34 НімціЕк філософ

3%0945335@.3 3$C=40<5=B0;L=0 3>=B>;>3VO.3

3/:I> 32 3%% 3AB.3 310BL:>< 35:78AB5=FV0;L=>W 34C<:8 31C2 3V@:53>@,3 3B> 34;O 3ACG0A=>W 3 30@BV= 3%0945335@.3 3%>G0 32V= 3V 3(3=5 3157 3?V4AB02)3 32V4<>2;O2AO 3(3«32V4E@5IC202AO»3)3 32V4 3?@8=0;56=>ABV 34> 3A0<>W 3B5GVW,3 30;5 3F5=B@0;L=8< 3?>=OBBO< 3«3CBBO 3V 3G0AC»3 3(313932373)3 3?>:;02 3A0<5 3«35:78AB5=FVN»3.3 3V= 365 3<02 328@VH0;L=89 32?;82 3=0 3D@0=FC7L:89 35:78AB5=FV0;V7<.3 3/:>N 3<V@>N 3DV;>A>DVO 3%0945335@0 3?@54AB02;OT 3A>1>N 3<>@0;L 301> 33C<0=VAB8G=C 3:>=F5?FVN?3 3>;>2=8< 3?8B0==O< 39>3> 35:78AB5=FV0;L=>W 3>=B>;>3VW 3T 3?8B0==O 3?@> 3A5=A 31CBBO.3 3;5 3?@>1;5<0 31CBBO 3AB028BLAO 32 370;56=>ABV 32V4 3;N48=8,3 3I> 37040TBLAO 3FVTN 3?@>1;5<>N:3 3"30?8BCT<> 3<8,3 3BCB 3V 3B5?5@,3 34;O 3A515"3.3 3‑B65,3 328EV4=>N 37040G5N 328O2;OTBLAO 3>?8A 3N48=8,3 3 3BVTW 3>A>1;82>W 3VAB>B8,3 3I> 37040TBLAO 3?@>1;5<>N 31CBBO.3 30A0<?5@54 3>A=>2=5 3?8B0==O 3157;VGV 3DV;>A>DV9 3 3"3'><C 3VA=CT 3)>AL,3 30 3=5 3VI>?3"3.3

3 >73;O=5<>,3 3O: 3%0945335@ 3287=0G0T 3;N48=C.3 3N48=0 3 3VAB>B0,3 3G8T 31CBBO 3T 35:-378AB5=F5,3 3B>1B> 3I> 32>=0 3T48=0 3A5@54 32AVE 3VAB>B 3C 3A2VBV,3 3I> 35:-378AB5,3 3?5@5-3ABC?0T,3 328E>48BL 370 3<56V 32AVE 3V=H8E 3VAB>B 3V 3A0<>W 3A515.3 3&5=B@0;L=>N 3B57>N 3T 3B25@465==O,3 32V4?>2V4=> 34> 3O:>3> 3"3ACB=VABL 3;N4AL:>3> 31CBBO 3?>;O30T 32 35:-378AB5=F5,3 3C 3?5@5-3ABC?0==V.3 3&5 3>7=0G0T 3=5 3BV;L:8 3B5,3 3I>,3 3O: 3E>BV2 3?>:070B8 3!0@B@ 3C 3B2>@V 3"3ﾧ:78AB5=FV0;V7< 3 3F5 33C<0=V7<"3,3 3;N48=0 32V4:@8B0 3A2VB>2V,3 30 3=5 3A:>20=0 37C<>2;5=VABN,3 30;5 3V 3B5,3 3I> 3CA5@548=V 3A515 3;N48=0 3 3?>ABV9=5 3?5@5-3ABC?0==O,3 3=5A:V=G5==5 374V9<0==O.3

