Жуков. Государство. Право. Власть
.pdf
Mj"v"[ff §J‘"[LёDff fqJ"Lff vf‘[gfqJfAj Ljvf[f"gj]j‘ff Dfv"у q"Dff №Lёgj fqAkqqJgjд ! ‘ё"U"L"J <jvё+ "№L"U"gёJE №qfM"ё‘ёvf> g ]jxqJgff zLjx] ]"g"vE‘" №"]L"U‘" LёqqRёJLfgёjJ №LfL"]k q"Tfу ёvE‘QM qg+>jx f A"‘DvfAJ"g №L"UvjRQ gvёqJf №Lёgё q№Lёgj]vfg"у qJf g"x‘Qд Hj q">]ёg Tjv"qJ‘"x №"vfJfGjqA"x Jj"Lff вJёAk™ >ё]ёGk "‘ №jLj] q"U"x f ‘j qJёgfvи zLjx] q]jvёv g f>gjqJ‘"R qRQqvj ["Lё>у ]" U"vEKj у "JALQv ‘"gQx №"уqg"jRk k‘fgjLqёvE‘Qx RjJ"] ё‘ёvf>ё q"TfёvE‘"у№"vfJfGjqAfM +gvj‘fxд HёfU"vjj LjvEjD‘" j[" №"vfJfGjу qAfj f]jf №Lj]qJёgvj‘Q g JёAfM LёU"JёM AёA sЮёqq"gё+ №qfM"v"[f+ f ё‘ёvf> Gjv"gjGjqA"[" sny s?"JjR f JёUky sHj]"g"vEqJg" AkvEJkу L"xy sp"GjRk g"x‘ёФyд
p"] №qfM"ё‘ёvf>"R вJjLRf‘ ggj]j‘ zLjx]"Rи №"‘fRёjJq+ g"у №jLgQM RjJ"] №qfM"v"[fGjqA"[" fqqvj]"gё‘f+ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QM №qfMfGjqAfM №L"Tjqq"g g"уgJ"LQM RjJ"] vjGj‘f+ ‘jgL"JfGjqAfM >ёу U"vjgё‘fx f gуJLjJEfM №qfM"v"[fGjqAё+ Jj"Lf+ " qJL"j‘ff f Dk‘Aу Tf"‘fL"gё‘ff №qfMfGjqA"[" ё№№ёLёJё Gjv"gjAёд pqfMfAё f‘]fgf]ё №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x ]f‘ёRfGjqAk™ qfqJjRk "q‘"g‘QR q"]jL<ё‘fjR A"J"L"x +gv+jJq+ A"‘DvfAJ q">‘ё‘f+ q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QRf gvjGj‘f+у Rfд Э U"vjj A"‘ALjJ‘"R №vё‘j qJLkAJkLё №qfMfAf gAv™GёjJ g qjU+ JLf §vjRj‘JёН n в1яхи r‘" в6чи f „gjLMуn вцVбГу1яхид n у §J" q"у >‘ёJjvE‘ё+ GёqJE №qfMfAf Gjv"gjAё A"J"Lё+ qJLjRfJq+ №">‘ёgёJE "UYjAJfg‘Qx RfL №Lfq№"q"UfJEq+ A ‘jRk f g AёGjqJgj №"qLj]‘fAё q"[vёq"gёJE JLjU"gё‘f+ LjёvE‘"qJf q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QRf gvjGj‘f+Rfд r‘" у qg"j"ULё>‘Qx Lj>jLgkёL Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QM gvjGj‘fx №"] g">у ]jxqJgfjR A"J"LQM Gjv"gjA gqj[]ё fq№QJQgёjJ <jvё‘fj №"vkGёJE k]"g"vEqJgfjд „gjLMуn JёA<j +gv+jJq+ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QR §vjRj‘J"R №qfMfAf A"J"LQx q"]jL<fJ fqM"]+wfj "J "UwjqJgё >ё№LjJQ gQqJkу №ёjJ g L"vf g‘kJLj‘‘j[" Tj‘>"Lё вq"gjqJEид
r]‘fR f> Av™GjgQM №"‘+Jfx №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ё +gv+jJq+ JёA ‘ё>Qgёjу RQx §]f№"g A"R№vjAqй A"J"LQx №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ §L"JfGjqA"j gvjGj‘fj LjUj‘Aё A L"]fJjv™ №L"Jfg"№"v"<‘"[" №"vё f ‘j‘ёgfqJE A L"]fJjv™ q"UqJgj‘‘"[" №"vёд p"qJj№j‘‘" q g">LёqJ"R ]ё‘‘"j gvjGj‘fj kM"]fJ g №"]q">‘ё‘fj f g">gLёwёjJq+ g q">‘ё‘fj g gf]j GkgqJgё gf‘Q A"J"у L"j №" zLjx]k f[LёjJ "[L"R‘k™ L"vE g q"Tfёvf>ёTff vfG‘"qJf f №"]ёgvj‘ff g ‘jx ё‘Jfq"TfёvE‘QM qAv"‘‘"qJjxд
Эё<‘jxKk™ L"vE g №"‘fRё‘ff q"TfёvE‘QM №L"Tjqq"g zLjx] "Jg"]fJ qA"‘qJLkfL"gё‘‘"x fR s‘ёkG‘"x [f№"Jj>jy " №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]jд ’ёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ fqM"]‘"x J"GA"x g Lё>gfJff Gjv"gjGjqJgё UQvё ‘jAё+ №jLg"UQJ‘ё+ qjRE+ №jLg"j Gjv"gjGjqA"j q""UwjqJg" №"+gvjу ‘fj A"J"L"x UQv" "Ukqv"gvj‘" ]gkR+ DёAJ"LёRfН ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE™ №Lf‘k<]j‘f+ A JLk]k f v™U"gE™ вRk<Gf‘Q A <j‘wf‘j f <j‘wf‘Q A qg"fR ]jJ+Rид “ёLёAJjL‘"x GjLJ"x ]ё‘‘"[" "UYj]f‘j‘f+ UQv" ёUу q"v™J‘"j ["q№"]qJg" "JTё [vёgQ qjREf ‘ё] gqjRf jj Gvj‘ёRf J"vEA"
й o]jqE zLjx] fq№"vE>"gёv ]Ljg‘j[LjGjqAfx RfD " J"R AёA Dfgё‘у qAfx TёLE m]f№ g"№LjAf qg"jx g"vj kUfgёjJ "JTё f <j‘fJq+ ‘ё RёJjLfд
ннт
