seminar5materials / P4AFM-RQB_PDF_d08 / P4AFM-RQB-Qs_d08
.pdf
REVISION QUESTION BANK – ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4)
Question 42 VADENER PLC
Vadener plc has instigated a review of the group’s recent performance and potential future strategy. The Board of Directors has publicly stated that it is pleased with the group’s performance and proposes to devote resources equally to its three operating divisions. Two of the divisions are in the UK, and focus on construction and leisure respectively, and one is in the US and manufactures pharmaceuticals.
Recent summarised accounts for the group and data for the individual divisions are shown below:
|
|
Group data £ million |
|
Income Statements: |
2003 |
2004 |
2005 |
Turnover |
1,210 |
1,410 |
1,490 |
Operating costs |
800 |
870 |
930 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Operating profit |
410 |
540 |
560 |
Net interest |
40 |
56 |
65 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Profit before tax |
370 |
484 |
495 |
Tax (30%) |
111 |
145 |
149 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Profit after tax |
259 |
339 |
346 |
Equity dividends |
146 |
170 |
185 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Retained earnings |
113 |
169 |
161 |
Statements of Financial Position: |
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
|
|
|
|
Fixed assets: |
|
|
|
Tangible fixed assets |
1,223 |
1,280 |
1,410 |
Intangible fixed assets |
100 |
250 |
250 |
Current assets: |
|
|
|
Inventory |
340 |
410 |
490 |
Receivables |
378 |
438 |
510 |
Cash |
10 |
15 |
15 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Total assets |
2,051 |
2,393 |
2,675 |
Less current liabilities: |
|
|
|
Payables |
302 |
401 |
430 |
Short term loans |
135 |
170 |
201 |
Taxation |
55 |
72 |
75 |
Dividends |
73 |
85 |
93 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
|
1,486 |
1,665 |
1,876 |
Financed by: |
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
|
|
|
|
Long term liabilities |
400 |
410 |
470 |
Shareholders’ equity |
1,086 |
1,255 |
1,406 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
|
1,486 |
1,665 |
1,876 |
|
––––– |
––––– |
––––– |
Note:
The 2005 amount for shareholders’ equity includes a £10 million loss on translation from the US division due to the recent weakness of the $US.
51
ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4) – REVISION QUESTION BANK
Other group data at year end: |
2003 |
2004 |
2005 |
Share price (pence) |
1,220 |
1,417 |
1,542 |
Number of issued shares (million) |
300 |
300 |
300 |
Equity beta |
|
|
1·10 |
The company’s share price has increased by an average of 12% per year over the last five years.
Other data at year end: |
2003 |
2004 |
2005 |
FT 100 index |
3,700 |
4,600 |
4,960 |
PE ratio of similar companies |
15:1 |
14:1 |
15:1 |
Risk free rate (%) |
|
|
5 |
Market return (%) |
|
|
12 |
Divisional data 2005 |
Construction |
Leisure |
Pharmaceuticals |
Turnover (£m) |
480 |
560 |
450 |
Operating profit |
160 |
220 |
180 |
Estimated after tax return (%) |
13 |
16 |
14 |
Data for the sector: |
Construction |
Leisure |
Pharmaceuticals |
Average asset beta 2005 |
0·75 |
1·10 |
1·40 |
Required:
(a)Evaluate and comment on the performance of Vadener plc and each of its divisions. Highlight performance that appears favourable, and any areas of potential concern for the managers of Vadener. Comment upon the likely validity of the company’s strategy to devote resources equally to the operating divisions.
All relevant calculations must be shown. Approximately 19 marks are available for calculations, and 9 for discussion (28 marks)
(b)Discuss what additional information would be useful in order to more accurately assess
the performance of Vadener plc and its divisions. |
(6 marks) |
(c)Discuss the possible implications for Vadener plc of the £10 million loss on translation, and recommend what action, if any, the company should take as a result of this loss.
