 70:>=><.
3.%C4LO< ?@54>AB02;O5BAO 70 AG5B 3>AC40@AB20 <0B5@80;L=>5 8 A>F80;L=>-1KB>2>5 >15A?5G5=85,
A>>B25BAB2CNI55 8E 2KA>:><C AB0BCAC. 65<5AOG=>5 45=56=>5 2>7=03@0645=85 8 565:20@B0;L=>5 45=56=>5 ?>>I@5=85 AC4L8 =5 <>3CB 1KBL C<5=LH5=K 2 B5G5=85 2A53> 2@5<5=8 ?@51K20=8O 53> 2 4>;6=>AB8.
КB@@9AF4D<= > EF. 11
1. "B?@02;5=85 ?@02>AC48O 2KABC?05B 2 :0G5AB25 >A>1>9 3>AC40@AB25==>9 DC=:F88, =0?@02;5==>9 =0 >15A?5G5=85 70I8BK ?@02 8 70:>==KE 8=B5@5A>2 3@0640= $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88,
0 B0:65 N@848G5A:8E ;8F 8 8=KE AC1J5:B>2. MB>9 A2O78 >ACI5AB2;5=85 ?>;=><>G89 AC4L8
38
C:07K205B =0 =5>1E>48<>ABL A>1;N45=8O @O40 B@51>20=89, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE :><<5=B8@C5<K<0:>=>< 4;O ?@8>1@5B5=8O A>>B25BAB2CNI53> AB0BCA0.
%>2>:C?=>ABL B@51>20=89, ?@54JO2;O5<KE : AC4LO< $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 <>6=> CA;>2=> @0745;8BL =0 =5A:>;L:> :0B53>@89: D>@<0;L=K5 8 :20;8D8:0F8>==K5. (>@<0;L=K5 B@51>20=8O ?@54?>;030NB =5>1E>48<>ABL ?5@540G8 ?>;=><>G89, GB> >4=>2@5<5==> B@51C5B ?>4B25@645=8O A>>B25BAB28O 3@0640=8=0 B@51>20=8O<, ?@54JO2;O5<K< : :0=4840B0< =0 4>;6=>ABL. (>@<0;L=K5 B@51>20=8O 2KB5:0NB 87 ACI5AB20 G. 1 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 8 ?@54?>;030NB =5>1E>48<>ABL
A>1;N45=8O CAB0=>2;5==>3> ?>@O4:0 =07=0G5=8O AC4L8. #> >1I5<C ?@028;C, CAB0=>2;5==><C>=AB8BCF859 $(, AC4L8 =07=0G0NBAO #@57845=B>< $( =0 >A=>20=88 ?@54AB02;5=8O C?>;=><>G5==>3> 70:>=>< AC1J5:B0 ?@8 =0;8G88 ?>;>68B5;L=>3> 70:;NG5=8O :20;8D8:0F8>==>9 :>;;5388 AC459.
&0:8< >1@07><, A>1;N45=85 CAB0=>2;5==>3> ?>@O4:0 =045;5=8O AC459 ?>;=><>G8O<8 ?@54?>;0305B 0:B82=CN @>;L B@5E :0B53>@89 AC1J5:B>2:
:20;8D8:0F8>==>9 :>;;5388 AC459, :>B>@0O >F5=8205B ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K5 :0G5AB20 ?@5B5=45=B0 =0 4>;6=>ABL AC4L8 8 53> A>>B25BAB285 20:0=B=>9 4>;6=>AB8, =0 :>B>@CN >= ?@5B5=4C5B. A;CG05 CAB0=>2;5=8O A>>B25BAB28O 70:;NG5=85 :>;;5388 =0?@02;O5BAO C?>;=><>G5==><C AC1J5:BC, :>B>@K9 ?@54AB02;O5B :0=4840BC@C #@57845=BC $( 4;O =07=0G5=8O =0 A>>B25BAB2CNICN 4>;6=>ABL;
C?>;=><>G5==KE AC1J5:B>2, ?5@5G5=L :>B>@KE 4>AB0B>G=> H8@>: 8 :>=:@5B878@C5BAO
?@8<5=8B5;L=> : >B45;L=K< :0B53>@8O< AC4>2. !0?@8<5@, :0=4840BC@K 4;O =07=0G5=8O =0 4>;6=>ABL AC4L8 >=AB8BCF8>==>3> %C40 $( #@57845=BC $( <>3CB 1KBL ?@54AB02;5=K G;5=0<8 %>25B0 (545@0F88 8 45?CB0B0<8 >AC40@AB25==>9 C<K, 0 B0:65 70:>=>40B5;L=K<8 (?@54AB028B5;L=K<8) >@30=0<8 AC1J5:B>2 $(, 2KAH8<8 AC451=K<8 >@30=0<8 8 D545@0;L=K<8 N@848G5A:8<8 254><AB20<8, 2A5@>AA89A:8<8 N@848G5A:8<8 A>>1I5AB20<8, N@848G5A:8<8 =0CG=K<8 8 CG51=K<8 702545=8O<8;
#@57845=B0 $(, :>B>@K9 =0 >A=>20=88 ?@54AB02;5==KE :0=4840BC@ ?@8=8<05B @5H5=85 > =07=0G5=88 =0 4>;6=>ABL AC4L8 3@0640=8=0 $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88, > G5< 87405B
A>>B25BAB2CNI89 C:07. ':07 #@57845=B0 $( 2KABC?05B >A=>20=85< 4;O >ACI5AB2;5=8O
3@0640=8=>< 45OB5;L=>AB8 2 :0G5AB25 AC4L8 A>>B25BAB2CNI53> AC40, B.5. ;538B8<8@C5B 53> ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K9 AB0BCA.
