Ридер к базовому курсу ИЭ №1 / Эггертссон Т - Экон поведение и институты / Эггертссон-гл 3

BblrO,ll,HO. «Ha caMOM ,ll,eJle B paC4eT Ha,ll,O npmIHMaTb Te pa311006p<l'j_ Hb!e ,ll,eHCTBI1}!. KOTopble 6blJll1 peaJIbHO I1cnp060BaHb!. 1160 I1MeHIIO \1') 11l1X. a He H3 KaKorO-TO Ha60pa 6e3ynpe4Hblx ,ll,ei::jcTSI1H oT611pal-Ol c~

. Ho HHCTpYMeHTbl aWL1113a, KOTOPblMH pal­ UOJlaraeT 3KOIlOMI1CT, nO-npeJKHeMY nOJIe3Hbi eCJII1 He ,ll,JI5I npe~lCl<a3a_

HI1H peaJlbtlhlX KOHTpaKTOS, TO ,ll,JI5I Toro, 4T06bl YKa3bIBaTb tlanpaB.le_ HHe H3MeHeHI1H Tl1nOB KOHTpaKTHblX COrJIaWeHI1H B OTseT tla 3K30rell_ Hble W3MeHeHI151. OCtlOBOnOJIarmOma51 l1,ll,e}! AJl451Ha tie Tep}!eT CSOej:j rJly60KoH aKTYaJIbHOCTI1.

." Ibid. P. 33.

06b~CHEH~EnpAB~n 3

3.1. n03MTMBHbie TeopMM rocYAapcTBa

IT0311TI1SHbie TeOp1111 roCY,ll,apCTBa I1rpalOT S HC0I1HCTI1TYUI10IiaJIb­ HOH 3KOHOMI1'1CCKOH TeOp1111 UeHTPaJIbHYIO POJlb, 1160 I1MCIHlO rocy­

.llapCTSO YCTaHasmiBaeT ¢YIi,ll,aMeHT3.J1bHble npaSI1Jla, o6Me11OM, 11 06ccne411saeT I1X c06mO,ll,CIIHc. 06ecne4CHI1C npaB C06CT­ BeHHOCTI1 3aSI1CI1T OT SJIaCTI1, a 113 C006paJKeHI1H 3KOIIOMI111 OT Mac­ wTa6a Ilpl1 npl1MCHClIl111 HaCI1JIWI MOHOnOJII151 Y3aKOllcIIHoro npl1Me­ HeHI151 HaCI1JlI151 LtaCTO npe,ll,OCTaBJI5IeTC5I e,ll,I1HCTBeHIIOMY areHTY ­ rocY,ll,apCTBY. Ho OTIIOIlleHI1}! Me)f(,ll,Y npaBaMI1 C06CTBCIIlIOCTI1 11 nOJlI1­ Tl1ljeCKI1MI1 CTpYKTypaMI1 IiOC5IT CJIQ)«lIbIH xapaKTep, TaK LITO I1CKJII-O­ 'IHTeJ1blible npaBa C06CTBCHHOCTI1 COBMeCTI1Mbl C ueJlbiM cneKTpOM

CXCM BJiaCTH. PaCCMOTpHM Tpl1 SI1,ll,a 0611\CCTSCHHoro

1. B KOTOPOM OTCYTCTBYI-OT 3aKOHO,ll,aTeJlbHble, cY,ll,c6­ Hble 11 npaSOOXpalil1TCJlbHblC opraHbl 11 HCT 06Lltl1X npaSI1J1.

2. 06mecTso, B KOTOpOM I1MeI-OTC5I 06ml1e npaBI1JIa.

111.I1e I1CKJII-0411TeJIbHbie npaBa, 3aKOHO,ll,aTeJlblibIH opraH, CY,ll,bl,

OTCYTCTByeT nOJIm~l151 I1JII1 apMI151 11 TeM caMblM npI1Hy)J(,ll,eHl1e K C06J110,ll,eIlHIO 3aKOHa HOCI1T LJaCTHblH xapaKTep.

3. C006mecTBo, B KOTOPOM rocY,ll,apCTBO YCTaliaSJll1SaCT npaBI1J1a, BblllOJ1H5IeT CPYHKQHI1 TpeTei1cKoro cY,ll,a Ilpl1 KOlI(pJlI1KTaX 11 06ec­ ne411saeT I1CKJIJ{)LII1TeJlbHble npaBa.

76 qaCtnb J. BGede/we G

Mb! 6blJlH 6bl y,nHBJleHbl, 06HapYJKHB BapHaHT 1, T. e. 'IaCTHOe flPI1_ HYJK,nelme K c06mo,neHHIO 'taCfWlblX npa6wl, B C0061l(CCTBaX, r,ne UHTllbl TaKl1e npml3Bo,ncTBcflHble aKTI1Bbl, KaK 3eMJlll. r,ne JlIO)lH )KI1BYI

COBMeCTHO, rpynllaMH, npaKTI1KylOT pa3)leJleIlHe Tpy,na 11 ToprylOT

C ~pyroM. 4T06bl B YCo1OBHlIX BapHaHTa 1 3aU(HTI1Tb lJaCHIYIO C06CT_ BeHiIOCTb, K(l)f()lOC J{OMaluHce X03l1HCTBO il,OJHKIIO 6blJlO 6bl Bbl)lCWlTb o1bBHHYIO ,UOJllO CB0I1X pecypcoB ,UJlll 06ccnelJemtll 'laCTllblM 06p,no\1 3aIl(HTbl )!<I13HH 11 HMyu.\eCTBa, a TalOKe Ha YCHJIHlI no ¢OpMHpOBaHI110 KOaJlHUl111 C ,npyfHMH HH,nHBH)laMI1. Tpy,nHO npe,ncTaBI1Tb ce6c 110Jll1nl_ lJCCKoe paBHOBeCl1e I1pl1 TaKOM 110JlO)!(eHHI1 ,neJl. B 110Jl.06Hb1X C006U(CCI.

Bax, BepmITHO, 6y,nCT Ha6J1IO,naTbClI TeH,neHUl1l1 JlI160 K xaocy H paclla;lY. o1H60 K KOIIl(eIHpaUI1I1 BJlaCTI1 11 06pa~mBaHI1IO rocy,napcTBa.

BapI1aHT 2, T. e. lJaCTliblH nopllJ{oK 06ecne'lelll111 C06J1IOJl.eIlHlI 06·

Il(CCTBCHHbIX npaSHJ1, H3BeCTeH B HCTOpHH. Ero MO)f(HO 06l1apYiKI.n b. lIanpHMep, B \.1CJ1allJ{HH nepHOL\a lIapO,UOBJ1aCTHlI, npOL\OJ1)l<aBweroclI C

930 no 1262 1'.1 B TO BpeM)! n0J1HTH4eCKall CHCTeMa HCJlaH}J,HH BKJnO­ lJaJla KOHCTHTYl(HIO, 3aKOHOL\aTeJlbHOe c06pamfe H CHCTeMY CYL\OB. HO HCnOJlHI1TeJ1bHall BeTBb BJlaCTH OTCYTCTBOBaJla, He 6blJ10 H HI1KaKHX nOo1l1lJ,ei1cKHx l101H BoeHHblX CI1J1.

4acTHblH nOpSlL\OK 06eCne4eHI151 npaB c06cTBeHHocTI1 MOJKeT L\Oporo 06XOL\HTbClI I1H,nHBH,naM, HYJK,nalOll(I1MClI B 3aIl(I1Te CBOI1X npaB OT nOCH­ raTeo1bCTB CO CTOPOllbl CI1JlbHorO 11 JKeCTOKOro npOTI1BHI1Ka. B HCo1aHl(HH nepl1o,Ua HapOL\OBo1aCTHlI I1HL\I1BI1)lbl I1CKaJll1 nOA}J.ep)J(KY B ,UCJ1e 3alUHThi CBOHX npaB (I.UHf nonpamfll npaB L\pyrHX) He TOJlbKO y CBOI1X PO}J,OBbIX KJ1aHOB 11 L\PY'3eH, HO 11 Y Cl101bHblX npOTI1BHI1KOB CBOI1X BparOB.

B Bapl1aHTe 3 rocYJl.apCTBO onpc,UemleT 6a311cllYlO cxeMY npaB CO(l' CTBeHHOCTI1, BblcTynaeT B POJ1li TpeTcHcKoro CY,UbH npH KOH¢o1HKTaX 11 06ecne<IHBaeT C06JlIO,neHICfe npaBHJ1. YCTaHaBJHfBall nopll,UOK npl1 OTI1O­ CI1TeJlbHO HI13KI1X 113L\ep)KKaX, rocy,napCTBO pa3,nBl1raeT rpaHI1Ubl npOlI'\' BOL\CTBemlbIX BO'3MOJKHocreH c006UteCTBa. B 6001ee ,[(peBHI1X 11J111 60011:'..' npl1MI1TI1BHblX Bapl1aHTaX rocYL\apCTBO 4aCTO aCCOI(l1l1pyeTclI C O,UHU\I I1Hll,I1BI1ll,OM 11)111 ceMbeH, 06eCnel ll1BalOlll,I1MI1 06111,eCTBeHHbIH nopllJl,ot,:. 060POHY 11 pa3Ho06pa3Hbie BI1,Ubl COl\l1aJlbHO-KYo1bTypHbIX yCJlyr B 06­

;'J,JBHJI <tlpHxtMall llOKaJaJI, '!TO cxeMa IIpaB COQCmeHHOCTH Il HCIIUll)IHH lIepHOJW pO;JOBJlaCTHIl 6hlJlU OTHOCHTCJlhHO 3q)())CKTHllHOH )la;KC Il cpaBlleHlHl c rocyxtapCTFleHllhl\l

OOCCIIC'lCHlleM coomOlleHl!l1 npallOBhlX HOpM II )\PYrHX oomecTBax ({hedman, David (197'1\ Private Creation and Enforcemcnt of Law: A Historical Casc II Journal o(Legal StudieS ~ (No.2): 399-415). Donec ;JenWhHO npHMep IlCJl3H)lCKOrO lfapOIlOll!IaCrWI paccMarpllBac 1C!l II J'JI. 9 HacTolllllci1 KIHlrH C'!lpaBa COQCTBeHHocTH R OOllIeCTBC. He HMC[OIlICM racyflapc 1­ lIeHlIoro

el::l Ha npaBO B3blCKI1BaTb HaJlOfl1. OTHOllleHl1l1 MeJK,Uy npaBI1TeJ1eM 11 ". )lllaHHblMI1 MOJKHO TpaKTOBaTb B TepMI1HaX KOHTpaKTa, TaK 'ITO npl1

CTBeHHbll1 nOpll,nOK 11 ,Upyrl1e yCJ1yfl1 no HerrOMepHO BblCOKI1M l{eHaM,

TO ero nOBe,UeHl1e, BepO.llTHO, Bb130BeT npe,UJ10JKeHlfe 60J1ee 6J1aronpl1­ jJTHblX YCJ10!3HH lIanor006J1())KeHI111 co CTOPOHbl "ToproBueB BJ1aCTblO" BHyrPH rocY·'l.apCTBa 11J111 3a ero npe)leJ1aMI1. B03M())KIIOCTI1 06J1araTb HaJIOrOM Orpal-1l1'leHbl TaKJKe np06J1eMaMI1, COnpllJKeHHblMI1 C 113'uCPJK­ KaMi1 areHTCKHX OTlIOWeHI1H 11 113Mepe1l1111. .LJ;J111 Toro lJT06bl nOJ1YlJI1Tb

.nOXOJl, B Ka3I1Y, Co1e,UyeT onpeL\eJ1I1Tb 11 113Mepl1Tb 6a3y lIaJ10roBoro 06­ JlOJKeHl1l1 11 c06paTb HaJlOrl1. flpl1 oCYIl(ecTBJleHI1I1 :nOH 3a,UalJl1 CyBc­ peHY npI1XOJl,I1TClI omlpaTbcSI Ha 60J1blllOe lll1Co1O areHToB, 11 pal(110HaJlb­ RbIH npaBI1Teo1b 6y,ner CTpeMI1TbClI OpraHI130BaTb ,neJ10 TaKI1M 06Pa30M,

'lT06b1 MI1HI1MI1311pOBaTb H3,UepJKKI1 areHTCKI1X OTHOWeHI1H.

