Ридер к базовому курсу ИЭ №1 / Эггертссон Т - Экон поведение и институты / Эггертссон-гл 3

94 t{acmb f. Beedelille (!

YBcpeHbl B TOM. qTO 3L1CCb ccpbe3HblH KaMeflh npeTKHOBeHH5I )])151 HI1') r.

C006pml(CHIUl, KOTOPbIC, KaK npCLlCTaBJl5lCTC5I, YKa3blBalOT Ha HCCO­ BMeCTHMOCTb HHLlHBHLlYaJlbHoro nOBCJl,CHH5l B onpCLlCJlCHHbIX c<jlepax C MOJl,eJlblO paUHOllaJlbHOro Bbl60pa, 3aqaCTYIO 51BJl5lIOTC5I 01llH60qI!bI­ MH, H60 0UCHKH ,UeJlaIOTC5I B TcpMHHax nOJlIIOH HH<jl0pMaUHH. To, 41'0

Ka)KCTC5I CJlyqaHHblM nOLlXO,UOM K npHII5ITHIO peWCHHH HanpHMCp.

B COJ'JlaCHH C Cal1MoHoBblM npHHUHnOM HaXO)KJl,CHH5I YLlOBJlCTBOPH­

THnH'WbIH HH,UHBHLI HC oCYI.u,eCTBJl5lCT onTHMH3aUHH B TOM CMbICJle, KaK CC onpC,UCJl5lIOT B MO,UCJlH C nOJllWH HH<jlopMaUHel1 22 . Ho Mbl yoe)KJl,CHbl B TOM, qTO TaKHC cHTyaUHH LlaCTO M())I(HO MOJleJlHpOBaTb B TepMHllax paUHOH!LlbHOro Bbl60pa H nop0)K,T\eHHbIX KOHKYPCHLH1Cfi orpaUH4emlH, nOJlyqa5l npH 3TOM nOJle3Hbie PC3YJlbTaTbi H rHnOTC3bI. no Kpal1HCH Mcpe, CCJlH cpaBHHBaTb C Jl,pyrHMH HMelOlllHMHC}1 Teope­ TH4CCKHMH napa,UHrMaMH.

B TroH CB5l3H Ba)KIIO OTMCTHTb, 4TO 3KOHOMHqeCKHI1 noJl,Xo,U HB­ J15lCTC5l no CyTH TaBTOJlOrHyeCKHM H B ero paMKax Hal1,UCTC}1 MeCTO BceM cOBoKynHocT5IM ueIlIIOCTeH, KOTopble HaM yrO,UHO BKJllOqHTb, H BceM B03MO)KHbIM orpalH1qeIlH5IM. 011 OKa3bIBaeTC5! HCCOCT05!TeJlb­ IIbIM, TOJlbKO CCJlH BKyCbl KOJle6nIOTC5! cnyLIaHHblM 06pa30M HJlH CCJlI1 nlOLlH peryJl5!pHO ,UCJlaIOT aJlOrl1'H1bIH Bb160p. 1l.aJlee, MOJl,CJlb paUHO­ HaJlbHOrO BbI60pa He 51BJl5leTC5l nOJle3HbiM HayqHblM HHCTpYMeHTOM. ecnH q)YHKUH5l npc,UnOqTeHHH He Bblpa)KeHa B ,UOCTaTO'H10 5!BHOM BH)J.e, LlT06bl n03BOJlHTb TeopeTHKY BbIBOJl,HTb Te3HCbl, nO'uLlalOl.UHeC51 <jlanbcHqmKaUHH.

IIOCJle,UHHM H3 06CY)K,UaeMbIX 3,UeCb BH,UOB KpHTHKH HH3T 5!Bn5l­ eTCH CJleJJ.YIOI.u,HH: Hepa3YMHO nblTaTbC5! 061,5!CHHTb COUHaJ1bHbie npa­

'I

- I-h:loiKellllc n071XOJlU 1m OCllOlle npmrUlma HaXOiK;lCllIllI Y.lOllJlCTBOPHTCJlbllOro pc­ 'lyHbTUT<l C~I. II KII.: Sill/on. Herbert A. (1957). Models or Man. New York: Wiley: Idem (197!1 1 Rationality as Process and as Product of Thought II American Economic l?eview 68 (May)

16 (pye. lIep.: CCIlhwlI I ~ PalUlOHaJIhllOCTb K3K npouecc 11 "PO)lYKT MbIW;leHlIlI. THESIS. 993. Bblii. 3). 3mlllHY MO)~e;1lI paWIOHWlbHoro Bbl60pa \I )KOIlOMII'ICCKOl'O 1l0.lXO;Ul MOiKHU

