Vnutrennyaya_politika_Turtsii_2002-2018

TeTHhIX oTpaCJie:H 3KOHOMHKH - o6pa3oBaHIDI, <PapMaQeBTHKH, HHOKP, )l{eJie3HO,ll;OpO:lf<HOfO CTpOHTeJibCTBa, a TaK)l{e ,lJ;.llH HMIIOpTHPYJOIQHX TeXHOJIOfHH IIpe,D;IIpIDITHM1.

B pe3yJihTaTe rrepeq11CJieHHbIX rrpeo6pa3oaatt11:H Mettee qeM 3a IUITh JieT 3KOHOMHKa CTpaHbl 6bIJia BbIBe,D;eHa H3 rJiy6oqa:Hrnero KpH3HCa, cyMeB ,ll;OCTHqb CTa6mibHOCTH. ,lJ;OCTHfHfTbie pe3yJibTaTbl II03BOJIHJIH IlCP fKpeIIHTb BJIHJIHHe Ha IIOJIHTHqecKOM apeHe rocy,D;apCTBa, a BCeCTOpOHHJI no,D;- ,D;ep)l{Ka HaCeJieHIDI, noJiyqeHHM 3a 3TH fO,ll;bl, CTaJia npoqHOM OCHOBOM ,lJ;.llH npOBe,D;eHIDI ,ll;aJibHeMIIIHX pe<PopM.

Pe<f>opMbl Coeera Ha~MoHanbHOM 6e3onacHOCTM, orpaHM'leHMeBnMJIHMJI BOeHHblX

,ll;pyrHM OCHOBOIIOJiaraIOIQHM nyHKTOM rrporpaMMbl 3p,D;oraHa Ha nepBOM 3Tane cTaJIH pa3JmqHbie ,Z1;eM0KpaT11qecK11e pe<PopMbI, HarrpaBJieHHbie Ha BbIIlOJIHeHHe KorreHrareHCKHX KpHTepHeB, Heo6XO,ll;HMbIX ,ll;JIJI BCTYIIJieHHJI TypQHH B Eapoco103. ,lJ;JIJI rrp1106peTeHHJI crnryca yqacTHHKa TypeQKOM Pecny6JI11Ke Tpe6oBaJIOCh cyIQeCTBeHHO H3MeHHTb BHfTpeHHIOIO pacCTaHOBKY IIOJIHTHqecKHX CHJI B CTpaHe.

CorJiacHo KpHTepHRM, CTpaHa-KaH,D;H,D;aT ,ll;OJI)l{Ha 06ecneq11Tb BepxoBeHCTBO ,D;eMOKpaTHH H npaBa, 3aIQHTY rrpaB qeJioBeKa, a TaK)l{e ,D;eMCTByroru;yro pbIHOqHyro 3KOHOMHKf. flCP HaqaJia pa6ory no BCeM 3THM nyttKTaM.

UeHTpaJibHhIM H3MetteHHeM B paMKax ,D;aHHOM nporpaMMhI cTaJio y,D;aJieHHe BOeHHbIX OT BJiaCTH B CTpatte. Heo6XO,ll;HMO OTMeTHTb, qTo pOJib BOeHHbIX B TypQHH BCer,D;a 6bIJia oco6eHHOM: HMeHHO OHH BbICTYfiaJIH rapaHTOM coxpaHeHHJI rrpHBep)l{eHHOCTH rrpHHQHnaM KeMaJIH3Ma, o6'bJIBJieHHhIXATaTIOpKoM.

Heo,D;HOKpaTHO BOeHHbie npRMO BMern11Ban11cb B non11T11qecKHM npoQecc. B 3TOM CBJI3H IIIHpOKOe BJIHJIHHe apMHH rrpe,D;cTaBJIJIJIO Henocpe,D;- CTBeHHYJO yrp03y JII060MY rrpaBJIIQeMy pe)l{HMy. npaBJIIQeM napTHeM 6bIJIH 3arOTOBJieHbl 3Haq11TeJibHbie H3MeHeHHJI, KOTOpbie KaCaJIHCb KaK BHfTpeHHeM IIOJIHTHKH, TaK H BHeIIIHeM. 0,D;HaKO nOJIHTHqecKHe rrpoQeCCbl ,ll;HHaMHqHbl no CBOeM np11po,Z1;e, 1103TOMY rapaHTHpOBaTb O,ll;H03HaqHbIM ycnex 3THX pe<PopM HHKTO He Mor.

ECJIH 6hI qTO-TO nOIIIJIO He 110 IlJiaHy, BOeHHbie BIIOJIHe MOfJIH orpaHHqHTb pOJib flCP H OTCTpaHHTb napTHIO OT rocy,D;apCTBeHHblX IIpOQeCCOB, 3aMeHHB ee Ha KaKOfO-JIH60 6onee ::i<P<PeKTHBHOro, no HX MHeHHIO, HrpoKa, H 3TO He MOrJIO He 6ecnOKOHTb flCP. JlH,D;epbI rrapTHH H3HaqaJibHO IIOHHMaJIH, qTO pOJib BOeHHblX B TypeQKOM o6IQeCTBe ,ll;OJl)l{Ha 6hITb orpaH11qeHa, O,D;HaKO BOIIpoc 3aKJI10qaJICJI B TOM, KaK 3TO CJie,D;yeT C,D;eJiaTb, qT06bI He Bbl3BaTb o6IQeCTBeHHbIM pe3oHaHC H BCe06IQee He,D;OBOJibCTBO. Be,D;b eCJIH OTCTpa-

1 Turkey Corporate -Tax credits and incentives. URL: http://taxsummaries.pwc.com/ID/ Turkey-Corporate-Tax-credits-and-incentives.

41

HHTb apMHlO OT IIOJIHTHqecKHX rrpou;ecCOB 6e30CHOBaTeJibHO, TaKOH mar BpH,ZJ; JIH 6y,D;eT O,ll;06peH 6oJibIIIeH qacTblO BOeHHbIX.

KorreHrareHCKHe KpHTepHH CTaJIH BepHbIM perneHHeM IlCP OTHOCHTeJibHOrO 3TOrO BOIIpoca, a TaIOKe JierHTHMHbIM OCHOBaHHeM ,ll;JUi orpaHHqemrn IIOJIHOMOq11:H BOeHHbIX: BepxoBeHCTBO ,D;eMOKpaTHH rrpe,ll;IIOJiaraJIO OTCYTCTBHe KaKoro-JI1160 HCTOqHHKa BJiaCTH, IIOMHMO H36paHHOrO rrpe3H,ll;eHTa 11 YTBep)J(,ll;eHHoro HM rrpaBHTeJihCTBa.

fJiaBHbIM opraHOM, rrocpe,ll;CTBOM KOToporo BOeHHhie BJIHHIOT Ha rrpoBO,ll;HMYID rroJIHTHKY, HBJIHeTCH CoBeT Hau;110HaJibHOH 6e3orracHocTH. C03- ,D;aHHhIH IIOCJie rrepeBopoTa 1960 r., COBeT BbIIIOJIHHJI KOHCYJibTaTHBHbie cpyHKll;HH H CTaJI O,ll;HHM 113 u;eHTpaJihHblX 3JieMeHTOB rocy,D;apCTBeHHoro yrrpaBJieHHH1• Ero rroJIHOMOqHH 3Haq11TeJihHO pacrn11pHJIHCh rroCJie rrepeBoporn 1980 r.: K rrpHMepy, CoBeT MHHHCTpoB rrpH rrpHHHTMM perneHMH 6bm o6H3aH o6pa:ru;aTh «rrepBooqepe,D;Hoe BHMMaHMe» 2 Ha peK0MeH,ll;au;1111 CHE, qTo cpaKT11qecK11 YKa3bIBaJio Ha TO, qTo CoBeT HBJIHJICH qacThlO 11crroJIHMTeJihHOH cMcTeMhI CTPaHhI.