ECo1l1 6bI npaBI1TeJ111 lie CTafJKI1BaJll1Cb npl1 B311MaHI111 HaJlorOB C nOJlOJKI1TeJ1bHbIMI1 TpaHCaKI~110HHblMI1 113,UepJKKaMI1, OHI1 npe,UnolJJII1 6.h1 TaKylO cxeMY npaB c06cTBeHHocTI1, npl1 KOTOPOH 6a3a HaJlOroBoro 06J10JKeHlfll ,nOCTl1raJla 6bl MaKcI1MYMa. Ecnl1 JKe Tpa1lCaKl{110HHble 113­ n;epJKKI1 BbICOKI1, TO, KaK nO,UlJepKI1BaJl HopT (North 1981), lJaCTO OKa­ 3hIBaeTClI, 'ITO B I1HTepecax npaBI1TeJleii pa3pa6aTblBaTb CXeMbJ npaB

c06CTBeHHocTI1, HeCOBMeCTI1Mble C 6blCTPblM 3KOHOMI14eCKI1M pOCTOM.

He)J,asHHH npl1Mep TaKOH ,U11J1eMMbl np06J1eMbl areUTCKI1X OTuowe­

HHii, CTOllBWl1e nepejl COBeTCKlfM PYKOBO,UCTBOM. Ha npOTlI)I(etll1l1 MHorl1X JleT If B caMOM COBeTcKoM COI03e, 11 :m ero npe,nenaMH OTMC­ Lf/lJlOCb, lITO pa3JII1'H1ble KOppeKTl1pOBKI1 cxeMbf npaB c06CTBeHHOCTI1 B CTpaue MOrJ111 6bI J(aTb cYU\eCTBeHHblH Bbll1r'pIMU B 06beMC lJl1CTOro BbmYCKa COBeTCKOH 3KOHOMI1KI1. ~:tro HeJl.BYCMbICJ1CHHO npl13HaBaJlOCb H JUi,nepaMI1 Knee, T. e. npaBlIIl(eH 3Jll1TOH cTpaubl, O)lHaKO HI1KaKI1X cYllJ.ecTBeHHblx 113MeHeHI1H B cxeMY npaB c06CTBellHOCTI1 BHeceHO He 6bIJlO. OL\HO 113 061>lICHeHI1H 3TOI'0 lIBHOro napa,nOKca COCTOHT B rOM, 4TO npaBHTC.111 3anYTaJII1Cb B np06JleMe areHTCKI1X OTHOWeHI1H 3.

North. Douglass C. (1981)_ Structure and Change in Economic History. New York:

W. W. Norton, Chapter 3: "A Neoclassical Theory of the Stat..:".

3

Hallpl1Mcp. TaKall TO'IKa 3peHl111 BhlCKU3aHa BpaooTe: Moore, John H ( 1981). Agenc) Costs, Technological Change ,md Soviet Central Planning II Journal o/Law and Economics 24 (October): 189-214. 3TH BonpOChI paCCMaTpl11laIOTCli B I'JI. 10 HaCTOII!lIeil" KlHlfH (''[ocy­ llapcTBO II IIeOIIllCTJ1TYUIIOHaJIhHOii )KOHOMH'leCKOH TeOplll1").

EOJlbLllHHCTBO npe,ll.JlaraBLllI1XC5I 113MeHeHI1H B npaBax co6CTBeHHOCTl1 npe,ll.YCMaTpHBaJlO ,ll.eueHTpaJllnaumO 3KOHOMWIeCKOH BJlaCTH, T. e. npC,ll.OCTaBJlCHHe 60JlbLlleH BJlaCTI1 arCHTaM rOCY,ll.apCTBa, H npaBHTeJlli 605lJlI1Cb, 'lTO :no npllBe,ll.eT K POCTY H3,ll.ep)KeK areHTCKI1X OTHOLlleHI1H H nOTepe KOHTPOJl5l.

3.2. ViHQ>opMal.(MOHHble MJAep)I{KM

M nOJlMTM~eCKMe npOl.(eCCbl

B TCOpHH nOJII1THKH HJlH B 3KOHOMHyeCKOH TeopHH 6JlarocoCTOl!­

HH5I cOBpeMCHHa51 ,ll.eMOKpaTH5I 'IaCTO aHaJlH3HpyeTCSl' B TepMHHax KOH­ TpaKTHbix oTHOlUelll1H Me)K,ll.Y paBllblMH. 06L1~eCTBeHHbIH .l1.0rOBOp

pa3pa60TaH TaKHM 06pa30M, YTO n03BOJISl'eT npe,ll.OCTaBJl5lTb ,ll.eHCTBcH­ Hble IIpaBa c06cTBeHHocTH, rapaHTl1pOSaTb cHa6)KeHHe 06I.UeCTBeH­ HblMH 6JlaraMH, KOTopble HC MO)KeT nOCTaSJl5lTb CBo6o,ll.HbIH pbIHOK. 11 opraHH30BbiBaTb o6eCneyeHI1e ",ll.OCTOHHblMH 6J1araMH"

KaK, HanpHMep, OKa3aHI1e nOMOI.UH 60JlbHbIM, npeCTapeJlblM H 6e!1­

HblM ~. npe.l1.nOJlaraercSl', 'ITO ¢opMYJla "O,ll.HH YCJlOBeK - O,ll.HH rOJloe" 3aI~Hl.UaeT 60JlblllHHCTBO rpa)K,ll.aH OT ,ll.HKTaTa MeHbLllHIICTsa. "EHJlJlb

o npaBax", onpe,ll.eJlSl'IOIlU1H "lIeOTheMJleMble npaBa yeJlOBeKa", lIap5l.l1.Y

C KOHCTHTYl\l10HHblMH YCTaHOSJleIlHHMH, 6Jlaro.l1.ap51 KOTOPbIM H3MeHC­ HHe CO.l1.ep)J(aI~HXC5I S HeM IWPM no BOJle 60JlbLllHHCTBa COnp51)KCHO e

60JlblllHMH H3,ll.ep)l(KaMH, npH3BaH 3aU~HIIlaTb MeHbLllHHCTBO OT THpa­

HHH 60JlbLllHHCTBa. TaKoe BH,ll.eHHC JIOrW-IeCKH BbITeKaeT H3 OCHOBaH­ HhlX Ha ,ll.onyu~eHHH 0 nOJlHOH HH¢opMaUHH MO.l1.eJlCH nOJlHTHyeCKHX

npoueCCOB B ,ll.eMOKpaTHyeCKOM 06I.UeCTBe.

B nOCJIe,ll.HHe rO.l1.bl 3BOJllOUlUI npHCYl.UerO 3KOHOMHyeCKOH HaYKe B03­ 3peHH51 Ha Hli¢opMaUHOHHble H3,ll.ep)KKH no6Y.l1.HJla 3KOHOMHCTOB H nOJlH­ TOJlOrOB HCCJIe,ll.OBaTb BJlH5IHHe HH¢opMaUHOHHblX H3.l1.ep)KeK Ha nOJl¥!­ Tl1yeCKHH "06MeH" B ,ll.eMOKpaTH'leCKOM o6l.UecTBe. Tenepb Mbl JlY'ILllC, yeM Ilpe)K)],e, nOHHMaeM, KaKHM 06pa.JOM He60JlbLllHe rpynnbl MOryT CO­ cpe)],oTollHTb B CBOHX PYKax BJlaCTb, npeBblLllalOl.UYIO HX OTHOCHTeJlbHbll! 3JleKTopaJlbHblH Bec, H TeM caMblM H3MeH51Tb B CBOIO 1l0Jlb3Y CXCMY npaB C06CTBeHHOCTH, B03MO)KHO, 3a C'IeT 60JlblllHHCTBa ln6HpaTeJlei1.

4 06CYlKUeHl1e (PYHKQHH npallHTeIlbCTBa, CB1l3allHbtX C pa3McmeHHCM H pacnpeil:eJ1CIIHe\1

Cpe}~CTIl. MOJKHO HaHTH, HanpHMep, II KH.: Musgrave. Richard A.; Musgrave, Peggy M. (1976).

Public Finance in Theory and Practice. New York: McGraw Hill. Chapter I "Fiscal Fum;­ tions: All Ovcrview". ABToPbl Bblil:CJlllIOT 'rpll (lll1CKaJlbHble <jlyUKQHH rocY.llapcTBa: HapJIllY C p,nMt!meHHcM 11 pacnpencJlellHeM 6101l.lKeTHblx pecypCOB fOcYilapcnlO emc IIt!CCT OTBCTCT­ IIt!HIlOCTh 33 )KOIlOMI1'lceKYIO CTaOHIILHOCTb.

J(aK B YCJIOBH5IX )]'eMOKpaTHH Hc60JlbLllHe rpynnbl MoryT 1l0,ll.aBJl51Tb

6oJIbWHHCTBO? O)]'HO H3 06b5lCHeHHH OIIHpaCTC51 Ha HepaBHOe pacnpe­ p,eJTeHl1e H3i\epJKeK H BhIro)]" MOrYl.Uce B03HHKHYTb B PC3YJlbTaTe MH­

tflfMaJlhHblX H3MeHCHHH B CXeMe npaB c06CTBeHHOCTH, H Ha aCHM­ MeTPH'IHOe paClIpc)]'eJlCHHC HH¢OpMaUI1H Me)K)],Y TeMH, KTO BblHrpbI­ paeT, H TeMH, KTO npOHrpblBaeT OT 3THX H3MeHCHHHu 5.

JTY'-ILlle Bcem IlOH51Tb 3TOT XO)], paCCY)K,ll.eHHH MO)KHO C 1l0MOl.UblO

rHnOTeTHyeCKOrO npHMepa. npe)]'CTaBHM ce6e, YTO B CTpaHe neLlle­

XO.nHH 06YBl.UI1KaM yrpO)KaeT HMnopT 113 FO)KHOH EBPOllbI H A3HH He.noporoH BbICOKOKaYeCTBeHHOH 06YBH. Y BJ13)],eJlbl\eB CTaHOB51H~HXC~

HeKOHKYPCHTOCIlOC06HblMI1 06YBHblX ¢a6pHK B03HHKaeT PHCK cYl.Ue­ CTBeHllbIx nOTepb ¢H3HyeCKOrO KanHTaJla, a Y pa60 t ll1x, OCYll~eCT­

BHBIllHX HHBeCTHlll1H B cneUH¢HyeCKYIO )],JI51 OTe'leCTBeHHOH 06YBHOH npOMblLllJlCHHOCTH npo¢eCCHOHaJlbHYIO no)], rOTOB KY, PHCK conp~­

)l(eHHOrO C 60JlblllHMH H3)],ep)KKaMH 06ecueHeHH~ HX 'IeJIOBC'leCKoro rcanHTaJla. Y MHOrHX H3 3aHHTepCCOBaHHbiX HH)],HBH)]'OB Ha KapTY no­

CTaBJIeHbl 60JIbLllHe CYMMbI OT TbIC51Y )]'0 MHJ1JIHOHOB )],OJIJlapOB.

3TH nOTcpH MO)KHO npe)]'OTBpaTHTb nYTeM H3MeHeHHlI npaB C06CT­ BellHOCTH HMllopTepoB H nOTpe611TeJleH, npH6cfHYB, HanpHMep, K 06Jlo)((CHHIO BB03HMOH 06YBH BblCOKHMH 1l0LllJIHHaMH, YCTaHOBJIe­ HHIO )({eCTKHX KBOT Ha KOJ1H'IeCTBO 3TOH 06YBH HJ1H nOJIHOMY 3anpeTY HMnopTa 06YBH. MepbI, OrpaHHYHBalOH1He HaJlHYHe He)]'oporoH HM­

nopTHOH 06YBH, npHHHMaIOTC5I 3a CyeT HIITepecoB Bcex nOTpe6HTe­ neM, HO 6peM51 3THX Mep OTHOCHTeJIbHO paBHOMepHO pacnpe)]'eJl51eTClI

Me)K)],Y 60JlbLllHM YHCJIOM JlHU - CKa)KeM, Me)K.l1.Y 60 MJlH. )],OMaLllHHX X0311HCTB.

npe)]'nOJlo)J<HM, YTO TeKYl.Ua51 CTOHMOCTb nOTeph nOTpe6HTeJleH B

pe3YJlbTaTe OrpaIlH'-IeHHM Ha HMIlOpT npH YCJIOBHH, YTO 3TH Mepbl 6y­

.l{YT OCYl.UeCTBJI5ITbC51 nOCTOllHHO, COCTaBJl51eT B cpe)]'HeM 50,ll.oJIJ!. Ha

.l{OMaLllHee X0351HCTBO. Tor)],a pat~HOHaJlbHoe )]'OMaLllHee X0351HCTBO co­

5 3TO omphlHIC CBJ!3aHO c paOOTaMH CTHmepa flO )KOHOMIl'leCKOH TeopllH lUullopMa­ l\Itlt H 3KOHO\III'leCKOH TeopHH roCYllapCTBelIJIOrO perYJlltpolI<lHI1JI: Stigler, George J (1961).

