
Ellinger Y., Defranceschi M. (eds.) Strategies and applications in quantum chemistry (Kluwer, 200
.pdf316 |
M. NAIT ACHOUR ET AL. |
In Table 5, we show the calculated magnetic susceptibilities for A1H and , and the Lipscomb et al. [7] obtained values for A1H using an extended basis set of field independent Slater type orbitals.
Our results are in close agreement with the values obtained by Lipscomb et al. [7]; this confirm the validity of our approach. Note that, A1H is predicted to be weakly diamagnetic
but |
should be paramagnetic. |
|
The results for the |
molecule are given in Table 6. |
AN AB-INITIO STUDY OF |
, BH, |
AND |
AIH, |
317 |
Our results indicate that the basis set I cannot describe correctly |
and that the magnetic |
susceptibility of this anion is strongly depending on the inclusion of diffuse orbitals in the basis set. We notice that the basis set II permits to obtain reliable results, its further extension by extra diffuse functions (basis set III) leading approximately to the same
results. should be diamagnetic, and its mean susceptibility is of the order of -22.
It should be noted that diffuse functions which are necessary for a good description of the magnetic properties of anions, have been found needless when computing the susceptibilities of the neutral molecules.
In Table 7, we reported the mean magnetic susceptibilities of the BH and molecules, obtained by G. Berthier et al. [3], using the same SCF ab initio method, employing a triple-zeta basis set augmented by a s-type bond function. We produce also in
this table, our values for |
and those of the AlH, |
and |
series for |
comparison. We note, that the magnetic susceptibilities exhibit the same features in the two analogous series of molecules, namely that diamagnetism decreases when the heavy atom nuclear charge increases.
3. Conclusion
The good agreement between our results and those obtained by Lipscomb and al. [7],
permits to think that the calculated susceptibility values for |
and |
are accurate. |
|
We observe also, that |
is predicted to be paramagnetic as its |
counterpart [13], |
|
whereas the AlH and |
molecules are diamagnetic. We could confirm the weakly |
||
diamagnetic character of the |
molecule whose susceptibility is strongly dependent on |
the introduction of several diffuse orbitals in the basis set. In both series of compounds, diamagnetism decreases with the increase of the heavy atom nuclear charge.
References
1.R.M. Stevens, R.M. Pitzer and W.N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys. 42, 3666 (1965)
2.R.A. Hegstrom and W.N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys. 45, 2378 (1966).
3.G. Boucekkine-Yaker, A. Boucekkine, A. Zaucer and G. Berthier, Int. J. Quant.
Chem.. 23, 365 (1983).
4.G. Boucekkine-Yaker, A. Boucekkine, and G. Berthier, Int. J. Quant. Chem.. 18,
369 (1984).
318 |
M. NAIT ACHOUR ET AL. |
5.P.W. Fowler and E. Steiner, Mol. Phys. 74, 1147 (1991).
6.M. Iwai and A. Saika, Int. J. Quant. Chem.. 24, 623 (1983).
7.E. A. Laws, R.M. Stevens and W.N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys. 54, 4269 (1971)
8.M. Iwai and A. Saika, J. Chem. Phys. 77, 1951 (1982).
9.F. London, J. Phys. Radium 8, 397 (1937).
10.G. Berthier, M. Maillot and B. Pullman, J. Phys. Radium 12, 717 (1951).
11.G. Berthier, M. Maillot, A. Pullman and B. Pullman, J. Phys. Radium 13, 15 (1952).
12.M. Maillot, G. Berthier and B. Pullman, J. Phys. Radium 12, 652 (1951).
13.M. Maillot, G. Berthier and B. Pullman, J. Phys. Radium 50, 176 (1953).
14.K. Wolinski, J.F. Hinton and P. Pulay, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112, 8251 (1990).
15.M. Zaucer and A. Azman, Croat. Chem. Acta 47, 17 (1975).
16.R. Ditchfield, Mol. Phys. 27, 789 (1974).
17.M. Zaucer, D. Pumpernik, M. Hladnik and A. Azman, Z. Nathurforsch A 32, 411 (1977)
18.G. Boucekkine-Yaker, L. Brunet and G. Berthier, J. Chim. Phys. 84, 671 (1987).
19.A. Boucekkine, G. Boucekkine-Yaker, M. Nait Achour and G. Berthier, J. Mol. Struct. (Theochem) 166, 109 (1988).
