Добавил:
Upload
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:участие адвоката / 38-39.дача объснения
.txt яю0G0 >1JOA=5=89 - A=0G0;0 8AB5F, B@5BL5 ;8F> =0 AB>@>=5 8ABF0, >B25BG8:, B@5BL5 ;8F> =0 AB>@>=5 >B25BG8:0, B@5BL5 ;8F>, 70O2;ONI55 A0<>AB>OB5;L=K5 B@51>20=8O.
48=>;8G=> - A0<.
! :;85=B>< - ;CGH5 :;85=B.
>;6=K 1KBL <0:A8<0;L=> :@0B:8<8 8 N@848G5A:8 5<:8<8. > E>4C >1JOA=5=89 :0640O AB>@>=0 45;05B 70<5B:8 8 2>?@>AK : =8<, GB> =0?><=8BL, GB>1K A:070;, 0 B0:65 4;O ?>A;54CNI59 @01>BK A ?@>B>:>;><.
01>B0 042>:0B0 A> AB>@>=K 8ABF0
>7<>6=>ABL >1@0B8BLAO 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 70 70I8B>9 A2>8E =0@CH5==KE 8;8 >A?0@8205<KE ?@02 ?@8=04;568B 708=B5@5A>20==K< ;8F0<, 0 2 =5:>B>@KE A;CG0OE 8 3>AC40@AB25==K< >@30=0<.
B:07 >B ?@020 =0 >1@0I5=85 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 =5459AB28B5;5=. 01>B0 042>:0B0 2 0@18B@06=>< ?@>F5AA5 @07;8G05BAO 2 7028A8<>AB8 >B B>3>, GL8 8=B5@5AK >= ?@54AB02;O5B.
@54AB02;OO 8=B5@5AK 8ABF0, ?@5645 G5< ?@8ABC?8BL : D>@<C;8@>20=8N 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, ?@>25@O5BAO, 8<55BAO ;8 B@51>20=85 : 40==><C 284C ?@02>>B=>H5=89 ?> 4>AC451=><C ?@5B5=78>==><C ?>@O4:C C@53C;8@>20=8O A?>@>2 ( ?. 5 AB. 4 $) . B5E A;CG0OE, :>340 70:>= ?@54CA<0B@8205B ?@5B5=78>==K9 ?>@O4>: 8;8 B0:>9 ?>@O4>: CAB0=>2;5= 2 4>3>2>@5, 87 :>B>@>3> 2>7=8: A?>@, 042>:0B 8AB@51C5B C :;85=B0 :>?8N ?@5B5=788, 5A;8 >=0 =0?@02;O;0AL @0=55, A 4>:070B5;LAB20<8 55 >B?@02:8 8 ?>;CG5=8O 8;8 >B?@028BL ?@5B5=78N A0<><C. ">340 2 8A:>2>< 1C4CB A>45@60BLAO A2545=8O > A>1;N45=88 4>AC451=>3> ?@5B5=78>==>3> ?>@O4:0 C@53C;8@>20=8O A?>@0 A >B25BG8:><. G5=L 206=K< O2;O5BAO >?@545;5=85 A?>A>10 70I8BK ?@02 :;85=B0, 0 MB> 7=0G8B D>@<C;8@>20=85 ?@54<5B0 8A:0. @54<5B 8A:0 - MB> <0B5@80;L=>- ?@02>2>5 B@51>20=85 8ABF0 : >B25BG8:C. B ?@028;L=>9 D>@<C;8@>2:8 ?@54<5B0 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 2 1>;LH>9 AB5?5=8 7028A8B CA?5E ?@>F5AA0. A>>B25BAB288 A> AB. 4 $ ;8HL 708=B5@5A>20==>5 ;8F> 2?@025 >1@0B8BLAO 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 70 70I8B>9 A2>8E =0@CH5==KE 8;8 >A?0@8205<KE ?@02. >MB><C A=0G0;0 042>:0B >?@545;O5B, 5ABL ;8 C :;85=B0 B> ?@02>, > :>B>@>< >= 2545B @5GL, =0@CH5=> ;8 >=>, G5< ?>4B25@6405BAO 708=B5@5A>20==>ABL :;85=B0 2 45;5. 54L ?@02> =0 8A: - MB> =5 A0<> =0@CH5==>5 AC1J5:B82=>5 ?@02>, 0 2>7<>6=>ABL ?>;CG5=8O AC451=>9 70I8BK 2 >?@545;5==>9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 D>@<5 8 ?>@O4:5. @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 :>45:A >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( $) - >B 2 4 . 0 7 . 2 0 0 2 N 9 5 - $
>OA=8< MB> =0 ?@8<5@5. 1I5AB25==0O >@30=870F8O, A>740=0O D878G5A:8<8 ;8F0<8, ?>;CG82H8<8 2 0@5=4C 75<5;L=K5 CG0AB:8 2 >4<>A:>2L5 8 >1J548=82H8<8AO 4;O 70I8BK A2>8E 75<5;L=KE 8=B5@5A>2, >1@0B8;0AL 2 @18B@06=K9 AC4 >A:>2A:>9 >1;0AB8 A B@51>20=85< > ?@87=0=88 =5459AB28B5;L=K< @5H5=8O 3;02K 04<8=8AB@0F88 >1;0AB8 >1 87JOB88 75<;8, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 MB8E CG0AB:>2, 4;O 3>AC40@AB25==KE =C64. >?CAB8<, 2 ?5@2>9 8 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8=AB0=F8OE 45;> 1K;> 2K83@0=>. 4=0:> :0AA0F8>==0O 8=AB0=F8O 2 8A:5 >B:07K205B, C:07020O 2 A2>5< @5H5=88, GB> ?>A:>;L:C >1I5AB25==0O >@30=870F8O =5 8<55B :0: N@848G5A:>5 ;8F> :0:8E- ;81> ?@02>2KE >A=>20=89 =0 ?>;L7>20=85 75<;59, B> 55 ?@020 =5 1K;8 =0@CH5=K. ;O B>3> GB>1K >?@545;8BLAO A ?@54<5B>< 8A:0, =5>1E>48<> ?@5645 2A53> >1@0B8BLAO : B5:ABC AB. 1 2 $. MB>9 AB0BL5 87;>65=K A?>A>1K 70I8BK 3@0640=A:8E ?@02. C6=> ?>=OBL, :0:>9 87 =8E 871@0BL 2 :>=:@5B=>< 45;5. 5@5G5=L MB8E A?>A>1>2 =5 O2;O5BAO 8AG5@?K20NI8<. -B> >7=0G05B, GB> ?@020 8 70:>==K5 8=B5@5AK <>3CB 70I8I0BLAO 8 8=0G5, => 2 0@18B@06=KE AC40E ?@82K:;8 : >1KG=K< A?>A>10<, ?>MB><C =5 AB>8B 87>1@5B0BL =8G53> A;>6=>3>, 2K18@0O B>B 8;8 8=>9 A?>A>1 70I8BK. '5B:> AD>@<C;8@>20BL ?@54<5B 8A:0 ?><>65B 87CG5=85 @C1@8:0B>@0 8 A0<8E @5H5=89 0@18B@06=KE AC4>2, >?C1;8:>20==KE 2 « 5AB=8:5 KAH53> @18B@06=>3> !C40 >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88»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
@028;L=0O D>@<C;8@>2:0 ?@54<5B0 8 >A=>20=8O 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 ?>72>;O5B 042>:0BC =0?@028BL 45;> 2 =5>1E>48<>5 @CA;>, >?@545;O5B ?@54<5B 8 ?@545;K 4>:07K20=8O ?> 45;C 8 O2;O5BAO >A=>2>9 4;O 2A53> ?>A;54CNI53> 53> @0AA<>B@5=8O. 06=>ABL MB>3> >?@545;O5BAO 5I5 8 B5< >1AB>OB5;LAB2><, GB> 0@18B@06=>- ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 70:>= =5 ?>72>;O5B 2 AC451=>< 70A540=88 87<5=8BL >4=>2@5<5==> 8 ?@54<5B, 8 >A=>20=85 8A:0 ( AB. 4 9 $) . A;8, =0?@8<5@, =5>1E>48<> 2 AC451=>< 70A540=88 70<5=8BL B@51>20=85 > ?@87=0=88 A45;:8 =5459AB28B5;L=>9 B@51>20=85< > @0AB>@65=88 4>3>2>@0 8 ?@825AB8 8=K5 >A=>20=8O @0AB>@65=8O, B> 8<55B <5AB> >4=>2@5<5==>5 87<5=5=85 8 ?@54<5B0, 8 >A=>20=8O 8A:0, GB> =54>?CAB8<>. MB>< A;CG05 @07@5H5=85 2>?@>A0 ?> ACI5AB2C 2 A2O78 A 4>?CI5==>9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 >H81:>9 1C45B 70BO=CB>.
