Добавил:
ivanov666
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Организация и управление внешнеэкономической деятельностью. Курс лекций
.pdf
D4EEDBK>4 C?4F9:4), ECBEB5G B59EC9K9A<S (B59EC9K9AAO9 < 5?4A>B6O9) <
71
F.8.
E6BR BK9D98P, 6 >4K9EF69 >D98<FBDB6 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E><I
E89?B> @B7GF 6OEFGC4FP Q>ECBDF9DO, <@CBDF9DO, 54A><, D4;?<KAO9
>D98<FAB-H<A4AEB6O9 BD74A<;4J<<, 4 F4>:9 7BEG84DEF6B.
(<A4AE<DB64A<9 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E><I E89?B> CDS@B <?< >BE69AAB
BEGM9EF6?S9FES >B@@9DK9E><@< 54A>4@<, 4 Q>ECBDF9D (<?< <@CBDF9D)
6OEFGC49F 6 >4K9EF69 <A<J<4FBD4 < BF69FEF69AAB7B ?<J4 ;4 E6B96D9@9AAB9
CB74L9A<9 >D98<F4 < E6S;4AAOI E QF<@ D4EIB8B6. @9:8GA4DB8AB=
CD4>F<>9 6OD45BF4AO BCD989?9AAO9 B5OK4< 6 BHBD@?9A<< < CBDS8>9
<ECB?A9A<S >D98<FAOI BC9D4J<=.
(<D@9AAO= >D98<F S6?S9FES CD9<@GM9EF69AAB= HBD@B= >D98<FB64A<S 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E>B= 89SF9?PABEF<. 7B @B:AB BI4D4>F9D<;B64FP >4>
>D98<F, CD98BEF46?S9@O= 6 FB64DAB= HBD@9 Q>ECBDF9DB@ <ABEFD4AAB@G
<@CBDF9DG 6 6<89 BFEDBK>< C?4F9:4 ;4 CDB84AAO9 FB64DO (BF 2 < 5B?99
?9F 6 ;46<E<@BEF< BF 6<84 FB64D4 < >BANRA>FGDO 6A9LA97B DOA>4).
D98<F 6 QFB@ E?GK49 CD98BEF46?S9FES CB8 B5S;4F9?PEF64 8B?:A<>4
CB74E<FP 6 BCD989?9AAO= EDB>, >4> EG@@G BEAB6AB7B 8B?74, F4> <
A4K<E?9AAO9 CDBJ9AFO.
%FB<@BEFP >D98<FB64A<S BCD989?S9FES GDB6A9@ CDBJ9AFAB= EF46><
A4 DOA>9 >D4F>BEDBKAOI >D98<FB6 EFD4AO, CD98BEF46<6L9= BFEDBK>G
C?4F9:4, 4 F4>:9 EDB>B@ >D98<FB64A<S — C9D<B8B@ 6D9@9A<, >BFBDB9
CDBIB8<F BF BF7DG;>< FB64D4 8B BEGM9EF6?9A<S D4EK9FB6 ;4 A97B. $4EK9FO
;4 >D98<FB64A<9 BF89?PAB, >4> CD46<?B, A9 CDB<;6B8SFES, F4> >4>
E6S;4AAO9 E QF<@ D4EIB8O GK<FO64RFES Q>ECBDF9DB@ 6 J9A9 FB64D4.
DG7B= D4ECDBEFD4A9AAB= HBD@B= >D98<FB64A<S S6?S9FES
54A>B6E>B9 >D98<FB64A<9. BF?<K<9 BF H<D@9AAOI >D98<FB6, 789 54A><
6OEFGC4RF ?<LP CBED98A<>4@< 6 @B5<?<;4J<< ED98EF6 A4 89A9:AB@
DOA>9 8?S >D98<FB64A<S 6A9LA9FBD7B6OI E89?B> ?<5B >BE69AAB
GK4EF6GRF 6 QFB@ CGF9@ H<A4AE<DB64A<S 89SF9?PABEF< H<D@ <
BD74A<;4J<=, ;4ASFOI 6A9LA9FBD7B6O@ 5<;A9EB@, 54A>B6E><9 >D98<FO
BEGM9EF6?SRFES CD< A9CBED98EF69AAB@ < 4>F<6AB@ GK4EF<< 54A>B6.
D98<FB64A<9 54A>4@< 6 QFB@ E?GK49 BEGM9EF6?S9FES 6 6<89 EEG8 CB8
;4?B7 FB64DB6, FB64DBD4ECBDS8<F9?PAOI 8B>G@9AFB6, 69>E9?9=, 4 F4>:9
GK9F4 FD4FF.
B?S 54A>B6E><I Q>ECBDFAOI >D98<FB6 <ABEFD4AAO@ CB>GC4F9?S@
8BEF4FBKAB 69?<>4 6 E<EF9@9 >D98<FB64A<S 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E><I E89?B>,
< EGM9EF6G9F F9A89AJ<S > DBEFG. 1FB E6S;4AB E 6B;D4EF4RM<@ ECDBEB@ A4
8B?7BEDBKAO9 >D98<FO. "8A4>B CDB8B?:<F9?PABEFP >D98<FB64A<S A9
S6?S9FES 98<AEF69AAB= < BEAB6AB= CD<K<AB= CBCG?SDABEF< <
D4ECDBEFD4A9A<S 54A>B6E>B7B >D98<F4.
4A>B6E>B9 >D98<FB64A<9 <@99F DS8 ;A4K<F9?PAOI CD9<@GM9EF6
72
C9D98 H<D@9AAO@.
B-C9D6OI, 54A>B6E><= >D98<F CD98BEF46?S9FES A9CBED98EF69AAB
<@CBDF9DG, KFB 849F 9@G 6B;@B:ABEFP E6B5B8A99 <ECB?P;B64FP ED98EF64 A4
CB>GC>G FB64D4. @CBDF9D ;4 EK9F 84AAB7B >D98<F4 D4EEK<FO649FES E
CDB846JB@, <, F4><@ B5D4;B@, ;46<E<@BEFP BF Q>ECBDF9D4, >BFBD4S
EGM9EF6G9F CD< H<D@9AAB@ >D98<FB64A<<, <EK9;49F. #BE>B?P>G CD< QFB@
<ABEFD4AAO= CB>GC4F9?P C?4F<F H<D@9-CBEF46M<>G A4?<KAO@<, FB
CDS@OI >D98<FAOI BFABL9A<= @9:8G CDB846JB@ < CB>GC4F9?9@ A9
6B;A<>49F.