HaliT!! BKII.: De Alessi, Louis (19&3a). Property Rights. Transaction Costs and X-Efficienc} An Essay in Economic Theory II American Economic Review 73 (March. No. I): 64-81 CM. TaKiKC OTlCIIIK Ha :ny CT3Tbi0 X. JldioeHcTaHHa: reibens/ein. !1al'\'ey(1983). PropCrl) Rights and X-Eflicicncy: Comment II American Economic Reviell' 73 (September. No.4) 831842 H oTBcT,lle AneccH Ha KPI1THKY: De Alessi (1983b). Reply II Ibid.: 843-845.

22 ')1'01'aCllCKT OOCpKJtaeTcli B CTaTbC: Alehian, Annen A. (1950), Uncertainty. Evolu­ tion and Economic Theory II Journal o/Political Economy 58 (No.3. June): 211221. C~l 9 2.6 rJl. 2 lIaCT. KimI'll.

~~:~~~~~e~~J;~~;~~c~e~~~7:~~~~O~~~'B~O~~U,:~~~:~O:::eTBc:.I~~~~

OflH CBo60LlHO H3MeWllOTCll napa'lJleJlbHO Kone6aHH51M UCH. HeT OCHO­ saHHll BepHTb B TO, LITO B Jl,ByX CTpaHaX CO CXO)KHMH 06beMaMH Ka­ I1HTaJ1a H TCXHOJIOrH5!MI1 6YJl,YT CXO)KHe CXeMbl npaB c06CTBeHHOCTH. DOJlHTH'JeCKI1C I3naCTH HC MeH5!IOT npaBHna Ka)K,UbIH pa3, KOr,Ua OTHO­ CHTeJlbHhle uefibI MeH5!IOTC5!, nblTa5!Cb MaKCHMH3HpOBaTb BeJIH4HllY 60raTCTBa 3a Bbl'WTOM H3,Uep)KCK npHHY)f01CHHll K H3MCHCHHIO ueH, TaK KaK LlaCTbie H3MeHeHH5! npaBHn Bbl3BaJII1 6bI xaoc H 6blJII1 6bl KOlnp­ I1p°,UYKTHBHbl.

3Jl,eCb eCTb HCCKOJlbKO MOMCHTOB, KOTopble Mhl paCCMOTpl1M no no­ pll,UKy. Bo-ncpBbIX, HH3T HC YTBep)K,UaCT, 4TO cxeMa npaB c06CTBeH­ HOCTH 3aBHCHT TO.'1bKO 0'1' TeXHOJlOrHH H HanHqHblX <jlaKTopoB npOH3­ BO,UCTBa. rIpHpoLla rocy,UapCTBa, T. C. cxeMa ynpaBJleHH5! CTpaHOH, SlB­ JllleTC5I KJlIOLleI3bIM onpCLlenlllOl.lJ,HM <jlaKTopOM CTpyKTYPbl npaBHJ1, a nonHTHqeCKaSi CHCTeMa CTpaHbl, B CBOIO OqepeLlb, 06pa3yeT cno)KHbJI1 $eHOMeH, 3aBHCHl.UI1H OT rcorpa<jlH4ecKoH 6JIH30CTH CTpaHbl K MOtH­ HblM ,Uep)KaB3M, HCTOPHH ec BTOp)f(eHHH B Llpyme CTpaHbl H HH03eM­ HblX oKKyn311HH ee caMOH, 3BomOUHH penHrH03HhiX H KynbTYpHblX s033pelll111 H MHO)KeCTBa JJ.pymx ncpeMeHHblX. OCMblCJleHl1e BO Bcex

.ll.eTaJlHX xapaKTcpa npHqI1HHO-CJle,UCTBeHHbIX CB5!3eH Me)l01Y 3THMH $aKTOpaMI! HaMBoro npeBOCXOJl,I1T Hawe nOHHMaHI1C. HanpHMep, Ma­ JIOBepOHHIO, LITO HH3T, Hcnonh3Y5! 3KOHOMHYCCKHH nOLlxOLl, CYMeeT B 6JlI1)[(aiiweM 6YJJ.Yl.UCM JJ.aTb LleTanH3HpOBaHHoe onHcaHHe npHQHH. 110 KOTOPblM COBCTCKOMY COlO3Y YLlanOCb pa3BHTh CBOIO HblHCUlHlOlO no­ JIHTHLlCCKYID H 3KOHOMH4CCKYlO CHCTCMY. Ho ')KOHOMHQeCKHH nOJJ.XOLl MQ)J(eT OKa3aThCll nOJlC3IIbIM npH MOJl,eJlHpOBaHHH MHO)f(CCTBa sapHaH­