?@>F5AA5 87CG5=8O <0B5@80;>2 45;0 8 ?>43>B>2:8 8A:0 C 042>:0B0 =0G8=05B D>@<8@>20BLAO ?>78F8O, >?@545;5=85 :>B>@>9 O2;O5BAO >A=>2>9 4;O 2A5E ?>A;54CNI8E @5H5=89.
>78F8O ?> 45;C - MB> 2K@01>B0==>5 042>:0B>< 3;02=>5 =0?@02;5=85 4>AB865=8O ?>AB02;5==>9 F5;8, 2:;NG0NI55 >?@545;5=85 AC1J5:B=>3> A>AB020 ;8F, CG0AB2CNI8E 2 45;5, D>@<C;8@>20=85 ?@54<5B0 8 >A=>20=89 8A:0, ?@545;>2 4>:07K20=8O, B> 5ABL D0:B8G5A:>5 8 N@848G5A:>5 >1>A=>20=85 B>3>, GB> 8 :0: =C6=> 70I8I0BL.
42>:0B ?@8 2K@01>B:5 ?>78F88 ?> 45;C @C:>2>4AB2C5BAO B>;L:> 8=B5@5A0<8 A2>53> 4>25@8B5;O. @8 ?>43>B>2:5 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, 5A;8 2 45;5 =5A:>;L:> >B25BG8:>2, =C6=> ?><=8BL, GB> 8A:>2K5 B@51>20=8O 4>;6=K 1KBL 87;>65=K : :064><C 87 =8E. @8G5< D>@<C;8@>20BL 8E A;54C5B B0:, GB>1K 2 A;CG05 2K83@KH0 45;0 @5H5=85 <>6=> 1K;> 8A?>;=8BL. 0?@8<5@, >H81>G=> D>@<C;8@>20BL 8A: >1 8AB@51>20=88 87 GC6>3> =570:>==>3> 2;045=8O 8<CI5AB20, :>340 C >B25BG8:0 >=> >BACBAB2C5B. 5H5=85 ?> B0:><C 8A:C ?@8 53> 2K83@KH5 =5;L7O 8A?>;=8BL. ;8, ?@87=020O =5459AB28B5;L=K< 4>3>2>@ :C?;8- ?@>4068 0:F89, A;54C5B A@07C 65 AD>@<C;8@>20BL B@51>20=85 > 2>AAB0=>2;5=88 8ABF0 2 @55AB@5 0:F8>=5@>2. A;8 >3@0=8G8BLAO B>;L:> ?5@2K< B@51>20=85<, B> A<KA; ?@>F5AA0 1C45B CB@0G5=, ?>A:>;L:C A0<> ?> A515 ?@87=0=85 4>3>2>@0 :C?;8- ?@>4068 0:F89 =8GB>6=K< 157 ?@8<5=5=8O ?>A;54AB289 =5459AB28B5;L=>AB8 A45;:8 4;O 8ABF0 15A?>;57=>. K18@0O A?>A>1 70I8BK =0@CH5==>3> ?@020, 042>:0B 2KOA=O5B, CAB0=>2;5= ;8 70:>=>40B5;LAB2>< ?>@O4>: 8A?>;=5=8O 70O2;5==KE B@51>20=89. "0:, =0?@8<5@, 2 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 8A:>2>3> B@51>20=8O >1 >1O70=88 10=:0 8A?>;=8BL ?;0B56=>5 ?>@CG5=85 8 ?5@5G8A;8BL >?@545;5==K5 45=56=K5 A@54AB20 ?> =5<C, B> 5ABL 8A?>;=8BL >1O70B5;LAB2> 2 =0BC@5, 1K;> >B:070=>, ?>A:>;L:C, :0: C:070; @57848C< KAH53> @18B@06=>3> !C40 $, 8AB5F 2K1@0; =5=04;560I89 A?>A>1 70I8BK A2>53> =0@CH5==>3> ?@020, 8A?>;=5=85 :>B>@>3> =5 ?@54CA<>B@5=> 70:>=>< « 1 8A?>;=8B5;L=>< ?@>872>4AB25» 8;8 8=K<8 ?@02>2K<8 0:B0<8 $.
@8 D>@<C;8@>20=88 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 042>:0B CAB0=02;8205B, :B> 1C45B >B25BG8:><, :B> - B@5BL8< ;8F>< 8 =0 GL59 AB>@>=5, =5 1C4CB ;8 70B@>=CBK AC451=K< @5H5=85< 5I5 GL8- ;81> 8=B5@5AK. ">340 8 MB> ;8F> 4>;6=> 1KBL ?@82;5G5=> : CG0AB8N 2 ?@>F5AA5 C65 2 AC45 ?5@2>9 8=AB0=F88, GB>1K C 2KH5AB>OI8E AC4>2 =5 1K;> >A=>20=8O 4;O >B<5=K AC451=>3> @5H5=8O ?> MB><C >A=>20=8N.
