Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Ellinger Y., Defranceschi M. (eds.) Strategies and applications in quantum chemistry (Kluwer, 200

.pdf
Скачиваний:
32
Добавлен:
15.08.2013
Размер:
6.42 Mб
Скачать

386

F. MOMICCHIOLI ET AL.

the dynamic aspects of BMPC photoisomerization in solution more thoroughly through a proper sequence of calculations and experiments.

As a first step of this work, we wanted to verify if the predictions of the previous theoretical study on the prototype system (PC) [24] were valid for BMPC, as well. For this aim we theoretically analysed the pathways leading from trans to (2-3 and 3-4) mono-cis isomers and explored, in addition, the possibility of concerted isomerizations at two C-C bonds (taking the 2-3, 4-5 double isomerization as an example).

Let us first recall some basic characteristics of the cyanine isomerization mechanism, as emerging from simple MO correlation diagrams like those of Fig. l. In

reference to Fig. la, it is evident that isomerization at one C-C bond involves formation

of a twisted

intermediate characterized by

two decoupled subsystems

having even

and odd numbers of centres. Due to the

localization, at

' the

cationic charge is borne by the even (polyenic) fragment in the ground state and shifts to the odd (polymethinic) fragment upon HOMO-LUMO excitation. A substantially similar situation arises with two-bond isomerizations (Fig. 1b) even if the scheme is

made more complex because of the presence of three mutually orthogonal

subsystems

at

In summary, Fig. 1 emphasizes the fact that the

foreseeable

photoisomerization intermediates have TICT-like nature (related to full localization of

PHOTOCHEMICAL PATHS BY A COMBINED THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

387

the positive charge, instead of charge separation as in the classic TICT donor-acceptor systems, e.g. DMABN [6]). As previously argued [24], the CT nature of the perp forms

points to some other basic properties: 1) quasi-degeneracy of the

and

(essentially

HOMO-LUMO) states, 2) low efficiency of the

intersystem crossing, 3) possible

occurrence of

intramolecular minima at the perp

conformations.

 

 

Since the

negligible contribution of intersystem crossing to

the

radiationless

decay of cyanine-like systems has been firmly established [26,58,59], henceforth we will consider only the properties of the and potential surfaces involved in the

388

F. MOMICCHIOLI ET AL.

photoisomerization and the

thermal back isomerization,

respectively. The results of the CS INDO CI calculations for the 2-3 and 3-4 one-bond and 2-3, 4-5 two-bond isomerizations are represented in Fig. 2. The concerted two-bond

isomerization is predicted to be hindered by high barriers at

in both the

ground

and the excited state

This result does not

explain the very short fluorescence lifetime

in

octanol at

room temperature [57];

for in 1:1 ethanol-methanol mixture see later) nor the aptitude

of BMPC and other streptocyanines for photoisomerization

[25]. We consider this as

sufficient proof to rule out definitely simultaneous isomerizations at two C-C bonds. On the other hand, the potential curves for both 2-3 and 3-4 single isomerizations are in keeping with the observed photophysical and photochemical behaviours. The main

aspect is the presence of pronunced perp minima in

which can be easily reached from

the directly excited

form by overcoming of more or less little barriers (4.5 and

for the isomerizations around 2-3 and 3-4 links, respectively) and through which decay to the ground state trans and cis isomers may rapidly occur (the barriers for thermal back isomerization of 2-3 cis and 3-4 cis isomers being 25.4 and 24.2 kcal respectively). From the comparison between the calculated barriers the formation of the 3-4 cis isomer appears to be decidedly favoured in agreement with both the CS

INDO CI calculations on PC [24] and the analysis of the spectrum of the phototropic form of BMPC in methanol solution [25].

In conclusion almost all the experimental observations concerning photophysics and photochemistry of BMPC in alcoholic solutions appear to be fairly accounted for by

PHOTOCHEMICAL PATHS BY A COMBINED THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

389

calculations performed in the “free space” approximation. Of course, this requires supplementary investigations since, in principle, one should expect both the photoinduced and the thermal isomerization dynamics to be influenced by solvent polarity, owing to the charge localization phenomenon in the and perp forms (Fig. 3), as well as by solvent viscosity, as has been observed with many other polymethine cyanines [16].

