Добавил:
Sekretar
kiopkiopkiop18@yandex.ru
t.me/Prokururor I Вовсе не секретарь, но почту проверяю
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз:
Предмет:
Файл:Ординатура / Хирургия / Библиотека им академика М.И. Перельмана / Книга_4437_Библиотеки_им_академика_М_И_Перельмана
.pdf
356
M. Sakr
Fig. 13.14 CT neck showing right-sided thyroid neoplastic lesion with query invasion of paravertebral
muscles
Fig. 13.15 CT neck showing enlarged right upper deep
cervical LN (level II)
Limitations
Both CT scan and MRI are relatively expensive
and have a limited role in the initial evaluation of
thyroid nodules as they have a limited ability in
distinguishing benign from malignant lesions.
However, they are necessary in some cases to
determine the staging and extent of the disease
and in planning surgery since CT scan can pro-
Fig. 13.16 CT neck showing enlarged left middle deep
cervical LN (level III)
Fig. 13.17 CT neck showing enlarged right middle deep
cervical LN (level III) (blue arrow), prelaryngeal (Delphic)
LN (level VI) (orange arrow), and goiter (green arrow)
vide structural information about the gland and
its relationship to adjacent structures as well as
detection of cervical LNs with high sensitivity
[179]. Unlike contrast media used with CT scan,
contrast media (Gadolinium) used in MRI does
not inuence thyroid function.
13.3.8.5 Positron Emission
Tomography (PET)
18F-2-uoro-2-deoxy-d-glucose-positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) and PET-CT are
nuclear medicine imaging tests that use a small
amount of radiolabeled glucose to identify can-
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

13 Malignant Thyroid Disease
Fig. 13.18 CT neck showing bilateral enlarged middle
deep cervical LN (level III) (arrows)
cer. Since cancer cells are more metabolically
active than normal cells, the cancer cells take up
more of the radiolabeled glucose than normal
cells and show up on the FDG-PET scan. FDGPET scans are frequently combined with computerized tomography (CT) scans (PET-CT) to
accurately identify where in the body a cancer is
located.
A recent meta-analysis conrmed that approximately one-third 18FDG-PET positive thyroid
nodules proved to be cancerous [180], with
higher mean maximum standardized uptake
value in malignant compared to benign nodules
(6.9 vs. 4.8, P<0.001).
13.3.8.6 Fine-Needle Aspiration
Cytology (FNAC)
In malignant conditions of LNs, US- or
CT-guided FNA enjoys a high sensitivity and
specicity, the average being 95% [181–187]. It
virtually has eliminated the need for open biopsy
of metastatic cervical lymphadenopathy and the
sequela of violating tissue planes prior to denite treatment [185, 186]. In addition, FNA is
quite helpful in differentiating metastatic squamous cell adenopathy from metastatic thyroid
malignancy and even from enlarged LNs secondary to lympho- proliferative and reactive adenopathy [187]. The high sensitivity of FNA for
PTC is strongly correlated with tumor size.
357
Tumors smaller than 0.5 cm and those larger
than 3cm may be more difcult to successfully
aspirate on FNA [188].
Ultrasound (US)-Guided FNA
The use of US-guided FNA can improve the
diagnostic accuracy and should be considered
whenever confronted with a patient whose thyroid nodule is difcult to palpate on physical
examination or in whom the initial FNAB was
nondiagnostic [189]. Still however, interpretation
of the aspirate for denitive diagnosis may still
not be possible.
A study by Yuan etal. on 78 patients, however,
indicated that the patterns of enhancement differ
signicantly between benign and malignant solitary thyroid nodules (STNs) examined with realtime, “contrast-enhanced” US, with most
malignant lesions showing irregular shape,
unclear boundary, and nonhomogeneous and
incomplete enhancement [190]. In addition, the
combination of the newer US techniques with
“molecular markers” now available for FNAB
may be able to accurately distinguish malignant
from benign thyroid nodules.
To date, FNAB remains unpopular in “children” because of their smaller neck sizes, the
need for heavier amounts of anesthesia and sedation, and the amount of specimen needed.
Furthermore, because the higher rates of malignancy in children, denitive pathological diagnosis is much more in demand. Despite of the
difculties associated with FNAB, in a series
involving 41 children, Al-Shaikh et al. reported
100% sensitivity, 86% specicity, and a 59%
decrease in surgery rates [191].
