Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018
.pdf8.A.AsaTKOB
TYPEUKAR PECnYoJll'lKA
BHYTPEHHHH nonVlTVlKA
OT 2002 K 2018
MOHOrPA<Dll1H
KHMra AoaynHa Ha 06pa3osa1enbHOM nna1+opMe «IOpalAT>> urait.ru, aTalOKe BM06MnbHOM npMnO>KeHMM «IOpaMT.6M6nMOTeKa»
MocKBa • IOpalAT • 2021
Y.l(K323
EEK 66.3(4/8)
Al8
Aamop:
|
ABaTKOB |
B.713,IJ;HMHp All:eKceeBWI - |
KaJUIUaT |
rro.'!JITWiecKHX HaYK, |
||||||||||
|
crapIIIHH Ha]"IHbIH coTpy,ZVIHK UeHTpa rrocrcoBeTCKHX 11cc1e,iosaHHH 11HCTHT)'Ta |
|||||||||||||
|
MHpOBOH |
3KOHOMHKH |
H MeJK,ZJJ'HapO.]Hb!X OTHOIIIeHJiH |
PocCHHCKOH |
aKa,zieMHH |
|||||||||
|
H3}'KHMeHH E. M. CTpHMaKOBa, ,J;OljeHT Kacpe.Jpbl ~!e~riapo.]Hb!X OTHOIIIeHHH |
|||||||||||||
|
,l(H1vro~iaTWiecKoil: aKa,:i;e11rnH M11H11crepCTBa HHOCTpaHHb!X ,:i;e.1 PoccHil:cKoH |
|||||||||||||
|
cf)e,iepa1um. rrpo¢eccop r.:acpe.lpb! rrpHK1a.JHO!I rro.11rro.1onm rocy,:i;apCTBeHHoro |
|||||||||||||
|
aKa.Je~m'!ea..:oro |
ymrnepcHTeTa |
fJ"!>!amrrapHb!X |
Hay'K, |
,J;HpeKTop |
UeHTpa |
||||||||
|
BOCTOKOBe.IHblX |
lfCC.1e.JOBaHHH. |
~!~riapo.JHb!X |
OTHOIIIeHHH |
ll rry6JIH'!HOH |
|||||||||
|
..IHII.10!.laTUl!. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ABanroB, B. A. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
.-\18 |
TypeIJKaR |
|
Pecrry6JIHKa. |
BHyTpemurn |
ITOJIHTI!Ka: |
OT 2002 K 2018: |
||||||||
|
MOHorpacpHH I |
B. A. ABaTKoB. - |
MocKBa: J13,11aTeJibCTBO !Opail:T, 2021. - |
|||||||||||
|
203 c. - |
(AlcryaJibHble MOHOrpa<lrnu). -TeKCT: Herrocpe,11CTBeHHb!H. |
|
|||||||||||
|
ISBN 978-5-534-11585-7 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||
|
MoHorpacpHH |
co,11eplKliT |
CBe,lleHHH |
0 33KOHOMepHOCTJIX, |
MO,lleJIJIX |
|||||||||
|
H MexaH113Max |
|
MeJK,eyHapop;Horo |
pa3Bl1Tirn |
TypeIJKOH |
Pecrry6JII1KH |
||||||||
|
B 11crop11'1eCKOHpeTpocrreKT!1Be |
H rrepcrreKTHBe; |
3BTOpOM |
rrpoaHaJIH3HpOB3Hbl |
||||||||||
|
<l>eHOMeHbl H <l>aKTbl, |
C03,113HHhie |
B pe3)'JlbTaTe |
pa3BHTHll MeJK,eyHapo,llHb!X |
||||||||||
|
OTHOIIIeHHH |
H B03HHK3!01IjHe |
B CBJI3H |
c HHMH |
MeJK,eyHapo,llHO-rrpaBOBb!e |
|||||||||
|
OTHOIIIeHHll, |
a TaIOKe |
paccMOTpeHbl |
11,11e11 |
|
COBpeMeHHb!X |
HCTOpHKOB |
|||||||
|
H !IOJIHTOJIOros; |
,113H3 |
OljeHKa |
3<l><l>eKTHBHOCTH |
yperyJIHpOBaHHll |
rrpo6JieM |
||||||||
|
MeJK,eyHapO,llHb!X OTHOIIIeHHH H yqacrHH B HHX Type!jKOH Pecrry6JIHKH. |
|
KHuza npeOHa3HalieHa OM cmyoeHmoe BbLCULUX Ylie6HblX JaeeoeHuii, a malO#Ce npaKmwow14ux cne4uanucmoe.
