34 НімціЕк філософ

10 1?>G0B:C 111913101 12V41C20TBLAO 1@>7@82 1A 1CAA5@;5< 1V 1B0: 1720=89 1"1?>2>@>B"2 2(2K2e2h2r2e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‑4=0: 22 212923242,2 2?V4 2BO30@5< 270;56=VABV 22V4 2=0F8ABAL:>W 2?>;VB8:8 29 2V45>;>3VW,2 270;8H0T 2@5:B>@AB2> 2V 2FV;:>< 22V440TBLAO 228:;040==N 2(2:C@A 2;5:FV9 2?@> 2VFH5)2.2

2 >1>B8 212923262-212925202-2E 2?@8A2OGCT 24>A;V465==N 235=578AC 2V 2:@8B8:C 2<5B0DV78:8 2(2"2'0A 2:0@B8=8 2A2VBC"2 2(212923282)2,2 2"2!;>20 28FH5 2"2>3 2<5@B289"2 2(212924232)2,2 2"2­>2>@>B"2 2(212924292)2,2 2"2­8B0==O 2?@> 2B5E=V:C"2 2(212925232)2.2 281C4>20=0 2VT@0@EVO 2=0 2:>@8ABL 2B@0=AF5=45=B0;L=>3> 2A2VBC 22VG=8E 2ACB=>AB59 27040T 2B>= 2CAL><C 2=0ABC?=><C 270EV4=>T2@>?59AL:><C 2@0FV>=0;V7<>2V 27 29>3> 20:F5=B>< 2=0 2ACI5 2O: 2B0:5 2V 2"2701CBBV"2 21CBBO 2=0 2:>@8ABL 2ACI>3>.2 2091V;LH5 2OA:@02> 2<5B0DV78G=0 2?V4AB020 228O2;OTBLAO 22 2<560E 2>2>3> 2G0AC,2 22 2CAB0=>2FV 2=0 2>?@54<5G820=85 2ACI>3> 2(2>?5@0FVO 2?@54-2AB02;5=8O)2.2 2­5@54-2AB028B8 2 228E>48BL,2 2?> 2X2.2,2 2?><VAB8B8 2?5@54 2A>1>N 2ACI5 2O: 2I>AL 2I> 2?@>B8-2AB>WBL,2 27@>18B8 29>3> 2?@54<5B>< 2V 2B8< 2A0<8< 2C?52=8B8AO 22 2=L><C.2 2­>@>G=VABL 2<5B0DV78:8 2=5 2BV;L:8 22 2"2701CBBV"2 21CBBO,2 20;5 29 2C 2=5<>6;82>ABV 2?>10G8B8 2ACB=VABL 2(2VAB8=C)2 2ACI>3>,2 2=0 2O:5 2<5B0DV78:0 29 2=0FV;5=0,2 2B><C 2I> 2<VAF5 2VAB8=8 2709<0T 22V@>3V4=VABL 2CO2;5==O,2 20 2V450;>< 2@>7AC4C 2AB0T 2B>G=VABL 2V 2AB@>3VABL 2?@8@>4>7=02AB20.2

