Жуков. Государство. Право. Власть

qJ"L"‘Q k<j g">‘fAKfM q"TfёvfqJfGjqAfM qJLё‘д r]‘ёA" №"]"Uу ‘Qj qvkGёf q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"[" №jLjg"L"Jё №" j[" R‘j‘f™ "Gj‘E Lj]Af f JLk]‘" qjUj №Lj]qJёgfJE Ljёvf>ёTf™ JLjUkjRQM ]v+ §J"у [" kqv"gfxд ЙёgL"g ‘ё]j+vq+ GJ" q"TfёvfqJfGjqAё+ Ljg"v™Tf+ g u"qqff g "JvfGfj "J oё№ё]ё Uk]jJ Rj‘jj AL"gёg"xд pLfGf‘ JёA"[" "№JfRf>Rё ]gjН g"у№jLgQM №jLjM"] A q"Tfёvf>Rk "Uvj[GfJ q"MLёу ‘fgKё+q+ ALjqJE+‘qAё+ "Uwf‘ёЖ g"уgJ"LQM ["q№"]qJgk™wfj Avёqу qQ g qfvk fM qvёU"[" №"vfJfGjqA"[" Lё>gfJf+ ‘j "Aё<kJ qfvE‘"[" q"№L"Jfgvj‘f+д

Э>[v+]Q ЙёgL"gё ‘ё Ljg"v™Tf™ Rj‘+vfqE №" RjLj g"gvjGj‘f+ j[" g №"vfJfGjqAk™ ]j+JjvE‘"qJEд „ qёR"[" jj ‘ёGёvё вgJ"Lё+ №"v"у gf‘ё ыауM [[ди "‘ №Lf>‘ёgёv Ljg"v™Tf™ AёA qLj]qJg" №jLjkqJL"xу qJgё "UwjqJgё Lё>vfGё+ Ljg"v™Tf™ №"vfJfGjqAk™ вqgjL<j‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"x gvёqJfи f Ljg"v™Tf™ q"TfёvE‘k™ вf>Rj‘j‘fj gqj[" q"TfёvE‘"[" qJL"+ид ЭRjqJj q JjR ]"g"vE‘" ]"v[" ЙёgL"g ]"№kqAёv g">R"<‘"qJE [ёLR"‘f>ёTff "J‘"Kj‘fx Rj<]k §Aq№vkёу JёJ"LёRf f §Aq№vkёJfLkjRQRf Uj> Lё]fAёvE‘QM f>Rj‘j‘fxд cj+у JjvE‘"qJE 6 !‘JjL‘ёTf"‘ёvё №" j[" q"UqJgj‘‘QR qv"gёR kUj]fvё j[" g ‘j№LfRfLfR"qJf Avёqq"gQM f‘JjLjq"gд „"UqJgj‘‘fAf ]"UL"у g"vE‘" ‘j LёqqJё‘kJq+ q" qg"fR fRkwjqJg"R ё ["qk]ёLqJg" gqj[]ё Uk]jJ fM >ёwfwёJEд ?"L<jqJg" q"Tfёvf>Rё ]jvёjJ "‘ gQg"] R"<jJ UQJE J"vEA" Lj>kvEJёJ"R ‘ёqfvf+ ё №"]vf‘‘Qx q"TfёvfqJ у gqj[]ё Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLд

pLfRj‘fJjvE‘" A u"qqff №"‘fRё‘fj ЙёgL"gQR №jLq№jAJfg Ljу g"v™Tff fRjv" qg"f "q"Uj‘‘"qJfд Эgf]k ‘jLё>gfJ"qJf Aё№fJёvf>у Rё f "JqkJqJgf+ №L"RQKvj‘‘"[" №L"vjJёLfёJё g u"qqff [vёg‘"x Ljу g"v™Tf"‘‘"x qfv"x "‘ qGfJёv ALjqJE+‘qJg"д p"‘ёGёvk "‘ №"vё[ёv GJ" LkqqAfx ‘ёL"] вfRjv"qE g gf]k ALjqJE+‘qJg"и A"‘qjLgёJfg‘Qx f q TёLfqJqAfRf ‘ёqJL"j‘f+Rf ‘j ["J"g A q"TfёvE‘"x Ljg"v™Tff f №"qJL"j‘f™ q"Tfёvf>Rёд „"gjLKj‘fj <j №"vfJfGjqA"x Ljg"v™Tff вqgjL<j‘fj qёR"]jL<ёgf+и №Lfgj]jJ vfKE A kqJё‘"gvj‘f™ gvёqJf ‘"gQM §Aq№vkёJёJ"L"gд p"§J"Rk fR UQvё №Lj]v"<j‘ё №L"№ё[ё‘у ]fqJqAё+ JёAJfAёН f‘Jjvvf[j‘Tf+ ]"v<‘ё f]Jf g ‘ёL"] №L"qgjwёJE j[" f ["J"gfJE A Uk]kwjx Ljg"v™Tffд s“"<]j‘fj g ‘ёL"]y g рВ.е у рВ.м [[д ‘j ]ёv" Lj>kvEJёJ"g GJ" >ёqJёgfv" ЙёgL"gё №jLjqR"JLjJE qg"j "J‘"Kj‘fj A №jLq№jAJfgёR №"vfJfGjqA"x U"LEUQ g u"qqffд r‘ №LfM"]fJ A gQg"]k GJ" qёR"]jL<ёgfj ‘j ]ёqJ g">R"<‘"qJf №"]у ["J"gfJE ‘ёL"] A q"TfёvE‘"x Ljg"v™Tffд rJq™]ё g">‘fAёjJ ‘"gё+ JёAJfGjqAё+ kqJё‘"gAё ‘ё qgjL<j‘fj qёR"]jL<ёgf+д ’ёJёvf>ёJ"L"R JёA"[" LjKj‘f+ qJёvё ]"qJёJ"G‘" §DDjAJfg‘ё+ JjLL"LfqJfGjqAё+ ]j+JjvE‘"qJE sHёL"]‘"x g"vfy kgj‘GёgKё+q+ kUfxqJg"R ШvjAqё‘у ]Lё 66д Hё qv"gёM ЙёgL"g №L"]"v<ёv "JqJёfgёJE Tj‘‘"qJE №L"№ё[ё‘у ]Q g ‘ёL"]j qGfJё+ j[" "q‘"g‘QR qkUYjAJ"R [L+]kwj[" q"TfёvE‘"[" №jLjg"L"Jё ‘ё ]jvj "‘ №jLjKjv A "JALQJ"x №"]]jL<Aj №"vfJfGjу qA"[" JjLL"Lё g u"qqff ё g Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLёM kgf]jv j]f‘qJgj‘‘k™ qfvk qgjL<j‘f+ ёUq"v™Jf>Rёд

ртр

ЙёgL"g Lё>LёU"Jёv kGj‘fj " №ёLJff q№"q"U‘"x g kqv"gf+M ]jу q№"Jf>Rё ]"qJf[ёJE №"qJёgvj‘‘QM Tjvjxд ?ёAё+ №ёLJf+ №"vё[ёjJ "‘ ]"v<‘ё №Lj]qJёgv+JE q"U"x Jёx‘k™ U"jgk™ "L[ё‘f>ёTf™ q <jqJA"x g"j‘‘"x ]fqTf№vf‘"x ё jj Gvj‘Q ]"v<‘Q UQJE qg"j[" L"]ё q"v]ёJёу Rf "U+>ё‘‘QRf gQ№"v‘fJE v™U"x №LfAё> qg"j[" LkA"g"]qJgёд cv+ №ёLJff №"]GjLAfgёjJ LkqqAfx q"TfёvfqJ s‘k<‘Q §‘jL[fGjqAfj Dё‘ёJfGjqAfj v™]f LfqAk™wfj gqjR f ["J"gQj <jLJg"gёJE gqjRд Hk<‘Q RkGj‘fAf vj[j‘]ё A"J"LQM №jLjL"qvё UQ ]ёvjA" fM fqJf‘у ‘"j ]"qJ"f‘qJg" fM ]jxqJgfJjvE‘k™ >ёqvk[kyд Эq+Afx g‘"q+wfx Lё>]"L g №ёLJf™ +gv+jJq+ jj f>Rj‘‘fA"R f gLё["Rд