Y,l(K323
EEK 66.3(4/8)
Bee npaea 3UU{UU{elibl. HUKUKWI t{QCmb OalilWU KHUZU He MOJtCem 6&Lmb BOCnpoU3Be0eHC B KUKOU 6&1 mo HU 6b1Jl0 <JjopMe 6e3 nucbMeHHOZO pa3peULeHWl 8.11UOeJZb4eB aemopcKUX npaB.
ISBN 978-5-534-11585-7 |
© |
ABaTKoB B. A., 2019 |
|
© |
000 «113,llaTeJihCTBO IOpaifT,,, 2021 |
OrnaeneHMe |
|
|
BBe,n;eHHe ............................................................................................... |
|
7 |
fJ1aBa 1. BBe,n;eHHe B npaBoByro cHcTeMY Typeu;xo:H Pecny6JmKH ......... |
|
9 |
CoBpeMeHttoe KOHCTHT}'IJ;HOHHoerrpaBo TypQHH ............................................. |
|
16 |
ITpaBOBOe rroJioJKeHHe HaQHOHaJibHbIX MeHbIIIHHCTB B TypQHH ........................ |
|
17 |
Cy.z:1e6HaJI cttcTeMa TypQHH .............................................................................. |
|
19 |
fpaJK,llaHCKOe H yroJIOBHOe cy.z:1orrpOH3BO,l\CTBO ................................................ |
|
20 |
fpaJK,llaHCKOe H qacTHOe rrpaBo ........................................................................ |
|
20 |
Pe<i>opMa KoprropaTHBHoro rrpaBa .................................................................... |
|
21 |
CeMefi:ttoe rrpaBo.............................................................................................. |
|
22 |
YroJIOBHOe rrpaBo ............................................................................................. |
|
23 |
fJiaBa 2. OpraHhI rocy,ll;apcTBeHHOH BJiacTH Typu;HH ............................ |
|
27 |
3aKOHO,llaTeJihHaJI BJiaCTb: BeJIHKOe HaQHOHaJibHOe co6paHHe TypQHH ............ |
|
27 |
l1CIIOJIHHTeJibHaJI BJiaCTb TypQHH: rrpe3H,lleHT H COBeT MHHHCTpOB................... |
|
30 |
CoBeT MHHHCTpoB ............................................................................................ |
|
32 |
COBeT HaQHOHaJibHOH 6e3orracttocTH (CHE) .................................................... |
|
33 |
Cy.z:1e6HaJI BJiaCTb ............................................................................................. |
|
33 |
BbICIIIHH cOBeT cy.z:1eH: H rrpoKypopoB ................................................................ |
|
35 |
KoHCTHT}'ll;HOHHbIHpeqiepeH,llyM 2017 ro.z:1a..................................................... |
|
36 |
fJiaBa 3. Peq>0pMhI IlapTHH cnpaBe,ll;JIHBOCTH H pa3BHTIDI ................... |
|
37 |
ITepBbIH 3Tarr peqiopM ITCP: H3MeHemrn B 3KOHOMHKe, |
|
|
c6JIHJKeHHe c EBporroH: .............................................................................. |
• |
......38 |
3KOHOMHqecKaJI pe<l>opMa ............................................................................... |
|
39 |
Pe<l>opMbI CoBeTa HaQHOHaJibHOH 6e3orracttocTH, orpaHHqeHHe BJIHHHHH |
|
|
BOeHHbIX .......................................................................................................... |
|
41 |
,ll;eMoKpaTHqecKHe rrpeo6pa3oBattHH: cB060.z:1a CJIOBa, rrpaBa qeJioBeKa ........... |
|
.43 |
BTopoH: 3Tarr: «,lleMOKpaTHqecKaJI HHHQHaTHBa» H KOHCTHT}'ll;HOHHbie |
|
|
H3MeHeHHH ...................................................................................................... |
|
44 |
KoHCTHT}'ll;HOHHbreH3Mettemrn: peqiepeH,llyMbI 2007 H 2010 ro,l\OB ................. |
|
46 |
IToJIHTHKa B OTHOIIIeHHH BOeHHbIX H JKYPHaJIHCTOB ......................................... |
. |
48 |
«,ll;eMOKpaTHqecKaJI HHHQHaTHBa»: peqiopMbI B OTHOIIIeHHH |
|
|
HaQHOHaJibHbIX MeHbIIIHHCTB .. ·········... ·····················........................................ |
|
so |