B-6FBDOI, 9E?< H<D@9AAO9 >D98<FO CD98BEF46?SRFES 8?S
H<A4AE<DB64A<S CBEF46>< B5BDG8B64A<S >BA>D9FAB= H<D@B=, FB
54A>B6E><9 >D98<FO K4M9 6E97B 6O84RFES 8?S H<A4AE<DB64A<S
EB7?4EB64AAB7B 6<84 B5BDG8B64A<S, >BFBDB9 @B:9F 5OFP ;4>4;4AB G
D4;?<KAOI H<D@ 84AAB= EFD4AO (6 ;46<E<@BEF< BF 6O7B8ABEF<
CD98?B:9A<=).
-FD9FP<I, 54A>B6E><9 >D98<FO 6 5B?PL9= EF9C9A<, K9@ H<D@9AAO9,
CB869D74RFES D97G?<DB64A<R < >BAFDB?R EB EFBDBAO 7BEG84DEF69AAOI
BD74AB6. !9D98>B EB7?4L9A<S, ;4>?RK49@O9 @9:8G 54A>4@<
EBBF69FEF6GRM<I EFD4A, E4A>J<BA<DB64AO CD46<F9?PEF64@< QF<I EFD4A <
S6?SRFES EBEF46AB= K4EFPR @9:CD46<F9?PEF69AAOI EB7?4L9A<=. E6S;< E
QF<@ GE?B6<S >D98<FB6 @B7GF 5OFP 5B?99 ?P7BFAO@<, A9:9?< CD<
B5OKAOI >B@@9DK9E><I >D98<F4I.
?47B84DS D4;?<KAO@ 7BEG84DEF69AAO@ CDB7D4@@4@ 54A>4@< @B7GF
CD98BEF46?SFPES Q>ECBDFAO9 >D98<FO A4 10-15 ?9F CB EF46>4@ A<:9
DOABKAOI. "8A4>B CD< QFB@ 54A>< B7D4A<K<64RF <ECB?P;B64A<9 >D98<F4
CD989?4@< E6B9= EFD4AO < A9D98>B EF46SF GE?B6<S B D4EIB8B64A<< 97B A4
BCD989?9AAO9 J9?<, A4CD<@9D A4 CB>GC>G FB64DB6 G H<D@, 6 >BFBDOI BA<
;4<AF9D9EB64AO. #D< QFB@ 54A>B6E><= >D98<F CD<B5D9F49F E6B=EF64
H<D@9AAB7B >D98<F4, FB 9EFP J9?96B= I4D4>F9D.
$4;AB6<8ABEFPR 54A>B6E>B7B >D98<F4 S6?SRFES E6S;4AAO9
H<A4AEB6O9 >D98<FO. #D< E6S;4AAB@ H<A4AEB6B@ >D98<F9 54A>
CD98BEF46?S9F >D98<F A9 A9CBED98EF69AAB CB>GC4F9?R, 4 CD98EF46<F9?R
CBEF46M<>4 6 EFD4A9 <@CBDF9D4, BC?4K<64RM9@G CBEF46>G FB64DB6,
A4CD46?S9@OI CB>GC4F9?R 6 D4@>4I >BA>D9FAB7B 8B7B6BD4 >GC?<CDB84:<.
%FB<@BEFP >D98<F4, CD98BEF46?S9@B7B 54A>B@ CB>GC4F9?R, >4>
CD46<?B, H<>E<DG9FES A4 DS8 ?9F A4 GDB6A9 A<:9 EFB<@BEF< ;49@AOI
ED98EF6 A4 DOA>9 EEG8AOI >4C<F4?B6, KFB CB6OL49F <I
>BA>GD9AFBECBEB5ABEFP.
%DB> >D98<FB64A<S 54A>4@< CD96OL49F EDB> H<D@9AAOI >D98<FB6: 6
BEAB6AB@ QFB ED98A9- < 8B?7BEDBKAO9 EEG8O. 4A>< CD< QFB@ @B7GF
BF>DO64FP >D98<FAO9 ?<A<< 8?S <ABEFD4AAOI ;49@M<>B6 A4 BC?4FG
73
;4>GC?9AAOI FB64DB6 EDB>B@ A4 15 < 5B?99 ?9F. %97B8AS CD< CBEF46>4I
<A69EF<J<BAAOI FB64DB6, >4> CD46<?B, ;4>?RK49FES 8B7B6BD,
CD98GE@4FD<64RM<= 6OC?4FG 464AE4 6 D4;@9D9 5% CDB84:AB= J9AO CD<
97B ;4>?RK9A<< < 10% — CD< BEGM9EF6?9A<< CBEF46B>. "EF46L<9ES 85%
BC?4K<64RFES A4 >D98<FAB= BEAB69. #D9:89 K9@ 54A> CD98BEF46<F >D98<F
6 D4;@9D9 85% CDB84:AB= J9AO, BA B5OKAB FD95G9F CB8F69D:89A<S B
6OC?4F9 15% Q>ECBDF9DG. CD4>F<>9 EB69DL9A<S 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E><I
E89?B> CBKF< 6B 6E9I D4;6<FOI EFD4A4I 64?RFO >D98<FB64A<S < C?4F9:4
EB6C484RF. E?< Q>ECBDF9D CD9D69F <?< CD9>D4F<F 6OCB?A9A<9 FBD7B6B7B
8B7B6BD4, FB >D98<FBD A9 B5S;4A 6B;6D4M4FP A9<ECB?P;B64AAGR K4EFP
>D98<F4. 4A> A9 @B:9F CD9F9A8B64FP < A4 8BEDBKAB9 CB74L9A<9 >D98<F4.
#BE>B?P>G >D98<F CB>GC4F9?R CD98BEF46?S9FES 6 FBKAB@ EBBF69FEF6<< E
>BA>D9FAO@ 8B7B6BDB@, 97B @B:AB <ECB?P;B64FP ?<LP A4 BC?4FG 84AAOI
CBEF46B>, <A4K9 A4DGL49FES BEAB6AB9 B5S;4F9?PEF6B ;49@M<>4.
#D< BC?4F9 CBEF46B> A4 CD4>F<>9 <EIB8SF <; FB7B, KFB >D98<FAO9
ED98EF64 BEF4RFES 6 EFD4A9 CDB846J4, 4 CB>GC4F9?P <@99F A4 A<I CD46B
CD< A4EFGC?9A<< EDB>B6 CB74L9A<S FD95B64A<= CDB846J4.
