Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Унификация оценочных признаков при квалификации преступлений против личности. Монография

.pdf
Скачиваний:
1
Добавлен:
08.09.2026
Размер:
2 Мб
Скачать
☆
vinxzknttu wvsvntqnu Ìtj uvnz iz zvsrv viyxsvksntj
nmvsq·tuquvéjstuqrj·nxzkjuyuntqnuizuvéjstvjlnr
kjztu zvp qsq qtvp xqzyj|qq j qtvp éjo q wvpzq kvwénrq vz
qk¡quuvéjstutvéuju
Æëzvpxk¹oqwénlsjmjnzx¹éjosq·jzëzqryuvéjsqtéjkxzknt
tvxzxsnlyíquviéjovuëzqrj²tjyrjvuvéjsqqtéjkxzknttv
xzq uvéjs ² tjqivsnn viqn wéqt|qwqjstn wvsvntq¹téjk
xzknttvxzq téjkxzknttvxz ² xwvxvi kéjntq¹ sq·tu wvxzyw
rvuuvéjstvëzq·nxrq}tvéukxvmsjxqqxxvknxzí·nsvknrj
Íéjkv k xvkénunttvp íéqlq·nxrvp tjyrn kvxwéqtqujnzx¹ k
zén}jxwnrzj}
x rjr xqxznuj vinvi¹ojznst} xv|qjst} tvéu wéjkqs
wvknlntq¹{véujstv vwénlnsntt}qojrénwsntt}kv{q|qjs
t} lvryuntzj} wvlzknéljnu} q v}éjt¹nu} xqsvp mvxyljéxz
knttvmvwéqtylntq¹ vinxwn·qkjínmv íéqlq·nxryí énmsjuntzj
|qívinxzkntt}vztv¡ntqp
x rjr tnrqp quwnéjzqk inoyxsvktp wéqt|qw wvknlntq¹
zénivkjtqn wvknsntqn xzv¹qp tjl mvxyljéxzkvu q ojrvtvu oj
qjíqp xwéjknlsqkp wvé¹lvr mvxyljéxzkj rjr {véu
xjuvvémjtqoj|qqvinxzkj
x rjr xvkvrywtvxz xv|qjst} énmys¹zvévk rvzvéj¹ uvnz
izvisn·ntjkxvvzknzxzkyíyíojrvtvljznstyí{véuyjuvnz
xynxzkvkjzqktnojrvtvljznsxzkj
Ðjrzq·nxrquvéjs q wéjkv wénlxzjks¹íz xvivp lkj wvl}vlj r
énmysqévkjtqí vztv¡ntqp k vinxzkn ² {qsvxv{xrvly}vktp
uvéjsqtéjkxzknttvxzq{véujsqovkjtvwéqtylqznstpwéj
kvkvn énmysqévkjtqn lkn xzvévt vltvp msvijstvp xv|qjstvp
ojlj·q {véuqévkjtq¹ q {ytr|qvtqévkjtq¹ vinxzknttvmvxy
ljéxzknttvmvyxzévpxzkjvxtvkjttvmvtjwéqt|qwj}·nsvkn·tvxzq
lviéj q xwéjknlsqkvxzq mln uvéjs q téjkxzknttvxz ¹ks¹ízx¹
lkqynp xqsvp wéjkvkvmv énmysqévkjtq¹ fk¹oyíqu okntvu
xkvnviéjotu ©wnén}vltu uvxzqrvuª unly wéjkvu q uvéjsí
¹ks¹nzx¹wvt¹zqnwéjkvxvotjtq¹
Íéjkvxvotjtqn²vxvij¹rjznmvéq¹znvéqqmvxyljéxzkjqwéjkjq
réquqtvsvmqqvotj·jíj¹x{néyvinxzknttvmvméywwvkvmvqqt
lqkqlyjstvmv xvotjtq¹ xk¹ojttyí x vzéjntqnu wéjkvotj·qu}
¹ksntqp q viyxsvksnttyí wéjkvotj·quuq uvéjstuq |nttvxz¹