Borrpoc BcryrrnettHH TypQHH B EBpocoI03 ......................................................... |
|
53 |
fJiaBa 4. IlapTHHHaH CHCTeMa B Typu;HH.............................................. |
|
56 |
ITapTHHHaJI cHcTeMa TypQHH rroCJie rrpaBJieHHH HPIT ....................................... |
|
57 |
ITpe.z:1rrocbIJIKH co3.z:1aHHH ITapTHH crrpaBe,llJIHBOCTH H pa3BHTHH ....................... |
|
58 |
ITapJraMeHTCKHe Bhr6ophr 2002 ro.z:1a ................................................................ |
|
61 |
3
ITapJiaMeHTCKHe Bhr6opbr 2007 H 2011 ro11:os ................................................... |
62 |
ITapJiaMeHTCKHe Bhr6opbI 2015 ro11:a: HIOHh, HoH6pb ........................................ |
63 |
ITapJiaMeHTCKHe Bhr6ophr 2018 ro11:a ................................................................. |
65 |
XapaKTepHCTHKa HaH6oJiee B<DKHhIX B Typrum rrapruil: .................................... |
67 |
Bb1BOt1 .............................................................................................................. |
70 |
fJiaBa 5. 11CTOpH"leCKCUI, IlOJIHTH'leCKaJIH BOeHHaH pom. apMHH |
|
B Typeu;Ko:H Pecny6JIHKe ...................................................................... |
72 |
CrnHOBJieHHe OcMaHcKott HMrrepHH H apMHH .................................................. |
73 |
Pe<l>opMbI B apMHH: ITOHBJieHHe CHnax H HHbl'Iap.............................................. |
74 |
IToHBJieHHe orHeCTpeJibHoro opj')Klui:B apMHH OcMaHcKott HMnepHH .............. |
75 |
CoseprneHCTBOBaHHe TaKTHKH Be,.'leHHH60.R: .................................................... |
76 |
KpH3HC B apMHH H rocy11:apCTBe ....................................................................... |
77 |
PoJih apMHH B XX BeKe ..................................................................................... |
78 |
BoeHHhIH nepesopoT 1960 ro11:a ....................................................................... |
78 |
BoeHHhIH nepesopoT 1971 ro11:a ....................................................................... |
80 |
BoeHHhitt nepesopoT 1980 ro11:a ....................................................................... |
82 |
Co6hITHH 1997 ro11:a ......................................................................................... |
83 |
«ITepeBOpOT» 2016 ro11:a ................................................................................... |
85 |
0CJia6JieHHe IT03HUHH apMHH B ITUJIHTHKe ·························.............86 |
|
ApMHH H KOHCTHT)'UHOHHhlepe<l>opMhI ............................................................ |
87 |
Bo3MO)l(HOCTH TYPe~oH: apMHH....................................................................... |
89 |
YqaCTHe TYPe~ BC B BOeHHhlX onepaQHHX HATO ........................................ |
93 |
3aKJIIOqeHHe .................................................................................................... |
95 |
fJiaua 6. Bonpoc HCJiaMa B noJIHTHKe Typu;HH ..................................... |
97 |
,.[QKaMaaTbI H HX BJIHHHHe ............................................................................... |
101 |
YrrpaBJieHHe no ,11eJiaM peJIHrHH ..................................................................... |
104 |
AccOQHaQHH rrpoMhlJ.J.J.JieHHHKOB H rrpe11:rrpHHHMaTeJiett (MIOC.l1A,Z:O ............. |
106 |
«3eJieHhIH KanHTaJI» B TypUHH ....................................................................... |
107 |
0THOJ.J.J.eHHH c soeHHhIMH: pe<l>opMbI Cosern HaQHOHaJihHOH |
|
6e3orraCHOCTH, ,lleJIO «3preHeKOH» ................................................................. |