"‘ UQv g№Lёgj gvё]jJE <j‘wf‘ёRf f Lёq№"L+<ёJEq+ <f>‘+Rf q"L"у ]fGjxд „Q‘"gE+ fq№QJQgёvf A "JTk ]g"xqJgj‘‘"j GkgqJg"Н q "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q у "‘f j[" v™Ufvf q ]Lk["x у U"+vfqE f ‘j‘ёgf]jvfд PJ"UQ kqJLё‘fJE k[L">k №"qJ"+‘‘" fqM"]+wk™ "J "JTё f >ёgvё]jJE <j‘wfу ‘ёRf qQ‘"gE+ q["g"LfvfqE f kUfvf [vёgk qjRjxqJgёд H" qLё>k <j №"у qvj kUfxqJgё fRf "gvё]jv" [vkU"A"j LёqAё+‘fj f №"+gfv"qE GkgqJg" gf‘Q >ё q"]j+‘‘"j <jvё‘fj fqAk№fJE №LjqJk№vj‘fjд „vj]qJgfjR JёA"x №qfM"v"[fGjqA"x RjJёR"LD">Q qJёv" kqJё‘"gvj‘fj >ё№LjJ"g вAё‘‘fUёvf>Rё f‘TjqJё kUfxqJgёи GJ" >‘ёRj‘"gёv" q"U"x №" zLjxу ]k L"<]j‘fj AkvEJkLQ вR"Lёvf Ljvf[ff №Lёgё ["qk]ёLqJgёи qfqJjу RQ ‘"LR f f‘qJfJkJ"g gQg"]+wfM Gjv"gjAё f> <fg"J‘"[" q"qJ"+‘f+д
Э "q‘"gj "UYj]f‘j‘f+ v™]jx g A"vvjAJfgQ vj<fJ №" zLjx]k qjAqkёvE‘Qx f‘qJf‘AJ f f‘qJf‘AJ Lё>LkKj‘f+ вmL"q gvjGj‘fj A <f>‘f f ?ё‘ёJ"qй gvjGj‘fj A qRjLJfид „jAqkёvE‘ё+ §‘jL[f+ gqJLjу Gё+ ‘ё qg"jR №kJf A Tjvf в[j‘fJёvE‘"j k]"gvjJg"Lj‘fjи №Lj№+JqJgf+ g gf]j >ё№LjJ"g >ёJ"LRё<fgёjJq+ f ]fDDk>fLkjJ №jLjLёqJё+ g №"у JLjU‘"qJE ]vfJjvE‘"[" ]Lk<jv™U‘"[" "Uwj‘f+ q v™]ERfд „ ]Lk["x qJ"L"‘Q №LfL"]‘ё+ ё[Ljqqfg‘"qJE f‘]fgf]"g qJLjR+qE k]"gvjJg"у LfJE qjU+ ‘ёM"]fJ AёA"xуJ" g‘jK‘fx "UYjAJ f ‘ё]jv+jJ j[" GjLJёRf gLё[ё A"J"L"[" ‘j"UM"]fR" k‘fGJ"<fJEд HёvfGfj "Uwj[" gLё[ё ]jу vёjJ jwj ALj№Gj k>Q A"vvjAJfgёд !Rj‘‘" §JfR qGfJёjJ zLjx] "UYу +q‘+jJq+ gLё<]ё Rj<]k AvёqqёRf ‘ёTf+Rf TjLAg+Rf ["qk]ёLqJgёу Rfд r‘ JёA<j kJgjL<]ёjJ GJ" [jJjL"qjAqkёvE‘ё+ v™U"gE g" R‘"["R q№"q"UqJg"gёvё №Lj"]"vj‘f™ [Lё‘fT JjR qёRQR gQ№"v‘++ gё<‘k™ AkvEJkL‘k™ Dk‘ATf™ J"[]ё AёA ["R"qjAqkёvE‘ё+ v™U"gE ‘ё№L"Jfg qJfRkvfL"gёvё qg+>f g‘kJLf Gjv"gjGjqAfM A"vvjAJfg"g в"q"Uj‘‘" g TjLAgf f‘qJfJkJ R"‘ёKjqJgёид
evkUf‘‘ё+ №qfM"v"[fGjqAё+ qJLkAJkLё q"gLjRj‘‘QM Tfgfvf>"у gё‘‘QM "UwjqJg №"vё[ёjJ zLjx] "qJёvёqE ‘jf>Rj‘‘"x q" gLjRj‘ №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]Q вqjREfи GJ" "q"Uj‘‘" +LA" №L"+gv+jJq+ g §Aqу JLjRёvE‘QM qfJkёTf+M вg"x‘ё Rёqq"gQj Ujq№"L+]Afид pLfKj]Kfj g ]gf<j‘fj gqvj]qJgfj AёAfMуvfU" GLj>gQGёx‘QM q"UQJfx Gjv"у gjGjqAfj RёqqQ §J" f jqJE №" zLjx]k "<fgKё+ №jLg"UQJ‘ё+ "L]ёд Э g">Uk<]j‘‘"R q"qJ"+‘ff RёqqQ JLjUk™J fvv™>fx ё ‘j fqJf‘Q fR qg"xqJgj‘‘" qJLjRvj‘fj A Lj[Ljqqff в"qvёUvj‘fj f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘"x ]j+JjvE‘"qJf §DDjAJfg‘"qJE "JqkJqJgfj >ё]jL<Af №Lf №jLjM"]j "J §R"Tfx A ]jxqJgf™ид Юёqqё №L"f>g"]fJ ‘ё Gjv"gjAё g№jGёJvj‘fj ‘jу "[Lё‘fGj‘‘"x R"wf f ‘j№Lj"]"vfR"x "№ёq‘"qJf "‘ё qJё‘"gfJq+ ]v+ ‘j[" gQqKfR ёgJ"LfJjJ"R A"J"LQx "qg"U"<]ёjJ f‘]fgf]ё "J >ё№Ljу J"g f №L"Uk<]ёjJ g ‘jR №jLgfG‘Qj f‘qJf‘AJQд evёg‘"x "q"Uj‘‘"qJE™ RёqqQ +gv+jJq+ ‘ёvfGfj g"<]+ q A"J"LQR Rёqqё "J"<]jqJgv+jJq+ gf]fJ g ‘jR qg"x f]jёv "q‘"g"№"vё[ё™wk™ №jLq"‘fDfTfL"gё‘‘k™ f]j™д Э"<]E RёqqQ у §J" g"qALjqKfx "JjT №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]Q A"J"у
й Э ]Ljg‘j[LjGjqA"x RfD"v"[ff mL"q у U"[ v™Ugf ?ё‘ёJ"q у U"[ qRjLJfд
нне
L"Rk qvj]kjJ №"Av"‘+JEq+д !‘]fgf]Q GkgqJgk™J qjU+ qg+>ё‘‘QRf v™U"gE™ A g"<]™у"JTk f ]Lk[ A ]Lk[kд „vj]k+ v"[fAj zLjx]ё R"<у ‘" q]jvёJE gQg"] GJ" Gjv"gjGjqAfj q""UwjqJgё qALj№v+™Jq+ fqAv™у GfJjvE‘" >ё qGjJ Lj[Ljqqff в№"v‘"x fvf GёqJfG‘"xи A №jLg"UQJ‘"Rk q"qJ"+‘f™ ё qёRf gvёqJ‘Qj "J‘"Kj‘f+ jqJE ‘j GJ" f‘"j AёA Ujqу A"‘jG‘"j g"q№L"f>gj]j‘fj fjLёLMfGjqAfM g>ёfR""J‘"Kj‘fx "JTё f qQ‘"gjx ]"fqJ"LfGjqA"x "L]Qд ЙfG‘"qJE №"]Gf‘++qE gvёqJf g vfTj g"<]+ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘" qJLjRfJq+ A "J"<]jqJgvj‘f™ qjU+ q gvёqJE™ LёqJg"Lj‘f™ g ‘jxд