1> 2A5< MB>< ;CGH5 ?>701>B8BLAO 70@0=55, A<>45;8@>20BL 2>7<>6=K5 A8BC0F88, BI0B5;L=K< >1@07>< 2725A8BL 2A5 0@3C<5=BK 8 >?@545;8BL ?5@A?5:B82K ?@>E>645=8O 45;0 2 0@18B@06=>< AC45, > G5< :;85=B 2A5340 C254><;O5BAO 42>:0BA:0O 45OB5;L=>ABL 8 042>:0BC@0 2 >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( 042>:0BA:>5 ?@02>) . . . !<>;5=A:89 - 8740B5;LAB2> « $5=8:A» : . 2 0 0 7 3. 5?>A@54AB25==K5 B@51>20=8O : D>@<5 8 A>45@60=8N 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O 87;>65=K 2 AB. 1 2 5 $, @0AA<>B@8< B>;L:> =5:>B>@K5 ?@0:B8G5A:85 >A>15==>AB8 ?>40G8 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 8A:0, ?>A:>;L:C B5E=>;>38G5A:8 MB>B ?@>F5AA 4>AB0B>G=> A;>65=, B0: :0: A>45@68B <=>3> D>@<0;L=KE B@51>20=89, =52K?>;=5=85 :>B>@KE 2;5G5B >AB02;5=85 8A:0 157 42865=8O 4;O 8A?@02;5=8O =54>AB0B:>2 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O.
1@0B8< 2=8<0=85 ;8HL =0 =5A:>;L:> 0A?5:B>2 B5E=8G5A:>9 ?>43>B>2:8 : 45;C.
5@2K9 - MB> =5>1E>48<>ABL G5B:>3> >1>7=0G5=8O ?>;=><>G89 ;8F0, ?>4?8A02H53> 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85, 5A;8 MB> =5 35=5@0;L=K9 48@5:B>@ ?@54?@8OB8O, :>B>@K9 <>65B 459AB2>20BL 157 4>25@5==>AB8. I5 @07 =0?><=8<, GB> =5:>B>@K5 ?>;=><>G8O 8<5NB 8A:;NG8B5;L=K9 E0@0:B5@ 8 4>;6=K 1KBL >3>2>@5=K 2 4>25@5==>AB8 >A>1> ( ?. 2 AB. 6 2 $) . ;N1>< A;CG05, 1C4L B> ;8F>, 459AB2CNI55 ?> 4>25@5==>AB8, 4>25@8B5;L=K9 C?@02;ONI89, 0@18B@06=K9 C?@02;ONI89 8;8 ;N1K5 8=K5 ?>4?8A02H85 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85 ;8F0, 8E ?>;=><>G85 =0 B0:>5 N@848G5A:8 7=0G8<>5 459AB285 4>;6=> 1KBL 87;>65=> 2 ?@8;0305<KE : 8A:>2><C 70O2;5=8N 4>:C<5=B0E B>G=> 8 =542CA<KA;5==>. B>@>9 - MB> =5>1E>48<>ABL G5B:>3> >1>7=0G5=8O 04@5A0 >B25BG8:0, ?> :>B>@><C =04;568B >B?@02;OBL 4>:C<5=B0F8N, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 AC451=K5 C254><;5=8O. @0:B8:0 A2845B5;LAB2C5B, GB> <=>385 ?@54?@8OB8O =5 =0E>4OBAO ?> 70O2;5==K< 04@5A0< 8 ?>GB>2K5 >B?@02;5=8O 2>72@0I0NBAO A C254><;5=85< >1 >BACBAB288 C:070==>3> ;8F0, 0 MB> 2;5G5B 70BO3820=85 ?@>F5AA0 8;8 <>65B O28BLAO ?@54?>AK;:>9 : ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 >H81:5. 0: 8725AB=>, 0@18B@06=>- ?@>F5AAC0;L=>5 70:>=>40B5;LAB2> =5 ?>72>;O5B @0AA<0B@820BL 45;0 ?@8 =5=04;560I5< C254><;5=88 CG0AB2CNI8E 2 45;5 ;8F. "@5B89 0A?5:B A2O70= A >?;0B>9 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K' . 5?@028;L=0O 55 >?;0B0 - MB> G0AB>5 O2;5=85 A@548 =5:20;8D8F8@>20==KE ?@54AB028B5;59. 5:><5=4C5< >1@0I0BL 2=8<0=85 =0 A;54CNI85 <><5=BK:
" 4>;6=> >?;0G820BLAO :064>5 8A:>2>5 B@51>20=85. A;8 8<55BAO 8<CI5AB25==>5 B@51>20=85, MB> >4=0 AC<<0 ?>H;8=K, 5A;8 =58<CI5AB25==>5 - 4@C30O, 8 ;CGH5 >D>@<;OBL 8E >B45;L=K<8 ?;0B56=K<8 4>:C<5=B0<8, :>340, =0?@8<5@, 420 B@51>20=8O >1J548=5=K 2 >4=>< 8A:5;
" >1O70B5;L=> =C6=> ?@>25@OBL <0B5<0B8G5A:CN ?@028;L=>ABL @0AG5B>2;
" =5>1E>48<> >G5=L B>G=> >D>@<;OBL ?;0B56=K5 4>:C<5=BK. 0?@8<5@, 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85 1K;> 2>72@0I5=>, :>340 =0 :28B0=F88 >1 C?;0B5 3>A?>H;8=K, >D>@<;5==>9 G5@57 !15@530B5;L=K9 10=:, >BACBAB2>20;0 ?>4?8AL :0AA8@0 8;8 2 :28B0=F88 >H81>G=> 1K;> C:070=>: « @0745; 2 » , 0 =04> 1K;>: « @0745; I I » ;
" : 8A:>2><C 70O2;5=8N 4>;65= ?@8:;04K20BLAO ?>4;8==8:, 0 =5 :>?8O ?;0B56=>3> 4>:C<5=B0 >1 >?;0B5 ?>H;8=K. "@5CH=8:>20 . . @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AA. - 740B5;LAB2>: « >@>45F» 2 0 0 7 3.
>H;8=0 <>65B 1KBL C?;0G5=0 :0: =5?>A@54AB25==> A0<8< 70O28B5;5<, B0: 8 ;N1K< 8=K< ;8F>< 70 =53>, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 =0;8G=K<8 45=L30<8 G5@57 10=:. >340 :;85=B AB5A=5= 2 A@54AB20E, 042>:0B E>40B09AB2C5B ?5@54 0@18B@06=K< AC4>< >1 >BA@>G:5, @0AA@>G:5 8;8 C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0. BA@>G:0 8;8 @0AA@>G:0 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, C<5=LH5=85 55 @07<5@0 ?@>872>4OBAO ?> ?8AL<5==><C E>40B09AB2C 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K. %>40B09AB2> <>65B 1KBL 87;>65=> 2 8A:>2>< 70O2;5=88, 2 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8;8 :0AA0F8>==>9 60;>15 ;81> 2 >B45;L=>< 70O2;5=88, ?@8;>65==>< : A>>B25BAB2CNI5<C 70O2;5=8N ( 60;>15) .