108 |
BJIHHHHe HCJiaMH3aQHH Ha Me)!(,ll)'Hapot1HhieOTHOJ.J.J.eHHH .............................. |
109 |
«EOJibJ.J.J.aH B3HTKa» H npoTeCTbJ. Ha TaKCHMe ................................................... |
112 |
ITorrhITKa nepesoporn 2016 ro11:a Hee rroCJiet1CTBHH ....................................... |
113 |
fJiaua 7. Oco6eHHOCTH 3KOHOMH':lecKoropa3BHTHH Typeu;Ko:H |
|
Pecny6JIHKH ....................................................................................... |
117 |
lIH6epaJIH3aQHH 3KOHOMHKH B 1980-1990-e rot1bI ....................................... |
117 |
3KoHoMnqecKHH KpH3HC 2001 ro11:a. PoCT 3KOHOMHKH 2002-2007 rOtlbI ...... |
119 |
Pa3BHTHe rroCJie MHposoro KpH3Hca 2008 ro11:a .............................................. |
123 |
Co6hITHH 2016 ro11:a H HX BJIHHHHe Ha 3KOHOMHqecKYJO cmyaQHI0 ................. |
125 |
Pa3BHTHe HHHOBaQHH B TypQHH ..................................................................... |
128 |
TpaHcrropT ..................................................................................................... |
131 |
CeJihcKoe X03HHCTBO ...................................................................................... |
134 |
TypeQKaH 3KOHOMHKa B 2015-2016 rot1hI ..................................................... |
134 |
3KOHOMH"IeCKHe OTHOJ.J.J.eHHH c PocCHHCKOH <l>e11:epaQHett .............................. |
135 |
«BH,lleHHe 2023» ............................................................................................ |
137 |
4
fJiaBa 8. POJib HeKOMMepqecKHX opraHH3~HH B IIOJIHTH'IeCI<OH
)KH3HH TypI.UfH ..•........................... |
|
•..•••••........... |
••••..• |
....... |
•.•.•.•............ |
|
|
140 |
|||
ITpaBOBbie OCHOBbI <l>YHKl\HOHHponamm attclJIHTH'J:eCKHX11ettTpOB |
|
|
|||||||||
B Typl.IHH .......... |
•..... |
•.......................................... |
|
|
•......... |
•.••............................... |
|
|
|
140 |
|
BH,llhI HeKOMMepqecKHX opraHH3al.IHH B Typl.IHH ....... |
•.• |
.............. |
•.............. |
|
•.... |
144 |
|||||
<l>HHaHCHpOB aHHe HeKOMMepqecKHX opraHH3al.IHH |
........ |
• ............... |
|
•... |
•.......... |
145 |
|||||
PeJIHrH03Hbre HKO ............................... |
|
•.................... |
|
|
••................................... |
|
|
|
|
148 |
|
AHa.nHTHqecKHe 11ettTpbr ................................................................................ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
148 |
||
BbIBOt:(bI •......... |
•.............................................. |
|
|
|
•....•.... |
•..................................... |
|
|
|
|
152 |
AHa.nHTwi:ecKHe 11eHTpbr Type11Koii Pecrry6JIHKH ............................................ |
|
|
|
|
|
153 |
|||||
fJiaBa 9. 06pa30BaHHe H Hayi<a B Typ~HH .••.•.••..••••.•................... |
|
|
•.•.••• 157 |
||||||||
l1HOCTpaHHbie Ii Hal.IHOHaJibHbie 3JieMeHTbI Typel.IKOH o6pa30BaTeJibHOH |
|
||||||||||
CHCTeMbI ...••...... |
•.... |
•..•....................... |
•.•.••.......................... |
|
|
....... ....... |
• |
• |
•............ |
|
158 |
Ka<J:ecTBo Typel.IKHX }'HHBeprnTeToB•.•••..•... |
•............ |
•.... .... .......................... |
•• |
• |
|
|
160 |
||||
Yponettb ttay-qttoro pa3BHTWI B Typl.IHH.......................................................... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
161 |
|||
Hay-qtthre )K)'pHaJihI.............................. |
••... |
•... |
•..•.............. |
....... ........... |