TOB Bhl60pa y COBeTCKHX npaBHTeneH H Toro, KaK TeXIIOJIOrHH, KanH­ TaJIhI, 11'~JJ.ep)l(KH areHTCKHX OTHOlueHHH H KOHKypeHUI15! orpallHLlH­

BalOT ::no MHOIl<eCTBO. Donee '1'01'0, 3TOT nOJJ.xo.Lt, B03MQ)J(HO, 1103BO­ nHT HaM npCj\CKa'3hlBaTb, KaKI1M 06pa30M paUHOHanhllbIc npaBHTCJ1H CKoppeKTl1PYIOT npaBa C06CTBCHIIOCTH C ueJlhlO aJtanTaUHH K H3Me­ HeHH5!M 3THX OrpaHHQCHI1H, HJIH no KpaHHeH Mcpe nporH03HpOBaTb HanpaBneHHe H3MeHCHHH.

BO-BTOPhlX, C QI1CTO 3KOHOMHQeCKOH TOQKI1 3peHH5I He npH I3cex 1i3MeHCIIHllX UCH UCJlCC006pa3HO MeHllTb cxeMY npaB C06CTBCHHOCTI1.

,­

_.l Field (1979): Field, Alexander 1. (1981). The Problem with Neoclassicallllstitutional Econol11ics; A Critique with Special Reference to the NorthlThomas Model of pre-I 500 Europe II /,\ploraliol1s in Economic Hislorv 18 (No.2): 174-198.

96 l[actnl, I. /3(1e(JeHlIe (i n/(,O!lIl/(;

eCfHl TpaHCaKUl10HHble 113,ll,ep)l(KI1 nOnO)l(l1TenbHbl. J;!3MeHeHl1e npaI3l1.'I. perynl1pYIOll.\I1X 06MeH, 51Bn5leTC5I BI1,ll,OM I1HBeCTl1pOBaHH5I, 11 3a4acTYI·o MeH5ITb npaBl1na CTOI1T nl1Wb TOr,ll,a, KOr,ll,a 113MeHelil1e OTHOCI1TC:lb_ HbIX ueH HOCI1T ,ll,OnrOBpeMeHHbIH xapaKTep, Hanpl1Mep, Kor,C(a TCX, HOJIOrl14eCKl1e 113MeHeHI151 HenpepbIBHo CHI1)KaIOT I1HcpOpMaUl10HHhiC 113)lep)KKI1.

B uenoM Oa3I1CHa51 cxeMa npaB c06cTBeHHocTH onpe,ll,en5leTC5I rocy­ ,ll,apCTnO~1 11 OTpa)l(aeT npe,ll,n04TeHI151 11 C,ll,ep)l(I1BalOWl1e cpaKTOpbI TC", KTO npaBI1T rocY,ll,apCTBoM. Bce Bapl1aHTbI Bbl60pa, ocyu~eCTBn5leMOn)

I1HJ.lI1BI1J.laMI1 11 rpynnaMI1, npaB5Ill.\I1MI1 rocY,ll,apCTBOM, OrpaHl14ellhi Tpe60BaHl1eM coXpaHeHI151 BnaCTI1, HO oKoH4aTenbHblH xapaKTep BO'l­ ,ll,(~HCTBI151 I1HCTl1TY1.ll10HanbHblx 113MeHeHI1I1. Ha COBOKYflHOCTb OTIIO­ WeHI1H 130 BnaCTI1 oKYTaH HeOnpe,ll,eneHHOCTblO. rI03TOMY npaB5IIl~a51

3nl1Ta 3attacTYIO C4l1TaeT HeBblro,ll,HblMI1 Te I1HCTl1TYUl10HaJIbHble 1J'l­ MeHeHI151. KOTopble 13 Tpa,ll,I1UI10HHbIX HeOKJIaCCl14eCKl1X MO,ll,en5lX cor.:Ja­ CYIOTC5I C npl1HUl1nOM Mal<Cl1Ml13aUl1l1 60raTcTBa: TaKl1e 113MeHeHII5I, BCP05lTHO, nOBblwalOT 113,ll,ep)l(KI1 areHTCKI1X oTHOWeHI1H I1nl1 ,ll,a)l-,c Hec)"r 13 ce6e yrp03Y nonHoH YTpaTbl KOHTpOn5l.