8B7B6BD9 B >D98<FB64A<< 6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E>B= E89?>< 54A>>D98<FBD @B:9F 5OFP GCB?AB@BK9A E4@BEFBSF9?PAB BC?4K<64FP
8B>G@9AFO, 6OEF46?S9@O9 Q>ECBDF9DB@. CD<AJ<C9 54A> CDB846J4, >4>
CD46<?B, CB?ABEFPR B7D4:849F E95S BF >D98<FAOI D<E>B6 E CB@BMPR
EFD4IB64A<S Q>ECBDFAOI >D98<FB6.
#D< >D98<FB64A<< CB>GC4F9?S 54A> CDB846J4 B5OKAB FD95G9F, KFB5O
54A> CB>GC4F9?S CD98BEF46<? 74D4AF<< CB >D98<FG 6 HBD@9, CB;6B?SRM9=
CB?GK<FP ED98EF64 BF QFB7B 54A>4 CD< CDBEDBK>9 C?4F9:4 ;49@M<>B@.
&4>4S 74D4AF<S 6O849FES B5OKAB 6 6<89 54A>B6E>B= 74D4AF<< (C?4F9:AB=)
<?< 69>E9?PAB7B B5S;4F9?PEF64.
O89?SRF F4>:9 A9E>B?P>B HBD@ >D98<FB6 CB>GC4F9?R:
— >D98<FO CB D4;B6O@ >BAFD4>F4@;
— «>D98<FAO9 ?<A<<»;
— >D98<FO A4 EBBDG:9A<9 CDB@OL?9AAOI <?< 7D4:84AE><I
B5N9>FB6 E CBEF46>B= B5BDG8B64A<S < B>4;4A<9@ GE?G7 CB EFDB<F9?PEF6G,
@BAF4:G < A4?48>9.
«D98<FAO9 ?<A<<» BF>DO64RFES A4 BCD989?9AAGR EG@@G <
CB;6B?SRF >D98<FB64FP CBEF46>< D4;?<KAO@ <@CBDF9D4@ 6 EFD4A9,
CB?GK<6L9= >D98<F. %C9J<4?PAO9 <?< «CDB9>FAO9» EB7?4L9A<S
CD98GE@4FD<64RF >D98<FB64A<9 BCD989?9AAOI B5N9>FB6. ?R5B@ E?GK49
6 CBEF46>4I @B7GF GK4EF6B64FP D4;?<KAO9 H<D@O CB 6O5BDG <@CBDF9D4
(;4>4;K<>4). #D< QFB@ F<C9 >D98<FB64A<S <@CBDF9D @9A99 E6S;4A CD<
BCD989?9A<< CBF9AJ<4?PAOI CBEF46M<>B6.
DG7B= EC9J<H<K9E>B= HBD@B= >D98<FB64A<S CB>GC4F9?S S6?S9FES
74
CDB9>FAB9 H<A4AE<DB64A<9 A4 «59;B5BDBFAB=» BEAB69. #D< F4>B@ F<C9
>D98<FB64A<S 54A> DG>B6B8EF6G9FES A9 EFB?P>B >D98<FBECBEB5ABEFPR
;49@M<>4, E>B?P>B CD<5O?PABEFPR 5G8GM97B B5N9>F4. 4A>->D98<FBD 6
QFB@ E?GK49 @B:9F ;4>D9C<FP ;4 EB5B= CD46B A4 8B?R 6 CDB8G>J<<
5G8GM97B CD98CD<SF<S <?< A4 BCD989?9AAGR K4EFP CD<5O?<
(«>B@C9AE4J<BAAB9 H<A4AE<DB64A<9»).
#DB9>FAB9 >D98<FB64A<9 — CDBJ9EE H<A4AE<DB64A<S CDB9>F4 BF
EF48<< 97B D4;D45BF>< 8B D94?<;4J<<. 1FB BEB5O= 6<8 >D98<FB64A<S, CD<
>BFBDB@ B59EC9K9A<9@ >D98<FAOI D<E>B6 E?G:4F 89A9:AO9 CBFB><,
6B;A<>4RM<9 CD< D94?<;4J<< CDB9>F4. #DB9>FAB9 H<A4AE<DB64A<9
A96B;@B:AB 59; IBDBLB D4;D45BF4AAB= E<EF9@O B59EC9K9A<S D<E>B6.
%GM9EF69AAGR DB?P 6 QFB@ CDBJ9EE9 <7D49F D4ECD989?9A<9 D<E>B6 @9:8G
GK4EFA<>4@< CDB9>F4.
O89?SRFES K9FOD9 EC9J<H<K9E><I GE?B6<S GEC9LAB= D94?<;4J<<
CDB9>FAB7B >D98<FB64A<S:
¾ B5BEAB64A<9 :<;A9ECBEB5ABEF< CDB9>F4 (A9B5IB8<@BEFP <
BEGM9EF6<@BEFP);
¾ GK4EF<9 6 CDB9>F9 BCOFAOI < A489:AOI C4DFA9DB6;
¾ GK9F < D4ECD989?9A<9 6E9I D<E>B6 CDB9>F4;
¾ GD97G?<DB64A<9 CD46B6OI 4EC9>FB6 < D4;D45BF>4 >BA>D9FAOI
E>BBD8<A<DB64AAOI 89=EF6<=.
%GM9EF6GRF FD< 6<84 CDB9>FAB7B >D98<FB64A<S:
¾ >D98<FB64A<9 E CD46B@ CB?AB7B D97D9EE4 (6 QFB@ E?GK49
>D98<FB64A<9 @B:AB D4EJ9A<64FP >4> >BDCBD4F<6AB9, F.9. ED98A9- <
8B?7BEDBKAO= >D98<F);
¾ >D98<FB64A<9 E CD46B@ K4EF<KAB7B D97D9EE4 (<A69EFBDO <@9RF
B7D4A<K9AAB9 CD46B C9D9ABE4 A4 ;49@M<>B6 BF69FEF69AABEF< ;4
A9E6B96D9@9AAB9 CB74L9A<9 >D98<F4);
¾ >D98<FB64A<9 59; CD464 D97D9EE4 (>D98<FBDO A9 CD98NS6?SRF
A<>4><I FD95B64A<= > <A<J<4FBD4@ CDB9>F4).
#DB9>FAB9 H<A4AE<DB64A<9 6 $BEE<< — QFB CDB8G>F, EBK9F4RM<=
@9I4A<;@O >?4EE<K9E>B7B CDB9>FAB7B H<A4AE<DB64A<S < ED98A9EDBKAB7B
>BDCBD4F<6AB7B >D98<FB64A<S.