Cytology Categories ofFNAC (Bethesda
System)
The recently issued Bethesda System for
Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (BSRTC)
[192], based on an NCI-sponsored conference
(2007), is currently considered to be the most
suitable for communicating ndings from thyroid
smears. The cytodiagnostic categories of
Besthesda Classication [192], with the corresponding estimated risk of malignancy, are listed
in Table13.8.
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

358
M. Sakr
Table 13.8 The Bethesda system for reporting thyroid
cytopathology recommended diagnostic categories [192]
Risk of
Category Description
I Non-diagnostic or
unsatisfactory: Cyst uid
only—Virtually acellular
specimen, other (obscuring
blood, clotting artifact)
II Benign: Consistent with a benign
follicular nodule, Hashimoto’s
thyroiditis or granulomatous
thyroiditis
III Atypia of undetermined
signicance (AUS) or follicular
lesion of undetermined
signicance (FLUS)
IV Follicular neoplasm (FN) or
suspicious for a follicular
neoplasm (SFN)
V Suspicious for malignancy
(SUSP)
VI Malignant 97–99%
cancer
1–4%
0–3%
5–15%
15–30%
60–75%
13.3.9 Surgery forPTC
13.3.9.1 Elective Surgical Treatment
Management ofthePrimary Tumor
(Thyroid Surgery)
The terms “subtotal lobectomy” and “subtotal
thyroidectomy” are imprecise and should be
avoided. They are inappropriate for the treatment
of thyroid cancer. The following terms should be
used (Table13.9).
The RLNs should be identied and preserved in virtually all instances. Permanent
damage to a RLN should occur in <5% of thyroid cancer but are higher after re-operative surgery [108]. Inltration by cancer contributes to
RLN palsy rates [193]. Attempts should also be
made to preserve the ELN by ligation of the
STA at the capsule of the gland. Injury rates
may be higher than for RLN damage [194]. The
parathyroid glands (PTGs) should whenever
possible be identied and preserved. If their
vascular supply is compromised, the gland/s
should be excised and re- implanted into muscle
[195, 196]. LN dissection (level VI) results in
increased risk of postoperative hypoparathyroidism [197].
Table 13.9 Terms used in thyroid surgery
Term Description
Lobectomy Complete removal of one thyroid
lobe including the isthmus
Near-total
lobectomy
Near-total
thyroidectomy
Total
thyroidectomy
Table 13.10 Levels of lymph nodes in thyroid surgery
Lateral compartment of neck
Level I Submental (Ia) and submandibular
Level II Deep cervical chain skull base to
Level III Deep cervical chain level of hyoid
Level IV Deep chain from cricoid to
Level V Posterior triangle nodes, divided by
Central compartment of neck
Level VI Pretracheal and paratracheal nodes
Mediastinal nodes
Level VII Superior mediastinal nodes superior
Compartment 4
LNs between the brachio-cephalic vein and tracheal
bifurcation within the anterior mediastinum
Total lobectomy leaving behind
only the smallest amount of thyroid
tissue (signicantly <1g) to protect
the RLNs
Complete removal of one thyroid
lobe (lobectomy) with a near-total
lobectomy on the contralateral side
or a bilateral near-total procedure
Removal of both lobes, isthmus,
and pyramidal lobe
nodes (Ib)
hyoid. Divided spinal accessory
nerve to IIa (medial) and IIb
(lateral)
to level of cricoid
supra-sternal notch
omohyoid muscle into Va (above)
and Vb (below)
from hyoid to sternal notch, and to
the carotid arteries laterally
aspect to brachiocephalic vein
Management oftheNodal Spread
The levels of LNs in the thyroid surgery are listed
in Table13.10, and types of neck dissections are
summarized in Table13.11.