Cy:ru;ecTByeT ToqKa 3peHMH, qTo AHKapa CTaJia rrpOBO,ll;MTh H3MeHeHMH yqaCTMH BOeHHbIX B IIOJIHTMKe c pa3perneHMH caMoro reHepaJIMTeTa, KOTOpbIH BH,ll;eJI rJiaBHOH ll;eJiblO Bcero rrpou;ecca ,D;eMOKpaTM3au;MM BCTyrrJieHMe B EBpOCOl03. I1MeHHO 6Jiaro,D;apH yCTyrrKaM co CTOpOHbl BOeHHbIX pecpopMa M 6bma ocy:ru;ecTBJieHa.

B HHBape M aBrycTe 2003 r. 6bIJIM rrpHHHThI rrorrpaBKM B 3aKoH o CHE. B pe3yJihTaTe cyBepeHMTeT M rroJIHOMoq11H opraHa 6bIJIM 3Haq11TeJihHO

orpaH11qeHh1: rnaBa CoBeTa Terrepb Ha3HaqaJicH rrpeMbep-MHHMCTpoM, a Ha ~OJl)KHOCTb MOrJIO 6hITb 1'136paHOH rpa>K~aHCKOe Jim~o; 3ace~aHmI

CoBeTa OTHhIHe C03bIBaJIMCb pa3 B ~Ba MecHu;a BMeCTO e:JKeMecHqHoro c6opa, a B03rJiaBJIHJI MX rrpe3H,ll;eHT.

IlOCJie,ll;OBaJIO COKpa:tu;eHMe IIOJIHOMOqMif CeKpeTapMaTa COBeTa, KOTOpbIH yme He Mor ,D;eHCTBOBaTb OT HMeHM rrpe3H,ll;eHTa HJIM rrpeMbep-MHHM- CTpa. EhIJIO pacrry:ru;eHo yrrpaBJieHHe no CBH3HM c o6:ru;ecTBeHHOCThlO. Bee 3TM M3MeHeHHH He TOJibKO OTO,ll;BMHYJIM CoBeT OT rrpou;ecca rrpHHHTHH perneHMH, HO M rrpeBpaTHJIM ero B KOHCYJihTaTMBHhIH opraH, IIO,ll;BJiacTHhIH rrpe311,ll;eHry cTpaHhI. KpoMe Toro, CTPYKTYPa caMoro CHE rrpeTeprreJia 3Haq11TeJihHhie M3MeHeHHH, ,n;orryCTMB ,n;o pyKOBO,ll;CTBa rpa)J(,ll;aHCKMe JIMu;a.

nepBbie pe3yJibTaTbI M3MeHeHHH rrpOHBHJIMCb y:JKe B 2005 r. IIpM pa3pa6oTKe HOBOH K0Hu;erru;1111 Hau;110HaJibHOH 6e3orracHocTM Typu;1111. B xo,n;e o6cy:JK,n;eHMH rro311u;MH CHE rrpaKT11qecKM He yq11TbIBaJiacb, MHMu;MaTMBa Terrepb IIOJIHOCTblO IIpMHa,n;Jie:JKaJia IlCP.

EBporreH:cKaH KOMMCCMH IIOJIO:JKHTeJihHO ou;eHMJia rrpoBe,n;eHHhie pecpopMbI, o,n;HaKo B ee ,n;oKJia,n;e 3a 2004 r. OTMeqaJIOCh, qTo «BoeHHhie rrorrpe:JKHeMy OKa3bIBalOT BJIMHHMe c IIOMOiu;blO pa3JIMqHbIX HeOcpHu;MaJibHblX

1 OBcenRH JI. PecpopMbI CoaeTa HaQHOHaJibHOii 6eJorracttocTu Typ11uu B KOHTeKcTe ~eMoKpaTuqecKHX rrpeo6pa30BaHttii /I MeJK,l\yttapo~HaJI IIOJil!TttKa. 2010. C. 41-53. URL: https://riss.ru/images/pdf./journal/2010/2/0vsepiyrr_2010_2.pdf.

2 TaM JKe.

42

Mexamf3MOB» 1. npeMaraJIOCh orpaHH'IHThyqaCTHe reHepaJIHTeTa B rrpHHHTHH BOeHHOrO 6IOA)KeTa H B BhlCTpaHBaHHH OTHOIIIeHHH c coce,n;HHMH CTPaHaMH.

Typeu;Koe pYJ<OBO.ZJ;CTBO rrpHHIDIO K cBe,n;eHHIO peKoMeH,n;au;HH EBpoKoMHCCHH, H3MeHHB TaKTHKY 6opb6bI c BOeHHhIMH. B 2007 r. 6hIJIO Ha'laTO ,ZJ;eJIO IIO,ZJ; Ha3BaHHeM «3preHeKOH». no oqmu;HaJibHOH BepCHH, «3preHeKOH» HBJIHJiaCh TaHHOH opraHH3au;HeH, rJiaBHOH u;eJiblO KOTOpOH 6hIJIO

cBep)l(eHHe rrpaBHil\eH rrapTHH ITYTeM rrpoBe,n;eHHH BOeHHoro rrepeBopoTa

B 2003 r.

no HTOraM cy,n;a 6oJiee 500 qeJI. 6bIJIH OTIIpaBJieHhl B TIOphMy, B TOM 'lHCJierrpe,n;cTaBHTeJIH BhICIIIHX BOeHHhIX 'IHHOB:KOMaH,n;yroll\HH IlOJieBOH apMHH cyxorrYTHhIX BOHCK l..J:eTHH ,ll;oraH, rJiaBa feHrnTa6a 11.nhKep Earn6yr. HoBaH BOJIHa apecTOB rrpoIIIJla B 2016 r. IlOCJie HIOJlhCKOH IlOilhITKH BOeHHoro rrepeBopoTa. EhIJIH apecToBaHhI 6oJiee 100 a,n;MHpaJioB H reHepa.n:oB, MHOrHe H3 KOTOpbIX TaK*e BXO,ZJ;HJIH B CoBeT Hau;HoHaJibHOH 6e3orracHOCTH.

Bee 3TH Mephl 3Ha'!HTeJihHOOCJia6HJIH BOeHHOe rrpHCYTCTBHe BO BJiaCTH, CBe,n;H era K MHHHMyMy. fJiaBHhIH HHCTpyMeHT BOeHHOro ,n;aBJieHHH Ha rroJIHTHKY - CoBeT Hau;HoHaJihHOH 6e3orracHocTH - B pe3yJihTaTe H3MeHeHHH 6bIJI CHJlhHO orpaHH'leHB IIOJIHOMO'IHHX,'ITOO,ZJ;HOBpeMeHHO BXO,ZJ;HJIO B Ccpepy HHTepeCOB rrpaBHil\eH nCP If OTBe'laJIOrJiaBHOH IlOCTaBJieHHOH rrapTHeH: u;eJIH - BCTYIIJieHHIO Typu;HH B EBpocoI03.

