Добавил:
Upload Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:
razrabotka Painting.rtf
Скачиваний:
18
Добавлен:
12.08.2019
Размер:
303.26 Кб
Скачать

Instructions

1. Work in group of 5–6 students (the whole group is participating in the discussion).

2. Elect a discussion leader who will act as the host (hostess) of the discussion:

a) leader opens the meeting and introduces the members to each other;

b) he invites each member to speak;

c) he politely interrupts any member who speaks too long;

d) he sums up the opinions of the speakers.

Note. In the course of the discussion observe the general rules:

Don't wander from the subject!

Don't monopolize the time and the discussion!

Don't be sharp towards those who do not agree with you!

Use the following formulas to make your entry into the discussion:

May I put a word in?

If you ask me...

It just occurred to me...

On the surface of it, it really is..., but...

Generally speaking...

Strictly speaking...

That depends on...

I want to press the point that...

On the one hand...

On the other hand...

Under the circumstances.

Conclude your reasoning in the discussion using such statements as:

All these show conclusively that...

To sum it all up...

All things considered...

The major point at issue was...

We can arrive at the conclusion that...

Topic 1. Different Genres of Painting.

Speak about different genres of painting (two or more students may choose the same genre provided they don't repeat each other in the discussion). Each student is to speak about the genre he has chosen pointing out its merits and advantages in comparison with other genres. It is essential that the participants should argue with each other, stressing the various merits of the genre they are defending and criticizing possible disadvantages of other genres.

Use the following:

My preference lies with the genre of portrait because...

I personally like genre paintings. They are...

My favourite painters are Shishkin and Levitan. So, naturally, I prefer landscape to other genres. You see...

I can't say I care much for still lifes. They seem to me meaningless, a merely decorative genre...

I can't agree that landscape has any social significance, because...

Will you explain what you meant by saying that the genre of portrait is thought-provoking? After all, a portrait is just a likeness of some person or other...

Topic 2. Old Art or Modern Art?

Consider the following arguments in favour of both old and modern painters and use them as theses in your discussion.

For Old Art

1. Painting of old masters is one of the greatest treasures man­kind has collected in the history of its civilisation.

2. Old painting reflects the collective experience of human spiritual life of many centuries.

3. The human experi­ence embodied in the great paintings of the past is also our experi­ence; hence the respon­siveness of modern people to old pictures.

4. The advanced technical experiments of modern painters would have been impossible without the supreme technical achievements of old masters.

For Modern Art

1. For most modern people old paintings are unintelligible. Even the subjects – mythological, biblical – are often ob­scure.

2. New times call for new songs. Modern man is naturally interested in the art reflecting his own time and his own experi­ence.

3. Worship of old masters is a drag on the development of new pro­gressive art. We should look forward instead of turning back all the time.

4. The techniques of old masters are hopelessly out of date; nor do they appeal to modern viewers who look for new, daring technical experiments in painting.

In your discussion, you may also make use of this interesting quotation from Romain Rolland.

"There are some excellent people who are nevertheless incapable of appreciating a new work of art before its age reaches at least twenty years. For their weak heads the odour of a new life is too strong, and it must be given time to evaporate. A work of art has an appeal for such people only when it is covered with the dust of time."

When getting ready for the discussion, choose the side you are going to support. By no means should you restrict yourself to the arguments given above: they are just hints which may help you in formulating your own ideas. Provide your arguments with illustrations.

* * *

Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]