Differences exist regarding the procedure of
choice for addressing the neck in PTC, from (1) a
prophylactic ND in a clinically negative neck
[147, 198, 199], to (2) expectant management
with resection limited to palpable LN metastases
that is selective removal or berry picking [200,
201] based on the view that nodal disease is clini-
cally insignicant and unlikely to inuence sur-
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

13 Malignant Thyroid Disease
359
Table 13.11 Types of neck dissection (ND)
Type Description
Selective
neck
dissection
Radical
neck
dissection
(RND)
Modied
RND
(MRND)
Extended
neck
dissection
Cervical lymphadenectomy of less than
levels I–V.The spinal accessory nerve
(SAN), internal jugular vein (IJV) and
sternocleidomastoid muscle (SCM) are
preserved
A classical RND removes all the
lymphatic tissue in levels I–V plus
SAN, SCM, and IJV
Removal of LNs I–V+preservation of
one or more non-lymphatic structures
as follows:
1. MRND type I: Preservation of
the SAN
2. MRND type II: Preservation of
the SAN and IJV
3. MRND type III (functional):
Preservation of the SAN, IJV
and SCM
Removal of one or more additional LN
groups for example Para-pharyngeal,
and superior mediastinal nodes and/or
non-lymphatic structures
vival [202], or (3) a formal comprehensive
dissection of all lateral LNs (MRND) [203–205]
in a clinically positive neck, based on the consensus of the high frequency of occult nodal disease
with reduced recurrence-free survival.
Surgical Decision forTreatment ofPTC
Patients with a node-negative cancer of <1 cm
(pT1) can be adequately treated by lobectomy
[39, 40]. For tumors >1cm, multifocal disease,
extra-thyroidal spread, familial disease, clinically
involved nodes, and children with history of previous neck irradiation, TT is indicated [206].
If the diagnosis of thyroid cancer is made after
thyroid lobectomy and completion (contralateral) lobectomy is required, it should be
offered within 8weeks of histological diagnosis
of cancer.
In patients with no clinical LNs, but who are
high risk (male, >45years, tumors >4cm, extracapsular, or extra-thyroidal disease), TT and central node dissection should be considered [108].
Palpable disease in level VI nodes discovered
at surgery is treated by a level VI node dissection. When suspicious/clinically involved nodes
are apparent preoperatively or are encountered
at surgery in the lateral neck, and conrmed by
needle biopsy or frozen-section, then a selective
neck dissection (levels IIa–Vb) is recommended, preserving the SAN, SCM, and IJV
[207].
Surgery forPapillary (or Follicular)
Micro-carcinoma
Patients with WDTCs <1cm have an extremely
low risk of death from thyroid cancer (0.1%)
[68] and hence can be treated adequately by thyroid lobectomy provided that the tumor does not
extend beyond the thyroid capsule, and there is
no evidence of metastases, vascular invasion,
multifocality, or contralateral disease.
Otherwise, completion of thyroidectomy and
RAI is necessary. Future treatment involves
TSH suppression with thyroxin and measurement of the serum Tg.
13.3.9.2 Emergency Surgery
It is rare for emergency surgery to be needed in
PTC. However, acute presentation of a patient
with thyroid cancer and severe airway compromise requires urgent/immediate surgery.
13.3.9.3 Surgery forLocally Advanced
Disease
When preoperative vocal cord (VC) examination
shows no sign of RLN palsy, every attempt
should be made to dissect the tumor from the
nerve/s. In patients with unilateral nerve involvement and extensive extra-thyroidal disease, the
nerve may have to be sacriced to achieve a curative procedure. It may not be possible to remove
the entire tumor without damaging both RLNs. A
small residue of tumor may be left behind to protect the nerve/s and be subsequently dealt with by
131
I ablation and -thyroxin with or without
EBRT [193].
In individual patients with locally advanced
disease involving the upper aerodigestive tract
and/or one or both RLNs, curative excisional surgery of the tracheal wall and/or esophagus should
be considered. When radical curative surgery is
not possible or agreed to by the patient, treatment
with radical radiotherapy
131
I should be
considered.
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

360
M. Sakr
13.3.10 Prognostic Indicators
In general, survival for patients with PTC is
believed to be relatively good, especially when
compared with that of patients with other thyroid
and non-thyroid malignancies. However, not all
patients with PTC fare well, and one of the major
challenges is to identify patients with poor prognosis to offer more aggressive and efcacious treatment [68].
13.3.10.1 Factors Aecting Prognosis
andSurvival
– Age: Nearly all the deaths from PTCs occur
when the tumor manifests itself after the age
of 40years.
– Gender: Women are said to have a better prog-
nosis than men, although in some series the
difference was not signicant.
– Extra-thyroidal extension: This feature
adversely affects the prognosis in a very signicant manner and has have been incorporated into the staging system of thyroid
carcinoma.