20.S. Huzinaga, J. Chem. Phys. 42, 1293 (1965).
21.R.Ahlrichs and P.R.Taylor, J. Chim. Phys. 78, 315 (1981).
22.R.C. Raffenetti, J. Chem. Phys. 58, 4452 (1973).
23.A.Veillard, Theoret..Chim. Acta 12,405 (1968).
24.T.H. Dunning Jr., J. Chem. Phys. 53, 2830 (1970).
25.G.W. Spitznagel, T. Clark, P.von Ragué Schleyer and W.J. Hehre, J.Comput. Chem. 8, 1109 (1987).
CI Calculations of Miscellaneous Spectroscopic Observables for the PN and States
G. de BROUCKERE
University of Amsterdam, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Valckenierstraat 65,
1018 XE Amsterdam, The Nederlands
1. Introduction
1.1 PN |
STATE |
The PN molecule whose ground state electronic configuration is
first investigated by Curry et al [1], has attracted a considerable amount of interest among experimentalists due to the availability of high quality optical spectra. The presence of sharp spectral lines made it possible to determine many of the rotational-vibrational
spectroscopic constants, such as |
with high accuracy. Some of these |
constants were subsequently refined by Wyze et al [2] using high resolution microwave spectroscopy by means of which several pure rotational transitions were also measured.
In recent years PN has been among the growing number of first and second row molecular species observed from a variety of astronomical sources, including Orion(KL), W51M, SgrB2. Several pure rotational transitions have been unambiguously identified [3]. It is of primary importance to assist astrophysicists in identifying potential interstellar species that as many spectroscopic constants as possible be available in order to recognize the measured spectral lines. As a large number of small phosphorus-containing compounds have either not been detected experimentally or have gaps in the known spectroscopic constants, theory might be able to fill in the missing information.
1.2. LOW-LYING PN A AND STATES |
|
The best characterized excited state of PN remains to be, without contest, the |
state yet |
experimentally detected in 1933 [1]. During the next fifty years no new excited state findings were reported for PN. However during the last decade a revival of experimental
as well as theoretical interest has lead to a reexamination of both and states.
Aside from improving the accuracy of certain spectroscopic constants' values, a few
perturbing states interacting selectively with some |
low lying vibrational levels (i.e. |
|
have been characterized [4]. These states are |
and |
, all arising from |
319 |
|
|
Y. Ellinger and M. Defranceschi (eds.), Strategies and Applications in Quantum Chemistry, 319–332.
© 1996 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
320 |
|
|
|
G. DE BROUCKERE |
|
the |
orbital occupancy. For example, the perturbation on v'=l in the |
||||
bands, first noticed by Curry et al [1] , was due to nearby low rovibrational |
|||||
levels of a |
, while the |
state was shown to perturb the level v'=0.Whereas a few |
|||
spectroscopic constants had been determined for the perturbed |
vibrational states by |
||||
these perturbing states a similar analysis had never been performed for the |
state |
||||
although this state should perturb in the same proportions [4] certain low lying |
|
||||
vibrational levels.For the sake of completeness, let us mention a new |
|
||||
transition [5] has been reported arising from the |
excitation which should interact |
||||
with high lying |
vibrational levels as well as a set of four new excited states, i.e. two |
||||
and two |
, but an absolute vibrational assignment for these states was not possible |
[6]. The technology of astrophysical measurements on excited states for molecules such as
PN is still in its infancy and, to the best of our knowledge, no results have been reported.
2. Procedure
2.1. POTENTIAL CURVES OF THE |
and STATES |
Details of the extended triple zeta basis set used can be found in previous papers [7,8]. It contains 86 cartesian Gaussian functions with several d- and f-type polarisation functions and s,p diffuse functions. All cartesian components of the d- and f-type polarization functions were used. CI wave functions were obtained with the MELDF suite of programs
[9]. Second order perturbation theory was employed to select the most energetically double excitations, since these are typically too numerous to otherwise handle. All single excitations, which are known to be important for describing certain one-electron properties, were automatically included. Excitations were permitted among all electrons and the full range of virtuals.
