318 |
X. THE SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION |
X-4. Multipliers of the periodic orbit of the van der Pol equation
In Example X-2-5, we looked at the van der Pol equation
(X.4.1) |
LX + e(x2 - 1) d + x = 0, |
where a is a positive number. Using Observation X-2-4, it was shown that every orbit of the system
|
(X.4.2) |
d |
[y112i |
/ |
112 |
|
dt |
] |
[ -E(y1 |
- 1)112 - 111 |
|
|
is bounded for t > 0. It was also remarked that 0 is the only stationary point of system (X.4.2) and that the stationary point 0 is not stable as t - +oo. In fact, the
linear part of the right-hand side of (X.4.2) at y = 0 is Ay, where A = [ 01 and
[i]. Since trace[A]=f and det (A) = 1, the stationary point is an unstable
Y21-
node for e > 2, while 0 is an unstable spiral point for 0 < e < 2. Therefore, using the Poincare-Bendixson Theorem (cf. Theorem IX-4-1), we conclude that there exists at least one limit cycle. Now, Theorem X-3-1 implies that system (X.4.2) has exactly one limit cycle and all the other orbits except for the stationary point 6 approach this limit cycle asymptotically as t - +oo. In fact, since h(x) = e(x2 -1),
H(x) = e I 3 - x] , and g(x) = x, the seven conditions (i) - (vii) of Theorem X-3-1
3
are satisfied. In particular, the positive zero of H(x) is a = J > 1.
In this section, we prove the following theorem concerning the multipliers of the unique periodic solution x = x(t, e) of the van der Pol equation (X.4.1).
Theorem X-4-1. The multipliers of the periodic solution x(t, e) of (X.4.1) at 1 and p such that )pI < 1.
Proof.
|
|
|
|
|
If we! set v = xz |
2 |
11 z |
, wwhere 11 = d, then dt = -e(x2 - 1)y2. This implies |
that eJ (x(t)2 - 1)dt = - / |
. Now look at Figure 11. |
Y
5. THE VAN DER POL EQUATION FOR A SMALL PARAMETER 319
On each of two curves Cl and C2, let us denote y as a function of v by yl (v) and y2(v) respectively. Note that x2 > 1 on C1, but x2 < 1 on C2. Hence, yl(v)2 < y2(v)2. This implies that
fT
e (x(t)2 - 1)dt > 0,
where T is a period. Therefore, we can complete the proof by using the following lemma.
Lemma X-4-2. Assume that two functions f (x) and g(x) are continuously differentiable in R. Assume also that the differential equation
d 2 2 + f(x) dt + g(x) = 0
r1
has a nontrivial periodic solution x(t) of period 1 such that J0 f (x(t))dt > 0. Then, the multipliers of the periodic solution x(t) are 1 and p such that jpI < 1.
Remark X-4-3. If system (X.4.2) has more than one periodic orbit, then at least one of them must be orbitally unstable. Therefore, the proof of Theorem X-4-1 is another proof of the uniqueness of periodic orbit of (X.4.2).
X-5. The van der Pol equation for a small e > 0
In this section, we explain a method to locate the unique periodic orbit of dif- ferential equation (X.4.1) (or system (X.4.2)) for a small e > 0.
Set e = 0. Then, system (X.4.2) becomes
(X.5.1)
dt[y2J LyYi
Every orbit of (X.5.1) is a circle and of period 2n in t. We expect that the periodic orbit of (X.4.2) must be approximated by one of those circles as e -+ 0. The main problem is to find the radius of the circle which approximates the periodic orbit of
(X.4.2) for a sufficiently small e > 0.