Claire (1962). What Can Regulators Regulate? The Case of Electricity II Journal

and Economics 5 (No.1): 1-16: Stigler. GeOl'ge1. (1971). Thc Economic Theory of Regula­ tion II Bell Journal ofEconomics and l.1anagement Science 2 (No.3): 3-21. ilo,'1xo,'1 CTlII­ lJepa IBMeHHJI XO)( MbICIICi1 3KOIIOMliCTOB 0 1'0CY.llapCTBCHHOM perYJIllpOBaHlllI. a TaKlKC liameJI WHPOKOC llpl1MCHeHilC B aUaJIH3e nOJIUTH'leCKHX npOUCCCOIl B neMOKpaTI1'leCKOM

oGll\eCTBc. Mhl llepllCMCll K 06CYlKIlCUl1IO II OQeHKt: MOIleJleH, BKJIIO'IalOmI1X :JH.llOrCHHLIC npaaa c06C'!1lt:llHOCTH. Il 'laCTIl IV KHHf'H.

maCl1JlOCb 6bI I1HBeCTl1pOBaTb MaKCI1MYM 50 /lOJ1J1., C TCM 4T06bl 06cc­ ne'HlTb CB060/lllbIH nOTOK I1MIIOPTHOH 06YBI1, HO TI1nl14110C /lOMaWHCe X03HHCTBO MO)l(CT Bo06w,c HC 3HaTb, 0 KaKoH cyMMe I1l(CT PC4b, a I1H­ cpopMaUl10HHbfC 113/lCP)!{KI1 BbHlCHCIHlH ::noro Mory-r OKa3aTbCH BbICO­ KI1MI1. rlPC)I()J.c I{CM npHHHTb pcweHHe /lCHCTBOBaTb, /lOMaWHce X03H11­ CTBO ;'10J1)1(HO nOllblTaThCH YCTaIlOSHTh, KaKOShI PCallhHblC nnaHbl y

06yBHOH npOMbIWJ1CHHOCTI1 IlcWCXO,[l1111, npOH3SCCTH OUCHKy Bbl,[lSI1­ I'aCMblX apI'YMCHTOB 11 paCC4HTaTb 113)1.Cp)j{KH 11 BbII'O/lbl. EcnH OTC4C­ cmemIblC 06ySW,I1KI1 YTBCp)!(/laIOT, 4TO I1MnopnJaH 06YBb /leq)CKTHa 1I onaClla 111111 'fTO I1HOCTpaHllblC np0I13S0)J.H1'Cnl1 C03)1.aIO'f IIOJ1I11'114C­ CKylO yI'p03y )J.)lH IlCWCXO/l1111 (HanpI1MCp, no TOH IlPWHlHC, 4TO S CHy­ 'laC, CCJlI1 pa3pa3HTCH KpynHoMaCwTa6HaH SOHHa H BCC KaflaJlbl SHCW­ HCH ToprOBml 6y)J.YT ncpeKpblTbl, pa:>opCHHaH OTC4CC1'SCHHaH 06YBWIll npOMhlllL1CHlIOCTb 6Y)1.CT He B COCTOHHI1H npOH3BO)1.I1Tb canonl j),JIlI BOOPY){(CHllbIX CHJ1 CTpaHbl), CJle)J.YCT OIlCHI1Tb l\OCTOBepHOCTb nO/l06­ HblX YTBep)l(,[lCHI1H. TaKaH oueHKa aprYMCHTallHl1 B IIOJIb3Y ToprOBblx OrpaHI14CHHH MO)j{CT 6blTb COllpH)I(eHa C 113)J.ep)j{KaMH, HC rOBopH y)!{C

KOr/la pCIJb I1/lCT 0 60J1ce CJJO)[<HhIX npO/lYKTax, IICM 06YBb, TaKHX, KaK cPa pMaUCBTI14eCKaH npoltyKI~HH, aBTOM06HJIH Hml

3JlCKTPOHHOC 060pY/lOBaHI1C. Y )l(allOCTnI1BorO nOTpe611TCJIH Mo)KCI B03HHKH)'Tb )l(CJlaHI1C paCCMOTpCTb, HaCKonbKO T04Hbi npC/lCKa3aHI111 nary611blX ,(JIH pa604HX 06yBHOH npOMblWJ1CHHOCTI1 nOCJ1C/lCTBI1I\ CB060)J.HOH TOprOBJlI1, a B I1/lCaJle paUHOHallbHOe /lOMawHee X03H~krBO

)1.0J1)KHO OI~eHI1Tb BepOHTHOC B03)J.CHCTBI1C orpaHH'ICHI1H HMnOpTa 11:1 nOJ1l1THKY UCII H JcPcPeKTI1BHOCTb OTC4CCTBCHHOH npOMblWJICHHOCHI

B ,LIOJlrOCp0411OH nepCnCKTI1BC.

B npOJIOJ1)I<CHI1C npl1Mepa npe/lnOnO)j{I1M, 4TO mrrpC6HTCJlh. OC) u~ecTBHB I1HSeCTI1Ul111 B npH06pCTCHI1C vlHcpopMaU,I1I1, np~IXO,rI.HT K Bbl­

BO/lY 0 HC){(CJlaTCnbHOCTI1 orpaHH4CHI1H Ha I1MnopT H BbIHCHHCT, 'lTO 3TI1 OrpaIll14CHI1H 060H)1.yTCH CMY npl1MCpHO B 50 JlOllJ!. EcnH OH Y){(\;.' flOHCC 113)(ep)I<KH nOI1CKa, TO OHI1 Ha JlaHHblH MOMelIT HCB03BpaTHbl, ~I nOTpc611TCJlb rOTOB BHCCTI1 BKlla/l B pa3Mepc He 60llec 50 /lonn., 4T06bl npon066lipoBaTb KarvmaHI1IO no npC/lOTBpaw,clIl1lO OI'pall114CHI1H IW

I1MOOpT. ECJlI1 Bce /lOMaWHl1e X03HHcTBa OPOI1HcPOpMl1pOBallbl H CO~~­ jlaH 06be)J.I1HcHHhIH cP0II,n, B KOTOPhlH OHI1 rOTOBbl BHeCTH B cpe/lHCM flO 50 ,nOllJl. KmKJlOC, TO B pacnopH)j{cHI1H 60 MJIH. /lOMaWHI1X x03H~krn

OKa){(CTCH 3 MJIP/l, )J.OJlJl. cYMMa BHYl.llI1TeJlbHaH. O)vtaKO Ha caMOM

"fJ,enc IIC Bce /lOMaWHI1C X03HHCTBa OC03HaJOT nOTellUl1allbllblH BpCJl

pOBalmC ,npyrl1x nOTpc611TcncH 0 JlaHlmH np06lleMc. HaKoHeu, 06'bCjll1­

aetH1C PCCYPCOB /lJlH COBMCCTHOH )J.CHTCJlbHOCTI1 oKynl1TcH JlJIH nOTpe­ 611TellcH llHllib B TOM cnY4ac, ccnl1 npl1 caopc I1Hq)QpMaUI1I1 11 Jlo6­ 611pOBaHI111 4HHOBHI1KOB li BbI60PHbiX npCJlCTaBHTcneH BnaCTI1 6Y/leT I1MeTh MCCTO cymccTBclmaH 3KOHOMHH 01' MaclliTa6a.

3.3.Jlon4Ka KOnneKTIIlBHOrO Ae.:1cTBIIl.A III npo6neMa "6e3611lneTHIIlKa"

ECJlH B /lcMOKpaTH'leclwH cTpaHc BCC HJlH nO'lTl1 BCC nOTpc611TC.ll1 06yBli 06cbCJ~I1IIHT CBOH pccypCbl, TO I1X )KOHOMH'ICCKaSl 11 nOJII1TH­

ljeCK3S1 MOW,b 6YJ~eT. KOIlC'IJIO, KOJlOCCaJlbHa, 110 CYUtCCTBYCT 11 O'lC­ BH/lHOC npcnHTCTBliC K TaKI1M CKOOnCpl1pOBallHblM YCI1J1I1S1M: 113jlep){(­

KI1 KOnJ1CKTI1BHOrO )lCHCTBI1S1 H B OC06CHHOCTH np06JleMa "6e3611­

~.. 6

JleTH11K<l

f10CMOTPllM, 'ITO, CYJlH no BCCMY, np0I130H/lCT, eCJl11 HCKI1H npell­ npl111M411BblH I1H,nI1BI1/l 3aX04CT BOCflOJlb30BaTbCH 3KOHOMI1eH OT Mac­

wTa6a npH c60pc I1HcPopMaUI1H 11 llo6611POBalll111 11 npC)1.J10){(I1T 3a B03­ Harpall{)1.CII l1e, HaMlloro HI1JI{C 50 )lOJJJ1,. CBOH yCJlyrl1 110 3a!l~I1TC no­

Tpe6HTcncH OT Orpall114ClmH HMoopTa IIC,nOPOroH 06YBI1 HHOCTpaH­ Horo npowmo,nCTBa. Opram13aTop TaKoH OnCpalll111 CKOPO nOHMCT, 'ITO yCJlyfl1 CBOOO/lIlOH TOprOBJlI1 HBJ1HKlTCH 06U(eCTBCllllbIM 6J1aroM. a H3,[lCP)I(KI1 ·'pa3)J.CJlCHI1H" 06w,CCTBeHllbIX 6Jlar H llpO/la){(H I1X 06w,ecT­

,By IICnOMCpIlO BCllI1KI1. ]1106011 1I0Tpc6l1TCllb. oTKa3blBalOII!l1lkH onlla­ THTb yCllYfl1 Halllero npe~'lnpI1HI1MaTCJIH, BbIl1rpaCT OT CB060/lHOH TOp­

rOBJ111 I1MnopTlloH 06yBbiO POBIIO CTOJlbKO }KC. CKOJ1bKO 11 Te, 'ITO 3a­ flJlaTl1nl1 3a IlOJ1)1.CP)KKY CBo6o}ll1OH TOprOBJII1, HCJlb3H 060COOJIHTh

HH/lI1BH/lOB 11 3aCTaBJIHTb I1X nOKynaTb TonbKO OTC4eCTBeHllYIO 06YBb, nOTOMY 4TO TaKoro pO/la J~HCKpI1MI1HaUI1H npOTI1BOpe ' Il1T KOH­ CTwryql10llHbIM npaBaM B 60llbliII1HCTBC /lCMOKpaTI14CCKHX c-rpall 11.

"ITO eutc BalKIIce. 113!'lCP){(KI1 npl111Yill1TCJlbHOrO ycnUIOBJlClIl1H raKOH

JlHCKpl1MHllaUl111 6blJII1 6bl lIenpl1CMnCMO BeJlI1KI1. Paql10ll<L1bHblH 110­ Tpc611Tellb lIoi1MCT, 4TO ero BKJ1a!'l HC OKa)[(CT ow,Yrl1Moro BJ1I1HHH~ Ha

06w,CllaUI10HaJlbHYI0 jlCHTCJlbHOCTb 110 J106611pOBaHI110 11 4TO B CJlY4ac YCllexa n066HpOBalU1H OH Bbll1rphIBaCT HC3aBI1CHMO OT TOro. BHec OH

CBmo ncnTY HJlI1 BeT. Ho CCJ1l1 nOJl06HbiM 06pa30M Oy)1.YT paccY)KJlaTb Bcc nOTpe6I1TCJlI1, III1KTO lie pa:mcpHcT KaMnaHI1K) npOTI1B IlpC)'feK­

The Logic of Collcctive Action. Cambridge. Mass.: Harvard University Press (pye. lIelL

OJ/COli M lIorm;a KOJI!leKl'HIlHOI'O JlciicTBHH. HOBocH6npcK, 1995).