uqwéjkvwvtqujtqnuqwénlxzjksntqnuvlvstvuwéjkvwvé¹lrn
Íéjkvxvotjtqn vwénlns¹nzx¹ xv|qjstvërvtvuq·nxrquq yxsv
kq¹uq uvéjstvëzq·nxrquq zéjlq|q¹uqj ©lvstpwéjkvwvé¹
lvrª vinxwn·qkjnzx¹ xqxznuvp wéjkvv}éjtqznst} vémjtvk r rv
zvévpk·jxztvxzqvztvx¹zx¹vémjtl votjtq¹qwénlkjéqznstvmv
xsnlxzkq¹

Òjrqu viéjovu uvéjs k}vlqz k xqxznuy wéjkjrjr téjkxzknt
tp ©réqznéqp qxzqtª wéjkvzkvé·nxrvp q wéjkvv}éjtqznstvp
ln¹znstvxzq ¹ks¹¹x wénlwvxsrvp yxsvkqnu q kjtu xzéyr
zyéturvuwvtntzvu wéjkj fëzvpzv·rq oéntq¹ wéjkv ²{véuj
vinxzknttvmv énmysqévkjtq¹ vxtvkjttj¹ tjmvxwvlxzkyínp vi
nxzknttvp uvéjsq Æ ëzvp xk¹oq ojrvtvljzns vi¹ojt y·qzkjz
tvéuqwéqt|qwvinxzknttvpuvéjsqkojrvtn
Íéjkvwvzénitvxzvinxzkjvxtvkjttj¹tjuvéjsqznxtvxu
rjnzx¹xwvt¹zqnu©nxznxzknttvnwéjkvª{véujstu kéjntqnu
rvzvévmv ¹ks¹nzx¹ wvoqzqktvn wéjkv Çvssqoq¹ unly nxznxzknt
tu wéjkvu ijoqéyínux¹ tj xv|qjstvëzq·nxrvp wjéjlqmun
wvt¹zq¹xwéjknlsqkvxzq q nn vzéjntqnu{qrxqéynuvuk ojrvtn
wéqokjtj éjoén¡jzx¹ ·néno Çvtxzqzy|qí èÐ Ëvéu msjk 
xz² Çvtxzqzy|qq èÐ kxzywjíz kx¡np {véuvp {qrxqév
kjttvmvwéjkjqwvxénltqrvuunlywvoqzqktuwéjkvuq uvéjs
tvëzq·nxrquxv|qjstvly}vktuquwnéjzqkvuwéjkj
Òjrqu viéjovu qxwvsovkjtqn wéjkvwéquntqznsnu xv|qvsvmq
·nxrvmvxwvxvijzvsrvkjtq¹v|ntv·t}wvt¹zqqqwéqotjrvk wyznu
xylnitvmvyxuvzéntq¹viyxsvksqkjnzwév¹ksntqn lqjmtvxzq·nxrvmv
}jéjrznéj énjsqoj|qq tvéu ujznéqjstvmv wvoqzqktvmv wéjkj tj
wéjrzqrnÆvqoinjtqnxylnit}v¡qivrqsqznuivsnnwévqokv
sj xv xzvévt wéjkvwéquntqzns¹ k xqzyj|qq éjxxuvzéntq¹ rvt
rénzt} lns mjéjtzq¹uq xwéjknlsqkvxzq q ojrvttvxzq wéqtqujn
u} én¡ntqq lvst iz qsq xzjz lvxrvtjstvn otjtqn tvé
ujzqktvwéjkvkvp ijo ymvsvktvmv ojrvtvljznsxzkj q kxvrqp
yévknt wéjkvkvp ryszyé wéjkvwéquntqzns¹ ¹ks¹íqux¹ téjk
xzknttvëzq·nxrqu{ytljuntzvunmvwéjkvxvotjtq¹
Êxxsnlvkjtqnwévknlnttvntjuqk x{nénwéjkvwéquntqznstvp
wéjrzqrqyinlqznstv xkqlnznsxzkynzvén¡jínpévsqéjokqzvmv
q kxvrvtéjkxzknttvmv wéjkvxvotjtq¹ k yxzjtvksntqq qxzqttvmv
xvlnéjtq¹tnrvtrénzqoqévkjtt}kojrvtnwvt¹zqpq wéqotjrvk
cxsq wéq jtjsqon wvxzv¹tt} {véujstvvwénlnsntt} rvtrén