•.. • |
• |
|
•....... |
163 |
||
PoJib y-qettoro B IIOJIHTHKe .............................................................................. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
163 |
||
fJiaBa 10. IlpoTeCTH&Ie B&1crynn:eHID1 B Typ~HH ••................. |
|
|
•..... |
•...... |
167 |
||||||
06CTaHOBKa nepBOH IIOJIOBHHbI xx BeKa ....................................................... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
167 |
|||
ITpoTeCTbI BTOpOH IIOJIOBHHbI xx BeKa•... |
··••·············•·············......................... |
171 |
|||||||||
Co11HaJibHO-IIOJIHTH<J:ecKtte npoTeCThI conpeMeHHOH Typl.IHM ...... ................• |
• |
|
• 174 |
||||||||
fJiaBa 11. KypACKHH Borrpoc H IIOJIHTHKa Typ~HH •... .......... .... |
• |
•.... |
•.... |
177 |
|||||||
XapaKTepttcTttKa Kott¢JittKTa ......................................................................... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
177 |
||
l1CTOpHH KOH<i>JIHKTa......................................................... |
|
|
|
............................ |
• |
|
|
|
178 |
||
06ocTpeHtte KOH<i>JIHKTa ............................... |
|
|
•........... |
•.... ........ ................... |
••.• |
• |
|
|
179 |
||
ITapTIDI cnpaBet:(JIHBOCTH H pa3BHTWI H Kypt:\CKHH BOIIpoc .................• |
|
|
•.•........ |
180 |
|||||||
Kypt:(CKHH BOIIpoc H COBpeMeHHOCTb .............................................................. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
182 |
|||
,ll,aJibHeHIIIaH cyt:(b6a KOH<i>JIHKTa.................................................................... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
183 |
||
3aKJIIOqeHHe .. |
•••••••••.•••••••.•..................... |
|
|
••••••••••••.•.•...... ............ |
•..• |
|
•...... |
185 |
|||
CrrHCOK HCToqHHKOB H JIHTepaTyp&I ...... |
|
•.•.•..•... |
•..•...... ............ |
•..• |
|
•...... |
187 |
||||
HoB&Ie H3AaHIDI 110 AHC~HIIJIHHe «CTpaHoBeAeHHe» |
|
|
|
|
|||||||
H cMe:>KHbIM AMC~HIIJIHHaM •••••••... |
••.••.•••.... |
•................ |
............... |
• |
|
••..... |
|
202 |
TiocJie OXJia)K,ll;eHI:UI poCCHHCKO-rypeu;KHX OTHOIIIeHHH, KOTOpoe ITOCJie- ,ll;OBaJIO 3a HHu;H,n;eHTOM y rpaHHu; Typu;HH oceHbIO 2015 r., ,n;Ba rocy,n;apCTBa BpeMeHHO npeKpaTHJIH coTpy,n;HHqecTBO no PMY BonpocoB, H TOJibKO B KOHu;e 2016 r. CTpaHaM y,n;aJIOCb npeo,n;oJieTb KpH3HCHbIH 3Tan lI IIOCTeneHHO BbIBeCTH ,ll;BYCTOpOHHHe OTHOIIIeHttJI Ha HOBbIH ypoBeHb.
0,n;HaKO KaKHMH 6bI 6bICTpbIMH HH 6bIJIH TeMIIbl pa3BHTHJI B3aHMO- ,n;eHCTBHJI Me)l{,n;y ,ll;BYMJI CTpaHaMH, IIOJIHTHKa POCCHH BIIpe,n;b Hau;eJieHa He TOJibKO Ha ycoBepIIIeHCTBOBaHHe ,ll;BYCTOpOHHero ,ll;HaJiora, HOH Ha npHCTaJibHOe H3yqeHHe CBoero napTHepa, KOTOpOMy, KaK IIOKa3aJI OIIbIT, CBOHCTBeHHO qacToe H3MeHeHHe BHeIIIHeIIOJIHTifqecKHX npHOpHTeTOB.
I1ccJie,n;oBaHHJI ITOKa3bIBalOT, qTo MaJITHHKOBOe IIOBe,n;eHHe Typeu;KOH Pecny6JittKH H Heonpe,n;eJieHHOCTb ,n;eH:cTBHH o6yCJIOBJieHhI noJIHTHqecKHMH 3a,zi;aqaMH, KOTOpbie CTOJIT nepe,n; rocy,n;apCTBOM H B HaH60JibllleH CTeneHH OTpa)l{eHbl B ero BHYTpeHHeH ITOJIHTHKe, TeCHO CBJI3aHHOH c ,n;eHCTByIOIIJ;HM BHeIIIHeIIOJIHTHqecKHM KypCOM.
I1cxo,n;JI H3 3Toro, H3yqeHHe PoccHeH: BHYTPHITOJIHTHqecKoH cHcTeMbI Typeu;KOH Pecny6JIHKH cerO,ll;HJI JIBJIJieTCH O,ll;HOH H3 OCHOBOITOJiaraIOIIJ;HX 3a,zi;aq, KOTOpaH B ycJIOBHJIX HeCTa6HJibHOH Me)K,ll;yHapo,n;HOH o6cTaHOBKH npe,n;cTaBJIJieT co6o:i1 oqeBH,ll;HbIH CTpaTerHqecKHH HHTepec, npe)K,ll;e Bcero B BOIIpocax 6e3onacHOCTH H 3KOHOMHKH.