– Microscopic variant: Among the different
variants of PTC, the diffuse sclerosing, tall/
columnar cell, and diffuse follicular variants
have the worst prognosis.
– Poorly differentiated, squamous or anaplastic
foci: These features have a markedly detrimental effect on prognosis. Fortunately, they
are present in <5% of cases.
– History of previous irradiation: Contrary to
previous statements, the prognosis of tumors
in which this antecedent is present does not
seem to differ signicantly from the others.
– Tumor size: A rough inverse correlation is
present between tumor size and prognosis.
– Capsule and margins: Tumors that are encap-
sulated and/or have pushing margins have a
better outcome than the others.
– Multicentricity: Patients in whom this is a
prominent feature have a greater incidence of
metastasis and a lesser chance of disease-free
survival.
– Distant metastases: Prognosis is adversely
affected by metastases to the lungs and is
more inuenced by metastases to other sites,
such as the skeletal system.
– Grading: This parameter bears a denite rela-
tionship with prognosis that has been underestimated. However, it needs to be clearly
dened in terms of criteria (necrosis, mitotic
activity, etc.) and properly standardized for it
to reach its full potential.
– Circulating tumor cells: The presence of cir-
culating tumor cells (as determined with an
RT-PCR assay for thyroglobulin (Tg)
mRNA) seems to be associated with a higher
likelihood of metastatic disease but may not
play a practical role in clinical
management.
13.3.10.2 Prognostic Scales/Scores
– AGES Scale: This is a postoperative prognos-
tic scale originated in Mayo clinic. It is an
acronym standing for Age, pathologic tumor
Grade, Extent of disease, and Size of tumor
[208].
– MACIS Scale: This more sophisticated post-
operative scale is a modication of the AGES
system. Factors assessed are distant
Metastases, Age at presentation (<40
or>40years), Completeness of original surgi-
cal resection, extra-thyroidal Invasion, and
Size of original lesion (in cm) [208].
– AMES Score: Cady and Rossi described a
prognostic scoring system, originating in
Lahey clinic, based on Age, Metastases,
Extent, and Size of tumor. Stage for stage and
risk of death are mostly related to age and gender [209–211]. Age limits were dened as
older than 40 years in men but older than
50years in women. Patients <45years of age
without distant metastases usually are considered to be at low risk [208]. Distant metastasis
at the time of diagnosis was the greatest predictor of survival [212]. The extent of tumor
indicated extra-capsular tumor invasion, and
size limits were greater than 5cm.
– The most signicant single prognostic indica-
tor overall is distant metastases, especially to
bone. Local invasion of the primary tumor
through the thyroid capsule into the adjacent
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

13 Malignant Thyroid Disease
Table 13.12 Stratication of patients and differentiated
thyroid tumors
Risk Description
Low-risk
patients
High-risk
patients
Low-risk
tumors
High-risk
tumors
Females under the age of 45years
All males and females over 45years
(patients under 16years should be
regarded as high-risk and are usually best
treated aggressively)
PTC <1cm in size and minimally invasive
FTC <1cm in size
PTC and FTC >1cm in size, any tumor
associated with signicant multifocality,
local, or distant spread
361
Fig. 13.19 FTC consisting of fairly uniform cells forming small follicles containing colloid
Table 13.13 The 5-year survival of PTC according to
stage
Stage 5-Year survival rate
I Near 100%
II Near 100%
III 93%
IV 51%
structures increases the mortality ten-fold over
matched patients with intra-thyroidal tumors
[213].
From these different systems, patients as well
as differentiated thyroid tumors are nally stratied into low-risk and high-risk patients and
tumors as shown in Table13.12. The 5-year survival rate (SR) of PTC according to stageof diseae is listed in Table13.13.
13.4 Follicular Thyroid Cancer
(FTC)
Follicular thyroid carcinomas (FTCs) account for
5–15% of primary thyroid cancers but constitute
25–40% in areas with dietary I2 deciency.
13.4.1 Gross Features
Follicular carcinomas appear as single nodules
that may be well-circumscribed or widely inltrative. Sharply demarcated lesions may be
exceedingly difcult to distinguish from follicular adenomas by gross examination. Larger
lesions may penetrate the capsule and inltrate
well beyond the thyroid capsule into the adjacent neck structures. They are gray to tan pink
on cut section and may be somewhat translucent
due to the presence of large, colloid-lled follicles. Degenerative changes such as center brosis and foci of calcication are sometimes
present.