p" qg"fR №"vfJfGjqAfR g>[v+]ёR zLjx] у UkL<kё>‘Qx vfUjLёv f A"‘qjLgёJ"Lд H" JLё]fTf"‘‘Qj ]jR"ALёJfGjqAfj f‘qJfJkJQ A"J"у LQj jRk №Lj]qJёgv+™Jq+ gё<‘jxKfRf ]"qJf<j‘f+Rf Gjv"gjGjqJgё g j[" g"qM"<]j‘ff "J №jLg"UQJ‘"[" q"qJ"+‘f+ A Tfgfvf>"gё‘‘"Rk "UwjqJgk №"‘fRё™Jq+ g ]kMj №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ёд cv+ ‘j[" vfUjLёvE‘Qx q"TfёvE‘Qx №"L+]"A jqJE №Lj<]j gqj[" Lj>kvEJёJ U"LEUQ "Uwjу qJgё q №jLgfG‘QRf gvjGj‘f+Rf f‘]fgf]"gд Э §J"R qRQqvj zLjx] gQq"A" "Tj‘fgёjJ №Lёg" A"J"L"j AёA "‘ №"vё[ёjJ gQLёqJёjJ f> ‘ёу qfvf+д p"qvj kUfxqJgё "JTё g №jLg"j gLjR+ g №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]j ["у q№"]qJgkjJ №Lёg" qfvE‘"[" vfKё™wjj gqjM f Aё<]"[" Uj>"№ёq‘"qJfд H" №"qJj№j‘‘" f‘qJf‘AJ qёR"q"MLё‘j‘f+ в§vjRj‘J mL"qёи UjLjJ gjLM "UwjqJg" kqJё‘ёgvfgёjJ >ё№LjJ ‘ё kUfxqJg" q" qJ"L"‘Q "J]jvEу ‘QM f‘]fgf]"g f №LfqgёfgёjJ §J" №"v‘"R"Gfj qjUjд pjLjM"] ‘ёqfvf+ "J "]‘"[" Gjv"gjAё A "UwjqJgk ">‘ёGёv №" zLjx]k L"<]j‘fj №Lёу gё у №Lf‘k]fJjvE‘"x ‘"LRёJfg‘"x qfqJjRQ №"]ёgv+™wjx gqjM Uj> fqAv™Gj‘f+ f‘]fgf]"gд
c"qJёJ"G‘" q]jL<ё‘‘" zLjx] "J‘"qfJq+ A f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"x qg"у U"]jд r‘ №"vё[ёjJ GJ" "wkwёjRё+ Gjv"gjA"R <ё<]ё qg"U"]Q jqJE ‘j GJ" f‘"j AёA ‘jk]"gvjJg"Lj‘‘Qj JLjU"gё‘f+ j[" gvjGj‘fx вr‘"ид Э qg"jx "q‘"gj qg"U"]ё gLё<]jU‘ё AkvEJkLj JёfJ g qjUj Lё>LkKfJjvEу ‘Qx №"Jj‘Tfёv №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A ["qk]ёLqJgk №Lёgk R"Lёvfд r]‘ёA" ]"qJ"f‘qJg" qg"U"]Q g J"R GJ" "‘ё №" zLjx]k qJLjRfJq+ A kqJё‘"gу vj‘f™ q№Lёgj]vfg"qJfд
pqfM"ё‘ёvfJfGjqAё+ JLёAJ"gAё zLjx]"R q№Lёgj]vfg"qJf fRjjJ g >‘ёGfJjvE‘"x qJj№j‘f §[ёvfJёLfqJqAfx MёLёAJjLд p" j[" R‘j‘f™ q№Lёgj]vfg"qJE g"№v"wёjJ g qjUj JLjU"gё‘fj v™]jx UQJE Lёg‘QRf ]Lk[ ]Lk[k "‘ё jqJE №Lf‘Tf№ AkvEJkLQ ё ‘j №LfL"]Q Gjv"gjAё q"Tfу ёvE‘"[" ё ‘j №jLg"UQJ‘"["д ?jR ‘j Rj‘jj fqJ"Af q№Lёgj]vfg"qJf qvjу ]kjJ fqAёJE №" zLjx]k g №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]j f gvjGj‘f+M Gjv"gjAёд
Э"у№jLgQM gqj Gvj‘Q №jLg"UQJ‘"[" q""UwjqJgё >‘ёvf J"vEA" "]‘k gvёqJE у gvёqJE ]jq№"JfG‘"[" "JTё UQvf Lёg‘Q g qg"jR Ujq№Lёу gff №" "J‘"Kj‘f™ A ‘jRkд ?ёAё+ R"]jvE №"gj]j‘f+ >ёv"<fvё [vkу Uf‘‘Qx №qfM"v"[fGjqAfx qJjLj"Jf№Н gqj M"J+J №"]Gf‘+JEq+ gvёqJf fqM"]+wjx J"vEA" "J "]‘"[" vfTё f UQJE Lёg‘QRf ]Lk[ ]Lk[kд
Э"уgJ"LQM g №jLg"UQJ‘"x "L]j gqj g Lёg‘"x qJj№j‘f M"Jjvf UQJE v™UfRQRf "JT"R GJ" JёA<j D"LRfL"gёv" §[ёvfJёLfqJqAk™ №qfM"у v"[f™д „JLjRvj‘fj A Lёgj‘qJgk "q‘"gё‘" JёA<j ‘ё qg"xqJgj Gjv"gjAё
ннн
Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘" "J"<]jqJgv+JE qjU+ q ]Lk[fR vfT"R вf]j‘JfDfAёу Tf+и g Lj>kvEJёJj Gj[" g">‘fAёjJ "wkwj‘fj Lёgj‘qJgёд
! ‘ёA"‘jT gуJLjJEfM JLjU"gё‘fj Lёgj‘qJgё g">‘fAёjJ f> GkgqJgё >ёgfqJfН Gjv"gjA ‘j R"<jJ q"[vёqfJEq+ q JjR GJ" ]v+ ‘j[" kqJё‘"gvjу ‘" >ё№LjJ"g U"vEKj GjR ]v+ ]Lk["[" f "‘ Rj‘EKj R"<jJ №"vkGfJE k]"g"vEqJgf+ "J k]"gvjJg"Lj‘f+ qg"fM gvjGj‘fxд
?jRё q№Lёgj]vfg"qJf Jjq‘" qg+>ё‘ё k zLjx]ё q №"‘fRё‘fjR №Lfу L"]Q q"TfёvE‘QM A"‘DvfAJ"gд „ j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ g "q‘"gj q"TfёvEу ‘"x ]fDDjLj‘TfёTff vj<ёJ "q"Uj‘‘"qJf №qfM"v"[fGjqA"x A"‘qJfу JkTff v™]jxд pvjRj‘ё f LёqQ q ‘ёfU"vjj qfvE‘"x §‘jL[fjx gvjGj‘fx вё qvj]"gёJjvE‘" f q №"gQKj‘‘"x ё[Ljqqfg‘"qJE™и №"]Gf‘+vf qjUj U"vjj qvёUQM у JёA D"LRfL"gёvfqE ["q№"]qJgk™wfj §vfJQд rqvёUvjу ‘fj gvjGj‘fx k LkA"g"]+wfM Avёqq"g gjv" fM A ]j[Lё]ёTff f >ёRj‘j ‘"g"x §vfJ"xд !Rj‘‘" §JfR zLjx] "UY+q‘+jJ №ё]j‘fj R‘"[fM R"‘ёLу MfGjqAfM DёRfvfx g hgL"№j g GёqJ‘"qJf g u"qqffд r]‘ёA" ‘jqR"у JL+ ‘ё "UYjAJfg‘Qx q J"GAf >Lj‘f+ zLjx]ё MёLёAJjL q"TfёvE‘"x ]fDDjLj‘TfёTff "‘ ‘j qAv"‘j‘ "№Lёg]QgёJE >‘ёGfJjvE‘Qx Lё>LQg g kL"g‘j <f>‘f Lё>vfG‘QM Avёqq"gд Hjk]"gvjJg"Lj‘‘"qJE gvjGj‘fx k[‘jJj‘‘QM qv"jg "UwjqJgё ‘jf>Uj<‘" L"<]ёjJ g ‘fM GkgqJg" №"у №Lё‘‘"x q№Lёgj]vfg"qJf f gLё<]jU‘"qJf A ["q№"]qJgk™wjx §vfJj GJ" GLjgёJ" vfAgf]ёTfjx ]ё‘‘"[" q"TfёvE‘"[" №"L+]Aёд Э J" <j gLjу R+ zLjx] gjqERё qAj№JfGjqAf "J‘"qfJq+ A Ljg"v™Tf+R A"J"LQj №" j[" R‘j‘f™ jqJE q"TfёvE‘"j №L"+gvj‘fj §]f№"gё A"R№vjAqё U"vjj RёqKJёU‘"j g"q№L"f>gj]j‘fj f>gjG‘"[" Uk‘Jё qQ‘"gjx в№"]gvёqJу ‘QMи №L"Jfg "JTё вgvёqJfид p"qvj qgjL<j‘f+ ‘jk["]‘"[" Lj<fRё g g"qqJёgKfM RёqqёM №"+gv+jJq+ LёqAё+‘fj f GkgqJg" gf‘Q >ё q"]j+‘у ‘"j GJ" qJё‘"gfJq+ R"w‘QR qJfRkv"R ]v+ "L[ё‘f>ёTff №"vfJfGjу qA"[" №"L+]Aё g" R‘"["R qM"]‘"[" q Lё‘jj k№Lё>]‘j‘‘QRд HjRj‘+™у wfxq+ №qfM"v"[fGjqAfx qJjLj"Jf№ №"vfJfGjqA"[" №"gj]j‘f+ ]jvёjJ №" zLjx]k Rёv"№jLq№jAJfg‘QRf №"№QJAf Lё]fAёvE‘"[" №Lj"ULё>"у gё‘f+ "UwjqJgёд