(6 marks)
(40 marks)
Question 43 HIOME PLC
Hiome plc has experienced a period of above average growth for its industry, but is now growing at the normal rate of about 10% per year. The company’s directors are reviewing the current dividend policy. One director has suggested that, as the company no longer needs as much internally generated funds to finance new investment, a higher proportion of earnings should be paid out as dividends in order to benefit the company’s shareholders. Another director has read that two eminent economists, Miller and Modigliani, have stated that the pattern of dividend payouts is irrelevant, and therefore shareholders will experience no gain from a higher level of dividends.
Required:
Discuss whether or not an increase in dividends is likely to benefit the shareholders of Hiome plc.
(10 marks)
52
REVISION QUESTION BANK – ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4)
Question 44 RETRO
(a)Outline the main factors that a multinational company should consider before deciding
whether or not to use a tax haven. |
(5 marks) |
(b)Retro plc has manufacturing subsidiaries in three overseas countries.
|
|
Country |
Corporate tax rate |
Proposed net dividend |
|
|
|
|
£000 |
|
Subsidiary 1 |
Mopia |
40% |
600 |
|
Subsidiary 2 |
Blueland |
35% |
800 |
|
Subsidiary 3 |
Saddonia |
20% |
1,500 |
|
The UK corporate tax rate is 30%. There are no taxes in the tax haven country. |
|||
|
Bilateral tax treaties exist between the UK and the countries where each of the subsidiaries |
|||
|
are located, which allow a tax credit against UK corporate tax liability up to a maximum of |
|||
|
the UK tax liability. This tax credit may be assumed to be available even when dividends are |
|||
|
channelled via a tax haven. UK corporate taxation on overseas earnings may be assumed to be |
|||
|
based upon the TOTAL dividends remitted to the UK (grossed up by one minus the relevant |
|||
|
national tax rate(s)), from EACH overseas country. |
|
||
|
Required: |
|
|
|
|
Evaluate whether or not Retro would benefit from using a tax haven holding company |
|||
|
through which dividends would be channelled. |
(5 marks) |
||
|
|
|
|
(10 marks) |
Question 45 SHARE REPURCHASE |
|
|
||
Discuss the main features of: |
|
|
|
|
(i) |
corporate share repurchases (buy-backs); and |
|
||
(ii) |
share (inventory) splits; |
|
|
|
and why companies might use them. Include in your discussion comment on the possible effects on share price of share repurchases and share (inventory) splits in comparison to the payment of dividends.
(15 marks)
53
ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4) – REVISION QUESTION BANK
Question 46 TYR
Summarised financial data for TYR plc is shown below:
|
|
TYR plc |
|
|
Year |
Post-tax earnings |
Dividends |
Issued shares |
Share price |
|
(£ million) |
(£ million) |
(million) |
(pence) |
1997 |
86·2 |
34·5 |
180 |
360 |
1998 |
92·4 |
36·2 |
180 |
410 |
1999 |
99·3 |
37·6 |
180 |
345 |
2000 |
134·1 |
51·6 |
240 |
459 |
2001 |
148·6 |
53·3 |
240 |
448 |
Year |
All-share index |
|
Inflation rate |
|
1997 |
2895 |
|
6% |
|
1998 |
3300 |
|
5% |
|
1999 |
2845 |
|
4% |
|
2000 |
2610 |
|
3% |
|
2001 |
2305 |
|
3% |
|
TYR’s cost of equity is estimated to be 11%.
Required:
(a)Explain, with supporting numerical evidence, the current dividend policy of TYR plc,
and briefly discuss whether or not this appears to be successful. |
(6 marks) |
(b)Identify and consider additional information that might assist the managers of TYR in
assessing whether the dividend policy has been successful. |
(4 marks) |
(c)Evaluate whether or not the company’s share price at the end of 2001 was what might have been expected from the Dividend Growth Model. Briefly discuss the validity of
your findings. |
(5 marks) |
(15 marks)
Question 47 BOXLESS PLC
(a)Briefly discuss possible advantages to a multinational company from using a holding
company based in a tax haven. |
(4 marks) |
(b)Boxless plc has subsidiaries in three overseas countries, Annovia, Cardenda and Sporoon. Corporate taxes for the three countries are shown below:
|
Corporate income tax |
Withholding tax |
% of after tax income |
|
rate |
on dividends |
remitted to the UK |
Annovia |
40% |
10% |
70 |
Cardenda |
25% |
– |
40 |
Sporoon |
20% |
5% |
80 |
The UK corporate tax rate is 30%, and bilateral tax treaties exist between the UK and each of the three countries. Under the treaties, any corporate tax paid overseas on income remitted to the UK may be credited against UK tax liability. Boxless currently remits income from its overseas subsidiaries direct to the UK parent company.