4. <;<A7 >4> HBD@4 @9:8GA4DB8AB7B <A69EF<DB64A<S.
@9:8GA4DB8AB= CD4>F<>9 D4;?<K4RF BC9D4F<6AO= < H<A4AEB6O=
?<;<A7.
"C9D4F<6AO= ?<;<A7 CB8D4;G@9649F C9D984KG 6 CB?P;B64A<9
<@GM9EF64 A4 EDB>, >BFBDO= @9APL9 CDB8B?:<F9?PABEF< :<;A9AAB7B
J<>?4 <;89?<S. BAFD4>F D4EEK<F4A, >4> CD46<?B, A4 3-5 ?9F <
I4D4>F9D<;G9FES A9CB?AB= 4@BDF<;4J<9= B5BDG8B64A<S ;4 6D9@S 4D9A8O.
#BE?9 <EF9K9A<S EDB>4 B5BDG8B64A<9 @B:9F EF4FP B5N9>FB@ AB6B7B
?<;<A7B6B7B >BAFD4>F4 <?< 6B;6D4M49FES 4D9A8B84F9?R. "5OKAB 6
75
BC9D4F<6AO= ?<;<A7 E849FES EFDB<F9?PA4S F9IA<>4 (>D4AO, Q>E>464FBDO <
F.8.), FD4AECBDF, 1 < 8D.
(<A4AEB6O= ?<;<A7 I4D4>F9D<;G9FES 8?<F9?PAO@ EDB>B@ >BAFD4>F4
(BF 5 8B 10 ?9F) < 4@BDF<;4J<9= 6E9= <?< 5B?PL9= K4EF< EFB<@BEF< B5BDG-
8B64A<S. (4>F<K9E>< H<A4AEB6O= ?<;<A7 CD98EF46?S9F EB5B= HBD@G
8B?7BEDBKAB7B >D98<FB64A<S CB>GC><. #B <EF9K9A<< EDB>4 89=EF6<S
H<A4AEB6B7B ?<;<A7B6B7B >BAFD4>F4 4D9A84FBD @B:9F 69DAGFP B5N9>F
4D9A8O, CDB8?<FP EB7?4L9A<9 <?< ;4>?RK<FP AB6B9, 4 F4>:9 >GC<FP
B5N9>F ?<;<A74 CB BEF4FBKAB= EFB<@BEF< (B5OKAB BA4 ABE<F K<EFB
E<@6B?<K9E><= I4D4>F9D). #B B5N9>F4@ E89?B> ?<;<A7 CB8D4;89?S9FES A4
?<;<A7 86<:<@B7B < A986<:<@B7B <@GM9EF64. #D< ?<;<A79
A986<:<@BEF< 4D9A8B84F9?P EFDB<F <?< CB>GC49F A986<:<@BEFP CB
CBDGK9A<R 4D9A84FBD4 < CD98BEF46?S9F 9@G 99 6 CB?P;B64A<9 6
>B@@9DK9E><I < CDB<;6B8EF69AAOI J9?SI. 4> < 6 E89?>4I E 86<:<@O@
<@GM9EF6B@, >BAFD4>F ;4>?RK49FES B5OKAB A4 EDB>, @9APL<= <?< D46AO=
4@BDF<;4J<BAAB@G C9D<B8G B5N9>F4; 4D9A84FBD A9E9F 6E9 D<E><, D4EIB8O
< A4?B7< 6B 6D9@S 89=EF6<S >BAFD4>F4. #B BFABL9A<R > 4D9A8G9@B@G
<@GM9EF6G @B:AB 6O89?<FP 8B7B6BD K<EFB7B ?<;<A74, >B784
8BCB?A<F9?PAO9 D4EIB8O CB B5E?G:<64A<R 4D9A8G9@B7B <@GM9EF64
59D9F A4 E95S 4D9A84FBD, < 8B7B6BD CB?AB7B ?<;<A74, CB >BFBDB@G
4D9A8B84F9?P 59D9F A4 E95S F9IA<K9E>B9 B5E?G:<64A<9 < 8DG7<9 D4EIB8O,
E6S;4AAO9 E <ECB?P;B64A<9@ B5N9>F4 E89?><. EIB8S <; BEB59AABEF9=
BD74A<;4J<< BFABL9A<= @9:8G ;49@M<>B@ < E84RM<@ 6A49@ 6O89?S9FES
CDS@B= ?<;<A7, >B784 <;7BFB6<F9?P <?< 6?489?9J <@GM9EF64 6OEFGC49F 6
>4K9EF69 ?<J4, E84RM97B 97B 6 4D9A8G, < >BE69AAO=, CD< >BFBDB@ E84K4 6
4D9A8G 6989FES K9D9; FD9FP9 ?<JB. #B @9FB8G H<A4AE<DB64A<S D4;?<K49FES
EDBKAO= ?<;<A7, CD< >BFBDB@ BEGM9EF6?S9FES B8ABD4;B64S 4D9A84, <
6B;B5AB6?S9@O= (D96B?P69DAO=), CD< >BFBDB@ 8B7B6BD ?<;<A74
CDB8B?:49FES CB <EF9K9A<< C9D6B7B EDB>4 >BAFD4>F4. !4 CD4>F<>9
CD<@9ASRFES < 8DG7<9 6<8O ?<;<A74.
