
- •Preface
- •Acknowledgements
- •Introduction
- •Russian Imperial Archaeology (pre-1917)
- •Soviet Archaeology (1917–1991)
- •Marxist-Leninist Ideology
- •Intellectual Climate under Stalin
- •Post–World War II
- •‘Swings and Roundabouts’
- •Archaeology in the Caucasus since PERESTROIKA (1991–present)
- •PROBLEMS IN THE STUDY OF CAUCASIAN ARCHAEOLOGY
- •1 The Land and Its Languages
- •GEOGRAPHY AND RESOURCES
- •Physical Geography
- •Mineral Resources
- •VEGETATION AND CLIMATE
- •GEOMORPHOLOGY
- •THE LANGUAGES OF THE CAUCASUS AND DNA
- •HOMININ ARRIVALS IN THE LOWER PALAEOLITHIC
- •Characteristics of the Earliest Settlers
- •Lake Sites, Caves, and Scatters
- •Technological Trends
- •Acheulean Hand Axe Technology
- •Diet
- •Matuzka Cave and Mezmaiskaya Cave – Mousterian Sites
- •The Southern Caucasus
- •Ortvale Klde
- •Djruchula Klde
- •Other sites
- •The Demise of the Neanderthals and the End of the Middle Palaeolithic
- •NOVEL TECHNOLOGY AND NEW ARRIVALS: THE UPPER PALAEOLITHIC (35,000–10,000 BC?)
- •ROCK ART AND RITUAL
- •CONCLUSION
- •INTRODUCTION
- •THE FIRST FARMERS
- •A PRE-POTTERY NEOLITHIC?
- •Western Georgia
- •POTTERY NEOLITHIC: THE CENTRAL AND SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •Houses and Settlements
- •The Kura Corridor
- •The Ararat Plain
- •The Nakhichevan Region, Mil Plain, and the Mugan Steppes
- •Ditches
- •Burial and Human Body Representations
- •Materiality and Social Relations
- •Ceramic Vessels
- •Chipped and Ground Stone
- •Bone and Antler
- •Metals, Metallurgy and Other Crafts
- •THE CENTRAL AND NORTHERN CAUCASUS
- •CONTACT AND EXCHANGE: OBSIDIAN
- •Patterns of Procurement
- •CONCLUSION
- •The Pre-Maikop Horizon (ca. 4500–3800 BC)
- •The Maikop Culture
- •Distribution and Main Characteristics
- •The Chronology of the Maikop Culture
- •Villages and Households
- •Barrows and Burials
- •The Inequality of Maikop Society
- •Death as a Performance and the Persistence of Memory
- •The Crafts
- •THE SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •Ceramics and Metalwork
- •Houses and Settlements
- •The Treatment of the Dead
- •The Sioni Tradition (ca. 4800/4600–3200 BC)
- •Settlements and Subsistence
- •Sioni Cultural Tradition
- •Chipped Stone Tools and Other Technologies
- •CONCLUSIONS
- •BORDERS AND FRONTIERS
- •Georgia
- •Armenia
- •Azerbaijan
- •Eastern Anatolia
- •Iran
- •Amuq Plain and the Levantine Coastal Region
- •Cyprus
- •Early Settlements: Houses, Hearths, and Pits
- •Later Settlements: Diversity in Plan and Construction
- •Freestanding Wattle-and-Daub Structures
- •Villages of Circular Structures
- •Stone and Mud-brick Rectangular Houses
- •Terraced Settlements
- •Semi-Subterranean Structures
- •Burial customs
- •Sacred Spaces
- •Structures
- •Hearths
- •Early Ceramics
- •Monochrome Ware
- •Enduring Chaff-Face Wares
- •Burnished Wares
- •LATE CERAMICS
- •The Northern (Shida Kartli) Tradition
- •The Central (Tsalka) Tradition
- •The Southern (Armenian) Tradition
- •MINING FOR METAL AND ORE
- •STONE AND BONE TOOLS AND METALWORK
- •Trace Element Analyses
- •SALT AND SALT MINING
- •THE PROCESS OF MIGRATION
- •The Mobile and the Settled – The Economy of the Kura-Araxes
- •Animal Husbandry
- •Agricultural Practices
- •CONCLUSION
- •FUNERARY CUSTOMS AND BURIAL GOODS
- •MONUMENTALISM AND ITS MEANING IN THE WESTERN CAUCASUS
- •CHRONOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS
- •THE NATURE OF THE EVIDENCE
- •THE SOUTHERN CAUCASUS
- •EARLY BRONZE AGE IV/MIDDLE BRONZE AGE I (2500–2000 BC)
- •Sachkhere: A Bridging Site
- •Martkopi and Early Trialeti Barrows
- •Bedeni Barrows
- •Ananauri Barrow 3
- •Bedeni Barrows
- •Other Bedeni Barrows
- •Bedeni Settlements
- •Berikldeebi Village
- •Berikldeebi Pits
- •Other Bedeni Villages
- •Crafts and Technology
- •Ceramics
- •Woodworking
- •Flaked stone
- •Sacred Spaces
- •The Economic Subsistence
- •The Trialeti Complex (The Developed Stage)
- •Categorisation
- •Mound Types
- •Burial Customs and Tomb Architecture
- •Ritual Roads
- •Human Skeletal Material
- •The Zurtaketi Barrows
- •The Meskheti Barrows
- •The Atsquri Barrow
- •Ephemeral Settlements
- •Gold and Silver, Stone, and Clay
- •Silver Goblets: The Narratives
- •Silver Goblets: Interpretations
- •More Metal Containers
- •Gold Work
- •Tools and Weapons
- •Burial Ceramics
- •Settlement Ceramics
- •The Brili Cemetery
- •WAGONS AND CARTS
- •Origins and Distribution
- •The Caucasian Evidence
- •Late Bronze Age Vehicles
- •Burials and Animal Remains
- •THE MIDDLE BRONZE AGE III (CA. 1700–1450 BC)
- •The Karmirberd (Tazakend) Horizon
- •Sevan-Uzerlik Horizon
- •The Kizyl Vank Horizon
- •Apsheron Peninsula
- •THE NORTHERN CAUCASUS
- •The North Caucasian Culture
- •Catacomb Tombs
- •Stone Cist Tombs
- •Wooden Graves
- •CONCLUSIONS
- •THE CAUCASUS FROM 1500 TO 800 BC
- •Fortresses
- •Settlements
- •Burial Customs
- •Metalwork
- •Ceramics
- •Sacred Spaces
- •Menhirs
- •SAMTAVRO AND SHIDA KARTLI
- •Burial Types
- •Settlements
- •THE TALISH TRADITION
- •CONCLUSION
- •KOBAN AND COLCHIAN: ONE OR TWO TRADITIONS?