54
REVISION QUESTION BANK – ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4)
The UK government currently only taxes income from multinational companies’ overseas subsidiaries when such income is remitted to the UK. UK tax liability is based upon the grossed up dividend distributions to the UK (grossed up at the local tax rate and before deduction of any withholding tax).
The UK government is now considering taxing the gross income earned by overseas subsidiaries. If such gross income were to be taxed, credit against UK tax liability would be available for all corporate tax paid overseas.
Required:
(i)Estimate the impact on the cash flows of Boxless if the UK government alters the tax rules as detailed above.
Assume that the taxable income in each of the subsidiaries is the equivalent of £100,000. (7 marks)
(ii)For each of the current and possible new tax rules, evaluate what benefit, if any, Boxless would experience if it were to transfer income from its overseas subsidiaries to the parent company via a tax haven holding company. Assume that the UK tax authorities would then treat all income from overseas
subsidiaries as coming from a single source, the tax haven holding company.
Comment upon your results. |
(4 marks) |
|
(15 marks) |
Question 48 SERTY |
|
(a)Discuss whether or not an increase in dividends is likely to benefit the shareholders of a
plc. |
(8 marks) |
(b)The board of directors of Serty Plc is discussing the level and nature of the company’s next dividend payment.
Three options are under consideration:
(i)A cash dividend of 15 pence per share, or
(ii)A 5% scrip dividend, or
(iii)The company repurchases 10% of the ordinary share capital at the current market price and then pays a cash dividend as in (i) above.
Summarised financial accounts for Serty are shown below:
Income Statement (£ million)
Turnover
Operating profit
Net interest earned
Taxation
Available to shareholders
150·0
_____
15·0
4·0
_____
19·0
6·3
_____
12·7
55
ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4) – REVISION QUESTION BANK
|
Statement of Financial Position |
(£ million) |
Fixed Assets (net) |
|
|
Current assets: |
Inventory |
20 |
|
Receivables |
20 |
|
Cash and bank |
40 |
Less current liabilities |
__ |
|
|
||
Shareholders funds
Issued ordinary shares (50p par)
Reserves
Serty’s current share price is 400 pence cum div.
Required:
60
80
(30)
_____
110
20
90
_____
110
Calculate the expected effect of each suggestion on a shareholder in Serty owning 1,000 shares. Explain briefly how accurate your estimates are likely to be.
Taxation may be ignored. |
(7 marks) |
(15 marks)
Question 49 AVT PLC
(a)Discuss how a decrease in the value of each of the determinants of the option price in the
Black-Scholes option-pricing model for European options is likely to change the price of a call option. (6 marks)
(b)AVT plc is considering the introduction of an executive share option scheme.
The scheme would be offered to all middle managers of the company. It would replace the existing scheme of performance bonuses linked to the post-tax earnings per share of the company. Such bonuses in the last year ranged between £5,000 and £7,000. If the option scheme is introduced new options are expected to be offered to the managers each year.
It is proposed for the first year that all middle managers are offered options to purchase 5,000 shares at a price of 500 pence per share after the options have been held for one year. Assume that the tax authorities allow the exercise of such options after they have been held for one year. If the options are not exercised at that time they will lapse.
The company’s shares have just become ex-div and have a current market price of 610 pence. The dividend paid was 25 pence per share, a level that has remained constant for the last three years. Assume that dividends are only paid annually.
The company’s share price has experienced a standard deviation of 38% during the last year. The short-term risk free interest rate is 6% per annum.