AeM0Kpant1.1ecKMe npeo6pa30BaHMJ1: cso6oAa cnosa, npasa 'l@nOB@Ka

BCJie,n; 3a H3MeHeifHHMH, 3aTpOHYBIIIHMH yqacTHe BOeHHhIX B rroJIHTHKe,

6hm OCYil\eCTBJieH PM ,n;pyrHx Mep, rrpH3BaHHhIX yCKopHTh BCTYIIJieHHe Typ- 1.l;HH B EBpocoI03. B MapTe 2003 r. Typu;HH rro,n;rrHcaJia rrpoToKoJI NQ 6 EBporreH:cKoH KOHBeHI.l;HH 110 rrpaBaM qeJIOBeKa, 3a11pell\aIOil\eH CMepTHYIO Ka3Hh B MHpHoe BpeMH. 7 MaH 2004 r. B CT. 38 KOHCTHTYD;HH 6hIJIH BHeCeHhl rrorrpaBKH, KOTOphie OTMeHHJIH CMepTHYIO Ka3Hh rrpH JII06hIX o6CTOHTeJihCTBax, a TaK*e 0611\YIO KOHcpHCKau;HIO HMYil\eCTBa. l13MeHeHHH KOCHYJIHCh

If 3aKOHOB 0 cpoH,n;aX If 0611\eCTBax: 0611\eCTBeHHhIM opraHH3al.l;HHM 6bIJIO pa3perneHO ,n;eJiaTb rry6JIH'!Hble3aHBJieHHH 6e3 rrpe,n;BapHTeJihHOrO corJiaCHH c BJiaCTHMH, OTKphIBaTh rrpe,n;cTaBHTeJibCTBa 3a py6e)l(OM, a orpaHH'leHHH Ha B3aHMO,n;eH:cTBHe TYPeu;KHX opraHH3au;HH: c HX Me)l(,ll;yHapo,n;HhIMH rrapTHepaMH 6bIJIH CHHThl.

KpoMe Toro, 6hIJIH JIHKBH,n;HpoBaHhI Cy,n;hI roc6e3orracHocTH, perneHHe KOTOpbIX He rro,n;Jie)l(aJIO o6)1(aJIOBaHHIO. EhIJIH BBe,n;eHbl rrpou;e,n;ypa o6pall\eHHH B EBporreH:cKHH cy,n; no rrpaBaM 'leJIOBeKaH rrpttopHTeT aKTOB

1 Oecerurn JI. Pe<l>opMbI CoaeTa Ha11110HaJibHOH 6e3orracttocTH Typ111111 B KOHTeKcTe ,11eM0KpaT11qecK11x rrpeo6pa3oBaHHH // MelKJIYHapo,11HaJI rroJIHTHKa. 2010. C. 41-53. URL: https://riss.ru/images/pdf./journal/2010/2/0vsepiyn_2010_2.pdf.

43

H perneHHH EC Ha,n; MeCTHhIM 3aKoHo,n;aTt~.JibCTBOM. B 2004 r. 6hm npHIIBT 3aKOH o cBo6o,n;e 11mpopMau;1111, cornacHo KOTOPOMY )f(}'PHa.JIHCThIHe 6bmH o6H3aHbl coo6~aTb 0 CBOHX HH<popMaIJ;HOHHblX HCToqHHKax. KpoMe Toro, B paMKax ,n;aHHoro 3aKOHa 6bmH ,n;aHbl lllHpOKHe npHBH.JierHH MeHblllHHCTBaM, B qacTHOCTH K}'P,ll;aM:OHH no.nyqH.JIH B03MO:>KHOCTb TPaHC.JIHpoBaTb nepe,n;aq11 H neqaTaTh ra3eTbI Ha po,n;HOM H3hIKe, a B qacTHhIX lllKO.Jiax pa3perna.JIOCb OTKpbrnaTb K}'PCblno H3yqeHHIO K}'P,ll;CKoroH3bIKa.

EhmH OTMeHeHhI HaKa3aHHH 3a KPHTHKY rocy,n;apcTBeHHhlX yqpe:>K,ZJ;e- HHif; HeMycy.JihMaHCKHM o6~ecTBeHHbIM cpoH,n;aM H opraHH3aIJ;HHM 6bmo

pa3perneHo HMeTb co6CTBeHHOCTh; 6bm npHHHT 3aKOH, no KOTOPOMY .JII06oif rpa:>K,ZJ;aHHH Mor MHpHO BbIHTH Ha ,n;eMOHCTpau;HIO H.JIH npoTeCT 6e3 npe,n;- BapHTe.JibHOro pa3perneHHHi.

l13MeHeHHHM no,n;Bepr.Jiacb H o6pa3oBaTeJihHaH ccpepa. B 2005 r. 6bma npoBe,n;eHa KpynHoMacrnTa6HaH pecpopMa B lllKOJiax: CHCTeMa cTaJia 6oJiee opHeHTHpOBaHHOH Ha yqeHHKOB H ,ll;OCTH)KeHHe pe3yJibTaTa, 6bmo peCTPYKTYPHPOBaHO pacn11caH11e, YBe.JIHqHJIOCh KOJIHqecTBO qacoB peJIHrHo3HhIX yqeHHH.

TaKHM o6pa3oM, Ha nepBOM 3Tane nocJie np11xo,n;a K BJiacTH napTHH cnpaBe,ll;JIHBOCTH H pa3BHTHH ,n;eHCTBOBaJia B paMKax 3aHBJieHHbIX u;e.JieH. EhmH 3Haq11TeJibHO ocJia6JieHhI orpatt11qeHHH CMl1, BOeHHbie 6bmH oT,n;a- JieHbI OT BJiaCTH, a HX ,n;eHTe.JibHOCTb CTa.JIH KOHTpOJIHpOBaTb HCnOJIHHTe.JibHbie opraHbI BJiaCTH. Ha npoTH)KeHHH qeTbipex JieT 6bma nepecMOTpeHa TpeTb CTaTeH KOHCTHTYQHH, a BHeCeHHhie nonpaBKH nOBbICH.JIH aBTOpHTeT Typu;1111 Ha Me:>K,ZJ;yttapo,n;Hoif apeHe H B rJia3ax Espocoro3a.

0,n;HaKo KpoMe o,n;o6peHHH 3ana,n;HhIX CTPaH Typu;HH He cMorJia no.nyqHTh rnaBHOH IJ;e.JIH - BCTynJieHHH B EC. EsponeifcKHH coI03 npo,n;oJI)KaTb npH,n;y- MbIBaTb HOBbie Tpe6oBaHHH B OTHOllleHHH Typu;HH, H TaKHe ,n;eHCTBHH BCepbe3 3aCTaBH.JIH IlCP 3a,zi;)'MaTbCH0 npaBHJibHOCTH BbI6paHHOH nOJIHTHKH.

BC.Jie,n; 3a BBe,n;eHHeM ,n;eM0KpaT11qecK11x np11Hu;11noB H npHBe,n;eHHH 3aKoHo,n;aTe.JihCTBa B COOTBeTCTBHe c HOpMaMH EBpOCOI03a B Typu;HH HaqaJIHCb

HOBhie H3MeHeHHH, KOTOpbie B nepByIO oqepe,n;b KaCaJIHCb ycHJieHHH BJiaCTH npaBH~eif napTHH. CBH3aHO 3TO 6bmO B 6oJibllleH CTeneHH c H3MeHHB-

rneifCH BHYTpeHHeif KOH'hIOHKTypoif:cpe,n;H HaceJieHHH 11,n;eH np11coe,n;11HeHHH K Espone yme He Haxo,n;HJIH 6b1Jioif no,n;,n;ep)KKH. KpoMe 3Toro, caMa napTHH Haqa.Jia CTa.JIKHBaThCH c HOBbIMH npo6JieMaMH, KOTOpbie Tpe6oBa.JIH He3aMe,n;JIHTe.JibHOro perneHHH.