r]f‘ f> gё<‘QM A"R№"‘j‘J"g №"vfJfGjqA"x Jj"Lff ЙёgL"gё у kGj‘fj " ["qk]ёLqJgj "JvfGё™wjjq+ §AvjAJfG‘QR q"j]f‘j‘fjR ]"у ["g"L‘"x Jj"Lff f RёLAqf>Rёд evёg‘"j qg"xqJg" ["qk]ёLqJgё q j[" J"GAf >Lj‘f+ у >ёA"‘‘"j "U+>ёJjvEqJg" [Lё<]ё‘ №"]]jL<fgёJE №Lёу g"№"L+]"A f №"‘k<]ёJE A §J"Rk gqjM "JAё>Qgё™wfMq+ №"]Gf‘+JEу q+ ]"UL"g"vE‘"д Э "q‘"gj ["qk]ёLqJgё vj<fJ ]jxqJgfJjvE‘Qx vfU" DfAJfg‘Qx ]"["g"L qg+>Qgё™wfx gqjM [Lё<]ё‘ ["qk]ёLqJgё f gQу Lё<ё™wfxq+ g >ёA"‘jд „ ]Ljg‘fM gLjRj‘ ["qk]ёLqJg" q"gRjwёjJ g qjUj ]gё ‘ёGёvё у №Lf‘k]fJjvE‘"qJE f ]"UL"g"vE‘"qJE q"qkwjqJgkу ™wfj AёA ‘jA"j №L"Jfg"LjGfg"j j]f‘qJg"д pL"[Ljqq Gjv"gjGjqJgё №L"+gv+jJq+ g J"R GJ" №Lf‘k]fJjvE‘"j ‘ёGёv" gqj U"vjj kqJk№ёjJ RjqJ" ]"UL"g"vE‘"qJf f ‘ёA"‘jT №Lf q"Tfёvf>Rj qg"]fJq+ A Rf‘fу RkRkд ЙёgL"g ["g"LfJ ]ё<j "U "JRfLё‘ff ["qk]ёLqJgё №Lf s>Ljv"R q"Tfёvf>Rjy в№"GJf AёA k ЮёLAqёид

e"qk]ёLqJg" qGfJёjJ "‘ R"<jJ qvk<fJE №L"[Ljqqk f LjёATffд Э kqv"gf+M Aё№fJёvf>Rё ["qk]ёLqJg" jqJE D"LRё Avёqq"g"[" ["q№"]у qJgё UkL<kё>ffд ?Lk]+wfjq+ q"gjLKё™wfj Ljg"v™Tf™ "JRjGёv ЙёgL"g g №">]‘fx №jLf"] ]"v<‘Q kqJё‘"gfJE qg"™ ]fAJёJkLk f q jj №"R"wE™ U"L"JEq+ >ё q"Tfёvf>R №L"Jfg §Aq№vkёJёJ"L"gд rULё>jT q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"[" ["qk]ёLqJgё у pёLf<qAё+ A"RRk‘ёд pLf §J"R ["qk]ёLqJg" qvj]kjJ LёqqRёJLfgёJE ‘j AёA TjvE №L"[Ljqqё ё AёA j[" qLj]qJg"д

p"qA"vEAk №" ЙёgL"gk q"Tfёvf>R №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ ]jTj‘JLёvfу >ёTf™ ["qk]ёLqJgё f Dj]jLёvf>R UQv" UQ <jvёJjvE‘" GJ"UQ "]‘ё ‘ёTf+ q">]ёgёvё ‘jqA"vEA" ["qk]ёLqJg в‘ё№LfRjL ]Ljg‘fj [LjAfид Э §J"R qvkGёj q">]ё™Jq+ Uvё["№Lf+J‘Qj kqv"gf+ ]v+ ALfJfGjqAf RQqv+wfM vfG‘"qJjx "‘f R"[kJ №jLjUfLёJEq+ f> "]‘"[" ["qk]ёLу qJgё g ]Lk["j g qvkGёj ["‘j‘f+ ‘ё ‘fMд cL"Uvj‘fj "]‘"x ‘ёTff ‘ё Lё>‘Qj ["qk]ёLqJgё q№"q"UqJgkjJ №L"[Ljqqkд

Э Rj<]k‘ёL"]‘QM "J‘"Kj‘f+M №L"[Ljqq №L"+gv+jJq+ g "JAё>j ["qk]ёLqJg "J >ёg"jgёJjvE‘QM g"x‘ f №Lf"ULjJj‘f+ ‘"gQM JjLLfу J"Lfxд

)dpЗdm ьmDBъЗЮ;AW\dn уЗBhЮdЮ врВрн l рВ.ми у [vёgё Uk‘JёLу qA"[" ‘ё№Lёgvj‘f+ g ‘ёL"]‘fGjqJgj f Jj"LjJfA ё‘ёLMf>Rёд ” ‘j[" UQvё +LAё+ Uf"[LёDf+ Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLёН kGёqJfj g jgL"№jxqAfM Ljg"у v™Tf+M рВнВ у рВнЛ [[д ["]Q >ёAv™Gj‘f+ g jgL"№jxqAfM f TёLqAfM

ртт

J™LERёM q">]ё‘fj ё‘ёLMfqJqAfM "L[ё‘f>ёTfx U"LEUё q ’д ЮёLAq"R f zд m‘[jvEq"R g‘kJLf Юj<]k‘ёL"]‘"[" J"gёLfwjqJgё LёU"GfM в6 !‘JjL‘ёTf"‘ёvи №"]]jL<Aё Jёx‘QM Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘QM "UwjqJg g u"qqffд

HёL"]‘fGjqAfj g>[v+]Q ЩёAk‘f‘ё "L[ё‘fG‘" q"GjJёvfqE q j[" ё‘ёLMfGjqA"x Jj"Lfjx qv"<fgKjxq+ №"] gvf+‘fjR pдtд pLk]"‘ё f Юд iJfL‘jLёд HёfU"vjj №"v‘" j[" g">>Lj‘f+ №Lj]qJёgvj‘Q g Lёу U"JёMН szj]jLёvf>R q"Tfёvf>R f ё‘JfJj"v"[f>Ry врВм.и pfqER" ЮдШд ЩёAk‘f‘ё A „дeд HjGёjgk вт f™‘+ рВ.а [ди se"qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"qJE f ё‘ёLMf+y врВ.еид

!qJ"Lf+ Gjv"gjGjqJgё q"[vёq‘" ЩёAk‘f‘k §g"v™Tf"‘fLkjJ "J sTёLqJgё <fg"J‘"qJfy A sTёLqJgk qg"U"]Qyд mAq№vkёJёJ"LqA"j "UwjqJg" ["qk]ёLqJg" f Ljvf[f+ у ‘f>Kfj qJk№j‘f g §J"R Lё>gfу Jffд Э" gqj fqJ"LfGjqAfj §№"Mf "UwjqJg" ]jvfv"qE ‘ё ]gj GёqJfН §Aq№vkёJёJ"L"g в№Lfgfvj[fL"gё‘‘"j Rj‘EKf‘qJg"и f §Aq№vkёJfу LkjRQM в№"]ёgv+™wjj U"vEKf‘qJg"ид Э №jLg"x [Lk№№j №Lj"Uvё]ёjJ q">‘ёJjvE‘"qJE f ]fqTf№vf‘ё g" gJ"L"x у Ujqq">‘ёJjvE‘"qJE f‘у qJf‘AJQ f qJfMfx‘"qJEд „"gLjRj‘‘ё+ Tfgfvf>ёTf+ JёA<j "q‘"gё‘ё ‘ё §Aq№vkёJёTffН UkL<kё>f+ fq№"vE>kjJ №Lf‘k]fJjvE‘Qx JLk] №L"у vjJёLfёJё f A"‘DvfAJ Rj<]k §JfRf AvёqqёRf g LёRAёM q"gLjRj‘‘"у [" "UwjqJgё f ["qk]ёLqJgё ‘jLё>LjKfRд