Required:
(i)Discuss the relative merits for the company of the existing bonus scheme and
the proposed share option scheme. |
(6 marks) |
56
REVISION QUESTION BANK – ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4)
(ii)Evaluate whether or not the proposed share option scheme is likely to be
attractive to middle managers of AVT plc. |
(11 marks) |
(iii)When told of the scheme one manager stated that he would rather receive put options than call options, as they would be more valuable to him.
(1)Discuss whether or not AVT should agree to offer him put options.
(3 marks)
(2)Calculate whether or not he is correct in his statement that put
options would be more valuable to him. |
(4 marks) |
(30 marks)
Question 50 BIOPLASM PLC
Bioplasm plc is a UK based company that has completed the preliminary development of a new drug to combat a major disease. Initial clinical trials of the drug have been favourable, and the drug is expected to receive approval from the regulatory authority in the near future. Bioplasm has taken out a patent on the drug that gives it the exclusive right to commercially develop and market the drug for a period of 15 years. Although it is difficult to produce precise estimates, the company believes that to commercially develop and market the drug for worldwide use will cost approximately £400 million at current prices. The expected present value from sales of the drug during the patent period could vary between £350 million and £500 million. The current long-term government bond yield is 5%. The annual variance (standard deviation squared) of returns on similar biotech companies is estimated to be 0·185.
The finance director of Bioplasm can see from the possible NPVs that the company has a difficult decision as to whether or not to develop the drug, and wonders if option pricing could assist the decision.
Required:
Using the Black-Scholes option pricing model for the life of the patent, estimate the call values of the option to commercially develop and market the drug. Provide a reasoned recommendation, based upon your calculations and any other relevant information, as to whether or not Bioplasm should develop the drug.
N.B. Because the value of the returns from the patent will fall over the period before the drug is commercially developed, it is necessary to adjust the expected present value from sales of the drug. In
all relevant parts of the Black-Scholes model, the present value from sales of the drug should be multiplied by exp(–0·067)(15) to reflect this potential reduction in value according to when the drug is
developed.
(15 marks)
Question 51 FOLTER PLC
Folter plc has short-term equity holdings in a number of companies that it considers might be future take-over targets.
The equity market has recently been very volatile, and the finance director is considering how to protect the equity portfolio from adverse market movements, in case some of the holdings need to be sold, at short notice, by the end of October.
The finance director is particularly concerned about 2 million shares that are currently held in Magterdoor plc. The shares are trading at 535 pence.
57
ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4) – REVISION QUESTION BANK
Assume that it is now 1 June and that option contracts mature at the month end.
LIFFE Traded options (1,000 shares)
|
|
CALLS |
|
|
PUTS |
|
|
July |
October January |
July |
October January |
||
500 |
37·5 |
52·5 |
60·5 |
2·0 |
24·5 |
35·0 |
550 |
6·5 |
24·0 |
34·0 |
21·0 |
51·0 |
60·0 |
Required:
(a)Illustrate how Folter plc might use traded options to protect against a fall in the share
price of Magterdoor plc. Assuming that Folter has to sell the shares at the end of October at a price of 485 pence, evaluate the outcome of the hedge(s). (4 marks)
(b)Assume that the call option delta of Magterdoor is 0·47. Illustrate how a delta neutral hedge might be used to protect against price movements of the shares of Magterdoor. Comment upon any practical problems of using a delta hedge for this purpose. (4 marks)
(c)Discuss the reasons why the January 550 call option premium is not the same as the
intrinsic value of the option. |
(4 marks) |
(d)The managing director of Folter suggests increasing its holding in Magterdoor from 2%
to 6% of that company’s issued shares. Discuss briefly the advantages and
disadvantages of this strategy. |
(3 marks) |
|
(15 marks) |
Question 52 NETRA PLC |
|
The finance director of Netra plc, a company listed on the AIM (Alternative Investment Market) wishes to estimate what impact the introduction of debt finance is likely to have on the company’s overall cost of capital. The company is currently financed only by equity.
