4//.2-.4.2++ 4 3*-D8/I-11/0 4:-,/0 43-6.* 24-: 4/4./;1+0 4/C151+; D/8I-1 7G.A /./7*5I-1 1- 2 D+:/./,++ - "1-- ", =D- "1-- " -4.A /7R-6.+21G0 ,+*, 5 2 D2/01/0 /33/C+F++:
&=>58?6 (" -,") - "456 7 89 5 ," -5=B C6 D 7 &=>58?6 (" -,").
7R-6.+25F+; 74/8H.5 3/1+,5-.4; CD-4A 656 /7R-6.+215; *-58A1/4.A, 153/81-115; 4@7R-6.+2- 1G, /.1/<-1+-, +1D+2+D5. 5 E./0 65.-=/*+-0 4./+. ./, 9./ . &1= 15CG258 ,+*/2/0 D@</0 (anima mundi), +8+ 3/3*/4.@ /D@<-28-11G0 ,+*, /.8+91G0 /. <@,/2/=/ B/15 + 15=*/,/ID-1+; D-- 6/*5F+0 .-,, 9./ 27+*5-. 2 4-7; 656 4*-D5 /7+.51+; 954.A 45,/=/ /7+.5.-8;. 51+,+4.+9-46/0 6@8A.@*- ("51+,+C," - /D@<-28-1+-) D5115; 954.A 34+:+6+ 4/4.528;85 1-/.R-,8-,G0 +1D+2+D@- 58A1G0 + 6/88-6.+21G0 /3G.. -2*/3-046/, +1D@4.*+58A1/, /7?-4.2-, .*-7@H?-, /.9-.8+2G: =*51+F +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+, E./. /3G. 2G.-41-1 + /6*@I-1+- 95?- 2/43*+1+,5-.4; 656 "1-- ".
4.528;; 2 4./*/1- 2-*/+43/2-D58A1G- + /1./8/=+9-46+- 4,G48G 74/8H.5, /.,-.+, -=/ 34+:/- 8/=+9-46/-, ..-. 3*/;28-11/- C159-1+-. D-; 74/8H.5, *-58+C@-,5; 2 I+C1+, "E./ +,,51-1.15; F-8A 4.51/28-1+; 8+91/4.+, + 2 ./ I- 2*-,; E./ 4+85, 6/./*5; 28-9-. 9-8/2-65 6 D/4.+I-1+H -=/ +1.-=*+*/2511/0 +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+" ( D8-*, 1996). /8-- /7?-- E6C+4.-1F+58A1/- 51.*/3/8/=+9-46/- C159-1+- 74/8H.5 2 I+C1+ /7@48/28-1/ .-,, 9./, 2G*5I5; 4/7/0 1-D/4.+I+- ,G0 +D-58 F-8/4.1/4.+, =5*,/1++ + 2G4/6/0 45,/*-58+C5F++, /1 24-=D5 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1 4@?-- 4.2/251+H +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ . 58+9+-, 2 1-;21/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ /7*5C5 74/8H.5 C5D5-.4; *5C*G2 ,-ID@ 3/.-1F+58A1G,+ + *-58+C/2511G,+ 35*5,-.*5,+ 8+91/4.+, 21/4+.4; 153*;I-1+- + 4.+,@8+*@-.4; D+15,+65 *5C2+.+;.
/C2*5?5;4A 6 65.-=/*++ "D*@=/- ", ,G D/8I1G 243/,1+.A, 9./ /15 2G3/81;-. 3*/.-6./*1@H B@16F+H. -48+ "D*@=/- ", +C2-4.1/- 656 /7GD-11/- 45,/4/C151+-, /7-43-9+25-. 2:/ID-1+- 2 4/F+@, + 42;CA 4 74/8H./, 2 -=/ 3*/;28-11/0 B/*,-, ./ "D*@=/- " 8-2/0 954.+ 4:-,G 4//.1/4+. "3/.-1F+58A1/- " 4 74/8H./, 1-;21/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+.
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
C 24-: ,+*/2G: *-8+=+0 +,-11/ 2 :*+4.+5146/0 *-8+=+/C1/-,+4.+9-46/0 6/1F-3F++ ,/.+2 7/=/- 9-8/2-9-4.25 3/8@95-. F-1.*58A1@H */8A. /1-91G0 4,G48 +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ + 24-9-8/2-9-46/=/ 7G.+; 153/81+84; +D--0 4354-1+; 9-*-C 21@.*-11-- 3*+1;.+- "D@:/21/=/ 9-8/2-65"
(B.C. /8/2A-2 [25]), +4./*+/4/B46+, 3*/./.+3/, 6/./*/=/ 4.58 *+4./4, 2/38/.+2<+0 -D+14.2/74/8H.1/=/ + 9-8/2-9-46/=/. -8+=+/C1/- 3/1;.+- "4354-1+-" 3*+/7*-.5-. 23/81- /3*-D-8-11/- 34+:/8/=+9-46/- 4/D-*I51+-. /=8541/ . .!8/*-146/,@ [26] (1990), 4354-1+-, 2 34+:/8/=+9-46/, 4,G4848/25, -4.A *521/2-4+- D@<-21/0 I+C1+. " 7*5CG /=5 + *+4.5, - 3+458 .&1= (1997,
81
4.76), - 3*/-F+*@-,G- *-8+=+/C1/0 B51.5C+-0 9-8/2-65, 1- ,/=@. 1- 7G.A 51.*/3/,/*B1G,+... 3/- 4-,@ +: ,/I1/ 3*/;41+.A 34+:/8/=+9-46+, 3/D/71/ 8H7G, D*@=+, 4+,2/85,".