Bropoit nan: «AeMoKpant'lecKaHHHHL\Hantea»

HKOHCTHTYL\HOHHble H3MeHeHHH

BTopoif 3Tan 03HaMeHOBaJICH ,ll;B)'MHKpynHbIMH co6bITHHMH, KOTOpbie B 3Haq11TeJibHOH cTeneHH noBJIHHJIH Ha BHYTPH- H BHernttenoJIHTHqecKHH

1 Turkey: Continuing Restrictions on Freedom of Assembly 2004 April 27. URL: https:// www.hrw.org/news/2004/04/27 /turkey-continuing-restrictions-freedom-assembly.

44

KypC Ilapnrn: cnpaBe,zvIHBOCTH H pa3BHTllil: pa3JICl,ll; B OTHOUieHIUIX C EBpOCOI030M H 3aMopCOKHBam1e npou,ecca rreperoBopoB no BCTYJVIeHHIO Typu,HH B ,ll;aHHYJO opraHH3all,HIO, a TaIOKe Cy,ll;e6Hoe ,ll;eJIO B OTHOllleHHH IlapTHH crrpaBe,ll;JIHBOCTH pa3BHTIDI, KOTOpaH MOrJia rrpeKpaTHTb CBOe ~eCTBOBa­

HHe.

B 2006 r. B ,ll;BycTOpoHHHX OTHOI1IeHm1x c):>opMaTa EBpoco103 - TypQIDI rrpOH30IIIJIH 3HaqHMbie H3MeHeHIDI, O,ll;HaKO He B IIOJib3Y IIOCJie,ll;HeH:. EBporreH:cKHH co103 rrpHocTaHOBHJI rreper0Bopb1 o BCTYJVIeHHH Typeu,KoH: Pecrry611HKH B opraHH3aU,HIO. IloBO,ll;OM ,ll;JIH 3Toro, no 3aHBJieHHIO Co103a, CTaJIO HeBbIIIOJIHeHHe Typu,HeH: BCex rrpe,ll;IIHCaHHbIX IIyttKTOB KaCaTeJibHO TOproBJIH, TaMo:>KeHHOro pery11HpOBaHID1, CB060,ll;HOro rrepeMeIQeHIDI TOBapoB H KaIIHTaJia, a TaIOKe 3arrpeT KHIIpCKHM cy,ll;aM HCIIOJib30BaTb Typeu,- KHe rropTbI rroc11e KHnpcKoro pec):>epeH,ll;yMa 2004 r., Ha KOTopoM rpeqecKaH qaCTb OCTpOBa rrporOJIOCOBaJia rrpOTHB BOCCOe,ll;HHeHml. Tor,ll;aUIHHH rrpe- Mbep-MHHHCTp Typu,HH Pe,ll;:>Kerr TaH:Hrr 3p,ll;oraH 3a.HBHJI, qTo «IIpHHRTOe EBpOKOMHCCHeH: peUieHHe RBJIReTCR HerrpHeMJieMbIM» 1.

B HTore 3TH co6hITIDI rrpo,ll;eMOHCTpHpOBaJIH HaJIHqHe rrepBbIX rrpoTHBOpeqHfi CTopoH no Borrpocy qneHCTBa Typu,HH B EC H 3arrycTHJIH MHoroJieTHHH rrpou,ecc pa3HOrJiaCHH: HeCMOTpR Ha ,ll;aJibHeHUIHe IIOilbITKH ncP c6JIH311TbCJI c EBporroH:, HHKaKHX CYIQeCTBeHHbIX ,ll;OCTH:>KeHHH no 3TOMY BOIIpocy ,ll;OCTHrttyTo He 6hmo. B ,ll;OIIOJIHeHHe K 3TOMY Typu,IDI caMa CTaJia Bhl,ll;BHraTb co6crneHHbie Tpe6oBaHHH K EBpoco103y, qeM c):>aKTHqecKH rrpe,Z1;orrpe,Z1;eJIHJia HX HCXO,ll;.

B ,ll;aHHbIH rrepHO,ll; rrpaBRIQaH rrapTHR TaIOKe CTOJIKHy11acb c orrpe,ll;eJieHHbIMH CJIO:>KHOCTRMH BHYTPH CTpaHbI. B 2008 r. B Kottcnnyu,110HHbIH cy,n; rrpOTHB Hee 6bm IIO,ll;aH 11CK 0 3aKpbITHH. IlpH IIOJIO:>KHTeJibHOM HCXO,ll;e napTIDI 6bma 6bI JII1KBH,ll;HpOBaHa, a Bee ee HMYIQeCTBO H3bJITO. 14 MapTa 2008 r. rrpoKypaTypa BbICTYflHJia c Tpe6oBaHHeM pacrryCTHTb rrapTHIO ITO rrp11qHHe «HapyUieHIDI CBeTCKOro pe:>KHMa» 2. JlH,ll;epaM rrapTHH, B TOM q11cJie Pe,ll;:>Kerry TaH:Hrry 3p,ll;oraHy 11 A6,ll;yJIJia fIDJIIO, rpo3HJI 3arrpeT Ha Be,ll;eHHe IIOJIHTHqeCKOH ,Z1;eRTeJibHOCT11 B TeqeH11e IIRTI1 JieT.

Ycyry6JIAAO CHTYau,1110 H TO, qTo ,ll;eJio He 6bmo rrpeu,e,ll;eHToM: KoHCTHTYQHOHHbIH cy,ll; Y:>Ke 3aKpbrnaJI pa3JIHqHbie rroJIHTHqecK11e rrapTHH, B TOM q11cJie 11 06BHHeHHbie B rrpOHCJiaMCKHX B3rJIR,ll;aX IlapTHH 6JiarO,ll;eHCTBHJI H ,ll;06pO,ll;eTeJII1 B 1998 H 2001 rr. COOTBeTCTBeHHO. B 3TOT pa3 IlCP y,ll;aJIOCb 1136e:>KaTb JIHKBH,ll;all,HH TOJibKO JIHlllb rrepeBeCOM B O,ll;HH rOJIOC, O,ll;HaKO napTI1IO Bee :>Ke JII1IIIHJll1 cj:>HHaHCHpOBaHHJI co CTOpOHbl rocy,ll;apcrna3. HecMOTPR Ha 3TO, JIH,ll;epbl ncp CTpeMHJIHCb rrpo,Z1;eMOHCTp11poBaTb CBOIO YBepeHHOCTb, II03TOMY HOBOCTb 0 COMHHTeJibHOM, HaXO,ll;Rlll,HMCJI Ha rpaHI1, HO BCe

1 3,11opraH ocy,11WI pernem1e 3aMopo3HTh rreperosopbI o BCT)'IllleHJm Typn;1111 B EC. URL: https://ria.ru/world/20061129/56185993.html.

2 KottcT11ryn;110HHhIH cy,11 Typn;1111 paccMOTpHT HCK o 3aKpbITl!H rrpas1m~ei1 rrapTHH. URL: http://izvestia.ru/news/421822.

3 Typn;1111 ocTaeTrn 11cJiaMcKoi1. URL: https:/ /www.gazeta.ru/politics/2008/07/30 _a_2797315.shtml.

45

)Ke rroJIO)KHTeJihHOM ,ll;JIR IICP perneHHH rrpe,zi;cTaBHTeJIH caMoH: rrapTHH Ha3BaJIH «II06e,zi;oH: ,zi;eMOKpaTHH»l.