Since the periodic orbit and its period are functions of e, we normalize the independent variable t by the change of independent variable
so that the period of the periodic orbit becomes 27r for every e > 0. Transformation (X.5.2) changes differential equation (X.4.1) to
x722 + e(1+eW)(x2-1)d + (1+&,d)2x = 0
that can be written in the form
|
d 2X |
(X.5.3) |
+ x = e(1 + ew)(1 - x2) - e(2W + ew2)x. |
320 |
X. THE SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION |
Observation X-5-1. In the case when a real-valued function f (r) is continuous and periodic of period 27r in r, the general solution of the linear nonhomogeneous differential equation
d2x
(X.5.4) |
d-T' + x = f(r) |
|
|
|
is given by |
|
|
(X.5.5) |
/'r+2n |
|
x(r) = K cos(r + m) + a- J |
sf(s)sin(r - s)ds |
|
r |
|
as it is shown with a straight forward calculation, where K and 0 are arbitrary constants. This solution is periodic in r of period 2ir if and only if
2w |
f (s) sin(s)ds = 0 |
|
2w |
(X.5.6) |
and |
f (s) cos(s)ds = 0. |
10 |
|
|
J0 |
Observation X-5-2. In the case when condition (X.5.6) is not satisfied, set
|
27r |
f(s) sin(s)ds and C[J] = 1 |
2, f (S) |
(X.5.7) |
S[ f ] = 1 fo |
cos(s)ds. |
|
i |
7t |
Jo |
Then, |
|
|
|
|
v(T) = Kcos(r + 0) |
|
(X.5.8) |
|
jr+21r |
1 |
|
+ 2a |
s f (s) - S[ f ] sin(s) - C[ f ] cos(s)Jsin(r - s)ds |
is the general solution of the differential equation
dr2 + x = f(r) - S[f]sin(r) -
Furthermore, v(r) is periodic of period 27r.
Observation X-5-3. Set
f ( X, ,W, E) _ (I + (w)(I - x2) |
- (2W + EW2)x. |
Letting K be a parameter and a function v(r, K, w, f) be periodic in r of period 27r, set
|
S(K,w,) _ |
1 |
j |
2w f (v(sKw,_(s,K,WE)WJf |
|
|
I |
C(K,, E) = - |
|
2w f |
(1T |
cos(s)ds. |
|
7r |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
5. THE VAN DER POL EQUATION FOR A SMALL PARAMETER 321
Now, let us consider an integral equation
(X.5.9) |
v(r, K, w, E) = K cos(t) + 2n fr |
+2 a |
s I f lV, |
|
|
|
|
|
dr, w, EL |
|
|
- S(K, w, c) sin(s) - C(K, w, f) tos(s)] sin(T - s)ds. |
Solutions of (X.5.9) satisfy the differential equation |
(X.5.10) |
d 2V |
+ V = E [f( V, |
Va |
, w, E I - S(K, w, c) sin(r) - C(K, w, E) cos(r) |
d-,r2 |
|
as long as v is periodic in r of period 2ir. This integral equation can be solved by using successive approximations in such a way that the solution v(r, K, W, E) is a convergent power series in c:
(X.5.11) v(r,K,w,E) _ |
EmVm(T,fi,w) = Rcos(T)+E vl(r,K,w)+ , |
|
m=0 |
where vm(r, K, w) are polynomials in (K, w) with coefficients periodic in r of period 2n. For any given positive numbers Ko and wo, there exists another positive number Eo(Ko,wo) such that series (X.5.11) is uniformly convergent for
I K1 < K0, |
IwI <- wo, |
IEI <- Eo(Ko,wo), |
-00<T<+00. |
This implies that S(K, w, c) and C(K, w, E) are also convergent power series in c:
00 |
0C |
(X.5.12) S(K,w,E) = E EmS,,,(K,w) and |
C(K,w,E) _ F, E"'Cm(K,w), |
m=0 |
m=0 |
where Sm(K,w) and C,,,(K,w) are polynomials in (K,w) with constant coefficients.
These two power series also converge uniformly for
Observation X-5-4. Inserting series (X.5.11) and (X.5.12) into system (X.5.10), we obtain
d2vi + vi = (1 - K2cos2(r))(-Ksin(r)) - 2wKcos(r)
dr2
-So(K,w) sin(r) - Co(K,w) cos(r)
=K3 cos2(r) sin(r) - K sin(r) - 2wK cos(r)
-So(K,w) sin(1T) - Co(K,w) cos(r)
= 4 K sin(3r) + |
1 |
- K - So(K, w)J sin(r) |
4
- [2wK + Co(K, w)1 cos(r).
322 X. THE SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION
|
Since v1 is periodic in r of period 2,r, we must have |
|
|
|
So(K,w) = I K3 - K and |
Co(K,w) _ -2wK. |
|
This implies that S(2, 0, 0) = 0 , C(2, 0, 0) = 0, and |
|
|
|
8K (2,0,0) |
x(2,0,0) |
_ 2 0 |
--8. |
|
200 |
8C200 |
-10 |
41 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Therefore, the system of equations S(K, w, e) = 0, C(K, w, e) = 0 has a solution K(e) = 2 + 0(e), w(e) = 0(e). The functions K(E) and w(e) are power series in e which converge if Iej is sufficiently small.