cv+ fvv™qJLёTff qg"fM "Uwjq"Tf"v"[fGjqAfM gQg"]"g zLjx] ‘jLj]A" "ULёwёvq+ A q"UQJf+R g „"gjJqA"x u"qqffд „ "]‘"x qJ"L"у ‘Q "‘ "]"UL+v №LёAJfAk U"LEUQ №L"Jfg fRkwjqJgj‘‘"[" ‘jLёgj‘у qJgё f ё‘JfLjvf[f">‘k™ ]j+JjvE‘"qJE U"vEKjgfA"gд H" "‘ qGfJёv [vkU"AfR >ёUvk<]j‘fjR №"v"<j‘fj " J"R GJ" kqJLё‘j‘fj q"Tfу ёvE‘QM A"‘DvfAJ"g qg+>ё‘" q vfAgf]ёTfjx GёqJ‘"x q"UqJgj‘‘"у qJfН q"UqJgj‘‘"qJE №Lj]qJёgv+jJ q"U"x vfKE "Lk]fj Gjv"gjGjqA"x ё[Ljqqff q jj k№Lё>]‘j‘fjR gvjGj‘f+ ‘j fqGj>ё™J ё J"vEA" Rj‘+™J D"LRk qg"j[" №L"+gvj‘f+д zLjx] №"vё[ёv GJ" g u"qqff []j "ULё> gLё[ё qQ[Lёv gё<‘jxKk™ L"vE g A"‘qJfJkfL"gё‘ff ‘"g"x gvёqJf №"qvj ‘ёqfvEqJgj‘‘"[" qgjL<j‘f+ UkL<kё>ff ‘ёG‘jJq+ №"fqA ‘"gQM gLё["g вAёA g‘kJLj‘‘fM JёA f g‘jK‘fMид r‘ ALfJfG‘" "J>Qgёvq+ "U kqJё‘"gvj‘ff f]j"v"[fGjqA"[" ]fAJёJё A"J"LQx №" j[" R‘j‘f™ GLj>gQGёx‘" qk<fgёv g">R"<‘"qJf Gjv"gjAё k]"gvjJg"LfJE qg"f gvjGj‘f+д
нны
Э Tjv"R №"vfJfGjqAfx f]jёv zLjx]ё ]"g"vE‘" A"‘qjLgёJfgj‘д r‘ №"vё[ёjJ GJ" RёqqQ g qg"jR U"vEKf‘qJgj A"q‘Q f ‘j]ёvE‘"gf]у ‘Q fM №"gj]j‘fj №"]Gf‘j‘" gvjGj‘f+R ё ‘j Lё>kRk "‘f ‘j fRj™J qAv"‘‘"qJf A JLk]k fR qg"xqJgj‘‘" qJLjRfJEq+ A gqj]">g"vj‘‘"qJf f Lёq№kwj‘‘"qJfд p"§J"Rk gvёqJE ]"v<‘ё UQJE q"qLj]"J"Gj‘ё g Lkу AёM k>A"[" ALk[ё v™]jx AkvEJkLQ A"J"LQR k]ёv"qE ]"UfJEq+ ["q№"]у qJgё ‘ё] q"UqJgj‘‘QRf gvjGj‘f+Rf f A"J"LQj q№"q"U‘Q ‘j f]Jf ‘ё №"g"]k k Rёqqд cё‘‘ё+ LkA"g"]+wё+ §vfJё ]"v<‘ё UQJE ‘j>ёgfqfRё "J Rёqq в"L[ё‘f>ёTf"‘‘" f RёJjLfёvE‘"и f fRjJE g qg"jR Lёq№"L+<jу ‘ff ]"qJёJ"G‘" qLj]qJg ]v+ №Lf‘k<]j‘f+ v™]jx A JLk]k f №"L+]Akд Эё<‘jxKjx >ё]ёGjx ["q№"]qJgk™wjx §vfJQ zLjx] qGfJёv Lё>gfJfj Lё>kR‘"[" ‘ёGёvё g Gjv"gjAj вnи f №L"gj]j‘fj LjD"LR №" kqJё‘"gу
vj‘f™ Uёvё‘qё Rj<]k gvjGj‘f+Rf вr‘"и f >ё№LjJёRf |
AkvEJkLQд |
Э §J"x qg+>f "‘ "Jg"]fv "[L"R‘k™ L"vE №qfM"ё‘ёvf>k |
A"J"LQx |
gvёqJE ]"v<‘ё UQvё g>+JE ‘ё g""Lk<j‘fj g AёGjqJgj Jj"Lff f JjLёу №jgJfGjqA"[" RjJ"]ёд
pqfM"ё‘ёvfJfGjqAfx RjJ"] zLjx]ё №"]gjv j[" A "Lf[f‘ёvE‘QR f >ёqvk<fgё™wfR g‘fRё‘f+ Dfv"q"DqAfR "U"Uwj‘f+Rд ’kvEJkLё в["qk]ёLqJg" №Lёg" R"LёvEи №" j[" R‘j‘f™ fRjjJ ]g"xqJgj‘‘Qx MёLёAJjLд „ "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q J"vEA" Uvё["]ёL+ AkvEJkLj Gjv"gjA qR"[ №L"Jfg"qJ"+JE №LfL"]j qg"fR ё[Ljqqfg‘QR f‘qJf‘AJёR f gQ<fJEд H" q ]Lk["x у AkvEJkLё q ‘j"UM"]fR"qJE™ ‘jqjJ q q"U"x Lj№Ljqqfgу ‘"qJE №Lf‘k]fJjvE‘"qJEЖ №"]ёgv++ gvjGj‘f+ Gjv"gjAё "‘ё ]jvёjJ j[" [vkU"A" ‘jqGёqJ‘QR vfG‘"qJE f>‘ёGёvE‘" qJё‘"gfJq+ gLё["R AkvEJkLQд Э">‘fAёjJ qg"j"ULё>‘Qx №"L"G‘Qx ALk[Н AkvEJkLё №"у ]ёgv++ fqM"]+wk™ "J v™]jx ё[Ljqqf™ ‘ё№Lёgv+jJ jj "ULёJ‘" g fM №"]q">‘ё‘fj "JAk]ё ё[Ljqqf+ g qkUvfRfL"gё‘‘"R gf]j g">gLёwёjJq+ g AkvEJkLk g AёGjqJgj ‘"gQM >ё№LjJ"gд „""JgjJqJgj‘‘" GjR U"vEKj ё[Ljqqff k "UwjqJgё JjR <jqJGj ‘"LRQ AkvEJkLQ вg GёqJ‘"qJf №"у vfJfGjqAfx Lj<fRи f ‘ё"U"L"Jд „ёRё AkvEJkLё gQqJk№ёjJ [vёg‘QR DёAJ"L"R q"TfёvE‘QM ‘jgL">"g Jд jд JёAfM №ёJ"v"[fGjqAfM q"qJ"+‘fx "UwjqJgё в‘ё№LfRjL J"JёvfJёLf>Rи A"[]ё v™]f q№"q"U‘Q №"[kUfJE qёRfM qjU+д Э §J"R qRQqvj q"gLjRj‘‘Qx RfL №Lj]qJёgv+jJq+ zLjx]k AёA U"LEUё mL"qё f ?ё‘ёJ"qё fqM"] A"J"L"x ‘jf>gjqJj‘д ?ёA zLjx] ]"g"vE‘" qAj№JfGjqAf "Tj‘fgёjJ Kё‘qQ Gjv"gjGjqJgё gQ<fJE g [L+у ]kwfM g"x‘ёM M"J+ f gQLё<ёjJ ‘ё]j<]k ‘ё №"Uj]k >]Lёg"[" qRQqvёЖ rq‘"g‘k™ >ё]ёGk q"gLjRj‘‘"qJf "‘ gf]fJ g J"R GJ"UQ "qvёUfJE ‘"Lу RQ AkvEJkLQ q]jvёJE jj U"vjj JjL№fR"x A Gjv"gjAk в№Lj<]j gqj[" g "UvёqJf qjAqkёvE‘"x <f>‘fи ‘j ‘ё‘"q+ №Lf §J"R qkwjqJgj‘‘QM №"у JjLE qёR"x AkvEJkLjд