QI10HI1CTOB'. TaKOBa Ha :lJ1eMeHTapHOM ypOBHe cyrb np06J1eMbl "6e'~­

HanaCT¥!, npeCJle11.YIOw.CM Jl1060e KOJIJleK­

TI1BHOC

B I1TOre nOJlI1TWleCKI1C aKUl111 Haml1X 6011.HOrO nOTOKa 06YBI1 4epC3 rOCY11.apCTBCHHble

COlJeTaHl1e TpCX CP<\J{TOPOB: BblCOKl1e 11311.Cp:>KKI1 npH06pCTeHI15! Halle)\(­ HOM I1Hq)OpMamll1 06 aKrYaJlbHblX cpaKrax, np06JleMa "6c36I1JleTHI1Ka" 11 OTHOCI1TeJlbHa5! MaJlOCTb CYMMbl, CT05lUleM Ha KapTC /lJl5! Cpe11.HcCTa­ TI1CTl14eCKOro HH11.HBI111.a. ECJlH )\(e Mb[ 06paTHMC5! K OTe4eCTBeHlIOf1 06YBlWH npOMbIWJleHHOCTI1, TO yBI1).lHM, 4TO B npOTI1BOnOJlO>KHOCTb CtHyaQ1111 C nOTpc6HTeJl5lMI1 aKrYaJlbHa5! t1HcpOpMaUH5I llocTymla KmK­ l1311.ep)KKI1 ee nptW6peTeHI15! OTHOCHTCJlbHO lIem;­

JlI1KU; B CPCtlHeM ).lJl51 Ka:>K11.OrO I1H11.HBH).la Ha KapTy nOCTaBJlCHO ropa'3­

11.0 60JlbWC: 3aHHTcpccOBaHHblx )\(e JIHll MeHbmc, a TCM caMblM Hl1iKe 11 11311.ep)I(KI1 peWeHI151 np06JleMbl ·'6e36HJleTHI1Ka".

Mbl 6Y,'leM ew.e B03Bpaw.aTbC5I K np06JleMe "6e36I1JleTHUKa" IHDKC B ::nOM KHurc, OC06CHHO B m. 9, HO 311.eCb 3aMCTI1M, 4TO onUH 113 cnoc060B 060MTU :ny np06J1CMY COCTOI1T B TOM, 4T06bI n03BOJll1Tb rocynapCTB)

"OC30IlJleTHHKa" CBJl3aHa C JlHJlCMMOH 3aKJ110'leml0rO B TCOpHH llrp. !lll' :!CM~la 'l<lKJII04CHIlOro B03I11IKaer IlpH lIaJlIPlI111 JlB)'X ycnoBIlH: (I) Ae~icTBlIH II 6:mrocOCT051­

HIIC IlHJlIlBlUIOB ll:lalIM01aBHCHMhl; (2) IlHllHBlinbl lie MoryT oOmaThCJI llpyr C npyroM Will. m'IIICC. He MoryT 3aKm04aTb AP)T C npyroM COfJlalllCHH5I. H3Kna;lblBalOmHC B3aifMllhic

OOJl3aTCJILCTB<I. ':}ry .!UUCMMY MO)f(IIO np0I1JL110C1'PHpOBarb lIa npHMcpe nByx 1aKJIIO'lCHllbl".. OOBIlHCHHhlX B COBMeCTHOM 3arOI!Ope npOTllB npaBHTe:IhCTBa H COllcp)f(amllXCli B OnHHO'I' lIblX K<lMCpax. CRHllCTCJlhCTSa npOHIB IU1X CKYllllbl, H Ka)f(nOMY H'J IU1X npCWlaraeTCJI CRO­ OO,la. CCIIl1 011 ,1UCT nOK8'laml~ npOTlIB tlpyrol'O 3aKJII04eHHoro. KOTOPOMY B JTOM cny4ae 0Y;ICT BblllCCCII C~lepTHb[H npU!,OBOp. EcnH ooa 38KmO'lCHHh[X Jla.:lYT II0K,naHHll )lPyr lIPO' THB Jlpyra. TO OOOHM 0YACT BblHCCCH CYPOBMH (HO He CMepTHblii) nplll'OBOp. EC!lH )f(C 1II1

TOT. 1111 "pyron lie 0YllYT llaB8Tb 1I0K31aIlUli. o6a OTileJI81OTC5I JlcrKIIM UI1'Pa1\)OM. Ka)f(Jlbli\ 'laK.~IO'lClIllblli OO,ilYMbwaer 1l03MO)f(lIble Jlci1CTl!HJI llpyroro. [CIII ')TOT .'lPYl'OiI ]3KJIIO'ICl!' !!blii 'lUnl[lOpIlT. TO }U1Jl lIepBoro 3UKJ1IO'[CIlIlOrO MOJ14aHIIC ooepllCTCli C~lepTllhl~[ npm'Ol!(\'

ror;w KaK Celli! 011 TO)f(C 'larOllopHT. TO nOJlY'lIIT cypOBblfL 110 iii: eMcpTllblfi nplll'OBOp )f(C Il'lOpoii 3aKJllO'!eHHblii OTK(l)f(CTCli COTpYllIlIl'Ja'n, C BJ!a(;fHMIL TO MOJI4UIlHC IlcpBorn [[plllle;lCT K JICrKOMY UlTpa(l»)'. TOrna KaK npenaTCJlbCTBO JlPIIHCCCT CIIOOOi(y. B T!'OII cllTya·

IUIII ila'!U !I0J.:a-l3111IH IIpOTllll OhllllllCrD COOOlUHHKa IIpeL\CTaSJHH!TCH Ka)f(.111MY In 3aK.:IIO'!CII" HhiX pmUIOIla.:lhllhlM IIOIlCl~eIIHC~L ECJlll ooa l(any-!' nOKa3aH1l1i. 11M nhlHCCCH cypollbliL

flO He CMepTllblil HpUrDllOp. Ho \taKCI1MH3a[(HlI cYMMapHO'o 6JtarOCOCTolllllm HMCJl3 Obi MeCTO, cellli ObI ooa JaK.:I!O'lCHHhIX OTK<lJaJ1I1Ch naa3Th 1I0Ka33Hl!5!. II ImelUIO ,TO. KaK IIpe;l'

CK33hl!laeT MO:WJlb. npOH'lOIUJlO Obi, CCJIII Ob[ 3aKJIIO'leHHblC liMCJIl! 1l01,\IO)f(1I0CTh 06cYlKtlaTb enol! [JJlUllbl llpyr c IWY.OM (II 3aKJIlO'taTb B'l3I1MIlO OOHJbISalO!l~lle COrJlalllCUHll 1.

r1011Jc6HTCJ!!!. 00,1),Mb!B3KJlUIlC, nO)1Jlcp)f(an li;1H lleT aHTlIllpOTCKUllOflIlCTCKYIO KUM' IIUllHl0. lIaXOllWfCll B cflTyalU!I1. cxo)f(eii C cHl,),a[llleH 38KJ1IO'lC!lIlh!X S npllSCllellHOM IlhllJlC

I!PHMCpC. Ka;K!lhllt 110Tpe0l1TCJlb MO)f(CT PCUlIITh, 'lTO H'l-33 OTCYTCTBIIH IIHl\mpManllll 0 flOBC;ICIIHII llPYrHX I!OTPCOIfTCJlcil 11 Bh!COKllX IBnep)f(eK Bb!5!CHClIIlll )'1'01'0 H 3aKlll{)'!CHIIH B3UIIMI!0 OOH3blBalO1UllX CorJlalilCllHH pam10HaJ1hHblM BblOOPOM 0YIlCT OTK31 OT BHeccml~

Ill(!lalla Il Ka~lI1amno.

83

yseflJll411Tb 113nCp)KKI1, BMeH5IeMble TeM UHJl,UBI1Jl,aM. KOTOPblC OTKa3bl­

satOTC5I BcrynUTb B COOTBeTCTBYIQW.I1C rpynnbl, nnaTI1TL lIJ1CHCKl1e S3f10Cbl H Boo6w.e npl1HI1MaTb Y4aCTUe B KOJlJlCKTI1BHOI'v1 /lC~CTBUU.

Hanpl1Mep, npaBO pa60Tan, no onpCAeJleWlblM CneUHaJlbIlOCT5IM. B OTpaCJl5lX I1JlI1 lIa onpeneJleHHblx cpa6pl1KaX MO)l(eT 6blTb 4JleHCTBOM B npocpCOT:03e HJlI1 I1IW~ npocpeCCI10HaJlbHOM

aCCOQHauuu. lill1POKO pacnpOCTpaHeHbl neJlOBble rpynnbI, rj1aBHOM Uefl btO KOTOPblX }{BJl5!eTC5I Jl066I1pOBaHl1e, 11 HHorna OTKa3 Bcrynl1Tb B TaKYIO rpynny MO)l.(CT nOBJlellb 11.Jl5! He nO)l(CJ1aBWeM COTpynHu4aTb CTOPOHbl np5lMblC 113tleP:>KKH. ,l].aJlee, B03MO)l(1I0, y CPI1PMbl, BJlanCIDll1CH 60JlbWOM nOJlCH pblHKa, eCTb CTI1MYJl neHCTBOBaTb B Onl11lO4KY 11 I1H­ BeCTUpOBaTb B OrpaHI1411TeJlbHOe 3aKOHOnaTCJlbCTBO 8.

KaK MLI y)l.(C OTMe4aJll1, eCTb Mlioro npH411H, no KOTOPblM 60Pb6a 061l1eCTBa B QeJlOM C He60JlbWI1MI1, HO XOpOUlO OpraHI130BaHHblMI1 rpynnaMI1 naSJ1eHYI5I OKa3bIBaeTC5I HepaBHoH, <PaKTI14eCKI1 Ila oeHOBe }f3JlO)l,eHHbIX BblllIe

qTO HCB03Mo)KHOCTb ~tiUUUJl,t1U11 MC)!(1J.YHap011.HOH TOprOBJlI1 B HaweM npl1MCpe 6blJla npeJl,onpe11.e,1eHa 3apaHee.

cpah.'TOpbl, KOTopble pa60TaIDT npOTHB rpynn, npeCJlenYIDIHI1X CBOI1 OC06blC mrrepCCbl, 11 OrpaHI1411BalOT 3cpcpeKTI1BHOCTb TaKHX rpynn, B TOM 1I11CJlC 3aKOHbi npOTI1B B3}{T04HU4CCTBa, npaSI1Jla, peryJll1pylQll1l1C nOBC11.CHl1e Jl066I1CTOB, 11 4YBCTBO rpa:>KtlallCKOM OTBCTeTBeHHOCTU y rocynapcTBeHHbIX CJlY)Kall1HX 11 '3aKOH011.aTeJICM. OrpaHI1411Tb BJlI15!HI1C XopOWO opraHU30BaHHbIX rpynn naBJleHI1}{ MO)l(eT 11 KOIlCPJlI1KT I1HTCpe­ COB Me)I(11.Y TaKI1MI1 rpynnaMH, B HaweM npl1Mepe - KOHCPJlI1KT Me:>K11.Y OTeqeCTBel'HlbIMI1 113rOTOBI1TeJl5!MI1 11 I1lImOpTepaMI1 06YBI1.

3.4. KOH~em.\MH paBHoBecHblx nonMTM<teCKIIIX MHCTMTYTOB

B cOBpeMellllOM 06u~ecTBe 06MeH U np0l13BOtlCTBO oCYIHecTBJl5IIQTC5I B paMKax COUl1aJlbHO 11 nOJll1TI14eCKI1 YCTaHOBJlCHHblX 11 o6eenc4cHHbiX npaBI1J1. OO)TOMY Ha pa3MelueHI1C pecypcoB OKa3blBalOT BO'3tlCMCTBI1C 113MeHeHH}{ B CTpyKType npaBHJl (nepepacnpetleJleHl1e npas C06CTSCII­ HOCTI1) 11, eCJlI1 CneJlaTb cu\e OJl,HH mar, 113MCHeHI15! COQl1aJlbHblX 11 110­

bO;ICC nOnpoolloe pacc~\(rrpel!lIe )TI1X MOMCHTOB eM. B KH.: Olson (l965) (pyc, ncp.:

OJ}COII AI. JIorHKa KOIIJleKTllBllOI'O neHcTBHH. HOIlOCHOI1PCK, 1995).