All three states were described by a single set of SCF molecular orbitals based on the
occupied canonical orbitals of the |
state and a transformation of the canonical virtual |
space known as "K-orbitals" [10] which , among other properties, approximate the set of natural orbitals. Transition moments within orthogonal basis functions are easier to derive. For the X state the composition of the reference space was obtained by performing two
Hartree-Fock single and double excitations (HFSD-CI) calculations at two typical internuclear distances, i.e. (equilibrium geometry) and about and adding to the HF
configuration all those configurations whose coefficients in either of these CIs were
. The resulting list of 44 configurations constituted the occupancy of the reference space for Multi-Reference Single and Double CI (MRSD-CI) calculations in the region The energy threshold value, hereafter referred to as ETHRESH, used in the
perturbation theory selection procedure of the configurations was set equal to
For the |
state, considerably more configurations contribute the above threshold |
|
coefficient |
and in order to increase the |
value of the sum of the squares of the CI |
coefficients |
in the reference space |
with respect to that obtained in either of the |
HFSD-CIs, two MRSD-CI calculations at the above internuclear distances were next performed, keeping in either case all configurations with expansion coefficients
SPECTROSCOPIC OBSERVABLES FOR THE PN |
AND STATES |
321 |
An avoided crossing did occur at |
which, however, was absent at |
[8].Thus the |
combined space spanned by all configurations whose coefficients equalled or exceeded
|0.03| in |
either of the MRSD-CIs (at |
and |
was chosen for the reference space to |
|
describe |
the |
potential function in the |
region. This space spanned 51 |
|
configurations. ETHRESH was set equal to |
This value as the above one |
should ensure that the overwhelming majority of the correlation energy was recovered via the variational CI calculation.
For the state, this procedure led to still much larger reference spaces and larger CI wave functions because of the still larger number of configurations possessing expansion
coefficients |
In order to keep the calculations tractable, this threshold was set |
||
equal to 0.043 while lowering the value of ETHRESH to |
This reference space |
||
was spanned by 28 configurations. In light of the primary goal for the |
state of being |
able to compute properties in the neighbourhood of the potential curve's minimum with acceptable accuracy, this wavefunction should still be adequate. This will be illustrated by comparing our lifetime results with those of CO obtained by a different CI approach as well as a set of spectroscopic constants with those obtained by similar CI calculations based on another algorithm.
Estimates of the energy contributions from higher than double excitations out of the reference space were obtained by means of one form of the "Davidson correction" [11,7]. More details can be found in references [7,8].
3. |
Results |
|
3.1. |
PN |
STATE |
3.1.1. Potential energy curve; one-electron properties; spectroscopic constants
The potential energy curve including the Davidson correction is shown in Figure 1. Among the calculated one-electron properties [7] only a few ones did show sizeable correlation effects (Table 1). The calculated and experimental values of the electric dipole moment are unexpectedly yet in good agreement although multiple bonded systems are known to require the use of a large number of higher angular momentum basis functions [ 12J. The rather large theoretical difference found for the nuclear coupling remains at the present time an open question: if the experimental value is accurate, this difference is due to a too small value of the electric field gradient. It should be pointed out this observable is neither easy to measure with precision nor to compute accurately, especially for multiple bonded systems involving third period atoms.
3.1.2. Spectroscopic constants
Selected spectroscopic constants (Table 2), derived by the well-known Dunham polynomial fit expansion method [13,14] were calculated from both the variational MRSDCI energies and the estimated full CI energies, i.e. including the Davidson correction. In general, the effects of the Davidson correction appear to be small. A very good agreement,
up to the second decimal, is obtained in case of |
leading to an exceedingly small |
|
theoretical deviation (0.007%) on |
The effect of the correction on the latter observable is |
322 |
G. DE BROUCKERE |
sizeable (24%) and decreases the agreement with experiment. The observables |
|
- in contrast with |
are closer to experiment at the full CI approximation, leading |
also to a subtantial lowering of the theoretical discrepancy for the anharmonicity whereas the relative error on the fundamental frequency amounts merely to 1.5%.