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
*+2-D-11G- D/7528-1+; 3/C2/8;H. 3*-D4.52+.A 15<@ 4:-,@ 2 48-D@H?-, 2+D-:
&=>58?6 - " =>58?6 5 ," - "456 7 89 5 ," - ": ;<5 ," -4 : 6 E >4 C6E &=>58?6
*/,-I@./91/- 3/8/I-1+- "574/8H.1/=/ '' 2 4.*@6.@*- 1-;21/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ /7R;41+,/ -=/ 3/4*-D1+9-46/0 B@16F+-0 + E6C+4.-1F+58A1G, C159-1+-,. 3*/4.*514.2/ 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/- 4.+, /7/C159-11/- "574/8H.1G, ", 3*/-F+*@H.4; +D-+, 3/C2/8;H?+- 4//.1-4.+ "3/.-1F+58A1/-" 4 74/8H./,.
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
/=1+.+21G0 543-6. 45,/4/C151+; +8+, +159-, 2-4A 2/C,/I1G0 43-6.* .*5143-*4/158A1G: 45,/- +D-1.+B+65F+0 ,/I-. 7G.A 3*-D4.528-1 2 4//.2-.4.2++ 4 3/D:/D/, 5158+.+9-46/0 34+:/8/=++.- 52./*@ - .&1=@, 656 +C2-4.1/, D8; /B/*,8-1+; 42/+: D/=5D/6 3/.*-7/25854A 1/25; /7R;41+-
.-8A15; =+3/.-C5 / 6/88-6.+21/, 7-44/C15.-8A1/, 4 22-D-1+-, 3/1;.+; "5*:-.+3".
*:-.+3G 656 2/38/?-11G- 2 6@8A.@*- +D-+ / 4/D-*I51++ 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+ 4/4.528;H. *5C8+91G25*+5F++ "574/8H.1/=/ ", *546*G25-,G- .2/*9-46/0 4+8/0 *5C@,5. 28;;4A .*514- F-1D-1.1G,+ 45,//./ID-4.28-1+;,+ "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ ", /1+ 3*-D4.52+,G 8+<A 2 6@8A.@*1/- +4./*+9-46/, 2G*5I-1++. *@=+,+ 48/25,+, 5*:-.+3 153/,+15-. "/6@8;*", 3*+43/4578+25H?+0 9-8/2-9-46/- C*-1+- D8; 2/43*+;.+; 1-;21/0 45,/,@ 9-8/2-6@ 4@7R-6.+21/4.+. 85=/D5*; *54- 3*/4.*51-11G, 2 6@8A.@*- 5*:-.+35, +C2-4.15; +1D+2+D@ + =*@3315D8+91/4.15; B+=@*5 74/- 8H.5 4.51/2+.4; D/4.@31/0 D8; 2C5+,/D-04.2+;. 5 B/1- 5*:-.+3+9-46+: 42;C-0 4 " 74/8H./," 158+91/- 7G.+- @I- 1- /3*-D-8;-.4; 1-2-D/,G,+ *5C*@<+.-8A1G,+ 4+85,+. 156/,4.2/ 4 4/- D-*I51+-, " 74/8H.1/=/ ", 42;C@H?-=/ 4 74/8H./,, /7-43-9+25-. 21@.*-11HH C5?+?-11/4.A 9-8/2-65.
/8AC@;4A 3*-D8/I-11G, 4*521-1+-, 1@I1/ 465C5.A, 9./ 6@8A.@*5 -4.A 48/I1G0 3*+7/*, 4/4./;- ?+0 7/8-- 9-, +C D2@: 8+1C. 1/=//7*5C+- 4,-11G: 8+1C 3*-D85=5-. 15, <+*/6+0 3*-D4.528-1- 9-46+0 B+8A.*, /7@48/28-11G0 1- ./8A6/ 6/8+9-4.2/, +C2-4.1G: +C 5158+.+9-46/0 34+:/8/=++ 5*:-.+3/2, 1/ + ,1/=/C1591/4.AH 65ID/=/ +C 1+:. 56+, /7*5C/,, ,/I-. 4@?-4.2/25.A C159+.-8A-
82
1/- 6/8+9-4.2/ 4*-D4.2 @,/3/4.+=5-,/=/ 478+I-1+; 4 74/8H./, + /3+451+0 2C5+,/D-04.2+0 4 1+,. *:-.+3+9-46+- /7*5CG -4.A 4*-D/./9+- 24;6+: *-8+=+/C1G: 3*-D4.528-1+0. : 157/*/,, +8+, 3/8AC@;4A ;CG6/, *-8+=+/2-D/2 + E.1/8/=/2, ,+B/8/=+9-46+, 351.-/1/,, /3*-D-8;-.4; D2@- 8+6/4.A 24-2G<1-=/ 65ID/0 /.D-8A1/0 *-8+=++. ,7+258-1.1/4.A, 3*+4@?5; 65ID/,@ 5*:-.+3@, 5
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
53*;I-11/4.A 4//.1/<-1+; "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " + 74/8H.5 + 41+,5H?+- -- 5*:-.+3+9-46+- +D-1.+B+65F++ 4 "574/8H.1G, " ,/=@. 48@I+.A 3*//7*5C/, 5BB-6.+21G: + 6/=1+.+21G: 4/4.52- 8;H?+: +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ 45,/4/C151+;. ./ D5-. 3/2/D 2G465C5.A =+3/.-C@ / 158+9++ 2 4@7R-6-
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
.+21/4.+ 15<5 4:-,5 ,/I-. 7G.A 3*-D4.528-15 2 48-D@H?-, 2+D-:
&=>58?6 - >D F8 5 > 5>5G - "456 7 89 5 ," -5=E: 5 > 5>5G - 5=B-C6 D 7 &=>58?6 .
