Добавил:
kiopkiopkiop18@yandex.ru t.me/Prokururor I Вовсе не секретарь, но почту проверяю Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Ординатура / Хирургия / Библиотека им академика М.И. Перельмана / Книга_4606_Библиотеки_им_академика_М_И_Перельмана

.pdf
Скачиваний:
0
Добавлен:
15.09.2026
Размер:
16 Мб
Скачать
☆
122
https://t.me/medicina_free
C. A. Foster
benign paroxysmal type” in their 1952 paper [3]. Their method, now called the Dix–Hallpike maneuver, built on Barany’s description and head hanging maneuvers used by his Swedish protégé, Dr. Carl Nylen. Dix and Hallpike were the rst to note a latency of several seconds between the positioning of the head and the onset of the nystagmus.
A few years later in 1956, Drs. John Lindsay and Garth Hemenway at the University of Chicago studied patients with acute unilateral vestibular losses fol­lowed by positional vertigo, and noted that the utricle was not the source of posi­tional vertigo spells following those losses, because their cases had a total loss of utricular function. They correctly surmised that the problem lay in the posterior semicircular canal or saccule, since these were the only structures undamaged in the ears they studied [4].
Dr. Harold Schuknecht, Chief of Otolaryngology at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear Inrmary, published a 1962 paper that identied the posterior semicircular canal as the site of the problem and provided a mechanism for the disorder [5]. He posited correctly that particles within the inner ear, probably otoconia, moved into the canal and affected the cupula. He proposed that cupulolithiasis, particles adher­ent to the cupula in the affected canal, cause the attacks. This is may be true for a small subset of patients with BPPV but did not explain the more typical attacks.
In 1979, Drs. Stephen Hall, Ralph Ruby and Joseph McClure at Queens University and the University of Western Ontario provided the critical mechanistic breakthrough by reasoning that it was free-oating dense particles in the posterior semicircular canal, called canalithiasis, that stimulated cupular motion and set off spells (Fig. 7.1). They correctly agreed with Schuknecht that the particles were likely to be otoconia [6].
The fact that particles could be moved by gravity and were in an open-ended canal suggested the possibility that they could be removed without surgery. A year later, Dr. John Epley devised a clever maneuver to remove these particles from the posterior canal, and over time demonstrated its efcacy [7]. A series of other maneu­vers have since been devised.
Fig. 7.1 Left labyrinth viewed from the medial side in the upright head position. Otoconia accumulate in the most dependent part of the ear, adjacent to the posterior canal ampulla. (With permission from Foster CA.Overcoming Positional Vertigo. Boulder, CO: Bull Publishing; 2019)
7 Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo
https://t.me/medicina_free
Within a few years, Dr. Joseph McClure identied that canalithiasis could also cause symptoms when particles were in the horizontal semicircular canal [8] and it became clear that all three canals were vulnerable to the disorder, with BPPV of the posterior canal being the most common.
123
Relevant Anatomy
BPPV results from an interaction of the semicircular canals with the adjoining utri­cle. The semicircular canals are narrow membranous rings encompassing about two thirds of a circle that originate from the sac containing the utricle and terminate at an ampullated end containing the crista and cupula. They are set roughly orthogo­nally, with the horizontal (lateral) canals and labyrinth tilted upward at about 30° from the horizontal plane. The anterior (superior) canal is thus set superiorly with respect to the horizontal canal, and the posterior (inferior) canal is set inferiorly. The nonampullated end of the two vertical canals are fused into a common crus that opens into the roof of the utricular sac, while the horizontal canal has an adjacent but separate entrance into the sac.
Each ampulla contains a motion sensor and is a rounded, dilated extension of the canal attaching it to the utricular sac. The ampullae are open to the utricular sac on one side, and open to the canal on the other, but are divided in half by the crista/ cupular complex that prevents uid or particle movement from the utricle across the ampulla into the canal (Fig.7.2). However, endolymph can freely enter or exit the canal at the nonampullated end.
The crista is set within the ampulla perpendicular to the canal. It is a saddle­shaped ridge nearly dividing the ampulla in half. The unattached edge of this ridge projects toward the center point of the circular plane of each canal. Hair cells located in the crista have long kinocilia that extend into the ampulla. They are contained in a transparent mass, the cupula, that stretches from the crista across the ampulla and is attached to the opposite wall [9]. This creates a fan-shaped structure that parti­tions the ampulla in half. The cupula consists of protein brils and glycosaminogly­cans. These mucopolysaccharides are highly hydrophilic and distensible.