E>40B09AB25 ?@82>4OBAO A>>B25BAB2CNI85 >1>A=>20=8O A ?@8;>65=85< 4>:C<5=B>2, A2845B5;LAB2CNI8E > B><, GB> 8<CI5AB25==>5 ?>;>65=85 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K =5 ?>72>;O5B 59 C?;0B8BL 3>AC40@AB25==CN ?>H;8=C 2 CAB0=>2;5==>< @07<5@5 ?@8 ?>40G5 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8;8 :0AA0F8>==>9 60;>1K.
4>:C<5=B0<, CAB0=02;820NI8< 8<CI5AB25==>5 ?>;>65=85 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K, >B=>AOBAO:
" ?>4B25@645==K9 =0;>3>2K< >@30=>< ?5@5G5=L @0AG5B=KE 8 8=KE AG5B>2;
" =08<5=>20=8O 8 04@5A0 10=:>2 8 4@C38E :@548B=KE CG@5645=89, 2 :>B>@KE MB8 AG5B0 >B:@KBK, 2:;NG0O AG5B0 D8;80;>2 8 ?@54AB028B5;LAB2 N@848G5A:>3> ;8F0;
" ?>4B25@645==K5 10=:>< 40==K5 >1 >BACBAB288 =0 A>>B25BAB2CNI5< AG5B5 8;8 AG5B0E, 5A;8 8E =5A:>;L:>, 45=56=KE A@54AB2 2 @07<5@5,
" =5>1E>48<>< 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, 0 B0:65 >1 >1I59 AC<<5 704>;65==>AB8 2;045;LF0 AG5B0 ?> 8A?>;=8B5;L=K< ;8AB0< 8 ?;0B56=K< 4>:C<5=B0<.
E>40B09AB2C >1 C<5=LH5=88 @07<5@0 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K ?@8;030NBAO 4>:C<5=BK > =0E>4OI8EAO =0 AG5B5 45=56=KE A@54AB20E. @54AB02;5=85 4>:C<5=B>2, ?>4B25@640NI8E >1@0I5=85 70O28B5;O : 10=:0< 8 8=K< >@30=870F8O< 70 ?>;CG5=85< 705<=KE A@54AB2, 0 B0:65 A2845B5;LAB2CNI8E >1 >BACBAB288 C =53> ;8:284=>3> 8<CI5AB20, 70 AG5B @50;870F88 :>B>@>3> <>3;0 1KBL ?>;CG5=0 45=56=0O AC<<0, =5>1E>48<0O 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, =5 B@51C5BAO.
%>40B09AB2> >1 >BA@>G:5 8;8 @0AA@>G:5 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0 <>65B 1KBL C4>2;5B2>@5=> 0@18B@06=K< AC4>< B>;L:> 2 B5E A;CG0OE, :>340 ?@54AB02;5==K5 4>:C<5=BK A2845B5;LAB2CNB >1 >BACBAB288 =0 10=:>2A:8E AG5B0E 45=56=KE A@54AB2 2 @07<5@5, =5>1E>48<>< 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K. @8 >BACBAB288 B0:8E 4>:C<5=B>2 2 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 E>40B09AB20 1C45B >B:070=>.
@18B@06=K9 AC4 =5 <>65B ?> A2>5<C CA<>B@5=8N >B:07K20BL 2 >BA@>G:5 8;8 @0AA@>G:5 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K 8 C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0, 5A;8 8<5NBAO >1J5:B82=K5 >A=>20=8O 4;O C4>2;5B2>@5=8O E>40B09AB20. @8 C25;8G5=88 @07<5@0 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 3>AC40@AB25==0O ?>H;8=0 C?;0G8205BAO 2 A>>B25BAB288 A C25;8G5==>9 F5=>9 8A:0. >MB><C : 70O2;5=8N >1 C25;8G5=88 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 4>;65= 1KBL ?@8;>65= 4>:C<5=B, ?>4B25@640NI89 >?;0BC ?>H;8=K 2 C25;8G5==KE @07<5@0E. 5>1E>48<> ?@>4C<0BL 2>?@>A 8 > <5@0E ?> >15A?5G5=8N 8A:0, =0?8A02 >1 MB>< A>>B25BAB2CNI55 70O2;5=85. "0:>5 70O2;5=85 4>;6=> 1KBL >1>A=>20==K< 8 87;030BLAO A CG5B>< :>=:@5B=KE >1AB>OB5;LAB2 45;0, :>340 2 MB>< 5ABL =5>1E>48<>ABL. 70O2;5=88 042>:0B 2 C1548B5;L=>9 D>@<5 AB0@05BAO 4>:070BL, GB> =5?@8=OB85 ?>4>1=KE <5@ A45;05B =52>7<>6=K< @50;870F8N <0B5@80;L=>- ?@02>2KE B@51>20=89 : >B25BG8:C. 5@K 4>;6=K 8A?@0H820BLAO >AB>@>6=>, A>@07<5@=> 70O2;5==K< B@51>20=8O<, A CG5B>< B>3>, GB> 2 A;CG05 ?@8G8=5=8O 8E ?@8=OB85< C1KB:>2 >B25BG8:C 8AB5F ?@8 ?@>83@KH5 45;0 1C45B >1O70= 8E 2>7<5AB8BL. >15A?5G8B5;L=KE <5@0E =5 <>65B 1KBL >B:070=>, 5A;8 ;8F>, E>40B09AB2CNI55 >1 >15A?5G5=88 8A:0, ?@54AB028;> 2AB@5G=>5 >15A?5G5=85. "@5CH=8:>20 . . @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AA. - 740B5;LAB2>: « >@>45F» 2 0 0 7 3.
?@>F5AA5 ?>43>B>2:8 8A:>2KE <0B5@80;>2 042>:0B ?@>4C<K205B 2>?@>A 8 > 27KA:0=88 @0AE>4>2, ?>=5A5==KE :;85=B>< =0 >?;0BC 53> CA;C3, A ?@>83@02H59 AB>@>=K. G. 2 AB. 1 1 0 $ ?@54CA<>B@5=0 B0:0O 2>7<>6=>ABL: @0AE>4K =0 >?;0BC CA;C3 ?@54AB028B5;O, ?>=5A5==K5 ;8F><, 2 ?>;L7C :>B>@>3> 1K; ?@8=OB AC451=K9 0:B, 27KA:820NBAO A 4@C3>3> ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI53> 2 45;5 2 @07C<=KE ?@545;0E. >=OB85 « @07C<=K5 ?@545;K»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« @07C<=>AB8» 27KA:0=8O A ?@>83@02H59 AB>@>=K @0AE>4>2 =0 >?;0BC CA;C3 042>:0B0. @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 :>45:A >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( $) - >B 2 4 . 0 7 . 2 0 0 2 N 9 5 - $
>43>B>2:0 8 2545=85 45;0 2 0@18B@06=>< AC45 - ?@>F5AA 4;8B5;L=K9, A>?@O65==K9 A =0?8A0=85< 042>:0B>< 1>;LH>3> :>;8G5AB20 4>:C<5=B>2 8 =5>1E>48<>ABLN >BA;56820=8O 8 2K45@6820=8O ?@>F5AAC0;L=KE A@>:>2.
48=>;8G=> - A0<.