/D/715; +1.-*3*-.5F+; 3*+28-65.-8A15 .-,, 9./ B@16F+; 42-*:8+91/=/ 45,/4/C151+;, C568H95H?5;4; 2 @4.51/28-1++ 42;C+ 4 74/8H./,, *521/F-115 3/4*-D1+9-46/0 B@16F++ +1D+2+D@58A- 1/=/ 45,/4/C151+;. 56 ,G 3/8@95-, -?- /D+1 5*=@,-1. 2 3/8AC@ ./=/, 9./ 4@?1/4.15; :5*56.-*+- 4.+65 15<-=/ /7GD-11/=/ 45,/4/C151+; E6C+4.-1F+58A15 + C568H95-.4; 1- 2 ./,, 9./ /1/, 656 3*+1;./ 2 ,5.-*+58+4.+9-46/0 34+:/8/=++, ;28;-.4; E3+B-1/,-1/, 4/C151+;, 5 2 ./,, 9./ /1/ -4.A 3/4*-D1+6 2/ 2C5+,/D-04.2++ "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " 4 3*-D,-.1G, + 4/F+58A1G, ,+*/,, 43/- 4/7/, -=/ /4@?-4.28-1+; 2 /7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+.
./. .-C+4, 3/ 4@?-4.2@, 1- 1/2. 1, 656 7G8/ 3*-D4.528-1/ *51--, 4/D-*I+.4; D5I- 6 ,5.-*+58+- 4.+9-46/0 34+:/8/=++, =D- "3/.-1F+58A1/- " /.4@.4.2@-., 5 24; D@:/215; 4@?1/4.A C568H9-15 2 4/F+58+C/2511/0 8+91/4.+. D-4A I- ,G :/.+, /7*5.+.A 21+,51+- 15 /9-2+D1@H @1+2-*458A1/4.A 3/4*-D1+9-46/0 */8+ 45,/4/C151+; 2/ 2C5+,/D-04.2++ 9-8/2-65 4 ,+*/, + 2G465C5.A4; /.1/4+-
.-8A1/ +4./6/2 E./0 */8+. - 3*+9+1G ,G 2+D+, 1- ./8A6/ 2 4/F+58+C+*@H?-0 B@16F++ /7GD-1- 1/=/ 45,/4/C151+;, 1/ + 2 .*5143-*4/158A1/0 3*+*/D- -=/ /41/251+0, 2 3*-DC5D511/4.+ /7GD-1- 1/=/ 45,/4/C151+; ,5.*+91G, 21-8+91/4.1G, 45,/4/C151+-,, 9A; *-58A1/4.A /7@48/28-15 @1+- 2-*458A1/0 E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 4+.@5F+-0 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+; 74/8H.@.
/14.5.+*@; 2 *5,65: 15<-0 4:-,G 42-*:8+91/4.1/- 45,/4/C151+-, ,G D-85-, 1-6/./*G- D/3@- ?-1+;, 656 + 3*+ 8H7/0 4:-,5.+C5F++, 1/ E.5 4:-,5 7/8-- 4/D-*I5.-8A15 3/ 4*521-1+H 4/ 4:-,/0- "1-- ", 3*+1;./0 D8; /3*-D-8-1+; 45,/4/C151+; 2 /7R-6.+21/0 34+:/8/=++ + 68+1+9-46/0 34+- :+5.*++. 2*+4.+9-465; F-11/4.A 3*-D8/I-11/0 4:-,G - 2 43/4/71/4.+ 5D-625.1/ 3*-D4.52+.A
83
D2/04.2-11/4.A 9-8/2-9-46/=/ 4@?-4.2/251+;, /.*5C+.A 21@.*-11HH 3/8;*1/4.A 45,/4/C151+; + 4/4.528;H?+- 3/.-1F+58A1/ 3*+4@.4.2@H?-=/ +1.*54@7R-6.+21/=/ 6/1B8+6.5. .5 I- 4:-,5 3/- C2/8;-. 15,-.+.A 2-6./*G *5C2+.+; "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " - 24- 3/.-1F+58A1/ 2/C,/I1/- 3*/4.*51- 4.2/ 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 - + *544,5.*+25.A 24- @*/21+ 35./8/=++ 656 2G*5I-1+- 15*@<-11/=/ *5C2+.+; 8+91/4.+ 2 6@8A.@*B+8/4/B46/, 6/1.-64.-.
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c2/-0 4@7R-6.+2- 1/4.+, 2 4//.2-.4.2++ 4 +1.*54@7R-6.+21G,+ C53*/45,+. .58/ 7G.A, +1D+2+D@58A1/- *5C2+.+- 1- 3*-6*5?5-.4; 4 D/4.+I-1+-, 4/F+58A1/ C*-8/=/ 2/C*54.5, 5 3*/D/8I5-.4; 15 3*/.;I-1++ 24-0 I+C1+, 3*+9-, +1.-14+21/4.A + 154G?-11/4.A E./=/ *5C2+.+; 23/81- ,/I-. 7G.A 4*521+,5 4 .5- 6/2/0 2 D-.46/, + H1/<-46/, 2/C*54.-. 5 E./, 3@.+, 656 + 2/ 2C*/48-1++, 4@?-4.2@H. 42/+ 3-*-- 8/,1G- 3-*+/DG, 42/+ "6*+C+4G +D-1.+91/4.+". 4.A 24- /41/251+; =/2/*+.A 1- ./8A6/ /7 /1./=-- 1-.+9-46+: 6*+C+45:, 1/ + / 3-*+/D5: 34+:+9-46/0 D-C+1.-=*5F++ + 1/2G: 3/+465: 45,/+D-1.+91/- 4.+ 2 7/8-- C*-8/0 I+C1+.
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
6 B/*,- /3G.5 2C5+,/D-04.2+; 4 4/D-*I51+-, 4/74.2-11/0 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+ + 43/4/74.- 2@H?+0 3/1+,51+H E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 /7@48/28-11/4.+ .