„">]ёjJ №"]]jL<fgёjJ f [ёLё‘JfLkjJ qfqJjRk §Aq№vkёJёTff у ["qk]ёLqJg" A"J"L"j gqj[]ё +gv+jJq+ >ё["g"L"R "L[ё‘f>ёTfjx §Aqу №vkёJёJ"L"g №L"Jfg §Aq№vkёJfLkjRQMд evёg‘ё+ >ё]ёGё v™U"[" ["qkу ]ёLqJgё f v™U"[" №LёgfJjvEqJgё у №"A"Lj‘fj f q"]jL<ё‘fj g LёUqJgj ‘ёL"]ёд mAq№vkёJfLkjRQx ‘ёL"] gjLfJ g kqJё‘"gfgKfxq+ №"L+]"A ‘" g qfvk ‘jwё]‘"x §Aq№vkёJёTff j[" q">‘ё‘fj ‘ёGf‘ёjJ №L"Uk<у ]ёJEq+д rJq™]ё >ё]ёGё ["qk]ёLqJgё у №"RjKёJE №L"Uk<]j‘f™ ‘ёL"у ]ёд p"qA"vEAk gvёqJE gqj[]ё ‘ёM"]fJq+ g LkAёM §Aq№vkёJёJ"L"g ["у qk]ёLqJg" у jqJjqJgj‘‘Qx gLё[ JLk]+wj["q+ ‘ёL"]ёд pL"vjJёLfёJ g qfvk qg"j[" №"v"<j‘f+ "U+>ё‘ qgjL[‘kJE UkL<kё>‘"j ["qk]ёLqJg"д

p"RfR" №"]]jL<Af qfqJjRQ §Aq№vkёJёTff ["qk]ёLqJg" №" ЩёAk‘f‘k +gv+jJq+ >v"R f №" ]Lk[fR №LfGf‘ёRд ?ёA ["qk]ёLqJg" k‘fGJ"<ёjJ f‘]fgf]kёvE‘k™ f "UwjqJgj‘‘k™ qg"U"]kд Э §J"x qg+у >f №"]gjL[ёjJq+ ALfJfAj Jj"Lf+ "UwjqJgj‘‘"[" ]"["g"Lё A"J"LQx №" R‘j‘f™ LkqqA"[" ё‘ёLMfqJё +gv+jJq+ ёUqkL]‘"x DfATfjx JдAд №Lj]№"vё[ёjJ R"vGёvfg"j q"[vёqfj "J]ёJE qjU+ f qg"j №"J"RqJg" g LёUqJg" ["qk]ёLqJgkд rUwjj Uvё[" " A"J"L"x ["g"LfJ ]"["g"L‘ё+ Jjу "Lf+ jqJE ‘fGJ" f‘"j AёA Uvё[" ["qk]ёLqJgёд rUwjqJgj‘‘Qx ]"["g"L >ёUfLёjJ k Gjv"gjAё ‘j GёqJE qg"U"]Q ё gq™ jj TjvfA"R "qJёgv++ jRk gRjqJ" qg"U"]Q Uj>"№ёq‘"qJEд „kgjLj‘fJjJ ‘ёL"]ё g q"gLjRj‘‘QM ]jR"ALёJfGjqAfM ["qk]ёLqJgёM oё№ё]ё у JёA<j DfATf+ №"qA"vEAk k№Lёgv+jJ JёR ‘j ‘ёL"] ё §Aq№vkёJfLk™wjj Rj‘EKf‘qJg"д

e"qk]ёLqJg" №LjqJk№‘" №" qg"jx №LfL"]jН "‘" gQLёqJёjJ f> №Ljу qJk№vj‘f+ f №Lf>gё‘" q"gjLKёJE №LjqJk№vj‘f+д H"LRёvE‘"j q"qJ"у +‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgё у gjqJf g"x‘k fvf ["J"gfJq+ A ‘jxд hqvf AёAfjуJ"

рте

RёvQj ["qk]ёLqJgё №L"g"]+J RfL"v™Ufgk™ №"vfJfAk J" ‘j №"J"Rk GJ" k ‘fM ]Lk[ё+ №LfL"]ё ё g qfvk fM qvёU"qJfд uё>g+>Qgё+ g"x‘k ["qk]ёLqJg" Lё>LQgёjJ gqj"Uwk™ q"vf]ёL‘"qJE v™]jx ‘ё >jRvjд e"у qk]ёLqJg" q">]ёjJ qg"™ q"UqJgj‘‘k™ R"LёvE R"LёvE №ёJLf"Jf>Rё qkJE A"J"L"x у kALj№vj‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"[" R"[kwjqJgёд Э" fR+ qg"j[" gjvfGf+ ["qk]ёLqJg" >ёqJёgv+jJ kUfgёJE f №"LёU"wёJE GJ" Lё>LkKёjJ vfG‘"qJE gj]jJ A №"№Lё‘f™ "q‘"g‘QM №Lf‘Tf№"g Gjу v"gjG‘"qJfд pLf JёA"x R"Lёvf q"gLjRj‘‘"j qfvE‘"j ["qk]ёLqJg" R"<jJ fRjJE J"vEA" "]‘k "№"Lk у Tj‘JLёvf>"gё‘‘k™ ёLRf™ f U™у L"ALёJf™д e"qk]ёLqJgj‘‘ё+ gvёqJE Lё>vё[ёjJ f LkA"g"]fJjvjx f №"]Gf‘j‘‘QMд Pjv"gjA ‘ё]jvj‘‘Qx gvёqJE™ "U+>ёJjvE‘" ‘ёGf‘ёjJ №LfJjq‘+JE ]Lk["[" Gjv"gjAёд ЭvёqJE D"LRfLkjJ №Lj>Lj‘fj A ‘ёL"]у ‘QR RёqqёR f "J]jvE‘"x vfG‘"qJfд PJ"UQ >ёwfJfJE ‘LёgqJgj‘‘"qJE v™]jx f "Ujq№jGfJE J"L<jqJg" Gjv"gjG‘"qJf ]jvёjJ gQg"] ЩёAkу ‘f‘ ["qk]ёLqJg" ]"v<‘" UQJE k‘fGJ"<j‘"д

ЩёAk‘f‘ q +L"qJE™ "ULkKfgёjJq+ f ‘ё Ljvf[f™ Jд Aд "‘ё qg"fR ёgJ"LfJjJ"R "qg+wёjJ qfqJjRk §Aq№vkёJёTff f ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"[" ‘ёqfvf+д ujvf[f+ kJgjL<]ёjJ "‘ у Lj>kvEJёJ Dё‘Jё>ff ‘j№L"qgjу wj‘‘"[" Gjv"gjAё "‘ё >ёqJёgv+jJ j[" "JLjGEq+ "J qg"U"]Q f qJёJE LёU"Rд pLf>‘ё‘fj Щ"[ё ">‘ёGёjJ №Lf>‘ё‘fj qg"j[" ‘fGJ"<jqJgё qg"jx >ёgfqfR"qJf "J ‘j[" GJ" L"<]ёjJ g Gjv"gjAj GkgqJg" LёUqJgёд mJk "q"Uj‘‘"qJE Ljvf[ff fq№"vE>kjJ ["qk]ёLqJg"д

?ёAfR "ULё>"R U"LEUё q qkwjqJgk™wjx qfqJjR"x §Aq№vkёJёTff №Lf‘fRёjJ k ЩёAk‘f‘ё D"LRk U"LEUQ q ["qk]ёLqJg"R f TjLA"gE™ ё ё‘ёLMf>R "J"<]jqJgv+jJq+ q q"Tfёvf>R"Rд Щ"LEUё >ё k№Lё>]‘j‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgё f TjLAgf ">‘ёGёjJ ]v+ ‘j[" U"LEUk >ё q"Tfёvf>Rд