3/: 3>?8ACT 3%0945335@ 3FN 3ACB=VABL 3;N48=8?3 3>=0 3 3C 3?>:8=CB>AB8,3 3=0 3A0<>BV 3;N48=8,3 3:8=CB>3> 32 3F59 3A2VB,3 3C 3BC3C,3 3C 3@>7?0G 3 3>A:V;L:8 3;N48=0 3=V:>;8 3=5 37'3O2;OTBLAO 3?5@54 3A0<8< 3A>1>N 3O: 3VAB>B0 3AB01V;L=0,3 37025@H5=0,3 3I> 32>;>4VT 3A>1>N 3V 3@5G0<8,3 30 3O: 3?>ABV9=5 3:>270==O,3 32B5G0 32 3?>@>6=5GC,3 3C 3=51CBBO.3 3 3E>G0 3;N48=0 3702648 3?V4=V<0TBLAO 3=04 3A0<>N 3A>1>N,3 328?5@5460T 3A0<C 3A515,3 32>=0 37=0T 3A2V9 3:V=5FL 3 3!<5@BL.3 3N48=0 3 3F5 3VAB>B0,3 3I> 3?@5-3ABC?05B 3CAV 3D>@<8 31CBBO 3V 328?5@5460T 3A0<>3> 3A515 3 3C 3@CAV 34> 3!<5@BV.3 3V= 3T 3"3ACBV-3B@820-3A<5@BV"3.3 3"3 3?>4V1=> 3B><C,3 3O: 3;N4AL:0 3VAB>B0 3 3702648 3=57025@H5=VABL,3 3702648 3"3I5 3=5.3.3.3"3,3 32>=> 3A?>:>=2VG=> 3T 3V 32;0A=8< 3:V=F5<.3 3&59 3:V=5FL,3 3I> 3?>7=0G0TBLAO 3A<5@BN,3 3=5 3@>18BL 3;N4AL:0 3VAB>B0 3O:>NAL 3:V=FV2:>N,3 30 3;8H5 3?@87=0G5==O< 34> 3FVTW 3:V=FV2:8,3 3=5 3"3VAB>B>N-3:V=F5<"3,3 30 3"3 3VAB>B8-3B@820-3:V=FO"3.3 3!<5@BL 3 3D>@<0 31CBBO,3 3I> 3;N4AL:0 3VAB>B0 3A?>:>=2VG=0 3?@85<;5B:3 3"3;54L 3;N48=0 3=0@>48BLAO,3 32V= 3C65 34>A8BL 3AB0@89,3 3I>1 3C<5@B8"3.3 3(3"3CBBO 3V 3'0A"3)3.3

3%0945335@>2A:>5 3?@54AB02;5==O 3?@> 3;N48=C 3B@038G=>.3 3'8 3=5 37=5FV=NT 32>=> 32 3B0:89 3A?>AV1 368BBO,3 3G8 3=5 3AB8@0T 3@>7E>465==O 3<V6 34>1@>< 3V 37;><?3 3V,3 3>A:V;L:8 3B@510 3?@89=OB8 3C<>28 3;N4AL:>3> 3VA=C20==O 3B0:8<8,3 3O:V 32>=8 3T.3 3)8@5 3VA=C20==O 3?@>B8AB02;OTBLAO 3=5VAB8==><C,3 3157>A>1>2>ABV,3 310=0;L=V9 3?>2AO:45==>ABV,3 3I> 370:@820T 3>:0 3=0 3A<5@BL.3 3AB>B0 3I8@5 32V4<>2;OTBLAO 32V4 3=5?@0248:3 32>=> 3 3"3I8@0 3VAB>B0 34;O 3:V=FO"3,3 3"3VAB>B0 34;O 3A<5@BV 3157 3>1<0=C 3V 32B5GV"3.3 3"3­>G0B:>289 3?>@82,3 3 3?8H5 3%0945335@,3 3 32V4:@820T 3?5@54 3;N4AL:>N 3VAB>B>N 3<>6;82VABL 31CB8 3A0<8< 3A>1>N,3 3?5@A?5:B828 3>;V 3157 3V;N7V9 3157;8:>AB8,3 3>;V 34VO;L=>W,3 3C?52=5=>W 32 3A>1V 3V 3?>2=>W 3AB@0EC 3?5@54 3A>1>N 3 32>;V 34;O 4A<5@BV"4.4 4(4CBBO 4V 4G0A"4)4.4

4# 4@>1>BV 4"4)> 4B0:5 4<5B0DV78:0?4"4 42V= 4?>:07CT,4 4O: 4AB@0E 47;820TBLAO 47 4<C6=VABN.4 4"4N4AL:0 4VAB>B0 4CA5 41V;LH 4?@>=870=0 42V4GCBBO< 4=51CBBO,4 4I> 4=01;860TBLAO,4 4V 4;8H5 4AB@0E 4<>65 47=09B8 49>3> 4A?@026=V9 4E0@0:B5@.4 4&59 4"4?5@2>@>4=89"4 4AB@0E 4C 4;N4AL:V9 4VAB>BV 4728G09=> 4?@84CHCTBLAO.4 4!B@0E 4=5 47=8:0T,4 42V= 4;8H5 44@V<0T.4 4>3> 4?>48E 4?@>=87CT 4;N4AL:0 4VAB>B0;4 4A;01:VH5 4CAL>3> 42V= 428O2;OTBLAO 42 4;N48=V 41>O7:><C,4 47>2AV< 4=52V4GCB=> 4 4C 44V;>28B><C,4 47=0NG><C 4;8H5 4"4B0: 4 4F5 4B0:"4,4 4"4=5<0T 4 4F5 4=V"4;4 4A8;L=VH5 46 4CAL>3> 4 4C 4;N48=V,4 4ACBBN 4O:>3> 4T 4<C6=VABL.4 4>6=0 4=02VBL 4A:070B8,4 4I> 4<C6=VABL 4=0@>46CTBLAO 47 4FL>3> 4AB@0EC,4 4I>1 42@OBC20B8 44>AB>W=AB2> 4;N4AL:>W 4VAB>B8"4.4