HHblMI1 CnOBaMI1, cYll.\eCTBYIOT pa3Hbie cnoc06bI 06b5lCHeHI151 OTHO­ CI1TenbHOH YCTOH'II1BOCTI1 cxeMbl npaB c06CTBeHHOCTI1, He Tpe6YIOWl1C OTKa3a OT MO,ll,enl1 paUl10HaJIbHOrO Bbl60pa. Ha caMOM ,ll,ene npaBa\1 c06CTBeHHOCTl1 OTHIO,ll,b He npl1cYll.\a OnaCHa51 rI16KOCTb, OHI1 4aCT(1 OTCTalOT OT 113MeHeHl1H OKpY)l(alOll.\eH Cpe,ll,bl 11 BblcTynalOT 13 ponl1 TOPM030B 3KOHOMl14eCKOro pa3BI1TI151 11 POCTa. I1MeHHo aHaJIl13 TaKoij npe,ll,OHOCHOH Hem6KOCTI1, nO)l(aJIYH, COCTaBn5leT Hal160nce I1HTepCC­ HylD 3a,ll,a4y, CT05llUYlO nepe,ll, HI13T.

~laeTb II

~l;':'

TIPABA COECTBEHHOCTH 11 HX 3l(OlfOMl1LJECKI1E nOCJIE;J,CTBl1fl

3KOHOM~4ECKAH TEOP~H 4

~CKnK>4~TEnbHbIX nPAB

4.1. BaeAeHHe

B 3TOH manc Mbl conOCTaBn5leM 3KOHOMl14eCKl1C TCOpl111 I1CKnI0411­ TenbHblX 11 Hel1CKnlO4l1TeJlbHbiX npaB c06cTBeHHOCTl1 11 113Y4acM cnCj~­

CTBI151 113 aJlbTepHaTI1BHbIX lIa60pOB COUl1aJlbHblX npaBHn. B § 2 npc,ll,­ CTaBneHa 3KOIIOMWICCKa51 TeOpl151 06ll.\l1x pecypcoB 11 ,ll,aeTC5I 06b5lCHC­

Hl1e TOMY, KaKI1M oopa30M KOHKypeHUI151 Me)l(,ll,y nonb30BaTen5lMl1 06­ llleH c06cTBeHHOCTl1 MO)l(eT npl1BeCTI1 K paCTpa4l1BaHl11O nOTCHI~l1aJIb­

Horo peHTHoro ,ll,OXO,ll,a OT I1CnOnb30BaHI151 06ll.\cro al<TI1Ba I. )J,n51 06b­

JlCHCHI151 KOHuenUl111 de facto 06ll.\eH c06CTBeHHOCTl1 I1CnOnb3YIOTC5I npl1MCpbl 113 3KOHOMl14eCK0l1l1CTOPl1H CillA.

B § 4.3 Mbl I1CCJle,ll,yeM 113,ll,ep)l(KI1 npe,ll,OCTaBJleHI151 H 06cCnC4CHI151 HCMI04l1TeJlbHbiX npaB. <DaKTI14eCKI1 YCTaHOBnCHI1C I1CKJII04l1TCJlbHbiX npaB conpoBo)K,ll,aeTC5I I1CTOIl~eHl1eM pecypcoB, T04HO Tal< )Ke KaK 11 KOHKypcIITlla51 60Pb6a 3a aKTI1B, Ha KOTOPblH HeT I1CKJlID4l1TeJlbHOrO npaBa coocTBeHIlOCTI1. B l<a4eCTBe npl1Mepa OTHOCI1TeJlbHO ,ll,oporo­

CT05lll.\CI-0 npouecca npHBaTl13aUl1l1 paCCMaTpI1BaeTC5I nepena4a 13 4aCT­ HYID coocTBeHHocTb rocy.'.~apcTBeHHblx JleCHblX yro,ll,HH B cCBepO-3ana)l­

HblX WTaTax B KOHue XIX - Ha4aJIe XX B. B 3aBepwcHHe naparpacpa nOKa3aHa HeS03MO)J(HOCTb Bblpa3HTb 13 Tepl\HlHaX MO,ll,eJlI1 06ll.\ero paB­

nOHlITHe:.t KO~l\lyllanhHoil C06CTIlellHOCTI1. C~l. m. 2, § 2.1.