! :;85=B>< - ;CGH5 :;85=B.
>;6=K 1KBL <0:A8<0;L=> :@0B:8<8 8 N@848G5A:8 5<:8<8. > E>4C >1JOA=5=89 :0640O AB>@>=0 45;05B 70<5B:8 8 2>?@>AK : =8<, GB> =0?><=8BL, GB>1K A:070;, 0 B0:65 4;O ?>A;54CNI59 @01>BK A ?@>B>:>;><.
01>B0 042>:0B0 A> AB>@>=K 8ABF0
>7<>6=>ABL >1@0B8BLAO 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 70 70I8B>9 A2>8E =0@CH5==KE 8;8 >A?0@8205<KE ?@02 ?@8=04;568B 708=B5@5A>20==K< ;8F0<, 0 2 =5:>B>@KE A;CG0OE 8 3>AC40@AB25==K< >@30=0<.
B:07 >B ?@020 =0 >1@0I5=85 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 =5459AB28B5;5=. 01>B0 042>:0B0 2 0@18B@06=>< ?@>F5AA5 @07;8G05BAO 2 7028A8<>AB8 >B B>3>, GL8 8=B5@5AK >= ?@54AB02;O5B.
@54AB02;OO 8=B5@5AK 8ABF0, ?@5645 G5< ?@8ABC?8BL : D>@<C;8@>20=8N 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, ?@>25@O5BAO, 8<55BAO ;8 B@51>20=85 : 40==><C 284C ?@02>>B=>H5=89 ?> 4>AC451=><C ?@5B5=78>==><C ?>@O4:C C@53C;8@>20=8O A?>@>2 ( ?. 5 AB. 4 $) . B5E A;CG0OE, :>340 70:>= ?@54CA<0B@8205B ?@5B5=78>==K9 ?>@O4>: 8;8 B0:>9 ?>@O4>: CAB0=>2;5= 2 4>3>2>@5, 87 :>B>@>3> 2>7=8: A?>@, 042>:0B 8AB@51C5B C :;85=B0 :>?8N ?@5B5=788, 5A;8 >=0 =0?@02;O;0AL @0=55, A 4>:070B5;LAB20<8 55 >B?@02:8 8 ?>;CG5=8O 8;8 >B?@028BL ?@5B5=78N A0<><C. ">340 2 8A:>2>< 1C4CB A>45@60BLAO A2545=8O > A>1;N45=88 4>AC451=>3> ?@5B5=78>==>3> ?>@O4:0 C@53C;8@>20=8O A?>@0 A >B25BG8:><. G5=L 206=K< O2;O5BAO >?@545;5=85 A?>A>10 70I8BK ?@02 :;85=B0, 0 MB> 7=0G8B D>@<C;8@>20=85 ?@54<5B0 8A:0. @54<5B 8A:0 - MB> <0B5@80;L=>- ?@02>2>5 B@51>20=85 8ABF0 : >B25BG8:C. B ?@028;L=>9 D>@<C;8@>2:8 ?@54<5B0 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 2 1>;LH>9 AB5?5=8 7028A8B CA?5E ?@>F5AA0. A>>B25BAB288 A> AB. 4 $ ;8HL 708=B5@5A>20==>5 ;8F> 2?@025 >1@0B8BLAO 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 70 70I8B>9 A2>8E =0@CH5==KE 8;8 >A?0@8205<KE ?@02. >MB><C A=0G0;0 042>:0B >?@545;O5B, 5ABL ;8 C :;85=B0 B> ?@02>, > :>B>@>< >= 2545B @5GL, =0@CH5=> ;8 >=>, G5< ?>4B25@6405BAO 708=B5@5A>20==>ABL :;85=B0 2 45;5. 54L ?@02> =0 8A: - MB> =5 A0<> =0@CH5==>5 AC1J5:B82=>5 ?@02>, 0 2>7<>6=>ABL ?>;CG5=8O AC451=>9 70I8BK 2 >?@545;5==>9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 D>@<5 8 ?>@O4:5. @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 :>45:A >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( $) - >B 2 4 . 0 7 . 2 0 0 2 N 9 5 - $
>OA=8< MB> =0 ?@8<5@5. 1I5AB25==0O >@30=870F8O, A>740=0O D878G5A:8<8 ;8F0<8, ?>;CG82H8<8 2 0@5=4C 75<5;L=K5 CG0AB:8 2 >4<>A:>2L5 8 >1J548=82H8<8AO 4;O 70I8BK A2>8E 75<5;L=KE 8=B5@5A>2, >1@0B8;0AL 2 @18B@06=K9 AC4 >A:>2A:>9 >1;0AB8 A B@51>20=85< > ?@87=0=88 =5459AB28B5;L=K< @5H5=8O 3;02K 04<8=8AB@0F88 >1;0AB8 >1 87JOB88 75<;8, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 MB8E CG0AB:>2, 4;O 3>AC40@AB25==KE =C64. >?CAB8<, 2 ?5@2>9 8 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8=AB0=F8OE 45;> 1K;> 2K83@0=>. 4=0:> :0AA0F8>==0O 8=AB0=F8O 2 8A:5 >B:07K205B, C:07020O 2 A2>5< @5H5=88, GB> ?>A:>;L:C >1I5AB25==0O >@30=870F8O =5 8<55B :0: N@848G5A:>5 ;8F> :0:8E- ;81> ?@02>2KE >A=>20=89 =0 ?>;L7>20=85 75<;59, B> 55 ?@020 =5 1K;8 =0@CH5=K. ;O B>3> GB>1K >?@545;8BLAO A ?@54<5B>< 8A:0, =5>1E>48<> ?@5645 2A53> >1@0B8BLAO : B5:ABC AB. 1 2 $. MB>9 AB0BL5 87;>65=K A?>A>1K 70I8BK 3@0640=A:8E ?@02. C6=> ?>=OBL, :0:>9 87 =8E 871@0BL 2 :>=:@5B=>< 45;5. 5@5G5=L MB8E A?>A>1>2 =5 O2;O5BAO 8AG5@?K20NI8<. -B> >7=0G05B, GB> ?@020 8 70:>==K5 8=B5@5AK <>3CB 70I8I0BLAO 8 8=0G5, => 2 0@18B@06=KE AC40E ?@82K:;8 : >1KG=K< A?>A>10<, ?>MB><C =5 AB>8B 87>1@5B0BL =8G53> A;>6=>3>, 2K18@0O B>B 8;8 8=>9 A?>A>1 70I8BK. '5B:> AD>@<C;8@>20BL ?@54<5B 8A:0 ?><>65B 87CG5=85 @C1@8:0B>@0 8 A0<8E @5H5=89 0@18B@06=KE AC4>2, >?C1;8:>20==KE 2 « 5AB=8:5 KAH53> @18B@06=>3> !C40 >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88»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
@028;L=0O D>@<C;8@>2:0 ?@54<5B0 8 >A=>20=8O 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 ?>72>;O5B 042>:0BC =0?@028BL 45;> 2 =5>1E>48<>5 @CA;>, >?@545;O5B ?@54<5B 8 ?@545;K 4>:07K20=8O ?> 45;C 8 O2;O5BAO >A=>2>9 4;O 2A53> ?>A;54CNI53> 53> @0AA<>B@5=8O. 06=>ABL MB>3> >?@545;O5BAO 5I5 8 B5< >1AB>OB5;LAB2><, GB> 0@18B@06=>- ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 70:>= =5 ?>72>;O5B 2 AC451=>< 70A540=88 87<5=8BL >4=>2@5<5==> 8 ?@54<5B, 8 >A=>20=85 8A:0 ( AB. 4 9 $) . A;8, =0?@8<5@, =5>1E>48<> 2 AC451=>< 70A540=88 70<5=8BL B@51>20=85 > ?@87=0=88 A45;:8 =5459AB28B5;L=>9 B@51>20=85< > @0AB>@65=88 4>3>2>@0 8 ?@825AB8 8=K5 >A=>20=8O @0AB>@65=8O, B> 8<55B <5AB> >4=>2@5<5==>5 87<5=5=85 8 ?@54<5B0, 8 >A=>20=8O 8A:0, GB> =54>?CAB8<>. MB>< A;CG05 @07@5H5=85 2>?@>A0 ?> ACI5AB2C 2 A2O78 A 4>?CI5==>9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 >H81:>9 1C45B 70BO=CB>.