The utricle can sense gravity and other forms of linear acceleration because it is topped by a membrane embedding relatively dense particles of calcium carbonate, the otoconia, that exert a downward force on the sensor. It is the movement of this mass of particles that bends the hair cell projections that extend into the membrane and allows the detection of linear acceleration. The particles are adherent to the membrane and are coated with a sticky proteinaceous substance that helps them adhere to each other. However, with aging, pieces of otolithic membrane and parti­cle masses can detach from the utricle and move throughout the endolymph. Because they are denser than endolymph, gravity can move these relatively heavy particles into dependent parts of the inner ear.
124
https://t.me/medicina_free
C. A. Foster
Fig. 7.2 Cross-section of the ampulla perpendicular to the crista and cupula, in the plane of the canal. The cilia from the hair cells extend into the cupula, which divides the canal side of the ampulla from the utricular side. Although ame-shaped in cross-section, if seen from the side, the cupula is a half-circular fan shape. (With permission from Foster CA.Overcoming Positional Vertigo. Boulder, CO: Bull Publishing; 2019)
Physiology of BPPV
During head rotation and acceleration in the plane of each canal, the relative inertia of endolymph causes it to move freely with respect to the skull in a complete circle through the canal and utricle and by this movement bows the cupula within the ampulla [9]. This moves the kinocilia and their linked stereocilia, resulting in hair cell depolarization. This in turns results in a nystagmus that is unique to that canal. Each semicircular canal responds to only two directions of uid movement: toward or away from the cupula. The responses are asymmetric, reecting asymmetries in hair cell responses. Ewald’s laws specify that uid movement toward the ampulla and cupula (ampullopetal) is stimulatory for the horizontal canal, while movement away from the ampulla (ampullofugal) is inhibitory. The opposite is true for the vertical canals [10]. Each canal responds best to movements in the plane of the canal, and not at all to responses at 90° to the canal, with graded responses in between. Most natural head rotations thus stimulate more than one canal [11].
7 Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo
https://t.me/medicina_free
125
BPPV results when otoconia that may contain portions of the gelatinous mem­brane [12] become detached from the utricle and enter a semicircular canal. The nonampullated ends of the semicircular canals open into the vestibule above the utricle, so particles are most easily displaced into the canal when the head is depen­dent. The otoconia can be easily moved by gravity. If only a few particles are dis­persed in the canal, no detectable effect may be noticed. However, if a large clump of particles forms that can move as a piston in the canal, symptoms of dizziness arise (Fig.7.3). The movement of the clump under the inuence of gravity, even when there is no head rotation, can cause movement of the uid in the canal, stimu­lating the hair cells via cupular movement. Unlike natural head movements, this can stimulate a single semicircular canal, giving rise to a unique set of ndings for each canal. The direction of movement of the particles (ampullopetal vs. ampullofugal) inuences the severity of nystagmus. For example, because ampullopetal movement in the horizontal canal is stimulatory, it causes a more intense vertigo than the same direction of uid movement in a vertical canal.
Because particles can potentially move in two directions in each canal (toward the ampulla or toward the utricle), most BPPV cases have a direction changing positional nystagmus when the head is rotated 180° in the plane of the affected canal.
The posterior canal is most often affected by BPPV, comprising about 86% of all BPPV cases [13]. When a person lies supine with the head turned to one side, the posterior canal opening and the entire canal on that side lies below the utricle,
Fig. 7.3 Just as a syringe moves uid with the action of a piston, free-oating particles in the narrow semicircular canal move the cupula as they are displaced by gravity. (With permission from Foster CA.Overcoming Positional Vertigo. Boulder, CO: Bull Publishing; 2019)
126
https://t.me/medicina_free
allowing reux of particles under the inuence of gravity. This canal is the most dependent part of the labyrinth in the upright head, so particles can easily accumu­late in it.
The horizontal canal is affected in about 11% of cases [13]. The position most likely to cause reux into this canal is lying supine with the head turned to the side and dependent, such as during the Dix–Hallpike maneuver. Although infrequent, the vertigo with horizontal canal involvement tends to be the most severe and is more likely to be accompanied by vomiting.