84 lJaclIlI, I. /3(ie()elme Ii IIl1!OPItI()

-.~--

KOCBCHHO, Kor,[(a roJlOCYfOT Bbl6pafHlhie npeJICTaBH­ CJIY'-Iae HCXO,[( rOJlOCOBaHH~ onpe,[(eJ(~eTC~ B COOTBCTCT­

BHH C TaK Ha%IBaCMbIM npaBI1J10M npOCToro 60JlbLUHHCTBa. B nOCJIC­ BnCIIHoe BpeMH ]KOHOMHCTbl l+ nOJllnOJlorl1 IlpOBeJlH HCllCPIlbll

HCCJle,'I,OBaHHe xapaKTepa pe3YJlbTaTOB, BblTeKalOLUI1X H3 roJIOCOBaHWI Ill) IIpmmII) npOCToro 60JlbW~1HCTBa. rII10HepHblH BKJla'[( npI1Ha,[(Jle)!(HT

poy IArrow. 1951), KOTOPblH CQJopMYJmpOBaJI "TcopeMY HeB03MOiKHOCTl1"

B JIHTcpaTYpc, nOCBHLUeHHOI1 roJIOCOBaHH5IM, 6blCTPO npHWJlI1 K cne­ ,[(YIOUlCMY 1aKJlIO'-lCHHfO. ,Ll,onYCTI1M, I1MeCTCH Kopnyc areliTOB C '3a,[(all­ Hblf\lH YCTOH'-II1BhlMI1 npe,[(no'-rreHI1HMI1, nepe,[( KOTOPblMI1 CTOI1T Bbl60p

Me)KllY pa3HblMI1 :meMeHTaMH MHOiKeCTBa aJIbTepHaTI1BflblX Bapl1all­ TOB. r:1TOT Bbl60p OCYLUeCTBJI~CTC5I Ha OCHOBC roJlOCOBallHH I'. COOTBCT­

CTBI1H C npaBHlIOM npOCToro 60JI bUH1 HCTBa. )laJlce, M())KHO IlOKa3aTb.

LJTO PC3YllhTaT Bbl60pa 3aBHCHT He OT npe'[(nO'-lTeI1l1H, a OT nOCJICllOBa­ TCJlbHOCnl rOJlOCOBaIlHH"'- KaK H I'. KaKOM nopH,[(Ke COIlOCTaBJlHIOTCH 3,lCf\leIITbl MH())KeCTl3a aJlbTCpHaTl1B. B 3aBHCHMOCT~i 0'1' 1I0CjIe,[(0l3aTeJIb­ 1I0CTH rOJIOCOBallHH BO'5MOiKeH IlO'-lTI1 JlI060H HCXOJl; HHblMI1 C.110BaMH.

Rena K BbIBO,[(Y 0 TOM, '-ITO C03,[(aHHC KOaJIl1l-lHI1 rO,10CYfOIJlHX HBJ1.IIeTCH HeYCTOH'-II1BbIM cnoc060M peWCHI1H np06J1eMbI TOproBJlI1 IOJlOCaMH H '[(Uf'OBOPCHHOCTCi1 06 061\1CHC roJlOCaMH

'I Arrow. Kennelh.J. (1<)51). Social Choic,~ and Individual Values. New York. Hl1)I(IX!I<:­

PallllOlleCJlJ.lc nCXO,lhl BO'l~IO)KII!'I, eCJ1II !lCI-'TO o6pcTacT MOIIO]](UbIlYIO \lilaCTb Ha.'l 110­ IlCCll(oii ;mH. 'I c. !lJIaCTh KOIlTPOJII!pOllaTI> nOC!IC)lOBaTC)lbllOCTb I'OJIOWlJaJlllli. \IOI'JIII Obi 1I011JIIll! l'b 11<1 IlCXO;lb! f'OJ10COBlItll1it tlOlIKylll!ll !!lillO, KOH'lllOJltlPYIOIlI(.'C [J()BCC1X) ;lWI FeJII! TpallCm,lIl'1(lIl1lblC II'11lepJKKII paBIIf.1 HYJIIO, OKOII'laTCc1hHblil IIcxo:t IlC 'lllllHCl!1 Of :lItua. KOropO\ly IIPl:!10C'IDIl,flcn KOlHPO;lh Ita)lIlOBCCTKOfi lIH)!, l.jTO IICJ1h'll! C YllcpellllOCThfO ymep­ ,KiUlTh Il CIlY'Ja~ 1l0JI0lKl1TeJlhHbIX TpaHeaKUHOHHhlX H3)lCPJKCI(. lIeplloii ny6JIIlKnnudL 1I0CHl!­

IllCllIIOii K0Il1110JIIO 11a)1 1I0BCCTKOi:j )U11I, OObll.jHD Cl.jIlTaCTClI Cl1lThl!: ROilier.

I km (//'(1 (11.)79). Bureaucrats Versus Voters: On the Political Econom)

b) Direct Democracy Ii QU(lrler~I'JolI,.n(/1 ojEconomics 93 (No.4, NovclIlbcr): 563-587.

Linda: }/allhelFs. Steven (1980). Constrained Plot Equilibria. Directional Euuilibria and Global Cycling Sets II Review of Fconoll1ic Studies 47 (No, 5. October):

3TH BbIBO,[(bl 4)OPMaJIbHOH nOJlHT0J10rH LleCKOH TCOpHH npOTHBOpe­ 'U:lJ1H HCCJlC'[(OBaHH}lM 3MnHpH'-IeCKOIO H onHCaTeJlbHoro xapaKTepa, lie o6HapY)({HBU1HM CBI1,[(eTeJlbCTB HcpaBHOBCCH~. KOTopoe TeopHH acco­ Ul1l-ipOBaJIa C npaBHJ10M npocToro 60JlbWHHCTBa. I--hncpccHO OTMe­ nrrb, 41'0 Ha (jJ0PMaJIbHYIO nOJlHTOJlOrH4eCKYIO TeopHIO OKa3aJIa CHJ1h­ Hoe BJIH~HHe COBpeMeHHall MHKP03KOHOMHlJeCKaH TeopH}I C cc aKIWH­ TOM Ha paIl~1OHaJIbHOM Bbl60pe H paBHoseCHH. )laJICe, 6HXCBHOPHCT­ CJ(all peBOJ1fOIlHH B nOJIHTOJIOrHl1, KaK H B 3KOHOMH'-IeCKOH HaYKe, He y,[(eJ1HJla HHKaKOIO BHHMaHH5I CTpYKrype HIicnrrYTOB H H:\' Cnep))(H­ BafOLUeMY RJII1HHHIO Ha IlOBcnCHHe. CCl1lJac 1I0JlO)({eHHe ,'I.e.1I MCHHeTC}l.

B nOCJlenllHC ronbi BJlI1HHHe no,[(xo,[(a C n03HUHH npan C06CTBCHHOCTH B 3KOHOMH'-IeCKoi1 HaYKe pacnpOCTpaHHJIOCb H Ha n0J1f.1'r0J10rHIO H nOJlOlJ(HJlO Ha4aJIO TCOPHH, HMcHyeMoH HCKOTOPblil.HI anTOpaMI1 HOBblM HHCTHTYllHOHlliIH3MOM HJlH HOBOH IIOJlHTH'-IeCKOH 3KOHOMI1Ci1 -­ nepeCC'-ICHI1H 1l0JIHTHKH H 3KOHOMH'-IeCKOH I1aYKH. Mb! C4H­ TaeM 3TOT llOl3hlH 1l0AXO,[( HCOTbCMJICMOHLJaCTblO HI13T.

B nOC.lIe,[(llee BpeMH KpHTHKH YTBCP)I<Jl,aJIH, '-ITO "'-IHCTa~ MOAeJlh npaBHJ1a npOCTOI'O 60JlhUIHIICTBa" He HMCCT aHaJIOI'a B 3aKOHOnaTeJlb­

HblX c06paIHHIX HJIH HHblX opraHax, Bblpa6aTbiBalOLUHX npaBHJla. OHH 3aRBJlHIOT, '-ITO lIa caM OM ,[(CJle rOJlOCOBaHl1e H llpHH5ITHC peUJe!IHH KOHTPOJ1HPYCTC5I TW,aTeJlbIlO pa3pa60TaHllblMH npoue,[(ypaMI1. npHBO­ L(5ILUHMI1 K paSHOBeCHbIM Hcxo,[(aM, HanpHMCp, lUCnCJIH (Shepsie.

1983) YKa3blBaCT Ha 600 C JIHWHHM cTpaHHu "Deschler's Proccdures of the U. S. House of Represcntatives" ("f1pOUCAYPbl naJIaTbl npC,[(CTaBI1­ Tenel1 CiliA"). HOBbie HHCTHTYUHOHaJIl1CTbI COrJlaWaIOTC5I C rCM, trro B CB060AHOH OT HHCTHTYTOB cpc,[(c npH HeOrpaHH'-ICHHOM '-IHCJ1e rOJIO­ COBaHHH C IlCJ1bfO Bbl60pa H3 aJ1bTepHaTHBHbIx BapHaIlTOB M())l(eT He 6blTb paBHOBeCHbIX HCXOnOB, HO OHH npH,[(ep)({HBaIOTC}I TOH TOtlKH 3peHI1H, LITO B peaJ1bHOM MI1pC CYLI~CCTBYfOT TaKHe BH,[(hl HHCTI1TYUHO­ HaJlhHOro YCTpoi1CTBa, npH KOTOPblX I1MeeT MeCTO TCIIACHUH}l K llOC­ TH)(eHHfO YCTOHIIHBblX HCXO'[(OB,

KaKOBbl ',TI1 BHL\bl HHCTHTYUHOHaJIbHOro YCTpOHCTBa? B pa60Te

o cmpyKl11ypllO Oelllep.HWIup06allllo.1I

ropOB no CyTH TaKOBa. 'H<U!bHaH CTpYKTypa opraHOB, Bblpa6aTbIBafOLUHX npaBHJIa,

Pa3Ho06pa311ble 3J1eMeHThl, KOTopble OrpaHHlJHBafOT lIOBe'[(CHHC TaKHM 06pa30M, L1T06b! B pe3YJ1bTaTC npHBecTH K YCTOH'-IHBb!M Hcxo,[(aM. 0POL\eCC Bbloopa He OXBaTblBaeT BCCX areHTOB, Y'-IaCTBYfOU\I1X B rOJlO-

Kenneth A.; Weingas[, Bam.: R. (198 I). Structure-induced Equilibrium and

Public Choice 37 (No.3): 503-519.

86 qacnll, J. Bae()ellue 6 meOp1ll0

COBaHHH no nOBOllY Bcex B03MO)l(HbiX rulbTepHaTHBHblX BapHaHTOR. CKopee, cOBoKynHocTb nHl(, npHHHMalOllI.HX peWeHH5I, pacnpeJ].eneHa, HanpHMep, no KOMHTeTaM, a MIlQ}KeCTBO anbTepllaTHBHblX BapHaHTOB pa3J].eneHO Ha ccjJepbl KOMnCTeHUHH. AreHTbl pacnpCJ].cn5lIOTC5I no KO­ MHTCTaM C nOMOll~blO HeKOToporo MexaHH3Ma, HanpHMep nYTeM CBO­ 60J].Horo Bbl60pa (MeTOll, npHH5ITbIM B KOHrpecce CiliA), a KOMHTeTaM npeJ].ocTaBJI5lIOTC5I HS;KJ1101lHTenbHble npaBa c06cTBeHHocTH Ha KOI1­

KpeTHble ccpepbl KOMneTeI1UHH. B KOHrpecce CiliA KOMHTeTM 4aCTO nperpa)KJ].aIOT nyTb H3MeHeHH5IM B paMKax cBoeH ccpepM KOMnCTCHI~HH

TeM, 4TO He BblJ].BHralOT HHKaKHX 3aKOHonpOCKTOB. I1x ex post BnaCTb Ha COBMCCTHblX 3aceJ].aHH5IX KOMHTeTOB n03BOn5leT HM HaB5I3b1BaTb 3TO orpaHWlellHe, a TaK)Ke B cyw.eCTBeHHoM Mepe npe,.'l.OCTaBn5leT MOHOllO­ nmo Ha KOHTponb Hall BHeceHHeM H3MeHcHHH B nOBeCTKY J].H5I.

KpaMIICM Mepe, JJ,n51 Toro 4T06bl 3aKOHonpoeKT HMen lllaHC npOXQ}IUC­ HH5I LIcpe3 Ka/KJ].YIO H3 06eHX IlruIaT KOHrpecca, n04TH BCCr,LJ,a Hc06xo­

J].HMa nOMCp)KKa BceMH KOMHTeTaMH H3MeHCHHM, CB5I3aHHbIX C Bonpo­ caMH, HaXOIl5l11~HMHC5I B ccpepe I1X KOMneTeHUI1H 13.