3TH co6hITHR B KaKOH-TO cTerreHH CTaJIH cHrHaJIOM ,ll;JlR IICP o TOM, 'ITO Ha cpoHe Hey,zi;aq, CBR3aHHbIX c rrpo3aIIa,D;HOH IIOJIHTHKOH, rrapTHH Heo6xo- ,ll;HMO yKpeIIHTb co6CTBeHHbIH aBTOpHTeT. ,Z:Vrn ,ll;OCTH)KeHHR 3THX u;eJieH TYPeD;KHe BJiaCTH peIIIHJIH OTOHTH OT ,zi;eMoKpaTH3aQHH, rrpttcyrneH: rrepBOMY 3Tarry pecpopM, H, CJie,zi;oBaTeJibHO, OT 3arra,zi;a. BMecTo 3Toro Ha'!aJIOCb IIOBCeMeCTHOe f)KeCTO'!eHHeIIOJIHTHKH, B qacTHOCTH B OTHOIIIeHHH CMI1 H BOeHHbIX. KpoMe Toro, 6bm 3arryrneH rrpou;ecc KOHCTHTYQHOHHblX H3MeHeHHH, KOTOpbie TaK)Ke ,ll;OJI)KHbI 6blJIH o6ecrre'!HTbIICP OTHOCHTeJibHYJO 6e3orracHOCTb OT HOBbIX cy,zi;e6HbIX ,ll;eJI B 6y,zi;yrneM. Ba)KHO, 'ITOIIO'ITHKa)K- ,ll;aR m rrpoBe,zi;eHHbIX IICP pecpopM IIJiaHoMepHo oT,zi;aJIRJia Typu;mo OT ,zi;eMoKpaTHH, a BMeCTe c 3THM H OT EBpOCOI03a.

KoHCTHTYQHOHHble H3MeHeHHH:

pe<t>epeHAYMbl 2007 H 2010 rOAOB

IIocJie co6bITHH c rrorrhITKOtt OTCTpaHeHHR IICP OT rroJIHTH'!eCKHx,zi;eJI rrepBoe H3MeHeHHe KOcttyJiocb Herrocpe,zi;cTBeHHO JaKpbITHR rrapTHH. ECJIH paHhIIIe ,ll;JIR Ha'laJia,zi;ena 6bmO ,ll;OCTaTO'!HOHHHQHaTHBbl rrpOKfPOpa (KaK 3TO H rrpmrnoumo B 2008 r.), TO Terrepb Tpe6oBaJICR YKa3 rrpe3H,D;eHTa H rrocTaHOBJieHHe COBeTa MHHHCTpOB. 06pa:w;eHHe )Ke B cy,zi; Terrepb ,ll;OJI)KHO ocyrneCTBJIRTbCR JIH6o HaIIpRMYJO MHHHCTpOM IOCTHQHH, JIH6o rrpe,zi;cTaBHTeJieM rrapJiaMeHTCKOH rrapnn1. KpoMe Toro, perneHHe o 3aKpbITHH rrapTHH B Harne BpeMR MO)KeT 6bITb 06)KaJIOBaHO. Ha ,zi;ene 3TH H3MeHeHHR C,ll;eJiaJIH rrpaKTH'!eCKHHeB03MO)f{HbIM 3arrpeT ,zi;eRTeJibHOCTH rrpaBR:w;eH: rrapTHH, KOTOpaR rro-rrpe)f{HeMy coxpaHAAa 60JibllrHHCTBO B rrapJiaMeHTe.

CTpeMJieHHe IICP He ,zi;orrycTHTh rroBTopeHHR co6bITHH rrpoumh1x JieT rrpORBHJIOCb H B ,zi;pyrHx KOHCTHTYQHOHHbIX H3MeHeHHRX, KOTOpbie HaumH cBoe oTpa)KeHHe B rryHKTax pecpepeH,zi;yMa 2007 r. CorJiaCHO rrpe,zi;crnBJieHHhIM IIOJIO)KeHHRM, rrpe3H,D;eHT HbIHe H36HpaeTCR BCeHapO,ll;HbIM rOJIOCOBaHHeM BMeCTO BbI6opoB B rrapJiaMeHTe; rrpe3H,D;eHTCKHH cpoK 6bm COKpa:w;eH c 7 ,ll;O 5 JieT, HO rrpH 3TOM rJiaBa rocy,zi;apCTBa MO)KeT 3aHHMaTb 3TOT IIOCT ,zi;Ba)K,ll;hI; KBOPYM rrapJiaMeHTa orrpe,zi;eJieH B 1/3 o6:w;ero 'IHCJia,zi;erryTaTOB

(184 ,zi;errYTaTa). Ha pecpepeH,zi;yMe rrporoJiocOBaJio 6oJiee 67 % )KHTeJieH: CTpaHbl, rrpH 3TOM «3a» BbICKa3aJIHCb 69 % rrporOJIOCOBaBIIIHX.

fJiaBHbIM rryHKTOM H3MeHeHHH RBJIRIOTCR BCeo6:w;He BbI60pbI rrpe3H- ,zi;eHTa. IICP 6hma fBepeHa B rrpRMOH rroMep)f{Ke HaceneHHR, 'ITOrro,zi;rnep- ,zi;HJiocb H Ha Bb16opax 2007 r.: rrapTHR 3p,zi;oratta rroJiyqHJia 46 % roJiocoB2. l13MeHeHHe crroco6a roJIOCOBamrn Hf)KHO 6bIJIO ,ll;JIR Toro, 'IT06bIo6oHTH

1 Typ~11J1 oCTaeTrn 11cJiaMcKoi1. URL: https:/ /www.gazeta.ru/politics/2008/07/30 _a_2797315.shtml.

2 Typ~l1JI. napJiaMeHTCKl1e Bw6opbl 2007. URL: https://www.electoralgeography.com/ new/ru/countries/t/turkey/turkey-legislative-election-2007.html.

46

HaJIO)l{eHHoe KoHCTH~HOHHhIM cy,n;oM orpaHw1eHHe: ,n;;rn Bcryruremrn: ITpe3H,ll;eHTa B ,ll;OJI)l{HOCTb B ITapJiaMeHTe ,ll;OJI)l{HO ITpHCYTCTBOBaTb 2/3 Bcex ,n;eIIYTaTOB1, 'ITOTeopeTH'leCKH,ll;aBaJIO OITIT03HQHOHHbIM ITapnrn:M B03M0)1{- HOCTb BOCITpern1TCTBOBaTb Ha3Ha'leHHIO.TeITepb )l{e 3TO orpaHH'leHHe6hmo ITpeo,n;oJieHo, a ITpaBa ,n;eITYTaToB orpaHH'leHhI.

l.J:epe3 HeCKOJibKO JieT ITOCJie 3THX H3MeHeHHH, B 2010 r., B TypQHH 6bm ITpOBe,n;eH ern;e O,ll;HH peqiepeH,ll;YM, KOTOpbIH Ha 3TOT pa3 6bm ITOCBHID;eH H3MeHeHHIO ITOJIO)l{eHHH KOHCTHTYQHH, KOTOpbre ,ll;OJI)l{Hbl 6bmH CTaTb MaKCHMa.JlbHO ITpH6JIH)l{eHHhIMH K cTatt,z:i;apTaM EC.