Cero,n;HJI Typu;HIO xapaKTepH3yeT MHoroo6pa3He noJIHTHqecKHX aKTOpoB, a II03TOMY HMeHHO OHH JIBJIJIIOTCH u;eHTpaJibHbIM o6'beKTOMH3yqeHHJI BHYTPHIIOJIHTHqecKoH: cHcTeMhI rocy,n;apcTBa. Cpe,n;H HHX - npHBbJqHbie MHPY IIOJIHTHqecKHe napTHH H OTJIHqHTeJibHbie ,n;JIH Typu;HH opraHH3aIJ;HH (TapHKaTbI), BHOBb o6pa30BaHHbie HeKOMMepqecKHe opraHH3aIJ;HH H BOO- p~eHHbie CHJibl, KOTOpbie ,ll;OJirHe rO,ll;bl JIBJIJIJIHCb O,ll;HHM H3 Ba)l{HeHIIIHX BHYTPHIIOJIHTHqecKHX 3JieMeHTOB.
0,n;HH aKTOpbI, HanpHMep Pa6oqaJI napTHJI Kyp,n;HcTaHa, H3BeCTHbI cBoeH: aKTHBHOH, qaiu;e BCero, arpeCCHBHOH ,n;eJITeJibHOCTbIO; IIOJIBJieHHe ,n;pyrHx Ha ITOJIHTifqecKOH apeHe, K npHMepy YHHBepCHTeTOB, Hao6opoT, MO)l{HO Ha6JI10,n;aTh KpaH:He pe,n;Ko. B3aHMo,n;eH:cTBHe nepeqHcJieHHbIX n ,n;pyrHx 3JieMeHTOB o6pa3yeT CJia)KeHHyIO BHYTPHIIOJIHTHqecKyIO CHCTeMy Typeu;Ko:H Pecny6JIHKH, KOTopa.H peryJIHpyeTCH rocy,n;apCTBeHHbIMH opraHaMH, TYPeu;- KHM o6iu;ecTBOM HJIH TeM H ,n;pyrHM O,ll;HOBpeMeHHO no,n; B03,n;eHCTBHeM onpe,n;eJieHHbIX, HMM )Ke Bbipa6oTaHHbIX <PaKTOpOB, BKJIJOqaJOIIJ;HX B cefoI COBpeMeHHOe 3KOHOMifqecKoe IIOJIO)KeHHe Typu;HH, npaBOBYIO CHCTeMy, a TaK)l{e OTJIIfqlfTeJibHbie qepTbl cou;HaJibHO-KJiaCCOBOH 6opb6bI.
7
CoBoKyrrttocTh 3THX cpaKTopoB HBJUieTrn tteoTDeMJieMoH: qacTbID BHyTpetttteH: IIOJIHTHKH Typu;HH, cymeCTBOBaHHe KOTopoH: TaIOKe Heo6xo,n;HMO ytIHTbIBaTb rrpH aHaJIH3e BHyrpHIIOJIHTH'IeCKoroCTpOH rocy,n;apCTBa.
rnaBa 1
BBEAEHME BnPABOBYIO CMCTEMY TYPEUKOM PECnY&nMKM
CornaCHo ,n;eifcTByiorn;eif Kottcnrry1v·m, TypeQK<UI Pecny6mrna - ,n;eMo-
Kpan1qecKoe, COQHaJlbHO-ITpaBOBOe, CBeTCKOe rocy,n;apCTBO c pecITy61mKaHCKOH <PopMoif ITpaBJ1ettIDI1. KoHCTHTYQIDI 6hma ITpmurTa B 1982 r. B pe3yJ1hTaTe BOeHHoro ITepeBopoTa H JIBJUieTCJI }')KeqeTBepTOH ITO cqezy c MOMeHTa octtoBaHHR pecITy6J1HKattcKoif TypQHH.
O,n;ttaKo ITpaBoBaR cHcTeMa cospeMeHHoif TypeQKOH PecITy6J1HKH
He orpaHHqHBaeTCJI Ha 3aKOHO,ZJ;aTeJlbCTBe, KOTopoe ITPHillJIO BMeCTe
c pecITy6J1HKaHCKHM CTpOeM H HMeeT ITpoqttyio 6a3y, C03,ZJ;aHHYJO 3a MHOroJleTHHH ITepHO,ll; cyrn;eCTBOBaHHJI rocy,n;apCTBa. lJTo6bJ ITOHJITb, qTo ITpe,n;- CTaBJIJieT H3 ce6JI COBpeMeHHaJI ITpaBOBaJI CHCTeMa TypQHH, tteo6xo,n;HMO ITOHHMaTb, Ha qeM Otta OCHOBaHa, KaK MeHAAaCb H KaK c<PopMHpOBaJICJI TOT KOHCTHTYQHOHHbIH CTpoif, KOTOpbIH cero,n;HR peryJ1HpyeT o6rn;ecTBeHHOrocy,n;apcTBeHHbie OTHOIIleHHJI.