?j"LjJfGjqA"j ‘ёqvj]fj zLjx]ё "Aё>ёv" >‘ёGfJjvE‘"j gvf+‘fj ‘ё №"qvj]k™wk™ №qfM"v"[fGjqAk™ Dfv"q"DqAk™ №"vfJfGjqAk™ f q"Tf"v"[fGjqAk™ RQqvE rULё>"gёg JёAfj ALk№‘Qj f]jx‘Qj ‘ё№Lёgу vj‘f+ AёA DLjx]f>R f ‘j"DLjx]f>Rд
ЛЗAm ВhъCЗ\ !ЮЖ врВ.ыурЛмри у gQ]ё™wfxq+ KgjxTёLqAfx №qfу M"v"[ f Dfv"q"D AkvEJkLQ №Lj]qJёgfJjvE №qfM"ё‘ёvf>ёд r‘ L"]fvq+
ннм
g qjREj №L"JjqJё‘JqA"[" qg+wj‘‘fAё ]j] f №Lё]j] j[" в№" №L"fqM"у <]j‘f™ ‘jRTQи UQvf gLёGёRfд
p" "A"‘Gё‘ff Rj]fTf‘qA"[" DёAkvEJjJё Щё>jvEqA"[" k‘fgjLqfу JjJё '‘[ >ё‘fRёvq+ gLёGjU‘"x №LёAJfA"x f fqqvj]"gё‘f+Rf g "Uvёу qJf №qfM"v"[ff f №qfMfёJLffд Щ"vEK"j gvf+‘fj ‘ё Jg"LGjqJg" '‘[ё "Aё>ёvё j[" gqJLjGё q ед zLjx]"Rд Э рЛрр [д '‘[ №" LjA"Rj‘]ёTff zLjx]ё f>UfLёjJq+ №jLgQR №Lj>f]j‘J"R Юj<]k‘ёL"]‘"[" №qfM"ё‘ёу vfJfGjqA"[" "UwjqJgёд
’ kqJё‘"gvj‘f™ ‘ёTf"‘ёvуq"TfёvfqJfGjqA"[" №"L+]Aё g ejLRёу ‘ff '‘[ №"‘ёGёvk "J‘jqq+ ]"g"vE‘" JjL№fR" f ]ё<j q ‘jA"J"L"x qfR№ёJfjxд ?ёA №" №Lj]v"<j‘f™ ‘ёTfqJ"g "‘ q"[vёqfvq+ g">[vёgfJE врЛееурЛеЛи Юj<]k‘ёL"]‘"j Rj]fTf‘qA"j "UwjqJg" №qfM"JjLё№ff q" KJёUуAgёLJfL"x g C™LfMj q"gRjqJ‘" q Юд eд ejLf‘["R в]g"™L"]у ‘QR ULёJ"R LjxMqRёLwёvё ejLf‘[ёи Lj]ёAJfL"gёv №qfM"v"[fGjqAfx <kL‘ёv f‘fTffL"gёv "Uqk<]j‘fj g"№L"q"g " Lё>vfGf+M g Lёq"g"x №qfM"v"[ffд H" №"qJj№j‘‘" '‘[ №jLjKjv g "№№">fTf™ A ‘ёTf>Rk №"v‘"qJE™ "JgjL[‘kg j[" f]j"v"[f™ f №LёAJfAkд p"qvj "A"‘Gё‘f+ g"x‘Q f g№v"JE ]" qg"jx qRjLJf '‘[ g "q‘"g‘"R >ё‘fRёvq+ ‘ёkG‘"x LёU"J"xд
'‘[ вAёA f zLjx]и №LёAJfGjqAf ‘j q">]ёv №L"f>gj]j‘fx q№jTfу ёvE‘" №"qg+wj‘‘QM g"№L"qёR №"vfJfAf gvёqJf ["qk]ёLqJgё №Lёgёд r]‘ёA" qJLjR+qE LёqALQJE f ёL[kRj‘JfL"gёJE qg"f Jj"LjJfGjqAfj №"v"<j‘f+ "‘ GёqJ" №LfUj[ёjJ A ё‘ёvf>k q"TfёvE‘"у№"vfJfGjqAfM q"UQJfx №L"Kv"[" f q"gLjRj‘‘"qJf gQqAё>QgёjJ g qg+>f q §JfR [vkU"Afj f "Lf[f‘ёvE‘Qj qk<]j‘f+д evёg‘QR <j g №qfM"v"[fGjqA"x Jj"Lff '‘[ё в№LfRj‘fJjvE‘" A fqJ"Lff №"vfJfGjqA"x RQqvfи +gу v+jJq+ J" GJ" "‘ё ]ёjJ ‘"gQx g>[v+] ‘ё DёAJQ №"vfJfA"у№Lёg"g"x LjёvE‘"qJfд Э §J"R №vё‘j ‘ёfU"vjj №"Aё>ёJjvE‘Q JёAfj LёU"JQ '‘[ё AёA spL"UvjRQ ]kKf ‘ёKj[" gLjRj‘fy s„"gLjRj‘‘"qJE f Uk]kwjjy srGjLAf " q"gLjRj‘‘QM q"UQJf+Mд pqfM"v"[f+ ‘ёTf>Rёyд
Cj‘JLёvE‘"j №"‘+Jfj ё‘ёvfJfGjqA"x №qfM"v"[ff '‘[ё у A"vу vjAJfg‘"j Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j №"] A"J"LQR №"‘fRёjJq+ ‘j"q">‘ёgёjу Rё+ v™]ERf №qfMfGjqAё+ §‘jL[f+ №Lj]qJё™wё+ g gf]j ‘ёqvj]kjRQM "J №"A"vj‘f+ A №"A"vj‘f™ f‘qJf‘AJ"g f qJjLj"Jf№"g g"q№Lf+Jf+ f №"gj]j‘f+д ’"vvjAJfg‘"j Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j >ёAv™GёjJ g qjUj ‘ёу A"№vj‘‘Qx "№QJ gqj[" Gjv"gjGjqJgё q"]jL<fJ ‘jAfx [j‘jJfGjqAfx A"] A"J"LQx "№Lj]jv+jJ f‘]fgf]kёvE‘k™ №qfM"v"[f™д Эё<‘jxKfR §vjRj‘J"R A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" +gv+jJq+ ЗApDCdk у §J" qg"j"ULё>‘Qx f]jёvE‘Qx ALfqJёvv GfqJё+ D"LRё A"J"Lё+ qJLkAJkу LfLkjJ GkgqJgj‘‘Qx f f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘Qx "№QJ Gjv"gjAё №" qg"jRk "ULё>k f №"]"Uf™д „"[vёq‘" '‘[k ёLMjJf№ fRjjJ ‘jRёJjLfёvE‘"j f ]"RёJjLfёvE‘"j №L"fqM"<]j‘fj j[" №LfL"]ё ‘fA"[]ё ‘j R"<jJ UQJE №"qJf[‘kJё ‘" "‘ №"qJ"+‘‘" "U‘ёLk<fgёjJ qjU+ g gf]j qfRg"vfGjу qAfM "ULё>"g g q‘ёM ULj]j №qfMfGjqAf U"vE‘QM RfDёM Ljvf[f">‘QM JjAqJёM Rё[fGjqAfM LfJkёvёM fqAkqqJgj f Jд №д !Rj‘‘" ёLMjJf№Q s"Jу gjGё™Jy >ё q№jTfDfAk q"Tf"AkvEJkL‘QM D"LR в["qk]ёLqJg" №Lёg"
нн.