,ll;eHCTBHTeJibHO, 60JibllIHHCTBO H3MeHeHHH KacaJIHCb ,n;eMOKpaTH3aQHH: CHHMaJIHCb orpaHH'leHHHHa ITpOTeCTbI pa60'IHX,BBO,n;HJiaCb ,ll;OJI)l{- HOCTb OM6y,n;cMeHa. 0,n;HaKO rnaBHbIM rryHKTOM pe<l>epett,z:i;YMa CTaJia TpaHC- <l>opMaQHH KoHCTHTYQHOHHoro cy,n;a. KoJIH'leCTBocy,n;eH: yseJIH'IHBaJioch c 11,n;o 17; 3 H3 HHX H36HpaJIHCb ITapJiaMeHTOM, a 14 TeITepb JIH'IHOHa3HaqaJI ITpe3H,ll;eHT; cpoK ITOJIHOMO'IHHH36paHHbIX cy,n;eH: COCTaBJIHJI 12 JieT2. IlOMHMO 3Toro ,n;eITYTaTbI, 'lbHITapTHH ITO,ll;Jle)l{aJia JIHKBH,ll;aQHH ITO peIIIeHHIO KoHCTHTYQHOHHOro cy,n;a, ITpO,ll;OJI)l{aJIH OCTaBaThCfl B ,ll;OJI)l{HOCTH

,n;o HCTe'leHHHcpoKa ITOJIHOMO'IHH.

IlaKeT ITOITpaBoK 6bm ITPHHHT rpa)l{,ll;aHaMH (57 % roJiocoB). IloCJie era ITpHHflTHH ncP ITpaKTH'leCKHo6ecITe'IHJiace6e ITpoBe,n;eHHe BHYTPHITOJIHTH'leCKOroKypCa, H HHKaKaH HHCTaHQHH He MOrJia orpaHH'IHTb,n;eHCTBHH ITapTHH HJIH ITOMeIIIaTh eH:. KoHCTHTYQHOHHbIH cy,n; - ITOCJie,ll;HHH opraH, CITOC06Hhlll 3aITpeTHTb HJIH orpaHH'IHTb,n;eHTeJibHOCTb ITapTHH, - OKa3aJICfl ITOJIHOCThIO B PYKaX ITpe3H,ll;eHTa cTpaHhI.

KpoMe Toro, B 2011 r. 3Ha'IHTeJibHbIMH3MeHeHHHM ITO,ZJ;Beprnocb TypeQKOe ITpaBHTeJihCTBO. BMeCTO rocy,z:i;apCTBeHHOH opraHH3aQHH ITJiaHHpoBaHHfl 6bmo o6pa30BaHO MHHHCTepCTBO pa3BHTHH, B 3a,ZJ;a'IHKOTOporo

BXO,ll;HT ITJiaHHpOBaHHe ITporpaMMbI pa3BHTHH CTpaHbI Ha MaKp0ypOBHe3. MHHHCTepCTBO OKp~aIOrn;e:H: cpe,ZJ;bI H JieCHOro X03HHCTBa 6bmo ITepeHMe-

HOBaHO B MHHHCTepCTBO JieCHoro H BO,ll;HOro X03HHCTBa. EbIJIO C03,ZJ;aHO MHHHCTepCTBO TaMO)l{HH H TOproBJIH. feHepaJibHOe yrrpaBJieH:He MOJIO,ZJ;e- )l{H H crropTa 6bIJIO ITpeo6pa30BaHO B MHHHCTepCTBO CITOpTa H MOJIO,ZJ;e)l{- HOH ITOJIHTHKH. BMeCTO MHHHCTepCTBa BHeIIIHe:H: TOprOBJIH 6bIJIO C03,n;a- HO MHHHCTepCTBO 3KOHOMHKH, a BMeCTO YrrpaBJieH:Hfl COQHaJihHbIX ycJiyr H 3aID;HTbI ,n;eTeH 3aHHJIO MHHHCTepCTBO ITO ,z:i;eJiaM ceMbH H COQHaJihHOH ITOJIHTHKH. HaKOHeQ, OT,ll;eJibHO 6hmO C03,ZJ;aHO MHHHCTepCTBO ITO ,ZJ;eJiaM EBpoITeHCKOro COI03a.

B TypQHH B 2013 r. Ha'laJiacbMaCIIITa6HM peqiopMa cHcTeMbI MYHHQHITaJibHoro caMoyITpaBJieHHH. KoJIH'leCTBOMyttHQHITaJIHTeToB 6bmo 3Ha-

1 Turkey's first five referendums: A look back. URL: http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/ turkeys-first-five-referendums-a-look-back.aspx?page!D = 438&n =the-five-referendums-in-the- history-of-turkey-2010-07-28.

2 Typl\HH rro.n;.n;ep)!(an:a KOHCTHTYl\HOHHYJO pe¢opMy. 2010. 12 cettrn6pH. URL: http:/I www.bbc.com/russian/international/2010/09I100912_turkey_referendum_vote.

3 Republic of Turkey ministry of development URL: http://www.mod.gov.tr/Pages/ Overview.aspx.

47

q1neJihHO cmrn<eHo - c 2047 s 2009 r . .n;o 1394 s 2014 r. EhVIO sse.n;etto qeTbipe ypOBIDI M}'HHI.J;HllaJlbHbIXo6pa30B3HHH: MeTPOilOJlbHbie M}'HHI.J;HllaJIHTeThl, KOTOpbie o6o3HaqaroT TYPeQKHe npoBHHQHH c KpyrrHhIM ropo.n;oM B KaqecTBe 3.n;MHHHCTP3THBHOro u;eHTpa (TaKHX paifOHOB 30); CTOJIHqHble MyttHI.J;HllaJIHTeTbl - pattOHbl CTpaHhl, r.n;e npmKHB3IOT Mettee 750 TbIC. qe.n.; paifOHHbie MyttHI.J;HllaJIHTeThl, a TalOKe ropo.n;cKHe, KOTOpbie cl>YHKI.J;HOHHPYIOT s Mettee KpyrrtthIX ropo.n;ax, He HBJIHIOII.J;HXOI 3.n;MHHHCTPaTHBHbIMH u;eHTpaMH.

PaifOHHhie MyttHI.J;HllaJIHTeTbl yrpaTHJIH CBOIO BJI3CTb, TaK KaK 60JiblIIHHCTBO HX IlOJIHOMOqHif Tenepb nepe.n;asaJIOCb MeTPOTIOJibHbIM H CTOJIHqHbIM MyttHu;HnaJIHTeTaM. KpoMe Toro, .n;epeBHH s6JIH3H CTOJIHqHhIX M}'HHu;HnaJIHTeTOB .n;omKHbl 6bITb npeo6pa30B3Hbl B MHKpopaifOHbl B npe.n;e.nax COOTBeTCTB}7lOII.J;HX ropo.n;osl. TaKHM o6pa3oM, BJiaCTh 6bma nepepacnpe.n;eJieHa B 110Jlb3Y KpyrrHbIX 3.n;MHHHCTP3THBHbIX e,ll;HHHI.J;.

