Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Процессуальная логика.pdf
Y8
*7 *+ !*3I*+8SI,*+/*#
/28*8./2*8R7U/
*
6/,+/;4!+37 #
3/2!4SI2..*+/**</#
4
*R**!/,.+R**+/*83**
48! SIR*+ 8./+ &8 *3++ R*#
*+/*/2 1.4*2 I3I,0 ! .R/! 4_ 4V
RR3+T+7S+*R!+
1.4*I3I!!4!*+/*!*73+/#
++!4T;!T;4!_*;
+*+/*<//.3*7+U3*+/*8
8!4R/7T+3*+/*!4R/*7T8/+
</ + 7 * R/ T, +U/
\; /R 4* *2! *SI.48
'*3I*7-.48',*7-\;*+/,/#
R! /+*8 /, .4*
7.3'*3I*7- 5R**! *U4#
!/,/R07.3',*7-\
4+3!4/87**/,/R#
7.3'*3I*7-2!343*20
*+/*./*8'8/+-!'83/+-4+*4V#
;.+/++3!4.8*7*7*
)+</!4!%*7U+/R7#
.3 '*3I*7- 4/7* <+ +3! 4
+;TU!7U87*7!SI8
+U+!47V+#+!*.</++#
73*7!48***+/*&*+/*
R3!*U4!8!4!8
7#
` +R3 87b !3,! *V'3#
I*- '*3I*- 4 + *34
./S*8 7/+0;:7*R*
*3I*34U! .4! *3I* 4 4
*)+T34U*3I*8_.4!*3#
1,*,+ '* .4'R7- *+/* *+34#
8!*4.8!8)*4*/,*#
,*T+283+
+8
'*
0 'R7- 44* 'X- *+/*
348! 8 IV ; '*8- R*,
%
7*4!4T+*$
#
*
+!8*SI,/R*7.3
',*7-!'*3I*7-6T+347V+*3I#
*4;32+/2*3I*,!/
+*7.*+!+S*8/47
V+32,*82;4/,.2*3#
I*8,*'2-!4V+T,*
R2*34824 :+ *34 ;'28I,-!
4;'2+/,-!4*8./,*+'2 #
-:3+ *34 4;'28I,-!'2+/,-
\; '-40 4**+*8
*3I*7!S4V/, *333 ,*8!T+3!
4'2-*R8!+/++3!4+*34!, #
*3S*333'28I,;2;2+/,- /#
0,*'2-!*3I*8+ +!.34U
*7,*8'2-!4*3I*8#
U*R8\807; *
R *7/,,*7! 4!4 /, / #
;,*!*78*)8_*!
4!*47.*+!4;,*7U
*+4!7/+!T!R.3*!+
8*.8373/ ++*!*. **+ #
+/,*
<3..70*2,*2+*'#
2-4_4V+.)b.)+!4T+*34
'27-;,*83320!*8!#
I!!*/UJP4T,4.8.#
48+3*+*, ),;2**,!8U,
+4**8#,*$S4 #
,*+!4+++*34 #
_4+ + +'/*-J *P!*/#
7*8 +2 3,** : *#3,
40 4*3 ,*+ '2-!
*UR *+!R_+T+34
'2*8- ; *3I*3+## 6T+3 ' #
2- 3 #3, ; ,* 83 32! /
,*7#*UU34!+SI#
*84_T;*R,*!7*3#
34
Y8
]8+4377U!4R/37 3S *3!
/SI3S*8*T,4.8 ^***37*33R#
4**7*.#+4**!
8*!4,**3374JS#
IP! J,*8P (4* T 40,*
.+ R. R2 *_ R */
.+/3R.3R.8,*8+3+
68T! +/,+V+! 4+34*+ .U+TS)
*31,*,1*1*34 R{5Rz!3U*#
4*7+++,*8#
8R/8J%.P+3++*3/.*7
*3I*! + R/7 *3 .*+
+04* R.34/,*4.8)**37#
,! *7 U3SI,8 *+* *.#
8/ R{5Rz
:V+*8 *3 #3, < 37! 4'U47!47!*/,/4/++ 373/+
+! .*+ 8 R*+ 8./+ R3 *#
4/7 * 7+3*+/*+33!