?@>F5AA5 87CG5=8O <0B5@80;>2 45;0 8 ?>43>B>2:8 8A:0 C 042>:0B0 =0G8=05B D>@<8@>20BLAO ?>78F8O, >?@545;5=85 :>B>@>9 O2;O5BAO >A=>2>9 4;O 2A5E ?>A;54CNI8E @5H5=89.
>78F8O ?> 45;C - MB> 2K@01>B0==>5 042>:0B>< 3;02=>5 =0?@02;5=85 4>AB865=8O ?>AB02;5==>9 F5;8, 2:;NG0NI55 >?@545;5=85 AC1J5:B=>3> A>AB020 ;8F, CG0AB2CNI8E 2 45;5, D>@<C;8@>20=85 ?@54<5B0 8 >A=>20=89 8A:0, ?@545;>2 4>:07K20=8O, B> 5ABL D0:B8G5A:>5 8 N@848G5A:>5 >1>A=>20=85 B>3>, GB> 8 :0: =C6=> 70I8I0BL.
42>:0B ?@8 2K@01>B:5 ?>78F88 ?> 45;C @C:>2>4AB2C5BAO B>;L:> 8=B5@5A0<8 A2>53> 4>25@8B5;O. @8 ?>43>B>2:5 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, 5A;8 2 45;5 =5A:>;L:> >B25BG8:>2, =C6=> ?><=8BL, GB> 8A:>2K5 B@51>20=8O 4>;6=K 1KBL 87;>65=K : :064><C 87 =8E. @8G5< D>@<C;8@>20BL 8E A;54C5B B0:, GB>1K 2 A;CG05 2K83@KH0 45;0 @5H5=85 <>6=> 1K;> 8A?>;=8BL. 0?@8<5@, >H81>G=> D>@<C;8@>20BL 8A: >1 8AB@51>20=88 87 GC6>3> =570:>==>3> 2;045=8O 8<CI5AB20, :>340 C >B25BG8:0 >=> >BACBAB2C5B. 5H5=85 ?> B0:><C 8A:C ?@8 53> 2K83@KH5 =5;L7O 8A?>;=8BL. ;8, ?@87=020O =5459AB28B5;L=K< 4>3>2>@ :C?;8- ?@>4068 0:F89, A;54C5B A@07C 65 AD>@<C;8@>20BL B@51>20=85 > 2>AAB0=>2;5=88 8ABF0 2 @55AB@5 0:F8>=5@>2. A;8 >3@0=8G8BLAO B>;L:> ?5@2K< B@51>20=85<, B> A<KA; ?@>F5AA0 1C45B CB@0G5=, ?>A:>;L:C A0<> ?> A515 ?@87=0=85 4>3>2>@0 :C?;8- ?@>4068 0:F89 =8GB>6=K< 157 ?@8<5=5=8O ?>A;54AB289 =5459AB28B5;L=>AB8 A45;:8 4;O 8ABF0 15A?>;57=>. K18@0O A?>A>1 70I8BK =0@CH5==>3> ?@020, 042>:0B 2KOA=O5B, CAB0=>2;5= ;8 70:>=>40B5;LAB2>< ?>@O4>: 8A?>;=5=8O 70O2;5==KE B@51>20=89. "0:, =0?@8<5@, 2 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 8A:>2>3> B@51>20=8O >1 >1O70=88 10=:0 8A?>;=8BL ?;0B56=>5 ?>@CG5=85 8 ?5@5G8A;8BL >?@545;5==K5 45=56=K5 A@54AB20 ?> =5<C, B> 5ABL 8A?>;=8BL >1O70B5;LAB2> 2 =0BC@5, 1K;> >B:070=>, ?>A:>;L:C, :0: C:070; @57848C< KAH53> @18B@06=>3> !C40 $, 8AB5F 2K1@0; =5=04;560I89 A?>A>1 70I8BK A2>53> =0@CH5==>3> ?@020, 8A?>;=5=85 :>B>@>3> =5 ?@54CA<>B@5=> 70:>=>< « 1 8A?>;=8B5;L=>< ?@>872>4AB25» 8;8 8=K<8 ?@02>2K<8 0:B0<8 $.
@8 D>@<C;8@>20=88 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 042>:0B CAB0=02;8205B, :B> 1C45B >B25BG8:><, :B> - B@5BL8< ;8F>< 8 =0 GL59 AB>@>=5, =5 1C4CB ;8 70B@>=CBK AC451=K< @5H5=85< 5I5 GL8- ;81> 8=B5@5AK. ">340 8 MB> ;8F> 4>;6=> 1KBL ?@82;5G5=> : CG0AB8N 2 ?@>F5AA5 C65 2 AC45 ?5@2>9 8=AB0=F88, GB>1K C 2KH5AB>OI8E AC4>2 =5 1K;> >A=>20=8O 4;O >B<5=K AC451=>3> @5H5=8O ?> MB><C >A=>20=8N.
1> 2A5< MB>< ;CGH5 ?>701>B8BLAO 70@0=55, A<>45;8@>20BL 2>7<>6=K5 A8BC0F88, BI0B5;L=K< >1@07>< 2725A8BL 2A5 0@3C<5=BK 8 >?@545;8BL ?5@A?5:B82K ?@>E>645=8O 45;0 2 0@18B@06=>< AC45, > G5< :;85=B 2A5340 C254><;O5BAO 42>:0BA:0O 45OB5;L=>ABL 8 042>:0BC@0 2 >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( 042>:0BA:>5 ?@02>) . . . !<>;5=A:89 - 8740B5;LAB2> « $5=8:A» : . 2 0 0 7 3. 5?>A@54AB25==K5 B@51>20=8O : D>@<5 8 A>45@60=8N 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O 87;>65=K 2 AB. 1 2 5 $, @0AA<>B@8< B>;L:> =5:>B>@K5 ?@0:B8G5A:85 >A>15==>AB8 ?>40G8 2 0@18B@06=K9 AC4 8A:0, ?>A:>;L:C B5E=>;>38G5A:8 MB>B ?@>F5AA 4>AB0B>G=> A;>65=, B0: :0: A>45@68B <=>3> D>@<0;L=KE B@51>20=89, =52K?>;=5=85 :>B>@KE 2;5G5B >AB02;5=85 8A:0 157 42865=8O 4;O 8A?@02;5=8O =54>AB0B:>2 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O.