Tpa,n;HQHOHHCUI ITepHO,ll;H3aQHJI HCTOpHH pa3BHTHJI ITpaBOBOH CHCTeMbl
TypQHH 6hma, B qacTHOCTH, ITPHBe,n;etta B ITepBOM TOMe «Bceo6rn;eif HCTO-
pHH rocy,n;apcTBa H ITpaBa» 0. A. OMeJlbqeHKO, KOTOpbIH ,n;eJIHT BCIO HCTOpHlO ITpaBa TypQHH Ha TPH 6a30BbIX rrepHo,n;a2•
,l(.nR nepBozo nepuooa (c MoMrnma o6pa3oBm-LUR OcMm-tcKozo zocyoapcmBa oo 1808 2.) xapaKTeptto 6e3pa3,ZJ;eJlbttoe rocrro,n;crno MYCYJlhMattcKoro ITpaBa. Tor,n;a OHO B03,n;ep:>KHBaJIOCb OT CHCTeMaTH3aQHH H coxpaHRJIO, ITO CYTH, ITpeQe,n;eHTHbIH xapaKTep.
0,n;HaKO B ,n;ettCTBHJIX OCMaHCKHX ITpaBHTeJlett ITPOCJle:>KHBaJIHCb CTpeMJ1eHHJI CKOHQeHTpHpOBaTb BJlaCTb B CBOHX PYKaX, IT03TOMY rro,n;o6H<UI CHCTeMa He COOTBeTCTBOBaJla HX HaMepeHHJIM H ITpeIIJITCTBOBaJla QeHTpaJIH3aQHH rocy,n;apcTBa. B CBR3H c 3THM 6hmo ttaqaTo c03,n;attHe co6cTBeHttoro 3aKotto- ,n;aTeJlhCTBa, KOTOpoe ITOJ1yqHJ10 CBOe OTpa:>KeHHe B <PopMe xaTTOB - ITOCTaHOBJleHHH cyJ1TaHOB, KacaIOI.I.J;HXCR HaceneHHJI H pa3JIHqHbIX a,n;MHHHCTpaTHBHbIX BOITpocoB (ttaITpHMep, coxpaHHJICR xaTT cyJ1Tatta A6,n;yJ1-Me,n;:>KH,n;a
1 Kottcnuyr~IDI Typ~mr (1982). 2017. 16 arrpem:r. URL: https://ria.ru/spravka/20170416/ 1492164143.html.
2 0Me.Jlb'l{eHKO 0. A. Bceo6maH 11cTopIDI rocy.n;apCTBa 11 rrpasa. B 2 T. 3-e 113,11;., 11crrp. M. : TOH-OcTO)!(be, 2000. T. l. C. 273.
9
no noBO,ll;Y peCTaBpa.QHH pH,ll;a MeqeTeifl)'qmpMaHOB - y1<a30B cyJITaHa, HanpaBJieHHbIX ,ll;HBaHy, rocy,ll;apCTBeHHOH a,ll;MHHHCTpa.QHH HJIH BeJIHKOMY BH3Hpl0. TaIOKe B KaqecTBe HCTOqHHKOB npaBa HHOr,ll;a paccMaTpHBalOTCH JmqHhle yKa3bI cynTaHa - Hpa,ll;e.
CBeTCKHe o6I.QHe 3aKOHhI ofol3aTenbHO Tpe6oBaJIH penHrH03HOH caHK-
.QHH - cpeTBbI, KOTOpyIO, KaK npaBHJIO, H3,ll;aBaJI rnei1x-yJib-HCJiaM, npH,ll;a- BaJI TeM caMbIM 3aKOHHOCTb HOBbIM npaBHJiaM H nO,ll;TBep)K,ll,aJI HX COOTBeTCTBHe c ,ll;yXOM rnapHaTa.