"4=>2@5<5==> A =5>1E>48<>ABLN A>1;N45=8O D>@<0;L=KE B@51>20=89, G. 1
:><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 C:07K205B, GB> AC4LO >ACI5AB2;O5B 4>;6=>AB=K5 ?>;=><>G8O =0 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>9 >A=>25, G5< :>=:@5B878@C5B A>>B25BAB2CNI85 :20;8D8:0F8>==K5 B@51>20=8O.
% >4=>9 AB>@>=K, ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=0O 45OB5;L=>ABL AC4L8 >?@545;O5B =5>1E>48<>ABL =0;8G8O A?5F80;L=>3> >1@07>20=8O — 2KAH53> N@848G5A:>3> =57028A8<> >B AB0BCA0 AC40, 2 :>B>@>< >ACI5AB2;O5BAO 45OB5;L=>ABL :>=:@5B=>3> 3@0640=8=0. % 4@C3>9 AB>@>=K, ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K9 E0@0:B5@ 45OB5;L=>AB8 AC4L8 A2845B5;LAB2C5B > ?>AB>O=AB25 53> 45OB5;L=>AB8, B.5. >B?@02;5=85 ?@02>AC48O 8 >ACI5AB2;5=85 8=KE 4>;6=>AB=KE ?>;=><>G89, ?> A2>59 ACB8, 2KABC?05B >A=>2=K< <5AB>< @01>BK 3@0640=8=0. G0AB=>AB8, C:070==>5 ?>;>65=85 >?@545;O5B 459AB285 2 53> >B=>H5=88 @O40 >3@0=8G5=89, ?@54CA<>B@5==KE 459AB2CNI8< 70:>=>40B5;LAB2><, =0?@8<5@, ?> A>2<5I5=8N 40==>3> 2840 45OB5;L=>AB8 A 8=K<8 >?;0G8205<K<8 2840<8 45OB5;L=>AB8, 2 B>< G8A;5 :><<5@G5A:8<8 8 B.?.
59AB2CNI55 70:>=>40B5;LAB2> CAB0=02;8205B @O4 A?5F80;L=KE B@51>20=89 : AC4LO< @>AA89A:8E AC4>2, :>B>@K5 45B0;878@CNBAO ?@8<5=8B5;L=> : AB0BCAC A0<>3> AC40. =0;87 ?>;>65=89 >B45;L=KE =>@<0B82=KE 0:B>2 ?>72>;O5B 3>2>@8BL > 2K45;5=88 >1I8E 8 A?5F80;L=KE
39
B@51>20=89 : AC4LO< >B45;L=KE AC4>2. "1I85 B@51>20=8O E0@0:B5@=K 4;O AC459 2A5E AC4>2 $(,
=57028A8<> >B 8E 2840 8 AB0BCA0. G8A;C B0:8E B@51>20=89 <>6=> >B=5AB8:
455A?>A>1=>ABL, :>B>@0O O2;O5BAO >1I8< ?>=OB85< 4;O 2A5E 3@0640= 8 A2845B5;LAB2C5B >1 C@>2=5 ?A8E8G5A:>3> @0728B8O AC1J5:B0, ?>72>;ONI5< 5<C >A>7=020BL 7=0G5=85 8 ?>A;54AB28O A2>8E 459AB289 8 =5AB8 70 =8E >B25BAB25==>ABL. %C4LO<8 <>3CB 1KBL B>;L:> ;8F0, >1;040NI85 ?>;=>9 455A?>A>1=>ABLN 2 A>>B25BAB288 A B@51>20=8O<8 $(;
3@0640=AB2> $>AA89A:>9 (545@0F88 — AC4LO<8 <>3CB 1KBL B>;L:> 3@0640=5 $(, B.5. ;8F0, >1;040NI85 CAB>9G82>9 ?@02>2>9 A2O7LN A 3>AC40@AB2>< ($>AA89A:>9 (545@0F859). ':070==>5 B@51>20=85 O2;O5BAO >1I8< 4;O A;C60I8E 2A5E >@30=>2 3>AC40@AB25==>9 2;0AB8, ?>A:>;L:C 8E 45OB5;L=>ABL =0?@02;5=0 =0 @50;870F8N >B45;L=KE 3>AC40@AB25==>-
2;0AB=KE ?>;=><>G89, >B=5A5==KE : :><?5B5=F88 A>>B25BAB2CNI53> >@30=0;
2KAH55 >1@07>20=85 — N@848G5A:>5, ?>A:>;L:C 45OB5;L=>ABL AC4L8 A2O70=0 A ?@8<5=5=85< ?@02>2KE =>@<, B> =0;8G85 A?5F80;L=KE 7=0=89 O2;O5BAO >1O70B5;L=K< 8 =5>1E>48<K< 4;O >ACI5AB2;5=8O ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>9 45OB5;L=>AB8.