Netra plc – Summarised capital structure
Ordinary shares (25 pence par value)
Reserves
£000 500
1,100
_____
1,600
_____
The company’s current share price is 420 pence, and up to £4 million of fixed rate five-year debt could be raised at an interest rate of 10% per annum. The corporate tax rate is 33%.
Netra’s current earnings before interest and tax are £2.5 million. These earnings are not expected to change significantly for the foreseeable future.
The company is considering raising either:
|
(i) |
£2 million in debt finance |
or |
(ii) |
£4 million in debt finance |
In either case the debt finance will be used to repurchase ordinary shares.
58
REVISION QUESTION BANK – ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4)
Required:
(a)Using Miller and Modigliani’s model in a world with corporate tax, estimate the impact on Netra’s cost of capital of raising:
(i)£2 million and
(ii)£4 million in debt finance.
State clearly any assumptions that you make. |
(6 marks) |
(b)Briefly discuss whether or not the estimates produced in part (a) are likely to be
accurate. |
(4 marks) |
(10 marks)
Question 53 MERCHANT BANK
You have purchased the following data from a merchant bank.
Company |
Forecast total |
Standard deviation of |
Covariance with |
|
equity return |
total equity return |
market return |
Dedton |
16% |
6.3% |
32% |
Paralot |
12% |
4.8% |
19% |
Sunout |
14% |
4.7% |
24% |
Rangon |
18% |
6.9% |
43% |
The market return and market standard deviation are 14.5% and 5% respectively, and the risk free rate is 6%. Returns and all other data relate to a one-year period.
Required:
(a)Estimate the “alpha” values for each of these companies’ shares and explain what use
alpha values might be to financial managers. |
(6 marks) |
(b)Briefly discuss reasons for the existence of alpha values, and whether or not the same
alpha values would be expected to exist in one year’s time. |
(4 marks) |
(10 marks)
Question 54 PHANTOM
Phantom plc wishes to buy £1 million of shares in each of two companies from a choice of three companies that it might wish to acquire at some future date. The companies are in different industries. Historic five-year data on the risk and returns of the three companies are shown below.
|
Average annual returns |
Standard deviation of returns |
Mangeit Foods |
11% |
17% |
Altalk Communications |
20% |
29% |
Legi Printers |
14% |
21% |
|
Correlation coefficients between returns |
Mangeit and Altalk |
0·00 |
Altalk and Legi |
0·40 |
Mangeit and Legi |
0·62 |
59
ADVANCED FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT (P4) – REVISION QUESTION BANK
An adviser to Phantom plc has suggested that the decision about which shares to buy should be based upon selecting the most efficient portfolio of two shares.
Required:
(a) |
Estimate which of the possible portfolios is the most efficient. |
(5 marks) |
(b)Discuss whether or not Phantom plc’s strategy should be to purchase the most efficient
portfolio of two shares. |
(5 marks) |
(10 marks)
Question 55 KULPAR
The finance director of Kulpar plc is concerned about the impact of capital structure on the company’s value, and wishes to investigate the effect of different capital structures.
He is aware that as gearing increases the required return on equity will also increase, and the company’s interest cover is likely to decrease. A decrease in interest cover could lead to a change in the company’s credit rating by the leading rating agencies.
He has been informed that the following changes are likely:
Interest cover |
Credit rating |
Cost of long term debt |
More than 6·5 |
AA |
8·0% |
4·0 – 6·5 |
A |
9·0% |
1·5 – 4·0 |
BB |
11·0% |
The company is currently rated A.
Summarised financial data:
Net operating income
Depreciation
Earnings before interest and tax
Interest
Taxable income
Tax (30%)
Net income
Capital spending
Market value of equity is £458 million, and of debt £305 million. Kulpar’s equity beta is 1·4. The beta of debt may be assumed to be zero. The risk free rate is 5·5% and the market return 14%.
£ million 110
20
___
90
22
___
68
20·4
47·6
20
The company’s growth rate of cash flow may be assumed to be constant, and to be unaffected by any change in capital structure.
60