zqoqévkjtt} wvt¹zqp q wéqotjrvk otj·ntqn wéjkvxvotjtq¹ xv
xzvqzmsjktuviéjovu k vinxwn·ntqq wéjkqstvmv y¹xtntq¹ znr
xzjojrvtjzvkxsy·jnwéquntntq¹v|ntv·tvprjznmvéqqtjwéjkv
xvotjtqn wéjkvwéquntqzns¹ kvosjmjnzx¹ xnénotj¹ lvwvstqznstj¹
ojlj·j vwénlnsqz xvlnéjtqn xvvzknzxzkyínmv tn{véujsqoqév
kjttvmvwvt¹zq¹qsqwéqotjrjqx}vl¹qozénivkjtqpojrvtjq w éj
kqstvmvwvtqujtq¹|nsnpqojlj·ymvsvktvmvwéjkj
Òjrquviéjovu wéjkqstvxzxylnitvmvzvsrvkjtq¹qwéquntn
tq¹ tj wéjrzqrn v|ntv·t} rjznmvéqp ymvsvktvmv wéjkj k otj·q
znstvp xznwntq ojkqxqz vz rvtrénztvmv kvwsvntq¹ k wéjkvwéq
untqznstvp wéjrzqrn wvt¹zq¹ ©wéjkvxvotjtqnª Ìtv xjuv qunnz

¹érvkéjnttpv|ntv·tp}jéjrznéfyévktnuéjokqzq¹wéjkv
xvotjtq¹qwéjkqstvxzínmvénjsqoj|qqkwvkxnltnktvpln¹zns
tvxzq xylvk xk¹ojt wnéxwnrzqk én¡ntq¹ kxn} wévisnu rvtrén
zqoj|qq{véujsqoj|qqv|ntv·t}wvt¹zqpqwéqotjrvk
Ívtj¡nuyutntqíxsnlvkjsvikknxzq wvxzjtvksntqnuÆné
}vktvmvfylj èÐ qsqxvvzknzxzkyíqu ojrvtvljznstu jrzvu k
xylnityíwéjrzqry zénivkjtqn xvmsjxtvrvzvévuy vivxtvkjttvxz
zvmv qsq qtvmv én¡ntq¹ wéjkvwéquntqzns¹ wvlzknéljsjx yévk
tnu xznwntí q }jéjrznévu vwénlnsnttvxzq rvtrénzqoj|qq qx
wvsoynu}quv|ntv·t}wvt¹zqpqwéqotjrvk
Òjrwéqqxwvsovkjtqqtjqivsnn}vz¹qktnlvxzjzv·tvpunén
rvtrénzqoqévkjtt} k ymvsvktvu ojrvtn v|ntv·t} wvt¹zqp q
wéqotjrvk vztvx¹q}x¹ wv xznwntq {véujsqoj|qq vwénlnsnttv
xzq r v|ntv·tv{véujstvp q} éjotvkqltvxzq isv i tnvi}v
lquv xvxsjzx¹ tj rvtrénztp tvéujzqktvwéjkvkvp jrz ojrvt
jrzvinvi¹ojznstvmvzvsrvkjtq¹mlnéjo~¹xt¹nzx¹otj·ntqnëzv
mvv|ntv·tvmv wvt¹zqpqsqwéqotjrj Æxsy·jnqxwvsovkjtq¹xsj
ivrvtrénzqoqévkjtt}k ojrvtn {véujstvv|ntv·t} wvt¹zqp q
wéqotjrvk wéjkvwéquntqzns lvsnt is i vivxtvkjz xkvn én
¡ntqnxxsrjuqtjjrz tvéujzqktvmv zvsrvkjtq¹ xvvzknzxzkyí
qnwvxzjtvksntq¹qvwénlnsntq¹Æné}vktvmvfyljèÐÍéqwéq
untntqqwéjrzq·nxrqtnrvtrénzqoqévkjtt} k ojrvtn xvixzknttv
v|ntv·t}wvt¹zqp q wéqotjrvkxsnlvkjsvi xxsjzx¹ tjvwén
lnsntq¹q wvxzjtvksntq¹ Æné}vktvmvfyljèÐ wv rvtrénztuln
sju rvtxzqzy|qvttn tvéujzqktvwéjkvkn jrz tvéu unly
tjévltvmv wéjkj lvrzéqtjstvn zvsrvkjtqn xylnityí wéjrzqry x