25B0DV78:0 27<V=NT 2ACBL 2;N48=8,2 2I> 2C 2>289 2G0A 272V;L=OTBLAO 22V4 2CAO:>W 272'2O70=>ABV 27 21CBBO< 2V 2?5@5B2>@NTBLAO 22 2AC1'2T:B0,2 2C 2B0:5 2ACI5,2 2:>B@5 22AL><C 2ACI><C 27040T 2<V@C 2V 2?@>?>=CT 2=>@<C.2 2­>4V1=5 2?5@5B2>@5==O,2 2?> 2X2.2,2 22545 24> 253>F5=B@87<C,2 20=B@>?>;>3V7<C 2V 2A0<>>1>6=N20==O.2 2=H8< 2=5<8=CG8< 2=0A;V4:>< 2@>73>@B0==O 2<5B0DV78:8 2AB0T 22V4GC65==O 2;N48=8 22V4 2A0<>3> 2A515 2V 21574><=VABL,2 2I> 2T 24>;5N 2CAL>3> 270EV4=>T2@>?59AL:>3> 2A2VBC.2 2!CB=VABL 2<5B0DV78:8 228O2;OT 2A515 2C 22AVE 2>1;0ABOE 2:C;LBC@8:2 2C 2=0CFV,2 2@5;V3VW,2 2<8AB5FB2V,2 2<>2V 29 2C 2B5E=V:C,2 23>;>2=V9 2A8;V 2ACG0A=>W 25?>E8.2 2!CBL 2B5E=V:8 2"2?>AB02"2 2(2G2e2s2t2e2l2l2)2 2A:;040TBLAO 22 2CAB0=>2FV 2"2282>48B8 24V9A=5 27 29>3> 2?>B05==>AB8 2A?>A>1>< 2?>-2B02;5=8O 29>3> 2O: 2A>AB>OI53>-22-2=0;8G88"2.2 2#A5 2ACI5 2>?@54<5G8205BAO 24;O 228@>1=8FB20,2 2I> 2?>AB02;OT,2 22BO3CTBLAO 22 2B5E=VG=5 2@>7?>@O465==O.2 2N48=0 2A?>:>=2VG=> 2A0< 2:>HBCT 2CA5@548=V 2AD5@8 2"2?>AB02C"2,2 2B><C 2"2?>AB02"2 2?@028BL 2V 2;N48=>N:2 2:>;8 2;N48=0 2@54C:CT 2A515 24> 2?>AB0G0;L=8:0 2"2=0O2=>3> 2AB0=C"2,2 22V= 2A0< 2A?@89<0TBLAO 2BV;L:8 22 2O:>ABV 2>AB0==L>3>.2 20E>?;5=89 2"2?>AB02><"2 2;N48= 2C?CA:0T 2A515,2 2=5 2<>65 27CAB@VB8AO 2V7 2A0<8< 2A>1>N 2V 2?>GCB8 23>;>A 21CBBO.2 2=0E>465==O 2VAB8=8 21CBBO 2V 2ACBV 2;N48=8,2 222060T 2X2.2,2 2<>6;82> 2G5@57 2<>2C 2(2<>20)2:2 2"2<>20 2-2 2F5 21C48=>: 21CBBO"2,2 2"2ACBL 2;N48=8 2A?>G820T 22 2<>2V"2.2 2@8B8:CNG8 2ACG0A=C 2=5A?@026=N 2<>2C 2O: 2D>@<0;V7>20=>N,2 272'2O70=>N 2;>3V:>N 2V 23@0<0B8:>N,2 2X2.2 22V47=0G0T 29>3> 2?@8:;04=C 27040GC 2?>AB02;OB8 2V=D>@<0FVN.2 2"8< 2A0<8< 2<>20 228ABC?0T 27=0@O44O< 2?0=C20==O 29 20:B8287<0.2 2)>1 27=09B8 2A?@026=O 2<>20 2V 27=>2C 228O28B8AO 2?>1;87C 21CBBO,2 2;N48=0 2?>28==0 2=02G8B8AO 2<>2G0B8.2 2>2G0==O 240T 2A;>2> 2A0<V9 2<>2V 2V 2G5@57 2=L>3> 2A0<><C 21CBBN.2 20<VABL 21030B>A;V2=>ABV 2(2"210;0:0=8=8"2)2 2X2.2 2?@>?>=CT 2>?0=C20B8 2C<V==O< 22A;CEC20B8AO 2C 228<>2=5 2(2GCB8 21CBBO)2.2 2&5 24>AO30TBLAO 2C 2D5=><5=>;>38G5A:>9 2?@>F54C@V 22A;CH820=8O,2 2"22=OB8O"2 2C 2B5,2 2?@> 2I> 2V 2O: 23>2>@8BL 2<>2C 2=0>48=FV 2V7 2A>1>N.2 2#B@0G5=C 2A2O7=>ABL 27 21CBBO< 2X2.2 2=0<030TBLAO 22V4=>28B8,2 2AB2>@NNG8 2A2>N 22;0A=C 2<>2C,2 2I> 2D>@<CTBLAO 2=0 23@0=8FV 2<>28 24V0;5:BC 2V 2<>28 2<VDC 2V 2<5B>N 2O:>3> 2T 22>?@>H0=85 2?@> 21CBBO.2 2 2V=H>3> 21>:C,2 2<>20,2 2C 2O:><C 2A?>G820T 21CBBO,2 2F5,2 2=0A0<?5@54,2 2<>20 2?>57VW,2 2<8AB5FB20.2 225@B0NG8 24> 24>A>:@0B8:0< 2(25@0:;VB0,2 2=0:A8<0=4@C,2 2­0@<5=84C)3,3 34> 3?>57VW 3=V<5FL:>3> 3@><0=B87<C 3(35;L45@;8=,3 3!.3 35>@35,3 35@8:5)3,3 3X3.3 3?>:07CT,3 3O: 3:@V7L 3?>5B8G=5 3<8A;5==O,3 3:@V7L 3B2V@ 3<8AB5FB20 3?@>A2VGCT 3ACB=VABL 3@5GV,3 374V9A=NTBLAO 3VAB8=0 31CBBO 3O: 3=5?>B05==>ABL.3 3!0<5 3?>5B 3(32V47=0G0T 3X3.3 3C 3?V7=VE 3AB0BBOE 3V 34>?>2V4OE 3"3(;OE 34> 3<>28"3,3 3"3!;>2>"3)3 3740B=89 32V4:@8B8 3B0T<=8FN 3<>28 3V 340B8 3<>6;82VABL 3@>7:@8B8AO 3VAB8=V 31CBBO.3 3!5@54 3<8A;8B5;V2,3 3=0 3DV;>A>DAL:5 3AB0=>2;5==O 3O:8E 3X3.3 3C?;8=C;8,3 39>3> 3157?>A5@54=V 3?>A;V4>2=8:8 3(3040<5@)3,3 39>3> 3:@8B8:8 3(3/A?5@A,3 30@=0?,3 3%015@-3<0A,3 34>@=>)3 3V 32V4HB>2ECNBLAO 32V4 39>3> 3<8A;5==O 3DV;>A>D8 3(3!0@B@,3 3ﾵ5@@V40,3 3;0=H>,3 3.3 3;N:A<0=,3 3 >@BV,3 3(.3 3(8@<0E5@,3 3‑@5=4)3.3