13.4.2 Microscopic Appearance
Microscopically, most FTCs composed of fairly
uniform cells forming small follicles containing
colloid (Fig.13.19). In other cases, follicular differentiation may be less apparent, and there may
be nests or sheets of cells without colloid.
Occasional tumors are dominated by cells with
abundant granular, eosinophilic cytoplasm
(Hurthle cell or oncocytic variant of FTC).
Whatever the pattern, the nuclei lack the features
typical of PTC, and psammoma bodies are not
present.
While nuclear features (optically clear nuclei,
nuclear grooves) are helpful in distinguishing
papillary from follicular neoplasms, there are no
reliable cytological difference between follicular
adenomas and minimally invasive follicular carcinomas. Making this distinction requires extensive histological sampling of tumor–capsule–
thyroid interface to exclude capsular and/or vascular invasion [214]. The criterion for vascular
invasion applies solely and strictly to “veins” in
or beyond the capsule; the presence of tumor
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

362
plugs within intra-tumoral blood vessels has little prognostic signicance, whereas the denition of capsular invasion is controversial [214,
215]. Some authors require penetration of the
capsule to diagnose a follicular carcinoma, while
others need tumor invasion through the capsule
into the surrounding normal thyroid [215, 216].
Distant metastases have been reported in follicular carcinoma diagnosed only on the basis of
capsular and not vascular invasion; however, in
some cases, metastases were already present at
initial diagnosis [217]. Unlike in papillary cancers, lymphatic spread is uncommon in follicular
cancers.
In contrast to minimally invasive follicular
carcinoma, the diagnosis of carcinoma is obvious
in widely invasive follicular carcinomas, which
inltrate the thyroid parenchyma and extrathyroidal soft tissue. Histologically, these cancers
tend to have a greater proportion of solid or trabecular growth pattern, less evidence of follicular
differentiation, and increased mitotic activity. Up
to 80% of patients with widely invasive follicular
cancer can develop metastases with a mortality
rate of approximately 50%.
13.4.3 Clinical Aspects
Follicular thyroid carcinomas (FTCs) are more
common in women (3:1) and occur more in older
patients than do PTCs; with the peak incidence
between 40 and 60years of age [218]. Symptoms
suggesting carcinoma include hoarseness of
voice, rapid growth of a thyroid nodule, dysphagia, hemoptysis, or pain in the neck. Uncommon
presentations include cervical lymphadenopathy,
symptomatic bone pain from metastatic disease
to the spine, pelvis or ribs, asymptomatic lung
metastases found radiographically, and focal
neurological abnormalities from distant spread to
the brain.
Physical examination may reveal a hard, irregular, solitary, xed thyroid mass causing local
compressive symptoms with or without associated cervical lymphadenopathy (Fig. 13.20).
Direct laryngoscopy should be performed to
detect a vocal cord paresis or, rarely, tracheal
M. Sakr
Fig. 13.20 A 41-year-old lady with a large, hard, irregular thyroid mass that proved by histology to be a follicular
carcinoma. Note the dilated veins over the sternum
invasion when present. A thyroid mass with an
associated ipsilateral vocal cord paresis contains
carcinoma until proven otherwise.
Multicentricity and LN involvement are less
frequent (10–20%) in FTC than in PTC [219],
and metastasis to the lungs and bones results
from a tendency of these tumors to spread by
hematogenous pathways instead of lymphatic
channels.
13.4.4 Surgical Decision
forTreatment ofFollicular
Carcinoma
At present, FNAC cannot distinguish follicular
adenoma or benign hyperplastic nodules from
carcinoma [220]. Thy three cytology usually
mandates lobectomy as the least surgical procedure. Frozen-section is unhelpful when the FNAC
diagnosis is that of a follicular lesion (Thy3). If
denitive histology reveals a follicular adenoma
(Fig.13.21) or a hyperplastic nodule, no further
teratment is required.
A “FTC”<1 cm with minimal capsular invasion should be treated by lobectomy [221].