The anterior canal is the least affected canal, about 1% of cases. This canal is entirely above the utricle, allowing the half of the canal proximal to the utricular opening to drain when the head is upright and reducing the risk of particle accumulation.
Velocity storage affects the responses to BPPV.Natural horizontal head rotations are larger and more prolonged than vertical head rotations and velocity storage is thus greatly enhanced for the horizontal canals compared to the vertical canals [14]. These differences tend to enhance the vertigo and nystagmus of H-BPPV compared to the anterior and posterior canal forms.
C. A. Foster
Clinical Presentation
Because the posterior canal is the most frequently affected canal, all the classic BPPV descriptions are of this canal. Over the past few decades, a greater apprecia­tion of the involvement of the anterior and horizontal canals has altered the under­standing of presenting symptoms. The main mass of otoconia can either be located deep in the canal in or near the ampulla (ampullary arm), or near the canal exit (utricular arm of the horizontal canal, common crus of the fused vertical canals), resulting in two opposite directions of direction-changing positional nystagmus for each canal. Particles can be either free-oating or entrapped and this also alters the clinical syndrome.
As noted, most BPPV patients have free-oating particles in the posterior semi­circular canal (P-BPPV). The particles accumulate in the ampullary arm adjacent to the ampulla and crista, so reclining will cause the particles to fall away from the vertically oriented ampulla in this position. This ampullofugal motion is stimulatory to the posterior canal and the vertigo is intense. The onset of this type of BPPV is typically in bed, while lying down quickly or rolling over. After a brief lag, the patient will awaken seeing the room spin torsionally and violently. The spell lasts from a few seconds up to a minute in a crescendo–decrescendo fashion. After the vertigo subsides, if no further head movements are made, the vertigo abates. However, any vertical or rolling head movement while reclining will set off another nearly identical attack, although the length and violence of the spinning declines (fatigues) if spells are set off repeatedly over a few minutes. Sitting up immediately after an attack will reverse the nystagmus to a transient downbeating nystagmus. Additional common triggers include arising from bed, lying down abruptly, and
7 Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo
https://t.me/medicina_free
127
tipping the head up or down. In the upright person most head rotations are horizon­tal, outside the plane of the affected posterior canal. This attenuates the vertigo, but there can be a low grade persistent disequilibrium throughout the day. Reaching up toward a high shelf, tipping the head up while washing hair in the shower, bending over toward the oor or other vertical head motions can set off brief spells of vertigo when upright. Nausea commonly accompanies the vertigo and vomiting some­times occurs.
Horizontal canal BPPV (H-BPPV) caused by free-oating particles is often more violent than the posterior canal variety and more likely to cause vomiting. Onset is usually while performing maneuvers for P-BPPV [15]. After a successful P-BPPV maneuver that has displaced particles back into the utricle, repeating the Dix– Hallpike maneuver places the horizontal canal immediately below the removed par­ticles. They can then easily reux into the utricular arm of the horizontal canal. Since this canal has its greatest response to ampullopetal uid motion, reux causes intense stimulation. The patient sees the room spin horizontally, exhibits consider­able distress, and may vomit within as little as 30s. Rotating the head while supine will set off additional spells with reversals in nystagmus direction. Nystagmus in H-BPPV is usually characterized as either geotropic (beating toward the oor), or apogeotropic (beating away from the oor/toward the ceiling). The nystagmus tends to last longer than P-BPPV, sometimes exceeding 1min.
The free-oating form of anterior canal BPPV (A-BPPV) is milder and much less common than the other two forms. Like the posterior canal, ampullofugal movements are stimulatory, but in the anterior canal, reux causes ampullopetal movement of uid and the vertigo is accordingly less severe. Like H-BPPV, it usu­ally arises after treatment for P-BPPV.The anterior and posterior canals are fused at the common crus, so reux into the crus must rst occur followed by a horizontal head movement to allow particles to fall into the ampullary arm of the anterior canal. This can happen when assuming the face-down position, such as during the Semont maneuver. The superior orientation of the anterior canal in the head allows particles in or near the common crus to fall back out when the head is returned to upright, often ending the attack.