As for the theoretical treatment, we could only try to include the electrostatic solutesolvent interactions and, in fact, we corrected the electronic potential energies for the

solvation effects by simply adding

as calculated according to the solvaton model

[eq. (2)]. The resulting potential curves are to be seen as effective potentials at equilibrium, i.e. reflecting orientational equilibrium distributions of the solvent dipoles around the charged atoms of the solute molecule. In principle, the use of potentials thus corrected involves the assumption that solvent equilibration is more rapid than internal rotation of the solute molecule. Fig. 4 points out the effects produced on the potential

390

F. MOMICCHIOLI ET AL.

energy curves by two solvents of very different dielectric constants

when

using the net charges derived from monoconfigurational descriptions of

(SCF

determinant) and

([HOMO, LUMO] configuration) states. Owing to the fact that the

cation charge begins to localize at highly twisted conformations, solvation manifests

itself as a potential energy lowering (much more marked in

than in

around the

perp forms

As a consequence, the small barriers impeding

 

conversion in

located at low values of

appear to be

very little

affected by the solvent polarity, while the barriers to trans-cis isomerization in S0, located at undergo a significant, yet not very large, decrease when the solvent polarity increases. Anyway, some 50% of the limit polarity effect is obtained on passing

from the gas phase

to a solvent of low dielectric constant

In order to check

the internal consistency of the predicted solvation effects we recalculated

using the

atomic charges obtained by rather extended CI wavefunctions (Fig. 5). Not surprisingly, appreciable changes were found only for the excited state and were confined to a smaller

PHOTOCHEMICAL PATHS BY A COMBINED THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

391

stabilization of the perp form. In summary, Fig.s 4,5 indicate, in agreement with the results of Fig. 2, that BMPC photoisomerization proceeds preferably through rotation around the 3-4 bond and involves overcoming of a small barrier (between 1 and 2 kcal

almost independent of the solvent polarity. significant polarity effects are expected for the

On the other hand, not very large yet barrier hindering

isomerization in

which is of

in the gas phase and goes down to

in a highly polar solvent

 

 

The validity of the above conclusions rests on the reliability of theoretical

predictions on excited state barriers as low as 1-2

Of course, this required as

accurate an experimental check as possible with reference to both the solvent viscosity effects, completely disregarded by theory, and the dielectric solvent effects. As for the photoisomerization dynamics, the needed information was derived from measurements of fluorescence lifetimes and quantum yields on solution of

Leaving out solvents of very low dielectric constant, where extensive formation of ion pairs may occur [60], the observed photophysical properties are confidently referable to the unperturbed BMPC cation. Figure 6 shows the temperature dependence of the

392

F. MOMICCHIOLI ET AL.

fluorescence lifetime of BMPC in 1:1 EtOH-MeOH mixture;

is about 1.6 ns at

temperatures lower than 100 K and drops suddenly upon heating the sample:

psat

Further heating causes a much slower lifetime shortening. Such a behaviour is parallel to that of the solvent viscosity, which undergoes a steep change between 100 and 130 K due to matrix melting [61]. This indicates that solvent friction considerably affects the photoisomerization dynamics of BMPC and poses the very question whether the photoisomerization of BMPC is a barrierless process, so that its kinetics would be affected by temperature only through the variation of the solvent viscosity. The results reported in Fig. 7 clearly show that the answer to this question is "no". The fluorescence quantum yields of BMPC in several linear alcohols at 298 K increase with solvent viscosity much more slowly than when measurements are carried out in ethanol at different temperatures. It is apparent that, in ethanol, a temperature lowering causes an increase of the quantum yield not only indirectly, by increasing the solvent viscosity to values comparable with those of the longer-chain alcohols, but also in a direct way: the photoisomerization of BMPC in alcohols features a significant intramolecular barrier.

Such a qualitative conclusion is supported by the observation that the room- temperature fluorescence spectrum of BMPC in alcohols (Fig. 8) is a good mirror image

PHOTOCHEMICAL PATHS BY A COMBINED THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

 

393

of the corresponding absorption band: its width at half maximum

is only

slightly larger than that of the absorption band

the Stokes shift

is small

and there is no evidence of the long tail extending to the red which is often

observed in the case of barrierless torsion in

(e.g., crystal violet [64]). This indicates

that fluorescence is emitted from a narrow

collection of

conformations

centred

around a minimum not much shifted with respect to the

one, in keeping

with

the

existence of an intramolecular barrier to

 

Evidently, this is

in

qualitative agreement with the theoretical predictions (Fig.s 4,5).