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

13 Malignant Thyroid Disease
Table 13.14 The 5-year survival according to stage
5-year survival
Stage Description
I Intra-thyroidal disease Near 100%
II With cervical LN
metastases
III With extra-thyroidal
extension
IV With distant metastases 50%
rate
Near 100%
71%
13.5 Hurthle Cell (Oncocytic)
Tumors
363
Fig. 13.21 Follicular adenoma with regular cells and no
capsular or vascular invasion
Patients with FTC showing evidence of vascular
invasion should be treated with TT and those
with FTC >4cm should be treated with TT.Lowrisk patients (women, patients <45 years with
tumors <2 cm) may be treated by lobectomy
alone and -thyroxin [222].
Clear recommendations for otherwise lowrisk patients with tumors 2–4cm showing minimal capsular invasion only cannot be made [205].
Palpable/suspicious cervical LNs are dealt with
in a similar manner to PCT.If the diagnosis of thyroid cancer has been made after thyroid lobectomy
and completion, (contra-lateral) thyroid lobectomy
is required; the latter should be offered within
8weeks of histological diagnosis of cancer.
13.4.5 Prognostic Factors
The outcome of patients with FTC is generally
worse than that of PTC and is directly related to
the stage of disease at the time of diagnosis.
Patients are divided into four clinical stages
based on the extent of disease at presentation as
shown in Table13.14.
Independent prognostic factors that inuence
survival in follicular carcinoma include (1)
age > 45 years, (2) extra-thyroidal extension
(capsular invasion and angioinvasion), (3) distant
metastases, (4) lymph node involvement, (5)
tumor size >4cm, and (6) an aneuploid DNA pattern [223].
13.5.1 Introduction
Hürthle cell neoplasms (HCNs) are an uncommon group of thyroid epithelial tumors that generate much controversy and have additional
names in the literature such as Ashkenazy cell or
Langhans tumors. There is ongoing disagreement, regarding the cell of origin of these neoplasms; follicular versus para-follicular.
Furthermore, some surgeons consider all Hürthle
cell neoplasms to be potentially malignant and
therefore warrant aggressive surgical therapy
[224], while others believe that certain histopathological features can predict the biological
behavior of HCNs and consequently can identify
patients for whom a more conservative treatment
is appropriate [225].
There is an increased incidence of malignancy
with increasing age, prior exposure to radiation,
and concomitant PTC or FTC at a site different
from the index nodule [224, 226]. Once a Hürthle
cell neoplasm is proven to be malignant, surgery
is the only effective therapy.
13.5.2 Clinical Presentation
The incidence of Hurthle cell neoplasm (HCN)
varies between 3 and 10% in all thyroid nodules
[224–230]., of which 10–35% is Hürthle cell carcinoma (HCC) [225, 227]. At the time of diagnosis of Hürthle cell carcinoma, approximately
75% are conned to the thyroid gland, 15% have
distant metastases, and 10% have LN metastases
[224, 226].
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

364
ab
M. Sakr
The clinical presentation of HCNs is similar
13.5.3 Pathology
to that of follicular neoplasms, appearing mostly
as a solitary, nonfunctioning nodule. The presence of symptoms should raise the suspicion of
carcinoma, which may be aggressive in nature,
grow rapidly, and cause compressive symptoms
(Fig. 13.22). However, about 30% of patients
with HCNs will have an additional benign thyroid disease such as Graves’ disease, MNG, or
Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (HT); and accordingly,
may present with symptoms of
hyperthyroidism.
13.5.3.1 Adenoma or Carcinoma?
HCNs have been classied into Hurthle cell adenoma (HCA) and Hurthle cell carcinoma (HCC)
[231]. In the absence of metastasis, a controversy
arises regarding the nature of HCN as whether it
is benign or malignant since cytological criteria
diagnostic of malignancy on FNA, like cellular
atypia and architectural distortion, may be found
in benign HCNs [232]. In this context, FNAB
usually reports “BHCL/HCN” [233].
Hürthle cell neoplasms generally present
later in life than papillary and follicular tumors,
most commonly appearing in the sixth decade
of life and are more common in females,
though malignant lesions are more common in
men [224].
characterized by large polygonal cells, distinct
cell borders, and voluminous granular cytoplasm
because of huge number of mitochondria lling
the cell,in addition to a large nucleus and prominent nucleolus (Fig.13.23) [234]. However, these
Hurthle cell neoplasms of the thyroid gland is
Fig. 13.22 A 53-old-gentleman with a huge thyroid gland, more on the right side, and retro-sternal extension. Biopsy
proved to be a Hurthle cell carcinoma (a). Lateral view of the same patient. Note the huge size and dilated veins (b)
Fig. 13.23 Hürthle cells arranged in loosely
cohesive clusters and single cells. The cells
are polyhedral and have abundant granular
cytoplasm with well-dened cell borders.