B;6D4FAO= ?<;<A7 (lease-back) ;4>?RK49FES 6 CDB84:9
CDB@OL?9AAO@ CD98CD<SF<9@ K4EF< 97B EB5EF69AAB7B <@GM9EF64
?<;<A7B6B= >B@C4A<< E B8AB6D9@9AAO@ CB8C<E4A<9@ 8B7B6BD4 B 97B
4D9A89. F4>B= BC9D4J<< GK4EF6GRF FB?P>B 4D9A84FBD <@GM9EF64
(5O6L<= 6?489?9J) < ?<;<A7B64S >B@C4A<S (AB6O= 6?489?9J). &4>4S
E89?>4 849F 6B;@B:ABEFP CD98CD<SF<R CB?GK<FP 89A9:AO9 ED98EF64 ;4
EK9F CDB84:< ED98EF6 CDB<;6B8EF64, A9 CD9>D4M4S <I Q>EC?G4F4J<<, <
<ECB?P;B64FP <I 8?S AB6OI >4C<F4?PAOI 6?B:9A<=. $9AF459?PABEFP
84AAB= BC9D4J<< 5G89F F9@ 6OL9, K9@ 8BIB8O BF AB6OI <A69EF<J<=
5B?PL9 EG@@O 4D9A8AOI C?4F9:9=. "C9D4J<< 6B;6D4FAB7B ?<;<A74
6O;O64RF G@9APL9A<9 54?4AE4 CD98CD<SF<S, F4> >4> BA< 698GF >
<;@9A9A<R EB5EF69AA<>4 <@GM9EF64. F4>B= E89?>9 @B:AB CD<5974FP <
76
FB784, >B784 G CD98CD<SF<S 8B6B?PAB A<;><= GDB69AP 8BIB8B6 <,
E?98B64F9?PAB, BAB A9 @B:9F CB?ABEFPR 6BECB?P;B64FPES ?P7BF4@< CB
GE>BD9AAB= 4@BDF<;4J<< < A4?B7BB5?B:9A<R CD<5O?<. "AB EB69DL49F
E89?>G, < ?<;<A7B64S >B@C4A<S CB?GK49F 97B A4?B7B6O9 ?P7BFO. BF69F
BA4 EA<:49F EF46>G 4D9A8AB= C?4FO. &4> >4> K4EFB ?<;<A7B6B= >B@C4A<<
A9 I64F49F EB5EF69AAOI ED98EF6 8?S BEGM9EF6?9A<S ?<;<A7B6OI BC9D4J<=,
BA4 @B:9F <I CD<6?9>4FP. &4>4S BC9D4J<S CB?GK<?4 A4;64A<9 ?<;<A74 E
8BCB?A<F9?PAO@ CD<6?9K9A<9@ ED98EF6. #B8EK<F4AB, KFB E6OL9 85%
6E9I ?<;<A7B6OI E89?B> S6?SRFES ?<;<A7B@ E CD<6?9K9A<9@ ED98EF6.
D9A8B84F9?P 59D9F 8B?7BEDBKAGR EEG8G G B8AB7B <?< A9E>B?P><I
>D98<FBDB6 A4 EG@@G 8B 80% EFB<@BEF< E84649@OI 6 4D9A8G 4>F<6B6 (59;
CD464 D97D9EE4 A4 4D9A84FBD4), CD<K9@ 4D9A8AO9 C?4F9:< < B5BDG8B64A<9
E?G:4F B59EC9K9A<9@ EEG8O.
+4EFB ?<;<A7 BEGM9EF6?S9FES A9 A4CDS@GR, 4 K9D9; CBED98A<>4.
"EAB6AB= 4D9A8B84F9?P CB?GK49F CD9<@GM9EF69AAB9 CD46B A4 CB?GK9A<9
4D9A8AOI C?4F9:9=. 8B7B6BD9 B5OKAB B5GE?B6?<649FES, KFB 6 E?GK49
54A>DBFEF64 FD9FP97B ;69A4 (CBED98A<>4) 4D9A8A4S C?4F4 5G89F CBEFGC4FP
BEAB6AB@G 4D9A8B84F9?R A9CBED98EF69AAB. #B8B5AO9 E89?>< CB?GK<?<
A4;64A<9 «EG5?<;<A7». $4;AB6<8ABEFPR ?<;<A74 EF4?< E89?>< «845? 8<A»,
CD<@9AS9@O9 6 @9:8GA4DB8AB= EH9D9. I E@OE? ;4>?RK49FES 6
>B@5<A4J<< A4?B7B6OI 6O7B8 6 86GI < 5B?99 EFD4A4I. CBE?98A99 6D9@S
CB?GK<?4 D4ECDBEFD4A9A<9 CD4>F<>4 ;4>?RK9A<S EB7?4L9A<S @9:8G
CDB<;6B8<F9?S@< B5BDG8B64A<S < ?<;<A7B6O@< >B@C4A<S@<.
EBBF69FEF6<< E QF<@< EB7?4L9A<S@< CDB<;6B8<F9?P BF ?<J4 ?<;<A7B6B=
>B@C4A<< CD98?4749F >?<9AF4@ H<A4AE<DB64A<9 CBEF46B> E6B9=
CDB8G>J<< E CB@BMPR ?<;<A74. &4><@ B5D4;B@, ?<;<A7B64S >B@C4A<S
<ECB?P;G9F FBD7B6GR E9FP CBEF46M<>4, 4 CBEF46M<> D4EL<DS9F 7D4A<JO
E5OF4 CDB8G>J<<. 1FB E89?><, CB?GK<6L<9 A4;64A<9 «CB@BMP 6
CDB84:9» (sales-aid). #D< CBEFBSAAB@ < F9EAB@ EBFDG8A<K9EF69
CD98CD<SF<= E ?<;<A7B6O@< >B@C4A<S@< 6B;@B:AB ;4>?RK9A<9
EB7?4L9A<= CB CD98BEF46?9A<R «?<;<A7B6B= ?<A<<» (lease-line). 1F<
EB7?4L9A<S 4A4?B7<KAO 54A>B6E><@ >D98<FAO@ ?<A<S@ < CB;6B?SRF
4D9A84FBDG 5D4FP 8BCB?A<F9?PAB9 B5BDG8B64A<9 6 ?<;<A7 59; ;4>?RK9A<S
>4:8O= D4; AB6B7B >BAFD4>F4.
%FB<@BEFP ?<;<A74 @B:9F 5OFP A<:9 <?< D46AB= EFB<@BEF< EEG8O
FB?P>B CD< A4?<K<< BCD989?9AAOI A4?B7B6OI ?P7BF. E?<
CD98CD<A<@4F9?P <@99F 6O5BD (?<5B >GC<FP B5BDG8B64A<9 E CB@BMPR
EEG8O, ?<5B 6;SFP 97B 6 ?<;<A7), FB 9@G A9B5IB8<@B ED46A<FP ;4FD4FO CB
>4:8B@G ECBEB5G >D98<FB64A<S. QFB@ E?GK49 A9<;59:AB 6B;A<>49F
6BCDBE B CD<AJ<C9, <EIB8S <; >BFBDB7B 8B?:AB CDB<;6B8<FPES ED46A9A<9,
F4> >4> C?4F9:< B8<A4>B6OI D4;@9DB6, AB D4;?<KAO9 CB 6D9@9A< EB6E9@
A9 B8AB;A4KAO. &4><@ CD<AJ<CB@ EF4AB6<FES H<A4AEB64S
77
Q>6<64?9AFABEFP C?4F9:9=. 1>6<64?9AFAO@< EK<F4RFES F4><9 C?4F9:<,
>BFBDO9, 5G8GK< CD<6989AAO@< > B8AB@G < FB@G :9 @B@9AFG 6D9@9A<,
D46AO. #DBJ9EE CD<6989A<S A4;O64RF 8<E>BAF<DB64A<9@, 4 CB?GK9AAGR
EG@@G — K<EFB= F9>GM9= EFB<@BEFPR (net present value). @<DB6B=
CD4>F<>9 CD< BCD989?9A<< K<EFB= F9>GM9= EFB<@BEF< C?4F9:9=
<ECB?P;G9FES E?98GRM4S HBD@G?4 8<E>BAF<DB64A<S:
&% = % I
t
789 &% — F9>GM4S EFB<@BEFP;
% — 5G8GM4S EFB<@BEFP;
t — >BQHH<J<9AF 8<E>BAF<DB64A<S.