qxwvsovkjtqnuësnuntzvkwén|nlntztvmvwéjkjtvwéquntqznstv
tnrxjuvuyxylnitvuyén¡ntqíjrqxwvsoynuvpznéuqtvsvmqqq
zéjrzvkrn v|ntv·t} rjznmvéqp Çévun zvmv vi¹ojznstv lvstj
izyxqsntjvzknzxzknttvxzxylnpojwvxzjtvksntq¹tnxwéjknlsq
k} q tnvivxtvkjtt} wéqmvkvévk ² jluqtqxzéjzqktj¹ wév{nx
xqvtjstj¹ jzznxzj|q¹ wnénjzznxzj|q¹ lqxrkjsq{qrj|q¹ q ymv
svktvwéjkvkj¹
Çjrwénlxzjks¹nzx¹k¡nqosvnttnwvl}vlrén¡ntqíwév
isnu xk¹ojtt} x qxwvsovkjtqnu v|ntv·t} wvt¹zqp q wéqotj
rvkxynxzknttvwvkx¹zqrj·nxzkvqyévkntwéqtqujnu}wéj
kvwéquntqznsnuén¡ntqpwvrvtrénztulnsjuêzviylyzxwvxvi
xzkvkjz q ivsnn qtzntxqktvuy wvwvstntqí xkvnviéjotvmv ©ijtrj
ljtt}ªv|ntv·t}wvt¹zqpq wéqotjrvk knx vi~nu rvzvé} oj
znu uvtv isv i qxwvsovkjz rjr wéq ktnxntqq rvéénrzqk k
lnpxzkyínnymvsvktvnojrvtvljznsxzkvzjrqwéqrvtxzéyqévkj
tqqtvkvmvkjéqjtzjznrxzjÏÇ èÐ k rvzvévu v|ntv·turjznmv
éq¹utnqointviylnzylnsntvivs¡nunxzjqktqujtq¹

ï&
Çjrqoknxztvwéjkv ¡qén ojrvtj jqot¡qén wéjkj Êunttv
ëzqu vixzv¹znsxzkvu k wnékyí v·nénl vi~¹xt¹nzx¹ xju {jrz xy
nxzkvkjtq¹kxqxznunymvsvktvmvwéjkjqtxzqzyzjv|ntv·t}rjzn
mvéqp ujrxqujstv kvouvtj¹ nxzrj¹ {véujsqoj|q¹ rvzvévmv
tnxvutnttv ¹ks¹nzx¹ tnvi}vlquu yxsvkqnu jlnrkjztvxzq rkjsq
{qrj|qqxvkné¡nttvmvln¹tq¹xvxzjkywénxzywsntq¹qqtlqkqlyjsq
oj|qq tjrjojtq¹ k zv·tvuxvvzknzxzkqq x zénivkjtq¹uq ymvsvktvmv
ojrvtjqwéqt|qwjuqwéjkjÌ|ntv·tnwvt¹zq¹qwéqotjrqkxzy
wjíz k évsq xkvnviéjotvmv xk¹oyínmv okntj unly {véujstuq
tvéujuq wéjkj q wvxzv¹ttv lqtjuq·tuq xv|qjstuq énjsq¹uq
tj {vtn rvzvé} wvkxnltnktv q tnwénéktv wévqx}vlqz méjtlqvo
tvnqléjujzq·nxrvnwévzqkvxzv¹tqnunlyqotíqxunézílvi
évu q osvu vinxzkvu q wénxzywtuq xvvinxzkjuq ojrvtvu q
wénxzywsntqnuwéjkvuqtjxqsqnulnsqrzvuqtjrjojtqnu
Ï·nzëzvp lqtjuqrq k otj·qznstvp unénxwvxvixzkynzrvtrén
zqoj|qq q wnéxvtq{qrj|qq ymvsvktvp vzknzxzknttvxzq ² wéq yx
svkqq wéjkqstvmv xwéjknlsqkvmv q ojrvttvmv qxwvsovkjtq¹ k
wéjkvwéquntqznstvpwéjrzqrn xwvxvijxylnitvmvyxuvzéntq¹cmv
énjsqoj|q¹ ojknlvuv wénlwvsjmjnz otj·qznstv ivs¡qp ·nu wéq
qxwvsovkjtqq nxzrv {véujsqovkjtt} rvtrénztvvwénlnsntt}