#.*! /R8'*3I*- 4*4
R3SIR*,.48& *373/#
*/S7/,/R;/R7.3',*#
7-*SI.48! *R34
+3 3! #3,* $R48 .+/_R
+U/*+/*8+/++.3*7*V+*.&+
R/48;7+3!4T/4*1#
+373/++\33733S/43#
4#'R7-!4#7!4R/S4*77#
8 +U *+/*8 : + *34! U+
+*3)+8 *!+ '+- /*3#
+/*+!)S!8.34URa#
8*8*!/48+:32 *34827#
8+U*+/*8+R/7.3I4+#+#
3+&30*!.+*77#
Ra8*8.!,*V*848*.4
57/,37*+/*8!7/,**R*+/*#
8; '+**,-! *R 'U-! +
R/7/ U+*R*+*.3, *; #
, + . .+/2 **R *+/*8! /+
B %
U*./!373/R4**#
! /*8 *R8 * 8 #
*78U*.8*,**+,373/2
&4+3+/+'+U*+/*8-!'**R
*+/*8- +3 R/2 I2b :7 47 R3
4V+# 47 *+ ; .4 *!4!*.
R*2* * + )%) `3* ; *+7
*7/R7*+28I.4t84!#
*8!7b
* R/ *8 *8 4*7+T+*+!
T+*347+R/ *+/*07+/!+
+!47+,.)7/2,*3#
1.+&+!4T+++/3!
!.++!3*,4U*8*7./++!
4R//R7',*-!'*3I*-!4**#
SI.48:74*R*!
U7/!3+!R*S4/*/_
1! 4 ; *U7 4t;.4
',*7-..4+'+/*7-!+7#47
*+Ra8* 778_T,#
.*, 1+3! +! 4 . R/ .4
U7..+/2'+/*S-&!*,.*#
+ ,*8 1*18 . *R8T+ *0 DEFGHE
KLFEMNO;37/,+7,* #
).+!+1* 4*, *3Ra*!R3SI, *R8!
7*R8!4*+1*'+/*S→*3I#
*3S-;T4***+/*3+.S48J#
1+3; *.+P!**+/*4 #
**+/*8 T'4*7-*7*+S
,*, 373t : 4+3 +/ V+ 47 373/2
2 '+U *+/*8-0 3*,4/
'*/8-373/.+Ra8*74
64+3,*,+/*7S .+4! 4*U#
4 8 .8! R3I *R+/! V/
U*.,*+373/++b5+!
4'+/*S! .4 ;,*3S- 437 +!4+
'+/*S!.4;*3I*3S-b
4V+',*7-;.8)/2#
, 3 5*8! .4! ',*7- )3*8 *3R#
Y8
*)^*',*7-! 4'+/*7-!;T *3R#
*)!+R/7+!4a++.*3Ra
<3+./*+*;!
4+R/7a8*3Ra4*/*8+3
]4!,37.*3I*9,*!37,#
*8!R3*8!#/2!+I,),373/2#
!*/2**+*',*7-4*#
3 *3R*)_! #/2!*R*/+! *.7!
*+*++,4#!4*8*+#
8 *3*3*3Ra68_*+*8R#
+
c8 U* ! + 4* 53*
#%w.xz! 3./ ! *V * +!
.4'**-.4'+/*7-4+R/7.4
. 4*!# 4 ; +*34 3V+
1*!; *3.7*R*.*+! *8#
+*34!*,4.8!8*.*7*3
*+T*!83R!7 #
+!*2RV*3*7!
4# R)/3+8! 3S.S* .3#
+/8*7+8S \+*+.*8 %3**7! 48
4*+8*7/74*/*33/*.8!.87
*R *V! 4 **8 **3S 3*3! ,
4*/ *+/*/ *.8_ 1+8*2*4!4
VT+33
&*+*7R/8!/8.#
*+ MNO ; '. *+7-!
*7/+ R.+
++3 3.+3'I +/*8I,- 'I8V#
,-!R/8*3Ra R/8 Ra! +33.+3!
*/+,*8*+*81*18R.3*U#
**8*2R.*8,/R3:7T
3.+.4*.'X-+!/,.+
R72,*,/,37*8.47,
'/*-R/8!*8*,'R/'*- :*VTU,. .I *+3!* 4+/
4!;3*+,R+4*.7*#
48U+**'X-T+!***3SI,
*4*7ST.*8R/*.8!V#
*7S**3S3*3
%
&8**,4*T8*40
.32 R*87*!R3SI2 /R3,*8 .#
*3I*9,*! *++ 88*8
#
/+ ! ./* !