3aKOHO,ll;aTeJibHbie aKTbI, H3,ll;aHHbie Henocpe,ll;CTBeHHO cynTaHOM, nonyqHJIH Ha3BaHHe KaHyH-HaMe (cnoBo 6hIJio 3aHMCTBOBaHo H3 BH3aHTHH H npoHCXO,ll;HT OT cnoBa «KaHoH,,2). HaqHHaJI c XV B., cynTaHhI H3,ll;aBaJIH He TOJibKO OT,ll;eJibHhie nocTaHoBJiemrn, HO H e,ll;HHOBpeMeHHO CHCTeMaTH3HpoBaHHbie co6pamm, nOCBHI.QeHHbie HaH6onee Ba:>KHbIM rocy,ll;apCTBeHHbIM BOnpocaM.
TaKHM o6pa30M, Ha npOTH:>KeHHH npaKTHqecKH BCeH CBOeH HCTOpHH OcMaHCKaJI HMnepHH coqeTaJia B ce6e MHOroo6pa3He cpopM H HCTOqHHKOB npaBa, a cocyI.QecTBOBaHHe HCJiaMcKoro npaBa Haprr,ll;y c pa3pa60TaHHhIM cyJITaHOM CBeTCKHM npaBOM ,ll;OJirHe rO,ll;bI HBJIAAOCb OTJIHqHTeJibHOH qepTOH OCMaHCKOH npaBOBOH CHCTeMbI.
qTo KacaeTcrr rpa:>K,ll;aHcKoro H yroJIOBHoro npaBa, TO onpe,ll;eJieHHhre 3HaHHH 06 3THX npo.Qeccax 6bIJm nonyqeHbI yqeHbIMH-lOpHCTaMH B XO,ll;e pacKonoK B TaKHx ropo,ll;ax, KaK qaHKbiphr H KacTaMoHy. Enaro,ll;aprr Haii- ,ll;eHHhIM cy,ll;e6HbIM ,ll;OKyMeHTaM (Bcero o6Hapy)KeHO OKOJIO 25 TOMOB) 6hIJIO C,ll;eJiaHO 6oJibllIOe KOJIHqecTBO BbIBO,ll;OB H npe,ll;nOJIO:>KeHHH OTHOCHTeJibHO cy,ll;e6HhIX H3,ll;ep)KeK, aJibTepHaTHBHbIX cnoco6oB pa3perneHHH cnopoB H cy,ll;e6Horo npo.Qecca B .QeJioM. B o6I.Qei1 CYMMe ,ll;aHHbie ,ll;OKYMeHThI oxBaThIBaIOT nepHO,ll; OT XI ,ll;O XVIII B. Eonee no,ll;po6Ho HHcpopMa.QHH no ,ll;aHHOMY Bonpocy H3JIO:>KeHa B pa6oTe Eoraqa A. 3preHe Local court, provincial society and justice in the Ottoman Empire3.
Bmopoii nepuoa (1808-1918) 03HaMeHoBaH nonhITKaMH pecpopMHpoBaTb MYcyJihMaHCKoe npaBo no eBponeM:cKoMy o6pa3.Qy. Tio MHeHHIO pH,ll;a yqeHbIX H HCCJie,ll;oBaTeneM:, B TOM qJiCJie H3BeCTHOro cne.QHaJIHCTa KeMaJIH fe3nepa (Kemal Gozler), TaKaJI TeH,ll;eH.QHrr cBrr3aHa c npHHHTHeM ,ll;OKyMeHTa no,ll; Ha3BaHHeM CeHe,ll;H I1TTHcpaK (co103HhIH ,ll;OroBop), paTHcpH.QHpoBaHHoro B 1808 r.4
~aHHbIH HOpMaTHBHO-npaBOBOH aKT CJIO:>KHO Ha3BaTb nOJIHO.QeHHOH KOHCTHTY.QHeii xoTrr 6br no TOH npHqHHe, qTo CeHe,ll;,ll;H I1TTHcpaK He CTaJI OCHOBOH rocy,ll;apcTBeHHOCTH, 3aKOHHOCTH H npaBonopH,ll;Ka. B TO )Ke Bpe-
1Hatt-1 Hiimayun. URL: http://tarihvemedeniyet.org/2009/08/hatt-i-humayun. html.?nggpage=2.
20Me.nbL£eHKO 0. A. YKa3. co'-1. C. 275.
3Bogaf A. Ergene, Local Court, Provincial Society and Justice in the Ottoman Empire: Legal Practice and Dispute Resolution in c;:ankm and Kastamonu (1652-1744). Studies in Islamic Law and Society, 17. Leiden/Boston: E. J. Brill, 2003.
4Anayasa Hukukuna Giri§. Gene! Esaslar ve Tiirk Anayasa Hukuku, 21. Bask1, Agustos 2013, p. 162.
10