Ljvf[f">‘Qj f ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘Qj "J‘"Kj‘f+и k Lё>vfG‘QM ‘ёL"]"g JёA AёA k Aё<]"[" §J‘"qё g >ёgfqfR"qJf "J "UqJ"+JjvEqJg j[" №"+gvj‘f+ f Lё>gfJf+ R"<jJ №Lj"Uvё]ёJE J"J fvf f‘"x ёLMjJf№д
HёGjLJё‘‘Qj '‘["R qMjRQ A"vvjAJfg‘"x f f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"x №qfM"v"[ff ‘ёM"]+J qg"j "JLё<j‘fj g j[" Lёqqk<]j‘f+M "U "UwjqJgj №"vfJfAj ["qk]ёLqJgjд
'‘[ №"vё[ёjJ GJ" Lё>gfJfj AkvEJkLQ D"LRfL"gё‘fj f‘]fgfу ]kёvE‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+ №"gvjAv" >ё q"U"x "JLQg Gjv"gjAё "J №LfL"]Q f A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"["д rq"Uj‘‘" №"Aё>ёJjvE‘QR g §J"R "J‘"Kj‘ff +gv+jJq+ oё№ё] []j >ё №"qvj]‘fj наа vjJ LёTf"‘ёvf>ёTf+ q">‘ё‘f+ ]"qJf[vё "№ёq‘"x [f№jLJL"Dffд ЭQq"GёxKfj ]"qJf<j‘f+ ‘ёkAf f JjM‘fAf q">]ёvf A"v"qqёvE‘"j ‘ё№L+<j‘fj Rj<]k f‘]fgf]kу ёvE‘"x f A"vvjAJfg‘"x №qfMfA"x qJ"vA‘kg g Lё>LkKfJjvE‘"x U"LEUj q">‘ё‘fj q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QR f №"[Lk>fg Gjv"gjAё g [vkU"A"j ‘jgL"Jfу GjqA"j q"qJ"+‘fjд „"gLjRj‘‘Qx Gjv"gjA oё№ё]ё q j[" qJL"[" LёTf"у ‘ёvfqJfGjqA"x kqJё‘"gA"x kUj<]j‘ g J"R GJ" RfL f №Lj<]j gqj[" №"vfJfGjqAfj "J‘"Kj‘f+ №"]Gf‘j‘ ]jJjLRf‘fqJqA"x >ёgfqfR"qJf f R"<jJ UQJE f>Rj‘j‘ g‘jK‘fRf RjMё‘fGjqAfRf qLj]qJgёRfд r]‘ёA" <f>‘E №"vё[ёjJ '‘[ g qg"jx "q‘"gj fLLёTf"‘ёvE‘ё №"№QJAё №"]у Gf‘fJE jj LёTf"‘ёvE‘"x g"vj №Lfg"]fJ A ALёMk AkvEJkLQ qfRg"v"g f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"qJf f vfG‘"qJE "Aё>QgёjJq+ g" gvёqJf A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"["д “"J+ A"vvjAJfg‘"j Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"j f +gv+jJq+ fqу J"G‘fA"R <f>‘f f Jg"LGjqJgё Gjv"gjA f "UwjqJg" ‘j ‘ёkGfgKfqE fR k№Lёgv+JE LfqAk™J №"]№ёqJE №"] gvf+‘fj Lё>LkKfJjvE‘QM qg"xqJg ёLMjJf№"g f JjR qёRQR №"[kUfJE qjU+д nLAfR №LfRjL"R №L"LQgё Ujqу q">‘ёJjvE‘QM qfv q"ALkKё™wfM №LfgQG‘Qj LёTf"‘ёvE‘Qj q"TfёvEу ‘Qj D"LRQ UQv №" R‘j‘f™ '‘[ё ьь gд
'‘[ +gv+jJq+ "]‘fR f> RQqvfJjvjx A"J"LQj №L"ё‘ёvf>fL"gёvf JёA"x Dj‘"Rj‘ ьь gд AёA "UwjqJg" Rёqq"g"x AkvEJkLQ f j[" qvj]у qJgfj у J"JёvfJёLf>Rд
“ёLёAJjL‘"x GjLJ"x "UwjqJgё Rёqq"g"x AkvEJkLQ +gv+jJq+ №" '‘[k gqj"UYjRv™wё+ №"vfJf>ёTf+ "UwjqJgj‘‘"x <f>‘fд p"vfу JfGjqAё+ f]j"v"[f+ L"<]ёjJq+ AёA A"R№j‘qёTf+ >ё №"JjL™ [ёLR"у ‘ff q">‘ё‘f+ q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QR AёA Lj>kvEJёJ №"]ёgvj‘f+ f f[у ‘"LfL"gё‘f+ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" AёA qkUvfRёTf+ fLLёTf"‘ёvE‘QM gvjGj‘fxд p"v‘Qx "JAё> "J A"‘JёAJё q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QR J"JёvE‘ё+ LёTf"‘ёvf>ёTf+ "UwjqJgj‘‘QM "J‘"Kj‘fx №Lfgjvf A >ёqfvE™ №"у vfJfGjqA"x f]j"v"[ff qkJE A"J"L"x q"qJ"fJ g f]j‘JfDfAёTff f‘у ]fgf]kёvE‘"[" q">‘ё‘f+ q A"vvjAJfg‘QRд uёqJg"Lj‘fj vfG‘"qJf g [Lk№№j №"JjL+ f‘]fgf]kёvE‘"[" vfTё №"L"<]ёjJ sRёqq"g"[" Gjv"у gjAёy f sRёqq"gk™ ]kKkyд rq‘"g‘"x №"JLjU‘"qJE™ sRёqq"g"[" Gjу v"gjAёy +gv+jJq+ kGёqJfj g №"vfJfAj GJ" ]fAJkjJq+ Ujqq">‘ёJjvEу ‘QR "wkwj‘fjR [vkU"A"x g‘kJLj‘‘jx ]fq[ёLR"‘ff qJLjRvj‘fjR q‘+JE qg"x ‘jgL"> g‘jK‘fR ёAJfg‘QR №"gj]j‘fjRд „""JgjJqJgj‘‘" GjR qfvE‘jj ‘jgL"> JjR U"vEKj №"vfJfGjqAё+ ёAJfg‘"qJEд Юёqq"у gQx ‘jgL"> №Lfg"]fJ A Rёqq"g"Rk №qfM">k f Rёqq"g"x №qfMfGjqA"x
ннВ
§№f]jRff Jд jд A q">]ё‘f™ №"vfJfGjqA"[" ]gf<j‘f+д ’"‘Tj‘JLfу Lk+ g qjUj qfvQ A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" f g J" <j gLjR+ ‘j k№Lёgv++ fR вLёTf"‘ёvf>R fM ‘j №Lf>‘ёjJи №"vfJfGjqAfj ]gfу <j‘f+ q"qLj]"J"Gfgё™J g‘kJLf qjU+ "[L"R‘Qx №qfMfGjqAfx >ёL+] A"J"LQx №Lf v™U"R gQg"]+wjR f> Lёg‘"gjqf+ q"UQJff g>LQgёjJq+ Lё>LkKfJjvE‘QR №"gj]j‘fjR Rёqqд
ЮjMё‘f>R "ULё>"gё‘f+ J"JёvfJёL‘"[" "UwjqJgё '‘[ LёqqRёJLfу gёjJ q fq№"vE>"gё‘fjR №"‘+Jfx s№qfMfGjqAё+ f‘Dv+Tf+y f s№qfу MfGjqAё+ ]jDv+Tf+yд pqfMfGjqAё+ f‘Dv+Tf+ у §J" Lj>kvEJёJ f]j‘у JfDfAёTff ‘"qfJjvjx gvёqJf вf‘]fgf]ё fvf q"TfёvE‘"x [Lk№№Qи q qfvёRf A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"["д
Эqvj]qJgfj №qfMfGjqA"x f‘Dv+Tff J"J fvf f‘"x qkUYjAJ №"у vfJfGjqA"x <f>‘f "KfU"G‘" "JALQgёjJ g qjUj ]jxqJgfj ёLMjJf№"g вq "UYjAJfg‘"x J"GAf >Lj‘f+ §J"[" ‘j №L"fqM"]fJи GJ" №Lf]ёjJ jRk A"v"qqёvE‘k™ qfvk f kgjLj‘‘"qJE g qjUjд rJ№Lёg‘"x J"GA"x №qfMfGjу qA"x f‘Dv+Tff gQqJk№ёjJ A"R№vjAq ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJfд !‘]fgf] вfvf q"TfёvE‘ё+ [Lk№№ёи "wkwё+ qg"x g‘kJLj‘‘fx f>Y+‘ f qJLjR+qE j["