%>3;0A=> AB. 119 >=AB8BCF88 $( AC4LO<8 <>3CB 1KBL 3@0640=5 $(, 4>AB83H85 25 ;5B,
8<5NI85 2KAH55 N@848G5A:>5 >1@07>20=85 8 AB06 @01>BK ?> N@848G5A:>9 ?@>D5AA88 =5 <5=55 ?OB8 ;5B. (545@0;L=K< 70:>=>< <>3CB 1KBL CAB0=>2;5=K 4>?>;=8B5;L=K5 B@51>20=8O : AC4LO< AC4>2 $(.
%?5F80;L=K5 B@51>20=8O E0@0:B5@=K 4;O >B45;L=KE :0B53>@89 AC459 ?@8<5=8B5;L=> : AB0BCAC AC40, 2 A>AB025 :>B>@>3> >=8 >ACI5AB2;ONB ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=CN 45OB5;L=>ABL. G8A;C A?5F80;L=KE B@51>20=89 459AB2CNI55 70:>=>40B5;LAB2> ?>72>;O5B >B=5AB8:
4>AB865=85 CAB0=>2;5==>3> 70:>=>< 2>7@0AB0, :>B>@K9 ?> >1I5<C ?@028;C =5 <>65B 1KBL <5=55 25 ;5B. "4=0:> 4>AB865=85 C:070==>3> 2>7@0AB=>3> ?@545;0 E0@0:B5@=> ;8HL 4;O
AC459 AC4>2 ?5@2>9 8=AB0=F88, 4;O AC459 2KH5AB>OI8E AC4>2 2>7@0AB=>9 F5=7 A>AB02;O5B =5 <5=55 40 ;5B;
=0;8G85 =5>1E>48<>3> AB060 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>9 45OB5;L=>AB8, :>B>@K9 ?> >1I5<C ?@028;C 4>;65= A>AB02;OBL =5 <5=55 ?OB8 ;5B @01>BK ?> N@848G5A:>9 ?@>D5AA88. "4=0:> 40==>5
B@51>20=85 B0:65 :>@@5:B8@C5BAO ?@8<5=8B5;L=> : AB0BCAC AC40, 2 :>B>@>< >ACI5AB2;O5B 45OB5;L=>ABL AC4LO, =0?@8<5@, 4;O AC459 >=AB8BCF8>==>3> AC40 $( =5>1E>48<K9 <8=8<0;L=K9 AB06 A>AB02;O5B =5 <5=55 ?OB=04F0B8 ;5B.
"4=>2@5<5==> 459AB2CNI55 70:>=>40B5;LAB2> <>65B ?@54CA<0B@820BL 8 @O4 8=KE B@51>20=89, :>B>@K5 2 1>;LH8=AB25 A;CG052 E0@0:B5@=K 4;O 2KH5AB>OI8E AC4>2. &0:, =0?@8<5@, 4;O 2KAH8E AC451=KE 8=AB0=F89 =5>1E>48<K< CA;>285< 2K42865=8O :0=4840BC@K O2;O5BAO 2KA>:0O :20;8D8:0F8O 2 >1;0AB8 ?@020, 0 B0:65 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K5 E0@0:B5@8AB8:8 AC4L8.
2. A8;C ?>;>65=89 G. 2 :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 AC4LO, ?@51K20NI89 2 4>;6=>AB8 1>;55
45AOB8 ;5B, 8 =0E>4OI89AO 2 >BAB02:5 ?@87=05BAO ?>G5B=K< AC4L59. ':070==K9 ?5@8>4 ?@54CA<0B@8205BAO :><<5=B8@C5<K< 0:>=>< 2 :0G5AB25 <8=8<0;L=> 4>?CAB8<>3> ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>3> AB060, :>B>@K9 4>;65= ?@52KH0BL 45AOBL ;5B @01>BK 2 4>;6=>AB8 AC4L8. #@8 MB>< 0:>= =5 :>=:@5B878@C5B, 2 :0:>< ?>@O4:5 <>65B >ACI5AB2;OBLAO B0:0O 45OB5;L=>ABL: 2
@0<:0E 2KH5AB>OI8E AC4>2 8;8 B>;L:> 2 >4=>< AC45 8 B.?. MB>9 A2O78 =5>1E>48<K< 8 4>AB0B>G=K< A;54C5B AG8B0BL >1I89 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K9 AB06 2 4>;6=>AB8 AC4L8, :>B>@K9 =5 <>65B 1KBL <5=55 45AOB8 ;5B.
#>;>65=8O :><<5=B8@C5<>9 AB0BL8 B@51CNB A>1;N45=8O 42CE CA;>289 4;O ?@87=0=8O 3@0640=8=0 ?>G5B=K< AC4L59:
=0;8G85 =5>1E>48<>3> ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>3> AB060;
40