wéqotjrvkéjoiévxutntqpqén¡ntqp ·zv tnqointv lnznéuqtq
éynzknév¹ztvxzxylnit}tnlv·nzvkqv¡qivr
Ëjxnénotvxz xsvqk¡npx¹ xqzyj|qq viéjzqsktqujtqn Íén
oqlntzèÐÆÆÍyzqtkxkvnunnmvltvuwvxsjtqq mvljÐn
lnéjstvuy fviéjtqí Ìt kéjoqs vinxwvrvnttvxz znu vixzv¹
znsxzkvu·zvlvxq}wvéytjxkxzéjtn©xylzjrqtnxzjstqxrv
éutqwéjkutqxwéjknlsqkuªqtnénlrvxylij·nsvknrjén
¡jnzx¹©wv yxuvzéntqíxyljªxsq¡rvuwévqokvstvzvsryínmv q
wéqunt¹ínmvojrvt
djunzqu ·zv zjrvn wvsvntqn lns xzjsv kvouvtu qunttv
wvzvuy ·zv otj·qznstj¹·jxz ymvsvktvmv ojrvtvljznsxzkj vxtv
kjtj qunttv tj qxwvsovkjtqq v|ntv·t} rjznmvéqp êzv tnqo
intvviyxsvksqkjnz tnvi}vlquvxz xylnitvmv zvsrvkjtq¹ vltjrv
olnxtnuntnnknsqrjqlvs¹vzknzxzknttvxzqojrvtvljzns¹kvstv
qsqxsy·jptvwvxzjkqk¡nmvwéjkvwéquntqzns¹kzjrqnyxsvkq¹
Ònu tn untnnljn inmsj¹ ©qtkntzjéqoj|q¹ª v|ntv·t} wvt¹
zqp q wéqotjrvk qxwvsoynu} k tjxzv¹nn kénu¹ k ymvsvktvu

wéjkn wvokvs¹nz tjuwénlsvqz véqmqtjstyí x}nuy q} rsjxxq
{qrj|qq q ljz tnrvzvén énrvuntlj|qq wv ytq{qrj|qq v|ntv·
t} rjznmvéqp Ê} xvvztnxntqn x vi~nuvu qunínmvx¹ ujxxqkj
©ijtrjªvwénlnsntqp ljtt}ktvéujzqktvwéjkvk}jrzj} qlv
ryuntzj} tvéujzqktvmv jyzntzq·tvmv lvrzéqtjstvmv q rjoyjs
tvmv zvsrvkjtq¹ tjms¹ltv xkqlnznsxzkynz v zvu ·zv vxtvktj¹
ujxxj wvt¹zqp q wéqotjrvk v|ntv·tvmv }jéjrznéj yn k tjxzv¹nn
kénu¹ uvnz iz {véujsqovkjtj k ymvsvktvu wéjkn k otj·qznstv
ivs¡npunénqxznwntq·nuëzvxlnsjsojrvtvljznskznrxznÏÇèÐ
Ënvi}vlquvxzzjrvmvévljrvtrénzqoj|qqljktvtjoénsjqxzj
sj vxvinttv jrzyjstvp tj {vtn wévkvlquvp k tjxzv¹nn kénu¹
xylnitvwéjkvkvp én{véu cn oéquu k wnéxwnrzqkn qzvmvu
lvstvxzjzyxqsntqnrvtxzqzy|qvtt}mjéjtzqpwéqvzwéjksntqq
wéjkvxylq¹²ljnkzn}xsy·j¹}rvmljwéjkvwéquntqznslnpxzky
nzkéjurj}xylnitvmvyxuvzéntq¹wvxkvnuy ktyzénttnuy yinln
tqíq vwnéqéynz tnlvxzjzv·tvrvtrénzqoqévkjttuq k ymvsvktvu
ojrvtnwvt¹zq¹uqqwéqotjrjuqznv|ntv·tuqrjznmvéq¹uqÊ}
ywvé¹lv·ntqn ytq{qrj|q¹ q {véujsqoj|q¹ rvtrénzqoj|q¹ tj
tj¡koms¹l lvstj xzjzvltqu qo kjtnp¡q} xvxzjkt}ësnunt
zvk tjun·jíq}x¹ rjélqtjst} wénviéjovkjtqp k xylnitvp xqx
znunèÐ
Íéqëzvu kivé znuqwévisnujzqry tj¡np éjivzis viy