ЩёAk‘f‘ №"]GjLAfgёjJ GJ" ‘ёkAё ‘j R"<jJ kAё>ёJE ‘ё gqj ]jJёvf Uk]kwjx "UwjqJgj‘‘"x <f>‘f ё №"v‘"j "qkwjqJgvj‘fj >ё]ёGf №"у qJL"j‘f+ q"Tfёvf>Rё у ]jv" qJ"vjJfxд evёg‘"j у ]"Aё>ёJE ‘j<f>у ‘jq№"q"U‘"qJE qkwjqJgk™wj[" qJL"+ "№Lj]jvfJE "Uwfj №Lf‘Tf№Q Uk]kwj[" kqJL"xqJgё f ‘ёRjJfJE №kJf fM ]"qJf<j‘f+д Hё qRj‘k §Aqу №vkёJёTff ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"Rk №Lf‘k<]j‘f™ f Ljvf[f">‘"Rk RLёу A"Ujqf™ ]"v<‘" №" ЩёAk‘f‘k №Lf]Jf q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"j "UwjqJg" "q‘"gё‘‘"j ‘ё ё‘ёLMfGjqA"R qёR"k№Lёgvj‘ff ‘ёkG‘"R RfL"g">у >Lj‘ff f ёJjf>Rjд „"Tfёvf>R ]v+ ‘j[" у §J" "UwjqJg" №Lf A"J"L"R fqAv™GёjJq+ §Aq№vkёJёTf+ Gjv"gjAё Gjv"gjA"R Aё<]Qx f‘]fgf] g№Lёgj №"vE>"gёJEq+ "UwjqJgj‘‘QR U"[ёJqJg"R f fRjJE Lёg‘Qj g">у R"<‘"qJf ]v+ Lё>gfJf+ qg"fM q№"q"U‘"qJjxд Щk]kwjj "UwjqJg" у §J" qJL"x []j ["q№"]qJgkjJ Lёgj‘qJg" f ‘fGjR ‘j "[Lё‘fGj‘‘ё+ qg"U"]ё Gjv"gjA ‘j>ёgfqfR "J gq+A"x gvёqJfд HёL"]Q qёR"qJ"+у JjvE‘" Uj> ["qk]ёLqJgё "L[ё‘f>k™J qg"™ <f>‘E q‘f>k ]"gjLMk g gf]j qёR"k№Lёgv+™wfMq+ JLk]"gQM в>jRvj]jvEGjqAfM f DёULfG‘"у LjRjqvj‘‘QMи JjLLfJ"LfёvE‘QM f ]Lk[fM ёqq"TfёTfxд „JL"fJjvEу qJg" ёqq"TfёTfx ]"v<‘" UQv" №jLjKё[‘kJE ‘ёTf"‘ёvE‘Qj [Lё‘fTQ f №LfgjqJf g A"‘jG‘"R qGjJj A "ULё>"gё‘f™ gqjRfL‘"x Dj]jLёTff ёqq"TfёTfxд pjLgQx Kё[ ‘ё §J"R №kJf у "L[ё‘f>ёTf+ „"j]f‘j‘‘QM

ртн

iJёJ"g hgL"№Q ‘ё "q‘"gj k№Lё>]‘j‘f+ qkwjqJgk™wfM ["qk]ёLqJg f q">]ё‘f+ Dj]jLёTff qёR"k№Lёgv+™wfMq+ "Uwf‘д

Эq+Afx GjL‘"LёU"Gfx Gjv"gjA f JLk]+wfjq+ RёqqQ g Tjv"R kJgjL<]ёjJ ЩёAk‘f‘ +gv+™Jq+ qJfMfx‘QRf q"TfёvfqJёRf №" qg"jу Rk №"v"<j‘f™д Э §J"R qRQqvj ‘ё oё№ё]j f g u"qqff q">Ljvf kqv"gf+ ]v+ №jLjM"]ё A ё‘ёLMf>Rk f q"Tfёvf>Rkд ЭRjqJj q JjR qvёg+‘qAfj ‘ёL"]Q f g GёqJ‘"qJf LkqqAfx ‘ёL"] g U"vEKjx qJj№j‘f ["J"gQ ]v+ JёA"[" №jLjM"]ёд cjv" g J"R GJ" №" qg"jx №LfL"]j qvёg+‘j у ‘ёL"у ]Q ‘j №"vfJfGjqAfj ‘j ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘Qj ‘f "]‘" qvёg+‘qA"j №vjR+ qёR"qJ"+JjvE‘" ‘j q">]ёv" ["qk]ёLqJgёд ?"vEA" >ёg"jgёJjvE‘Qj ‘ёу L"]Q q">]ё™J ["qk]ёLqJg" qvёg+‘j <j у ‘ёL"]Q >jRvj]jvEGjqAfjд !qJ"Lf+ qvёg+‘ у §J" fqJ"Lf+ fM >ёg"jgё‘f+ JkLAёRf JёJёLёRf Rё]E+LёRf f [vёg‘QR "ULё>"R [jLRё‘TёRfд pLfL"]‘Qx ё‘ёLMf>R qvёg+‘qAfM ‘ёL"]"g L"<]ёjJ Uvё["№Lf+J‘Qj kqv"gf+ ]v+ q"TfёvEу ‘"x Ljg"v™Tff f kqJё‘"gvj‘f+ Dj]jLёTff qёR"k№Lёgv+™wfMq+ ёqq"TfёTfxд Э §J"R "J‘"Kj‘ff qvёg+‘ёR "Jgj]j‘ё gjvfAё+ L"vE у gjqJf Gjv"gjGjqJg" A kqJё‘"gvj‘f™ ‘"g"[" ё‘ёLMfGjqA"[" №"L+]Aёд

Э]ёvE‘jxKjR A ‘fR №Lfq"j]f‘+Jq+ vёJf‘qAfj f [jLRё‘qAfj ‘ёL"]Qд

Э§J"R ]gf<j‘ff A q"Tfёvf>Rk f ё‘ёLMf>Rk "q"U"j >‘ёGj‘fj fRjjJ LkqqAfx ‘ёL"] AёA qёRQx R‘"["Gfqvj‘‘Qx f> qvёg+‘qAfMд ЩёAk‘f‘ gQ]jv+jJ JLf "q‘"g‘Qj GjLJQ LkqqA"[" ‘ёL"]ё ]jvё™у wfM j[" ‘ёfU"vjj №"]M"]+wfR ]v+ q"TfёvE‘QM №Lj"ULё>"gё‘fxН

ри kUj<]j‘fj GJ" >jRv+ №Lf‘ё]vj<fJ ‘ёL"]k ти kUj<]j‘fj GJ" №Lёg" ‘ё №"vE>"gё‘fj >jRvjx №Lf‘ё]vj<fJ ‘j "J]jvE‘"Rk vfTk ё "Uwf‘j еи "Uwf‘‘"j qёR"k№Lёgvj‘fj f gLё<]jU‘"j "J‘"Kj‘fj "Uwf‘Q A ["qk]ёLqJgkд r]‘ёA" k LkqqA"[" ‘ёL"]ё jqJE AёGjqJgё q A"J"LQRf ‘ё]" U"L"JEq+Н ри №ёJLfёLMёvE‘"qJE ти №"[v"wj‘fj vfTё "Uwf‘"x еи gjLё g TёL+д rUwf‘Q №Lf gqjx fM gё<‘"qJf ]v+ №"qJL"у j‘f+ q"Tfёvf>Rё f[Lё™J f ‘j[ёJfg‘k™ L"vEН g qfvk qg"jx ёgJ"‘"Rу ‘"qJf "‘f ‘j fRj™J qg+>f ]Lk[ q ]Lk["R GJ" q№"q"UqJgkjJ k№L"Gjу

‘f™ ]jq№"Jf>Rёд

Э ]kMj ‘ёL"]‘fGjqA"x JLё]fTff ЩёAk‘f‘ Lё>vfGёjJ Ljg"v™Tf™ №"vfJfGjqAk™ вqRj‘ё gvёqJfи f q"TfёvE‘k™ в№L"gj]j‘fj [vkU"AfM q"TfёvfqJfGjqAfM №Lj"ULё>"gё‘fx f k№Lё>]‘j‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgёид hqvf №"vfJfGjqAk™ Ljg"v™Tf™ R"<‘" q"gjLKfJE g "]‘"x qJLё‘j J" q"TfёvE‘ё+ Ljg"v™Tf+ №"JLjUkjJ q"gRjqJ‘QM ]jxqJgfx jqvf ‘j gqjM J" U"vEKf‘qJgё ‘ёTfxд hgL"№ё f u"qqf+ <fgkJ g №jLf"] ‘jу Rf‘kjR"x ‘ёL"]‘"x Ljg"v™Tff ‘" LkqqAfx ‘ёL"] ["J"g A ‘jx U"у vjj GjR ]Lk[fjд Э u"qqff jqJE kqv"gf+ ‘j"UM"]fRQj ]v+ q"gjLKjу ‘f+ q"TfёvE‘"x Ljg"v™TffН ри GLj>RjL‘Qj ‘fwjJё f qJLё]ё‘f+