84
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
/65 ,/I1/ /4.51/2+.A4; 15 ./,, 9./ D/4.+I-1+- .-*53-2.+9-46+: F-8-0 D/8I1/ 4//.1/4+.A4; 4 C5D59-0 4/:*51-1+; "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ ", + CD-4A ,G 2+D+, D2- 2/C,/I1/4.+. -*25; +C 1+: (358- 8+5.+215;) C568H95-.4; 2 3/3G.6- 3/I-*.2/25.A "3/.-1F+58A1G, " + 24-, 15:/D;?+,4; C5 1+, 3*/4.*514.2/, 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ *5D+ @6*-38-1+; /7GD-11/=/ 45,/4/C151+; (/7R-6.+21G: 45,/- +D-1.+B+65F+0 2 "D*@=+: "). /4.+=5-,5; E.+, 4/F+58+C5F+; (4/F+58A15; *-57+8+.5F+;) D/4-
./015 3*+85=5-,G: @4+8+0, /D156/ 48-D@-. 3/,1+.A, 9./ +C 2/43*+;.+; 3*+ E./, @4.*51;-.4; 1- 3/D8-I5?5; @4.*51-1+H + 56.@58+C+*/252<5;4; E6C+4.-1F+58A15; 4+.@5F+; 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1+;74/8H.@. 511G0 43/4/7, 15C2511G0 .!*/,,/, (1990) 7-=4.2/, /. 42/7/DG, 15+7/8-- @3/.*-- 7+, 2 4/F+58A1/0 I+C1+ + .-*53++, /D156/ /1 7-43/8-C-1, 6/=D5 45,5 I+C1A C54.528;-. 3*+C15.A 158+9+- .*514F-1D-1.1G: +C,-*-1+0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ + 2/C1+65H?+: 2 42;C+ 4 E.+, E6C+4.-1F+- 58A1G: 3*/78-,.
3/=*51+91G: 48@95;: 21@.*-11+0 6/1B8+6. *5C*-<+, 3*+ 4,-?-1++ B/6@45 21+,51+; 15 3*-D- ,-.1G- 543-6.G 74/8H.5, ..-. 3*+ 3*/-6F++ 21@.*-11-=/ 6/1B8+6.5 2 158+91G0 4/F+58A1G0 6/1-
.-64.. D156/ 2 48@95- 4-*A-C1/0 35./8/=++ E./ 3*56.+9-46+ 7-43/8-C1/. 56 2/C,/I1/ 3*/D@6-
.+21/- 3*-/D/8-1+- E6C+4.-1F+58A1/=/ 6/1B8+6.5, -48+ 2 4/C151++ 7/8A1/=/ /1 3*+/7*-8, 6 3*+- ,-*@, B57@8@ 7*-D5 /.*528-1+; 4/ 4./*/1G 15+7/8-- 78+C6+: */D4.2-11+6/2? 41/21/0 1-D/4.5-
./6 E./=/ 43/4/75 - 2 +C15958A1/, 3-*-1/4- F-1.*5 "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " 2 3*52@H 954.A *544,/.- *-11/0 4:-,G, 2 3*/4.*514.2/, =D- "3/.-1F+58A1/- " *-D@F+*@-.4;, 5 3*/78-,5 1-*5C*-<+,5 2 3*+1F+3-. 35./8/=++, 68+1+9-46/0 + 4/F+58A1/0, 3*+2/D+. + D*@=5; 6*501/4.A - 3/81/- 45,//./- ID-4.28-1+- 4 5*:-.+3+9-46+,+ 543-6.5,+ 45,/4/C151+; 7-C +: +1.-=*5F++ + 3/1+,51+; /.1/4+-
.-8A1/4.+ 8H7G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0.
-*53-2.+9-46+0 43/4/7, @9+.G25H?+0 1- ./8A6/ E6C+4.-1F+58A1G-, 1/ .*5143-*4/158A1G- 54- 3-6.G 35./8/=++, 3*-D3/85=5-. 15 3@.+ 6 2GCD/*/28-1+H *5C2+.+- "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " 2 =5*,/- 1+91/, 4/9-.51++ 21-<1+: + 21@.*-11+: 45,//./ID-4.28-1+0. /=D5 4@7R-6.+21/4.A /D@:/.2/*;- -. 158+91/- 7G.+-, 5 158+915; D-;.-8A1/4.A 43/4/74.2@-. 3*/;28-1+H 5*:-.+3+9-46/=/ 2 D-;-
.-8A1/4.1/0 3*-D,-.1/0 4B-*- 6/16*-.1/=/ 4@?-4.2/251+;.
511G0 3/D:/D 1- ;28;-.4; 9-,-./ 3*+1F+3+58A1/ 1/2G,. .9-.8+2/ + 2/ 24-: D-.58;: /1 +C8/- I-1 2 5:5;1- (F-1.*58A1/, B+8/4/B46/, @9-1++ 7@DD+C,5) 656 *-D+11G0 @.A, 2 /41/2- 6/./- */=/ 8-I+. 4/-D+1-1+- 3/8;*1/4.+ 42-*:8+91G: + /7GD-11G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0, 4/CD51+- -D+- 1/=/ 3*/4.*514.25 45,/4/C151+;, +1.-=*+*/2511/=/ 2 +1D+2+D@58A1/, . */78-,5 21@.*-11-=/ */4.5 1- /4.5854A 7-C 21+,51+; + 2 -2*/3-046/0 B+8/4/B++. 56 + 2 7@DD+046/0 D@:/21/0 3*56.+- 6-, D8; E./=/ 3@.+ ./I- -4.A 42/+ "*-F-3.G". " 4- ./, - 3+<-. .!@6/ (1997, 4.53), +C-C5 9-=/ ,+* 152-6+ 3*/7@D-. ,+*/, 7-C@,+;, C*-8+?- -=/ 3@4./.G, -=/ 3@4.@H <@,+:@, F5*;?@H 2 1-0 4@,;.+- F@ C2@6/2 + 6*54/6, 24- E./ 48-D@-. 3*+1+,5.A + D5I- D/3@465.A 2 4-7;, 4/:*51;;, /D156/, ;41/- 4/C151+- -=/ =8@3/4.+ - =8@3/4.+, /D+156/2/ 3*+4@?-0 + C*+.-8H, + 45,/,@ C*-8+?@. 1+,5.A 24-,@ E./,@ 48-D@-. 1- 4-*A-C1/, 1- .56, 656 21+,5H. +4.+1-, 1/, @D-8;; ./8+6@ 8-=6/=/ +1.-*-45,
85
4,-4+ +*/1++ + 41+4:/D+.-8A1/4.+, /.6*G./4.+ + .501/=/ C151+;, 1- 3/C2/8;H?-=/ 22-4.+ 4-7; 2 /7,51".