Observation X-5-5. Set
x(t, e) = v (T+ f1w(E) K(E), w(E), e/f
I
Then, x(t, e) is a periodic solution of (X.5.3) and
x(t, e) = K(e) cos |
t |
+ 0(e) |
as a --+ 0. |
|
(1+Ew(e) |
|
|
From the fact that
y2(t, E) _ |
(t, f) = - 1 K(f) sin C 1 + ew(e))t |
+ 0(e) |
as e -+ 0, |
we obtain the following conclusion.
Conclusion X-5-6. The unique periodic orbit of (X.4.2) tends to the circle yl +
Y22 = 4 ase-.0+.
X-6. The van der Pol equation for a large parameter
In this section, we consider the van der Pol equation (X.4.1) for a large e. Let us write (X.4.1) in the form
(X.6.1) |
|
|
_ |
(`1 |
|
|
|
|
dt [z21 |
|
|
|
|
|
-z1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 |
by setting x=z1 and |
=z2-ef 3 - zl). |
21 - I Eu' |
|
and t = er. Then, system (X.6.1) becomes |
Set {z2] |
|
|
|
|
|
I |
|
|
|
(X.6.2) |
d |
[$2 Il |
|
|
dr |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
where a = 1-
6. THE VAN DER POL EQUATION FOR A LARGE PARAMETER 323
Observation X-6-1. Note that, along an orbit of (X.6.2),
3 - wtl
Therefore, if 3 > 0 is sufficiently small, the slope dw, of any orbit is small at a
point (wl, w2) far away from the curve C : w2 = 3 - w!. This implies that every
orbit moves toward the curve C almost horizontally (cf. Figure 12).
Observation X-6-2. From Observation X-6-1 a rough picture of orbits of (X.6.2) is obtained (cf. Figure 13).
Actually, defining the curve Co by Figure 14, we prove the following theorem.
Theorem X-6-3. For a sufficiently small positive number J3, the unique periodic orbit of (X.6.2) is located in an open set V(/3) such that the closure of V(f3) contains the curve Co and shrinks to CD as 0 -+ 0+.
Proof of Theorem X-6-8. In eight steps, we construct an open set V(13) so that
(1) the closure of V(O) contains the curve Co,
(2) the closure of V(J3) shrinks to the curve Co as O |
0+, |
(3)if an orbit of (X.6.2) enters in the open set V(!3) at r = ro, then the orbit stays in V(/3) for r > ro.
Step 1. Fixing a number a(3) > 2, we use the line segment
C1(a) = j wi, a(3)3 - a((3) I : 0 < wi <_ a(/3)}
as a part of the boundary 8V(i3) of V(/3) (cf. Figure 15).
324 |
X. THE SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION |
Note that the slope of an orbit given by (X.6.3) is negative on C1 (O) and decreasing
to -oo as wt increases to a(f3). Also, is 0 on C1(f3).
dw2
Step 2. Let us consider a curve
CO) = j (wi, ws) : w2 = 3' - wl - Op(wi, 0), 1 < wl < a(fl)} ,
where
(i)µ(w1,3) is continuous for 1 < wl < a(0) and continuously differentiable for
1< wl < a($),
(ii)µ(w1, 0) > 0 for 1 < w1 < a(0), and (iii) µ(a(,3), 0) = 0.
On the curve C2(f3),
3
\ 31 - wl = -0µ(w1,13)
and, hence,
|
_ |
|
/32w1 |
|
Owl |
|
W2 _ |
f wl _ wl l |
µ(w1, 0) |
|
|
|
3 |
/f |
|
|
|
|
|
|
On the other hand, the slope of the curve C2($) is |
|
dw2 |
_ |
2 |
|
dEc(w1,f) |
|
dwl - |
w1 - 1 - ,8 |
dwl |
This implies that if µ is fixed by the initial-value problem |
(X.6.4) |
dwl |
|
1, |
µ(a(0),,8) = 0, |
|
|
|
|
|
we obtain |
|
|
|
|
|
|
/32w1 |
|
|
dw2 |
for 1 < wl < a($), |
|
|
|
1 |
dwl |
|
|
|
|
W2 - |
C 3 |
- w'/ |
|
|
where dw2 denotes the slope of C2(0). The unique solution to problem (X.6.4) is
i
given by
|
|
a(/3)2 - wl. |
|
Thus, we choose the curve |
|
|
|
C2(O) _ {(wt, wz) : u,2 = |
3 |
- wl - O a(0)2 - wi, |
1 < w1 < a(0) } |
|
|
|
as a part of the boundary OV(#) of V(f3) (cf. Figure 16). Note that on the curve
C2(,8),
w2 = -3 - Q a(f3)2 - 1 at w1 = 1.