IlpH TaKOM YCTpOMCTBe areHTbl OTKa3bIBaIOTC5I OT 3Ha4HTenbHol1 BnaCTH BO MliOrHX ccjJepax B 06MeH Ha HenponopUHoHrulbHO 60JlbWYIO BnaCTb B cneUHcpHyeCKHX ccpepax KOMneTeHUHH . .ll.enempoBaHHe Bna­ CTH KO\UrreTaM npellnonaraeT cyw.eCTBOBaHl1e areHTCKHX OTHOllleHI1H H Hc06xOJ].I1MOCTb B CHCTeMe Ha,U30pa co CTOPOHbl rOJlOBHOH OpraHI1­ 3aUIcHl. Ha npaKTHKe cyw.eCTByeT MHoro CPOpM Ha,U30pa HaJ]. KOMHTC­ TaM 11. lIIHCTHTYUI10HanH3HpOBaHHble nHJ].epbl MoryT HMeTb nOBcpCH~

HblX "l11U B Ka)KJ].OM KOMHTeTe, a TaIOl(e OTCne)l(l1BaTb peaKUHIO 3aKOHO­ J].aTenei;j, n066I1CTOB, 1136HpaTeneM H I1cnonHHTenbHOM BnaCTH Ha pa­

60TY KOMHTeTOB. ,nanee, "npoJ].YKUH5I" KOMI1TeTOB - 3aKOHonpOeKThi. ncpCJ].aBacrvlble B 3aKOHOllaTenbHblM opraH M5I H3Y4eHH5I H ronocoBa­ HH5I, J].OJDKHa npOHTH npouecc BHeCeHH5I nonpaBOK. Pa3pa60TaHbl npo­

13 B CTIlThC 1981 r. II!cncIHI H Y:lHHraCT 061,HClilIIOT ll)1aCTb KOMltTt:rOIl npCU?>IYU(CCT­ llClIlIO B TCPMHlJaX I1X pOIlU "npHBpanmKoB", HJ1H HHcTaHUHii. (llOpMHp) IOU(HX nOIJl':I:TK) BXOAlIlUHM B cQlepbl HX 1<0MneTel!lUlH. B oJllloll H3 1l0C:ICj(IIHX CHOW' panOT and Weillgast, 1987) aBTOpb! flcpccMarpllsalOT eBmo 110'3IlUlllO, llcn<lJl IlKI(CIII lIa 11C'!X)'lHHl<aX ex posl BHaCTH KOMHTCT<lB: "KOMHTeTbl B 1<<l'ICCTBC HHCTlIllUl1i1, <jlOPMHPYIO­ mHX 1I0BCCl'KY JJ.1I11 no BonpocaM, llXOllllU\IlM B C<pCPbl HX I<OMm:TCHUI1H, MoryT HaBJl3blBaTh MHOfllC CHon 1I0)J(eJlaHHlI B 06J1aCTH nomlTIlKII He ,[OJlbKO flOTOMY, 'lTO 01111 HllfIUHl1pYIO'1 l31<0HonpOCKrM, HO II llOTOMY. 'lTO 11 noene '[oro. l<aK ax na.na ra Bblpa11l;1a CHOIO Homo, YlUIX aCTaCTC,1 emc OJJ.HH U(aHC Ao6HT6CJl Clloero. 3TOT wallc MO)J(HO pCam130BaTb Ha CTalll1H COBMeCTtlOro paCCMOTpeHIlJl Jal<OHonpOel<Ta 06eHMlI na.naTaMH 3aKOHOllaTCJlbHOrO Oprall<l C

UCJlhlO YCTpaHCIHIJl pa'3JlH'lIl[1 MCIKlJ.Y HepCHilMI1 3al<Ofl()[Ipoel<Ta, llPC!UlO)J(ClIlIhIMIl KalKlJ.oii In na.'JaT" (Shepsle. Kenneth A.; Weingast. Bany R. (1987). 'Ibe Institutional Foundations of COI11­

millec Power II American Political S'cience Review 81 (No. I, March): 85-104. P. 85).

87

eccyaJ1bHblC HOPMbl, npeJ].Ha3HaYCHHble J].n51 KOllTpOnHpOBaHH5I pC3ynb­

U 6 "

-raTOB pa OThl Ha,lJ, 3aKOHonpOCKTaMH, ocyll{eCTBn5leMOH BceM 3aKOHO­ )laTenbHblM opnlllOM HJ1H O,lJ,HOM H3 ero nanaT. HanpHMep, CYll.eCTBYIOT npaBl-wa, pernaMeHTHpYIOW.HC, KaKHe THnb! nonpaBOK J].onYCTHMbl 11 B KaKOH nOcnC,lJ,OBaTenbHOCTH lIaJ]ne)l(HT conOCTaBn5lTb anbTepHaTHBHble BapHaHTbl. Jlrulee, pe3KO HeraTHBHa51 peaKUH5I co CTOPOHbl TOM 4aCTH 3aKOHOJ].aTencH, KOTOpa51 He COCTOHT B KOMHTCTe, 51Bn5leTC5I 3acnY)l(H­ BalOW.HM J].OBepHC CBl1.l1.eTenbCTBOM B nonb3Y TOro, YTO pa60Ta KOMHTeTa HY)l(llaeTC5I B KaKHX-TO H3MeHeHH5IX. EcnH TaKl1e npeTeH3HH Bbl,lJ,BHraeT )lOCTaT04HO 60J1blllOe YHCnO 3aKOHOl.aTeneM, TO MO)KHO O)l(H.lI.aTb Ka­ KHX-TO J].CI1CTBHM HnH npeBeHTHBHOM peaKUHH co CTOPOHbl KOMI1TeTa C uenblO H36e)J(aTb B03MQ}I<HbIX KOHTponHpYlOllI.HX MepOnpH5ITHM,

HaJlHYHC TaKI1X THnOB HHCTHTYUHOHrulbHoro YCTpOHCTBa, KaK pa3­

.lI.eJleHHC nl1U, npl1HHMalOllI.HX peLlJeHH5I, Ha I<OMI1TeTbl H npe,LJ,OCTaBJ1e­ HHC npaB C06CTBellliOCTH Ha KOHKpeTHble ccpepbl KOMrIeTeHUHH 4ne­ HaM KOMHTeTa, BHOCHT KOppeKTHBbl B Tpac1.I1UHOHHble BblBO,LJ,bl, CJ].enaH­ HblC B mnepaType, nOCB5Ill\eHHOH 06ll1.eCTBeHHOMY Bbl60py. 0611\eCT­

Bbl60p 113 cOBoKymlocTH COUHanbHblX npeJ].n04TeHHM 60nbllJe He HOCHT UHKJlH4ecKoro xapaKTepa, H Y)l(C Hcnb351 CKa3aTb, 4TO B03­

OnpenenHM HHCTHTYTbl KaK MHo)KeCTBa npaBHn, ynpaBJl51lOllI.HX Me)!(­ Jll1'lHOCTllblMH OTHOllleHI15IMH, OTMeTHB npH :nOM, LITO peYb H,lJ,CT 0 cpopManbHOH nOJ1HTHLJeCKOM H OpraHI13au,HOHHol1 npaKTHKe, IlpeJ].no­ nO)l(HM, YTO y areHTOB eCTb KaKHe-TO ex ante O)l(I1,lJ,aHH5I no nOBollY CB5I3H Me)I(IlY HHCTHTYUHOHrulbHOH CTpyKTYPOH H HCXOllaMH 06w.ecT­ BCHHoro Bbl60pa. TorJ].a, eCJlH 3allaHbi npeJ].nOLJTeHI151 areHTOB B OTHO­ WeHHH HCXO,lJ,OB, Mo)[<I-IO onpeJ].enHTb xapaKTep cnpoca Ha HHCTHryTbl. Ecnl1 HHCTHTYTbl KaKI1M-TO 06pa30M Bbl6pallbl (4TO Mbl H XOTHM nOKa-

Mbl CHOBa B03Bpaw.aCMC5I K HepaBHOBCCHblM HCXO.ll.aM r0J10COBa­ HH5I no npaBHny npOCToro 60JlblllI1HCTBa, H Bb160p H3 cOBoKynHocTI1 I1HCTHTYIOB He npHBeJ].eT K YCTOM4HBblM HnH paBHOBCCHblM HHCTHTY­ TaM. 11 HaM He nOMo)KeT YTBep)l(J].eHHe, 4TO Bhl60p HHCTI1TYTOB caHK­

lI,HoHHpoBaH npaBHnaMI1 60nee BblCOKOro nOp5l,LJ,Ka rIHCaHblMH I1nH HermcallblMH KOHCTI1TYl~H5IMH, H60 TeM caMblM aprYMeHTaUH5I TonbKO

OTcTynacT lIa war Ila3a,LJ" nOCKonbKY Mbl Torlla ,LJ,OJ1IKHbl npol'Ho:mpo­ BaTb HeYCTOH4HBbie I<OHCTHTYUHH.

88 l{aC",b I. H6eiJcllue G I1I(!O/JIiI()

TaK )l(C KaK B cnyLtaC HCXOllOB ronocoBaHHH. ')MmlpH4CCKHe !Ia6mo.uCHHM 1l0Ka3blBalOT. 'ITO HHCTHTYUHOHafIbHblC cTpywrYPbl B ll.CMO­ KpaTHlICCKHX crpaHax OTHOCHTcnbHO YCTOH'1HBbl. 'ITO HM npm~yUla Tell.!ICIIUH~ K YCTOH4HBbiM HHCTHTYTaM. IilcncJIH (Sheps/e. ]983) no­

flbITaJ1C» pa3pCWI1Tb 3TY ll.HncMMY H 06b5ICIUlTb npH4HlibI TaKOH TCB­ ;l,CIll~HH B TcpMHHax MOll.CJlH paUHoHaJlbHoro Bbl60pa.

1l03HUH» UlcncnH COCTOHT, Bo-ncpBblx, B TOM, 4TO CTpYKTypa fIO­

nHTH4CCKHX HHCTHryTOB H CB»3aHHbIC C HHMH HCXO.!lbl OTpa)l(alOT HI!­ TCPCCbl TCX, KTO 06JIa.!laCT BJlaCTblO: :7KOHOMHLICCKa~ BJlaCTb nopo)l(ll.<i­ CT BJIaCTb nonHTH4CCKYIO. 1111ll.HBH.!lbl. nblTalOlllHeC~ YCHJIHTb CBOtO

BJlaCTb nYTCM H3MCHCHH~ nOJlHTHlICCKHX HHCTHTYTOB, MorYT O)l(H.!laTh

B C,lYLIaC, ccnH HX YCHJlH» HC npHHCCYT ycncxa. B03Me3ll.H», KOTOPOC

.!lOporo 11M 060H.!lCTC~. 4aCTO Hcnb3~ C onpC.!lCJlCHHOCTblO npC.!lCKa3aTb 3apaHCC, 6Yi1.Y1 JlH ycncwHblMH nonblTKH H3MCHHTb nonHTH4CCKHC

HHCTHTYTbl, HanpHMCp, no TOH npH4HHC, 4TO arCHTbl MorYT C'lCCTb CTpaTcrH4eCKI1 L~eneco06pa3HblM He paCKpbIBaTb CBOH IIpCll.n04TCHHM

.!lO (llHHaJlblloro rOJIOCOBaHH~.