. &1= 3*/F-44 *546*G.+; 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ 2 *5C1//7*5C++ 4/4./;1+0 4/C151+; + 45,/+D-1.+B+65- F+0 /3*-D-8+8 656 "+1D+2+D@5F+H". F-165 2 H1=/246/, + 6*/446@8A.@*1/, 6/1.-64.- .-*;-. 656/0-8+7/ D/=,5.+9-46+0 (34+:/35./8/=+9-46+0, ,-.5B+C+9-46+0, *-8+=+/C1G0 + ..D.) :5*56.-*.
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
*+,-95.-8A1/, 9./ :*+4.+51465; .*5D+F+; 3*+D-*I+25-.4; .-: I- 6/1-91G: /*+-1.+*/2 4.51/2- 8-1+; +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+. =1/4.+9-46/, 251=-8++ /. !+8+335 3/ E./,@ 3/2/D@ ,/I1/ 3*/9+.5.A 48-D@H?--: " 65C58 +4@4... " /=D5 2G D25 4D-85-.-4A /D1+,, 6/=D5 21@.*+ 2G 4.51-.- 656 415*@- I+, 5 415*@I+ - 656 21@.*+, 6/=D5 ./, 9./ 22-*:@, 4.51-. 3/D/71G, ./,@, 9./ 21+C@... ./=D5 2G 2/0- D-.- 2 [ 5*4.2/ /I+-]"" (F+.. 3/: /5651+1, 1993, 4.97).
@I1/ C5,-.+.A, 9./ /75 43/4/75 3*-/D/8-1+; E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 4+.@5F++ 2 42/-, C568H9+.-8A- 1/, 25*+51.- -4.A /6/1951+- E6C+4.-1F++ (4,-*.A), "1-I+C1-43/4/71/- 4/2-*<-14.2/" ( -..-8A- :-0,, 1998). D156/ -48+ 3-*2G0 48@950 - E./ .-,1G0 .@3+6, /42-?-11G0 +88HC+;,+ E6C+4.-1F++,
./ 2./*/0 -4.A *-58+C5F+; 24-: 3/.-1F+0 +1D+2+D@58A1/=/ , 6/1-91G0 4,G48//7*5C@H?+0 E.53, 1-D/4.+I+,5; ,-.5F-8A I+C1+, 3*-D3/85=5H?5; 154G?-11/- 42-*<-1+;,+, 3/81/F-11/- 4@?-- 4.2/251+- [31].
[18]564 '-8-* (1874-1928)- 1-,-F6+0 B+8/4/B + 4/F+/8/=, /D+1 +C /41/25.-8-0 B+8/4/B46/0 51.*/3/8/=++.
[19]+:5+8 5:.+1 (1895-1975) - *@446+0 3-D5=/=, B+8/8/=, B+8/4/B, 52./* 6/1F-3F++ "D+58/=+- 9-46/=/ 4/C151+;", /D+1 +C /41/25.-8-0 <6/8G "D+58/=5 6@8A.@*" (15*;D@ 4 . . G=/.46+, +. . 8A6/1+1G,).
[20]!*+D*+: +F<- (1844-1900) - 1-,-F6+0 B+8/4/B, */D/15958A1+6 "B+8/4/B++ I+C1+", 52./* /7*5C5 "42-*:9-8/2-65", 2/C*/D+2<+0 +**5F+/158A1G- +D-+ C535D1/0 B+8/4/B++.
[21]1564+,51D* +C +8-.5 (610 - 3/48540=. D/ 1.E.) - D*-21-=*-9-46+0 -4.-4.2/+43G.5.-8A, =-/- =*5B + 15.@*B+8/4/B.
[22]/.B*+D -071+F (1646-1716) - 1-,-F6+0 B+8/4/B, ,5.-,5.+6, B+C+6, ;CG6/2-D.
[23]/D/71G- /1./8/=+C5F+0 +,-H. ,-4./ + 2 4/2*-,-11G: 5.-+4.+9-46+: *-8+=+;:, +C 6/./*G:, 2 954.1/4.+, 3*/+C/<8+ :/*/</ C156/,G- /7*5CG "2-91/ I+2/=/" -1+15, "/.F5 15*/D/2" - .58+15.
[24]5I@?5;4; ,5.-*+58A1/4.A E./0 2-*4++ 74/8H.5 1- 3*/.+2/*-9+. ./,@, 9./ /1 4/4.528;-. 4/D-*I51+- 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+. +D-- 74/8H.5 21-<1-- + 21@.*-11--, *5F+/158A1/- + +1.@+.+21/- 15:/D;.4; 2 D+15,+9-46/, *521/2-4++, 2 -- 5158+C- /.6*G25-.4; =8@7+115; 2C5+,/- 42;CA 65*.+1 ,+*5, 3*-D4.528-11G: 6251./2/0 B+C+6/0 + ,+4.+9-46+,+ @9-1+;,+ D*-21/4.+. 3-- F+58A1/ E./,@ 2/3*/4@ 3/42;?-15 61+=5 !. 58*G (1994, 4.14), 2 6/./*/0 /1 3+<-., 9./ "4/2*-,-1- 15; B+C+65 3*-D85=5-. 15, .+3 ,+*/2/43*+;.+;, C159+.-8A1/ 153/,+15H?+0 ,+4.+9-46/- ,+*/- 2/43*+;.+- 24-: 2*-,-1 + .*5D+F+0".
[25]85D+,+* /8/2A-2 (1853-1900)- *@446+0 *-8+=+/C1G0 B+8/4/B, 52./* B+8/4/B46/0 6/1F-3-
86
F++ 24--D+14.25. .,-95; @ +F<- 656 1-9./ 3/8/I+.-8A1/- -=/ 3/3G.6@ 2G*5C+.A /7?-9-8/2-- 9-46/- 4.*-,8-1+- 2G0.+ C5 3*-D-8G ./8A6/ 9-8/2-65. . /8/2A-2 6*501- 1-=5.+21/ /.1/4+84; 6 "4/9+1-11/,@ 1-4954.1G, +F<- + +, 45,+, 1*524.2-11/ +C78-2511/,@ 42-*:9-8/2-6@".