6. THE VAN DER POL EQUATION FOR A LARGE PARAMETER 325
Step 3. We choose the curve
C3(/3) = {(wIw2): W2 = -3 - Q a(N)2 - w1, 0 < wl < 11
as a part of the boundary OV(/3) of V(/3) (cf. Figure 17).
C
C1(p)
|
FIGURE 16. |
|
|
FIGURE 17. |
|
On the curve C3(/3), |
|
|
|
|
|
|
1w3 |
|
2 |
31 - wl l - /3 |
a(/3)2 - wi |
|
W2 |
wl) |
3 - |
|
31 |
|
|
|
|
|
and, hence, |
|
|
|
|
|
|
/32w1 |
|
|
|
0'w1 |
|
|
(,w3 |
|
/ a(Q)2 - w1 + 3 + (31 - wl |
|
31 |
wl/ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
dw2 |
This |
|
On the other hand, the slope of the curve C3(/3) is dw,1 |
|
a(Q)2 - wl |
|
implies that |
02W, |
<dm2 |
|
|
|
|
for 0<w1<1, |
|
w2- (u, |
-wI ) |
dw, |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 |
|
|
|
|
where denotes the slope of C3(0) (cf. Figure 17). Note that on the curve awl
C3(3), W2 = - 3 - Qa(Q) at wI = 0.
Step 4. Now, let us fix the positive number a(/3) > 2 by the equation
|
2 |
3 |
(X.6.5) |
+ 3a(3) = a(3) - a(13). |
Denote by C+(/3) the curve consisting of Cl(/3), C2(13), and C3()3), i.e., C+(Q) _
C1(Q) UC2(/3) UC3($). Let C_(0) be the symmetric image of C+(Q) with respect to the point (0, 0). Then, C+(3) U C_ (/3) is a closed curve if a(,Q) satisfies condition
(X.6.5). We use the closed curve C+(/3) UC_(/3) as a part of the boundary 8V(/3) of V(/3) (cf. Figure 18).
|
|
|
|
326 |
X. THE SECOND-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION |
Step 5. Fixing a positive number b($) < 2 so that 3 = |
b(3) |
3 |
|
- b(j3) +,A(0), we |
choose the curve |
|
|
|
r!(,3) = {twiw2) : w2 = b(3)3- b(j3) +,6b($)2 - w;, |
0 < w, < b(13)} |
as a part of the boundary 8V(j3) of V($) (cf. Figure 19). Note that, on r,(j3),
2
w2=3 at w, = 0.
On the curve r, (,B),
|
/32w1 |
02w1 |
|
|
|
Q b(B)2 - wl + |
b(3) 3 |
w2 |
- b(8) - (3' w,) |
On the other hand, the slope of the curve 171(3) is
dullw2
ap)2'- wi
Step 6. We use the two curves
r2(0) = {(wiw2): w2 |
3 |
-wi, 1 <w, <b(S) |
|
3 |
|
|
r3($) = {(wltw2): U2 |
-2, |
0 < wl < |
ll |
|
|
3 |
|
JJ |
as parts of the boundary 8V(j3) of V(8) (cf. Figure 20). Note that on r3(Q), the
slope of an orbit given by (X.6.3) is positive and dd is negative.
Step 7. Denote by r+(j3) the curve consisting of r,(8), r2(8), and r3(8), i.e.,
r+w) = r1(Q) u r2(a) u r3(8).
Let r_ (j3) be the symmetric image of r+(j3) with respect to the point (0, 0). Then, r+(p) U r_(8) is a closed curve. We use the closed curve r+(j3) U r_ (f3) as a part of the boundary OV(0) of V(8) (cf. Figure 21).