ти q"TfёvfqJfGjqAfx f]jёv k LkqqA"[" ‘ёL"]ё еи gjLё ‘ёL"]ё g qg"j №Lёg" <fJE №" §J"Rk f]jёvk вJдjд Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘Qx ‘ёqJL"xид ukqqAfx ‘ёL"] №" ЩёAk‘f‘k "Uvё]ёjJ №"gQKj‘‘"x Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"qJE™ g qfvk J"[" GJ" "‘ Uk‘J"gwfA №" №LfL"]jН gq™ LkqqAk™ fqJ"Lf™ "‘ Uk‘J"gёv №L"Jfg ["qk]ёLqJgёд r‘ ["J"g g v™Uk™ Rf‘kJk №" №Lf>Qgk ‘ёGёJE [L"RfJE f Lj>ёJE №"RjwfA"g Gf‘"g‘fA"g f Ak№T"gд HfGj["

рты

‘j qJ"fJ kJgjL<]ёv LkqqAfx ё‘ёLMfqJ №"]‘+JE ‘ё Uk‘J v™Uk™ ]jу Ljg‘™д

„"[vёq‘" ЩёAk‘f‘k g LkqqA"R Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"R ]gf<j‘ff gQ]jу v+™Jq+ ]gё ‘ё№Lёgvj‘f+ у №L"№ё[ё‘]fqJqA"j f Uk‘JёLqA"jд pjLg"j ‘j fRjjJ №jLq№jAJfg Jд Aд qfv"x qv"gё ‘jvE>+ f>Rj‘fJE q">‘ё‘fj LkqqA"[" ALjqJE+‘qJgё №ёJLfёLMёvE‘"qJE qvfKA"R qfvE‘ёд ?"vEA" Uk‘J qv"Rёg kqv"gf+ <f>‘f LkqqA"[" Rk<fAё q№"q"Uj‘ №LёAJfGjу qAf №"]gf‘kJE j[" g qJ"L"‘k q"TfёvE‘"x Ljg"v™Tffд

ЩёAk‘f‘ №"]GjLAfgёjJ GJ" Ljg"v™Tf+ g u"qqff ]"v<‘ё UQJE J"vEA" qJfMfx‘"x ]Lk[ё+ №L"qJ" ‘jg">R"<‘ёд „fvё q"gLjRj‘‘"[" ["qk]ёLqJgё qvfKA"R gjvfAё GJ"UQ jj R"[vё qv"RfJE AёAё+уJ" "L[ёу ‘f>ёTf+ Ljg"v™Tf"‘jL"g №"RfR" qёR"[" ‘ёL"]ёд ujg"v™Tf+ ]"v<у ‘ё UQJE qJfMfx‘"x JёA<j №"J"Rk GJ"UQ №Lj]"JgLёJfJE g">‘fA‘"у gj‘fj ["qk]ёLqJgё qLё>k №"qvj qgjL<j‘f+ №Lj<‘jx gvёqJfд Эq+Ak™ №"№QJAk kqJё‘"gvj‘f+ Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"x ]fAJёJkLQ вAёA №Lj]vё[ёv ’д ЮёLAqи qvj]kjJ "JgjL[‘kJE Jд Aд "‘ё Uk]jJ qJLjRfJEq+ qjU+ kgjA"у gjGfJE f "ULёJfJ ‘ёL"] g LёUqJg"д „g"U"]‘"j "UwjqJg" R"<jJ UQJE "L[ё‘f>"gё‘" J"vEA" RjJ"]"R qg"U"]Q Jд jд gqj‘ёL"]‘QR Uk‘J"R f g"vE‘"™ "L[ё‘f>ёTfjx LёU"GfM Rёqq q‘f>kд

Э JёAJfAj ЩёAk‘f‘ё jqJE №L"Jfg"LjGfjН gQqJk№ё+ >ё qJfMfxу ‘"qJE Ljg"v™Tff "‘ qGfJёjJ ‘j"UM"]fRQR q">]ёJE Jёx‘k™ U"jgk™ "L[ё‘f>ёTf™ A"J"Lё+ q №"R"wE™ ‘jgf]fRQM qLj]qJg LkA"g"]fvё UQ №"]["J"gA"x f M"]"R Ljg"v™Tffд p"qA"vEAk ALjqJE+‘qAfj "Uу wf‘Q Lё>"Uwj‘Q gё<‘jxKё+ >ё]ёGё Ljg"v™Tf"‘jL"g у kqJё‘"у gfJE Rj<]k ‘fRf qg+>E f "Ujq№jGfJE fM "]‘"gLjRj‘‘"j gQqJk№vjу ‘fjд p"qvj Ljg"v™Tff Jёx‘ё+ "L[ё‘f>ёTf+ ]"v<‘ё №"R"GE ‘ёL"]k qJL"fJE ‘"g"j "UwjqJg" ‘ё "q‘"gj Lёgj‘qJgё f qg"U"]Q ‘j ]"№kqJfg gRjKёJjvEqJgё AёA"xуvfU" ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"x gvёqJf вgLjRj‘‘"x fvf №jLjM"]‘"xид

Эf]‘jxKfR f]j"v"["R >ё["g"LwfGjqA"[" ‘ё№Lёgvj‘f+ g ‘ёу L"]‘fGjqJgj UQv бDCA »dBdCdn "BЗnD\ врВнн у рВВмид r‘ L"]fvу q+ g ‘jU"[ёJ"x ]g"L+‘qA"x qjREjд Э рВмр [д №"qJk№fv ‘ё ™Lf]fGjу qAfx DёAkvEJjJ pjJjLUkL[qA"[" k‘fgjLqfJjJё в"A"‘Gfv §AqJjL‘"R g рВмВ [ди f qLё>k <j "Aё>ёvq+ g [kwj Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘" ‘ёqJL"j‘‘"x R"v"]j<fд Э "AJ+ULj §J"[" <j ["]ё >ё kGёqJfj g qJk]j‘GjqAfM g"vу ‘j‘f+M j[" >ёAv™Gё™J ‘ё ]gё Rjq+Tё q‘ёGёvё g pjJL"№ёgv"gqAk™ ё >ёJjR g ’L"‘KJё]JqAk™ ALj№"qJEд cёvE‘jxKё+ <f>‘E ?AёGjgё g u"qqff у §J" GjLj]ё ёLjqJ"g >ё Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘k™ №L"№ё[ё‘]k f №Lfу ‘ё]vj<‘"qJE A №"]№"vE‘QR "L[ё‘f>ёTf+Rд „ рВмт [д ?AёGjg ‘ёGf‘ёу jJ q"JLk]‘fGёJE q L+]"R <kL‘ёv"g №kUvfAk+ qJёJEf ‘ё Lё>vfG‘Qj >v"U"]‘jg‘Qj JjRQ L"qqfxqA"x ]jxqJgfJjvE‘"qJf GjR №Lf"ULjv f>gjqJ‘"qJE f ёgJ"LfJjJд

Э рВмВ [д LkqqAfx Uvё‘AfqJ qUvf<ёjJq+ q „дeд HjGёjgQR >‘ёRjу ‘fJQR q">]ёJjvjR Jёx‘"x "L[ё‘f>ёTff sHёL"]‘ё+ Lёq№Lёgёy №Lf‘у Tf№ ]j+JjvE‘"qJf A"J"L"x UQv sTjvE "№Lёg]QgёjJ qLj]qJgёyд Hjу Gёjg s№L"qvёgfvq+y JjR GJ" "L[ё‘f>"gёv >gjLqA"j kUfxqJg" Gvj‘ё

ртм

sHёL"]‘"x Lёq№LёgQy qJk]j‘Jё !д!д !gё‘"gё >ё "JAё> №"qvj]‘j[" №"]Gf‘+JEq+ №ёLJfx‘QR JLjU"gё‘f+Rд cё‘‘Qx qvkGёx gQ>gёgKfx KfL"Afx Lj>"‘ё‘q g "UwjqJgj vj[ g "q‘"gk DёUkvQ L"Rё‘ё sЩjqQy zдЮд c"qJ"jgqA"["д