BO-BTOPbIX, nOJlHTH4CCKHC HHCTHTYTbl pa3pa60TaHbl TaKHM 06pa­ 30M, lJTOObl CIIOC06cTBOBaTb COTPY.!lHH4CCTBY MC)J(ll.Y JlI1uaMH, npHHH­ MalOWHMH peweHHH, HJlH, no KpaHHCH MCpC. K 3TOMY CBOll.HTC~ O.!llla 113 HX qJYHKllHH. ITPH 06MCHax MC)I(.!lY nOJIHTH4CCKHMH II,CSlTCJI~MH

Tpallc<lKql10HHblC l13.!lep)I(KH 6bIBalOT BblCOKHMH (KaK H H3llCP,KKH 06­ Melia MCII(.LlY npccTynHHKaMH HJlH MC)J(llY CYBCPCHHblMH rOCYll.apCT­ BaMH), nOTOMY 4TO, B OTJlH411C OT cHTyaUHH pblHKa, 3ll.CCb OTCYTCTBYC'J CHJlbHaSi TPCTbSl CTopOHa, nOMor3lOw~ npHBCCTH B I1C[(OIlHeHHC KOH­

D031'OMY IlpH nOJ)HTH4eCKOM 06MCHe OTHOCHTCJlbHO Ba>KHYIO POIlb HrpaCT ll.CHCTBHC aBTOMaTH4CCKHX McxaHH3MOB, 06CCIlc'mBalOll~HX

BblflOJllleUHC KOHTpaKTOB. ITpH nOBTopHblX CllCIlKax )lJl~ HX Y4aCTl1H­ KOB npe.ll,CTaBJ1~CT L\CHHOCTb xopowa~ pcnYTaUH5I, TOrll.a KaK pCllyra­ UH~ .ll,eJlbL\a, H3MeH~IOwcro CBoeMY CJlOBY, MO)l(CT nOBJlC'lb 60;lbWHC 113llep)KKI1. Ho 3TH aBTOMaTH4CCKHe MCXaHH:3Mbl ~BIl5lIOTCH 6ecnOIlC3­

f1blM <IlaKTopOM BO MHOrHX cHTyanHHX, B OC06CHHOCTH npH MHorOCTO­ pOHHHX 06MeHax: B :JTHX CJlyLJa~X Bbl~CHeHHe, KTO Koro 06MaHb1BaeT. conp»)KeHO C H3ll.Cp)J(KaMI1, BccrAa HaH)lCTC~ MCCTO ll.JlSl "6C36HJ1CT­

HHKOB", H neHCHO, KTO llomKCH HCCTH H3Aep)l(KH lJaKa3aHH» arCHTOB 3a onnopTymlcTHlleCKOC nOBeAeHHC.

11MC51 BCC 3TO B BH}l,)', IilcnCIlH )TBep)J(llaeT, lITO nOJlHTH4CCKHe HHCTHTYTbl CYTb ex ante comamCHH5I no nOBO)lY KooncpaUHH MC)Klly nO,lHTllllCCKHMH .uC5ITeJISlMH. B COOTBCTCTBHH C TaKHM B3mHll.OM HH­ CTHTYTbl MOJI<HO TpaKTOBaTb KaK CTPYKTYPY KanHTaJla, npc.rVJa3Ha4ell­ HYIO ]])1» "npOH3BOll.CTBa" nOTOKa YCTOH4HBblX f10JlHTH4eCKHx HCXO­

3a)laHHa~ CTpYKTypa MOIKeT 6blTb ex ante CB5I3aHa C MHO)l(eCTBOM TOtJeK CTpYKTypIIO-ll.CTCPMHHHpoBaHHoro paBHoBccH». Ex post 3Ta He­ onpe.!lCJleHHOCTb nOCTcnCHHO YMcHbwacTc» 110 Mepe Toro, KaK CTaHO­

SSlTC.!i H3BCCTHbiMU oncpaUHOHHhle xapaKTcpHcTHKH HOBOH I1HCTHTY­ UJiOHaJIbHOH CTPYKTYPbl.

HaKoHcu, WeIlcIlH YTBCp)l(ll.aCT, 'ITO :na HCOnpCll.CJleHHOCTb no IIO­ sO)lY BIlH~lIl1j{ CTPYKTypHblX 113MCHCHHH Ha paBHOBCCHble HCXOll.bl 51B­ JlBeTCSI llOCTaT04HblM OCIlOBaHHCM .!lJl~ cTa6HJlH3aUHH I1HCTHTYTOB H

npellOTBpaweHH5I HcnpcpblBHblX I1HCTHTYUHOHaJ1bHbIX H3MCHCHHH. TaKHM 06pa30M, OH OTCTaHBaeT T04KY 3pCIIH~, comaCHO KOTOPOH pac­ qeTbl arCHTOB I1pH npHH~THH PCWCHHH, CB»3aHHbIX C nonHTH4eCKHM BbI60pOM, Ka4CCTBeHHO OTJlH4aIOTC~ OT paClJeTOB B CBS/3H C HHCTl1ry­

UHOHaJ1bHbIMH H3MCHeHH~MH.

3T01' HOBblH 110llXOll K nonHTH4CCKHM opraHH3aUH~M aHaJ10rl14eH HCCIlell.OBaHH~M npupOllbl 3KOHOMH4ecKHX OpraHH3aU,HH, KOTOPblC Mbl npe.!lCTaBHJ1H B npcAhlllYweH rJlaBC. HanpHMCp, CHCTCMa KOMHTCTOB B KOHrpccce CUlA H KOHTPOIlb Hall. nOBeCTKOH ll.H5I TpaKrycTcH KaK Ile­ Ka» panHOHaJlbH~ CTpYKrypa, aHaJ10rl14Ila~ COBpCMeHHOH KopnopaItHH .

B TOM )KC ;'l,)'XC BblACp)l(aHO H YTBep)l(llCHHC Y:7HHraCTa

\984), 4TO Hepa3YMHO )l,eJlaTb anpHopHoe llonywcHHc 0 COTpYll.HHKax

q,e.!lepa'lbIIOH a.!lMHHHCTPaUHH CIlIA KaK 0 HcnollKOHTPOJlbHblX arCH­

Tax, nOCKOJlbKY B I1HTcpccax HX HcnocpCllCTBeHHblX llOBcpHTeIleH 4JIeHOB KOHrpccca H KOHCllHO )l(e HX maBHblX llOBepl1TCJlCH - H36H­ parcneH pa3pa60TaTb HHCl'HTYUHOHaJ1bHYIO CTPYKTYPY. orpaHH4l1BalO­

BOAY, 'ITO CHCTCMa TaKora pOlla Ha caMOM ll.cJle YMCCTHa: 3TO paBHO­

BeCHblH nOJll1TH4CCKHH HHCTI1TYT, KOTOPblH HrpOKH nl160 He Moryl',

.i11160 HC CTpeM~TC~ H3MCHHTb.

3Ta CI1CTCMa BKJ1104aeT CneUHaJll13HpOBaHHbiC KOMI1TCTbl KOH­ rpecca, ny6IlH'iHble CJ1ywaHH~, KOHTPOJlb nOBCll.eHH~ 4HHOBHHKOB CO

CTOPOHbl npell.CTaBHTeJlCH 06WeCTBCHHOCTH, ,'l,OKJlallbIBalOlUHX 0 pC­ 3ynbTaTax CBOI1M ynOJ1HOMOlJeHHbIM. B TcpMHHax MOllCJ1H Y3HHraCTa

u Barry R. (1984). The Congressional-Bureaucratic System: A PrincipalAgent Perspective /1 Public Choice 44 (No. I): 147-192; Idem (1983). Bureaucratic Discretion Or Congressional Control') Regulating Policymaking by the Federal Trade Commission II

Journal orpOlilical Economy 91 (October, No.5): 766 ·800.

lIaJUOp 3a HcnO"1HHTeHbHoii BeTBblO BJlaCTH co CTOPOHbl 1aKOHOlta­ TeJlbHOH BeTBH

YTBep)I<,'latOT. 4TO Y4eHble. 06BHH5IIOIl\He

CBOI1I\IH Ha,LJ,30pHbIMH 06H3aHHOCT5IMH. He BH1~HT

30BaHHblii OCliOBaHHblM Ha 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH McxaHH3M KOIITPOJBI. KOTOPblH MaK-Ky66HHC H I1IBapI~ HMeHYIOT 1I(f(J:WpO.11 110 71p 1111 //11111'

nO.JlcaplI()l1 ClIpeJibl.

nmnOK 'iac. Kor}la npHJlO){(eHHe 3KOIlOMHLIeCKHX TeopHM npaB co6­ CTBeHHOCTH. TpaHcaKUHOHHblX H3}lep){(eK H 3reHTCKHX OTlIOllleHHil Tpallccpopl\1HpyeT HallH1 npCJ1CTaBJlCHH5I 06 aMepHKaHCKIiX nonHTH4e­ CKHX I1HCTHT)'Tax. ECTb OCHOBaHIH BCpHTb. 4TO ,)TOT HOBblH nOJlXo:\ ,laCT ueHHblC OTKPhIHU!, TeOpeMh!. rHnOTC3bl H )MllI1pH4eCKHe Ha6mo·

.1elll151. I1MelOIllHe OTHOllleHHe He TOJlbKO K aMepHKaHCKHl\1 HHCTHT) Ta~L

HO H K 1I0JlHTH4CCKHM HHCTHTYTaM pa3HhiX crpaH 11 BpeMeH

3.5. IIIAeOJlOrlr1H Ir1 MOAeJlb paLtlr10HaJlbHoro 8bl6opa

B XOll,e HaLUero aHaJ1H3a JlOrHKH KOJlJleKTHBlloro ,'lCHCTBH5! H npo­ "6e36HJleTIIHKa" 6hlJlO ynoM5III)'TO 0 TOM, LITO 3KOHOMH'-ICCKHfl nO,'lxoJ\ lie npHllec ycnexa B ]leJle 06b5lCllellH5I onperle,lCHHb!X rpynno­

LIHCTO JKOHOMH4ecKoro nOJIXO,'la K rpYllnoBoMY nOBC]leHHIO B cl1Tya­ UHH. KOrJla HMelOT MeCTO cTHMynbI K CJlC]lOBamIIO CTpaTerHH ""6e'l­ KJla]leT B OCIIOBY cBoeH TCOpHH ]lOnyu~cHI151 (l pallHollaJlbHOM Bbl60pe H nOJlY4aeT no CyTH TeopHIO I136e}KaHH5! peBo­

JIl0UHH, C nOMO!l\bIO KOTOPOH MO)l(HO ,.'laTh xopoUlee 06b5lCHCHHC TOi\l} cpaK'ry, 4TO peBOJIIOI\HH npOHCXO]lllT OTHOCHTCJlbHO peJlKO JlmKC B ro­ cy,clapCTB3x. f'Jle IlpaBliT THp3Hb!.

1(' McCubbins. }!a/!lew D.: Schwarl::. 7IlOIIWS (! 984), Congressional OY~rsight OYer­ looked: Police Patrols Versus Fire Alarms 1/ ,jlllerican Journa/ o/Po/iliml SCience:: INO.

February): 165 179.

17 Tullock, Gordon (1971). Thc Paradox of Revolution Ii Public Choice I} (Fall): 89-99

MaJIOBep05lTHO, LITO 3KOHOMH4eCKHH 4CJlOBeK npHMCT Y4aCTHC B Ha-

OJltlOM BOCCTaHHH. KOJlh CKOPO ero npe]leJlbllblH BKJla}l B ycnex peBO­

~!OUHH TCXHH4eCKH "YJleBOH, ero JlH4HblH 3KOHOMH"leCKHH Bbll1rphlUl

]1«6 0 HH4TOfKCH. JII160 Bo06ruc OTpHuaTeJleH, 3aTO ero UlaHCbl 6blTb y6HTbI M HJlH palleHblM ]lOCTaT041i0 BCHHKH. ECJlH OCTaBHTb B CTOPOl!C cH1)'auHH, KOr]la 06ruCCTBO mlJ1araCT CypoBble H3nep)KKH Ha Tex, KTO 0'1­ Ka3bIBaeTC5I npHcoe]lI1II11TbC5! K BOCCTaBlIlHM, ytJacTHe B peBOJllOlIHH [(PH T3KHX 06CT05lTCJlbCTBaX MOfKHO 06b5lCHI1Tb TOJlbKO B TcpMHllax IlpH­ BCp){(eHHOCTH HeKHM HpaBCTBeHHblM l\eHIIOCTS!M, T. e. H]leOJlOrHeH.

B 3KOIIOMHLIeCKHX TeOpH5IX BKyCbl TpanHUHOHHO nOJlaratOTC5I )K'30­

He MeHec H]leOJlOfH4eCKH MOTHBHpOBaHHoe nOBcnc­

tltlC qJOprvHlJlbllO COBMeCTHMO C MO]leJlbtO paUHOHaJJbHoro Bbl60pa H C 3KOHOMWICCKHM nOnXO]lOM. C4HTaCTC5I, 4TO HH]lHBHJlbl HMelOT BKyC K l1]leOJlOfHH, npH4eM IIpe]llH)JIaraeTC5I, 4TO TaKaS! 'lepTa xapaKTcpa, KaK qeCTHOCTb, B npC]lCJlC MO)KCT CJlY){(HTb ""hf"TUTVT'''U

eCJlH HC npHnHCblBaTb <PYHKUHH npenllOLITCIIHH .