Kt=1/(1+E)
t-1
,
789 — ABD@4F<6 CD<6989A<S 6B 6D9@9A< (CDBJ9AF
8<E>BAF<DB64A<S);
t — AB@9D 7B84 D4EK9FAB7B C9D<B84.
?S ED46A9A<S 86GI 64D<4AFB6 H<A4AE<DB64A<S 6 >4:8B@ E?GK49
CB8EK<FO649FES K<EF4S F9>GM4S EFB<@BEFP. B-C9D6OI, A9B5IB8<@B
GK9EFP A4?B7B6O9 ?P7BFO. B-6FBDOI, 9E?< B5N9>F A9 A4IB8<FES 6
EB5EF69AABEF<, FB A9?P;S <ECB?P;B64FP 4@BDF<;4J<BAAO9 ?P7BFO. FD9FP<I, CD< CB>GC>9 B5N9>F4 H<D@4 8B?:A4 BC?4F<FP D4EIB8O CB
F9IB5E?G:<64A<R (6B @AB7<I EFD4A4I QF< D4EIB8O 6OK<F4RFES <;
A4?B7BB5?4749@B= CD<5O?<), 4 CD< CD98BEF46?9A<< B5N9>F4 6 ?<;<A7 QFB
BCD989?S9FES >BA>D9FAO@ EB7?4L9A<9@. -K9F69DFOI, F4> >4> B5N9>F A9
CD<A48?9:<F 4D9A84FBDG, BA F9DS9F CD46B A4 BEF4FBKAGR EFB<@BEFP.
$4EK9FO, 4, E?98B64F9?PAB, < CD<ASFB9 D9L9A<9 6B @AB7B@ ;46<ESF BF
FB7B, >4>B= 5G89F 6O5D4A CDBJ9AF 8<E>BAF<DB64A<S.
<;<A7 — BC9D4J<S, BF?<K4RM4SES 8B6B?PAB E?B:AB=
BD74A<;4J<9=. B @AB7<I E89?>4I <@9RF @9EFB >4> @<A<@G@ FD<
>BAFD4>F4:
— @9:8G 4D9A84FBDB@ < 4D9A8B84F9?9@;
— @9:8G CBEF46M<>B@ < 4D9A8B84F9?9@;
— @9:8G 4D9A8B84F9?9@ < 97B 54A>B@.
"5OKAB C9D98 A4K4?B@ E89?>< >?<9AF4 FM4F9?PAB <;GK4RF, KFB
CD98CB?4749F:
— BJ9A>G 97B ECBEB5ABEF< 6OC?4F<FP 4D9A8AO9 C?4F9:< (<EIB8S
<; CD9864D<F9?PAOI 8BIB8B6 BF <ECB?P;B64A<S 4D9A8G9@B7B
B5BDG8B64A<S);
— BJ9A>G FB64DB6 (ECDBE A4 A<I E FBK>< ;D9A<S 6B;@B:AB=
C9D9CDB84:<).
#D< @9:8GA4DB8AB@ ?<;<A79 BEB59AAB 64:AO: 6O5BD 64?RFO
>BAFD4>F4, BJ9A>4 D<E>4 <;@9A9A<S >GDE4 64?RFO, F4@B:9AAO= D9:<@
4D9A84FBD4, A4?B7 A4 H<D@G, CD<@9AS9@O= > 4D9A8B84F9?R, A4?<K<9
EB7?4L9A<= B A9CD<@9A9A<< 86B=AB7B A4?B7BB5?B:9A<S @9:8G EFD4A4@<,
78
;4M<F4 CD464 EB5EF69AABEF< <ABEFD4AAB7B 4D9A8B84F9?S 6 EFD4A9
4D9A84FBD4.
#D< ?<;<A79 E 8BCB?A<F9?PAO@ CD<6?9K9A<9@ ED98EF6 BEB59AAB
BEFDB 6EF4RF 6BCDBEO ;4?B7B6B7B CD464, EFD4IB64A<S, D4;?<KAB7B DB84
74D4AF<=. 4:AO F4>:9 6BCDBEO CD98BEF46?9A<S F9IA<K9E><I 74D4AF<=
CDB<;6B8<F9?9@.
5. (4>FBD<A7 < HBDH9=F<A7 — <AEFDG@9AFO >D98<FB64A<S
6A9LA9Q>BAB@<K9E>B= 89SF9?PABEF< CD98CD<SF<=.
AB7<9 DBEE<=E><9 CD98CD<SF<S 6 F9K9A<9 8?<F9?PAB7B 6D9@9A<
EF4?><64?<EP E A9I64F>B= B5BDBFAOI ED98EF6; D4EFGM<@< D<E>4@<
>D98<FB64A<S; 6OEB>B= 895<FBDE>B= ;48B?:9AABEFPR; DBEFB@
A9C?4F9:9=.
%CD46<FPES E QF<@< FDG8ABEFS@< CB@B:9F H4>FBD<A7 — B8<A <;
E4@OI C9DEC9>F<6AOI 6<8B6 54A>B6E><I GE?G7.
(4>FBD<A7 S6?S9FES A4<5B?99 D<E>B64AAO@ 6<8B@ 54A>B6E>B7B
5<;A9E4, AB 6@9EF9 E F9@ 6OEB>BCD<5O?PAO@, QHH9>F<6AO@ BDG8<9@
H<A4AEB6B7B @4D>9F<A74, B8AB= <; HBD@ <AF97D<DB64A<S 54A>B6E><I
BC9D4J<=, >BFBDO9 A4<5B?99 CD<ECBEB5?9AO > EB6D9@9AAO@ CDBJ9EE4@
D4;6<F<S Q>BAB@<><. &9D@<A «H4>FBD<A7» CDB<EIB8<F BF 4A7?<=E>B7B
E?B64 factor — CBED98A<>, 479AF.