Э рВ.е [д ?AёGjg ‘ёM"]+qE g qqQvAj Uj<fJ >ё [Lё‘fTk []j ‘jу A"J"L"j gLjR+ q"JLk]‘fGёjJ q <kL‘ёv"R pдЙд ЙёgL"gё sЭ№jLj]Мyд „ рВ.ы №" рВВр [д q"gRjqJ‘" q LkqqA"у№"vEqAfRf §Rf[Lё‘JёRf f>у ]ёgёv <kL‘ёv +A"Uf‘qA"[" ‘ё№Lёgvj‘f+ sHёUёJyд Э qjLj]f‘j рВ.ауM [[д qUvf>fvq+ q DLё‘Tk>qAfRf Uvё‘AfqJёRfд Э A"‘Tj рВВт [д J+у <jv" >ёU"vjv f №"qvj]‘fj ["]Q №L"gjv g №qfMfёJLfGjqA"x U"vE‘fTjд

pд Hд ?AёGjg у ёgJ"L R‘"["Gfqvj‘‘QM qJёJjx №" qёRQR Lё>‘""у ULё>‘QR g"№L"qёRН №"vfJfAf №Lёgё §A"‘"RfAf fqJ"Lff Dfv"у q"Dff №qfM"v"[ff q"Tf"v"[ff №j]ё["[fAf §qJjJfAf vfJjLёJkу L"gj]j‘f+д r]‘ёA" gqj j[" LёU"JQ №"]Gf‘j‘Q "]‘"x kJfvfJёL‘"x №Lё[RёJfG‘"x TjvfН №L+R" fvf A"qgj‘‘" "U"q‘"gёJE f]j™ Ljg"v™у Tff g u"qqff Lё]fAёvE‘QM q"TfёvE‘QM №Lj"ULё>"gё‘fxд HёfU"vjj MёLёAJjL‘QRf g §J"R "J‘"Kj‘ff +gv+™Jq+Н soё]ёGf Ljg"v™Tf"‘у ‘"x №L"№ё[ё‘]Q g u"qqff в№fqER" A Lj]ёAJ"Lk <kL‘ёvё ХХЭ№jLj]Мbиy врВ.ни sHёL"] f Ljg"v™Tf+y врВ.ми sШ‘ёLMfGjqA"j ["qk]ёLqJg"y врВ.ми sHёAё‘k‘j f ‘ё ]Lk["x ]j‘E Ljg"v™Tffy врВ.м у рВ..ид

zfv"q"DqA"уRjJ"]"v"[fGjqAё+ "q‘"gё №"vfJfGjqAfM g>[v+]"g ?AёGjgё §AvjAJfG‘ё f №L"Jfg"LjGfgёд h[" RfL"g">>Lj‘fj qv"<fу v"qE №"] "№Lj]jv+™wfR gvf+‘fjR Hдeд PjL‘QKjgqA"[" HдЭд ijvу [k‘"gё cд!д pfqёLjgё Hд’д ЮfMёxv"gqA"["д Э Tjv"R "‘ qJ"+v ‘ё №">fTf+M RёJjLfёvf>Rё qJёLёvq+ "№fLёJEq+ ‘ё jqJjqJgj‘‘"‘ёkG‘"j >‘ё‘fj M"J+ >ёGёqJk™ №"‘fRёv qg+>E Rj<]k f]jёvE‘QR f RёJjLfёvEу ‘QR k№L"wj‘‘" gkvE[ёL‘"д p"] gvf+‘fjR ’д ЮёLAqё f zд m‘[jvEqё g"q№Lf‘+v "J]jvE‘Qj №"v"<j‘f+ RёJjLfёvfqJfGjqA"[" №"‘fRё‘f+ fqJ"Lff ‘" №Lf §J"R "J]ёgёv ]ё‘E f]jёvfqJfGjqAf №"‘+J"x Jj"Lff №L"[Ljqqё в№LjkgjvfGfgёv L"vE >‘ё‘f+ g Lё>gfJff Gjv"gjGjqJgёи f g"v™‘JёLf>Rk вg №jLjv"R‘Qj §№"Mf Lё>gfJfj fqJ"Lff >ёgfqfJ "J ёAJfg‘"[" Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"[" Rj‘EKf‘qJgёид

„"Tfёvf>R №" ?AёGjgk jqJE A"‘jG‘ё+ J"GAё №L"[Ljqqёд ’Lfу JjLfx №L"[Ljqqё у qGёqJEj "J]jvE‘"[" f‘]fgf]ёд „""JgjJqJgj‘‘" TjvE №L"[Ljqqё у №"qJL"fJE "UwjqJg" q№"q"U‘"j "Ujq№jGfJE qGёу qJEj gqjM f‘]fgf]"g j[" q"qJёgv+™wfMд ?ёAfR "UwjqJg"R R"<jJ UQJE J"vEA" q"Tfёvf>R Jдjд JёA"j q"TfёvE‘"j kqJL"xqJg" []j "Ujу q№jGfgёjJq+ Lёgj‘qJg" qg"U"]ё f ULёJqJg"д p"qA"vEAk gvёqJE jqJE Lj>kvEJёJ ‘jLёgj‘qJgё J" q"Tfёvf>R kqJLё‘fg ‘jLёgj‘qJg" kqJёу ‘ёgvfgёjJ f Uj>gvёqJfjд „"Tfёvf>R №"A"fJq+ ‘ё [ёLR"‘ff GёqJ‘QM f‘JjLjq"g J"G‘"x q"Lё>RjL‘"qJf qLj]qJg f №"JLjU‘"qJjx Aё<]"[" q" qLj]qJgёRf f №"JLjU‘"qJ+Rf gqjMд eёLё‘Jf+ §JfM №Lf‘Tf№"g у "UwjqJgj‘‘"j A"vvjAJfg‘"j №Lёg"д „"Tfёvf>R у §J" "UwjqJg" A"J"L"j g">‘fAёjJ g Lj>kvEJёJj A"Lj‘‘"x v"RAf qkwjqJgk™wfM f‘qJfJkJ"g в["qk]ёLqJgё TjLAgf qjREf f Jд№ди f f>Rj‘j‘f+ №Lfу L"]Q Gjv"gjAёд

рт.

Ш‘Jf№"]"R q"Tfёvf>Rё gQqJk№ёjJ v™U"j "UwjqJg" №"qJL"j‘‘"j ‘ё ‘jLёgj‘qJgj v™]jx вDf>fGjqA"R f‘JjvvjAJkёvE‘"R §A"‘"RfGjу qA"R №"vfJfGjqA"R f gq+A"R ]Lk["Rи у fqJ"G‘fAj gqjM q"TfёvEу ‘QM Uj]qJgfxд ?ёA"j "UwjqJg" MёLёAJjL‘" ё‘Jё["‘f>R"R GёqJ‘QM f‘JjLjq"g f A"‘DvfAJ"R f‘]fgf]"g kqJLё‘j‘fjR ["qk]ёLqJgё "J gq+A"[" gRjKёJjvEqJgё g Lёq№Lj]jvj‘fj JLk]ё f g">‘ё[Lё<]j‘f+ "J Lj[kvfL"gё‘f+ f‘]fgf]kёvE‘QM №"JLjU‘"qJjxд Э §J"R "UwjqJgj ["q№"]qJgkjJ GёqJ‘"j №Lёg"д

Э ]kMj ‘ёL"]‘fGjqA"x JLё]fTff ?AёGjg qg+>QgёjJ №jLq№jAJfу gQ q"Tfёvf>Rё g u"qqff q ALjqJE+‘qA"x "Uwf‘"x ‘" "UY+q‘+jJ §J" №"уqg"jRkд !]jёv LkqqA"[" ‘ёL"]ё Lёqqk<]ёjJ "‘ у qёR"kу №Lёgv+™wё+q+ "Uwf‘ё ALk["gё+ №"LkAё ULёJqAё+ q"vf]ёL‘"qJE gqjM Gvj‘"g "Uwf‘Q Jд jд f]jёv q +q‘" gQLё<j‘‘QR A"RRk‘fqJfу GjqAfR "JJj‘A"Rд r]‘ёA" §J"J f]jёv M"JE f q"]jL<fJ >ёL"]QK A"RRk‘f>Rё ‘" g Tjv"R "‘ A"‘qjLgёJfgj‘д „ёR"qJ"+JjvE‘" Lkqу qAfx ‘ёL"] ‘j q№"q"Uj‘ Lё>gfJE g qjUj A"RRk‘fqJfGjqAfj ‘ёGёvёд Э M"]j Ljg"v™Tff ‘ёL"] R"<jJ №L"+gfJE qjU+ J"vEA" g AёGjqJgj Lё>LkKfJjv+ qJёL"[" №"L+]Aё q">]ёgёJE ‘"gQx qJL"x у k]jv Ljу g"v™Tf"‘‘"[" Rj‘EKf‘qJgёд p"§J"Rk g M"]j Ljg"v™Tff f qLё>k №"qvj ‘jj [vёg‘ё+ L"vE №Lf‘ё]vj<fJ ‘j ‘ёL"]k ё Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"у Rk Rj‘EKf‘qJgkд