1@0B8< 2=8<0=85 ;8HL =0 =5A:>;L:> 0A?5:B>2 B5E=8G5A:>9 ?>43>B>2:8 : 45;C.
5@2K9 - MB> =5>1E>48<>ABL G5B:>3> >1>7=0G5=8O ?>;=><>G89 ;8F0, ?>4?8A02H53> 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85, 5A;8 MB> =5 35=5@0;L=K9 48@5:B>@ ?@54?@8OB8O, :>B>@K9 <>65B 459AB2>20BL 157 4>25@5==>AB8. I5 @07 =0?><=8<, GB> =5:>B>@K5 ?>;=><>G8O 8<5NB 8A:;NG8B5;L=K9 E0@0:B5@ 8 4>;6=K 1KBL >3>2>@5=K 2 4>25@5==>AB8 >A>1> ( ?. 2 AB. 6 2 $) . ;N1>< A;CG05, 1C4L B> ;8F>, 459AB2CNI55 ?> 4>25@5==>AB8, 4>25@8B5;L=K9 C?@02;ONI89, 0@18B@06=K9 C?@02;ONI89 8;8 ;N1K5 8=K5 ?>4?8A02H85 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85 ;8F0, 8E ?>;=><>G85 =0 B0:>5 N@848G5A:8 7=0G8<>5 459AB285 4>;6=> 1KBL 87;>65=> 2 ?@8;0305<KE : 8A:>2><C 70O2;5=8N 4>:C<5=B0E B>G=> 8 =542CA<KA;5==>. B>@>9 - MB> =5>1E>48<>ABL G5B:>3> >1>7=0G5=8O 04@5A0 >B25BG8:0, ?> :>B>@><C =04;568B >B?@02;OBL 4>:C<5=B0F8N, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 AC451=K5 C254><;5=8O. @0:B8:0 A2845B5;LAB2C5B, GB> <=>385 ?@54?@8OB8O =5 =0E>4OBAO ?> 70O2;5==K< 04@5A0< 8 ?>GB>2K5 >B?@02;5=8O 2>72@0I0NBAO A C254><;5=85< >1 >BACBAB288 C:070==>3> ;8F0, 0 MB> 2;5G5B 70BO3820=85 ?@>F5AA0 8;8 <>65B O28BLAO ?@54?>AK;:>9 : ?@>F5AAC0;L=>9 >H81:5. 0: 8725AB=>, 0@18B@06=>- ?@>F5AAC0;L=>5 70:>=>40B5;LAB2> =5 ?>72>;O5B @0AA<0B@820BL 45;0 ?@8 =5=04;560I5< C254><;5=88 CG0AB2CNI8E 2 45;5 ;8F. "@5B89 0A?5:B A2O70= A >?;0B>9 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K' . 5?@028;L=0O 55 >?;0B0 - MB> G0AB>5 O2;5=85 A@548 =5:20;8D8F8@>20==KE ?@54AB028B5;59. 5:><5=4C5< >1@0I0BL 2=8<0=85 =0 A;54CNI85 <><5=BK:
" 4>;6=> >?;0G820BLAO :064>5 8A:>2>5 B@51>20=85. A;8 8<55BAO 8<CI5AB25==>5 B@51>20=85, MB> >4=0 AC<<0 ?>H;8=K, 5A;8 =58<CI5AB25==>5 - 4@C30O, 8 ;CGH5 >D>@<;OBL 8E >B45;L=K<8 ?;0B56=K<8 4>:C<5=B0<8, :>340, =0?@8<5@, 420 B@51>20=8O >1J548=5=K 2 >4=>< 8A:5;
" >1O70B5;L=> =C6=> ?@>25@OBL <0B5<0B8G5A:CN ?@028;L=>ABL @0AG5B>2;
" =5>1E>48<> >G5=L B>G=> >D>@<;OBL ?;0B56=K5 4>:C<5=BK. 0?@8<5@, 8A:>2>5 70O2;5=85 1K;> 2>72@0I5=>, :>340 =0 :28B0=F88 >1 C?;0B5 3>A?>H;8=K, >D>@<;5==>9 G5@57 !15@530B5;L=K9 10=:, >BACBAB2>20;0 ?>4?8AL :0AA8@0 8;8 2 :28B0=F88 >H81>G=> 1K;> C:070=>: « @0745; 2 » , 0 =04> 1K;>: « @0745; I I » ;
" : 8A:>2><C 70O2;5=8N 4>;65= ?@8:;04K20BLAO ?>4;8==8:, 0 =5 :>?8O ?;0B56=>3> 4>:C<5=B0 >1 >?;0B5 ?>H;8=K. "@5CH=8:>20 . . @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AA. - 740B5;LAB2>: « >@>45F» 2 0 0 7 3.
>H;8=0 <>65B 1KBL C?;0G5=0 :0: =5?>A@54AB25==> A0<8< 70O28B5;5<, B0: 8 ;N1K< 8=K< ;8F>< 70 =53>, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 =0;8G=K<8 45=L30<8 G5@57 10=:. >340 :;85=B AB5A=5= 2 A@54AB20E, 042>:0B E>40B09AB2C5B ?5@54 0@18B@06=K< AC4>< >1 >BA@>G:5, @0AA@>G:5 8;8 C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0. BA@>G:0 8;8 @0AA@>G:0 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, C<5=LH5=85 55 @07<5@0 ?@>872>4OBAO ?> ?8AL<5==><C E>40B09AB2C 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K. %>40B09AB2> <>65B 1KBL 87;>65=> 2 8A:>2>< 70O2;5=88, 2 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8;8 :0AA0F8>==>9 60;>15 ;81> 2 >B45;L=>< 70O2;5=88, ?@8;>65==>< : A>>B25BAB2CNI5<C 70O2;5=8N ( 60;>15) .
E>40B09AB25 ?@82>4OBAO A>>B25BAB2CNI85 >1>A=>20=8O A ?@8;>65=85< 4>:C<5=B>2, A2845B5;LAB2CNI8E > B><, GB> 8<CI5AB25==>5 ?>;>65=85 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K =5 ?>72>;O5B 59 C?;0B8BL 3>AC40@AB25==CN ?>H;8=C 2 CAB0=>2;5==>< @07<5@5 ?@8 ?>40G5 8A:>2>3> 70O2;5=8O, 0?5;;OF8>==>9 8;8 :0AA0F8>==>9 60;>1K.