A"R№j‘qfL"gёJE ‘ё]jv+jJ qjU+ qgjLMGjv"gjGjqAfRf AёGjqJgёRf GJ" g qg"™ "GjLj]E jwj U"vjj №"]GjLAfgёjJ ‘fGJ"<‘"qJE ]ё‘‘"x vfG‘"qJf f JLjUkjJ ‘"g"x qgjLMA"R№j‘qёTffд p"vkGёjJq+ №"L"G‘Qx ALk[Н LёqJkу wjj GkgqJg" ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf №Lfg"]fJ A qJLёMk №"JjLf gvёqJf Lё>у gfgёjJ №ёLё‘"f]ёvE‘k™ №"]">LfJjvE‘"qJE A" gqjR g">R"<‘QR №"vfу JfGjqAfR A"‘AkLj‘JёR GJ" JLjUkjJ jwj U"vjj §‘jL[fG‘"[" kALj№vj‘f+ vfG‘"x gvёqJfд ?ёA kqJё‘ёgvfgё™Jq+ JfLё‘f+ f J"JёvfJёLf>Rд
pLf №qfMfGjqA"x ]jDv+Tff GkgqJg" ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf №Lf‘ё]у vj<fJ k<j №"]gvёqJ‘QR A"J"LQj №jLj‘"q+J qfvQ Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" ‘ё g"<]+д rwkwё+ qjU+ UjqqfvE‘QRf ]ёvjAfRf "J №"vfJfAf RёqqQ JjR ‘j Rj‘jj qALQgё™J g qjUj Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘k™ <ё<]k gvёqJf A"J"у Lё+ ‘ёM"]fJ qg"j kJ"vj‘fj №"qLj]qJg"R f]j‘JfDfAёTff q g"<]jRд PjR qfvE‘jj GkgqJg" ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf JjR U"vjj R"[kwjqJgj‘‘"x gvёqJf Uk]kJ M"JjJE №"]gvёqJ‘Qjд ?fLё‘fGjqAё+ gvёqJE qJfRkvfLkу ™wё+ q №"R"wE™ ‘ёqfvf+ A"R№vjAq ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf Rёqq q">]ёjJ JjR qёRQR №"Ggk ]v+ jwj U"vEKj[" ‘ёqfvf+д p"Jj‘TfёvE‘ё+ kqJLjRу vj‘‘"qJE Rёqq A gvёqJf gQvfgёjJq+ g g"qqJё‘fj №L"Jfg JfLё‘ff jqvf №L"Tjqq f]j‘JfDfAёTff q g"<]jR >ёAё‘GfgёjJq+д
HёL+]k q №qfMfGjqA"x f‘Dv+Tfjx f ]jDv+Tfjx '‘[ gQ]jv+jJ JёAfj Dj‘"Rj‘Q AёA Rё‘ёуvfG‘"qJE f Rё‘ёу]gf<j‘fj Jд jд JёAfj vfGу ‘"qJf fvf ]gf<j‘fj A"J"LQj ]jxqJgfJjvE‘" "gvё]jvf JjR fvf f‘QR ёLMjJf№"R f q№vёGfgё™J ‘ё j[" "q‘"gj gqj "UwjqJg"д ?ёA ‘ё№LfRjL A Rё‘ёуvfG‘"qJf "‘ "J‘"qfv Hё№"vj"‘ё f Йё"уC>Qд H" '‘[ JёA f ‘j qR"[ gQLёU"JёJE +q‘"[" "J‘"Kj‘f+ A §J"Rk g"№L"qkд r‘ №Lf>‘ёjJq+ GJ" №LёAJfGjqAf "JvfGfJE №qfMfGjqAk™ f‘Dv+Tf™ вfvf ]jDv+Tf™и "J Rё‘ёуvfG‘"qJf f Rё‘ёу]gf<j‘f+ ALёx‘j JLk]‘"д cjxqJgfJjvE‘" jqvf №qfMfGjqAё+ f‘Dv+Tf+ у §J" J"vEA" "KfU"G‘"j №Lj]№"v"<j‘fj " qg+>f q ёLMjJf№"R J" AёA J"[]ё "UY+q‘fJE kqJ"xGfg"qJE f R"wE J"JёvfJёL‘QM Lj<fR"gд Эj]E q №">fTfx qёR"[" '‘[ё №"+gvj‘fj J"у
ннЛ
JёvfJёL‘QM "UwjqJg f jqJE Lj>kvEJёJ ]jxqJgf+ A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqу q">‘ёJjvE‘"["д
rq"Uk™ L"vE g "UwjqJgj Rёqq"g"x AkvEJkLQ f[LёjJ ?j‘E у ‘j№Lfу >‘ёgёjRё+ ‘j[ёJfg‘ё+ qJ"L"‘ё LёqQ ‘ёTff q"TfёvE‘"x [Lk№№Qд cv+ Rёqq"g"[" "UwjqJgё MёLёAJjL‘" "JLfTёJE g qjUj >v" "№Lёg]QgёJE qjU+ f g">vё[ёJE "JgjJqJgj‘‘"qJE >ё №L"+gvj‘fj q"TfёvE‘"x №ёJ"v"[ff ‘ё ]Lk[fj ["qk]ёLqJgё f ‘ёTffд Э Rёqq"g"R "UwjqJgj ?j‘E f‘qJf‘AJfgу ‘" gQJjq‘+jJq+ g №"]q">‘ё‘fj GJ" ]jvёjJ j[" №qfMfGjqAf U"vE‘QRН JёA"j "UwjqJg" №"qJ"+‘‘" q">]ёjJ qjUj g‘jK‘j[" gLё[ё q Rё‘fёAёvEу ‘"x §‘jL[fjx qJLjRfJq+ A A"‘DvfAJёR f Lё>LkKj‘f™д „g"x ‘jgL"> Rёqq"g"j "UwjqJg" f><fgёjJ q №"R"wE™ g"x‘ f Ljg"v™Tfxд
HёfU"vjj +LA" Rёqq"g"j "UwjqJg" №L"+gv+jJ qjU+ №" '‘[k g q"у gLjRj‘‘"R ["qk]ёLqJgj вAёA J"JёvfJёL‘"R JёA f №Lёg"g"Rи A"J"L"j qJёv" qёR"Tj‘‘QR f №LjgLёJfv" vfG‘"qJE g qg"™ Dk‘ATf™д Э>ёfR"у "J‘"Kj‘f+ q"gLjRj‘‘"[" ["qk]ёLqJgё f Gjv"gjAё ‘ёM"]+Jq+ g" gvёу qJf ёLMjJf№ё rJTё вЮёJjLfиН f‘]fgf] №"]"U‘" LjUj‘Ak q" qJLёM"R f Uvё["["gj‘fjR "J‘"qfJq+ A ["qk]ёLqJgk GJ" ["g"LfJ "U "JqkJqJgff k ‘j[" >Ljv"qJf f "JgjJqJgj‘‘"qJfд e"qk]ёLqJg" №"]ёgv++ gvjGj‘f+ Gjv"gjAё ]jvёjJ j[" №qfM"№ёJfG‘QR f J"vAёjJ A ‘ёqfvf™ в‘ё№LfRjL A JjLL"LfqJfGjqAfR ёAJёRид ’ёA №"vё[ёjJ '‘[ "q‘"g‘ё+ Jj‘]j‘Tf+ q"gLjRj‘‘"qJf у qJLjRvj‘fj A JfLё‘ff ‘ё[v+]‘" №L"+gfgKjjq+ g A"RRk‘fqJfGjqA"x u"qqff f ‘ёTfqJqA"x ejLRё‘ffд Hj <ёvkjJ '‘[ f >ё№ё]‘k™ ]jR"ALёJf™ A"J"Lё+ №" j[" R‘j‘f™ "№fLёjJq+ ‘ё "Uj>vfу Gj‘‘QM v™]jx ["J"gQM "J]ёJEq+ v™U"Rk f> qg"jx qLj]Qд ?jR ‘j Rjу ‘jj ]jR"ALёJf+ ‘ё j[" g>[v+] №Lj]№"GJfJjvE‘jj GjR J"JёvfJёLf>R f g"J №"GjRkд r‘ №Lf>‘ёjJ GJ" ]v+ Gjv"gjAё jqJjqJgj‘‘QR +gv+jJq+ q"qJ"+‘fj g"x‘Q вq №LfL"]"x qg"fRf gvjGj‘f+Rf "UwjqJg"Rи ]"у qJf<j‘fj №"v‘"[" f ёUq"v™J‘"[" RfLё вg J"R Gfqvj q"TfёvE‘"["и ‘jg">R"<‘" f ]ё<j gLj]‘"д p"№QJAё kqJё‘"gfJE "A"‘GёJjvE‘Qx RfL №Lfgj]jJ A qfvE‘jxKjRk №"]ёgvj‘f™ gvjGj‘fx Gjv"gjAё ‘ёA"№fJ "[L"R‘Qx "JLfTёJjvE‘Qx >ёL+] GJ" Lё‘" fvf №">]‘" >ёA"‘GfJq+ gqj"Uwjx g"x‘"xд cjR"ALёJf+ AёA Lё> f +gv+jJq+ §DDjAJfg‘QR q№"у q"U"R №Lj"ULё>"gё‘f+ f kLёg‘"gjKfgё‘f+ ё[Ljqqfg‘QM f‘qJf‘AJ"gд Э §J"R qRQqvj '‘[ MёLёAJjLf>kjJ ]jR"ALёJf™ AёA ML"‘fGjqA"j q"у qJ"+‘fj kRjLj‘‘"x [Lё<]ё‘qA"x g"x‘Q f ё‘ёLMffд