rJvfGё™Jq+ qg"j"ULё>fjR g>[v+]Q ?AёGjgё ‘ё №jLq№jAJfgQ Ljg"v™Tff g u"qqffд Э ‘ёqJ"+wjj gLjR+ kJgjL<]ёjJ "‘ TёLqA"j №LёgfJjvEqJg" sgfqfJ g g">]kMjy k ‘j[" ‘jJ "№"LQ g "UwjqJgj f LjёvE‘QM qfv №L"Jfg"qJ"+JE ‘ёL"]kд H" g qJLё‘j Lё>gfgёjJq+ Aёу №fJёvf>R Lё>vё[ё™wfx "Uwf‘k f D"LRfLk™wfx Avёqq qjvEqA"x Uё‘A"gqA"x J"L["g"x f №L"RQKvj‘‘"x UkL<kё>ffд Э Lj>kvEJёJj L"qqfxqAё+ R"‘ёLMf+ №"vkGёjJ Avёqq ‘ё A"J"LQx R"<jJ "№jLjJEq+ ё L"qJ"A q"Tfёvf>Rё g vfTj "Uwf‘Q fqGj>ёjJд rJq™]ё >ё]ёGё qJ"+у wё+ №jLj] LkqqAfRf Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLёRfН "№jLj]fJE ‘j[ёJfg‘" Lё>у gfgё™wfjq+ q"UQJf+ f AёA R"<‘" UQqJLjj q"gjLKfJE Ljg"v™Tf™д cё‘‘Qj ёL[kRj‘JQ ?AёGjg №Lfg"]fv ЙёgL"gk ALfJfAk+ j[" >ё №L"у №ё[ё‘]fqJqAk™ JёAJfAkд

Э "q‘"gj JёA"x kqJё‘"gAf vj<ёvё A"‘Tj№Tf+ q"[vёq‘" A"J"L"x fqJ"Lf+ ‘j qkwjqJgkjJ №"RfR" v™]jx f vfG‘"qJE вsёAJfg‘"j Rj‘Eу Kf‘qJg"yи g q"qJ"+‘ff f>Rj‘fJE jj M"]д rJqkJqJgfj "UYjAJfg‘QM kqv"gfx ]v+ f>Rj‘j‘fx ‘j ]"v<‘ё UQvё "qJё‘ёgvfgёJEд ujg"v™Tf"у ‘jL №"vё[ёjJ ?AёGjg ‘j <]jJ №"Aё JjGj‘fj fqJ"LfGjqAfM q"UQJfx kAё<jJ Rf‘kJk "‘ gQUfLёjJ jj qёR №Lf>‘ёgё+ ‘ёL"] gqj[]ё ["J"у gQR A Ljg"v™Tffд r‘ qGfJёjJ qjU+ g№Lёgj №Lf>QgёJE A g"qqJё‘f™ Jд Aд gq+Afx ‘ёL"] >ё]ёgvj‘‘Qx №L"f>g"v"R gqj[]ё A ‘jRk ["J"g ‘j"UM"]fR vfKE g‘jK‘fx J"vG"Aд h]f‘qJgj‘‘"j GJ" fRjjJ >]jqE >‘ёGj‘fj у §J" ‘ёvfGfj k ‘ёL"]ё f Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘"[" Rj‘EKf‘qJgё ёDDjAJfg‘QM fR№kvEq"g q""JgjJqJgk™wj[" §R"Tf"‘ёvE‘"[" ‘ёу qJL"+д rJq™]ё "]‘ё f> gё<‘jxKfM >ё]ёG Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLё g u"qqff у Lё>gfgёJE g "UwjqJgj ёDDjAJfg‘Qj fR№kvEqQд

ртВ

Hj"UM"]fR"qJE g UQqJLjxKjR q"gjLKj‘ff Ljg"v™Tff L"<]ёvё №" ?AёGjgk j]f‘qJgj‘‘" g">R"<‘k™ JёAJfAk l >ё["g"L q TjvE™ >ёу MgёJё ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘"x gvёqJfд oё["g"L ]"v<j‘ UQJE "qkwjqJgvj‘ Jёx‘"x <jqJA" Tj‘JLёvf>"gё‘‘"x "L[ё‘f>ёTfxд PJ"UQ Ljg"v™Tf+ UQvё kq№jK‘"x >ёMgёJk gvёqJf ‘ёgjLMk ]"v<j‘ q"№kJqJg"gёJE ‘ёу L"]‘Qx Uk‘J g‘f>kд p"qvj qgjL<j‘f+ R"‘ёLMff kqJё‘ёgvfgёjJq+ Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘ё+ ]fAJёJkLё ]jxqJgk™wё+ ]" JjM №"L №"Aё ‘j Uk]kJ k‘fGJ"<j‘Q gLё[f Ljg"v™Tff f ‘"gQx №"L+]"A ‘j №kqJfJ U"vjj fvf Rj‘jj [vkU"Afj A"L‘fд

PJ"UQ ]j+JjvE‘"qJE №" q">]ё‘f™ ‘"g"[" qJL"+ №"v‘jj gQLё<ёу vё №"JLjU‘"qJf ‘ёL"]ё Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘ё+ gvёqJE "L[ё‘f>kjJ qfqJjRk "L[ё‘"g ‘ёL"]‘"[" №Lj]qJёgfJjvEqJgё g" [vёgj q HёL"]‘"x ckR"xд ujg"v™Tf"‘‘ё+ ]fAJёJkLё "№fLё+qE ‘ё HёL"]‘k™ ckRk ]"v<‘ё №L"gjqJf L+] LjD"LRН ри №Lj"ULё>"gёJE ALjqJE+‘qAk™ "Uwf‘k "q‘"у gё‘‘"x ‘ё №Lf‘Tf№j GёqJ‘"[" gvё]j‘f+ g "Uwf‘kуA"RRk‘k "q‘"gQу gё™wk™q+ ‘ё №Lf‘Tf№j "Uwj[" q"gRjqJ‘"[" №"vE>"gё‘f+ "Lk]f+Rf №L"f>g"]qJgё f q"gRjqJ‘"[" JLk]ёЖ ти №"qJj№j‘‘ё+ §Aq№L"№LfёTf+ qLj]qJg №L"f>g"]qJgё ‘ёM"]+wfMq+ g GёqJ‘"R gvё]j‘ff f g №jLj]ёу Gj fM g "Uwjj №"vE>"gё‘fjЖ еи kqJLё‘j‘fj ]"["g"L‘QM "J‘"Kj‘fx g "URj‘j №L"]kAJёRf f >ёRj‘j fM "J‘"Kj‘f+Rf ULёJqA"x v™Ugf f q"у vf]ёL‘"qJfЖ ни №"qJj№j‘‘"j kqJLё‘j‘fj Df>fGjqA"[" kRqJgj‘‘"[" f ‘LёgqJgj‘‘"[" ‘jLёgj‘qJgё Rj<]k v™]ERf №kJjR g"q№fJё‘f+ fM g ]kMj v™Ugf Lёgj‘qJgё f ULёJqJgёЖ ыи k‘fGJ"<j‘fj qkwjqJgk™wjx qjREf "q‘"gё‘‘"x ‘ё №Lf‘Tf№j №"]Gf‘j‘‘"qJf <j‘wf‘Q LёUqJgё ]jJjx f §["fqJfGjqA"[" №L"f>g"vё Rk<Gf‘Ж ми Lё>gfJfj "Uwf‘‘"[" qёR"k№Lёgvj‘f+ f №"qJj№j‘‘"j k№Lё>]‘j‘fj Tj‘JLёvE‘QM Dk‘ATfx ["qk]ёLqJgёд

?AёGjg Lj>A" ALfJfA"gёv svёgLfqJ"gy вJд jд №"qvj]"gёJjvjx ЙёgL"gёи >ё f>ULё‘fj №L"№ё[ё‘]fqJqA"x JёAJfAf f sUёAk‘fqJ"gy в№"qvj]"gёJjvjx ЩёAk‘f‘ёи >ё "JLfTё‘fj L"vf ["qk]ёLqJgё g №L"у gj]j‘ff Ljg"v™Tf"‘‘QM №Lj"ULё>"gё‘fxд HjqR"JL+ ‘ё J" GJ" >ёу ["g"LwfGjqAё+ JёAJfAё q №LfRj‘j‘fjR RjJ"]"g JjLL"Lё g Ljg"v™у Tf"‘‘"R ‘ёL"]‘fGjqJgj g fJ"[j g">"Uvё]ёvё g ‘ёL"]‘fGjqA"x qLj]j ?AёGjg kqJk№ёv №" №"№kv+L‘"qJf f ЙёgL"gk f ЩёAk‘f‘kд „]jvё‘‘"j LkqqAfR Uvё‘AfqJ"R sHёL"]‘"x g"vjy №Lj]v"<j‘fj " q"JLk]‘fGjу qJgj UQv" j™ "JgjL[‘kJ"д