All three canals can also show BPPV due to entrapped particles. This always affects the ampullary arm of the canal. Classically this has been ascribed to particles within the ampulla that adhere to the cupula (cupulolithiasis). Particles can be con­tained within the ampulla or may be blocked from free movement by an obstruction near the ampullary-canal junction, or possibly at an anatomic narrowing near the midpoint of the canal or at the common crus (canalith jam) [16–19]. Typically, this arises in patients undergoing maneuvers for pre-existing BPPV.It is heralded by a sudden very persistent vertigo that is milder in the vertical canal forms, and more violent for the horizontal canal form. This usually results in a very prolonged direc­tion changing positional nystagmus when the head is rotated in the plane of the canal. Once it arises, maneuvers may seem to have no effect on the vertigo and the symptoms can last indenitely in some.
Cupulolithiasis—attachment of otoconia to the cupula—is believed to be the dominant cause of persistent direction-changing positional nystagmus. This belief
128
https://t.me/medicina_free
C. A. Foster
is based on studies showing a basophilic deposit on the cupula, affecting up to 22% of cupulae in Moriarty’s postmortem anatomic studies [5, 20]. None of the patients in this series of 1031 temporal bones had BPPV symptoms, however. Otoconia were dissolved by the preparation method so were not proven to be the source of the deposits, and the frequency of deposits greatly exceeds the infrequent incidence of cupulolithiasis in the literature. If otoconia adhere to the cupula, one would expect more deposits to occur on the utricular side of the cupula (short arm cupulolithia­sis), because the ampulla is widely open to the utricle and its otoconia on that side, but most reported cases appear to be consistent with lithiasis of the canal side of the cupula.
Canalith jam can result in a prolonged blockage of the canal with a spontaneous nystagmus and canal paresis on caloric testing, or can be reversible [17, 19, 21]. It can result in an apogeotropic positional nystagmus, and thus can mimic cupuloli­thiasis [17]. Free-oating particles trapped in the ampullary arm by a narrowed area in the canal could alternately lodge in the narrowing to form a jam, then dislodge and move into the ampulla and directly impact the cupula. This type of reversible jamming results in an apogeotropic positional nystagmus and so may not be easily distinguished from cupulolithiasis.
Physical Examination
The Dix–Hallpike maneuver has been successfully used for the detection of P-BPPV for many decades and is the standard of care. The head and body are rotated through nearly 180° at high acceleration in the plane of the posterior semicircular canal, causing any particles it contains to be dislodged. At the conclusion of this move­ment the head is hanging and turned to one side (Fig.7.4). This allows any particles
Fig. 7.4 The Dix–Hallpike maneuver, left ear. The head is rotated 45° to the left prior to reclining the patient to the head hanging position. (With permission from Foster CA.Overcoming Positional Vertigo. Boulder, CO: Bull Publishing; 2019)
7 Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo
https://t.me/medicina_free
129
near the ampulla of the posterior canal to move ampullofugally (the stimulatory direction) by gravity, maximizing nystagmus. The head is also placed facing the examiner, so that any nystagmus that occurs can be easily seen. Some practitioners apply Fresnel lenses on the patient to reduce xation and further enhance the nystagmus.
Once placed in the head hanging position, there is a brief latency of a few to several seconds, followed by the onset of a torsional up beating nystagmus follow­ing a crescendo-decrescendo pattern that peaks and declines over 10–60s [22]. The velocity of the nystagmus is very brisk. The upward most eye is easiest to view and is best used to analyze the nystagmus. The axis of rotation of this eye is located in the upper medial quadrant of the upward eye near the iris edge if the pupil is cen­tered, resulting in a mixed torsional and upbeating nystagmus (Fig.7.5(1)), but the position of the rotational axis in the upper quadrant of the globe does not change with pupil movement [23]. If the pupil of the upward eye is moved toward the rota­tional axis nearer the medial canthus, the nystagmus becomes more purely torsional, and as it is moved away from the rotational axis toward the lateral canthus, it tran­scribes a wider arc and thus the nystagmus becomes more vertical. During success­ful maneuvers, the torsional and upbeating nystagmus continues as particles are rotated ampullofugally and out of the canal. On repeated Dix–Hallpike, a torsional upbeating nystagmus will be seen if some particles remain in the canal. The appear­ance of a new, ne downbeating nystagmus on Dix–Hallpike after a successful maneuver indicates that removed particles are reuxing back into the posterior canal through the common crus. This can also occur if particles are not completely removed during a maneuver, allowing them to reux back toward the ampulla when the patient sits up. Particles trapped within the ampulla will result in a persistent positional nystagmus that resembles classic torsional upbeating nystagmus when supine or in head hanging, but milder and prolonged greater than 1min. When the patient is raised to the upright seated position and then bent forward with the face down, the nystagmus reverses to a ne downbeating nystagmus [24].