’Lёx‘fR №L"+gvj‘fjR ]j[Lё]ёTff >ё№ё]‘QM "UwjqJg qJёv №" '‘[k [jLRё‘qAfx ‘ёTf"‘ёvуq"Tfёvf>R A"J"LQx ]ёv ‘j[ёJfg‘Qx №LfRjL №Lj‘jULj<j‘f+ A"vvjAJfg‘QR Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘QRд HjqR"JL+ ‘ё J" GJ" '‘[ ‘ёGёv ё‘ёvf>fL"gёJE №qfM"v"[f™ ‘jRTjg jwj q" gLjRj‘ pjLg"x RfL"g"x g"x‘Q "‘ ]"v[" ‘j R"[ "№Lj]jvfJE qg"j "J‘"Kj‘fj A ‘ёTf"‘ёvуq"Tfёvf>RkН J" vf §J" Rё‘ёу]gf<j‘fj q">‘ёJjvE‘" k№Lёgу v+™wjj ёLMjJf№ёRf J" vf №L"+gvj‘fj №qfMfGjqA"x f‘Dv+Tffд
Э"f‘qJgk™wfx Lёqf>R g ejLRё‘ff UQv gQ>gё‘ №" '‘[k ]gkR+ "q‘"g‘QRf DёAJ"LёRfН g"у№jLgQM A"R№vjAq"R ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf ‘jRTjg f g"уgJ"LQM №L"Uk<]j‘fjR ёLMjJf№ё Э"Jё‘ё у [jLRё‘qA"[" +>QGjqA"[" U"[ёд
ныа
’ёA "JRjGёjJ '‘[ A"R№vjAq ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf k ‘jRTjg fRjjJ fqJ"LfGjqAk™ "q‘"gkд HjRTQ qvfKA"R №">]‘" №"+gfvfqE g ck‘ёxу qA"x ]"vf‘j "‘f "№">]ёvf q "q‘"gё‘fjR fR№jLff f >ёMgёJ"R A"v"‘fxд ’"[]ё ‘jRTQ "ULё>"gёvf j]f‘"j ["qk]ёLqJg" f kgf]jvf GJ" U"[ёJqJgё k<j Lёq№Lj]jvj‘Q "‘f "Uf]jvfqE f qJёvf >ёgfqJvfgQRfд ejLRё‘qAfj №vjRj‘ё №jLjULёgKfqE q Э"qJ"Aё ‘ё oё№ё] JёA f ‘j qJёvf №"v‘QRf jgL"№jxTёRf "‘f ]ёvjA" jwj ‘j "J"LgёvfqE "J gёLgёLqAfM A"L‘jx fM kL"gj‘E Lё>gfJf+ q""JgjJqJgkjJ №"]L"qJA"g"Rk g">LёqJkд p"]L"qJу A"gё+ №qfM"v"[f+ ‘jRTjg у fqJ"G‘fA fM GkgqJgё ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJf f №Lj]Lёq№"v"<j‘‘"qJf A №qfM"№ёJffд ejLRё‘f+ kJgjL<]ёjJ '‘[ gqj[]ё UQvё qJLё‘"x №qfMfGjqAfM AёJёqJL"DН ujD"LRёTf+ ALjqJE+‘у qAfj f Ljvf[f">‘Qj g"x‘Qд Э q""JgjJqJgff q №"]L"qJA"g"x qJk№j‘E™ Lё>gfJf+ ]v+ ‘jRjTA"x ‘ёTff MёLёAJjLj‘ qALQJQx ["R"qjAqkёvf>R GёqJfG‘"j kqJLё‘j‘fj Ш‘fRё в<j‘qAfx ёLMjJf№ g №qfMfAj Rk<Gf‘Qи GJ" №L"g"TfLkjJ ‘jgL"JfGjqAk™ ё[Ljqqf™д ” ‘jRTjg AёA f k №"]L"qJу A"g ALёx‘j ‘jLё>gfJё §R"Tf"‘ёvE‘"уGkgqJgj‘‘ё+ qDjLё <f>‘fд cё‘у ‘Qx ‘j]"qJёJ"A A"R№j‘qfLkjJq+ q "]‘"x qJ"L"‘Q №LfqJLёqJfjR A f>"wLj‘‘QR f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘QR №"qJL"j‘f+R вDfv"q"Df+и ё q ]Lkу ["x у ё‘JfqjRfJf>R"R JёA AёA jgLjf Uk]kGf GkgqJgj‘‘" Lё>gfJQRf ‘jg"vE‘" №"]GjLAfgё™J ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"qJE ‘jRTjgд HjRTQ у v™]f q Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘" >ё‘f<j‘‘"x qёR""Tj‘A"x ‘jkgjLj‘‘Qj g qjUj "JAkу ]ё №L"fqM"]fJ fM Rё‘f+ gjvfGf+ qJLjRvj‘fj qJёJE ‘ёTfjx ["q№"] <jvё‘fj №L"]jR"‘qJLfL"gёJE RfLk qg"™ g>L"qv"qJEд Э §J"R №vё‘j "L[ё‘f>"gё‘‘"j k‘fGJ"<j‘fj v™]jx R"<‘" LёqqRёJLfgёJE AёA №"]у L"qJA"gQx §№ёJё< №"№QJAk "ULёJfJE ‘ё qjU+ g‘fRё‘fj f JёAfR "Uу Lё>"R g">gQqfJEq+ g [vё>ёM ]Lk[fM ‘ёL"]"gд ’ Lё>L+]k №"]L"qJA"gQM A"R№vjAq"g "J‘"qfJq+ f №"gQKj‘‘ё+ g‘kKёjR"qJE ‘jRTjg ‘j"q"у >‘ё‘‘"j <jvё‘fj ‘ёxJf qjUj ёgJ"LfJjJ g vfTj g"<]+д
Э q"qJ"+‘ff №qfM"№ёJff gQ>gё‘‘"x A"R№vjAq"R ‘j№"v‘"Tj‘‘"у qJf ‘jRjTAё+ ‘ёTf+ №"vё[ёjJ '‘[ f]j‘JfDfTfL"gёvё qjU+ q" qgjLMу Gjv"gjA"R №"]Av™Gfg JjR qёRQR RjMё‘f>R Lj[Ljqqff A ёLMёfGjqAfR [vkUf‘ёR qg"j[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"["д Hj№"qLj]qJgj‘‘QR №Lj]qJёgfу JjvjR A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" ‘jRTjg qJёv ёLMjJf№ Э"Jёу ‘ё у +>QGjqA"[" U"[ё UkLf f ‘jfqJ"gqJgё AkvEJfgfLk™wj[" qJLёqJE A g"x‘jд Э GёqJ‘"qJf ёLMjJf№ Э"Jё‘ё №L"GfJQgёjJq+ g ‘ёTfqJqA"x qgёqJfAj у gLёwё™wfxq+ ALjqJ "ULё>k™wfx gfMLE q ‘ё№Lёgvj‘fjR ]gf<j‘f+ g vjgk™ qJ"L"‘k вg Uk]]fqJqA"x qfRg"vfAj у A №"]q">‘ёу JjvE‘"Rkид pL"q‘kgKfxq+ Э"Jё‘ №L"Lgёv J"‘Ak™ №vj‘Ak MLfqJfё‘у qA"x §JfAf f kgvjA ‘jRTjg g Uj>]‘k Mё"qё f Lё>LkKj‘fxд „">‘ё‘fj ‘jRTjg ‘j qR"[v" gQ]jL<ёJE ‘ё№"L Э"Jё‘ё "Aё>ёv"qE ‘jq№"q"U‘QR №"]Gf‘fJE qjUj qfvQ A"vvjAJfg‘"[" Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" f UQv" fRf №"[v"wj‘"д !J"[ ]jxqJgf+ ‘jk№Lёgv+jRQM qfv Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"[" у gqj"Uwё+ AёJёqJL"Dёд
ЭjqERё ‘j"]‘">‘ёG‘" "J‘"Kj‘fj '‘[ё A efJvjLkд „ "]‘"x qJ"L"у ‘Q "‘ gf]fR" №"]Gf‘++qE "Uwj№Lf‘+J"x R"Lёvf gf]fJ g Dj‘"Rjу ‘j efJvjLё Jf№fG‘Qx №LfRjL №qfMfGjqA"x f‘Dv+TffН L"vE D™LjLё
ныр