[26]52-8 !8/*-146+0 (1882-1943)- *@446+0 *-8+=+/C1G0 B+8/4/B, @9-1G0, 42;?-11+6, /D+1 +C 2+D1G: 3*-D4.52+.-8-0 B+8/4/B++ 24--D+14.25.
[27]=H4. /1. (1798-1857) - B*51F@C46+0 B+8/4/B, 3*-D4.52+.-8A 68544+9-46/=/ 3/C+.+2+C,5.
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
[29]*5143-*4/158A1G- 6*+C+4G @65CG25H. 15 3*/78-,G 45,/+D-1.+B+65F++ 15 ,+B/8/=+9-- 46/, @*/2145,/4/C151+;.
[30],-11/ E./0 3*+9+1/0 /7@48/28-1G 68+1+6/-/1./=-1-.+9-46+- 35*588-8+ 34+:/8/=+9-46/0
1-4.57+8A1/4.+ 2 3@7-*.5.- + D-3-*4/158+C5F+0 2 7/8-- 3/CD1-- 2*-,; ( -CC@7/25, 1993). /91/ /3+4G25-,/- 2 68+1+9-46+: *57/.5: B-1/,-1/8/=+9-46/- 4:/D4.2/ 1- +,--., /D156/, +1.-*3*-.5- F++, 6/./*5; 2/C,/I15 8+<A 4 @9-./, E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 3*/78-,5.+6+ *5C2+.+; 45,/4/C151+; + 3*-D4.528-1+; / ./,, 9./ E./ *5C2+.+- 3*/D/8I5-.4; 24H I+C1A.
[31] /65C5.-8A1/, 9./ D8; . &1=5 3*/F-44 D/4.+I-1+; "45,/4.+" 7-46/1-9-1 + 7/8-- 25I-1, 9-, 6/1-91G0 *-C@8A.5..
5.3.
*-D8/I-115; 4:-,5 4@7R-6.+21/0 *-58A1/4.+ 3/C2/8;-. 3*-D4.52+.A 6@8A.@*1/-B+8/4/B46+0 6/1.-64. +C@9-1+; 3/.-1F+58A1G: 4/4./;1+0 45,/4/C151+; (4/C151+;). ,-4.- 4 E.+, 3/;28;-.4; 2/C,/I1/4.A 2G*5C+.A E6C+4.-1F+58A1/- C159-1+- +C,-1-1+0 4/C151+; + 4B/*,@8+*/25.A 51.*/- 3/8/=+9-46/- 3/1+,51+- .-*53++. E./0 F-8AH ,G 22/D+, 3/1;.+- "E6C+4.-1F+58A1/0 5D53.5- F++" ( ). 6C+4.-1F+58A15; 5D53.5F+; -4.A +468H9+.-8A1/ 9-8/2-9-465; B/*,5 3*+43/4/78-1+; - 5.*+7@. 4/74.2-11/ 9-8/2-9-46/0 I+C1+, /3*-D-8;H?+0 -=/ 2+D/2/- 42/-/7*5C+-
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
.5-.4; 46*G.G,. 4.525;4A C52@58+*/2511/0 D*@=+,+ 2+D5,+ 5D53.5F++, 3/.*-71/4.A 2 3*+- D5-. 3*+43/4/78-1+H 9-8/2-65 .2/*9-46@H 43-F+B+6@, /3*-D-8;H?@H 1-3/2./*+,/4.A +1D+2+- D@58A1/4.+.
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
87
1G,) +**5F+/158A1G, ,/.+25,. 15@91/0 4*-D- .-C+4 / 3-*2+91/4.+ 7-44/C15.-8A1/=/ + / 4//.- 2-.4.2@H?-0 */8+ 3/D=/./28-1 .*@D5,+ '.'5*6/, . *-0-*5, .)51-, 3.!*-0D5, . 8535*-D5,. *5B.- 7+1=5, . 8-08-*5 + D*@=+: +448-D/25.-8-0, +C@952<+: 28+;1+- +14.+16.+21/0 EBB-6-
.+21/4.+ 15 24- 4/C15.-8A1G- @4.51/26+. *;D@ E.+: 4-*A-C1G: @9-1G: 154 2 /4/7-11/4.+ +1.-- *-4@-. B+=@*5 .&1=5. -=/ *57/.5: 23-*2G- 15 E,3+*+9-46/0 /41/2- 7G85 4D-8515 3/3G.65 @2;- C5.A 7+/8/=+9-46+- /41/251+; 9-8/2-9-46/0 3*+*/DG 4 D@:/21G,+ +C,-*-1+;,+. &1=/2465; 6/1- F-3F+; 5*:-.+3/2 2/44/-D+1+85 "D@:/21/4.A" 4 1-0*/7+/8/=+9-46+,+ 3*-D3/4G865,+ 9-8/2-91/- 4.+, 4/4.52+2 /41/2/3/85=5H?+0 75C+4 - 1-9./ 2*/D- "I+2/.1/=/ D@:5" D*-21+: ,G48+.-8-0.
5<- 3/1+,51+- 75C+*@-.4; 15 ./, I- ,+*/2/CC*-19-46/-=1/4-/8/=+9-46/, 3/1+,51++ 3*+- /*+.-.5 7-44/C15.-8A1/=/. 544,5.*+25; 7-4c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
.+- /6*@I5H?-=/ ,+*5 + 45,/4/:*51-1+-, 3/C2/8;H?+- "3/.-1F+58A1/,@ " 7-43*-3;.4.2-11/ 28+.A4; 2 3/./6 4/F+58A1/0 I+C1+.