- •KOBAN: ITS PERIODISATION AND CONNECTIONS
- •SETTLEMENTS
- •Symmetrical and Linear Structures
- •TOMB TYPES AND BURIAL GROUNDS
- •THE KOBAN BURIAL GROUND
- •COSTUMES AND RANK
- •WARRIOR SYMBOLS
- •TLI AND THE CENTRAL REGION
- •WHY METALS MATTERED
- •KOBAN METALWORK
- •Jewellery and Costume Accessories
- •METAL VESSELS
- •CERAMICS
- •CONCLUSION
- •10 A World Apart: The Colchian Culture
- •SETTLEMENTS, DITCHES, AND CANALS
- •Pichori
- •HOARDS AND THE DESTRUCTION OF WEALTH
- •CERAMIC PRODUCTION
- •Tin in the Caucasus?
- •The Rise of Iron
- •Copper-Smelting through Iron Production
- •CONCLUSION
- •11 The Grand Challenges for the Archaeology of the Caucasus
- •References
- •Index
Conclusion |
473 |
Houses have not been located within proximity to these sites, and other signs of domesticity such as household pottery are few. Instead, these dedicated metalworking sites have sherds of vitrified ceramics, some with slag residue, tuyère fragments, burnt platforms, and pits that acted as furnaces.
The sites in the Supsa and Gubazeuli region were all copper smelting sites, whereas slags located in the Adjara region point unequivocally to iron production.These bloomery iron slags in Adjara are rich in metallic iron and devoid of copper-bearing elements. Even so, the occasional presence of wüstite and metallic iron from slags in the Supsa and Gibazeuli region, and the very high temperatures their furnaces could reach, indicate that the coppersmiths from western Georgia had the technical skills required for iron production. Even so, no one site has as yet produced unequivocal evidence for both copper and iron smelting.This poses problems for the copper-to-iron hypothesis.Two models lend themselves to the data: one is that the production of bronze and iron comprised two separate systems, involving different technical and social processes.The other posits that they formed an integrated system and that the spatial differences between copper and iron smelting sites reflects the geographical variability of ores in western Georgia. Metalworkers might have been exploiting a range of ore-bearing deposits and experimenting with different metals simultaneously.This model appeals to metallurgy in western Georgia, whether copper or iron, embracing one social network.
CONCLUSION
By any comparative measure,whether it is the moat and canal systems that connected certain settlements, or villages built of wooden planks and logs, or even the high number of smelting sites, Colchis was a place apart.Arguably, western Georgia, more than any other region in the Caucasus, reflected a sense of cultural continuity, stretching over 2,500 years. By the end of the eighth century BC, technological advances such as the widespread use of iron foreshadowed things to come, including Greek colonisation some two centuries later. By this stage, bronze metallurgy had diminished substantially. Colchian bronze axes all but disappeared, with most implements now forged on the blacksmith’s anvil. The heyday of bronze had passed, and though the metal still had appeal, it was restricted to the production of jewellery and special items such as cauldrons. From its fledgling days in the Late Bronze Age, iron production grew rapidly. The occasional weapons forged in iron soon gave way to mass-produced items. By the beginning of the seventh century the bronze-working artisan had been reinvented as a functional blacksmith, producer of utilitarian items.
Another striking characteristic of Colchis is the overt sense of ritual. Two practices stand out. First is hoarding, which more than any other cultural behaviour links the region to Europe. Although the deposition of objects has been explained in various ways, the notion of ‘sacrificed’ wealth resonates
474 |
A World Apart |
strongly in the western Caucasus.We can only speculate on the purpose of this consumption.We shall never know whether the burial of objects was to purchase fame, or to invoke the gods and supernatural powers, yet it is clear that these votive hoards and offerings reflect a practice that has no equivalent in the ancient Near East.The other element that distinguishes Colchian ritual is drinking, as testified by carefully made drinking vessels. In any society, alcohol is a strong symbolic substance that is used to identify, construct and manipulate cultural systems and interpersonal relationships. In much the same way as commensality pulls together a group, in Colchis drinking alcohol would have been loaded with social meaning, presumably conveying messages in terms of norms and expectations of the participants.The type of beverage, in this case presumably wine, would rarely be a personal choice and would have reinforced the sense of group participation.Through these drinking vessels, then, we can assume that Colchian communities had long-standing customs in which alcohol formalised the nature of the occasion.