For H-BPPV, determining the affected ear is critical before a maneuver is applied. H-BPPV is often rst noted while performing maneuvers for P-BPPV and is typi­cally seen on Dix–Hallpike. The nystagmus is brisk, horizontal, and often frighten­ing to the patient (Fig.7.5(2)). During reux, the beat direction will be toward the ground (geotropic) and toward the affected ear. The affected ear is the ear that has just undergone treatment for P-BPPV.
If a patient arrives with a history suggesting pre-existing H-BPPV, it will be nec­essary to determine whether it is the geotropic or apogeotropic form, which will determine whether the particles are freely moving in the utricular arm (geotropic form) or are within the ampulla or moving in the ampullary arm of the canal where they are likely to become entrapped (apogeotropic form). H-BPPV nystagmus will reverse direction when the supine patient is rolled from one side to the other, and also if the upright head is centered and tipped downward and upward. Recording the direction of nystagmus in these positions can be used to determine which ear is involved (Table7.1).
130
https://t.me/medicina_free
C. A. Foster
Fig. 7.5 The nystagmus of BPPV.The axis of rotation for each semicircular canal is perpendicular to the plane of the canal. Projected forward onto the eye, this axis determines the nystagmus seen. The eye is in mid-position in this series. Dark lines indicate the movement of the pupil during fast phases. (1) The posterior canal axis is near the iris, allowing torsional upbeating movement to be seen. (2) The horizontal canal axis is near the bottom of the globe, so little torsion is seen. (3) The anterior canal axis is near the canthus and slightly tilted, so little torsion is seen, and the nystagmus is downbeating and oblique (With permission from Foster CA. Overcoming Positional Vertigo. Boulder, CO: Bull Publishing; 2019)
Combining a half-Hallpike with Asprella’s single maneuver test technique [25] is usually sufcient to determine the side of involvement. The head of the table is raised to 30°, and the seated patient is rapidly reclined with the head centered. This movement places the horizontal canal in the vertical plane, maximizing particle
cA
7 Benign Paroxysmal Positional Vertigo
https://t.me/medicina_free
Table 7.1 Determining the affected ear in H-BPPV
A. Head roll Geotropi pogeotropic
131
B. Supine head center (“Lean”)
C. “Bow” Right beang Le beang Right beang Le beang
D. Side with greatest nystagmus
E. Null point side Right LeLe Right
F. Canal Paresis side
Affected Ear Right Le Le Right
Gray shading=test method and affected ear. Circle the nystagmus direction or affected side for each test, and mark under the “Geotropic” column or “Apogeotropic” column based on results of the head roll test. The bottom box of the column with the most circled answers gives the affected ear
(A) Head roll test: patient placed with right ear down, then left ear down (geotropic=nystagmus beats toward ground; apogeotropic= nystagmus beats toward ceiling). (B) Supine head center (Asprella method, Lean test): patient faces ceiling, note nystagmus direction. (C) Bow test: Patient bends forward facing oor, note nystagmus direction. (D) Side with greatest nystagmus: nystag­mus velocity or intensity is increased with one ear down compared to the other ear down. (E) Null point side: Measure nystagmus while slowly rotating the head from right to left or vice versa. The null point is the point at which no nystagmus is seen or abruptly switches direction on VNG, usu­ally about 20° to one side only. (F) Canal paresis side: side with a 25% or greater canal paresis. If there are no localizing ndings on tests (D–F), the results of tests (A–C) are sufcient to determine the affected side
Le beang Right beang Le beang Right beang
Right LeRight Le
Right LeLe Right
displacement. A horizontal nystagmus will be seen, and the direction should be noted. The head is then turned 90° to one side and any nystagmus direction and intensity noted, then turned to the opposite shoulder while noting nystagmus direc­tion and intensity. It is important to note whether the nystagmus intensity is greater when one ear is down. A geotropic nystagmus beats toward the oor, while an apo­geotropic nystagmus beats toward the ceiling. Similarly, patients can also be tested from the seated position using the bow-and-lean test by tipping the head to face the ceiling (“lean”), noting nystagmus direction, and then moving the head to face the oor (“bow”) and again noting the direction of the resulting nystagmus. A roll test