Unless otherwise noted, the phosphorus atom is placed at the origin of the reference frame, with nitrogen pointing in the positive z direction
Entries |
|
'Generated' |
Total number of spin and symmetry adapted configurations |
'Selected' |
Number of spin and symmetry adapted configurations selected by second- |
|
order perturbation theory and treatedvariationally |
'*' |
Property calculated with respect to the center of mass. |
|
For the dipole moment, the polarity has not been measured experimentally. |
|
The sense found is the same as that of McLean and Yoshimine [17] and the |
|
agreement between observation and the MR SD-CI result leaves little doubt |
|
on the correctness of this sense. |
'EXP' |
Experimental values, see Raymonda and Klemperer [18] |
'Est.full CI En' Estimated full-CI energy [11]
These results have been compared with those issued from smaller CI calculations based on another algorithm [15]. Except for the anharmonicity, our results are generally closer to experiment. Another instructive comparison has been made with CASSCF results on
singly bonded [19] using a comparable basis set: for and the theoretical deviations are quite comparable, the CASSCF result on the anharmonicity being however much closer to experiment. The size of the H-CI matrix handled in the latter methodology
(350,000 - 385,000) is not commensurable with that in the present study (93,000 -
SPECTROSCOPIC OBSERVABLES FOR THE PN |
AND STATES |
323 |
110,000). Therefore, it appears that the overall agreement obtained for a variety of spectroscopic constants is comparable for the two methods while the present method allows us to use a more compact wavefunction. It should also be noted that a good CI description of a triple bonded system involving a third period atom is much harder to achieve. It can be concluded that the shape of the theoretical potential energy curve reflects its experimental counterpart with acceptable accuracy in the interatomic region of interest.
In column A , use is made of the variational MRSD-CI energies. In column B, these energies are corrected for higher excitations (see text)
Entries
'Em i n ' 'E0 '
'E(ZP)'
'f '
Energy of the minimum of the potential curve
Energy corresponding to vibrational quantum number v=0
The Dunham polynomial fit expansion of the theoretical curves involves polynomials of 9th and 10th degree leading to the data in columns 'A' and
'B' respectively.
Using the variational CI energies and correcting these for higher order excitations, the radial Schrödinger equation solutions for E(ZP) are equal to
and respectively with and
3.1.3. Pure rotational and vibrorotational transitions; spontaneous radiative lifetimes
Pure rotational transitions, vibrorotational transitions and spontaneous radiative lifetimes have been derived by solving numerically [20] the one-dimensional radial part of the
Schrödinger equation for th e single X state preceded by constructing an interpolation
324 |
G. DE BROUCKERE |
curve - using |
tensioned spline functions [21] - of this state adopting the data including the |
Davidson correction. For the calculations of lifetimes within a single state ,in contrast to two distinct states , the vibrational/rovibrational decays occuring via a cascade mode, the electric dipole moment function replaces the usual electric dipolar transition moment function required in case of transitions between states. More details can be found in [7,8] as well as the references quoted therein.
A remarkable agreement with experiment had been found for pure rotational excitations (Table 3). The calculated values are systematically a little smaller because the theoretical internuclear distance is slightly larger than the experimental one, i.e.
(expt), (theor.) and this deviation affects the parameter values
leading to our previous observation. A slight deviation with respect to the expected effect of the anharmonicity on the vibrorotational transitions is observed in contrast to the same effect noted on the pure rotational excitations.
To the best of our knowledge, pure rotational transition calculations for the PN X state are reported for the first time.
The calculated lifetimes (Table 4) are several powers of ten larger then those corresponding
to usual electric dipolar transitions |
They constitute therefore true predictions |
which require special techniques of measurements that were available only in recent years.
Molecular lifetimes corresponding to pure vibrational (v =0-4) and rovibrational (v =0-4, j=l-5) levels - derived for the first time - were found to be eight to ten powers of ten larger
than those corresponding to an electric dipolar transition state above state). In the latter case large transition moments for non-orthogonal off-diagonal vibrational states are also responsible for the resulting magnitude of these lifetimes. In this case, the
SPECTROSCOPIC OBSERVABLES FOR THE PN |
AND STATES |
325 |
off-diagonal elements of the dipole moment for orthogonal vibrational states are several powers of ten smaller compared to their transition moment counterparts, leading to much smaller values of the transition probabilities and Einstein spontaneous emission coefficients and therefore very large lifetimes. A very important rotational effect on the lifetime for v'=0, becoming rather weak for v'=l and being not existent for higher v's considered in this study is noted.
3.2. |
PN |
and EXCITED STATES |
|
3.2.1. |
Potential energy curvesfor the |
and states. Selected one-electron |
|
|
properties. Spectroscopic constants |
|
MR SD-CI potential curves including the Davidson corrections are presented in Figure 1.