(4>FBD<A7 — CD<B5D9F9A<9 CD464 A4 6;OE>4A<9 8B?7B6, A4
C9D9CDB84:G FB64DB6 < GE?G7, CBE?98GRM<@ CB?GK9A<9@ C?4F9:9= CB
A<@. #D< QFB@ D9KP <89F, >4> CD46<?B, B >D4F>BEDBKAOI FD95B64A<SI.
DG7<@< E?B64@<, H4>FBD<A7 S6?S9FES D4;AB6<8ABEFPR CBED98A<K9E>B=
89SF9?PABEF<, CD< >BFBDB= H<D@4-CBED98A<> (H4>FBD<A7B64S >B@C4A<S)
;4 BCD989?9AAGR C?4FG CB?GK49F BF CD98CD<SF<S CD46B 6;OE><64FP <
;4K<E?SFP A4 97B EK9F CD<K<F4RM<9ES 9@G BF CB>GC4F9?9= EG@@O (CD46B
<A>4EE<DB64FP 895<FBDE>GR ;48B?:9AABEFP). "8AB6D9@9AAB E QF<@
CBED98A<> >D98<FG9F B5BDBFAO= >4C<F4? >?<9AF4 < CD<A<@49F A4 E95S 97B
>D98<FAO= < 64?RFAO= D<E><.
DBEE<=E>B@ ;4>BAB84F9?PEF69 CB8 H4>FBD<A7B@ CBA<@4RF 8B7B6BD
H<A4AE<DB64A<S CB8 GEFGC>G 89A9:AB7B FD95B64A<S. 1FB 8B7B6BD, CB
>BFBDB@G B8A4 EFBDBA4 (H<A4AEB6O= 479AF) C9D9849F <?< B5S;G9FES
C9D984FP 8DG7B= EFBDBA9 (>?<9AFG) 89A9:AO9 ED98EF64 6 EK9F 89A9:AB7B
FD95B64A<S >?<9AF4 (>D98<FBD4) > FD9FP9@G ?<JG (8B?:A<>G),
6OF9>4RM97B <; CD98BEF46?9A<S >?<9AFB@ FB64DB6, 6OCB?A9A<S <@ D45BF
<?< B>4;4A<S GE?G7 FD9FP9@G ?<JG, 4 >?<9AF GEFGC49F <?< B5S;G9FES
GEFGC<FP H<A4AEB6B@G 479AFG QFB 89A9:AB9 FD95B64A<9. 9A9:AB9
FD95B64A<9 > 8B?:A<>G @B:9F 5OFP GEFGC?9AB >?<9AFB@ H<A4AEB6B@G
479AFG F4>:9 6 J9?SI B59EC9K9A<S <ECB?A9A<S B5S;4F9?PEF64 >?<9AF4
C9D98 H<A4AEB6O@ 479AFB@. "5S;4F9?PEF64 H<A4AEB6B7B 479AF4 CB
8B7B6BDG @B7GF 6>?RK4FP 6989A<9 8?S >?<9AF4 5GI74?F9DE>B7B GK9F4, 4
79
F4>:9 CD98BEF46?9A<9 >?<9AFG <AOI H<A4AEB6OI GE?G7, E6S;4AAOI E
89A9:AO@< FD95B64A<S@<, S6?SRM<@<ES CD98@9FB@ GEFGC><. >4K9EF69
H<A4AEB6B7B 479AF4 8B7B6BD H<A4AE<DB64A<S CB8 GEFGC>G 89A9:AB7B
FD95B64A<S @B7GF ;4>?RK4FP 54A>< < <AO9 >D98<FAO9 BD74A<;4J<<, 4
F4>:9 8DG7<9 >B@@9DK9E><9 BD74A<;4J<<, <@9RM<9 D4;D9L9A<9
(?<J9A;<R) A4 BEGM9EF6?9A<9 89SF9?PABEF< F4>B7B 6<84.
#D98@9FB@ GEFGC><, CB8 >BFBDGR CD98BEF46?S9FES H<A4AE<DB64A<9,
@B:9F 5OFP >4> 89A9:AB9 FD95B64A<9, EDB> C?4F9:4 CB >BFBDB@G G:9
A4EFGC<? (EGM9EF6GRM99 FD95B64A<9), F4> < CD46B A4 CB?GK9A<9
89A9:AOI ED98EF6, >BFBDB9 6B;A<>A9F 6 5G8GM9@ (5G8GM99 FD95B64A<9).
9A9:AB9 FD95B64A<9, S6?SRM99ES CD98@9FB@ GEFGC><, 8B?:AB 5OFP
BCD989?9AB 6 8B7B6BD9 >?<9AF4 E H<A4AEB6O@ 479AFB@ F4><@ B5D4;B@,
KFB5O CB;6B?S?B <89AF<H<J<DB64FP EGM9EF6GRM99 FD95B64A<9 6 @B@9AF
;4>?RK9A<S 8B7B6BD4, 4 5G8GM99 FD95B64A<9 — A9 CB;8A99 K9@ 6 @B@9AF
97B 6B;A<>AB69A<S. 1FBF F<C 8B7B6BD4, L<DB>B CD<@9AS9@O= 6
@9:8GA4DB8AB= CD4>F<>9 CB8 A4;64A<9@ H4>FBD<A7, 6 $( 6C9D6O9
CB?GK<? ;4>D9C?9A<9 6 K4EF< 6FBDB= AB6B7B D4:84AE>B7B >B89>E4 $(.
(4>FBD<A7B6O9 BC9D4J<< 6B;A<>?< A4 BEAB69 >B@@9DK9E>B7B
>D98<F4, >BFBDO= CD98BEF46?S9FES CDB846J4@< CB>GC4F9?S@ 6 6<89
BFEDBK>< C?4F9:4 ;4 CDB84AAO9 FB64DO. ;@9A9A<9 FD95B64A<= >
D4EK9F4@ E FBK>< ;D9A<S GE>BD9A<S B5BDBF4 ED98EF6 6O;64?B
A9B5IB8<@BEFP 8?S CBEF46M<>B6 <E>4FP CGF< D9L9A<S CDB5?9@O
895<FBDE>B= ;48B?:9AABEF<. (4>FBD<A7 S6?S9FES ED46A<F9?PAB AB6B=
QHH9>F<6AB= E<EF9@B= G?GKL9A<S ?<>6<8ABEF< < G@9APL9A<S
H<A4AEB6B7B D<E>4 CD< BD74A<;4J<< C?4F9:9=. B@@9DK9E><9 54A><, D4;6<64S QF< BC9D4J<<, 8BCB?ASRF <I Q?9@9AF4@< 5GI74?F9DE>B7B, <AHBD@4J<BAAB7B, D9>?4@AB7B, E5OFB6B7B, RD<8<K9E>B7B, EFD4IB6B7B < 8DG7<I
6<8B6 B5E?G:<64A<S >?<9AFB6. 1FB CB;6B?S9F D4EL<DSFP >DG7 >?<9AFB6
54A>4, GE<?<64FP E6S;P E A<@<, G69?<K<64FP CD<5O?P 54A>4 ;4 EK9F
D4EL<D9A<S BC9D4J<=.