xsvksntvxzévp tnvi}vlquvxzí x}nujzqoj|qq zqwqoj|qqrsjxxq
{qrj|qq q ytq{qrj|qq v|ntv·t} rjznmvéqp qxwvsoynu} wéq
rkjsq{qrj|qq q tjotj·ntqq tjrjojtq¹ oj wénxzywsntq¹ wévzqk
sq·tvxzqvzknzxzknttvxzojrvzvénwvoqzqkqévkjtjkéjolnsn9,,
msjk²xz²ÏÇèÐ
Êoiéjttptjuqrvt|nwzyjstp wvl}vlrén¡ntqíëzvpwév
isnu q wvokvsqs vxynxzkqz q jwéviqévkjz é¹l tjy·tv
wéjrzq·nxrq}éjoéjivzvrwénlsjmjíq}
x rsjxxq{qrj|qí q kivév·tn xsvkjéqwnén·tq v|ntv·t}
rjznmvéqp qxwvsoynu} k Ìinp ·jxzq ÏÇ èÐ q k éjolnsn 9,,
©Íénxzywsntq¹wévzqksq·tvxzqªÌxvinttvp·jxzqymvsvktvmvwéjkj
x xwqxvr v|ntv·t} rjznmvéqp wéqunt¹nu} wéq ymvsvktv
wéjkvkvp rkjsq{qrj|qq q tjotj·ntqq tjrjojtq¹ oj wénxzywsntq¹
wévzqksq·tvxzq
x tvkn{véuysqévkrqé¹ljvxtvkt} znéuqtvkxk¹ojtt}x
qoy·ntqnuznuqwévisnu
x énrvuntlj|qq wv qountntqí znrxzj é¹lj xzjznp k Ìinp q
Ìxvinttvp·jxz¹}Ï Ç èÐ xvlnéjq} v|ntv·tnwvt¹zqpqwéq
otjrqwvén{véuqévkjtqíxqxznutjrjojtq¹o jwénxzywsntq¹wv
qxwvsovkjtqírvuwntxj|qvttvmvwvl}vljwéqtjotj·ntqqtjrjoj
tq¹

x tvkyí rsjxxq{qrj|qí kqlvk zvsrvkjtq¹ tvéu ymvsvktvmv
wéjkj krsí·jíq} v|ntv·tn rjznmvéqq énrvuntlj|qq wv éj
|qvtjstvuy qxwvsovkjtqí v|ntv·t} wvt¹zqp q wéqotjrvk k
ojrvtvljznstvpln¹znstvxzqqwéjkvwéquntqznstvpwéjrzqrn
x wv éjx¡qéntqí q ywvé¹lv·ntqí wvt¹zqptvznéuqtvsv
mq·nxrvpijov|ntv·t}rjznmvéqpkÏÇèÐ
x vivxtvkjtqn tnvi}vlquvxzq q |nsnxvviéjotvxzq ytq{qrj
|qq v|ntv·t} wvt¹zqp q wéqotjrvk k wvt¹zqptvznéuqtv
svmq·nxrvu qtxzéyuntzjéqp rjr ymvsvktvmv wéjkj zjr q wéqrsjl
t} tjyr réquqtjstvmv |qrsj ymvsvktvmv wév|nxxj ymvsvktv
qxwvstqznstvmv wéjkj réquqtvsvmqq q réquqtjsqxzqrq tj vx
tvknwénlsvnttvptjuqrvt|nw|qq rsjxxq{qrj|qq q {véujsqoj
|qqrvtrénzqoj|qqv|ntv·t}rjznmvéqp
Òjrquviéjovuénoyszjztjxzv¹nmvqxxsnlvkjtq¹tjwéjksn
ttjylvksnzkvéntqné¹ljwvzénitvxznpkx{néj} qwéjkvzkvé·nxz
kjqwéjkvwéquntqznstvpln¹znstvxzq

fzéyrzyéj
v|ntv·t}
rjznmvéqp
   
Ìztvxqznstvwév
xznwvt¹zq¹qwéq
otjrq
÷
Çsjxxq{qrj|q¹v|ntv·t}rjznmvéqpqxwvsoynu}kÌinp·jxzqÏÇèÐ
fznwnt{véujsqoj|qq
Ì|ntv·tv{véujstn
wvt¹zq¹qwéqotjrq
tnlvxzjzv·tvrvtrén
zqoqévkjttnkojrvtn
Æqtj
Æunt¹nuvxz