B Typu;HH s 2012 r. 6bma sse.n;etta HOBaH CHCTeMa o6pa3oBaHHH, yCJIOBHO o6o3HaqeHHaH KaK «4 + 4 + 4»: qeTbipe ro.n;a y.n;e.nHeTCH ttaqaJibHOMY o6pa30BaHHIO, CTOJibKO )Ke - sceo6iu;eMy o6JI3aTeJibHOMY cpe.n;HeMy. ~aJiee

IIIKOJibHHKaM npe.n;ocTaBJIAAOI caMOCTOJITeJibHbIH Bb16op. 0HH snpase npo- ,ll;OJI)KHTb o6yqeHHe, npHqeM KaK B o6iu;eo6pa30BaTeJibHbIX IIIKOJiax, TaK H B pe.nHrH03HbIX - IIIKOJiaX HM3M-X3TH6os.

nonMTMKa B OTHOW@HMM BO@HHblX lr1 >KypHanMCTOB

lfro KacaeTCJI soeHHbIX, TO 3HaqHTeJibHbIX H3MeHeHHH He npe.n;noJiaraJIOCh H He 6bmo. CTPoraH JIHHHH s OTHOIIIeHHH soeHHOCJif)KaII.J;HX 6hma npo.n;oJI)l{e- Ha H YKPellJI5IJiacb c K3)1{,ll;hIM ro.n;oM. ~oIIIJio .n;o Toro, qTo s 2011 r. see soettttoe PYKOBO,ll;CTBO Typu;HH YIIIJIO s OTCTaBKy: ocl>Hu;HaJihHOH npHqHHOH 6ecnpeu;e.n;eHTHoro IIIara CTaJIH «pa3HOrJiaCHH c npaBHTeJibCTBOM 3p.n;oratta»2.

KpoMe Toro, Ha pecl>epett.n;yMe 2010 r. ttaceJiettHe nporoJiocosaJio 33 OTMeHy nonpaBKH, 1103BOJI5IIOII.J;eif BOeHHbIM - yqaCTHHKaM nepesopoTa 1980 r. H36e)l{aTb cy.n;a. I1oCJie 3Toro cy.n;e6ttoMy npeCJie.n;osaHHIO no.n;seprnHCb 6hIBIIIHH npe3tt.n;eHT CTpaHhI, rettepaJI KettaH 3speH H 6brnIIIHH ttaqaJibHHK feHIIITa6a 11.n:hKeH EaIII6yr, KOTOpb1e s 2014 r. noJiyqHJIH 110)1{H3HeHHhie cpOKH.

HaKotteu;, nocJie 3asepIIIeHHH paccJie.n;osaHHH no .n;eJiy «3pretteKOH», B pe3yJibTaTe KOTOporo B TIOpbMY 110113JIH MHOrHe npe.n;cTaBHTeJIH reHepaJIHTeTa, Typeu;KHe soeHHhie nepecTaJIH npe.n;cTaBJIHTh pean:hHYIO yrpo3y BJI3CTH I1CP.

1 Husniye Akilli, H. Serkan Akilli. Decentralization and recentralization of local governments in Turkey. URL: http://ac.els-cdn.com/S1877042814034193/1-s2.0-S1877042814034193- main.pdf.?_tid=f2a3a900-9708-lle7-8e76-00000aabOf6c&acdnat=l505145214_0786a4c37 703ceb2bde2ad8d88857df9.

2 .4PYJICUJ!OBCKUU c. E. 0 BHyrpeHHl:IX np11q11Hax TIOJIHTHqecKOH HeCTa611JibHOCTl1 BType11KOH Pecny6JI11Ke // 2016. N2 2 (47). BecTHHK MfI1MO YH11Bepc11TeTa. C. 15-21. URL: http://www.vestnik.mgimo.ru/sites/default/files/pdf./002_druzhilovskiisb.pdf.

48

TioCJie,n;HeH nonbITKOH BOeHHblX nOBJillilTb Ha cinyau;mo CTa.JI Hey,ll;aqHblH nepesopoT 15 lUOllil 2016 r., KOTOpbIH 3aBepIIIIUICH nOJIHbIM nopa:JKeH11eM BOeHHbIX. B pe3y11bTaTe 6011ee 100 reHepa.rroB 11 3,1J;M11pa.rroB 6bIJI11 B3.HTbI no,ll;

CTpa:JKY, a 113 npaBooxpaH11TeJihHhIX opraHOB 6bm11 YBOJieHbI TbIDJq11 JIIO,ll;eH. CTa.rro oqeBH,ll;HO, qTo apM11.H YTPaTIUla cBoro cillly 11 He cnoco6Ha KaKHM111160 o6pa30M nOBJillilTb Ha BHy-TpeHHIOIO c11ryau;11ro.

TIOM11MO :noro Y:JKeCToqaJiaCb nOJI11Tl1Ka no OTHOIIIeH11IO K :lKypHaJI11CTaM. Tioc11e nepe)l<HTbIX co6bIT11H 11 nonbITOK orpaH11q11Tb BJiaCTb TiapTllil cnpaBe,ll;Jl11BocT11 11 pa3Bl1Tl1.H nepe:JKHBa.rra 3a CBOH 11MH,ll;:lK KaK BHYTP11 CTpaHbl, TaK 11 3a ee npe,1J;eJiaM11. Cpe,ll;CTBa MaCCOBOH 11H<l>opMau;1111 6hIJI11 TOH CIUIOH, KOTOpa.H OCBeID;a.Jia nOJI11Tl1KY npaB.HID;eH napT1111 B HeBbirO,ll;HOM ,ll;Jl.H Hee CBeTe. I1MeHHO n03TOMY B paMKax npoBO,ll;l1MbIX pecpopM 3Haq11TeJibHOe ,1J;aBJ1eH11e CTa.Jll1 HCnbITbIBaTb H :JKYPHaII11CTbl.

Typu;11.H B 2012-2013 rr. 3aH11Ma.Jia nepBoe MeCTO B MHpe no KOJIHqeCTBY HaXO,ll;.HID;HXCH B JaKJIIoqeH1111 :JKYPHM11CTOB, onepe)f(a.H I1paH 11 KHTaii1• Tip11 3TOM Hl1 O,ll;HOMY )f(ypHa.JI11CTY He 6hIJIH Bbl,ll,Bl1Hy-Tbl 06B11HeHl1.H B yroJIOBHOM npeCTy-IIJieH1111. TIOM11MO apeCTOB B CTpaHe pa3BepHyJiaCb II111p0Ka.H BOJIHa )f(ypHa1111cTcK11x yBOJibHeH11ii: 3a BpeM.H npaBJieHllil TICP 6011ee

2 TbIC. )f(ypHaJI11CTOB noTep.HJI11 pa6ory2.

Heo,ll;HOKpaTHO Typeu;KoMy pyKOBO,ll;CTBY nOCTYIJaII11 )f(a.JI06b1 OT Me)f(,ll;y- Hapo,ll;HhIX opraH11Jau;11H:: «PenopTephI 6e3 rpaH11u;», KoM11TeT JaID;l1TbI )f(ypHa1111cTOB o6paID;a.JI11Cb K npaB11TeJibCTBY c Tpe60BaH11eM npeKpaT11Tb 6e30CHOBaTeJibHbie npeCJie,ll;oBaHH.H CMI13.

Cpe,1J;11 Hatt6011ee pe3oHaHCHbIX ,1J;e11 B OTHOIIIeHH11 npeccb1 - 3a,1J;ep)f(a- H11e r11aBhI KpynHeiiIIIeii raJeThI Cumhuriyet H apecTbI )f(ypHaJIHCTOB B paMKax ,ll;eJia «3preHeKOH». B 2016 r. cttryau;tt.H ycyry6HJiaCb: noCJie 11IOJibCKOH nonbITKH BOeHHOrO nepeBopoTa B CTpaHe 6hIJIO 3aKpbITO 23 pa,ll;HOCTaHu;HH,

60 ra3eT H :JKYPHaJIOB, 16 TeJieKaHaJioB4. Te, qTo OCTa.Jll1Cb, BeJIH H npO,ll;OJl- :JKaIOT BeCTH nponpaBHTeJibCTBeHHYJO nponaraH,ll;y. TaKHM o6pa30M, rpa)f(- ,ll;aHe Typeu;KoH: Pecny61111KH JIHIIIHJIHCh npaBa He TOJihKO Ha o6'heKTHBHYJO ou;eHey KaKoH:-111160 cttryau;tt11 B CMI1, HO 11 Ha Bb1pa)f(eH11e cy6'heKT11BHoro MHeHllil.