4>:C<5=B0<, CAB0=02;820NI8< 8<CI5AB25==>5 ?>;>65=85 708=B5@5A>20==>9 AB>@>=K, >B=>AOBAO:
" ?>4B25@645==K9 =0;>3>2K< >@30=>< ?5@5G5=L @0AG5B=KE 8 8=KE AG5B>2;
" =08<5=>20=8O 8 04@5A0 10=:>2 8 4@C38E :@548B=KE CG@5645=89, 2 :>B>@KE MB8 AG5B0 >B:@KBK, 2:;NG0O AG5B0 D8;80;>2 8 ?@54AB028B5;LAB2 N@848G5A:>3> ;8F0;
" ?>4B25@645==K5 10=:>< 40==K5 >1 >BACBAB288 =0 A>>B25BAB2CNI5< AG5B5 8;8 AG5B0E, 5A;8 8E =5A:>;L:>, 45=56=KE A@54AB2 2 @07<5@5,
" =5>1E>48<>< 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, 0 B0:65 >1 >1I59 AC<<5 704>;65==>AB8 2;045;LF0 AG5B0 ?> 8A?>;=8B5;L=K< ;8AB0< 8 ?;0B56=K< 4>:C<5=B0<.
E>40B09AB2C >1 C<5=LH5=88 @07<5@0 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K ?@8;030NBAO 4>:C<5=BK > =0E>4OI8EAO =0 AG5B5 45=56=KE A@54AB20E. @54AB02;5=85 4>:C<5=B>2, ?>4B25@640NI8E >1@0I5=85 70O28B5;O : 10=:0< 8 8=K< >@30=870F8O< 70 ?>;CG5=85< 705<=KE A@54AB2, 0 B0:65 A2845B5;LAB2CNI8E >1 >BACBAB288 C =53> ;8:284=>3> 8<CI5AB20, 70 AG5B @50;870F88 :>B>@>3> <>3;0 1KBL ?>;CG5=0 45=56=0O AC<<0, =5>1E>48<0O 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, =5 B@51C5BAO.
%>40B09AB2> >1 >BA@>G:5 8;8 @0AA@>G:5 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K, C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0 <>65B 1KBL C4>2;5B2>@5=> 0@18B@06=K< AC4>< B>;L:> 2 B5E A;CG0OE, :>340 ?@54AB02;5==K5 4>:C<5=BK A2845B5;LAB2CNB >1 >BACBAB288 =0 10=:>2A:8E AG5B0E 45=56=KE A@54AB2 2 @07<5@5, =5>1E>48<>< 4;O C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K. @8 >BACBAB288 B0:8E 4>:C<5=B>2 2 C4>2;5B2>@5=88 E>40B09AB20 1C45B >B:070=>.
@18B@06=K9 AC4 =5 <>65B ?> A2>5<C CA<>B@5=8N >B:07K20BL 2 >BA@>G:5 8;8 @0AA@>G:5 C?;0BK 3>AC40@AB25==>9 ?>H;8=K 8 C<5=LH5=88 55 @07<5@0, 5A;8 8<5NBAO >1J5:B82=K5 >A=>20=8O 4;O C4>2;5B2>@5=8O E>40B09AB20. @8 C25;8G5=88 @07<5@0 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 3>AC40@AB25==0O ?>H;8=0 C?;0G8205BAO 2 A>>B25BAB288 A C25;8G5==>9 F5=>9 8A:0. >MB><C : 70O2;5=8N >1 C25;8G5=88 8A:>2KE B@51>20=89 4>;65= 1KBL ?@8;>65= 4>:C<5=B, ?>4B25@640NI89 >?;0BC ?>H;8=K 2 C25;8G5==KE @07<5@0E. 5>1E>48<> ?@>4C<0BL 2>?@>A 8 > <5@0E ?> >15A?5G5=8N 8A:0, =0?8A02 >1 MB>< A>>B25BAB2CNI55 70O2;5=85. "0:>5 70O2;5=85 4>;6=> 1KBL >1>A=>20==K< 8 87;030BLAO A CG5B>< :>=:@5B=KE >1AB>OB5;LAB2 45;0, :>340 2 MB>< 5ABL =5>1E>48<>ABL. 70O2;5=88 042>:0B 2 C1548B5;L=>9 D>@<5 AB0@05BAO 4>:070BL, GB> =5?@8=OB85 ?>4>1=KE <5@ A45;05B =52>7<>6=K< @50;870F8N <0B5@80;L=>- ?@02>2KE B@51>20=89 : >B25BG8:C. 5@K 4>;6=K 8A?@0H820BLAO >AB>@>6=>, A>@07<5@=> 70O2;5==K< B@51>20=8O<, A CG5B>< B>3>, GB> 2 A;CG05 ?@8G8=5=8O 8E ?@8=OB85< C1KB:>2 >B25BG8:C 8AB5F ?@8 ?@>83@KH5 45;0 1C45B >1O70= 8E 2>7<5AB8BL. >15A?5G8B5;L=KE <5@0E =5 <>65B 1KBL >B:070=>, 5A;8 ;8F>, E>40B09AB2CNI55 >1 >15A?5G5=88 8A:0, ?@54AB028;> 2AB@5G=>5 >15A?5G5=85. "@5CH=8:>20 . . @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AA. - 740B5;LAB2>: « >@>45F» 2 0 0 7 3.
?@>F5AA5 ?>43>B>2:8 8A:>2KE <0B5@80;>2 042>:0B ?@>4C<K205B 2>?@>A 8 > 27KA:0=88 @0AE>4>2, ?>=5A5==KE :;85=B>< =0 >?;0BC 53> CA;C3, A ?@>83@02H59 AB>@>=K. G. 2 AB. 1 1 0 $ ?@54CA<>B@5=0 B0:0O 2>7<>6=>ABL: @0AE>4K =0 >?;0BC CA;C3 ?@54AB028B5;O, ?>=5A5==K5 ;8F><, 2 ?>;L7C :>B>@>3> 1K; ?@8=OB AC451=K9 0:B, 27KA:820NBAO A 4@C3>3> ;8F0, CG0AB2CNI53> 2 45;5 2 @07C<=KE ?@545;0E. >=OB85 « @07C<=K5 ?@545;K»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« @07C<=>AB8» 27KA:0=8O A ?@>83@02H59 AB>@>=K @0AE>4>2 =0 >?;0BC CA;C3 042>:0B0. @18B@06=K9 ?@>F5AAC0;L=K9 :>45:A >AA89A:>9 $545@0F88 ( $) - >B 2 4 . 0 7 . 2 0 0 2 N 9 5 - $
>43>B>2:0 8 2545=85 45;0 2 0@18B@06=>< AC45 - ?@>F5AA 4;8B5;L=K9, A>?@O65==K9 A =0?8A0=85< 042>:0B>< 1>;LH>3> :>;8G5AB20 4>:C<5=B>2 8 =5>1E>48<>ABLN >BA;56820=8O 8 2K45@6820=8O ?@>F5AAC0;L=KE A@>:>2.
Соседние файлы в папке участие адвоката