Nuclei are enlarged and have a central
prominent macro-nucleolus
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH

13 Malignant Thyroid Disease
365
features can also be found in nodular goiter, foci
of nonspecic chronic thyroiditis, long-standing
hyperthyroidism, and HT [235].
Thus, the mere presence of Hürthle cells does
not necessarily signify a neoplastic process. The
presence of a capsule surrounding Hürthle cells,
on the other hand, is the dening characteristic of
Hürthle cell neoplasms, which contain at least a
75% Hürthle cell component.
Hurthle cell tumors are generally believed to
be a variant of follicular neoplasms [226].
However, other authors believe that they represent a distinct entity, citing the unique oncogenic
expression and the relative inability of Hürthle
cells to absorb radioiodine [225].
13.5.3.2 Cytological/Histopathological
Features
Diagnosis of a HCN by FNA can typically be
classied as a follicular lesion of undetermined
signicance (FLUS) or atypia of undetermined
signicance (AUS) with Hürthle cell features
(AUS/FLUS/Hürthle cell lesion of undetermined
signicance [HLUS], Bethesda III). Both benign
and malignant oncocytic lesions can demonstrate marked cytological atypia, complicating
the process of diagnosis on biopsy alone.
Overall, the projected risk of malignancy for this
diagnostic category is 5–15%. A cytological
diagnosis of suspicious for HCN (Bethesda IV)
carries a projected 15–30% risk of malignancy
[236].
The diagnostic category “AUS” should be
reserved for thyroid FNAs containing cells with
architectural and/or nuclear atypia that is not sufcient to classify as suspicious for neoplasm,
suspicious for malignancy, or malignancy; however, atypia is more marked than can be designated as benign [237, 238]. Thus, AUS is a
heterogeneous category with different cytological scenarios. It is suggested to use the AUS category if there is a predominance of Hurthle cells
in a sparsely cellular FNA with scant colloid or
when there is a moderately or markedly cellular
sample composed of a virtually exclusive population of Hurthle cells yet the clinical setting suggests a benign Hurthle cell nodule, especially
lymphocytic thyroiditis and multinodular goiter
[239].
Unfortunately, intra-operative frozen-section examination was consistently reported to
be unhelpful in discriminating benign from
malignant HCNs [240–243]. Thus, the sole distinction is based on the presence or absence of
capsular invasion (CI) and vascular invasion
(VI), which can only be reliably identied in
parafn-section. Therefore, in patients with
FNAC demonstrating an HCN, diagnostic surgical excision should be performed if molecular testing is not done or if it is inconclusive
[244].
Given the aggressive behavior of histologically proven malignant HCN reported by some
investigators, such indeterminate ndings
impose a challenging situation in which clinicians tend to follow a more aggressive surgical
approach. However, the incidence of malignancy among nodules, cytologically suspicious
HCN, was found, by histopathology, to range
from 5% to 35% only [241, 245]. Thus, a considerable proportion of these patients are unnecessarily exposed to the risk of surgical
complications.
13.5.3.3 Stratication ofHurthle Cell
Carcinoma Risk
Hurthle cell carcinoma (HCC) is currently designated by the World Health Organization (WHO)
as a histopathological variant of FTC, and this is
echoed in the American Thyroid Association
(ATA) and National Comprehensive Cancer
Network (NCCN) treatment guidelines, with
HCC following the same risk stratication as that
of follicular carcinoma. For the ATA, intrathyroidal encapsulated tumors with minor capsular or vascular invasion (<4foci) or≤5 metastatic
LNs where the foci of metastases are <0.2cm are
considered to be “low risk.” The “intermediate
risk” is dened by vascular invasion, minimal
extra-thyroidal extension (ETE), or>5 metastatic
LNs (0.2–3 cm). “High-risk” patients include
those with macroscopic ETE, incomplete tumor
resection, distant metastases, or metastatic LNs
>3cm [246].
t.me/Dr_Mouayyad_AlbtousH
Соседние файлы в папке Библиотека им академика М.И. Перельмана