HanpHMcp, ')KCnCpHMeHTbl C bYMa){(HHKaMH, OCTaBJl5IeMhlMH B

ll.\CCTBeHHbIX MCCTax, C TCM 4T06bl HX HalIlJlH npoxo){me, nOKa3aJJH, 4TO "'4en'Hoc nOBC]lCHHC" BCTpe4aeTC5I 4allle TOr]la, KOr)(a Ha KapTy no­

CTaBJlellbl MaJlCllbKHC CYMMbl, oTKyna tJTO KpHBa51 cnpoca Ha

HpaBCTBellllYlo 4HCTOTY HMeeT HHcXonllruHH HaKJlOH. Ho 3THM CIO){(eT

He HCLlepIlb!BaeTC5I, H60 IlpH aHaJJH3e HHcTHTyuHOHaJlbHblX H3MCHCHHH B03HHKaeT CcpbC3Ha51 np06JleMa, Korna H]lCOJlOrH4CCKHe y6e){(}l.eHH5!

<PaKTOPOB npH HIlCTHTYUHOllaJJbHblX H3MeHCHH5IX, TaK LlTO 6e'3 TeopHH l1L\eOJlOnm Hl13T 6yncT HenOJlHoH. B nOJlrOCpO'IHOH nepClleKTHBe UJHPOKO pacnpOCTpaHeHHOC YBa){(CHHC K 3aKOHY, IIpaB3M COrpa)K]laH.

rOCY]lapcTBy H BJlaCTH npaBHTeJlH HrpaCT CyruCCTBCHHYtO pOJlb B coxpa­ HeHHH Jllo60ro 0611~eCTBa. "<l>OH]l" COUHa.J1bHbIX UCHHOCTCH 51BJl5lCTC5I

$OpMOH K<:H1HTaJla, KOTOPblH npaBHTeJ1H MorYT YBCJlH4HTb, oCYI1(eCTB­

92 '-[{len//} I. Hiier)elllle~~.t~I=,-,!::.:::

JUI51 HHBCCTHLl.HH B nponaraH,ny, lIanpHMCp, 4epe3 CHCTeMY oOpa30BU. HH51. npH OTCYTCTBHH H,nCOJlOrH4CCKOH no,n,nCpIKKH H3,nCP)KKH npaB}I_ 3JIHTbl, COnp51IKCHHble C Ha,n30pOM 3a rpa)K,L{aHaMH. H H:~,nCpjKKI1 rpa)K,naH, conp5DKeHHbie C Ha,L{30pOM ,npyr 3a /l,pyrOM. YCTpeMHJIHCb Obi

K 6eCKOHe4HOCTH. 06111CCTBO, r,ne Ka)l(l{blH Be,neT ce651 HCKJl104HTCJlbHO 3rOHCTH4eCKH H paBHo,nYIIJCH K ,nPyrHM, He)KH3ItCCnoc06Ho.

B cHTyaLl.I1H, Kor,na COl(HaJlbHbIC H3MCHCHH51 CB513aHbl C H3MCHC­ HH51MH B HIl,eOJlOrH4eCKOM nOBe,nCHHH, HaC HHTepCCYCT, IlPOHCXOll,lIT ;111

IlOBC,nCH4CCKHe H3MCHeHH51 HCK.nI04HTeJlbHO 110 npH4HHC 113MeHCHHH B aJlbTepUaTHBHblX l13,nep)lCKaX YBa)KeHl1l1 3aKOHa H noplI,nKa (nepeMClllC. HHe B,nOJlb KPliBOH cnpoca) HJlH IKe OHI1 OTpa)l(alOT IWBYIO CHCTCl\l~

11,eHHOCTeH (lICpeMemeHHe caMoH KPHBOH cnpoca). HeT COMHCHH51. 4TO HHCTHTYll,HOHaJlbHble 113MeIieHH51 Bo06me H H,neOJlOrH4eCKOC nOBell,e­ HHe B lIaCTHOCTH npe,nCTaBJlHIOT C060H O,nI1H H3 BaIKHcHlIIHX H Ha1160­ Jlee Tpy,nHbiX nepe,nOBblx py6CIKcHI1CCJle,nOBaHHH B HM3T.

3.6. MO>KeM mt Mbl 06bSlCHHTb npaBHna?

HCKOTOPblC Y4eHblc BblCKa3aJJI1 COMHCHHlI no nOBOll,y COCT05lTeJlb­ HOCTH 3KOIIOMH4CCKoro 1I0ll,xo,na npH aHaJlH3C cI>YHll,aMcHTaJJbHbl:-­ IIpaBHJI, ynpaBJI.SllOlllHX 06MCHOM B o6111eCTBe. Mbl 3aBepwaCM 3'1.) rnaBY OIGrrblM paCCMOTpeHHeM HeKOTopblX 113 3THX B03paIKCIiHH.

npe)J(ll,e Bcero, 4aCTO YTBep)l(l{aeTCH, 4'1'0 3KOHOMI14CCKHH aHaJIYIl lVlaJJO 4TO MO)l(CT npe,nnOIKI1Tb B CMblCJle llo)]Jl,aK)llll1xc51 npoBcpKe rHIIO­ TC'l, 3a HCK.nK)4eHHeM cH'lyaLl,HI1, Kor,na 1l0Be,neHHe Cll,epIKI1BaeTClI KOII­

KYPCHI~Hel1 H OPI1CHTHpOBaHo HCK.H104HTCnbHO Ha a,nanTall,HIO K 3K30reu­ Hbltl.l napaMeTpaM. COLl.HaJJbHbIC npaBHJHl onpc,nCJllllOTC51 Ha nOJII1HI4e· CKOH apcHc. a n0J1HTH4eCKoe nOBe,neHHe 06bl4HO BKJ1104aeT cTpaTerH­ 4eCKHe B3aHMOlleHcTBHlI H B3aHM03aBHcHMOCTH, a He KoppeKTHpOBKI! cI>HKCHpOBaHHbIX napaMeTpOB. YnpomellHble ,nonymeHHlI 3KOIIOMH4e­ CKoro no,nxo,na nOpOIKll,alOT none3Hbie rHnOTe3bl, eCJ1H npHMeH51Th :rrOT no,nxo,n K 60JlbUlHM rpynnaM J11O,neH, TaK KaK 3aKOH 60J1bLIIHX 4HCCJ1 HekrpaJJH3yeT 6ecnopll,n04Hoe HH,nHBHAYaJlbHOC nOBeAeHHC; tit)

:lKOHOMH4eCKI1H aHaJJH3 nOJ1HTHKH 4aCTO I1MCeT ,neno C MaJlblMH rpyn­ naMH, 11 3KOHOMI1CTbl ,no6l1nl1Cb nHWb orpaHH4CHHoro ycncxa B

60TKe JMIII1pl14eCKH 3Ha4HMblX MOAeJ1eH nOBeACHHlI onHronO,1HCTOB. HeCM()Tp51 Ha TeOpeTHLJCCKI1H nporpecc B 06JlaCTH TeOpl1H Hrp.

B ::lTHX aprYMCHTax eCTb, KOHe4HO, ,nOJlll HCTI1Hbl, H Mbl He XOTHl\1 npeYMeHblllaTb Tpy,nHOCTH TeopCTH4eCKoro xapaKTepa, CBH'3aHHble c HccneAOBaHHeM CTpaTerH4eCKOro nOBe,neHHlI. 11 Bce IKe B npOWJ10M

JoIMeJ1a MCCTO Te!l.rl,eH[~l1l1 He,nOOl~eHHBaTb orpaHH4CHH5I. HaJlaraeMLle tJa nOBe,neHHe CHnaMH KOHKypCHLl.HH. B03bMCM KpaHHHH npHMep: Aa· :lICe YiOCHC/:)3 CranHHa. nO-BHAHMOMY, c,nepIKHBaJJH C006pa)l(CHWI. CB5I­

orpaHH4CHH5I. !laJlaraeMble KOHKypelHl,HeH, B caMblX HeO)l(H,naHHbIX MeCTax. HanpHMCp, B TeopHH cI>HPMbl Tenepb AOCTHrHYTO nOHHMaHHe Toro, 4TO PYKOBO}\HTeJleH KpynHblx KopnopaUHH C}J,ep)KHBaeT KOHKy­ peHLl.H5I Ha pblHKe ynpaBJ151I0111HX, Ha pblHKe CCy,nHOro KanHTaJJa H Ha pbHlKe nOI'JlOlll,CHH51 KOpnOpaLl.HH ,naIKe npH TOM, 4TO Ha,n IlHMH HCT np5lMOrO KOHTP0J151 CO CTOPOllbI paccpC,aOT04CHHbIX aKLl.HOHepOB. AHa­ nOrH4HbIM 06pa30M B none Hawero BHHMaHH5I OKa3anHCb H 06pa3Hble orpaHH4eHHlI, HaJJaraeMble Ha nOBe,neHHe B nOJIHTH4eCKOH ccpepc. Bblwe Y)J(e rOBOpHJ10Cb 0 TOM, KaKHM 06pa30M nOBeAeHHe cpe,nepaJlbHblX 4HIIOBHHKOB c,nepIKHBaeTCH CHCTeMOH KOMHTeTOB KOB­ rpecca H KOHTponHpyeTclI 06U(eCTSeHHOCTblO. )../,pYrHe Y4eHbie Hccne­ ,IlOBaJIH, HanpHMep, KOHTponb 3J.leKTOpaTa HaA BbInOnHeHHeM AOn)!c­ HOCTHblMI1 JlHLl.aMH B03J1o)lCeHHblX Ha HI1X 06H3aHHOCTeH H T. n.

)../,pyroe HanpaBneHHe KpHTHKH, HMCIOIll.ee OTHoweHHe K MaTCpHaJ1Y npe,nbl,ny1ucro lIaparpa cI>a, 3aK.HI04aCTC5I B TOM. 4TO 3KOHOMI14eCKHH no,nxo,n HKOObl HC B COCT05lHI1H y4HTbIBaTb HeJKOHOMH4eCKYlO MOTH­ BaUI1IO, a npB aHam13e nOJIHTH4eCKHX I1HCTI1TYTOB 3TO oc06eHHO cepb­ e3Hoe ynyll(eHl1e. KpHTHKa TaKoro po,na OT4aCTH OCHOBaH3 Ha He,nopa­ 3YMeHHH. Y)!(e rOBopHnOCh 0 TOM, 4TO Bbl60p aprYMeHTOB HH,nHBH­ ,IlyanbHblx cI>YHKLI,HH npe,nnOLJTeHHH 51BJljleTC5I npe)l(,nc Bcero lfeCKOH 3a,na4eH oT60pa ycnoBHH, KOTopble n03BOJIlIT c,neJ1aTb HaH­ 60J1ce rJly60KHc TcopeTH4eCKHe OTKpbITI151 H 06na,nalOT HaH60nbweH npomOCTHlleCKOH CHJ10H. Ilp06neMa B03HHKaeT, Korjla npOHcxo,nHT H3MeHeHHe CHCTeMbl 06111eCTBeHHbIX qeHHOCTeH, H60 HM:~T He pac­ nOJ1araeT pa6oTocnoc06HoH TeopHcH I1,nCOJIOrHH. 3TOT H3'MIH npH­

3HalOT MHorHe Y4eHble, pa3pai)aTblBalOlllHe HM3T, B TOM 4Hcne H HOPT

(North, 1981).

Eu\e OlUla pa3HoBH,nHOCTb KpHTHKH HM3T COCTOHT B TOM, 4TO MaK­ CHMH3aLl.HlI 60rarcTBa I1J1H nonC3HOCTH eCTb He 06111HH 3aKOH nOBe,ne­

IiH.I1, a, cKopee, 3aKOH nOBeLJ,eHl1l1, nOll,4HHeHHoro npaBHnaM, ,neHCTBYIO­

10

Ul,HM J1HLllb B OC06LIX CJlY4351X - Ha KOHKypeHTHblx pblHK3X - . MI,l He

IJllllhlM fI;mCTIl II ern KOHTPOllJl fHlJl CllOlIMH arellTaMH H1l nponllKCHIIH OOJICC 'lCTBepTH IlCKa.

20Field. Alexander J (l979)~ On the Explanation of Rules Using Rational Choice Models u/Ecol1omic Issues J3 (No~ I):