4+37*8*3DEFGHE83*DEFGHE+DEFGHE
*+!*73SR*+3R/R/ DEFGHE_4
+3783*T+*+/+ DEFGHE4V++#
*77,U.1*1b 40MNO!
'.*+7- &U#**V*80 4+3 '8,*3S-b
64+3 *+*7 DEFGHE!3.4 SR3S
87*7*.8RI!.4 *+*7*3I*#
8! ,*8b:7+4! 4*. , #
*3!4SR8+8+/*7!!I3I;T
/*.8:'**3,1*1-#
4*8"!!**8SI DEFGHE!*8,.
0.4!8*3I*3S&'8,*3S-7t:7
*DEFGHE*++# .404R/,*7!
R/7_ 4R/R/7!,*7: *++!*3I #
*'X-R*DEFGHE!,*8+0!R#
! *8! +/U & ,*7 + 7 *3#
I*3SI :.+8 R**7*3I*8 ,*8
4/:7 *3I* DEFGHE!a++
_*73DEFGHE;T,*J74!4*#
.,*3!_%3**7R#
)7**.8P!.4!,*a++*3I#
*8!*3I*;,*8 ',*7'*3I*7-;.t$R.3S!+/!.#
3!,+*377.323,!.3#
*7 +U3 *+/*8+3. .+/2#
!*3R',*7-!R'*3I*7-\
37.8*+*7_27.873t
68*SI8 *+*+*7##/*7 3
&!.++0*+*+*7 #+ 3,!2!#
/23/*/*3Ra#/*3)_a+#
+*7 3 3 ; IV.3/2! +3,!
,'4-!IV .U*7 .48',*#
7- '*3I*7- R3S 33S 3
3
Y8
Cogito как целостность
6/+!*.+*8,*81#
*18! /R 7.3'*3I*7-! ',*7-
$R*/T/R!*484/+&4IV
*!!4/R *++ *8#
/R ! * DEFGHE → MNO .4! 4
*+S:740+/!4'*3#
I*7-',*7-! .8/ DEFGHE! *7#
/!SR3S33$ ;%0
*3I*7 .4,*7! ,*7 ; *3I*7!
+/V+ 47 DEFGHE \.V*7a++*7
3**8S4,U3S .3$ + R/
**74,U,*,1*1!*R/R/.+#
4/&.+4*74,*,1*1;
.7/,1!+1
\; 0*8+!4DEFGHEKLFEMNO;
T*.+4**!!#
*!3!4 KLFE .*7 /4#
!;*73 4**+3S
1+3!1+3*3Ra#,*3)$*V
+! 4 '- .4 ; )* *V3
6)/+2.+/.4S*V3*7!.#
4S7+.32.+/23, ;R3
*3I*8!R3,*8]4!,#
+7*V3*7!7)**7^7#
.8,.46T+3*KLFEMNO;)
UR4 :/R8 .4 '*3I*-! .3U
3S )**7 *3I*8##,*8
.4/,/R7.3*3I*8
+ T 4 * MNO '. *+7- ; *3Ra
&*3Ra+ R/7 /+!* R3
Ra8 /+ :7 '4*/,*3Ra- ; *V '4'-!.4!*3Ra#8*,!*3Ra*+
*R`*/,*3Ra!4*R/!4R8S#
I *3Ra*!;*S+ .R7*3Ra* +
7+ **R+ ; /3)**7! , *3I#
* ,* * 7/+ V/+ 3
3 .48+_ * /+! R3S *3Ra*!
%
R3S.V3* **88 Y/*84*)
1*1*2*4, +3!4+3 '*3I*- ;
+.47R/*3I*!/#
ST.U+.3 ,*, 1*10 7.8
347*3Ra*7!.R8*\;.!
R,_+/3+!88*8&*34,/'(#
6#88-!483!8!4'8*7-.4;
'8 *7 *3I*3SI,-0 1+3 '?J*8.7Py- . *S
#
4,!.+ +7 *3Ra!+8 +
*3I*8*8*8.7*3Ra;3,*!
!.* **R *+/*8Y+!