TIO nOH.HTHblM np11q11HaM n0,1J;06Hbie H3MeHeHH.H He MOrJIH He 3aTpOHYTb 11HTepHeT, a 11MeHHO - BOnpoc CB060,ll;bl CJIOBa B HeM. B 2007 r. Ha TeppHTOp1111 Typu;HH 6bIJI np11H.HT «AKT 06 11HTepHeTe», corJiaCHO KOTOpOMY JII06oH: caH:T c 3anpeID;eHHbIM KOHTeHTOM Mor 6hITb 3a6JioKHpOBaH. Tip11qeM nOBO,ll;OM ,ll;llil 3TOro MOrJio nOCJIY:JKHTb noqTH Ka)f(,ll;Oe ,ll;eHCTB11e, HanpaBJieH-

l ,l(pyJKwzoecKuu C. E. 0 mryrpeHHHX rrpwmHax rroJIIITH'leCKOH HecTa6HJihHOCTH BTypeQKOH Pecrry6JIHKe // 2016. N° 2 (47). BecTHHK Mfl1MO YHHBeprnTeTa. C. 15-21. URL: http://www.vestnik.mgimo.ru/sites/default/files/pdf./002_druzhilovskiisb.pdf.

2TaM JKe.

3Cy,'1,b6a apeCToBaHHbIX JKypHaJIHCTOB B TypQHH. URL: http:/ /www.svoboda. org/a/24472458.html.

4BJiacTH TypQHH Ha'laJIH KaMrraHHIO rro MaccosoMY 3aKphITHIO CMYI. URL: https://vz.ru/ news/201617/27 /823882.html.

49

HOe nponrn ,n;eiieTByro~ero npaB11Te.JibeTBa IDIM KpMTMKYJO~ee OT,ll;e.JlbHbIX JIMQ, 3aHMMaIO~Mx He noCJie,n;Hee MeCTo B roey,n;apeTBe. K npMMepy, rrpMqnHoii 6JIOKMpOBKM Morna eTaTb KpMTMKa ATaTIOpKa.

E,z:\MHbIH peeCTp 3anpe~eHHbIX eaHTOB 6bm e03,n;aH B 2011 r., a B 2014 r. Ha3BaHHbIH 3aKOH e~e eMJibHee }')KeeTOqMJIM:Tenepb ,n;mI 6JIOKMpOBKM JI106oro eaii:Ta He Tpe6oBaJioeb perneHMe ey,n;a. 3a 3TMM rroCJie,n;oBMa 6JioKMpOBKa MHOrMx M3BeeTHbIX eeTeii: Faeebook, Twitter, YouTube.

B 3TOM KOHTeKeTe aKryaJibHbIM HBAAeTCR BOnpoe rrpaB M IIOJIHOMOqMif TYPeQKMX npaBooxpaHMTe.JibHbIX opraHOB. B MapTe 2015 r. napJiaMeHT rrpMHHJI 3aKOH, 3HaqMTe.JlbHO paernMpHIO~MH IlOJIHOMOqMJI IIOJIMIJ;MM M :>KaH- ,n;apMepHH. B eoOTBeTeTBMM e HMM IlOJIMri;eiieKMe noJiyqIDIM rrpaBO ,n;oeMaTpMBaTb JII06oro rpa:>K,n;aHMHa M JI106oe TpaHenopTHoe epe,n;eTBO B eJiyqae IlO,ll;03peHM5I KaeaTeJibHO HaJIMqMJI opy:>KMH MJIM ,n;pyrMX 3anpe~eHHbIX epe,n;eTB. B,n;o6aBoK rroJimi;eiieKMM pa3perneHo MerroJib30BaTb 6oeBoe opy- :>KMe npOTMB Tex, KTO HanaJI IDIM e,n;e.JIM IIOIIbITKy Hana,n;eHMH Ha IlOJIMIJ;eHeKoro IDIM ,n;pyroro rpa:>K,n;aHMHa.

KpoMe Toro, npaBooxpaHMTeJibHbIM opraHaM no3BOJieHo opraHM30BbIBaTb npoeJiyIIIKy JI106oro yeTpoiieTBa Ha epoK ,n;o 48 q 6e3 pacnopH:>KeHMH ey,n;a B qpe3BbrqaifHbIX eMryari;HHX, a TaK:>Ke 3a,n;ep:>KMBaTb JI106oro rpa:>K,n;a- HMHa Ha 24 q 6e3 op,n;epa Ha apeCT B eJiyqae rrpOHBJieHMH arpeeeMM IDIM :>KeeTOKOeTM B o6~eeTBeHHbIX MeeTax. BBO,ll;IDICR TIOpeMHbIH epoK (OT 6 Mee.

,n;o 3 JieT) ,ll;JIH yqaeTHMKOB ,n;eMOHCTpari;HH, KOTOpbre BbIXO,ll;IDIM Ha npoTeCT B o,n;e:>K,n;e e eMMBOJIMKOH He3aKOHHbIX opraHM3aQMH. TaK:>Ke :>KaH,n;apMepHH rrepernJia no,n; 10pHe,n;MKQMIO MMHMeTepeTBa BHYTpeHHMX ,n;e.n1. Bee 3TM M3MeHeHMH eyrn;eeTBeHHO paernMpIDIH noJIHOMOqMJI TYPeu;KMx rrpaBooxpaHMTe.JibHbIX opraHOB.

<<AeMOKpaTH'leCKaJIHHH"'HaTHBa»:pecl>opMbl B OTHOWeHHH

Ha"'HOHanbHblXMeHbWHHCTB

AHTM,ll;eMOKpaTHqeeKaH IIOJIMTMKa CTCP oeo6eHHO IlpOHBMJiaeb B OTHOIIIeHMHX e HaQMOHaJibHbIM MeHbllIMHeTBOM roey,n;apeTBa, B qaeTHOeTM Kyp- ,n;aMM. Typeri;Ko-Kyp,n;eKMH KOHci>JIMKT eyrn;eerneHHO o6oeTpIDieH. B 1978 r. 6hrJia o6pa30BaHa Pa6oqaH napTHH Kyp,n;HeTaHa. K 3TOMY ,n;o6aBMJieH M apMHHeKMH BOIIpoe, KOTOpbIH Ha rrpOTH:>KeHMH Beeii MeTOpHH roey,n;apeTBa Haxo,n;IDieH Ha IIOBeeTKe ,ll;HH.

C HaqaJia eBOero npaBJieHMH ,n;JIH eM5J:rqeHM5I 3TMX rrpo6JieM IlapTHH errpaBe,ll;JIMBOeTM M pa3BMTMH rrpe,n;npHHMMaJia pH,n; rnaroB, M HaM60Jiee KpynHbIM M3 HMX eTM «IlpoeKT e,n;MHerna H 6paTerna» (Milli Birlik ve Karde~lik

Projesi), qaeTo Ha3bIBaeMbIH «,ll;eMoKpaTMqeeKoii MHMQMaTMBOH». CYTb rrpoeKTa 3aKJI10qaJiaeb B rrpe,n;oeTaBJieHMH HaeeJieHHIO IIIMpOKoro Kpyra rrpaB

MCB06o,n;.

1Wendy Zeldin. Turkey: Recent Developments in National and Public Security Law. URL: https ://www.loc.gov/law/help/national-security-law/turkey-recent-developments-2015.pdf.

so