éywwj
Êuynxzkv
Êtlqkql
Îjsvsnztqn
Ëjrjojtqn
Ënkunt¹nuvxz
Ìéylqn
Ìéyqn
Íénxzywsntqn
èqxr
fmvkvé
fwsv·nttvxz
fénlxzkj
Ðvéujstvv|ntv·tnwvt¹zq¹q
wéqotjrqxsjivrvtrénzqoqév
kjttnkojrvtn
¬srvmvs
Ènolnpxzkqn
Ènovwjxtvxz
Æéjlj
Æénl
bnpxzkqn
nxzvrvxz
djrvttvxz
Êolnkjznsxzkv
Êxwéjksntqn
Îvzqk
Îy·ntq¹
Ëjxqsqn
Ëntjkqxz
Ìivxtvkjttvxz
Ìxzjtvkrj
fvixzknttvv|ntv·tnwv
t¹zq¹qwéqotjrq
wéjrzq·nxrqtnrvtrénzqoq
évkjttnkojrvtn
¬srvmvsqou
Æsjxz
Ævs¹
Ævxwqzjtqn
vxyljéxzkv
yujtqou
nsjtqn
qot
djknlvuvxz
Éq·tvxz
Éq|v
Îvéjs
Înlq|qtj
Ëjérvujtq¹
Ëj|q¹
Ënvi}vlquvxz
Òjisq|j
   
Ìwjxtvxz
Ívknlntqn
Ívlryw
Ívéy·ntqn
Ívé¹lvr
Ívx¹mjznsxzkv
Ívznéwnk¡qp
Íénxzywtvxz
Íéqrjo
èjktvwéjkqn
fjlqou
fvixzknttvxz
fvxzéjljtqn
Ïinlntq¹
Ïmvkvé
Ïmévoj
Ïnéi
ïnsvknr
Íévlvsntqnzjis
Ìinxzkv
Ìw¹tntqn
Íéjkv
Íévzqkvwéjktvxz
Íxq}qrj
èjkntxzkv
èjxj
ènsqmq¹
fkvivlj
fwéjknlsqkvxz
êuv|q¹
   
fsvtnwvt¹zq¹
qwéqotjrq
fsvtvxvxzjktn
wvt¹zq¹qwéqotjrq
éywwjsq|
dsvxztvntnqxwvstntqn
Êuynxzknttpynéi
Îjsvsnztqnlnzq
Îjznéqjstj¹ojkqxq
uvxz
Îtquj¹vivévtj
Ënvi}vlquj¹vivévtj
Ò¹rqnwvxsnlxzkq¹
fwvxvixzkvkjtqnéjx
rézqíwénxzywsntq¹
krjxwvkqttvp
Ènoojqztvnsq|v
Ènxwvuvtvnxvxzv¹tqn
bn¹znstvnéjxrj¹tqn
Êountntqnvixzjtvkrq
Çvtxzqzy|qvttpxzévp
Îvzqkwénxzywsntq¹
Îvzqkxvxzéjljtq¹
Ìlyéujtqkjíqnknnxzkj
Ìxvij¹nxzvrvxz
Íéjkj·nsvknrj
Íénxzywtvnwvknlntqn
Íénxzywtvnwvx¹mjznsxzkv
fsynitj¹ln¹znstvxz
fsynitvnwvsvntqn
fzq}qptvninlxzkqn
fwéjknlsqkvntjrjojtqn
Ïmévojtjrjojtq¹
Ðqoq·nxrvntjxqsqn
Ðqoq·nxrvnwéqtylntqn
ïénok·jptvnwvsvntqn
Ìixzjtvkrjxvkné¡ntq¹
wénxzywsntq¹
Ìxynxzksntqnxsynitvpln¹
znstvxzq
fsy·jptvnxzn·ntqnvixzv¹
znsxzk
Ò¹nsnqotnttn
vixzv¹znsxzkj
Ìrvt·jtqnzjis
¬uvéjstvnwvknlntqn
Îjxxvkninxwvé¹lrq
Îvéjstpkénl
Ìinxzknttvninlxzkqn
Ìinxzknttj¹inovwjxtvxz
Ìinxzknttplvsm
Ìinxzknttpwvé¹lvr
Ìréyjíj¹xénlj
Íjzvsvmq·nxrvnvw¹tntqn
Íénlxzjkqznsksjxzq
Íévzqkvwéjktvnwvknlntqn
Íxq}q·nxrvnwéqtylntqn
fv|qjstj¹xwéjknlsqkvxz
Ïmvsvktj¹wévzqkvwéjk
tvxz
Æwvstntqnvinxzknttv
mvlvsmj
èjkntxzkvméjljtwnénl
ojrvtvu

Íéqsvntqnrzjisq|n
Æivév·tpznéuqtvsvmq·nxrqpxsvkjéwnén·ntwvt¹zqp