. '*3I*9,*- /RS 37 *3I*#
8!T1+3R'?*7y-
]1*3+//!/++/U
+*!*7!1*#
*7.+/+/33U+*R#
*+'X-(SR DEFGHE! SR,*.8!R3#
.7'X-4/+!*3I*3SI+!+*+/+;,*3SI+
R0SR DEFGHE ; ,*!4R/,*7!'X 4*7! *3I*7 \ *7*7 ;
*_ *3I* ,* R3*S 3
3$*;*/*+2*R833!4
7.873
3I*##,*/ +U+ *.+
U*.\.*8**47!4'X-+/0
'X-*3I*3##,*3!+*3I*3##,*3 3I#
*3+)+!,*3R*)7/,!*3R*)7
U 'X-! +/ * 2+ + 'X- +/!
.+88*7!+8+*8*S.7!+!*8*7+!*V
+8; ,,*! a++ *3I*8! +
+8+'X-
\8+)+!8,I+3Ra#
*7)3*87+)+!3SI7
V+Y4!+3U+*+88S*8
'3R*/,! * ! +! 8 #
S0 122!! 388*84* *3R*/+!
+34 T+ *+ *8*8*+/, RI,. R3; 3
R!.4!3!!-f5!&7==0g
Y8 =
I!4+/*+!R334++*;3+!
*R8./*+.+'4-!./*8.+#
8SI+*8 '- '* *)-! *8I*8. .! #
+3'*-!4R3'V/+-'/+-!#
;'3I+*8-!'3/+-!*8*7'*)+-
B</**R/ *V+*. 37*R**#
._T .4!4 +/**R/ *7*8 3 DEFGHE
:DEFGHE 4. DEFGHE U+ *.+ + *)*#
*7_+/++!+++/*+V+;*3Ra#
/+ *3)8+ 3Ra#/ *3)
.4S)**7!+3.SV&U#
+ J! 4 7U ./ '43* *8-P!
U8./U*3*R47*3Ra#
*38
3Ra#*3;*,'4-'#
-</!*8*7+!*V+8/,++;3#
&U'X-**/*8 +*'8-0 *88;34!
.;347_ *,4*88T;2U,!8;
#
2,!87;R..4X*V+8',#-!*#
; *+/,'X-,*3Ra**!
'4-'- ./*8 .*7!T+ a+++ *
I3IU,**\I3I ; *#
.!+*3*3SI+.*_SR,
U,**28*8U*7
\3)8*3Ra#*8!.+*
*27'4-!R*4+88'-!8*.4#
`4**.\**R*7; *8!
.V .+*7 7 + **+3 I,! 7.7*8
8./+! *7.7*:*8+_8./_ 4#
*+/U;*/238!R*!37#
*.8! 34U . 3 **R* *3Ra#
*8 R8, $RI* *.!
373/!/*S**+/!T!#
!*.SI .+*7RI*, .! *S4#
7!.8SI.U2.+*7373/
& ** T **R*7 *3Ra#
*8
[**7!8+U *. 87#
*!DEFGHE!*8*R,*V3*7</3++.#
B %
47V7*3Ra#*38!
* *3Ra#, *,! 3)8 ,
+U+'X98- +!U'X98-!8* #
SI, 1 U! 44* *.80 +/ **R#
/.37 *+/* 8+ *3Ra#
*8
[**7! .88 DEFGHE! T )**7 *3I*#
8##,*8 [**7!4, *3
.3+! *3 3*+4,3!
+R/783:*V*.3 *V+*3Ra#
*3 3.T3 )**7 DEFGHE +
*+/*!4RV3!73!*3)**!*3I#
*R,*!*3*+/*8&U*.#
+ .3*3I*9,*!*3#
837*3Ra#*38
=
[**7 /*37*3Ra#8 *8. #
*7&U*.*8.*73! *73 **R R #
7 * *3Ra#/+ *,+! * '4- '-
&,8.3 *3I*9,*!*. 8
)**7!*73)**7*7DEFGHE;*R*8
87*7:.84*!SR37*.
**R7*8SR+3.323,*3Ra#
*8! ./2 ., *3I*9,* :.8
,*7*!SR37*.S43
3S**+3373/2R/44*#
*.88./! R/RI*! .4!
**+/373/2373/.8S
7 . .+/2 **R *+/*8 4*
;! +3U*.34*8#
R7USR/2.43,**R*+/*#
8 /*8*8 1S! *)*8 '7#
/,-!'34/,-!'R//,- +3*8
R**.73*8U,*8*.+/,/R
7.3 . .+/2 **R *+/*8!*S#
I,+87*++/R
Y 373 .4 /* *R8 *
3.32.+/2**R*+/*8!.8#
/2*3Ra# *3!8*7 *2#
/,*SI, /RR*3I*8! R,*8