88
2- .-1D-1F++, E,3+*+9-46+ 3*-D4.528-11G- D2@,; /41/2/3/85=5H?+,+ 3*+1F+35,+ 4/F+58A1/0 6/,,@1+65F++ [37], +,-H. /.9-.8+2G- E62+258-1.G 2 6@8A.@*- + 34+:/8/=++. 1+ ./ID-4.2-11G @1+2-*458A1/0 D+:/./,++ /=/45 + */45 ( 5C@,5 + H72+, 1A + 1), .*5D+F+/11/ :5*56.-*+- C@H?-0 ,@I46/- + I-146/- 4/C151+-, *5F+/158A1G0 3*+1F+3 + 3*+1F+3 */D4.25. " */4, - 3+<-. .6/7+ (1996, 4.90), - E./ 9@24.2-115; 42;CA, 6/./*5; 4/-D+1;-. 154 4 D*@=+,+, 4 3*+*/D/0 + 4 15- <+, 21@.*-11+, ,+*/,. /=/4 - E./ 15<5 43/4/71/4.A /.D-8+.A 4-7; /. /6*@I5H?-=/ ,+*5, 3*-- 2*5.+2 -=/ 2 /7R-6., 9./7G /7R-6.+21/ -=/ *544,5.*+25.A + / 1-, *5C,G<8;.A". */4, 2/38/?-1- 1G0 2 I+C1+, -4.A 43/4/7 6/,,@1+65F++, +,-H?+0 42/04.2/ 4/-D+1;.A - @4.51528+25.A 42;C+ -G. /=/4, 2 42/H /9-*-DA, 3*-D4.528-1 6/,,@1+65.+21/0 @4.51/26/0, +4:/D;?-0 +C ,+*//?@?-- 1+; *5CR-D+1-1+0 - 1/. 53*528-11/4.A 15 /285D-1+- /7R-6./, 3/,+,/ B+C+9-46+: 35*5,-.- */2 +,--. + 3/C1525.-8A1G0 543-6.. 5F+/158+C+*@H?5; + *5CD-8;H?5; B@16F+; /=/45 478+- I5-. -=/ 4 3/C1525.-8A1/0 +1.-1F+-0 "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " 2 4+4.-,- /.1/<-1+0 6 21-<1-0 + 21@.- *-11-0 D-04.2+.-8A1/4.+. ,3+*+9-46+ 3*+1F+3 /=/45 2G*5I-1 3/+46/, 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 2 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1++ 6 /6*@I5H?-,@. 1 4/4.528;-. 6/=1+.+21@H B@16F+H 45,/4/C151+;. 42/H /9-*-DA */4 2 E,3+*+9-46/, 2G*5I-1++ -4.A E,/F+/158A1G0 543-6. 45,/4/C151+; - ,/,-1. 45- ,/*-=@8;F++. 1-, /7-43-9+25-.4; 4.57+8A1/4.A 150D-11G: 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0, "3/.-1F+58A- 1/- " 4/:*51;-.4; 2 6/=1+.+21/0 52./1/,1/4.+ + 2 D2/04.2-11/, 3*/.+2/3/4.528-1++.
9-2+D15; @1+2-*458A1/4.A D2@: /41/21G: .-1D-1F+0 3/D9-*6+25-. +: 7-44/C15.-8A1@H, 3*-7G- 25H?@H 21- 6/16*-.1/0 6@8A.@*G + 2*-,-11G: *5,/6 3*+*/D@. @?-4.2/251+- D2@: 7-44/C15-
.-8A1G: @4.51/2/6 /7@48/28-1/ *544,/.*-11/0 *51-- 51.*/3/8/=+9-46/0 4+.@5F+-0 3*/.+2/3/4-
.528-11/4.+ "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ " 74/8H.@. 4./*+; *5C2+.+; 6@8A.@*G D-,/14.*+*@-., 9./ 3-*-- I+251+- /.6*G./4.+ 7-46/1-91/4.+ 3*/D@F+*/258/ EBB-6.+21/4.A - 2+.58A1@H +**5F+/158A1@H
.*-2/=@, 15 3*-/D/8-1+- 6/./*/0 + 153*528-1G D2- +1.-1F++ "3/.-1F+58A1/=/ ". 56+, /7*5C/,, -48+ /1./8/=+C+*/25.A 7-44/C15.-8A1/-, ./, 15*;D@ 4 @65C511G,+ .-1D-1F+;,+, 6 -=/ 4/D-*I51+H 1@I1/ /.1-4.+ + 3/*/ID5H?@H +: .*-2/=@ [38]. 6C+4.-1F+58A15; 5D53.5F+; 2 E./, 6/1.-64.- -4.A 43/4/7 4/=854/251+; D2@: 7-44/C15.-8A1G: 34+:/7+/8/=+9-46+: .-1D-1F+0 2 3*/F-44- 3-*-I+25- 1+; .*-2/=+.
2- /41/21G- 7-44/C15.-8A1G- .-1D-1F++ /3*-D-8;H. /4/7-11/4.+ D2@: 25*+51./2 . .=*51+- 9+25; B/*,G 5D53.5F++ @ I+2/.1G:, 1- +,-H?+: 45,/4/C151+;, /. 5D53.5F++ 9-8/2-65 /.,-.+,, 9./ -4.A 659-4.2-11/ 1/25; 2 *5C2+.++ I+2/=/ B/*,5 5D53.5F++, 42/-/7*5C+- 6/./*/0 C568H- 95-.4; 2 @4.51/28-1++ 2C5+,/42;C+ 4/ 4B-*/0 1-;21/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ [39].
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
89
/7*5C@ /.1/<-1+0 - G. /43*+;.+- /6*@I5H?+: 2/ 24-0 +: +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+ 4 E,/F+/158A1/ 154G?-11G,+ 4@7R-6.-4@7R-6.1G,+ 42;C;,+ 43/4/74.2@-. 1- ./8A6/ 3/1+,51+H E6C+4.-1F+58A- 1/0 4+.@5F++ + 75C/2G: 3/.*-71/4.-0, 3*+4@?+: D*@=+, 8HD;,, 1/ + 2/43*+;.+H 4/74.2-11/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ 2 3/C+.+21/, 68H9-.