qwéqotjrvkqxwvsoynu}kÌinp·jxzqymvsvktvmvwéjkj
,Ìztvxqznstvwévxznwvt¹zq¹qwéqotjrq
Ì|ntv·tv{véujstn
tnlvxzjzv·tvrvtrénzqoqévkjttnkojrvtn
Æqtj²vxvotjtqnsq|vukvouvtvxzqymvsvktvp vzknzxzknttv
xzqqtjrjojtq¹ojxvkné¡nttvn ln¹tqnkuvuntzxvkné¡ntq¹ëzvmv
ln¹tq¹qkwnéqvlxylnitvmvéjoiqéjznsxzkj
Æunt¹nuvxz ² xwvxvitvxz qsq kvouvtvxz vxvotjtq¹ xkvnp
kqt sq|vu kv kénu¹ xvkné¡ntq¹ ymvsvktv tjrjoynuvmv ln¹tq¹
wénxzywsntq¹qkwnéqvlxylnitvmvéjoiqéjznsxzkj
éywwj ² vméjtq·nttj¹ k ·qxsnttvxzq vitvxz sílnp kln
s¹nuj¹qo xv|qjstvmv |nsvmvtj vxtvkn vwénlnsntt} wéqotjrvk
}jéjrznéjkwvst¹nuvpln¹znstvxzqxv|qjstvpwéqtjlsntvxzq
xzéyrzyén yévktí éjokqzq¹ q zw Ëjqivsnn éjxwévxzéjtnttn
rsjxxq{qrj|qq méyww wv ·qxsnttvxzq ivs¡qn ujsn uqrév
méyww² lqjlj zéqjljwv vinxzknttvuy xzjzyxy {véujstn
v{q|qjstn tn{véujstn tnv{q|qjstn wv tnwvxénlxzknt
tvxzq kojquvxk¹onp énjstn rvtzjrztn yxsvktn wv yévktí
éjokqzq¹ tqorvmv yévkt¹ jxxv|qj|qq rvéwvéj|qq lq{{yotn
méyww kxvrvmv yévkt¹ ² rvssnrzqk wv otj·quvxzq én{n
éntztn qtln{{néntztn Ænsq·qtj xzéyrzyéj q xvxzjk méyww
vwénlns¹nzx¹ |ns¹uq q ojlj·juq ln¹znstvxzq k rvzvéyí vtj
krsí·ntjqsqéjlqrvzvévpxvoljtj

Íéqxvxzjksntqq xsvkjé¹ jkzvévu qxwvsovkjt xsnlyíqn qxzv·tqrq Íx q
}vsvmq¹ xsvkjé fvxzÉ¬Çjéwntrv ² Î  Èvs¡vp ët|qrsvwnlq·n
xrqp xsvkjé  ènl ¬fy}jénk ÆËdvérqt ÆcÇéyzxrq} ² Î 
Çéjzrqp xsvkjé znéuqtvk wv ymvsvktvuy wéjky è nl ÈÆ|nsntrv
ÆÈÈvévkqrvk²ÎÈvs¡vpët|qrsvwnlq·nxrqpxsvkjéÆlky}z vuj}
ènl ¬ÎÍév}vévk ² Î Ðqsvxv{xrqp xsvkjé ènlÊÒÐévsvk ²
ÎÌnmvkfÊfsvkjééyxxrvmv¹orj²ÎbjsÆÊÒvsrvkp
xsvkjéqkvmvknsqrvéyxxrvmv¹orjÆ }z²Î  ÌnmvkfÊ kn
lvkjËìÒvsrvkp xsvkjé éyxxrvmv ¹orj ² Î  Çéjzrqp {qsvxv{
xrqp xsvkjé ènl Îèvontzjs Íìlqt ² Î  Ëvknp¡qp {qsvxv{
xrqp xsvkjé ènl ¬¬éq|jtvk ² Îqtxr  Ívwys¹étp íéqlq·nxrqp
ët|qrsvwnlq·nxrqp xsvkjé ènl rvs ÌcÇyzj{qt Æ¬Òyujtvk
ÊÆujévk²Îìéqlq·nxrj¹ët|qrsvwnlq¹ ènl ÎìÒq}vuqévk
²Î ïy{jtvkxrqpìÆìéqlq·nxrj¹wxq}vsvmq¹ kvwévx qvzknz ²
Î  ¬rvwvkÆÊÎnlq|qtxrvn wéjkv k kvwévxj} q vzknzj} ² Î 
fsvkjéwvymvsvktvuywéjkyÌzkénl¬ÆËjyuvk²Î

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]