ч IЭ эЧ( •Эд Э(э э ш 9Ч ,Э9 э•Ч Э эЧ(э Эжд шжЭ( эЭ•ш Эжч

НпЭ• 9 эж• Ш Э эЧ(э7­3 -ч2ч зш •ЭжЧ

Э L"qqfxqA"x №"vfJfGjqA"x <f>‘f ‘ёGёvё ьь gд gf]‘k™ L"vE f[Lёvё №ёLJf+ q"TfёvfqJ"gуLjg"v™Tf"‘jL"g qJёgKё+ №L+у R"x ‘ёqvj]‘fTjx ]gf<j‘f+ ‘ёL"]‘fA"gд pjLgQj "L[ё‘f>ёTff q"TfёvfqJ"gуLjg"v™Tf"‘jL"g №Lj]qJёgv+™wfj q"U"x [vkU"A" >ёу A"‘q№fLfL"gё‘‘Qj ALk<Af №"+gfvfqE g ЛауM [[д ь6ь gд D"LRёvEу

ртЛ

‘"j kGLj<]j‘fj №ёLJff q"qJ"+vёqE g A"‘Tj ]jAёUL+ рЛаы [д у ‘ёGёvj +‘gёL+ рЛам [д rq‘"gk №ёLJff q"qJёgfvf "JUQgKfj AёJ"L[k f qqQvу Ak ‘ёL"]‘fAf f Lё]fAёvE‘" ‘ёqJL"j‘‘"j qJk]j‘GjqJg"д n]L"R №L"у [LёRRQ q"TfёvfqJ"gуLjg"v™Tf"‘jL"g qJёvё ‘ёL"]‘fGjqAё+ f]j+ "U "q"U"R ‘jAё№fJёvfqJfGjqA"R №kJf Lё>gfJf+ u"qqff g">R"<‘"qJf №"qJL"j‘f+ q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"[" "UwjqJgё g kqv"gf+M ё[LёL‘"x qJLёу ‘Qд rJq™]ё у "q"U"j g‘fRё‘fj §qjL"g A ALjqJE+‘qJgk "Uvё]ёgKjRk №" fM R‘j‘f™ q№"q"U‘"qJE™ №L"Jfg"qJ"+JE UkL<kё>‘"Rk gvf+‘f™д Э ё[LёL‘"x qJLё‘j q"MLё‘fgKjx "Uwf‘‘Qj JLё]fTfx №"vё[ёvf §qjLQ q"Tfёvf>R L"<]ёjJq+ f Lё>gfgёjJq+ g ]jLjg‘j f J"vEA" №"у J"R "ALj№‘kg "MgёJQgёjJ ["L"]д “ёLёAJjL‘"x GjLJ"x §qjL"gqA"[" q"Tfёvf>Rё UQvё Jj"Lf+ q"Tfёvf>ёTff >jRvf A"J"Lё+ №Lj]№"vё[ёу vё "JRj‘k GёqJ‘"x q"UqJgj‘‘"qJf ‘ё >jRv™ Uj> gQAk№ё №LjgLёwjу ‘fj >jRvf ‘j g ["qk]ёLqJgj‘‘k™ q"UqJgj‘‘"qJE ё g "Uwj‘ёL"]‘"j ]"qJ"+‘fj Uj> №Lёgё Ak№vfу№L"]ё<f f №jLj]ёGk jj Tj‘JLёvE‘QR f RjqJ‘QR "L[ё‘ёR qёR"k№Lёgvj‘f+д p"vE>"gё‘fj >jRvjx ]"v<‘" UQv" UQJE skLёg‘fJjvE‘"уJLk]"gQRy GJ" ">‘ёGёv" Lёg‘"j jj Lёqу №Lj]jvj‘fj Rj<]k gqjR JLk]"gQR ‘ёqjvj‘fjRд

pL"[LёRRё §qjL"g gAv™Gёvё JёA<j JLjU"gё‘f+ "U kqJё‘"gvj‘ff ]jR"ALёJfGjqA"x Dj]jLёJfg‘"j Ljq№kUvfAf gqj"Uwj[" №L+R"[" f Lёg‘"[" f>UfLёJjvE‘"[" №Lёgё №Lf Jёx‘"R ["v"q"gё‘ff "q‘"g‘QM №Lёg f qg"U"] [Lё<]ё‘д ujKj‘fj LёU"Gj[" g"№L"qё №Lj]kqRёJLfgёv" ggj]j‘fj ВуGёq"g"[" LёU"Gj[" ]‘+ q"TfёvE‘"[" qJLёM"gё‘f+ LёqKfу Lj‘fj №Lёg №L"Dq"™>"g fM kGёqJfj g k№Lёgvj‘ff №L"f>g"]qJg"Rд

Эё<‘QR qLj]qJg"R U"LEUQ q qёR"]jL<ёgfjR §qjLQ qGfJёvf f‘]fgf]kёvE‘Qx JjLL"L №L"Jfg №Lj]qJёgfJjvjx gvёqJf вg №jLf"] Ljg"v™Tff рЛаыурЛа. [[д fRf q"gjLKj‘" ]" таа JjLL"LfqJfGjqAfM ёAJ"gид

pёLJf+ §qjL"g UQvё "]‘"x f> qёRQM gvf+JjvE‘QM f Rёqq"gQMд hqvf ‘ё R"Rj‘J q">]ё‘f+ №ёLJff A"vfGjqJg" jj Gvj‘"g q"qJёgv+у v" тут ы JQqд Gjv"gjA J" vjJ"R рЛр. [д "‘ё ‘ёqGfJQgёvё k<j "A"v" р Rv‘ Gvj‘"g в]v+ qLёg‘j‘f+Н U"vEKjgfAf A §J"Rk gLjRj‘f fRjvf "A"v" тна JQqд Gvj‘"g №ёLJffМид pёLJf+ gAv™Gёvё g qjU+ №Lj]qJёу gfJjvjx qёRQM Lё>vfG‘QM q"TfёvE‘QM qv"jg ‘" q" >‘ёGfJjvE‘QR №Lj"Uvё]ё‘fjR ALjqJE+‘ LёU"GfM f q"v]ёJд CёLqA"j №LёgfJjvEу qJg" gf]jv" [vёg‘k™ "№ёq‘"qJE ‘j g Aё]jJёM "AJ+ULfqJёM fvf ]ё<j q"Tfёvу]jR"ALёJёM в№Lj<]j gqj[" U"vEKjgfAёMи ё g §qjLёM q fM U"jgQRf JjLL"LfqJfGjqAfRf ]Lk<f‘ёRfд Э""Lk<j‘‘Qj g"qqJё‘f+ g Ю"qAgj врЛаыи ’L"‘KJё]Jj f „gjёU"L[j врЛами q"qJ"+vfqE g" R‘"["R Uvё["]ёL+ kGёqJf™ §qjL"gд c"qJёJ"G‘" KfL"A" q"TfёvfqJQу Ljg"v™Tf"‘jLQ UQvf №Lj]qJёgvj‘Q g e"qk]ёLqJgj‘‘QM ]kRёMд

ujg"v™Tf™ рЛаыурЛа. [[д §qjLQ "Tj‘fvf AёA №jLjM"]‘k™ Rj<у ]k Ljg"v™Tf+Rf UkL<kё>‘"x f q"TfёvfqJfGjqA"x AёA Lj>kvEJёJ ‘jLjKj‘‘"qJf >jRjvE‘"[" g"№L"qё LjD"LR"x рВмр [д Hё fM g>[v+] ]gf<kwjx qfv"x Ljg"v™Tff рЛаыурЛа. [[д UQv" ALjqJE+‘qJg" g q"™>j q №L"vjJёLfёJ"R f sJLk]"g"xy f‘Jjvvf[j‘Tfjxд Э §A"‘"Rfу

реа