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
-2*/3-046/0 6@8A.@*- .56/0 .+3 /.1/<-1+0 /C15,-1/2584; 3/;28-1+-, :*+4.+5146/0 +D-+ / 2/44/-D+1-1++ 4 4-2G<1+, + :*+4.+5146/0 8H72+ 6 78+I1-,@. 8H72+ .*-2/=5 41+,5-.4; 3*+- 1;.+-, 4@?1/4.1/=/ -D+14.25, 4.*-,8-1+-, 6 4+1.-C@ + F-8/4.1/4.+. *+ E./, D5I45,G- 1-- D/4.@31G- 3/1+,51+H =8@7+1G 4/74.2-11/0 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ 3-*-4.5H. 2GCG25.A .*-2/=@.
5*;D@ 4 25*+51./, , =D- @.2-*ID-1+- +1D+2+D@58A1/4.+ /4@?-4.28;-.4; 785=/D5*; 4.57+8+- C5F++ 45,/+D-1.+B+65F+0 4+8/0 */45, 1@I1/ 3*-D4.52+.A + ./. 25*+51., =D- 3*+1F+3 +14.+16-
.+21/0 E,/F+/158A1/0 42;C+ 2G.-41;-.4; 3*-/785D51+-, 5C@,5. 4.528;; 2 4./*/1- 24- 3/C+-
.+21G- 543-6.G *5F+/158A1/4.+, C5,-.+,, 9./ 45,/+D-1.+B+65F++, @.2-*ID5-,G- /D1+, 5C@- ,/,, /65CG25H.4; 1-@4./09+2G, 5 1-3/81/F-115. 2;C51/ E./ 4 .-,, 9./ @.2-*ID-1+- +1D+2+- D@58A1/4.+ /D1/0 8+<A 4+8/0 5C@,5 /4@?-4.28;-.4; 3@.-,, 3*-D3/85=5H?+, 2/C,/I1/4.A 3/- C151+;, /285D-1+; + +43/8AC/251+; 74/8H.5. !56.+9-46+ 5C@,, 3*-2*5.+2 74/8H. 2 +9./, "/42/7/D+84; + 4-7; 45,/=/ /7R;2+8 =/43/D+1/," (&1=, 19965, 4.63). D156/, 656 42+D-.-8A4.2@-.. 50D-==-*(1993), +9./ 3*/D/8I5-. /4.525.A4; +4./91+6/, @=*/CG + *-2/=+. /C,/I1/, 3/E./- ,@ /D+1 +C ;*6+: 3*+2-*I-1F-2 *5F+/158+C,5 3. !*-0D 3+<-. 1- / 2C5+,/D/3/81+.-8A1/4.+ */- 45 + 5C@,5, 5 / 3*-7G25H?+: 2 2-91/, 6/1B8+6.- +14.+16.5: I+C1+ + 4,-*.+ - */45 + 515./45.7-*-=5H?+0, 2465*,8+25H?+0 + 3/,/=5H?+0 ,5.-*+146+0 /78+6 */45, *-D@F+*@-,G0 D/ +1- B51.+8A1/0 C52+4+,/4.+, 3-*-4.5-. 7G.A 3/81/F-11/0 51.+.-C/0 5C@,@, + 3/48-D1+0, 1-3/,-*- 1/ 2/C2-8+9-11G0, 8-=6/ 3-*-:/D+. /. 5158+.+9-46/=/ *5498-1-1+; ,+*5 6 -=/ /2-?-4.28-11/,@ +43/8AC/251+H, @1+9./I-1+H D@:/21/0 /6*5<-11/4.+, 3/.-*- +1.@+.+21/=/ 3-*-I+251+; 4/3*+- 954.1/4.+ ,+*@ + D*@=+, 8HD;,. " /=D5 9-8/2-6, - 3+<-. . .&1= (.5, I-, 4.84), - 7-44/C15.-8A1/ 3*/.+2/D-04.2@-. 4-7- 45,/,@, 3/;28;-.4; 1-.-*3-8+2/4.A, *5CD*5I+.-8A1/4.A + 7-44+8A1/- I-- 851+- 8H7G,+ 4*-D4.25,+ *5C + 1524-=D5 3/D9+1+.A 3*/.+21+65". C5+,/3*/1+F5-,/4.A 21-<1-- =/ + 21@.*-11-=/ /C1595-., 9./ 1+C2-D-1+- 21-<1-=/ ,+*5 D/ +9./ *521/F-11/ @1+9./I-1+H D@- :/21G: 4,G48//7*5C@-H?+: /41/251+0 2 =8@7+1- 21@.*-11-=/ ,+*5. -8/2-9-46/- "7G.+--4-1+9./" ( 5*+.-1, 1955, F+.. 3/: @7,51, 1994, 4.147) "3/D2-*I-1/ @2;D51+H + .*5=+9-46/,@ B+158@ 4,-*-
.+". 56 3+<-. 1-,-F6+0 34+:/8/= + 34+:/.-*53-2. !. +,51 (1998, 4.13-14), "2/8; 6 ,/=@?-4.2@ + /785D51+H 153*528-15 3*/.+2 3*+*/DG + I+C1+ + 2GCG25-. @ 154 4.*5:, 6/./*G0 3*+ ,51+3@8+*/- 251++ +, 2GCG25-. D@<-21@H /3@4./<-11/4.A".
@I1/ C5,-.+.A, 9./ 1-C52+4+,/ /. 3*+1+,5-,G: /7/C159-1+0 3*+*/D5 74/8H.5 1-0.*58A15, 7-46/1-91/4.A /7R-6.+21/=/ ,+*5 + =8@7+1 4@7R-6.+21/4.+ 1- +,--. 9-8/2-9-46+: :5*56.-*+4.+6./I-4.2-11/- +8+ D-,/1+9-46/- "8+F/" 74/8H.5 /3*-D-8;-.4; D/,+1+*/251+-, ./0 +8+ +1/0
90