 

 

In order to go further into the experimental check we constructed Arrhenius plots of the fluorescence quantum yield of BMPC in a few solvents (methanol, ethanol, propanol, hexanol and methylene chloride), all of which showed good linearity. The activation energies and ratios, calculated from the slopes and intercepts of those plots, are collected in Table 1. The smooth increase of both parameters in the alcohol series is mainly associated with the increase of solvent viscosity. On the other hand, decrease of the solvent dielectric constant from 32.7 (methanol) to 8.9 (dichloromethane) causes a small but significant increase of the activation energy; also, this increase is probably somewhat compensated by the decrease of the viscous-flow

#2 The oscillator strength of the longest wavelength absorption band of BMPC (1.1, [25]) is very similar to those of two previously studied carbocyanines (DOC and DTC) [45] so that we can expect that, for

BMPC as well as for DOC and DTC, the radiative constant

is equal to

Combining this

value with the fluorescence quantum yield of BMPC in methanol,

we can estimate its

room-temperature fluorescence lifetime to be

 

 

394 F. MOMICCHIOLI ET AL.

activation energy of the latter solvent with respect to the former one#3. However, in view of its slight size this change is not contrary to the theoretically predicted "insensitiveness" of the conversion barrier to solvent polarity.

With the aim of getting a quantitative evaluation of the "intramolecular" activation energy for the photoisomerization of BMPC in alcohols, a parameter which can be directly compared with calculated barriers, isoviscosity plots were drawn at 2, 6 and 10 cP using data obtained in methanol, ethanol, propanol and hexanol (Fig. 9). In all cases, the hexanol points lie slightly above the lines drawn through the points of the three shorter alcohols. This is probably a manifestation of the saturation of viscosity effects emphasized by Fig. 7: as the size of the alcohol molecule increases, the microscopic friction felt by the isomerizing solute is less and less adequately described by the solvent shear viscosity. Therefore, in spite of the fact that, due to the very low barrier and associated frequency, an almost diffusive reaction dynamics is expected [16], shear viscosity only provides a rough description of the frictional interaction between the twisting solute and the solvent molecule. This is confirmed by the finding that the slopes of the isoviscosity plots, determined omitting the hexanol points, decrease with viscosity. The "intramolecular" activation energies obtained at 2, 6 and 10 cP were equal

to 1.24, 1.08 and 0.98 kcal

respectively. In conclusion, because of the

approximations in our analysis, related to the problematic use of shear viscosity as a measure of solvent friction, we can only provide an estimate of the "intramolecular"

#3 Comparison of these results with those found for DOC and DTC , whose activation energies in dichloromethane were equal or even smaller than in methanol [55], indicates that the effect of solvent polarity on the photoisomerization barrier, although still small, is more pronounced for the open-chain cyanine BMPC than for the carbocyanines.

PHOTOCHEMICAL PATHS BY A COMBINED THEORETICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

395

activation energy for the photoisomerization of BMPC in short-chain linear alcohols: This finding strongly supports the theoretical prediction that photoisomerization of BMPC proceeds efficiently by twisting about the 3-4 bond in the

surface. In fact, the calculated barriers to conversion in highly polar solvents ranged between 1.10 kcal and 1.75 kcal (Fig. 5) according to whether the atomic charges derived from single configuration or extended-

CI wavefunctions were used to evaluate (the calculated barrier in the isolated molecule being

Finally, the dependence of the back isomerization kinetics of BMPC in the ground state on solvent polarity was investigated by measuring spectrophotometrically the rate constant of this process in methanol, dichloromethane, chlorobenzene and toluene. These solvents have similar room-temperature viscosities (from 0.45 to 0.8 cP) and viscous-flow activation energies (from 1.60 to

[66]). Because of this, and of the probably small relative factional contribution to the overall activation energy connected with the high curvature of the potential function at the barrier top [16], solvent polarity effects can be evaluated by direct inspection of the measured activation energies. These were calculated as usual from Arrhenius plots and are shown in Table 2. As the solvent dielectric constant decreases, the measured activation energy increases on going from methanol to dichloromethane, decreases slightly in chlorobenzene and, finally, drops to a substantially lower value in toluene. The preexponential factor, too, shows a strong decrease in toluene with respect to the

other solvents, reaching an atypical value of

A similar behaviour of the

Соседние файлы в предмете Химия