EBBF69FEF6<< E BA69AJ<9= B @9:8GA4DB8AB@ H4>FBD<A79,
CD<ASFB= 6 1988 7B8G 9:8GA4DB8AO@ <AEF<FGFB@ GA<H<>4J<< K4EFAB7B
CD464, BC9D4J<S EK<F49FES H4>FBD<A7B@, 9E?< G8B6?9F6BDS9F >4> @<A<@G@
86G@ <; K9FOD9I CD<;A4>B6 (A4?<K<9 >D98<FB64A<S 6 HBD@9
CD9864D<F9?PAB= BC?4FO 8B?7B6OI FD95B64A<=; 6989A<9 5GI74?F9DE>B7B
GK9F4 CBEF46M<>4, CD9:89 6E97B GK9F4 D94?<;4J<<; <A>4EE<DB64A<9 97B
;48B?:9AABEF<; EFD4IB64A<9 CBEF46M<>4 BF >D98<FAB7B D<E>4). @9EF9 E
F9@ 6 DS89 EFD4A > H4>FBD<A7G CB- CD9:A9@G BFABESF < GK9F EK9FB6H4>FGD — BC9D4J<R, G8B6?9F6BDSRMGR ?<LP B8AB@G, C9D6B@G <;
G>4;4AAOI CD<;A4>B6.
(<A4AEB6O9 <AEF<FGFO, >BFBDO9 CD98BEF46?SRF H4>FBD<A7B6O9
80
GE?G7<, A4;O64RFES H4>FBD-H<D@4@<. "A< EB;84RFES >DGCA9=L<@<
54A>4@< (<?< E4@< 54A>< 6OCB?ASRF HGA>J<< H4>FBD-H<D@), KFB
B59EC9K<649F 6OEB>GR A489:ABEFP H4>FBD<A7B6OI E89?B> < @<A<@4?PAO9
<;89D:>< 8?S >?<9AFB6. $4;69F6?9AA4S E9FP EC9J<4?<;<DB64AAOI
H<?<4?B6 8?S H4>FBD<A7B6B7B B5E?G:<64A<S CD98CD<SF<= 6 D4;?<KAOI
EFD4A4I EB;84A4 >DGCAO@< FD4AEA4J<BA4?PAO@< >BDCBD4J<S@<. !4
@9:8GA4DB8AB@ GDB6A9 89=EF6G9F 4EEBJ<4J<S «(Q>FBD; K9=A <AF9DAQL?»,
K?9A4@< >BFBDB= S6?SRFES 95% H4>FBD<A7B6OI >B@C4A<= <; 40 EFD4A
@<D4.
BC9D4J<< H4>FBD<A74 B5OKAB GK4EF6GRF FD< ?<J4: H4>FBD (54A>)
— CB>GC4F9?P FD95B64A<S, C9D6BA4K4?PAO= >D98<FBD (>?<9AF) < 8B?:A<>,
CB?GK<6L<= BF >?<9AF4 FB64DO E BFEDBK>B= C?4F9:4.
CBE?98A99 6D9@S @9:8GA4DB8AO@< H4>FBD<A7B6O@< BC9D4J<S@<
;4<AF9D9EB64?<EP @AB7<9 >DGCAO9 DBEE<=E><9 54A><.
@9:8GA4DB8AB= FBD7B6?9 CD<@9AS9FES K9FOD9 @B89?<
H4>FBD<A74:
¾ 86GIH4>FBDAO=;
¾ CDS@B= <@CBDFAO=;
¾ CDS@B= Q>ECBDFAO=;
¾ «5Q>-FG-5Q>» (back-to-back).
6GIH4>FBDA4S @B89?P CB;6B?S9F D4;89?<FP HGA>J<< < D<E>< @9:8G
<@CBDF-H4>FBDB@, D4ECB?B:9AAO@ 6 EFD4A9 <@CBDF9D4, < Q>ECBDFH4>FBDB@, D4ECB?B:9AAO@ 6 EFD4A9 Q>ECBDF9D4. ?46A4S J9?P QFB= @B89?<
— B59EC9K<FP H<A4AE<DB64A<9 8B 100% < G@9APL<FP A4>?48AO9 D4EIB8O
6 48@<A<EFD4F<6AB= EH9D9.
К?4EE<K9E>4S 86GIH4>FBDA4S EI9@4 EBEFB<F <; E?98GRM<I QF4CB6:
1. 4CDBE ?<@<F4/B59EC9K9A<9 D<E>B6.
2. #BEF46>4/D4EEO?>4 H4>FGDO.
3. (<A4AE<DB64A<9.
4. "C?4F4.
4 C9D6B@ QF4C9 Q>ECBDF9D ;4CD4L<649F G E6B97B Q>ECBDF-H4>FBD4
EG@@G, CB8?9:4MGR B59EC9K9A<R. 1>ECBDF-H4>FBD ;4CD4L<649F G
<@CBDF-H4>FBD4 FD95G9@O= ?<@<F. @CBDF-H4>FBD CDB69DS9F <@CBDF9D4
< CD98BEF46?S9F Q>ECBDF-H4>FBDG 74D4AF<<. 4?99 Q>ECBDF-H4>FBD 849F
Q>ECBDF9DG D4;D9L9A<9 A4 ?<@<F, CBE?9 K97B BEGM9EF6?S9FES CDB84:4
8B>G@9AFB6.
4 6FBDB@ QF4C9 Q>ECBDF9D CBEF46?S9F FB64D <?< GE?G7G < C9D9849F
>BC<R EK9F4 Q>ECBDF-H4>FBDG, 4 FBF CBEO?49F 99 <@CBDF-H4>FBDG.
"8AB6D9@9AAB E FB64DB@ Q>ECBDF9D A4CD46?S9F <@CBDF9DG EK9F E
CB@9F>4@< B C9D9GEFGC>9.
Соседние файлы в предмете [НЕСОРТИРОВАННОЕ]